Latest / Pediatrics Now: Cases Updates and Discussions for the Busy Pediatric Practitioner / “My Brain Feels Better!”
Transcript
- 0:00Lisa and Craig, what makes you so brave to be able to speak out about this?
- 0:09A lot of people would want to just put it all behind them. It was a nightmare,
- 0:13but it didn't have to be a nightmare.
- 0:15It didn't have to be as much of a nightmare as it was. The reason it went on
- 0:18for so long is we couldn't get the proper medical attention and help that we needed.
- 0:23So that's why we're motivated to speak out, because I want things to change,
- 0:27and I don't want any other families to go through what we went through.
- 0:30He was about 14 and a half, almost 15.
- 0:34It started off, you know, just looking like basic OCD at first,
- 0:41washing your hands a lot and being kind of a little neurotic about walking barefoot on the carpet.
- 0:47But then it quickly just went to a whole other realm.
- 0:50Like, you know, I called OCD therapists to try to help them.
- 0:54And they were like, this is way beyond anything we see. um.
- 1:00And so that's when we started trying to dig into what else could be causing this.
- 1:04It progressed from the typical germophobia thing to what you call emotional contamination.
- 1:14So when he got the illness and it just progressed, he associated his sickness
- 1:22with the place we lived, the people we knew,
- 1:26the cars we drove, the actual house we lived in.
- 1:30Everything became contaminated.
- 1:33So he didn't even want to be inside our house. He would not get in the vehicle,
- 1:39which made it extremely complicated because we could not get him to a doctor.
- 1:44He refused to get in a car.
- 1:47He would sit outside on our patio all day. This was early on.
- 1:53And it got to where, you know, things that he and his sisters used to do for fun.
- 2:00Became contaminated too and he couldn't even look at images of games or anything
- 2:06that they used to do without just becoming extremely agitated and upset yeah
- 2:12there was a period early on where he would just go ballistic if he even heard
- 2:15his sister speak you know like she.
- 2:20And then that kind of transferred over to me for a long time.
- 2:24And then he made everything about mom, everything.
- 2:27It was just like so typical with Pan's kids.
- 2:30They make one parent, like the good parent. One parent is the off-limits parent.
- 2:34And then the worst aspect of it was he started to refuse eating or drinking
- 2:40unless he could go through his own kind of made-up rituals,
- 2:46OCD rituals, to make himself feel kind of clean.
- 2:50Um, and again, not necessarily the germs anymore. It was more of the emotional side of it.
- 2:56Yeah. So, um, these are things he made up that he felt like he had to do with
- 3:00no explanation to us, but, uh, get him to eat or drink unless we did it.
- 3:06And it would be hours and hours and hours and hours of usually me repeating
- 3:10sentences and phrases, um, all sorts of like things, objects I would have to
- 3:15hand him and he would have to do all these things, like spit into a cup, like all this.
- 3:21They got more and more bizarre and entrenched as time went on.
- 3:24He actually very quickly wouldn't even go to his room. We ended up moving out
- 3:28of the house that we found had mold in it.
- 3:30And we moved from Houston here to Austin in the Leander area.
- 3:34And he was.
- 3:38Every single day on the couch, he couldn't get off the couch.
- 3:40He was on the couch 24-7, no clothes on, just a blanket. Would not use the toilet.
- 3:45The toilets became contaminated, so we had to put a bucket in the living room.
- 3:50And he has two sisters, so you can imagine what that would have been like.
- 3:56Trying to help them have some kind of life, the trauma for them and us.
- 4:03His sleep cycle was completely upside down. He would be up all night screaming
- 4:07and yelling, demanding for me to do all these rituals.
- 4:11And like I said, we could go, he could keep me up for up to like 36 hours straight
- 4:16with rituals, like not eating or drinking anything until everything was right.
- 4:23And when we would get to a point of crisis, we would have to call EMS because it would be so bad.
- 4:33And he wouldn't get in a car so we couldn't go to any specialist we were calling
- 4:37specialists for help and they would advise but he wouldn't go see them we had
- 4:42no way to get him yeah he wouldn't even put clothes on much less get out the
- 4:46front door and and you know it.
- 4:50It got pretty severe pretty quickly. Like even before we moved out of the house
- 4:53in Houston, it was like first he was, he actually, we tried to go to the hospital
- 4:58in the Woodlands and they did nothing for us.
- 5:01And it was a situation where they was very traumatized and the cops and the
- 5:04EMS dragged them out of the shower, kicking, screaming naked,
- 5:08sedated them with ketamine, got to the ER and they did nothing for us,
- 5:11sent us back home empty-handed.
- 5:13They didn't even have a doctor on site. There was a nurse practitioner,
- 5:17but we were there all night and that's, they didn't do a single thing.
- 5:21They just sent somebody, some kind of counselor to talk to him. It was just pathetic.
- 5:26And so he locked himself down in our shower for about seven months.
- 5:29Like every waking moment he would come downstairs naked and like would stay
- 5:33in the shower all day long. And that's the only place he would drink.
- 5:37In the shower? Yeah. It could be a four hour stretch. It could be a 21 time he did a 24 hour stretch.
- 5:43With the water going? with the water running if we tried to
- 5:46turn it off he would start slamming the glass and banging and
- 5:49the reason people say well why did you tell her why didn't you just because we've
- 5:52already tried to get help and we'd already
- 5:55got through a very traumatizing experience with our boy you know and they did
- 5:59nothing for us so we felt stuck and so we're trying to ride this out we're trying
- 6:04we were trying to get him off an ssri the psychiatrist put him on that made
- 6:07him however bad it was as soon as we put him on the ssri he went about 10 times
- 6:11worse so we were trying to taper him off that safely.
- 6:15We felt like that was our only choice was to do that, and nobody at the hospital was going to help us.
- 6:19So we hunkered down for six or seven months until we got to the hospital again,
- 6:24and then that cycle repeated itself probably seven or eight or nine times with no help.
- 6:30So this was, sorry, the chronology were bouncing back and forth,
- 6:34but that's when we were still in Houston. It's before we moved here.
- 6:38That whole phase where he would spend all night in the shower was still there.
- 6:44And, uh, he lived on the couch for several years, like would not get up,
- 6:49um, could not use the toilet, couldn't go get food for himself.
- 6:53Um, totally at like, we've lost our child.
- 6:57Like, I don't know who this person is. He's not rational at all about any of
- 7:00this, but he would have conversations with us. Like he knew what he was doing.
- 7:05Didn't make sense, but he was in my brain hurts.
- 7:08My brain hurts me so bad. And it makes me do these things. If I don't do them, it hurts even worse.
- 7:14And so I have to live like this because I'm in so much pain.
- 7:18And by this time, we had the diagnosis of PANS.
- 7:21Because if you look at the, it's a clinical diagnosis primarily.
- 7:24If you look at Texas Health and Human Services site for PANDAS and PANS,
- 7:29he checks every single box. So it's diagnosed clinically at first.
- 7:32And there are extra tests you can do to double up on that and verify that.
- 7:37But he checked every clinical box.
- 7:40He's like the poster child of Xtreme.
- 7:43So, and Lisa and Craig, thank you so much for being here on Pediatrics Now and talking about this.
- 7:50And I know you're hoping that this will help pediatricians who are listening
- 7:54and help parents who are listening.
- 7:57So it sounds like the behavior became stranger and stranger.
- 8:03And then the more you're trying to get help, it's not helping.
- 8:08We went from out of the frying pan into the fire.
- 8:11And so then we would get into these situations in the hospitals because we had
- 8:16to call EMS and take them.
- 8:18And they would just continue to send us to psych, send us to psych.
- 8:21And by this time, we already had a diagnosis of PANS from his doctors that are
- 8:25on the Health and Human Services Advisory Board with this condition.
- 8:29But the hospital doctors wouldn't talk to them. They wouldn't listen to us and
- 8:33they would just stick us back in psych again. And.
- 8:37It was extremely frustrating. We were wearing down, my wife,
- 8:40and the level of care, the burden of care on us was through the roof.
- 8:44We felt like our health was declining, and we were not going to make it much longer.
- 8:49And if we hadn't found Dr. Infante in San Antonio when we did,
- 8:52I don't know where we'd be today.
- 8:54By the time we got to Dr. Infante, I think we had been about 12 hospitals,
- 9:01probably about 20 visits total between the 12.
- 9:05That you know like all the big cities all very traumatizing all dried in your
- 9:10mouth and it was the same repetitive um speeches every time uh it was always
- 9:16the psych team that boiled down to.
- 9:19Uh and that's really the only way that any of them wanted to handle it even
- 9:24though we kept requesting because of the parent support groups and advice we
- 9:29were being given to do some tests,
- 9:32certain tests for the autoimmune.
- 9:34Yeah, his specialist and other parents who've been through it to do some certain
- 9:41tests for the autoimmune antibodies in the brain.
- 9:45No hospital would do it. They just didn't like the test. I don't know why.
- 9:52But Dr. Infante, he recognized what we were asking and knew the test.
- 9:58So he was in agreement and that's how we finally found what we needed to find.
- 10:03And he, and to his credit, he not only ran the right test and gave us the right
- 10:07treatment from the first meeting with him, he was extremely compassionate.
- 10:12He saw how long we'd been suffering. He saw that this was devastating,
- 10:15not only our son, but us and our other children, the whole household.
- 10:20And he did not hesitate to step in and do the right thing. Yeah.
- 10:28If it wasn't for him we could still be stuck in that cycle and
- 10:31and he he was courageous and faithful enough
- 10:34our son is totally better after the test we
- 10:37dr infante prescribed ivig treatment which
- 10:39is a monthly iv infusion um at home and at home we had the first one in the
- 10:44hospital and then every month after that we had a nurse that would come um and
- 10:49and treat him it's two days in a row so it's like seven hours straight very
- 10:53long gives you a nurse and they show up they send the supplies and they administer
- 10:58the whole thing at the house.
- 10:59I would like to also note that we were accused, because this is something,
- 11:08and to me it should be drastically changed in policy,
- 11:12of Munchausen's by proxy, which basically is saying we caused our son to be this way.
- 11:20Um, which is very painful when you're trying to help your child and,
- 11:25um, people don't believe you, you know?
- 11:29Um, so that's something that needs to change because I don't know what kind
- 11:35of training goes into, you know, doctors as they, as they're going through med
- 11:40school and all that, but like, that's something we encountered several times. Yes.
- 11:44We actually, ironically, we actually.
- 11:47That that happened. It's sounds just awful.
- 11:50It was terrible. I mean, ironically, we had one of the hospitals,
- 11:54the last one there, a pediatric abuse specialist, you know, never came and interviewed
- 12:01us, never came and saw Ryan or talked to Ryan,
- 12:06wrote this scathing affidavit out of thin air and submitted it to a CPS guy
- 12:12and the CPS guy is the third one.
- 12:14And the first two CBS agents totally dismissed it because they talked to our
- 12:17doctors and we were trying to get help.
- 12:19And they talked to us and Ryan and realized. They did their due diligence.
- 12:23There's nothing wrong here. The parents are trying to do the best they can with this situation.
- 12:29But the third time we were reported from a hospital.
- 12:33The same hospital, yeah. Yeah, the same hospital did it every time.
- 12:37This agent did not come meet us. He did not interview our son.
- 12:41He did not interview any of our doctors. He just went and got a court order.
- 12:45And this is after we came home with Dr. Infante's prescription for IVIG to be started right away.
- 12:53We were home from San Antonio for two days and got the knock on the door. And it was CPS.
- 13:00A bunch of police came and took him.
- 13:03And for the next three weeks, we were in a court battle. We could not start the IVIG.
- 13:11And we didn't even know if we'd get our son back at that point to even start it.
- 13:14Yes. They were trying to take him away. And we spent about $20,000 in legal fees to get him back.
- 13:21It sounds like most people did not have any idea what you were going through, what this actually was,
- 13:29and that it was just one problem after another, just kind of snowballing,
- 13:35just something that it would,
- 13:38any parent, it would just, like we talked about, but like we said earlier,
- 13:42what a nightmare where you're just trying to help your child. your child.
- 13:48Can you tell me once he got the antibody treatment, because we'll be, Dr.
- 13:53Infante is going to be talking about, he's joining us on the show to talk about the treatment.
- 14:00But so how does it work? And then what change did you see in Ryan once he got the treatment?
- 14:08Well, immediately the first thing that got better was his sleep.
- 14:12So prior to this, he, his circadian rhythm was totally off.
- 14:16He could be up from, from, he could wake up at midnight and be up until noon
- 14:21the next day and then fall back to sleep at noon.
- 14:23And then he could stay up for 30 hours straight and then maybe sleep four hours
- 14:27and wake up and do it all over again.
- 14:28We had no, our lives were just, there was no rhyme or reason to our lives or schedule.
- 14:32Once he got his first treatment, the only thing that changed at first was that
- 14:36he just started sleeping when we went to sleep.
- 14:38He fell asleep at 11 o'clock at night and wake up at
- 14:41like nine in the morning it was great um and
- 14:44then about a couple of months after that uh some of his rituals started falling
- 14:48off like asking my wife to repeat certain things by about the fourth month he
- 14:54asked my wife to come bring him his clothes he's still stuck on the couch he
- 14:58said bring me my clothes she laid him on the couch and he put him on lickety split you know.
- 15:04All by himself i mean which is amazing
- 15:07um and then that just kind of kind of
- 15:10increased every month every after every infusion uh one
- 15:13more thing then he'd go start taking a shower on his own then he'd start
- 15:16brushing his teeth then he started using the restroom again you know until we're
- 15:20going out and we're going to see movies and we're meeting other families with
- 15:23sick kids at restaurants that and he's and he's starting to form relationships
- 15:27and social circle again um to the point where Like then he starts taking violin lessons and, um,
- 15:34and he's showering every day on his own and he's sleeping in his bed and he's
- 15:37got his own bathroom and he taking care of his own hygiene again and walking
- 15:42in the kitchen and getting his own food, you know?
- 15:44Yeah. It sounds like, it was like a reverse, you know, of the progress down.
- 15:49It was like going backwards, like little by little coming, him coming back.
- 15:55How old was Ryan at this point when you started to see your son coming back? He was 18.
- 16:02Wow. So three and a half years, you said? Three and a half years,
- 16:06totally lost. And this treatment, it sounds like.
- 16:11It's miraculous for us. It was. Yeah.
- 16:16Um, how is Ryan doing now? Great.
- 16:21Yeah. He's, uh, he loves, he's just, he loves life. He loves feeling good every day.
- 16:26He just like, thanks God that he doesn't feel sick anymore. And then his brain
- 16:30doesn't hurt. And he's able to go out and do what he wants to do.
- 16:33And we take him down to Georgetown square and drop him off the library.
- 16:36And he has a great time there. He'll walk around the square and just start forming relationships.
- 16:41He started playing the tin whistle and he'll go down on the square and play
- 16:45songs on his tin whistle. People like give him money, you know?
- 16:48So he's really playing catch up right now.
- 16:51Socially. He had to drop out of school or out of homeschool even,
- 16:55right? Yeah. Did you homeschool all three of your children?
- 16:58Yes, he was at the tail end of ninth grade when he got sick. So he lost all of that.
- 17:02We're trying to get him going with his GED at this point because he'll be 20 in May.
- 17:08Wow. I'm so sorry for everything that you've gone through, Lisa and Craig,
- 17:14and I am so thankful to you for being willing to be on the podcast and to talk to us about this.
- 17:23Is there anything you want to say to the parents who are listening and then
- 17:29anything else to the pediatrician listener?
- 17:34Well, to the pediatricians, I would say, you know, listen to the parents and do your due diligence.
- 17:40If they already have an outside physician that they're working with that is
- 17:43that may have a contrary opinion to your first analysis, go talk to them.
- 17:48Go to Texas Health and Human Services and see that there's an advisory board
- 17:53created by our governor of the state.
- 17:57And these doctors serve on this advisory board. Or sorry, just so we can maybe
- 18:02tell me more about what did you love about Dr. Infante? It sounds like he really listened.
- 18:08Well, he really listened. He saw our suffering and it affected him.
- 18:12And he also was very knowledgeable about the condition.
- 18:14He was, in fact, the first hospitalist doctor. I mean, we'd been in front of
- 18:19dozens of hospitalists in almost every city,
- 18:23every major city in this state, from Austin to Houston to Dallas to San Antonio.
- 18:31He is the first physician that actually knew anything about this condition and
- 18:35knew how to diagnose it and knew how to treat it.
- 18:37When we asked for the Cunningham panel, which none of the other hospitals would
- 18:42acknowledge or knew, he knew what it was right away.
- 18:47Because he was actually a colleague with Dr.
- 18:52Coyne Hamm who developed the test.
- 18:54So he knew her and knew that this was a good test and worth our time.
- 19:00So, you know, I think he has a lot of valuable information to share also when
- 19:08it comes to this illness, you know, for other doctors to learn from, you know.
- 19:15Well, I think another thing that he did, too, was that he saw the history of,
- 19:19He saw that we had already been down the psych road. We've already tried several psych facilities.
- 19:24Ryan had been on a number of psychiatric meds that all did not help or made him worse.
- 19:29And he went when he was being logical. He said, well, they've tried this,
- 19:32but they haven't tried this.
- 19:34Yes. What set Dr. Infante apart was he used his head and his heart.
- 19:41And that's what we'd like to see more of.
- 19:46Well, I'm so glad that Ryan is doing so much better. And now do you just,
- 19:51I mean, tell me what you're feeling now that you've been through all of this
- 19:54and that your son is, it sounds like he's, he's back to normal.
- 20:00Yeah, it's amazing. I mean, our lives are still very much touched by all this
- 20:06because we lost our home.
- 20:09We are in a different city now. I still have to travel every week back and forth to Houston.
- 20:13It wiped out all of our, any savings that we had is gone.
- 20:17I mean, we're, so we're still dealing with all the repercussions of it,
- 20:21but to have him back is so worth it.
- 20:24I mean, the relationship now that we have with him is so strong and he's so
- 20:29solid emotionally and spiritually and so mature that he this trial has really shaped him.
- 20:35And now he's a point of like strength and comfort to his older sisters who are
- 20:41still trying to recover from all that they went through on the sidelines.
- 20:45You know, they got pretty neglected as we all our attention was focused on him.
- 20:52Before we go, can you describe just when you were going through all of this,
- 20:55just some of the emotions you were feeling and did you ever even consider giving up?
- 21:02Or do you think, what if we had given up? Where would we be now? Yes, absolutely.
- 21:09I mean, it was a totally inhuman thing to go through. Inhuman.
- 21:16To not sleep for almost four years, to have other children who need you just as much and you can't.
- 21:25Um you know i
- 21:28think the only reason we made it through was support
- 21:32from friends and family and the parent support group you know advice we had
- 21:38from other people going through it uh specialist doctors who did acknowledge that this was real uh,
- 21:50But unfortunately, their hands were tied because, you know, they couldn't,
- 21:53they didn't have a voice in the hospital setting, which was the only place we could get.
- 21:58So, but, you know, if it weren't for many, many people, I can't say that,
- 22:06you know, we would have had this outcome. No, no, it was, it was amazing to come out of that.
- 22:11I mean, like waking up from a nightmare, an utter nightmare that you're just exhausted.
- 22:16You don't want to give up because you love your child.
- 22:20But you're like, I physically can't, physically and emotionally,
- 22:23I don't know if we can go another day or another week.
- 22:26And then somehow you do. And I mean, the insanity that we went through,
- 22:31I mean, I didn't even, I scraped the surface of it.
- 22:33I mean, you can make like a Netflix drama out of this. It was so,
- 22:38if I watched it on TV, my jaw would be hanging on the floor.
- 22:41But to live through it, I mean, I couldn't believe this had become our life.
- 22:43And just such a wonderful story, though, of love,
- 22:50parental love and perseverance and amazing medical care.
- 22:57It's incredible what can be done in the medical world, really.
- 23:00Like you saw both sides, drastic sides.
- 23:05Oh, yes. I would really, my goal is I would hope that if pediatricians or physicians
- 23:10are not familiar with this condition, that they would talk to somebody like Dr.
- 23:15Infante, who is. We'll be talking to Dr.
- 23:18Infante in just a few minutes.
- 23:21And so he'll be here on Pediatrics Now. But Lisa and Craig Wilkerson,
- 23:26thank you again so much for being here on Pediatrics Now and sharing your story.
- 23:32Thank you for giving us the opportunity.
- 23:35Joining me now is Dr. Anthony Infante. Dr. Infante, thank you so much for being
- 23:40here today on Pediatrics Now.
- 23:42So let's pick up where they finally get to you. They've been through a lot,
- 23:47and you finally see Ryan.
- 23:49What's your first clue regarding what needed to be done?
- 23:56Yeah, good question. You know, I've been seeing these patients,
- 24:02patients like Ryan, since, you know, the early 2000s.
- 24:08This PANDAS syndrome was, you know, really only well described in the 90s.
- 24:15So in terms of the way medicine works, that's pretty recent.
- 24:20And it remains controversial.
- 24:25And, um, you know, it, it falls within, it falls in the cracks.
- 24:31Um, and so many, many families that are faced with this kind of situation, um,
- 24:40get frustrated and, um, look for answers and, and, and, um,
- 24:49And they eventually find their way to different referral patterns.
- 24:59So can you tell us about, because you mentioned PANDAS, but they said,
- 25:04so was this something different called PANS?
- 25:06So what Ryan has, it's related to PANDAS or what he had?
- 25:11You know, it's a continuum. them.
- 25:14PANDAS was originally described as a syndrome that occurred after streptococcal infection.
- 25:24And then people broadened the definition because it seemed as if it could be
- 25:31initiated by other infections or inflammatory triggers.
- 25:38And once established, it could be You know, further episodes could be triggered
- 25:45by other triggers in addition to strep.
- 25:52And so the diagnostic description were modified to include that.
- 26:02So, you're an immunologist with 43 years of experience at UT Health and University Health.
- 26:14For pediatric providers who may be less familiar, can you tell us about PANS,
- 26:19what it stands for, and how it is fundamentally different from primary psychiatric illnesses?
- 26:28Yeah, I mean, the term stems from—it's an acronym—Pediatric Acute Onset Neurological Syndrome. And—.
- 26:46You know, that's a description of something that happens in children that are
- 26:53generally, you know, either neurologically typical or stable.
- 26:59They may have other mental health conditions, but they're stable,
- 27:07and they seem to have an acute onset of a limited number of neurological and
- 27:16psychiatric symptoms, systems.
- 27:21Uh, among which the most common are movement disorders, uh, including tick disorder,
- 27:28and, um, obsessive compulsive disorder.
- 27:32And then there are a list of other things that are less common,
- 27:36but, um, can also be included.
- 27:39And, um, uh, and, and that, and that, and that's kind of the case,
- 27:44uh, definition, uh, of things, you know, how it differs from, um,
- 27:52you know, what you might call primary or garden variety tick disorder and OCD
- 27:57and, and, you know, other behavioral and neuropsychiatric disorders is I think
- 28:03the crux of the, of the controversy.
- 28:05Um, because, you know, those, those things are really not well explained.
- 28:11And, and so when you have a disorder that, um, you, you can't tell the,
- 28:17the, the family what the, uh, what the basis, uh, for it is and, um, um.
- 28:25And they don't respond to the typical treatment that's used,
- 28:31then that generates a lot of anxiety, frustration,
- 28:35and, you know, seeking behavior from the parents, you know, about what else can be done.
- 28:44So, when PANS and PANDAS was
- 28:49described and was proposed to be a disorder that was post-infectious or post-inflammatory
- 29:00and involved activation of the immune system and inflammatory pathways,
- 29:05you know, that opened up a window to doing additional diagnostic studies.
- 29:12And offering additional treatments above and beyond medicines whose primary
- 29:24mechanism of action is suppressing the symptoms through acting on the central nervous system.
- 29:33Um, so I think that's the key, the main gist of, of, of where we are now with, with this syndrome.
- 29:43You know, I got involved, um, it's kind of interesting that I,
- 29:49I, I used to get a lot of funding, uh, from the National Institutes of Health,
- 29:53uh, for, um, uh, basic research studies.
- 29:57And so they had my name on a list.
- 30:00And I got a call one time to go to Bethesda, Maryland,
- 30:05where the National Institutes of Health are, and be part of a panel to review
- 30:10one of the medical scientists that was working at the NIH campus,
- 30:17the so-called intramural program.
- 30:19And it was the laboratory of Dr.
- 30:22Susan Suido, who was the person who initially described and popularized the term pandas.
- 30:30And so I was sort of a blank slate at that time and sat on that panel and participated
- 30:39with some other outside advisors in reviewing the research.
- 30:45And, you know, we had some very lively discussions and it was obviously,
- 30:48it was a controversial, uh, area.
- 30:51And, um, but, you know, I, I, I took that information back and,
- 30:56and, um, um, you know, continued, continued my, my practice.
- 31:01You know, then and later, you know, maybe five or 10 years later,
- 31:06I was contacted by a friend of mine, an immunologist from Oklahoma City named Dr.
- 31:14Madeline Cunningham, who developed a battery of tests that were assessed in patients with PANDAS.
- 31:25And shown to have some usefulness in identifying which cases might be due to
- 31:33autoimmune activation by the strep or other infection.
- 31:39As a way of, you know, a back story, Dr.
- 31:46Cunningham made her career reputation
- 31:49in studying some very well-defined post-streptococcal disorders,
- 31:56particularly post-streptococcal heart disease.
- 32:03Rheumatic heart disease, as well as other post-streptococcal syndromes.
- 32:09Like Sydenham's chorea, which is even closer, you know, to PANDAS in terms of
- 32:15a post-infectious neurological syndrome.
- 32:20So I talked with Madeline and she started offering these tests in a commercial
- 32:26laboratory that she spun off from her academic work because she was getting so many.
- 32:35Requests to do the studies with the idea that, you know, if we could show that there was some,
- 32:42immunological activation, then that would justify doing immune interventions in addition to, and I.
- 32:54Try to dissuade families from seeking psychiatric help.
- 32:57In fact, I encourage it because symptom control is still important even while
- 33:06you're trying to do underlying immunotherapy.
- 33:12But in this case, didn't it sound like it made things worse?
- 33:16Or can you tell us what anything should have been done differently?
- 33:21No, I don't think so. So I don't, yeah, I mean,
- 33:24and that's a common story that I hear in the cases that reach me is that not
- 33:34only don't these medications work in some of these cases, but yeah,
- 33:40they actually seem to make the situation worse.
- 33:46And then, of course, in this particular case, and you may have gotten into it with the family.
- 33:52That engendered allegations of neglect and not following through with medical
- 34:02recommendations and that kind of thing,
- 34:05which then snowballed and really became a big mess in this particular case.
- 34:16And it sounded like that all happened when they finally got the prescription
- 34:22for the right treatment from you, and then they still had to wait because of the court battle.
- 34:30Yeah, yeah, that was part of it. But so what state was Ryan in when you saw him?
- 34:38And was there something right off, right when you saw him that clued you into,
- 34:44hey, I think this is what he needs? It's.
- 34:47Well, I, you know, it was just the fact that, that Ryan was so,
- 34:51um, disabled, you know, by any, um, definition.
- 34:57Uh, I mean, I'm, I'm sure the parents told you, you know, he wouldn't,
- 35:00he wouldn't wear clothes.
- 35:01He, he, he wouldn't, he wouldn't use the, the, the bathroom and the hospital room.
- 35:06Um, you, you know, he couldn't, um, uh, comply with any, uh,
- 35:11requests of the medical team, uh, without going through, uh,
- 35:15some ritualistic, uh, behavior.
- 35:17Years that were usually, usually had to be led by his mother so that he could,
- 35:21you know, get into whatever psychological frame of mind to, you know, uh, to do that.
- 35:27So, you know, so, so from the one standpoint, it was, you know,
- 35:31is particularly clear that he was, you know, kind of, uh, in an extreme,
- 35:36uh, uh, condition of, uh, of, of disability.
- 35:41And, and then there were some clues, in the medical record, and of course then
- 35:46we did the battery of tests that Dr.
- 35:49Cunningham runs that showed that there was evidence of autoimmune activation.
- 35:56So, you know, at that point, I recommended that we go ahead and,
- 36:03treat him as such. So.
- 36:12It was after you ran the Cunningham test, then you prescribed the antibody infusion?
- 36:19Yeah, IVIG, yeah, it's an infusion of antibodies.
- 36:23I mean, I think that the story that pediatricians here, is that this was a child
- 36:34that was previously normal or stable.
- 36:38Then they had an acute change in their behavior, and that that included certain
- 36:49items that raise concern, uh,
- 36:53that among the most common are, uh, a movement disorder, uh,
- 36:59including facial and motor and vocal tics, um,
- 37:04and, and, um.
- 37:06Um, obsessive compulsive, uh, behavior.
- 37:10Again, those are not the only ones, but, but those are among the major ones that are,
- 37:16that And then if there's evidence that they've had a streptococcal sore throat,
- 37:27strep throat, or other significant infection within that window,
- 37:34because it's, you know, it's not the infection per se that causes the symptoms.
- 37:43It's the body's immune response to the infection that, um, gets redirected,
- 37:50um, to the nervous system that causes the symptoms.
- 37:54And so that history of an infection during that kind of early period is the
- 38:08other thing that happened.
- 38:13Causes or should cause pediatricians to think about that as a diagnostic possibility.
- 38:20So an otherwise healthy... And some kids with mild symptoms will just respond
- 38:29to the treatment of the strep infection where it's present.
- 38:32You put them on amoxicillin or a simple antibiotic.
- 38:38Some people also add in anti-inflammatory medicines like we would do in arthritis
- 38:43or some other inflammatory condition.
- 38:46And their symptoms improve significantly and may go away and never come back
- 38:53or may come back with a recurrence and then respond to the same treatment.
- 38:59So it's only the most severe and long-lasting symptoms that we would even think
- 39:05about treating with immunotherapy.
- 39:10So what you just described, so in what case would you advise if,
- 39:15what needs to be happening to try the amoxicillin and go from there,
- 39:21what you just described?
- 39:23Um, well, you know, I, as I said, I mean, if a, if a child is having symptoms
- 39:29that interfere with, uh, day-to-day activity, you know, um,
- 39:35they can't go to school or they, they can't, uh, excel in school.
- 39:40Um, you know, they, they can't function within the, the, the,
- 39:46the family group, uh, because their behavior is, is, is out of the ordinary, um,
- 39:52you know, then, then, then those patients are, are the ones that are,
- 39:57you know, that have, that have concern. Mm-hmm.
- 40:02And then if it's lasting longer than how long, is it time to get an immunologist on board?
- 40:10And, you know, I don't really think about it in those terms because,
- 40:15you know, I'm at the receiving end, you know, rather than the referring end in those cases.
- 40:24And, you know, I rely on my general pediatric colleagues to tell me when a child is, you know,
- 40:37exceeding their comfort level, you know,
- 40:40outside of the 95th percentile, if you will, of what would be commonly seen
- 40:46in a general pediatric practice.
- 40:50I mean, you know, these are a lot of these symptoms are relatively common and,
- 40:57you know, I'm sure they don't all come my way.
- 40:59So, you know, they're, they're, they're being, they're usually being very well
- 41:02screened at that, at that level.
- 41:05So, in Ryan's case, though, it was still the right thing for him to be seen by psychiatry?
- 41:12Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely.
- 41:17Yeah.
- 41:19Right. I mean, symptom control is, you know,
- 41:27very important to, you know, try to make the patient more comfortable and to
- 41:32break the cycle, which is so disruptive to the family and that kind of thing.
- 41:40So, yeah, as I mentioned previously, not only do I not tell them not to go to
- 41:48a psychiatry, I encourage them to be seen by psychiatry, neurology,
- 41:53you know, whatever consultant in those related fields are available to them. You know, yeah.
- 42:08What happened in this case, in Ryan's case, though, where the parents are saying
- 42:13it went from what could have been an eight-month process to four years of a nightmare?
- 42:20What can be done better or differently next time? Or is it because his symptoms
- 42:27were so rare or so severe, which is a lot less common?
- 42:33That's a good question. What did they say?
- 42:36Um, they felt like it was just the right treatment was, was missed that,
- 42:42that a lot of the doctors who, um, were even knew a lot about pans.
- 42:48It wasn't until they saw you that they got the right, that panel test,
- 42:54uh, prescribed for him and the right treatment that you were the only one who
- 42:59really knew what to do. Yeah.
- 43:02Yeah. Yeah.
- 43:04You know, I get a lot of people that both in and out of the medical profession
- 43:09that say they don't believe in pandas.
- 43:12Oh, really? And my response to that is that medicine is not a belief system.
- 43:22While it is both an art as well as a science,
- 43:27medicine is based on observation, experimentation, intervention,
- 43:34and figuring out what works and what doesn't.
- 43:39And so I think –.
- 43:44Um, you know, the, the information is out there, uh, people that are not familiar
- 43:48with it, um, should, should review that information, review what's written out
- 43:53there and, you know, consider the source and, um,
- 43:57um, you know, uh, things like this, um,
- 44:01uh, interview and, um, podcast, uh, uh, are important to, uh, spreading, uh, um,
- 44:09awareness, uh, of that information, uh, is important.
- 44:14And, um, yeah.
- 44:17And, and, and, and so I think it, I think it starts, um, I think it starts there.
- 44:23So, the way his parents describe it, they felt like he cycled through the psychiatric
- 44:31care without improvement.
- 44:33Yeah. So, is the right way to have that psychiatric care plus see the immunologist
- 44:42as well as things are not improving?
- 44:45Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think as in many cases, you know, you give these things
- 44:52a fair try and if they don't go the way that you think they should go.
- 45:00You know, you either question whether your diagnosis is correct or you question
- 45:07whether there are additional therapies that are available that might be helpful.
- 45:15You know, when I was in training, I had a child neurologist at the Mayo Clinic
- 45:21tell me one time at lunchtime, what did he say?
- 45:26Something like, I'm paraphrasing now, but, you know, neurology is the branch
- 45:31of medicine where you observe the, no, you diagnose the obvious and you observe the inevitable.
- 45:37And I thought, wow, how cynical and fatalistic is that?
- 45:47And, you know, maybe we need to rid, you know, not just neurology,
- 45:56but lots of branches of medicine with that kind of attitude and thinking.
- 46:03Um, you know, you know, uh, things change, uh, new information becomes available
- 46:08and new understanding, you know, that leads to new treatment and, you know,
- 46:14uh, uh, eventually there's a, uh, a time where, where things, uh,
- 46:19uh, that were once considered, uh, uh.
- 46:23Uh, fringe, uh, uh, you know, left field, uh, kind of things,
- 46:29uh, becomes mainstream.
- 46:30I mean, I think we can all, um, uh, cite examples of that.
- 46:36When I was in training, uh, you know, if you had stomach ulcers,
- 46:40they would call a surgeon and you would have most of your stomach removed.
- 46:44Uh, now, now, now we know that most stomach ulcers are caused by a,
- 46:49uh, a novel bacteria that was discovered.
- 46:52And, you know, most cases of gastric ulcers are cured by antibiotics.
- 46:58So, again, I think you just have to change with the times and adapt and evolve.
- 47:12Yes. And they said that when he was in a psychiatric hospital, he wasn't eating.
- 47:18And so he would just lie on the floor for days and then he would have to go
- 47:22to another hospital to get an IV, um, so that he could survive.
- 47:27And then he would go back to the same setting for a while. It just sounds awful.
- 47:31Yeah. Yeah. Our, our, our, our medical system is not very well set up to,
- 47:36to deal with those kinds of, um, uh, situations.
- 47:43Yeah. It's not just an either or it's, uh, you know, it really requires a,
- 47:48uh, multidisciplinary kind of team.
- 47:55And again, you know, patients that are so disabled,
- 48:00um.
- 48:02Again, you may have to edit some of this for content,
- 48:06but I made
- 48:10a remark in the court hearing that we had where one of the psychiatrists that
- 48:21was involved had laid out this plan of psychological counseling and behavior modification.
- 48:28And, you know, I mean, I had just seen, um, um, Ryan on a couple of occasions
- 48:34and, you know, I was just obvious to me.
- 48:36I said, I mean, I said, you know, you're not going to talk him out of these symptoms.
- 48:40You know, he's just not, uh, you know, he's so severely, uh,
- 48:45impaired that, uh, uh, it's going to take, is going to take more than just some
- 48:49talk therapy to adjust his brain chemicals to, uh, you know, to make him better.
- 48:54And is that where, instead of it being behavioral, the symptoms were behavioral,
- 48:59but it's a medical issue that requires a particular treatment?
- 49:04Well, again, I'm speaking as an outsider, and I'm not trying to put down other specialists.
- 49:13Right, of course. I never understood why neurology and psychiatry were different.
- 49:18But, you know, they're both manifestations of brain and nervous system illness
- 49:25is just the symptoms are somewhat different.
- 49:28Dr. Gross wants to start a clinic, a special clinic that combines both.
- 49:32Well, you know, Sheldon is a free thinker and ahead of his time, just like I hope to be.
- 49:39So, yeah, we're on the same wavelength with that.
- 49:43And the other thing I have to say is one of the biggest areas of growth in my
- 49:50practice over the last five to 10 years has been not just in PANDAS,
- 49:55but has been in other neurological disorders, which are now well accepted to
- 50:03be manifestations of autoimmune disease.
- 50:06And so, you know, I get called for things that I never would have dreamed of
- 50:14being called about when I first started.
- 50:17You know, you talk about 43 years. That's a long time now.
- 50:20But, you know, things like intractable seizure disorders, things like behavioral
- 50:27regressions and Down syndrome.
- 50:28And, you know, there are a number of things that are out there where these syndromes
- 50:35are responsive to immunotherapy and either have been shown with, you know,
- 50:41documentation or are strongly suspected of being mediated by changes in the
- 50:48immune system and the inflammatory response.
- 50:52And Anthony, I know you said, and I know what you mean, where the pediatrician
- 50:59knows when to send to you, but I do get asked a lot, like,
- 51:03we want to know, when should we send, what can we treat in our office?
- 51:09Is there anything you want to mention there that could be helpful where they're
- 51:13seeing 40 patients a day often, and of course you don't want to miss anything,
- 51:18but you don't want the family to worry unnecessarily?
- 51:21Any advice there?
- 51:23Yeah, I mean, yeah, right. I mean, that's, that's why I'm not in primary care.
- 51:29You know, I like to take 30 to 60 minutes and, and, and, you know,
- 51:35have the luxury of doing that.
- 51:37And, and, and they don't, again, I think, you know, it's, it's listening, listening to the story.
- 51:44You know, there are, there are some things you can do to document strep infection
- 51:49in particular, whether that's a rapid strep test or culture,
- 51:54doing blood studies for streptococcal antibodies like the well-known ASO and
- 51:59anti-DNASB titers that can be done.
- 52:07And then, yeah, you know, in terms of therapy, I think many people are comfortable
- 52:13with treating with antibiotics.
- 52:15The two most common ones are used are amoxicillin and azithromycin,
- 52:21and using NSAIDs like ibuprofen and naproxen are also advocated.
- 52:28And then in patients that are significantly disabled or parents that are,
- 52:36you don't have exhausted trials of psychiatric medications and things like that,
- 52:45that's an appropriate time to refer.
- 52:48Do we know why some kids who get strep develop this and others don't?
- 52:53Yeah, you know, not well understood, but there are probably genetic factors
- 52:59of the particular strep strain that's involved.
- 53:05And there are probably also genetic factors involved in the particular host,
- 53:13the patient that's making that immune response.
- 53:16You know, the antibody response to infection is interesting from the standpoint
- 53:24that the antibodies that you make in the beginning of an infection can be very
- 53:31different than the antibodies that you make toward the end.
- 53:35And that's a reflection of the fact that the immune system fine-tunes its response
- 53:40to get stronger over time.
- 53:44Wow. So it's not confusing.
- 53:49When you say pandas and pans, it kind of can be used interchangeably.
- 53:56Because why? Do you want to explain that?
- 54:01Yeah, I mean, just because of observations that have been made over time.
- 54:08You know, it seems like the condition is not or can be triggered by infections other than strep.
- 54:23This family they talked about they thought it could be from a tick bite um,
- 54:32is is that possible you know uh i don't i don't remember that part of the story
- 54:37uh very well at at this point i i don't like all i guess they said all three
- 54:43i know you see so many patients but all three of their children had lyme disease
- 54:47so they're wondering if it could have been,
- 54:51it could have been triggered by Lyme disease. Yeah. Yeah.
- 54:55No, I, I, I, I, yeah, no, I, I, we don't know. I don't, I don't have any,
- 55:00I, I, yeah, I don't have any.
- 55:03We don't know. Comment on that. Is it possible or do we, should we not speculate?
- 55:10I wouldn't speculate. Okay.
- 55:16So when did you see Ryan improving? Was it pretty dramatic? or did it happen slowly?
- 55:27It happened over time. It happened over time.
- 55:31You know, some of the original descriptions of response to IVIG,
- 55:38which were also done by the same NIH group,
- 55:43showed dramatic improvement.
- 55:47And I have seen a couple of cases of dramatic improvement within the first,
- 55:51you know, few weeks of treatment.
- 55:55But I think in my experience, that's been somewhat exceptional.
- 56:00So my current practice is to at least try to get treatment approved for six months.
- 56:13Because I think, you know, in some cases, it takes that long to get significant
- 56:20or optimal improvement.
- 56:25But, you know, Ryan improved enough during that period that we were encouraged
- 56:32to push further with therapy.
- 56:38And, you know, as you probably have noticed, you know, Ryan doesn't live in San Antonio.
- 56:45So a lot of this was done through telemedicine, which, you know,
- 56:51which is a good use of that, you know, kind of technology.
- 56:54I've treated a couple of patients from different states, for example,
- 56:57and it was clear even from the videos that,
- 57:04you know, much like we're doing today, that he was significantly improved,
- 57:09that he was able to engage,
- 57:11you know, do things that he was just not capable of doing.
- 57:16He had clothes on for one thing. Wow. Yeah.
- 57:20I mean, that's a big change. It's, and your clinic is in university hospital, um.
- 57:31Do you want to explain or talk about anything else regarding the antibody treatment?
- 57:35It sounds so fascinating.
- 57:38Yeah. It sounds like this miracle cure.
- 57:46It is.
- 57:49Maybe it's the simplest explanation. So,
- 57:53antibody replacement therapy has a long and interesting history and was originally
- 58:02a niche treatment for very rare patients that don't make antibodies.
- 58:11They don't make any antibodies or they don't make antibodies very well and they
- 58:16get recurrent infections.
- 58:18So that was, you know, that was a very small, uh, well-defined, um, um,
- 58:27area for antibody replacement therapy.
- 58:33And then over time, people made some interesting observations that the replacement
- 58:43antibody therapy could also correct or improve.
- 58:52Um, autoimmune conditions. This was originally defined in a, in a, in a disorder,
- 59:00in a hematologic disorder called ITP, idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura,
- 59:06where the platelet counts go way down and people get bruising.
- 59:09Um, and, and they showed that when you gave the antibody replacement that the
- 59:14platelet counts went back up.
- 59:16And, and so this basically opened up a whole area,
- 59:21over the last 40 or 50 years where the IVIG or the antibody replacement therapy
- 59:30has really exploded and dwarfs the original indications for replacement in patients
- 59:39that don't make antibodies.
- 59:40So it's easy to understand how if you don't make antibodies and we give you
- 59:46antibodies from somebody that does make good antibodies, that you'll stay free of infection.
- 59:51But it wasn't clear initially why it corrected the platelet count in ITP or other blood disorders,
- 1:00:01why it suppressed the inflammatory response in some of these neurological conditions and other things.
- 1:00:09So now we know that.
- 1:00:13Probably the two main areas where the antibody therapy works are,
- 1:00:21number one, because it has strong anti-inflammatory activities.
- 1:00:28So it feeds back on cells of certain white blood cells that are involved in
- 1:00:36causing inflammation and signals them to stop.
- 1:00:40So it's an inhibitory signal for inflammation.
- 1:00:44Secondly, and probably equally important,
- 1:00:48especially in things like PANDAS and other autoantibody-mediated diseases,
- 1:00:52it dampens or shuts off the production of new antibodies, including the autoantibodies.
- 1:00:59And so it has a dual effect, which is very powerful.
- 1:01:06And combined with the fact that it's a very safe therapy,
- 1:01:12you know, it's essentially a natural human product that's repackaged,
- 1:01:20that it makes it a very attractive therapy, you know, for these conditions.
- 1:01:29Is it made from someone else's antibodies? Yeah, basically, it's a product of the plasma industry.
- 1:01:40So you've all seen plasma donation rooms popping up in strip malls and other places, right?
- 1:01:49And what happens to that plasma? Well, that plasma goes to a number of big companies that pool it, test it.
- 1:01:58Purify the various products, of which the antibodies are one of the main ones.
- 1:02:04And then it's sold as a product for use for these kind of conditions. Yeah. Wow.
- 1:02:16From your lens, Anthony, as an immunologist with so much experience,
- 1:02:21What's the take-home message for the community pediatric clinician who's watching
- 1:02:28or listening? Well, I think...
- 1:02:33Um, the, the, the take-home, I mean, I think we, I think we,
- 1:02:38we've been over the take-home message, uh, already, but just to,
- 1:02:42to, to re-edit, to reiterate, you know, it's to, um,
- 1:02:46be, uh, be aware of, of pandas, uh, pans.
- 1:02:50And, you know,
- 1:02:56when you see a patient that has an acute change in behavioral or neurological
- 1:03:04symptoms after an infectious episode.
- 1:03:09You know, consider that in the differential diagnosis.
- 1:03:15You know, we're not superheroes. You know, we don't, you know,
- 1:03:22this didn't take any kind of clairvoyance or, you know, anything like that.
- 1:03:30It's just a matter of being aware and being open to possibilities and,
- 1:03:44you know,
- 1:03:46trying to do what's been in the best interest of patients.
- 1:03:50It must feel so gratifying or how
- 1:03:52how does it feel to know when you've made such a big difference in a family's
- 1:03:57life in this child now adult ryan the adult his yeah it's all better it's it's
- 1:04:03it's it's very gratifying it's uh um humbling um at the same time um.
- 1:04:13Yeah, I don't, yeah, couldn't put any different than that.
- 1:04:19And what about this family who just, who didn't, the parents did not give up?
- 1:04:26It sounded horrible, but what is the take-home message for parents?
- 1:04:32Do you want to say anything there, Dr. Infante?
- 1:04:37Um, you know, there, there's a, there's a fine line, uh, between, um,
- 1:04:51Well, maybe that's not the right, right way to say it.
- 1:04:54Um, yeah, uh, uh, parents are, are natural advocates, uh, for their children.
- 1:05:02And, and I think, uh, doctors, pediatricians, other doctors have to,
- 1:05:08uh, uh, appreciate that.
- 1:05:11And, and every once in a while, you know, although I think, uh,
- 1:05:16you know, as professionals, We don't like to think about the old question,
- 1:05:24you know, what would you do if it was your child?
- 1:05:27Sometimes you actually do have to put yourself in that position and think about
- 1:05:36how you would respond to that.
- 1:05:39And we all know the saying in medicine, if you hear hoofbeats,
- 1:05:43it's a horse. Is that right?
- 1:05:45Not a zebra. But in this case, is it that this was the zebra or is it becoming,
- 1:05:50it's not. I don't think. Oh, I have it right here.
- 1:05:52So, so this, this, this pin, can you see it?
- 1:05:58It looks like it has zebra stripes. Yes. You see the black and white stripes.
- 1:06:02So, so this is a pin that was promoted by the immune deficiency foundation.
- 1:06:09And they had a campaign a few years ago. They called it the zebra campaign.
- 1:06:14And and and basically the the
- 1:06:17the point is just as you uh mentioned is
- 1:06:21sometimes when you hear hoof beats they really are zebras and and
- 1:06:24you know so if you if you dismiss that out of hand um you you know you're gonna
- 1:06:31you're gonna you're gonna miss some important opportunities to uh intervene
- 1:06:36in in a positive way uh now yeah most of the time they're going to be horses uh but,
- 1:06:43Again, you have to be aware.
- 1:06:47Dr. Anthony Infante with University Health and UT Health San Antonio,
- 1:06:51thank you so much for being here today on Pediatrics Now. This has been so great.
- 1:06:56It's been fun, Holly. Thank you for having me.