Latest / The STA Clinician Podcast / Ep199: 'Understanding Tendinopathies Of The Hip & Pelvis' with special guest Dr Alison Grimaldi
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Sports Therapy Association podcast, putting evidence
- 0:04back into soft tissue therapy.
- 0:07Music.
- 0:18Welcome to the Sports Therapy Association podcast, episode 199.
- 0:24My name is Matt Phillips, creativerunchatlife.com. And as always,
- 0:27this episode of the Sports Therapy Association podcast is being recorded live
- 0:31on the Sports Therapy Association YouTube channel.
- 0:34And also for those of you who prefer it on Facebook, it's normally recorded live at eight o'clock.
- 0:40But because this episode, like last week, is going out at nine o'clock,
- 0:45basically, because my guests, it seems like the experts of tendinopathy all
- 0:47live in Australia for some reason, which we might pick up again tonight.
- 0:50So it's kind of a bit kinder to do this at nine o'clock BST because that's six o'clock over there.
- 0:56So, if you have joined us live, then thank you very much. You're welcome to
- 1:00ask questions as always.
- 1:01If you're listening to the podcast and you want to join us live,
- 1:03then next week, just put this out there now so you know, those of you who are
- 1:07listening to the first part of the podcast, next week there won't be anything happening.
- 1:11But the week after, part three of this Tendon special with Dr.
- 1:15Ebony Rio will be happening at nine o'clock BST as well.
- 1:18Okay, so do join us then if you fancy being able to ask the guest questions
- 1:22directly and hang out with people in the live lounge.
- 1:24So yes as i've already said this is part two
- 1:26of a three parts tendon special in part one
- 1:29last week i had the pleasure of spending time with
- 1:33dr a professor sorry doctor hush my mouth
- 1:36professor peter maliaris and let's just bring
- 1:38those of you who listen to podcasts you can't see the screen i'm going
- 1:41to put some nice screenshots up here so yeah it was with professor pete
- 1:44maliaris has been on the show before who like all of my guests is a
- 1:47hugely prominent and internationally respected tendon researcher and educator co-author of
- 1:51over 100 peer review publications peter is
- 1:54also creator of the internationally acclaimed mastering lower limb tendinopathy
- 1:57online and face-to-face course now in its seventh edition
- 2:00details of which can be heard in episode 198 of the sports therapy association
- 2:05podcast available as always on all popular podcasts players and youtube so a
- 2:10huge thank you to professor peter maliaris for opening our tendon special last week so tonight in part
- 2:17two, which is entitled Understanding Tendinopathies of the Hip and Pelvis.
- 2:22My guest coming up shortly is the one and only Dr. Alison Brumaldi.
- 2:25And then, like I say, in two weeks' time, on June the 4th, in episode 200.
- 2:30200. Isn't that fantastic? The topic will be managing tendon pain with special guest Dr. Ebony Rio.
- 2:38Right then, back to my guest tonight. It really doesn't get much bigger than
- 2:41this, people. I'm so excited and rightfully so. People have been messaging me all day.
- 2:45Dr. Alison Rowdy has got over 30 years of clinical experience with particular
- 2:48expertise in the management of hip, groin and lumbopelvic pain dysfunction.
- 2:53She's also a fellow of the Australian College of Physiotherapists, Principal
- 2:56Physiotherapist at PhysioTech and an Adjunct senior
- 2:59research fellow at the university of queensland so
- 3:02as always this is a huge opportunity for people who have joined us live
- 3:05and if you listen to the podcast i really do encourage you next in two
- 3:08weeks time to join us live as well because you don't really these opportunities
- 3:11don't come along all the time to ask questions live direct to guests of this
- 3:15caliber so i do encourage you if you've if you've got um some time free then
- 3:20do join us in a couple of weeks time so anyway i'm babbling on without further
- 3:23ado let's bring up dr allison grimaldi.
- 3:27Music.
- 3:28Stick to the sports therapy association podcast evidence back soft tissue therapy,
- 3:37how you doing good thanks matt i'm sorry i started babbling then because i'm
- 3:42so keen for people to actually join this i feel quite guilty that i'm not like
- 3:47there's not hundreds of people joining now but it's hey that's education we
- 3:50want to reach people who don't know you don't we Otherwise, it's just an echo chamber. That's right.
- 3:55So thank you very much. I do appreciate it, especially since it's like six in
- 3:58the morning, isn't it, where you are in not-so-sunny Brisbane, I hear?
- 4:02It's beautiful. Actually, the weather's been lovely. Just a little cool,
- 4:06but only 10 degrees, so it's not sort of like… 10 degrees. Wow, you guys are suffering.
- 4:12Anyway, great to join you today. I really appreciate it.
- 4:16People are joining us now. That's good. People are coming through the door.
- 4:18Let's just bring some people up. Like I say, if you have joined us live,
- 4:21then do ask questions away.
- 4:22And if you do ask questions, I'll bring your lovely logo or photo up onto the screen.
- 4:27Cecily Hislock says, evening. I have another. No, I'm not having another joke,
- 4:31Cecily Hislock. I'm just going to hide it now.
- 4:32I just listened back to the way I started Peter's podcast last week.
- 4:38No, Cecily, I banned you. Forget it.
- 4:40Let's just move on. Fine. Thanks for joining us, people who are live.
- 4:44All focus has got to be on Dr. Grimaldi, I'm afraid. So, Dr.
- 4:48Kamaldi, fantastic to have you here.
- 4:51It's a huge topic. We talked about understanding tendinopathies of the hip and
- 4:56pelvis, and we're not going to get through all of that tonight.
- 4:58But I'm wondering, just for listeners who aren't aware, what would the kind
- 5:01of most common tendinopathies of that region be if we were going to dip into
- 5:05a few of them tonight? Dr. Kamaldi,
- 5:06The most common ones would be gluteal tendinopathy and proximal hamstring tendinopathy.
- 5:12Then we can have some other tendon problems that might occur.
- 5:16Sometimes with adductor-related groin pain, you may get the tendon involved.
- 5:21So we can have adductor tendinopathy.
- 5:23Rectus femoris tendinopathy, we can get sort of at the front of the hip there.
- 5:27And then we can even get other tendons involved, often associated with osteoarthritis.
- 5:33So, for example, at the back of the hip, the obturator internus tendon that
- 5:37runs right across the back of the hip there can get tendinopathy as well.
- 5:41But the most common ones that we see are going to be gluteal tendinopathy at
- 5:46the lateral hip and proximal hamstring tendinopathy at the ischium.
- 5:50Fantastic. Yeah. So we haven't got time.
- 5:54It would do a massive discredit to you and everything if we tried going into all of those areas.
- 6:00But I'm wondering as an opening question, in the topic of tendinopathy in general,
- 6:05are there some common themes, do you think, in treating those areas?
- 6:08Although obviously, there's going to be distinctions.
- 6:10Do you think there are some areas which are responsible for mismanagement of
- 6:14tendinopathy of the hip and pelvis, things that aren't quite trickling through to the clinic floor?
- 6:20I guess one of the common things is that a lot of the tendinopathies around
- 6:24the hip and pelvis are insertional tendinopathies, which just means that the
- 6:29the tendon sort of wraps around a bone for it sort of inserts into that bone.
- 6:34And so there's opportunity for compression of the tendon.
- 6:38And so compression is a really important factor in the development,
- 6:43we think, certainly in the management of tendinopathy.
- 6:46It's something that we tend to reduce to try to reduce pain.
- 6:50But I guess in terms of mismanagement, I think one of the things that's often
- 6:56prescribed for tendinopathies is stretching.
- 6:59And so particularly with gluteal tendinopathy, which has previously been diagnosed
- 7:04as trochanteric bursitis.
- 7:06And one of the really strong beliefs around trochanteric bursitis was around,
- 7:12it's all about tightness of the ITB.
- 7:14And so there was lots of, you know, one of the main treatment approaches was
- 7:19stretching of the ITB or trying to mechanically lengthen the ITB and eventually
- 7:25surgically lengthen the ITB.
- 7:28Similar with proximal hamstring tendinopathy that a lot of patients will try
- 7:32to stretch and stretch and stretch.
- 7:34But for both of those situations, stretching isn't terribly helpful and might
- 7:38be provocative because you're actually exposing that insertional tendon to more compressive load.
- 7:46And with gluteal tendinopathy, particularly tendinopathy,
- 7:49That population is actually really short in their lateral soft tissue structures,
- 7:56even though that's still the common belief, even though now we've sort of moved
- 8:00towards, you know, gluteal tendinopathy is our understanding of the primary
- 8:04condition, but we might also have bursal change there.
- 8:07But there's still this sort of belief that the
- 8:10ITB must be tight and so there's
- 8:13still some stretching going on out there perhaps but when we actually assess
- 8:17these people in clinic they're actually really tight and they're much more likely
- 8:22to be long in that lateral stability mechanism and that's because that population
- 8:27tends to sit with their knees crossed in adduction,
- 8:31stand and hang on one hip in adduction,
- 8:34walk with excessive adduction, you know, in their normal everyday gait patterns.
- 8:40And so they spend a lot of time in adduction in a lengthened position.
- 8:44And so they do actually tend to be longer rather than shorter in their ITB and hip abductors.
- 8:52And so stretching is not going to be useful and it's just going to be provocative.
- 8:57We do see a subgroups that are tight, more commonly males that stand with wide
- 9:02legs, sit with wide legs, but they're the much smaller population.
- 9:05But stretching won't help them either because it'll just cause that compression.
- 9:10Massage can be useful, but the massage is not about lengthening the ITB.
- 9:15What we see in those with gluteal tendinopathy is they often get tender and
- 9:23a bit overactive, if you like, in the vastus lateralis, so in the lateral part of that quads.
- 9:29But that's simply because that muscle is part of the more superficial stability
- 9:34system for the pelvis in the lateral lateralis.
- 9:39Lateral stability mechanism. And so when the vastus lateralis contracts,
- 9:43it pumps out the ITB and so that helps the ITB in the upper glute max.
- 9:48So if you're weak in the deeper abductors, glute min and glute med,
- 9:52then you need to use more of the superficial abductors and that includes vastus lateralis.
- 9:57So I think, you know, a lot of that tightness and tenderness that we feel down
- 10:01the side of the thigh there is about vastus lateralis trying so hard to,
- 10:07you know, help the lateral hip.
- 10:09Actually, a couple of weeks ago, I saw a patient who was so weak and she had a large BMI.
- 10:16So there was a big physical mismatch between her ability to load bear and she
- 10:22would get this massive cramp in her vastus lateralis just trying to weight bear
- 10:26because she had a lot of atrophy and just was not strong enough to weight bear
- 10:32with the weakness that she had and the body weight that she had,
- 10:35but she'd been through all of these investigations trying to,
- 10:39you know, figure out what this problem was in her thigh.
- 10:42Well, I can explain what the problem is in the thigh. It's a,
- 10:46you know, an enormous overload on your vastus lateralis.
- 10:49So massage can be really useful to help sort of, you know, reduce pain and,
- 10:53but it will only be a very temporary.
- 10:56You know solution because we have to get to
- 10:59the the root of the cause which is which which is up
- 11:02at the hip there very long answer no that's
- 11:05just i should really just stop the episode there because there's
- 11:08enough there to keep our listeners going on for a good couple of hours
- 11:11i'm like it's just it's everything it's just
- 11:14ticking all my boxes it's fantastic i mean it's recently
- 11:17i gave a webinar for physique management on proximal hamstring tendinopathy
- 11:20and i i say on that guys i'm just a conduit people
- 11:24maybe like the way i give the information but this information is
- 11:26coming from experts like yourself like peter maliaris in
- 11:29particular the paper he did with tom goom on that and other
- 11:32people as well so to hear you can to hear
- 11:35it from i hate especially from the horse's mouth always seems so disrespectful
- 11:37but hearing it from from you saying things like it's you know it's not always
- 11:43a stretchy tight issue okay just because it hurts doesn't mean it needs to be
- 11:47stretched and a lot of cases when it comes to insertional tendinopathy the research kind
- 11:52of suggests that maybe that that extra tensile could cause some compression, et cetera, et cetera.
- 11:57So it's really refreshing to hear this message kind of said,
- 12:00because unfortunately, especially with soft tissue therapists,
- 12:05massage therapists, sports massage therapists.
- 12:08Most of the principles taught are about increasing range of movement,
- 12:12because we know that laying hands and massaging can increase,
- 12:17even though it's kind of not for very long.
- 12:20It's temporary we can increase visible flexibility and
- 12:23range of movement but because of that all the
- 12:26techniques people use is to kind of stretch and increase but so
- 12:29when it comes to conditions where it's not lack of range of mobility isn't the
- 12:34issue here it's actually the opposite it's actually need to put some stiffness
- 12:38in it sounds like a foreign entity so now it's great thank you so much for mentioning
- 12:42that because it's it really does help therapists think oh god maybe i better
- 12:47I better crack on with this because if Dr.
- 12:49Alison Grimaldi is saying it's not always a stretching issue,
- 12:51then it must be true. So that's really good. It's really good to hear that.
- 12:55So, yes, common themes in treating tendinopathies in the hip and pelvis.
- 12:59Yeah, they may well be in insertional and stretching is not always the answer.
- 13:04I wonder whether I'm going to dip into research that you've done.
- 13:08Obviously, it's a long, illustrious career. I don't want to make you feel too
- 13:11old, but I just want to we're going to go back to 2008.
- 13:15Now, I don't like I said off air, I don't need you to recall the afternoon and
- 13:19who you were with and that sort of stuff.
- 13:20But I think it's just interesting. I just wondered because I looked on ResearchGate.
- 13:23And again, I encourage listeners to go to ResearchGate and look up the names
- 13:26of my guests because you'll get a lovely idea.
- 13:29Obviously, reading just the abstract can be a little bit dangerous.
- 13:32But in most cases, there's links or a lot of cases, there's links to the full text.
- 13:36And in many cases, I hear that if you actually contact the author,
- 13:39they'll be more than happy to give you where they can full text anyway.
- 13:42But in 2008, your publication, the first one I could find on ResearchGate was
- 13:48MRI Investigations of the Muscles Involved in Lateral Stability of the Hip.
- 13:51So I was just interested in having you on the show how you
- 13:55came about as that being you know one of the first published
- 13:58papers and at that time did you realize then that this was going to be your
- 14:02future that you're going to become kind of such a respected professional and
- 14:07educator of this area of the body no but it was something that I guess I had
- 14:15a burning desire to try to
- 14:17figure out, you know, some more information about the hip.
- 14:20And so that paper, well, I think that's actually a link to my PhD thesis.
- 14:26So it was interesting. I did a coursework master's, a sports physio master's in 1997, a while ago now.
- 14:37And that was a very intense year and I absolutely loved it, but it was a lot
- 14:42of work and lots of exams.
- 14:44And, you know, at the end of that That year I went, well, that's it with university.
- 14:48I won't be going to university.
- 14:51But, you know, as you start sort of,
- 14:55applying that extra knowledge that you get from Masters, which is fantastic.
- 14:59But there were still so many unanswered questions. And back then,
- 15:03there was so little research on the hip.
- 15:06There's been an absolute explosion in the last 10, 15 years, which is fantastic.
- 15:11But back then, there was very little. And as is very common with people going into particular areas,
- 15:19I'd had a bit of my own hip issue and so and
- 15:22it had been to every course there weren't very
- 15:25many courses either looked up everything the literature and
- 15:28I'm going oh I'm going to have to go and try to answer some questions myself
- 15:32so you know went back to uni to try to answer some questions and I think again
- 15:39with a lot of PhDs that are driven in that way you've sort of got so many questions
- 15:44and you expect to answer all these things when you go into a PhD.
- 15:48But, you know, and actually I'd intended to do some EMG, but,
- 15:53you know, there was so little information on the hip that we thought,
- 15:57well, let's do some MRI studies first to try to figure out which muscles might
- 16:02be most affected by, you know, joint pathologies.
- 16:05And so then we might be able to, you know, direct the EMG, like figure out what
- 16:11we actually want at EMG. Anyway, the MRI...
- 16:14Studies ended up so big that my whole PhD ended up a MRI study.
- 16:19And, you know, I initially started, you know, wanting to measure all the muscles around the hip.
- 16:24And then it ended up that, you know, it was such a big project that I ended
- 16:29up focusing on the abductor mechanism, which was the part of the muscular system
- 16:35around the hip that tends to be very regularly affected.
- 16:39It's probably most consistently affected across all different types of pathologies
- 16:44with the hip and hip joint pathologies.
- 16:47So it ended up sort of focusing more on the hip abductors and looking at people
- 16:54with joint pathologies, so earlier joint pathology and more advanced joint pathology.
- 17:00And then I had an opportunity to also be involved in a bedrest study,
- 17:06which was really interesting. So their PhD ended up being a bit about pathology
- 17:10and then about unloading.
- 17:12And that was actually fascinating.
- 17:14And I think it did start to really change the way I prescribe exercises and
- 17:20the way that I looked at things as well.
- 17:21Because my, so it was with the Berlin Bedrest Study, which is a study that was
- 17:26run by the European Space Agency.
- 17:28And that's because they were you know
- 17:31looking at trying to keep astronauts up there in space for.
- 17:34Longer with less you know effect on their musculoskeletal system
- 17:37because it's you know unloading is you
- 17:40know has such dramatic impacts on you know
- 17:43not just bone of course we're aware that it has effects on bone
- 17:46but on the muscular system and it's interesting that
- 17:49all muscles aren't affected equally and so
- 17:52my part of that study was to have a look at what happened to
- 17:55the the abductors after eight weeks of bed rest and so
- 17:58these were normal healthy they were all males but normal
- 18:01healthy males and a lot of them were PhD students
- 18:04and it was a bit harder than I
- 18:07thought I think they thought it was going to be you know they
- 18:10thought oh I'm just going to lie in bed and you know maybe write up
- 18:12write my papers up and things like that but they
- 18:16weren't allowed to even incline their trunk more than 30 degrees
- 18:19they had to shower and do their
- 18:22daily hygiene you know lying down
- 18:25in bed and so they had force plates in
- 18:28the end of the bed so they weren't even allowed to you know push into the
- 18:31bed so they wanted them completely unloaded yeah it
- 18:33was crazy so and there was lots of things done
- 18:37to these poor fellows but my part of it was just to look at MRIs sort of over
- 18:42you know every two weeks over that sort of period and it was really interesting
- 18:46because the all muscles aren't affected equally by you know lack of gravitational loading and And like.
- 18:54So within two weeks, like gluteus minimus, so our deepest hip abductor there
- 19:00had lost on average about 23% of its muscle size, which is quite phenomenal.
- 19:06Whereas muscles like upper glute max and TFL, which both, you know, superficial abductors,
- 19:13the upper fibers of glute max being anything above the center of rotation of
- 19:18the hip joint is more an abductor rather than extensor.
- 19:21So those muscles didn't actually lose any significant size over eight weeks of bed rest.
- 19:28And piriformis didn't lose size over that time frame either, which is interesting.
- 19:34But lower glute max, which is an extensor, so it gradually lost size over time over that eight weeks.
- 19:43So a bit similar to the quads, other studies done on quads in unloading situations,
- 19:48they gradually sort of reduce, you know, size, but these deeper muscles involved
- 19:53in, you know, joint support seem to be particularly affected by lack of loading.
- 19:58So multifidus is also particularly affected.
- 20:01Quadratus femoris seems particularly affected as well.
- 20:05And so it really made me start thinking because we see similar sort of patterns
- 20:10happening in joint pathology as well that, you know, we start losing those deeper muscles.
- 20:15We see sort of that more of that fatty atrophy in those deeper muscles in people
- 20:20with joint pathologies as well.
- 20:22So that link there about loading, I think is so important because when you start getting joint pain,
- 20:30you naturally start offloading that leg and you see people with hip OA standing,
- 20:35they'll be standing on their unaffected side with the other,
- 20:38you know, side bent when they, you know, get up and down out of their chair,
- 20:42they put all their weight through their affected side.
- 20:45So it's something that I think the lack of loading has a big impact,
- 20:50you know, on muscles and changes in muscle contribution to the synergy.
- 20:56So around the hip, all of our muscles work in synergies, of course,
- 21:00and we see it all the time.
- 21:02And your listeners would be aware of, you know, that that TFL dominance and
- 21:07the TFL hypertrophy that we see.
- 21:10So that's very common. When we see that, it's usually associated with some deficits
- 21:15in the deep muscles, so particularly gluteus minimus, the deep parts of gluteus medius.
- 21:20And so in terms of then how does that, you know, relate to exercise,
- 21:26then I think getting your foot to the ground is really important to try to stimulate
- 21:33that deeper part of your hip synergies, like particularly your synergies of
- 21:37your buttock. So they're...
- 21:40Important weight-bearing muscles. So I think having your foot on the ground is really important.
- 21:45So like, I'm not a big fan of what I call leg flapping, which is leg off the
- 21:50ground, you know, type exercises and clams are not my favourite either.
- 21:55But this is sort of a process. I used to prescribe those exercises,
- 21:59but this paper was part of, you know, my shift,
- 22:05I suppose, in how I prescribe exercise and how I understand muscle function
- 22:10and what drives muscle function and muscle health and weight bearing,
- 22:14I think, for these particular muscles is so incredibly important.
- 22:18So that's one of the main things that I learned, I suppose, out of that study.
- 22:24That's brilliant. I've been surrounded for years of the importance of loading
- 22:31and how to do it and why to do it but i'd never i've never heard that a lot
- 22:36of it evidently came from yeah a study on forcing phd students to stay in bed
- 22:42supine with force plates under their feet that's incredible,
- 22:45i'm not i'm not sure what that makes you being involved in that i'm not quite
- 22:49sure about the ethics of it but it's no i mean that opened doors i guess in
- 22:53treatment and and it's so relevant isn't it to tendinopathy because tendons
- 22:57it seems in particular need that loading to regain their stiffness and very
- 23:03interesting very interesting.
- 23:05And actually, something hats off to, who was it here? Carol.
- 23:09Yeah, Carol jumped in very early on at 9-11 saying, should the tendon not be
- 23:13loaded as a continuation to release pain?
- 23:19Yeah, which is interesting as well, because thanks, Carol, because I've got a script here.
- 23:23I'm just going to ignore it because you guys in the live lounge are going to
- 23:27stimulate my questions for Dr. Alison Grimaldi tonight.
- 23:29So it's interesting.
- 23:32When it comes to loading, there's this continuum,
- 23:35which a lot of people read about with isometric first and then
- 23:38introduce the isotonics and some people i've heard
- 23:41and seen online which is a terrible place to learn sometimes but
- 23:44that the isometrics are overrated and it's
- 23:47not necessary and take them straight to isotonics but then other people will
- 23:50quote papers which show that isometrics have been linked in with actually
- 23:53reducing pain so what's your take on
- 23:56isometrics as part of let's stick
- 23:59with gluteal maybe to make it more concrete but yeah isometrics
- 24:02for a rehabilitation of gluteal tendinopathy sure
- 24:06i might just address i think
- 24:09that question might have come in when i was
- 24:12talking about compression and not stretching and i'm not sure if so i'll come
- 24:17back to the isometrics but i guess just addressing that question about should
- 24:22a tendon not be loaded and isn't stretching loading so i guess stretching Stretching
- 24:27is loading, but it's the type of load.
- 24:29So I guess it's that sort of balance between compressive and tensile loading.
- 24:34So when we're stretching, we're getting a really high amount of compressive loading.
- 24:40And that's one of the things that we...
- 24:43Think is like stimulates a tendon response to create changes in the tendon,
- 24:50but probably not only the tendon, the bursa and at the lateral hip,
- 24:53the iliotibial band as well.
- 24:55So all of those structures actually end up thickening themselves by,
- 25:00you know, laying down larger proteoglycans, you know, gel sort of molecules
- 25:04in those structures, which are hydrophilic, that suck water into the tendon and the bursa.
- 25:09And the iliotibial band has also been shown to be thickened over the ITB in
- 25:14those with gluteal tendinopathy.
- 25:16And so all of those structures become better at absorbing compressive load.
- 25:20However, particularly for the tendon, a tendon that is more adapted to compressive
- 25:25load becomes less adapted to its normal tensile load because the collagen fibres
- 25:31get disorganised and they're not all lined up in those nice lines to be able to absorb tensile load.
- 25:37So I guess I just wanted to address that first in
- 25:40terms of compressive and tensile loads are different things so
- 25:43yes we need to load a tendon but what we're doing
- 25:46in rehab of insertional tendinopathies is particularly
- 25:49in those early phases is trying to reduce exposure
- 25:53to compressive load while we gradually increase
- 25:56exposure to tensile load so then
- 25:59back to exercise mode then how do
- 26:02we do that hold on actually i should therefore say cow sorry
- 26:05if that's what you were implying and sorry i didn't realize you were going down
- 26:08that path of isn't stretching loading as well
- 26:11i just wanted to say because i've heard that again on
- 26:14social media it's like very polarized and as soon as some
- 26:17people start saying stretching is is excellent
- 26:20for everything other people say we shouldn't be stretching suddenly and then
- 26:23people come back saying ah but stretching is actually a form of load and therefore
- 26:27we should be stretching but then i think the research shows that yes stretching
- 26:30can cause a load but you'd need to do it something like 12 hours a day for six
- 26:35days a week for it to have the same load as a traditional resistance exercise.
- 26:40So again, it's interpretation of studies, isn't it? You wouldn't be able to
- 26:43give enough load, I think.
- 26:46The equivalent of going to a gym or something by stretching
- 26:49would you or am i mistaken no no i
- 26:52wouldn't think so particularly with tendons where
- 26:54you know and even the itb like you're going to
- 26:57get more load in the itb when you have muscles contracting
- 27:00it as well but yeah again if
- 27:04if you put someone in stretch position for 12 hours
- 27:07with gluteal tendinopathy i think you'd end up having to
- 27:10yeah put them on a walking aid the next day
- 27:13yeah you'd prove your point and get a bit of low but I
- 27:15don't think it would yeah be totally anyway so I
- 27:18just thought I'd mention that because I just hear it used as an excuse for
- 27:22people who are trying to defend stretching and we're not saying that stretching is really
- 27:24terrible but I think insertional tendinopathy and I quote it is it's an example
- 27:29of where stretching is not the the fix for all and unfortunately a lot of us
- 27:34and patients believe stretching is the solution for everything we need to educate
- 27:36a little bit don't we yeah no that's right and I mean again I'm not saying we
- 27:41should never stretch anyone one.
- 27:42But it's just, you have to understand the condition that the patient has when
- 27:46you're providing advice around exercise.
- 27:49And that's, you know, that's not a helpful thing to give to someone with gluteal
- 27:53tendinopathy. It doesn't mean that no one should stretch.
- 27:57But, you know, again, you know, prolonged, sustained stretching just before
- 28:01exercise is also often not a great idea.
- 28:04You know, a dynamic warm-up is usually better in those situations.
- 28:08But yeah, so it's It's just about the situation when it's appropriate or not
- 28:12to prescribe stretching.
- 28:13But if we go back then to the exercise modes and loading the tendon and how
- 28:18do we do that, I do start with isometrics for gluteal tendinopathy.
- 28:25And I often do it for proximal hamstring tendinopathy as well.
- 28:29And it's something that can help from a pain relief point of view.
- 28:33And if it helps, great. right?
- 28:35That's, you know, a great little tool that they have that they can actually
- 28:38give themselves some rapid relief actually with proximal hamstring tendinopathy.
- 28:43I had this patient once who was a cabbie, taxi driver.
- 28:47And so obviously he was sitting all the time and he had lots of sitting pain
- 28:51from the proximal hamstring tendinopathy.
- 28:53But so I taught him, you know, an isometric in standing, just,
- 28:57you know, hooking his foot under something and just pulling up.
- 29:00And so what he'd do is that he'd do a fair and then
- 29:03he'd jump out of his car and he'd stand up
- 29:06next to his sort of door and he'd put his foot you know
- 29:08underneath the door jamb and he'd just pull up you know do that
- 29:11a couple of times and he'd feel so much better so then he
- 29:14was comfortable to sort of do his next his next fair but of course that wasn't
- 29:19going to cure the situation but it was a really good thing for him a tool for
- 29:24him if you like for getting through his day with more comfort it by having something
- 29:29that he could do to give him some immediate relief.
- 29:32Now, it doesn't work like that for everyone, but for someone who it helps,
- 29:36that's fantastic. Full gluteal tendinopathy.
- 29:39The isometrics that we do, you know, I started doing isometrics for gluteal
- 29:44tenopathy a long time ago, a long time before Ebony's lovely research sort of came out.
- 29:49And initially, it wasn't to do with pain relief.
- 29:52That wasn't why I was prescribing isometrics. It was actually about retraining
- 29:56that muscle recruitment strategy because we do see such disorder in how that synergy functions.
- 30:04Contractions so normally when you recruit your abductors
- 30:07you and we use a lot of real-time ultrasound so
- 30:10we can watch it which is lovely so a normal recruitment in
- 30:13the abductors is glute min first so deepest abductor
- 30:17then the deep fibers of glute med then the superficial fibers
- 30:20of glute med and then finally tfl and upper glute max come on just as you're
- 30:25having to you know lift the load of your leg but in the preparation phase we
- 30:29get this early recruitment of the deep muscles And that's really important because
- 30:33early recruitment of those muscles helps stabilise that hip joint,
- 30:38helps stabilise the centre of rotation.
- 30:40Ready for those big muscles to then do their job and provide some of that power for lifting.
- 30:47So that's a normal recruitment strategy. But what we often see in people with
- 30:51gluteal tendinopathy, but joint pathologies as well, is that we often see an
- 30:57outside-in recruitment pattern instead of an inside-out recruitment pattern.
- 31:01And so we'll actually see TFL recruit first and sometimes like superficial glute
- 31:06med, you know, recruit with TFL and we'll see this sort of lagging behind in
- 31:11glute med. It's not like that they don't work at all.
- 31:14But there's just a lag in that sort of recruitment and reduced sort of recruitment
- 31:19in those muscles sometimes.
- 31:21And so what we do is then, you know, try to train them to re-instigate,
- 31:27you know, that early recruitment in that deep muscle system.
- 31:31And so I started doing isometrics, just training the preparation for lift phase,
- 31:36which is where that, you know, that motor control was sort of going wrong.
- 31:40But it was really interesting and it was fantastic when ebony's paper came out because.
- 31:45Because yeah i'd send someone home and i might have
- 31:48only you know got through that exercise and education and
- 31:51all of that on the first day and then they came back the next session and said
- 31:55oh that exercise you gave me it really helps with my pain and initially i'd
- 32:00go oh okay doesn't really make any sense but when ebony's research came out
- 32:06okay now it really makes sense.
- 32:09So some people get a lot of relief from doing isometrics, not everyone.
- 32:13And it doesn't necessarily have to be high load isometrics because what we were
- 32:17doing was low load isometrics because we're trying to keep the TFL out of it.
- 32:22So it was more motor control sort of training initially, but we were getting
- 32:26great sort of pain relief from low load isometrics.
- 32:28So even though Ebony's work initially was more high load, like 70 to 80% of
- 32:33an MVC, I'd say ours would be more 20 to 30% of an MVC.
- 32:39Of a maximum voluntary contraction and so yeah
- 32:41so it's I think it's a nice place to start but there's
- 32:44no way I'd put someone on isometrics and say right
- 32:47you go and do that for six weeks and and then we'll move on to the next phase
- 32:51it's certainly not that and all of my patients usually get isometrics and isotomics
- 32:57on the same day because they are moving and we have this you know it's not like
- 33:02they're in bed they're they're standing they're walking they're going upstairs
- 33:05stairs, they're getting in and out of chairs,
- 33:07this is our opportunity right now to actually start,
- 33:10movement training with them, which is their early isotonic type exercises. And so I love sort of.
- 33:18Direct transfer into people's everyday life. So, you know, I'd also be starting with, you know,
- 33:24squatting and bridging and lovely closed chain functional exercise,
- 33:29but, you know, teaching them how to do that more comfortably by,
- 33:33you know, positioning their body in a better way.
- 33:36So with gluteal tendinopathy, it's often about using excessive abduction.
- 33:39And so it's, you know, giving them clues of right, okay, don't shift to the
- 33:44side, you know, keep your knees facing straight ahead.
- 33:47And it's not, again, when we provide education, it's important that we provide
- 33:52it in a way that's not fear-inducing.
- 33:54And so it's not like, you should never walk like that or you're going to damage your tendon.
- 33:59It's not about that. It's cumulative loading. So I talk a lot about grumpy tendons
- 34:03and I just say to my patients, right, well, educate them around what the problem
- 34:08is and how certain joint positions are going to make your tendons more grumpy.
- 34:13Be. And so this is how that might apply in the things that you're doing in everyday life.
- 34:18And the big things are sitting positions, standing positions,
- 34:21sleeping positions, you know, walking upstairs, you know, and walking generally,
- 34:26getting in and out of chairs, things like that.
- 34:28And so when you, you know, crystallize that information into a meaningful way
- 34:34for the patient, and these are usually things that are painful for them,
- 34:37then it starts meaning something.
- 34:39And so exercises, sizes, if we can prescribe them in a way that directly starts
- 34:44targeting the problems that they're having, I think they get there a lot faster.
- 35:11Yes, I am biased, what with Brighton being my hometown, but the Brighton Beard
- 35:15Company really do offer an absolutely amazing selection of luxurious beard balms
- 35:20and impeccably scented oils,
- 35:22all handmade in small batches with 100% natural ingredients.
- 35:27Their current spring collection, for example, contains bergamot, coriander,
- 35:31thyme and lavender, giving you a fresh and energising essence with both citrusy
- 35:36and peppery notes, making it the perfect gift for you, a family member or any
- 35:41friend with facial hair.
- 35:42Go to thebrightonbeardcompany.co.uk and get 15% off now by entering the discount code STA15.
- 35:52Doesn't include already discounted bundles.
- 35:57I've always admired, and you're doing it now, I love the way that you are so patient-centered.
- 36:03And I've heard you talk on other podcasts about how important the subjective assessment is.
- 36:08I want to talk about objective assessment as well, but I think we would do it
- 36:13injustice by not mentioning how important subjective assessment is as well,
- 36:17because like you say, it can be be different in the case of
- 36:20each patient and also the the rehab you give has to be built around their lives
- 36:25and what they can do and their understanding and they need to understand how
- 36:28important it is so can you give us some kind of ideas of where the subjective
- 36:32assessment should take us and when we're dealing with a patient in front of
- 36:36us with suspected due to tendinopathy.
- 36:39Yeah great point matt and yeah absolutely the the patient interview is something
- 36:44that it's just a wealth of information.
- 36:47And by the time you get to your objective assessment, you should pretty much
- 36:51have sort of narrowed down your potential diagnoses to usually two or three things.
- 36:57But so for gluteal tendinopathy, well, anything around the hip,
- 37:02like area of pain, I think is really important.
- 37:05And for tendon pathologies, you do often have a fairly, you know, localized area of pain.
- 37:11And so I do think that's very important for gluteal tendinopathy.
- 37:14Where is the pain and that area of pain should be over the greater trochanter.
- 37:20They might also get pain down the thigh, whether that's from the tendon themselves
- 37:24itself or whether it's actually related to the changes that I talked about in the iliotibial band.
- 37:31So we might have an ITB fasciopathy, if you like, down the side of the thigh
- 37:36as well. But area of pain I think is a good place to.
- 37:40Start in terms of you thinking about what might
- 37:42be some local problems sort of going on and
- 37:46so even in my patient interview I'll get the patient to stand
- 37:49up and point with one finger I say can you
- 37:51just stand up and show me exactly where that pain is and because if they can
- 37:56localize it fairly exactly it's probably likely to be something more local rather
- 38:01than oh it's sort of just running across my buttock and down into my thigh so
- 38:05that might tell me oh okay it might be something a bit bit more referred.
- 38:09So I'm going to be thinking a bit more about the lumbar spine.
- 38:11If it's less local and focal and they can't point to it, they sort of use more
- 38:16a broad hand stroke for where their pain is right across their buttock, down their thigh.
- 38:21So those things are important. And area of pain, again, when you're asking them
- 38:25about aggravating factors and night pain is very common with this population
- 38:30with gluteal tendinopathy and hip joint pathologies as well.
- 38:34And even with lumbar spine, you can get pain at night. But we want to ask those extra questions.
- 38:39So I think in a patient interview, well, in your objective as well,
- 38:43we become detectives. And I think that's part of the fun part of what we do
- 38:48as well, you know, being a detective.
- 38:50And so you want to ask more questions about their night pain.
- 38:54So I get pain lying on my side. So don't just go, tick, yep,
- 38:59they've got pain lying on their side. It must be gluteal tenonophily.
- 39:02Actually, a lot of things have pain lying on their side. So when they lie on
- 39:07their side, you know, what is it that hurts? Where does it hurt?
- 39:09And if they say, oh, over that bone on the side of my hip and it's like I roll
- 39:14onto this bone, I get sharp pain over my bone.
- 39:17If they're talking about the pain directly over the greater trochanter.
- 39:21Then, okay, yeah, that really sounds like gluteal tendinopathy.
- 39:25But if they're saying, oh, yeah, no, it's sort of just a deep ache somewhere,
- 39:30you know, deep around my hip there.
- 39:33And sometimes it's a bit at the front or a bit at the back. I mean,
- 39:36that might be more hip joint.
- 39:37So we might be thinking more OA, femoris tabulae impingement.
- 39:42Dysplasia depends on how old the patient is. If they're post 50,
- 39:46we might be thinking a bit more about OA. way. If they're sort of younger,
- 39:49we might be thinking FAI or dysplasia.
- 39:52Or it might be, yeah, when I lie on my side and, you know, I'm sort of a bit
- 39:56in a rotated position, then I get this pain that, you know, comes across my
- 40:01buttock, down my legs. Sometimes it hurts in my foot.
- 40:04You know, those are really important pieces of information.
- 40:07And so I think whenever we ask about aggravating factors, and sometimes early in our career,
- 40:13we're so fixed on the questions and And getting through the questions that we
- 40:19go, right, I've asked that, I've asked that, I've asked that,
- 40:22right, written down the aggravating factors,
- 40:24but we're not thinking about it as we go along sometimes.
- 40:27And that's where you get so much more information when you're thinking about it.
- 40:31And it's a puzzle and you're adding pieces of information to the puzzle.
- 40:36And the patient offers a piece of information and you go, oh, that's interesting.
- 40:39I want to know a bit more about that because that's going to hit me here or
- 40:43there. So I think area of pain, behavior of pain, you know, those aggravating
- 40:49factors are really important.
- 40:51Past history is so important or the history of, you know, this condition as
- 40:56well. So when did it come on?
- 40:58Oh, well, so this is a, you know, maybe 55-year-old woman.
- 41:03Well, it's sort of when I went through menopause, I started putting on weight
- 41:08and, you know, my cholesterol was a little high.
- 41:11And so my GP said look you really need to start
- 41:14losing some weight and you know looking after your heart health
- 41:17and so I started you know walking you know my kids
- 41:20were finally old enough that I didn't have to look after them
- 41:23all the time so I started focusing on myself and
- 41:26I started getting out there and walking and and he said
- 41:29okay and and how were you walking well you know it's
- 41:31really power walking so striding it out and I
- 41:34was trying to do lots of hills so that that's really good
- 41:37for my heart the GP said and so I started doing all this
- 41:40hill walking and so going from nothing to
- 41:43doing long stride walking which you know puts a lot of sort of impact you know
- 41:49up into the hip when you're taking those really big strides lots of hills which
- 41:53is quite provocative for the hip tendons as well and so there'd sort of been
- 41:58this sudden increase in activity levels.
- 42:02And then we've also got the demographic of the patient. So, you know,
- 42:05age, you know, menopausal status, you know, a little bit of being a little bit overweight.
- 42:10So we know that that's also linked with, you know, tendinopathies around the
- 42:14hip and lots of tendinopathies as well.
- 42:17And so, again, we've got the demographics, we've got this history,
- 42:20we've got area of pain, we've got behaviour of pain.
- 42:23Those things are really interesting. And then, you know, give us a lot of information about our diagnosis.
- 42:28Diagnosis but then as you said before Matt that information about
- 42:32what are the problems that you know how is
- 42:35this impacting your life so what are the functional issues
- 42:38that you have and then you know what do you want to do what do you need to do
- 42:43in your everyday life in your sport in your recreation in your occupation so
- 42:48those are really important things and it was because those are the things we
- 42:52want to focus on it was really interesting in the LEAP trial that we did on gluteal tendinopathy,
- 42:57that we did a secondary analysis looking at things that might moderate or mediate the effects.
- 43:04So might impact, so baseline factors that might impact your outcomes or the
- 43:09treatment effects of the three different treatment interventions we did,
- 43:13one of those being education and exercise, and then mediators,
- 43:17things that by changing this thing, it was the a change in that thing that might
- 43:23have created the treatment effects.
- 43:25And it was really interesting in that one of the things that ended up as a significant
- 43:30mediator, something that if we change that, that had a big impact on the overall
- 43:35outcome was patient function,
- 43:38patient specific function that was measured on the patient specific functional scale.
- 43:43So things that patients had identified, this is a problem for me.
- 43:47And if we change those things, then the patient's overall rating of condition,
- 43:55you know, seem to be, you know, significantly affected by the treatment.
- 44:00So it was interesting. So the message coming from that is that,
- 44:03you know, to optimize our management outcomes,
- 44:08if we can focus on the things that are important to the patient and they're
- 44:12are affecting their lives,
- 44:13that's likely to give them, you know, the outcome that they want in terms of
- 44:19their global rating of outcome, if you like, and their quality of life.
- 44:23So that also affected quality of life as well. So yeah, really important points
- 44:28about the things that we want to get out of that patient interview.
- 44:31It's amazing. Again, it's so valuable and you explain it so So,
- 44:36well, a lot of guests on the show have talked about the importance of subjecting.
- 44:42We say it time and time again, and a lot of the issues with our industry are.
- 44:47Is is jumping to the objective especially if you've
- 44:50just done a cpd course and it's like suddenly you've
- 44:53learned about this and guess what everyone who walks to the clinic the next day
- 44:55has got that thing you found it like why haven't i seen this before so
- 44:58we know we've got our own confirmation biases as soon as
- 45:01we put our hands on i love the way that you
- 45:04say get the patient to point to the
- 45:07area of pain because again if we jump in with
- 45:10our hands and go does this hurt you know guess what
- 45:13you know it might hurt but it's just because it's coincidence or if
- 45:16you went on the other side they'd probably say it hurt as well so it's really
- 45:19it's so refreshing hearing all of this stuff which we
- 45:22do to get a decent hypothesis
- 45:27and to understand what's going on and look already at
- 45:30ways of rehabbing this person in front of us before we've
- 45:33even touched them and and at the moment there's this
- 45:35again is it getting a bit better i don't know it depends where you look but
- 45:39this is like hands-on hands-off debate as if it's one or the other which is
- 45:42ridiculous because Because all of the stuff you've talked about means that when
- 45:46we do put our hands on and use the important palpation and all the different
- 45:51stuff we can do to assess, it's more meaningful.
- 45:54So it's not like one or the other. It's just it needs to be in that order, doesn't it?
- 45:57You've got to give them a good listening to, which I love as a kind of a quote.
- 46:01Some patients just need a good listening to.
- 46:03And they'll give you all the answers. They'll tell you how to fix them. You know, it's amazing.
- 46:09Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I think that's incredibly important that you get that information.
- 46:13And the thing is that there are so many tests.
- 46:16And I know that, again, there's lots of debate about how meaningful are all
- 46:19these tests. But again, they're just clues.
- 46:22We're sort of gathering clues in our objective assessment.
- 46:26But in my HIP Academy, for my video library, I've recorded over 100 different
- 46:32tests around the HIP. There are so many different tests.
- 46:36You cannot possibly do do all the tests to try to screen for everything.
- 46:41So you're always going to do a joint screen, a hip joint screen.
- 46:45You're always going to do a lumbar spine screen for anything around the hip
- 46:48and pelvis. So, you know, you've got those things that you've got to do.
- 46:52And so then other specific tests, you need to already, before you get to that
- 46:57objective assessment, have a bit of an idea of which things you're going to test.
- 47:02Otherwise, you're going to spend your whole time assessing and you're not going
- 47:05to get to any treatment and you might even be still assessing in the next treatment
- 47:09session if you want to do all the tests.
- 47:11So I think from a point of efficiency, it's also really important that you've
- 47:16got an idea of what you need to test when you get to that objective assessment.
- 47:21It's um it's interesting for professionals
- 47:24out there because now we know that subjective is
- 47:27so important and and thanks to educators to yourself hopefully therapists
- 47:32and listeners and people in the live lounge whether you've gone very quiet
- 47:35is it because you're scribbling away notes you can put the pen down we
- 47:38are recording this okay people if you want to ask questions you don't have to
- 47:41write a thing down but now that therapists are appreciating that we need to
- 47:46listen more and that we're kind of more facilitators rather than operators to
- 47:50quote kind of the diane jacobs and silver and all that but it means the subjective
- 47:55is going to take more time and it's important but.
- 47:58Unfortunately patients and clients aren't quite on the
- 48:01same page yet and we've got to be careful when they come in we
- 48:04might suddenly think i'm just going to talk to you for an hour and have this that's
- 48:07where the answers are i listen to dr allison groundy i'm going to touch you
- 48:10and yet again with classic mistake is that at that moment in time the patient
- 48:15just wanted to come in and feel good from a massage and they're not happy they
- 48:18don't come back and see you so again it's checking the expectations of the patient
- 48:24isn't it before you jump in with any protocol.
- 48:26Yeah yeah absolutely and hands-on is just so powerful and yes you definitely
- 48:32need to do a physical assessment but even in that first session if you can get
- 48:36your hands on a patient and i often do a little bit of massage in that first
- 48:41session for example with gluteal tendinopathy As I said, they're often,
- 48:45you know, tender up that lateral thigh and their TFL and the upper glute max,
- 48:51you know, is often quite, you know, tender and stiff, if you like.
- 48:55So I'll get them in a nice, comfortable position and I'll give them some massage
- 48:59while I'm educating them.
- 49:01And it's really great because they get their hands-on treatment that,
- 49:05you know, will give them some, you know, very short-term relief,
- 49:08but it'll give them some relief.
- 49:09But you're getting your hands on. And I think there's something about that in
- 49:13terms of that sort of therapeutic alliance.
- 49:15But you're telling them that I understand that you're in pain and that you need some relief right now.
- 49:21But while we're doing that for you, we're going to educate you about what the
- 49:25longer term, you know, treatment or longer term management is going to involve.
- 49:29And so, you know, I'll talk to them about, you know.
- 49:32The role that massage plays while I'm doing that massage, that massage can help
- 49:38ease some of your symptoms, but it's not going to be something that's going
- 49:42to solve the situation for the longer term.
- 49:45So while we're sort of giving you some relief here, I'm going to talk you through
- 49:49some things that you can do in everyday life to try to reduce that grumpiness in your tendon.
- 49:56And then exercise is going to be the other thing that's going to be so important
- 50:00in your long-term outcome and management of this condition.
- 50:04So I do believe hands-on treatments are useful,
- 50:07but not in, like, if we were just massaging and then they think that that is
- 50:13the treatment and then we keep just providing massage for months and months
- 50:18and months, you know, that's not going to ever get an adequate solution.
- 50:23It'll give them some short-term relief and that can be very useful
- 50:26as an adjunct but i think it's just important
- 50:29that we put that together with you know our education and
- 50:32our and exercise approaches as well it's fantastic
- 50:35man so that's really hopefully it's really empowering for listeners to understand
- 50:39that because again in this era we live in where it's kind of like hands on our
- 50:44hands off people don't understand it's not a case of that it's just you're going
- 50:48to do different things with your hands you know not everybody likes being touched
- 50:51That's what you could call it, like,
- 50:53again, Diane J, because it's all about this primal grooming.
- 50:56It's social grooming. It's like humans like touch.
- 50:59When we're educating kids, normally the best education is done with an arm around them.
- 51:03It's that contact which starts off, which opens up that alliance,
- 51:06if you like, that third particular alliance.
- 51:08So it's not a case of hands on, hands off, is it? It's just explaining to the
- 51:12client, this isn't fixing you.
- 51:13I'm not going to bend you back in position again. But this is what we're going
- 51:16to do as you're doing that. And it can be really useful.
- 51:19Yeah, that's right. Right. And even when we're doing things like movement education
- 51:22and like providing exercise therapy, and if we're doing functional things,
- 51:28you know, it's like movement training as well.
- 51:30We're going to put our hands on like, because tactile facilitation is really
- 51:34useful in terms of helping them find that, you know, that better position,
- 51:40that position that's going to be less provocative for them.
- 51:42So hands-on can be very useful, you know,
- 51:45not just in hands-on manual your therapy techniques but but also in the way
- 51:50we you know train our patients and provide them cues and feedback for what they're
- 51:55doing in movement training or exercise therapy.
- 51:59Amazing um i'm just looking at the clock and thinking great six minutes left
- 52:03i wish it was only we just started six minutes but there's you've already given
- 52:06such amazing information of allison it's incredible but i want to no i can't
- 52:11i can't go into anything else i was oh just quickly because i know it's topical
- 52:14as well and i've heard you talk about it before and i think you put it really nicely.
- 52:19Corticosteroid injections is something which a lot of listeners will probably
- 52:23either have clients coming saying, I think I need an injection, I need this.
- 52:27And unfortunately, sometimes they're told by other therapists.
- 52:30As they're moving around trying to find an answer they want.
- 52:33But what is the lowdown, according to you and your research on corticosteroid
- 52:38injections with either tendinopathies of the region in general or gluteal tendinopathies? Where is their place?
- 52:44Okay. So the evidence that we have for gluteal tendinopathy suggests that cortisone
- 52:51can definitely provide some short-term relief,
- 52:55but longer term that tends to be poorer outcomes, And the outcomes are often
- 53:00not better than wait and see or doing nothing in the longer term.
- 53:07So we did a randomized controlled trial comparing education,
- 53:11exercise, a corticosteroid approach, and a wait and see approach.
- 53:16And we looked at their global rating of change, so their global improvement,
- 53:22and we looked at pain intensity. So they were our primary outcomes at eight weeks and 52 weeks.
- 53:29And so at eight weeks, and I think someone in the chat there has asked about
- 53:34timeframe as well. So this might answer that question.
- 53:37So at eight weeks, education and exercise was superior.
- 53:42And so it had significantly better outcomes in terms of overall change that
- 53:48the patient had rated their overall condition, but also in terms of pain intensity.
- 53:53So education exercise had reduced pain intensity at eight weeks more than corticosteroid
- 53:59injection and the wait and see, of course.
- 54:03And then at 12 months, again, the education exercise group was again significantly
- 54:09better in terms of their global rating of change.
- 54:14So their overall outcome and their quality of life was significantly better.
- 54:18The pain intensity was
- 54:21similar so it was not significantly different
- 54:25between cortisone and education exercise at
- 54:28that 12-month period because pain had sort of generally you know reduced in
- 54:33all groups but the corticosteroid group and the education exercise group still
- 54:38had less pain than the wait and see group so there was still some effect on
- 54:43pain levels at that 12-month point So it's interesting looking at, right,
- 54:48well, why were they rating themselves as, you know, not as good compared to
- 54:53the education exercise group?
- 54:55And part of that is, you know, and that's why we did sort of the moderator and
- 55:00mediators things as well to sort of see what factors might have been affected.
- 55:04But so things like, you know, quality of life was certainly higher in the education and exercise group.
- 55:11So there's something that was changing in that group that was more than just pain intensity.
- 55:17One of the things we found that was interesting was pain constancy.
- 55:20And so we asked patients, so over the last week, as a percentage of time,
- 55:26what percent of time have you had pain?
- 55:29Where 0% is you haven't had any pain and 100% is you've had constant pain.
- 55:34And interestingly the education and
- 55:37exercise group had significantly lower pain
- 55:40constancy both in the short term and
- 55:43in the long term as well which is something to be really
- 55:47aware of for clinicians as well because patients will often come
- 55:50back and say the pain's the same but they might be talking about pain intensity
- 55:54and so you might get similar pain intensity but actually pain constancy is much
- 55:59less so if you've got a patient who has come in initially with I've got pain
- 56:04constantly or 80% of the time I have pain,
- 56:07but now you've got the same pain intensity,
- 56:10but the pain constancy is only 20% of the time.
- 56:13That's a really big improvement. And that's, you know, that really has a good
- 56:17impact on your quality of life because you're not having to think about this pain all the time.
- 56:22So that's, that's something that probably, you know, influenced that outcome as well.
- 56:27But I think the other thing about cortisone is that like within that very early
- 56:32period, like they do get some immediate pain relief.
- 56:37And we can get some change in education and exercise even within a few weeks.
- 56:42So we usually talk about tendinopathy management as it's a longer term thing
- 56:48because you need to do exercise for the longer term and to address any deconditioning
- 56:54and tendon health, that's a a longer term game.
- 56:58So we're sort of talking six to 12 months with that, but we can change pain
- 57:02relatively quickly, but not as quickly as cortisone.
- 57:05In that cortisone, you'll get an immediate response from having that cortisone injection.
- 57:10And the interesting thing that I see in clinic and actually looking at the results
- 57:17of the trial as well, we tracked activity levels as well for these three different groups.
- 57:23Now, it wasn't significantly different, but I'm mentioning it because it's something
- 57:28that I see in the clinic all the time in terms of behavioural response to different interventions.
- 57:33And so the education exercise group got obviously detailed, you know,
- 57:37education and advice, and they
- 57:39were told to reduce your activity for the moment, for the first few weeks.
- 57:43We're going to, you know, help you, you know, learn to walk in ways that are
- 57:48less, you know, aggravating and, you know, we're going to get your exercises
- 57:51going and then we'll gradually increase your activity levels again,
- 57:54usually after that four-week mark. And.
- 57:58The other two groups, the cortisone group and the wait and see group,
- 58:01they both did get a basic pamphlet.
- 58:04And that pamphlet did give them some information about what the condition was.
- 58:09And it basically said something like, you know, if you're getting pain with
- 58:14activity, reduce your activity initially and then gradually increase it,
- 58:19avoiding rapid spikes in activity levels.
- 58:21So just that basic piece of information.
- 58:24And it's really interesting to look at the traces of what
- 58:27happened so the education exercise group and the
- 58:30wait and see group their activity levels both
- 58:34came down for the first four weeks and
- 58:37then gradually increased over time the corticosteroid group who'd got the same
- 58:42information as the wait and see group their activity levels from baseline went
- 58:46up for four weeks and then it came down and stayed down lower over time yeah
- 58:52and as i said it wasn't statistically significant,
- 58:56but it's what I see in clinic.
- 58:58If you take pain away really immediately, I see it as robbing the patient of
- 59:05the opportunity to learn how to effectively load manage themselves.
- 59:09Because if the pain's not there the next time they go upstairs,
- 59:13they forget that actually my therapist told me to walk with my feet a little
- 59:19bit wider, to not shift my hips to the side, you know, the tips that we give
- 59:24people, you know, I started getting pain in sitting.
- 59:27Oh, I've been sitting with my knees crossed the whole time.
- 59:29You know, these things that pain is a really important teacher.
- 59:34If we take that away completely, really rapidly, then patients don't attend
- 59:42to that load management advice, not because they're naughty people,
- 59:45but just it's not there. The stimulus is not there to learn.
- 59:49And again, with exercise, are they as compliant with exercise?
- 59:53No. Again, not because they're naughty people, but because, you know, we all have busy lives.
- 59:59We've got other, you know, demands on us.
- 1:00:02We've got children and work and everything going on. If you don't have pain
- 1:00:06there saying, you need to do something about me, then they're going to go,
- 1:00:11well, actually, you know, my son needs me to do this.
- 1:00:14My work needs me to do that. I'll get to the exercise later,
- 1:00:17you know, and so we see less exercise compliance, less exercise volume,
- 1:00:23less attendance to load management.
- 1:00:26So a lot of the time, you know, our medical colleagues, you know,
- 1:00:31who are trying to do the right thing by their patient, but they're trying to
- 1:00:34give them that quick pain relief.
- 1:00:36But it's often given in the context of we'll reduce your pain quickly so that
- 1:00:41you can attend to your exercise.
- 1:00:44Actually, that doesn't happen in the real world. If you reduce the pain,
- 1:00:49they're not going to attend to their exercise.
- 1:00:52Not that I'm an awful person saying we need to keep them in pain.
- 1:00:55No, it's not that. We want to reduce their pain rapidly.
- 1:00:58But you want to have a little inkling there so that they get that little reminder
- 1:01:03and then immediately they start learning. They start learning.
- 1:01:06And these are the things that are going to change them for the longer term and
- 1:01:11help them them effectively load manage for the longer term.
- 1:01:15If we rob them of that opportunity, actually, when the pain comes back,
- 1:01:19interestingly, patients don't think from my conversations with them,
- 1:01:23they don't think, well, that didn't work.
- 1:01:25I'm not going to have another injection. They think, well, that worked.
- 1:01:28I need to go and have another injection.
- 1:01:31Even if the pain relief was only for two days, I'll go, well, that worked.
- 1:01:35I'm going to need to have another injection. And so it seems to set up this
- 1:01:39cycle of, you know, passive treatment, you know, seeking passive treatments and quick fixes.
- 1:01:45And so I think from a lot of behavioral effects that it has,
- 1:01:50and then of course, it's the biological effects it has on the tissue. So cortisone is toxic.
- 1:01:57It's a very powerful pain reliever, but it's toxic to tendon tissues.
- 1:02:02It's toxic to all our musculoskeletal tissues. So, and how much is safe?
- 1:02:08We actually don't have information for that, but we know that the more cortisone
- 1:02:13injections people have had around their gluteal tendons, the more unhealthy
- 1:02:17those tendons are, the more likely they are to progress to surgery.
- 1:02:22You know, the worse they're often going to do post-surgery.
- 1:02:26So, you know, more cortisone is not going to be a good thing for them.
- 1:02:32So, So it's important that, you know, and we don't want to make,
- 1:02:35if someone, a patient comes to you and they've already had a cortisone injection,
- 1:02:39of course, we're not going to say, oh dear, that's terrible.
- 1:02:41We can't help you now. But it's just, I suppose, being mindful that if they
- 1:02:48have already had cortisone injection,
- 1:02:50often our outcomes are actually slower and they might be reduced,
- 1:02:54particularly with multiple injections.
- 1:02:57You might have to lower your expectations about how fast they might progress
- 1:03:01and where you might get them to, because I think it does change the responsiveness
- 1:03:05of the tendons and the health of those tendons.
- 1:03:09But, you know, this is just, a lot of that is my.
- 1:03:12Clinical extrapolation of the research and what I've seen from 30 years of clinical practice.
- 1:03:18And so I would much rather treat a patient who's never had a cortisone injection.
- 1:03:23And so it's educating, you know, our doctors as well and say, don't try to help me.
- 1:03:29Like they're trying to be really helpful. I mean, they're trying to help the
- 1:03:32patient, of course, but often it ends up not being that helpful.
- 1:03:36And so I educate my referrers about, yeah, just,
- 1:03:39you know, can you just not help me don't don't
- 1:03:43give that cortisone injection and so but you
- 1:03:46know it's hard because the patient you know is pushing the
- 1:03:49doctor for you know you know a pain response but I'd rather them actually have
- 1:03:55some oral pain medication for a period of time um rather than that sort of local
- 1:04:00injection at the at the hip and then if you know so often patients will come
- 1:04:06to me for my referrals and And they might have a,
- 1:04:08like a referral for a cortisone injection,
- 1:04:12although I haven't had that recently, but, you know, probably earlier in my
- 1:04:15education process before the doctors could see, I suppose that actually,
- 1:04:20you know, we can have the effect without the cortisone, the patient would turn
- 1:04:23up with the referral and they'd say, the doctor told me to ask you about whether I should have this.
- 1:04:28And then I'd go, all right, it's good that you've got that up your sleeve.
- 1:04:32So we've got that up, you know, as a backstop, but let's try these things first.
- 1:04:36And then if you need it, we've got that, you know, we can fall back on.
- 1:04:41But, you know, let's try this first. And generally, I'd prefer people to,
- 1:04:45you know, if they're really severe, I'd prefer them to use a walking aid and
- 1:04:49use some oral analgesics initially and just see if we can get them calmed down.
- 1:04:54Of course, if they need it, they need it. If their pain is severe,
- 1:04:58they're not sleeping and things like that.
- 1:05:00But you'd be surprised how much impact we can
- 1:05:02have in a couple of weeks with some good good
- 1:05:05education and you know a walking aid
- 1:05:08if necessary if it's really severe limping so walking
- 1:05:12stick crutch or something yeah and that's not that
- 1:05:15like that we're saying you need to be on a stick forever now no this
- 1:05:18is a temporary thing and so often i use a crutch rather than a stick because
- 1:05:22a crutch seems like a an injury that you'll progress past rather than a stick
- 1:05:26seems like a disability it's interesting yeah good good points you know that's
- 1:05:32so a lot of patients will be happier to use a crutch than a stick.
- 1:05:35Very cool. And it is all about behavior. And I think that that conversation
- 1:05:40really can test the relationship you've got with the patient.
- 1:05:45It tests all your skills of active listening and letting them speak and then educate.
- 1:05:51Education is not something we're taught as clinicians, isn't it?
- 1:05:54We're typically taught, whatever we are, to do things with our hands.
- 1:05:57And we're not taught how to educate or to get on with people and help behavior change.
- 1:06:01It's missing from our toolbox. box so yeah it's fascinating
- 1:06:04to hear that but putting it into effect is yeah it's a little
- 1:06:07change of conditions look i'm keeping you past your time i
- 1:06:10know i mean i've got nothing to do now i've got somebody watching tv eat
- 1:06:13up my dinner go to bed but it's different for you you've probably got a whole
- 1:06:16day ahead for you so i'm conscious of that i do
- 1:06:19want to just quickly mention thank
- 1:06:22you for the questions in there sorry i didn't get to them but
- 1:06:24you can understand why i didn't want to interrupt that car gregory
- 1:06:27says just joined and already love what i hear re-watching tomorrow
- 1:06:30cloud car you will love this i know you and
- 1:06:33you will really enjoy the full hour and maria
- 1:06:36maxieri thanks for joining us and maria from the
- 1:06:39st school says absolutely touches context for health literacy yep lovely and
- 1:06:43maria is one of our national champions for modern approach to your hands on
- 1:06:50and massage and everything time frame we had gary benson here says was there
- 1:06:54and increased confidence and movement in the education and exercise group?
- 1:06:59Good question, Gary. Yeah, good question, Gary. And yes, there was.
- 1:07:03And that's really important.
- 1:07:05Well, what we measured was pain self-efficacy.
- 1:07:09Okay. So, and part of the questions in there are around, you know,
- 1:07:13doing your physical activity and despite the pain.
- 1:07:16And I do think that change in confidence is something that does underpin them,
- 1:07:22you know, feeling more like supervised training
- 1:07:25that we do feeling more confident in the way that they move
- 1:07:29I think that does really impact on
- 1:07:32their quality of life because they start doing more things and getting back
- 1:07:35to the things that they want to do and need to do and so yes confidence is something
- 1:07:40that I think is really important and education and reassurance and showing them
- 1:07:46how to move and sometimes I think education gets a bad rap because it's sort
- 1:07:50of like like, you know, you're making them fearful.
- 1:07:52Actually, no, we shouldn't be making them fearful.
- 1:07:55It's how you do it. And it's actually about empowering them.
- 1:08:00So if they can't walk upstairs because they feel like someone's ice-picking
- 1:08:04them in the greater Trichana, but you can show them how to do that without an
- 1:08:08ice-picking the greater Trichana, that's not fear-inducing, it's empowering and it's relieving.
- 1:08:14And they finally understand why they have this problem and what they can do about it.
- 1:08:19And it's, you know, the impact on their confidence, I think, is incredible.
- 1:08:24And that's what we showed in that first sort of eight weeks there,
- 1:08:26pain, self-efficacy, that confidence dramatically increased, which is great.
- 1:08:31Fantastic. Right.
- 1:08:34I love the way you provided a fantastic segue for Ebony, Dr.
- 1:08:37Ebony Rio, for next week. We'll be talking about pain and pain management.
- 1:08:40And you mentioned her paper as well with the isometrics. And yeah,
- 1:08:43so that's a lovely segue.
- 1:08:44Like I say, in two weeks' time, people, not next week.
- 1:08:47We're having a bit of a break. But the week after, Ebony Rio's not.
- 1:08:51She's flying somewhere and coming back somewhere. So that's why we're moving it forwards.
- 1:08:54But we will have the pleasure of an hour with Dr.
- 1:08:57Ebony Rio in two weeks' time, still at 9 o'clock BST. but i
- 1:09:00just want to make sure if people are interested in further
- 1:09:04education obviously there's so much great work you
- 1:09:07do for education as well as in clinics i'm just going
- 1:09:09to bring this up for people in the live lounge let's put
- 1:09:12it on here the website if you're interested people so drallisongramaldi.com and
- 1:09:17across social media thank you allison for just having dr allison gramaldi anywhere
- 1:09:21with a lot of people it changes it depends whether you're on twitter or Instagram
- 1:09:25or that it's just so simple Dr Alison Grimaldi is where you will find Dr Alison
- 1:09:29Grimaldi so well done on that I'm getting your name in there but yeah the website
- 1:09:32is a wealth of knowledge just talk us briefly if you're okay for a couple of
- 1:09:36minutes because I'm conscious it is.
- 1:09:3812 past where I am and where you are. You mentioned the Hip Academy.
- 1:09:42Let us know a little bit quickly, briefly about that.
- 1:09:45Sure. So, excuse me, Hip Academy is a group of health professionals from all
- 1:09:51over the world. So health and exercise professionals.
- 1:09:53And it's a lovely community that we get together, you know, every couple of
- 1:09:59months or so and do an extra lecture and a live lecture and questions and we
- 1:10:04do case presentations as well.
- 1:10:06And those are all recorded and part of our library of resources,
- 1:10:11but Hip Academy members also get access to all the hip courses.
- 1:10:15So there's four different hip courses, there's four eBooks as well.
- 1:10:18And then there's that large video library that I mentioned before that contains
- 1:10:22little short videos of all the different assessment techniques.
- 1:10:27And so that's not only diagnostic techniques, but muscle assessment techniques
- 1:10:31as as well, and exercises.
- 1:10:34And so that goes through how we'd, you know, prescribe the exercise to a patient.
- 1:10:38So it's got voice over there of the cues that we use for patients.
- 1:10:42Yeah, so there's lots of information there and information on reading x-rays
- 1:10:48and MRIs and things like that.
- 1:10:50So yeah, so it's a great community. And the bit I love best is the live meetings
- 1:10:55because we do have people sort of logging in from lots of different professions
- 1:10:59and different places all over the world.
- 1:11:01So it's great to get discussion from different perspectives as well about different conditions.
- 1:11:10So yeah, you're very welcome if you'd like to join us at Hip Academy.
- 1:11:13If you have a specific interest in gluteal tendinopathy and you don't want to
- 1:11:17do the whole Academy thing, there's a course on lateral hip and buttock pain.
- 1:11:22There's an e-book on gluteal tendinopathy and there's one on proximal hamstring
- 1:11:25tendinopathy as well, or you can get the whole e-book series as well.
- 1:11:29So depending on how deep you want to go into it, there are different resources for your needs.
- 1:11:36Fantastic. And hopefully, listeners, you can hear from the hour we've spent
- 1:11:40with Dr. Alison Grimaldi tonight.
- 1:11:42You can imagine how it's going to be presented in, if I can say,
- 1:11:46a wonderfully infectious, passionate way. It's just amazing.
- 1:11:48And that's important as well. There's so many courses out there.
- 1:11:51And one of the things is, is the person giving the course presenting it in a
- 1:11:54way that you can take in and enjoy it.
- 1:11:56So yeah, do check that out. And there's also on On the website,
- 1:11:59dralisongabaldi.com, there's also a blog.
- 1:12:03There is loads of information. Oh, I've just taken it off. There's loads of
- 1:12:06information for you to check out. So I do recommend you go there.
- 1:12:08It will be in the show notes, people, if you want to go and have a look.
- 1:12:12So yeah, do check it out. And there's some wonderful blogs there.
- 1:12:15And also, like Alison has said, links to the books and the video library.
- 1:12:19So yeah, a wealth of information, fantastic stuff.
- 1:12:21So we appreciate that, Alison. Thank you.
- 1:12:24And also, ironically, you're over in the UK in a week or so,
- 1:12:26aren't you? It's too late to book you people. Don't get excited.
- 1:12:28But you're coming over here.
- 1:12:31Yeah yep so i'll be over i think there
- 1:12:34might be there might be a couple of places left on a
- 1:12:37couple london courses i'm not sure but a lot of them are booked out but there
- 1:12:41might be a couple of places in london so vital pm is who's hosting it so that's
- 1:12:47available there and matt the other thing i just wanted to mention to your listeners
- 1:12:51is that course on my other website if they're interested in that.
- 1:12:56So there's another website that I have that is patient-facing, so hippainhelp.com.
- 1:13:03And if you're interested, or you might have patients that are interested as
- 1:13:07well, but there is a course that I've done there for patients on gluteal tendinopathy.
- 1:13:12And so that sort of goes through a number of educational videos.
- 1:13:16And so from your therapist perspective, that might be nice at least to sort
- 1:13:22of see what sort of education that I'm usually providing to my patients.
- 1:13:26And then there's also exercises there as well.
- 1:13:29And so there's videos of the exercises and cues about what things that we focus
- 1:13:34on in the exercises and information about how to progress or how to regress
- 1:13:39if you have a flare up or things like that.
- 1:13:41So that's another resource that might be helpful as well. And that's, what was it, hip health?
- 1:13:49Hippainhelp.com. Hippainhelp.com. We'll make sure that goes in the notes.
- 1:13:52Yeah, that's brilliant like we're saying off air seeing how you
- 1:13:56can educate a patient and using the terminology of patient we get
- 1:13:58on with that that's going to be a wealth of information as well so thank you for that
- 1:14:01yes all of that will be in the in the notes
- 1:14:04people so there we go it's 17 minutes
- 1:14:07past dr arson round i hope i haven't caused you to miss anything
- 1:14:10coming up no that's okay so and thank
- 1:14:16you so much everyone who's joined us live as well some amazing questions in
- 1:14:19there thank you for people listening to the podcast if you are listening then
- 1:14:23check out all of the links which will be in the
- 1:14:26show notes and do please leave a
- 1:14:28rating as well on particularly google podcasts apple podcasts
- 1:14:31because it just helps the information shared by
- 1:14:35our wonderful guests just appear more in google which is all about what's all
- 1:14:37about it's all about education like i say next week in
- 1:14:41two weeks time sorry dr ebony rio will be with us um
- 1:14:44to focus on managing tendon and pain which will be
- 1:14:46a lovely continuation of some of tonight's themes so if
- 1:14:49you listen to the podcast you want to join us for that then that will be june
- 1:14:52the 4th at nine o'clock bst british standard time so there we go right thank
- 1:14:57you once again dr alice good mouthy for your time it's been absolutely amazing
- 1:15:00really really appreciate it no worries thanks so much for having me and thanks
- 1:15:04all the listeners to um listening thanks people take care of each other we'll see you soon.
- 1:15:10Music.