Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / White Culture
Transcript
- 0:01The sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:10Hello and welcome to My Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:13This is a show where a stand up comedian and a therapist who are
- 0:16sisters talk to you. Here's my sister.
- 0:18Hi, I'm Laura Ryan, Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist
- 0:21and sister to the stars, Virginia Jones.
- 0:24Laura, what is our topic? This week, our topic this week
- 0:27is what is white culture? So Virginia, what do you think
- 0:30white culture is? You know, when I think of white
- 0:32culture, I think of a term that we used to use that we don't use
- 0:36anymore for a lower middle class upbringing that involves a lot
- 0:41of junk food. Our mother's Frito Pie salad,
- 0:44which had, I think, five ingredients.
- 0:47Fritos, melted cheese Whiz, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, Well,
- 0:52and Taco meat, of course. It was a classic.
- 0:54Let's be honest, that was a banger.
- 0:55It was a banger. Look, Donna's kitchen, I've.
- 0:58Duplicated it as an adult hey there's just certain things that
- 1:01is I look at I'm like wow that is really white.
- 1:03One of them is scrapbooking writing ATV.
- 1:07I think that honestly planning weddings is a super wide
- 1:10activity. Anything about conspicuous
- 1:13consumption and junk food seems super white.
- 1:16There's just things that you say, wow, that's super white of.
- 1:19US consumerism, poor quality food, and a lot of attention to
- 1:24like memory creation it seems like.
- 1:27Creating the cult of your own family and kind of worshipping
- 1:30at that cult. What do you think?
- 1:31I mean, I think it's lots of things.
- 1:32I think it's mayonnaise. I think it's ugly sweater
- 1:36parties. I think.
- 1:37Oh. Yeah, I hate that liking
- 1:40something because it's bad aggravates me a lot.
- 1:42Yeah, I think it's indie rock music.
- 1:46I think it's record players. I suggest you go talk to the
- 1:50Furious 5 and Grandmaster Flash about that.
- 1:53I think it's liking comic books. I was noticing that 'cause I
- 1:56went to the pre comic book day and it was wall to wall whites.
- 2:00It is a pretty white activity. Swing dancing's pretty white.
- 2:03Activity. Oh 100% So I was inspired to
- 2:07make this episode. It was actually Madonna that
- 2:10brought this episode to my mind. I was looking at pictures of my
- 2:14trip to Belize, which is extremely white to do, to go to
- 2:17an island, take advantage of the local culture.
- 2:20But I was noticing in the tags on my phone that was La ES la
- 2:23Bonita. And then I was thinking about
- 2:25Madonna and because I have a DHDI, went on a rabbit hole and
- 2:28I was thinking about all the things Madonna has done that are
- 2:32Co opting other cultures. We have Vogue, which is, you
- 2:35know, the queer trans community, low SES, BIPOC community.
- 2:39It's not necessarily just Black, but BIPOC community in New York,
- 2:43Evita, the Argentinian population, like a prayer, which
- 2:48was really where I took pause. I remember thinking at the time
- 2:52the video came out, I mean, don't go watch it 'cause you'll
- 2:54cry. But I remember thinking at the
- 2:56time, oh, she's, she's so controversial.
- 2:59You know, she's doing sexual things in a church, but it's so
- 3:04white savior complex, it's so racist, and it's just horrific.
- 3:09Madonna. Papa don't, Papa don't preach.
- 3:11She's Co opting the experience of pregnant teens.
- 3:14That's not really a cultural. Experience justify my love.
- 3:17She's Co opting the experience of sluts.
- 3:19I think she was a firm member in that group.
- 3:22I think she did actually belong there.
- 3:23But yes. So what is white culture
- 3:26exactly? Well.
- 3:28I mean I think you make a good point.
- 3:29White culture is Co opting other cultures.
- 3:33Yeah, pretending you made stuff up that you didn't and making it
- 3:36more palatable for white people. But like Elvis Presley, Justin
- 3:40Timberlake, right? Modern day Jack Harlow, it's all
- 3:43white people doing black person impressions and that's what
- 3:47white people are interested. In well, even things that you
- 3:49and I really like. Like your Tom Waits.
- 3:51He's just doing an old Blues man.
- 3:54So I was watching a TikTok video of all these BIPOC kids who are
- 3:58watching old videos and listening to old music.
- 4:01So they were listening to Michael McDonald.
- 4:03He got sued by Holland Dozier because they had a song by a
- 4:08black artist. I keep forgetting.
- 4:09No, I didn't the same. Song.
- 4:12Yeah. Essentially the same song.
- 4:14I was not aware of that, but you're doing an impression of a
- 4:16black person. Jim Croce.
- 4:18I'm being faced with a lot of things these days.
- 4:21Well, I'm realizing hey, I'm part of the problem.
- 4:24Wolfman, Jack. Yeah, Tom Waits.
- 4:28I remember specifically because my father was a huge Michael
- 4:31McDonald fan and I turned him on to Tom Waits.
- 4:35And the way I did it was I just put CD in the player.
- 4:38He didn't see the, you know, cover or anything like that.
- 4:40And that was one of our places where we bonded.
- 4:42And I remember maybe a year in or something, I don't know, he
- 4:46looked him up or something. He's like, wait, that's a white
- 4:48man. He had no idea.
- 4:50Well, that's normal for a white guy from, you know, the suburbs
- 4:54of California to, to sing in that format.
- 4:56That makes sense. So there's an article in the
- 4:58Guardian called What is White Culture exactly by Mona Chalabi.
- 5:03Anita Thomas, an associate professor of counseling
- 5:06psychology at Loyola University, said regarding Rachel Dolezal,
- 5:11in some ways it's normal, but not at her age.
- 5:13Many white adolescents behave similarly to Dolezal, attempting
- 5:17to take on what they perceive to be the characteristics of
- 5:20another race while exploring their own identities.
- 5:22Being quote the other End Quote sure as hell has its downsides,
- 5:26but it turns out that not being the other does too, especially
- 5:29if you're a teenager. For white American youth who are
- 5:32disconnected from European heritage or legacy, it often
- 5:34feels like whiteness as a concept is empty.
- 5:37Thomas added in a quote that has really stuck with me.
- 5:39It seems to tie together some disparate thoughts I have had on
- 5:42white as an adjective. Rachel Dolezal was treated as if
- 5:46she were a bizarre outlier, but she's part of a much bigger
- 5:49pattern of white behavior. It includes Mez Mesro.
- 5:52In the 1930s, this jazz musician declared himself a quote,
- 5:55voluntary Negro End Quote after marrying a black woman and
- 5:59selling marijuana, and includes the millions of white Americans
- 6:02who take DNA tests and proudly reveal that they are in fact X
- 6:05percent non white. This all ultimately finds that
- 6:08the concept of whiteness isn't empty.
- 6:10If white culture remains vague, then it can lay claim to every
- 6:13recipe, every garment, every idea that is not explicitly non
- 6:17white. That would mean that my identity
- 6:18is just a sum, that my non whiteness can only be understood
- 6:22as an abstraction from the totality of whiteness.
- 6:24I refuse to be a remainder. OK So what we're saying is
- 6:27Rachel Dolezal, even though we act like she was a freak, she
- 6:30was just one extreme of a spectrum of Co opting black
- 6:35experience. I mean, Justin Timberlake, he
- 6:37was a freaking Mouseketeer and then suddenly he's speaking in
- 6:41what would be termed a black scent and making music.
- 6:45That is not okay. There are definitely comics
- 6:49you're Matt Rife that talking to black scent.
- 6:51It's very aggravating to me. I think the whitest thing you
- 6:54can do as a child is take a hip hop dance class and there
- 6:59doesn't seem to be anything. Any of us can do.
- 7:02About You cannot stop a girl from Kentucky taking a hip hop
- 7:06dance class. It just continues to happen.
- 7:08Even one of my recent heroes, Ryan Gosling, was recorded
- 7:12performing hip hop dance as a 12 year old.
- 7:15Not a cute look, Ryan. I think he may have made-up for
- 7:18it since then. The way that I started to become
- 7:21aware of white culture, it was this website called Stuff White
- 7:24People Like. Do you remember this?
- 7:26I do remember it. So I'm going to read some of the
- 7:29camping. If you find yourself trapped in
- 7:31the middle of the woods without electricity, running water, or a
- 7:34car, you would likely describe that situation as a quote
- 7:37nightmare or a quote worst case scenario, like after a plane
- 7:41crash or something, and quote white people refer to it as
- 7:44camping. When white people begin talking
- 7:46to you about camping, they will do their best to tell you that
- 7:49it's very easy, and it allows them to escape the pressures and
- 7:52troubles of the urban life style for a more natural, simplified,
- 7:55relaxing time. Nothing could be further from
- 7:57the truth. In theory, camping should be
- 7:59very inexpensive since you're literally sleeping on the
- 8:02ground, but that's with anything in white culture.
- 8:04The more simple it appears, the more expensive it actually is.
- 8:08I've always been curious about why we like to camp, because I
- 8:11certainly don't. Evidently it comes out of the
- 8:13German military and like kind of cosplaying a German military
- 8:17person in nature. That made a lot more sense to me
- 8:20that we're just pretending to be soldiers.
- 8:23But you do it with your dad. That's super weird.
- 8:26Here's another one from the stuff white people like book.
- 8:29White people are drawn to farmers markets like moths to a
- 8:33flight. In fact, white people have such
- 8:35strong instincts that if you release a white person into a
- 8:38random Saturday morning, they will return to you with a
- 8:41reusable bag full of fruits and vegetables.
- 8:43All white people are born with a singular mission in life.
- 8:46In order to pass from regular white hood into ultra white
- 8:49hood. Just as Muslims have to visit
- 8:51Mecca, all white people must eventually renovate a house
- 8:54before they can be complete. White people love ethnic
- 8:56diversity, but only as it relates to restaurants.
- 8:59You've. Hit me with a couple things
- 9:00pretty hard. I'm going to lay this on you.
- 9:02White people love organic food. 100,000% you know I've fallen
- 9:08for it. The same thing about Christian
- 9:10Landers observations is that they are 100% accurate.
- 9:13That's the hurtful part. OK, so this kind of ties into
- 9:16your swing dancing interests. One thing that white people like
- 9:19is historically black music that black black people do not listen
- 9:23to anymore. Historically speaking, the music
- 9:26that white people have kept on life support the longest period
- 9:29of time is jazz. Thanks largely to public radio,
- 9:32bookstores and coffee shops, jazz has carved out a niche in
- 9:35white culture that is not yet ready to be replaced by and.
- 9:38You know, and Speaking of Ryan Gosling, in the film La La Land,
- 9:42he also taught black people about jazz. 100% that's why I
- 9:46didn't watch La La land because I was like this is giving cringe
- 9:49so hard that parts. Of it are cringy but it's very
- 9:52cute. The biggest role that jazz plays
- 9:54in white culture is in the fantasy of leisure.
- 9:57All white people believe that they prefer listening to jazz
- 10:00over watching television. This is not true.
- 10:03No, no one does. When I was in college, I went to
- 10:05a college that was very well known for its jazz program and
- 10:09had a really strong musician population.
- 10:12The thing about jazz bows is that they're the main consumers
- 10:16of jazz. The people who play it are the
- 10:18people who listen to it, just like there's more people who
- 10:21write poetry than read poetry. It's become a recursive act.
- 10:24Absolutely. So every few months a white
- 10:26person will put on some jazz and pour themselves a glass of wine
- 10:30or Scotch and tell themselves how nice it is.
- 10:33I will get bored and watch or write emails to other white
- 10:37people about how nice it was to listen to jazz.
- 10:41Quote. Last night I poured myself a
- 10:43glass of Shiraz and put on Charlie Baker on the bows.
- 10:47It was so relaxing. I wish I had a fireplace.
- 10:49End Quote. Listing this activity as one of
- 10:52your favourites is a surefire way to make progress towards a
- 10:55romantic relationship. Than white First.
- 10:57I've had a lot of questions and am uncomfortable with the degree
- 11:01to which Lindy Hop and swing dancing is by and for white
- 11:05people these days. The people who are the very best
- 11:07at it in the world, the people who study it are Swedish.
- 11:10One of the biggest camps in the world is is in Sweden.
- 11:13And whenever I see a person of color doing swing dancing,
- 11:17especially like a young queer one, I just want to give them
- 11:19$5. I'm like, yeah, stay with us.
- 11:21Come on. Please stay.
- 11:22Please make this not feel like a mayonnaise factory every day.
- 11:25Please make this not feel completely illegitimate.
- 11:28Every day. Well, and also, I think it would
- 11:30make me feel a little gross. You're like, wow, all of these
- 11:34upper middle class white people have taken on this thing that
- 11:37historically black poor people were doing.
- 11:40Along with jazz, white people have been taking quite a shine
- 11:43to the Blues, an art form that captured the pain of the black
- 11:47experience in America. Then in the 1960s, a bunch of
- 11:50British bands started playing their own versions of the music,
- 11:53and white people have been loving it ever since.
- 11:55Yeah. The black man impression that
- 11:58Mick Jagger has been doing for 60 years is super embarrassing.
- 12:02It's super SUS and embarrassing. I was also thinking about, you
- 12:06know, you're talking about jazz. A fellow white at my college was
- 12:09telling me about how he was taking a jazz appreciation class
- 12:13where he had to sit down and spend hours of time in a
- 12:17classroom to learn to appreciate jazz.
- 12:19And I said, hey, if it doesn't come naturally, I think it's
- 12:22kind of weird that you feel like you have to take a class on it.
- 12:25If you have to learn how to appreciate a style of music and
- 12:28it doesn't naturally come to you, maybe it's because it's not
- 12:30for you. I'm going to argue this and say
- 12:32sometimes because something is not dominant in the culture, you
- 12:36don't have the equipment to appreciate it.
- 12:38So I think there is validity in taking an appreciation course
- 12:42for an art form that you don't know very much about.
- 12:45Well, I remember in another SUS move, I took a class in college
- 12:50that was all about blaxploitation, the films and
- 12:55books. And do you know how many black
- 12:57people were in my class? None, people.
- 13:00Correct, but again, why the hell was I taking that class?
- 13:04Why am I learning about icebergs?
- 13:06Slim don't know how to make a. Pimp Stick.
- 13:09Here's something extremely white that I really like, and I've
- 13:12discussed it before, but free Little Libraries.
- 13:14I love a free little library. That's why it is.
- 13:16I am totally aware that it is. Why is F OK?
- 13:20Ironic tattoos. I mean tattoos in general.
- 13:22Well, David Cross was recently making fun of hipsters and
- 13:25talking about tattoos of toasters on your arm, like a
- 13:28sleeve or a. Sewing machine or a vintage
- 13:31camera. I've often thought, well, there
- 13:33was that moment where mustaches. They handled our mustaches.
- 13:36That's the next one, yeah. Mustaches tried to ruin the
- 13:39culture and then people would get a mustache tattooed on their
- 13:43fingers so they could have an impromptu mustache now I think.
- 13:46Anytime I need it, got it right there.
- 13:48I do think the first person to get a mustache tattooed on their
- 13:51finger was very clever. That's a funny joke.
- 13:55The second person to do it was a giant a hole like in everybody.
- 13:59After that was a classic idiot. So what is whiteness you may be
- 14:05wondering? According to Monica Williams,
- 14:08PhD in Psychology Today, the concept of whiteness was
- 14:11imported from Spain and Portugal during the slavery era, where
- 14:15whiteness was defined to as a way to contrast one's identity
- 14:18as different from slaves. This was devised to create a
- 14:22deliberate hierarchy to define who was privileged, who was
- 14:25property, or a second class citizen.
- 14:26While one can be proud of one's German heritage, French Canadian
- 14:30culture, American nationality, or African American ethnicity,
- 14:34one should not be proud of one's whiteness.
- 14:36Whiteness is a forced group membership that originated from
- 14:39oppressing people of color, and it causes psychological and
- 14:42spiritual damage to white people just as it damages non whites.
- 14:45White Americans are imbued with whiteness from infancy.
- 14:48They do not choose it for themselves.
- 14:50People who look white and who have immigrated to America are
- 14:53generally afforded whiteness upon arrival, whether you want
- 14:55it or not. You'll talk to an American,
- 14:57they'll make a huge distinction between a person from Spain and
- 15:01a person who's a Mexican American.
- 15:03Well, they both speak Spanish. There's the European one.
- 15:06Right, because again, this is all made-up.
- 15:08Ethnicity and culture are good things as long as they're built
- 15:11for the well-being of that group, but not race which is
- 15:14defined by the dominant culture and imposed upon non dominant
- 15:17groups. Why do we keep using the word
- 15:19Caucasian? Crossword puzzles.
- 15:22Crossword puzzles? Scrabble.
- 15:23Yeah, that's super white. Yeah, bicycling long distances.
- 15:27Bicycling is a vacation. Taking your bike to work, beach
- 15:31biking, having a great big old timey bicycle with a basket,
- 15:35having the first aluminum body bike using the Tour de France.
- 15:39These are all super super white. I think talking about Tour de
- 15:42France, talking about European football 0.
- 15:45Something I'm I'm very self-conscious about is a white
- 15:48person is veganism and vegetarianism.
- 15:51Oh 100% that is white AF. It when I started traveling a
- 15:54lot in Asia, I became aware of the level of white privilege of
- 15:59saying I choose not to eat this, this kind of food.
- 16:02Like excited for my own reasons. 'Cause I was going places where
- 16:06you just eat what you have and you're glad to have it and
- 16:09you're like. Wait, you're turning down food,
- 16:12huh? What?
- 16:13Yeah, I choose not to eat this because I think where it comes
- 16:15from sucks. You know what else is super
- 16:17white? And I don't know what order
- 16:19we're going to release these episodes in, but talented and
- 16:23gifted programs. 100% that is white AF.
- 16:27So why do we keep using the term Caucasian?
- 16:29Yolanda Moses looked into that. The term Caucasian originated
- 16:34from a growing 18th century European science of racial
- 16:36classification. German anatomist Johann
- 16:39Blumenbach visited the Caucasus Mountains, located between the
- 16:43Caspian and Black Seas, and he must have been enchanted because
- 16:47he labeled the people they're Caucasians and proposed that
- 16:50they were created in God's image as an ideal form of humanity.
- 16:54Oh my. Sweet Lord.
- 16:55Yes. So his system of racial
- 16:57classification was adopted in the United States to justify
- 17:01racial discrimination, particularly slavery.
- 17:03Popular race science and evolutionary theories generally
- 17:07posited that there were separate races, that differences in
- 17:10behavior were tied to skin color, and that there were
- 17:12scientific ways to measure race. Blumenbach's category of
- 17:15Caucasian a problem because his classification of white also
- 17:20included some N Africans, Armenians, Persians, Arabs and N
- 17:23Indians. The definition of Caucasian had
- 17:26to be reinvented to focus the ideological category of
- 17:29whiteness on Northern and Western Europe.
- 17:32The term, even though it's exact definition changed over time,
- 17:35was used to shaped legal policy and the nature of our society.
- 17:39The. On the topic of like defining
- 17:41race, a lot of terms, they're very uncomfortable.
- 17:44Quadroon Octaroon. It's a decor room defining
- 17:48exactly how much of this perceived blackness was in a
- 17:53person. Well, I mean, it's the whole the
- 17:54whole colorism thing. Have you seen this dating show
- 17:57where you pop a balloon if you don't like somebody?
- 18:00No. So basically a man will walk
- 18:03into a room and stand by the host of the show, and a bunch of
- 18:06women are standing there with balloons and just popping them
- 18:10maybe as soon as they see him or you know.
- 18:13As Nope. Nope, this is not it right?
- 18:15It's I, I can't, I, I can't imagine having any shred of self
- 18:18esteem after it's over. I was watching an episode of it.
- 18:20It was African American gentleman and a bunch of women
- 18:24of different races and he specifically refused the
- 18:29attention of two very dark skinned women.
- 18:31The host asked him. Hey, buddy.
- 18:34What's that? What's that?
- 18:35About well, you know, what's your reasoning for getting rid
- 18:37of them Because they hadn't spoken yet.
- 18:39Like it was literally just looking at them and he made-up
- 18:41some poppycock reason. Man.
- 18:43This is your internalized racism.
- 18:45To circle back to a term that I just learned, Hexadecca run
- 18:49someone who is 116th black. You and I would be Hexadecca
- 18:54Italos if we considered Italian people to be non white.
- 18:59Italians used to be non white right?
- 19:00So there was a court case in 1923 that went to the Supreme
- 19:04Court United States versus Bhagat Singh Indh.
- 19:08They decided that Bhagat was an Indian Sikh who identified
- 19:12himself as an Aryan and he was ineligible for naturalized
- 19:16citizenship in the United States.
- 19:17He filed a petition for naturalization under the
- 19:20Naturalization Act of 19 O 6 which allowed only quote free
- 19:24white persons, End Quote and persons of African descent to
- 19:27become United States citizens by naturalization.
- 19:30And it doesn't have the quote here in the Wikipedia article.
- 19:32But basically the judge said, well, although technically you
- 19:36meet criteria, what we consider Aryan or Caucasian is what the
- 19:41man on the street would consider a cultural.
- 19:43Definition. It's the what it's like just
- 19:46visually, what we look at and say, yeah, that person's a
- 19:49white. Person, which means that it's
- 19:50fake of. Course, it's all fake.
- 19:52All gender stuff is fake. All the stuff that we're super
- 19:55concerned about, high heels and wigs and lipstick.
- 19:58That was how Louis the Sun King. Dressed and like anyone in his
- 20:02court would kick your butt. These are all made-up things,
- 20:05and it's all to define yourself by what you're not.
- 20:08Well, I think it's all to establish a hierarchy and keep
- 20:12certain groups in the hierarchy and others not.
- 20:15The crap part about whiteness is that because of the domination
- 20:19of culture, things that are white are considered normal.
- 20:23Like this is the normal way of doing things.
- 20:25Of course I'm going to put my children in chess camp.
- 20:28Of course I need to have a bilingual toddler.
- 20:30This is normal and everything else is abnormal.
- 20:33Right. Of course, the people that I
- 20:36hired to work as domestic laborers are not white.
- 20:40OK, so in the book The History of White People by Nell Irvin
- 20:45Painter. Although science today denies
- 20:47race any standing as objective truth, and the US Census faces
- 20:52taxonomic meltdown, many Americans cling to race as the
- 20:56unschooled cling to superstition.
- 20:58So long as racial discrimination remains a fact of life, and
- 21:01statistics can be arranged to support racial difference, the
- 21:04American belief in races will endure.
- 21:06But confronted with the actually existing American population,
- 21:10its distribution of wealth, power and beauty, the notion of
- 21:13American whiteness will continue to evolve as it has the creation
- 21:16of the American Republic. And this is something we observe
- 21:19growing up in the South, that the less an individual has going
- 21:23for them personally, the more ferociously they will cling to
- 21:26whiteness like the more important that is.
- 21:29Because if you were happy with your life, if you were happy
- 21:31with your job, if you were happy with your family, if you were
- 21:34happy with your position in society, you would have other
- 21:37things to worry about then who your great, great, great
- 21:39grandfather was. Because I think it's about
- 21:42creating these fake structures. So that you can put yourself on
- 21:45top. And I think that slavery created
- 21:48whiteness because I think that rich white people were noticing,
- 21:52oh, there's some poor whites who are getting close to black
- 21:56people, and there's more of them than us.
- 21:59And so we have to find a way to separate these groups.
- 22:02And so we're going to do it with whiteness.
- 22:04Did you know slavery comes from Slavic, the word Slavic?
- 22:07Because those were the first slaves.
- 22:09Slaves, people. Oh wow, that is interesting.
- 22:12You know, the Greeks sometimes would get enslaved by people,
- 22:15but they would just call it in. Greekify Mostly Greek scholars
- 22:18focused on climate to explain human differences.
- 22:21Humors arising from each climate's relative humidity or
- 22:25aridness explained a group's temperament.
- 22:28Where was the seasons do not change.
- 22:31People were labeled Placid where seasons shift dramatically.
- 22:34Their dispositions were said to display wildness, unsociability,
- 22:37and spirit. For frequent shocks to the mind
- 22:41impart wildness, drawing, tameness and gentleness.
- 22:44Those words come from Hippocrates, air, water and
- 22:47places. If you were from the desert, you
- 22:49were fiery and passionate. If you were from near to the
- 22:54sea, you were pretty chilled. You were chilled out.
- 22:56Right. You might as well to describe
- 22:58different types of people. Or, you know, it makes about as
- 23:01much sense as saying a person who's a descendant of enslaved
- 23:04people is like this. I mean, it's just arbitrary
- 23:07nonsense. It has been interesting as we
- 23:09become the most genetically sorted generation.
- 23:13There's a lot of stories. Of like, my family always
- 23:16identified as culturally Irish and we would cry and talk about
- 23:20Catholicism and eat soda bread. And then when we did our work
- 23:25up, we're not Irish at all. It was just something that
- 23:27somebody was just an idea that somebody had Like, oh, you know,
- 23:30we're passionate. We cry a lot.
- 23:31We're good at, we're good at poetry.
- 23:32We're Irish. We drink whiskey.
- 23:35We drink, we cry, we love our mothers.
- 23:37We're Irish. The problem is, you say, OK,
- 23:39well, this is all made-up, so who cares?
- 23:41But there are real stakes in it for people.
- 23:44You know, when we get into the statistics, I'm trying to avoid
- 23:46making an extremely depressing episode.
- 23:49I'm not going to get into the statistics.
- 23:51But, you know, if you're wondering if black people are
- 23:54killed by the police at a higher rate in America, the answer is
- 23:57absolutely yes, by a lot. I.
- 23:59Don't think anyone's wondering that.
- 24:01Well, so somebody was living in a hole and they just got out.
- 24:05They just got their first iPhone because they don't even know
- 24:08what that is. And they decided this is their
- 24:09first episode. Podcast, but then it's going to
- 24:12be a a series of shocks to the system.
- 24:15Welcome. Welcome to sorry, sorry for
- 24:18sorry about it. For the tough entry.
- 24:21But that's just the way it is. The 18th century created the now
- 24:25familiar equation that converts race to black and black to
- 24:28slave. Back to our friend Blumenbach.
- 24:30Remember that guy, good old Blumenbach, Caucasian man
- 24:34Blumenbach labeled his prize skull.
- 24:36He had a prize skull, which is great 'cause that was also part
- 24:39of the sciences, looking at people's skulls.
- 24:42And he labeled his prize skull beautiful and female Georgian,
- 24:46going on to call the human variety.
- 24:48It inspired Caucasian. A mysterious slippage he didn't
- 24:52explain. Why not call it Georgian, we may
- 24:54ask. Since the skull came from
- 24:57Georgia. The answer may lie in North
- 24:59America, where the newly formed US already had a state called
- 25:02Georgia, and presumably people there were called Georgians.
- 25:05At any rate, during Blumenbach's time, the notion of Caucasian
- 25:09achieved wide circulation. It doesn't matter what word you
- 25:12use, but the important part is that you are making up a list of
- 25:17traits that are quote good and a list that are more desirable and
- 25:20a list of traits that are less desirable.
- 25:22And all of the 20th century white people have been putting
- 25:27forth like, yeah, ideas like, oh, a skull from this part of
- 25:30the world will be more like this.
- 25:31Oh, a Europeans, man, their beard will grow in this way.
- 25:35That's different. We are always trying to define
- 25:38ourselves by what we are not and then elevate what we.
- 25:42Are our group? Yes, right.
- 25:43I remember reading an article about the Catholic Protestant
- 25:47We're going to go back to Ireland the Catholic Protestant
- 25:50issues right? Because Ireland for a long long
- 25:52time didn't have many non white people, but they did have.
- 25:56Leprechauns. Huge divide, right?
- 25:58But they did have leprechauns. They've always had leprechauns.
- 26:00They still do. If anyone's wondering, find out
- 26:02more about that is the Luck episode.
- 26:04But. So they didn't have that many
- 26:07non white right so. They had to find some way to
- 26:10separate this group from that group.
- 26:13And So what happened was Catholic people were moved to a
- 26:17different area of town. There were fences built around
- 26:20areas. You couldn't walk in certain
- 26:22areas at night. Catholics, I think prior to the
- 26:25enslaved people, I think Catholics were the number one
- 26:29beefing group. People just did not like
- 26:31Catholics. And in early American history,
- 26:33there's a lot of stuff that was put up to keep Catholics out of
- 26:37the United States. Catholic versus Protestant
- 26:40versus, you know, whomever. Now a cultural idea is that
- 26:43Irish people stop being a minority through the police.
- 26:46Force right, creating public systems, that's where all the
- 26:49Irish. People ended up and then.
- 26:51Like working for the government. Yeah.
- 26:53And then when we elected John F Kennedy, it was official.
- 26:57You could be Irish and still be valued person and Catholic and
- 27:01Catholic. Have you heard of Jane Elliott?
- 27:04The Blue Eye experiment. Oh, I've heard the of the blue
- 27:07eye experiment, but tell me about it.
- 27:08So Jane Elliott was a teacher in an elementary school.
- 27:12It happened when MLK was murdered.
- 27:16She had this moment where she was like, you know, this is A
- 27:18reckoning for the United States and we need to do something.
- 27:21So she started this experiment where she had children, I think
- 27:24it was for a week. She would separate the children
- 27:26in her class because I think she was in the Midwest.
- 27:28Everyone was white. She would separate them into the
- 27:31brown eyed group and the blue eyed group and the blue eyed
- 27:34group was treated like we treat racial minorities.
- 27:37I've seen interviews with the kids as adults and they were
- 27:40like, it just made me think so differently about the world I
- 27:44live in because these are arbitrary choices, but they
- 27:46really do have real consequences.
- 27:48Well. And I read a thing about
- 27:50advertising and especially advertising to children in the
- 27:54early days of Barbie and baby dolls, and they asked minority
- 27:58children, would you rather have a doll that look like you or a
- 28:01white doll? And they all pick the white doll
- 28:03because they're like that doll. Is that's the good doll?
- 28:06I learned about racism in college where white people learn
- 28:09things. I mean, I knew about racism,
- 28:11obviously, but we'd. Heard of it?
- 28:13I'd heard of it, of course, but I didn't really understand the
- 28:16insidiousness of it and how it affects everything in a person's
- 28:20life. I watched Jane Elliott do a
- 28:21presentation where she was talking to a group of white
- 28:24people, and it was a pretty big theater.
- 28:27And she said, now all of you guys are saying race doesn't
- 28:30matter, you know, who cares? And she said, raise your hand
- 28:33right now if you would be happy to be treated the way that we
- 28:37treat black Americans in this country.
- 28:39And guess what? Not a hand was raised.
- 28:42So we all, we all know it. It's insidious and it's hiding
- 28:45in the background. It's like.
- 28:46The man versus bear argument. Men know why a woman would
- 28:50choose the bear, but they want to pretend that they don't know.
- 28:53You know we know. Because it makes you feel
- 28:55uncomfortable. Because it's uncomfortable.
- 28:57It's uncomfortable to say I would not prefer to be a
- 29:00minority because I've seen how I and other people treat in the
- 29:03country. Right, exactly.
- 29:05Caucasian is a racial terminology harkening back to
- 29:08Blumenbach. The term had more complex
- 29:11genealogy too, one connecting to its larger history of race,
- 29:14beauty, and reactionary politics.
- 29:15I remember when reading the history of white people, I found
- 29:18out that Caucasians were actually some of the first
- 29:21enslaved people and people thought that they were the most
- 29:24beautiful. PT Barnum had two Caucus women
- 29:28as things to look at in his original circus.
- 29:32Beats working. Yeah, they would sit on a bed
- 29:34and brush their hair. I could do that.
- 29:36I could absolutely do that. Anyone wants to pay me to do
- 29:39that, I'm happy to do that. Virginia, have you?
- 29:41Have you heard of Tanahesi Coats?
- 29:43I haven't tell me all about him. So tell me he See, Coats wrote
- 29:46the book Between the World and Me, and in the book it says But
- 29:49race is the child of racism, not the father, and the process of
- 29:53naming the people has never been a matter of genealogy or
- 29:57physiognomy so much as one of hierarchy.
- 29:59Difference in hue and hair is old, but the belief in the
- 30:03preeminence of hue and hair, the notion that these factors can be
- 30:06correctly organizing a society, that they signify deeper
- 30:10attributes which are indelible, this is the new idea at the
- 30:14heart of these new people who have been brought up hopelessly,
- 30:16tragically, deceitfully to believe that they are white.
- 30:19Well. Comes back to the same thing.
- 30:21It comes back to trying to separate people assign as
- 30:25different tribes and different attributes.
- 30:27It's all BS and it's all made-up and it puts some people at a
- 30:30tremendous disadvantage and white people at a tremendous
- 30:34advantage. It's all horse S, right?
- 30:37TA Nehisi Coates also says Americans believe in the reality
- 30:41of race as a defined, indubitable feature of the
- 30:44natural world. Racism, the need to ascribe bone
- 30:47deep features to people and then humiliate, reduce and destroy
- 30:50them inevitably follows from this inalterable condition.
- 30:54People who believe themselves to be white are obsessed with the
- 30:58politics of personal exoneration.
- 31:00Are you obsessed with the politics of personal
- 31:03exoneration? I think we've all come to this
- 31:05point where the true discomfort of whiteness is recognizing the
- 31:09privilege that it has afforded you and that you are part of the
- 31:13problem, even if you don't think you are.
- 31:15What I have discovered is that I am benefiting from it even
- 31:19though I'm not actively doing anything.
- 31:21I recently had an experience going out to a dance club that
- 31:26is not not for white people, and it was me and some friends, all
- 31:31white, and we were wearing crowns because it was my
- 31:34birthday and probably behaving obnoxiously.
- 31:37I've been to this place before, but there's been kind of a sea
- 31:40change I think recently. I think they're just tired of
- 31:43our of our stuff. We felt really unwelcomed.
- 31:46It was a very unusual feeling because it was.
- 31:48Being presented to you that you were invading the space.
- 31:51Right. The woman up on stage was making
- 31:54comments about dumb white women, and a woman started pushing my
- 31:58friend and we just had to leave. And they were both
- 32:01flabbergasted. Yeah.
- 32:03And I said, ladies, we are experiencing in a very minute,
- 32:07very small way, something that every other group in this
- 32:10country experiences every day of their lives.
- 32:13We are being treated as other and we are being treated as we
- 32:17don't belong here. And it was unusual for all of us
- 32:19because we're all privileged white ladies.
- 32:21Yeah. And one wearing crowns on your
- 32:24birthday? Super white. 2 Bachelorette
- 32:26parties. There's nothing more white than
- 32:28that, I think. A gaggle of women screaming
- 32:31there's nothing more white. Than right thing of all is
- 32:35feeling that you're going to be welcome in every environment
- 32:38inherently. And believing that I have a
- 32:40right to be in every environment inherently.
- 32:42I mean that everyone has to make space for you.
- 32:44What I was saying to my friends was, you know, these folks have
- 32:47been dealing with white nonsense all day, probably all week, and
- 32:50this is their weekend and they're thinking I'm not going
- 32:53to spend my free time accommodating white people
- 32:56anymore. It didn't feel good, respected.
- 33:00Oddly, the only time that I've had that kind of experience, it
- 33:04happened after hours in a Russian bakery.
- 33:05And it was a dance club. And everybody in there was
- 33:09Russian, Ukrainian, Georgian. And they did not want us there,
- 33:15even though we were also white. But they could tell by the fact
- 33:18that our genes were not bedazzled that we were not
- 33:21Russian. And you got to say, hey, this is
- 33:24your space. I get it.
- 33:26Right. And I, I think it's very unusual
- 33:29for white people to one acknowledge that and to respect
- 33:33it. One more quote from TA Nehisi
- 33:35Coates. This is from an article by Sarah
- 33:38Ruiz Grossman. TA Nehisi Coates breaks down why
- 33:41white people can't say the N word in a rap song.
- 33:45Thank you. It needs to be said.
- 33:47It needs to be said, white privilege or white people being
- 33:50raised in a society whose laws and culture communicate to them
- 33:53that quote, everything belongs to you and quote, as Coates puts
- 33:57it, makes some white people feel as though they have a right to
- 34:00do anything, including using a word that they have been
- 34:02repeatedly told is inappropriate for them to use.
- 34:05Quote for white people, I think the experience of being a hip
- 34:08hop fan and not being able to use the word and will be very
- 34:12insightful, Coates concluded. This will give you just a little
- 34:17peek into the world of what it means to be black, because to be
- 34:20black is to walk through the world and watch people doing
- 34:22things that you cannot do and quote.
- 34:25That is interesting. When I was coming up in Portland
- 34:27Comedy, my friend Nathan is very funny black comic.
- 34:31He had this bizarre experience where at some point or another,
- 34:35every white dude in our scene asked him if they could say the
- 34:39N word. Are you asking me if I will if
- 34:42me, someone who knows you will be offended if you use the N
- 34:45word in front of me? No, but that doesn't mean
- 34:48anything about the rest of the like I'm not giving you a
- 34:50superpower. This doesn't mean you're not
- 34:52going to be offending people. This doesn't mean you're not
- 34:54going to get your butt kicked. This is not a gift I can give to
- 34:56you. Well, because it's the idea that
- 34:58a racial group is a monolith. I remember, again, I'm a white
- 35:02lady, so this doesn't happen to me much, but I remember living
- 35:04in the UK when George Bush was president.
- 35:07I would not speak to people because I didn't want people to
- 35:10hear that I was American and have them start costing me about
- 35:13George Bush. But right, I can't control you
- 35:15guys. Every group that I went into, I
- 35:18had to justify American politics, and it was exhausting.
- 35:21And that was just a tiny little nothing of life.
- 35:24But let me also say just in general, if you're a white guy
- 35:28and you have a black wife, you're not black.
- 35:29If you're a white guy who's friends with black guys, you are
- 35:32not black. Proximity.
- 35:34Has does not make you belong. I mean, just like that jazz
- 35:38musician who dealt marijuana and married a black woman, you're
- 35:42not a part of that group. You don't have a tattoo
- 35:44sculpture. You're not a part of it, and you
- 35:45don't have to deal with it every day.
- 35:47I think that's the other big difference.
- 35:49I'm reading this book by Madeleine Pendleton when she was
- 35:52talking about how she was trying to get a job and she was going
- 35:56for a more lucrative job, kind of a fancier job.
- 35:58And so she took out her nose ring.
- 36:01She dyed her hair brown and she wore clothing to cover her
- 36:05tattoos because she could pretend and be accepted, right?
- 36:09She could pass. But if you're a black person,
- 36:10you can't just take out your nose ring.
- 36:12You're just, you're that all the time.
- 36:13And so you just have to deal with that all the time.
- 36:15You don't get to decide when you're going to be in the
- 36:18accepted group and when you're not.
- 36:19I was. Talking to two comics women of
- 36:22color yesterday, but we were talking about the very
- 36:25aggravating thing for them of being in front of industry and
- 36:29being told to be more Asian, be more Dominican, be more black
- 36:35for the amusement of white people.
- 36:36Like that's the product that we want from minority performers.
- 36:40We want racial stereotypes to be a print.
- 36:42We want to have our beliefs confirmed and like every
- 36:45minority comic, if you do an exaggerated impression of your
- 36:49mother, that's just like printing money and we put it on
- 36:53them. It's very frustrating and it's
- 36:56aggravating and I think the whitest thing of all is.
- 36:59What do you think is the whitest thing of all?
- 37:02Having this conversation. I think you're correct.
- 37:05There was an interview that I saw with Jake Johnson from New
- 37:08Girl and Hannah Simone. She is also from New Girl.
- 37:12But he was asking her, you know, what was it like for you to get
- 37:15this job? And she said, well, I had
- 37:17stopped acting for years and years because they kept asking
- 37:20me to play South Asian stereotype characters.
- 37:23I'm not going to do that. I'm just going to be a person,
- 37:25and she said this was the first job where they just told me I
- 37:28could be a person. I didn't even have to talk about
- 37:30my race. On the show, I'm an American and
- 37:33this is what I look like. And here's where I am.
- 37:35Virginia, what are your closing thoughts on this super fun
- 37:39topic? Well.
- 37:41I think it's never a bad idea to examine why you think the things
- 37:46about yourself that you do, what you cling to.
- 37:49I'm not going to be ashamed of my love of tap dancing and comic
- 37:52books and indie rock music, but I'm aware of the particular
- 37:56space that occupies in the culture.
- 37:58Laura, what are your final? Thoughts.
- 38:00I just think it's such a complicated issue.
- 38:02As I was doing the research for this episode, I could make this
- 38:0515 episodes because there's so much here.
- 38:08I think all white people listen to black people, listen to
- 38:12people from other groups. Read, learn stuff and just try
- 38:17in your in your own corner. Just try to make the world a
- 38:20better place for the people around you.
- 38:22You know, it's also super. White saying your own corner.
- 38:24And telling people to read stuff.
- 38:26Go to your local library after you've heard about it on your
- 38:29local community radio station. Laura, where can people find you
- 38:33online? Should they?
- 38:34Choose to they can find me at lauraryan.org.
- 38:37They can also find me on TikTok at I am Laura Ryan or they can
- 38:41check out the shows Instagram account at My Sister's A
- 38:45Therapist. Virginia, where can people find
- 38:47you? You can find me at badinia.com.
- 38:50BADINIA. That's also my TikTok and my
- 38:52Instagram. The message that I want to give
- 38:55everybody listening to this right now, giving five stars is
- 38:58great. That's fantastic.
- 39:00We love that. We need your words because we
- 39:03want to read it. Virginia how do people reach out
- 39:05to the show if they want to contact us?
- 39:08If you want to talk to us, you can write us at Hello at My
- 39:11Sister's a therapist.com. We are happy to receive
- 39:14feedback, show ideas, compliments, any kind of
- 39:18Starbucks gift cards that you can send by e-mail.
- 39:21And if you'd like to hire us to speak at your women's
- 39:24conference, mental health conference, women's leadership
- 39:26event, Wellness event, women's retreat, educational seminar,
- 39:30corporate retreat, or workshop, you can write us at Hire Us at
- 39:33My Sister's A therapist.com. You can also go to My Sister's A
- 39:36therapist.com to find all the episodes of this show.
- 39:39And Laura, this is the part of the show where we read review.
- 39:41Do you have a review to share with us?
- 39:43This week I certainly do. This one is called funny and
- 39:48informative. The user is called UN.
- 39:51Thank you UN. Virginia and Laura keep me
- 39:54interested in laughing throughout this pod.
- 39:57Love all the different topics. Thank you.
- 40:01That was short and sweet. But we really appreciated it.
- 40:04In closing, I want to remind us all of the cultural icon Billy
- 40:09Ray Valentine. Capricorn, my personal hero.
- 40:13Hero. And someone we think about every
- 40:15day when he said we can make it baby.
- 40:19Me and you.