Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Tesla Model S vs Model X: Ultimate 2025 Electric Luxury Sedan and SUV Comparison
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are strapping in for a
- 0:13high speed fact checking machine focused on two of the most well
- 0:16scrutinized electric vehicles in the world.
- 0:19The Tesla Model S and the Model X.
- 0:20Exactly. We are diving deep into the
- 0:23discourse around these cars. Not just the specs, but the
- 0:26intense market perception, the media battles, and you know what
- 0:31these massive new revisions really mean for the luxury EV
- 0:35space. And I have to say, right up
- 0:37front, the Model S has always been my personal favorite car.
- 0:40Oh, really? Yeah, there's just something
- 0:42about that blend of like early EV ambition, the high tech
- 0:46minimalism and that jaw-dropping speed that I think few cars can
- 0:50really match. I can.
- 0:51See that? And that actually brings us
- 0:53right to the core of this. Yeah.
- 0:54Well, our mission today is to try and extract some objective
- 0:57truth from these really polarized sources we've been
- 0:59looking at. We've got forum discussions with
- 1:02owners passionately defending battery physics, you know, and
- 1:05then we have these legacy media articles that the community
- 1:08claims are just fundamentally flawed.
- 1:10It's a total crash. It is.
- 1:12We need to get past all the noise and figure out what truly
- 1:15makes the S&X stand out or, you know, where they genuinely fall
- 1:18short in today's really competitive market.
- 1:22And that's the core conflict, isn't it?
- 1:23This tug of war between owners who live with these cars every
- 1:27single day and the traditional auto media, where some sources
- 1:32suggest reporters might not be fully objective.
- 1:35Right. Maybe because they're trying to
- 1:36protect interests from their traditional advertisers.
- 1:38It's a classic case of new tech clashing with the old guard.
- 1:42OK, so let's get into this media minefield.
- 1:44One really specific point of conflict we found in the forums
- 1:47was about an article by the director of Quattro Root, A GL
- 1:51Pellegrini, on the Model S100D. Yes.
- 1:54And the community pointed out what they saw is pretty
- 1:56significant factual mistakes in his piece, which, you know,
- 2:00ultimately led to his very negative conclusion about the
- 2:03car's viability. So what were these mistakes?
- 2:06Well, what's so interesting is how technical they were.
- 2:08It suggests maybe a lack of deep prep before the test.
- 2:12For instance, he stated that the entire Model S range had a
- 2:15double motor setup, a small one in the front and a large one in
- 2:19the back. Which is just wrong, isn't it
- 2:21for the car he was testing? Completely wrong.
- 2:24The community corrected this and it's it's crucial for
- 2:28understanding the car. The D models which means
- 2:31all-wheel drive. They actually have two small
- 2:33identical motors. For balance and efficiency.
- 2:37Bitter balance. It's only the high end
- 2:39performance the P models that get that big powerful motor in
- 2:42the rear. So he basically misunderstood
- 2:45the core drivetrain. And it didn't stop there.
- 2:47There was also some confusion around the software, which is, I
- 2:49mean, that's Tesla's whole thing.
- 2:51Right, he focused on the chill mode, which is the slower, more
- 2:54efficient setting and somehow created this confusion that
- 2:58ludicrous mode might have been like removed in a software
- 3:01update. That makes no.
- 3:02It doesn't. He completely missed that
- 3:05Ludicrous mode is often an optional upgrade you buy after
- 3:08you get the car, just like Autopilot features.
- 3:12The idea that Tesla secretly removed a headline feature?
- 3:16It's just, well, it's misleading.
- 3:18But the real kicker, the So what statement that really got people
- 3:21fired up was his final conclusion.
- 3:24Even though he had access to great charging at his office
- 3:27superchargers on his commute, he just concluded that EVs are not
- 3:31a real alternative. And that statement, coming from
- 3:35a director of a major publication, was called
- 3:37potentially devastating by the EV community.
- 3:40I can imagine. It implies that even with
- 3:42perfect infrastructure, the car still fails.
- 3:45And that led people to ask, is a problem that technology or is it
- 3:49just a psychological resistance to changing your driving habits?
- 3:52And that resistance so often comes down to range anxiety,
- 3:54doesn't it? The journalist criticized the
- 3:56100 D for getting about 350 kilometers in the real world
- 3:59versus a stated 441 kilometers. OK.
- 4:02That's a 20% drop, which sounds like a lot, but don't all car
- 4:06makers, I mean gas and electric kind of play high with their
- 4:08official numbers because of the testing cycles?
- 4:11That's the thing they all do. Everyone optimizes for the
- 4:13official tests, which never really match real world driving.
- 4:17But let's put that Tesla's efficiency into context.
- 4:20Even with that drop, its consumption is equivalent to
- 4:22about 35 kilometers per liter. Wow, that's that's incredible
- 4:28for a big luxury car. It is, especially when you put
- 4:30it next to something comparable like say, a BMW759 drive.
- 4:35That car's official consumption is around 8.2 liters per 100
- 4:38kilometers. The Tesla is nearly three times
- 4:40more efficient. The physics are just
- 4:42overwhelmingly on the EV side. OK, but hang on, comparing it to
- 4:46a huge V8 powered BMW feels a little stacked in Tesla's favor.
- 4:50What about a high end plug in hybrid?
- 4:52Wouldn't that be a fairer comparison on running costs?
- 4:55That's a great point, and it does show how tricky these
- 4:57comparisons are. But even against the best
- 4:59hybrids, the pure EV still wins on pure efficiency because a
- 5:03hybrid is always carrying the weight of, you know, 2 entire
- 5:06power trains. The hybrid uses less gas for
- 5:08sure, but the EV uses none for daily driving.
- 5:10It really just comes down to the price of electricity versus gas
- 5:13where you live. OK, let's tackle the biggest
- 5:17myth of all supercharging speed. The claim was that getting 270
- 5:21kilometers of range takes double the advertised 30.
- 5:25Minutes. And this is where the
- 5:26journalists missed the key insight that every EV owner
- 5:29learns on day one. It's about the charging curve.
- 5:32So let's break down the math. The math nugget.
- 5:34Let's hear it. The stated range is 441
- 5:37kilometers. Right charging from 20% to 80%
- 5:40is a 60% charge window. Well, 60% of 441 kilometers is
- 5:44264.6 kilometers. Which is pretty much exactly the
- 5:48270 kilometers he was talking. About precisely.
- 5:51And that 20 to 80% window is the fastest part of the charge.
- 5:54It really does take about 30 minutes.
- 5:55The huge slowdown only happens after 80% because the system
- 5:59slows down to protect the battery's health.
- 6:00So you just have to break that old habit of filling the tank
- 6:03all the way to the top. You've got it.
- 6:04It's a mental shift. And what about that home
- 6:07charging claim that a normal 3 kilowebi connection takes 30
- 6:10hours for a full charge? Again, technically true from
- 6:13zero, but totally misleading in practice.
- 6:15No one does that. The reality is overnight
- 6:18charging. If you plug in for 10 hours at
- 6:19home, you'll add about 23 kilowatts.
- 6:22And what does that get you? For 100 D, that's 1/4 of the
- 6:25battery. For the smaller 75-D, it's a
- 6:28third. It's more than enough for
- 6:30average daily commute. It becomes a completely
- 6:32frictionless habit. And we saw real world proof of
- 6:35this. A forum user covered 7600
- 6:38kilometers in 45 days. That's 170 kilometers a day.
- 6:43Wow. Yeah, with a 75 D And they said
- 6:46the Supercharger network makes it a totally viable alternative,
- 6:49especially because that force 20 or 30 minute break is perfect
- 6:52for catching up on emails or grabbing a coffee.
- 6:55And you can't forget Gennaro, the taxi driver in Italy.
- 6:58He drove his Model S for 300,000 kilometers, 300,000 as a taxi.
- 7:03Imagine the reliability and maintenance savings compared to
- 7:06a normal sedan. It's just such a powerful real
- 7:08world story that flies in the face of all that media
- 7:11skepticism. That's a perfect transition
- 7:13actually, because that long term viability story leads us to the
- 7:16new generation of the S&X. They're back in Europe with some
- 7:19major updates. And what's so fascinating is the
- 7:22new focus. It's clearly on luxury and
- 7:24comfort now, moving beyond just pure speed.
- 7:27They've tackled that long standing complaint about cabin
- 7:30noise. Oh yeah, the road noise.
- 7:31Exactly. They added new sound absorbing
- 7:34materials, they've optimized the chassis design and they've
- 7:37enhanced the active noise cancellation they're aiming for.
- 7:41And this is their term limousine silence.
- 7:44That is a high bar, especially compared to their German rivals.
- 7:48How are they doing that? Well, it seems to be a midst of
- 7:50things. Stiffer chassis, maybe some
- 7:52acoustic glass. They've also retuned the air
- 7:55suspension for better comfort. And they have new wheel designs,
- 7:59Nineteens and 20 ones for the S 20s and 20 twos for the X that
- 8:03are designed for better aerodynamics, which also cuts
- 8:05down on wind noise. And inside, the tech has gotten
- 8:08a big refresh too, right? A new user interface.
- 8:10Yeah, a much more intuitive UI, which is critical when the whole
- 8:14car runs on that one screen. They've also added dynamic RGB
- 8:18ambient lighting, which is a bit of a nod to that classic
- 8:21European luxury feel. And some important safety
- 8:24upgrades. For sure a new front bumper
- 8:26camera for tight spots, better blind spot indicators, and new
- 8:29adaptive headlights. Oh, and for the Model X, they've
- 8:31managed to make that third row a bit more spacious.
- 8:34Which was definitely needed. It was, but of course the real
- 8:37headline, what everyone is talking about is that ridiculous
- 8:41Plaid performance. OK, let's do the numbers,
- 8:43because this is where physics starts to feel optional.
- 8:46It really does. The Model S Plaid does zero to
- 8:48100 kilometers per hour in 2.1 seconds. 2.1.
- 8:52At a top speed of 322 kilometers per hour.
- 8:56But, and this is a big but, you only get that top speed if you
- 8:59buy the optional carbon ceramic brake kit.
- 9:02Wait, hold on, so the headline number is locked behind an
- 9:04expensive upgrade? Isn't that a little bit of a
- 9:07sneaky marketing tactic? Especially after we just
- 9:09critique journalists for being misleading.
- 9:11You know, it definitely walks a fine line.
- 9:13It's physically possible, but not out-of-the-box.
- 9:17Still, even with that insane power, the Plaid model gets 611
- 9:21kilometers of autonomy. The engineering is just it's
- 9:24incredible and the giant Model X Plaid still does zero to 100 in
- 9:282.6 seconds and. For a little while, they're
- 9:30throwing in unlimited free supercharging, but there's a big
- 9:33catch there, too. A huge one.
- 9:35It's only for the first owner and it explicitly excludes
- 9:38commercial use. So no taxis, no ride sharing.
- 9:42They are clearly protecting the supercharger network from the
- 9:45strain of high mileage commercial drivers.
- 9:47Maybe learning a lesson from guys like Gennaro.
- 9:50So if we pull all this together and look at the big picture, the
- 9:52new S&X still have some really distinct advantages, even
- 9:56against newer competitors like the Audi E Tron GT or the
- 9:59Mercedes EQS. What are those specific data
- 10:02points that you think keep them ahead?
- 10:05Well, first is autonomy. They're still generally getting
- 10:08higher real world range, you know up to 611 kilometers where
- 10:11a lot of rivals are in that 400 to 500 kilometer bucket.
- 10:15Second is software. Nobody else is really close on
- 10:18the over the air updates and the integrated ecosystem.
- 10:20And the charging network. And the charging network, the
- 10:22supercharged network is just more reliable and better
- 10:25integrated than the patchwork of third party networks everyone
- 10:27else is using. But there are still some really
- 10:30good reasons not to choose a Tesla Price, obviously.
- 10:33But what about the more subjective things?
- 10:36Well, subjectively, that minimalist interior, even with
- 10:39the new lighting, it just doesn't have that same plush,
- 10:43classic European luxury feel you get from Mercedes.
- 10:47If you want lots of buttons and wood grain, you're still going
- 10:50to lean toward the Germans. And service centers can still be
- 10:52an issue in some areas. That's a big one.
- 10:55The service network just isn't as built out as the legacy
- 10:57brands, which could be a real logistical headache.
- 11:00So the trade off is clear and meanwhile the competition is
- 11:03getting so much tougher. Oh, it's relentless.
- 11:06Look at the new Corsch Macon Electric.
- 11:08It's aiming right for that sporty SUV crown, and it's using
- 11:11an 800 Volt architecture. Which is a technical advantage.
- 11:15A big one. It could mean faster, more
- 11:17efficient charging. Then you've got challenges from
- 11:19China, like at Densa Z, promising 950 horsepower, going
- 11:23right after the Tican and Model S Plaid.
- 11:26Every single segment is under attack.
- 11:28It's happening everywhere. Absolutely, from hypercar tires
- 11:32to compact city EVs. And this pressure is also
- 11:35forcing compliance. Nissan for example is under huge
- 11:38pressure in Europe to sell more EVs or face massive fines for
- 11:42CO2 targets. The whole market is just
- 11:44evolving at a crazy pace. So after this whole deep dive
- 11:48chart and physics, media bias, hypercar specs, what does this
- 11:52all mean for you, the listener trying to make sense of the EV
- 11:55world right now? I think the key take away is
- 11:57that the evolution is so constant, any knowledge you gain
- 12:00today has to be seen as temporary.
- 12:02What's a real drawback right now?
- 12:03Like, you know, juggling 5 different charging apps might be
- 12:06completely solved by an integrated system tomorrow.
- 12:08You have to be ready to reassess things every six months.
- 12:10That's really great context and given our whole discussion about
- 12:13traditional media versus these powerful enthusiast forums,
- 12:17here's a final thought for you to chew on.
- 12:19Does the opinion of the traditional print magazine
- 12:21director even hold the same market sway it once did,
- 12:24especially when real world user reviews and you know, 300,000
- 12:29kilometer taxi driver reports are just a click away for
- 12:32everyone. Thank you so much for joining us
- 12:34for this deep dive into Tesla's flagship cars and the wild media
- 12:37landscape around them. We really hope you feel more
- 12:39informed, and if you want more curated explorations like this,
- 12:42be sure to follow our channel. We'll see you next time.