Latest / Two Talking Fools Podcast / Where Did the Mall Go? The End of an American Hangout
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome back to the late night madness on W fool radio you tune into the only
- 0:09show where chaos comes complimentary the only duo break.
- 0:37I'll be your co-host today. We are the two talking fools, just two average,
- 0:42and I mean average girls, taking their phone calls to the podcast.
- 0:46Welcome back, you guys. It is Monday. It is the first Monday in March.
- 0:51The sun is shining. It's warmer.
- 0:54It just feels good. It feels good to be a New Englander. It feels good that
- 0:57spring's on the way, and it feels good that it's March. So welcome back.
- 1:01Hey, listen, over the weekend, Shabba and I, if you follow us on social media.
- 1:05We did a food review at the Traveler restaurant in Union, Connecticut.
- 1:09We had a really good time. First time for both of us being there,
- 1:13even though we've lived in this Connecticut region for many years of our life,
- 1:18the number one Facebook comment is like, I can't believe you guys have never
- 1:23been there before. We agree.
- 1:25We totally agree.
- 1:28So welcome back to the podcast. Today, I want to talk about something we bring up a lot,
- 1:32which is what happened to the american mall like what happened to it we whether
- 1:40we go in one distance or we go in the other the malls that we have around us
- 1:44the malls that we see they're all dying and i always say like what happened
- 1:49when when did this when did it happen when did it start,
- 1:53And so today, I would like this podcast to be what happened to the American mall.
- 2:00And I'll be honest with you, it feels strangely emotional when thinking about it.
- 2:06And as we talk about this today, it's clear that the American mall for 80s and
- 2:1190s kids and people in that time period, it was more than just a mall.
- 2:17And we're going to talk about that today.
- 2:20Because for so many of us, a mall was not just simply a building.
- 2:26It was where we hung out after school.
- 2:28It's where we got our first job. It's where we went on awkward middle school dates.
- 2:33It's where we met friends, walked laps, bought prom outfits,
- 2:38grabbed pretzels, and spent hours doing absolutely nothing.
- 2:41The mall was America's indoor town square.
- 2:45And now in so many towns across the country, those same malls are quiet. Parking lots are empty.
- 2:53Anchor stores are boarded up.
- 2:55Entire wings are dark. Some malls have been demolished. Others are half alive and half abandoned.
- 3:03So what happened? The decline of the American mall is not just about Amazon.
- 3:08It is not just about teenagers being on their phones. It is not just about one
- 3:14bad economy or one pandemic.
- 3:16It is a result of overbuilding, shifting consumer habits, economic pressure
- 3:22on the middle class, the collapse of department stores, and the digital transformation
- 3:27of retail. Let's start at the beginning.
- 3:31After World War II, America experienced a massive suburban expansion.
- 3:36Families moved out of cities and into newly developed suburbs.
- 3:41With that shift came car culture and a need for centralized retail hubs.
- 3:45The enclosed mall solved that problem perfectly.
- 3:49It was climate-controlled, it was safe, and it was convenient.
- 3:54Department stores like Sears, JCPenney, and Macy's became anchors.
- 4:00These stores were massive and powerful. They drew in thousands of shoppers.
- 4:06Smaller stores inside the mall thrived because they benefited from the steady foot traffic.
- 4:12For decades, this model worked almost flawlessly. By the 1980s and 1990s, malls were booming.
- 4:20Being culture revolved around them. Movies featured them.
- 4:24Fashion trends were born inside of them. But beneath the surface,
- 4:28a structural problem was growing.
- 4:31America built too much retail space.
- 4:34Compared to many other developed nations, the United States developed significantly
- 4:38more retail square footage per person.
- 4:41That meant more malls competing for the same shoppers.
- 4:45When economic conditions shifted even slightly, weaker malls began to struggle.
- 4:50Then came the slow decline of the anchor stores.
- 4:54Sears, once one of the largest retailers in the world, closed thousands of stores over two decades.
- 5:02JCPenney filed for bankruptcy in 2020. Macy's announced plans to close 150 stores
- 5:08as it restructures its footprint.
- 5:11When anchor stores disappear, malls lose their gravitational pull.
- 5:16Foot traffic drops immediately.
- 5:19Smaller stores begin to suffer.
- 5:21Vacancy increases. The mall begins to feel empty, and once a mall feels empty,
- 5:28customers stop seeing it as a destination.
- 5:31At the same time, online shopping fundamentally reshaped consumer behavior.
- 5:38E-commerce now represents a significant percentage of total retail sales in the United States.
- 5:44And that number has steadily grown over the past decade.
- 5:48Consumers discovered that convenience and comparing prices instantly,
- 5:53reading reviews, and having items delivered directly to their homes.
- 5:58Online retail does not require massive parking lots, escalators,
- 6:03or even physical anchors to create traffic.
- 6:06It operates around the clock.
- 6:08The mall was built around browsing and discovery.
- 6:13Online retail is driven by algorithms and personalization.
- 6:18Instead of wandering through stores hoping to find something,
- 6:22your phone suggests what you want before you even search for it.
- 6:26That is not a small change. That is a complete transformation of how buying
- 6:31decisions are made. Then came the pandemic.
- 6:35When COVID-19 Lockdowns began, but traffic to malls collapsed almost overnight.
- 6:42Many stores were already operating on thin margins, never reopened.
- 6:47Consumers who had been hesitant to shop online became comfortable doing so for everything.
- 6:52Groceries, clothing, electronics, even home goods.
- 6:56For struggling malls, the pandemic acted like an accelerant.
- 7:01It sped up trends that were already in motion. But here is something important.
- 7:06Not all malls are dying. The strongest malls in affluent areas have reinvented themselves.
- 7:13They added luxury brands, high-end dining, entertainment venues,
- 7:18and mixed-use development, including apartments and office space.
- 7:23These malls function more like lifestyle centers than traditional retail corridors.
- 7:29Weaker malls, especially in areas with declining populations or lower median
- 7:33incomes, have struggled more severely.
- 7:36Across the country, many former malls are being repurposed.
- 7:41Some have become medical centers. Others have been converted into community
- 7:45colleges, churches, distribution centers, or mixed residential developments.
- 7:51In some cases, they have been demolished entirely to make room for new projects.
- 7:56The mall as we know it may be fading, but the physical structures are often
- 8:01being adopted rather than erased. And perhaps the most important part of this
- 8:06conversation is cultural.
- 8:10The mall represents a specific era of American life, one where community and
- 8:17gathering happened physically and retail was central to social interaction.
- 8:22Today, community often happens online. Social interaction is digital.
- 8:28Shopping is personalized and instantaneous.
- 8:31Entertainment is on demand.
- 8:34The American mall is not just a retail casualty. It is a symbol of how society evolves.
- 8:40When we look at an empty mall, it feels nostalgic because it reminds us of a
- 8:43time when our lives were structured differently, when weekends revolved around
- 8:48physical spaces instead of screens, when discovery required walking, not scrolling.
- 8:54So what happened to the American mall? We built too much of it.
- 8:58The anchor stores collapsed.
- 9:01Technology rewrote shopping behavior. The pandemic accelerated the shift.
- 9:06And culture moved forward. The mall is not simply dying.
- 9:10It is transforming into something new.
- 9:13And like many American institutions before it, what survives will not be what
- 9:19stays the same. It will be what adapts.
- 9:22The story of the American mall is ultimately a story about change,
- 9:26about economics, technology, and culture colliding.
- 9:31And whether we miss it or not, the mall reflects something bigger.
- 9:35How America reinvents itself again and again.
- 9:40And just by reading that to you, I get emotional.
- 9:46I get emotional. It's no different than getting emotional thinking about things
- 9:51in your childhood or things that once were.
- 9:54For some reason, when it's not here anymore, it's sad.
- 9:58Because those times, as in our youth, were probably some of the best times that we've ever had.
- 10:04They were some of the most special times that we ever had. and your childhood
- 10:08should be and are some of the most beautiful times that you have.
- 10:14So the American Mall and what happens from here, I think online shopping just continues to take over.
- 10:22But it's funny to me, we talked about this on a couple podcasts ago and it's
- 10:26similar in the sense, we're a new generation that is lonely and looking for socialization.
- 10:35However, when we think about socialization, it's overwhelming.
- 10:40And so we often say we want to socialize, but we don't want to take the measures
- 10:45to do so like we did back in the olden days, the olden days,
- 10:49back in the 80s, 70s, the 90s.
- 10:53We don't visit people like we once did. I think for some of us,
- 10:56we feel like in order to have people over, instead of just having to come to
- 11:01the table and sit around and talk, you feel like you've got to do too much.
- 11:06You've got to have an appetizer or have drinks ready, this or that.
- 11:10So we made life overcomplicated.
- 11:14So whether it's the mall that's leaving us and making way for a line to take
- 11:20over, or it's a simple art of visiting people.
- 11:24They're totally different, but they're the same. Things are evolving.
- 11:28And like we say, socialization now, instead of happening under a building or
- 11:33in a building, a lot of it's happening online.
- 11:36That's what we're getting used to, thanks to the pandemic and just evolution
- 11:41of technology and moving forward.
- 11:44So I want to know, how do you feel about the American Mall?
- 11:48And if you have a mall near you, what does it look like?
- 11:51Does it, is it, is it, is it where the Target's the only store open in it?
- 11:57Or does it still have stores? Is it still functioning?
- 12:00Do you still go there? Are there restaurants connected to it?
- 12:04You know, in my town, the Enfield Square Mall in Enfield, Connecticut was iconic.
- 12:11That was our, that was our mall. And we had Buckland Hills. And Buckland Hills
- 12:14still operates today, though it's missing many of their anchor stores.
- 12:19Seems like Macy's is holding on by a thread.
- 12:21And JCPenney, you know...
- 12:25Like how much longer does JCPenney stay open for?
- 12:29These are the questions. I'll tell you though, you've heard me say this before
- 12:32and I'll say it again. The day that JCPenney closes, Kate's gonna cry.
- 12:38Anyways, guys, that's all I wanted to talk about today. That's the topic I wanted
- 12:42to talk about today is the American Mall.
- 12:44You drive by them and you're saying to yourself, what happened? How does this happen?
- 12:48How does a mall that was once thriving now not thrive at all?
- 12:52And I think we got our answers in there.
- 12:54Everybody, make sure you check us out at the twotalkingfools.com website.
- 13:00If you're interested in merchandise, go to the merch tab. That's changing and updating all the time.
- 13:05Other than that, we've got some great topics in the works coming your way.
- 13:10And shorter form content for now, kind of like in these 15-minute episodes.
- 13:15Guys, keep smiling, keep dreaming, keep being kind to one another.
- 13:21Check us out, make sure you follow us, leave a review.