Latest / Newcomer Pod / Episode 3: Liz Jarvis-Shean
Transcript
- 0:05Hey, it's Eric newcomer. I'm here with Tom doverton & KT,
- 0:08Benner and this week's dead cat. We're talking with Elizabeth
- 0:12Jarvis Sheen. She's worked for Brock Obama and
- 0:14Elon Musk. Today, she runs policy and
- 0:16Communications for doordash Liz was behind some of the biggest
- 0:20political stories of the Obama years, researching Sarah Palin's
- 0:23history as governor of Alaska and digging into Mitt Romney's
- 0:26Fortune. We talk tool is about working
- 0:28for Elon Musk, Carl. Elevators prop, 22 and
- 0:31technology companies, circumventing the media and
- 0:33talking directly to the public. Now, let's get to our chat with
- 0:37lips. I just wanted to bring you back
- 0:48to your time at Tesla and just ask.
- 0:50First of all, what was it like to work with this CEO?
- 0:54Who is at the time building, you know, such a large Twitter
- 0:57following or just what was the experience, you know, working
- 1:00with one of these CEOs, when, when they can sort of go direct
- 1:04so powerfully, and what was that like back then, I think it was
- 1:08more than anything in. In 2014, you know, at Tesla, we
- 1:12were just fighting for respect. That was a war.
- 1:14Again, it was a war with the auto.
- 1:16We question the time or who is the real enemy.
- 1:20I don't know. That it was a, it was a, it was
- 1:23a war but it was, we were this little Silicon Valley startup
- 1:28that up until Model S you know, the The Roadster.
- 1:32I was not there for roaster, but Roadster was not a production
- 1:34car that Tesla actually built it.
- 1:36It's factory over in Fremont, right?
- 1:37It was a Lotus Elise chassis that you dropped a battery pack
- 1:40into and so Model S, I arrived the year but but after Model S
- 1:46one car of the year which was like the thing that really put
- 1:50it on the map and started should Propel electric vehicles, Tesla
- 1:56and Ilan. I think into a different place
- 1:58in terms of the Public's Consciousness, right?
- 2:00Electric vehicles. Up to that point are thought of
- 2:02as like golf carts, nobody wants them.
- 2:04They're super dorky and all of a sudden there was a documentary
- 2:06Who Killed the Electric Car. Do you remember that one who
- 2:09killed the electric car? I do?
- 2:10Oh yeah, everybody has like two hours of Ed Begley jr.
- 2:14Being very sad that his electric car wasn't as popular as he
- 2:17wanted it to be, right? And all of a sudden there is
- 2:19this sexy hot shit. Sedan.
- 2:23That is powered by. I'm a lot of curse encourage.
- 2:26Oh yes. Okay, yeah, it's that kind of
- 2:30podcast act like it. That that just was incredibly
- 2:34compelling and it was this it was it was fighting for respect
- 2:39that we weren't just going to be a niche sort of rich person's
- 2:43toy and you know for Ilan like he feels incredibly passionately
- 2:49about the mission at Tesla like he and I would you describe that
- 2:54mission that means just that mission is to is to accelerate
- 2:59the Advent of sustainable transportation.
- 3:01Action. And like, to my mind, it is
- 3:04unquestionably succeeded back in 2013. 2014 like major Automotive
- 3:08companies were not serious about their TV programs.
- 3:12Nobody was serious about charging infrastructure.
- 3:14Nobody was serious about it. I thought it was hilarious.
- 3:17He was the person who really taught me about.
- 3:21I think Eric is less about sort of going direct and more about
- 3:24controlling your own destiny, right?
- 3:27Like historically. Automakers.
- 3:31This is probably not that dissimilar from like Tech
- 3:33Hardware, right? Like you you Peg your the
- 3:35launches of your new vehicles and the new models to some often
- 3:39to some given motor show, right? And so you time it to launch
- 3:43around Detroit in the winter, or Geneva, or Paris Frankfurt.
- 3:49And Ilan was like that's not what we're going to do.
- 3:51We're going to we're going to launch our you know whether it's
- 3:54cars or updates or anything like that.
- 3:56We're going to do that on our own timeline and we're going to
- 3:58do it in our own. And we and, you know, listen
- 4:02everybody else, like I expect the media to cover it, and it
- 4:07was about creating that product. That was so compelling, just
- 4:09saying, like, no, we're going to do this on our own terms, and I
- 4:11think that was very different and it, he is somebody who
- 4:14again, he believes in it. So passionately, you know, you
- 4:18listen to him. I've heard him tell the story
- 4:20and every time he tells a story about the like, nearly going
- 4:22bankrupt in that winter of 2008, he tears up because heat, like
- 4:27this means so much To him and it but the direct, you know, this
- 4:33the sort of going direct idea. He has an incredibly clear voice
- 4:40that is, by the way, like impossible to write in or
- 4:42anything like that. Anybody who I think truly like,
- 4:44tries to write for Elon Musk. Yeah.
- 4:46How do you do comms for that? I mean, he doesn't, he claims
- 4:49not to have. So I think there's a shares
- 4:50these days. My understanding is there's not
- 4:52sort of an headquarters based team anymore.
- 4:55I think there are still some folks in some of the, some of
- 4:58the National markets, but but I think, you know, as a company,
- 5:02what we were trying to figure out at the time was less, like,
- 5:04how do you write in elon's voice?
- 5:06Like, that's not what that's about.
- 5:07It's how do you try to capture his vision?
- 5:12And his way of articulating things that makes it so
- 5:15compelling and translate that into something that Bridges the
- 5:19Gap. Then to the media and ultimately
- 5:22the public. And so, you know, I think one of
- 5:25the examples I was there during the era of the The, the first
- 5:29car fires and what year was that?
- 5:34That God Katie. I think that was 2014.
- 5:36Yeah, because I feel like it's hot Fortune when Tesla be there
- 5:42was Buzz around it and then the emergency started happening when
- 5:45I moved out to Silicon Valley. Yeah.
- 5:47And and that was, you know, we had there were just there doing
- 5:51the secret. We had never had a never had a
- 5:52fire in one of the battery packs and then, just sort of
- 5:56circumstances were such That we ended up with two fires within
- 6:02about like six weeks of each other.
- 6:05One in a car that was in Mexico, which was a little odd because
- 6:08we didn't actually have food and sell cars in Mexico.
- 6:13But one of the, you know, One of Eli's points was like let's just
- 6:19show what we're doing to fix this.
- 6:20And so we created this underbody shield and everything like that
- 6:23and we the team without testing it and like running it over
- 6:26cinder blocks out on in the parking lot.
- 6:29So I think in Fremont and we filmed it and we just, you know,
- 6:32put that into a blog post, put it up on medium, with a gif of
- 6:36the car, running over the cinder block, and sort of the impact
- 6:38and the way in which the cinder block exploded.
- 6:41And it was so it that was not sort of the direct communication
- 6:44that we might think of these days of like Twitter or House or
- 6:47what have you but it was we are going to tell our own story and
- 6:51we're going to tell it in a way that is compelling and
- 6:54interesting. And probably at that time, at
- 6:56least very unique for automotive.
- 6:58I remember too that the the auto press was not going to pay
- 7:01attention to Tesla and Tesla fault very Tesla Tesla was going
- 7:08up against. Not just the idea of the auto
- 7:10press but the relationships that the automotive companies have
- 7:13with the auto press, you know, for a really long time covering
- 7:17Automobiles, basically, until the financial crisis was a very
- 7:20Boys in their toys type industry.
- 7:22It was a bunch of male reporters, generally who went
- 7:26out with corporate Executives and drove really fast together
- 7:30and then had a drink. And so that was such an
- 7:33entrenched community of back slapping that for Tesla to
- 7:37enter, it felt like a non-starter and I can even
- 7:39remember being at Fortune, seeing the way cool.
- 7:42Tesla wasn't getting coverage felt so much about that.
- 7:45And so for you to make these almost most gorilla videos that
- 7:48no Auto reporter. It pay attention to you were
- 7:51allowing the public to obviate. You know, this group of men.
- 7:56Basically. Who decided which cars were cool
- 7:58that you're well it was I think that's.
- 8:00It was a very entrenched, I think you're absolutely right.
- 8:05It was it was a very entrenched sort of relationship, and we
- 8:11were absolutely the upstarts. I mean, it's your point on men.
- 8:13Like the number of times I was I was referred to as a PR girl.
- 8:16Oh, hey, you Look like a PR girl.
- 8:18Can I talk to you? Can I talk to you about the car
- 8:20and like go fuck yourself? But yeah, I'll talk to you.
- 8:22Very, very mad man. I like that.
- 8:24Ya know, very well, would you like would you like in Manhattan
- 8:27and a backrub to it? Looks like it can be kidding.
- 8:29Yeah. But you know it was that was
- 8:33where we were fighting for respect.
- 8:35Yeah. And it was very challenging but
- 8:38I think the Wait, elon's ability in the company's ability to go
- 8:43sort of tell these stories, more broadly, and in different ways
- 8:47began to generate the enthusiasm within the public most of whom,
- 8:50by the way, like, couldn't afford a Model S, right?
- 8:53Very high price, point car publicly acknowledged.
- 8:57But there became this enthusiastic public that wanted
- 9:01to read about Tesla and that in some ways I think help to both
- 9:05create The credibility but drive the impetus for for coverage.
- 9:09More broadly to me, one of the pivotal moments in elon's
- 9:14relationship with the Press came.
- 9:17And I think it was probably the time that you were there.
- 9:19Which was that the Wall Street, journal's Car.
- 9:21Reviewer did a, you know, fairly scathing review involves your
- 9:25times with the times. I was the time, sorry, it was
- 9:28before, it was before I get was a few as six months before I
- 9:32started but it was the times. Yeah.
- 9:34Okay. Sorry.
- 9:35My apologies to the journal but it was like one of their big A
- 9:39big deal car, reviewers who wrote this review in which he
- 9:42said, this thing left me stranded in the middle of like,
- 9:46the New England Wilderness because the battery, the battery
- 9:49levels were not accurate and I ran out of juice and Ilan
- 9:52responded. Very publicly by tweeting out
- 9:56the data that I guess. The company gathers on all
- 9:58drivers which is interesting on its own showing that its battery
- 10:01levels will totally accurate. What the fuck is this guy
- 10:03talking about? If anything, the Tesla over
- 10:06performed based on the conditions that it was put in
- 10:08and how Are over the limit. This guy was driving in terms of
- 10:12battery levels. And I mean, I thought it was a
- 10:14honestly, I don't know why, you know, the accuracy one way or
- 10:18the other there and where the public ended up deciding, who
- 10:21the right person was. But it was a pretty impressive
- 10:23like big dick move on his part to say, like what you're saying
- 10:26is not true and we have the data to back it up and I don't know
- 10:29if the cult of Elon as you know, this important Force combating
- 10:34against a negative press if it began their, but to me, it
- 10:37seemed like it was very fully formed at that.
- 10:39Point where it's just like, I am my own media platform.
- 10:42Here is my audience, I will send them against the mainstream
- 10:45Media or the antagonistic media to show them that I'm right.
- 10:48And they're wrong. And I've won and they've lost
- 10:49in. This is the new Dynamic, like I
- 10:51said. That was, that was about, I
- 10:52think that story was about six months before I got there, but I
- 10:58I don't think that it is an antagonism towards media, it
- 11:03like, right. I'm sitting on one side of the
- 11:06outside, the island. Um, you know, I'm sure that, you
- 11:09know, we would call Danna hall or others and they have four
- 11:12different perspectives. But I think I really do think
- 11:15like, I situate that within the context of the company not being
- 11:20taken, seriously, broadly, and the cars and electric vehicles,
- 11:24not being taken. Seriously, like feeling like an
- 11:25upstart feeling like to, Right was against us, you know, in the
- 11:30German automakers and like all the vested interests and Wall
- 11:33Street, and everybody. And I also situated within the
- 11:36context again of like, you know, and I know we're going to talk
- 11:39about this later but the The passion that founder CEOs.
- 11:44And in this case, Elon in particular like really feel
- 11:47about their companies. And I think also in his, you
- 11:50know, in this particular case like really feel about the truth
- 11:55Thor and the data and he was he was going to tell the story and
- 12:04share the data that he believed to be true to refute this and
- 12:09push back against what felt again at the I'm it really did
- 12:12feel inside those four walls, it really did feel like it was sort
- 12:17of an us against the world mentality.
- 12:18It was everybody was so dismissive and like, these are,
- 12:23I mean, this theme, I mean, the truth, I mean, one of the
- 12:25reasons I wanted to talk to you is, you know, you worked with
- 12:29Obama doing research, right? So there you get sort of ground
- 12:32truth, you know, the campaign sort of exposing to you the
- 12:35potential scandals. You sort of see the world of
- 12:37what could have been reported versus what is and then again
- 12:41working within the The companies, you know, you see
- 12:43what they they have facts obviously that they don't always
- 12:46reveal. So you have this sort of
- 12:48interesting view of the truth. Now I would say it's probably
- 12:52distorted somewhat by being like in this Tesla case you know
- 12:55you're on the team and everybody inherently is going to serve
- 12:58root for their perspective, a little bit.
- 13:00But I guess the big question that I just want to ask is, do
- 13:03you think yeah in that episode in broadly, sort of the direct
- 13:07communication means, the public gets a better sense of the
- 13:11truth. Then if it had been sort of
- 13:13intermediated by this sort of middle person who's trying to
- 13:17figure out the truth or just this way of the truth.
- 13:20I mean that's such the core question to me of that
- 13:22conversation. You think this is improved with
- 13:25the public receives. I think it's a yes.
- 13:27And I think like, I don't I think that, you know, sort of
- 13:34the more direct channels and opportunities for anyone, you
- 13:39know, politicians Advocates CEOs, you know, the folks who
- 13:45are in the broader public civil society, organizations, the
- 13:48ability to disseminate information directly and tell
- 13:53that story. Like I think that that is if
- 13:56done responsibly value additive to a strong and robust.
- 13:59Fourth estate. I don't I don't think that It's
- 14:02a like we should only do quote unquote, traditional Media, or
- 14:05we should only do direct channels because I think that
- 14:08you do one, you're missing out on an opportunity on the and
- 14:11George opportunity and we're in the other.
- 14:13Yeah. And working with Elon and with
- 14:15Tesla and that time did it, did you have sort of flashbacks to
- 14:20your time on the Obama campaign? Because keep in mind even though
- 14:22Barack Obama did win the presidency?
- 14:25It was not a sure thing. Hillary Clinton was supposed to
- 14:27win the presidency. She was the shoe and she was the
- 14:30General Motors. She was the Ford.
- 14:32She was Chrysler and Obama was the Tesla in.
- 14:37I will not say how I feel about his presidency.
- 14:39Whether I voted for him, I will say he was not a friend to
- 14:42traditional media through the course of his presidency.
- 14:45He did very few interviews with the Washington Post, it might
- 14:49have been none. Margaret Sullivan had this in a
- 14:51column, but he did interviews with Between Two Ferns
- 14:55interviews. He did late night TV interviews.
- 14:58He did interviews with Jay Leno. He did not sit, and actually
- 15:01speak. Weak and he did podcast.
- 15:03He did not sit and speak with the reporters who cover the
- 15:07White House Marc Maron podcast. And some of that felt like it
- 15:10came from a campaign in from a place where he had not been
- 15:13taken seriously by the traditional media.
- 15:16So you know, can you compare some of the experience you had
- 15:18working on the Obama campaign with, you know, how that
- 15:21translated to your work with Tesla?
- 15:23Sure, I mean, so full transparency, you know, I was
- 15:26not there in the early days I was actually working at CNBC I
- 15:30did a tour of Duty. In Englewood Cliffs with a bunch
- 15:34of fine folks there. But I when I joined the campaign
- 15:37in Chicago in during the summer 2008, we had already.
- 15:41I was part of the crew that sort of joined once they had locked
- 15:44up the general so I cannot I'm like a half OG Obama person but
- 15:48not full. Oh gee but yeah.
- 15:50No. I mean they were down what 40?
- 15:52He was down 40 points in Iowa. Something like that.
- 15:54I, you know. Yeah.
- 15:54It was it was like you gave a great speech in 2004.
- 15:58Congratulations, Junior. Senator from Illinois, like,
- 16:02you're not going to be president and I, but I saw, I think that
- 16:05part of the, the media strategy was about finding like political
- 16:12Playbook. How did I compact accountability
- 16:16though? Because, you know, the AMA, the
- 16:20late night talk show, Ilan speaking to sort of a
- 16:23friendlier, not maybe press Corps but a friendly or group of
- 16:26actors or finding his voice on Twitter.
- 16:28Or those things I think are fantastic for messaging but what
- 16:31about the accountability piece that reporters with expertise
- 16:36can bring to bear by asking harder questions?
- 16:41Yeah, I guess I don't. I'd be interested in your girl's
- 16:47perspective, having not sat on, like the reporting side of it
- 16:50does. Is that a sort of necessary
- 16:55condition for accountability a sort of that, that like access
- 16:58to the person at the top of the food chain?
- 17:02Or I don't know if I'm on the same page with Katie on there
- 17:05being much, more accountability through beat reporters asking
- 17:09questions and be like, Oh, letting Politico or whoever set
- 17:12the agenda, I would say would be a net negative.
- 17:15Really, I'm more sympathetic to Katie on having sort of the big
- 17:19washing pose for New York Times be reporters.
- 17:22Check in with the principal's every wet once in a while and
- 17:24like make sure their questions are being put up.
- 17:27But I do worry that some of the like meat respected, media loves
- 17:32to drive attention to sort of. Well, I also thought I also
- 17:35think that we saw you know with with Trump who was clearly you
- 17:39know, he did sit down with the beat reporters, you know, he
- 17:41would talk to Maggie all the, you know all the time.
- 17:43I think that's He he didn't really sit for a lot of big
- 17:48interviews of the type. We're talking he didn't have his
- 17:50press secretary, go out like gents.
- 17:52Ah he does every day and take hard questions from the Press.
- 17:55He didn't let people get grilled in the way.
- 17:57The reporters are currently grilling sake and Tony blinken
- 18:01on Afghanistan, that did not happen.
- 18:04But do you think it matters as much?
- 18:05Because, you know, we saw it when with a few times that I
- 18:08don't know if you or not, but the times that Trump did sit
- 18:11down with the media, whether it was, I don't know, John Ethan
- 18:14Swan or any of the like TV network guys?
- 18:18They would ask the questions. He would dissemble, he would
- 18:20just kind of Trail off and change the subject.
- 18:22He would get combative and then they would just sort of move on.
- 18:25Like I don't know, like accountability was achieved
- 18:27because the question asked the public was allowed to see what
- 18:32he was. Like, as a person being asked
- 18:33questions, the public was allowed to see the answers that
- 18:35he gave the public was allowed to see who he was as a leader
- 18:38through those answers. And, you know, people can say
- 18:40that that doesn't matter because folks already had strong
- 18:43opinions of Humph. But don't you think for a if
- 18:46nothing else historic record it was important to capture him
- 18:50speaking and yeah I'm sure his leadership style.
- 18:55I guess I just don't know if that leadership style was
- 18:57captured any more clearly through his insane speeches at
- 19:00CPAC versus you know what? He would say to Jonathan Swan
- 19:04where he was, hello, some of the Jonathan Swan interviews
- 19:07actually had impact. I don't know that it's such a
- 19:09sprawling. Yeah, street from is it gets
- 19:12crazier different impact and accountability are completely
- 19:15different. Talk a little bit about your job
- 19:18on the campaign because it's I think it would be fascinating to
- 19:21people. I mean you're accumulating
- 19:25Dossiers or I don't know your style of the dark because it
- 19:28sounds so sexy like that. It is not let me tell you guys
- 19:32research it's like dossiers on reporters.
- 19:35Well no no well maybe but Sarah Palin certainly right.
- 19:39You were you're researching her and then Mitt Romney.
- 19:41Yeah but Romney Romney a lot a lot of Hello to my friends from
- 19:462012. Yeah.
- 19:48No look it's not about again. It's I think research often gets
- 19:51described as the dark arts and like oh you guys digging through
- 19:54trash bin, Since I know we are sitting trolling through
- 19:58LexisNexis results and video clips and local, you know,
- 20:04records and going to libraries and things like that and it's
- 20:08like to call this m. It is in fact a lot like
- 20:11reporting I would argue about so sorry.
- 20:13You know what sweetie I mean this is he'll make choices in
- 20:16life when reporting is being hollowed out.
- 20:19You know, Rings having to produce research that they can
- 20:22fill some of the gaps, right? Or yeah I think I think that
- 20:26It's not, that was one of the interesting Dynamics.
- 20:28I think at that period of time. So like 2008, the midterms of
- 20:322010, the 2012 reelect, you know.
- 20:36Again you all live through this. I think in a much more personal
- 20:39way of the, the gyrations and the changes, the Fairly Tech
- 20:42like tectonic changes within media and I think at that point,
- 20:46you know for political media there was a lot of emphasis on
- 20:50kind of the embeds who were on the trail or you know, Politico
- 20:54had come up So there became a lot more emphasis on shorter
- 20:57form kind of breaking news and that kind of stuff.
- 21:01And so a lot of the investigative bureaus, even in
- 21:05places like the times the journal, the post, you know,
- 21:10probably did not have the resources that they had had
- 21:13historically and and probably don't, I would imagine now have
- 21:17have rebuilt, some of that. So one of the functions of the
- 21:21research team, I mean the primary function of any research
- 21:23team is actually to know. About your own gal or guy like
- 21:26to know their record and to be able to go out there and tell
- 21:30the story of the accomplishments, understand
- 21:32where the vulnerabilities are and help.
- 21:34The the teams that are there's doing sort of the thrust and
- 21:36Parry with whether it's reporters or, you know, looking
- 21:39for endorsements or any of that sort of stuff, you know,
- 21:42understand the record and be able to speak to it in a
- 21:45compelling and convincing way. But there is then the the side
- 21:48you on the campaign side, those different at the White House.
- 21:51But on the campaign side where, you know, you had an opponent or
- 21:54several opponents in the The primary and so needed to know
- 21:58about them and, you know, you think about a candidate like so,
- 22:01you know, Eric United talked about Sarah Palin so I ran the
- 22:03Palin crazy, right? Yeah, tell be real Taylor.
- 22:05Yes, I rather Palin research in 2008.
- 22:09And, you know, she had been, I think she had, we had moved her
- 22:15to like, tier 3 or if you thought, no way they're going to
- 22:18pick her. It's there was no way.
- 22:19They were going to pick her because she had, they had been
- 22:21an open. There was an open ethics
- 22:23investigation. Into her her governor's office
- 22:27and like, was that what you're gay?
- 22:29It was Trooper. Guess is that right?
- 22:31Yeah, yeah, well, nobody. Nobody in their right Minds
- 22:33picks, that person's before to, that's helpful, you know?
- 22:38Troopergate was like deeply enmeshed in like big snowmobile,
- 22:40right? I think that's probably right.
- 22:42And actually, it's snow machine. I learned through my time
- 22:46researching. But you know, we started hearing
- 22:50Rumblings the morning of the announcement that they, that
- 22:53Senator McCain is selected. A On the ticket and I think we
- 22:56all thought it was gonna be somebody like Kay Bailey
- 22:58Hutchison and so we started like pulling it together and I'll
- 23:01send some, I think somebody yells out across the Across The
- 23:06Campaign Headquarters. It's Sarah Palin like from
- 23:10Alaska on Maverick. He did a Maverick.
- 23:14Yeah, you know in like the state of Alaska website crashed, the
- 23:17whole, the whole day was insane but it was also I don't know
- 23:20that you're going to have a moment like that again in modern
- 23:22American politics where it was. We an eight week Sprint, to
- 23:27figure out who, this woman was, what was his record?
- 23:32And it was, I mean, it was just kind of Bonkers.
- 23:35But, and I mean, I don't think there's anything untoward about
- 23:37this, but your, I don't know if it's you or the campaign.
- 23:40But you breathe, like, Katie Couric before the big
- 23:43interviewer. How does that play out?
- 23:45How does this get to the, to the slowly?
- 23:47So, it's not uncommon before. You know, big interviews or
- 23:54debates or anything like that for for producers reporters
- 23:58whoever's doing it, but like sort of and everybody to reach
- 24:01out to folks on both campaigns and say, like what you know,
- 24:04what do you think would be interesting, what should we
- 24:06highlight? And so, you know, they were, I
- 24:09have no doubt asking the McCain campaign and Sarah Palin's
- 24:11folks, in the same way that they came to us.
- 24:14And one of the points, the one of the, I think one of the
- 24:17things for the Couric interview, which I was the, you know, I can
- 24:20see Russia from my house, right? Key to her.
- 24:23Well, the way we should be clear.
- 24:24That was not something that she said that was something.
- 24:26I said no later parodied in which people erroneously
- 24:29believed that. She said that she did say that
- 24:32the orders right there. Good fact, check right done.
- 24:35Tom back. Yes, snopes.com over here but it
- 24:40was the one where it was. Yeah.
- 24:41I think Katie asks, you know like what do you know what are
- 24:44the like where do you get your news?
- 24:45What do you mean the one of the points to Couric's folks was,
- 24:50you know, Sarah Palin is Probably a one of the most like
- 24:54pre naturally. Talented politicians of her
- 24:56generation. She is incredible.
- 24:58On her feet. She's great with this sort of
- 25:01the one-liners and the, the phraseology that just like
- 25:06sticks in your brain, but she had not up to that point really
- 25:09been pressed Beyond kind of the Top Line stuff Beyond like the
- 25:13main bullet point and maybe the first sub bullet.
- 25:15And so the point to the I think that we made to to Katie's
- 25:19producers and other folks was like push her beyond that.
- 25:21Keep asking the Follow up, see what's there and it wasn't about
- 25:26any particular subject. It was just that at that point,
- 25:29you know, all of Palin's interviews have been very I
- 25:32think surface level because nobody knew anything about this
- 25:35woman. And so a lot of it was just like
- 25:37getting to know this person and it was I think the Couric
- 25:39interview was that first one. I've like, real deep substance
- 25:42and then the Mitt Romney story, I don't want to give away.
- 25:44Oh man. Okay, so I mean I have so many
- 25:46Romney stories but and again all my love tulle on each end and
- 25:50Ben Ginsberg and all my friends folks why Become friends with
- 25:53since then who did not love me at the time.
- 25:58So you know, among them like we did all this research on the
- 26:02governor his record as Governor, you know, is time at Bain
- 26:06Capital, all of that, but the one, I think that everybody
- 26:08remembers is the car elevators? Yes, yes yes.
- 26:13The car elevators. So as is normal course of
- 26:17business in research, you collect information public.
- 26:22For information about. But again, both your own gal or
- 26:25guy and and the folks on the other side and part of that
- 26:28especially with someone like Mitt Romney is his his sort of
- 26:35personal Holdings of inclusive of property and right.
- 26:37So he had this house and like a cabin in Lake.
- 26:39Winnipesaukee he had a home and in Boston area, there's a
- 26:43property in Utah, obviously. And then there was this, we knew
- 26:48that there was a house in San Diego.
- 26:50Yes, San Diego house. I don't know why that One is the
- 26:52one that pushed me over but I was like he's got a San Diego
- 26:55pad, it wasn't because of they there.
- 26:57There's because of the car over, there's Tom and I'll tell you
- 27:00why. So what you do so like you fight
- 27:02you figure it out and then you do on the ground collection
- 27:05document collection of whatever might be publicly available and
- 27:08in a place like La Jolla. It turns out there's there are
- 27:12many, many Hoops to go through to renovate a house
- 27:16unsurprisingly right there. Looks like California, so there
- 27:19were documents. We had some folks in, we heard
- 27:22some folks. who are based in Southern California, and they
- 27:24went down and collected like California Coastal commission,
- 27:27records and blueprints for the new house and the permit
- 27:31filings. And like, I mean, I think that
- 27:32Governor Romney had now centered around.
- 27:34He had a higher like a local lobbyists, the shepherd, all
- 27:36this thread is ridiculous. There's a tons of paperwork all
- 27:40the publicly available so they package it up and they ship it
- 27:42back to us in Chicago. And I'm sitting in my desk one
- 27:45day that package arrives and seems like going through it and
- 27:48one of my deputies, Jamis Lynch pins me.
- 27:50He's like, hey boss, can you come out here for a second?
- 27:52I was like, I can't ride on out and out on the desk.
- 27:55Is this big Blueprint of the plans for the new house, right?
- 27:57Because remember they bought the property and plan was to build a
- 28:01new house. He's like so we're looking at
- 28:03it. This nice like what is this is
- 28:05like car lift to car lift. What is that?
- 28:09And I was like that is a car elevator.
- 28:12That is exactly what that is. So when you discover the car
- 28:16elevators, can you walk us through your emotional journey?
- 28:18Is it like you literally jump up and down for joy to keep it
- 28:22inside. So nobody sees you like, what's
- 28:24going on. I think I was fairly dumbfounded
- 28:28at first, mostly, because I'd only heard of car elevators,
- 28:31like with in automotive, like I come from, a family of cart
- 28:34nuts. We Like Love formula one and all
- 28:36that. And I was like, I didn't even
- 28:39know that people had Carville elevators in their houses.
- 28:41That's so first, I was like, that's kind of cool.
- 28:44But, oh my God. That one was a little bit less
- 28:48celebratory because they're sort of, like, what what am I gonna
- 28:51do with this? The one, I will say the, the
- 28:55instance I do remember, Katie jumping out of my chair and,
- 28:57like running over to Jim Messina is office in a celebratory
- 29:00manner, was when I was with Clint Eastwood started, talking
- 29:03to a chick and empty chair at the Republican National
- 29:06Convention I also believe a greatly misunderstood moment.
- 29:12I thought it was a solid performance.
- 29:14I thought people were being unfair to tried to convince
- 29:16everybody that had been good for the Republican.
- 29:20I mean, yeah, I'm better. I'm at a point to this.
- 29:23I mean, I do think often like campaigns and companies.
- 29:25Spend a lot of time. People like yourself
- 29:27Communications people trying to say, oh this like silly one-off
- 29:31case that obviously people are going to seize on any.
- 29:33We talked about the condoms in the stairwells with Parker, you
- 29:36know, these iconic things. Distort.
- 29:39Honestly, how people understand reality?
- 29:42Right, because they grab on or I mean maybe disagree but then, on
- 29:45the other hand, obviously humans, understand things
- 29:48through stories. That's exactly what the campaign
- 29:49understood. So it's interesting where you
- 29:51sit, where you're functioning like a reporter where it's like
- 29:54we're not looking for sort of a graph necessarily on his wealth
- 29:57over time we're looking for something that sort of expresses
- 30:00emotionally his wealth which is also what reporters are often
- 30:04looking for and leads and that's what the public consumes.
- 30:07And so Putting these in campaigns.
- 30:09You know, you guys are sometimes on both sides of whether it was
- 30:13emotional, anecdotes are smart or dumb because they want to
- 30:16package something that's going to do well with the media.
- 30:19Like, you have to think in the same way that a journalist does.
- 30:21Like is this story going to sell the public things, right?
- 30:24But I'm curious here, you know, just add onto Eric's question.
- 30:27Like when you come to a place like the Tribune or Politico and
- 30:31say, Here's this pre, you know, that it's this perfect package
- 30:34of the story gets love that you think it was perfectly packaged.
- 30:37Its best Things like it never is it's like really because I mean
- 30:41I don't you know and I you know, Katie understands this more so
- 30:44having been in d.c. for a bit. I have in all my years as a tech
- 30:47reporter never been called up. Almost never been called up by a
- 30:52comms person. And say, here is something you
- 30:55should write right now. This is a great really story.
- 30:57Never I don't think so. I mean, I'll tear your
- 31:02wheelhouse here. I mean, there are times that
- 31:06there are times that, you know, companies will certainly have an
- 31:10agenda. They want to push, that benefits
- 31:12me, but I feel like it's so much more common in political circles
- 31:16than it is in Tech reporting surgeries beside has to be
- 31:19convinced that you had the smart idea, so they give you the
- 31:23little thing and then you come come, come to it.
- 31:26Well, yeah, I mean, I'm just giving you know, but it's also
- 31:28like, I guess I mean I'm good. It is like I want to be very
- 31:33clear like anybody to whom we have ever like on the campaign's
- 31:37we ever shared research. Like everybody went out and did
- 31:40additional shoe-leather reporting and like validated,
- 31:43what we gave to them, nobody was just like, oh yeah, papa papa
- 31:46and like up and go it. Like it was That I do that has
- 31:53never been my experience and it is like, I don't come any other
- 31:57source. Yeah, it's like, here's here's
- 32:01what, here's what we've got. Here's here's what we've got.
- 32:04Like, think you'd be interested. You know, here's here's some
- 32:09backup for it. Like happy to talk through it,
- 32:12but want you to be able to do your own reporting on this.
- 32:16But I think Tommy may also just be a function of Right?
- 32:21Like, it's a different campaign is a different Dynamic than then
- 32:26Tech, right? Like particularly in like the,
- 32:30you know, the way that our democracy is set up.
- 32:33Hopefully for a little while longer is you know, you like you
- 32:36do have those oppositional forces and and again I think at
- 32:41the time you had a lot of news rooms that didn't have.
- 32:45It wasn't that there weren't great reporters, it just looks
- 32:47like they were, it was a really sort of like, in the Very
- 32:52challenging times, especially for local media of, like, do we
- 32:56have the resources to go out and spend like a week and a half
- 32:58doing document collection? The answer to that is no and but
- 33:05but also just like it is. I do think it is a little bit.
- 33:08It is more common within the political media and like some of
- 33:12the just like the flow of information, you know, in the
- 33:16same way that like where was the Brock Obama's birth certificate
- 33:20like is this thing real? Like, you know that Was stuff
- 33:22that was coming to us, not necessarily from the McCain
- 33:24campaign but like from crazy as people, you know, out on Out On
- 33:28The Fringe but like that that was getting sort of moved
- 33:30against us in the same way that we were sharing things on the
- 33:34other side. I have a question about
- 33:36accountability again because what's so interesting is we've
- 33:41established that it's okay to you know as an entity it whether
- 33:44you're a politician or the CEO of a company or Corporation,
- 33:48there's so many good ways to tell your own story without the
- 33:52Us. Why is it important for -
- 33:55information about your competitor to be pushed through
- 33:58the Press? Why can't a company or a
- 34:00politician simply say? Well, you know what Mitt Romney.
- 34:05You're not a man of the people, you have car elevators.
- 34:08What's going on with that? I mean, that could be a pretty
- 34:10good debate Zinger. So why was it more impactful for
- 34:13that to be pushed through a media organization?
- 34:17I think, you know, to be quite honest.
- 34:19So I think it Number one. There were only there was only
- 34:23so much that we could we could do through public records and
- 34:30and learn and share. And I think we did at the time,
- 34:35there were some things where we would sort of begin to deploy it
- 34:39and then share the back up and those kinds of things.
- 34:42But I think it was also, I just think 2012 was a different era,
- 34:46you know. 2008 certainly was and I think if you look at campaigns
- 34:50now Are probably is more kind of direct sharing of information.
- 34:58It actually would be really, I mean, Katie, it's a great.
- 35:01It'd be really interesting to think about a 2024 campaign
- 35:05where teams just shared this stuff, more directly as opposed
- 35:10to sharing it with media first. But I mean I mean you don't
- 35:14think masking The Source UPS. The credibility level I mean and
- 35:18it's from public records. So then but that sort of to me,
- 35:21would I assume the game is that it's better?
- 35:23There are plenty of, there are plenty of stories where, you
- 35:26know, the it is made very clear in the story that this
- 35:30information was provided by You know, the Obama campaign or the
- 35:33Romney campaign or whomever it was, does that hurt the impact
- 35:37of the story? You think if it sounds like it
- 35:39came directly as an Oppo dump versus like I the enterprising /
- 35:43little, you know, political reporter have uncovered, you
- 35:45know, yeah, elevator car line. So it's a, you know, I'm
- 35:51actually like I'm not just blowing but like I actually
- 35:53don't because I don't know. How much?
- 36:02II like legitimately don't know how much weight that would carry
- 36:05with an average voter, like, people goes to Media so little
- 36:09that it doesn't need to necessarily come from the
- 36:11present. Like there could be a world in
- 36:13which like, you know, a campaign sharing that directly in 2024,
- 36:18has more credibility with a certain audience than it being
- 36:21shared pressing. But yes.
- 36:23Yeah. But Trump supporters will
- 36:25believe they're more apt to believe information that comes
- 36:28from him directly then push through the wall.
- 36:31Street Journal, right? And I think that and I don't
- 36:35want to only criticize. That's I'll just say that's one
- 36:38example and we see shades of it too.
- 36:42And more mainstream circles where people were willing to
- 36:47embrace information. It was later to be proven to be
- 36:49untrue about Donald Trump because they just liked him so
- 36:53much and it didn't matter where the information came from the
- 36:56yeah, it's entirely possible that that's the case.
- 37:00And it's, you know, and Even in like a non trumpian sort of
- 37:04world. You know, information that is
- 37:08shared by a figure, you know in whom you believe passionately
- 37:12like probably does have a different weight to it and land
- 37:17differently and like attached itself to you in a way that is
- 37:19different from, like I read it. And you know, my local
- 37:22newspaper. I want to talk about doordash
- 37:26where you work now, and sort of the tech press, which Tom was
- 37:30touching on a little bit earlier.
- 37:33I mean, there have been two major, you know, to me doordash
- 37:39Troy's one sort of, the, I mean there.
- 37:42I'm sure you have many stories, but, you know, it's really neat
- 37:44Alaric, you know, there's the prop 22 in this sort of
- 37:47consumption of how press deals with prop 22.
- 37:51And then there's sort of how doordash He has handled tipping
- 37:56over the years. What what, how would you rate
- 38:00the media's coverage of prop? 22?
- 38:01I mean, do you think it's fair, if it's not fair, what would
- 38:05sort of your main criticism of it?
- 38:07Be as in say, can we just get a new sentence description of
- 38:10prop? 22?
- 38:11What, what is it something like 15:22 was the ultimate Triumph
- 38:16of capital, Over The Working, Man, in which in which no
- 38:19basically, it was a rule that allowed all the gig, make your
- 38:22gig worker companies, Uber Lyft instacart doordash to keep using
- 38:29their gig workers as contractors rather than employees and
- 38:33appreciate it overturned or superseded a previous law that
- 38:37the legislature State Legislature had passed, which
- 38:40had required. These companies to treat them
- 38:43more like employees and give them benefits.
- 38:45And this kind of push them more towards contractor status and
- 38:48made them. Frankly, less expensive, but
- 38:50also and the over us originally overwhelmingly Favored it,
- 38:54right? I mean it wasn't like 59 to 40
- 38:5750 % Li I've written in favorite of it as disclosure.
- 39:03Anyway, what do you think of the sort of the broader media's
- 39:08coverage of prop 22? I think that, you know, there
- 39:10were, there are obviously Outlets covering 22 and sort of
- 39:16broader worker classification issues that have points of view.
- 39:21I'm like, that's cool. You know, I think the the that
- 39:27is y'all can tell me better. I'm not like the world's leading
- 39:30historian of Journalism but like it's it's not you know uncommon
- 39:36for there to be Outlets that have a point of view.
- 39:39There are less than a point of view on the left on the right.
- 39:41What have you, you know, I think When you're covering policy
- 39:51issues, whether it was, you know, the passage of a B5 which
- 39:53is the the bill that the Tom referenced that had passed in.
- 39:57Oh God, can't time. Keep me honest.
- 39:59This summer of 2019? Yeah.
- 40:02Yeah, it was right before the election.
- 40:03Well, the auctioneer. Yeah.
- 40:05Yes. Is the Dynamics, it was Dynamite
- 40:08lives. People really don't know down
- 40:10the road is steep, but I'm sure you've got.
- 40:13Yeah, we're gonna do a bonus episode.
- 40:14We can just talk through the long fascinating history of all
- 40:18of these, which goes back to life. 2014, actually a Dynamax
- 40:21was a, a courier service. Not even related to these
- 40:26companies specifically everybody has stopped listening.
- 40:31So you know, I do think when it's when it's an assessment of
- 40:35those kinds of whether it's a worker classification, policy
- 40:38issue, you know, like And I promise you act like I'm not
- 40:43adding the point but like having dealt with us at the White
- 40:45House, like there were other like very hot button policy
- 40:48issues. That folks sort of like is
- 40:51clear. I mean, reporters went to
- 40:52afflict the comfortable Comfort, The Afflicted, and in their
- 40:55view, certainly drivers or The Afflicted.
- 41:00And, you know, to be against prop 22, you have to come to a
- 41:04conclusion of what what's right for drivers.
- 41:07But I do think Justin, how who's attracted to Reporting and in
- 41:13sort of the prerogatives of reporting, I think reporters are
- 41:18pretty much set up to be against prop, 22.
- 41:22And sort of probe, never worked at Forbes or fortunate.
- 41:26Why would give Bloomberg? Are you getting me non non union
- 41:29workplace if there ever was one? So yeah, they're certainly
- 41:32corporate corporate meeting. But what's interesting with I
- 41:34think all the coverage of Labor from the mainstream and non
- 41:38mainstream press is that I think they missed the story.
- 41:41Tori. I think you can you know
- 41:42non-controversial issei and especially that was the case
- 41:45with the Amazon, you know, unionization effort which failed
- 41:50even worse than the prop 22 opposition.
- 41:54If you would only read, you know, a couple of outlets that a
- 41:56lot of people tend to read, you would have thought that both
- 41:59were going to be extremely in favor of the workers.
- 42:02And, you know, there was a lot of I think self-examination
- 42:05after the facts reflection, whatever in newsroom saying how
- 42:08how did we miss the story so badly that we would have made it
- 42:11Seemed like this was going to be a huge victory for labor.
- 42:14And in fact was quite the opposite and I think that's what
- 42:17you're getting at. Eric that like this maybe
- 42:19reflects just the ingrained biases that journalists have
- 42:23maybe as part of Union's themselves or you know the
- 42:26natural inclinations of being a reporter which is to like you
- 42:29say you know root root for the love.
- 42:32Yeah and I well and I would say time I think, you know where we
- 42:37spent a lot of our time before during Is it like it before
- 42:42during and after 22, you know, and are continuing to advocacy
- 42:47elsewhere, it like but it was for like again, I'm I am yes, I
- 42:53work at doordash. So like, you are getting my
- 42:55spin, but like I am also a, you know, taking off my professional
- 42:58hat. Like I am a Democrat.
- 42:59Like, my background that we've talked through like is no secret
- 43:02to anybody and I wouldn't, you know, be be at a company like
- 43:07this, if I didn't feel comfortable with it, like
- 43:09they're there are enormous Societal inequities that are
- 43:13absolutely worth talking about and how gig work is treated and
- 43:19regulated. And what is expected of
- 43:21increasingly powerful platforms is absolutely inappropriate.
- 43:24You know, debate instead of conversations to have and nobody
- 43:28at doordash would tell you otherwise but you know what, we
- 43:31do here very consistently in surveys of Dashers in what we
- 43:37see in the data is like the choices that folks are making
- 43:40and why they are doing this and that they that this like these
- 43:45are folks who are overwhelmingly looking for small increments of
- 43:49work to cover gaps in their finances from other jobs and
- 43:55like we are, you know, I do think that that In particular,
- 44:04sort of the survey data that shows that in the other things
- 44:06that show that like, I don't know that that's always given
- 44:09the weight. That I think that those that
- 44:15those workers would want for it to get.
- 44:18Well yeah I didn't catch a body in that broader understand.
- 44:21The companies have the data, the best data on workers the types
- 44:26of workers and then I think people tend to be skeptical of
- 44:32the independent surveys. I mean, most of them are
- 44:35commissioned by the companies. I mean, I do think it's sort of
- 44:38suspicious that the pro-labor side really can't produce.
- 44:42I think a lot of surveys that show the drivers are on their
- 44:45side, but you know, it is sort of like your you're going
- 44:48against your intuition which is, you know, drivers getting
- 44:52employee status is good for them or you trust the companies which
- 44:56I think a lot of left right left.
- 44:58My name is trust, right? Try any of us.
- 45:01It's not about trusting, right? Well, thank you talk about data.
- 45:05It's just like the data comes from the company's, so, so data.
- 45:08And the companies are sort of synonymous, well, in my hand.
- 45:13Yes, I don't, I don't know that I necessarily agree with that.
- 45:15I mean, I am even think about some of like, You know, I think
- 45:21I'd look, I just I think it's to Tom's point of like, when you,
- 45:24you know, when you look at some of the results here that that
- 45:29see that, you know, whether it's that like don't seem in keeping
- 45:34maybe with what you would understand.
- 45:36If you read some of the coverage that it's, you know, it's a good
- 45:39conversation to have of like, what's what are the other
- 45:42elements worth considering and taking into consideration?
- 45:44It's like, I don't, you know, it's not about like take my word
- 45:47for it, as A person from doordash.
- 45:51I think the public, you know, these are super important
- 45:55topics, like, the way in which work is changing the way in
- 45:59which Tech platforms intersect with Society.
- 46:01In the economy, these are super important and they should be
- 46:04topics of debate and conversation, not only with
- 46:07voters, but with lawmakers, like I don't think there's any I will
- 46:10never disagree with that. And and, you know, we're going
- 46:14to even getting back a little bit to the conversation about
- 46:17like direct versus going through the media, like we're We're
- 46:20going to engage everywhere, you know, and like we're gonna keep
- 46:23having the conversation with, with media and we're going to
- 46:26keep telling the stories directly, but I do think, you
- 46:29know, I think that there were sometimes there can be a.
- 46:33Maybe this is also where you were going a little bit, Eric of
- 46:35like a perception within Tech of like, is there a reflexively
- 46:39negative portrayal of the of the industry, right?
- 46:44And like we get, you know, happiness or talk about that.
- 46:47But like, in some ways, Yes. It's both a worthy topic of
- 46:52conversation and doesn't matter because like you have to engage
- 46:56like a healthy. Fourth estate is good for
- 47:00everybody. It is good for society.
- 47:02It is good for the economy. It is good for workers and
- 47:06companies and voters and everyone and everyone should
- 47:10want there to be robust coverage and accountability and covers
- 47:16that were that like that does Shed light on things, both
- 47:21positive and negative, all that should exist.
- 47:24And if you don't, if you don't engage with it, like that's the
- 47:26wrong place to end up. I'd loved my goal is to always
- 47:29be in the, in the, in the first place.
- 47:31This is my Pro media bias, but I feel like we should end there.
- 47:35We love to have people, come on and tell us, it's our favorite
- 47:39anytime we also like to end up in the quickest, but what's
- 47:43always been the good place together?
- 47:44If Facebook Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 48:08Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 47:56Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 48:08Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.