Latest / Interfaiths / Interfaiths: Building Trust Through Trauma: Stuart and Diane on the Unbiased Initiative
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome back to the Interfaiths program. I'm
- 0:09your host, Iqbal Akhtar, and we are here with
- 0:12a... power couple Stuart and Diane who are pillars
- 0:19of the Jewish community here and they do a lot
- 0:21of remarkable work here in Israel in terms of
- 0:23supporting humanitarian causes and they've been
- 0:27an integral part of our Muslim Jewish dialogue
- 0:30group and so we're going to start a little bit
- 0:33about their backgrounds what got them interested
- 0:35their own identity and kind of evolution in terms
- 0:42of being Jewish and how they understand some
- 0:45of the challenges that we have today and their
- 0:47hopes for the future in terms of developing interfaith
- 0:51dialogue and relationships and particularly Jewish
- 0:55-Muslim sort of engagement, which I think is
- 0:57something that is at the heart of the work that
- 1:00they do. So who wants to start? You start. Okay,
- 1:05start. Give us a little bit about your background.
- 1:08Where do you come from? Who are you? Well, since
- 1:11I think it's important. I was born in 1940, which
- 1:15was eight years before the establishment of the
- 1:19State of Israel. So I was kind of just becoming
- 1:22aware of things. And that does color my long
- 1:27-term views of things. But I was born into a
- 1:31family. We have four of us, three boys and a
- 1:34girl, in a... pretty blue -collar community with
- 1:39a well -established middle -class Jewish community
- 1:44and my family was not religious in the sense
- 1:51of observance, but we were very Zionistic, very
- 1:58involved as I remember in the state of Israel
- 2:03once it began to be established. And we were
- 2:08very Zionistic. My parents contributed to it.
- 2:11They participated in the groups that discussed
- 2:14it. And I guess some of that rubbed off. My dad
- 2:19was a meatpacker. And I, as in many fairly large
- 2:26Jewish families, was thought, come into the business.
- 2:30And so I worked from the time I was very small
- 2:32as butcher. which kind of plays itself out later
- 2:36on in life. So I knew what it was like to work.
- 2:40I was active in high school, a fairly normal
- 2:44high school, public school life and education.
- 2:49I was president of the student government. I
- 2:52was active in gymnastics. And then went on to
- 2:56undergraduate school at Franklin and Marshall,
- 2:58a small liberal arts school in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
- 3:03where we were also exposed to the Amish and Mennonite
- 3:08people that were a little different and it was
- 3:11it was it was an education in itself was an education
- 3:14and made me very interested in some of the other
- 3:18ways that people live their lives out. I went
- 3:24then to med school at the University of Pennsylvania
- 3:27in Philadelphia and then did my residency in
- 3:34radiology and then deciding that I didn't like
- 3:39that. I had been very fortunate to be exposed
- 3:43to one of the early pioneers in echocardiography
- 3:49and use of diagnostic ultrasound, Claude Joyner,
- 3:52in 1962 when I came to med school and he kind
- 3:59of took me under his wing and exposed me to echocardiography
- 4:02which then of course played itself out later
- 4:04in my career. I was also interested in nuclear
- 4:09medicine and particularly in nuclear cardiology
- 4:13and decided that I really didn't like radiology.
- 4:17I liked the physics and clinical aspects of both
- 4:21echocardiography and nuclear cardiology, and
- 4:24so another Penn graduate, Manny Viamonte, who
- 4:27was head of the radiology department here at
- 4:30the University of Miami, asked me to come down,
- 4:32start those two areas, and complete a residency
- 4:38in nuclear medicine, which is what I did. So
- 4:41I stayed at the university for almost 10 years.
- 4:44and started other programs in both those fields
- 4:49and ran them for many years in other hospitals.
- 4:54As you can tell, I kind of like physics and a
- 4:59kind of combination of clinical medicine and
- 5:00physics. But I was here during the influx from
- 5:0771 until 80 of the Cuban migration. was fascinating
- 5:13to me. But I don't have a very interesting background.
- 5:23That kind of sums up where I am. I've since been
- 5:28in private practice and taken an interest in
- 5:31what we do because I think that, as I pointed
- 5:37out in the beginning, my age tends to tends to
- 5:45have associated with it certain prejudices and
- 5:49biases and there's certain aspects of that that
- 5:53are a little bit confusing to me. I had one patient
- 5:56from Saudi Arabia who I used to see periodically
- 6:02and he would always hug me and say cousin you're
- 6:06my cousin and I guess I had Harvard and still,
- 6:11to some extent, harbor doubt about my relationship
- 6:14with Islam. And I thought, gosh, that's true.
- 6:20We are cousins. Why all this animosity? And I
- 6:26wasn't ignorant of the history, of a 3 ,000 -year
- 6:29history. But nevertheless, it created some confusion
- 6:32and some desire to kind of learn more about what
- 6:39it was that I seemed to have these prejudices
- 6:41about and that's what took me into doing what
- 6:45we do now. I think to some extent those same
- 6:49prejudices are different from the younger generation
- 6:54and sometimes I wonder if they hold us back or
- 7:01hold me back but one thing I have learned that's
- 7:05been interesting is that through the dialogue,
- 7:09it is possible to, with time and some confrontation,
- 7:15to trust. And I've always felt that in order
- 7:20to solve a problem, to have a dialogue, die,
- 7:23it's two. Two people have to talk. Two groups
- 7:28have to talk. But two people talk and they learn
- 7:31to trust. And even friendship. to some extent
- 7:38comes out of this with all of its complications
- 7:42and all of its expectations but I have learned
- 7:47that it's possible and that's why I continue
- 7:50and why I hope that you know perhaps if you know
- 7:57that others will see that we can struggle with
- 8:01this and come out of it understanding one another
- 8:04a little bit, trusting one another, perhaps more
- 8:08so even than understanding, and that that can
- 8:12serve as a basis for going forward. Absolutely,
- 8:16yeah. That's been very, very important, I think,
- 8:19the trust part of it. I think the other thing
- 8:21that has dawned on me as well is just that how,
- 8:24in a way, we live within our own worlds and our
- 8:29faith traditions, and they're things that are
- 8:30self -evident. that sometimes need to be said.
- 8:35And that was one of the things that, you know,
- 8:37with our anti -Semitism statements and stuff
- 8:41like that. I mean, I thought it was self -evident
- 8:44that people realized that the majority, you know,
- 8:47I would say majority Muslims are not okay. I
- 8:50mean, they completely condemned that sort of
- 8:52violence. It was unacceptable. But then, you
- 8:55know, actually it was because of you, Stuart.
- 8:57Like, you would ask me, I was like, where are
- 8:59the, you had messaged me, I think earlier about,
- 9:02you know, where the Muslim, moderate Muslim voices
- 9:04and where you've seen that. And then I would
- 9:06actually, I was like, well, I'm sure. Everybody's
- 9:09been saying stuff. And then I looked online,
- 9:11I was searching, and I was like, there are very
- 9:13few statements that are actually condemning anti
- 9:16-Semitic violence from Muslims. And so I was
- 9:18like, wow, that's very surprising to me. So I
- 9:23think that that's part of it is also just being
- 9:25able to communicate that. and learning what is
- 9:30the language of communicating in a pluralistic
- 9:33democracy, that there are ways that you need
- 9:35to say things, you need to support people, you
- 9:38need to be able to articulate your position and
- 9:40your viewpoint. And I think that's been really,
- 9:43really helpful, just sort of being able to have
- 9:46these conversations and having that honesty.
- 9:49Yeah. That's been very, very helpful. It also,
- 9:53you know, what comes along with it is an expectation.
- 9:58And sometimes those expectations aren't completely
- 10:00met and we take a step back. But then we step
- 10:03forward and say, you know, you didn't meet my
- 10:05expectation. I wrote you because I feel close
- 10:09to you now. And we've had a number of personal
- 10:12meetings. I would expect that when things happen,
- 10:17that you say something as I feel I would. And
- 10:21you responded. And that reinforced. That relationship.
- 10:26So we can take another step forward. Right, exactly.
- 10:29Absolutely. So Diane, talk to us about you. So
- 10:33I have a very different story than most people.
- 10:36I was raised Catholic. And when I was young,
- 10:42I was married and I got divorced. And at that
- 10:45time, the Catholic Church really didn't embrace
- 10:49people who were divorced. And I decided if the
- 10:56Catholic Church doesn't want me, then I don't
- 10:59really want to be part of a faith that I don't
- 11:03feel comfortable accepting. So I really was not
- 11:06doing anything. And my parents, my father was
- 11:10fairly observant. So I saw that in him. And I
- 11:15didn't really do anything about it. And then
- 11:18I met Stuart. And he made it pretty clear that
- 11:23even if we weren't going to have children or
- 11:24whatever, that he was not getting involved with
- 11:27somebody who wasn't Jewish. So I had been thinking
- 11:31about Judaism because my father worked in the
- 11:36garment industry, which was primarily Jewish.
- 11:39And we had a lot of friends, unlike most. Christians
- 11:43that don't really know Jews. I knew a lot of
- 11:46Jews. A lot of our friends, we went to their
- 11:48celebrations and stuff. So it wasn't foreign.
- 11:51And I kind of thought to myself, maybe I should
- 11:55explore this. But I didn't do anything formal.
- 11:57So when he said that, I said, you know, this
- 11:59is as good a time as any to do it. So I went
- 12:02down that path and I became a Jew by choice.
- 12:06But part of it is that I kind of made the commitment
- 12:09to myself that There wasn't a reason to give
- 12:13up a religion to embrace another if you weren't
- 12:16going to understand that religion. Because part
- 12:19of my problem with Catholicism is I really didn't
- 12:22understand it that much. You know, you just grow
- 12:24up and you learn certain things and you do them.
- 12:26And when you don't do them, you have to go atone
- 12:29for them. And that didn't go with me, really.
- 12:32So I always credit... my husband, my mother -in
- 12:38-law for teaching me about Judaism, my rabbi.
- 12:41And then I stumbled onto Hadassah, which is a
- 12:44women's Zionist organization. It's the largest
- 12:48Jewish volunteer organization in the world. And
- 12:51they really taught me about the connection that
- 12:59you were embracing, not just a religion, but
- 13:01a peoplehood. And so I really learned about the
- 13:06culture, about the religious practices, but mostly
- 13:10I learned about Israel. So I learned one of the
- 13:12things that you learn is that to be Jewish is
- 13:17to embrace the land of Israel, the history, the
- 13:21people, you know, how we started there, how we
- 13:24remain there, how we have been expelled, come
- 13:27back. But still, we survive. And then, of course,
- 13:31the Holocaust played a role in creating the state.
- 13:34So I really learned a lot about Israel. And I
- 13:37kind of fell in love. I fell in love with the
- 13:40country, the people with the concept. I guess
- 13:43it was because I was looking for something. I
- 13:45was really looking for something to connect to.
- 13:48The funny thing, my mother, I thought she'd be
- 13:50upset when I was converting. She said, well,
- 13:52at least you're going to do something. So my
- 13:54parents were fine with me converting because
- 13:57they were just happy to see me have some kind
- 14:00of faith -based practice. And one of the things
- 14:06I learned through Hadassah was that in Israel,
- 14:11despite what people might think, there is cooperation
- 14:16between the Arabs and the Jews because they have
- 14:18to. They live in the same country. They use the
- 14:21same health care system. They go to the same
- 14:23schools. So at Hadassah, it was very easy. I
- 14:27mean, we have 25 % of the staff is Palestinian.
- 14:33More are Arabs, Israeli Arabs. When patients
- 14:37come in the door, they check their religion at
- 14:39the door, and the caregiver checks his religion
- 14:42when he comes to work. and the Arab is in bed
- 14:47next to the Jew and the Druze and the Christian
- 14:50and whatever. And it seems for the most part
- 14:53to work. We have remarkable stories about, you
- 14:58know, Palestinian doctors who saved the life
- 15:01of a Jewish child and now he goes to the bar
- 15:04mitzvahs and the weddings and vice versa. So
- 15:08I really... I really believed in that and believed
- 15:13that it can work and that believed that medicine
- 15:15could be a bridge to peace. And I'm a nurse midwife
- 15:20by profession. I'm a nurse. So that was kind
- 15:22of part of me was that medicine is a tool that
- 15:25we can use to build bridges. So when October
- 15:297th came, it kind of turned everything upside
- 15:32down because there were struggles in the hospital
- 15:35with the staff and just like here, everybody
- 15:38trying to deal with. this kumbaya aspect you
- 15:43have of everything and that you can make everything
- 15:45better. And then these things happen. So when
- 15:49I heard about the Unbiased Initiative, I thought,
- 15:51you know, I feel really strongly that we all
- 15:56really are just human beings and have common
- 15:59issues and want to solve them together. And that
- 16:04maybe this is something I, and you know, after
- 16:06October 7th, everybody feels like they want to
- 16:08do something. Right. So when they asked me to
- 16:12get involved, I said, yes, because I'm comfortable
- 16:15with this work. I don't have a lot of, because
- 16:19of how I grew up, I don't have a lot of preconceived
- 16:21notions about Arabs, Jews, and whatever. It's
- 16:24mostly what I've learned as an adult. So I thought
- 16:29it was a good fit. And I've enjoyed it because
- 16:32it's... You know, it does challenge a lot of
- 16:36the things that you think are fine and you don't
- 16:39have to worry about it. It does challenge that.
- 16:41But by the same token, I feel that once people
- 16:45know each other, it's very hard to hate people
- 16:48that you're having a meal with. Right, exactly.
- 16:50And that you know their son and that they talk
- 16:53about their wife or something. So I think it's
- 16:57important work. And I hope that we, we always
- 17:00use the phrase, move the needle. But if we can.
- 17:03If 10 people can change their idea about things,
- 17:06I think that that's a start. We're not going
- 17:08to change the world, but we can do it. And I
- 17:11feel like through Hadassah, I try to make a bigger
- 17:13change. And then through this, a smaller change.
- 17:16Absolutely. I mean, you have this interesting
- 17:20perspective because you're kind of an insider
- 17:22-outsider. What has been your general impression
- 17:26of your engagement with... With with Muslims
- 17:31because you you You know, you kind of convert
- 17:36it into Judaism you all you work with with Muslims
- 17:39in Israel and also now you're getting to know
- 17:42people here in the United States What do you
- 17:44see are the commonalities into the differences
- 17:48in terms? It's fascinating because you know,
- 17:50I had to learn about Jewish practice So I know
- 17:52a lot about more about Jewish than a lot of Jews
- 17:55do exactly My friends call me and say what do
- 17:57we do for that holiday? So does your husband.
- 18:00So we're so similar. It's really so sad that
- 18:07we really are cousins. Somebody was talking about
- 18:11burial practices and how quick you have a funeral.
- 18:13I said, that's exactly the way Jews do things.
- 18:16We do the same thing. So it is sad. But look,
- 18:19politics is responsible for most of the world's
- 18:23ills and challenges. And I think if left to our
- 18:27own devices, we would all get along because it's
- 18:29much better for us. Because all we really want
- 18:31is to send our kids to school and have a home
- 18:35and raise our kids and have enough to eat and
- 18:40whatever. Do we really care about these other
- 18:43things? I don't think so. But we're forced into
- 18:46those positions. And I work with a lot of, we
- 18:50have a lot of initiatives in Hadassah. to train
- 18:54Palestinian nurses and doctors to go back to
- 18:57their community. I'm involved with a group called
- 18:59Nurses in the Middle East, and they do that.
- 19:02So I have very positive opinion of Muslim health
- 19:07care workers. I mean, that's my experience and
- 19:09how dedicated they are to their community, how
- 19:13they want to learn and help and how we learn
- 19:17things from them. So I really didn't have that.
- 19:21kind of ingrained thing like, oh, let's see what
- 19:23happens. But October 7th, you know, what's that
- 19:31phrase where it's like it shakes you up a little
- 19:35bit and you think, was I just being naive? So
- 19:38I'm trying to push that down and just say, no,
- 19:43we can go back to the way things were. Because
- 19:46it's not the first time this has happened in
- 19:48history, that there's clashes between different
- 19:51cultures, people, and you have to overcome it.
- 19:55I think the challenge is for us to overcome it
- 19:57in a positive way. Yeah, I mean, I think that
- 20:00it's been very interesting because I've never
- 20:02been to Israel. I'm probably going to go in November.
- 20:06So there's a conference that I've been invited
- 20:08to the University of Haifa. So I think that'd
- 20:10be really interesting to go see. Haifa is a largely
- 20:13an Arab town. Yeah, and they have a really good
- 20:16interfaith studies program there at the university.
- 20:19So I'll be giving a lecture there. But I think
- 20:24that's been... something very interesting to
- 20:27hear and understand Israel from your perspectives,
- 20:33as people that are kind of going there quite
- 20:35often, just to understand kind of the complexity
- 20:38and diversity of the society. Because I think
- 20:41that's another thing is that if you've never
- 20:43been there, you assume things about the society.
- 20:49And I think that that's something that in the
- 20:51long run, That's my hope with the Abraham Accords
- 20:55as well, is once you actually start having Arabs
- 20:58going, hopefully it goes to Saudi Arabia and
- 21:01other places, you have people coming back and
- 21:03forth, they'll really be able to have that citizen
- 21:06-to -citizen diplomacy. I think that's something
- 21:09that's remarkable about it. the programs we have
- 21:11in America, like the Fulbright and all these
- 21:13sorts of programs where once you have people
- 21:15to people connections across societies, across
- 21:18civilizations, you're able to kind of change
- 21:20people's entire perspectives in terms of like
- 21:23how they relate their understanding. And I think
- 21:26that that barrier, the fact that a lot of the
- 21:28country, Muslim countries don't recognize Israel
- 21:30and that their people don't go there. They're
- 21:32not able to see what a remarkable society Israel
- 21:35is and to create it from such a short period
- 21:38of time into a very dynamic and prosperous society
- 21:42that has its own challenges as well and its own
- 21:45problems. But to see that, I think that's quite
- 21:48an achievement in that, you know, the society
- 21:52is able to build and create things. I think that's
- 21:57also something that's really valuable because
- 21:58when you go to a lot of these other countries
- 22:00in the Middle East right now, they tend to be
- 22:03purely consumer societies. They just buy things,
- 22:06but then rarely are they producing. technologies,
- 22:10ideas, things like that. And I think that's something
- 22:12that they could probably learn from Israel as
- 22:14well, kind of the entrepreneurship sort of as
- 22:17an idea for society. And especially, you know,
- 22:20you're constrained, right? You're constrained
- 22:21by geography, by climate. um but despite those
- 22:25constraints you're able to develop and construct
- 22:28um and grow things i think that's really quite
- 22:31a remarkable experience so i think just sort
- 22:32of that lived reality i think would be in the
- 22:35long run something very very helpful for muslims
- 22:37and jews and to be able to do yeah and i think
- 22:40that they've tried that i that if when you get
- 22:44around the existential issues which is a big
- 22:46issue Israel has a lot to teach and they want
- 22:51to share. They've already done that in many places
- 22:54in South America, for example. And their handling
- 22:57of water conservation, of growing products, is
- 23:05really secondary to none. And I believe what
- 23:09we've seen, the willingness to share that is
- 23:13there. Yeah. So, I mean, that's, I think that
- 23:17in the, you know, in the long run, a lot of this
- 23:19stuff, I think doing those trips, I think in
- 23:22the long run, I think would be also extremely
- 23:24helpful. And then I think, you know, vice versa
- 23:27to have, you know, people from Israel and from
- 23:31the Jewish diaspora to go to Muslim countries
- 23:33and to be able to experience those, those societies
- 23:38and kind of the openness and willingness that
- 23:40they're, it's not such a. It's not as hostile
- 23:45as it appears to be from the outside, that there
- 23:46is incredible spaces for generosity and hospitality
- 23:50and getting to know each other. So it was very,
- 23:55I mean, one of the heartbreaking things I was
- 23:57listening to, there was a podcast about the two
- 24:02Israeli interns that were killed. And right before
- 24:05that, they actually had gone to Morocco and they
- 24:07were there on kind of like an interfaith. uh
- 24:12project um and then you know right after and
- 24:15they were very much dedicated towards kind of
- 24:17building peace unfortunately that's that's what's
- 24:19happening in boulder we had a home in boulder
- 24:22and it's really a community that embraces i can't
- 24:30say embraces diversity it doesn't have a lot
- 24:32of diversity but the concept and there would
- 24:37more likely be as many rallies in support of
- 24:42something, an Arab Muslim issue, as there is
- 24:45for a Jewish issue. And so the fact that it was
- 24:48targeted, I think the problem with that is the
- 24:51fact that it was targeted. Does that make people
- 24:54say maybe it's not worth those efforts? then
- 25:00we seem to be targeted rather than rewarded for
- 25:03those things. That's the danger of that. With
- 25:06October 7th, too. I mean, the people that were
- 25:07killed there, they were also, you know. And that's
- 25:09something that's not generally appreciated either.
- 25:12That the Kibbutzim that were located near the
- 25:16border very often were the most liberal of the
- 25:21Israelis. They were the group that used to take
- 25:24people to hospitals, etc., etc. And that was
- 25:27unfortunate. They were the most vulnerable. We
- 25:31spent four days on a kibbutz a few weeks ago
- 25:35and you know, we see the fence and we see life
- 25:43on one side and it seems to me that they want
- 25:49what we all want. The kids are running around.
- 25:52They want a certain amount of security and feed
- 25:56their families and do their thing, which is what
- 25:58really everyone wants. The educational aspect
- 26:02of that is the most difficult, I think. How does
- 26:08one establish the trust that if one's worried
- 26:14about an existential... about existential issues.
- 26:18How do we want to go on and then put these other
- 26:20things into focus? How do we get to young people
- 26:28so that this isn't repeated time after time?
- 26:34And I am hoping that groups like this and the
- 26:39younger people establishing a dialogue with yourself
- 26:43will offer that opportunity. But I have to say
- 26:47that I'm... I can only start with one person
- 26:50which is me and hope that that serves as an example
- 26:55that it can be done because otherwise we're kind
- 26:58of doomed to repeat it. Yeah, absolutely. And
- 27:01I think that we have to... These days we can't
- 27:06rely on... politicians and government to make
- 27:10things better. I think we have to find our own
- 27:13space where we have control and we can make things
- 27:16better in our own world. And then maybe if every
- 27:20single person we know does that, then it'll just
- 27:23happen by itself because then we'll have tens
- 27:27of thousands of people doing that at the same
- 27:29time. But I'm losing my faith in the ability.
- 27:35government to help us get out of that. Right
- 27:37now it's just a mess across the world I think
- 27:39at this point. But I think exactly having these
- 27:42sorts of like small groups and sort of being
- 27:45able to and then I think you know whatever our
- 27:47best practices are things that we're learning
- 27:48being able to share that with other people and
- 27:51being able to replicate it in other parts of
- 27:52the country in other parts of the world I think
- 27:54are very important you know. So I'm very grateful
- 27:57for both of you in terms of like just taking
- 28:01the time and interest and putting your energy
- 28:03into developing these relationships and having
- 28:06these very tough conversations. And for Stuart,
- 28:09especially, I think you do a really great job
- 28:11of probing me and asking very difficult questions,
- 28:14but it really gets you to think and it really
- 28:16helps me to be able to better understand. It
- 28:20just clarifies not just my own thinking, but
- 28:22also pushing me to think about things in different
- 28:24ways that I'm not used to. Thank you for doing
- 28:26that. I appreciate that. Thank you for doing
- 28:27that. It means a lot. It really does. You know,
- 28:33I know she keeps reminding me that I say how
- 28:37old I am, but unfortunately that really colors
- 28:41our feelings about this. And having been exposed
- 28:46to these different things, I approach this with
- 28:49a lot of skepticism and very strong feelings.
- 28:58I don't have a lot of time to waste. I want to
- 29:00ask you the things that need to be asked and
- 29:02not dance around them. Fortunately, you've been
- 29:05honest enough to answer them. And that means
- 29:10a lot. Thank you. That means a lot. I mean, the
- 29:13good thing is that you're, I think... Your age
- 29:16also, like you've also been very thoughtful,
- 29:19right? So you just haven't grown old. I feel
- 29:21you've also grown wise. And that's really helpful
- 29:23because you're able then to bring a perspective
- 29:26to the conversation that most of us don't have,
- 29:29right? I mean, you've seen events and you've
- 29:31lived through things that we haven't been through.
- 29:34And so that gives us a different sort of lens
- 29:36in terms of thinking about understanding, you
- 29:39know, understanding kind of what it means, right?
- 29:42But I hope I don't take us back. so far that
- 29:46it becomes difficult to get through that, to
- 29:49relive these kind of hurts. No, no, I think it
- 29:53gives us a good perspective. And one of the things
- 29:56I like also about our group is that it's kind
- 29:58of multi -generational. So we have younger people,
- 30:02we have older people, so you have a much more...
- 30:06um comprehensive set of um ages and sort of groups
- 30:10that are that are represented so there's a diversity
- 30:13of opinions and perspectives and each of the
- 30:15generations can kind of give their own perspective
- 30:18and i think that that that's also been very helpful
- 30:21to us yeah because it's uninteresting if there's
- 30:24only one group of people right that are kind
- 30:27of and we're just talking within our own generation
- 30:29You're able to get people from different countries,
- 30:31different generations, different backgrounds
- 30:34here in the United States. I mean, you've grown
- 30:36up differently from from Diane, Susan. Like everyone
- 30:40has had such interesting perspectives. Right.
- 30:43And then, you know, from conversion to interfaith
- 30:47marriage to all types of stuff. I mean, all of
- 30:49these different perspectives, I think, gives
- 30:51us different ways of thinking about it and also
- 30:53gives us hopefully. We're developing a language
- 30:57that we can talk about these things together
- 30:59with each other. That's important. That's really
- 31:00important. You have to have the words to be able
- 31:02to say that. It's not just a trust, but being
- 31:05able to communicate. And understand the emotion
- 31:09attached to those words. The subtleties of differences
- 31:14in what a word means to you and means to me.
- 31:18I think that's right. This is the thing that
- 31:21I think with our last dialogue. when we were
- 31:26talking about kind of the emotion, the emotional
- 31:28sort of characteristic of this idea of settler
- 31:32colonialism and all these sorts of things and
- 31:34how it's resonating with you all. And I think
- 31:38that was something that you don't necessarily
- 31:40get the Jewish perspective on that because I
- 31:44think, yeah, I mean, there's a whole emotional
- 31:49level to sort of what that means. Even the word
- 31:51Zionism. and how Zionism has a resonance within
- 31:57the Jewish community and then outside of the
- 31:59Jewish community, what Zionism means. But it's
- 32:01been given that negative connotation. Yeah, exactly.
- 32:04And it takes on. Right. You know, I think that
- 32:08the conflation of Zionism and Judaism and Jew
- 32:14is sometimes not well understood. Oh, yeah. And
- 32:20it can be negative in terms of that if it's utilization.
- 32:23Right. And becomes a political. Right. Judaism
- 32:28and you have Zionism becomes used as a political
- 32:30tool. Well, that's the thing I've seen with anti
- 32:32-Semitism as well, particularly like in the Muslim
- 32:34world. It's like everything is conflated with
- 32:36each other. Israeli, Jew, you know, ideas of,
- 32:44you know, being. And just kind of like a lot
- 32:49of the conspiracy theories and things like that
- 32:50as well. So being able to explain to people that
- 32:54there are differences and there are differences
- 32:57of opinion. And also I think the other thing
- 32:59that's been really helpful from your perspective
- 33:02on Israel and then even me kind of exploring
- 33:04a little bit more through, you know, the times
- 33:06of Israel and stuff like that. that there's so
- 33:09much diversity within the state of Israel itself.
- 33:12There's so much diversity among American Jews
- 33:14in terms of thinking about lots of these issues.
- 33:17So you can't just say this is the Jewish position,
- 33:19Jewish perspective on one issue. And there's
- 33:22a lot. And, you know, especially the other thing
- 33:24that I think has been remarkable is just seeing
- 33:26how committed you all are to social justice.
- 33:31And that's been really, you know, this whole
- 33:33Tikkun Olam thing, but just... trying to make
- 33:36the world a better place and putting your time,
- 33:39your energy, your money into these sorts of philanthropic
- 33:42efforts. I think that's also been quite remarkable
- 33:45to see. What's the saying? If not now, when?
- 33:48Yeah, exactly. And I appreciate you, Diane, for
- 33:51supporting Stuart all the time. You're always
- 33:54at his side and I really do appreciate that.
- 33:56I know you could be doing other things, but you
- 33:59really are coming and supporting and that's very
- 34:02much appreciated. With that, I want to thank
- 34:06you both. Thank you. Thank you so much for this.
- 34:09And we're looking forward to continuing the conversation.
- 34:12So thank you so much. Thank you. Of course.