Latest / Serves You Right / #73 Rajat Parr: Why Winemaker Is the Wrong Word
Transcript
- 0:02Focus on organic, try to try to work, try to drink, try to
- 0:06taste, try to see people who farm organically.
- 0:09It's important because really, wine is a living beverage.
- 0:14Breathing is living every day. It's changing every day.
- 0:18And if it's neutral chemicals and if it's completely dumbed
- 0:23down with all the additives, then it's not alive.
- 0:25And that's not wine. Thank you for listening to
- 0:30Serves Your Right. My name is Andrew and today I
- 0:33have a treat for everyone out there.
- 0:34We are talking to the world famous Somalia, Rajat Parr.
- 0:39I first came into contact with Raj with his book Secrets of the
- 0:43Somalia. He has since written another.
- 0:46A lot of people know him from his appearance of the movie Saw.
- 0:49He is a world class blind taster and recently has been focusing
- 0:54on Phelan Farms, growing grapes and making wine.
- 0:59So super exciting talk. I was thrilled to get a hold of
- 1:03Rajat. And without any further ado,
- 1:06here is serves your rights and I hope you enjoy it.
- 1:13Well, cool. Hey, Rajat Bar, thanks for
- 1:16coming on. Serves your right.
- 1:18Yeah. Thank you.
- 1:19Thanks for having. Me, of course, I wanted to
- 1:21start. I, I was wondering, and I tried
- 1:24to frame this in a couple of different ways, but I thought
- 1:27I'd frame it. How did probably one of the most
- 1:31famous and well known Psalms in the world end up farming?
- 1:35You know that that's quite a transition, or at least to my
- 1:39mind. Maybe not, but.
- 1:41Yeah, you know, working in restaurants, you know, when like
- 1:45maybe, you know, I worked the floor for 18 years and the last
- 1:50maybe like year 1213, I'm like, I was thinking to myself, I'm
- 1:53like, you know, I'm going to turn 40 soon and you know, how
- 1:57much longer am I going to work the floor?
- 1:59And, and also the times were changing because it was like,
- 2:02you know, service, you know, I, I think for me, the constant
- 2:08like, I think stopping service, like, oh, take a photo.
- 2:12I was in the bottle. It was just, it became a little
- 2:14bit. And I, my patients after 18 down
- 2:16there, I'm going to find something else.
- 2:18You know, I, I, I can't work the floor all the time because I
- 2:21love working the floor. And then I kind of started
- 2:23making a little bit of wine. And that's what I, you know,
- 2:27after I made wine, I kind of, I did both for several years
- 2:30between 2004 and TWEN till maybe 2014 or even 16.
- 2:40I did both. I was like, working the floor a
- 2:42few days a week and in the cellar.
- 2:44And not until the pandemic, I really felt the urge to farm.
- 2:49I was like, it's the best time to learn something I haven't
- 2:52done before. Because, you know, making wine
- 2:55and farming are two different things.
- 2:57And I think sometimes there's mistaken that I'm a wine maker.
- 3:01So you make the wine. But like really, a wine maker
- 3:03should be a wine grower. The word doesn't exist.
- 3:06The word vini roll in French. There's no word for winemaker in
- 3:11French, for example. Now, I think I remember you
- 3:13saying that in the Secrets of the Sommelier, right?
- 3:16Yeah, Yeah. So.
- 3:18So I was like, I got to jump in and see what it's all about.
- 3:21And and so I spent, you know, we had a lot of time in 2020 to
- 3:25kind of read and then I moved to Cambria and start farming this
- 3:30piece of land and start 11 acres.
- 3:33And yeah, I did it alone for a couple of years and and then got
- 3:37some help and kind of still trying to figure it all out.
- 3:43So yeah, but it but it was just, it was just an urgent side to do
- 3:46something which is not like which I hadn't done before.
- 3:50Sure. Yeah.
- 3:53Service is one of those things I feel like if you aren't in love
- 3:56with, it can quickly wear you down.
- 3:59Is it? You know, you are on your feet.
- 4:01You are on your feet constantly. I can only imagine if people not
- 4:04only wanted to talk to you about wine, but wanted to take
- 4:06pictures of you because you're well known.
- 4:08Like I could see that being a real grind.
- 4:10Obviously, I'm not saying about that.
- 4:12It also, you know every time, like you know the Instagram or
- 4:16the phone times like you serve a while.
- 4:19Let me take a photo of the bottle.
- 4:21I'll put it on the table in a minute, but it was like it was
- 4:23like, I'm sure you you see any time I.
- 4:26Was interrupting the flow. OK, got it.
- 4:28Yeah, it was, it was just like everything was like, you know,
- 4:32it was, it was a, you know, even now a lot of, you know, take a
- 4:35photo of the food or the bottle of the not necessarily what me,
- 4:39but it's, it's more what the, the flow.
- 4:42Your guests were inadvertently recreating the difficulty of
- 4:46like the Quartermaster Psalms test, like trying to throw you
- 4:48off your game but just because they wanted to take pictures.
- 4:51Yeah. And then and then that's fine.
- 4:53But just when it's when it's in every every bottle is served,
- 4:57then it gets a little all right, That's that's not, that's not
- 4:59how it was back in the day, but. Any any place that you could
- 5:05have ended up being, as you put it in French chiffin your own in
- 5:09California, you chose one off the beaten path.
- 5:13Why not a Napa or Sonoma or you know, was was there a reason
- 5:18that you ended where you were or?
- 5:20Yeah, you know, it was, it was a somewhat of a calculated guess
- 5:23because yeah, yeah. I would never, I've never done
- 5:27things on like something which has already been done.
- 5:31I like to do things and find new places, new things, newer idols
- 5:39so I can then you know, really, you know, champion that and be a
- 5:44part of that. The Cambria was still is a very
- 5:47unknown wine growing region. It's, it's a part of the slow
- 5:50coast, but it's the northern end.
- 5:52The Appalachian was only formed like five years ago.
- 5:54So it's very, really, really new.
- 5:56And Cambria only has three veneers.
- 5:59When I moved there first there was 0 organic farming happening
- 6:02there, at least in the vineyard veneer.
- 6:05So it was something, you know, something near a new challenge
- 6:07and something and, and I thought Cambria would work because, you
- 6:10know, I did some soil testing and just the, you know, I knew
- 6:14the challenges I was going to get into, but it had clear
- 6:17soils, so high water retention close to the ocean, so extremely
- 6:21cool climate and working in nature.
- 6:24So the vineyards are all around forests, unrafted vines.
- 6:27So had a lot of kind of uniqueness.
- 6:30So you could kind of dry farm. You could, you know, you and you
- 6:33have quartz and you have some kind of calcareous soils.
- 6:37So I had a lot of kind of interesting things and of course
- 6:39I knew all I could tell all the positives.
- 6:42But I, you know, of course, then he started farming and he
- 6:44realized why there aren't many other people doing it with you.
- 6:48There's a reason this place is abandoned, yeah.
- 6:50Yeah, but, but you know, it's, yeah, I know it's a unique spot.
- 6:54It's very different than, you know, I've made wine a few
- 6:57different places in in the US and it's uniquely different.
- 7:00And, and what I've learned from this experience so far is that,
- 7:05you know, you just have to kind of continue on the path and, and
- 7:08work with nature and that's it. So you have to just be fully
- 7:11dedicated to nature and, and yeah, Cambria is, you know,
- 7:15there's no other place in the world I would rather be except
- 7:17here. That's beautiful.
- 7:18On that note, continuing on the path, I think I may have put the
- 7:22cart in front of the horse. So you know, I definitely, I
- 7:26know of you because back in my studying for the Psalm
- 7:28certification days, I know Secrets of the Somalia was a big
- 7:32book for me. I got your Somalia's Atlas of
- 7:34taste recently and I like yes, I love both.
- 7:38But I think the listener at home, I might have people who
- 7:41perhaps are a little bit younger than me just entering the
- 7:44restaurant world, maybe don't know you.
- 7:46Do you mind going back and kind of walking us through a little
- 7:50bit, just 30,000 foot view of your career, kind of what you've
- 7:54done, where you came from and why I was so nervous to talk to
- 7:57you? Yeah, yeah.
- 7:59OK. So I guess so.
- 8:02I was born in India, in Calcutta and.
- 8:06And I love food. I went to hotel management
- 8:09school in India. I really wanted to be a chef
- 8:13when I was young and I got a chance to spend a little time in
- 8:18England. And then I finally moved to Hyde
- 8:21Park, NY to the to the Coronary Institute of America.
- 8:25And this was in 94. And the goal was to kind of, you
- 8:30know, go to school two years and then go back home and work with
- 8:34my, my family because they had restaurants there.
- 8:36So Kevin, New York spent two years.
- 8:39It was a great, great program and fell in love with wine and
- 8:43decided not to pursue cooking, decided to, you know, learn
- 8:48about wine. I moved to San Francisco and
- 8:52connected with somebody called Larry Stone who took me under
- 8:55his wing, trained me and worked with him for three years.
- 8:58And I kind of stayed in the country then because like, you
- 9:00know, I was like, no point going back now because I'm not
- 9:03cooking. I'm going to be in wine.
- 9:05But that was like the beginning. And that was so I started my
- 9:07career. I first started as a food
- 9:11runner, became a bar back server, and then eventually
- 9:14became Larry's assistant. So I went through the whole
- 9:18gamut of the restaurant because I've never worked in restaurants
- 9:20before and learned that and then just started running wine
- 9:23programs. I've only had three jobs my
- 9:25entire life. And yeah, so I'm all in San
- 9:30Francisco. And then since then I've been
- 9:32working for myself. And but you know, the most
- 9:35important part of the whole journey was that that I learned
- 9:39from somebody. I learned from a great person,
- 9:42mentor, human, that kind of Larry who kind of molded me in
- 9:46the greatest way possible. And my job is to pay that
- 9:49forward. So it's important, important to
- 9:53spend time and, and, and teach in any way I can, because I
- 9:58still get people who want to come and, you know, learn about
- 10:02wines and stuff. And I'm like, I work at a farm
- 10:05now. So I, but, but still, if there's
- 10:07a chance, you know, people still come and they, they locate real
- 10:10blind tasting for us to come. They absolutely.
- 10:12I mean, you know, it's, it's, you know, it's, it's, it's
- 10:15different. I, I don't work in a restaurant
- 10:16floor, so I can't really be a part of that.
- 10:19But when I travel, if sometimes I do, you know, have a chance to
- 10:23kind of do an event and work the floor and talk about other
- 10:27wines, because for me, it's easier talking about other wines
- 10:29than my own wines. But it's, it's the most
- 10:31important part is that the, the mentorship that kind of is
- 10:37what's, I think, I mean, that mentorship is, is kind of
- 10:39failing in every part of society now because, you know, it's,
- 10:44it's hard because people who like a lot of my peers who don't
- 10:48work the floor anymore do other things or even in, in other
- 10:52industries, it's, it's hard to find mentors because everyone's
- 10:56busy and traveling. And so any chance I have to kind
- 11:00of, you know, spend time with young people to teach, It's,
- 11:03it's my, it's my privilege because I learned from someone,
- 11:06you know, I want to learn it on my own.
- 11:08And back then there was no, there was no Google.
- 11:10You know, it wasn't like back in the 90s.
- 11:13Yeah. What, what, what's the soil type
- 11:15of Hermitage? You know, it wasn't like
- 11:17something you can just, you have to go to a library and find a
- 11:20book or ask someone. Today it's much easier.
- 11:23Today you can, you can get all these things through the
- 11:26Internet and and other things, though warning that there's a
- 11:30lot of information out there is still kind of a little bit, you
- 11:33know, it's a lot of accurate information is a lot of it is
- 11:36not. Yeah.
- 11:38And I feel like with mentorship, you get the added bonus, not
- 11:42only of the knowledge, because I mean, in a time before knowledge
- 11:46was abundant, that was important, but you get the added
- 11:49benefit of filtration because there's too much knowledge.
- 11:53There's too many things that you could look at and there's too
- 11:56many things that you could learn, especially like a subject
- 11:59as deep and just like all-encompassing as beverage
- 12:03wine, you know, but looking through all the different things
- 12:06and zeroing in like you, you may not need to know all these oil
- 12:10types, but learn Armitage. Like, look here, this is an
- 12:13important thing. And you, you don't get that if
- 12:15you're just kind of going blind by yourself.
- 12:16But if you have the guiding hand of a mentor, you do get a little
- 12:20bit of a leg up on. They've made the mistakes that
- 12:23you don't have to anymore. Sorry to interrupt.
- 12:26We will get back to Rajat and me in just a second.
- 12:30But I wanted to take a second to say, if you have not had a
- 12:33chance to follow the show, please do.
- 12:37It would mean the world to me. All right, back at it.
- 12:42Yeah, yeah, yeah. Experience is the most important
- 12:45part, you know, in listening, because I think in, you know, a
- 12:50lot of people might not listen, you know, because it's like,
- 12:56it's not like hearing I'm listening to you.
- 12:58I'm now OK. I'm like, because it's so
- 13:00important to, to listen to the failures the previous generation
- 13:05has had because, you know, success is easy to kind of so I
- 13:09did this. I did this.
- 13:11But like, the failures are the most important part of anyone's
- 13:14success because if you haven't failed, you never succeed
- 13:18because at one point, because sometimes you kind of fail at
- 13:21something and you like, stop and say, OK, you know what?
- 13:23I'm out. And that's when you kind of
- 13:24learn from the failure and say, OK, how could I have gotten past
- 13:29this step? How could I have, you know,
- 13:31yeah, I failed at this. How how could I get better?
- 13:33Not better, but how could I reverse this and not make the
- 13:36same mistake? And then and that's, that
- 13:39happens only with experience, you know, in, in everything, in
- 13:42anything really. It's not only what in
- 13:44restaurants, but in in life. Well, I think, I think for our,
- 13:48our conversation now and your past and what I'm concerned with
- 13:51now is I'm thinking blind tasting.
- 13:54You know, the blind tastings where you actually get the lions
- 13:57right may feel good, but I think they're a lot less instructive
- 14:00than the times that you do it and you're confident and you get
- 14:04it wrong. And especially if you have the
- 14:06chance to taste that thing right afterwards and you're like.
- 14:09Yeah. Talked myself into that one
- 14:11there, you know? Yeah, Yeah, no, for sure.
- 14:13I mean, I've had many experiences with with people who
- 14:15are going for their Ms. or the advance and just before the day
- 14:19forward rotating for them and they're like do terrible.
- 14:22And then the next day they go nail it and pass the test.
- 14:26It's happened so many times because it's like, it's, it's
- 14:28just that, you know, it's, it's, it's like, you know, great
- 14:32athletes who are, you know, taking a shot in tennis or envy,
- 14:35whatever. You're taking a shot and you
- 14:37miss it. You can't think about that shot.
- 14:39You got to go move forward, take the next shot, because if you're
- 14:42going to just keep thinking about what you did, you got to
- 14:46do it again. And that's why repetition.
- 14:48That's why that's why you know, blind tasting, you can only be
- 14:52good at it if you do it a lot. You can't just do it low.
- 14:55I'll do it once in a while. It has to be completely
- 14:57fanatical. You have to be completely into
- 15:00it. So deep, so intense because it
- 15:03has become muscle memory. Like when I was, when I, when I
- 15:06used to do not many times that I had a couple of really amazing
- 15:11assistants when I was going to like solidify their role as you
- 15:14know, I would, I would take them off for dinner and then we
- 15:16would, you know, drink a bunch of wine and then have the whole
- 15:20night. And then after the end of the
- 15:22night, then I'll do a blind tasting because you're the you
- 15:28are, you are blind tasting has to become muscle memory.
- 15:32It can't be. Oh yeah.
- 15:34First thing in the morning. I have nothing to eat.
- 15:36I'm just fresh. No, that's that, that's good.
- 15:40That's that's professional style.
- 15:41But. That's how you train.
- 15:43Really. Yeah, that's how you train.
- 15:45But like if you really, if you'll really be at the highest
- 15:48level, it has to become muscle memory.
- 15:49It just has to have you had a feeling you smell a wild, it
- 15:52smells like limestone, smells like granite on the nose.
- 15:55But that's just muscle memory. It's not something I can't tell
- 15:58you why it smells like limestone or why it smells like granite.
- 16:01It just it's engraved in your system.
- 16:04And that's when you do it thousands and thousands and
- 16:06thousands of time. And these days become really
- 16:12hard. These days, honestly, it's hard
- 16:13because there's so many places where wines are made now and
- 16:19people know the techniques and people know how to make it, how
- 16:23to grow it. So it's, it's hard.
- 16:26You could, you know, it's, it's not as easy as it used to be
- 16:28back in the day for sure. Sure.
- 16:32Yeah. I think, you know, maybe not
- 16:36blind tasting for identification, but just blind
- 16:40tasting in general. Like I'm trying to pull that
- 16:42apart because I do think that there is still like if if you
- 16:46have someone who's picked a representative, something that
- 16:49shows typicity, I think that there's still a lot of like you
- 16:52can get there blind tasting as long as the person who sets it
- 16:56up knows like what it be reasonable for a person to
- 17:00guess. But if if you're putting some
- 17:01random like indigenous grapes that I can't even pronounce that
- 17:04I've never seen before. Right.
- 17:07Oh yeah. Description is also very useful.
- 17:10It's just it's a different, yeah, it's a different game
- 17:12almost. I don't know, Yeah.
- 17:14Yeah, Yeah. No, it's, it's, it's it's
- 17:17definitely getting gotten more complicated than it used to be,
- 17:20for sure. Yeah.
- 17:22Yep, it's probably good that you've gotten out of out of the
- 17:25game a little bit then. So if I'm a, you know, if I'm
- 17:29listening to this and I'm just a new server, a new bartender, and
- 17:35I'm thinking I want to get into wine.
- 17:37I'm lost here. I just turned 2122.
- 17:41Where would you recommend someone start?
- 17:43So I mean, I know a lot of young people are in the game right now
- 17:47and learning. I think the, the, the, the more
- 17:51theory knowledge you can get as of, of the basics of what like I
- 17:57will start with classic regions, you know, borough, Burgundy,
- 18:00Rome, Champagne, Asas like that, like, you know, classic reasons.
- 18:06Then you go for our France, you go to maybe Germany, go to
- 18:09Mosul, you know, and try to stay on the classic infrastructure
- 18:13and just read as much about them and try to get the feel for
- 18:16that. And then, then the only thing is
- 18:18to taste. Then you got to taste.
- 18:20And that's the hardest part because wines become expensive.
- 18:22You know, it's then you have then you have to, then you have
- 18:24to find, find a serious enough, a serious enough, I would say,
- 18:30because you don't have to be too serious or a group of people who
- 18:33would want to kind of, you know, want to do it with you because
- 18:36you know it, it costs money and takes time.
- 18:39So you create a, some kind of a, you know, will buy wines at, you
- 18:45know, certain price point or as much money because you know, as
- 18:48long as you have, then you can get together once a week, once a
- 18:51month, whatever the case may be and taste wines and pick a topic
- 18:56and have wines from that region. You don't have to have it blind
- 18:59in the beginning because that's like next stage.
- 19:01But even if you open a bottle of, you know, a classic German
- 19:05Riesling or you know, Burgundy Blanc or whatever the case may
- 19:09be. And then you kind of like learn
- 19:11about the place, the taste and learn classic because once you
- 19:16learn classic, then you can move on.
- 19:18You don't want to go into, you know, a carbonic Zweigel from
- 19:23Austria. It's delicious fun, but you
- 19:27know, and but then you, you know, learn about because they
- 19:30probably won't ask you what's why I got on the test and you
- 19:33know, you should learn about, you know, maybe Pinot noir or
- 19:36Cabernet or Mariloa Syrah before we learn about the other
- 19:40varieties and it and it the most important part is having that
- 19:43group, you know, and then staying true and no one.
- 19:46And blind tasting comes much later.
- 19:48First is the reading and tasting and then eventually, eventually
- 19:54save money and take a trip because the fastest way to learn
- 19:59is to be in the place. Yeah, that's that's the fastest
- 20:02way to learn. There's no other way to learn.
- 20:04You can learn a lot from the book.
- 20:06You can learn a lot from tasting and repeat and repeat and
- 20:09repeat. But when you go there, you know,
- 20:11you look at the vines. Makes sense.
- 20:14And also I know. You know, it's not easy
- 20:17travelling everywhere these days, but you know, go see a
- 20:19vineyard, go see how pruning is done.
- 20:22You know, there's so many videos online how they do it, you know,
- 20:25and they pick the right people to do it and learn about
- 20:27pruning, learn about shoe thinning, learn about how how
- 20:30wines are grown decisions are picking.
- 20:33Go, go, go to a vineyard. Just just ask someone ask, ask
- 20:36someone who's, who you would trust of how, what the process
- 20:40is and that all the things will all come together and eventually
- 20:44it's, you know, it's, it's, it's, there's so many different
- 20:49things you can do in wine, in wine growing and wine making,
- 20:53but they're quite simple. So if you know the honest,
- 20:58simple truth, then you understand it much easier.
- 21:00There's a lot of complexity. There's a lot of funny business
- 21:04happening in the wines. A lot of things people add a lot
- 21:07of things you do in the you know, all that stuff that's all
- 21:11noise. Focus on the vineyard, focus on
- 21:13the soil and try to focus on organic.
- 21:18Try to try to try to work, try to drink, try to taste, try to
- 21:22see people who farm organically. It's it's important because
- 21:26really wine is a living beverage.
- 21:31Breathing is living every day, is changing every day.
- 21:35And if it's neat with chemicals and if it's completely dumbed
- 21:40down with all the additives, then it's not alive and and
- 21:43that's not why. And that's just a alcoholic
- 21:46beverage. You might as well have AI.
- 21:49Don't know. What do you get on this?
- 21:51Yeah, Claw, whatever. Like Claw or Yeah, one of those
- 21:55guys. Yeah.
- 21:56Miller High life. Maybe it is the champagne and
- 21:59beer that's. Right, it is delicious.
- 22:03Yeah, that's a good point. And you know, I really like
- 22:05that. I I feel like people that get
- 22:10really deep into things like wine, like spirits, it always,
- 22:15you can always tell when someone's gotten to a really far
- 22:17level because they they go from, you know, have you ever seen the
- 22:20midwit meme? It's kind of funny where so it's
- 22:24this idea on the left hand side, it's a really simple person who
- 22:27figures something out in the middle of someone who's trying
- 22:30to be smart and it's always they're overcomplicating
- 22:33everything and then they'll fall far right.
- 22:35It's someone who's a super genius sage and they almost
- 22:38always have the same realization as the person on the left side.
- 22:41That's simple. And it's just like, you know,
- 22:43start and you learn a little bit about the regions of the grapes
- 22:47and then you get into it and you start like learning all this
- 22:50really this maze of Appalachians of Italy.
- 22:52And you start drawing these maps and you get all this chaos as
- 22:56you're going deeper and deeper into certification.
- 22:58And at the end, I feel like we end up like you or it's just
- 23:01like, no, it's all about the vineyard.
- 23:03Go to the vineyard, learn the basics.
- 23:05It's like you always end up in the same place after you've done
- 23:08on this huge journey through all this minutia.
- 23:11Yeah. And then, you know, to actually
- 23:13second your group idea, the only time I was ever a part of a
- 23:18tasting group, it was a group of us that went for our certified.
- 23:22Then later I went to the advanced and I ended up not
- 23:25passing the tasting last time I took it.
- 23:27So I'm still on that journey. But the certified, you know, the
- 23:30pass rate isn't horrible, but it's not the best.
- 23:34But our whole group passed together in one go.
- 23:37And it was fun. You know, We spirit, we spent
- 23:39like, money out together. We got champagne bottles to
- 23:42pack, practice service. And then we just had parties
- 23:44afterwards because we have champagne bottles.
- 23:47Yeah. And you, like, have a group, you
- 23:48go on, you get to celebrate together.
- 23:50We all pass. And it's like, this is great,
- 23:52you know? And I don't think I would have
- 23:54kept studying when I was that young had I not had the pressure
- 23:57of other people depending on me too.
- 24:00So yeah, yeah, it helps. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 24:05Awesome. So tell me a little bit about
- 24:07your journey with it's Phelan Farm, right?
- 24:11Yeah, You have some unique grapes, some unique
- 24:13philosophies. I'm really excited.
- 24:15I I can tell from what you're saying that you're big into
- 24:17organic, which awesome. Yeah, I mean, it's, you know, it
- 24:21all comes what comes down to where we are living in this
- 24:24planet. It's one planet.
- 24:25Everything should be living. And humans are the only race
- 24:28that poison our our own food and then just to kind of kill the
- 24:33weeds and then eat it. Systematically poisoned their
- 24:36own food, yeah. Yeah.
- 24:37So, you know, and then and sometimes it's not tall because
- 24:40there's so many layers of things because, you know, we don't
- 24:43always look at the farm where we buy the buy the food from
- 24:47because not everyone's surrounded by nature and so on
- 24:51with the farms, what things are growing.
- 24:53So for me, when I was during the pandemic, I was like looking at
- 24:59what, you know, how I'm going to farm the minion and what I'm
- 25:01going to do is like, you know, I looked at different and I was
- 25:05never looking at conventional ideas.
- 25:06As always, were farming organically.
- 25:08And you know, looking at reading about Steiner and bio dynamic.
- 25:13And now we focus more on regenerative farming, kind of
- 25:16look at what's around us and minimum soil disturbance,
- 25:19including animals in our in the cycle and using color crops and
- 25:23kind of really kind of, you know, trying to make the soil
- 25:26better, you know, because because the vineyards that took
- 25:29over, they were not organically farmed prior to me.
- 25:32And so my job is to kind of turn back that to healthy soils.
- 25:36And that's something which is a global thing, healthy soils,
- 25:40because you know, there's soil and then there's, there's dirt,
- 25:43right? Dirt is not living.
- 25:45The soil has living microbes in it.
- 25:48It's it's about the nutrients and anything that grows needs
- 25:51nutrients. And if it's planted on healthy
- 25:54soils, it's going to have a much better chance of growing and
- 25:58producing A nutritious product. So.
- 26:01In in that process, how long did it take for that to reverse?
- 26:05Did you see it just slowly progress year by year or was it
- 26:08a pretty quick like turn around? No, no.
- 26:10It's still happening I. Mean it's.
- 26:12Starting, starting, starting in 20/17/2018.
- 26:18It's still in the process. We have still, we made progress,
- 26:21but you know, it's just a slow process.
- 26:25People say it could take three to 10 years.
- 26:29We are in our 10th year now and our 9th year now.
- 26:34And you know, it's, we still feel that there's, there's more
- 26:39work to be done. And it only gets better because
- 26:41from the time you start forming, converting from conventional to
- 26:45organic, you know, you have to build, build your, your fungal
- 26:49matter because your soils are bacteria driven.
- 26:52You try to build that fungal matter back in the soils, then
- 26:55you have a natural nutrient cycling because nature is very
- 26:58forgiving, right? It's like in the forest, things
- 27:00grow and then a storm comes, takes a tree down, a big animal
- 27:04comes, takes, takes plants down, but it grows again.
- 27:07You know, when when a tree falls in the in the forest, no one is
- 27:10clapping about it. It's just for right.
- 27:12It's just there. So, so how do we kind of stick
- 27:15the same idea of we have, we have growing grapes.
- 27:18It's for a reason to make wine. But if you leave it to its own
- 27:22devices, it's going to probably never grow because he doesn't
- 27:26have enough sunlight or, you know, water or.
- 27:29Or to just grow a giant Bush and very few grapes because it's
- 27:33just vegetation everywhere or something.
- 27:35Yeah. Exactly.
- 27:37So you have to kind of there's human intervention needed to the
- 27:40trellising and you know, make it because you know, what does the
- 27:43plant look for, looks for, looks for sunlight and nutrition, the
- 27:47soil. We can't change sunlight because
- 27:49that's nature. Sun comes when it comes, rain
- 27:52comes when it comes. But what we can do is we can
- 27:55work towards change the soil structure so you know, cover
- 27:58cropping, using compost, using soil amendments to kind of make
- 28:03the soil healthy and then the plants grow.
- 28:06And this whole cycle is something which has been the
- 28:09most rewarding to see because the.
- 28:12It's been 9 years now since the slow conversion and I think it's
- 28:16all coming back. I think if I taste the wine from
- 28:19the first year to now, it's leaps around different because
- 28:22the wine again is full of life. It's full of microbes.
- 28:25The soil is much lighter, much softer, much more airy, and
- 28:29things are growing everywhere. You know, we need to, we need to
- 28:35add nature to nature. You know, we need to have things
- 28:38growing with because if you only have one plant growing and
- 28:42everything else is completely clear, then that one plant is
- 28:47only going to be a singular flavor.
- 28:50But like in at Fairland Farm, we have all these different
- 28:52sycamores and willows and, and Bay Laurel.
- 28:56And when you taste the wine, the wines include the flavors of all
- 29:01those other elements in the forest.
- 29:02That's part of the wine. And that was that was the most
- 29:06important part for me to kind of, you know, focus on what
- 29:10nature has. How?
- 29:11How can you mimic nature in your wine?
- 29:14You know, I'm thinking mental image I have in my mind is
- 29:19tequila, oddly enough, just picturing, you know, if you've
- 29:23ever seen in Jalisco just those rows and rows of the one agave
- 29:29and that's it almost in a desert like environment.
- 29:32And like that is kind of the model for a lot of
- 29:35conventionally farmed vineyards versus kind of the more
- 29:40artisanal like mezcal, which may be more akin to what you're
- 29:43doing where some are wild harvested and there's a little
- 29:46bit more variety. And, and yeah, I mean, it's not
- 29:49a perfect analogy because there is some industrially produced
- 29:51mezcal too, but yeah. Yeah, mezcal is truly amazing
- 29:55because mezcal is like a lot of it is wild, but they also how
- 29:59it's how it's grown and how it's made.
- 30:02It's I mean, it's a whole different story.
- 30:04And you know, because some mezcal, the Pineas and they are,
- 30:08they'll be like, you know, 20 years old plus 25 years old.
- 30:13And that's like, and it's like, you know, it's, it's wild and,
- 30:16and a mountaintop and you have to go there with a mule and go
- 30:19cut it and carry it back. And the whole process is wild
- 30:23and crazy, very different. It's.
- 30:24Shocking that it's like 20 bucks a bottle.
- 30:27Yeah, I, I heard a master saw him once referred to mezcal as
- 30:31it was the sustainability of it was the same sustainability of
- 30:35making a distillate from the coral reef.
- 30:37Just the amount of time and working.
- 30:40It's like, I always thought that was funny.
- 30:41You know, I would be remiss if I didn't ask you about this.
- 30:45Just with everything you're talking about with the farm
- 30:48regenerating the soil. Can you talk to us a little bit
- 30:51about terroir? Because yeah, yeah.
- 30:54It's it's a big one. I don't know.
- 30:55It's like one of the biggest topics in wine.
- 30:57You have 5 minutes. No.
- 30:59Yeah, no, it's, it's, you know, of course, you know, first of
- 31:03all, it takes time, right? It's like, you know, I don't
- 31:07know if some somebody thought, Oh yeah, we had great terroir in
- 31:09the second vintage. You're like, OK, so you know
- 31:12what soil you have. So basically in the purest form,
- 31:16terroir is basically the different layers of of course
- 31:19the soil structure. You have the whatever you have
- 31:21limestone that your elevation, slope, whatever the case may be.
- 31:28It's basically your entire place plus the weather pattern.
- 31:33So for me, it's, it's three things.
- 31:36It's the place. It's the place includes the
- 31:39climate, the soil structure, all that.
- 31:42The other part is is the plant material is no one talks about.
- 31:46It's like if somebody has a really shitty roostock and some
- 31:51clonal material that will not, never exemplify, will never show
- 31:57the terroir in the best way. And then the human element, the
- 32:00human element is, you know, unfortunately it's humans are
- 32:04part of the planting, growing and making.
- 32:08So terroir on his own is just the place, which is the soil,
- 32:13which is the weather, which is how it's planted.
- 32:16But then the two other levels above that which also influenced
- 32:20terroir is the human element and the plant, the plant material,
- 32:24which is never mentioned by anybody because the plant
- 32:26material, if you think about it, if you have the shittiest clonal
- 32:31material and the shittiest rootstock in amazing in Romani
- 32:36Conti, Romani Conti had the worst plant material rootstock
- 32:40in that. You think Romani Conti would be
- 32:41as great as Romani Conti is probably not.
- 32:44It's really good because it already has a great.
- 32:47It checks all the boxes, yeah. Yeah, so.
- 32:49So that's the same thing in farming.
- 32:52If you're farming a great place which has perfect drainage soil.
- 32:56Because the reason clay and limestone is important in many
- 33:00parts is because clay and limestone both hold water.
- 33:05Vines need water, right? If Romani Conti has to irrigate
- 33:09one day, it will not be the same Roman Corinthians that was not
- 33:12irrigated. That's just the truth of it,
- 33:15right? It's just the way life is.
- 33:17If you, if you have to irrigate to keep your vines alive, then
- 33:21the wine be different. And I'm not telling you better
- 33:23or worse, but it'll be different.
- 33:25But terroir on his pure form is soil, human and inflammatory.
- 33:33Yeah, I'm glad the reason I did want to ask you about that was
- 33:37because of the human element. And I wanted to highlight that
- 33:39because, you know, you are actively involving yourself in
- 33:43the terroir of Phelan Farm by moving it from conventional to
- 33:47organic and a little more in tune with nature, a little more
- 33:51sustainable. I was thinking in the extreme,
- 33:54the plant material conversation. In my head, I was thinking you
- 33:59take Burgundy and you RIP out the Pinot Noir and plant
- 34:02Cinfandel. Definitely.
- 34:03It's going to be a different terroir for sure.
- 34:06I don't know if anyone would ever do that.
- 34:08Yeah, I know. It's, I think it's, it's
- 34:11interesting to kind of, if you look at just yeah, because it
- 34:14all has to match, right? Because there's a reason why the
- 34:17Appalachian system has you can grow these grapes in this place.
- 34:20So everyone kind of conforms the same idea.
- 34:23And the terroir is what's kind of commonly believe that this is
- 34:26what's going to be great. And you know, people are
- 34:28fortunate to introduce new grapes and new varieties and
- 34:31other things. But really you, I mean, the
- 34:34genetic material in the ground has to match the soil.
- 34:40I think now there's a lot more conversation in, in Europe about
- 34:43the genetic material, you know, because everyone, of course,
- 34:47when you have, when you have clones, they are giving you
- 34:50certain things yield or color or a certain idea.
- 34:54But when you have a plant that just works in this place, it
- 34:57works. And that's is working for
- 35:00hundreds of years. And yeah, why change it for
- 35:04yield? Because at certain time in
- 35:06history, people did plan things just to get yield because they
- 35:10were they're making a certain style of wine.
- 35:12But now as wine has become so popular and certain regions are
- 35:17extraordinary, have their, have their niche and have a certain
- 35:22price point and stuff. So why would he not convert back
- 35:25to the good plan material? Yeah, I mean, that is a funny
- 35:29point. Like I'd never thought about it
- 35:31that way until you were saying this.
- 35:33For a little while in Europe, we had this phenomenon where the
- 35:38most coveted bottles are shooting up in price, becoming
- 35:41more and more precious. And it also coincided with the
- 35:45vine pool scheme because we have an ocean of cheap, high
- 35:49production wine. No one wants it.
- 35:51Like both have been going on simultaneously for a while.
- 35:53Like it is, it is funny you get to see both sides of that there.
- 35:58Yeah. I was hoping we could talk a
- 36:00little bit about the varieties, just kind of talking about the
- 36:03vine, the vines and the vine stock that you grow at Phelan
- 36:07Farm because you don't grow only the traditional varieties that
- 36:11people kind of pair in their mind.
- 36:12With California you have other things.
- 36:15The Seven Young, the Pulsar, like interesting varieties that
- 36:20you may not first think of when you are thinking of America.
- 36:24Yeah. So you know, I've made Pitot
- 36:27Chardonnay for for many, many years and that, you know, as we
- 36:32know grows in certain places and has a certain and they both are
- 36:35kind of earlier ripening varieties.
- 36:38And Cambria we get our really a warm, a warmth of summer happens
- 36:44only in October, end of September, October.
- 36:46So you start picking around that time.
- 36:48So I decided to plant late ripening varieties.
- 36:53These are ripened more in October, November and they were
- 36:57all the Jura and Saba varieties like Savinia which we harvested
- 37:04last year on on on Halloween. Then we have trousseau which
- 37:09usually people harvest on early aside, but we always harvest in
- 37:11the end of October. Gammy, we harvest end of
- 37:15October, Mondus early November, Grande Altes, Jacques, all of
- 37:20that is early November usually so very late wrapped in
- 37:23poolside, which they still try to grow it.
- 37:25It's not the easiest grape to figure out.
- 37:28And yeah, so all kind of more late rattling varieties,
- 37:31Sauvignon being one of the most important ones because that
- 37:33truly is, you know, we get to 13° of alcohol like late just
- 37:39barely get there. So it's a very important to
- 37:43normally think about the growing condition, but also like how
- 37:46late the season, how long and late the season is, because in
- 37:49Cambria, like last year, the warmest day of the year was
- 37:5488°F. Yeah, which is?
- 37:58Not a lot, not a lot. And it just was a cold year last
- 38:03year and and we got to 13% in Sauvignon, you know, Pinot 1212
- 38:081/2 you know, it's it's just Mondo's usually 10 1/2 eleven in
- 38:15November. Yeah, it's and they're right.
- 38:18They're like ripe grapes, but they just sugar accumulation is
- 38:21very slow because so we we kind of focus more on late frapping
- 38:25varieties and some of them kind of haven't been as successful as
- 38:30others, but most of them are. Yeah.
- 38:33So far so good. That's awesome.
- 38:35Yeah. It's it's nice to hear wines
- 38:37from California that aren't 16% or anything crazy.
- 38:40You Yeah, yeah. Get a lot of sun out there for
- 38:43sure. Yeah.
- 38:45Yeah. Well, that's cool.
- 38:47That's cool. Do you think that there's a
- 38:48feature for those grapes in the rest of California or is it just
- 38:52did your spot worked well or? I think, I think there are, I
- 38:56think Savinia could be interesting and there, there are
- 38:58some, some venues planted in Santa Barbara County, some
- 39:02venues planted up north, Mendocino and stuff.
- 39:06Yeah, I think slowly, I think, you know, I mean, Savinia was
- 39:09mostly grown to make vengeance and only of 25 years ago they
- 39:13started making dry wine from it. So it's, it's not a, it doesn't
- 39:16have a history of dry wine. Some people did, but not
- 39:19everyone did. So Trousseau's been around
- 39:21California for a long time. And Pulsar, there's not much
- 39:25Pulsar here. That's a hard grape to grow.
- 39:27Mondus has been in California for a long time.
- 39:29Also there's, there's so I think these, these grapes, you know,
- 39:35it's just that, you know, the culture of drinking, you know,
- 39:39has to also, you know, because, you know, a lot of people are
- 39:42kind of attached to the idea of making wine with richness and
- 39:46viscosity and a certain amount of alcohol, a certain amount of
- 39:50oak that's pleasing, you know. But, you know, as we change our
- 39:55eating patterns and eat fresher things and I think the palate's
- 40:00going to change and drink fresher things, you know,
- 40:02because I think that when I started in, in the, in the mid
- 40:0790s, there were very few California wines, you know, I
- 40:11mean, maybe the old school wines, but through the nineties,
- 40:152000s, very few California wines in the 12% alcohol range.
- 40:19Yeah, there were some, you know, old school producers making
- 40:22that. But then with climate change and
- 40:24everything else, with the with the palate change and the wine
- 40:27critics and everything else. Some people wanted a bigger,
- 40:31bigger style wine through the 2000s.
- 40:34I mean, it was tough. It was tough to find something
- 40:36in the 12:00-ish range. It was, you know, it was more
- 40:40like 14 ish range. And slowly this kick kept going
- 40:43up. I mean, also think of the
- 40:46culture of drinking. When Americans start drinking
- 40:48wine, the baby boomers, they're moving from drinking whiskey to
- 40:51wine. Oh, yeah, so.
- 40:54So with the body and the oak and everything, yeah.
- 40:56Yeah. So it's it's just a natural
- 40:58progression. So now what we're seeing is that
- 41:01the younger people are maybe moving towards more fresher wine
- 41:04and then that's just the way it is, you know, and, and but
- 41:07that's been the European stuff for a long time.
- 41:09And Europe's having a hard time keeping alcohols down now, you
- 41:13know, because of the string of warm years.
- 41:15So it's in reverse. So, you know, who knows what's
- 41:18going to happen? We're pushing it up and they're
- 41:21pushing it down, both furiously. Not because they want to.
- 41:25That's just the way nature is going in that way.
- 41:28It's just getting harder and harder, yeah.
- 41:30Yeah, there, there are two things that I want to throw out
- 41:33there there. So I have two responses to
- 41:36guests. Usually they're looking for only
- 41:38body or only oak. And so I may actually have
- 41:41stolen the body thing from you. Actually, I don't remember where
- 41:43I got it. So there's a chance it's from
- 41:44your book. If so, let me know.
- 41:46It's that saying that you like a bottle of wine because of the
- 41:50body. It's like saying that you like
- 41:52music for how loud it is. I heard that from someone once
- 41:56and I was like, that is awesome, I'm going to steal that.
- 41:59And then the oak thing actually stole from Ivy Mix.
- 42:03She wrote a book about distillates, but she describes
- 42:07oak. Imagine it like the frame on a
- 42:10painting and she's like to say that you are into the painting
- 42:15for the frame is strange. It can complement it.
- 42:17It shouldn't overpower and it shouldn't be the main point of
- 42:20focus. It should just be the frame.
- 42:22But like I, I like that sort of mental image because it even
- 42:26fits. It's a piece of wood around a
- 42:28pretty image. And yeah, I like that the
- 42:31expansion of grapes. You get more cool images with or
- 42:35without a frame. But yeah, so don't know where
- 42:39it's going. Yeah, no, no, it's, yeah.
- 42:41No, you, you have to kind of put things in your head in order so
- 42:44you can remember it and kind of, yeah, no, it's, it makes sense.
- 42:50Yeah, it's kind of like how old Psalms almost always end up
- 42:53organizing information, all the wine information geographically,
- 42:57it's like you have to have buckets because otherwise you
- 43:00just get lost. There's there's really no way.
- 43:03I did want to ask you because I, I was curious the progression
- 43:07from the CIA to when you went to California and you were getting
- 43:12into a restaurant, working your way up.
- 43:14What was that transition like from CIA to food runner?
- 43:19Because I feel like that was, you know, you kind of threw that
- 43:22out there. But I know like, especially in
- 43:24my career, I know in other people, I've seen the idea of
- 43:28taking a step back almost will paralyze you and you'd like, you
- 43:33don't want to do something because you're afraid that
- 43:35you're kind of stepping into a lower role maybe like, did you
- 43:39ever think that or. No, you know, for me, it's
- 43:43always been one learning. Even when I started farming
- 43:47here, it was about learning, right?
- 43:48Because it's, it's not, it's not like I know anything.
- 43:51I know what I know, but that's very little.
- 43:53So no, back then I was was 20. I was when I moved to
- 43:57California, I was 24 years old. I mean, working on 24 year old
- 44:00now. Also remember back then there
- 44:02were, there were very few some ways.
- 44:04There was there was like very, very few.
- 44:06And all the some ways were either European or there were
- 44:10older, like they were like twice my age.
- 44:12You know, there were, there were no, there were no some ways in
- 44:15the 20s for a long time when I started.
- 44:19And so when I when I applied for, you know, and my, my
- 44:24instructor in school said you should go work with someone who
- 44:27knows about why and who can too much teach you.
- 44:29So that was my case. Then I heard about Larry Stone
- 44:31and I went there. And for me, it was only a
- 44:34learning when I moved from New York two years in New York from
- 44:39India to New York 2 years and New York to California.
- 44:43My whole, I only had a six month visa.
- 44:45And I was like, I'm going to learn as well kind of six months
- 44:48and I'm going to go back home. And that's how it started.
- 44:51Because then I was like, wow, there's more to learn.
- 44:53I can't go yet. And then that's when Larry Stone
- 44:56kind of, you know, sponsored me and I got, I got a work visa and
- 45:00I got a state. But it was the time was like for
- 45:03me, it was only when learning. I used to work.
- 45:05I used to get to work, you know, at whatever 9 or 10 AM and work
- 45:11both shifts and, you know, work six days a week, close on
- 45:14Sundays and come back home. And that was like just on
- 45:17learning because I only had that much time.
- 45:20It was never, I never felt anything except like, how do I
- 45:24keep learning and maximize my six months because I have to go
- 45:27back home after that. Yeah, the, the time constraint
- 45:30kind of gave you the impetus. Yeah.
- 45:32You you only have this time, you're done.
- 45:34Yeah. I wonder if that also helped
- 45:36kind of frame it like, you know, even if you do something that is
- 45:39hard and difficult six days a week double shift, you know it's
- 45:43going to end in six months. So you can actually kind of step
- 45:47in and not worry about it even if it did keep extending and it
- 45:50seems like you're still here now, but.
- 45:54Yeah, well, just all we're learning, it's more like how
- 45:57much can you learn and who's going to teach you?
- 45:58Because you know, it's different than if you're stuck in a room
- 46:02and you're just reading a book and you have to give a test
- 46:04after that. But but other than that, you're
- 46:06reading a book and studying something that you have to talk
- 46:08to people about and and enhance the experience, the dining
- 46:13experience. So the perspective was quite
- 46:16difficult. Oh yeah.
- 46:17You know, I have to just to learn because, you know, also in
- 46:20a young you don't, you don't know how much other people know
- 46:22because you're like, oh, yeah, I'm young, I know this, but you
- 46:25have no idea. Someone sitting across the table
- 46:27is like someone who's like a wine critic or some of the wine,
- 46:31you know, because also real wine knowledge in the night was quite
- 46:34low. There were not that many experts
- 46:37and it was much different. Yeah, a bunch of whiskey
- 46:40drinkers. Got to love them.
- 46:41Got to love them, yeah. No, I was good because they,
- 46:45they, the baby boomers are still, they were the ones who
- 46:47had the money to spend. And it was, it was important to.
- 46:51Yeah. Now and you, you do need
- 46:53someone, even if it is a group of people that like super ripe,
- 46:57super bold, super big ones, you do need a segment spending money
- 47:02because if there is not any assuredness that this is
- 47:06something that's economically viable, people don't go in.
- 47:10And I mean, for better or worse, wine growing, producing wine is
- 47:16economically pretty intensive. You know, it just is takes a
- 47:20couple of years. Oh, yeah.
- 47:21If you could go back and give yourself some advice, you know,
- 47:24would you do things the same way?
- 47:26Would you have changed anything? Not really.
- 47:28I would have probably maybe slowed down a little bit towards
- 47:34the middle. I was, I went to little kind of
- 47:37just maybe too focused, maybe too, too much work focused out
- 47:44of maybe maybe been a little bit more calm and slower.
- 47:52That makes sense. I want to make work priority
- 47:55every single day. Yeah.
- 47:58Well, I feel like you are probably getting a rebalance.
- 48:02I'm guessing that where you are farming, growing the grapes,
- 48:05making the wine is a lot less hustle and bustle than what
- 48:09you're used to. Oh yeah, for sure.
- 48:12Yeah. For sure.
- 48:13Awesome. Yeah.
- 48:15Well, for my listeners who are at home who might want to find
- 48:19out more about you or find your wines, where could someone go
- 48:24online to learn more about you? Yeah.
- 48:27Yeah, online there's, you know, there's a bunch of stuff around
- 48:31online. You can just type many more.
- 48:36Instagram is my name at Raja Park.
- 48:39And then the wines that we make, lots of little little queers.
- 48:44It'll all be available under Park collective.com.
- 48:47So Parr collective.com, Yeah. And then we do a bunch of events
- 48:51in Cambria. So it's yeah coming up and yeah.
- 48:55Awesome. Yeah.
- 48:56And if you're at home listening and you didn't get to write that
- 48:58down, I will have all that in the show notes.
- 49:01You can also pick up Rajat Parr's books, The Secrets of the
- 49:04Somalis, Somalis, Atlas of Taste.
- 49:06He's in the Saw movie. He's he does, he's done it all.
- 49:09So Rajat, it was, it was a real pleasure getting to talk to you
- 49:14today. Thank you, Andrew.
- 49:16Thanks for having me. Of course, thank you again for
- 49:22taking a moment to listen to Serves Who Write.
- 49:25It really means the world to me. Episodes of this show come out
- 49:28every Tuesday and Thursday, and if you have not had a chance,
- 49:33please take a moment and check out our website
- 49:36servesyourightpod.com. We have all the episodes past
- 49:40and present, a list of our coolest episodes, a forum to get
- 49:43in touch with me, and what else could you want?
- 49:49All right, I will see you again soon.
- 49:52Cheers.