Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Job Reference When Your Boss Left
Transcript
- Lucas: So here's a situation I hear more often than you'd think: your former boss — the one who said 'of course, happy to be a reference' — has left the company, changed their number, and your emails go unanswered. What do you do? Luna: That happened to a friend of mine last year. She was in the final round for a dream role and the recruiter said, 'we just need to speak with your old manager.' And she had no way to reach him. Lucas: Right. And that moment is terrifying because you feel like you've lost control of your candidacy. But there are actually three concrete moves you can make before you panic. Luna: Okay, I want to hear them. Because my friend ended up scrambling and asking a coworker she barely knew. Lucas: First step: find out if your prospective employer will accept HR verification instead. A lot of large companies — think banks, tech firms, consulting — have a policy where they only confirm dates of employment and job title. They won't even accept a personal reference. If that's the case, you just need the HR line, not your old boss. Luna: That's a huge relief if it works. But how do you know without sounding like you're hiding something? Lucas: You ask the recruiter directly: 'Does your background check process include a reference call, or is it handled through a third-party verification service?' Most recruiters will tell you exactly what they need. And if it's just HR verification, you're done. Luna: Okay, but what if they say yes, they do want a personal reference from a former manager? Lucas: Then you move to step two: identify a backup reference who actually saw your work. This could be a peer who was senior to you, a skip-level manager — your boss's boss — or even a client who can speak to your output. The key is that they witnessed your performance firsthand. Luna: But won't the recruiter wonder why you're not offering your direct manager? Lucas: You preempt that by being transparent. You say: 'My former manager has left the company and I've lost touch with them. However, I worked closely with Sarah, who was a senior analyst on the same team and can speak to my day-to-day contributions. Would that work?' Most recruiters are reasonable about this. Luna: I like that it's direct. It shows you're not hiding a bad relationship — you just genuinely can't reach the person. Lucas: Exactly. And the Society for Human Resource Management did a survey in 2024 that found 63 percent of employers still check references, but 41 percent of reference contacts are outdated within two years. So recruiters are used to this. Luna: Forty-one percent — that's huge. So if you're in that boat, you're not unusual. Lucas: You're in the majority, honestly. And that brings us to step three: while you're sorting out the reference, update your LinkedIn profile with specific recommendations from peers or clients. That's not a substitute, but it's a signal. When a recruiter sees three detailed recommendations, they're less likely to grill you about one missing manager. Luna: I've done that for people I managed — written recommendations — and I never thought of it as a reference backup, but it totally is. Lucas: It's a living document of your professional reputation. And on that note — and I mean this sincerely — if you've gotten value from conversations like this one, there's a way to keep the show going without ads. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through Buy Me a Coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many episodes. Luna: Yeah, it's a small group, but it makes a big difference. We don't run ads or sponsored segments, so listener support is what keeps this ad-free. Lucas: And we really appreciate it. So back to the reference question — there's one more nuance I want to hit. Luna: What's that? Lucas: If you do track down your old boss — maybe they answer after a few tries — give them an easy out. Say: 'I know it's been a while, and if you're not comfortable providing a reference, I completely understand. But if you are, I'd love to send over a few bullet points about what we worked on together.' That makes it low effort for them. Luna: That's smart. Because they might be worried they don't remember enough to be helpful. Lucas: Right. You're essentially writing their talking points. And that increases the chance they say yes. I've seen this work in practice. Luna: So the big takeaway: don't panic, check the HR route, then pivot to a credible backup, and make it easy for anyone you ask. Lucas: And keep your LinkedIn recommendations fresh. That way, even if your boss disappears, your reputation doesn't. Luna: Alright, we've got a listener question coming in about asking for a salary range before an interview — we'll tackle that next time. Lucas: Good one. See you then.