Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 137 – Why we don’t spank our children
Transcript
- 0:43Hello, and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD, and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com.
- 0:50And last week, Gary Thomas posted an article on his substack on the topic of discipline versus punishment.
- 0:57Not taking a stance, but rather offering it up as a controversial conversation starter.
- 1:03And reading it made me curious about something. Does your view of hell change your parenting approach?
- 1:10After all, if God is our example, and you believe that hell is eternal punishment,
- 1:15does that lend to a more heavy-handed approach to parenting versus someone who believes that hell is an act of mercy?
- 1:23And I posed that question in our forum, and that led to a discussion on using physical punishment.
- 1:29And I spent a fair bit of time in the last week or two writing on that thread,
- 1:32so I thought I'd repurpose it here for those who might be curious about how we raise our children and why.
- 1:38Because we, that is, Christina and I, don't believe that hell is eternal torture.
- 1:43We don't believe such a view is in keeping with the Bible.
- 1:47And while we both grew up in a denomination that taught that it was,
- 1:51it was one of the reasons we left, because the doctrine couldn't stand up to either biblical scrutiny or logic as we saw it.
- 1:58And if you want to know why and or argue that stance, I fully welcome you to read the post,
- 2:04What Happens When You Die, that I wrote about four years ago now.
- 2:08But that's not the point of this episode.
- 2:11The point of this one is to share why we don't spank our children,
- 2:15and now that my children are growing up into adults, what the outcome of such a choice has been.
- 2:20And before we get to that, though, just quickly, if you haven't filled out the survey yet, please go and do that.
- 2:26This is probably your last chance to get your data in.
- 2:29I'm probably going to be doing the analysis for next week, whether we hit 1,000 or not.
- 2:35We only need 100 and some odd left to go, so if you want to help us hit 1,000 responses,
- 2:41really it wouldn't take many of you to jump in and do it.
- 2:44And with that out of the way, let's get to the topic at hand.
- 2:47Now, I think hell is one of the greatest showcases of God's character.
- 2:52When I was growing up, I was raised in a denomination that taught that,
- 2:55one, you are either predestined for heaven or hell, and free will is an illusion.
- 3:01Number two, that hell is eternal torture.
- 3:04And number three, that very few people will go to heaven, relatively speaking.
- 3:10And so I grew up being taught that God created everyone,
- 3:13randomly picked a few selected to go to heaven,
- 3:16and the rest he would torture for eternity for a choice that he didn't make.
- 3:21It also made evangelism a bit of a farce, but that's a topic for another day.
- 3:26And this set of beliefs to me does not depict a loving God.
- 3:29Rather, it shows an entity that gets closest to deserving eternal torment
- 3:34than any other being I've met or heard of.
- 3:38And even then, I think the punishment is overkill.
- 3:41I mean, this depicts an evil worse than history's largest villains.
- 3:45It is the equivalent of having children, choosing one at random to treat like a king,
- 3:49and then torturing the rest while simultaneously keeping them alive.
- 3:54Except in this case, it's trillions of children, and they are alive forever.
- 3:59Even if you believe in different variations of this,
- 4:01for example, maybe you believe in free will,
- 4:04then you're still left with a father raising children that he fully intends to torture
- 4:08the vast majority of beyond their natural lifespan.
- 4:12In this case, an infinite lifespan.
- 4:15And if this is the view of God that you hold to,
- 4:17and you somehow have managed to hold on to the cognitive dissonance that it is loving,
- 4:22then I completely understand why one could be deceived into thinking
- 4:25that beating your children is a loving act.
- 4:28It is because your view of love is distorted.
- 4:32Now, when I grew up and started studying it for myself,
- 4:35I learned more about God and hell and realized that,
- 4:38one, God picks all of us.
- 4:41Number two, we don't all pick God.
- 4:45Number three, if we pick God, then our works are the evidence of that choice,
- 4:49but it is the choice that keeps our name in the book of life.
- 4:53If we do not choose him, then our names are blotted out.
- 4:56And lastly, eventually, God will destroy sin.
- 4:59And if we have chosen to stand with sin, then we will be destroyed along with it.
- 5:05God is not keeping sin around,
- 5:07and he's certainly not participating in the sin to keep it around
- 5:11and keep us continually being tortured by it for eternity,
- 5:15because that would make him an evil God.
- 5:19And again, I'm going through this quickly because my intent is not to debate hell.
- 5:22I did that in the other posts, which I'll link to in the show notes.
- 5:26But this paints a very different picture of God and subsequently love.
- 5:31God is not a cruel person who created the majority of mankind only to see them tortured for eternity,
- 5:37an eternity that he manufactures.
- 5:39Rather, God created us to be free in the hopes that we would see sin for what it is
- 5:44and choose life with him.
- 5:46If we do not, then we go back to where we came from.
- 5:50Nothingness.
- 5:51No harm, no foul in the grand scheme of things.
- 5:55In this situation, death is a mercy.
- 5:58It is a final loving act.
- 5:59It is the acknowledgement that a child has grown up and chosen to disown his father.
- 6:05And so all support is removed at their request.
- 6:08In this case, it just so happens that their very existence comes from the father.
- 6:12So when you remove that inheritance, the only possible outcome is death.
- 6:18Not because you were killed, but because you rejected life and it was removed from you.
- 6:24It is God saying, I wish you had chosen differently, but I will respect your wishes.
- 6:28If we choose death and destruction, then we get death and destruction.
- 6:32And with this view of God and love, the idea of hell being torture is, well, it makes no sense.
- 6:40This God, this love is focused on grace, on mercy, and on relationship.
- 6:45You know, what utility does hell have?
- 6:48It teaches nothing because you cannot come back from it.
- 6:51It doesn't build a relationship because you are cut off.
- 6:54It doesn't build discipline because you cannot grow anymore.
- 6:57It doesn't bring hope because there is no hope in hell.
- 7:00It doesn't even teach anyone else because Judgment Day is the same day for everyone.
- 7:06And that happens after Christ returns.
- 7:09The very idea of eternal hell by a God that is loving is nonsense.
- 7:15And in the same way, claiming to love your child using this view of God and his love by beating them is nonsense.
- 7:23And you know that if you take a second to think about it, because the hypocrisy jumps out pretty quickly.
- 7:29You know, if your child hits another child, and in response you tell them not to hit people, and then you hit them, what do they learn?
- 7:37Well, they're primarily going to learn that their parent is a hypocrite.
- 7:40But, of course, if they point that out to you, you will become enraged, and so you'll likely hit them again.
- 7:46And what part of that is loving?
- 7:48You know, we taught our children that it's not okay to hit people.
- 7:53Now, there are some exceptions.
- 7:55They know that they can defend themselves, and they understand when violence is allowed, such as during martial arts training.
- 8:01But in day-to-day life, violence is not okay.
- 8:05And that rule goes for children as well as parents.
- 8:07I have hit my kids when we were training, but I'm using 1% of my strength or less, and they've got pads on to protect them.
- 8:16They're also anticipating it, and they know this is not for punishment, because we don't hit people because we're upset with them.
- 8:25And outside of that, I've never had to hit them, because the only other acceptable use would be if my life was threatened,
- 8:32and I have never had my life threatened by my own children.
- 8:34So, I don't get to hit them.
- 8:38And many people have told me over the years that children should have a healthy fear of their parents.
- 8:43To me, this just teaches your children to run from you rather than towards you when there's trouble.
- 8:48You build better liars and deceivers, but not better people.
- 8:52You know, my parents raised me this way, and to this day, I would not go to them for advice if I was in trouble.
- 8:58I would run from them and go somewhere safe, because I do not see them as safe people.
- 9:03I wanted better for my own children.
- 9:07And now, when my children make mistakes, they come to me.
- 9:11They ask for help.
- 9:12They ask for forgiveness, knowing that it will be given.
- 9:15And we don't punish them for mistakes.
- 9:18There may be consequences, but that's not the same thing.
- 9:21Often, we negotiate the consequences with them, because ultimately, they need to learn how to set their own consequences to bad decisions and make their own rules.
- 9:30And honestly, sometimes they choose harsher punishments than I do.
- 9:35My kids call me out, actually, for not holding them accountable for their punishments.
- 9:40If I let them off the hook, down the road, they will probably tell me that I probably shouldn't have done that.
- 9:47Usually not in the moment, because they're happy to have whatever restriction it was lifted.
- 9:51But later, looking back, they realize that that may have not been the best thing for me to do.
- 9:58And do they sometimes still try to hide and deceive?
- 10:01Yeah, especially when they're younger.
- 10:03Adam and Eve did the same thing, even with a perfect father.
- 10:06But as they get older, they come to us more easily, asking for help before problems arise.
- 10:13And if there is a problem, their parents are the first people they turn to.
- 10:18And I wanted that relationship with them, and I'm glad to say it's worked out that way.
- 10:23And if our theology is correct, we should see evidence of that in real life.
- 10:28And this is one of the reasons I like running surveys.
- 10:31I like seeing the intersection between theology and practical application.
- 10:35So this week, I did some searching for large meta-studies, studies collecting data from multiple other studies.
- 10:43And I'll put two of the links in the show notes of the ones that I read through.
- 10:47And here are some of the stats that I found.
- 10:50Firstly, somewhere between 70% to 90% of parents spank their children.
- 10:56Second is that corporal punishment from parents leads to higher aggression rates in their children.
- 11:02It becomes a cycle of the child being more aggressive, the parents ramping up their aggression to match it,
- 11:08and then the child, of course, responding with more aggression, bringing more physical punishment.
- 11:14Spanking also doesn't make children more compliant in the short term.
- 11:18It's not linked with long-term compliance either or internalization of morals.
- 11:23Because they don't adopt what they should do, they only flee from what's hurting them.
- 11:28And if you have ever met a Christian running from hell versus one that is drawing closer to God,
- 11:35you know that those aren't the same thing at all.
- 11:38Spanking is not linked with reductions in aggression or antisocial behavior.
- 11:42It's actually linked with worse, not better behavior in children.
- 11:47And it is associated with significantly more aggression and antisocial behavior problems.
- 11:53Not one of the studies in this meta-study showed a link between spanking and better behavior.
- 12:00Now, these were pulled from 75 studies over 50 years from 13 different countries.
- 12:06160,000 children were included.
- 12:10So if spanking children worked, we should see evidence of it.
- 12:13Instead, statistically, we see the opposite.
- 12:16While all the wished-for behaviors that I hear from parents who spank their children,
- 12:21my children seem to have picked up without the need to spank them,
- 12:24such as internalization of morals, less aggressive, better behavior,
- 12:29and a good relationship between parents and kids, as well as with their siblings.
- 12:33But it actually gets worse than this.
- 12:3775% of abuse cases against children in Canada start as physical punishment that gets carried away.
- 12:44Children who are spanked are seven times more likely to be severely assaulted by their parents.
- 12:49Infants who are spanked are 2.3 times more likely to require medical attention
- 12:53due to an injury inflicted by a parent.
- 12:57In fact, what they found in the meta-analysis is that spanking has all the same outcomes as physical abuse,
- 13:04only with two-thirds of the strength and correlation.
- 13:07So this means it is abuse.
- 13:09It's merely less severe.
- 13:11And I found it interesting, too, that kids who have been spanked
- 13:16are more likely to develop anxiety and depression disorders.
- 13:20They have more difficulties in school and with skills of regulation.
- 13:24There's also correlation between physical punishment
- 13:27and decreased brain gray matter in areas associated with performance on intelligence tests.
- 13:33And further studies showed that spanking a child from ages 2 to 4
- 13:37shows, on average, a 5-point drop in IQ.
- 13:41Between the ages of 5 and 9, it's a 2.8 drop in IQ.
- 13:45And the correlation gets stronger the older they are when you stop spanking them.
- 13:51Countries where spanking is more prevalent tend to have lower national IQs as well.
- 13:56So you are literally taking away their intelligence by spanking them.
- 14:00So in summary, kids who are spanked have higher aggression, lower conflict resolution skills,
- 14:05they have a higher chance of depression, anxiety, and other mental disorders,
- 14:09and an increased struggle with self-regulation.
- 14:12And this all sets them up to struggle more in their marriages when they grow up as well.
- 14:17And yet, kids who are spanked tend to have a more positive view of physical punishment,
- 14:22and so they are more likely to use it on their own children.
- 14:27And to me, this sounds like a generational curse if ever there was one.
- 14:32Now, people will say, you know, doesn't the Bible tell us to beat our children?
- 14:36And there are some confusing Bible verses that get brought up when this topic is discussed.
- 14:40Probably the strongest one that is brought up is Proverbs 23, verses 13 to 14.
- 14:46And it says,
- 14:47Do not withhold correction from a child, for if you beat him with a rod, he will not die.
- 14:52You shall beat him with a rod, and deliver his soul from hell.
- 14:56And the problem with this verse is that Proverbs is often poetic instead of literal.
- 15:01And you may think that's a cop-out until you read Exodus 21, verse 20, where it says,
- 15:07If a man hits his servant or his maid with a rod, and he dies, he shall be severely punished.
- 15:14So the problem here is that the Bible says that if you beat a grown man or woman with a rod,
- 15:20you may very well kill them.
- 15:22And that makes sense, because a rod is not a small stick.
- 15:26It is a club.
- 15:28It is a wooden equivalent of a mace.
- 15:30In fact, David used a rod to kill lions and bears.
- 15:34So as for what this proverb means, there is lots of debate, and I'm not entirely sure myself.
- 15:42But it certainly cannot mean what the plain reading is,
- 15:45because both logic and the Bible tell us that you very well can kill a child by hitting them with a rod.
- 15:51And for myself, I don't build doctrines out of verses that contradict the rest of the Bible.
- 15:57I would rather set that one verse aside for a time until I grow in understanding,
- 16:02rather than set the rest of the Bible aside in favor for that one verse.
- 16:06Because nothing about beating a child with a club seems to line up with the rest of Scripture.
- 16:11Lastly, the most common verse I hear is Proverbs 13, verse 24.
- 16:16He who spares his rod hates his son, but he who loves him disciplines him promptly.
- 16:23And the problem with this verse is that people no longer know what a rod was used for.
- 16:28A shepherd's rod, like I said, is a short club-like stick.
- 16:32It is a symbol of authority.
- 16:34You know, the kings and pharaohs had rods.
- 16:35They had scepters, that's the same kind of thing.
- 16:38And it was also used to guide sheep, to count them.
- 16:42But the only time it is used to hit someone or something is when you're hitting an enemy,
- 16:47like a bear or a lion or someone trying to steal your sheep.
- 16:51And then you are literally trying to kill them.
- 16:54This is a weapon in those situations.
- 16:57And so I believe, in light of the context of the culture that it's talking about,
- 17:03this is not talking about physical violence against your children,
- 17:06but rather authority and guidance.
- 17:09Discipline comes in many ways, and violence is the lazy and, I'd argue, evil route to do it.
- 17:17So for us, we are glad we chose not to spank our children from the beginning.
- 17:22Is it harder?
- 17:23Absolutely.
- 17:23You have to use your brain, patience, gentleness, kindness, self-control,
- 17:29and other fruit of the spirit in place of violence.
- 17:32No one ever said it was going to be easy, but it has been worth the effort for us.
- 17:37And statistically, it seems like it's not a fluke.
- 17:40Now, if you disagree, want to debate, have questions, want to share your experiences, etc.,
- 17:45feel free to post them in the comments.
- 17:47I am not afraid to have people disagree with me.
- 17:51In fact, I welcome to the discussion.
- 17:53And if you agree, I'd love to hear from you in the comments as well,
- 17:57so that people don't feel like they're alone if they choose this path.
- 18:01Like I said, these studies say 70 to 90% of parents choose to spank their children.
- 18:07So when you don't, you can certainly feel like you're the odd man out.
- 18:12But then we as Christians should be comfortable feeling that way anyways.
- 18:15And that's what I wanted to share with you today.
- 18:19Once again, don't forget to take the survey if you haven't yet.
- 18:21Funnily enough, it does have a question about spanking, I believe, although in a very different context.
- 18:27And that's it for today.
- 18:28Talk to you next time.