Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep8: GRD036: Should I Use My HSA in Retirement?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:29You, a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:33each side of the debate to your own personal situation to decide
- 0:36what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go, welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 0:43Ed, you think that most people are good with money or bad with money?
- 0:47Uh, a little of both, but probably most people are bad with money.
- 0:50Alright.
- 0:51I think that's probably true, and I think it's especially true with HSAs.
- 0:55What if I told you that What's an HSA?
- 0:57A Health Savings Account.
- 0:58Alright.
- 0:59Uh, for most people, what effectively becomes a slush
- 1:02fund for their medical expenses.
- 1:04And actually, it's one of the things we're going to talk about today.
- 1:06What if I told you that nearly 90 percent of people weren't using HSAs efficiently?
- 1:12Would you believe that?
- 1:13I would.
- 1:13Uh, I guess if you say so, I believe it.
- 1:15That's it.
- 1:16I'm not a liar.
- 1:16Right?
- 1:17? Actually, it's true.
- 1:18Uh, according to an ERE study, that's the Employee Benefit Research Institute,
- 1:21uh, about 90% of individuals in their HSAs keep those dollars only in cash.
- 1:28Now, uh, you know, one of the biggest benefits of the HSA is the fact
- 1:33that there's tax free distributions for qualified healthcare expenses,
- 1:36which means if you invest the HSA and you let it grow over time.
- 1:41That growth can be used tax free to pay for your qualified medical expenses.
- 1:45And you get a deduction on the way in.
- 1:47That's right.
- 1:47In fact, the HSA Triple tax.
- 1:48Yes.
- 1:49In fact, you know, a lot of people say triple tax.
- 1:51I don't even like that.
- 1:53I think for a lot of people we should talk about quadruple tax.
- 1:55All right.
- 1:56I know the first three.
- 1:57All right.
- 1:57What are the first three?
- 1:58Well, obviously the deduct we just talked about them the deduction on the way in
- 2:02Yep the tax by the way No matter how much income you make something that's
- 2:06different between that and a lot of other like your ira contribution deduction
- 2:09No matter how much money you make You cannot be phased out of an HSA deduction.
- 2:13Sounds like a good deal if you got a lot of money.
- 2:15Not too bad.
- 2:16All right, so that's one.
- 2:17All right, the tax deferred growth in the account.
- 2:19Definitely number two.
- 2:20And the other one you just talked about, if you pay qualifying
- 2:22medical expenses, tax free.
- 2:24That is, that's three.
- 2:25So there's the fourth one.
- 2:27For a lot of people who have access to an HSA via their employer, if they make those
- 2:32HSA contributions as a payroll deduction through something called a Section 125
- 2:37Cafeteria Plan, that's basically the a la carte version of employee benefits, right?
- 2:42I want a little bit of this, a little bit of that.
- 2:44It's kind of where it gets its name, cafeteria plan, you know, a little
- 2:47bit of this, a little bit of that.
- 2:48Those contributions not only reduce income tax, but they also lower employment
- 2:54taxes, like social security taxes.
- 2:56And medicare.
- 2:56And medicare, exactly.
- 2:58So, the HSA can actually be quadruple tax benefit for a lot of folks.
- 3:02But, uh, You know, while people are working, they should be contributing
- 3:05to the accounts if they can.
- 3:06In fact, because the HSA is triple tax free or triple tax benefit, I should
- 3:12say, uh, and in some cases quadruple.
- 3:15In general, it should be the place where people put their first dollars
- 3:18of savings each and every year.
- 3:20You mean some people don't?
- 3:21I, uh, I've heard that, yes.
- 3:23I'm looking at one of our producers here.
- 3:24We had a little conversation before we started.
- 3:26And he said, what did he say?
- 3:28He said he has money in his 401k, but not his HSA, and I said, uh,
- 3:32he said, why would you do that?
- 3:33And he said, well, isn't that the place where we start?
- 3:35And I said, well, that's why we're having this podcast, you know?
- 3:38Right, right.
- 3:39That's right.
- 3:39So, uh, The very first thing that you should be doing.
- 3:41I might even correct him on something totally unrelated.
- 3:44Why is a young person, this guy, putting money in a 401k?
- 3:48Let's keep talking about him as if he's not in the room with us.
- 3:50Yeah.
- 3:50That's good.
- 3:51All right.
- 3:52Roth.
- 3:52You should go Roth.
- 3:54Roth 401k.
- 3:55Build tax free while you're young.
- 3:57There we go.
- 3:57Look, this is a podcast for one, ladies and gentlemen.
- 4:00All right.
- 4:00An audience of one.
- 4:01That's right.
- 4:02An audience of one.
- 4:03There you go.
- 4:04Hopefully.
- 4:04Maybe we'll get two.
- 4:05We'll double our audience.
- 4:06All right.
- 4:06So here's the deal, right?
- 4:07Once HSAs are, are, are unique.
- 4:10Um, different from any other type of account.
- 4:13You know, normally when we think about things like a 529, that's usually the
- 4:16account that people compare it to because it's a tax preference account for a
- 4:20very specified type of expense, right?
- 4:23And you might say retirement account, but retirement account, once you hit a
- 4:27certain age, you can use it for anything, but 529s are for education expenses.
- 4:32If, uh, if you have an, a healthcare savings account.
- 4:36you can reimburse yourself for previous, uh, previously incurred medical expenses.
- 4:43As long as you haven't taken them out to date with a 529
- 4:46plan, expense and distribution have to align in the same year.
- 4:49That's not true for HSAs, which means what you should really be doing for the
- 4:53most part is putting away your whatever, three, four or five thousand, whatever
- 4:57you can put into the HSA each year.
- 4:59And if you have the ability to do so, Let it grow and pay any current medical
- 5:04expenses out of out, you know, out of pocket, so to speak, because if you
- 5:08put in 5, 000 today to your HSA and it grows to let's say 30, 000 over
- 5:15the next Let's call it five years.
- 5:18If each of the next five years, you had 6, 000 of unreimbursed medical expenses,
- 5:23that's six times five is 30, 000.
- 5:25Well, lo and behold, in five years, your 30, 000 can come out
- 5:29completely tax and penalty free.
- 5:31So the government is paying.
- 5:33The cost of your healthcare, essentially.
- 5:35Yeah, it's a, it's one of the unique features of HSAs and it's why, you
- 5:39know, when we talk about 90 percent of people, according to that research
- 5:43study from, uh, EBRI, which we can include a link to within show notes
- 5:46or something like that so people can look at the study themselves, but
- 5:4990 percent of people putting this money in cash, cash doesn't grow like
- 5:54other assets over time, which means you're not using your HSA efficiently.
- 5:58I get it.
- 5:58If you're tight on funds and you've only got, you know, uh, you know, your
- 6:05You may want to put money into your HSA, at least get the deduction, and then
- 6:08use that money for medical expenses.
- 6:10But to the extent you have the available cash flow, your medical expenses,
- 6:15at least while you're young, should be paid from other sources to let
- 6:19that HSA grow tax and penalty free.
- 6:21It effectively becomes like another Roth IRA.
- 6:23Right.
- 6:24Because you've had a lifetime's worth of medical expenses to accumulate.
- 6:28Well, not exactly, uh, like a Roth IRA because you have to, to get the third
- 6:33benefit, getting it out, uh, tax free, you have to use it for qualified expenses.
- 6:38That's right.
- 6:38It does have to be used for qualified medical expenses, but as people age,
- 6:42they tend to have medical expenses.
- 6:43So, I mean, if we think about this.
- 6:44That's a pretty good bet.
- 6:46Yes.
- 6:46Yes.
- 6:47I would take the long on that for sure.
- 6:49So, so that brings us to the, the real focus of today's discussion,
- 6:53Ed, which is when should individuals Use their HSA during retirement.
- 6:59Now, we're really focused on the when here, so I think it's actually
- 7:03worth noting, you know, we talked about what happens with your HSA
- 7:06during life and how this works.
- 7:08Uh, we should talk about HSAs, I think, a little bit at death as well.
- 7:11Well, that's where, the way I understand it, it's, it's not that
- 7:15great tax wise because beneficiaries have to take the whole shebang and
- 7:19they get hit on that all at once.
- 7:21That's exactly right.
- 7:22So, we, we really actually, if we want to be more specific, we've got to look
- 7:25at two different types of beneficiaries.
- 7:27Right.
- 7:27Right, a spouse.
- 7:28And everyone or everything else.
- 7:31Well it's kind of like with the IRA, the spouse has special privileges.
- 7:35Uh, but after that, that's why you have to manage how, how much you build it up.
- 7:39Yes, that's true.
- 7:40Yep.
- 7:40Which I, kind of, you're, you're, you're getting to, you're hitting on
- 7:44exactly, I think, some of the things that we're going to need to expand on
- 7:46to make sure our listeners, uh, Uh, are really understanding how to think
- 7:50about using their HSAs most efficiently over the course of their retirement.
- 7:54But just to reiterate, right, at death there's these two possibilities.
- 7:57Either you're the spouse beneficiary or you're anyone or anything else.
- 8:00If you're a spouse.
- 8:02then effectively the moment the person with the HSA dies, the spouse is the
- 8:06owner of that HSA instantaneously.
- 8:09Like there's in retirement accounts, you've got options.
- 8:11Do we want to remain a beneficiary?
- 8:13It's basically like a spousal rollover except it's treated
- 8:17that way instantaneously.
- 8:18Yeah.
- 8:18If it's any other beneficiary, I think you used the words, The whole shebang.
- 8:22Well, that's true.
- 8:23The whole shebang becomes taxable immediately.
- 8:27Right away.
- 8:28And there is no, uh, No way to stretch it out.
- 8:31That's right.
- 8:31There's no, it's the year of death.
- 8:33It becomes immediately taxable to the beneficiary.
- 8:35Now, But remember, there's still a beneficiary.
- 8:37That's right.
- 8:37They're still getting money that they weren't, they didn't have elsewhere.
- 8:40Now, there is, You know, not really relevant for our discussion today, but
- 8:44I would be remiss if I didn't insert a little bit of a planning nugget here.
- 8:48There's one exception to this rule where the beneficiaries, well,
- 8:51it's not even an exception, but one interesting thing you can do.
- 8:55Normally, if you leave the HSA outright to an individual, let's
- 8:58say a child, the child will pick up that income on their own tax return.
- 9:03By contrast, if you name your will or your estate the beneficiary of your HSA,
- 9:08which you would almost never, ever do for a retirement account, but there's actually
- 9:12a potential advantage on the HSA side.
- 9:14If your will or the estate is the beneficiary, then that HSA becomes
- 9:19taxable on your final tax return.
- 9:22So if you're at a lower tax bracket than, say, your beneficiary, You
- 9:26know, maybe you're 80, 85, you're not working, your income in retirement is
- 9:29lower than your child who's 50 or 55 or 60, maybe they're still working.
- 9:33You might leave it to your will.
- 9:36Pay tax on it at your own rate and then have the proceeds at or after tax
- 9:42be distributed through your estate To the you know to your child anyway, so
- 9:46they'll get the money but having paid tax at your rate versus theirs, right?
- 9:50Let me ask you that I'm not sure about this, but if you do it that way Yep, and
- 9:54there are still unpaid medical bills at death Can any of that be used for that?
- 10:00It's a really good question.
- 10:01All right, so the, the way that it works with the HSA is that what we
- 10:07know for certain is that year of death.
- 10:09Yeah, exactly.
- 10:10So, so, so you have, you have a one year, you can pay medical expenses
- 10:13for the previous year and those distributions, if paid by the beneficiary
- 10:18will be tax free for the decedents.
- 10:20medical expenses.
- 10:21In other words, if dad dies and dad had some medical bills before he died that
- 10:25hadn't yet been paid but need to be, the beneficiaries of the HSA can pay
- 10:30those expenses tax free within a year.
- 10:33If they don't, then it's taxable.
- 10:34But it's important, and this is kind of, it leads into the second issue.
- 10:39What is not clear, however, what the IRS has never Uh, the one thing
- 10:43that's not perfectly clarified is what happens to an HSA, uh, the
- 10:47built up tax free accumulation that you can repay yourself if you will.
- 10:52Like all your previous unreimbursed medical expenses, does that transfer
- 10:56if you will to a beneficiary?
- 10:58And it would seem that at least if we're talking about a non
- 11:02spouse, the answer is probably no.
- 11:04So, effectively, right, to, to make this a little bit clearer, to
- 11:07give an example here, so everybody.
- 11:09Because that's opposite what you just said on the other scenario.
- 11:12Correct.
- 11:12Exactly.
- 11:13So, let's make sure everybody, uh, you know, listening follows along this.
- 11:16Let's say, let's just say you had put in over the years 20, 000 worth
- 11:20of HSA contributions and that over the course of your life, that 20,
- 11:26000 had grown to be worth 100, 000.
- 11:29Right.
- 11:29And let's say that over, you know, a, a 30 year period from the time
- 11:33you started your HSA to the time you died, you had accumulated 100, 000
- 11:38of unreimbursed medical expenses.
- 11:40You had paid these dollars out of pocket all these years.
- 11:43Well, if that's the case, then you could turn around and take that
- 11:46100, 000, 100 percent tax free.
- 11:49Who's you when you're talking?
- 11:50The, the, the person during their lifetime, right?
- 11:52The, the original HSA owner could turn around and take that 100, 000 out 100
- 11:58percent tax free before they died.
- 12:01However, if they died having not taken that distribution first,
- 12:06it at least appears, at the very least it's gray, but I would say
- 12:09it appears that the beneficiary, pays tax on the full 100, 000.
- 12:14Whereas if, you know, the original HSA owner, the moment before they died, right?
- 12:18Like their last act as a human being on the face of this earth
- 12:21was to make sure that's right.
- 12:23Somebody grabbed their arm.
- 12:25Yeah.
- 12:25That's it.
- 12:26Somebody grabbed the arm and grabbed the HSA distribution, you
- 12:28know, form and said, take it out.
- 12:30It would have been tax free could then be left to the kids tax free that way.
- 12:34It appears that goes away when it's a non spouse.
- 12:37Uh, and so.
- 12:39So that, that brings us to the idea of how do you efficiently
- 12:42use your HSA during retirement?
- 12:45One thing you really have to be mindful of is you don't want to
- 12:48die with unreimbursed medical expenses having not been taken out.
- 12:52But you want to do that later in life to keep the account building.
- 12:55That's right.
- 12:55It's like a game of tax chicken, right?
- 12:57It's like how long can you wait and let the growth, you know, the
- 13:00earnings continue to grow so that you have more tax free wealth.
- 13:04But don't wait too long because if you do, you might, you know, so
- 13:08like anything has to be monitored.
- 13:09That's right.
- 13:10Yeah.
- 13:11Certainly as someone approaches the end of their life, especially
- 13:14at, if they're single, right?
- 13:15Because if they're married, that HSA immediately becomes the spouses and
- 13:19it would seem that you could still reimburse yourself for your deceased
- 13:22spouses, unreimbursed medical expenses.
- 13:25But if it's again, if it goes to a non spouse, like once, if you're
- 13:28a single person or if the first spouse has already passed away.
- 13:31Then you want to be really mindful about not dying with potentially tax
- 13:35free distribution dollars in your HSA.
- 13:38that would be taxable to your heirs if they passed on that way.
- 13:41Now these unreimbursed, I've seen this come up in some tax articles
- 13:45and things, these expenses, they could be back for years.
- 13:48Unlimited from the time you established your HSA.
- 13:51That's the problem.
- 13:52Yes.
- 13:52Documentation.
- 13:54That's fair.
- 13:55That's fair.
- 13:55It's why I actually I encourage people they should create a digital folder.
- 13:58That's a good idea.
- 13:59That's a, that's a digital meaning like on a computer.
- 14:02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:02You know, that's the thing where you type with it.
- 14:03Yeah, I'm just making sure you know.
- 14:04Yeah.
- 14:05So, uh, you know, the idea, create a digital folder and
- 14:08just compile a running total.
- 14:10What I would actually encourage people to do is have You know, just PDF after
- 14:15PDF or a copy of these receipts in there, scan it all in there and then keep a
- 14:20spreadsheet, you know, like an Excel spreadsheet where each year you total up
- 14:23your unreimbursed medical expenses and you have a running total there for yourself.
- 14:27Even if people don't do that, a simple thing, every time you
- 14:30pay a bill, because these are unreimbursed, you paid them yourself,
- 14:34but you didn't reimburse yourself.
- 14:36So now you didn't get any insurance to cover it after the fact either.
- 14:39Yeah.
- 14:40Okay.
- 14:41I know you know what unreimbursed means, Ed.
- 14:43I'm talking to the listener.
- 14:44All right, but I'm saying an easier way than people, you know, in the, on their
- 14:49deathbed starting an Excel spreadsheet.
- 14:51Uh huh.
- 14:51All right.
- 14:52Yeah, that might not be reasonable.
- 14:54Yeah, fair.
- 14:54All right.
- 14:55But it's gotta be a running, you know, like with any expense, a medical
- 14:59expense on a return or charitable, you have to have contemporaneous
- 15:03expenses at the times, documentation of the expenses at the times you
- 15:08just scan the bill as you pay it.
- 15:09Okay.
- 15:10or have somebody do it, and like you say, you put that in some file
- 15:13on your computer, and at the end, because this could be a big item,
- 15:17like you used 100, 000, that could be something that gets examined by IRS.
- 15:21Sure.
- 15:22A big hit.
- 15:23So you'd have to, it'd be, you can't say, well, that was 20 years ago,
- 15:27you know, that's not going to cut it.
- 15:29You know, and, and today this is a bigger issue than it ever has been
- 15:32in the past, because Ed, you know, today, uh, More than half of all
- 15:35workers who receive their employment, uh, or their health insurance through
- 15:38their employer have HSA eligibility.
- 15:41Which means that more people than ever today Can contribute to an
- 15:46HSA and obviously, that's right.
- 15:48Well, he can, he just, we're looking at our producer again, making sure that he,
- 15:51he takes advantage of his HSA next year.
- 15:54Uh, but more people than ever can contribute to their HSA and to
- 15:58make sure that they're getting this benefit of this triple.
- 16:02Or quadruple tax benefit account and to use those benefits.
- 16:07Remember, if all you do is contribute dollars and then take them out as
- 16:10soon as you have a medical expense, which is what most people do, you've
- 16:14only gotten one of the tax breaks.
- 16:16You only got the deduction.
- 16:17You didn't get tax deferred growth because you didn't have any growth and
- 16:20you didn't get distributions of tax free earnings because you had no earnings.
- 16:24So you take this beautiful triple tax benefit account and you turn it
- 16:28into a single tax benefit account.
- 16:30And clearly Ed, we know three, is better than one!
- 16:33Right, but you made a point earlier, it's not as easy as it sounds.
- 16:37Especially if you're younger, you use the term, if you have the cash flow outside.
- 16:42If you don't have the money, you have to use that money.
- 16:45That's right.
- 16:46You're right.
- 16:46If you look, if you need the money, you need the money.
- 16:49But there are too many people put their money into the HSA.
- 16:53They leave it in cash.
- 16:55They think about it as the first place they go for medical expense.
- 16:58And for most individuals, it should be thought of as kind
- 17:01of a supplemental Roth IRA.
- 17:03Because as long as they have a cumulative record of those medical
- 17:06expenses, any amount of medical expenses that have been unreimbursed.
- 17:10from the time they establish their HSA onward can be redistributed,
- 17:15repaid, reimbursed from the HSA, tax and penalty free.
- 17:19And by the way, if there are no medical expenses at 65, any of the
- 17:24earnings inside, well, any of the HSA dollars, I should say, not just the
- 17:27earnings, but the contributions and the earnings, become available penalty
- 17:30free, kind of like a traditional IRA.
- 17:32So at worst case scenario, If you put money into an HSA, it
- 17:37functions like an IRA after 65.
- 17:39And in a best case, at least from a tax perspective, assuming you have
- 17:43medical expenses, which look, we hope you don't have, but the reality is
- 17:46almost everyone has medical expenses.
- 17:48Yeah, then you can reimburse yourself and your IRA, uh, your
- 17:52pseudo IRA becomes a pseudo Roth.
- 17:55It is a home run from a tax perspective.
- 17:57One other little rule we didn't, because you just mentioned
- 18:0065, can't keep contributing.
- 18:02That's right.
- 18:02You can only contribute.
- 18:04Well, Most people can't contribute after 65, and the reason is you can't
- 18:08be on Medicare, uh, and contribute.
- 18:10However, some individuals, if you continue to work for, let's say, a large employer
- 18:14with more than 20 employees, after 65, you can continue on with the employer's
- 18:18health coverage, and that might still, you know, and delay Social Security.
- 18:22Um, that is something you could be aware of.
- 18:24Also, uh, one other note there, if you're taking Social Security, Right.
- 18:28And 65.
- 18:29Yep.
- 18:29Then you have to enroll in Medicare.
- 18:31At least part a, you have no choice, in which case, once again, you need
- 18:35to stop those HSA contributions.
- 18:37There's lots of nuances around this.
- 18:40Uh, there's a six month retroactive rule that catches a lot of
- 18:43people off guard if they retire after 65 from a large employer.
- 18:47All of that is important.
- 18:48And That's why you should have a, you know, professional advice
- 18:51when you're in these situations.
- 18:52But, you know, today for today, our primary focus was, you know, when
- 18:56should you use your HSA in retirement?
- 18:59And the answer is, at least today.
- 19:01You know, if we think about this from a theory perspective, as close to your
- 19:04death as possible, But not too much.
- 19:06But before, yeah.
- 19:08But before you die.
- 19:09But, uh, the point is, the amazing benefits of something that's not used,
- 19:13what'd you say, that's used, that's not used by more than 95 people, at a minimum,
- 19:18using it incorrectly, or at least, let me say not, at least they're not
- 19:22using the HSA as efficiently as we can.
- 19:24Because they keep it in cash.
- 19:26That's right.
- 19:26Keep it in cash and use it as a slush fund as opposed to having that
- 19:29long term tax free growth and then reimbursing oneself down the road.
- 19:34Something to think about.
- 19:35Absolutely something to think about.
- 19:37And lots to think about for us, including what we're going to talk about next
- 19:40time, because today, Ed, we're done.
- 19:42Okay.
- 19:43See you next time on The Great Retirement Debate.
- 19:47Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 19:51This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should
- 19:54not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice.
- 19:57Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information
- 20:00which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 20:03Third party information is deemed to be reliable but its accuracy and
- 20:06completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 20:08The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 20:11and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth Partners.