Latest / DIVEBOMB Formula One Podcast / Episode 6 - Surprises In Singapore
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to another episode of the Dive Bomb F1 Podcast.
- 0:03I'm Maham and I'm joined by my 2 wonderful Co hosts Marie and
- 0:06Rohan. Today we'll be doing a Singapore
- 0:08Grand Prix review and like always, I'm not going to wait
- 0:10too much longer before starting because there's so much that we
- 0:13have to cover. Today.
- 0:15I want to start with our race winner George Russell, because
- 0:17if there was anyone that I could have predicted to have won that
- 0:19race on Thursday, I don't think that he would have been on my
- 0:22list. So he's entirely unexpected as a
- 0:24race winner in my eyes. Faultless.
- 0:26The entire weekend, Russell looked to be in a league of his
- 0:29own in a car that has not been at the front of the grid for the
- 0:31whole season. He became the sixth different
- 0:34race winner in the last 6 editions of the Singapore Grand
- 0:36Prix, and while everything seemed to be going on behind
- 0:39him, he built his lead pretty smoothly on two different
- 0:42occasions and basically just drove off into the distance.
- 0:46Of course, Max Verstappen was having issues with his car,
- 0:48which meant that he couldn't pressure Russell at the front in
- 0:50the way that he wanted, But even without that, Russell was cool
- 0:53and calm and collected despite reporting issues with tyre deck
- 0:57at certain races at certain stages of the race.
- 1:00I wanted to cover the Mercedes contract situation a little bit
- 1:03later in the episode because it wouldn't be an episode hosted by
- 1:05the three of us if we weren't talking about contracts in some
- 1:08form or another, But what did you guys make of the Russell
- 1:11showing this weekend? Well, we we've seen with that
- 1:14Mercedes car, it seems to be one of the fastest cars around this
- 1:18circuit throughout the whole weekend, especially not just in
- 1:21the race but in qualifying as well.
- 1:23I, I think it was just one of those victories where Russell
- 1:25just checked out on lap one. No one saw him ever again.
- 1:29It was just a consistent lapse, then in, then out and there's
- 1:34nothing else to say. It was a controlled victory.
- 1:37Yeah, I I agree. I was honestly surprised we
- 1:39didn't see any like Max and George stuff turn 1 lap one.
- 1:43But I mean, good for George. Yeah, he just drove into the
- 1:47distance really, and had a pretty lonely race.
- 1:50But when you start on pole, that's definitely what you're
- 1:52looking for and something that I thought was kind of surprising
- 1:55considering the last few years they've really only shined at
- 2:00these cold tracks. Canada is a great example of
- 2:02that. Las Vegas Spa, they've really
- 2:06only done well at these really cool tracks and obviously we all
- 2:10know Singapore is the exact opposite of that, so to see them
- 2:14perform so well at such a hot track was shows their
- 2:17development. Yeah, I mean they were showing
- 2:19you on, I think, I don't know if you what you networks you watch
- 2:23the programming on, but they were showing on Sky Sports about
- 2:27how maps Verstappen has these always interesting lap 1
- 2:30launches. And then I thought it was sort
- 2:34of interesting when I was watching how the first part the
- 2:36lap played out, especially our George seems to just park it in
- 2:41the middle and through turns 1-2 and three, and that was the
- 2:44closest ever gone. He had a phenomenal start, I
- 2:46would say, and he knew, I think he had the full intention of
- 2:50that's exactly what he was going to do.
- 2:52If he could get away with basically just driving off into
- 2:55the distance by launching really well.
- 2:57That's exactly what the game plan was.
- 2:58And I think it was quite smart because although they had shown
- 3:02pace, although Mercedes had shown pace over practice and in
- 3:06qualifying as well, I think they kind of had in the back of the
- 3:08heads that if push came to shove, despite how much
- 3:12disruption dirty air can have in Singapore, they maybe wouldn't
- 3:15have the pace to be able to battle it one-on-one.
- 3:18Whether that's Red Bull, whether that's McLaren, whether that was
- 3:20Ferrari, I think because they had that in mind, he was very
- 3:23clear in terms of what he wanted to do.
- 3:25And I would say to a certain extent, Kimmy Antonelli kind of
- 3:27followed that rule as well. Absolutely.
- 3:30I think it was a really impressive race by Kimmy to
- 3:33finish in P5 and qualifying P4. A really great improvement,
- 3:39especially after some of the rumblings that Mercedes has been
- 3:43making. It looks like he has his
- 3:45contract pretty much squared away at this point.
- 3:47But yeah, great improvement on a really difficult track and on
- 3:53his first visit to Singapore. I just like to add for George
- 3:58Russell that not only has he given Mercedes their first win
- 4:01in Singapore since 2018, this is also his second race win this
- 4:04season and his fifth win overall.
- 4:06All of these wins have come in Mercedes cars that have not been
- 4:09entirely and consistently competitive.
- 4:12He also maintains a 100% pole to win record this season and he is
- 4:16actually the only driver in 2025 who can say that.
- 4:19So if you pair these starts with the performance of his teammate
- 4:22Kimi Antonelli, like we were just talking about the
- 4:24constructor, as Mercedes has actually left Singapore with a
- 4:28really decent haul of points considering that they're
- 4:30battling with Ferrari for P2 and the Constructors Championship.
- 4:33Was that pretty much as perfect a weekend as Mercedes could have
- 4:36hoped for? Especially when you add into the
- 4:38mix that Kimi Antilelli was also dealing with steering issues
- 4:41down the Straits in Singapore this weekend.
- 4:43Yeah, I would. I would definitely say so.
- 4:45I mean, especially Ferrari, The battle with Ferrari seems to be
- 4:48more of a one sided battle now. Ferrari, I don't know what's
- 4:52happened with them. It just seems to be a downhill
- 4:54slope now, and they seem to want the seasons run quick, sooner
- 4:59rather than later. But yeah, it's a great result,
- 5:01especially as you're saying, Mohammed, those steering issues
- 5:05he was having, that would have been hampering him a lot.
- 5:08So I think that was what they need.
- 5:09Right, so let's stop talking about Mercedes and move on to
- 5:13the other M teamed name on the Crit.
- 5:15Let's talk about McLaren. So they were experiencing both
- 5:18highs and lows this weekend and I feel like there's so much to
- 5:21say about our 2025 World Constructors Champions.
- 5:24So let's start with that and the highs.
- 5:26McLaren with one call on the podium and Lando Norris scored
- 5:29the points required of them to seal their first back-to-back
- 5:32World Constructors Championship since the 1990 since 1988 to
- 5:371991 period. Let's look at their season.
- 5:40What do you think of their turn around from the beginning of the
- 5:422023 season where they were the slowest car till now, where they
- 5:46have effectively basically dominated from about midpoint
- 5:50last season till now? I would definitely say the
- 5:53change is major, but I think the changes stand back to probably
- 5:572016 when was that Brown took over.
- 5:59I think although the performance on track has been the most
- 6:03significant thing in the last two years, I think it's more
- 6:05representative of a larger shift that's happened in I guess what
- 6:09we we called the McLaren revival phase.
- 6:11It's sort of happened between when he took over to now and
- 6:14it's signifying that long journey that it took to get back
- 6:17to where we were from and McLaren of nine years ago that
- 6:22maybe not everyone will remember as well.
- 6:23But they were a shadow of their former selves and seems that
- 6:27they've stepped back into the the light as the dominant team
- 6:30they have been throughout their time this sport.
- 6:32Yeah, I agree. We talked about sponsorships on
- 6:37this podcast before, but that's obviously a big thing that Zach
- 6:40Brown has brought. If you look at their car in
- 6:432016, I think there's like 3 sponsorships on the car for
- 6:47obviously now. I don't think there is a square
- 6:49inch on that car that does not have some sort of logo on it.
- 6:54And obviously that's such a huge help to the team into their
- 6:57development. And to see their development,
- 7:00the last three years especially has been super impressive and
- 7:04makes me wonder honestly, if something it's something
- 7:06Williams could do. Because obviously we talk a lot
- 7:09about how they have a whole project and the whole plan and
- 7:11if they'll be able to execute it as well as McLaren has.
- 7:16That will definitely be a big talking .2026 and beyond.
- 7:20But yeah, their development, I mean, is really unlike any other
- 7:24team and it's crazy to see. I think also, I just want to
- 7:28touch on that point that Rohan was talking about, about Zac
- 7:31Brown, the importance of Zac Brown in this.
- 7:33I like that phrase that you use, this McLaren revival period,
- 7:36because I think he's done a really excellent job, I think of
- 7:40honouring the team's history, which is obviously incredible
- 7:43and very important. If you look at the long list of
- 7:46phenomenal drivers that have driven for them, but also very
- 7:49much keeping an eye on the future.
- 7:52It isn't a case of McLaren have had their revival underneath the
- 7:56banner of, oh, look at what we used to be and this is exactly
- 7:59what we're going to go back to now.
- 8:00It is very much keeping an eye on.
- 8:03We have two very excellent drivers in our cars right now.
- 8:06They are going to write the future basically.
- 8:09So we need to find a way to balance it.
- 8:11And I think he's been obviously very integral in having this
- 8:15image come around. And it's not been a case of, oh,
- 8:18this is an overnight thing or oh, this is a thing only for
- 8:21this set of regulations. And next year or next,
- 8:23regulations, we're going to kind of tail off.
- 8:26There's very much an incentive and a drive.
- 8:28You can see with the way that Zac Brown talks to the media,
- 8:31with the way Andrea Estella talks to the media as well, that
- 8:34this is something that they're in for the long run.
- 8:36And yes, it's paying off in the here and now, but this is
- 8:39something they want to continue for regulations and regulations
- 8:43to come. I think this is the success
- 8:45they'll just continue to build on.
- 8:47If they've got everything correct on track, I think it'll
- 8:50be fine. Although I think there's many
- 8:52things to discuss off track, which I'd imagine will come up
- 8:54later with this team that you know, arguably may have
- 8:57overshadowed the major success today, recently, I should say.
- 9:02But I agree, you're not. Well, talking about the off
- 9:05track things, I think that's a great segue for me to start
- 9:07talking about potentially the lows of this weekend for them.
- 9:11And there's only really one place to start for this.
- 9:13And I think we need to go back to lap one of the Singapore
- 9:15Grand Prix and that incident between Lando Norris and Oscar
- 9:18Piastri. So just as a reminder for anyone
- 9:20who didn't watch the race, Oscar Piastri qualified P3 and Lando
- 9:24Norris qualified P5. On the start of the race, Norris
- 9:27jumped his teammate to take P3, but in the process he had to
- 9:31avoid action with Verstappen, which caused him to tap his
- 9:33teammate. Norris carried wing damage,
- 9:36although minimal, for the entirety of the race, but
- 9:38teammate Piastri was not happy with the situation and the way
- 9:41that it came out. There were multiple radio
- 9:43messages between Oscar Piastri and his race engineer in which
- 9:47Piastri basically expressed how annoyed and how frustrated he
- 9:51was with the situation. What did you guys make of the
- 9:54incident? First of all, what did you think
- 9:56of Oscars radio messages and is it now?
- 9:58Gloves off for both McLaren drivers with the Constructors
- 10:01championship safely wrapped up and back at home in the factory.
- 10:04I think it should have been gloves off at the start of this
- 10:06year, realistically with the car performance they had.
- 10:09But in all seriousness, I think with the incident, I think he
- 10:13tapped. I mean, when I was looking at, I
- 10:15think they showed it on the rebate.
- 10:16Norris tapped the back of Verstappen's car and that went
- 10:20for me, made his car will go wheel bang with his teammates
- 10:24car. I don't think it was
- 10:25intentional. I think it was just his teammate
- 10:28being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
- 10:31I think with the radio messages, I'm not, I wouldn't say I'm not
- 10:36sure what entirely you think about them, but I'm not going to
- 10:38say they're not entirely justified considering the heat
- 10:41of the moment and that that's what I think about that.
- 10:45And the interesting thing with the wings, think elders on
- 10:49Twitter brought up a good point. Kevin Magnussen got a black and
- 10:52orange flag for pretty much the same thing four years ago, three
- 10:56years ago, four years ago. So it's interesting that the the
- 11:00FIA didn't decide to do anything about that.
- 11:02Although I'd imagine stewarding will come up later on this
- 11:05episode as we always seem to discuss.
- 11:08I thought that would be interesting to highlight as
- 11:10well, and I think Norris said on a radio during the race like he
- 11:13was actually making him quicker. I might be wrong about that, but
- 11:16I think he said it that like the wing which was poking out of it,
- 11:20actually made him faster. Now if you ever feel useless
- 11:23just remember that end plates in Formula One exist because the
- 11:26same thing happened with Charles in China.
- 11:29He lost his front wing end plate and nothing happened.
- 11:33There was no performance like downgrade, like it was great.
- 11:37He was chilling, but and obviously the same with Lando,
- 11:43but for his move on Oscar, I thought it was great.
- 11:46I thought it was super aggressive, which is what we
- 11:48need to be seeing at this point in the title.
- 11:52And honestly, Lando has been so criticized for not being
- 11:55aggressive enough. So and then when he is
- 11:59aggressive, he gets criticized again.
- 12:02Just a little bit of hypocrisy going on in the F1 universe.
- 12:06But that's OK. But it's a lap one incident.
- 12:10At the end of the day he didn't have enough space, which isn't
- 12:13really something he can control. He said a lot in the post race
- 12:17interviews. Paraphrasing obviously, but any
- 12:20other driver on the on the grid would have done the exact same
- 12:25thing. And if he hadn't he would have
- 12:26been criticized for it. And I agree, you have to go for
- 12:29the gap that exists, have to be aggressive, especially when it's
- 12:32such a close title fight between him and his teammate.
- 12:35I mean, obviously it wasn't ideal that he hit Oscar, and if
- 12:39Oscar was out of the race, that would be a totally different
- 12:42story. But yeah, there's nothing really
- 12:47he could do. He's not going to not go for a
- 12:50gap in a title fight with his teammate.
- 12:53But As for radio, As for Oscars radio messages, I mean, of
- 12:57course they're justified. It's heat of the moment.
- 13:00Like he has a right to be angry that he was hit by his teammate.
- 13:04But at the same time, part of me was a bit like, come on, Oscar,
- 13:09it's racing like we we gotta get over it.
- 13:13Like, because also he spent so long on the radio being that was
- 13:18unfair, that was unfair, that was unfair.
- 13:21It's not like you're going to switch positions over that
- 13:23because he would have gotten that position either way.
- 13:25He was up the inside. We saw with multiple drivers all
- 13:28the way down the grid that the inside was much more effective
- 13:32and many people got the best of the person beside them.
- 13:37So to spend that long on the radio just complaining, I
- 13:40thought was just kind of useless because he could have been up
- 13:44next to Lando trying to get that position back, but instead he
- 13:48was on the radio. So I think it's kind of a
- 13:50default of this whole papaya rules thing of like, yeah, you
- 13:56can say something's unfair and like, maybe it will be changed
- 14:00sometimes. But at the same time, we can't
- 14:02be relying on the team or the radio to make races fair or not.
- 14:06And every single situation is so drastically different and has
- 14:10different implications that to have this overarching papaya
- 14:14rules don't hit your teammate. We can switch positions if we
- 14:18deem something unfair and just doesn't work.
- 14:21And we sing that time and time again.
- 14:22I think this is more of a systemic issue with this papaya
- 14:26rules. I mean, it seems to just create
- 14:28so many flashpoints, you know, incidents.
- 14:31I think this is generally a problem they need to think about
- 14:34in the future of just how do they approach things instead of
- 14:37having maybe one sort of de facto rule, but for any type of
- 14:41incident, just approach every situation differently.
- 14:44And I guess it's good he didn't do Fernando Alonso and
- 14:47threatened to unplug the radio at this point in the race.
- 14:51But I I just, I just think it's more of a wider thing at the
- 14:57team. I think there's a couple of
- 14:59things that I want to say to what you guys have said.
- 15:01I think the comment that he made, Landon Norris made about
- 15:04the damage potentially making him faster.
- 15:05I do believe that was in the cooldown room and he was talking
- 15:08to George Russell about it or it was in the post race interviews.
- 15:11It was one or the other. What I do find very interesting
- 15:14is the way that, and I do want to get on to Fernando Alonso in
- 15:18just a moment, so I'm going to talk about his radio messages.
- 15:20I think the radio as a concept has been very interesting in
- 15:24McLaren this season because it almost feels like they're
- 15:27running the race on the track, but they are also running the
- 15:30race on the radio between communication between Landon
- 15:34Norris and his race engineer, Oscar Piastri and his race
- 15:36engineer. What I also found very
- 15:38interesting is I was looking back through everything that's
- 15:41been said by the team about this notion and concept of papaya
- 15:44rules, and I believe it was Zac Brown late stage last season
- 15:49that said that as long as the team is happy and the drivers
- 15:53are happy and the stewards and the FIA are happy, prior rules
- 15:56they're going to try and limit. What I found interesting is that
- 16:00obviously the incident was noted and it was referred to the
- 16:04stewards and they said that there was no further action
- 16:06required because they viewed it as a lap one incident which
- 16:09often happens, especially in places like Singapore where you
- 16:13do have often very chaotic start.
- 16:16So it's very difficult for stewards to keep track of, OK,
- 16:18this car did this, this car did that.
- 16:20These maneuvers with this. Like Marie said, had it have
- 16:23been a situation where Oscar was out of the race, the
- 16:25conversation, the parameters of the conversation would be
- 16:28entirely different. But it was actually in fact,
- 16:31Lando was who was the driver who was carrying damage in
- 16:34comparison to it potentially being Oscar.
- 16:37I will also say on the radio messages that perhaps media
- 16:42perception of it has been a bit skewed or at least I have felt
- 16:45maybe it's been a bit skewed this season.
- 16:47I do think off the top of my head, it's been Oscar that has
- 16:50been using the radio more to have these kind of
- 16:52communications with his race engineer and then by extension
- 16:55the team as well in comparison to Lando Norris.
- 16:58Like I said, in my perception, I think media coverage of this has
- 17:02been potentially a bit skewed and maybe it's gone the other
- 17:06way. But it's I find it very
- 17:08interesting that the blanket term papaya rules has been
- 17:11banned around by the media. And I found it very interesting
- 17:14looking back at kind of, it almost seems very odd to say
- 17:17considering the phrase hasn't been around for more than a
- 17:20calendar year, I think. But looking at the heritage of
- 17:22this phrase, what it initially started out as versus what it's
- 17:26kind of transformed into and who it's being used by, I have found
- 17:31quite interesting. But to cut a Long story short,
- 17:34essentially to answer my own question from earlier, in the
- 17:38same way that I feel Monza 2024 was characteristic of how
- 17:41McLaren viewed the fighting between the two teammates for
- 17:44the remainder of that season, I do believe that Singapore 25 is
- 17:48going to serve the exact same purpose.
- 17:51I do agree with Rohan you saying that it should have been elbows
- 17:54out, gloves off from the beginning, but especially now
- 17:57that they no longer have the constructors championship to be
- 18:00concerned about. Not that it was much of A
- 18:02concern before, but now that they really don't have it like
- 18:05that technicality has been completed, I do think that it is
- 18:09time that it is a situation where if they're on track
- 18:12together, they will race how they're going to race and that
- 18:15should be the end of. Yeah, I definitely agree with
- 18:19you on that part. Yeah.
- 18:22Yeah, agreed. And I mean, McLaren financial
- 18:24statements just came out. They made some $400 million off
- 18:28Formula One alone make over a billion dollars a year.
- 18:33I mean, they can afford a few broken front wings and side
- 18:36pods. So if anyone on the entire grid
- 18:40is going to let their drivers race, it has to be McLaren.
- 18:42And yeah, I mean, they have to have gloves off at this point.
- 18:47There's no reason why they have. They would have them on.
- 18:52I mean, we can have some sort of like 2021 to light title that
- 18:56over the last couple rounds and then we get to Abu Dhabi and
- 18:59then there's, OK, you know, of safety car with about 5 laps to
- 19:02go or something. It's way too soon to be making
- 19:05those jokes. Way too soon.
- 19:07We need to wait another 2 regulations.
- 19:10Maybe Stefan Odom and Nikoli will step down and we'll all
- 19:12win. That will be a win for Formula
- 19:16One. But yeah, I mean, with that
- 19:19World Constructors championship check coming McLaren's way at
- 19:22the end of the season, I do truly believe that a couple of
- 19:24maybe more damaged end plates or just, you know, anything in
- 19:28general. I think it's something that they
- 19:30should hopefully be able to find in the budget.
- 19:32If Red Bull can do it with their catering, I do think that
- 19:34McLaren will be able to do it with their with their chassis.
- 19:38I want to give a special mention to Aston Martin this weekend,
- 19:41which is often A-Team I think we kind of don't talk about on the
- 19:44podcast, but I think that they tried something different and
- 19:47they deserve some attention for it.
- 19:49I'm going to start with Lance Stroll who started the race on
- 19:52soft tires and he managed to keep them in decent enough
- 19:55condition until at least lap 35 if I'm not mistaken, which is
- 19:58far beyond the pit window for a pair of soft tires.
- 20:02Fernando Alonso had what I am going to say is the opening
- 20:05stint of his life and his career and despite a 9.1 second stop he
- 20:10still managed to finish in the points as well ahead of Adrian
- 20:14Newey getting his hands on an Aston Martin design.
- 20:17Are the team ready to be fighting at the front where they
- 20:19want to be? No, I don't.
- 20:22Just in the in the situation they are now, I think they just
- 20:25need to approach it like many teams do when they get to the
- 20:29front. I mean, we've seen as Racing
- 20:32Point how they were competitive and then it's sort of a gradual
- 20:35decline. I think it'll be a gradual
- 20:38incline back to the front. I think Adrian Newey's presence
- 20:42will make a difference, but not as much as net.
- 20:44Perhaps the media or fans of saying it will be initially.
- 20:48I think maybe it's possible to have some sort of 2023
- 20:51performance where Fernando gets on the podium a couple times,
- 20:55but for sure they're not gonna bounce up into the top four
- 20:58teams anytime soon. Because also, like, while they
- 21:02had a pretty decent performance, that radio was insane that every
- 21:07single point of the race, the drivers were just like screaming
- 21:11at their race engineers 'cause I don't even know Lance's.
- 21:16Lance Stroll's engineer at one point told him the driver in
- 21:21front of him was on. How 14 lap old car tires or some
- 21:27sort of version of that. And he said, well, it feels like
- 21:30my mediums are on a are 100 laps old.
- 21:33And then we have Fernando like screaming into the radio at
- 21:37every given point. What was that?
- 21:39What was that? And like when Lewis lost his
- 21:41brakes and was, I mean, that's a whole different discussion, but
- 21:44he was, I mean, at every single point they were mad at the team.
- 21:48So well, they had a decent performance.
- 21:50I think we got to fix some things internally before we can
- 21:53start having these top team conversations.
- 21:57I hope he was going. It was probably one of the most
- 22:00entertaining parts of the weekend.
- 22:01Yeah, yeah. I think Fernando saying that if
- 22:05you talk to me every lap, I'm going to disconnect my radio was
- 22:08probably one of the highlights of everything that was
- 22:11happening. And then his radio message once
- 22:13he did overtake Isaac Hajar, where he was like, well, this is
- 22:17hero of the race or something along those lines was also, I
- 22:21appreciate radio messages like that, especially from Fernando
- 22:24Alonso, because it goes back to how much drivers do love this
- 22:28sport. All the politics and everything
- 22:30that happens off the racetrack kind of all go silent when
- 22:34they're in the car and they're just fighting for position.
- 22:36Even if they're not fighting for points and they're just fighting
- 22:39for position. I think it is.
- 22:41It's really nice as a fan to be able to see that.
- 22:43And Fernando Alonso, I have said this for so, so long.
- 22:46I do think it's one of the funniest drivers on the grid.
- 22:48And so unintentionally as well. The man shows, he races, he
- 22:52entertains and he leaves and that's kind of what he does.
- 22:55We can week out talking about Alonzo.
- 22:58Obviously he's been making a couple of comments in the media
- 23:01about his kind of future in the sport.
- 23:03He has retired before and then come back.
- 23:06He's made team changes in that time then as well.
- 23:09Do we think that we in the last season or potentially two
- 23:12seasons of having him on the grid?
- 23:15I think he was coming about this earlier, earlier in the year
- 23:18about something it was to do with like how the team's going
- 23:22to perform in next year. And he'll probably take 2026 to
- 23:26decide whether he's surely done. I mean he'll always be the
- 23:30rookie in most fans eyes, but I think he'll decide probably when
- 23:34the time's right for him to leave.
- 23:37Yeah, I think if 2026 doesn't go as planned, that will be his
- 23:40last year. That seems to be his message to
- 23:43the media. But if they are able to get
- 23:45podiums and things like that, then I do believe he'll stay,
- 23:49stay 2027 and 2027 will probably be his last year.
- 23:53I mean, at some point you got to be like, bro, time to pack, like
- 23:57you're amazing, but time to pack it up because, I mean, it's
- 24:01insane how long he's been in the sport.
- 24:05And I mean, to devote your so much of your life to something
- 24:10for so long is crazy. So yeah, I think he's definitely
- 24:15coming to the end of his track, so to speak.
- 24:19But it'll be exciting to see what they do in 2026.
- 24:23Yeah, definitely. I mean, he's been in this sport
- 24:26longer than many fans of this world, may be even a lot of
- 24:29people, so the longevity of his career is something to be
- 24:33applauded. And even some of the drivers
- 24:35have been alive. So there you go.
- 24:39Yeah, It just goes to, I feel like a driver of Fernando's
- 24:44caliber and also of his mindset and just of that generation.
- 24:47They're not, they don't come around very easily.
- 24:50They're not there all the time. You're very lucky if you get
- 24:521-2, maybe potentially 3 every generation.
- 24:56But I will say that until he hangs up the helmet, I will be
- 25:00keeping hope that win #33 is on the way.
- 25:03We got Aston Martin got so, so close with that good run at the
- 25:06beginning of 2023, I want to say.
- 25:10And it looks like it was going to happen.
- 25:11There were so many opportunities or there were so many chances
- 25:14where it looked like if this falls this way, that falls that
- 25:16way, it's going to happen. But yeah, it's we'll just have
- 25:20to wait and see whether it's next year, the year after or
- 25:22whether it just doesn't end up happening.
- 25:24I will keep hope that it will happen eventually.
- 25:26Me too. So if there was ever A-Team to
- 25:29have a weekend of two halves, I think it would be Williams this
- 25:32weekend off the back of sciences podium last time out in Baku
- 25:35spirits. And I would say morale was
- 25:37pretty high going into this weekend where historically
- 25:40they've actually not done too badly after showcasing decent
- 25:43pace in the practice sessions. Qualifying didn't go to plan
- 25:46because both cars ended up missing Q3.
- 25:48And ultimately qualifying didn't actually end up mattering all
- 25:51that much because both cars were disqualified because of a breach
- 25:54in their rear wings. The race however, especially for
- 25:57Carlos Sainz, was a very, very different story.
- 26:00Like Stroll, signs were showing a bit of magic with the medium
- 26:03ties that he started on, as he managed to make them go far
- 26:05beyond the traditional pit window again and he ended up
- 26:08taking the final points position.
- 26:10I'd love to get your general thoughts on Williams this
- 26:12weekend, and specifically on Carlos Sainz because I believe
- 26:15that he actually said this point means more than the podium last
- 26:19time out because of how hard it was to come by.
- 26:22Yeah, I mean, you saw James Val saying on Williams social media,
- 26:26I'm not sure it's just that ticked off specifically about
- 26:29how impressive that was for him to make this comeback.
- 26:32And I would agree with what he said.
- 26:34I mean, at the start of this year, we all anticipated him to
- 26:37be of the quality he is probably now at the team and that hadn't
- 26:41shown for most of the year. But I think the performances
- 26:44like that podium in Baku, the point here that very hard earned
- 26:48is showing why William probably worked so hard, harder, so many
- 26:52years to get in to join and why he's such a successful driver.
- 26:56Snaps to Sparkles is all I have to say.
- 27:01Those who don't know Carlos Sainz, this little girl who's
- 27:06like a huge Williams and Carlos Sainz fan, drew this little
- 27:09Unicorn. And then it's been on the back
- 27:11of Carlos's helmet for the last two races and it's doing its
- 27:14job. And Williams is coming out with
- 27:16Sparkles for clearly the Unicorn worked.
- 27:22Yeah, after the big disappointment of Saturday
- 27:25disqualification, it was great to see them come back.
- 27:29And honestly, I did not see Carlos Sainz getting a point
- 27:34since he went so long on his first stint.
- 27:36So for him to be able to fight back and get that last point was
- 27:40super impressive and yeah, shows how far he's come at the team.
- 27:44It's a shame that Sparkles his magic couldn't extend out across
- 27:47the entirety of the grid because I think that it's time to talk
- 27:49about the team who had a less than stellar weekend.
- 27:52So let's start with the Prancing Horses.
- 27:55Wow, where? Where can you really begin with
- 27:58Ferrari in Singapore? I almost feel like we might
- 28:00actually have something to do with this sudden move backwards
- 28:03because we've been so complimentary of them the last
- 28:05couple of race weekends, but things just did not go that way
- 28:08in Singapore. Both Hamilton and Leclaire were
- 28:11the recipient of slow stops. There was an order to swap the
- 28:14cars towards the end of the race so that Hamilton could go and
- 28:17try and hunt down Antonelli for P5, but they ended up in their
- 28:20original positions because Hamilton reported issues with
- 28:22his brakes. These issues, as we later found
- 28:25out, were that his brakes had entirely failed 2 laps before
- 28:28the end of the race, which cost him enough time to allow Alonzo
- 28:33to finish only 4/10 behind him when it was a much more and a
- 28:36much bigger gap during the race. To make matters worse, he was
- 28:41given a 5 second penalty for track limits once the race had
- 28:44finished because of the break issues.
- 28:46So he went from being P7 to being P8.
- 28:49Where did it all go wrong for Ferrari this weekend?
- 28:52Or was this just not a track that they could have hoped for
- 28:54anything better? Yeah, I mean, I think in terms
- 28:57of the steward decision, when your brake doesn't work, usually
- 29:01it's hard to drive the car. So I don't, I don't know, maybe
- 29:04there needs Jaime is one of the stewards at this point because
- 29:07I'm failing to see how you can get a track limit penalty.
- 29:10But yes, you're you are extending the track limits.
- 29:12But when your car doesn't really brake properly, I think it's
- 29:16natural. I guess.
- 29:17I don't really know what's going on there to be honest.
- 29:19I think they need to get sparkles and give the panting
- 29:22horse a brake. Let's just replace the Ferrari
- 29:25logo. Racing horse has left.
- 29:28Actually. You can have, like a deal with
- 29:32the Williams. Feel like since we gave you
- 29:33Carlos, maybe we get sparkles. You know, I don't even know.
- 29:38Every weekend I predict that, yeah, Ferrari's going to be
- 29:42great. Ferrari's going to get a podium.
- 29:44Nope, it's just depressing honestly.
- 29:48I mean, why do we do this to ourselves is not my first
- 29:51thought. Lewis was doing so great.
- 29:54The two stop, He had perfect opportunity.
- 29:58He was 40 seconds ahead of Alonzo, was able to get past
- 30:01Charles was about to pass Kimmy and then the four.
- 30:04I said Nope, OK, the yeah, exactly at that moment, 2 laps
- 30:11before the finish, the printing horse left it said bye.
- 30:15I don't feel like passing the guy who replaced you, but that's
- 30:18OK. I don't even know.
- 30:22I mean, Charlotte, the whole weekend was so upset.
- 30:25He said. At the moment, it feel, it kind
- 30:27of feels we're passengers of the car, which I think is so
- 30:31apparent watching everybody, watching their onboards.
- 30:34You can just see them constantly adjusting the steering, just
- 30:38fighting with the car through every corner.
- 30:39Which when you look at people like George or people like
- 30:43McLaren who are not at war with their own car, it like it
- 30:49doesn't look that way, of course.
- 30:51And it looks like the car is working for them.
- 30:53And Ferrari is just absolutely not the case.
- 30:55And let's just hope 2026 is better because I don't know how
- 31:01much longer we can do this guys. Yeah, that's all I have to say.
- 31:06I guess Ferrari do better. Although I don't know what the
- 31:10significance of it is, but I think that it's like
- 31:12back-to-back six and seven places for it.
- 31:15And I've seen people highlighting it on social media,
- 31:17but I don't actually know what it means.
- 31:19But I think, but I just think this new direction they took
- 31:24this year in terms of the car is just not produced anything
- 31:28really. And I think they just need the
- 31:29new regulations to reformat themselves for the next couple
- 31:33of years of the sport. Yeah.
- 31:35I mean, we've had this conversation before on the
- 31:37podcast about trying to understand or decipher the
- 31:40decision to move in a completely different direction in the final
- 31:43year of a regulation set, especially obviously off the
- 31:46back of a car that was in contention for the world's
- 31:49constructors championship last time around, literally to the
- 31:52final race. So it wasn't as though, oh,
- 31:55developmentally we tailed off and that's why we decided to go
- 31:58in a different direction. It was very much a case of we
- 32:02are in it until the final race. So we have done something right,
- 32:05especially with the McLaren that was still developing throughout
- 32:08the season, which meant that they were getting faster as
- 32:10well. It wasn't a situation where it
- 32:14wasn't a situation where Ferrari had any reason, I think of
- 32:17needing to write that car off and needing to write that
- 32:19concept in general off. It just, it feels as though they
- 32:25go one step forward and then like 5 back and then they lose
- 32:28their brakes. So they go even further back or
- 32:30they can't stop how much further back they're going.
- 32:32Which is unfortunate because obviously Ferrari is synonymous
- 32:36with Formula One. You wouldn't expect this or you
- 32:38would hope that. You wouldn't have to expect this
- 32:40from a team of their caliber. But it seemed as though they get
- 32:45one thing right in terms of, OK, we've got a really solid driver
- 32:48line up, which they had before, but again, maybe that was what
- 32:50they felt they needed. So Lewis Hamilton joined the
- 32:52team and yet now the car concept isn't working.
- 32:55If the car concept starts working, for example, next
- 32:58season, will something else fall apart?
- 33:00They're losing personnel that are going to different teams.
- 33:02Then at the same time, it seems to be, or at least my concern
- 33:06from an outsider's perspective is, is this a situation where
- 33:09Ferrari's house is almost going to stop caving in on itself?
- 33:14Because like I said, we've seen instances this season where
- 33:18they've been quick, they have been quick, they've known how to
- 33:20do things. And yet there's always a pivotal
- 33:22moment which often ends up being qualifying for some reason,
- 33:25where it all just falls apart. So is it indicative, I think, or
- 33:28we should be asking the question, is this indicative of
- 33:31something bigger that's going on that they just cannot seem to
- 33:34get a grasp of? I think they've they've shown
- 33:37glimpse of pace, are you saying throughout the year, but it's
- 33:39ultimately just they build the foundations and then they can't
- 33:42build the rest of the house is to use all of a metaphor that
- 33:46they get the ground running in free practice.
- 33:48You've seen how they've top free practice before or been in the
- 33:52top five and FE123 respectively in weekends.
- 33:56But I think it just seems to be a case, maybe that peaking too
- 33:59early or something, but it just seems to be a lack of pace.
- 34:04Right. I mean, if you take away the
- 34:05last 5 laps, 2 laps, whatever, Lewis had a pretty strong
- 34:11weekend. I would say he was in front of
- 34:12Charles most of the weekend. He looked really comfortable.
- 34:15I mean, as comfortable as you can be in that Ferrari, but
- 34:18relatively comfortable in the car.
- 34:21And so to just see all that progress fall apart is just
- 34:25disappointing. And I don't know where they can
- 34:27go from here. And it makes you wonder, like
- 34:30Charles Leclerc, I mean, both drivers, of course, but
- 34:33Charlotte, Claire especially, is so devoted to Ferrari and also
- 34:37of course, devoted to this idea of winning a championship in
- 34:39red. How much longer than can they
- 34:42keep up their performance and still have Charlotte be there?
- 34:46Because, I mean, his loyalty for our to Ferrari might be never
- 34:51ending, but surely his patience is not.
- 34:55And I think he's shown more this season than any his frustration
- 34:59in the media, as he should, as he has the right to, of course,
- 35:04but his frustration with the car and with the team and just with
- 35:07their lack of development and lack of pace.
- 35:09So it makes me wonder if the time will Cheryl does leave
- 35:14Ferrari is coming and even who they would replace him with.
- 35:19So I'm looking forward to a hopefully a Charles Leclerc book
- 35:22in maybe 10 years time where we get all the get all the little
- 35:26details about what's going on right now.
- 35:28I think we might be waiting a little bit longer on the Charles
- 35:30book. I'm still waiting for the Lewis
- 35:31Hamilton book where he's going to detail exactly what happened
- 35:34with those chassis changes and the personnel changes back in
- 35:362016. I haven't forgotten.
- 35:38He made that promise in an interview a very long time ago.
- 35:41And I think we're coming up to the deadline of that book being
- 35:43out. So I will be will be checking my
- 35:45local bookstore until I see it on the shelf one day. 1/2 of our
- 35:49Championship Watch segment has been concluded with the official
- 35:52confirmation that McLaren have won the Constructors
- 35:54Championship in 2025. I just want to do a quick recap
- 35:57of how that's come about this season, because McLaren tied the
- 36:00record with Red Bull in 2023 by winning the title with six races
- 36:05still to spare. They also have three Sprint
- 36:07races still to come. So they've obviously won it with
- 36:10a very, very decent amount of time left before the end of the
- 36:13season. They have 12 race wins out of 17
- 36:16rounds, out of which 5 have been one twos.
- 36:18They've won iconic races like Monaco, Silverstone.
- 36:21They put on a very decent performance in Austria where
- 36:23they kind of excited spectators with the back and forth between
- 36:26Lando and Oscar at the front. I would say it's been a pretty
- 36:30good season for McLaren. With the time that we would have
- 36:33spent talking about the team, I want to talk about the drivers.
- 36:36Instead, what was initially A2 horse race has seemingly become
- 36:39a three man Sprint, with Max Verstappen re emerging on the
- 36:42scene as a possible championship contender.
- 36:45Whether that happens or whether that doesn't happen is obviously
- 36:48a whole separate conversation, but it's looking at the two
- 36:50McLaren drivers that I want to focus on.
- 36:52Now, before I start throwing out some statistics and
- 36:55hypotheticals, I'd just like to get your thoughts on the
- 36:57championship battle itself so far.
- 36:59Yeah, it's, it's been a very good championship battle.
- 37:02I think it's been up and down for many.
- 37:05Matt Verstappen's re entry into the battle seems to be more of a
- 37:08long shot to me. I mean, considering the amount
- 37:11of rounds we have left about points, I think it will be very,
- 37:14very soon that he's mathematically out of it as
- 37:17well, not just in my view, morally out of it.
- 37:20And I don't think he's going for it as well.
- 37:22I think between the two drivers, it's hard to throw your weight
- 37:26behind one of them because it seems to just change so much.
- 37:29Yeah, I think the kind of inclusion of Max in this whole
- 37:34title discussion is very reminiscent of Lando last year,
- 37:37where we don't like to talk about and like to see that it's
- 37:41a thing. But really it's a it would take
- 37:44a miracle for him to win a fifth this season.
- 37:49But As for the overall championship fight, honestly,
- 37:51it's just been kind of odd with all the McLaren kind of
- 37:56interventions and stewarding decisions as we love to talk
- 38:00about. It's just, I don't know,
- 38:05realistically Oscar will win the championship, although based on
- 38:10the last two races, I don't know if you could fully say that
- 38:13because he does seem to be kind of losing his mojo, you could
- 38:17say, and just losing his kind of calm headedness.
- 38:23Whether that's for good or for worse, obviously we'll have to
- 38:25see in the next few rounds. But he's definitely, we are
- 38:29seeing more things faze him than we have in past races.
- 38:33Lando's season so far, like I've mentioned before on the podcast,
- 38:36has been characterized, I think, by extremes.
- 38:39He's had phenomenal highs like Monaco and Silverstone and lows
- 38:42like Zanvo in Canada, but he's still a championship contender
- 38:46and he considers himself as such as well.
- 38:48I was working out some hypothetical numbers in
- 38:50situations prior to us recording the episodes and I worked out,
- 38:54if my maths is correct, which it might not be, that Lando Norris
- 38:58and Oscar Piastre would have actually been equal on points at
- 39:01this point of the season. Had Norris not suffered ADNF in
- 39:05Zanvort, which cost him 18 points.
- 39:07Or if he was not the recipient of a four second stop in Baku,
- 39:11which potentially cost him P4 or even P3 depending on how that
- 39:15would have worked out. Obviously, this is not trying.
- 39:17This is not including the impact of dirty air and overtaking, but
- 39:21that stop was very costly like we have discussed.
- 39:24What I'm curious to know from both of you is where you think
- 39:26the impression comes from this season that Oscar has been
- 39:29perhaps miles ahead of Lando in terms of driving ability, in
- 39:33terms of cool headedness, in terms of effectively running
- 39:36away with it, Especially when the numbers, at least in terms
- 39:40of the hypotheticals that I've just laid out for you, suggest
- 39:42otherwise? I think it's generally
- 39:45personality based to me. I think in terms of how they've
- 39:48dealt with the bumps in the road and the polarity between, that
- 39:53is for me what has affected this, not how they deal with
- 39:56things on track. Yeah, I agree.
- 39:58I mean, I think Lando's. Media responses have been way
- 40:03blown up and people just don't really take into account that
- 40:07that's just kind of the person who he is, is someone who talks
- 40:10really openly to the media, for better or for worse.
- 40:12And obviously Oscar is not that type of person.
- 40:15He's very much cool headed no matter the circumstance, which
- 40:20seems to have played into his favor.
- 40:22But at the same time, I mean without a few DNFS, which or a
- 40:28few things that were completely uncontrollable for Lando, they
- 40:32would be in opposite positions or at least equal on points.
- 40:38So I think also there's this whole, I mean there's this whole
- 40:42discussion, of course that McLaren have almost manufactured
- 40:44with their whole, we have two number one drivers situation.
- 40:51And I think a lot of people assume because of Lando's
- 40:55loyalty to the team, obviously he's been a McLaren driver for
- 40:58seven years. He's been part of the McLaren
- 40:59program since he was a teenager, known Zach Brown since he was a
- 41:03teenager, and has just generally been involved for much longer
- 41:08than Oscar. Because of that loyalty, they
- 41:10favor him. And I think that discussion
- 41:12really got blown up yesterday with and even like in Hungary
- 41:18when he got a different strategy, when really in any
- 41:20other team, I don't think that would have been a discussion
- 41:22because you have two different drivers in two different
- 41:25positions. No reason not to split strategy.
- 41:29But yeah, the whole, I think every Lando fan would like to
- 41:32say McLaren prioritizes Oscar. Every Oscar fan would like to
- 41:36say the opposite. So honestly I just think it
- 41:40stems from their whole number one driver thing and how McLaren
- 41:43has dealt with their two number one drivers.
- 41:48I think a lot of the issues just in the McLaren team, I mean, it
- 41:51seems with speaking about it so much and clearly is that big
- 41:55real thing, is that they just stem from how things are dealt
- 41:58within the team, how different drive, the different drivers
- 42:03have the influence within team, the way the team deals with
- 42:06things it it kind of just stems from approaches to situations.
- 42:10And I think that's probably being McLaren's Achilles heel
- 42:13this season. I think it is very interesting
- 42:15because obviously we've spent and just within the media in
- 42:18general, there's been a lot of conversation about McLaren in
- 42:21some form or another basically since lights went out in
- 42:24Australia. Obviously, there's the pressure
- 42:25of being reigning constructors, world champions that hangs over
- 42:29your head, especially coming into a new season, because
- 42:31everyone wants to see whether you have built a car that can
- 42:34match up to what you had that won the season before, which is
- 42:37entirely understandable. When it comes to the drivers, I
- 42:39think the reason I asked the question about kind of like this
- 42:43media perception is because a lot of what I have been seeing,
- 42:46whether it's former drivers, whether it's just kind of
- 42:49pundits in general, whether it's commentators, whether it's kind
- 42:51of the news that you read about F1 as well.
- 42:54I keep seeing this narrative that it feels like it's Oscar
- 42:58running away with things. And yet if you look at it on
- 43:01paper with numbers, Lando's had two DNFS and yet is still less
- 43:06than a race wins worth of points away from taking the
- 43:10championship lead back. He's I believe after Singapore
- 43:13now is 22 points away from Oscar in the championship.
- 43:16So Despite that, it's not as though we're not in a situation
- 43:20like we were last season between Lando and Max where the points
- 43:24gap was much more significant and it felt like a championship
- 43:27battle was being forced on us. This is happening in real time
- 43:30and yet it doesn't. Maybe it's just of the media
- 43:33that I'm seeing and or that I'm interacting with, but it doesn't
- 43:36feel like it's being acknowledged that same way in
- 43:39the media. The fact that Lando is still so
- 43:41close despite 2D NFSI think is something that maybe not as
- 43:48being brushed aside, but is something that isn't being
- 43:51spoken about on the same level. And also in terms of the
- 43:56narrative being the manufacturing about all because
- 43:58Lando's been here longer, he deserves the championship more.
- 44:02I find that really interesting because there have been
- 44:04incidents over the course of this season where people, Oscar
- 44:09fans have been pointing to one thing, Lando fans have been
- 44:11pointing to the other thing. Like you said, Marie, I think
- 44:14Monza was one of those ones where it was like, well, if it
- 44:16was a slow stop, why on earth are they swapping with the
- 44:18drivers? Like you wouldn't normally do
- 44:20that. It's very interesting because
- 44:22McLaren almost tried to make it work for them and sometimes it
- 44:26works and then 90% of the time it just works against them.
- 44:29And yet they keep going through this cycle, which makes it
- 44:33harder because they keep as a team having to reiterate the
- 44:36same possibly wrong parameters about this, like about this
- 44:40title fight. It's it's really interesting and
- 44:44I am really hoping, and I know that we've said this before, now
- 44:47that the constructors championship is done and out of
- 44:49the way, the team have nothing left to lose.
- 44:52It is unlikely, obviously, unless they end up taking each
- 44:55other out, Barcelona 2016, Mercedes style, that there's
- 44:58going to be something that changes the driver's title
- 45:03coming back to one of them. So letting them, it would be in
- 45:07McLaren's best interest I think as a team to kind of almost do
- 45:10damage control to let this situation just play out the way
- 45:13that it is. But also at the same time, it's
- 45:18I think it needs to happen that whether it's the team doing it,
- 45:22whether it's just on track talking by one of the drivers,
- 45:25this narratives needs to shift that one of them has run away
- 45:28with it and the other one is lagging behind so badly that the
- 45:31fact that he's even still considering himself in the
- 45:34championship fight is astronomical.
- 45:36Because I think that's wrong, and I don't think that it
- 45:39actually accurately reflects the situation as it is right now.
- 45:42I agree. And I think McLaren has gotten
- 45:45so almost scared of this idea that they have two drivers who
- 45:50are really good and really young, so they want to keep them
- 45:53for a really long time. I think they've gotten really
- 45:54scared of that like relationship dynamic that they've tried and
- 46:00manufactured a friend. I mean, obviously their
- 46:03relationship is pretty PR at this point, but they've tried
- 46:07and made their relationship as good as possible through all
- 46:12these kind of track interventions.
- 46:14And I think it's, as you were saying, just done the exact
- 46:17opposite that Oscar says, OK, well, we did this here and we
- 46:21didn't do it here. So that's not fair.
- 46:23Orlando saying the same thing. And they're all valid points.
- 46:26But every situation is so drastically different and has
- 46:30such different implications that to have this like overarching
- 46:34papaya rules we've seen again and again just doesn't work and
- 46:38doesn't play out in the way that they want to.
- 46:40They try and make it so that both drivers are happy and ever.
- 46:44Everyone in Formula One is happy at every point and it just makes
- 46:49it so that nobody's happy at any point it seems like.
- 46:52So I think they need to have figure out where they're going
- 46:56and figure out their message. And one that isn't.
- 46:59Let's try and make everybody happy because that's never going
- 47:02to end well. Now in the world around the
- 47:05Singapore Grand Prix, there's also plenty to talk about.
- 47:07For those of you who are on the edge of your seats in
- 47:10anticipation of our discussion on stewarding, as we love to do
- 47:13on this podcast, you will be happy to know that's exactly
- 47:16what I am turning to next. Now, within the race itself, the
- 47:19stewards were not overly busy because things were fairly
- 47:22straightforward and simple, but there's an incident during
- 47:25qualifying that I would like to discuss.
- 47:27Now, during Q2, there was an incident between Charles Leclerc
- 47:30and Lando Norris where Leclerc's Ferrari was released straight
- 47:33into the path of McLaren and given the configuration of the
- 47:36pit lane in Singapore, Leclerc basically drove straight into
- 47:39Norris's car. Now there was no damage to
- 47:41either car, but it was still a hit.
- 47:42Ferrari will find €10,000 as a result.
- 47:46Earlier this season, Carlos Sainz was fined either 10,000 or
- 47:50€20,000. I couldn't get an exact number
- 47:52anywhere for missing the national anthem ahead of the
- 47:55Japanese Grand Prix due to feeling unwell.
- 47:57So it was a medical reason and that was authorized.
- 47:59Doctors were discussed, everything was OK.
- 48:03What are your thoughts on these two very different incidents
- 48:06being fined either the same amount or signs being charged
- 48:09more for what I would personally say is a more minor infraction?
- 48:14Is it that thief? It's, I know, I know, it's a
- 48:17serious medical thing, but I'm not saying that the problem is
- 48:21why should you be fined for something when obviously for
- 48:25health reasons you can't make it?
- 48:27And if it has been authorized, I don't see the problem.
- 48:31He's done nothing wrong there. I see more of a problem with the
- 48:33stewarding. I'm not sure why you would find
- 48:35someone for something they've been authorized to do that does
- 48:38set a bit of a dangerous precedent.
- 48:40But I think that's a strange decision by the stewards.
- 48:43And I think for the institute in the pit lane, that was
- 48:46justified. I don't know what the mechanic
- 48:49#1 mechanic was thinking if they saw the McLaren was going
- 48:52through the pit lane. And obviously they do travel I
- 48:54think is between 60 to 80 kilometers depending on the
- 48:57tracks. So I think I just don't.
- 48:59I think that was a mistake, silly mistake.
- 49:04I actually found it, sorry, looking it up.
- 49:09Carlos was fined €20,000 with 10,000 of that being suspended
- 49:15for 12 months, which is actually much lower than the typical
- 49:20€60,000 penalty for missing the national anthem, which is a
- 49:27little bit insane. I think Formula One is one of
- 49:30the wealthiest sports in the world.
- 49:32Why are we finding drivers? I mean, it's not like they can't
- 49:34afford it, but why are we finding drivers $60,000 for
- 49:37missing a national anthem? I understand it's like a respect
- 49:40thing, they should be there, but like he had a doctor's note.
- 49:45So I don't understand how like that is worse than like putting
- 49:49someone genuinely in danger by Carla, by Cheryl, just running
- 49:54straight into Lando. I mean obviously he was fine,
- 49:56but bit of an interesting decision if you would ask me.
- 50:02You hit the nail on the head, Marie, with sorry.
- 50:05I was just going to say the reason I decided to put these
- 50:07two incidents side by side is because of the implications of
- 50:10both of them. Of course, drivers are required
- 50:13to be at National Anthem at national anthems prior to the
- 50:16race, which is completely understandable.
- 50:19It's FIA procedure. But also at the same time,
- 50:22Carlos Sainz was completely cleared to have not been.
- 50:24It's not that he didn't come, he came late, which is what he was
- 50:27fined for. But also at the same time, in
- 50:29the hierarchy of things that you are to be fined for, for that to
- 50:33have had a higher fine compared to this is an incident
- 50:37happening. And it's not even though it's
- 50:38not even like it was a practice incident.
- 50:41This was happening during qualifying after what had
- 50:44already been a session. I've been red flagged twice.
- 50:46So it is something that was on the minds in terms of, OK, we
- 50:50need to make sure that there's no more damage.
- 50:51We need to make sure that there's no more kind of I can't
- 50:55think of the word now, but that there's no more impediments to
- 50:57the session continuing on as normal.
- 51:01Again, both cars were fine. Both drivers was were fine.
- 51:04There was no damage to either chassis, but it could have been
- 51:07a lot worse as a situation. What I also found really
- 51:10interesting was that in the Carlos Sainz incident, Sainz as
- 51:14a driver was fined. In the Ferrari incident it or in
- 51:18the Charlotte Claire incident, it was Ferrari that was fined.
- 51:20Now obviously I completely understand and acknowledge that
- 51:24Leclaire doesn't have a say in terms of when he is told to
- 51:27leave his garage. But at the same time there's it
- 51:31just seems to be that there's more exceptions to any rule that
- 51:34the FIA and stewards try to implement than there are
- 51:37anything that follows the rules that they try and get drivers
- 51:41and teams to follow. Also I can just add Carlos was 5
- 51:45seconds late. He as you said, he he was there.
- 51:48He was 5 seconds late. That 5 seconds was the most
- 51:51expensive 5 seconds of his entire life.
- 51:54Because that's insane to me. I don't.
- 51:57Now, we like to talk about drivers and teams and tracks on
- 52:01this podcast, but we do also look at people outside of the
- 52:05paddock, and one of those people is the CEO of F1, Stefano
- 52:08Domenicali. He's recently come out and made
- 52:11an interesting comment about historic tracks and their place
- 52:15on the calendar. The quote as follows is young
- 52:18people don't care whether they watch a race in Monaco or Las
- 52:21Vegas. Young people's ability to forget
- 52:24who won last year is very high. The history of a circuit is not
- 52:27enough to stay in F1. Now this is an all your only
- 52:30podcast, so I'd just like to say that both of my Co hosts are
- 52:33currently holding their heads in their hands because of this
- 52:35comment. Now he was talking about the
- 52:38Imola track when he was making these comments in the context of
- 52:41the discussion that he was having.
- 52:42And Imola is obviously home to the Emilia Romagna Grand Prix,
- 52:45which we have spoken about before briefly on the podcast.
- 52:48But I'd like to get your thoughts not only on his
- 52:50comments, but also about the perception that he has of young
- 52:54people and young F1 fans. As a young person myself, I'd
- 52:58like to say that the most questionable take about I'm not
- 53:03going to use, I'm going to be careful to say a person who is
- 53:06not a young, a young person would say about young people
- 53:14might get a bit of heat without in the comments, But I don't
- 53:16know what it means by that. It's it's a dangerous precedent.
- 53:19I mean, you can argue the same for a trout like Monaco.
- 53:22I mean, there's been so much debate.
- 53:23I mean, I wouldn't personally myself mind seeing Monaco not on
- 53:26the calendar, but that's the debate for another day.
- 53:29It's just sets a dangerous precedent.
- 53:31You know, Monaco, Spa, Silverstone, you know, their
- 53:36historic tracks. Don't get me wrong, even though
- 53:39it probably wasn't the best track for racing and so on and
- 53:42so forth, but it has that historic element and that is why
- 53:47it was on the calendar, I think so long.
- 53:48It's just what it means for the calendar.
- 53:50It's like, it's like taking the 24 hours of the month off the
- 53:53World and George Championship calendar or the Indy 500 off the
- 53:58IndyCar calendar. It has that much tradition, I
- 54:03just don't. I just I'm struggling to
- 54:05understand this comment unless it's been taken out of context.
- 54:08I just don't get it. I'd like to know what young
- 54:11person he's talking to and officially put in my application
- 54:13to be that young person because I don't get it personally.
- 54:17Because for me, one of the best things about watching Formula
- 54:21One is watching these super historic tracks that have so
- 54:23much history and being able to see how the racing has changed
- 54:26from year to year as the regulations has changed, as the
- 54:29drivers has changed since the team dynamics have changed.
- 54:32Like Silverstone is my my favorite race of the year.
- 54:35So it's like Suzuka I always look forward to and OK, Suzuka
- 54:39especially. Maybe there's not always the
- 54:41best racing, but maybe then we think about our regulations and
- 54:45what makes it not the best racing, which are is these just
- 54:49gigantic cars we have now. I think it's just so tone deaf.
- 54:54I think he doesn't know his audience and he can't be talking
- 54:57about it. As Rohan said, not a young
- 55:00person to say the least, but it's just ignorant.
- 55:06And something I've seen kinda on social media, which I totally
- 55:09agree with, is if you want us to be invested in the races, let's
- 55:14work on our broadcasting skills. Because I mean, I don't know how
- 55:17it was on Sky, but on F1 TV we had Lewis losing his brakes and
- 55:22I was seeing Lando failed to make a move on Yeah, Max, which
- 55:27I had seen for the last five laps.
- 55:28Like, I didn't really need to see that, but I would have liked
- 55:31to see like Fernando and Isaac's battle or Louis losing his
- 55:35brakes and cutting every corner or any, any sort of overtake.
- 55:41But they just have to have to pan to the crowd in the middle
- 55:45of the cooldown room or have to pan to the top of the field when
- 55:51a huge overtake is happening, or just have it on like the tiny
- 55:54little like screen on the side. Like, let's work on our
- 55:57broadcasting skills and then we can talk about it.
- 56:00Because while Las Vegas is a great race, it's definitely not
- 56:05my favorite. And I definitely wouldn't be mad
- 56:07if it left because it's doesn't mean much to me honestly
- 56:12anyways. Yeah, I guess it's important for
- 56:14context that after the F1 intro starts and I think until like
- 56:17the podium or something, it's the field entirely managed by
- 56:20F1. It's the same for wherever
- 56:21you're watching. Even more reason why we need to
- 56:24be having that discussion. There's two points that I'd like
- 56:27to pick up on in what he said. First of all, yes, I would like
- 56:31to know what young people he's talking to because as a young
- 56:35person, I don't agree with anything that the young person
- 56:38he's talking to has been saying. I think also historic tracks
- 56:45being taken off the calendar, if they're being taken off because
- 56:49of racing ability, because of regulations and the cars that
- 56:52are on them. I completely agree with you,
- 56:54Marie. We need to think about the
- 56:55regulations then because otherwise we're just going to
- 56:57end up being the cars are going to end up being too big for any
- 57:00kind of track and then what are we going to be left with?
- 57:03My issue or my hesitation with historic tracks being taken off
- 57:09is when they are then replaced by tracks that don't serve the
- 57:14same kind of purpose. If a historic track was being
- 57:17taken off because another one was being put back on, for
- 57:19example, if the conversation was Imola is going to be taken off
- 57:23but we are going to be returning to Germany for F1.
- 57:27This would be the parameters of this conversation would be
- 57:29entirely different. If we are taking off Imola to
- 57:32add another St. circuit in a city where the residents
- 57:36themselves are actually not happy with F1 being there,
- 57:38similar to what we're seeing in Madrid.
- 57:40And obviously I'm not saying that that's exactly what
- 57:42happened, but just as a hypothetical, the parameters of
- 57:45that are entirely different. Also, as an F1 fan, I do
- 57:49entirely remember who won the race that we're at the year
- 57:53before, and I would pretty much wager that I can tell you who
- 57:57won the race the year before that as well because it's part
- 58:00of what being a fan is. I'm not saying that you have to
- 58:03sit there and be the encyclopedia of F1, but you
- 58:07there are certain things that you do remember that exist in
- 58:11your mind, especially when, for example, I obviously watch F1 on
- 58:14Sky F1, they will always have a small graphic before the lights
- 58:18go out on a Sunday to say these are the race winners for the
- 58:21last five years. The reason they have statistics
- 58:23like that available when you're watching to broadcast is because
- 58:27these things matter and they are important.
- 58:29And I think to constantly have this label of young F1 fans or
- 58:33young people saying that they don't want so and so they don't
- 58:37want so and so actually gives a very negative reputation of
- 58:40young F1 fans, especially in an environment where sometimes
- 58:45perhaps more experienced F1 fans are borderline hostile to
- 58:50younger fans. Because it's very much the
- 58:52stance of, although you haven't been watching it as long as I
- 58:54have, which is unfortunate because sport is there for
- 58:57everyone to be to enjoy together.
- 58:59And it should be a bonding experience regardless of how old
- 59:02you are or anything like that. So it's comments like this, I
- 59:06agree they are tone deaf and I think they completely miss the
- 59:09point of what kind of discourse is actually happening in F1
- 59:12versus what is being picked up on, perhaps most importantly by
- 59:16the people who can actually make change.
- 59:18If this was someone who was just talking and they didn't really
- 59:22have any stakes or any any involvement in future decisions,
- 59:25again, the parameters of this conversation would be entirely
- 59:28different. This is the CEO of Formula One
- 59:30who's saying this, which means that if we're not careful, these
- 59:34things will actually be taken as fact without any interrogation,
- 59:37and who knows what kind of situation we'll end up in then.
- 59:41Yeah, I just, I mean, I just find it ridiculous because I I
- 59:44agree. I mean, I know the race winners
- 59:46of races I haven't even watched or wasn't even alive for like,
- 59:51so to say that is just so odd to me.
- 59:54And honestly, in my experience, I, I or other young fans know
- 1:00:01more than some of the older fans who have been watching but maybe
- 1:00:04aren't as invested in it like I think there's.
- 1:00:07All the new fans, I mean, not all of course, but there's a
- 1:00:10large demographic of young fans that are so incredibly invested
- 1:00:14in the sport and are really looking to make it their career,
- 1:00:17make it their whole lives and are so and things like this just
- 1:00:20turn them away. And I think it's tone deaf in a
- 1:00:25in a season of Formula One where they're so hell bent on getting
- 1:00:29new fans, getting more female fans, getting more American fans
- 1:00:33to say things like this just turns away and does exactly the
- 1:00:36opposite of what they try and do.
- 1:00:39And to go back to the circuit discussion, they say, oh, we
- 1:00:45can't have there's two races in Italy.
- 1:00:48We don't need that many. There's three races in the
- 1:00:50United States. I wouldn't mind if Austin is a
- 1:00:54great track. I love Austin.
- 1:00:56Austin should stay on the calendar, of course, but I
- 1:00:58wouldn't if Miami and Las Vegas disappeared off the face of the
- 1:01:01earth tomorrow, I would not have a care in the world about it.
- 1:01:04I'd let's just put it that way. So I agree if we were replacing
- 1:01:09it with other historic tracks or with tracks in Africa or in
- 1:01:13really interesting places with interesting turns and circuits
- 1:01:18and all this kind of all these kind of things, the yeah, the
- 1:01:21discussion would be way different.
- 1:01:22And to say things like this is just, I mean, writes his firing
- 1:01:29letter, really. So if our regular dose of
- 1:01:32stewarding discussion wasn't enough, then anyone listening
- 1:01:35will be pleased to know that the next topic I'd like to turn to
- 1:01:37is contracts, and we will be starting with our usual culprit,
- 1:01:40Mercedes. Now, we've spoken about George
- 1:01:42Russell's heroics this weekend and the only thing I have to say
- 1:01:45about his contract situation is that Toto Wolff should probably
- 1:01:49be adding another 0 onto whatever he was originally
- 1:01:51planning on offering him. What could Toto possibly be
- 1:01:55waiting for now? God knows it seems to keep
- 1:01:58kicking the can down the road. And that this isn't the drive I
- 1:02:01was expecting him to do that with.
- 1:02:03Exactly. I mean, at this, I mean they
- 1:02:06said it on the broadcast yesterday.
- 1:02:07He's just costing himself money at this point.
- 1:02:10Like we got to get this squared away or we're going to be out of
- 1:02:13a out of a few million here, Dodo.
- 1:02:17Like, yeah, I don't it, I mean, my only rational answer is he
- 1:02:23must be waiting for a certain Max Verstappen to show up with
- 1:02:27his on his doors saying I'm not happy at Red Bull anymore.
- 1:02:30But I mean really, what more can he ask for, especially when it
- 1:02:36seems pretty locked down that he's going to sign Kimmy for
- 1:02:392026. Toto said Kimmy is 100% Mercedes
- 1:02:45driver next season during the F2 or FP2 broadcast.
- 1:02:51So yeah, to have your young driver confirmed who's had a
- 1:02:54pretty inconsistent season, which is characteristic of a
- 1:02:57rookie season, so there's no criticism here.
- 1:03:00But to have him locked, almost locked down it seems, and your
- 1:03:04driver who's been loyal to you for God knows how long and is
- 1:03:10performing and performing and doing great things with the car
- 1:03:13that isn't that great at the moment, is just confusing to me.
- 1:03:17I think there's certain things that you go into a season
- 1:03:21expecting from your drivers, obviously dependent on what your
- 1:03:24car is like and what kind of the SIM is telling you your car is
- 1:03:28going to be in terms of in rankings and what stage and age
- 1:03:32your drivers are at as well. For Kimi, as a rookie, I would
- 1:03:36have said that the pole position in Miami and the podium in
- 1:03:39Canada are more than enough to say, OK, despite the
- 1:03:43inconsistency that is characteristic of a rookie.
- 1:03:45I have done what I need to be able to secure my seat.
- 1:03:48And it sounds like that's exactly what's happened for
- 1:03:51George Russell as an experienced driver, as an experienced driver
- 1:03:54who's leading the team two race wins in a season where they're
- 1:03:58not consistently close to the front, then not I would even say
- 1:04:02consistently second place. They are just able to lock in
- 1:04:06and perform when and make the most of the situation when it
- 1:04:09presents itself again. I don't I cannot even begin to
- 1:04:12fathom what it is that Toto is expecting George to be able to
- 1:04:15do before signing him in. I'm also very intrigued because
- 1:04:19I do have no doubt that the contract will come eventually.
- 1:04:21I just am curious as to what's taking so long.
- 1:04:25I'm very curious to know how long this contract will be
- 1:04:27because if he is holding out in the hope, oh, I'm going to give
- 1:04:31George another year because potentially by then, Max, if
- 1:04:34he's disgruntled with the 2026 regulations with Red Bull, maybe
- 1:04:38then he wants to jump ship. I think again, that would be a
- 1:04:41very interesting done dynamic. I wouldn't quite understand, but
- 1:04:44it would be, it would still be something, It would still be a
- 1:04:47contract announcement even if it's just for another year.
- 1:04:50But that is the other thing that I'm very curious about.
- 1:04:52What kind of deal are they actually working on behind the
- 1:04:55scenes? Right.
- 1:04:56But to me, it has to be at least a two year deal because I think
- 1:04:59Toto is going to drive away these drivers with a 1 + 1 deal
- 1:05:03because you can't give Lewis Hamilton, who's debatably the
- 1:05:07best, the best racing driver to ever step into a Formula One
- 1:05:11car, a 1 + 1 deal. You say we've had our time.
- 1:05:16I think it's time to part. Or you give him a huge contract
- 1:05:19with, I mean, ambassador rights and all this kind of stuff.
- 1:05:22And that's why, I mean, that's a huge part of why he stepped away
- 1:05:25to Ferrari. And if George, after all these
- 1:05:28years of his loyal, after all these years of his loyalty and
- 1:05:32after all his performance and Mercedes and his dedication to
- 1:05:35the team is given a 1 + 1 deal, he has to start thinking, OK,
- 1:05:39well, maybe this is the place for me after this.
- 1:05:42And then Shirley Kimmy has to start thinking, OK, well, no
- 1:05:46matter how much loyalty I give to this team, are they going to
- 1:05:48give it back to me? Because it doesn't look like
- 1:05:50that right now. It's, it's interesting really
- 1:05:53what they're going to do. This seems to be in about 3
- 1:05:56different minds. I mean, as I was been saying on
- 1:05:58previous episodes, I'd imagine with contracts like this,
- 1:06:00something is obviously being discussed in the background, but
- 1:06:04we we won't see that for a while to be honest.
- 1:06:08I mean, at this rate, yeah, I was just at this rate, I
- 1:06:10wouldn't be surprised if the contract and now the official
- 1:06:13announcements, because obviously Toto can say, well, you want
- 1:06:15some broadcast, the team have to issue something once pen has
- 1:06:19actually been put to paper. I wouldn't be surprised if it's
- 1:06:22during the break after Abu Dhabi that we hear that all Mercedes
- 1:06:25have actually, they do have drivers for their cars next
- 1:06:28season because I think we're headed in that direction.
- 1:06:32But yeah, we will just time will have to wait and tell.
- 1:06:35And we'll just have to see what it is that Mercedes and Toto are
- 1:06:38able to put to their drivers, what the drivers are able to
- 1:06:42negotiate back if things aren't favorable.
- 1:06:44We'll just have to wait and see. As always for our closing
- 1:06:47remarks, I would love to know how you would sum up this year's
- 1:06:50Singapore Grand Prix in one word, and also what you're
- 1:06:52looking forward to next time out in Austin.
- 1:06:55Unplugged radios. This is so difficult.
- 1:07:02I'm going to say brakes. Brakes is good, Brakes is good.
- 1:07:08I'm going to say dazzling because we're under the lights.
- 1:07:11It was my favorite track or one of my favorite tracks on the
- 1:07:13calendar. George Russell undoubtedly
- 1:07:15dazzled with his race win and I think in terms of looking
- 1:07:20forward to what happens in Austin next time out, I'm
- 1:07:23intrigued to see if Ferrari can go any further back than what
- 1:07:27they are already compared to where they were immediately
- 1:07:31after the summer break. And I'm really intrigued to see
- 1:07:34if Oscar Piastre is going to have anything to say on track in
- 1:07:37response to what happened in Singapore.
- 1:07:40Yeah, I'm very excited for those press conferences in Austin.
- 1:07:44And I mean, Ferrari got a 12 here last year, so I'm still
- 1:07:47holding that hope. That's all from us for our
- 1:07:50Singapore Race Review. On behalf of myself and my
- 1:07:52wonderful Co host, thank you so much for listening and we hope
- 1:07:54that you enjoyed the episode. Join us again next time for our
- 1:07:57first All Stars episode where we will be discussing our perfect
- 1:08:00team based on the performances we've seen so far this season.
- 1:08:04Thank you.