Latest / The Vegan Report / Why Do People Care About Animals? | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00This is Bastian Jäger for the vegan reports.
- 0:03I am an assistant professor of social psychology
- 0:06at Tilburg University in the Netherlands. And
- 0:10today I want to talk about some studies that
- 0:12I conducted recently together with various collaborators
- 0:15on the link between sentience and specifically
- 0:19people's beliefs about whether other animals
- 0:23are sentient and their concern for animal welfare.
- 0:28Now, as a psychologist, one of the core questions
- 0:32I want to answer with my research is what makes
- 0:37people care about animal welfare, whereas others
- 0:41often don't. So if you're listening to this,
- 0:44you are probably weird, just like me, because
- 0:48you care quite a lot about animal welfare. This
- 0:51is not true for most people. They might say so,
- 0:55but it might not be necessarily reflected in
- 0:57their actual behavior, how much time and money
- 0:59they spent on this. So I want to understand what
- 1:03explains this difference. Why do some people
- 1:06care, whereas others don't? And I also want to
- 1:11understand why we tend to care about some animals,
- 1:16but less about others. So most people actually
- 1:19care quite a lot about the welfare of a dog.
- 1:22but less so about the welfare of a bird and even
- 1:27less so about the welfare of a shrimp. So fundamentally,
- 1:33my research tries to understand what is that
- 1:37determinant, what is that quality or attribute
- 1:40of an animal that makes us care about their welfare.
- 1:45And more importantly, What do lay people, what
- 1:50do regular people, not in philosophy, not in
- 1:53biology, where we might try to come up with a
- 1:55normative answer to this question, what should
- 1:58we rely on when deciding whether we should care
- 2:01about someone, something, an entity? But I'm
- 2:06more interested in how regular people, not philosophers,
- 2:10spontaneously think about these questions and
- 2:13what actually determines whether they care or
- 2:15not. So if you go back to philosophers like Jeremy
- 2:22Bentham, John Stuart Mill, they of course wrote
- 2:26about this question from the normative perspective.
- 2:29So they tried to find answers to the questions,
- 2:33when should we care about the interests or welfare
- 2:37of another individual? And of course, you might
- 2:41be familiar with this quote, Jeremy Bentham famously
- 2:44wrote, the question is not can they reason nor
- 2:47can they talk, but can they suffer. And this
- 2:50is also picked up in a lot of the communication
- 2:54by animal advocates. So for example, in Peter
- 3:00Singer's book, Animal Liberation, he writes,
- 3:04the limit of sentience is the only defensible
- 3:06boundary of concern. for the interests of others.
- 3:10Now, as a psychologist, I'm of course more interested
- 3:14in what regular lay people think than in what
- 3:19philosophers think. We should think about moral
- 3:23concern and the role of sentience in it. But
- 3:26before I tell you more about the studies that
- 3:30we ran in order to better understand what kinds
- 3:34of qualities or attributes people pay attention
- 3:38to when deciding whether they should show concern
- 3:41for an entity's well -being. It's probably good
- 3:45to get some definitions out of the way because
- 3:48there is a lot of confusion in the scientific
- 3:51literature, but there's also some confusion in
- 3:55just conversations by lay people and communications
- 3:59by institutions. where different terms are sometimes
- 4:04used to communicate the same idea or different
- 4:09terms should be used because actually people
- 4:12are talking about very different things. So in
- 4:14order to avoid some confusion here, let's just
- 4:16quickly go over some basic definitions because
- 4:19when it comes to caring about animals and why
- 4:22we should care for their welfare, you often hear
- 4:26people reference consciousness. the question
- 4:29of whether different animals are conscious. And
- 4:33in the following, I will just treat consciousness
- 4:37or I will define consciousness as there being
- 4:40any kind of subjective experience. So Thomas
- 4:44Nagel famously had the example of a bat and the
- 4:48question of what it's like to be a bat. So this
- 4:50quality of that it's like to experience something
- 4:55like to see the color blue is like to get hit
- 5:00by a stick. These are all subjective experiences
- 5:03that individuals, humans, or non -human animals
- 5:06can experience. And this is what I mean when
- 5:09I say consciousness. Now sentience, I and many
- 5:14others usually define this as a subcategory of
- 5:18consciousness. So these are specific types of
- 5:22conscious experiences. And specifically, these
- 5:25are types of conscious experiences that have
- 5:29some valence, that feel positive or negative.
- 5:32If you simply look at a white wall, like I'm
- 5:37doing right now, there's nothing really positive
- 5:40or negative that I feel. I experience something.
- 5:44I'm conscious of that white wall. But I don't
- 5:47necessarily experience any positive or negative
- 5:50feelings. Now, sentience is specifically that
- 5:54capacity to experience positive and negative
- 5:57feelings. So we're talking about pain, happiness,
- 6:00pleasure, sorrow, fear, hunger, all of these
- 6:05different things that we associate with often
- 6:09strong feelings of positive emotions or negative
- 6:12emotions that is captured by the term sentience.
- 6:17Now, I also quickly want to measure two other
- 6:19terms that often come up in these debates or
- 6:23these questions. First one is intelligence. This
- 6:26is a term that I won't be using or typically
- 6:30don't use in my research on this topic. I rather
- 6:34talk about agency, which is a term that captures
- 6:38not people's ability to feel things or animals
- 6:41ability to feel things, but animal's ability
- 6:45to do things. You can think about it this way.
- 6:48So these are capacities for self -control, memory,
- 6:53planning, navigating through the world. These
- 6:57are all kinds of capacities that we would group
- 7:00under the label agency. And there are some philosophers
- 7:03that say, wait a minute, it's not only animals'
- 7:08feelings, whether they're capable of experiencing
- 7:11pain or pleasure, that should matter from this
- 7:14normative point of view. It's also their agency,
- 7:18whether we allow them to follow their goals,
- 7:22pursue whatever motivations they have. That's
- 7:28also important from a moral perspective. All
- 7:32right, so with this out of the way, I want to
- 7:35give you an overview of three research projects
- 7:39that I've been working on in the past year or
- 7:43two, which all in different ways tried to look
- 7:47at the role of sentience and other qualities
- 7:51in predicting whether or not people will care.
- 7:55whether people will be concerned about the welfare
- 7:59of animals and other entities. Today I want to
- 8:04share findings from three projects. And the first
- 8:09paper that I want to tell you about was a collaboration
- 8:12with my former student, Martin Boston. And in
- 8:16that study, we had a look at a seminal paper
- 8:22in the literature on moral concern in literature
- 8:26that tries to understand what makes people care
- 8:29about some individuals and less about others.
- 8:32And that was a study that was published in 2007
- 8:34in Science by Heather Gray, Kurt Gray, and Daniel
- 8:39Wagner, where they really tried to answer two
- 8:43questions. The first one is, how do people think
- 8:47about the minds of other beings? That could be
- 8:51a robot, a human, a non -human animal, even God.
- 8:55And what they did is they asked participants
- 8:59to rate different kinds of beings, so different
- 9:04kinds of humans and non -human animals, on all
- 9:08kinds of different mental capacities. So they
- 9:12asked, for example, whether that entity was capable
- 9:15of experiencing pain or pleasures, capable of
- 9:20planning or self -control or memorizing things.
- 9:24on all different things, different kinds of qualities
- 9:27or attributes that might be important in how
- 9:31people think about their moral status. And then
- 9:34they ran something that is called a factor analysis,
- 9:39basically trying to understand the structure
- 9:43that describes people's ratings on all these
- 9:46different kinds of attributes. And what they
- 9:49found was that there are basically two dimensions
- 9:52along which people rate other entities' minds.
- 9:56The first one they called experience. So this
- 10:00includes individuals' capacities to experience
- 10:04pain, hunger, pleasure, and other affective states.
- 10:09You might think, well, this sounds a lot like
- 10:11sentience. And like I said, different people
- 10:13have been using different terms for pretty much
- 10:16the same concept. This, I think, is one example
- 10:19of this. So this is basically the perceived sentience
- 10:23of different entities. So this is one dimension
- 10:26on which people evaluate others' mental capacities.
- 10:31And the second dimension that emerged from this
- 10:34analysis they called agency. So these are capacities
- 10:38for self -control, planning, being able to memorize
- 10:42things, these kinds of things that help you do
- 10:45stuff in the world. So this was basically their
- 10:49answer to the first question. How do people think
- 10:52about the mental structure or mental capacities
- 10:55of others? And there seems to be this two -dimensional
- 10:58structure where people mostly judge others' perceived
- 11:02sentience and their perceived agency. And crucially,
- 11:06the second thing they did in that paper was to
- 11:09ask participants to rate for all these different
- 11:11entities and targets that they rated on different
- 11:15mental capacities. They also asked them to rate
- 11:19how difficult or how bad it would be to harm
- 11:24that entity. And what they found in their analysis
- 11:28was that specifically the entities perceived
- 11:32sentience predicted whether or not participants
- 11:36would feel particularly bad when harming that
- 11:39entity. So the stronger they thought the entity
- 11:42was sentient, the stronger their capacity. for
- 11:45experiencing pain and pleasure, the more wrong
- 11:49they thought it would be to harm that entity.
- 11:54Perceived agency was also related to concern
- 11:58for the entity to wanting to avoid harming that
- 12:01entity, but to a much weaker degree. So it seems
- 12:07to be the case that when it comes to the question
- 12:10of how lay people think, When is it particularly
- 12:14wrong to harm an entity? When should you be concerned
- 12:18about an entity's welfare? It is specifically
- 12:21their perceived sentience that seems to guide
- 12:23them in answering that question. So that fits
- 12:26really well with philosophical perspectives which
- 12:30have emphasized sentience to be a key determinant
- 12:34of when we should care about an individual. study
- 12:40is now quite old, almost 20 years old. So what
- 12:46we wanted to do is have another look at this
- 12:48finding, because this is a really central finding
- 12:50that has been cited quite a lot. This is probably
- 12:53the most prominent explanation for when people
- 12:57care about an entity that is particularly their
- 13:01perceived sentience. But in follow -up work,
- 13:03there has been some mixed evidence. Sometimes
- 13:07studies found support for this idea, sometimes
- 13:10less so. Sometimes agency was actually more important.
- 13:14And importantly, there was also some follow -up
- 13:16work which suggests that maybe people don't organize
- 13:19the mental capacities of others, not in these
- 13:22two dimensions of perceived sentience and perceived
- 13:25agency. Maybe they're actually three dimensions.
- 13:28Maybe agency actually splits up into two dimensions
- 13:31that we might call perceptual cognitive skills,
- 13:36like memory, organization, self control, and
- 13:40socio emotional, or socio moral skills, like
- 13:45being able to tell right from wrong, being able
- 13:48to judge others intentions, think about how others
- 13:52are feeling. So these more empathy related kinds
- 13:55of skills that might be important in social interactions.
- 13:59So there's been some work that's found that these
- 14:03three dimensions, perceived sentience, perceived
- 14:07perceptual cognitive agency and perceived socio
- 14:10moral agency, that these are better dimensions
- 14:15to make sense of how people spontaneously judge
- 14:19others minds. So one thing that we wanted to
- 14:23do is see if we could replicate their work in
- 14:28a cross cultural setting. So we wanted to test
- 14:31if perceived sentience is the key mental dimension
- 14:36for predicting when people will care about the
- 14:40welfare of others. When we also look at this,
- 14:44not only in Western North American or European
- 14:48samples, which has been done most of the time
- 14:50in the past and previous studies, but when we
- 14:53sample people from more diverse cultures. And
- 14:57the second thing that we wanted to focus on is
- 15:00use these three dimensions as predictors. So
- 15:04look at the different roles of socio -moral capacities
- 15:09and perceptual cognitive capacities, because
- 15:12perhaps these socio -moral capacities, which
- 15:15haven't really been researched a lot in the past,
- 15:17maybe they are actually more important because
- 15:21some philosophers say that morality is basically
- 15:25a contract between people of acting morally,
- 15:28which ultimately works out nice for all of us,
- 15:31to put it very briefly. And in order to enter
- 15:34in such a social contract with other individuals,
- 15:38you of course need to be able to tell right from
- 15:40wrong, to understand others' motives and intentions.
- 15:44So maybe these social -moral capacities are actually
- 15:46quite important in how people think morally about
- 15:50others. So what we did is we measured people's
- 15:54perceived or people's ratings of the perceived
- 15:59mental capacities of 14 different entities. So
- 16:03this included non -human animals like a chimpanzee,
- 16:06a dog, a pig, a bird, a fish, or a fly. But we
- 16:10also wanted to sample a wide variety of targets.
- 16:13So we also asked participants to rate a typical
- 16:16human adult, a human adult in a coma. a one -month
- 16:19-old human embryo, a tree, an artificial intelligence
- 16:23system, and some other targets. And each of these
- 16:26targets was rated on their perceived mental capacities,
- 16:31so their perceived sentience and their perceived
- 16:36socio -moral capacities and perceptual cognitive
- 16:39capacities. And crucially, we also asked participants
- 16:42how wrong it would be to harm that entity. And
- 16:46what we found in Basically, all six countries
- 16:50was a very similar pattern of results, which
- 16:55nicely replicates actually that initial finding
- 16:58by Gray and colleagues that perceived sentience
- 17:02seems to be key. So you might have heard about
- 17:04the replication crisis and the social sciences
- 17:07more broadly. The sciences more broadly is only
- 17:12happened in the social sciences that a lot of
- 17:14initial findings cannot be replicated. called
- 17:18into question, this was actually a finding that
- 17:21we were able to replicate years later with a
- 17:25sample of more than a thousand participants from
- 17:28six very diverse countries. We sampled people
- 17:31from Italy, Nigeria, Brazil, Saudi Arabia, India,
- 17:35and the Philippines. And basically in all six
- 17:38countries, when we predicted how much people
- 17:43thought it was wrong to harm a specific entity,
- 17:46What predicted that rating was their perceived
- 17:50sentience, whether they thought that specific
- 17:53entity was more or less able to feel pain and
- 17:58pleasure. Now, these other two dimensions didn't
- 18:02really show a strong association with people's
- 18:06moral concern for the different entities. What
- 18:08really was the strongest predictor was perceived
- 18:11sentience. So the results of this project suggest
- 18:18that lay people seem to agree with utilitarian
- 18:22philosophers and other philosophers and many
- 18:26animal welfare advocates in that sentience is
- 18:31really key. Whether or to what extent an animal
- 18:36can feel pleasure or pain is at least one of
- 18:40the most important determinants of how much we
- 18:44should care about the animal, how much protection
- 18:47an animal might deserve, and how much we should
- 18:51worry about causing harm to that animal. Now,
- 18:55I say one of the strongest determinants of people's
- 19:00concern because Where, while in this study, we
- 19:04looked at different mind dimensions, different
- 19:07mental capacities that might predict people's
- 19:10concern. These are, of course, not the only determinants
- 19:13that people might care about when weighing the
- 19:17kind of moral birth of a target. So in a follow
- 19:22-up project that I'm working on with Maddie Wilkes
- 19:26and Kasper van Lyssa, we wanted to zoom out a
- 19:30bit more. And try to answer this question a bit
- 19:35more generally, the question being what makes
- 19:39people care about a animal, different targets.
- 19:45So again, we looked at non -human animals, but
- 19:48we also looked at different humans, embryo, child,
- 19:53a fully grown adult, a human in a coma, a person
- 19:56from another country versus a person from your
- 19:59own country. And we also looked at environmental
- 20:02entities like a coral reef or a famous mountain
- 20:07in your own country. So again, we wanted to take
- 20:10a very general look, a very general step at this
- 20:13question. What attributes or qualities make people
- 20:18care about the welfare of others? And in this
- 20:21study, we not only measured these mental capacities,
- 20:26so perceived sentience or perceived agency, But
- 20:30we actually reviewed the entire literature on
- 20:33the psychology of moral concern, and we tried
- 20:36to identify all the different factors that have
- 20:40been proposed as important determinants of moral
- 20:44concern. So these are perceived attributes of
- 20:48the target, like their perceived sentience, but
- 20:51also their perceived beauty, their perceived
- 20:53vulnerability, or how harmful they might be.
- 20:58And we also looked at individual differences.
- 21:02So nothing specifically about the attributes
- 21:04of the target, but the attributes of the person
- 21:07who is making that judgment who is or is not
- 21:11showing concern for another being. So we also
- 21:14try to identify all of these factors. So we,
- 21:17for example, looked at empathy, social dominance,
- 21:21orientation, how much people think that a hierarchy
- 21:25is normal to have in social life, and identification
- 21:31with all beings. So these are all factors, all
- 21:35individual differences or attributes that have
- 21:38been proposed as important predictors of how
- 21:41much concern people show for the well -being
- 21:44of others. And what we're doing right now, like
- 21:47I said, this is an ongoing project, so I can
- 21:49only provide some preliminary insights into what
- 21:54we actually find there. We're still running the
- 21:57analysis. What we actually do is we run some
- 22:00machine learning models. So we do some fancier
- 22:04statistics where we basically throw all of these
- 22:07different predictors, all of these different
- 22:09factors into one big statistical model in order
- 22:14to see what sticks. These have all been proposed
- 22:18to varying degrees as important predictors, but
- 22:21how important are they actually? So we're basically
- 22:24doing a horse race between all these different
- 22:26kinds of predictors to see which ones can predict
- 22:30people's concern for others' welfare best. And
- 22:35while we're still running these analyses, some
- 22:37preliminary results suggest that, again, perceived
- 22:42sentience seems to be one of the most important
- 22:45predictors of people's moral concern. So this
- 22:49is a sample where we recruited participants from
- 22:52the United States. This is, however, a nationally
- 22:57representative sample. So in the previous study,
- 22:59we had very diverse participants from diverse
- 23:01cultures, but these were not representative samples.
- 23:04Here we only have people from the US, but this
- 23:07is a representative sample. We have a much broader
- 23:10list of entities of different kind of human and
- 23:13non -human beings that people rate. And we have
- 23:16all these different kinds of predictors that
- 23:18have been proposed to be important determinants.
- 23:21And what we again find here in this context is
- 23:25that perceived sentience seems to be one of the
- 23:29most important qualities that makes people care
- 23:32about the welfare of an entity. So we're still
- 23:36working on that. Stay tuned for the results there.
- 23:39But again, we seem to find evidence that supports
- 23:43the findings from that first study that sentience
- 23:45is really important. Okay, so both philosophers,
- 23:53but also lay people seem to agree that sentience
- 23:56matters when it comes to attributing moral concern
- 24:00to different kinds of beings. So the next question
- 24:04that I had then was, do people actually recognize
- 24:09that Some animals are sentient. Do they tend
- 24:13to over attribute sentience to animals? So do
- 24:17they tend to attribute sentience to animals that
- 24:19are probably not sentient at all? Or are they
- 24:22more skeptical about animal sentience than they
- 24:26should be? So they fail to recognize that some
- 24:29animals are sentient, even though they are. Because
- 24:32that question, of course, has important consequences.
- 24:35If sentience is what is needed for people to
- 24:38care about an entity, then it would be really
- 24:41bad if people fail to recognize that a specific
- 24:45animal is sentient. And therefore they might
- 24:49treat that animal in an indifferent or harmful
- 24:52way because they think wrongly that that animal
- 24:55is actually not sentient. So in order to answer
- 24:58that question, we of course have to know which
- 25:02animals are or to what extent they are sentient,
- 25:06how rich they're. inner mental lives are when
- 25:09it comes to experiencing positive and negative
- 25:12feelings. And we could then compare people's
- 25:15own beliefs to those ground truths to those actual
- 25:20states of the world to figure out if people under
- 25:23attribute or over attribute sentience to animals.
- 25:26Now, unfortunately, we don't really know that
- 25:30much about the inner mental lives of animals,
- 25:33or at least we cannot with confidence. rank or
- 25:38even say whether different animals can or cannot
- 25:41experience certain affective states. This is
- 25:45a famously difficult question that has kept philosophers
- 25:49and biologists busy for many, many decades. And
- 25:53I think it will keep them busy for many decades
- 25:56to come. So this is unfortunately not one thing
- 25:59that we could do to better understand people's
- 26:02beliefs about animal sentience. What is maybe
- 26:05the next best thing, and this is what we did
- 26:09in this study, is we can compare people's beliefs
- 26:12about animal sentience, about animals' mental
- 26:16lives, with the beliefs of experts. So these
- 26:20would be evolutionary biologists or other scientific
- 26:23experts that study animal behavior and animal
- 26:27minds for a living, and that we would hope have
- 26:31kind of the best estimate. of animal sentience
- 26:35that we have right now. So for this project,
- 26:39I teamed up with Stefan Leitch, who's a social
- 26:43psychologist, and with Matthew Zippel, who is
- 26:46a biologist. And we wanted to compare whether
- 26:50or we wanted to test whether lay people are more
- 26:53or less likely to think that different animals
- 26:56are conscious and that they're sentient so that
- 26:58they have emotional experiences. compared to
- 27:01scientific experts, compared to experts on animal
- 27:05minds. So for this, we relied on a sample of
- 27:09100 evolutionary biologists and other scientific
- 27:13experts that Matthew had recruited for an earlier
- 27:16project, where they were asked for eight different
- 27:21kinds of animal groups. So this was non -human
- 27:24primates, other mammals, birds. fish, amphibians,
- 27:28and non -avian reptiles, octopuses, squids, and
- 27:31cuttlefish, insects, and other vertebrates. For
- 27:35each of these categories of animals, they were
- 27:38asked to rate how much they believe that those
- 27:44animals are conscious. So specifically, they
- 27:48were asked whether they're aware of their own
- 27:51existence, these animals. and whether they show
- 27:54emotional responses. So not the most direct measures
- 28:00of sentience given our earlier definition, but
- 28:04this is what they were asked in this project.
- 28:06So what we did then is we recruited, again, a
- 28:11nationally representative sample of US Americans,
- 28:15and we asked them exactly the same question for
- 28:18exactly the same kinds of animal groups. that
- 28:23these experts were asked about so that we could
- 28:26compare whether people are more or less skeptical
- 28:28than the experts about the consciousness and
- 28:32emotional lives of these different animals. And
- 28:36what we found in this project was that, in generally
- 28:39speaking, across different species, across different
- 28:43animal groups, laypeople were less likely to
- 28:47attribute both consciousness and emotional experiences.
- 28:51to these different kinds of animals. So one of
- 28:54the bigger differences was, for example, for
- 28:58octopuses. So the experts, 63 % of the experts
- 29:04thought that most nearly all or all octopus,
- 29:09squid and cuttlefish are aware of their own existence,
- 29:13whereas only 43 % of laypeople thought that.
- 29:18And around 71 % of experts thought that they
- 29:23have emotion experiences, whereas only 38 % of
- 29:27all lay people thought the same. So similarly,
- 29:31big differences were found for the consciousness
- 29:34and emotion experiences of fishes, for example.
- 29:37So for many of these groups, the lay people were
- 29:41systematically more skeptical, were systematically
- 29:43less likely to think that these different animals
- 29:47are conscious and have emotional experiences.
- 29:52Now, another thing we measured in this study
- 29:55was people's confidence in their beliefs. These
- 29:58are, of course, famously difficult things to
- 30:01study. Knowing about other people's minds is
- 30:04already difficult. Knowing about the minds of
- 30:07non -human animals is even more difficult. And
- 30:10what I found really striking was how confident
- 30:15laypeople actually are in their beliefs. So not
- 30:19only were they overall relatively confident in
- 30:22their beliefs, they were also more confident
- 30:25than our experts in their beliefs. So no matter
- 30:28what they were thinking, no matter if they thought
- 30:31that a certain animal has emotion experiences
- 30:34or doesn't have emotion experiences, In general,
- 30:38they tended to be more confident in their judgments
- 30:41than our scientific experts. So overall, it seems
- 30:46like people are less likely than scientific experts
- 30:49to think that various types of animals are aware
- 30:54of their own existence, are conscious, and that
- 30:57they're able to experience emotions, which again
- 31:00comes really close to this question of whether
- 31:02or not they're sentient. So, what does all of
- 31:07this actually mean for animal advocacy, for the
- 31:12mission to make people care more about animals?
- 31:15Well, on the one hand, our results suggest that
- 31:19whether or not people believe that an animal
- 31:21is sentient is really key for whether or not
- 31:24they care about the welfare and interests of
- 31:27an animal. And the other finding that we see
- 31:32in these studies is that people tend to be more
- 31:36skeptical about animal sentience than experts.
- 31:40They tend to under attribute consciousness and
- 31:44emotional experiences to animals relative to
- 31:47evolutionary biologists and other scientists
- 31:50who should know quite a lot about this topic.
- 31:54So what does it actually mean? So one thing it
- 31:57could mean is that in messaging, in advocacy,
- 32:02we should focus on highlighting animal sentience
- 32:06in order to make people care about the animal's
- 32:10lives. I don't think there's a lot of research
- 32:14that has directly tested this, so I'm very curious
- 32:17to see some people actually try this out, to
- 32:21see some interventions that test what happens
- 32:24to, let's say, people's beliefs about animal.
- 32:27animal lives or animals' moral worth or their
- 32:30meat consumption when you highlight that these
- 32:33cows and pigs and chickens that they eat are
- 32:36actually able to experience pain. I am not very
- 32:42confident. This is just my own intuition. I am
- 32:45not very confident that this will be more effective
- 32:49than, for example, highlighting factory farm
- 32:53conditions or talking about practices like tail
- 32:57docking, but perhaps putting these two together
- 33:01might actually prove to be pretty effective.
- 33:04So maybe some people are not already moved by
- 33:07information on factory farm conditions because
- 33:10they think, well, yeah, it looks bad, but these
- 33:13animals have actually experienced this. They're
- 33:16not really experiencing that much. They don't
- 33:18really have rich inner mental lives. They might
- 33:20not really experience pain like we do. They might
- 33:24not really suffer like humans would. And actually
- 33:27educating them about scientific evidence, which
- 33:30shows that many, many animals, including all
- 33:33of the animals that humans typically eat, do
- 33:37have rich inner mental lives and do have the
- 33:40capacity to suffer. Maybe putting those two together.
- 33:43will actually make for a more convincing argument
- 33:46and for a more persuasive message to, for example,
- 33:50curb meat consumption. So this is something that
- 33:53I'm curious about. This is something that I hope
- 33:56at some point to test or maybe someone else will
- 33:58pick this up. So this is where I also want to
- 34:02leave you for today. I hope you found this interesting.
- 34:05Thank you for listening. I appreciate your interest.
- 34:07And if you have any questions or comments, feel
- 34:10free to reach out. You can find my contact information
- 34:14by just googling for Bastian Jäger, Tilburg University.
- 34:18And there you can also find a list with all of
- 34:21my work. And you will also find the specific
- 34:25papers that I discussed today in case you want
- 34:27to have a closer look. All of them are free to
- 34:30download, accessible. If not, then simply drop
- 34:34me an email and I can send them to you. Alright,
- 34:37that's it from me today. I hope you'll tune in
- 34:40for future episodes of The Vegan Report.