Latest / Newcomer Pod / Spaceman Explains to Earthman How Things Work (with Delian Asparouhov)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:04This week I have Dalian Asperohav, the cofounder of
- 0:08Varda and a partner at Peter Thiel's Founders Fund.
- 0:12Varda has sent a satellite into space and is planning on
- 0:16manufacturing drugs there. A really exciting company, and
- 0:21we dig into space startups more broadly.
- 0:24Give it a listen. Before that, a word from our
- 0:28sponsor, This episode is brought to you by Juniper Square.
- 0:32It's time to let go of the disjointed technology used in
- 0:34venture and private equity today.
- 0:37More than 1800 GP's now rely on Juniper Square to manage over
- 0:41$700 billion in investor equity. Juniper Square offers a unified
- 0:46solution for fund administration, fundraising and
- 0:50investor operations. Work with an institutional grade
- 0:54fund administrator you can trust and get a shared source of truth
- 0:57for all your fund and investor data.
- 1:00Learn more at junipersquare.com. That's JUNIPERSQU. are.com.
- 1:09Juniper Square, thanks so much. Now for my conversation with
- 1:12Dalian Dalian. Welcome to the newcomer
- 1:15podcasts. Thanks for coming.
- 1:17Thanks for having me Eric. Where I assume you're at Vardo
- 1:20right now. What's the background scene
- 1:22here? That's basically our facility in
- 1:24the background. So this conference room has a,
- 1:25you know, nice viewpoint and it happened to be the only one that
- 1:27was available right now. So where is the facility?
- 1:31It's about like 10 minutes South of LAX in this town called El
- 1:34Segundo on Aviation Blvd. It's literally like a Blvd. that
- 1:37is like filled with like we're on the same block as like the
- 1:39Space Forces. The headquarters here in LA,
- 1:40there's an Air Force Base down the street.
- 1:42Northrop Grumman and Raytheon, etcetera, all have offices
- 1:44within like, you know, 1/4 of a mile.
- 1:46When did you open it up? We moved in this office May 22,
- 1:49so-called a year and you know sort of 2-3 months ago and how
- 1:52many people roughly are working there?
- 1:55Right now we're about 8384 people fulltime.
- 1:58I think that's with interns and everything.
- 1:59Maybe gets up to like 8687. Somewhere around there.
- 2:02Has it hit you? I feel like I run like this
- 2:04little newsletter business. You know, I have an employee,
- 2:07but I feel like being at home really changes the vibe.
- 2:10And then when I go to like a friend whose company has like an
- 2:14office and use Lord, you know, it's intense.
- 2:17And then when I see this, I'm like, oh man, that must really
- 2:20hit you. Or what was it like to, like,
- 2:22open up an office like that? You know, at the time, I think
- 2:27you was actually more like existential terror and that you
- 2:31know it's going to be like a massive expense in that.
- 2:34When we were considering the lease and actually signing it,
- 2:36the amount that I was going to increase our burn was definitely
- 2:39not insignificant. And I definitely, at one point,
- 2:42you know, I think it's like the first time I'm revealing this
- 2:44publicly, there was actually a point where after we had already
- 2:46signed the lease, I almost wanted to like back out because
- 2:48like we're not ready. Like the company isn't going to
- 2:50do well enough to justify this. This is going to be the thing
- 2:52that like, kills us because like we like moved into a too big of
- 2:54an office too quickly. And then I actually called Matt
- 2:56Grimm, the COO over at Anderl. And I was like, bro, like how
- 2:59the fuck do you get comfortable with this level of like monthly
- 3:02burn just on the office? You don't even like
- 3:03accomplishing anything. This is just like like how is
- 3:05the people you like, let alone like actually investing into
- 3:08like the hardware and the things that like.
- 3:09Our customers are actually paying for.
- 3:11Yeah. And I think he's like, look, you
- 3:13just, you're building a startup, Dell, you have to bet on upside
- 3:16and the fact that it's going to work.
- 3:18If you keep thinking about what's gonna happen if it
- 3:19doesn't work, you're never gonna give yourself the opportunity to
- 3:21work. And you guys are clearly packed
- 3:23in like sardines to your prior office?
- 3:25It's a lot of effort for this type of company to switch
- 3:27offices. Like this isn't like a SAS
- 3:28company where you're just like swapping over a bunch of like
- 3:30laptops and desks. Like you can kind of see there's
- 3:31a bunch of equipment out there. That equipment is not something
- 3:33that you can like hire Joe's movers to go move.
- 3:35That is equipment that like needs to be uninstalled by a
- 3:38like a highly skilled engineer technician and then reinstalled
- 3:40at the new location, right. And so if you don't move into an
- 3:42office you can at least be at for like 2-3 years in the upside
- 3:45case, then you're spending a lot of effort.
- 3:47You know every single how many people could workout of this
- 3:49office it? Depends on who you ask.
- 3:51And you know what you know constraints You focus on you.
- 3:54We probably run out of parking. Yeah, like the like, you know,
- 3:5613140 mark, But we technically could jam in like, you know, 202
- 4:00fifty in terms of like, you know, desks and like office
- 4:03space. And so SpaceX did this back in
- 4:05the day where they actually like got a parking lot nearby.
- 4:07They would shuttle people. But I guess there was just some
- 4:09level of like morale hit because like you could just like walk
- 4:12out of the office and go to your car, you'd like walk out, wait
- 4:14for the shuttle, then get to your car, etcetera, even at a
- 4:16relatively small scale. So anyways, we have to, you
- 4:19know, figure that out. But I feel confident we've got
- 4:20at least another yeah. To two years at minimum in here
- 4:25and we've already had been here for a year and a half and the
- 4:26goal was it needs to be just something that lasts at least
- 4:29three years. I feel pretty good about even if
- 4:31we do have to upgrade in two years, you tweeted that you were
- 4:35you had a month July maybe where you're cash flow positive, is
- 4:39that right? What does that mean exactly?
- 4:42Technically it could mean that we just like received investment
- 4:44dollars and that was what caused our bank had to go up.
- 4:46They're like you know very simple term of it is just like
- 4:48if you look at you know sort of cash in the bank, you know the
- 4:5031st of the prior month and then the 31st of the next month, did
- 4:53basically that cash go up or down.
- 4:54It's a very so is it about investment dollars?
- 4:57Or it was not in theory one could have you know, done this
- 5:01with investment dollars. So that's why it's not that
- 5:02important of a metric because it confounds many of the different
- 5:05variables, right. It's nothing like free cash flow
- 5:07positive or even a positive etcetera there.
- 5:09This is why you have these type of terms, because you can't.
- 5:12Build this type of business just that simply however ours was a
- 5:15customer payment from that Air Force contract that we announced
- 5:17earlier this year and that payment was larger than our
- 5:20total all in burn that month. And so our bank account did go
- 5:23up because of customer payments. That's great.
- 5:25Yeah, OK. We'll talk more about Varda in a
- 5:28bit. LK 99, there is sort of the idea
- 5:31that there is a superconductor at room temperature.
- 5:35You know, people think a new maglev type train or certainly
- 5:39consumer electronics. You know you're working in space
- 5:42manufacturing. I'm sure you're thinking of tons
- 5:45of different ways you could put it to use.
- 5:47What was your initial reaction when you sort of read about the
- 5:51research paper in the first place?
- 5:53For the first 24 hours, it was definitely sort of like extreme
- 5:56curiosity. You know, my first reaction was
- 5:59go to our Chief Scientific Officer whose prior background
- 6:02was actually at this company called Liam Research that does,
- 6:05you know, phenomenal world class material science and helps
- 6:07basically bring mostly semiconductors to market.
- 6:09So he has a really strong background in the either sort of
- 6:11exact type of sort of physics materials that the
- 6:14superconductor was based off of. And so my first reaction was
- 6:17like, this could be a fraud, but let me just like go ask our
- 6:19Chief Scientific Officer. And his response was like
- 6:21there's a there like, you know, I don't have the time right now
- 6:24to like, you know, dig into this and validate it, but like at
- 6:26first glance. It's definitely possible.
- 6:27And so then I was extremely excited for the 1st 24 hours.
- 6:30Did you just say negative about it or I forget?
- 6:32No. I don't remember exactly.
- 6:34I know my emotional states at the various times.
- 6:35I don't remember my like tweet various times for the 2nd 24
- 6:39hours. I was extremely skeptical
- 6:41because there was a handful of the I think like if I'm
- 6:44remembering it was like certain graphs in the original like
- 6:48Korean paper just had some weird anomalies that made it look like
- 6:51it was fabricated data. The, you know, authors then did
- 6:54eventually respond and basically. 48 hours after the
- 6:57paper was published, then the first handful of like you sort
- 7:00of supportive comments started to come in and some of the
- 7:02dynamics are like the coauthors what why the drama there started
- 7:05to come out as well. So then I sort of got like more
- 7:07and more bullish and then basically have generally gotten
- 7:10more and more bullish basically since you know hour 48.
- 7:12So it was interesting roller coaster where it was like first
- 7:1424 hours elated 2nd 24 hours really depressing and then sadly
- 7:18basically improvement over the past like you know sort of 10
- 7:20days or so in terms of my and I mean you guys interest
- 7:23replicated it, right, I mean basically in some form or why it
- 7:27motivated you to sort of actually spend company time on
- 7:29it? Yeah, you know, I believe we
- 7:31were the first, yeah, at least like, you know, sort of public
- 7:35verifiable attempt at the replication.
- 7:37Yeah. I still think there's, you know,
- 7:38work to be done to verify whether did we perfectly
- 7:40replicated, did we get a sample, etcetera.
- 7:42Obviously there's work to be done, but you had little things
- 7:44standing up basically, right? There were some you know, and
- 7:47this could be explained by you know, different effects
- 7:50potentially. Yeah, I still say I think there
- 7:52is a decent likelihood that we had some non just you know,
- 7:57standard iron filings, ferromagnetic, you know, so
- 7:59sample in there. There's some either extremely
- 8:00strong diagnotism which is, you know, weird and of itself, a 1D
- 8:04superconductor, or potentially actually superconducting
- 8:06material in the sample. But yeah, we were the very first
- 8:09basically I believe you know again publicly, you know
- 8:12disclosed and verifiable Western let's say NATO country
- 8:16replication attempt. Why did we decide to do it?
- 8:19This is definitely much more on, you know, nights and weekends
- 8:21project than it was like a whole company project or anything like
- 8:23that. But yeah, there's just like a
- 8:24handful of engineers that you know, in the 1st 24 hours
- 8:27recognize that because of the type of chemistry that these
- 8:31Koreans were doing and the skills that were necessary for
- 8:34it, it had a oddly weird overlap with the work that we do with
- 8:37Varda in relation to biopharmaceutical solid-state
- 8:40formulation. And so we had all of the
- 8:42necessary equipment to do the replication already in our
- 8:45facility and some of the precursors were obtainable
- 8:48within called 24 hours to three or four days via commercial
- 8:52supply chains. So yeah, we basically decided
- 8:54you know a handful of the sort of engineers said hey let's like
- 8:57you know trying to do you know 19 weekends replication of this.
- 9:00Obviously our Chief Engineer, Andrew Mccaleb got, you know, a
- 9:02ton of attention on Twitter as he was publicly documenting.
- 9:04Great recruiting marketing. Certainly worst case scenario I
- 9:08imagine. Yeah.
- 9:09If you can see how what we can do nights and weekends over the
- 9:11course of eight days, imagine what we're doing here day in,
- 9:13day out. Yeah, we're really happy with,
- 9:16you know, sort of how it portrayed the company over the
- 9:18past, you know, 810 days. And then at this point,
- 9:20definitely sort of, yeah, handing off the project to sort
- 9:22of the academic and national labs where this type of work is
- 9:24sort of more appropriate to be done.
- 9:25The goal is to produce like this the Meissner effect, right?
- 9:28I would say the goal is to produce superconductors and then
- 9:31obviously in effect that superconductors have.
- 9:33Could be minor effect, but there's a wide set of
- 9:34applications of superconductors. I mean, right now it sounds like
- 9:38you're like this back to academia.
- 9:39You're not like, oh, this is going to be important to Varda
- 9:42in any meaningful way in the next couple years or?
- 9:45No, this stuff is you know, where the like, you know,
- 9:48transistor was, you know, in the, you know, very early days.
- 9:51There's still a lot of work that needs to go into like
- 9:53experimenting around the formulation of this, getting the
- 9:56yields higher, understanding how to get this from like right now,
- 9:58what is like crumbles of rocks into something that can actually
- 10:00be like used commercially, right.
- 10:02You know, even like the original sort of high temperature or
- 10:04sorry, you know, they're called high temperature
- 10:05superconductors. But the things.
- 10:07That, you know, can you know, operate at the temperatures that
- 10:09like liquid nitrogen is at. Those took like over a decade
- 10:11from like initial discovery to actually like large scale
- 10:13commercial use. And now they are use every MRI
- 10:16machine in hospitals. You know, Commonwealth fusions,
- 10:18you know Bill Gates's fusion company utilizes them at you
- 10:20know, significant scale. But yeah that took like a year
- 10:23to decade plus. And so it's just we're
- 10:24fundamentally A venture backed, you know, commercial company.
- 10:26You know, basic research is not necessarily the best place for
- 10:29us to be doing this. I do hope somebody I was, you
- 10:30know, texting with a friend earlier, lucky groom, about how
- 10:33somebody should create the equivalent of like fast grants
- 10:36for COVID. But you know, for LK 99 where
- 10:38it's like this stuff is more fundamental, basic research, but
- 10:42it could probably be done best outside of a truly traditional
- 10:45academic or like national lab setting.
- 10:46But it needs to be somebody that's like just funding it for
- 10:48goodwill because you're not going to see return on that
- 10:50capital for, you know, 5-10 years, you know, potentially
- 10:54longer. After our conversation, deli and
- 10:57tweeted, alas, the rocks we made floated due to iron impurities.
- 11:02We did confirm we were able to synthesize the lead appetite
- 11:06lattice, so it's not looking good for room temperature
- 11:10superconduction. I'm glad you brought up COVID
- 11:13because it felt on Twitter or X or a lot like that moment where
- 11:18Silicon Valley felt like it had caught on to something in a way
- 11:23that the rest of the world can sort of feel flat footed, right?
- 11:29And clearly with COVID, it panned out big time and ended up
- 11:34being a big prediction. It's harder to tell this.
- 11:35You know, to some level, you know, there's nothing wrong with
- 11:40just like enthusiasm on Twitter. It doesn't necessarily have to
- 11:42be world predictive. I feel like in the case of
- 11:45COVID, it became sort of a test case for, you know, media
- 11:50blindness and and sort of Twitter accuracy.
- 11:54But yeah, I guess, I mean you see the connection when I'm
- 11:57getting at there. I'm curious like, yeah, how
- 12:00predictive does this have to be? Or like, is it just like, it's
- 12:04fine to be enthusiastic here, regardless of whether this is
- 12:07like a world historical event or how much do you take sort of
- 12:11your enthusiasm here to be a sign that this is truly a
- 12:15significant research paper? Yeah, I think at this point it's
- 12:19pretty clear that this was Ito, sort of a field of academia that
- 12:22was somewhat discarded after the Soviet Union collapsed.
- 12:24They were by far the sort of world class.
- 12:26In this particular call it like shake and bake chemistry, you
- 12:28know sort of alchemy. Especially why you see that you
- 12:30know should Russian, you know cat anime girl Irish GB actually
- 12:33studied under one of the last Soviet Union professors that
- 12:35previously you know had a lab that was running this.
- 12:38And then the Koreans also had a connection to that original, you
- 12:40know, sort of last, you know, standing Russian labs.
- 12:42So I think it's sort of pretty clear that this is a, you know,
- 12:44sort of academic field that needs to be revived and in some
- 12:46ways again borrows a lot of you know, sort of analogies and you
- 12:49know, potential techniques from the biopharmaceutical world
- 12:51around. You can just make these like,
- 12:53you know, very disparate, unique salt state formulations.
- 12:55They're very difficult to predict in terms of how they
- 12:56interact, but they can have like very weird, you know, sort of
- 12:59effects. And again, it was just something
- 13:01that like hasn't been a field of study because it's one that is.
- 13:04Not particularly like theoretically sexy in that you
- 13:07it's a very practically applied, you know, sort of science.
- 13:10And then after you create things, you may be able to
- 13:12understand the theory behind them to dumb it down and tell me
- 13:15if this is wrong. But it's like you're saying in
- 13:16medicine and drugs, it's like there's a lot of value in sort
- 13:19of coming up with random drugs that might have uses without,
- 13:22like a clear theory behind why, right?
- 13:25And similarly here we could have an awesome material that could
- 13:27be really good for industry without it proving something
- 13:30about science that people are necessarily.
- 13:32Yeah, The biopharma world has like.
- 13:34No ego around. We're just gonna like throw shit
- 13:36at the wall and see what sticks basically and then like
- 13:38afterwards figure out basically what's going on.
- 13:40And in materials world, for some reason, especially around
- 13:43superconductors, that just hasn't been the way that people
- 13:45have sort of thought about things.
- 13:47And so I think what this has unlocked is in it or I would
- 13:50hope that it unlocks, is like the NSF funds a billion dollars.
- 13:53To basically create like if you look in like the early 2000s
- 13:55especially around small molecules which is the you know
- 13:57sort of primary drug category, think of like something like
- 13:59ibuprofen, it's a small molecule.
- 14:01In the like early 2000s there was a ton of effort basically
- 14:04around doing basically mass scale robotic creation of small
- 14:08molecules and screening of them that rather having to basically
- 14:10like rely on individual basically scientists doing by
- 14:12petting and process control and things like that.
- 14:14You didn't said have this like mass scale screening and now
- 14:16that's like an extremely standardized, like commoditized.
- 14:19Offering Even so much so that like we actually exported a
- 14:22decent amount of it to, you know, the Chinese like companies
- 14:24like Wushi for example. This is basically like they're
- 14:26either sort of bread and butter is like doing this stuff is like
- 14:28a service until one would hope that basically the NSF is
- 14:30recognizing, hey, there's a parallel pattern here here.
- 14:32We actually need to invest like a billion dollars into
- 14:34incentivizing people to actually go create this type of, you
- 14:37know, mass scale robotics. And it is gonna have to look
- 14:39very different than biopharma if you think about the temperature
- 14:40ranges, the types of. Elements that you're working
- 14:43with, they're very different than what you're working with in
- 14:44either supply form of these things are obviously like non
- 14:46organic, you know, metal compounds, they're being done at
- 14:48much higher temperatures. Some of these things have
- 14:50explosive properties And so there's like somebody needs to
- 14:52go create a robotic facility that does this stuff basically
- 14:54like you know at scale, you know safely to go figure out what is
- 14:58eventually that chemistry that really does produce like kind of
- 15:00like the blockbuster result. And then that's the thing that
- 15:02one day can commercialize. But you know, if I had to like
- 15:04put Finger in the Air guest gun timeline, it's like.
- 15:07Minimum two years, probably closer to like five years for
- 15:10that infrastructure to get built, somebody to find that
- 15:12formulation that actually is sort of viable.
- 15:14Then it's going to like begin the commercialization and like
- 15:17you know the early places will probably just be where
- 15:19superconductors are already used today like MRI machines like
- 15:22fusion etcetera. And it's going to be like a ways
- 15:24away until like you have like I don't know, you know, consumer
- 15:26floating skateboards or you know, whatever you want to, you
- 15:28know, think about, OK, so Varda, what is your focus at the
- 15:33moment? What are you trying to build
- 15:35today? So our goal is to basically take
- 15:37some of the research that's been shown on the International Space
- 15:39Station to have a ton of promise in terms of you know like we've
- 15:41been talking about solid-state formulation, it turns out
- 15:43solid-state formulation is significantly affected by
- 15:45gravity. That may also be true in
- 15:46superconductors. So one day down the line if
- 15:48somebody does discover these formulations, they're showing
- 15:50issues that we think gravity actually solve.
- 15:52There's the world where Varda flies a superconductor and, you
- 15:55know, four or five years. But definitely not anytime soon,
- 15:57given that the biopharma side is so much more sort of prove.
- 15:59Sorry, I'm gonna be dumb again to me.
- 16:01Solve state I think of like hard drives.
- 16:03Is that or what do you mean solid-state formation?
- 16:06Oh yeah. So if you look at basically
- 16:08what's happening, both the superconductors and what we do
- 16:10in like bio farmer world, you're basically taking things that
- 16:12were previously like very fine grained powders or liquids.
- 16:16You're basically making solid-state crystalline like
- 16:18versions of them. And so in the bio farmer world
- 16:20that ends up looking like a little bit of table salt that
- 16:22you take and it turns out that thing actually has like a either
- 16:24drug cancer molecule in or mRNA molecules.
- 16:27In the world of superconductors, it turns into these things that
- 16:29look like, I mean, you've seen the monitors Twitter, they look
- 16:31like these kind of like weird half ceramic, half metally shiny
- 16:34kind of objects. So solid-state is just what the
- 16:37form is. The matter, sort of in
- 16:39solid-state in particular, typically means it's a larger
- 16:41crystalline lattice structure, not just like individual.
- 16:43Small thesis, then, is that solid-state manufacturing is
- 16:47easier in space. Yeah, basically when you think
- 16:50about what is solid-state manufacturing, it's not just the
- 16:53individual atoms, right, being solids themselves, it's
- 16:56specifically what is that crystalline lattice structure
- 16:58that is formed as you're like melting down.
- 17:00This is why for example the superconductors are having this
- 17:01like yield problem where you have these like you know LAD and
- 17:04then either that copper, phosphorus, you know atoms.
- 17:06Occasionally they happen to arrange themselves in just the
- 17:08perfect state where they, like you know, appear to potentially
- 17:10creating a superconductor. You sometimes see the same
- 17:12issues in biopharmaceuticals where things arrange themselves
- 17:14in just the particular state where it then allows it to be
- 17:16like dissolved in your blood or delivered through the blood Bay
- 17:19barrier or allows it to be shelf stable on a shelf at a pharmacy.
- 17:22And when you go up to gravity, basically what you remove or
- 17:24what are, they're known as convective currents.
- 17:26And so to explain those sort of really quickly, if I basically
- 17:28light a candle in front of me here on the desk and I put my
- 17:30hand above it, I basically taught that as a kid, hot air
- 17:33rises. Why is that actually happening?
- 17:34You basically have this like combustion reaction.
- 17:36It's creating thermal energy. That atmosphere around it is
- 17:38basically becoming less dense because it's basically got that
- 17:40thermal energy getting transferred to kinetic energy.
- 17:42And when you're in a gravitational field, right, less
- 17:44dense gases or less dense liquids move to the top, right?
- 17:47This is why you're not as a kid. Again, the hot air rises.
- 17:50So let's take that same candle. Imagine you and I were on a
- 17:52space station. I light it, you know, in front
- 17:53of us. What actually happens?
- 17:55You still can light the candle and it's still basically like,
- 17:57we'll start that combustion reaction.
- 17:58The gas around it still gets hotter and actually, you know,
- 18:01becomes less tense. But there's no gravity to make
- 18:03it, like, go up or down, right? And So what ends up happening is
- 18:05instead basically that gas just very steadily diffuses
- 18:08throughout the entire room. So think about both.
- 18:10Again, This is why it's been kind of fun.
- 18:12This is the first time actually talking about with in parallel,
- 18:14but it applies to basically both, right?
- 18:15Imagine you have a bunch of lead or copper atoms or you have a
- 18:18bunch of like, you know, sort of, you know, carbon and the
- 18:20oxygen and hydrogen atoms or whatever you have in bio from
- 18:22the land. If you are thinking about what
- 18:24is a solid-state formulation, you're basically typically
- 18:26applying some level of like thermal energy to disparate atom
- 18:29structures. And those atoms typically have
- 18:31different weights. And so the lead might end up
- 18:33starting to move faster or slower than the copper does.
- 18:35And so because that one's less tense than the other.
- 18:37And so, just like on a candle, where you have that hot air
- 18:39rising. And they actually have cold air
- 18:40coming in typically at these like crystalline lattice scales.
- 18:43So not it's like the Super microscopic scale was just like
- 18:452 atoms attaching, but you're thinking about hundreds of atoms
- 18:48and how they form lattices, They're like dominant basically
- 18:50like what's knows, like a transport mechanism or basically
- 18:53the dominant factor that affects.
- 18:54How these atoms arrange themselves when you're in a
- 18:57gravitational field is convective pressures.
- 18:59So basically like how do they move either due to the thermal,
- 19:01you know, pressure versus when you go up into zero gravity.
- 19:04There is no up, there's no down, there's no convective pressures,
- 19:07and so instead you can actually heat things up and they just
- 19:09stay in a very basically like stable state.
- 19:11So in some ways you can kind of arrange them how you want, heat
- 19:13them up, cool them down, freeze them basically in that
- 19:15solid-state form that you want. You don't have these basic
- 19:17conductive pressures constantly moving them around.
- 19:20So this has been, you know, proven on the International
- 19:21Space Station. In the world of
- 19:23biopharmaceuticals, you're decently well.
- 19:24So one of the blockbuster results was done by Merck by the
- 19:27scientist Paul Reichardt. He basically showed that Merck
- 19:30has his blockbuster drug Keytruda does $25 billion a year
- 19:32of revenue for them. Right now it's a monoclonal
- 19:34antibody biologic basically just it's a drug that is very large.
- 19:38And simpler way of saying it and when this drug that is very
- 19:43large, they try to make a solid-state form of it because
- 19:45it's very large and basically flops around.
- 19:47It moves a lot when it's being like basically crystallized
- 19:50because it's particularly they does Merck make it in space or
- 19:53they just showed they could but they end up making it?
- 19:55Merck currently makes it on the ground and when they make it on
- 19:57the ground, it flops around so much that it makes these really
- 19:59large crystals that makes you are very varying in size,
- 20:01diameter, etcetera. It's because that it's difficult
- 20:03for them to control dosing when they give it to a patient
- 20:06because it breaks down and disparate rates in your blood.
- 20:08And so you end up having to go into an intravenous clinic every
- 20:10single day for anywhere from like 1 to 4 hours and actually
- 20:13have a nurse basically monitoring your dosing.
- 20:14So you get it appropriately. They're able to show on the
- 20:16International Space Station when they crystallize it because you
- 20:18don't have any gravity there. It's not flopping around.
- 20:20And so instead it basically just forms a bunch of individual
- 20:22crystals that are basically all the exact same size.
- 20:24And So what does that mean? I know exactly how it's going to
- 20:26dose and how much I can give you second incentive to basically
- 20:29send you home with a bunch of syringes.
- 20:30So Merck and Paul Reichart from Merck in particular approved
- 20:33this out on the International Space Station but they had no
- 20:34way of commercializing it because fundamentally a
- 20:36government run human rated space station is not not a place where
- 20:39even a company like Burke and say hey shut down the like you
- 20:41know, Dubai or you know, shut down like you know Saudi Arabia
- 20:44sending you know astronauts up there or the Russians instead
- 20:47let me take over this whole station and do mass
- 20:48manufacturing. Merck both doesn't know how to
- 20:50do that cuz they don't develop hardware and you know, NASA, you
- 20:53know, wouldn't let them, you know, do so.
- 20:54And Savarta's whole thesis was how do we take those types of
- 20:56results and allow companies like Merck to scale them up.
- 20:59And I think one of the most exciting moments for the company
- 21:01was on the day of our launch, we had a CNN article come out that
- 21:04unbeknownst to us, the journalist had actually reached
- 21:06out to Paul Reichardt at Merck. This, like, you know, world
- 21:08famous, you know, by the most famous scientists in
- 21:10microgravity, you know, pharmaceutical manufacturing.
- 21:11He had a quote in there, well, you know, tried roughly
- 21:13paraphrase, which is basically like the International Space
- 21:15Station was like a great place for me to do my initial
- 21:17research. But there are significant
- 21:19limitations and costs and cadence.
- 21:21I'm really excited by what, you know, Varta is working on.
- 21:22We don't yet have a contract, but we're looking forward to
- 21:24basically like. You heard it here first.
- 21:26Media. Good.
- 21:29Accidentally. Good.
- 21:31What's your capacity to do this right now?
- 21:33Or like how close are you to actually being able to
- 21:35manufacture anything in space? So we sent our first satellite
- 21:39up on June 12th of this year on a transporter mission with
- 21:42SpaceX. I think of those basically like
- 21:43the rideshares. A lot of what enables a company
- 21:45like Varda to work is the fact that, you know, even 345 years
- 21:48ago you basically had to book whole individual rocket flights
- 21:50entirely on your own. Those things were massively
- 21:52expensive. Instead, now I can basically do
- 21:54a rideshare flight which you know cost anywhere from caught
- 21:56like 5000 to $7000 a kilogram. To think about something that
- 21:59like Varta that you know weighs roughly 300 kilograms grams,
- 22:02you're talking about us being able to go to space for like 1.5
- 22:04to 2 million rather than like 30 or 40,000,000.
- 22:06That is something that is like possible with like a seed in the
- 22:08Series. A round versus obviously
- 22:10previously was very much so not possible.
- 22:12You're taking like a piece of manufacturing equipment for that
- 22:14much money. So that is just the like ticket.
- 22:17And then yes, we do also have to design the like manufacturing
- 22:19equipment and everything. So yeah, on our basically first
- 22:22mission it's about a 300 kilogram basically total
- 22:24satellite. You can think of it, It is about
- 22:25it like you know, a third of the satellite is basically what
- 22:28looks like a standard satellite, basically the infrastructure
- 22:30that you need to operate up there in orbit.
- 22:31So this is everything from like solar panels to a satellite
- 22:33radio to communicate with the software down at the ground, you
- 22:36know reaction wheels that allow you to keep the satellite
- 22:38pointed in the right place, basically all the infrastructure
- 22:40you need typically for a satellite.
- 22:41The second portion is basically yeah what you would think of as
- 22:43like manufacturing equipment that actually has basically all
- 22:46of the reagents and all the molecules preloaded on board.
- 22:49And the third part is basically a small reentry pod that
- 22:51basically brings those finished pharmaceuticals you know back
- 22:53down amazing. So we launched on June 12th, we
- 22:56executed that first manufacturing run I want to say
- 22:58somewhere around like July 6th or 7th or something like that.
- 23:00And then we're looking forward to hopefully being able to re
- 23:02enter. Right now, we're still working
- 23:03and collaborating with several of our government and commercial
- 23:05partners to work on bringing the capsule back, but we're looking
- 23:08to hopefully bring it back caught like you know late
- 23:10August, mid-september. And somebody.
- 23:11Paid you like the other companies, you're doing research
- 23:14on behalf of companies and government agencies or this
- 23:17first one was very much so like demonstration mission like show
- 23:20our customers that this type of thing is possible.
- 23:22Given that, you know, despite the fact that, you know,
- 23:24companies like Mercury have been super enthusiastic about these
- 23:26value propositions, I think they've been actually somewhat
- 23:28skeptical there would ever be a way for them to commercialize.
- 23:30And so they sort of needed, you know, an existence proof of
- 23:33something like VARD actually showing it end to end either
- 23:35before being willing. But.
- 23:36Do we know any confident, do you know worked yet?
- 23:38Or I mean, it partially depends on how it comes back, I assume.
- 23:41But so we know that the satellite generally worked quite
- 23:44well. We know that the manufacturing
- 23:46equipment, the analogy that my cofounder likes to give that,
- 23:48yeah, I like to use is imagine that in the world of farm and
- 23:51manufacturing, imagine that it's basically like a kitchen.
- 23:53And in the kitchen you have a whole series of appliances and
- 23:56you might have everything from a toaster to a conduction oven
- 23:58into a blender to, you know, a little scale that weighs your
- 24:01beresito sort of ingredients. On this first mission, we very
- 24:03much so built like a very basic, like toaster.
- 24:05It is basically the simplest appliance, you know possible.
- 24:08And all that I can tell you is that the like toaster did heat
- 24:12up and cool down as we wanted it to.
- 24:15I cannot tell you whether or not the toast inside got like fully
- 24:17burned to a crisp or not toasted appropriately, etcetera.
- 24:20But generally, as we know, toast does do certain things when you
- 24:24apply certain temperatures to it.
- 24:26So I feel pretty confident that the toast inside is like nicely
- 24:28baked. And now that toast also does
- 24:30need to basically survive reentry.
- 24:31So I'd say there were like three or four things we want to prove
- 24:33out on the first mission. We have been able to prove out
- 24:35roughly half of them already, but there are some, you know,
- 24:37future things we need to prove out.
- 24:38But even if, like the mission were to like die tomorrow, we
- 24:40still definitely, you know, sort of learned a lot that will make
- 24:42it even more likely the future missions are able to do
- 24:44everything that they need to end.
- 24:46When's the toast come back home? Basically as are I mentioning
- 24:49you know sort of working with our government partners to get
- 24:51that you sort of fully lined up. We have to work with both the
- 24:53FAA around approval and license to reenter the Utah Housing
- 24:56rating range, which is a military range that allows us to
- 24:59basically land in their land. And then Rocket Lab, which is
- 25:01our partner that actually executes the actual deorbit
- 25:04burn, basically the rocket small rocket engine that basically
- 25:06brings us back from space into the atmosphere.
- 25:09But we're, you know, normally targeting basically like a sort
- 25:11of late August every entry date. I mean, it's amazing.
- 25:14It's like a great thing you're doing.
- 25:15I feel like it's such an unambiguously, like awesome
- 25:19thing to be working on. I really from the outside, the
- 25:22whole sort of story of like the milestones and you're sort of
- 25:24talking about, you know, what would be sort of a viable thing
- 25:28and like what you remind me of the whole like SpaceX experience
- 25:31where I forget it was like a couple months ago where one of
- 25:34their shuttles like blew up or something.
- 25:36Do you remember that whole? What was?
- 25:37You know much more about this than I do I yeah, about this
- 25:40one. It's so hard for the, I guess
- 25:44the sort of layman world, myself included, to know like and
- 25:48believe like. Obviously, you know, my
- 25:50experience as a reporter, like every company tells you
- 25:52everything that happens in the most positive light.
- 25:55So it's so hard, even when you're like cheering for these
- 25:58things to know sort of as an external observer, what is a
- 26:02sign that the company is like on track versus like?
- 26:06What's not and like what's the level like yeah, I don't know
- 26:09what was your reaction to sort of, I mean the media obviously
- 26:12like the New York Times especially like frame that the
- 26:15SpaceX like blow up like super negatively.
- 26:18It seem right. Yeah.
- 26:20I think the layman's view in particular obviously the New
- 26:23York Times view is like completely you know sort of
- 26:25clueless and off base. What I generally say, you know,
- 26:27I'll maybe touch on a one part comment which is I think at
- 26:29least in aerospace it's a lot easier to like publicly verify
- 26:31how a company is doing in that the, you know, sort of the
- 26:34traction is not like oh, we're not gonna tell you our revenue
- 26:36numbers. We're like doing well and our
- 26:37software is good. It is like did the rocket
- 26:40launch, did the like spacecraft reenter?
- 26:41Those are like physically verifiable facts or you know,
- 26:43not facts. And so they can't really
- 26:45sugarcoat it, you know, as much as you can.
- 26:47And like software, you know world in relation to SpaceX
- 26:49thing, you know, maybe I'll provide a little bit of context
- 26:51here. So you know SpaceX is trying to
- 26:52develop an extremely ambitious, completely new rocket, right.
- 26:55So they have a rocket that we launch on Cuddle Falcon Nine.
- 26:57That rocket is a workhorse. It is not now exploded for like
- 27:00210 or 12 launches in a row, which is by far the most that
- 27:04any rocket has ever done in a row, by far the fastest,
- 27:06cheapest, etcetera, stay of this workhorse.
- 27:08That is like the safest thing that humanity has ever developed
- 27:11and is working really well. Yeah, they are trying to now
- 27:13build a new very risky rocket, but it is a new rocket that is
- 27:17even more capable. The reason this rocket is
- 27:19particularly interesting is you may be familiar with the Falcon
- 27:219 in that it actually lands a portion of itself back onto a
- 27:24landing pad. However, even though this is the
- 27:27best that we've done and it's the cheapest, it still is not
- 27:29perfect in that it still loses basically like the top fifth of
- 27:33the rocket every single time. And that's just how it's
- 27:35designed. Basically, that top fifth like
- 27:36basically burns up every single time.
- 27:37Is it like a one time use? So if you ever like heard, you
- 27:40know, Elon's basically like, you know, imagine you were taking
- 27:42like a 747 across the country and every single time, basically
- 27:45the 747 like completely disintegrated when you like
- 27:47landed on the other side. Air travel be pretty damn
- 27:49expensive, right? So we've gotten better for sure.
- 27:52Imagine it like most of the plane survived but like the
- 27:54cockpit fell off every single time.
- 27:55You'd like rebuild the cockpit every time.
- 27:56That's basically like how rocket travel like works today.
- 27:58So we definitely improved with this new rocket that Elaine's
- 28:00trying to make is basically like the full 747 goes all the way up
- 28:04to space, comes back and lands. It's a very difficult it's been
- 28:07basically single stage reusable rocket you know orbital rocket.
- 28:10So because it's so risky your SpaceX has taken the approach of
- 28:13rather than certain groups where they get stuck in infinite your
- 28:17decades long of sort of like analysis paralysis.
- 28:19They like try to engineer the perfect thing.
- 28:21Elon's approach which has worked very well if you remember the
- 28:23early Falcon rockets definitely exploded it blew up.
- 28:25His approach has been just, you know, ship things and do it and
- 28:28you'll learn even from, like, what is perceived as failure.
- 28:31And so if you were to pull most of hell, the Varda team or most
- 28:34of the team with, yeah, SpaceX, they worked on Starship.
- 28:36Nobody thought the thing was even going to get off the pad.
- 28:38Like, they thought I was just going to blow up, like on the
- 28:39ground. Basically before it even managed
- 28:41to get in the air. It made it way further than
- 28:43anybody expected. It made it through Max Q1 of the
- 28:45most difficult things. They basically actually, like,
- 28:46you know, basically failed around stage separation.
- 28:49And so I think to claim that it's like a failure is, like,
- 28:52insane to me, given that this is like the most ambitious project
- 28:55that like, humanity has ever taken on.
- 28:57It did way better than anybody possibly expected.
- 28:59Like, people thought it was going to blow up on the ground,
- 29:01let it up in the air. And then this is just like the
- 29:03state of engineering. Like you need to test things and
- 29:05obviously if it only works then you haven't been ambitious
- 29:08enough and ever like pushing the way forward.
- 29:09It's like the New York Times framing, but it is just like
- 29:11complete cluelessness to even call it like a space shuttle.
- 29:14Like you know failure type thing is like first the space shuttle
- 29:17was supposed to be the workhorse safe thing and that blew up.
- 29:20That is a different thing. Everybody in the space community
- 29:22knows there are no humans anywhere near that rocket.
- 29:24Like this thing is explicitly in development, right?
- 29:26Right. And in order to get to something
- 29:28that is safe, it originally has to be like unsafe to be able to
- 29:31prove it out and build it overtime.
- 29:32How much does Varda depend on Spacex's continued success?
- 29:36Like bringing down the cost curve, like could Varda work
- 29:40with the cost of satellite deployment today or are you
- 29:43counting on sort of further reductions in the cost of
- 29:47deployment? I would say at today's launch
- 29:50cost where we're spending the 1.5 to $2,000,000 either sort of
- 29:52per flight that is sort of more than low enough for us to be
- 29:55able to build a really strong sort of business around what
- 29:58we're currently doing today. So I'd say none of our business
- 30:01models the way that we think about the world are predicated
- 30:03on an any sort of future, you know, cost dropping.
- 30:05Obviously, you know, I'd be thrilled for either something
- 30:07like Starship to come online. I think that'll take some time.
- 30:09I'd be thrilled for either sort of more players coming to the
- 30:11market and actually start landing rockets.
- 30:13Nobody's really either sort of done that yet even though it's
- 30:15been, you know, 8 1/2 years at this point since SpaceX landed
- 30:17their first rocket. So I'm not counting you know, on
- 30:20it, you know, happening anytime soon and we've made sure to
- 30:22architect our business. So it's not you guys are
- 30:23predicated. On it, I'm going to continue my.
- 30:26Spaceman explain to Earth man how things work.
- 30:30But you know you hear people like worry about like, oh, is
- 30:34the sky gonna get to like cluttered like we had a UFO
- 30:38conversation that turned into like, oh satellite density.
- 30:41Like what is the capacity like? How much more crowded can the
- 30:44sky get with satellites? Couple of different ways to you
- 30:47should explain this. First, let's just think about
- 30:49like the Earth's crust. How crowded is it?
- 30:52I'm sure you've flown on a like 747 flight at certain times and
- 30:54you like stare down like the middle of like Kansas or even
- 30:56like, you know, you drive them currently in LA, if you like,
- 30:59fly two hours northeast of here, it is like a completely empty
- 31:02desert, right? So imagine that you only had a
- 31:04like single, you know, crushed equivalent of the Earth in
- 31:07orbit. You had to fit all the
- 31:08satellites on there. Well, the amount of satellites
- 31:09we've said obviously way, way smaller than what we've built on
- 31:11the entire Earth's crust. And even then, the Earth's crust
- 31:14is pretty like not crowded. And in space, by the way, you
- 31:17have a like a whole multitude of altitudes that you can be at,
- 31:20right? When you're on Earth, you
- 31:21basically really only be at a single altitude wherever the
- 31:23crust is. Basically, when you're up in
- 31:24space, you can be at 500 kilometers, 607 hundred, 800.
- 31:27So imagine a bunch of, like shells of the Earth's crust,
- 31:30each of which may hold its own individual satellite.
- 31:33There's a lot of room in space when you think about that way,
- 31:35especially because of the further way you get, the bigger
- 31:37the shell becomes because like the larger the shell is
- 31:40relative, you know, sort of to the Earth.
- 31:42Now I'll provide the caveat that things are moving much faster up
- 31:45there. And so because of that, even
- 31:47very small things, you know, sort of coming close to you or
- 31:50hitting you are much more dangerous than like a little
- 31:52pigeon, you know, basically like hitting you when you're like
- 31:54driving along a highway. So there are risks in that.
- 31:57And then the last comment that I'll make is also people under
- 31:59appreciate there are basically these like lower altitudes where
- 32:02things will basically like naturally decay because space
- 32:04isn't this like strict line of like atmosphere to no atmosphere
- 32:07and instead like actually like steadily basically decays.
- 32:09And so even satellites that are up in space still actually
- 32:11experience atmospheric drag with certain altitudes and so they'll
- 32:14basically like naturally decay. So there's sort of like this
- 32:16like self cleaning mechanism that the Earth has basically for
- 32:19a decent amount of the altitudes that we operate at.
- 32:21Now once you get up to like geosynchronous, where you're
- 32:23super far away from Earth, at that point, it's like, yeah, I
- 32:25think on the order of like billions of years, something
- 32:27like that to ever, like, clean itself.
- 32:29So is it a problem? Yes, it is something that you
- 32:32don't need to be managed with. Is it this existential thing
- 32:35where humanity is totally screwed?
- 32:37No. Is it well regulated right now?
- 32:39You can set up a satellite, leave it there or you need to
- 32:43sort of you're culpable if you're satellite collides with
- 32:46something, Yeah. It's not particularly like you
- 32:49know, there's some light regulations today.
- 32:50And like I think eventually what you want to get to is basically
- 32:53requiring people that send satellites to space either
- 32:56deorbit themselves or they have to set aside capital as a bounty
- 33:00for somebody else to come into orbit them.
- 33:02That way you could have basically these I cleaned up
- 33:03crews where you know, I send my satellite for, you know,
- 33:06whatever $1.52 million. But then I leave a like $200,000
- 33:10bounty and then whoever like you know, comes grabs me, ditches me
- 33:13in the atmosphere and they go on to like the next guy can make
- 33:16like money off of that. So I think that would be like
- 33:17the ideal situation that you have like some sort of
- 33:19regulating agency that handles the verification of that.
- 33:23But that type of regulatory framework require pretty you
- 33:25just sort of forward thinking probably like you know this is
- 33:27something that it feels like a vice president would be doing
- 33:29given the typically space stuff falls under the vice president.
- 33:31And so who knows, maybe even in the, you know, whatever next
- 33:34administration, there's a world where whoever ends up being VP
- 33:36tackles this is a project because it is roughly starting
- 33:38to become appropriate, timely to start to think about.
- 33:40Yeah, something like this. But yeah, nothing really today.
- 33:42In the Total Fun category and since I referenced it, do you
- 33:47have a view on this UFO situation or have you spent much
- 33:50time thinking about it? You know, I admit relative to,
- 33:52like, you know, some of my colleagues like, you know,
- 33:54Salana and crew, I definitely have not spent me to sort of
- 33:56nearly as much time on this. So I can't claim that my views
- 33:59are super sophisticated other than, like there's clearly some
- 34:01weird data. There's also some like mixed
- 34:03incentives in terms of like, you know, some of these people that
- 34:05are testifying in front of Congress might be just doing it
- 34:06for the attention. But yeah, they're also obviously
- 34:09some like, weird anomalists, you know, sort of, you know, videos
- 34:10and things like that have been published.
- 34:12I don't have like a strong opinion other than like.
- 34:14What's your percentage that the UFO's are aliens.
- 34:17I have this like, you know, somewhat net new conspiracy
- 34:19theory that like I actually think that what we're, you know,
- 34:22seeing is actually an intelligent life that lives on
- 34:24our same planet. But it's like a like, you know,
- 34:25Atlantic style, like under the Pacific Ocean.
- 34:28Because if you look at this recycle whole half of the Earth,
- 34:30like you can actually look at the Earth.
- 34:31If you look at just the Pacific, it's basically literally almost
- 34:33entirely like, you know, water. And it could have not been
- 34:36water. You know dolphins just.
- 34:38Yeah. Or something that we like.
- 34:39You know, yeah. Some off branch of humans that
- 34:41like you know discovered, you know, some set of technologies
- 34:44you know 10,000 years ago and like advanced very rapidly in
- 34:47isolation and then decided to isolate themselves.
- 34:49Or would you give that a percentage chance?
- 34:52Hard to like give like a betting odds, but yeah, I don't know
- 34:5415%. But you think majority, it's
- 34:56like some military vessel or something or no, not
- 35:00necessarily. Like I think it could be like
- 35:02some sort of radionominally some sort of like physics phenomenon
- 35:04that we don't appreciate or something where it's like you
- 35:06know, ball lightning or something like that.
- 35:08We're just like some crazy freak edge case of like
- 35:10electromagnetism that we just don't totally understand yet.
- 35:13So my guess is more like freak, you know, edge case of the
- 35:16universe. You're convinced it is a real
- 35:18physical phenomenon that people. Yeah, I think there is a real
- 35:20physical phenomenon. There's like way too any, like
- 35:22you sort of, you know, instances of this, but I'm not convinced
- 35:24that it's necessarily like an intelligent, you know, thing
- 35:27that is causing it. Back to our serious part of the
- 35:30car. Like what's the Air Force and
- 35:31what's NASA like paying you for? What are these contracts like,
- 35:35given that you're still in the early development of
- 35:37manufacturing? Yeah, so the Air Force and NASA
- 35:40are not paying us for anything manufacturing related.
- 35:42Basically if you remember I gave that you know, sort of three
- 35:45parts spacecraft summary before the like satellite, the
- 35:47manufacturing and the net reentry pod.
- 35:50That reentry pod has been of significant interest to various
- 35:52groups within the government. Because basically when we're
- 35:54coming back, because we don't have any humans on board, we
- 35:57come back basically at much higher sort of speed G load, you
- 36:02know, sort of heat flux basically like they're on
- 36:04thermal energy that's being, you know sort of created.
- 36:06Then what a vehicle that has typically humans on board.
- 36:09Like, if you think about the ones that have humans on board,
- 36:10they're kind of trying to like surf their way into the
- 36:13atmosphere so that they like just steadily slow down and
- 36:16they, you know, astronauts don't experience too many G forces and
- 36:18they keep everybody alive. We don't have a hues on boards.
- 36:21We're just like screw it, rip it just like, you know, dig right
- 36:23in. And so because of that, we
- 36:25experience an environment that is very useful both for groups
- 36:28like NASA to basically test out like new heat Shields that they
- 36:30want to use for like a marvelous mission, as well as groups like
- 36:33the Air Force. They want to actually be able to
- 36:34use this as a way to basically test out, for example, like they
- 36:37want to build hypersonic interceptors to intercept.
- 36:39You know, China is basically hypersonic boost glide like
- 36:41space missiles. And so they use us as a way to
- 36:44test out, OK, how do we build out like sensors and navigation
- 36:46equipment and heat Shields and wing shapes and things like
- 36:49that. So you kind of think of it as
- 36:51like imagine like you were trying to build an airplane
- 36:53before there was a wind tunnel. And every single time in order
- 36:55to test it, you basically just have to like throw it out in the
- 36:57air. That's basically what we're
- 36:57doing anytime we're trying to build these hypersonic like
- 36:59interceptor systems. And so we're basically that wind
- 37:02tunnel where instead you go and test things out that when you go
- 37:05and build the full hypersonic interceptor, you feel really
- 37:07confident. And so if like, you know, the
- 37:09Wright brothers are like Boeing didn't have a wind tunnel to be
- 37:11a huge pain in the ass right now, it's a huge pain in the ass
- 37:13for the government. They basically don't have a,
- 37:15like hypersonic wind tunnel. And VARD is basically they, you
- 37:17know, sort of closest equivalent to what you can get to a
- 37:20hypersonic wind tunnel, given how quickly we come in.
- 37:22The wind tunnel is the you're the experiment that they can
- 37:25test like they would in a wind tunnel or.
- 37:28We are the wind tunnel. Or they're literally like
- 37:30following behind you and using there ain't like, imagine that
- 37:33our reentry capsule is the wind tunnel.
- 37:35They're inside the capsule being rested.
- 37:37So like they're the capsule is the wind tunnel.
- 37:40Like blocking. Yeah, exactly.
- 37:42So like they might test different things.
- 37:43They might test a wing inside of that wind tunnel.
- 37:45They might test like a piece of like sensors and equipment.
- 37:48You know, it's basically, you know, each of the various like
- 37:49government customers is different things that we touched
- 37:51and we figure out where to put them in the wind tunnels that it
- 37:54like gets the test that they want basically.
- 37:56And so we basically do all our farmer manufacturing and we come
- 37:58down and if we just only had our pharmaceuticals on board, we
- 38:01just look like a you know, sort of boring, you know reentry
- 38:03capsule. And instead we have a bunch of
- 38:05things sticking out in like in various places, basically to
- 38:07like touched out for the sort of DoD in NASA.
- 38:11What's your. And I don't know how open you
- 38:13would be on this now that you have government contractors.
- 38:15But what's your general like view of what pieces of space are
- 38:20best for like private industry and which parts are like best
- 38:25sort of in government and like how effective you think sort of
- 38:28NASA is today. I guess is it.
- 38:31Yeah. If we're going to go like NASA
- 38:32specific, you know, rather. Yeah.
- 38:33I think you're asking like a broad government question.
- 38:35But for NASA. If I were to, you know, sort of
- 38:37give a general, you know, sort of pitch and philosophy on what
- 38:39I think NASA should be doing, I think they should continue to
- 38:41lean into the things that are just like very far out and
- 38:45difficult true basic research and science.
- 38:47So it's like you don't lean into like helicopter on Mars, super,
- 38:51like probably the coolest thing that humanity's made in like the
- 38:53past two or three years. Like take that like little drone
- 38:56and turn it into like human scale helicopters that like, you
- 38:59know, when we lay in humans there, we're doing that and they
- 39:00are starting to already like work on that.
- 39:01That team is getting like a huge boost in, you know, funding, you
- 39:05know? Just like a helicopter works in
- 39:07Martian atmosphere, basically. Yeah, we've already proven that.
- 39:10So you know, they landed a mini helicopter alongside the Rover
- 39:13in the last Mars Rover mission. That helicopter has now been
- 39:16flying for like, you know, forgive me if it's taken, but I
- 39:19probably guess like 15 or 16 months or so it is covered like
- 39:22a more ground than all of our Rovers over the past 30 years
- 39:25like combined, basically because it flies and by the way it flies
- 39:28on a different planet, like it is a thing that humanity has
- 39:31done. We like made it.
- 39:32And by the way, in order to fly in like that thin of an
- 39:35atmosphere, like it's like wing tips are going like Mach four or
- 39:38something like that. So it's like I call it a
- 39:39helicopter, but it's like closer to like a like jet engine
- 39:43helicopter that you know is like just spinning crazy fast blades,
- 39:46but it's like really like you. They literally, they have like a
- 39:48video where they basically had the Rover filming the helicopter
- 39:51taking off and landing. So like there are like videos
- 39:53not from like it has onboard cameras that are like pretty
- 39:55good, but there's like an off board camera like the Rover that
- 39:59like does it. And like, watching a video of a
- 40:00helicopter on Mars is probably like the coolest experience one
- 40:02can have. So NASA do do that.
- 40:05Yeah, keep doing, you know, sort of that stuff.
- 40:07And then they have a portion of their mandate which is basically
- 40:10like kickstart the like, you know, economic flywheel of
- 40:13humanity expanding into space. They did a really phenomenal job
- 40:16of that with basically like launch services, right.
- 40:18So basically like rather than saying like here's how you
- 40:20should go build your rocket, here's how you should go
- 40:23basically like resupply the International Space Station,
- 40:25instead, they said we'll pay you like, you know, $50,000 per
- 40:28kilogram. Do you get to lower Earth orbit
- 40:30and we'll pay you $200,000 per kilogram that you basically like
- 40:33deliver to the International Space Station?
- 40:35Without what you wish basically. And so that's how you've seen
- 40:37the success of programs you know like commercial resupply, like
- 40:40commercial launch. And so now they're starting to
- 40:42think about how they do that serve basically for future
- 40:44programs that I think they should continue to have this
- 40:46like split world where basically like everything that is sort of
- 40:48like close to earth and in the realm of what like venture
- 40:51backed companies should do, can do, they should basically just
- 40:55act as the first buyer in the marketplace.
- 40:57And that's what kick starts to supplies that, you know, the
- 40:59early days maybe NASA was buying most of SpaceX launches, but now
- 41:01companies like Varda can buy Spacex's launches.
- 41:04Do the same thing for these like you know, sort of Commercial
- 41:06Services, be that first like guaranteed buyer and then don't
- 41:10focus on engineering as much there.
- 41:11Just be a buyer and then focus all the engineering, basic
- 41:14science that are on the things that are like super far out.
- 41:16Like who do you think would do a Martian mission like the
- 41:19government or SpaceX? Right now it's just the
- 41:22government that is like you sort of playing on those and I think
- 41:24that is the place where they should continue to play in.
- 41:26Same thing with like, you know, the first lunar base will be,
- 41:28you know, done by the government as well.
- 41:30I feel like one of the challenges when NASA or like the
- 41:33government does something, like I feel like every American can
- 41:37feel like some sense of like ownership over it because it's
- 41:40like their money. It's their part of it in some
- 41:43ways. Like, I don't know if I'm
- 41:44incriminating myself with this view or not.
- 41:46Like when SpaceX does something it can feel like you have to
- 41:51like go and like say Elon's Grit.
- 41:53Like it's like it's almost like you're obligated to like go
- 41:56thank this sort of like strong man billionaire instead of when
- 42:01the government like does something it feels like, oh
- 42:04that's like us. Or like, do you think there's
- 42:06like part of the barrier to sort of national sort of popular
- 42:11embrace of sort of the space exploration stuff is this
- 42:15private enterprise and that it's done in a way that sort of the
- 42:18regular person feels like irrelevant to?
- 42:22Well. I mean, there are plenty of
- 42:24political polls that show that Elon Musk is the most favored
- 42:27like public figure in the United States.
- 42:29So I would argue that your entire thesis is flawed,
- 42:32basically, which is, you know, Elon does the best job of any
- 42:35figure of making the public populace feel like a part of
- 42:39space exploration. Even better than any other
- 42:42government. It's very much like it's a
- 42:43strong man. Like he gets the credit for it.
- 42:46Like even more. I don't even more than like the
- 42:48SpaceX engineers and stuff. It's a very central like the
- 42:51story that humanity is telling is one of the brilliant sort of
- 42:55Elon Musk taking us there. Yeah, I mean, that's
- 42:58collectivist. Always been true in history is
- 43:00that like stories are. The Great Man is always the
- 43:03easiest sort of story to tell rather than the collective, but.
- 43:07Yeah, yes. I'm not sure entirely where the,
- 43:08you know, sort of like how to answer the question.
- 43:10Oh yeah, It's not a very pointed question.
- 43:12It's just something I'm like I struggle with or it's like on
- 43:15the one hand I want. I mean, yeah, I guess I'm not
- 43:17gonna let ideology get in the way of cheering for something
- 43:20that I'm. Yeah, I guess it's like
- 43:22struggling with, like, the sky being blue.
- 43:23Like I say like, you know, go talk to your therapist.
- 43:25But like, you know, it's like a law of physics.
- 43:27So I assume you watch Oppenheimer.
- 43:29Like, I mean the reality of SpaceX is that there are a lot
- 43:32of people like doing it. He's doing a lot of things.
- 43:35Like some of it is there's sort of the myth building around one
- 43:38person, but the reality is like they are collective endeavors.
- 43:41Yeah, I don't know. I feel like just like the
- 43:43stories that are paired with the scientific accomplishments of
- 43:48our time is injure. The one telling the stories,
- 43:51change the narrative. Go go interview.
- 43:52Like you're telling the stories as well, I mean, yeah.
- 43:57I mean we highlight our team members, you know, we have
- 43:59Andrew Mccale up, you know, out and doing public interviews and
- 44:01talking about things. We I think do a pretty good job
- 44:03of like highlighting like the broader talent of art of beyond
- 44:06just like the founding team. And I would you know put it on
- 44:08the media of like, you know, I don't know like the information
- 44:10did like this like profile police on Gwyn Shotwell who's
- 44:12like one of the most like phenomenal executives, you know,
- 44:15in the space industry. And like her article was like
- 44:17half like a takedown article. So, you know, I would put it on
- 44:20like the onus of like, yeah, being journalists should do a
- 44:23better job of. Recognizing that there are a
- 44:24collective of people that you know contribute significantly to
- 44:27SpaceX, and they aren't highlighted or appreciated well
- 44:30enough. Like people should be banging
- 44:31down Gwyn Shotwell's door to be like routing books about her.
- 44:33And people don't, I'm sure. Well, I'd happily write a book
- 44:37about her, you know, I feel like she's probably hard to access,
- 44:40but yeah. Maybe because people write
- 44:42takedown pieces about her. How do you think there's, you
- 44:44know, yeah, the media can't sort of help itself, but sort of have
- 44:49sort of a negative angle at any given moment.
- 44:51It does. For some reason, media loves to
- 44:53destroy powerful women. I don't know why do you think
- 44:55it's women specific or it's just yeah, I think stories.
- 44:58There's definitely a trend of like every strong woman founder,
- 45:01every strong woman like aerospace leader, like gets torn
- 45:04down by the media for some reason.
- 45:06Yeah, I mean, I agree. I agree that no quibble on that
- 45:09that there was like especially you know the startup founder.
- 45:12Period. Yeah, like the away story, the
- 45:13Outdoor Voices story. Like there was so many of these
- 45:16that were just like complete nonsense.
- 45:19Do you, I mean, do you think are you supportive of like Musk's
- 45:23time spent on X Twitter like or do you think it is sort of a
- 45:27detriment to SpaceX? I think he's a phenomenal
- 45:31entrepreneur and you know, it's not up to me to judge where and
- 45:34how he spends his time. If he's like most intrigued by
- 45:37and things that like X is going to be the most impactful, like,
- 45:40you know, good on him and I think.
- 45:41You know, he obviously is still a phenomenal visionary and
- 45:44leader for SpaceX. But also the company is like in
- 45:46a very mature state where it has a really great set of leaders,
- 45:48including people like Quinn Shotwell and you know, seems to
- 45:51be making really phenomenal progress.
- 45:52So, you know, I don't think that like, you know, the marginal
- 45:55hour that he spends on like Twitter is somehow like
- 45:57preventing Starship from coming online or anything like that.
- 46:00So, you know, I think Starship is just like a very difficult
- 46:03project and that is just going to take a series of cycles and
- 46:05iterations and it's really exciting to see what's happening
- 46:07at Boca Chica and the progress that's being made there.
- 46:09But you know, I don't think that like.
- 46:11Twitter is somehow preventing that progress from happening.
- 46:15You got promoted at Founders recently?
- 46:16Yeah, Yeah. And it's like new set of funds
- 46:18and I think we announced it late May, June time frame.
- 46:22How do you do both? Or yeah, it's certainly a lot of
- 46:25time. Yeah, I think it's mostly that
- 46:27like 1 + 1 = 3 in that I think part of what allows me to, I
- 46:32think do decently in both roles is.
- 46:35There are times where when I'm working at VARDA, there's a huge
- 46:37sort of upside to having the Founders Fund.
- 46:39You're sort of brand and they like investing your sort of hat
- 46:41on whether it be when I'm fundraising on behalf of VARDA,
- 46:44when I'm on Capitol Hill meeting with particular, you know,
- 46:46Congressional figures that may have a lot of respect for the
- 46:48Founders Fund name but may or may not have actually heard
- 46:50about, you know, VARDA quite yet to my ability to understand the
- 46:52broader landscape and you know how things are going in
- 46:54airspace, in the airspace world given that.
- 46:56Not only do I know how VARD is doing but I also know how a lot
- 46:59of the like you know near peer companies are doing as well.
- 47:01And so that really unlocks an inside of like where are we in
- 47:04terms of headcount, burn revenue etcetera relative to like you
- 47:07sort of certain peers. And I think having that broader
- 47:09perspective makes me very effective at VARDA.
- 47:11And then on the flip side, you know on the Founders Fund side
- 47:13of things, you know, being the man in the arena I think is I
- 47:15think that makes me both the most helpful to founders that
- 47:17are starting companies. And just significantly
- 47:20increases, they're like it's a top of funnel of people that are
- 47:21interested in working with me conversion rate you know all the
- 47:24way down through making investing.
- 47:25So although over the past year since starting Varda about three
- 47:27years and if we spent less time on the investing sort of role, I
- 47:31actually think I've been able to sort of deploy just to have a
- 47:33pace and with just as great of IRR if not higher than where I
- 47:37was sort of before. I think it's a unique set up for
- 47:39two reasons. Which is 1, obviously, being a
- 47:42part of a platform like Founders Fund, that is very encouraging,
- 47:44basically, of this type of role, right?
- 47:45If you look at our team, it's almost like half the team now
- 47:47that is in this type of role where they're actively basically
- 47:49building something alongside investors and Peterson, chairman
- 47:52of, Yeah, Flexport, yeah. Trey Stevens, Keith Redboy.
- 47:56I'd argue Peter Thiel as well. And then I think the other thing
- 47:59that's Peter's company. You know I can't claim that I
- 48:02have a specific one in mind right now more that he does
- 48:04spend a lot of time with certain like biotech companies that is
- 48:06this has been publicly reported on where he's like you know
- 48:09Chairman and I'm not like super deeply familiar with it.
- 48:11But there are like a handful of biotech companies where he goes
- 48:12like very, you know, sort of deep the life extension type or.
- 48:16I don't think any of them are life extension related.
- 48:18One of them was like an antibodies company, but I'm not
- 48:19even like that, Deeply familiar with the company, but OK.
- 48:22Anyway, sorry. Oh.
- 48:22Yeah, no problem. What I was going to say is I
- 48:25think at least when I think about when is it sort of worth
- 48:27incubating something and actually you're subjecting
- 48:29yourself to the torture of two jobs.
- 48:31You know, when you I think fit a certain set of criteria, one is
- 48:34the company that you're going to incubate isn't something that is
- 48:37already available on the market. You could just like invest in,
- 48:39give it the opportunity. Cost of building something is
- 48:41like massive. To it's something that is like
- 48:43uniquely suited to be incubated and built by venture capitalists
- 48:46in that it's something that either like your ability to
- 48:48fundraise because it's capital intensive or your ability to put
- 48:51together disparate talent that may not come together otherwise
- 48:53makes it a company possible. And then third, ideally that
- 48:56this is a company that is also any category that you're highly
- 48:59interested in investing in. So that by basically working
- 49:01deeply in this category you could assess things more easily
- 49:03and you get basically the best top of funnel.
- 49:05And so for me Varta sort of fit all three of those categories
- 49:07where there wasn't really anybody working on it.
- 49:08It's going to be capital intensive and I can help
- 49:10basically put together the financing.
- 49:12And three, I was highly interested in investing even
- 49:14more in aerospace than I was before.
- 49:16And So what better way to basically have as much top of
- 49:18funnel and like access an aerospace than starting a
- 49:20company. And so I think you know, it's
- 49:22rare to, you know, I feel very, you know, fortunately grateful
- 49:24to find myself in this situation where I am able to balance these
- 49:26two. You think there's you should
- 49:28have a million different variations of this that you know
- 49:30wouldn't quite work, but the particular variation that I'm in
- 49:32right now sort of happens. It happens to work.
- 49:34What are your main investments? I founders fun I've made.
- 49:38If you look at top performing over the course of my entire
- 49:40investing career, both at Founders Fund and Coastal
- 49:42Ventures, at Coastal Ventures that led the Series A of Sword
- 49:45Health and then continue to double down at it from Founders
- 49:48Fund, that company was last valued at roughly $1.8 billion
- 49:51and we originally invested in the Series A at 25 posts and
- 49:54then it founders when I moved over it, I believe like 40
- 49:56posts. I also, you know I worked
- 49:58alongside Keith, but did Source Ramp Financial their original
- 50:02basically both Seed and Series A round was the point person on
- 50:05both of those where we originally invested again in
- 50:08similar roughly price points to Sword and ultimately obviously
- 50:11that company was last valued at $8 billion in their last
- 50:14financing. These are probably the two,
- 50:16let's say you know unicorns and there's a whole you know set of
- 50:19like let's say mid stage companies that are you're
- 50:21tracking relatively well. Lula for example insure tech in
- 50:23Miami just and as their series be Hadrian another aerospace
- 50:26company sort of down the block cover this home building company
- 50:29in LA. Those are some of the examples
- 50:31in the mid stage range. Don't want to deprive our
- 50:33listeners of your wonderful tweets.
- 50:35You had a great one. Imagine having to wake up every
- 50:37day and work in sass while the world is regularly landing
- 50:40orbital rockets, reading life into silicon and synthesizing
- 50:44superconductors using Alchemy. And then Roon.
- 50:47Always, the troll says. Now tell us how you really feel
- 50:49about corporate cards. Are you guys writing off Sass or
- 50:53like? I mean, I know that just comes
- 50:54from you, but what is sort of the view over Founders Fund on
- 50:58software investments right now? That's very much so my personal
- 51:01view and it more has to do with my personal innovation than
- 51:03necessarily like you know, where IRR is.
- 51:04Obviously we've hired some phenomenal folks including, you
- 51:07know, Sam Blonde who is formerly a CRO at Breck's that you know,
- 51:10his primary focus isn't, you know, sort of sass and
- 51:12previously had, you know, phenomenal SAS career before
- 51:15Breck's. So no, does not fix way Parker.
- 51:18Yeah, he was at echo sign back in the day under Jason Lemkin is
- 51:21it. And then was at you know
- 51:23Zenefits with Parker and then Brax with Henrique and I forget
- 51:26the other guys name at Braxton and and then joined us.
- 51:29So no, not at all. You know, obviously something
- 51:31that we were going to continue to invest in.
- 51:32It's just something that I personally at least prefer to
- 51:34you know not spend time on. So I'm very glad we've hired
- 51:36people like Sam. They can go get all the returns.
- 51:39Somebody shit on you in the replies saying didn't you sell
- 51:42tshirts for seven months or so? What was that?
- 51:45I didn't even know that about you or what it was, your seven
- 51:47month. Oh, yeah, I worked at a tea
- 51:49spring for about Oh, yeah, Yeah. Would you learn from that
- 51:53experience? I did learn a lot.
- 51:55It was one of these examples where I was at the time I
- 51:58believe 22 or 23 year old like single time sort of failed
- 52:00founder. The company was in a little bit
- 52:02of a floundering state where they basically had a very highly
- 52:05priced and they are flying high. Let's say they were like the hot
- 52:08startup darling of Silicon Valley in the call 20/15/16 time
- 52:12frame. And then basically shortly after
- 52:13that round, maybe like flatline in revenue for the next like 2
- 52:161/2 years, if not slightly declining revenue?
- 52:18And so there was interest in you sort of making some more risky
- 52:22moves. And so one of those moves that
- 52:24the board was, you know, convinced of was let's give this
- 52:2623 year old, you know, single time failed founder like a whole
- 52:29department of the company just like seeing what he does with
- 52:31it. So I really enjoyed it.
- 52:32Like you know, I think I did a decent job of also like drinking
- 52:34the kool-aid while I was there. So I really believed in tshirt
- 52:36selling, even if you know, looking back, maybe it's not the
- 52:39most exciting thing, but I was really appreciative for the
- 52:41opportunity to like. Get to lead.
- 52:42The largest team that I think to date is still the largest that
- 52:45I've ever led in terms of like the number of direct reports
- 52:47that I had that reported in to me and managed to grow.
- 52:50You know, so the revenue line that I was handed from like
- 52:51roughly 12 and a half million annualized GMV to about
- 52:5475,000,000 annualizing GMV. And so I learned a ton during
- 52:57that time, about just like how to manage, how to be the
- 52:59executive price, you know, if you see string exit or whatever
- 53:02happened. I believe there is still a
- 53:04privately held company and they've been like even out
- 53:06positive actually basically since roughly the quarter after
- 53:08my laugh. Basically we like went through a
- 53:10riff around the same time that I actually decided to leave and
- 53:13the company's actually have been profitable now for instead a
- 53:15period of time. And some of the stuff that
- 53:16actually worked on back in the day, some of the things that are
- 53:18actually like working the best for the company now.
- 53:20So it's cool to see that finally play out.
- 53:21What's your political involvement these days?
- 53:24Or I'm very happy that we've made the piece you've come back
- 53:28on. Like our first, I think, Silicon
- 53:30Valley encounter was over that like Chesa Boudin thing when we
- 53:34were all going crazy during the clubhouse era.
- 53:38But then we got to see each other at Web Summit and I think
- 53:41both are Twitter. Well, you're much more feisty on
- 53:44Twitter than I am, though. I think also my combativeness
- 53:48and time spent on Twitter has calmed down.
- 53:50But are you active in, you know, looking out for the presidential
- 53:53candidates or San Francisco politics stuff these days?
- 53:57Yeah, I think at the time I was deeply passionate.
- 54:00You know, back in even 2018, I want to say I actually was one
- 54:04of the, oh, no, 2019. I was actually one of the
- 54:06largest fundraisers for Leaf Douch, who was one of the DA
- 54:09candidates. You know, I campaigned.
- 54:11For him, you know, spent a ton of energy and resources, you
- 54:14know, sort of personally trying to get people to understand
- 54:16basically why this race was very important.
- 54:18I couldn't get like the light of day from anybody, including
- 54:20people like Solano, for example, who like, you know, came around
- 54:23to how important it was. But at the time, Mike Solano,
- 54:25who's also founders, fun and writes with tire wise, which is
- 54:30always fascinating and worth at least having on your radar if
- 54:33diametrically opposed and stylings to.
- 54:37Exactly. But yeah, yeah, nobody really
- 54:39paid attention. And so that was definitely, at
- 54:40least for me, my breaking moment with like basically interest in
- 54:43San Francisco sort of politics and that I felt like I put in a
- 54:46ton of effort and like nobody in the tech community was basically
- 54:48like paying any attention, you know, sort of do this.
- 54:50And it ended up having a real impact on my life and obviously
- 54:51ended up, you know, I started deciding to move away almost
- 54:54like 2 years to the day after, you know, that campaign to
- 54:56Miami. So yeah, since moving to Miami,
- 54:58obviously, I don't feel like I've much insensitive to care
- 55:00much about San Francisco politics.
- 55:01I mean, credit to like, I'm sorry, Vard is in California.
- 55:04Right. Vard is in Los Angeles where I
- 55:05do about like four months of the year and then 7-8 months of the
- 55:08year. I'm in Miami anyway, so credit
- 55:09to folks like Gary Tan and then I forget the guys name Sachin
- 55:12with like Grow SF maybe not pronouncing his name correctly.
- 55:15So it's really good to see some people that maybe are starting
- 55:17to get, you know, sort of more traction, although still doesn't
- 55:20seem like there's, you know, sort of been the change that
- 55:21people have been sort of hoping for.
- 55:24And then you know beyond that, you know sort of particular
- 55:25incidents I'd say I'm definitely not opposed to you know, sort of
- 55:28becoming more politically involved over time, but at least
- 55:29right now very narrowly focused in on basically Varda.
- 55:32And so all of my political contributions go into the Varda
- 55:35Pack. Of the Varda Pack contributions
- 55:37basically go to our, you know, particular company policy
- 55:39priorities that are very specific to, you know, basically
- 55:43our work around reentry, hypersonic testing, you know,
- 55:46the future programs of NASA. All right, great.
- 55:49Thanks so much for coming on the show.
- 55:50This was awesome. Cool.
- 55:52Thanks for having me, Eric. That's our episode.
- 55:54Thanks so much to Dellian for coming on the show.
- 55:56Shout out to Juniper Square, our sponsor for the episode, Tommy
- 55:59Herron, the audio editor, Riley Kinsella, my chief of staff,
- 56:03Annie Wen, who's producing for the summer and of course, young
- 56:06Chomsky for the theme music. Like, comment, subscribe on
- 56:10YouTube, give us a review on Apple Podcasts, and please
- 56:14subscribe to the sub stack newcomer.co.
- 56:17See you next week. Goodbye.
- 56:18Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:20Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:20Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:22Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:24Goodbye. Goodbye.