Latest / The Philanthropists / What No One Tells You About Giving — and Why It Matters Now
Transcript
- Quanda: We both spent years around people who give and I think it's fair to say that most of the real conversations about giving never actually happened out loud. Meredith: or when they do, they're polished, curated, very safe. Quanda: And giving, real giving is none of those things. Welcome to The Philanthropist, Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith: And I'm Meredith Hanley. So, Kwanda, what made you say this conversation needs to exist right now? Quanda: Yeah, for me, there's a lot of discussion today around charitable giving vehicles and institutional giving. But the real untold story is about individuals and what motivated them to give and how they're individually impacting our community and our society. So for me, that was one of the primary reasons why I thought that, this story needs to be told. Meredith: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. For me, honestly, I think it's curiosity. Probably a little frustration too. For the better part of 20 years I've been watching people make extraordinary decisions about their resources and I kept noticing that the most interesting part of those conversations almost really never make it into the public discourse. And right now, if you follow the news, philanthropy has become this super loaded word. It's attached to mega donors, tax strategies, and even most recently in the Times, this debate about billionaires deciding the fate of democracy. look, I think those conversations are really worth having, but somewhere in all that noise, we've completely lost the thread of what the word philanthropy actually means. It comes from Greek. It means to love humans, humankind, the love of humanity. And I think I'm a little frustrated right now because I've... feel we've lost that in some way. Quanda: Yeah, it's interesting. I always reflect back to my time as a fundraiser. Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: Many decades ago, and the first major gift that I had the privilege of bringing into the organization that I served. And, I had a young heiress who wanted to make a real impact on her new city and find a Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: way to give back. And we talked a lot about her family, about the legacy that she wanted to leave, that she was already thinking about in her early Meredith: You Quanda: 30s. She was a young mother. And the one thing that emerged from that conversation was the power of her gift. to provide a musical experience for children who didn't have the same level of access as her family did. And she ended up funding this incredible community festival where Meredith: Hmm. Quanda: we had a musical petting zoo and there were concerts. Meredith: fuck. Quanda: And it was just amazing to kind of step back and say, this is what a gift can can do. when you look around at an event like that and you see the smiles on children's faces, you see light bulbs go off, people are discovering new passion, new interests. And for me, that's the untold story. I mean, we're focusing kind of to your point about which is the right vehicle. And I think not enough time is spent on What is the difference ultimately that is being made, especially by some of these transformative individual gifts? Meredith: Yeah, the thought process is very interesting. how you get from an original idea to like the impact. Yeah. Quanda: and the other thing too, to kind of go back to your question and interested in your personal perspective on this, I'm kind of at a point in my life and my career where I'm asking myself questions Meredith: Hmm. Quanda: about personal legacy and the impact that I want to make. so selfishly in a lot of ways, this podcast is a platform for exploration and for curiosity and to make sure Meredith: Okay. Quanda: that as I evolve as a philanthropist in my own right that I can continue to align my personal values with the impact that I want to make. Meredith: Totally, I love that. And it's why I love you so much because I'm sort of thinking same thing right now, right? As I'm looking at my own life, as a mom, as a colleague, a daughter, a friend, I'm asking myself, am I living in a philanthropic way? Like it's been my Quanda: bread. Meredith: business for the last 25 years, but how am I doing it in, how am I moving through the world, right? And so I'm at this moment Quanda: Right. Meredith: where I'm searching and. constantly trying to find meaning in my work and a way to honor everything that's come before me and also still leave some room for what's coming next. And the Jesuit tradition that I've been shaped by talks a lot about giving to others and being of service, not as a transaction, but as like a way, a way of being, a way that you move through the world. And I think Quanda: Right. Right. Meredith: a lot of people are sitting with that same question right now, whether they call it Jesuit or not. Yeah, so I don't know, I think my giving, know, time, talent, treasure should be a way of, should model a way of being. And that's important for my kids, So, Kwanda, you too have been in this business for a long time, so how are you thinking about it? Quanda: Yeah, that's exactly why. I mean, I feel like in so many ways, we're kindred spirits because I've worked in and for nonprofit organizations as a staff member, as a volunteer leader, and as a service provider. And so I really feel like I have over, three decades seen philanthropy in so many incredible forms. And, Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: at this point in my life, I just want to make sure that I'm living the values and that I am expressing what I care about in my own giving in a way that positively impacts my family, my community, and the causes ultimately that I care about. Meredith: Absolutely. So I'd love to turn to some questions about yourself and some of the things you reference and experiences. Quanda: Sure. Meredith: So what's the most unexpected act of giving that you've ever witnessed and what did it reveal to you? Quanda: Yeah, it's funny. Again, at the very beginning of my career, when I worked in wealth management as a philanthropic advisor, I had a client who was an NFL football player, and we were working Meredith: Hmm. Quanda: with him on his charitable giving strategy. And, we had lots of ideas about how he could impact his community. we had lots of kind of frameworks on paper that looked at his personal values and kind of tying that to specific organizations and the impact that, ultimately he wanted to have. And he called me on a Tuesday and he's like, I just gave away 500 gas cards at a football game. And how Meredith: Wow. Quanda: can we incorporate that into the plan? And I thought it was initially a little bit shocking because it wasn't something that our team had advised him on or Meredith: you had suggested. Quanda: been involved in in any way. We were still trying to figure out if we could even include that as Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: part of his activity underneath the. the foundation or if we had to find another way to account for that giving. But what it told me at the end of the day is that, people give to other people and they give from what they know and they give from what they care about. And this young man just had a really incredible story. and he had struggled as a young person and Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: didn't have all that he needed. And he saw the impact of not being able to get to work or get to school Meredith: Right. Quanda: or wherever it is that you needed to be the impact that that had on a family's economic mobility. And at that particular point in time in our economy, people were stressed out. And in his Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: mind, the best way to impact that was to give them something tangible and not necessarily, Meredith: Yeah, in immediate. Quanda: right, not to stroke a check to a food bank or type of direct service organization, but to figure out a way to get the money in the hands of the people and figure the rest of it out later, right? He Meredith: Right, yeah. Quanda: had a heart for impacting his fans. and he Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: wanted to do it in a really authentic way. And to me, we were able to figure out where that fit in the philanthropic strategy or not, it was what he thought was gonna make the greatest difference in his immediate community. I'm sure some people didn't know how they were gonna get to work the next day and he gave them the means to make that happen. Meredith: Yeah, small acts of kindness often have a big impact. was thinking about a recent unexpected act of giving and most, I think it was two weeks ago, my kids and I are talking about chores and allowance and when can I get my allowance, mom? to give them cash, right? So they Quanda: rights. Meredith: understand what money is. tangible to your point. But I only had a 20 in my wallet and that's definitely more than they're supposed to get for their weekly allowance. And so I give it to my youngest daughter and she merely looks over at her sister and nods and then puts it directly in the rice bowl box that they get for school during Lent. And Quanda: wow, yes. Meredith: like, Madeline, here, you turn this into the school for their community Lenten project. I was like, wow, you're giving the whole 20? And she's like, yeah, mom, it's for, it's for Lent. We're supposed to do, acts of giving, almsgiving. And I thought that was, I was so surprised because they've been, they had been sort of whining a little about, wanting to get this allowance. And I had thought that maybe they had already a list of things that they wanted to buy, Kwanda. And I clearly know, Quanda: Yeah. Meredith: like just. And it was almost like they had talked about it because they'd gotten nodded at each other. So I was floored, blown away. And I thought to myself, Quanda: love that. Meredith: we're, again, small acts of kindness, right? It doesn't have to be, it wasn't a big strategy. In fact, it was very spur of the moment, but it will have an impact and they felt good about it. So anyway, I was gonna ask you, Quanda: That's such an amazing story. Meredith: yeah, I thought it was lovely. Proud mama moment. I was also gonna ask you, who, Who has influenced your own giving over the last decade or so? Quanda: Yeah, it's so funny. We do have so much in common. mean, for me, it actually has been, my kids have really influenced my giving. Not because they've shown any extraordinary acts of kindness, although, they do their part. And it may sound, a little trite, but I mean, I definitely want to make sure that, like, the world is a better place for them. And... my giving is really in the spirit of making sure that the organizations that I support have development programs that allow Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: people to be like the best version of themselves. So that's kind of one of the threads that I think about for my own giving. And I love that approach because like for me, it reminds me that that's also the gift that I want to give my children as well. Meredith: Hmm. Quanda: the ability to move through the world and figure out, what you truly care about and make choices that kind of amplify that goodness. And so looking at them, being with them, loving them. inspires me to do more good. Meredith: I love that. I love that. And a little bit of ditto, evidenced by the last story I just shared that my kids do influence my philanthropy. And it's focused on youth and community programs for youth. one of them is First Tea. We're very active in that. Jackson's Pantry. Those are things that my kids can be a part of with. with me, giving Quanda: Yeah. Meredith: up their time and money. So at the one end of the spectrum, it's like very direct ground level philanthropy. And then at the other level of the spectrum, I've been influenced by my think tank colleagues. I've been in policy think tank land for 20, 25 years and really believe after being sort of surrounded by these, by these. intellectual big idea people who want to solve big problems that you supporting patriotic causes really Quanda: Yeah. Meredith: is important to me and advancing national security and US competitiveness is super important if someone's not thinking about that all the time as at the same time they're thinking about whether you can feed people on the ground then there's not a lot of a lot a lot of hope for the future but they've taught me that every issue is a national security issue. And I hadn't thought about that, right? So Quanda: That's interesting. Yeah. Meredith: whether it's education or technology, energy in the environment, and healthcare, family, parental leave issues, Quanda: Right. Meredith: and childcare issues, like these are all national security, US competitiveness issues that make me feel good about supporting, because I... I think it's part of my patriotic duty and I'm so blessed to have been surrounded by these folks who think that and work day in and day out to advance those causes. So that's what I would say. Quanda: it's really interesting though, Meredith, I want to go back, it's so funny when I think about what has shaped the specific things I care about. I mean, I literally Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: have to go like all the way back to childhood where, I Meredith: Mmm. Quanda: mean, I personally had an affinity for the arts. I mean, as a young, person. I loved theater. I loved visual arts. I went to a performing arts high school and I Meredith: really? Wow. Quanda: did. I did. So if you are over 40, it's like fame. If you're under 40, Meredith: I was just gonna say that. Quanda: it's Meredith: It's glee! Quanda: like Glee or High School Musical or whatever. Meredith: Right. Quanda: I made a choice when I graduated high school to pursue a business degree for my undergrad instead of pursuing theater. And one of the reasons I made that choice was it was an economic one. I didn't think Meredith: Mm. Quanda: that theater was a viable choice for me because Meredith: Right. Quanda: I needed to be independent and I needed to take care of myself. And I was afraid, I didn't think that I could do that and pursue theater at the same time. And so similar Meredith: I'm sorry. Quanda: to like, know there's always time, right? Like watch out, Meredith: Right, right. Quanda: when I'm 70, the world will get to see my name on Broadway somewhere. But, when you were talking about your think tank experience, that one decision point in my life has so informed my giving back. for me, it really was a situation where I wish I had a choice, right? I wish that Meredith: Yeah. Quanda: there was infrastructure. I wish that there were people. I wish that, there was a path that, I was aware of that would have given me some safety and security to make a decision. to have a creative pursuit. And I didn't make that choice solely because of fear. And so my philanthropy today is really focused on mostly cultural organizations that support emerging artists. So Hamiltonian Artists is an organization that I care deeply about on the board of. That's exactly what they do. They provide visual artists with support, with space, with networks that enable Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: them to make a choice, to pursue visual arts full-time, or to focus on a particular body of work. And knowing that they have that type of support enables them to have a level of freedom around their creativity. that would be very difficult for them to create without that type of institutional support. it is, Meredith: I love that. Quanda: yeah, I mean, it's very interesting how one decision Meredith: Yeah. Quanda: or life experience can really transform how you think about everything else. And I'm kind of getting back to the podcast for a second. Like that is what I'm interested in hearing about from Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: our guests. Like what was that moment for you? When Meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: did that this was something that ultimately you wanted to focus on? Meredith: Yeah, that phrase, sometimes parents want to live vicariously through their children. think Quanda: Right. Meredith: like, how are you living vicariously through your philanthropy? that's like Quanda: I love that. Meredith: another way of thinking about it. So last question, what opinion about giving do you have that you very rarely get to say out? Quanda: my goodness, that is a tough one. You're putting me on the spot. I would say the one thing that I don't typically say out loud about giving is that, there are a lot of places and spaces where giving can feel very diluted. And, Meredith: Mmm. Quanda: I wanna explore that on the podcast, and there... problems that feel so big that you wonder as an individual donor, know, how far does my $250 go or my Meredith: Thank you. Quanda: $5,000 go to address this really massive issue? And it Meredith: Great. Quanda: can feel very abstract. a lot of organizations work really hard. to bring the giving down to a level that people can understand. So you give $50, you feed 10 children for a day, or you give $1,000 and you pay for kids to go to camp. I think that's really helpful for individual donors to understand the direct impact of their work. But there's so many places in philanthropy where that level of impact is abstract and it's very Meredith: Mm. Quanda: difficult for those organizations to quantify exactly how any particular gift is going to positively impact any given cause. So that is something I'm, I don't often say out loud, but it's something I'm curious about how others feel when they make a gift. Do they feel like... this is a specific gift that's gonna make an impact? do they feel like this is an organizational gift and as long as I'm giving it to an organization that I trust, I'm okay with that? And however they deploy those resources for the mission of the organization is fine with me? Or do they give and they just wonder like, wow, I made this gift but I don't really know what the impact of that gift is gonna be. So that's the rub, the friction that I'd love to explore. Meredith: That's really interesting, Kondah, thinking about the philanthropist who wants the impact report or wants to see what the effect is in their lifetime. And then there's the maybe Mackenzie Scott strategy of You're good organization, you do good things. Here's a big transformative gift. Keep doing what you're Quanda: Right. Meredith: doing. And yeah, that is actually interesting. And maybe relates to one of the reasons I'm excited about doing this podcast, because there's such a, I think there's a big emphasis on philanthropy at this moment. And I work in academia and academic institutions have been in the spotlight for sure. I think there's a really interesting opportunity to have a conversation about incentive structures and Quanda: Mm. Meredith: how that affects decision making and philanthropy. Are people incentivized in different ways? What's the goal? Quanda: Right. Meredith: I don't know, I just, and maybe, I'm a little worried about the future of philanthropy. And so I wanna explore it with you on this Quanda: so Meredith, I'd like for you to answer the question too. mean, what opinion do you hold about philanthropy that you don't typically say out loud? Meredith: Hmm. I can say that I'm a little concerned about the future of philanthropy because of these swirling conversations and, I'm in academia and the policy world. And so there are a lot of conversations in those two ecosystems swirling around about what incentive structures will look like. in the future and whether people will continue to give these big transformative gifts or whether they'll be so many strings attached and they'll set up these big organizations or have a big impact but it's not sustaining and so then they'll easily Quanda: Thank you. Meredith: turn their attention to something else. So I just, I'm really, I'm a little worried about... about the future of philanthropy and if it really is about the love of humanity, know, going back to how we kind of started and Quanda: Mm-hmm. Meredith: whether it's more utilitarian, I think. I don't know. I'm Quanda: Yeah, that's really interesting. Meredith: a little worried, but it can't be that worried because it's my business. So I really want to do, I want to do right by it again on the curiosity Quanda: Right. Meredith: journey here. So yeah, that's me. I'm a little worried. So, Quanda, we're at Quanda: Thank you. Meredith: the part of the podcast. hip. So if someone's Quanda: Mmm. Okay. Meredith: listening and wants to be more intentional with their giving, where should they start? Quanda: Hmm. That's a good question. I think that they really should start with who and what they love. So the kind of Latin definition of philanthropy is love of humanity. So I think there's just no better place to start than there. And what about you? Meredith: Yeah, similar thinking. I believe writing things down has a funny way of making things feel less abstract and scary. So writing down your passions and your passions can be what you love, like you referenced, or they can be what makes you really angry and what Quanda: Hmm. Meredith: gets you fired up so much that you need to do something about it. That... like what upsets you about the world right now? And maybe that's the approach how you think about targeting your philanthropy. Quanda: Yeah, channel some of that energy for good, right? Meredith: Yeah, right, right. Totally. Quanda: Awesome. Well, this has been such a fun conversation Meredith: Yeah! Quanda: with you. I'm glad that we took some time to chat with each other and share our thoughts. And I look forward to the next episode where we get to have our first interview. It's going to be awesome. Thank Meredith: I love that. Me too. Thanks, friend. Okay. Quanda: you. Thank you for joining us for this episode of The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. If this conversation stayed with you, we hope you'll share it with someone in your own life who is thinking deeply about generosity, legacy, impact, or what it means to truly show up for others. You can find episode show notes, guest resources, reflections, and additional conversations at thephilanthropistpodcast.org. Meredith Hanley: To continue the conversation with us directly, email us at hello at the philanthropistpodcast.org. We generally want to hear what these stories are stirring in you. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind the scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. Quanda: And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us to grow this community. I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith Hanley: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Until next time, give with purpose, give with joy, and give in a way that changes you too.