Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / When Law Fails the Planet: The Iran War, Nuclear Fears, and the Ecocide
Transcript
- 0:05Excellent. Gary, welcome back to Science Behind
- 0:10the Glass. 100 guests in Science Behind the Glass.
- 0:14And then we are coming back for the third part
- 0:16because this hasn't ended. And I think that it
- 0:20would be awesome that we give a little bit of
- 0:23a background story what is happening right now.
- 0:26Talking also that when law fails the planet and
- 0:31the war, nuclear fears are not mentioned in many
- 0:37news, but the ecocide that is happening also
- 0:41in Iran and is affecting everyone. So thank you,
- 0:45Gary, for accepting this invitation. And to give
- 0:50a little bit of background, because actually
- 0:52it was in all the news I was reading, most of
- 0:55the people were complaining and saying like,
- 0:58oh, well, it's terrible. The U .S. declared war
- 1:00together with Israel. So joined together in Iran
- 1:05while they were in conversations. And some people
- 1:12were mentioning the Ayatollah. Well. he was a
- 1:19dictator and he did horrendous things to the
- 1:22population the recent protest but also we have
- 1:27to mention i think that go back a little bit
- 1:30in 1953 when actually iran had a democratic elected
- 1:37secular that his name the prime minister name
- 1:42was mozadegh and his purpose once One of the
- 1:48purpose that he wants to do for his people was
- 1:51to own the oil. But UK disagree and US joined
- 1:59forces and then he was overthrown. And then all
- 2:03this led to different conflicts. And then it
- 2:06was an opportunity also for who was in the regime,
- 2:12Ayatollah, to change completely the Iran history.
- 2:17This is a bit of a rush, but I'll be giving a
- 2:19little bit of a context. Yes. So what's happening?
- 2:26What's happening? Things have gotten, I think,
- 2:28even more complicated since the last time we
- 2:31spoke, and it wasn't that long ago. And it's
- 2:33going to be enormously difficult if we're looking
- 2:35at the law. It's going to be enormously difficult
- 2:37to get the legal process involved here. None
- 2:40of these countries are members, for example,
- 2:43of the International Criminal Court. with one
- 2:45small exception, and that's Cyprus. So the attack
- 2:49on Cyprus by Iran could give the International
- 2:54Criminal Court jurisdiction over Iran, but I
- 2:57think only for the attack on Cyprus. But it was
- 3:01aggression, so that would be an international
- 3:04crime. And it was... Look, while it was an attack
- 3:09on a military base, there were civilians there
- 3:11as well. So it... I'd like to be more sure of
- 3:16what I'm saying, but it's still very confusing.
- 3:18But like I said, that's the only country, really,
- 3:21that is a member of the ICC. None of the other
- 3:24countries in the region are members. Israel is
- 3:27not a member. The U .S. is not a member. Turkey
- 3:29is not a member. The only country in the region
- 3:33at all that is a member of Afghanistan, but nobody
- 3:37at the moment is attacking Afghanistan. That's
- 3:40because Afghanistan and Pakistan are engaged
- 3:42in their own war. It really gets complicated.
- 3:45The other thing that could invoke international
- 3:48legal jurisdiction in respect of Iran in particular
- 3:53is the Iranian attacks on vessels, commercial
- 3:58vessels, using the Straits of Hormuz. There have
- 4:02been three attacks. on three vessels one of them
- 4:06was a vessel that's flagged in thailand but thailand's
- 4:09not a member of the international criminal court
- 4:11but an attack on a vessel that is flagged in
- 4:13a particular country that flagging effectively
- 4:17means that that jurisdiction in total has been
- 4:21attacked so for example if they were to either
- 4:26mine or put a missile into a ship from, let's
- 4:31say, Germany, that would give the ICC jurisdiction
- 4:34in respect of that particular crime. So it's
- 4:37very, very messy at the moment. Very messy. But
- 4:40I have a question. You mentioned in our last
- 4:44podcast that it doesn't need to be a member of
- 4:47the ICC to be prosecuted for the international
- 4:54law. What was happening is that they were having
- 4:57a talk in the UN with Iran related with the enrichment
- 5:02of uranium, right? Yes. And while this was happening,
- 5:08while this was talk happening, US and Israel
- 5:11decided to attack Iran. So actually there was
- 5:16a nuclear threat and this is not a violation
- 5:19of the international law, even though that there
- 5:22are... No members? The UN Security Council has
- 5:26the capacity to give the International Criminal
- 5:29Court jurisdiction over any country, whether
- 5:31or not they're a member of the International
- 5:32Criminal Court. So you could get the Security
- 5:36Council together to provide jurisdiction to the
- 5:41International Criminal Court in respect of everything
- 5:43that Iran has done. I'm tempted to say that that
- 5:46might work. It would depend. The UK would go
- 5:52along with that. France would go along with that.
- 5:54The US, of course, would go along with that.
- 5:56That's three of the permanent members of the
- 5:58UN Security Council, which have a veto. Would
- 6:01Russia and China go along with that? That's really
- 6:04hard to predict. To some extent, Russia and Iran
- 6:07are allies of sorts. And in fact, Iran has been
- 6:14manufacturing weapons for Russia to use against
- 6:17the Ukraine. i don't know i can't really predict
- 6:20whether russia and china would go along with
- 6:22it if on the other hand you had a resolution
- 6:25before the security council which took in everybody
- 6:29that said all right we're going to get the u
- 6:32s is not a member Israel is not a member. Iran
- 6:34is not a member. We, the UN Security Council,
- 6:37are going to give the International Criminal
- 6:39Court jurisdiction over all three to prosecute
- 6:42whatever war crimes or crimes against humanity
- 6:45have been allegedly committed by any of the three
- 6:48countries in any of those various jurisdictions.
- 6:53It could work on a... on an individual basis
- 6:57but you know again it's it's international law
- 7:00so it's as i tell my students it's messy it's
- 7:03tricky i wish i had a better answer i'm sorry
- 7:07no it's okay i think that is very convoluted
- 7:10yeah so i think there's a few things that we
- 7:14should highlight that there's like humanitarian
- 7:17catastrophes happening either in lebanon because
- 7:21of the israel attacks yes And in Iran. So right
- 7:25now we have 700 ,000 people displaced in Lebanon.
- 7:31That is 12 % of the population. There's environmental
- 7:36catastrophes happening within the country and
- 7:40their borders are also shrinking day per day.
- 7:45So there's a lot of international violations
- 7:47that are just happening within the borders of
- 7:50Israel, north of it, just in Lebanon. And then
- 7:53we have the U .S. striking a girls' school in
- 7:57Iran, which, if you ask some parts of the administration,
- 8:03that was voluntarily, involuntarily, or it was
- 8:07a catastrophe that happened. What repercussions
- 8:11can be in any of these actions that either Israel
- 8:13or the U .S. are doing in both of these? It seems
- 8:18like a violation on a magnitude of scale of international
- 8:23law. While we're at the Iranian, like the bombing
- 8:28of the oil refinery in Tehran, it's another environmental.
- 8:34catastrophe happening within that border as well,
- 8:37which is like what nitrogen oxide mixed with
- 8:41rain that's forming like sulfuric and nitric
- 8:45rain. Look, in respect to that bomb that the
- 8:48U .S. dropped on the girls' school in Iran, they've
- 8:51come out this morning and effectively said that
- 8:57their technical mapping of the area was old,
- 9:04and that's why they accidentally hit that school,
- 9:09if it in fact was the U .S. that hit it. And
- 9:12it's pretty clear that it was the U .S. The bomb
- 9:15has been identified as a U .S. bomb. It's not
- 9:17the kind of, it's an advanced weapon beyond what
- 9:20has already been given to Israel, so it really
- 9:22couldn't have come from anywhere else. And I'm
- 9:27not entirely convinced that it's a defense to
- 9:29an attack on a civilian institution, which is,
- 9:32of course, a war crime to say, oh, well, our
- 9:36maps were off. That's a pretty weak excuse. So
- 9:39again, I mean, if we could get jurisdiction here,
- 9:42the U .S. could be prosecuted. Well, it would
- 9:44have to be probably Trump and the Secretary of
- 9:48Defense, maybe the general that was in charge
- 9:51of giving the actual order to drop that particular
- 9:54bomb. We could all get charged with a war crime.
- 9:57The Lebanon situation is strange or weird. because
- 10:03you have this sort of on -again, off -again conflict
- 10:09between Lebanon, or actually Hezbollah within
- 10:12Lebanon, and Israel. And Israel could argue,
- 10:18well, it was self -defense. They attacked us
- 10:22with, oh, I think they sent a missile into Tel
- 10:24Aviv. and so this is our response and our response
- 10:28is effectively to you know bomb the hell out
- 10:30of the all of southern lebanon and anywhere that
- 10:33we think hezbollah leadership is headquartered
- 10:35because they had a hotel just because there were
- 10:38two or three supposedly two or three hezbollah
- 10:41members staying in or meeting in this particular
- 10:44hotel. That's an attack on a civilian installation
- 10:47as well. And just because, and there's this rule
- 10:51about proportionality, you know, can you kill,
- 10:54can you bomb a whole hotel and kill a hundred
- 10:56civilians in order to maybe kill two leaders
- 11:01of Hezbollah? Proportionality applies. I don't
- 11:04think so. But again, we've got no jurisdiction
- 11:08until We can figure out a way to get jurisdiction.
- 11:12The only other thing I can think of here in respect.
- 11:15Additionally, I mean, in addition to the hotel,
- 11:18Israel has been targeting what they did, what
- 11:20they they've been doing, what they did in Gaza,
- 11:22which is targeting ambulances. So and they've
- 11:26killed already 14 ambulance drivers, which is
- 11:29very. Yeah, that's that might just chip in because.
- 11:33Just reading like on the ground news in Iran.
- 11:36So we also have to bear in mind that the people
- 11:39of Iran have been without Internet. There is
- 11:42a complete blackout since the end of February.
- 11:48Prisons are without water, without basic facilities.
- 11:53There's airstrikes and there's no shelter for
- 11:57people. No. And they don't have information.
- 12:00There's no place for them to go either. Absolutely.
- 12:04How is this warfare being carried in a humane
- 12:09way? It's not. It's not. And while it's going
- 12:13on, what's happening in Gaza is being neglected.
- 12:17It's still happening in Gaza as well. There are
- 12:19airstrikes every day, despite a supposed ceasefire.
- 12:22There are airstrikes every day in Gaza. Well,
- 12:25the Canadian Prime Minister Carney was talking
- 12:27about the collapse of the... international rules
- 12:32-based order i'm not sure that it's entirely
- 12:35collapsed but you've got a problem in that the
- 12:37most probably the most powerful country in the
- 12:41world is being led by somebody who has absolutely
- 12:44no concern for any rules -based order whether
- 12:47it's the international rules -based order or
- 12:49the domestic one i mean he's gone to war with
- 12:52iran without any congressional approval. That's
- 12:55illegal. But so far, Congress has been unwilling
- 12:58to enforce their right in terms of under the
- 13:01War Powers Act. So you've got a big problem.
- 13:04And at the moment, I can't see any way for the
- 13:08International Criminal Court to get involved.
- 13:10What you could do, perhaps, is get the International
- 13:14Court of Justice involved. One country could
- 13:17take all of these people. off to the International
- 13:19Court of Justice and allege a whole lot of violations.
- 13:21And then you would get the International Court
- 13:23of Justice issuing an opinion, which might do
- 13:26some good, but it might just be ignored. And,
- 13:28you know, I'm looking at Linda. I'm looking at
- 13:30Linda's face. She's getting sadder and sadder
- 13:32and sadder as I keep talking. So I better shut
- 13:34up. Yeah, I just got one remark on that. Like,
- 13:37would it change anything? Because yesterday,
- 13:39the Pentagon reportedly considered deployment
- 13:41of special forces in Tehran to capture enriched
- 13:44uranium. Yes. What triggers if there's deployment
- 13:49like special forces, which will be just an operation
- 13:53going in? So is it military invasion as per se?
- 13:57Yeah. Yeah. Which the U .S. have been doing since,
- 14:01you know, like past all the Iraq and Afghanistan
- 14:04wars, just been special forces and operations
- 14:07or, you know, like Blackwater contractors going
- 14:11in and just doing military strategic operations
- 14:15as per se. You ask tough questions, too. I think
- 14:22I'm going to guess and say, yeah, there's talk
- 14:28of it. I think ground troops are unlikely. You've
- 14:33got 150 ,000 Revolutionary Guard troops in Iran.
- 14:40So it's not just a... you know, a battalion or
- 14:43a division of special forces to go in and do
- 14:45what it is that they want to do. And I wouldn't
- 14:48be surprised. Even if a few Republicans didn't
- 14:52switch over and say, wait a minute, wait a minute,
- 14:54we better consider the War Powers Act here and
- 14:56let Congress decide whether we're going to put,
- 14:59as they say, boots on the ground. Look, I'm not
- 15:01saying it couldn't happen because the current
- 15:03administration is so unpredictable, you know,
- 15:05from not just day to day, but minute to minute.
- 15:07You don't know what it's going to do. This morning,
- 15:09the war is going to be over in a couple of days.
- 15:12That was Trump talking at the airport. And then
- 15:16also that leads us to that. US, well, Trump didn't
- 15:22ask for permission to the Congress, right? And
- 15:27they don't have, like, he initiated the conflict
- 15:30without any permissions to start this war. True.
- 15:35So can someone stop this war, at least from the
- 15:40part of the US, or he just can't just keep going
- 15:43and doing whatever he wants to do? Again, I mean,
- 15:47the Security Council could act, but you've got
- 15:50a veto sitting right there in the middle of the
- 15:52Security Council. The justification for their
- 15:57action is, or the U .S. action is, is what we
- 16:03would call one of preventive self -defense. And
- 16:06there's a difference between preventive self
- 16:07-defense and anticipatory self -defense. Anticipatory
- 16:12self -defense happens when you can see. It's
- 16:15immediate. You can see an immediate problem.
- 16:17For example, I'll give you a good example, okay?
- 16:19U .S. sends a whole fleet, including aircraft
- 16:24carriers and whatnot, filled with planes and
- 16:26other warships, parks somewhere near the coast
- 16:29of Iran and says, we're going to blow you out
- 16:31of the water unless you come to the table and
- 16:34do this, this, and this. Iran takes a look at
- 16:36that and says, they're right there on the border.
- 16:38We've got an immediate threat, okay? That's...
- 16:42we're going to act first. That's anticipatory
- 16:44self -defense. And that is generally accepted
- 16:48by the international community. Preventive self
- 16:52-defense, though, is one that looks long range
- 16:55and says, oh, hey, if we don't act today, Iran
- 17:00is going to get nuclear weapons. and intercontinental
- 17:03ballistic missile capability in 10 years so we're
- 17:07going to act to prevent that by acting today
- 17:09something that's going to happen way remotely
- 17:12down the road and that was the u .s position
- 17:16it's one of preventive self -defense if we don't
- 17:19act we're going to have a problem now one of
- 17:25them either the secretary of state or the president
- 17:30said, one said, we're going to act because we
- 17:33think Israel's going to go to war against Iran.
- 17:36And the other one said, no, we're acting because
- 17:38we think Iran is going to go to war against Israel.
- 17:41That could be preventive or anticipatory self
- 17:45-defense if they've got enough information that,
- 17:47look, Israel's getting ready to go or Iran's
- 17:49getting ready to go, so we're going to attack
- 17:50somebody. That could be anticipatory self -defense,
- 17:53but it's messy, really, again. It's messy. It's
- 17:57tricky. It's international stuff. Yeah. And then
- 18:00also they were talking about the nuclear threat
- 18:03and the international agency, the International
- 18:07Atomic Energy Agency and the director said that
- 18:11the inspectors didn't found elements of systematic
- 18:14and structured program to manufacture nuclear
- 18:17weapons in Iran. And he did confirm that Iran
- 18:20had enriched uranium at 60 % purity. But it's
- 18:24far beyond civilian energy needs. But the U .S.
- 18:29Director of National Intelligence testified in
- 18:32March 2025 that Iran was not pursuing nuclear
- 18:36weapons. Yeah, yeah. And the director of the
- 18:42International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed
- 18:44this. And that, so that's another... beautiful
- 18:49excuse because actually they are bombing these
- 18:53places that have enriched uranium and that would
- 18:57be catastrophic that would be another chernobyl
- 19:00or fukushima so it could easily be though yeah
- 19:03exactly so i mean suppose that even in war they
- 19:07shouldn't be bombing these areas so that can
- 19:10lead to uh i don't know like a way to stop this
- 19:14war possible as possible. And again, we're sitting
- 19:24on a lot of data, but some of it we're just not
- 19:29sure whether or not it's accurate. But you're
- 19:32right about the International Atomic Energy Agency.
- 19:35Under the treaty that existed between the U .S.,
- 19:44the other four permanent members of the Security
- 19:47Council, and a representative from the... European
- 19:51Union and Iran. When Trump pulled out of that
- 19:54treaty, Iran was complying. And the IAEA said
- 19:59they were complying. They weren't enriching anything.
- 20:03There was an interview last night with the recently
- 20:09retired director of MI6 in the UK. And he said
- 20:13they haven't got it. enriched irania they didn't
- 20:16have enriched irania so we're looking at another
- 20:18one of those weapons of mass destruction scenarios
- 20:21that we used that the u .s used to go to war
- 20:23against iraq and there weren't any weapons of
- 20:26mass destruction uh the former secretary of state
- 20:28colin powell said look you know they lied to
- 20:30me and i went to the u .n and said well they
- 20:31got weapons of mass destruction and they didn't
- 20:34you hope that you don't bomb the wrong thing.
- 20:38I mean, Russia has faced that issue in terms
- 20:40of the Ukraine and has pretty much stayed away
- 20:43from whatever that nuclear power station is in
- 20:46the Ukraine because it doesn't want to unleash
- 20:48another Chernobyl either. But, you know, our
- 20:50information about where things are, at least
- 20:53where we think things are in Iran, is probably
- 20:56a little bit more sketchy than having a nuclear
- 20:58power station sitting out in the middle of the
- 21:00open. And then also, like we have all the...
- 21:04Complete silence from European Union and all
- 21:07the members. And some of them have, they have
- 21:11support, but they, at the same time, they don't
- 21:15remain neutral because the US have been using
- 21:18their bases to deploy. Yeah. There are, including
- 21:23Germany, France, including UK. And the only one
- 21:27country that was opposing was Spain. And then
- 21:31Trump was. threatening them with tariffs and
- 21:36etc. Look, you have to admit the fact Iran is
- 21:41a bad guy, a very bad guy. And so Western countries
- 21:47tend to sort of overlook. the issues that may
- 21:50arise and go, well, you know, Iran is a bad guy.
- 21:53Therefore, what we're doing is, well, we want
- 21:55to prevent Iran from being a bad guy. Maybe this
- 21:57will work. I don't know if it's going to work
- 21:59or not. Fortunately, none of the European powers,
- 22:03in particular France, none of them are providing
- 22:05offensive weapons. They're there supposedly to
- 22:08provide defensive capability, although the UK
- 22:11looks as though it's moving. into the more offensive
- 22:16weapons area. Because it was, you know, it was
- 22:18a UK base in Cyprus that was attacked. But the
- 22:21rest of them are sort of sitting there saying,
- 22:23look, we're here to provide defense. But, you
- 22:26know, you've got Australia's provision of a wedge
- 22:31tail, whatever a wedge tail is, it's a strategic
- 22:34aircraft that allows both the capacity to see
- 22:41incoming missiles and drones and provide some
- 22:44defense against those incoming missiles and drones.
- 22:47And Australia has sent one. I think two other
- 22:53European countries have also sent one. Australia's
- 22:59went to the UAE. I think maybe Germany's went
- 23:02to Qatar. I can't remember exactly because it's
- 23:05changing so rapidly. Minute by minute, it's hard
- 23:07to keep up with. But there are at least a couple
- 23:10of them there. hopefully provide some sort of
- 23:13defensive assistance. It's a funny line. When
- 23:16does defensive assistance become offensive assistance?
- 23:21Yeah, just talking about the European Union,
- 23:24because I was following Giorgia Meloni, which
- 23:27is the prime minister of Italy. She's been a
- 23:29huge supporter of the Trump administration and
- 23:32Trump because of her political party is more
- 23:35in the right wing. But she came out yesterday
- 23:37to speak to the Italian parliament. condemning
- 23:41the war, even stating that were international
- 23:44crimes that were committed and said that Italy
- 23:48will not be dragged into this war. But Italy
- 23:51has gone and sent defensive support to Kuwait.
- 23:55That's because of vested interest that most European
- 23:58countries have to all those Gulf states with
- 24:01natural resources that are coming out of there.
- 24:04And that brings my next point is, you know, most
- 24:07European leaders have stated some sort of not
- 24:11wanting to be dragged into this war in one sort
- 24:14or another, but they have vested interest into
- 24:16that region because of that strait that most
- 24:20of the oil production comes out of. What I found
- 24:23quite interesting is that I thought at the beginning
- 24:26that was you know like this whole operation was
- 24:29to kind of you know because of the relations
- 24:32with china to create like a choke point for oil
- 24:35not to be flowing over to china but actually
- 24:39we found out that china's flow of oil has been
- 24:43ramping up and they've been able to buy oil from
- 24:48iran below market prices yeah so um Yeah, it's
- 24:54interesting how this operation is being driven
- 24:56by the need of oil production. Absolutely, yeah.
- 25:01And the U .S. administration, I would have assumed
- 25:04that they're going in to stop the prevention
- 25:07of oil production going into China. But actually,
- 25:10China is kind of gaining from this in one way
- 25:13or another, which I found interesting. Yeah.
- 25:16Yeah, they are. But China could also get it from
- 25:19Russia. I mean, they're going to get the oil.
- 25:21The question is whether we're going to get oil
- 25:23here. But, you know, the sort of, well, both
- 25:26short -range implications and even potentially
- 25:28long -range implications of what's going on and
- 25:31the impact around the world are enormous. I mean,
- 25:33if you think about here in Australia, we've seen
- 25:37the, here where we're located in Cairns, we've
- 25:42seen the price go from about $100. about $1 .70
- 25:48a liter to this morning, I paid $2 .09 a liter.
- 25:54Okay. So that's, you know, 39 cents in just a
- 25:58few days. And yesterday, you know, I thought,
- 26:01oh, maybe I'll stop and get it for $1 .99. And
- 26:06I thought, oh, no, I'll be all right. I'll get
- 26:07it tomorrow on the way to work. And it was at
- 26:0910 cents a liter. So, yeah. the implications
- 26:14are significant. And our reserve bank is talking
- 26:20about an interest rate hike next week because,
- 26:24of course, the prices are going up. So they're
- 26:26looking at that and they're calling that inflation.
- 26:29And so not only are people going to end up paying
- 26:33more at the... petrol station, they're going
- 26:37to end up paying more for just about everything
- 26:39because the gas prices are going to affect the
- 26:41delivery of goods and whatnot to the grocery
- 26:44stores. So we're going to pay more for that.
- 26:47Farmers are in trouble. They can't get enough
- 26:49oil and or diesel to run their farming equipment.
- 26:52And we're not going to be the only ones. It's
- 26:54going to be true in the U .S. It's going to be
- 26:55true everywhere that people are suffering that.
- 26:59It just wasn't well thought out. Yeah, so that's
- 27:03important because actually, like, this war affects
- 27:06everyone in this, from the economic point of
- 27:09view, politics, and also in ecosystem point of
- 27:15view, because what is happening is, as Rafa mentioned,
- 27:18an ecocide. So all this has been on chain for
- 27:23these two. bigger powers so that's not another
- 27:27reason for like actually trying to stop this
- 27:30war and what mechanisms could work or something
- 27:36someone kind of feel yeah wouldn't it be nice
- 27:38gary's got a magic wand i'll fix it And the U
- 27:47.S. president has said, oh, I'll be over in a
- 27:49couple of days. But history says that that's
- 27:52not really the case. They are really good getting
- 27:56into trouble and not to get out of trouble. This
- 27:58operation is costing taxpayers money at roughly
- 28:03$2 billion per day? No, it's costing the U .S.
- 28:08a billion dollars a day. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. There
- 28:13are already how many trillions in deficit. So
- 28:16that's interesting. That's all happening. Oh,
- 28:19yeah. Yeah. But we didn't have enough money for
- 28:21SNAP, the food nutrition program for low -income
- 28:24families in the U .S. But we've got a billion
- 28:26dollars a day to spend on blowing up whatever
- 28:29it is that we want to blow up in Iran. Yeah.
- 28:32Actually, since we're all in Queensland in Australia,
- 28:35I just wanted to shift the anti -war protests.
- 28:38I don't know if you heard. the new law that Queensland
- 28:41has passed in regards of like hate speech that
- 28:45some of the, you know, pro -Palestinian protests,
- 28:49you know, they have one of their saying, which
- 28:52is from the river to the sea. And that's been
- 28:54considered to be hate speech, which is a criminal.
- 28:57It is. Yeah. Along with what is it? Globalize
- 29:01the Antifa. Both of those are considered hate
- 29:04speech because they are in support of effectively
- 29:07Palestinian statehood. I do teach, I mean, in
- 29:10addition to the international subjects that I
- 29:12teach, I did teach constitutional law last year
- 29:15and I'm going to teach it again this year. And
- 29:18the question is whether or not those two terms,
- 29:21globalize the intifada and from the river to
- 29:23the sea, can actually be considered as hate speech
- 29:28in light of the high court determination that
- 29:32we have. we have a freedom of political communication.
- 29:36And it's going to be interesting to see when
- 29:38those two clash, which comes out on top. I think
- 29:42it's, you know, it's going to depend on context.
- 29:45It's not, neither one of them is anti -Semitic
- 29:50because you can't be anti -Semitic if you're
- 29:53supporting the Palestinians because the Palestinians
- 29:55are Semitic people. You know, they're... And
- 29:58the Jewish people are, you know, they're cousins,
- 30:03for God's sake. And so that's a problem. The
- 30:06hate speech stuff is very, very, very, very tricky.
- 30:09It's almost as tricky, maybe it's more tricky
- 30:10than the international stuff because it hasn't
- 30:13been tested particularly well yet. You know,
- 30:15it's one thing to go put a Nazi symbol on a synagogue.
- 30:22Yeah, that's hateful conduct, hate speech. That's
- 30:26easy. But to stand up and say, I support Palestine,
- 30:29I support Palestine's right to statehood, is
- 30:31not, I don't think, hate speech. We'll have to
- 30:34wait and see. And I mean, it's not just Queensland,
- 30:36but the Commonwealth has got some stuff on that.
- 30:39And New South Wales passed a recent piece of
- 30:42legislation as well. And at some point in time,
- 30:45they're all going to come together and there'll
- 30:47be a big clash and we'll have an idea of where
- 30:51the ball is actually going to land. Well, what
- 30:57measures will you send to people to give a little
- 31:00bit of hope? This is very dystopic. What is happening?
- 31:05Oh, look, I wish I had better answers. But at
- 31:09the moment, the answers are really all contingent
- 31:12on how things go and things are going one way
- 31:15one day and one way the other day. And it is,
- 31:18you know, and look, there are, you know, thousands
- 31:23of people are dying. Let's just put it that way.
- 31:26And that's not a good thing. Not a good thing
- 31:28at all. Thank you, Gary, again. Do you have another
- 31:34question? No, I don't. All I was going to say
- 31:37is that 3 ,600 sites have been attacked, civilian
- 31:41sites have been attacked in Iran. Yeah. And something
- 31:47that hasn't been really involved is the echo
- 31:50site that they are committing, not only in Iran.
- 31:53Yeah. And also affects the entire population
- 31:58without dismissing the point that if they are
- 32:01bombarding these sites of nuclear enrichment,
- 32:05that is going to be a catastrophe. And that's
- 32:07something that hasn't been considered. And also,
- 32:10like in 12 days of war from, oops, sorry. That's
- 32:16right. Around. 9 ,000 to 12 ,000 hectares of
- 32:23forest had been completely burned to ashes without
- 32:26considering what Rafa was mentioning, that they
- 32:29are attacking all the oil. There was a bit of
- 32:34interesting bit of research that I ran into the
- 32:37other day that just says that the catastrophe
- 32:40of the oil refinery bombing in Tehran, the burning
- 32:44of petroleum, of course, has released nitrogen.
- 32:48oxide that mixed with rain that formed sulfic
- 32:50acid. But if we take into contrast something
- 32:55that happened in the past, in the 1991 operation
- 32:59when Saddam burned Kuwait's oil as well, that
- 33:03contributed to what became known as the Gulf
- 33:06War syndrome, where veterans developed chronic
- 33:09illness and cancer decades later. So there'll
- 33:13be a repercussion, I suppose, in the future for
- 33:16what has been unleashed in some of the in those
- 33:20countries i suppose so uh oh you're actually
- 33:25right yeah and i mean if you look even if you
- 33:30look you know if you look at what's happened
- 33:32in gaza if you know if gaza had any wildlife
- 33:35habitat at all it's gone it's gone so war is
- 33:41always a disaster for the environment one way
- 33:43shape form or another this is just a different
- 33:45form Unfortunately. Unfortunately. Because it's
- 33:49like we completely rely on nature. That's what
- 33:52we want to see. And it's like we said, yeah,
- 33:55the forests of Iran, but all these catastrophes
- 33:59when they attack those oil reserves and the effects
- 34:05that it has on the groundwater, because Iran
- 34:08already had a problem with the water reserve.
- 34:12So they are in crisis also already because of
- 34:16the drought. So this is a massive impact because
- 34:20it's not separated, right? Yeah. There are a
- 34:25multitude of problems and issues. Yeah. Thank
- 34:31you, Gary, for your talk. You're welcome. For
- 34:33explaining this to us. Let's hope that this doesn't
- 34:37continue. A pleasure to be back for part three,
- 34:39and hopefully things don't get bad enough that
- 34:42you need me back for part four. Hopefully not,
- 34:44Gary. Okay. Thanks, Gary. Thank you very much.
- 34:49Times Between the Glasses is much more than a
- 34:52podcast. We are a bilingual science communication
- 34:54initiative that bridges the gap between science
- 34:58and the public through immersive storytelling
- 35:00and high -impact visual content. We offer video
- 35:03production for research, 360 -degree virtual
- 35:06tours, educational video formats, and consulting
- 35:09in educational content design. If you are looking
- 35:12to expand the visibility of your research or
- 35:14connect with diverse audiences, visit our website
- 35:18to learn more about our services for scientists
- 35:21who communicate. Remember that Science Behind
- 35:23the Glass is an independent project hosted by
- 35:27me, Linda Hernandez. and Daniel Esguerra, and
- 35:31in this occasion, Rafael Yorda. Don't forget
- 35:35to subscribe. Remember that your support helps
- 35:39us to continue with this podcast. And don't forget
- 35:43to share. Sharing is caring. See you next time.