Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / The History Of Queer Comics with Documentarian Vivian Klieman
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, everybody, Welcome back. It's Word Balloon the Comic Book Conversation show
- 0:04John Sutras Here. Earlier this year on PBS, there was a great documentary
- 0:10about the origins of queer comics and a great profile of a lot of queer
- 0:15creators. Vivian Climan was the filmmaker that was responsible for this excellent documentary,
- 0:21and given that it's Pride Month, I decided to represent it. Now it's
- 0:25a little quick for a rerun, but again, I just felt that this
- 0:29thing deserved the attention, and I felt like Pride Month good time to do
- 0:33it. Really great documentary, tremendous personal stories about a lot of fantastic cartoonists
- 0:39that are very important to the culture. So this was great and I'm very
- 0:45proud to have had the opportunity to speak to Vivian and promote this excellent documentary
- 0:51that ran on PBS. I hope it runs this month. It certainly should
- 0:54have, given that it's Pride Month. Vivian Climan talking about the history of
- 0:58queer comics on Today's Word Balloon. Word Balloon is brought to you by Alex
- 1:03Ross Art dot Com. Alex will be at San Diego Comicon in just a
- 1:10few weeks. His booth number is twenty four fifteen. You can't miss the
- 1:15Alex Ross booth always this incredible gallery presentation of some of his most iconic covers
- 1:23and interiors, but also new stuff as well that you will likely see on
- 1:30your favorite comic covers in the months ahead. Make sure you check out Alex
- 1:34Ross Art dot com at San Diego Comicon Booth twenty four fifteen. It's always
- 1:42very distinctly and gigantically located in the center of the action in San Diego on
- 1:48the main convention floor. Check it out or go online for Alex Ross art
- 1:53dot com. This episode of word Balloon is brought to you by Post College.
- 1:57Post College has three decades of a proven track record delivering professional industry training
- 2:02courses in audio, music, film, games, and animation. Since nineteen
- 2:07ninety one, pulses received international recognition for both its vocational and practical driven academic
- 2:15courses. All courses are designed and delivered by experienced industry professionals and offer cutting
- 2:21edge blends of academic perspectives used with practical skill sets in the areas of film,
- 2:25music, games, and animation. This, combined with the unique teaching
- 2:30and learning environment of the iconic Windmill Lane Recording Studios makes world class industry education
- 2:36attainable. Learners from around the world can join in in a variety of short
- 2:39courses offered remotely via zoom in the fields of sequential art and design, two
- 2:45D animation, three D animation, character design, and game environments. For
- 2:49more details, visit Pulse College dot com. Word Balloon is brought to you
- 2:55by my followers, the League of word Balloon Listeners. That's the name I
- 3:00gave my followers through Patreon. Patreon dot com slash word balloon Listen. Things
- 3:07are tough this year. I won't deny it for me financially. If you've
- 3:10ever considered supporting word balloon, I could really use your help. So if
- 3:15you think word Balloon is worth the price of a comic book, even a
- 3:20dollar a month would be greatly appreciated. Patreon dot com slash word balloon.
- 3:25Thank you very much for your patronage and your attention the League of word Balloon
- 3:31Listeners. If you subscribe to word Balloon, I will send you an email
- 3:35that will have a domino mask and cape and a nice League of word Balloon
- 3:38Listeners emblem that you've seen here. On word Balloon as well, but thank
- 3:44you for your support Patreon dot com slash word Balloon. Welcome back everybody,
- 3:50time again for word Balloon, the Comic Book Conversation Show. John Sutras here,
- 3:54very happy to welcome. It's Vivian Kleiman, who has made an incredible
- 3:59document enery that is currently running on PBS. I've got a still of the
- 4:03title. Hang on one second, everybody, and I'll grab it's it's called
- 4:06Straight Lines, Story of Queer Comics, and man, it has turned out
- 4:12just fantastic. It's a it's a great documentary. Welcome Vivian. Thank you
- 4:15so much for talking today. Well, thank you for having me John,
- 4:18it's my pleasure. Well done. I think it, as I was telling
- 4:21you off here and I'm not being nice, this is going to be one
- 4:25of those movies that when people look at the history of comics. You told
- 4:30the story quite well. And I would never claim to know a lot of
- 4:35the beginnings of gay comics, but you certainly did fill in a lot of
- 4:40the blanks. Thank you. It's it's really been quite a project, and
- 4:46I'm delighted to hear someone like you, with your with your expertise, recognized
- 4:50that there was a gap that the film will be filing. That's really awesome.
- 4:56You know, I had the pleasure of seeing Mary Wings, Howard Cruse,
- 5:00a couple of the creators that you focus on who were really responsible for
- 5:03a lot of the earlier efforts in in gay comics speak at well. I
- 5:09want to say, either printers Row the Chicago Tribune book Expo that happens yearly,
- 5:14or maybe it was San Diego or New York. I'm not sure,
- 5:17but it was really great to get even more information about them and others that
- 5:24were early creators all the way up to a modern day. I saw Sena
- 5:30Grace, who I've had the pleasure of talking to in the past, and
- 5:33yeah, absolutely, and also some others that are our current creators that I
- 5:42had yet to meet. Will certainly talk about them. But I'm so glad
- 5:46because we lost Howard Cruz just a couple of years ago, and I'm so
- 5:49glad that you got him and his partner and had the opportunity to speak to
- 5:55him at length, because you know, again, the great guy so respected
- 6:00in the comics community in general, and clearly in the gay comics community as
- 6:05a kind of like a Will Eisner. You know, will Will was considered
- 6:10really one of the founding fathers, and thankfully, you know, made it
- 6:14well into the two thousands, so a lot of Martin creators had the opportunity
- 6:16to meet him and be inspired by him on on one on one basis,
- 6:21not alone through his work. But yeah, that's that's great. If you
- 6:26don't mind, I'd love to start with the fact that you did start with
- 6:29Howard. Well, really, before we get into that, shame on me.
- 6:31What interest? What made you interested in doing this as a subject.
- 6:36Well, um, as I mentioned to you before we got started officially,
- 6:43my connection with comics was obviously as a kid, you know, clutching either
- 6:49the nicey, nicey animal ones or you know, moving on to you know,
- 6:55Superman and Batman and all that terrific. Yeah, did you like us
- 7:00superhero comics? That's great, Well, tell me tell me some titles that
- 7:02you read, oh as a kid, you know, Fantastic four and a
- 7:08Superman and you know, all that delicious stuff up to um, a certain
- 7:14point, and then I got very busy in high school preparing, you know,
- 7:20for an academic track as it were. Not this is not everybody's path,
- 7:26but it was mine and I didn't get involved in comics again until I
- 7:34came out as a lesbian and there was Alison Bechtel's Likes to Watch Out For
- 7:40that was serialized in our local feminist newspaper here in the Bay Area. It
- 7:45was called Plexus and Alice. I think, if I recall correctly, I
- 7:49don't recall, but I think Alison's series came out every other week and we
- 7:57would just wait with baited breath to find out what happened to our character to
- 8:03her characters. And you know, it could range from a bad hair day
- 8:07looking forward to the hut date that night or at least hot sex, to
- 8:13you know, packing as many, you know, people in a tiny little
- 8:16Volkswagen bug and bogging down from Boston, from Boston or New York down to
- 8:24DC for to demonstrate against something that was going on up on the political arena
- 8:28that people were protesting about. And you know, John, I can't tell
- 8:35you what it was like. I cannot describe the impact of seeing stories of
- 8:39our own lives represented in the comics. You know, you're just commenting about,
- 8:46you know, the superheroes or the fuzzy animal comics, and those were
- 8:50really wonderful and exciting and they fed into a kid's imagination and adults who still
- 8:56held on to their imaginations. But in in Allison's work and then the other
- 9:03work by other queer cartoonists, we saw ourselves and we actually got to hear
- 9:09our own stories being actually represented. And the power of seeing yourself represented in
- 9:16the comics, both the visual and the verbal, is unbelievable for people who
- 9:22have been so traumatized by the whole process of coming out. So that that's
- 9:28really my entree into comics. And then, just to conclude the little anecdote
- 9:37here, I wasn't involved in comics until Justin Hall, who is an expert
- 9:43in queer comics in particular history of queer comics in particular, and himself a
- 9:48cartoonist and teaches queer comics or sorry, teaches comics at the California School for
- 9:56the Arts called California College for the Art CCA here in the Bay Area.
- 10:01And Justin had edited the first anthology of Queer Comics, a very beautiful anthology
- 10:09of some the work of some seventy artists, beautifully reproduced and in fact they're
- 10:15going to be reissuing that. It's going to be the tenth anniversary coming up
- 10:18I think next year, and yeah, so you can keep your eyes out
- 10:24for that. And Justin had a friend who said, hey, you should
- 10:26make this into a documentary, and Justin was introduced to a filmmaker named Greg
- 10:33Serota. The two of them got started on this endeavor and didn't seem to
- 10:41be able to get the traction needed to pull it off. Greg and I'd
- 10:46work together on a few projects. I had hired him to edit some of
- 10:48my work, and when Greg came knocking my door asking if I wanted to
- 10:52take over the project, I hesitated because of all the reasons. I just
- 10:58described that I was my connection with comics, you know, it was limited
- 11:03and not contemporary, and he said, no, no, no, you're
- 11:05really gonna like this story. It's a great story. It's a great way
- 11:07of telling queer history in the US through the comics. And Justin encouraged me
- 11:13to attend the world's first in gathering of queer comic book artists. I think
- 11:20it was twenty and fifteen, and so I think it was June two thousand
- 11:26and fifty maybe sixteen. I think it was fifteen, okay, And it
- 11:31was organized by Jen Camper, who's in the film with the help of Justin
- 11:35there. She is the inimitable Jennifer Camper and um uh. When I walked
- 11:43into that conference space in New York, it was held at the building at
- 11:50Hunter College, I was completely overwhelmed by what I saw. You know,
- 11:56my again, I didn't have much connection with comic since I've said three times
- 12:01now that I did have. I did work on a project with some guys
- 12:05who had stacks of zapp and all kinds of all kinds of Robert Crumb stuff
- 12:11all around, you know, the office. I was very familiar with mister
- 12:15Natural and a lot of the imagery was quite familiar, and some of it
- 12:20not to my taste. And my expectation was that it would be people who
- 12:28are more like Robert Crumb, who were more snarky and not so eager to
- 12:37meet new people, and instead it was a room full of people who were
- 12:41so excited about being together. And in the middle of the room when I
- 12:46walked in this first day, there was this guy with a balding head and
- 12:50a punch stomach and a crumpled shirt and he was completely engaged in conversation with
- 12:58a gender non binary person um with covered in tats. Chartruse dyed hair.
- 13:07Ah, many generations like probably to at least two generations younger than the dude
- 13:13standing there. They were completely like, happy to be talking and certain.
- 13:18They were surrounded by other people like the whole panel, pally, the whole
- 13:22arc of the kinds of folks that you that that constitute what it means to
- 13:30be lgbtq um were there and happy to be talking with one another. And
- 13:35I went and over the next few days I heard um panels, I heard
- 13:41people talker panels, I saw, I saw the artwork. It ranged from
- 13:48the political stuff Alison Bechtel, to sci fi to bondage to you know everything.
- 13:58Ever, the whole works, everything was there, and I went,
- 14:01oh, my goodness, this is a casting director's dream. There's all these
- 14:05amazing storytellers with wonderful stories. It's a different way of thinking about our history.
- 14:11It's different way of telling our history certainly. And the artwork, my
- 14:18goodness. You know, documentary filmmakers were usually scrounging for images to compliment our
- 14:24stories. Yeah, and here it was just the opposite. Here it was
- 14:28a case of a tsunami of images. And how do you choose, you
- 14:33know, one or two or three images to compliment a story. And I
- 14:41knew at that point that this was going to be um, this was going
- 14:45to be a project that was going to speak to a younger generation, and
- 14:48I wanted to be a part of bringing that story to them. It's it's
- 14:54so interesting that all these cartoonists, whether they be gay, straight, whatever
- 15:01their orientation, is a lot of them the new the new generation sometimes doesn't
- 15:05know the history and and it's and it really and it was so great to
- 15:11see in your film, Uh, the response of so many of the younger
- 15:15cartoonists. And wow, I had no idea how far back it went.
- 15:20Uh, that that feeling even of a lot of the people that you leaned
- 15:24on to tell the story when they discovered they weren't the only ones and that
- 15:31we're doing this and it and and it happens. It happens in Underground Comics,
- 15:35which was the home for gay comics. In a lot of ways,
- 15:39I'm so glad. And as I assumed that Howard, I didn't know the
- 15:45direct connection between Howard Cruz and Dennis Kitchen and Dennis has been on the show
- 15:50a couple of times, and I've had the pleasure of having audiences with him
- 15:54and he he's such a great guy and and and so important and and you
- 15:58know, there's that, as you say, because because Crumb is kind of
- 16:02the underground comic that everyone I think, you know, initially thinks of.
- 16:06But he really is just one voice in a sea of many. And actually
- 16:10I just talked to Drew Friedman, the wonderful artist, and he just did
- 16:14um a book of about celebrating underground comics. I don't remember if Howard is
- 16:18in there or Mary is in there. I do know that Trina Robbins,
- 16:22who has spoken about a lot in your in your documentary, is represented,
- 16:26and you know, but yeah, it's it's just it's great that even back
- 16:32then, as far back as the seventies, there was a place for gay
- 16:37cartoonists to be able to go tell their stories. Well, well, I
- 16:41am so thrilled to hear that you've taken advantage of Dennis's kitchen and his generosity
- 16:48to come on your show more than once. That is so awesome. He's
- 16:51just like, so pivotal and seminal for the history of comics undergraund comics in
- 16:57particular. And the thing that struck me is, um, it's every time
- 17:03I think about this, I I get ready to cry the whole what the
- 17:07key? Well, Mary Wayne's launched the first out first comic by an out
- 17:15lesbian that it was published and known about. I'm sure there are others that
- 17:19were not published and not known about. But um. Then comes Dennis Kitchen,
- 17:26a self described straight man, very very successful in terms of anthologies on
- 17:33different kinds of uh genre and themes and from the underground comic scene. And
- 17:40he wakes up one day and he decides that, Hey, I've done all
- 17:45these comics about you know, potheads and this and that, and what's missing
- 17:52from when I look on my shelf. What's missing is the voice of the
- 17:55LGBTQ comics because there weren't because everybody was really frightened in the seventies. And
- 18:03in nineteen eighty he reached out to Howard Cruz and said, Hey, I
- 18:07think you're queer, not that they didn't used the word queer, that I
- 18:10think you're gay. Yeah, how would you like to be the editor of
- 18:15the first anthology of gay comics? And thus began the whole story at that
- 18:19moment. And when you think about the fact that it took a straight man
- 18:23to be comfortable enough to say, hey, there's this piece missing from our
- 18:30representation of ourselves of the world that I you know, that we all inhabit.
- 18:36Let's do something to change that and fill in the gap. I just
- 18:41feel like that is such an important reminder that we are all in this together,
- 18:47you know. And it's not just about queer people telling queer stories,
- 18:52you know though, though that's obviously, you know, vital, but absolutely
- 18:57we all help each other out and getting a leg up in the world.
- 19:00I guess is what I'm saying, I understand, and that is that has
- 19:03been my experience going beyond a reader to discover the workings of comics, beyond
- 19:10DC and Marvel and Image and some of the bigger publishers that there's, uh,
- 19:14there really has been this strong, independent, underground movement and yeah,
- 19:18I mean no, Dennis gets it and gets it across the board and also
- 19:23understands the needs for retaining rights to your your comics. He was never a
- 19:30guy that God there's sol Vance, the guy who uh the public like,
- 19:40oh man, what a great guy. He made the English patient film enslowing
- 19:44myselves anti me, my former landlord here in Berkeley. Way no way,
- 19:48wow, I am I am seated right now. In a building that used
- 19:52to be known as the Fantasy Film Building. Okay, Fantasy and the building
- 19:56got built because of the success of Credence Water Revival and all those gold records,
- 20:03and then they built the two story building, and then they added they
- 20:06made a seventh story building based on the success of the English Patient and the
- 20:08poor people that the poor people. The ridiculous group of men who created,
- 20:15you know, the Fantasy Record label and the Fantasy Film Company. They they
- 20:23really did their best to screw the musicians, you know that they were recording.
- 20:29So Creden's Clearwater Revival is that famous incident that you're talking about. And
- 20:33I'm so till I'm so glad, you know, I mean, and you
- 20:37told the story a lot better than I could have. Absolutely. John Fogerty
- 20:40of CCR, who made all that amazing music Solvance kind of held on to
- 20:45the rights of that, and so many record producer labels and different companies publishers
- 20:52would just be, hey, great, you know, while it's ours now,
- 20:56and uh you know, yeah, we paid you that you know,
- 20:59mythical five hundred dollars for your comic and that's about all you're gonna make.
- 21:03We're gonna make millions following. Yeah, totally unethical. He was a nice
- 21:07guy to us, the tenants. That's pretty here, all right, I'm
- 21:11plenty here. But he was such a bastard, you know, as a
- 21:15as a producer. Yeah, I mean again that was that was just the
- 21:18way things were. And Dennis was one of those guys. It's like,
- 21:22yeah, I'll keep the rights for three years, five years, and then
- 21:26after that they go back to you, and if you want to go back
- 21:29to Press, more power to you. I didn't know that about Dennis.
- 21:33I'm going to send him a note. Well, yeah, no, that's
- 21:37great. And again, um, just what came from Dennis's efforts. And
- 21:42then of course, uh, these cartoonists did find homes at The Gay Advocate
- 21:48and other other gay publications. Um, you know which is which is great?
- 21:53It is so interesting too, and you spelled this out in the documentary
- 22:00that there's a boom and bust in the area of queer comics, much like
- 22:04straight comics had the same issue at the same time. I mean, there
- 22:08was this crescendo in the nineties where all of a sudden, after things were
- 22:12going right great, where there was this huge bust period. Even Marvel comics
- 22:17was on the verge of bankruptcy, you know, And I mean so again,
- 22:22it's it's a familiar story, taking nothing away from the personal stories that
- 22:29your documentary shows of these cartoonists. But I think also a straight audience will
- 22:33apps and certainly a straight comics audience will see that, hey, everybody kind
- 22:40of went through the same thing, and also that for the most part,
- 22:45the comic business, including the queer comic business, is a giving business and
- 22:48everyone's there to help each other. Right. Actually was enormously important to me
- 22:55to really go into detail and include the story about the boom and bust,
- 23:00because I wanted people to understand that here's this artist, like Alison Bechtel MacArthur
- 23:07Genius Award recipient. Her book fun Home was on the New York Times bestseller
- 23:11list for almost a year. Somebody then gets the silly idea to convert it
- 23:17into a musical, and it goes on Broadway and win The performance wins more
- 23:22Tony Awards than any other prior musical. Has success success, success. But
- 23:27there you see in the film Alison telling the story that you know, at
- 23:30the turn of the century, at near two thousand, she was ready to
- 23:34throw them the towel because she wasn't able to support herself as an artist.
- 23:40And I just feel like, and then things change, you know, her
- 23:44luck change because of the tap on the shoulder and some advice from a wise
- 23:49person and she wisely listened to that person or luckily, it's probably luck,
- 23:55and her fortune changed completely. I think that is so vital a message to
- 24:00give to artists today, young artists, that it isn't necessarily a linear progression,
- 24:07and that sometimes there are setbacks in the road, and they're often there
- 24:11always will be hurdles to overcome. And here's examples of artists who faced those
- 24:17some of those you know, same hurdles, different ones also and managed to
- 24:22you know, go along with their lives in different ways. And I think
- 24:25that's vital, a vital message for young artists today to understand. And independent
- 24:32creators of all mediums. I so agree, And in fact, certainly during
- 24:37COVID that was a recurring theme as I spoke to people that worked for DC
- 24:44and Marvel and then mainstream comics, but also people that were doing independent comics,
- 24:51and it's like, how are you handling this? And I mean it's
- 24:53just like any walk of life, COVID was debilitating and for some creative people
- 25:00and paralyzing in some ways. Others were resourceful and like, well, I
- 25:04can't rely on publisher X to provide me with work. What are the opportunities?
- 25:11And you made this film prior to COVID, and that's great because this
- 25:15is the general story of queer comics. Um did you have you have you
- 25:19spoken to any of them and what their experiences have been during during the COVID
- 25:25period. You know, I don't know. Well, you know, John,
- 25:27if I were as talented an interviewer as you, I would have gone
- 25:32back and asked them that question. It's a very good for It's a very
- 25:33interesting question. I have been in touch with everyone over over this time for
- 25:40various reasons, um Um. Not the Lisa, which is to keep them
- 25:44posted on our progress and let them know about the peak national PBS broadcast or
- 25:48and plus the premiere at the Tribeca Film Festival, no less, but wow,
- 25:55I haven't asked them specifically about the impact of COVID on them in their
- 26:00work. I suspect a certain number of them will say that they put it
- 26:06to good use, that they have an introspect. What's the word kind of
- 26:10like antisocial part of them that makes them happy to be sitting in at their
- 26:15you know, drawing tables, sure, and creating arts supposed to being being
- 26:21distracted with day to day stuff and going to you know, dinner and parties
- 26:26with friends. So I think the most of most artists put the isolation a
- 26:30lot. Most a lot of arts that I know put the isolation of COVID
- 26:33to good use. VINNI And I'm sorry, did I? I hope I
- 26:37did mention at the beginning that No Straight Lines is now at PBS documentary that
- 26:42you can see on your local stations. And also you were taught me off
- 26:45the air that it is available to stream on the PBS websites that again you
- 26:53can you can enter for free if people haven't used it before. I've done
- 26:57it for various PBS docum memories. W TTW here in Chicago is our local
- 27:03station, and it will allow you access to the programming and stuff. It's
- 27:07and it's interesting you're telling me too. You were kind. You sent me
- 27:11the unedited version that you know, uh, all the all the nudity is
- 27:17intact in the version that I got to see. You might see some blurring
- 27:21or some uh uh, strategic spots where nipples and the like are. Don't
- 27:26say that word. We we uh, we have to do a lot more
- 27:33covering up of exposed body parts than I anticipated. You know. Yeah,
- 27:37no, kid, PBS is part of the US, a broadcaster as opposed
- 27:44to us on the Internet like Netflix and HBO, and so they're beholden to
- 27:48FCC regulations, and PBS has their own set of regulations that are that exceed
- 27:56the FCC because they they're they funding from Congress, and they got attacked right
- 28:03all the time by people who would prefer to have arts not funded. Um
- 28:10so, but I try. Here's what I here's the deal when I knew
- 28:14when when they When PBS approached me and asked to include the film in the
- 28:21Independent Lens series, I at first balked because I was aiming for Netflix and
- 28:27Hulu and HBO. Apparently the film is two in your face for those people.
- 28:33And when we got rejected by all of them, all the big streamers,
- 28:37Wow, PBS saw that and came back a second time and said,
- 28:41hey, we still are interested. We just you have to conform the images
- 28:47and the audio to FCC regulations. And I asked all the artists who I
- 28:52asked the five main artists how they felt about it, and they all said,
- 28:57we hate the idea of covering up and of making any changes to our
- 29:02work, but we love the idea of the story reaching two to three million
- 29:07viewers, which is kind of awesome when you think about it. Absolutely,
- 29:11so with their blessings, I did go ahead, and I like to say,
- 29:15I put on digital fig leaves over certain body parts and certain words.
- 29:25And you know, actually it was first shown Monday night on national public television.
- 29:32Not all stations show at the same time, and I watched it with
- 29:34a bunch of friends who hadn't seen the FCC okay version, and they all
- 29:41said, you know, we missed a couple of words. We certainly understood
- 29:45what some of the covered words were, probably, but nonetheless we got it
- 29:49didn't impede in figuring out, you know, the meaning of it all.
- 29:53And you know, it worked. And they actually they liked the idea that
- 30:00of making it discreet, kind of a gentle blurb black and white to fit
- 30:04into the black and white comics when they are black and white. Yeah,
- 30:08I actually went the opposite way. I decided to make it very blatant and
- 30:12very make it known to the viewer. This is an intentional altering of the
- 30:18artist's work, and I wanted to put it to good use to make a
- 30:22statement, rather than to obscure the fact that we are changing their artist's work.
- 30:27But you know, just the fact of zooming in on a section of
- 30:32an artist's work, that's me editing. Sure, you know that's an edit
- 30:36right there. That's me making a statement about their work of a certain kind.
- 30:41So it's a complicated deal doing a documentary film on the subject of graphic
- 30:47art. Anyone who is a fan of comics appreciates when we see process and
- 30:55how the artists do it. And that's another great thing about this. You
- 31:00see Howard at the draft board, you see all of them. You know,
- 31:03here's here's Allison at her at her draft board, and you know Howard
- 31:07in his studio. It is wonderful to see and you literally do see them
- 31:11putting the pen to paper and inking. And was it was it Jen that
- 31:18was talking I forget, or maybe it was Alison who talked about how they
- 31:22they start doing pencils and then they race, and then they go back and
- 31:26they ink and and that's where the magic happens. And that again, it's
- 31:32that is a universal cartoonist comment and feeling, and you convey it so well,
- 31:38and they convey it so well, and we literally see it happening.
- 31:41We see the art happening. That's fantastic. So I think it's worth those
- 31:47unfortunate agreements that you have to concede to to tell the general story. And
- 31:53again I can only imagine because I'm glad I saw the aversion, but I
- 32:00do think it's an important story. And wait a minute, this blows my
- 32:02mind. That Hulu Netflix, there's all right, there's a very u there's
- 32:08a puerile website called mister Skin. I don't know if you're aware of it.
- 32:13They actually do cater to the gay audiences. Well we are audience as
- 32:15well. But that said, the amount of television and streaming television that is
- 32:22as graphic and blatant as it gets. I mean, we'll look at look
- 32:28at HBO with shows like euphoriae some of the other shows, you know,
- 32:31and yet these streamers are like, I don't know, that's a little in
- 32:37your face. Really, that's fascinating. That is a well the only one,
- 32:42only one of them said that to me directly. You know, there's
- 32:44various polite ways of saying that. But it's so curious John that you named
- 32:50you for you because that's the example I'm always giving, that full frontal male
- 32:53nudity of a show that has won so many awards. Yes, you know,
- 33:00PBS is UM. I'm grateful to PBS for Dare I say, having
- 33:07the balls or in this case, having the ovaries? You know, to
- 33:10take it on because even even with you know, the the digitized fig leaves,
- 33:15it's still and in your face piece and uh. In an age when
- 33:22just saying certain words has become taboo, you know, the ban on trying
- 33:25to a ban on the word gay, and the ban on trans people,
- 33:30and the ban on the censorship of books. One of the young artists in
- 33:35the film, Mayakobabe, has a book Gender Queer, a graphic memoir that
- 33:39is the most censored book in America today. I mean the most, and
- 33:46I promise you there is nothing nothing in there except uh, an attempt for
- 33:53a person to describe their feelings. And and that's another thing that I it
- 34:00comes through in the documentary you talk about the creators talk about how UM parents
- 34:05are buying these books to help their children understand as they understand their own sexuality,
- 34:12what they who they are. And and again this is this is really
- 34:15great stuff. And no, I do know that sad story. And and
- 34:19also the tightrope that PBS has to walk to get public funding and certainly government
- 34:25funding. We're sadly aware of the pressure that Congress and the like can put
- 34:31on. Why are we paying for the arts? Uh? And again it
- 34:36is such a isn't it strange? I mean, one of the freest countries
- 34:38in the world. And and the hypocrisy when it comes to the arts and
- 34:43not supporting the arts, and not just queer voices, but just the arts
- 34:47in general. I remember the great Tony Randall, the great comedian, who
- 34:52was such an advocate for public support of the arts. And he didn't know
- 34:57that yeah yeah, well you know when he creates on a theater company in
- 35:00New York that that was privately funded, and you know, yeah, anytime
- 35:06he was raising money, he would you know, point out again the sad,
- 35:09the sad fact that so many other enlightened countries of course they sponsored the
- 35:14arts. Of course they you know, promoted funding for the arts. It
- 35:17is what it is. Thank god, Hey god, you guys on your
- 35:22own your Kickstarter campaign raising the money for this very documentary. You raised over
- 35:25forty one thousand dollars. Am I right to make a movie? Yes?
- 35:30And then me also a footnote that it ranged from literally one dollar to I
- 35:36think the biggest donation was three thousand dollars, and every single dollar was put
- 35:40to good use. It's a great looking movie, truly, Vivian, you
- 35:45did a all of a job. It's it's great And also you mentioned Tribeca.
- 35:50The documentary has won a few awards, hasn't it. Yeah. I've
- 35:52been really quite touched by the reception to the film. It's but you know,
- 35:58I knew that the queer community would love the story. I knew that
- 36:02the comics community would many people would be interested in the story, and I
- 36:07had zero expectation that the film would be embraced by the most prestigious of the
- 36:15film festivals like Tribeca. So it shows that if you do something with the
- 36:22goal of having a be have a long shelf life and not just superficial,
- 36:30but really it's I think it's because it's more than just who did what encyclopedia,
- 36:36it's really my My goal was to have it be more like a novel
- 36:38where you have different chapters in different stories that are that and different events that
- 36:44unfold, and where that's more of an emotional ride than informational ride. Information
- 36:51can be gotten, especially now by the push of a button on the Internet.
- 36:57So my goal in during the film was to take the audience into a
- 37:00world with an emotional connection that they otherwise wouldn't normally know anything about. Well
- 37:07and also much like yourself telling me that your attenant, you were attendant of
- 37:09Saul Vance and you know that story so well, it was it was great
- 37:14to see. I had no idea that Howard Cruise was at Stonewall, the
- 37:19infamous incident in New York that prompted gay advocacy on a bigger scale and led
- 37:25to things like the gay Pride parades that happened in every major city. I
- 37:30remember explaining to my younger cousins, why why is gay Pride parade in June?
- 37:35Well, this thing happened in New York in the late sixties, and
- 37:38and I didn't have the correct information. It was great to hear Howard's depiction
- 37:44and that Howard himself was there. Yeah, he was there high on acid.
- 37:52Well, he remembered he remembered enough. And you know in the film
- 38:00when you see this older guy, he was the guy I was describing earlier
- 38:04in our conversation. You know, the balding head and the punch stomach.
- 38:08You know, when audiences come to that section of the film, they hear
- 38:14that they see this guy talk about this is the art that I created when
- 38:17at the period when I was high on acid. Everybody helse with laughter.
- 38:24Well again, I mean underground. I mean that's part of underground comics.
- 38:28As as you say in the in the documentary, that's the place that you
- 38:32could buy underground comics was in head shops. So yeah, man, I
- 38:36mean it's that's where you bought your barb that's where you bought your wantitor all
- 38:39your paraphernalia and everything. And but yeah, but a younger generation doesn't think
- 38:45about older generation as smoking dope and doing you know, dropping acid and you
- 38:52know that kind of stuff. You think if themag us old and other.
- 38:55Actually, that's one of the things if I can just add a little footnote
- 38:59to something talked about earlier, because you were talking about how how cool it
- 39:04was that the young generation of artists in the film were saying how little they
- 39:09knew about their history and how grateful they were for the folks who went before
- 39:13them. I just want to add how much that surprised me, because when
- 39:17I grew up, when I was in my early twenties, the notion was
- 39:22that you don't trust older people, and that they vote more conservatively, for
- 39:27example, and that their ideas are more limited. They're kind of, you
- 39:30know, outdated, and we're hip and young and we're the future. And
- 39:36so I expected that kind of a tone of dismissiveness of the older artists and
- 39:42dismissiveness of you know, the past and we are facing the future generation.
- 39:47And I was so touched to be wrong. I was so touched by how
- 39:52appreciative these artists were and and I just didn't expect that at all. I
- 40:00understand, and uh man again, I learned so much. I did not
- 40:05know who Rupert Kinnard was, and uh Jesus, the shame on me,
- 40:09because a guy who grew up here in Chicago, where where I'm where I'm
- 40:14broadcasting from, and to hear his story as one of the through lines of
- 40:19the documentaries is really amazing, great story. I mean, that's the thing.
- 40:23All the all of these people have such wonderful stories that again contribute to
- 40:29the whole of the history of queer comics, but their own individual stories I
- 40:32think are relevant. And again, um and and I don't I keep saying
- 40:37this, and I don't want, I don't mean to say it to separate
- 40:40the subject of it being about the queer lifestyle and then what they were able
- 40:44to accomplish. But it's a universal story in a lot of ways. And
- 40:47I think that's terrific. Well, you know, that's actually what captured my
- 40:52heart. Um when I when Howard was doing his presentation at that conference,
- 40:57he I think was the keynote, and he talked. He showed one comic
- 41:02that he had done, one strip, and it was about somebody who a
- 41:07young guy wrote coming to the family one snowy, dark, snowy night.
- 41:13He went outside and put it in the mailbox and then immediately felt regret.
- 41:17Oh my god, what have I done. I wish I hadn't sent that
- 41:21letter, And could I reach in and take that letter out of the US
- 41:24mailbox? And I went, my goodness, don't we all haven't we all
- 41:32had that sense of regret and remorse at either having sent an email that we
- 41:37wished we hadn't or said something to somebody that we wished we hadn't or done
- 41:43something, you know, at that sense of regret and remorse, I just
- 41:46felt like, Oh, that's what we all share. And if I can
- 41:51do a film that captures the feelings that we all share, or that many
- 41:57of us share, then that would be an awesome way to kind of like
- 42:01normalize what it is to be a queer person in the US. I agree
- 42:07absolutely. I didn't know, uh, And it's again I still read DC
- 42:12and Marvel books. I didn't know that Ivan valz A was gay. I
- 42:15wasn't aware of his Marvel work. There he is wearing a black panther T
- 42:19shirt and you see a bit of it. Sena Grace is in the documentary
- 42:23as well and seen as a wonderful Marvel writer who's written. Uh. They
- 42:28they have gone back and taken a couple of characters, uh and and rewritten
- 42:31them, like like sina I had Iceman one of the X Men and X
- 42:36Men and Bobby Drake Iceman is now a gay character. Um, you know
- 42:39they've done it. In the Batman family. Um, Tim Drake, one
- 42:43of the Robins, is now non buyingary and of course Superman's son is is
- 42:49bisexual. I believe you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's scandal
- 42:53even it's even each front page to the New York Times. Oh yeah,
- 42:58it was quite the scan. Oh yeah, Fox Fox, and he has
- 43:00made a meal of it. Unfortunately, that's a great line. Sad but
- 43:07true. Yeah. Actually I met, I met Stina for the first time
- 43:10at that conference. He was one of the people standing in the circle around
- 43:14Howard Ony. Funny thing enough, I thought when I looked at him before
- 43:17I met him, I met, I saw him standing there, I thought,
- 43:21oh, he's he's like the GQ gentleman. And little did I know
- 43:25later on I was soon to discover that, oh he's much more complicated than
- 43:30that great guy. Another friend of mine that did make it in the documentary.
- 43:35I don't know if you're aware from Steve Orlando is his pen name,
- 43:37and he's done a lot of writing for both DC and Marvel. He's a
- 43:42bisexual gentleman and uh and and very accomplished writer. And you know that's the
- 43:46thing A lot of times got it, uh Joan Hilty. There's a brief
- 43:51picture of her in the bathtub with I want to say, Alison, no,
- 43:54not Alison. Yes, Allison and jen Camper okay video taken in the
- 44:00nineteen ninety I think they were babies well. And and I've admired Jones editing
- 44:07at DC in Vertigo Comics for years and she edits or edited tied two of
- 44:12my favorite people in comics, Greg Rucca and his wife Jen Van Meter her
- 44:15and i just knew her again from her work and I'm like, oh,
- 44:20that's I'm like, Oh, I didn't know Jonah's gay. I'm like,
- 44:22wait a minute, and apparently, yes, of course Jona is gay,
- 44:24and shame on me. I haven't heard it had her on word baloon yet,
- 44:28but I've got to have her on about her own comic book. That
- 44:30would be That would be so awesome to get her on. I would love
- 44:34to hear what she says about her career. No, I you know,
- 44:37I'm gonna have to. Greg and Jenner are really good friends and and I've
- 44:43told them in the past to make that connection for me, and now after
- 44:45seeing the movie even more so, I'd be happy to introduce you to her.
- 44:50Oh it would be Oh my god, Vivian, that would be great
- 44:52because truly, and some of the others that you have here in the in
- 44:55the in the documentary, and again, I'm just so glad that got Howard.
- 45:00I mean literally, I don't know when you finished filming, but he
- 45:02died in twenty nineteen. Yeah, let me let me let me just stop
- 45:06you there, if you don't mind, and say that he passed away Sunday
- 45:10night in twenty nineteen, and the plan had been in the hospital, but
- 45:16the plan had been for him to leave the hospital that afternoon go home and
- 45:22on Monday at morning watched the film from his hospital hospital that they brought into
- 45:27the house. And sadly he never got to see what it wouldn't have been
- 45:30the final film. He was going to watch a good rough cut of the
- 45:35film, and it breaks my heart that he never got to see it.
- 45:38Absolutely, I'm assuming his partner did get to see it. Yes, that's
- 45:44wonderful, that's great. No, you you really And again it's you know,
- 45:46the home life that you show of him and of Rupert as well.
- 45:51It just shows that people are people. You know, you got to eat
- 45:54breakfast. You might want to eat breakfast in front of the TV watching the
- 45:58news. He might not. You might have a dog looking out the window,
- 46:01or you might not. You might have a cat, you know,
- 46:04going between your feet or looking out the window, you know, Howard and
- 46:08his partner watching TV and having their little TV trays out and stuff, and
- 46:13reminded me of mel Brooks and Carl Reiner on that Comedians and cars getting coffee
- 46:19that Jerry Seinfeld shot and the two of them, and certainly even my elder
- 46:22relatives and stuff. How they how they cat about in front of the TV
- 46:27with their meals and stuff. I will I will not tell Eddie Howard's partner.
- 46:30That will be That will be our secret. Yeah, I can appreciate
- 46:36that definitely. Is So, is there a graphic novel as well of No
- 46:40Straight Lines? No? What it is? It's a incine anthology of queer
- 46:46comic books. But yeah, that's what I meant. Actually, yeah,
- 46:50that yeah, anthology. But Justin is working on a personal graphic memoir.
- 46:57I think it's part memoir, part fiction. Uh, and I think it's
- 47:00I think it's due to come out in twenty twenty five. Oh great,
- 47:04he's busy, busy, meeting some deadline for an editor, and um,
- 47:08that's going to be an awesome publication because his artwork has really in these five
- 47:14six years that we've been collaborating on the film. His artwork has just really
- 47:19sword. Is this uh this visual I'm showing now, is that Justin's artwork?
- 47:23There? Uh No, that's art that he commissioned for the cover of
- 47:27the book. It's Maurice Fellencoop, who's a Canadian, brilliant Canadian artist.
- 47:31Okay, love love that work. That's great. Will there be a DVD
- 47:37of the documentary? Yes, but um, it's so curious that you are
- 47:42asking that. Do you find that a lot of your audience is eager to
- 47:45have a DVD? Yes, I am. I've spoken to other documentarians that
- 47:52have covered comics. A friend, Maria Carbernardo made a wonderful, actually an
- 47:58interesting story Jeffrey Jones, who became Jeffrey Catherine Jones and transgender, you know,
- 48:04transitioned to being a woman before she passed away, and it was very
- 48:08anxio. She is a very interesting story. Better Things the Life of Jeffrey
- 48:14Catherine Jones is the title of this documentary. It's out through Keeno Lober kidding
- 48:20absolutely, Keeno Lber distributes it. And it's a great story because she referred
- 48:27to herself and her comics career. She would refer to herself as Jeffrey,
- 48:30and when she spoke of that part of her life, it was okay to
- 48:34refer to her as Jeffrey then. And and she was a very significant fantasy
- 48:38artist of the seventies and was shared a studio in New York with luminaries that
- 48:45you may or may not know, these names, Michael Kaluda and Barry Windsor
- 48:51Smith and oh god, swamp Thing shame on me, I can't think of
- 48:55his name right now. Shame on me. One of the one of the
- 48:58co creators of swamp Thing and uh amazing fantasy were beautiful stuff. And then
- 49:05um, and was married too too, um Walt Simonson's wife, Louise Simonson,
- 49:09who was a very important comic book writer and artist or an editor.
- 49:15Uh. Then he uh he was in a relationship with Gilbert Gilbert Shelton,
- 49:19I believe, back in the day, who a gentleman who was also a
- 49:22bisexual gentleman. Um, very interesting life. And yeah, that's great.
- 49:28And also Will Eisner there's a wonderful documentary about him. So yeah, I
- 49:30think, um, yeah, that is on DVD. And and I think,
- 49:35uh no, I do think there is a buying audience for for a
- 49:37DVD. I hope you guys make that choiceful. Yeah. No, we
- 49:39actually did make it, but we didn't make a fancy uh cover for the
- 49:44DVD. And now listening to you, I will are their commentaries on the
- 49:47DVD? Uh no, going about you to do that too? No,
- 49:53no, but that's actually an interesting idea. Thank you very much for the
- 49:57suggestion, like the director's commentary. Yeah, okay, I bet you guys.
- 50:01And also, man, all right, see I'm already making you go
- 50:05back and then make a special edition because I don't know if you include any
- 50:09raw interviews that, you know, beyond the completed documentary and stuff more material.
- 50:15I was actually going to do that and put it on the website.
- 50:17But it's an idea too. If we do uh an expanded DBD that we
- 50:22certainly would include some of that or any podcasting, any elements of audio where
- 50:29where you're just doing your interviews and stuff. I mean, any any beyond
- 50:32the visuals, because again, the visuals are amazing, you know, the
- 50:36audio, it's kind of interesting. Are you being you know, an audio
- 50:39person? Um, by the way, you have a great radio voice,
- 50:43thank you. You know, the audio for the film is you know,
- 50:49it's part of what has made the film as rich as it is. As
- 50:53a filmmaker, I happen to know that it's the soundtrack that is the most
- 50:58important part of the film content, of course, But if the image is
- 51:02kind of funky and nuts and maybe the colors aren't so saturated, but the
- 51:07sound is pristine and well developed, that's what gets to an audience. That
- 51:12that's what gets to It gets directly to the person's heart. And let me
- 51:15point out that we did the sound mix up at the famous Lucasfilm Studios and
- 51:21where they have this amazing archive of audio. So, for example, in
- 51:27Paige Braddock's panel of this a Dike but Stike on a motorcycle and luring somebody
- 51:34else on for a ride, and you hear the sound or the motorcycle revving,
- 51:38well guess what on Page's image she wrote that it's a Ducati I think
- 51:45seventy two or sixty nine, And the sound mixure goes, oh wait a
- 51:49second, and he goes into this amazing vast library of Lucas sounds and he
- 51:53found the actual sound of a Ducati motorcycle from that year that we use film
- 52:00outstanding. There you go, I'm sure some motor for cycle, Efficianadas Gonnavate
- 52:05Man. They nailed it very good. That's wonderfully here. And by the
- 52:08way, speaking of Chicago where we were, Rupert Canard is talking about growing
- 52:14up in Chicago. We see which is of the elevated train the l We
- 52:20are actually hearing the actual sound of the il from that year. That's excellent,
- 52:24outstanding. No, and again these individual stories will touch everyone's hearts when
- 52:30they see it as well, and the universality, but also again there they're
- 52:35separate stories. And then what it was like to be queer, the times
- 52:38they chose to come out, the difficulties and other personal hardships that they persevered
- 52:45through. And I won't I won't tip it because we do want people to
- 52:47watch the documentary. But really, Vivian well done. I really think top
- 52:52to bottom excellent film. It's on PBS now. It's part of Independent Lens.
- 52:58Yes, if you go to the PBS website pbs dot org and click
- 53:02on Independent Lens, it's available for free for the next three months through April
- 53:07twenty third, I think, and after that it's still available but to PBS
- 53:13members and hey, I think it's like six bucks a month. For PBS,
- 53:16so it's a nice thing to do. Support your PBS station. Indeed,
- 53:22no question, your PBS are your public radio station as well. Same
- 53:25you know you'll you'll forgive me being the audio guy, but no straight lines.
- 53:30The Story of Queer Comics a wonderful documentary now showing through PBS and independent
- 53:37lens. And very happy to have this conversation today with Vivian Climan. Well
- 53:44done, Vivian, truly excellent job. I really wish you luck with this
- 53:49any other projects that you're working on that you wouldn't we would like to telegraph
- 53:52yes, thank you very much. I know not right now for in terms
- 53:57of a comics content, but I after spending a lot of time pulling this
- 54:01one across the finish line, I'm going back and doing commission work. So
- 54:07a couple of folks are hiring me to do short projects, you know,
- 54:10a family history, a portrait of the corporate blah blah, you know,
- 54:16interesting stories, but paid work that's going to pay the bills. Fantastic,
- 54:22that's great, well continued success. I certainly hope that people will become more
- 54:28aware of your work through this wonderful documentary. Thank you, thank you so
- 54:31very much and really thank you so much for having me on the show and
- 54:35for your kind words. I can't tell you it really helps me plenish a
- 54:38very dry soul after working in isolation. It's just it's a joy and a
- 54:44delight. So thank you so and thank you for all you're doing, like
- 54:46you have an amazing program here, so you're very kind. I hope,
- 54:51I'm only I hope I'm one of many that are taking the opportunity to talking
- 54:54to you about this fantastic project. So thanks everybody for watch ching more great
- 55:00Ward balloon coming your way very soon. Until next time, stay safe,
- 55:04stay happy, stay healthy.