Latest / Her Culture: Books, Film, Music & Women in the Arts / The Art of Invisible Witnessing: Drawing Strangers on the Subway | Her Culture
Transcript
- You know that specific, electric silence when you’re sitting next to someone on a crowded train and you both pretend not to see each other? I’m about to ask you to break that rule. There’s a texture to this particular kind of courage. It’s not the loud, brash kind where you stand on a soapbox or demand attention. No, it’s quiet. It’s soft. It lives in the space between your sketchbook and the person sitting three feet away from you, pretending to read a novel they’ve already finished three times. I want to talk about drawing strangers on subway cars while they pretend not to notice. And before you think I’ve lost my mind—before you imagine me as some chaotic artist causing a scene—I need you to understand that this isn’t about performance art for an audience. It’s about witnessing. It’s about seeing people who are usually invisible, even though they are right there, breathing the same recycled air. Let’s unpack that word, witness. We use it so lightly, don’t we? But to witness someone means to truly see them. On the subway, we have this unspoken social contract. We look at our phones. We stare into the middle distance. We avoid eye contact because eye contact feels like an invitation, and we are all just trying to get home. We are tired. We are carrying the weight of our days in our shoulders. When I pull out my charcoal stick, my hand actually shakes a little. Not because I’m afraid of being caught—though, let’s be honest, there is a tiny thrill in the transgression—but because I am terrified of being seen myself. To draw someone is to say, 'I see you.' And sometimes, being seen is more vulnerable than looking away. There’s a guilt in seeing someone when they want to be hidden. You become the intruder in their private moment of rest. I’ve been doing this for years. It started small, really. Just quick gestures, capturing the curve of a neck or the way a hand grips a strap. I treat these sketches like sacred texts now, in the same way my mother treated vinyl records. They aren’t just paper; they are archives of human experience. I remember one woman, maybe in her seventies, wearing a coat that had seen better decades but was pressed with military precision. She was asleep, her head tilted against the window, catching the streetlights in flashes of amber and blue. I didn’t move for twenty minutes. I watched the rise and fall of her chest. I watched the dust motes dance around her. And then, slowly, I drew the line of her jaw. Not to capture her beauty, necessarily, but to capture her peace. In a city that never sleeps, finding moments of stillness in another person feels like discovering a secret garden. It changes how you move through the world afterward. You start noticing the poetry in exhaustion. But here’s the thing nobody talks about: the fear. What if she wakes up? What if she thinks I’m crazy? What if she asks why I’m watching her sleep? These questions loop in your head like a bad song you can’t get out of your head. I once drew a young man with tattoos covering his arms, reading a thick paperback. He opened his eyes mid-sketch. Our gazes locked. The entire car seemed to hold its breath. I froze, pencil hovering. I expected anger. I expected him to snatch the book from my bag. Instead, he looked at the sketch, then at me, and gave this small, almost imperceptible nod. It wasn’t friendly, exactly. It was acknowledgment. A silent treaty. In that second, the barrier between stranger and stranger dissolved. We were just two humans sharing a space. That nod stayed with me for weeks. It reminded me that beneath the grime and the rush, there is a basic human desire to be recognized. To know that we exist to someone else. It reminds me, actually, of something we touched on recently in those letters to ghosts—writing to those we never met. Because in a way, that’s what I’m doing. I’m writing visual letters to people whose names I will never know. I’m sending them out into the ether of my studio, filed away in folders labeled with dates and locations. 'Tuesday, 5:15 PM, Blue Line.' 'Rainy Thursday, Midtown Station.' These drawings are my way of saying, 'You were here. You mattered.' It’s a counter-narrative to the loneliness of modern urban life. We live next to thousands of people and feel entirely alone. But when I draw you, I am claiming a connection. I am saying, 'I noticed the way you held your coffee cup. I noticed the sadness in your eyes. I noticed you.' It’s a radical act of kindness in a world that rewards indifference. It’s messy, it’s intimate, and it’s deeply necessary. So, how do you start? Do you need expensive supplies? Absolutely not. You need a small notebook, something that fits in your palm. You need a pencil that doesn’t smear too easily. And you need permission to be awkward. Tell me more about why that landed. Why does the idea of being awkward feel safer than being ignored? Start by sitting. Just sit. Observe. Look at the lines of faces, the architecture of bodies. Then, when you feel ready, make a mark. Don’t try to create a masterpiece. Try to capture a feeling. The slump of a shoulder. The tension in a jaw. The softness of a smile directed at a phone screen. Let your hand move without judgment. If someone catches you, smile. Say sorry. Explain that you’re trying to remember their face. Most people are flattered, even if they pretend not to be. And if they’re not? Well, then you’ve practiced bravery. And that’s worth something too. Thank you for letting me into your day. Keep noticing things. Keep drawing the lines that connect us. Until next time, I’ll be listening.