Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Tesla Model 3: Equal Cost, Superior Quality
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. You know how we do it.
- 0:12Here we take a stack of dense, detailed research and, well, we
- 0:18distil the essential knowledge. Today, we were putting our
- 0:22financial lens squarely on the road, digging deep into the true
- 0:25cost of car ownership here in Europe.
- 0:28We're moving well past the sticker price to compare battery
- 0:31electric vehicles or Bevs head to head against, you know, the
- 0:35traditional combustion engine cars, the ICE vehicles.
- 0:39And this is so important because it's really moved beyond just an
- 0:41environmental debate now. This is a financial one.
- 0:44We've got a really powerful set of sources, most importantly the
- 0:48Avon's Car Cost Index 2025, which gives us this
- 0:52comprehensive look at the total cost of ownership TCO across 28
- 0:56European countries. OK.
- 0:57So our mission today really is to figure out, does it actually
- 1:00make financial sense for you to go electric right now?
- 1:02OK, let's unpack TCO then, because that calculation is the
- 1:05foundation for this entire deep dive.
- 1:07What criteria is the Avon's report actually used?
- 1:10It's a pretty rigorous definition.
- 1:11They calculate the average cost over the first four years of
- 1:15ownership. Four years, okay.
- 1:17And they're assuming a relatively high annual mileage
- 1:20of 30,000 kilometers. Wow, okay, so that's a crucial
- 1:22factor. It is because high mileage is
- 1:25where you really maximize those operational savings.
- 1:28They factor in everything Depreciation, interest,
- 1:32insurance, those are the big three, plus all the running
- 1:35costs. Like repairs, maintenance.
- 1:36Exactly. Repairs, maintenance, tires, tax
- 1:39but not VAT and of course the big one, energy or fuel.
- 1:44And before we get lost in the weeds of the data, what's the
- 1:47big attention grabbing headline? What's the main take away from
- 1:50all this? Here's where it gets really
- 1:51interesting, the transition to electric.
- 1:54It's not only happening, but it's already winning financially
- 1:57in the high end market, winning. The biggest take away is that
- 2:00battery electric vehicles are already positively cost
- 2:02competitive across an entire premium segment.
- 2:05The change is coming from the top down.
- 2:07That totally flips the script on the idea that EVs are always
- 2:10this unaffordable luxury it. Does.
- 2:12So if premium cars are already cost competitive, let's look at
- 2:15the map. Does this TCO advantage hold up
- 2:19across all 28 countries? No, absolutely not.
- 2:22The geography is key. OK, based on the 2024 data, the
- 2:25overall cheapest country to lease and run a car, any car,
- 2:29any powertrain is Greece. Greece.
- 2:32Interesting. And on the other end.
- 2:33On the other end of the spectrum, one of the most
- 2:34expensive is Switzerland. No surprise there.
- 2:36Right. And that difference is really
- 2:38driven by things like local taxes, insurance costs and, you
- 2:42know, labor costs for maintenance in that region.
- 2:45So Greece is cheap overall, but what if I specifically want a
- 2:49Bev to maximize those savings? Does Greece still come out on
- 2:53top? It does.
- 2:53It's up there. In 2024, driving a Bev was
- 2:57cheapest in Hungary, Finland, and Greece.
- 3:00What's fascinating about Hungary and Finland is that they likely
- 3:03have some strong incentives or maybe lower energy costs that
- 3:07are pushing BEVS ahead of ICE, even if their overall operating
- 3:11costs aren't the absolute lowest in Europe.
- 3:13So we have these sort of regional pockets where BE VS are
- 3:16super affordable. What about the broader trend
- 3:19across the whole continent? The trend is pretty clear.
- 3:22The EV leasing is typically cheaper than petrol and diesel
- 3:26in the wealthier, often higher taxed Western and northern
- 3:28European countries. So think Scandinavia, Benelux.
- 3:31Exactly. But that advantage is much less
- 3:34pronounced in Southern and Eastern Europe.
- 3:37There ICE vehicles still have a stronger foothold, maybe lower
- 3:40upfront prices. That makes sense.
- 3:43Low energy taxes, low purchase costs, the TCO different
- 3:47shrinks. But you mentioned a universal
- 3:49exception, A segment where Bevs win everywhere.
- 3:52Yes, that exception is the mid sized premium segment.
- 3:55That's the one place where the Bev advantage holds true pretty
- 3:58much everywhere we looked. OK.
- 4:00So that leads us right into the different vehicle segments.
- 4:02It does because the map changes completely when you focus on one
- 4:06class of Car. Before we do that, let's just
- 4:08quickly nail down the numbers. When Avon says a Bev is cost
- 4:12competitive, what does that actually mean?
- 4:15They said a pretty strict financial yardstick.
- 4:17ABEV is cost competitive if it's TCO is within a 5% margin of its
- 4:22ICE counterpart. 5%, so it has to be really close.
- 4:25Yeah. If it's in that narrow window,
- 4:27it's considered a rational financial choice over those four
- 4:29years. And the undisputed champions of
- 4:32that are the premium mid size cars, the D2 and SUV D2
- 4:36segments. Absolutely.
- 4:37This is the single most successful area for BE VS
- 4:40They're competitive in an incredible 27 out of 27
- 4:43researched countries. 27 out of 27.
- 4:46Wow, and the sources give us this really telling comparison.
- 4:49The BMW I4A leading B EV in this class actually has a lower TCO
- 4:54than its petrol sibling, the BMW 3 Series in 20 one of those
- 4:59countries. That's massive.
- 5:00So in a clear majority of Europe, the high tech EV is
- 5:04cheaper to own than the classic petrol sedan is replacing,
- 5:07right? But why this segment first?
- 5:10That's the critical question. Yeah, why D2 and not, say, the
- 5:14compact cars that sell in huge volumes?
- 5:17It comes down to two things. First, the buyer in that premium
- 5:20segment is just less sensitive to the initial sticker price and
- 5:22they're already used to high depreciation.
- 5:24And 2nd EEV efficiency gains are just maximized in bigger heavier
- 5:30vehicles that are usually driven longer distances.
- 5:33The savings on energy and maintenance for a premium Bev
- 5:36driven 30,000 kilometers a year, they just start to pile up and
- 5:40cancel out the higher purchase price.
- 5:42That makes perfect sense. The math works best when the
- 5:44starting cost is already high and the mileage is high.
- 5:47So now let's look at the mass market where that's not always
- 5:50the case. Where are Bevs struggling?
- 5:52OK, let's start with the smaller cars, the sub compacts.
- 5:55You know like a VW Polo or a Peugeot 2O8 right here.
- 5:59Bevs are competitive in 18 out of 28 countries, so it's a
- 6:03majority, but it's a long way from that universal win we saw
- 6:07in the premium space. OK, what about one step up the
- 6:10popular compact segment? Your Renault?
- 6:12Megan's Kia Neros. This is where the struggle
- 6:15becomes more acute. Bevs are more affordable in only
- 6:1814 out of 28 countries. Exactly how only half?
- 6:20Yeah, they tend to win in Western and Northern Europe, but
- 6:23in a key market like Germany, for example, the TCO for a
- 6:26compact Bev still struggles against its ICE equivalent.
- 6:29And I'm guessing that has a lot to do with the recent scaling
- 6:33back of government incentives. That's very likely a big part of
- 6:36it. So where are Bevs the least
- 6:38competitive? That would be the mid size
- 6:40standard segment, the D1 and SUVD one class.
- 6:44Think Lee W Passat or Hyundai Ionic 5 OK there.
- 6:48Bevs are competitive in only 11 out of 28 countries.
- 6:52The sweet spot for BEVTCO right now is clearly that mid size
- 6:57premium car where the higher initial cost is just less of a
- 7:00shock. All these figures, though, they
- 7:02hinge on one monster cost we haven't fully explored, and
- 7:05that's depreciation. The single largest component of
- 7:08TCO, yes. So let's.
- 7:09Deconstruct that total cost of ownership a bit.
- 7:11More right? The TCO chart really highlights
- 7:13this trade off. While BE VS have much lower fuel
- 7:16and maintenance cost compared to petrol and diesel, they come
- 7:20with this huge anchor, a much higher depreciation value.
- 7:23And when you look at the raw numbers, that initial loss is
- 7:26staggering. The sources point out that
- 7:29depreciation can be up to 50% of a Bev's total cost of ownership
- 7:34over those first four years. 50%. 50%.
- 7:37It's the dominant cost block for any new car buyer and the real
- 7:41question is why is Bev depreciation so much higher
- 7:45right now? It can't just be the purchase
- 7:46price. It's not.
- 7:47It's the residual value risk a lot of buyers fear.
- 7:51You know, rapid technological obsolescence.
- 7:54The battery in a 2024 Bev might seem ancient by 2028.
- 7:58And that would kill its resale value compared to a proven
- 8:02stable IC car. Exactly.
- 8:05Plus, the changing landscape of government incentives makes the
- 8:08used price just so unpredictable.
- 8:10That uncertainty, that risk, is something the buyer has to bear.
- 8:14And to make this really concrete, we found this great
- 8:16example of a user who tracked their personal records for a
- 8:20Tesla Model 3 Long Range. Yes, this real world anecdote is
- 8:24extremely clarifying. There are pure maintenance and
- 8:26charging current. Combined, it only came to about
- 8:29$0.20 per kilometer. Which is really low.
- 8:31That's comparable to running a much cheaper, older used car.
- 8:33Right. The operational benefits are
- 8:35clearly there, no question the. Depreciation figure completely
- 8:38overshadows it. It does that hit them hard at
- 8:40$0.59 per kilometer. That's almost three times the
- 8:43combined running costs. It really puts the operational
- 8:46benefits in perspective. I mean, even if you're driving
- 8:49on free electricity, if you bought that car new, your long
- 8:53term cost is just dominating by that massive initial loss of
- 8:56value. And this feeds right into the
- 8:59financing discussion. If depreciation is the monster,
- 9:03what does this data say about the best way to get a new car?
- 9:07The sources basically confirm that buying a brand new car is
- 9:10an intrinsically expensive hobby.
- 9:13Leasing looks attractive because it transfers that unpredictable
- 9:16risk. You know, the kind that wiped
- 9:18out diesel residual values when the regulations changed
- 9:21overnight. It transfers that to the leasing
- 9:23company, but. There's a catch.
- 9:24There's always a catch for a financially savvy buyer.
- 9:27The consensus is that while leasing removes the risk, it's
- 9:30generally expected to be financially worse than buying
- 9:33outright because the leasing company has to make a profit
- 9:35from taking on that risk for you.
- 9:37And that's before you even get into opportunity costs, assuming
- 9:40you could earn, say, 7% on the money you didn't spend on the
- 9:43car. Precisely.
- 9:45It all comes back to the initial capital.
- 9:47That's the big hurdle for BV's, which is exactly why the premium
- 9:51D2 segment, where buyers already accept huge capital outlay and
- 9:55depreciation, is where BV's are winning financially.
- 9:58They're just insulated from that sticker shock.
- 10:01So if depreciation is the problem, how does a luxury Bev
- 10:06managed to compete with some of the cheapest IC cars over a
- 10:09longer period? Let's pivot now and look closer
- 10:12at the Tesla Model 3. Right, because Tesla's own
- 10:15impact report provides this really powerful five year TCO
- 10:18analysis. This is over 60,000 miles or
- 10:21about 96,000 kilometers. They found that the Model 3 rear
- 10:24wheel drive TCO was 49 US cents per.
- 10:27Mile and that figure was. It's virtually identical to a
- 10:302023 base model Toyota Corolla. It is.
- 10:33The Corolla came in at $0.46 per mile.
- 10:35We are talking about a $2000 difference over five years and
- 10:39nearly 100,000 kilometers. And that tiny difference just
- 10:42evaporates the second you factor in government incentives.
- 10:45Even a small $6000 rebate would flip it.
- 10:48Instantly. The Bev immediately becomes
- 10:51cheaper than the base Corolla in a lot of markets.
- 10:53And that parody holds up even longer when we look at a 10 year
- 10:56analysis from one of our Italian sources.
- 10:59This one covers 200,000 kilometers.
- 11:01Yeah, that analysis is really compelling.
- 11:03Over a decade, the estimated TCO for the Model 3 was about
- 11:07€54,500 and that was remarkably similar to new entry level
- 11:15diesels or hybrids like a Fiat Tipo diesel at 51,000 or AVW
- 11:20Golf diesel at 55,000. So the ICE cars have a lower
- 11:23sticker price for sure, but they're much higher operational
- 11:26costs, fuel, maintenance, Rd. tax.
- 11:28It just perfectly balances the equation over the long haul.
- 11:31This is the real aha moment of the deep dive.
- 11:34The sources put it perfectly. Costi simile my difference at
- 11:37quantity teeth. Similar cost, but massive
- 11:40qualitative differences. Let's break that down.
- 11:42OK, If you're paying around €54,000 / 10 years for a Model 3
- 11:47and a similar amount for a Fiat Tipo diesel, what are you
- 11:50actually getting for your money? You are getting a completely
- 11:53different class of vehicle. The Model 3 is a premium high
- 11:57end car, right? It offers superior assisted
- 11:59driving performance that the Fiat or the Gulf can't even
- 12:03dream of matching and minimal maintenance.
- 12:05We're talking no oil changes, dramatically less brakeware
- 12:09because of region. Far fewer scheduled services.
- 12:12Exactly, so the data is telling you that a premium EV can
- 12:15deliver the same long term financial cost as a basic entry
- 12:19level ICE commuter car. You're essentially getting a
- 12:22luxury upgrade for free over the life of the vehicle.
- 12:25It's the superior value proposition that pushes it
- 12:27ahead. And if we look to the future,
- 12:29the sources hint at Teslas third generation platform, which is
- 12:33aiming to cut production costs per vehicle by 50%.
- 12:36That would be the seismic shift the mass market is waiting for.
- 12:39If they really cut production costs that much, potentially
- 12:42putting the next platform under $20,000, that just completely
- 12:45rewrites the TCO equation against all base ICE models.
- 12:50Globally, not just in Europe, it would move the needle from just
- 12:52premium superiority to universal TCO dominance.
- 12:57So what does this all mean for you the listener?
- 12:59We've established that the TCO advantage for Bevs is strongest
- 13:03in that mid size premium market and you know geographically
- 13:06favored in Western and Northern Europe.
- 13:08The biggest financial hurdle for wider adoption is that huge
- 13:12initial depreciation cost, not the day-to-day running costs.
- 13:16And if we connect this to the bigger picture, the data really
- 13:19confirms that for many European buyers today, especially those
- 13:23who drive high mileage and are looking at larger cars, choosing
- 13:26ABEV isn't just an ecological choice anymore.
- 13:29It's already an increasingly rational financial decision that
- 13:32also happens to give you superior performance in tech for
- 13:35the same long term cost. So here's a final thought for
- 13:38you to consider. If battery technology keeps
- 13:40getting better and helps reduce that massive 50% depreciation
- 13:43hit, and if manufacturers like Tesla actually hit that 50%
- 13:47production cost reduction goal, will the next car cost index we
- 13:50look at show Bev's dominating all segments, even the sub
- 13:53compact class, truly ending the financial competition with ICE
- 13:57vehicles for good? That future index is really
- 14:00going to provide the definitive answer to the ultimate financial
- 14:03question of this whole energy transition.
- 14:07This has been a fascinating deep dive into the true cost of
- 14:10driving electric. We really encourage you to
- 14:13follow the channel to make sure you never miss episode.
- 14:15And thank you for listening. We really appreciate you tuning
- 14:17in.