Latest / Local Sports Network / More Than A Game - The All Abilities Podcast With Travis Kemp
Transcript
- FIDA Ep3: And that's why I want to finish this episode by telling you a story. That still continues to break my heart, right? Hello, all and welcome to the third episode of Feeder Football. It's more than a game because it is to those who are a part of it. Thanks again to Alice and Local Sports Network, who without their support, this program would just be a dream. What if we could actually measure the difference a football club makes to someone's life? Not just about goals scored, games won, or players registered, but confidence, friendships, belonging. Participation and well-being. Today we're going to explore something that I think could fundamentally change the way community sport programs like Feeder are understood and supported. Social impact, social value, and importantly, the data behind it. Ian Borman is the impact and strategic partnership manager for the YMCA, a non-profit organization, which do amazing work across all levels of community. And Welcome to the studio, Ian. thank you so much for having me. I can't wait to share my passion around impact measurement, but also some personal stories around my son and his interactions with sport as well and the great impact it's had. So our connection is through my wife, who's the general manager of Rec at the YMCA. We're talking about it over a coffee, maybe a wine, and brought your name to the conversation, which is Pretty important for me and what we're gonna about to talk about today. But y you've worked across some really diverse areas, you know, of the community and social impact. tell us a little about your background, what ultimately led you to the YMCA and the role you're in today. Well, hopefully, as you can tell by my accent, from the UK originally, my background is outdoor education and youth work. so working in community organizations. And all the way through my career, I've always been asked that question. Around you deliver all these programs, but but what it so what? What's the impact that these programs have? So a big thing for me is trying to, I kept asking myself that question. And I wanted to understand how do we go about measuring programs and the impact and the changes in people's lives. And I was really fortunate to get a job in 2012 at YMCA Victoria. I had a background there in youth services and running all their amazing youth services programs. out in their recreation centers and in other communities. And then I was really fortunate in 2019 to get an opportunity to have an investment from the organization, so from Y Victoria, to roll out a social impact strategy to better understand all of the impact that our programs had. And then from a personal point of view, my son Sean was diagnosed with autism around about six years ago. and we've always really struggled with that integration into community sport to start with. And you sort of stop asking about whether or not they'll get on the team and you know, how many goals they'll score and all that sort of stuff. And it was just is there a space where they can feel like they belong, that they can be around other people who care about them and it's a place where he wants to go, it's not where he needs to go. As parent with a child with a disability, I totally concur with your message, but Could speak hours about that, mate. But let's start with the obvious question. When we talk about social impact or social value, what are we actually talking about? Yeah, it's a great question. And it's one I get asked all of the time when I'm out. And social impact for me is more than the amount of people that are turning up for the programs. Social impact is all around the change we make because of a program or an activity that we run. And then social value expands on that and it looks at the financial value that those programs and services bring back to the community, but also the deeper impact. So the sense of belonging, the sense of connection, the skills that people learn. Okay. It's it's is it working off and maybe going off script here a little bit, but y you talk around qualitative and quantitative data. Yep. and it actually does go into the next, next question. it's easy to say a program has a positive impact. And but how do you actually measure the impact? Yeah. So w we start with outputs. So, you know, every day you you have a game of footy and you run your club and you might have thirty kids that turn out to your session. So each week you might have thirty or twenty and and and that's what like people used to track. If it was good, the more people you have and we would get more people to come. And then we start going into around the outcomes. So, like what is it? What's the change that we want to see in that program? And we start looking at connection, at belonging, at the skills that young people are learning. And then what we do there is we develop something called a theory of change. So we sit down and we go, what is it that our program is trying to do? And we go and we map out, okay, people are going to come along and they're going to do this activity. This activity is going to take an hour. And we'll do all sorts of different sports and coaching and activities, and then there'll be a game. But what we do then is we look at what's the short term outcomes. So from the coaching sessions, what's the skills they're gonna learn? But then we also look at like in the medium and long term. So we're talking their past six months, 12 months, two years. What's the relationships that they're gonna build, the friendships that they're gonna develop, the the different things that we can track and measure over time. That's what you measure. Where does it this might be a silly question, but where does the data for that come from? So we can do that in multiple different ways. so the the one probably most people know about is you send a survey out. So you run a program, afterwards you hand out some paper or you send out a survey link and you ask a number of questions. And what we do is we ask impact questions, so the outcomes that we were just talking around, but we also ask demographic questions so we understand the community. And whether or not the outcomes are different for different parts of that community. Circling back before I get to the next question here, how important is that in your organization now? And what role does that play? Going off script here, to be honest with you, but what role with that data, how important is that role within the YMCA? Is is capturing, reporting, actually delivering that? Yep. So At the Y, we were really interested in understanding the impact not just of our youth services programs, which were funded by the profits of our organization. We deliver six different services. So we have recreation, we have children and youth programs, we have action sports, we have camping, we have a private swim school as well called King Swim. And what was really important, what our executive and our board really wanted to understand is what's the overarching impact of all of our services in the communities that we work. So they invested, and it does take investment to do this work. It doesn't come for free. we started with around about 50 different outcomes that we wanted to measure, and that becomes really complicated and it confuses people on the journey. So we did a process within our organization. We actually used COVID as the catalyst for that change when some of our services were unfortunately closed. Yep. And we really drilled down is what are the most important outcomes for us? And we landed with five. Okay. Which are physical well being. Yep. Mental well being. Connection and belonging. We sneak two together there. Yep. future skills, so skills young people will need into the future. Yep. And voice and empowerment. You've been in this role since two thousand nineteen? Yep. You there's a term in business that I like to use a lot and is around trend as your friend. Yep. Ha have you seen any trends that have led you to change the to alter your course of the business that That you you have a belief of this, but it but the data is showing you why. And is that have you seen the data to make you alter your course to go another direction, if you want to call it that? We we've had like all organizations, financial situations change, program funding changes. the great thing for us is we're able to use that evidence to make those informed decisions. Yep. and that's where we talk around data driven decision making. And what's really important for us is every program can have an impact, but how does that Data align and deliver towards a strategy that we're working towards. And what's been amazing for us is we're actually booking the trend. While unfortunately within our community, social impact outcomes across the community are going down. So people's mental well-being, their physical well-being, you're seeing it in the community every day nowadays. We've had a really positive, gradual increase over the past five years. So it's really good to see the evidence that we have is. Informing the programs. But what we've got to do though is sometimes you get feedback that tells you your program's not having the desired impact you want. So what we do is a process called learning and reflection, where we come together at the end of a program and we go, let's celebrate the successes. That's really important. Let's share those amazing stories. Let's go back to the councils and that feedback is just as important as a positive feedback. 100%. Yeah. And the biggest thing is that's why we collect. the demographic information as well. So just so one cohort might be having a positive impact, that might be slightly different from you know, all sorts of different communities that we work with. And an outcome for us is we need to use the data and we need to inform our programs to have the best outcomes they possibly can. So you're not working so well, you are working off quantitative data. Yes. So we basically, if we find an area, a specific area where a lower social outcomes might be happening, we might delve deeper and gather more information. So that's where we'll use qualitative data. We'll go out and we'll do face to face, we'll run focus groups, group focus groups, one on one interviews, and we'll really drill down and try and find that information out. And that's a great segue into the next next question we have. If we applied that thinking to an organization like Feeder. Yep. Yeah, what sort of things could we potentially measure or uncover that people may not cease from simply looking at a football game? And I think, you know, I started to explain that before. There's a there's a great opportunity, I feel, talking around the five outcomes, that the why, they're they're really transferable to many community organizations. You know, when we talk around physical well-being, you know, you could track physical activity levels of the young people that are coming through your programs. How do you track that? How do you track the physical So we track that. So we align to national benchmarks. So the way that we gather physical activity levels within the the government and local community. So we track the number of minutes of physical activity. So only 54% of the Victorian population meet the physical activity guidelines. So that 180 minutes of medium to physical activity, whether that be going out for a walk, playing sport, going for a jog, doing a road. Can just repeat that set? Only 54%. of Victorians meet the physical national physical guidelines. Yep. That's extraordinary. And what's amazing. Sorry that that's extraordinary in in a in a in a in an underwhelming kind of way. And unfortunately the decrease declining. And it's declining. And what's been really exciting for us, so within the recreation services that we run at the Y, our members of 89% of them are meeting the physical activity levels. And it's the old saying that you know if you're physically fit, you're mentally fit. A hundred percent. So that then leads into mental well being. Life satisfaction. So how happy? That's the way we track that. And a simple question of how happy you are with your life. And we track that over time. And I think the average is 7.22% or seven out of ten. and what we're finding is people that are active really active in community sport and they have those networks and friendships around them, they have a healthier outlook on life. So growing more confidence. Yep, absolutely in their lives. Yeah. you mentioned physical. activity, mental well being. A strong sense of belonging. Yeah. You can mention but also the family impact, your the impact it has on your family, if you're if you've got those connections. And we're talking if we you know we if we can bring it back to center, we're talking w about you know feed of football and people with with with a disability, an intellectual disability, you know, but if they have a sense of belonging and they had that real community connection. Yep. But that's all is that also extends as parents. Yep. That also opens up our network as well, not just for our children with a disability, but it also o also opens up our network as well. And I think I I touched on I think it was in the first episode or the second episode where as much as you're mate to your mates, right? Yep. They don't understand the path going through and having a child with a disability. Yep. They can empathize. And, you know, I've got great friendships and, you know, my best mates are sitting here to me. To be left here. But you do tend to isolate yourself a little bit because you isolate yourself. This is what I speak in personally, because you want a place in a in a safe environment. So not only does open up platforms like this and measuring the impacts of it, but also opens up the the the the friendships and the family impact, not just for your child, but as a family, as a collective. And I think that's the most, there's the the participants. So the in in this case, we've got our children that are going through the program. So we've got all the amazing outcomes that that's happening for them. We've also got those you know, if we're getting someone physically active early on in life, the implications and the and the knock on effect of not going into sort of sedentary behavior and making sure that we're, you know, a burden on the health service later in life, we're introducing some really key, we call them in physical well being. We also look at physical literacy. So there's key motor skills that kids need to learn. They they learn all of that kicking, footing, catching, all of those types of things. you then go for connection and belonging. So at the Y, the when we talk around belonging, we measure four areas to get a belonging score that people feel those four areas. They feel safe. Yep. So in a space so safe with the coaches, with others, with the parents around them. They feel welcome. So it's a place that they can come and they feel welcome. They feel accepted by their coaches and by others on their team. and then the that they belong. And how do you how do you get that data for the So again, that for us is we do that in a survey or an interview format and they and they mark themselves how much do they agree or strongly agree with certain statements. And then that gives us a percentage. Yep. And the the main thing for us then, we're looking at in the generation that we're going in now, we've got a lot of young people who spend quite a lot of time on technology. And, we've got all the challenges with the AI coming in. And the big thing for me is those skills that young people will need around teamwork, around communication skills, all of those are learned through footy. Yep. It's amazing, you know, when Daz and I started this chat some weeks ago. Months back or weeks back now, it's amazing how a footy club growing up in a footy club as as does did as well, does did as well and mate and yourself back in back in the UK, it is a community. I I've got my second job through my, coach at the time. And it is a community. It also it's a good way to weed out dickheads, to be honest with you, because people won't tolerate dickheads, but they'll also embrace people in the right club will embrace the right people. A a football club is part of the it's is the core. To a f to a community. It really is. As the pub is at times, so is a footy club, a career club, it is the core to to all of it. But it should never just be isolated, let's call it mainstream. Yep. You know, this is where I I I I'm doing this and creating this awareness around feeder that it's not just for mainstream people in in society, it's it's open for everyone and that there's platforms here to it. So let's let's put the business case together, right? Happy to help. So One of the things that We feeder all all of the all abilities teams out there that I think we've got I think there's thirty-one teams by memory, close to a thousand participants. Yep. And and and it was highlighted in the second episode where there's no funding. Where we're relying off fees. You've got you've got people with a disability who in their ad adult years struggling to work because they can't for for for varying reasons, still have to pay still have to pay registrations. Yep. we're we're still that there's still and I know John and Logan from FEDA are doing a great job in in in working with the AFL to try and get some funding, but that's yet to be forthcoming. Yep. There and there is such a huge opportunity for businesses to involve themselves into feeder or their all abilities football side. But but let's say I'm a business owner and I'm listening to this and I'm considering putting 10k of me lar of of my hard earned into the feeder or their all my local all about his time. Wha why should I? Firstly, why should I? What's the return for the business? And and perhaps more importantly, what's the return for the community? So we'll go back to why should I? Yeah. And I think one of the main things, the conversation we started talking about before around that theory of change. So as a community organization, if you're able to articulate the impact you have. on the young people in that community, the the the broader network, so the parents and the broader community, you you've got something that is very appealing to to local communities because they want to be seen to investing back into the local community. And you know, first of all, they'll want to know outputs. So the number of people that go in through your programs and services, how many eyes are they going to get on their name associated with with their brand? But also they get to share in those amazing stories. So you talk around a 10,000 investment, but for me, a story that comes out of that of being part of something bigger in your local community. And it, as you said, you'll find in a community around there's so many people out there who mainstream sport and the challenges, the barriers of participation, it just seems so simple for everyone else and it seems so easy. But to be able to be part of that and to make that change. To be able to talk about how you have helped increase young people's confidence, how you have created a space where young people feel that they belong and that they can connect with others, and they feel part of a community. But also those parents, as you said, if you're a local funding community, a a bigger funding community, people talk. They're out and they're at a barbecue and they talk about the great things, that you get past the work conversation and you talk about the great things that you get to do at the weekend. You get to share on a podcast like this. And you get that story around true data. and there's also a lot of larger organizations have, corporate social responsibility or ESG packages. Yeah. Can you talk about, can you touch on ESG and what it st stands for? Yep. and what it actually means. So ESG is obviously the measurement, a corporate responsibility to measure environmental, yep, social. So the impact stuff we're talking about now. and governance of how they run their business. Something I've briefly touched on in my work work life. And and it's a f federal and yep. I'll let you explain it. Yeah, it's and it's being driven by the federal government. Yeah, it's being driven by a federal and a government. We have a lot of organizations out there who they want to make sure that they are doing everything they can to contribute to a healthy community or a healthy society. so making sure, at the Y, we have one of our pillars is a sustainable planet, making sure that we reduce ten thousand tons of carbon by twenty thirty. Yep. From a social impact point of view, we want to make sure that four million people have a better sense of or well being or belonging. So for from our perspective, other organizations out there will be looking to partner with organizations to help them deliver on that because their business might not deliver a broad social impact. And is the ESG, the environmental social governance platform driven by the federal government, is that going to be legislator that They're part of it part of your part of reporting. Part of reporting. Yeah. So so just to return back to that question, let's say I'm a business owner, wouldn't it 10k of me large of me hard earned into feeder or or my local all this podcast because, you know, you y y you sponsor this podcast and and yes, we're looking for a sponsor because it's not doesn't go in my skyrocket. To helping people in the community Who may not have the ability to support themselves. So what we're saying is it can be measured. Yeah. And I think from our perspective, you can have evidence as well as reach the outcomes that we'd live in, the changes in people's lives. And I think for the why, that's one of the main reasons why we've been investing so much in this work, because our community partners, our local councils, our governments that we work with. They have plans and we provide them with the evidence to show that we're delivering on those plans. And I see no reason why, with the right amount of support, and I'm happy, more than happy, as I've said to Nadine many times, to help on that journey so that we can truly understand the. We'll take this question offline. So I do have a question offline to ask you. But if I'm a business business listening today and thinks I want to be a part of us, what can they actually do? I I think a big thing is to look at what you're trying to achieve, what your strategy is and the outcomes you're trying to achieve. And ask yourself, what can I give back to my local community? And what would I expect with that? And what I can guarantee if you come and partner with an organization like this, is you will get endless reach, endless stories, but also you'll be part of something that's making a real difference in our community. I was going to share this story right today, but I'm going to share it very quickly. And it and it still brings a tear to my eye. And I'm going to digress here and go off, go off topic a bit I was at the Riding for Disabled function a function ten years ago at my local Caribbean park. I I changed a guy's life and I didn't know I did. Right. It was an auction and it was an auction item and and Smiley's name is a severely disabled out elderly man. if you're out there smiley, get a he he him and his his his helper, they had ten dollars between They they wanted to they wanted to ten years on, I'm still getting emotional talking about it, right? And ten years on and He just wanted to buy an Esky, you these little foam eskies. It was ten it was ten bucks. Anyway, long story short, he put his hand up, some scumbag in the crowd outvoted him. So they put their hand up and they've got twenty dollars. And got to thirty, got to for forty. And a friend of mine, Liz McEwen, said, Hey Trev, just buy the buddy thing. So I did. And I paid 70 bucks for this little Leskey and I walked up to Smiley and I said, Here you go, mate. This is for you. I I didn't realise the impact that had. I just sat down and went, let's crack a beer. Mm-hmm. That changed my life, to be brutally honest with you, because it gave me gave me the feeling of the art of giving, giving something back, right? That's ten years ago and I still get emotional about it. The year later, he rocked up to the same to the same function for the riding for disabled with that ESC with a couple of Cascade lights in there to share with me. So I sat down and had a couple of beers with him, and a year later I saw him washing cars at Toyota a chook and I said, G'day Smate Away, guys, you know who I'm because you bought me the ESC. My investment was only seventy dollars and it was an i and it was an eskey that that that changed his life. But he had no idea that changed my life. Yeah. That changed my life. That really did. And as a business, businesses have the ability to change people's lives. I changed one. They have the ability to change people's lives. That impacted me severely, but so in such a positive light, you know, amazingly positive light. and businesses out there can change a whole group of a collective of of people. So, you know, but we move on, you know, and this is probably the final and the mo I reckon one of the most powerful questions I've got. If you can change one thing about the way businesses and governments evaluate community programs like feeder, what would it be? I'd go two pronged. the I think the most important thing for us is long term ongoing investment. Yep. what we see nowadays is a lot of quick hits. They want to get a good news story and then they're on to the next one. Yeah. what the the biggest change I would love to see is we talked around five key social outcomes together today. Yeah. For us, can we imagine if we we expanded that? And then we looked at the links between community organizations and local investments in companies. And we're talking around five, 10, you know, local footy clubs have been around forever. You know, programs, I know it's only been going for a couple of years, but can you imagine the impact in five, 10, the amount of families like ourselves who are out there a little bit lost and are looking? And you You might have a most significant change story where we've just shared, a couple of stories today around we're just going through life, we're trying to make a difference. And I think that's the biggest thing for us. The opportunity of coming together and trying to lean into some of these challenges that we're facing together. Yeah. I think will be, you know, if we measure and we have the evidence to prove they're having making a difference, that's the thing. That is the really big thing for us. Because I an anecdotal story is amazing and is really powerful. But an ana a story with evidence of impact and the economic value that it brings, the savings to healthcare for different things, is a a real opportunity, is the way I do it. And I think that's what keeps me coming to work every day. You know, we run a diverse business, but I see in all of the communities we work, so many families who are just trying to get by, they're trying to figure it out. There's So many stories out there and I am just privileged to be able to help share within, a relatively large organization some amazing stories to the community. Yeah. It's been and you hit the nail on the head there like one of the previous episodes. We spoke about, you know, we had people who who came to the the Alpha Mall Ability site who questioned the fees. They have to pay fees. Now, which led to, you know, understanding getting trying to trying to get investment in into this platform through for reasons we said before, but we can measure your investment. Yep. But that by measuring the investment, and hopefully that promotes more people to start really diving into how to invest into feeder and all abilities sports. But also, geez, it opens up communities. It opened it's opened up like Friday night, I watched the grand final. My son's grand final, Alpha All Abilities, C grade, well done, great win. unbelievable we know celebrate a bit hard. We watch it Friday night. I'm texting one of the one of the parents there and I'm just having a ball, you know, Friday night having a having a beer. But it's changed my life in a positive way. So but if businesses have the ability to who wanna who wanna invest into this platform, the main message is it can be measured and your investment can be measured. Yeah. And I think a really important thing is, you know There's there's the stories that we talk about, there's then evidence that shows that. And but I think the opportunities that it creates for other partnerships and other opportunities, those connections when you start talking around a shared goal and shared outcomes, it it for me is where it gets really exciting. And I think, you know, whether you run a club for 10, 15, 50, 100, 5,000 people, you know. The inve you will never regret that investment into truly understanding, stopping and thinking, what is it that we want our program to achieve? Yep. Yes, it does lots of things, but what's most important to us? And really investing the time and gathering that data to truly tell back up those amazing stories that we all have. Totally agree. And you you give me a completely different perspective on this journey that I that I've started and will continue to go for a long time. And because we talk about social impact, it's easy to talk about numbers and measurements and quantitative data and outcomes, but ultimately behind every number is a person. Absolutely. And that's why I want to finish this episode by telling you a story. That still continues to break my heart, right? So I read this story. I was having dinner by myself up in Sydney last week or two weeks ago, and it was about a on October 5th this year, a a 15-year-old boy from Ararat who has autism and epilepsy was targeted through what he believed is a genuine friendship. He had been communicating with a group of teenagers through Snapchat and and excited at the possibility of making new friends, he traveled to store to meet them. But what he believed was an opportunity to make friends. It turned into an ambush and he was assaulted and had his douche shoe stolen. That's terrible. I broke down, I had to leave the table. It absolutely broke me heart and it still does, mate. It breaks me hard because not just what happened, not just what happened to him. It's because what he was looking for. Yep. He was looking for friendship. He was looking for connection. Yep. He was looking for something where he belonged. Yeah. You know. And that's and that's why I do this podcast. You know, feeder can't prevent every bad thing from happening in someone's life. But what feeder can do and all the all all abilities sport can do is create a place where people with a disability can come together and make friends, play football, be a part of a team, and more more importantly, feel like a sense of belonging. And sometimes belonging is isn't just about playing sport. Yeah, sometimes it's about knowing that there is somewhere you can go. Somewhere where you're accepted. And exactly what you said before, somewhere where you're safe. And somewhere you're a part of something. We're doing this podcast to try and grow to continue growing awareness that there is there is environments out there where people like that poor kid don't have to go searching for friends. And I want to keep growing this awareness of this journey and with the help of the the business partners out there who want to get on board and that now you can under understand that your investment into this can be invested, can be measured, can be monitored, can be delivered. Ian. You're a champion. I appreciate you coming and sharing the story around this. We'll keep talking. I look forward to helping map out the journey and pull together that evidence to really help those businesses invest. You're a good man. this isn't just about football. It's more than a game because it is to those who are a part of it. Thank you, Ian. Until next time, let's keep the game going. Growing.