Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Investment Podcast #40 - Emerging Markets
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with Asponsor,
- 0:06Orbis Investment Advisory Preparatory Limited,
- 0:08ABN 15101-387-964, AFSL 237-862,
- 0:13and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:16Before acting on any general advice,
- 0:18you should consider whether appropriate
- 0:19and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:23Ensemble does not hold an AFS license
- 0:25and does not provide any financial advice or services
- 0:28or endorse any general advice.
- 0:29If a PDS or IM exists,
- 0:31you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly
- 0:33before making a decision.
- 0:35Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
- 0:40Hi, I'm Amy Baker from Recovered Vice
- 0:43and I'm here to help navigate the investment landscape
- 0:46to get you the best results for your clients.
- 0:48Let's jump in.
- 0:51Orbis has been investing in undervalued global stocks globally for over 30 years,
- 0:56focusing on long-term potential
- 0:58rather than short-term performance.
- 0:59Their team of 60-plus investment professionals
- 1:02focuses on unearthing companies trading below their true value
- 1:05rather than timing market trends.
- 1:07With over $80 billion Australian dollars in assets under management,
- 1:10Orbis has consistently applied the same fundamental,
- 1:13long-term, and contrarian approach since its inception.
- 1:16In today's rapidly changing investment landscape,
- 1:18Orbis' contrarian style and high-value exposure
- 1:21can make it an effective diversifier in client portfolios.
- 1:25Last year, I had an opportunity to attend an emerging markets conference in Singapore,
- 1:31and honestly, it completely shifted the way I think about emerging market investing.
- 1:36Being on the ground in Asia, seeing the pace of innovation,
- 1:38infrastructure, consumer growth, and economic development firsthand,
- 1:42challenged a lot of the traditional narratives we often hear about
- 1:45emerging markets from an Australian perspective.
- 1:48And while much of the discussion naturally focused on Asia and China,
- 1:51it also highlighted just how broad and diverse
- 1:54the emerging market opportunity set really is,
- 1:57from India and Korea through to Mexico, Latin America,
- 2:01Eastern Europe, and beyond.
- 2:03What struck me the most was this feeling that many investors
- 2:07may still be viewing emerging markets through the framework
- 2:10built 20 years ago.
- 2:12And while their actual economies and business themselves
- 2:15have moved so dramatically, which is quite exciting,
- 2:18I really found the whole experience mind-blowing,
- 2:21which makes me very excited about this interview today.
- 2:24So today, I'm in a conversation with Stanley Liu.
- 2:29Emerging markets portfolio manager at Orbis,
- 2:31who's visiting Australia from Hong Kong, welcome.
- 2:34Thank you so much for today and being here.
- 2:37Thank you.
- 2:38So I'm going to jump straight in.
- 2:39This is one of my favorite topics since being away last year.
- 2:44One thing I kept thinking in Asia was this doesn't look
- 2:49anything like emerging the emerging market story
- 2:52Australian still having their heads in my opinion.
- 2:55And the pace of development, the sophistication,
- 2:58technology, it totally surprised me.
- 3:00So do you think investors are still looking at emerging markets
- 3:04through an outdated lens?
- 3:06Yes, I think it's quite badly.
- 3:09I think the idea of emerging markets,
- 3:13this often still anchor back in the 90s.
- 3:16And that was a crisis point era where you have currency crises.
- 3:20You have countries with external deficits and companies with excess leverage.
- 3:27But I think emerging markets have come a long way since then.
- 3:31Now the emerging markets have some of the most,
- 3:35I will consider some of the most versatile companies,
- 3:40businesses and economies in the world.
- 3:43You have these dominant internet platforms in China,
- 3:48manufacturing powerhouse and technology giants in Korea and Taiwan.
- 3:53And you have some of the innovative financial institutions,
- 3:57including Fintech in countries like Brazil.
- 4:00So it has really come a long way.
- 4:03But most investors are still thinking particularly based on their past experience
- 4:09in the last 10 to 15 years that emerging markets
- 4:12actually have underperformed the world index by the margin.
- 4:18So I think that that sort of anchors people's view on what emerging markets really are.
- 4:24Yeah, that's certainly okay.
- 4:26Take away I had from last year.
- 4:28It makes me think about what people, I guess the missed opportunities,
- 4:33people are potentially experiencing,
- 4:35don't even realise they're experiencing in their portfolios.
- 4:40I saw when I was doing some research on this fund myself,
- 4:44I was quite impressed by its performance.
- 4:47It certainly has done really, really well.
- 4:50So for advisors who may currently be underweight in emerging markets,
- 4:55how should they think about allocating today without feeling like they've already missed an
- 4:59opportunity?
- 5:00Yeah, I think despite the recent strong performance in emerging markets,
- 5:05overall valuation, if you look at
- 5:08on the normalised earnings basis, because we have the data on the
- 5:13cyclically adjusted price earnings ratio, otherwise, you know,
- 5:17widely known as normalised price earnings ratio.
- 5:21The EMs are still at a very big discount compared to, for instance,
- 5:26the United States, which constitute 70% of the world's index.
- 5:30So our data shows that the normalised ratio for the United States today is about 30,
- 5:38mid 30s, and the emerging markets is about mid-tings.
- 5:42So that's more than 50% discount.
- 5:44And if investors only invest in a world index, that might sound like a broad market,
- 5:52but like I said, in reality, 70% is in a single country,
- 5:57whereas in emerging markets has, you know,
- 5:59depending on how you look at it, how you define the emerging markets,
- 6:04it has well above two-thirds of the world's population, nearly half.
- 6:08Well, if you look at on the PPP basis, it's well above half of the world's GDP.
- 6:15And with the big variety of businesses and wide dispersion evaluations,
- 6:21that means you have plenty of opportunities to pick great companies,
- 6:26from the emerging markets.
- 6:28So if you look at it from that perspective, particularly considering that my understanding is
- 6:34that, you know, an average global portfolio would only have 10% in emerging markets compared to,
- 6:40you know, the size of emerging markets really is in the economy.
- 6:45And also, as we started this conversation, the volatility of emerging markets
- 6:52and the correlation between the emerging markets and the world index have sort of moderated
- 6:58over the years. So it isn't really much more volatile than developed markets.
- 7:05And not that we look at volatility as our way to measure risk,
- 7:10but if you can have a relatively uncorrelated or low correlation against, you know, your current
- 7:18existing portfolio, I could, you know, actually also add to the diversification benefits.
- 7:24Absolutely, which is imperative when we're considering what a diverse portfolio looks like for
- 7:30our clients. So when the argument is raised around whether emerging markets has it placed,
- 7:37it sounds really clear that why wouldn't it want it creates a diversification,
- 7:42but based on the opportunities and its actual global exposure, it sort of trumps that question
- 7:49really to say that you should be having it considering emerging markets in a portfolio.
- 7:55So moving on, let's think about emerging markets from sort of really where it stands right now.
- 8:01What's changed most over the last decade that you think the investment world still isn't fully
- 8:09appreciating? A lot have changed. Well, first of all, if you anchor back to the, you know,
- 8:16to the crisis pro-era, the 90s, I think the, well, first of all, the central bank's credibility
- 8:23and independence have largely improved in countries like Brazil, Mexico, India, Indonesia,
- 8:31they have much improved. And secondly, I think the fiscal framework has changed.
- 8:38So like I mentioned in the past, these emerging markets typically have a lot of external deficits,
- 8:44external debts. They have US-dynaminated, US-dollar-dynaminated debts, heavy debt burden,
- 8:53but particularly the Asian countries after the, you know, they have been scarred from the Asian
- 8:59financial crisis in 1997. And I think ever since that, they've been running a much cleaner
- 9:05balance sheets from the government standpoint and comfortably, you know, better than, I think,
- 9:12most of the developed markets. So this has also changed. And I think capital markets' developments
- 9:18have also changed quite a bit. I mean, if you look at China and, you know,
- 9:23Chinese domestic Asia is a large stock market. And it used to be of access to, you know, foreign
- 9:30investors. But now, through a stock connect via Hong Kong, you know, international investors can
- 9:36access capital markets much more easily. And also, there is a more mature venture capital,
- 9:44investor landscape. And in the past, it was much harder for a young company to raise capital
- 9:52before they come public. And it was also much harder to go through the domestic banking system,
- 9:59because most of them would be state-owned enterprises. And it's for a young and enterprise-in-private
- 10:06company to borrow from a state-owned enterprise bank. It's much harder. So that has also
- 10:14improved the overall entrepreneurship. There's more. I can keep going.
- 10:19Oh, no. It makes me think really the term emerging markets. Does it really still make sense? Given,
- 10:25you know, we've got China, India, Mexico, and Korea, they're completely different economies
- 10:31with different political systems and demographics and opportunities. And as you pointed out,
- 10:35it's such a broad space that we already have recognized the disparity in, say, just looking at
- 10:42a portfolio itself and the focus on just the traditional equity space. But really does the term
- 10:49emerging markets really sum it up? Okay. So if you look at the how the index providers
- 10:56define emerging markets, there are 24 countries or markets in the MSCI emerging markets index.
- 11:04But in reality, there are more, right? Because everything that's not
- 11:10included in developed markets, but it's developed to a certain degree you can define as emerging
- 11:16markets. So it's a very, very big map. But we don't look at it from a top-down point of view.
- 11:23What we're trying to do is we look at these markets and we know that this is a relatively young
- 11:31part of the world in terms of the business history. And so we know that there are, you know,
- 11:36more young companies and entrepreneurs that are there to solve problems, big problems.
- 11:43There are less rent seekers. I mean, in where, how we filter our investment ideas.
- 11:50So we tend to look for the investment opportunities on the company level, not so much from country
- 11:58level, who usually start from looking at, you know, what are the high-quality companies run by
- 12:06the management team that we would admire? And, you know, are they overmodetizing or are they
- 12:13just monetizing in a very sustainable way? Are their business models sustainable?
- 12:19What's their relationship with their supply chain and, you know, customers and suppliers?
- 12:25So really bottom up start picking process rather than looking at it from a top-down angle.
- 12:32But you're right. The emerging market is just a term, right? That includes everything. But
- 12:38everything is not the same. And they're also including valuation. So there's a very wide
- 12:44valuation dispersion between some of the more expensive markets in the EM versus the cheap markets.
- 12:51And the dispersion is very, very wide. There's so many questions out of that. But you answered one
- 12:55of them. I was going to ask. So I'm, thank you for that answer. Because I was going to ask you
- 13:01sort of a bit of your, I guess, investment philosophy. You started to touch on that. Do you want to
- 13:06just expand on that because that was an interesting take when we're looking at it from an emerging
- 13:10markets point of view, but how you're actually looking at core business and how you're actually
- 13:17constructing this portfolio, this fund versus actually looking at it from that theme.
- 13:22So do you want to just expand on some of your, I guess, your investment philosophy and how you've
- 13:26kind of created this fund in that perspective, which is, I know I'm going completely off topic
- 13:31to what foot on this page. I'm sorry I did that, but you just triggered that thought. So I wanted
- 13:36to just take on from there. Yes. Thank you. Well, I would say this way. So in Orbis, our philosophy
- 13:44is consistent has been consistent for decades, right? So it's fundamental long term and contrarian.
- 13:51So that philosophy has stayed the same. Well, let's start from fundamentals. So what do we really
- 13:58look at from the fundamentals? We believe that, you know, after years of experience making mistakes
- 14:05and, you know, picking some winners, we have come to realization that the gap between an exceptional
- 14:14company and an average one is very wide in emerging markets. There are many reasons to it. I mean,
- 14:21one of which is that there's typically a weaker minority shareholder protection. There is also
- 14:30weaker shareholder activism culture. And particularly because some of these companies are run by
- 14:38first generation owner manager, you can say that the founders. So as a result, you have a
- 14:46combination of weak shareholder protection. And the first generation founder, that single person
- 14:53has a very significant control influence on the direction of the business. So as a result,
- 15:02it can be very great if he is run by a great person. And that person can also run the company
- 15:08to the ground very easily without much of resistance from stakeholders. So with that, we really need
- 15:16to pay attention on the people's front and the company's culture. So that's how that's where we
- 15:22spend particular emphasis on when we look at fundamentals, not just looking at the business itself
- 15:29and how the business delivers the profits, the business practice, the company's culture,
- 15:35and also we do some due diligence on the founders as well. So that's one thing. The other is long
- 15:42term. So when we say long term, we typically look beyond a three to five years horizon. For the
- 15:50reasons that, you know, pretty much for the first reason, because if you think that a company
- 15:58with a strong strong stewardship and a strong growth runway, given that emerging markets,
- 16:04there are lots of business opportunities remain untapped. And you have great guys running the
- 16:09company, then you can really just treat a short term volatility as the process of a long term
- 16:15compounding. And you can look beyond, they say, one year, three years, five years, you can really
- 16:21take a very long term view and grow with the company. And in doing so, in the process of doing that,
- 16:29you can build a more meaningful stake in the company. I mean, we can talk a little bit about
- 16:34portfolio characteristics later. But once you have a more meaningful stake in a company,
- 16:42it's much easier to engage with them and to meet with the company management. And then to,
- 16:48you know, to discuss ideas, shareholder returns, capital allocation, incentive for their management
- 16:56team, then we can have some inputs. Excellent. Thank you. Because I mean, I brought to everyone's
- 17:02attention earlier how well the portfolio has done. So I was incredibly curious on understanding
- 17:10some of that success. So that gives me some insight. But I'm going to go back to some more of a
- 17:15broad of view. So because we are on the topic of emerging markets, and it'd be silly not to actually
- 17:22focus on some of these countries. So let's talk about China. Because I think this is one of the most
- 17:27fascinating tensions in global investing right now. So on one hand, China is still categorized as an
- 17:32emerging market. But on the other hand, it's effectively competing head to head with the US
- 17:40economically and technology and geopolitically. So do you think, how do you think,
- 17:45or how do you place China at the moment, or what are your views on China today? And does it still
- 17:52have behave like a traditional emerging market from an investment perspective? Yeah, I think in
- 17:58every aspect, I would say China is an emerging economy. The income and wealth disparity remains
- 18:05very, very wide. And if you look at it from GDP per capita, or if you look at it from, I mean,
- 18:11there are many aspects you can look at, right? The governance structure, the regulations, policies,
- 18:19transparencies and enforcement is still pretty much in the developing stage.
- 18:25Then you've got markets like Mexico suddenly becoming a huge discussion point because of
- 18:30reassuring and manufacturing shifting away from China. How significant do you think that
- 18:36thing could become over the next decade? Well, we don't really look at it that way
- 18:43because we don't really take views on a very big topic like this. I mean, it is an interesting
- 18:49topic to discuss. If we found a company that are directly exposed to same manufacturing base
- 18:58in Mexico, which we have some companies, we have some Taiwanese companies that used to have
- 19:04manufacturing based in China. But for the reason that ensuring or friend's showing,
- 19:12they need to move some other production base to Mexico. So there is that element to our investment
- 19:18thesis. But I think more of the investment thesis for us for that kind of companies is really,
- 19:26are they good? Can they manage that transition smoothly? What they run into bottlenecks hiring
- 19:33in new markets? And culturally, if they're not close, if they're Taiwanese, if they're Chinese,
- 19:41can they manage their staff effectively in Mexico or other countries? So we look at those things
- 19:50and much more so than thinking about some of these very big topics and for an extended period of time,
- 19:58if that makes sense. Yeah, absolutely. You've got to, I mean, looking at the portfolio,
- 20:05I sort of looked under, briefly looked under the hood of some of the countries that you have
- 20:09exposed it to. I'm aware that Mexico was actually a small portion in comparison to, say,
- 20:17Korea, Taiwan, and other parts of Asia. So I guess now I have more of an understanding of your,
- 20:27investment thesis in how you actually select your assets, a sort of kind of almost trump some
- 20:35of my questions in here because I was like, oh, why did I ask that? Because now I went, I was thinking,
- 20:40I was going to ask about Korea. And I guess maybe we should probably look at some of the opportunities
- 20:46that you're seeing globally and maybe the pin point where they're coming from as opposed to just
- 20:52going, we look at one particular country because now I understand you're looking at things so
- 20:56differently to how I perceived, I actually thought you were. And I guess that really debunks that
- 21:03concept of what emoting markets is because we sort of got this big, as you said, global map right
- 21:08in front of us. And there's opportunities everywhere. What you're really doing is finding all those
- 21:14gems. So where are you seeing those gems? What sort of areas and what sort of the key things,
- 21:22key factors are sort of cost the governance and the way businesses are structured and whatnot.
- 21:28But what kind of countries or what areas are they sort of primarily in right now?
- 21:34So I can give you an example in terms of Korea. So we have about, I think, 20% of the portfolio in
- 21:41Korea. And obviously we didn't go into Korea with a top-down view. But we look at different parts
- 21:48of the world and we typically start from looking at what are the major market dislocations. And that
- 21:56means, you know, there are many things that are priced by the market at clearly well below our
- 22:03assessment of their actual value, intrinsic value. And Korea is one clear example where, you know,
- 22:10you have, we have an online broker that's been taking market share year by year. It's the largest
- 22:16online brokerage firm in Korea. And running at the high teams return on equity. This is very decent
- 22:24business. And the retail brokerage, you don't need a lot of capital for growth. But, you know,
- 22:32Korea has this perennial famous Korea discount, which we can talk a little bit more. So the company
- 22:38was trading at, you know, very low valuation below 10 times earnings, whereas depending on where
- 22:46you find your comparable companies in the Western part of the world, I mean, if you compare that
- 22:53to other online brokers, then there will be at much, much higher valuation, if not 20, if not 30,
- 23:01right? And so that's how we started looking into more Korean companies. And then,
- 23:09since in terms of governance in the Korean discount, maybe I can elaborate a little bit more.
- 23:15So I think Korea has also come a long way. In the past, you know, there's a capital misallocation
- 23:22is very common. And the profits and cash that's generated by the businesses normally don't translate
- 23:30to shareholders. Either they've been hoarded in the company or it's been reinvested in areas
- 23:37that are much less attractive. But in recent years, Korea started a value up program by the
- 23:44governments. And this was in 2024. And by the time 2025 election, they have continued to push for
- 23:53these reforms. So that would include, you know, adding the fiduciary duty for the border
- 24:01directors not only to the company, but to the shareholders directly. And then they have also
- 24:07revised the tax code to encourage companies to pay higher dividends, just not holding cash.
- 24:14And I think as a result, the Korean discount has narrowed. But even as of today, they are still
- 24:21trading at a big discount compared to the developed markets and compared to some other parts of
- 24:27the emerging markets. And that's why I mean, we have, you know, a sizable position in Korea. And
- 24:34but we also look at company by company. We don't just say we take this view and there's a top-down
- 24:41view that reform will come through. Typically, reforms don't come in a straight line, right?
- 24:47There will be pushbacks and there will be, you know, there will be a stage where you pass and
- 24:52there will be a stage where you kind of retreat a little bit. So we don't think these things
- 24:57will come in a straight line. But in combination of the how attractive the valuations are and how
- 25:04durable within these businesses are, we have a reasonably sizable position in Korea.
- 25:10Yeah, I was fascinated by that last night. So thank you for answering. Now, in terms of also your
- 25:16position, when I looked through the portfolio, what I noticed, it wasn't the old school emerging
- 25:22markets exposure, many investors. Imagine there's meaningful exposure of technology,
- 25:28digital infrastructure, online financial platforms and consumer businesses. So I have emerging
- 25:35markets evolved faster than investor perceptions. And I imagine that this probably would be quite
- 25:43a busy space for like a better wording. In some areas, yes. So I can give you an example in a,
- 25:52I mean, if you travel to China, it's a cashless society, right? It's been cashless for a long time.
- 25:58And I think that development was fast probably because, you know, there wasn't a scrutiny from
- 26:06the government in terms of how these innovative internet companies intend to facilitate these
- 26:12transactions. And so the governments allowed them to develop. And also in some emerging markets,
- 26:20they are the lack of legacy or existing infrastructure also facilitate the development of some
- 26:27businesses. So for instance, e-commerce, e-commerce has developed very, very rapidly in China,
- 26:33partly because your offline retail space and the retail offering isn't good. And it takes much
- 26:42longer time to develop a offline retail space than putting up warehouses and logistic
- 26:50infrastructure in the website. So I think yes, in some areas where as long as you have strong
- 26:59technology, strong execution, and you don't have the, you know, the legacy investments in infrastructure,
- 27:06you can develop faster than the markets that have already these infrastructure.
- 27:13I'm thinking about again, your role and all the opportunities that must come across your
- 27:21desk, the amount of discipline that you would need because there's so many fantastic opportunities
- 27:29that are going around globally. And as you pointed out from the very beginning, it's a huge
- 27:33math with a huge global map in comparison to the standard, you know, first of all, equity space.
- 27:41You probably seeing so many, I guess, shiny new toys, so to speak, when it comes to investing.
- 27:47Is there a particular method or way, you know, I've spoken to pins that have a process of
- 27:54elimination, particularly to work out what's going to be in the portfolio and what's not?
- 28:00Have you got anything that sort of grounds you and keeps you on track with the vision of this fund?
- 28:07I think I can summarize that quite simply in one sentence, so we invest in businesses that we like.
- 28:14There are durable and run by the management team that we admire. We don't overpay them and then
- 28:20we compound with them. So to elaborate on that, the first of all, we like these businesses with
- 28:28durable competitive advantages. Like I said, we tend to look for the companies that are
- 28:35solving problems and are valued by solving these problems, rather than having these
- 28:40rents seeking behaviors. And so companies with durable competitive advantage.
- 28:47Normally, they don't require a lot of capital for growth. Normally, they are run conservatively
- 28:54with strong balance sheets, healthy cash flows. And then they have a very strong
- 29:00steward. So we strongly prefer owner manager, the founder run company because we just think that
- 29:08the interests are much more aligned. But in identifying those companies, we have a very strict
- 29:15filter in terms of the governance. So we don't define corporate governance the way that some of
- 29:23the third party agencies do. So we really do a lot of due diligence, the incentives,
- 29:31how the company executives are incentivized. Are there interest aligns with the operational outcomes
- 29:39of the company or not? And furthermore, are there incentives align with the other shareholders
- 29:47outcome returns or not? And so if we find companies that don't really fit this criteria,
- 29:57then most of the time we wouldn't invest in them, even if they are very cheap. Because what we're
- 30:06trying to do is really to find these great companies and invest in long run and then evaluate
- 30:12them along the journey and then to engage with them. So if we find the companies that are operating
- 30:17on a fundamentally different philosophy, then we prefer them to, even if they have some seemingly
- 30:24great businesses, but if they are milking their customers and their business practices bad,
- 30:31and the management incentive is not aligned with that of the minor leisure holders,
- 30:37then it's an easy filter. So if you apply that filter in emerging markets, first of all, you take
- 30:41out most, if not all of the state or enterprises, because the incentives are much less about
- 30:49shareholder returns. Sometimes it's more about the other missions, because their role has been
- 30:55owned by the state. And then you would also exclude some of the companies that you can identify,
- 31:03you know, the founder or the controlling share holders, having done many strange self-interest things,
- 31:11like related party transactions, which is very common. And then so after you filter this thing out,
- 31:17you don't have a lot left. And then we tend to invest in these great opportunities when
- 31:26when there are some hiccups, when they are, you know, they run into some turbulence in their
- 31:30businesses that we believe are cyclical, rather than structural. So the typical situation will be
- 31:37a great company that is temporarily ignored or disliked. And that's where we go in.
- 31:45Excellent. So I'm going to dive deeper into one of your holdings. So key wound securities is one
- 31:52of your larger positions. Am I right to think? Yes. Yeah. And it's probably not business, many
- 31:58or many advisors would know particularly well. Can you talk us through the investment thesis there?
- 32:03I mean, you've pretty much covered a lot, but I wouldn't mind just unpacking a bit around this
- 32:07particular business. Yeah. So key wound security isn't online broker, right? Like we discussed
- 32:14a little bit earlier. So it's really very simple, right? You you have a in retail brokerage,
- 32:22you cost is very important, right? If you have a very lean structure in your firm and then
- 32:29then you compete against the traditional brokers that are operating in a much higher cost structure,
- 32:35then you then you have a sort of structural advantage and it can be very doable. And so key
- 32:42wound is like that. And it's been you know, the market leader in Korean on a career overall retail
- 32:49brokerage and that business you can imagine and Korea is also the trading volume in Korea is also
- 32:58very, very high. So in different markets, there are different stock investing, behavioral culture
- 33:05and in Korea that you know, the turnover is typically very high. They also have a very well
- 33:12developed derivatives markets like options and futures that also adds to the trading volume.
- 33:19And therefore we believe that the you know, the addressable market is big. At the same time,
- 33:26like I said, it is by running at high return on equity. It is a part that's been ignored
- 33:33pretty much because of it's almost like it's a double whammy on a career discount because
- 33:41typically a brokerage business would prosper if your stock market, if you have a bull market,
- 33:47trading volume increase. So your your cost is relatively fixed and you have a big volume,
- 33:55the big business volume, but Korea in the past has this discount. So you know, it was trading
- 34:00at very low multiple and particularly if you normalize it's where we think it's a normal
- 34:07earning power should be. So this is part both because of business quality and evaluation.
- 34:14Yeah, and then we've been only in that company for I don't know how many years to be honest,
- 34:19but it's more than 10. Wow. Okay. Yeah. And you've I mean, we've already discussed your performance
- 34:25and I actually looked over the last five and 10 years. So it's pretty steady growth. So
- 34:31you know, that that speaks for itself in in respect to why that's a particular large position
- 34:37you've got. Now I'm going to jump over because we've we've covered a bit of Mexico, we've
- 34:40covered a bit of China, we've covered to a career. Now let's also just cover a little bit of India
- 34:45as well because when we're talking emerging markets, this I guess the point here is that
- 34:51there is so much global opportunity. And I think a lot of it's being missed unless you're in this
- 34:56space, which is why I get so excited about this particular asset class because there are so many
- 35:03gems. That's why I made that comment. You know, the shiny new toy. Let's have a look at India here.
- 35:08It's become incredibly popular globally. Strong demographics, strong growth, huge capital flows.
- 35:14But how do you think about markets where the structural story is exciting yet valuations
- 35:20have already run very hard? So we don't have much investments in India.
- 35:27Not that we have any buyers against it. But like you said, we believe that the the future is more
- 35:34than discounting in the share price. So it becomes very hard for us to to act because we can
- 35:42have all kinds of scenario analysis as to what the future of the companies and the business will
- 35:47look like. But then we layer that with the valuation and the prices. We don't find it, you know,
- 35:54justifiable. So we've been we have a team of diversified backgrounds and nationalities. So
- 36:03so we do have an Indian national and then we do look at them quite comprehensively. But like I
- 36:13said, we, you know, when a lot of people get excited and maybe over excited and when things are
- 36:20this, when people really bid things up and that's where we become cautious.
- 36:26There's another thing that I haven't raised is actually currency. So there's another complexity,
- 36:30I guess, with emerging markets here. And I'm sure that I'm speaking from an advice perspective
- 36:36as well that advisors worry about emerging markets when you might get the company right,
- 36:41but you can still lose money through currency weakness. How does all this think about a currency
- 36:47risk? Yeah, well, we managed currency risks on the company level. So when we go into a company or
- 36:56a country, we take a look at the business holistically, right? And including the environments in which
- 37:05it operates. So that would include some of the macro. So we don't really predict macro, but
- 37:10we need to know, you know, what kind of environments that it is, you know, for this company to run
- 37:17this business. And so therefore, we tend not to, you know, hedge currencies because, you know,
- 37:26part of the reason that we invest in that company is the attractiveness of the whole package,
- 37:31right? Including the currency. So we manage the currency risk on that level. And we also position
- 37:37size based on our view of the holistic risk assessment. So we don't really do a lot of currency
- 37:46hedging. And particularly, you know, when things are dire, the cost of hedging is high. And being
- 37:54contrary and sometimes that is the part of the reason that we go into these markets because we
- 38:00believe that there are so undervalued. And if we lock in that difference, then, you know,
- 38:08that that actually could be part of the thesis and locking in that, not just to have a stable
- 38:15US dollars return by paying high cost. If we have to do that, then, you know, then the attractiveness
- 38:22of the investment opportunities will be reduced quite significantly. So yeah, goes against your
- 38:28thesis, really contradicts. And that actually clears that risk up based on what you're saying.
- 38:33So again, I'm trying to debunk some of the theories that many would have around emerging markets
- 38:39in this, particularly in this current climate, which I don't know how we're going for time that
- 38:44I'm going to ask this other question because the elephant in the room, how is this being,
- 38:49how in this current geopolitical climate, how is it emerging markets fared? And I mean, we see
- 38:56the opportunities, but could there be challenges with this current space that we're in and how they,
- 39:03you know, how, how things actually forming over the next, how the last last year is actually
- 39:08performed in the last few months, particularly in terms of, we see that correlation with the standard
- 39:16equity space, how's it playing out in the emerging market space? So we are aware of these geopolitical
- 39:25shocks or risks. But again, we don't really take a lot of top-down view. What we're trying to
- 39:33really do here is we want to find some attractive businesses. And obviously we would do some
- 39:40stress test to some of the risk factors and sensitivity analysis to let's say if something happens
- 39:48particularly, you know, a top-down factor and how much, how exposed is this company?
- 39:56And we will do that, but we don't take a specific geopolitical event outcome as part of the thesis.
- 40:05So again, what we're really trying to do is we find some great businesses and then, you know,
- 40:11we basically look at, you know, how long is the growth runaway and how sustainable is the
- 40:19growth runaway? Does it have durable competitive advantage to continue to grow? And then do we like
- 40:25the people who run them? And are they good people? And so we've done a lot of due diligence on this
- 40:32very specific question. Are they decent people? Are they people with integrity, demonstrated integrity,
- 40:39looking after minority shareholders, and then we allocate capital to them? And these people are,
- 40:45well, if you write, they can navigate different kinds of environments, better than we do,
- 40:51and they are trustworthy and they are capable. So it is the very critical aspect because
- 40:57like you mentioned, right, these geopolitical events and shocks and risks are very, very hard to
- 41:04handicap. And there are very, very hard to predict. And it's not our expertise. I mean, our expertise
- 41:12is to look at companies, look at businesses, and we're really business analysts. And yeah, so it's
- 41:18the bottom up looking at the specific company level. Excellent. Now I'm, we are running out of time,
- 41:26which is such a shame because I have pages and pages and pages, questions. So I want to finish
- 41:30on something slightly more personal. You spent years investing across emerging markets and
- 41:35through multiple cycles, the biggest lessons that you've learned through, I guess your mistakes
- 41:42and your wins. There are plenty. So this is the last question we'll take a long time.
- 41:49My biggest lessons is that we tend to think linearly about the outcome of a business. And we
- 41:58tend to extrapolate things linearly. Whereas if you, this business is long enough that you know,
- 42:05things are not linear and your winner can really win big time. And some wonderful things would happen
- 42:16if your business is, if you have a, you know, great team running their business and they're
- 42:24looking after all kinds of business opportunities. They have a great company culture and they have a
- 42:32very strong philosophy to create win win situations for the companies and shareholders and the
- 42:39stakeholders. Then over time, some great things will happen. And vice versa, if you have a company
- 42:46that looks profitable and by milking its users, by over monetizing, by not investing enough
- 42:56for the future challenges and run by the team that is self-interested, not looking after shareholders.
- 43:03Things can go really, really bad. So I think the biggest lesson is that, oh, don't sell your
- 43:09winners too early. And just if you don't want to, you don't, if you don't want to have a beer
- 43:16with someone, maybe you shouldn't invest in him. If you, if you have difficulty engaging with someone
- 43:24in a very reasonable conversation, and that is typically a, a ref flag. And, and so I think that
- 43:32that's really the biggest lesson. And that lesson can be applied across, you know, the winner
- 43:39case and the loser case. That's great. I like the analogy if you can't have a beer with somebody.
- 43:45Then we all, we could use that across our lives in, you know, where's the red flags that got
- 43:50feeling because it's going to be difficult, it's going to be a difficult journey. Sally, thank
- 43:55you so much. This has been a fantastic conversation. I think we have probably debunked some myths
- 44:00around emerging markets. I feel it is still quite a misunderstood as a class here. I do find
- 44:07this very exciting. There is, as you pointed out, it's a global landscape and there's incredible
- 44:11opportunities and why miss out. So I really appreciate your time today. Thank you.
- 44:17Well, it's my pleasure. Thank you.