Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / The Terrifying Abduction and Murder of Samantha Jospehson
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Columbia police need your help finding a missing twenty one
- 0:04Speaker 1: year old woman, Samantha Josephson.
- 0:06Speaker 2: They were kind of throwing her a little party for
- 0:09Speaker 2: her for getting into law school. She was tired, wanted.
- 0:12Speaker 3: To go home.
- 0:13Speaker 2: She went outside and called her.
- 0:14Speaker 4: An uber eat circle the way. It's almost like a
- 0:17Speaker 4: shark circling in the water.
- 0:19Speaker 2: She willingly got in the vehicle because like she thought
- 0:22Speaker 2: it was her Uber drives off and that's the last
- 0:24Speaker 2: time that we could see her on any kind of video.
- 0:27Speaker 5: He has the child locked on, so she cannot open
- 0:30Speaker 5: the door. She cannot roll the windows down. They are
- 0:33Speaker 5: on and locked.
- 0:34Speaker 6: Well, this was more than a missing person.
- 0:36Speaker 7: This was an abduction. It was a complete panic. My
- 0:40Speaker 7: heart dropped to my stomach.
- 0:42Speaker 8: And I just watched that video for her getting that
- 0:43Speaker 8: car easily one hundred times part of going to shift.
- 0:49Speaker 8: Here's the deal, man, I pulled your car over to
- 0:52Speaker 8: the matress of suspect. Get your hand of your pocket.
- 0:54Speaker 8: What are you crazy?
- 0:55Speaker 3: Get over here, hey, go over here.
- 0:58Speaker 6: I think God had a hand on us that day.
- 1:01Speaker 6: There was certainly some divine interventions.
- 1:04Speaker 9: I got him, I got him.
- 1:07Speaker 10: Some Samantha and Joseph's footprints on the window.
- 1:14Speaker 9: Nathaniel Rowlings in Paula.
- 1:17Speaker 11: This was hard cry for help.
- 1:21Speaker 12: While we're swinging, while we're saving in whatever rage is
- 1:25Speaker 12: going on, and there's not a cut on him.
- 1:31Speaker 11: How do you accomplish that with this?
- 1:41Speaker 3: This is what he's gonna tell me.
- 1:42Speaker 7: I'm a noun situation and the gun he's trying to
- 1:46Speaker 7: find the first place to put a body.
- 1:47Speaker 13: No, sir, the only thing they could do was killing.
- 1:50Speaker 3: You want to.
- 1:50Speaker 14: Say anything, lead the jury and to find the defendant.
- 2:06Speaker 15: Columbia's home to the University of South Carolina, and.
- 2:10Speaker 16: For students, the place to be on a Thursday night
- 2:13Speaker 16: is a part of town called Five Points.
- 2:15Speaker 17: Burdog Barr is right in the middle of all of it.
- 2:18Speaker 17: So when you get close to that two am hour,
- 2:21Speaker 17: it gets pretty crowded out on the streets with folks
- 2:23Speaker 17: looking to get something to eat or catch a ride home.
- 2:26Speaker 16: That's what college senior Samantha J. Justinson was trying to do,
- 2:29Speaker 16: catch a ride home.
- 2:31Speaker 17: She'd come down here from Robbinsville, New Jersey. She was
- 2:35Speaker 17: about to finish up and was getting ready for graduation
- 2:38Speaker 17: in May.
- 2:39Speaker 2: She was getting ready to get into law school and
- 2:42Speaker 2: they were kind of throwing her a little party for
- 2:44Speaker 2: getting into law school.
- 2:45Speaker 3: She was tired.
- 2:47Speaker 2: She wanted to go home, but she didn't want to
- 2:49Speaker 2: spoil the party for her friends, so she went outside
- 2:53Speaker 2: and called her an Uber.
- 2:54Speaker 17: The ride was confirmed that it was on the way.
- 2:57Speaker 17: As she was waiting, she talked to her boyfriend again
- 3:00Speaker 17: on the phone.
- 3:01Speaker 4: It seems that when she walked outside, as opposed to
- 3:04Speaker 4: taking a right, which is where she was supposed to
- 3:08Speaker 4: meet the ride, she took a left, so.
- 3:10Speaker 17: They never got synced up together, and eventually the actual
- 3:14Speaker 17: Uber driver had to cancel the ride because he could
- 3:17Speaker 17: not find her to pick her up. She's still looking
- 3:20Speaker 17: for the ride. She doesn't realize that it's been canceled.
- 3:22Speaker 17: At this point, there were several other ride shares that
- 3:26Speaker 17: came by. She walked up to the car, tried to
- 3:29Speaker 17: approach it as if it was hers, and then quickly
- 3:32Speaker 17: realized it was not hers. She then goes back over
- 3:36Speaker 17: to the corner to the curb and stands there and
- 3:38Speaker 17: continues to wait.
- 3:39Speaker 16: The Uber was supposed to be a dark colored Dot,
- 3:42Speaker 16: but a dark colored Chevy Impalak is also nearby.
- 3:46Speaker 17: So the Chevy had been driving around five points already
- 3:49Speaker 17: there was video surveillance of the car circling through five
- 3:53Speaker 17: points for about the previous fifteen minutes or so, and
- 3:57Speaker 17: including one time it had driven by about five minutes
- 4:00Speaker 17: prior he'd circle.
- 4:01Speaker 4: He'd way, never engaging with anybody, never stopping to talk
- 4:04Speaker 4: to anybody, but just circle in the area. It's almost
- 4:07Speaker 4: like a shark circling in the water.
- 4:09Speaker 17: She's standing outside alone. The Chevy then does a U
- 4:14Speaker 17: turn about a block away and comes back around, and
- 4:17Speaker 17: as he approaches where she's standing, pulls into the parking
- 4:20Speaker 17: lot next to where she is.
- 4:22Speaker 5: Samantha looks towards him as if, oh, that's my ride.
- 4:28Speaker 6: He spent a lot of time in search of a victim,
- 4:31Speaker 6: and he found somebody that you know, was vulnerable and
- 4:34Speaker 6: obviously confused on you know what car was her uber
- 4:39Speaker 6: ride and took advantage of that.
- 4:42Speaker 2: She had been drinking that night, but she didn't look
- 4:44Speaker 2: like she was in any kind of distress or anything.
- 4:47Speaker 2: She willingly got in the vehicle because like she thought
- 4:50Speaker 2: it was her Uber drives off and that's the last
- 4:53Speaker 2: time that you know, we could see her on any.
- 4:56Speaker 5: Kind of video.
- 5:01Speaker 16: The darkened windows made it impossible to see what was
- 5:05Speaker 16: happening inside, But the car was driving off in the
- 5:08Speaker 16: wrong direction, so.
- 5:10Speaker 5: It wouldn't have taken very long for her to recognize
- 5:13Speaker 5: he was not driving in the direction of her apartment.
- 5:17Speaker 5: He has the child locks on, so she cannot open
- 5:20Speaker 5: the door. She cannot roll the windows down, they.
- 5:22Speaker 18: Are on and locked.
- 5:30Speaker 16: Samantha's friends did not call the police until the next day.
- 5:33Speaker 17: They assumed that she had gone somewhere with a friend perhaps,
- 5:38Speaker 17: and went to bed for the night. When they awoke
- 5:41Speaker 17: the next morning and saw that she still was not there,
- 5:45Speaker 17: that's when they began to worry and attempted to try
- 5:49Speaker 17: to find her. If she worked in a local restaurant
- 5:51Speaker 17: here in Columbia and she was due to work that
- 5:53Speaker 17: morning and never missed work, was never late for work.
- 5:57Speaker 16: Using a feature on her phone, Samantha's friend's track where
- 6:00Speaker 16: she had gone.
- 6:01Speaker 4: And at some point in time her phone just stopped tracking.
- 6:04Speaker 16: Then the friends went back to the Bird Dog restaurant
- 6:07Speaker 16: and got the surveillance video. Now it was time to
- 6:11Speaker 16: call the police.
- 6:14Speaker 2: So it was like ten hours after she'd been missing.
- 6:17Speaker 6: Well, this was more than a missing person, this was
- 6:20Speaker 6: an abduction.
- 6:21Speaker 19: Samantha would call us or text us every day and
- 6:25Speaker 19: she hadn't done, so that day.
- 6:27Speaker 2: I actually put out what we call a bolo be
- 6:29Speaker 2: on the lookout co't. We couldn't get a license plate.
- 6:33Speaker 2: All we could get was that it was a black Impala.
- 6:35Speaker 2: That was pretty much all we could get from the video.
- 6:39Speaker 4: Couldn't pinport the car owner at that point, but we
- 6:41Speaker 4: could say it was a late model Chevy and Pala,
- 6:45Speaker 4: and we're able to at least narrow the search down
- 6:49Speaker 4: a little bit from there.
- 6:50Speaker 16: Time was of the essence to find Samantha as new
- 6:53Speaker 16: clues came in videos of the possible suspect.
- 7:00Speaker 4: He attempted to use her debit card or a credit
- 7:02Speaker 4: card multiple times at different banks, two times at a
- 7:06Speaker 4: Welles Fargo that was in Sumter, South Carolina, at an
- 7:08Speaker 4: ATM in nine times actually at another location about forty
- 7:13Speaker 4: five miles from that that was actually in the Columbia area.
- 7:16Speaker 16: And then the staff that are Wendy's drives are reported
- 7:18Speaker 16: they may have seen the suspect in his car, a
- 7:21Speaker 16: white sheet covering the headrest and part of the back seat,
- 7:25Speaker 16: but there was no side of Samantha Justinson.
- 7:28Speaker 7: So it was a complete panic.
- 7:31Speaker 3: My heart.
- 7:34Speaker 7: Dropped to my stomach. For whatever reason, I knew that
- 7:37Speaker 7: I had to get down there.
- 7:38Speaker 16: Samantha's parents, Marcy and Seymour Justinson, headed to South Carolina
- 7:43Speaker 16: from their home in New Jersey.
- 7:45Speaker 7: And I would say about maybe four hours into the ride.
- 7:49Speaker 7: Five hours into the ride, Officer Odem called me from
- 7:57Speaker 7: the Columbia Police Department and for the second time asked
- 8:01Speaker 7: me what's my eta and hung up the phone, and
- 8:08Speaker 7: I just said, this is not good. I this is
- 8:11Speaker 7: going to end really bad.
- 8:13Speaker 16: There had been an ominous report an hour and a
- 8:16Speaker 16: half away from Columbia from the sheriff in the Clarendon
- 8:19Speaker 16: County town of New Zion.
- 8:21Speaker 5: It is in the middle of nowhere. Two hunters had
- 8:24Speaker 5: been in the area, were looking for turkey and just
- 8:27Speaker 5: came upon her body.
- 8:29Speaker 20: She was.
- 8:32Speaker 17: Covered in her own blood on her face, her arms,
- 8:36Speaker 17: her legs, her feet. There were numerous wounds all over
- 8:39Speaker 17: her body.
- 8:40Speaker 2: They called up to our department and requested a picture
- 8:45Speaker 2: of her, which came off the video that she was
- 8:48Speaker 2: last seen in. So she had all the same clothes
- 8:50Speaker 2: that she was found in.
- 8:52Speaker 7: And when we got to the police department, they brought
- 8:54Speaker 7: us into a conference room. They really couldn't identify her
- 8:58Speaker 7: because of everything that had happened, how bad she was,
- 9:03Speaker 7: and they said that we're very confident that.
- 9:09Speaker 3: This is your daughter.
- 9:12Speaker 16: And then the parents had to tell their other daughter, Sydney,
- 9:16Speaker 16: still back in New Jersey.
- 9:17Speaker 7: And that was the hardest call I have her had
- 9:25Speaker 7: to make, was telling Sidney that her younger sister was dead,
- 9:35Speaker 7: you know, broke our heart. But to hear her drop
- 9:40Speaker 7: to the ground screaming and not being there for her
- 9:50Speaker 7: hurts still does to this day.
- 9:54Speaker 16: Police filed to the justice in that they would find
- 9:57Speaker 16: the killer, the mystery man in the black chad.
- 10:00Speaker 3: The impact.
- 10:10Speaker 1: He isn't going to be a black you know, there
- 10:13Speaker 1: was an immediate fear throughout the community and that we
- 10:16Speaker 1: had the predator on the lease. We literally were looking
- 10:19Speaker 1: for a black impalace city wide.
- 10:21Speaker 6: We had every officer that was available looking for that car.
- 10:24Speaker 4: And you know, we had.
- 10:26Speaker 1: Our foot on the accelerator and we didn't take it
- 10:28Speaker 1: off till we were able to make an arrest.
- 10:33Speaker 8: That's something that doesn't really happen in our city. And
- 10:35Speaker 8: I just watched that video for getting that car easily
- 10:38Speaker 8: on hundred times perty going to shift. I wanted that car.
- 10:42Speaker 16: When Columbia Police Officer Jeffrey Kraft began his shift, he
- 10:46Speaker 16: decided to patrol around the same five Points area where
- 10:49Speaker 16: Samantha Justinson had disappeared.
- 10:52Speaker 8: And I just circulated that area for hours and hours
- 10:54Speaker 8: and hours looking for that car matched that description and
- 10:57Speaker 8: happened to find it within a couple of blocks away
- 10:59Speaker 8: from Word Ends took place. It was like two thirty
- 11:10Speaker 8: in the morning. That was the last place I thought
- 11:16Speaker 8: I would find him. It's an adrenaline rush, and it
- 11:22Speaker 8: took him a couple of seconds to pull over, and
- 11:24Speaker 8: you can see some movement going on in the car.
- 11:27Speaker 16: Officer Craft did not know that Samantha's body had already
- 11:31Speaker 16: been discovered.
- 11:32Speaker 8: My was hopes to find Samantha Joseph still inside the car.
- 11:38Speaker 8: When I approached the car, of course, I smelled the
- 11:41Speaker 8: odor of marijuana come from the cars. And then I
- 11:45Speaker 8: approached him and the seat was far back. You know,
- 11:49Speaker 8: it was unusual. What's going on, sir? You got your license,
- 11:55Speaker 8: got a license on you? I want colub me please
- 11:57Speaker 8: forman K nine license on you.
- 12:07Speaker 3: Gonna be a black.
- 12:10Speaker 4: Twenty eight that played a.
- 12:12Speaker 3: Who's smoking the marijuana?
- 12:22Speaker 8: Alright, man, that's stup on out man, here's the deal man,
- 12:34Speaker 8: I bolt your car over to the matress and suspect,
- 12:35Speaker 8: get your hand in your pocket.
- 12:36Speaker 3: What are you crazy? Get over here, Hey, get out here,
- 12:41Speaker 3: got run. We reached the dog. I can't help. Just stop.
- 12:49Speaker 3: Brother Mike wearing a great sweat pants, great sweatshirt, welcome
- 12:54Speaker 3: up doors blots a five hundred block h nudis keep
- 13:00Speaker 3: goings go me on your left. He out ran me.
- 13:06Speaker 3: He was fast, Temple. I'm gonna go back to the
- 13:10Speaker 3: car and rolled on.
- 13:10Speaker 8: You really shouna leave the car especially, you know. My
- 13:13Speaker 8: thought is, hey, that's where there's evidence inside of the car.
- 13:15Speaker 16: And there was a female passenger in the front seat.
- 13:18Speaker 16: Who should know the identity of the driver who ran away?
- 13:23Speaker 3: What's his name? Nate?
- 13:27Speaker 16: Nate the first clue to the suspect's identity through a.
- 13:31Speaker 8: Probable call search for the marijuana coming from inside the vehicle,
- 13:34Speaker 8: and while searching that vehicles, when I find a side
- 13:36Speaker 8: of keys, I looked at a pinky chain, which I
- 13:38Speaker 8: thought was odd.
- 13:39Speaker 3: Whose car is this his car? Did you usually have
- 13:44Speaker 3: pink keychain?
- 13:46Speaker 16: It's a sister looking for anything that might belong to Sabantha,
- 13:51Speaker 16: the missing person called an eighty one in police jarget.
- 13:57Speaker 3: And do you know what kind of cell phone or
- 13:59Speaker 3: eighty one has reported today?
- 14:06Speaker 8: That's why I stopped because the matches the description. I'm
- 14:09Speaker 8: finding the girl's cell phone and the girl's keys in
- 14:11Speaker 8: the driver's seat.
- 14:24Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, that's a pink iPhone.
- 14:29Speaker 8: Pink keys for the USB driving did just good for students,
- 14:33Speaker 8: and the keys labeled room.
- 14:36Speaker 3: Yeah, it's kind of weird.
- 14:38Speaker 8: And then uh, once we go in the back seat,
- 14:40Speaker 8: another also brought up to my attention and saying, hey,
- 14:42Speaker 8: you know, we found a bunch of blood in the
- 14:44Speaker 8: back seat. Look at the back seat right here, it's
- 14:47Speaker 8: blood all over his car.
- 14:47Speaker 3: Men, We're not.
- 14:48Speaker 4: Gonna touch something else.
- 14:51Speaker 3: Just leave what we got from now makes sense.
- 14:52Speaker 8: Now that's where like, hey, we got a major crime
- 14:55Speaker 8: scene here, apostile murder of uh scene of a murder.
- 14:58Speaker 8: Let's back up and all our professionals Crimectine, Texas.
- 15:02Speaker 3: I got him, I got him, I got.
- 15:06Speaker 7: Some.
- 15:08Speaker 16: It didn't take long to track down the drivers.
- 15:14Speaker 4: Multiple officers came to the area and they were able
- 15:16Speaker 4: to uh to secure him about two blocks away from
- 15:19Speaker 4: the area where he ran.
- 15:20Speaker 12: Ultimately, I'm agread you're right sir, all right, Roger mainsign
- 15:24Speaker 12: that anything you say can would be used against the corlaw.
- 15:27Speaker 17: At that point, he wasn't really saying a whole lot,
- 15:30Speaker 17: and wasn't even saying what his name was.
- 15:32Speaker 3: It's a yes no answer.
- 15:35Speaker 16: Come on, man, sit up.
- 15:37Speaker 3: Yeah, I know you're tired after running. I get it,
- 15:39Speaker 3: but sit up. Come on, do you understand you sues
- 15:42Speaker 3: his wives have explained to you yes or no.
- 15:45Speaker 16: He claimed he had the flu, so the officers called
- 15:48Speaker 16: EMTs to check him out and then take him in
- 15:51Speaker 16: for questioning. Soon identified as Nathaniel Rowland, twenty four years old.
- 15:57Speaker 17: He was reluctant to provide much information. Initially, he denied
- 16:01Speaker 17: having been in Five Points the night before. He indicated
- 16:04Speaker 17: that he had been going to house parties the night before,
- 16:08Speaker 17: but he could not provide any specific information about who
- 16:11Speaker 17: he was with, or what parties he was at, or
- 16:14Speaker 17: anything of that nature.
- 16:15Speaker 16: And Roland denied having been anywhere near the town of
- 16:18Speaker 16: New Zion, where Samantha's body had been discovered.
- 16:21Speaker 17: Investcators later found out that his parents actually still live
- 16:25Speaker 17: and his family still lives in the New Zion area, so.
- 16:29Speaker 4: New Zion is not a big town. It's a small place.
- 16:32Speaker 4: It's not someplace that you go to unless you're trying
- 16:35Speaker 4: to get there that you start putting the pieces of
- 16:37Speaker 4: the puzzle together. That was one of those pieces. That
- 16:39Speaker 4: was a major piece that just you know, the place
- 16:42Speaker 4: where she's found just happens to be a little you know,
- 16:45Speaker 4: just you know, a mile as the crow flies from
- 16:48Speaker 4: his family home.
- 16:50Speaker 16: But investigators were scratching their heads over why Roland, if
- 16:54Speaker 16: he was indeed the killer, would have driven right back
- 16:57Speaker 16: into the Five Points area where police were looking for
- 17:00Speaker 16: a black Chevy IMPAULA.
- 17:01Speaker 6: Well, that's a great question for a psychiatrist. I guess
- 17:05Speaker 6: for us, you know, better to be lucky than good sometimes,
- 17:09Speaker 6: and it's a good thing for us that criminals often
- 17:13Speaker 6: make bad decisions, poor decisions. Don't know what was, you know,
- 17:17Speaker 6: going through his mind. I think God had his hand
- 17:20Speaker 6: on us that day. There was certainly some divine intervention.
- 17:24Speaker 16: But prosecutors knew he was going to take more than
- 17:26Speaker 16: divine intervention to build a case against Nathaniel Roland that
- 17:30Speaker 16: would stand up in court.
- 17:41Speaker 21: Good morning, and welcome to the spring twenty nineteen commencement
- 17:45Speaker 21: at the University of South Carolina.
- 17:48Speaker 16: It had been only six weeks since Samantha was murdered.
- 17:54Speaker 21: Now, I'd like to take a moment to recognize and
- 17:57Speaker 21: honor the life and the legacy of Samantha Josephson, our cherish,
- 18:02Speaker 21: twenty one year old senior political science major whose life
- 18:06Speaker 21: was tragically taken from us in March. Samantha's family is
- 18:12Speaker 21: here with us today and she'll receive her college degree
- 18:15Speaker 21: posthumously directly after this ceremony.
- 18:19Speaker 16: Samantha's parents, Marcy and Seymour Josephson, had been hesitant to
- 18:23Speaker 16: send their new Jersey daughter off to a school in
- 18:25Speaker 16: the South.
- 18:26Speaker 7: You know, we talked a lot about it because it's
- 18:28Speaker 7: completely different than the Northeast. You know, she's a female,
- 18:33Speaker 7: she's Jewish.
- 18:35Speaker 16: But at least it seems safer to them than the
- 18:37Speaker 16: big cities of the Northeast.
- 18:39Speaker 7: Everybody was, you know, very gracious and very nice upon
- 18:43Speaker 7: meeting them, so yeah, it seems safe.
- 18:46Speaker 19: We just really wanted her to be happy with whatever
- 18:48Speaker 19: she did. She wanted law school, so we were behind
- 18:52Speaker 19: her one hundred percent. Just wanted her to be happy.
- 18:57Speaker 16: And her father had told Samantha to use his had
- 19:00Speaker 16: a card to call uber whenever she needed a ride
- 19:02Speaker 16: home to take no chances.
- 19:05Speaker 7: Especially at one clock two o'clock in the morning. I
- 19:08Speaker 7: didn't want her walking.
- 19:10Speaker 16: But the surveillance video showed how it went wrong.
- 19:13Speaker 19: Because what the kids told us that they were doing.
- 19:16Speaker 19: They would say, are you here for Samantha, So Samantha
- 19:18Speaker 19: said that when she got in the car, he would
- 19:20Speaker 19: have said yes, and then they would have taken off.
- 19:23Speaker 19: If she said to the driver or you know, what's
- 19:27Speaker 19: my name and he couldn't respond to it correctly, then
- 19:30Speaker 19: she wouldn't get in the car.
- 19:31Speaker 16: But that is not what happened. And now the task
- 19:35Speaker 16: for police and prosecutors was to prove that it was
- 19:37Speaker 16: Nathaniel Roland who was behind those windows, not someone who
- 19:41Speaker 16: borrowed his car as he claimed.
- 19:44Speaker 3: Well.
- 19:44Speaker 17: The biggest weakness from the outset was that there was
- 19:47Speaker 17: no evidence that put mister Roland in the vehicle. Definitively
- 19:52Speaker 17: at the time the MSS Justicon was in the car,
- 19:55Speaker 17: you could put him as the primary driver of the vehicle.
- 19:58Speaker 10: Both before and after.
- 20:00Speaker 17: No one saw him get in or out of the vehicle.
- 20:03Speaker 17: There was no camera or anything like that that showed
- 20:05Speaker 17: his face inside the.
- 20:07Speaker 16: Vehicle, nor was it clear whether he was the man
- 20:09Speaker 16: trying to use Samantha's debit card at the different ATM machines.
- 20:14Speaker 4: He had a bandana around his head, and he also
- 20:16Speaker 4: hit the hoodie that he was wearing, hit white draws rings,
- 20:19Speaker 4: and he hit on gloves as well. He pulled the
- 20:21Speaker 4: draws rings really tight so you could never see his face.
- 20:24Speaker 16: And the autopsy and Samantha found she had not been
- 20:27Speaker 16: sexually assaulted, so no seaman to test for DNA, and
- 20:31Speaker 16: no DNA that belonged to Nathaniel Roland anywhere else on
- 20:35Speaker 16: her body, including under the fingernails.
- 20:38Speaker 4: Hit on multiple layers of clothing, and you're not going
- 20:40Speaker 4: to have skin under your fingernails with somebody's clothed.
- 20:43Speaker 16: So the key was going to be what the state
- 20:45Speaker 16: police forensics team could find inside the black Chevy Impalla,
- 20:51Speaker 16: a footprint on the inside of one of the back
- 20:53Speaker 16: seat windows, evidence of Samantha's struggles to get free.
- 21:01Speaker 17: They processed it for all men are forensic evidence, fingerprints, DNA,
- 21:06Speaker 17: hare all those sorts of things, any paperwork that's found
- 21:10Speaker 17: in the.
- 21:10Speaker 16: Car, including an eviction notice written by a female friend
- 21:15Speaker 16: of Roland's.
- 21:16Speaker 17: And ultimately that led investigators to a residence where mister
- 21:20Speaker 17: Roland had been spending time with a lady friend of
- 21:23Speaker 17: his at the time.
- 21:24Speaker 16: Her name was Maria Howard, and she had met up
- 21:27Speaker 16: with Roland the morning after Samantha disappeared.
- 21:30Speaker 17: As she's actually driving his car now and he's in
- 21:32Speaker 17: the passenger seat. He begins trying to clean the car.
- 21:35Speaker 17: He has rubber gloves that he puts on. He's wiping
- 21:39Speaker 17: down part of the console and she sees him grab
- 21:42Speaker 17: this knife or multitools it has been referred to throughout
- 21:46Speaker 17: the case, this double bladed knife that has what appears
- 21:50Speaker 17: to be blood on it. He's cleaning that off, and
- 21:53Speaker 17: that really raised some suspicions for her. She asked him
- 21:57Speaker 17: repeatedly about all of this, and he just told her
- 21:59Speaker 17: to mind her ininess repeatedly and wouldn't tell her anything
- 22:02Speaker 17: else about what occurred.
- 22:05Speaker 16: Then they searched her home looking for a physical evidence
- 22:08Speaker 16: to corroborate her story.
- 22:10Speaker 17: And it was in the garbage outside where they located
- 22:14Speaker 17: a number of valuable items of evidence, to include the
- 22:17Speaker 17: knife wrapped up in plastic grocery bags. There was whites
- 22:22Speaker 17: that had been used, paper towels, clothes of his, the
- 22:25Speaker 17: clothes that she had seen him wearing for the last
- 22:27Speaker 17: couple of days covered in blood and this black leather jacket.
- 22:33Speaker 5: If you look on the black jacket, there are striations
- 22:36Speaker 5: that looked like nails being drugged down the jacket, and
- 22:40Speaker 5: so that would be our She scratched the jacket and
- 22:43Speaker 5: trying to scratch him. They find a ton of the evidence,
- 22:46Speaker 5: and all of this is in her trash. None of
- 22:49Speaker 5: it's like laying around our house. Really, it's all either
- 22:51Speaker 5: hidden or in the trash, and so they're able to
- 22:54Speaker 5: collect all of that when they look in his car
- 22:56Speaker 5: and they see that viction letter. If they'd have just
- 22:59Speaker 5: ignored the trash, people would have picked up the trash
- 23:02Speaker 5: and all that evidence would.
- 23:02Speaker 11: Have been gone.
- 23:08Speaker 16: And Maria Howard's account also helped to explain the surveillance
- 23:11Speaker 16: video for Wendy's. A white sheet visible over the headrest.
- 23:15Speaker 15: And this is extremely important because you can see Nathaniel
- 23:18Speaker 15: Roland in the driver's seat at the Wendy's drive through
- 23:22Speaker 15: the morning to afternoon after this happened. And this is
- 23:26Speaker 15: crucial because it corroborates what Maria said that she got
- 23:31Speaker 15: into the car and she noticed that there was a
- 23:33Speaker 15: sheet draped over the backseat, and that was to cover
- 23:36Speaker 15: up essentially the evidence, the blood that came from Samantha Josephson.
- 23:42Speaker 16: So the prosecution knew as it prepared for trium that
- 23:46Speaker 16: much would depend on Maria Howard's decision to turn on
- 23:49Speaker 16: and turn against her friend Nathaniel Roman.
- 23:53Speaker 4: It was very tough. She didn't want any part of this.
- 23:55Speaker 4: She had nothing to do with what happened to Samantha.
- 23:58Speaker 4: I mean, she was afraid for her life and her
- 24:00Speaker 4: child's life.
- 24:11Speaker 19: We had to be present at the trial for Samantha
- 24:15Speaker 19: as a family unit, as our friends. We just needed
- 24:18Speaker 19: to be there to make sure that he got what
- 24:21Speaker 19: was what he deserved.
- 24:23Speaker 13: We'll proceed now to opening statements from.
- 24:27Speaker 16: The state Solicitor Byron Gibson opened the case for the prosecution.
- 24:33Speaker 4: Ladies and gentlemen of the jury. March twenty eighth, twenty nineteen,
- 24:39Speaker 4: was supposed to be a celebration. Samantha Josephson and friends
- 24:44Speaker 4: were gathering together as a celebration of life. But what
- 24:48Speaker 4: they didn't realize, what they could never have realized, is
- 24:53Speaker 4: that the defendant, Nathaniel David Roland hit his eyes firmly
- 25:00Speaker 4: fixed on Samantha Josephson, the evidence will show that after
- 25:05Speaker 4: she got into that vehicle, that's the last time that
- 25:09Speaker 4: anybody saw her alive.
- 25:12Speaker 16: But the prosecutor knew the jurors would soon hear from
- 25:15Speaker 16: the defense about the lack of DNA evidence anywhere on
- 25:18Speaker 16: Samantha's body that tied Roland to the crime.
- 25:22Speaker 4: With all things being considered, the simplest explanation is the truth.
- 25:28Speaker 4: We believe that the simple explanation is that Nathaniel David
- 25:34Speaker 4: Roland kidnapped Samantha Josephson. We believe that's a simple explanation
- 25:41Speaker 4: is that Nathaniel David Roland murdered Samantha joseph After you
- 25:46Speaker 4: hear all of the evidence in this case, we'll be
- 25:48Speaker 4: asking that you return a burden took guilty of all
- 25:50Speaker 4: counts because he is indeed guilty in all counts. Thank
- 25:55Speaker 4: you for your time, Thank you for depictions.
- 26:00Speaker 16: Leisha Good of the Public Defender's Office presented the defense
- 26:03Speaker 16: opening statement.
- 26:05Speaker 20: Zero.
- 26:09Speaker 11: That's the amount of DNA.
- 26:13Speaker 22: On Samantha Josephson's body that matches Nathaniel Roland.
- 26:17Speaker 23: Zero.
- 26:21Speaker 22: It's not on her clothing, it's not under her ripped
- 26:25Speaker 22: and torn fingernails, it's not on her ankles, ladies and gentlemen,
- 26:31Speaker 22: there's zero evidence that Nathaniel Roland was the one that
- 26:38Speaker 22: kidnapped and killed Samantha Josephson.
- 26:41Speaker 3: Thank you very much.
- 26:48Speaker 11: They would now call Maria Howard.
- 26:53Speaker 17: She was crucial to the case. They had to hear
- 26:56Speaker 17: from somebody other than cops and the analysts. They needed
- 27:01Speaker 17: to hear from somebody who had spent some time with
- 27:03Speaker 17: Mr Rowland.
- 27:04Speaker 16: Roland's girlfriend described how she first wondered what happened to
- 27:07Speaker 16: the visor she needed for her work that was missing
- 27:10Speaker 16: for the Chevy and Paula.
- 27:12Speaker 11: Did you ask him about that?
- 27:13Speaker 24: This moon?
- 27:13Speaker 3: And what he tell you?
- 27:15Speaker 11: That it was in the country? And what'd you say
- 27:18Speaker 11: to that? Why would it be in the country? And
- 27:20Speaker 11: what he tell you it had blood in it? And
- 27:22Speaker 11: when did you repeat that it had blood on it?
- 27:24Speaker 11: He told you that the visor had blood on it?
- 27:26Speaker 3: This mood?
- 27:26Speaker 11: Did you ask him? What'd you ask him? Why would
- 27:29Speaker 11: that ha have blood on it?
- 27:30Speaker 17: And what he tell you?
- 27:33Speaker 11: Can you telling me mind my business? Mindja business? Did
- 27:36Speaker 11: you ask him again?
- 27:37Speaker 4: Yes?
- 27:38Speaker 6: And what he tell you?
- 27:39Speaker 11: Mind my business? And what if anything did you notice
- 27:43Speaker 11: about the car at that point? That it was like
- 27:47Speaker 11: dry blood in the car.
- 27:49Speaker 17: Where in the car, on the dashboard and beside the seats,
- 27:54Speaker 17: and where else did you see blood in the back seat?
- 27:56Speaker 11: In the back seat, was anything else in the back seat.
- 27:58Speaker 11: There was a sheet over the over the backseat and
- 28:02Speaker 11: the back of the driver's.
- 28:03Speaker 16: Seat, matching the video of the car at the Wendy's
- 28:07Speaker 16: drive through.
- 28:08Speaker 18: These are just.
- 28:08Speaker 15: Small things, small details that corroborate previous testimony that are
- 28:12Speaker 15: extremely important.
- 28:14Speaker 5: I'm gonna show you what the mark the States is
- 28:16Speaker 5: at number thirteen and ask if you recognize.
- 28:18Speaker 10: Thatlf, m'am, what is that?
- 28:21Speaker 16: The data was cleaning the knife that had both his
- 28:24Speaker 16: and Samantha's DNA on it.
- 28:29Speaker 11: And when you saw his car.
- 28:31Speaker 24: I believe you said earlier you saw his car at
- 28:33Speaker 24: some point on the news, yes, ma'am. And I believe
- 28:37Speaker 24: you said you put two and two together, yes, ma'am.
- 28:39Speaker 24: Can you again explain to the story why you didn't.
- 28:41Speaker 11: Call the police then?
- 28:42Speaker 25: Because I was scared, scared of boy Mo for my
- 28:45Speaker 25: life and my child.
- 28:49Speaker 11: No further question, Dring.
- 28:50Speaker 5: She had to come in and testify about what was
- 28:53Speaker 5: probably the most horrendous two days of her life, and.
- 28:56Speaker 3: She did it.
- 28:57Speaker 7: She paid the price, then afterwards of having death threats
- 29:00Speaker 7: and being put into bad situations, losing her job because
- 29:05Speaker 7: she couldn't go back to work because of the death threats.
- 29:08Speaker 11: We owe a lot to her for.
- 29:11Speaker 19: Testifying.
- 29:18Speaker 16: The prosecution had played long stretches of the surveillance video
- 29:22Speaker 16: showing the black Chevy im Paula that night, but it
- 29:24Speaker 16: was impossible to see who the driver was.
- 29:28Speaker 11: They called Oshimer.
- 29:29Speaker 26: Williams clear on hers with the true hetty healthy got
- 29:36Speaker 26: the now.
- 29:37Speaker 16: Detectives had turned up a witness, Oshimer Williams, who ran
- 29:40Speaker 16: a cell phone repair. Shot at his store's cameras showed
- 29:44Speaker 16: a man who had tried to sell Samantha's cell phone
- 29:47Speaker 16: the morning after she disappeared.
- 29:50Speaker 5: Do you see the person who tried to sell you
- 29:52Speaker 5: the phone in the courtroom?
- 29:54Speaker 11: Where is he? What does he have on on? For
- 30:00Speaker 11: sure talk? Please let the record reflect that he has
- 30:04Speaker 11: identified the defending your own.
- 30:06Speaker 13: It does thank you're number the question you, sir, may
- 30:10Speaker 13: step down.
- 30:14Speaker 16: The final days of the trial focused on the physical evidence.
- 30:18Speaker 3: This is states Exhibit one eighty six the brawl.
- 30:22Speaker 19: There were times where I had to put my head
- 30:24Speaker 19: down because I didn't want to see certain things that
- 30:28Speaker 19: they were showing rob We had in our mind what
- 30:34Speaker 19: had happened, but it was a lot worse. Going through
- 30:39Speaker 19: the trial was very difficult. Definitely.
- 30:42Speaker 11: So this is the left shoe.
- 30:45Speaker 27: This strap is still intact.
- 30:48Speaker 7: However it was on attached to the front of her
- 30:51Speaker 7: left foot. Made it one hundred and ten percent worse
- 30:55Speaker 7: because of all the information and how crude all it was.
- 31:00Speaker 16: But on cross examination, the crime scene investigator was asked
- 31:03Speaker 16: about the photos she took of Roland after his arrest.
- 31:06Speaker 16: Was there any evidence he had been involved in a
- 31:09Speaker 16: violent struggle.
- 31:10Speaker 11: You don't see anything on him right in what terms?
- 31:13Speaker 11: On his face as far as scratches, As far as scratches, no,
- 31:17Speaker 11: I do not. You don't see any marks. I do
- 31:19Speaker 11: not see any marks on his face. I do not
- 31:21Speaker 11: see cuts on his face.
- 31:23Speaker 22: The same thing with the arms, same thing, both sides
- 31:27Speaker 22: correct and his hands correct.
- 31:32Speaker 11: Thank you very much.
- 31:34Speaker 16: The defense had made its most important point, and Nathaniel
- 31:38Speaker 16: Roland's lawyers decided they did not need to call any
- 31:41Speaker 16: of their own witnesses, did not need to put on
- 31:44Speaker 16: their own case.
- 31:55Speaker 13: Good morning, you have heard all of the evidence. It's
- 31:59Speaker 13: now time to close arguments.
- 32:01Speaker 17: Yes, sir, your uncle ladies and gentlemen, twenty one year
- 32:05Speaker 17: old Samantha Josephson did not deserve this.
- 32:10Speaker 10: The Samantha Josephin's blood was on everything. It was all
- 32:16Speaker 10: over that car, the back seats, the headrests, and let's
- 32:21Speaker 10: not forget that her blood was on the blade of
- 32:25Speaker 10: this way, the one that he was seeing cleaning in
- 32:29Speaker 10: the car. Samantha Joseph's footprints were on the window Nathaniel
- 32:37Speaker 10: Rollings in Paula the inside.
- 32:40Speaker 9: This was her cry for help.
- 32:47Speaker 10: This was her way to try to get somebody to
- 32:50Speaker 10: help her and save her from him.
- 32:52Speaker 9: But also what it did, She left a trail. She
- 32:59Speaker 9: left her own trail of evidence, her.
- 33:03Speaker 26: Own trail.
- 33:05Speaker 11: Leading right to the defendant.
- 33:09Speaker 26: I told you before, Samantha's whole life was right there,
- 33:16Speaker 26: was right there in front of her. She could have
- 33:19Speaker 26: been anything that she wanted to be, and it.
- 33:24Speaker 11: Was right there for the taking.
- 33:27Speaker 9: To do whatever she wanted.
- 33:31Speaker 11: The defendant did.
- 33:33Speaker 21: The taking.
- 33:38Speaker 10: Took her from five points, He took her life.
- 33:50Speaker 16: Roland's lawyer, Tracy Pitdick pointed to the lack of evidence.
- 33:54Speaker 23: Nathaniel Roland did not have a mark on him, not
- 34:01Speaker 23: a cut, not a bruise, they check them and nothing.
- 34:10Speaker 3: Now, how.
- 34:13Speaker 11: In the back seat of a car.
- 34:17Speaker 20: In the dark, with a young woman who is fighting
- 34:20Speaker 20: for her life, somebody is supposed to hold this, this
- 34:24Speaker 20: tool with a blade literally pointed in their direction and
- 34:30Speaker 20: not injure themselves in some way.
- 34:33Speaker 11: How somebody does that is beyond me.
- 34:37Speaker 20: It's it's this law when it's the other yell, look,
- 34:43Speaker 20: just try to get it.
- 34:44Speaker 11: Look at it.
- 34:46Speaker 12: Wildly swinging, wildly, stabbing in whatever rage is going on,
- 34:53Speaker 12: and there's not a cut on it.
- 34:57Speaker 23: How do you accomplish that.
- 35:00Speaker 5: With this?
- 35:02Speaker 11: She put up a fight and Nathan and Roland had
- 35:04Speaker 11: not a mark on him.
- 35:06Speaker 4: That is what we know.
- 35:07Speaker 18: They've created a narrative and he's the villain in their
- 35:11Speaker 18: narrative because for them, he is the easy answer. He
- 35:15Speaker 18: is the simple answer. In this case, it's the wrong answer.
- 35:20Speaker 18: It is the wrong answer. The state has not proven that.
- 35:25Speaker 11: Nathaniel Roland kidnapped Samantha Joseson.
- 35:30Speaker 18: They have not proven that he has killed her, and
- 35:33Speaker 18: they have not proven that he had a weapon during
- 35:35Speaker 18: those crimes.
- 35:37Speaker 11: What they prove is that he tried to sell her
- 35:39Speaker 11: cell phone.
- 35:40Speaker 20: He's not on trial for that.
- 35:44Speaker 18: They have failed at meeting their burden.
- 35:47Speaker 11: I asked that you find him not guilty. Thank you.
- 35:53Speaker 16: The jury came back after one hour and seven minutes.
- 35:59Speaker 13: Uh, her, you reached a verdict. Is it unanimous? Okay?
- 36:04Speaker 13: If you will passed it up please, and you may
- 36:06Speaker 13: be seated, Madame clerk, you may publish the verdicts.
- 36:11Speaker 11: Says versus. The role is invited for her usually undefended.
- 36:25Speaker 3: Yes.
- 36:37Speaker 16: The court moved immediately to the sentencing phase, and Samantha's
- 36:41Speaker 16: parents and her older sister Sidney finally had the opportunity
- 36:45Speaker 16: to voice their anguish Nothing will replace her.
- 36:49Speaker 6: Nothing I can say will bring her back, and nothing
- 36:52Speaker 6: that I can say I know will use my family's
- 36:54Speaker 6: skin and heartache.
- 36:55Speaker 19: No time to say goodbye, No time to tell Sahim
- 36:59Speaker 19: all the things I will have wanted to say.
- 37:01Speaker 11: No time because kiss her Cavalos. We were thrown into
- 37:07Speaker 11: this world of terror. My world is now complete.
- 37:11Speaker 19: Nothing but memories can fill the emptiness of Sammy's passing.
- 37:15Speaker 11: He is pure evil. I pray that he feels Smail's pain.
- 37:20Speaker 16: But the prosecution had already decided not to seek the
- 37:23Speaker 16: death penalty for Roland, and the family reluctantly agreed.
- 37:27Speaker 3: I fought for it.
- 37:28Speaker 7: Up to the last month, I've wanted the death penalty.
- 37:32Speaker 7: I've wanted him execute it.
- 37:34Speaker 27: Do I tell you that I've complicated suicide so several
- 37:43Speaker 27: times over the past twenty eight months.
- 37:46Speaker 7: I did stop a couple of times to look at
- 37:50Speaker 7: him and to make sure that he knew that I
- 37:52Speaker 7: was talking about him.
- 38:00Speaker 27: He the monster has stolen this bright light, this enthusiasm
- 38:04Speaker 27: of light out of me.
- 38:06Speaker 11: In the end, you have taken my baby away, Judge,
- 38:13Speaker 11: I only.
- 38:13Speaker 27: Wish we could inflict the same or more pain be
- 38:17Speaker 27: inflicted upon Sam.
- 38:19Speaker 11: Please, I thank you. Please give him light and never
- 38:24Speaker 11: see the light.
- 38:28Speaker 16: The defense called Roland's mother, Loretta, to speak for him.
- 38:32Speaker 25: Thank you you.
- 38:34Speaker 12: Does thing have accused our son of crimes that he
- 38:37Speaker 12: hasn't didn't committed.
- 38:41Speaker 13: I'm not gonna hear him any claim of innocence. He's
- 38:45Speaker 13: been convicted by the jury.
- 38:47Speaker 11: Okay, he's a very Karen young man.
- 38:52Speaker 9: I know my son didn't do this.
- 38:56Speaker 13: He is guilty of murder. And if he had any
- 38:59Speaker 13: any testimony that you wanted to give for the jury
- 39:02Speaker 13: to consider the trial, was the time to do that.
- 39:05Speaker 13: I'm not listening to any claim of what he did
- 39:08Speaker 13: not do. You are not a witness.
- 39:14Speaker 11: When he's a lovely child. He's a good person, very
- 39:17Speaker 11: respected and respect.
- 39:19Speaker 14: Of And I say the court and.
- 39:26Speaker 13: I feel uh defend that would come before the court
- 39:30Speaker 13: for sentencing. Is there anything you would like to say.
- 39:41Speaker 3: I'm gonna.
- 39:47Speaker 25: I know him anything, but I guess what I know
- 39:53Speaker 25: and what I think really doesn't matter. M I just
- 40:01Speaker 25: wish the state would've would've done more and finding out
- 40:07Speaker 25: who to ask what a person was, instead of being
- 40:11Speaker 25: satisfied with with detaining me and proving my guilt. I
- 40:28Speaker 25: feel like they if they would've done further research in
- 40:33Speaker 25: certain areas, that's all out.
- 40:44Speaker 13: M I have dealt with the heartless and you fall
- 40:50Speaker 13: into that category a person without any remorse whatsoever. And
- 40:57Speaker 13: for whomever asked me for leniens, see, yeah, that's not
- 41:01Speaker 13: part of my DNA. The sentence in this case is easy,
- 41:10Speaker 13: though painful.
- 41:11Speaker 25: It may be.
- 41:13Speaker 13: The sentence of the court for murder is that you
- 41:16Speaker 13: be committed to the State Department of Corrections for life.
- 41:23Speaker 13: So thanks to all if you're removing mister mister Rover
- 41:27Speaker 13: from the courtroom.
- 41:35Speaker 16: Since then, the Justinson's have launched a campaign so that
- 41:38Speaker 16: what happened to Samantha when she got in the wrong
- 41:40Speaker 16: car that night. Does not happen to anyone else.
- 41:45Speaker 19: If she said to the driver, you know, what's my name,
- 41:48Speaker 19: and he couldn't respond to it correctly, then she wouldn't
- 41:52Speaker 19: get in the car.
- 41:53Speaker 7: Once you're in the car, it's too late. We started
- 41:56Speaker 7: the What's My Name Foundation.
- 41:58Speaker 16: Hoping their daughter's life legacy will be one that saves lives.
- 42:04Speaker 21: Class of twenty nineteen, On account of three, would you
- 42:08Speaker 21: join me in repeating what's my name? My name is
- 42:12Speaker 21: Samantha Josephson altogether? One, two, three, what's my name? My
- 42:19Speaker 21: name is Samantha Josephson. Thank you, everybody,