Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Generosity: The Ransom of Jerusalem's Poor
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Saladin's military campaigns, his diplomacy, his tax system, even his spies. But there's one aspect of his conquest of Jerusalem in 1187 that's often mentioned but rarely dived into — the ransom of the city's inhabitants, and specifically how Saladin handled the poorest of them. Luna: I remember hearing something about that — that he let people go free if they couldn't pay? Lucas: Well, it's a bit more complicated. After the Battle of Hattin in July 1187, Saladin's forces swept through the Kingdom of Jerusalem, taking town after town. By September, he was at the gates of Jerusalem itself. The city was defended by Balian of Ibelin — a Frankish noble who had escaped from Hattin and made his way to Tyre, then got permission from Saladin to enter Jerusalem to retrieve his wife and children. But once inside, the city's leaders begged him to stay and organize the defense. Luna: So Balian ended up leading the defense of Jerusalem? Lucas: Exactly. Balian knew the situation was hopeless — he had maybe sixty knights and a few thousand men against Saladin's army. After a siege that lasted about two weeks, Balian came to negotiate a surrender. Saladin initially wanted to take the city by force, which under medieval custom would mean slaughter and enslavement of the inhabitants. But Balian threatened to destroy the city and kill everyone themselves if they didn't get terms. So Saladin agreed to a ransom: every man in the city could leave for ten dinars, every woman for five, and every child for one. Luna: That's surprisingly cheap, actually. A dinar is a gold coin, right? Lucas: Yes, it's a gold coin. And you're right, it was relatively modest — but for the poorest inhabitants, it was impossible. Many of the refugees who had flooded into Jerusalem from the surrounding countryside had no money at all. The Frankish leaders managed to collect about 30,000 dinars from the city's treasury and wealthy citizens, but that covered maybe 7,000 people. The rest — perhaps 15,000 to 20,000 — could not pay. Luna: What happened to them? Lucas: This is where it gets interesting. Saladin's chronicler, Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, gives a detailed account. He says that after the initial ransom period, about 7,000 people — mainly women and children — were still in the city, huddled in the streets. Saladin's brother al-Adil came to him and said, 'I have a request. Give me a thousand of them as my share of the booty.' Saladin agreed. Then al-Adil freed them all. Luna: That's a clever move — he ransomed them himself. Lucas: Exactly. But then the other emirs started making similar requests. Balian of Ibelin and the Patriarch Heraclius asked for some, and they freed those too. But there were still thousands left. Imad ad-Din writes that Saladin then said, 'My brothers have given their ransoms, the bishops have given theirs, the knights have given theirs. I will not let them surpass me.' And he freed all the remaining poor, about 5,000 people, from his own share. Luna: So in the end, almost everyone was freed? Lucas: A large portion, yes. But not all. Some were still enslaved — particularly those who resisted or were captured in the initial assault on the city walls. And there's a darker side: many of those freed had nowhere to go. They marched in columns to Tyre, which was still held by the Crusaders under Conrad of Montferrat. But Conrad refused to let them enter — he thought they were fifth columnists or that they'd overwhelm the city. Luna: That's terrible. So they were left stranded between the Muslim army and a closed gate? Lucas: Exactly. Many of them died of exposure or were captured again by Muslim patrols. It's a grim footnote to the story. But for Saladin, the ransom episode became a cornerstone of his reputation for magnanimity. In Western chronicles, he's often portrayed as a chivalrous enemy, and the ransom of Jerusalem's poor is one of the key examples. Luna: Though I suppose it also served his interests — by showing mercy, he made future surrenders more likely. Lucas: Absolutely. It was part of a calculated policy of clemency that had worked well before. After Hattin, he had released many prisoners for ransoms or services. But there was also genuine religious motivation. Saladin saw himself as a mujahid, a holy warrior, but also as a ruler who should embody Islamic ideals of justice and mercy. The Quran says, 'If you forgive, it is nearer to piety.' And his chroniclers emphasize that he wanted to emulate the Prophet's example. Luna: So how many people actually ended up enslaved? Lucas: Estimates vary. Imad ad-Din says about 7,000 were enslaved from the initial capture, but many of those were later freed by the ransoms. Other sources suggest a total of around 10,000 to 15,000 were taken as slaves, with the rest freed. It's hard to be precise because the chroniclers had their own agendas. Muslim writers wanted to highlight Saladin's generosity; Christian writers wanted to highlight the tragedy. Luna: And this is still remembered today — the image of Saladin as a merciful conqueror. Lucas: Yes, it's a powerful image. When Kaiser Wilhelm II visited the tomb of Saladin in 1898, he donated a new marble sarcophagus with the inscription: 'To the great Sultan Saladin, the knight without fear and without reproach, who often had to teach his foes the right way of chivalry.' That's the legend. But the reality, as always, is more complex — a mix of policy, piety, and pragmatism. Luna: And it's a story that still resonates — how do you balance mercy with the realities of conquest? Lucas: Exactly. And it's a question Saladin grappled with throughout his career. In the end, the ransom of Jerusalem's poor is a window into his character, but also into the messy, human side of history.