Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Amazon (AMZN) Q2 2025 Earnings Exposed: Valuation, Growth, Risk Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. We're here to cut through the
- 0:02noise and get you informed fast. You know, when you think about
- 0:05Amazon, it's just, well, it's this global Titan, right?
- 0:08Seems woven into almost everything we do online
- 0:10shopping, cloud stuff, powering the Internet.
- 0:12They are truly everywhere. But for investors, especially
- 0:16those looking through that disciplined value lens, think
- 0:19Warren Buffett, a big question pops up.
- 0:21How does this massive company actually stack up?
- 0:24Is it really a great company at a fair price?
- 0:26So today we're going deep. We're digging into Amazon's
- 0:29financial performance over the last 10 years, 2014 right
- 0:32through to 2024. Our mission for you is to really
- 0:35get a handle on Amazon's financial health, see how it's
- 0:38evolved and then put it to the test, the ultimate test really
- 0:42against those tough investment criteria championed by Warren
- 0:44Buffett himself. We're on tacking for pretty
- 0:46comprehensive investment analysis of Amazon.
- 0:48That's ticker AMZN. It cross validates its numbers
- 0:51against SEC filings, reputable databases, you know the works
- 0:55and it focuses on the key stuff valuation, cash flow, balance
- 0:58sheet metrics. Now, before we jump in, there's
- 1:01something important the source makes clear right up front.
- 1:03This analysis. It's based on public info, and
- 1:06like all financial data, it could be revised.
- 1:08People might interpret it differently.
- 1:09That's just. How it is?
- 1:10And. Crucially, what we're.
- 1:11Talking about today. It's.
- 1:13Purely for educational purposes. This is not investment advice.
- 1:16You should always, always do your own homework, your own due
- 1:18diligence. Before making any investment
- 1:20calls. This deep dive is about
- 1:22understanding the data, not telling you what to.
- 1:23Buy or sell? OK, so with that crucial context
- 1:27set, let's kick things off. Let's look at Amazon's pretty
- 1:29remarkable journey over the last decade, starting with valuation.
- 1:33When we look at Amazon's valuation from 2014 to 2024, the
- 1:36growth is, well, it's. Extraordinary isn't.
- 1:39It oh absolutely mind boggling, really.
- 1:41Market cap went from about $143 billion back in 2014 to an
- 1:47estimated $2.35 trillion by the end of 2024.
- 1:51Yeah, that's more than a 15 fold increase.
- 1:54Just massive. Reflects huge revenue growth,
- 1:57obviously, and just incredible investor optimism even with some
- 2:00bumps along the way. Right, that volatility is part
- 2:02of the story, too. Now the price to earnings ratio,
- 2:05the PE, that's always been pretty high.
- 2:07Historically high, yeah. Often way above 50, sometimes
- 2:11even over 100 in those earlier years.
- 2:13Definitely signals a rich valuation.
- 2:15You even see NM not meaningful sometimes like in 2014 and 2022.
- 2:19That's because earnings per share went negative those years.
- 2:21Exactly, and in 2024 it landed around 39.7.
- 2:25Still pretty punchy. But the price to book PB, that's
- 2:28actually trended down a bit from over 13 times down to about 8
- 2:31times in 2024. Yeah, that's interesting.
- 2:33It suggests shareholder equity grew faster than the stock price
- 2:36itself over that period. OK.
- 2:38But here's where things get really interesting.
- 2:40I think the return on equity Roe and return on invested capital
- 2:43ROIC. Big improvements there.
- 2:46They went from negative or you know, low single digits back in
- 2:50the mid twenty 10s to hitting the 2024% range between 2018 and
- 2:552021 and still strong like 1521% for Roe in 2023-2024.
- 3:02And ROIC followed a very similar path, showing much better
- 3:05capital efficiency in recent years.
- 3:06So what's that telling us once profitability really kicked in,
- 3:09especially from AWS and those other high margin areas?
- 3:12They started generating genuinely strong returns on the
- 3:15capital invested in the business, which is key.
- 3:18You know, what's really fascinating here is how those
- 3:20profitability metrics, the Roe and ROAC, they only recently got
- 3:24to levels that you'd conventionally say justify those
- 3:27really premium valuations. Amazon always had, right?
- 3:29For a long, long time, the market was basically placing
- 3:32this huge bet on future growth, pricing, and massive
- 3:35expectations way before the company consistently delivered
- 3:37those kinds of returns. It really was a story of delayed
- 3:40gratification on the profitability front.
- 3:42Or maybe just a different way of valuing a company with that kind
- 3:45of dominance and reinvestment potential?
- 3:48That's a great point. So if they had those high
- 3:50valuations for so long, long without the matching
- 3:53profitability, how did that play out in their actual cash flow?
- 3:57Let's talk about the money moving in and out.
- 3:58Absolutely. Well, First off, the revenue
- 4:00growth itself is just breathtaking, from just under
- 4:03$89 billion in 2014 to an estimated $638 billion by 2024.
- 4:09Wow. And crucially, their gross
- 4:12margins climbed significantly too, from around 29% up to
- 4:15nearly 49%. So it wasn't just selling more
- 4:18stuff. No, exactly.
- 4:19It was a big strategic shift towards those higher margin
- 4:22businesses like AWS you mentioned and also their
- 4:25advertising business which has just exploded that really
- 4:28boosted the overall profit picture and.
- 4:30That huge revenue growth that must have translated into a
- 4:33massive jump in operating profits too.
- 4:35From just $178 million in 2014 to $68.6 billion by 2024, the
- 4:41operating margin went from basically zero to almost 11%.
- 4:44But I noticed looking at the numbers, net income was actually
- 4:47pretty volatile. There were even net losses in
- 4:492014 and 2022, although it did hit a record $59 billion in
- 4:532024. How does that square with free
- 4:55cash flow? That volatility, yeah, it
- 4:58carries right through to free cash flow or FCF.
- 5:00We saw FCF actually turned negative in 2021 and 2022 dipped
- 5:05by billions. Right, I remember that.
- 5:06But it wasn't necessarily a sign the business was struggling.
- 5:09It was more a direct result of just massive capital spending.
- 5:13Amazon was pouring money into building out fulfillment
- 5:16centers, expanding AWS structure just at an incredible rate.
- 5:21OK. So investing heavily for the
- 5:22future. Exactly.
- 5:24But the good news, FCF bounced back strongly over $38 billion
- 5:28projected for 2024. And our source brings up owners
- 5:32earnings too. That's a Buffett measure.
- 5:33Right, trying to get at the real cash earnings available to
- 5:36owners. Precisely after accounting for
- 5:38the spending needed just to maintain the business's
- 5:41competitive position. And what's interesting is even
- 5:43when FCF went negative those couple of years, owners earnings
- 5:47were positive every single year except 2022.
- 5:50In fact, owners earnings often exceeded FCF during those heavy
- 5:53investment years like 2020. It suggests that even while cash
- 5:57was being plowed back in, the underlying earning power was
- 6:00still pretty solid. OK.
- 6:01So connecting the dots, Amazon's cash generation has been, let's
- 6:06say, lumpy as you put. It yeah, lumpy is a good word.
- 6:09Because they just aggressively reinvest basically every spare
- 6:13dollar into expansion. Like a farmer constantly
- 6:16planting more fields maybe? That's a good analogy.
- 6:18It often leads to these temporary droughts and free cash
- 6:21flow while the money's going out.
- 6:22Followed by surges once those investments actually start
- 6:25paying off. Exactly.
- 6:26It's a very different cash flow pattern compared to, say, a
- 6:30mature company just churning out dividends, which is often what
- 6:33Buffett looks for. All right, let's shift gears to
- 6:35stability, financial strength. Let's look at the balance sheet.
- 6:39Over the decade, total assets just exploded right $54.5
- 6:43billion up to over $620 billion. Huge expansion.
- 6:47And shareholders equity grew even faster thanks to keeping
- 6:50all those earnings in the business.
- 6:51It's really quite something, and while the absolute amount of
- 6:54debt did go up, it peeped over $67 billion in 2022.
- 6:58The key thing is the debt to equity ratio.
- 7:01What happened there? It actually fell dramatically
- 7:03from .77 back in 2014 down to just .1 eight in 2024.
- 7:08Wow, that low. Yeah, it's a clear sign their
- 7:11equity grew way faster than they're borrowing.
- 7:13So leverage is actually quite low now.
- 7:14And liquidity, yeah, How are they looking on cash?
- 7:16Very strong, over $100 billion in cash and equivalents on the
- 7:20books in 2024, OK. And the current ratio I noticed
- 7:24it tends to hover around one point O isn't below 1 sometimes
- 7:28seen as a red flag? It can be for some companies,
- 7:31but for Amazon, their model is different.
- 7:33They collect cash from customers very quickly and they have that
- 7:36huge cash pile. So while it's around one point O
- 7:40maybe 1.17 in 2024, it's generally not seen as a major
- 7:45risk for them. Right, context matters.
- 7:47What about covering the interest on their debt?
- 7:48Oh, exceptionally strong there. EBIT earnings before interest
- 7:51and taxes covered their interest payments dozens of times over in
- 7:55the strong years, like 28.5 times in 2024 so.
- 7:58No worries about making debt payments.
- 8:00Absolutely none. It really highlights that
- 8:02despite all the aggressive growth, Amazon's balance sheet
- 8:04has become incredibly robust. Low debt relative to equity,
- 8:08tons of cash, strong interest coverage.
- 8:10It gives them enormous flexibility.
- 8:12That's a real strength maybe sometimes overlooked with all
- 8:15the focus on growth. Definitely.
- 8:16OK, let's wrap this section up with growth rates.
- 8:18What's the big picture take away from a decade of Amazons growth?
- 8:22I think the standout is just the sheer scale and the sustained
- 8:26pace of that growth. Revenue growth exceptional.
- 8:29A compound annual growth rate CGR of about 28% / 10 years.
- 8:34That's. Incredible.
- 8:35Yeah. Annual growth was often between
- 8:3720% and 38% and even now at their massive size, they still
- 8:42managed around 11% year over year growth in 2024.
- 8:45Still double digits on that huge base.
- 8:47Exactly. Net income growth, as we said
- 8:49more volatile with that 2022 dip, but the long term trend is
- 8:53explosive, nearly doubled from 2023 to 2024 and owners earnings
- 8:58growth has also been positive long term despite those
- 9:01investment dips. So the key take away.
- 9:03Exceptional growth overall, especially on the top line
- 9:06revenue and that's been absolutely critical in
- 9:08supporting its premium valuation over the years.
- 9:11OK, this is where it gets really interesting.
- 9:12I think we've looked at the numbers, the incredible journey.
- 9:16Now let's put Amazon through that ultimate filter, Warren
- 9:19Buffett's criteria for a great company at a fair price.
- 9:23He wants valuation, discipline, strong cash generation,
- 9:25consistent growth, a solid balance sheet, high
- 9:28profitability. So the multi trillion dollar
- 9:32question does Amazon actually fit that mold?
- 9:34Yeah, this is always the fascinating part, isn't it?
- 9:36Because Buffett's philosophy often looks for things that seem
- 9:39almost contradictory to a high growth, constantly reinvesting
- 9:44tech company. Predictability versus
- 9:45disruption. Kind of, yeah.
- 9:47Predictability and buying assets at a discount.
- 9:49Let's see how Amazon stacks up point by point.
- 9:51Yep. OK, first valuation discipline.
- 9:54Buffett likes a low PE, maybe 15 or less, PB of 1.5 or less.
- 9:59Amazon. Well, it consistently fails on
- 10:01both counts. It's PE has never been below 15.
- 10:03Yeah, often way higher. Fifty 100 plus even now around
- 10:0640. Nowhere close.
- 10:07No, and PB still around 8 times in 2024, much higher than 1.5.
- 10:12What about margin of safety buying below intrinsic value?
- 10:15Also debatable, leaning towards fail.
- 10:18Amazon just hasn't typically traded at a clear 25% discount
- 10:21to a conservative estimate of its value.
- 10:24The price has almost always baked in very optimistic future
- 10:27growth. So on traditional value metrics,
- 10:29it's a clear mismatch pretty much.
- 10:31Yeah. OK.
- 10:31Criterion 2, Cash generation and allocation.
- 10:35Buffett wants positive free cash flow every year and FCF relative
- 10:39to revenue above 5%. How does Amazon do there given
- 10:43the reinvestment? This one's a partial fail.
- 10:46While it's FCF to revenue ratio has often been above 5%, the
- 10:49consistency isn't there. Remember, FCF turned negative in
- 10:532021 and 2022 because of all that heavy spending.
- 10:56Right. That inconsistency would be a
- 10:58red flag for Buffett. Definitely he prices
- 11:00predictability. However, on return I retain
- 11:02earnings where he likes to see at least 12% and Amazon probably
- 11:06passes in the long run. Because they keep everything and
- 11:08reinvest it effectively. Exactly.
- 11:10They don't pay dividends, they retain it, and the growth in
- 11:13equity and net income over time suggests a very good return on
- 11:16those retained earnings, especially driven by things like
- 11:18AWS. The long term results of the
- 11:20reinvestment are impressive, even if the FCF path was bumpy.
- 11:24Next up, growth and predictability.
- 11:27Buffett loves companies where earnings per share EPS are
- 11:30positive and just steadily rise year after year for a decade.
- 11:34Amazon's volatile earnings. Yeah, that's a fail.
- 11:37EPS was negative in 2013 and 2022, and it dipped in other
- 11:40years too. It's definitely not that smooth
- 11:43upward line Buffett looks for. But what about book value per
- 11:45share? He wants a 10 year CAGR over
- 11:4810%. No annual declines.
- 11:50Ah, here Amazon passes with flying colors.
- 11:53Book value per share grew at an incredible 38% CAGR over the
- 11:57decade, and it rose every single year.
- 11:59OK. A clear pass there, but then
- 12:01owners earnings positive every year yielding at least 10% of
- 12:04market cap. That's another fail.
- 12:05Owners earnings dip negative in 2022, remember, And the yield
- 12:09owner's earnings divided by market cap is usually low single
- 12:11digits, maybe 2% in 2024, way below DEF it's 10% benchmark.
- 12:16So phenomenal growth overall, but lacking that year to year
- 12:19predictability and the high owner earnings yield he likes.
- 12:22That sums it up well. All right, Criterion 4, balance
- 12:26sheet safety. This seems like an area where
- 12:29Amazon has really shored things up over the decade.
- 12:31It really has first Test debt to equity below .5 pass comfortably
- 12:36below around .18 now. Good interest coverage of three
- 12:40times or more. Another clear pass.
- 12:41Coverage is very strong, 28.5 times in 2024, no issues there.
- 12:46Interest expense less than 15% of operating income.
- 12:49Also a pass generally well under that, though 2022 is a bit of an
- 12:53outlast. OK, but what about the current
- 12:55ratio? He likes to see it above 1.5.
- 12:57Amazon's around one point O. Right.
- 12:59So technically that's a fail on his strict criteria, even
- 13:02though, as we discussed, Amazon's cash pile and business
- 13:04model mitigate the risk, it doesn't meet that specific 1.5
- 13:08buffer. Mostly strong on the balance
- 13:09sheet, but a technical miss on the current ratio.
- 13:11Exactly. Rock solid on debt and interest.
- 13:14Just a quark on that liquidity ratio compared to his role.
- 13:17And finally, Criterion 5, profitability and efficiency.
- 13:21Has Amazon finally reached the kind of consistent high
- 13:23profitability metrics Buffett looks for?
- 13:26It's a mixed bag here. Still gross margin of 40% or
- 13:29higher passed, but only recently.
- 13:31It was below 40% until 2018. Now it's climbed up near 49%
- 13:35thanks to AWS and ads. OK.
- 13:37Net profit margin 20% or higher. That's a clear fail.
- 13:40Never even close to 20%. The highest was around 9.3% in
- 13:442024. Amazon's model is built on
- 13:47volume and scale, not super thick net margins.
- 13:49Right. What about return on equity Roe
- 13:52and return on invested capital ROIC?
- 13:55He likes 15% or more on average over 10 years.
- 13:58These are kind of marginal passes.
- 13:59Maybe recent years have been strong, often above 15%, but the
- 14:0310 year average is pulled down by the weaker results earlier
- 14:05on. So it's borderline.
- 14:06OK. And depreciation relative to
- 14:08gross profit less than 10%. That's a definite fail.
- 14:11It's consistently been in the mid teens.
- 14:13This points to how asset intensive parts of Amazon's
- 14:16business are, which is something Buffett typically doesn't favor.
- 14:18He prefers asset late businesses.
- 14:20So summing up, profitability improvements, especially in
- 14:24gross margin and recent returns, but still falls short on Net
- 14:28margin consistency and capital efficiency judged by that
- 14:31depreciation metric. Precisely mixed results against
- 14:35his profitability benchmarks. OK, so we've run Amazon through
- 14:38Buffett's checklist. It's clear it doesn't take every
- 14:40box, maybe not even most for a traditional value investor
- 14:44following his rules strictly. But what about its actual
- 14:47intrinsic value? Our source also looked at this
- 14:49using a discounted cash flow analysis DCF, trying to estimate
- 14:53what the company's really worth based on projected future cash
- 14:56flows. Right.
- 14:57And the DCF always brings up that critical question, what
- 15:00growth rate do you assume for future free cash flow because
- 15:03the output is hugely sensitive to that implant.
- 15:05This analysis used Amazon's 2024 FCF of about $38 billion as the
- 15:10starting point, a standard 10% discount rate and a 3% long term
- 15:14growth rate after the initial 10 years.
- 15:16So what? Are the different scenarios
- 15:17show? Let's start conservative.
- 15:19OK. The Conservative case used
- 15:21Amazon's lowest positive historical FCF growth rate,
- 15:24which was 20% annually. Plugging that in, the intrinsic
- 15:28value came out around $1.98 trillion.
- 15:31That's about $185 per share. And the implication with the
- 15:34stock trading around say $234? The implication is pretty stark.
- 15:39This conservative DCF suggests Amazon is actually overvalued
- 15:42right now, offering no margin of safety for an investor demanding
- 15:451. Wow.
- 15:46OK, that's a strong perspective. But what if we assume growth
- 15:50closer to its historical average, more of a middle
- 15:52ground? That's the nominal case.
- 15:54This one assumes 35% FCF growth annually for 10 years.
- 15:58Which is still very high. Very aggressive, yes, especially
- 16:01for a company this size sustaining it for a decade.
- 16:03But if you assume that, the intrinsic value jumps
- 16:06dramatically to about $5.75 trillion, or roughly $538 per
- 16:11share. OK.
- 16:11So if they can sustain that kind of growth, the current price
- 16:14looks potentially undervalued. Big if, though.
- 16:17Huge if it highlights how much belief in continued high growth
- 16:21is needed to justify the current valuation, let alone see upside.
- 16:25And just to show the extreme sensitivity, there's an
- 16:28optimistic case. This assumes 50% FCF growth
- 16:32annually. Which seems wildly optimistic.
- 16:36It's definitely bullish, though maybe not totally out of the
- 16:39realm of possibility given some past spikes, but plugging that
- 16:42in gives you a valuation of roughly $15.5 trillion, or $450
- 16:49per share. OK, that seems more like a
- 16:50theoretical upper limit. Exactly and mainly serves to
- 16:53illustrate just how massively the valuation swings based on
- 16:56that growth assumption. So boiling down these different
- 16:59DCF models, what's the practical take away?
- 17:02The key take away is just how extremely sensitive Amazon
- 17:05valuation is to your assumptions about its future growth.
- 17:07You really only get an intrinsic value comfortably above the
- 17:10current stock price with a decent margin of safety if you
- 17:12plug in very robust growth numbers.
- 17:14Think 30% plus sustained for a decade.
- 17:17Which is a big ask. It's a very big ask.
- 17:20So a value investor demanding that classic 25% margin of
- 17:24safety, like Buffett often does, would likely only find today's
- 17:27price justifiable under those highly optimistic scenarios.
- 17:30It really underscores the significant growth expectations
- 17:33already baked into the share price.
- 17:35OK, let's try and pull this all together.
- 17:36Amazon is, well, it's undeniably unique, isn't it?
- 17:41Transformed from just selling books online to this diversified
- 17:44tech behemoth. It shows absolutely
- 17:46extraordinary growth, scaling cash fleas dramatically,
- 17:50especially lately. And it's built a really strong
- 17:52balance sheet, established powerful competitive advantages
- 17:55with AWS e-commerce advertising. No question it's a powerhouse.
- 17:59And if we circle back to Buffett's, it's great company at
- 18:01a fair price idea. Amazon certainly looks like a
- 18:04great company by many measures, innovation, strong moats and now
- 18:07as it matures showing those high returns on capital.
- 18:09But it historically lacked that stable, predictable earnings
- 18:13stream and, crucially, the low price entry point that Buffett's
- 18:16framework really favors. It always traded at high
- 18:19valuations. Profitability was thin for a
- 18:21long time. Only recently have the earnings
- 18:24quality and margins started looking more like something
- 18:26Buffett might typically like. But by then, the price already
- 18:30reflected a lot of that, right? Exactly, which fundamentally
- 18:33makes Amazon more of a growth investment case rather than a
- 18:36classic value play in the traditional Buffett sense.
- 18:39And our source highlights the potential rewards and of course,
- 18:42the risks. The rewards are tied to
- 18:44continued dominance in cloud with AWS and advertising,
- 18:48e-commerce, maybe new ventures like AI or healthcare.
- 18:52If those engines keep firing, the day's price might look
- 18:54perfectly reasonable down the road.
- 18:56But the risks are real, too. Yeah, margin pressure, rising
- 18:58costs, maybe unionization, significant regulatory heat,
- 19:02especially antitrust concerns, fierce competition, particularly
- 19:06from Microsoft and Google in the cloud, and just the basic law of
- 19:10large numbers. A company this big simply cannot
- 19:13keep growing at 30% plus forever.
- 19:15Growth has to slow eventually. So wrapping up, what does this
- 19:18all mean for you, the listener? I think this deep dive really
- 19:22shows how Amazon challenges those traditional value
- 19:25investing principles. It's a fascinating case study.
- 19:29It shows how immense scale and hyper growth, even with bumps
- 19:32and profitability along the way, can create enormous value.
- 19:35It's kind of a paradox that even Buffett himself seems to have
- 19:38acknowledged or grappled with in recent years by actually
- 19:41investing in it, albeit perhaps through his lieutenants
- 19:45initially. Yeah, the insight might not be
- 19:47just whether Amazon fits the old rules, but whether those rules
- 19:50fully capture the value in today's tech giants.
- 19:53Think about Buffett's famous line.
- 19:55It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair
- 19:57price than a fair company at a wonderful price.
- 20:00Amazon, arguably a wonderful company.
- 20:03The key question for your investment approach is whether
- 20:06today's price will ultimately prove to have been fair.
- 20:09A dyed in the wool value investor looking for that big
- 20:12margin of safety might still wait for a significant pullback,
- 20:15maybe a market correction. While a growth.
- 20:17Oriented investor might see the quality, the potential, the
- 20:19moats and be willing to pay the current price, betting on that
- 20:22future expansion and innovation continuing.
- 20:25Different strokes for different folks.
- 20:27And just one final reminder, all the analysis we discussed today
- 20:30is based on publicly available sources, might be subject to
- 20:32revisions, different interpretations.
- 20:35This content is strictly for educational purposes.
- 20:37It is absolutely not investment advice.
- 20:40Please always conduct your own thorough due diligence.
- 20:43Maybe talk to a qualified financial advisor before making
- 20:46any investment decisions. Thanks for joining us on the
- 20:49Deep Dive.