Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Imitation of Life (1934) featuring Antonia Carlotta
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And once again, I would like
- 0:22to introduce the great -grandniece of Carl Laemmle,
- 0:25founder of Universal Studios, and the host and
- 0:28founder of Universally Me, a YouTube series dedicated
- 0:32to Universal Studios and classic horror. This
- 0:35is Antonia Carlotta. Hi. Nice to be here again.
- 0:40It's so nice to see you again, and I'm looking
- 0:43forward to talking about another movie with you.
- 0:45Yeah, the last time we talked was kind of about
- 0:48All Quiet on the Western Front and just Universal
- 0:50during the shift into the 1930s, and now we're
- 0:54halfway through the 30s talking once again. Yeah,
- 0:57and you know, this movie, Imitation of Life,
- 1:00when they were promoting it, Carl Laemmle called
- 1:02it the greatest movie since All Quiet on the
- 1:05Western Front. Oh, really? Yes. Well, that's
- 1:08perfect because then the greatest episode we've
- 1:11had so far will be followed by the next greatest
- 1:13episode. The next greatest episode since that
- 1:15one. We'll just continue the trend. Yeah, we'll
- 1:17keep that going. I hope you're ready for the
- 1:18next great episode because we'll need you for
- 1:20that. So, Antonia, the question that I have for
- 1:24you right off the bat, you know, I know we're
- 1:25doing a little bit different of a format than
- 1:27we had last time when we had you on the show.
- 1:29So we're excited to have you join us to talk
- 1:31about The Imitation of Life today. But how many
- 1:34times, if any, have you seen Imitation of Life
- 1:37before this coverage? Oh. Tons. I saw it for
- 1:42the first time probably 10 or 15 years ago at
- 1:46this point. Loved it right from the jump. But
- 1:50there was a time maybe seven years ago when I
- 1:52remember watching it and starting to look more
- 1:54into it for an episode of one of my... for a
- 1:58universally me episode. And that's when I found
- 2:00out that the movie not only today can be controversial,
- 2:02but even when it came out was controversial.
- 2:04And so I've seen it quite a bit more since then
- 2:07trying to discern my own feelings about the movie.
- 2:11Nice. Yeah, that was my experience. I mean, this
- 2:13was my first time watching it. Avid listeners
- 2:16of the pod will know that whenever I'm picking
- 2:19up Criterions, I have a really bad habit. I guess
- 2:22it's a good habit in this case of picking up
- 2:23movies that I haven't watched yet. And I'm like,
- 2:25I'm going to get there. And Imitation of Life
- 2:27was one of them. I can't tell you when I picked
- 2:29it up, but I was so happy to have it because
- 2:31this looks like we'll start with the Criterion
- 2:34cut, I guess. I love the restoration of this.
- 2:37It looks beautiful. Yeah, 100%. It's a gorgeous
- 2:40cut of the movie. All of the colors. The colors.
- 2:43It's black and white, but, you know, like...
- 2:45It's a very crisp cut of the movie, is what I'm
- 2:48saying. Yeah, no, it's really great. I mean,
- 2:49so the way that you watched it in, Tony, this
- 2:51most recent time, do you have the Criterion as
- 2:54well, or do you have a physical copy of it? No,
- 2:56I rent it on Apple TV, Amazon Prime. There's
- 3:02a really shady Russian site that sometimes I'll
- 3:05watch it on online. Thank you for shouting out
- 3:08that Russian site. It is, like, my best friend
- 3:10for this podcast. I'm really embarrassed to admit
- 3:14that, like, I'm terrible when it comes to, you
- 3:17know, Blu -rays and DVDs and physical media.
- 3:20I really just catch things where they are, and
- 3:23I don't own anything. Zero issue with that. I
- 3:26mean, like, you have a great collection as it
- 3:28is right now. Does that happen to be a Blade
- 3:30Runner collection at the top left? Me? Yeah,
- 3:33never mind. Nope. For some reason, I thought
- 3:35it was a Blade Runner collection. That's my own
- 3:37dumb brain. I'm not even sure where you're looking.
- 3:39Right there. That's a Dracula coffee table book.
- 3:43Much cooler than what I was thinking it was.
- 3:45So no, that makes way more sense. Romancing the
- 3:48Vampire from Past to Present by David Scull.
- 3:52Okay, neat. I like it. Very cool. Check it out.
- 3:56I think it used to belong to my Aunt Carla. Oh,
- 3:59that's cool. Really cool to pass that down. So
- 4:02I think what we'll do is we'll hop right into
- 4:04the idea of going into the imitation of life.
- 4:07So we are going to continue the trend of covering
- 4:09the 1935, or sorry, this is 1934. I'm getting
- 4:13ahead of myself. Yeah. The ceremony was in 1934.
- 4:16Yeah. Sorry. So 1934 nominations. So the Imitation
- 4:21of Life had three nominations in total. One was
- 4:24sound recording, and this was for Theodore Soderbergh.
- 4:27Assistant director was for Scott Arbiel. And
- 4:29outstanding production, of course, was for Universal.
- 4:33Yeah, and this was directed by John M. Stahl,
- 4:35starred Claudette Colbert as Bay B. I'm sorry.
- 4:39She is Bay. For you, yes, this is true. She is
- 4:42Bay. But yeah, B. Louise Beavers as Delilah,
- 4:45Freddie Washington as her daughter Piola, Warren
- 4:48Williams as romantic interest Steve Archer, and
- 4:52I want to shout out Ned Sparks as Elmer Smith
- 4:54because he's one of my favorite side characters.
- 4:56We love Ned Sparks on this pod. He's great. Antonia,
- 4:59do you want to tell us a little bit what the
- 5:01film is about? Sure. So the movie opens with
- 5:05a black housekeeper coming upon Bea's home, Claudette
- 5:09Colbert's home, in search for work. But she accidentally
- 5:12went to the wrong home. But they become friendly.
- 5:16She starts working for Claudette Colbert, or
- 5:19for Bea, and living in her home. And they go
- 5:24into business together with a pancake business.
- 5:27And from there, the movie goes into just being
- 5:30a really... interesting commentary on race, on
- 5:34passing, a little bit on class. There's a love
- 5:38story, kind of the story of the different experiences
- 5:42of the mothers and their relationships with their
- 5:44daughters and all of that and their successful
- 5:46booming pancake business. Yeah, absolutely. Beautifully
- 5:50done. You know, I'm not ashamed. Well, actually,
- 5:52I am. That's the wrong sentiment. I am ashamed
- 5:55to admit that there's a scene in which I was
- 5:58confused because Louise Beavers, Delilah, uses
- 6:01the term you just did there, Antonio, which is
- 6:03passing. It's when she goes to visit Viola in
- 6:06her classroom. And after she realizes, Delilah,
- 6:11that her daughter is in the class with white
- 6:14students, she says the phrase, or she asks the
- 6:16question, is she passing? And in my eyes, I was
- 6:20like, yeah, of course, you want to know if she's
- 6:22doing well in the class. Of course. Like, not
- 6:23a problem. And this was lost on me until they
- 6:27come back to the house and Claudette Colbert
- 6:28is involved. And she's like, oh, she was passing
- 6:30for white. I was like, oh. This is, of course,
- 6:34a very common phrase that I just had not really
- 6:36stopped to think of. And this is like maybe 35
- 6:39minutes into the movie. And that's when it kind
- 6:41of unlocked the whole idea of race identity at
- 6:44this time. Because, of course, you start thinking
- 6:46about Claudette Colbert's race versus Louise
- 6:49Beaver's and their relationship and how that
- 6:51affects things. But it's a completely different
- 6:53story with Piola. And I was astonished by tackling
- 6:58this kind of subject in 1934. Yeah, it's really
- 7:01ahead of its time in a lot of ways. And, you
- 7:04know, the movie ran into some issues while it
- 7:06was being made because 1934, that's when the
- 7:09production code really starts to be enforced.
- 7:12And so it was really controversial and Universal
- 7:15had a lot of issues having this storyline at
- 7:19all about not just race, but passing and the
- 7:22fact that Piola is so white because there's this
- 7:27implication of relations. between races, and
- 7:31that was not okay by production code standards.
- 7:34And so that was something they had to, like,
- 7:36be careful with as they were making the movie.
- 7:40Yeah, everything I've read in the research of,
- 7:42like, the hurdles that the film went through
- 7:45for the production code, it all centers around
- 7:47Freddie Washington's character, Piola, and, yeah,
- 7:51the misogyny... Wow. Misogy... How do you say
- 7:55that? Misogynation? Misogynation? Yeah. I say
- 7:59it wrong every time. But yes, the interracial
- 8:02relationships. That was the big problem that
- 8:05the production code had with the film. Which
- 8:07is... Something I've never maybe had the answer
- 8:11to, I'm not positive, is once... Because schools
- 8:14were not integrated for another 20 years after
- 8:17this movie was made. So once they know that Piola
- 8:22is in fact black, is she still allowed to...
- 8:26go to that school or attend those classes? Like
- 8:29to what extent was she passing for her own personal
- 8:32choice versus like necessity? Yeah, I don't know
- 8:36because she is going to school in New York. So
- 8:39obviously that's going to be a lot different
- 8:41than school in the South during that time period.
- 8:43But I don't know like which specific areas were
- 8:47already being segregated and if New York was
- 8:50kind of a little more loose on that or if they
- 8:53just never brought it, like it was never brought
- 8:55up. Well, I do know that there's a line that
- 8:58Louise Beavers has where she says that, you know,
- 9:01we can't keep like switching schools. So this
- 9:03has happened a couple of times, maybe not for
- 9:04this reason, but it sounds like the idea of switching
- 9:07schools is something that's pretty common. So
- 9:09it might just be that. I have some questions
- 9:12also of like how Louise Beavers doesn't know
- 9:13like that her school, her daughter's going to
- 9:16this school and passing in that sense. Right.
- 9:18So there's a couple of things like that. There
- 9:20are some confusion, cause some confusion for
- 9:22me. But overall, very minor things that otherwise
- 9:25it was just absolutely insane to see like the
- 9:28nominees for this year and see the subject matter
- 9:31at hand for Imitation of Life. Yeah, I completely
- 9:34agree. Like there are certain moments, everything.
- 9:38that involves louise beavers and freddie washington
- 9:41in this movie is so captivating every time they're
- 9:43on screen and as as much as i love claude colbert
- 9:47uh bay if you will like i i enjoy her at the
- 9:52beginning when she meets delilah and she has
- 9:55this this bond with her um when delilah after
- 9:59i think it's after the first day of when she's
- 10:01working for b she comes home from work and she
- 10:04gives b a foot massage and she's like You know,
- 10:06you shouldn't be selling maple syrup on your
- 10:09feet all day and you should have just a better
- 10:12job. And just the bond between the two characters,
- 10:15like I loved that. But as the movie went on and
- 10:18it be like the two stories kind of split and
- 10:21Delilah was very much dealing with Piola and
- 10:24then Claudette Colbert has her romance with Steve
- 10:28Archer. I lost interest in all of that so quickly.
- 10:32It's just not the highlight of the movie for
- 10:35me. Yeah, I mean, none of the love story carries
- 10:39the same weight as the rest of the movie at all.
- 10:42And I think there are so many beautiful scenes
- 10:45between, yeah, Claudette Colbert and Louise Beavers
- 10:48that sort of speak to sort of the race and that
- 10:51difference in status. You mentioned, you know,
- 10:54giving the foot rubs. I always think of the scene
- 10:57right after she finds out that Piola was passing
- 11:01when... what's her name? Jesse, like Jesse called
- 11:06Piola black and she's crying. I won't be black.
- 11:09I won't be black. And Claudette Colbert is standing
- 11:11there like, how could you say such a cruel thing?
- 11:14That's so terrible. That's so cruel. And just
- 11:17the fact that even acknowledging Piola's blackness
- 11:20would be considered cruel. And she's saying that,
- 11:23you know, right in front of her. And there's
- 11:25sort of that interesting moment there too, where
- 11:27Louise Beavers like breaks the fourth wall. She
- 11:30looks. like directly into the camera and she's
- 11:33like say something like you know it's it's not
- 11:35your fault it's not my fault it couldn't be the
- 11:39lord's fault it just puzzles me you know why
- 11:41things are the way they are or something like
- 11:43that um also the other scene that always sticks
- 11:46out to me is just when they're starting that
- 11:49pancake business and um b says you know something
- 11:54about oh we'll give you 20 of the company and
- 11:57you can get your own house and louise she's uh
- 12:00Not Louise, but Delilah is like, no, you want
- 12:02to kick me out? Oh, no, but I want to live for
- 12:05you and work for you and rub your feet all day.
- 12:08Right. Yeah. It's like she's she's so stuck in
- 12:13that mindset of like servitude that the thought
- 12:16of leaving that lifestyle, even if it is for
- 12:19her benefit, she's just she's so against it.
- 12:21And I think that's what makes Piola's relationship
- 12:24with her mother and with being black so. damaging
- 12:28to her because the way that she has seen it the
- 12:30most in her life is her mother being kind of
- 12:34this servant character. And she's like, well,
- 12:36I don't, I don't want that for me. Yes. And she's
- 12:38so close, you know, she, she's so close to looking
- 12:42like Jesse or B or, you know, having that privilege
- 12:47that she, you know, it probably feels so within
- 12:50her grasp, but because of her mom and because
- 12:53of where she comes from, she feels like that's
- 12:55what she's, you know, um just like destined to
- 12:59be as well yeah yeah this was i mean I want to
- 13:04take a quick step. We've talked about a couple
- 13:06people here. Obviously, Rochelle Hudson as Jesse
- 13:09Pullman was someone else I wanted to kind of
- 13:10shout out because I liked her performance a lot
- 13:13here. And it's something that Kyle and I kind
- 13:15of, it's funny how our research comes into play
- 13:18here sometimes. We just watched Les Mis from
- 13:211935. And we had noticed in that, I brought up
- 13:24to you recently, Kyle, that Marilyn Nolten plays
- 13:26the young version of Jesse. And it's, of course,
- 13:29Rachel, Rochelle Hudson, who plays the older
- 13:31version of Jesse. And they did the same thing
- 13:34in Les Mis with Cosette. Those two actresses
- 13:37played the younger and older versions of themselves
- 13:39in that. And I thought it was really impressive
- 13:41because the one thing my wife, Taylor, watches
- 13:43with me and she was like. If they nailed one
- 13:46thing in this movie, it's that they found an
- 13:48actress who looked enough like Claudette Colbert,
- 13:51where it could be her daughter, and then found
- 13:53a younger actress who looked so much like the
- 13:55older version of the daughter that they're like,
- 13:56these three people can pass. And it was very,
- 13:59very effective. So I wanted to shout that out.
- 14:01But also just in terms of the acting, I can't
- 14:04say I'm very familiar with Louise Beavers. But
- 14:06I mean, she just captivated me the entire time.
- 14:08Well, if you remember, she was in She Done Him
- 14:11Wrong. Oh, she was. Oh, you're right. She was.
- 14:15She was Mae West's servant character in that
- 14:17as well. She was basically just in the bedroom
- 14:19and that's it, right? She often played this type
- 14:23of character. You know, I think that's a lot
- 14:25of what was available at the time. But it's interesting
- 14:28because Louise Beavers was born and raised in
- 14:30Pasadena. You know, she's very California. She
- 14:34was not naturally overweight. She would have
- 14:36to eat, you know, like she would have to maintain
- 14:38her weight in order to play this type of character
- 14:40because that's, again, what was available for
- 14:42her to play. It's so wild, yeah. Yeah, everything
- 14:46that I've seen her listed as, it is very much
- 14:49this character. And I will say, like, the only
- 14:52other thing that I've seen her in that I can
- 14:54remember, at least, is she done him wrong. And
- 14:56like you said, she has a very small role in that.
- 14:58So it really was incredible to see her kind of
- 15:01take the stage here and just she's the dominant
- 15:05character throughout this entire movie. That's
- 15:08awesome. You don't see that. No, it's a real
- 15:09exchange between her and Colbert. Like it feels
- 15:12like an actual like communication of two actors
- 15:15and not like one trying to take the stage over
- 15:17another, which not to say that they would, but
- 15:19it's just it's very it feels very earned in a
- 15:22movie like this in a time like that, which is
- 15:23a miracle. first achievement if I'm sure they
- 15:45just weren't that level of progressive yet which
- 15:48is wild to say in you know Hattie McDaniels in
- 15:511940 like that was more progressive than this
- 15:53but yeah I mean it's all about you know you know
- 15:56and actually if you go back and look at a lot
- 15:57of the marketing for imitation of life Louise
- 16:00Beavers and Freddie Washington are left out of
- 16:02a lot of it like they don't really address race
- 16:06you know front and center they don't include
- 16:09them i think in one of my videos i actually showed
- 16:12a an example from i forget if it was a universal
- 16:15weekly or something else but they had a picture
- 16:16of every single character from the movie they
- 16:20had a picture of john m stall of carl lemley
- 16:23of everybody involved in it and all the kids
- 16:25and all the side characters and freddie washington
- 16:28and louise beavers were not included in it at
- 16:30all wild yeah so it again for as As progressive
- 16:35as it might have been for the time, it still
- 16:37also very much wasn't. Yeah. The Criterion version,
- 16:42I borrowed Brian's copy as well. And one of the
- 16:45bonus features there is actually a theatrical
- 16:46trailer that was cut for black audiences. And
- 16:50the only people highlighted in that movie are
- 16:52Louise Beavers and Freddie Washington. So that
- 16:54was really interesting to see. And I guess that
- 16:56was fairly common practice back in the time.
- 16:59But that's the first. time i've ever actually
- 17:02seen one yeah a trailer like that it's interesting
- 17:05because the way that we saw the advertisement
- 17:07for this i mean even the movie itself opens with
- 17:09claudette colbert and warren william uh starring
- 17:13in imitation of life and then just happens to
- 17:16mention louise beavers and freddie washington
- 17:17afterwards so even the movie itself is portraying
- 17:21itself differently than some of the advertising
- 17:22i mean the the cover that we know is of claudette
- 17:25colbert and louise beavers sharing the screen
- 17:27i think it has both of them built at the top
- 17:29so very interesting how it's done i mean it makes
- 17:31sense at the time but again just crazy that it's
- 17:36even happening there i want to go back real quick
- 17:37you mentioned hattie mcdaniel um did you know
- 17:39she appears in this movie really she's in the
- 17:42uh funeral scene at the end Oh, wow. She's one
- 17:45of the guests at the funeral. I read that. Which
- 17:47I thought, to your exact point, right? Like the
- 17:49history of Hattie McDaniels being the first to
- 17:53win that Oscar. Nominated or to win? She won.
- 17:57Or is it both? You know what? I don't know. Definitely
- 18:00won. At least the first to win. So that makes
- 18:02perfect sense. But I thought it was a nice little
- 18:04bit of trivia that she happens to be in that
- 18:07scene in this movie with Elise Beavers five years
- 18:09before that happens. Yeah, that's really cool.
- 18:11You mentioned a few scenes that stood out to
- 18:15you. Did you have any others? Like, I kind of
- 18:17want to go around the room and everyone points
- 18:20out their favorite scenes. Because there were
- 18:22so many that, like, there's a lot of camera work
- 18:24in this that really stood out to me and does
- 18:26a lot of visual storytelling in a way that these
- 18:29Best Picture nominees don't always hit the same
- 18:31way. And this is one where it does. So was there
- 18:33anything like that for you? You know, one of
- 18:35the most beautiful... that I think might be kind
- 18:41of symbolic in the film is that one shot right
- 18:43after the party when Louise Beavers and Claudette
- 18:48Colbert, they kind of have their moment and Louise
- 18:50is going down the stairs as Claudette is going
- 18:52up the stairs. And for Louise Beavers, you really
- 18:57see her kind of shadowed. She's going into like
- 19:00a little more darkness. Claudette Colbert is
- 19:03right above her kind of walking up into the light
- 19:06like in her beautiful gown. And it's just a beautiful
- 19:08shot that I think holds a lot of meaning behind
- 19:11it as well. Absolutely. There's so much storytelling
- 19:14done in that shot. alone it's incredible absolutely
- 19:17i mean that was that was definitely one of my
- 19:19favorites the other one too happens pretty early
- 19:21on and it's when claudette colbert i think is
- 19:23on the phone she just got done from giving uh
- 19:26jesse a bath and she's on the phone and it's
- 19:29a tracking shot that follows her from the uh
- 19:31i guess entry area to the kitchen where you can
- 19:34fully see her like working in the oven and everything
- 19:36and like everything is really close and she comes
- 19:38back to the phone and you see the camera just
- 19:40pull back and it's those kind of tracking shots
- 19:43that i didn't expect In something that is like,
- 19:46I mean, I don't mean this as an insult. I think
- 19:48that's the actual genre, the melodrama of something
- 19:50like this. Yeah. I did not expect that. Yeah,
- 19:53that was actually the shot I was going to call
- 19:55out because it does start at the top of the stairs
- 19:57still in the bathroom. And you follow Claudette
- 20:00all the way down the stairs and it does that
- 20:01push and pull back. And I don't know if it was
- 20:04intentional, but I felt like the suspense that
- 20:07was built. during that scene felt like Hitchcock
- 20:10levels of suspense. Absolutely. Because the door,
- 20:12the screen door is in the background and you
- 20:15immediately clock it. And you're like, well,
- 20:16I mean, what is it? Schrodinger's back door,
- 20:20I guess, in this sense. Right. You see a back
- 20:22door, you know, it's about to get knocked on
- 20:23or something. Yeah. So I agree with you. It's
- 20:25almost like a level of suspense of like, okay,
- 20:27what's going to happen with that door? Right.
- 20:29And to me, even it was like, okay, I've just
- 20:32seen her come down the stairs and I've just seen
- 20:34her kid in the bathtub. You don't break that
- 20:36camera. at all during that first opening scene
- 20:39i was like is the kid gonna fall in the tub is
- 20:42the kid gonna walk down the stairs is something
- 20:44going to happen to this kid and the fact that
- 20:45the camera never cuts away it makes you sit with
- 20:48all of those elements that are introduced one
- 20:50at a time including the back door and i was genuinely
- 20:53scared at the beginning of this film and like
- 20:56something does happen but it's not you know bomb
- 20:59doesn't randomly go off in the oven or something
- 21:00no it's a 10 second issue yeah i also just realized
- 21:03i said schrodinger's are not checkoffs uh back
- 21:05door my bad oh my god oh yeah the door is open
- 21:08and closed someone's there and not there yeah
- 21:12um totally different vibe and i know you know
- 21:15we spoke to that the sort of love story as not
- 21:20being nearly as maybe engaging as the other part.
- 21:24But I do love the scene at the party when she
- 21:26meets Stephen Archer for the first time and he
- 21:28doesn't know that it's her. And he's being a
- 21:31little snarky about, you know, the pancake queen.
- 21:34And it feels, you know, like you're just very
- 21:36classic, cute, light rom -com in a way that's,
- 21:41it is really fun to watch. And I think there's
- 21:43a lot of charm in that scene from both of them.
- 21:45I agree. Like, I think it's written really well
- 21:49and it is very sweet and they are great together.
- 21:51I just think in any other movie I would be able
- 21:54to like dial into that story a little easier
- 21:57than I did with this. But totally. Like I love
- 22:01his profession being an ichthyologist. Yes. And
- 22:04everybody just having no idea what that is. It's
- 22:07such a funny little gag. It was a great running
- 22:09bit of everyone being like, yeah, for sure. Yeah,
- 22:11I love Jesse being like, no, of course. What
- 22:13do you think I go to school for? Of course I
- 22:15know what an ichthyologist is. And then going
- 22:17to her encyclopedia like, ichthyologist. It's
- 22:20so good. Me talking to Kyle about any movie.
- 22:24Yeah, man, for sure. And I go do my research.
- 22:26It's so good. I do, you know, even though it's
- 22:29not as great a storyline, I guess it could speak
- 22:32a little bit to just the difference in. The weight
- 22:36of the problems between Piola and Jesse, that
- 22:40Jesse is, you know, falling in love with her
- 22:42mom's boyfriend, you know, has a schoolgirl crush.
- 22:45When she thinks about leaving school or maybe
- 22:47wants to go to Switzerland or this or that, you
- 22:49know, her mom's easy breezy about everything
- 22:51because nothing matters. They can do what they
- 22:54want. They're perfectly fine, safe, financially
- 22:57well off, etc. But for Piola, there's like real
- 23:00scary life implications to any choice that she
- 23:04makes. That's a great point. That's a great point.
- 23:07So the relationship between Bea and Steven is
- 23:10obviously something that takes up the majority
- 23:12of the second half of this movie. But there's
- 23:15kind of a wrinkle to it in the sense that at
- 23:16one point Bea has to travel with Delilah, or
- 23:19at least decides to travel with Delilah, because
- 23:21they found and have an idea of where Piola might
- 23:24be. So she leaves Steven with her daughter, Jessie,
- 23:28to get to know each other. And there's like a
- 23:32bit of a romance on Jessie's side towards Steven.
- 23:35And there's a section of this where it almost,
- 23:38I want to see how you both felt about this. There's
- 23:40a section where it almost kind of like the movie
- 23:42tricks you into thinking that Steven might also
- 23:44be in on this. Did you both feel that way as
- 23:46well? I worried when she was first leaving to
- 23:51accompany Delilah. I worried that that was the
- 23:54direction that it was going to go in. Right.
- 23:57But once... Things were really in motion. I didn't
- 24:01feel anything improper from Stephen Archer. Yes,
- 24:05which is correct. I mean, the movie tells you
- 24:07that, like, Stephen was somehow blind to this
- 24:09and didn't know, even though there is a line
- 24:11he says where he's like, I think he says something.
- 24:13Or no, Jesse says, like, if mother found out,
- 24:15she would just die or something. And he's just
- 24:17like, letting that go. Don't know what that's
- 24:19about. But I mean, Jesse develops feelings for
- 24:22Stephen, right? Because she doesn't know at this
- 24:24time that, again, we're in the 1930s, miscommunication
- 24:27abound. But she doesn't know that her mother
- 24:29is interested in pursuing a relationship with
- 24:31Stephen, in fact, of getting engaged. So she
- 24:34develops feelings for such an older man. I mean,
- 24:37let's assume 30s, right? And she's 18, I think,
- 24:41at the time. Yeah, 18 or 19. Yeah, she must be
- 24:43either 18 or 19. Right. So did you feel that
- 24:46at all, Kyle? Did you feel that coming? Yeah,
- 24:49when it first happened and they're together,
- 24:51I'm like, man, I hope this guy isn't just like,
- 24:53oh, this girl's into me too? La -di -da. And
- 24:57I was so relieved when he really makes no type
- 25:01of advancement or no reaction to this at all
- 25:04other than, hey, girl, I'm going to need you
- 25:07to chill out. And it was such a relief. I was
- 25:10so worried. But I still think, like, I know this
- 25:13is based on a book. I don't know if we mentioned
- 25:14that at the top of the show. Yeah, it is based
- 25:16on a novel by Fanny Hurst. Yeah. Yes. And I think
- 25:19based on her road trip with Zora Neale Hurston,
- 25:23they had like a road trip to Canada that I think
- 25:26became the inspiration for this book. Okay. Wow.
- 25:29I'm curious, like I'd kind of like to read the
- 25:31book because I want to know what this part of
- 25:34this romance looks like in the book, if it exists
- 25:37at all. If it doesn't, I'm so confused as to
- 25:39why it was added because it really feels like...
- 25:42Does this add conflict to the relationship at
- 25:45all, like necessary conflict, or is it just another
- 25:47piece? You know, I've never read the book, so
- 25:50I don't know if it's in there. You know, my hypothesis
- 25:53might be that, again, if we're thinking about
- 25:57film censorship and what is allowed or not allowed,
- 26:00that having this other story lets you say, oh,
- 26:03but it's a love story. Look at Claudette Colbert
- 26:06and Warren William together. You know, that's
- 26:08really what the movie is about instead of. Without
- 26:11it now, it's purely a movie about race. Sure.
- 26:15Yeah. I just even then, if that is true, I feel
- 26:18like you can get by with Steven and B to have
- 26:22to throw Jesse into the mix. I'm just like, OK,
- 26:25sure. I guess we can do that. Yeah, it didn't
- 26:28feel it felt out of place. It didn't feel like
- 26:30it was earned in the story, especially when maybe
- 26:33as well. You know, again, if we're going to make
- 26:36the parallels between Claudette Colbert. Or I
- 26:40guess I should use their, but Bea and Jesse versus
- 26:43Delilah and Piola, sort of the lengths that moms
- 26:48will go to to protect their daughters. Yes. So,
- 26:52you know, Bea was willing to give up that relationship
- 26:54in order for her daughter to, you know, move
- 26:58on and be happy and not think about it. Yeah.
- 27:00The same way that, you know, Delilah, obviously
- 27:03with much bigger things, was like willing to
- 27:05do anything her daughter wanted to keep her safe
- 27:08and happy and healthy. That's that helps me so
- 27:12much because I could not figure out like by the
- 27:14end of the movie. Spoiler B does throw away that
- 27:18relationship, like you said, to kind of protect
- 27:20and help her daughter get over it. And when that
- 27:23was happening, I was like, really, really? Would
- 27:25you not just say, hey, sorry, Jesse, I'm you
- 27:28know, this is my guy. It just felt weird to me.
- 27:31But your explanation of it makes complete sense.
- 27:34And while I still think it's kind of a weird
- 27:36choice. it does add some context. Yeah, like
- 27:39maybe the fact that that whole storyline feels
- 27:41empty is the point. Like maybe there is a commentary
- 27:46there that white people problems are frivolous.
- 27:49White people problems are, you know, nothing
- 27:52compared to what others have to go through. Yeah.
- 27:55Or maybe I'm really making something like...
- 27:59big and brilliant out of a nothing burger. Well,
- 28:01no, I mean, you know, there, there's a reason
- 28:03that this is, this film is held in high regard.
- 28:06There's a reason that it has a criterion addition.
- 28:08And I think that you're reading correctly into
- 28:10it. You know, I think I, I still agree with Kyle
- 28:13that like, I was 100 % behind Steven when he
- 28:16was like, she's 18. She's about to go off to
- 28:18school. She's going to forget about me. Like,
- 28:20it's going to be okay. Yeah. She's like, no,
- 28:22no, I can't do it. So, but you're again, like
- 28:24to echo Kyle's thoughts or. what he said uh you're
- 28:28right like you gave me a lot to think about with
- 28:30that but that's probably what it is and especially
- 28:32the lack of importance in something like that
- 28:36story versus like delilah on her deathbed over
- 28:39piola like it doesn't seem as major and that
- 28:42must be the point yeah i agree So thank you for
- 28:45that, because I was like, this is a bummer. I
- 28:49do want to call out, we talked a little bit about
- 28:52the framing and the shots, and I really enjoyed
- 28:54that. Another thing that I really liked with
- 28:56Stephen Archer, it wasn't even him or, sorry,
- 29:00Warren William. It was the camera work of him
- 29:03leaving the apartment at one point. I don't know
- 29:05if you know the shot I'm talking about, but he's
- 29:07walking down the stairs and outside and the camera
- 29:11has a tracking shot, but there's like trees that
- 29:13pass by. And it really reminded me of It's a
- 29:16Wonderful Life when he's running through, Bailey's
- 29:19running through the town at the end. It felt
- 29:21very similar in that tracking shot. So I didn't
- 29:24know. This one specifically stood out to me.
- 29:26A lot of the themes were obviously very important,
- 29:28but I really, really liked the framing of this
- 29:30movie overall. Enough to a point where I want
- 29:32to check out more from John M. Stahl. I can't
- 29:34say I'm very familiar with him either, but this
- 29:37was, I really enjoyed it. Yeah. Have you seen
- 29:39anything else from the director, Antonia? I was
- 29:42just about to IMDb him. Yeah. I'll do the same
- 29:46thing. I'm a little embarrassed to admit that.
- 29:49No, don't be. Please. We live on IMDb. It's taken
- 29:52me six times to get this audio going. On the
- 29:57Criterion, it does have like a short 20 minute
- 30:00documentary that includes information about him.
- 30:03And it does say that his early career leading
- 30:05up to this, he did work with a lot of female
- 30:09writers and he would adapt a lot of female stories.
- 30:12And a lot of his films did focus on like a strong
- 30:15female lead. And I thought that was very interesting
- 30:18that. He kind of followed that trajectory through
- 30:21his whole career. You know, I haven't seen it,
- 30:23but on my very short list of movies to watch
- 30:26is Magnificent Obsession, which was one of my
- 30:29family's final films at Universal. It was, I
- 30:32think, one of the movies that they spent a ton
- 30:35of money on right before Showboat that then led
- 30:37to them to be so cash -strapped to have to sell
- 30:40the studio. Kyle, recently, did you mention In
- 30:43Old Kentucky? I did not. That was brought up
- 30:46on that short documentary. Yeah, on the Criterion.
- 30:49But ultimately, what I've been able to tell from
- 30:52this director is a lot of female stories, woman
- 30:55led stories. And I want to go back and I want
- 30:57to watch a lot of the movies that have led up
- 31:00to this, because this is very much that story.
- 31:03Yeah. The main relationship in this movie being
- 31:06between Bea and Delilah. I love how much of this
- 31:11movie. doesn't even involve a male character
- 31:14obviously when the business and the and the romance
- 31:16and like the third act shows up then then you
- 31:19have that there but so much of it is just here
- 31:22are two mothers here are two women here are two
- 31:24like women in business too which is incredible
- 31:27single women single women with kids in business
- 31:31i wish we got to see you know we hear a lot of
- 31:34be running her business and i don't know she's
- 31:37a shark she's a whatever like i wish we got to
- 31:39see a little more of that. We get hints of it
- 31:42at the beginning as she's kind of smooth talking
- 31:45and finessing everybody to get things up and
- 31:47running. But, you know, they talk about she's
- 31:50working all the time and she's, I don't know,
- 31:52such a ball buster in the office. Like, I want
- 31:55to see that. Yeah, absolutely. There are so many
- 31:57of these old movies that I'm like, oh, I want
- 31:59to see this remade in, you know, where they don't
- 32:01have to skirt the production code and all of
- 32:03this. And this was remade in the 50s, I believe.
- 32:07Yeah, with Lana Turner. Oh, is that it? Okay.
- 32:10I've not seen it. Have you seen that version?
- 32:12Maybe 10 or 15 years ago. Gotcha. I was actually
- 32:17going to watch it yesterday. I was like, oh,
- 32:19that would be a great thing to watch to prepare
- 32:21for today. And we had a spectrum internet outage
- 32:24yesterday. Oh, no. So I couldn't get it loaded.
- 32:28They always get you. They always do. I had thought,
- 32:32you know, one of the performances that I was
- 32:33just really struck by the most, I mean, obviously,
- 32:36Louise Beavers and Claudette Colbert, but I really
- 32:39was taken by Freddie Washington. I thought the
- 32:41idea of, like, tackling race and tackling your
- 32:44own identity, because to your point, you know,
- 32:45we talked about Colbert and her problems, or
- 32:47rather, Bea and her problems, and Delilah and
- 32:50her problems. And in reality, like, you know,
- 32:53flip that, Jessie and her problems, and then
- 32:55Piola and her problems. It's night and day of
- 32:58a difference. And I thought it was so convincing,
- 33:00and so did the mass audiences, because there
- 33:03was kind of a misconception about Freddie Washington
- 33:05after this movie, where they thought that she
- 33:07had some kind of self -hatred, and she was passing
- 33:10because she was lighter in skin tone. In reality,
- 33:14she was like an avid civil rights activist. So
- 33:17it's really impressive to see, A, not just this
- 33:21kind of performance in 1934, but to see that
- 33:24of a woman of color, like to stand up against
- 33:28those things. I really thought she was incredible.
- 33:30Yeah, I mean, she's an incredible actress, beautiful,
- 33:33really compelling. Yeah, I enjoy her very much.
- 33:38Yeah, again, I haven't seen the remake. But it's
- 33:42my understanding that the actress that plays
- 33:44the character of Piola, it's a different name
- 33:46in that movie, but she's actually a white actress.
- 33:50Oh, which is something that I find very interesting
- 33:53that in 1934, they went against what they normally
- 33:57do and, you know, did some form of blackface
- 34:00or just used a white actor in this circumstance.
- 34:03And then in the 50s, when things should have
- 34:05been progressing a little bit beyond that, that's
- 34:09when they chose. to have just a white actress
- 34:11play. So I don't know. I see, like on Letterboxd,
- 34:14a lot of the reviews for this movie do kind of
- 34:16point out its flaws from kind of a modern perspective.
- 34:19But I think this movie has so much that, like,
- 34:23I think you should kind of force yourself to
- 34:25look past all of those negatives and really take
- 34:28it in for what it was, especially during 1934,
- 34:31because it's really doing some incredible things.
- 34:33And I think casting Freddie Washington is one
- 34:35of those things. Absolutely. And I do think that
- 34:39that's true. I think one of the things that became
- 34:41really surprising for me as I dug more into it
- 34:44was that some of the modern lens critiques of
- 34:49it that we give today. were already being said
- 34:53in the 30s, maybe not as widespread as today.
- 34:56But I remember reading about students at Oberlin
- 35:00College who were trying to protest the film and
- 35:03have it not play in theaters because of what
- 35:05they were calling the mammy character of Louise
- 35:08Beavers because of stereotypes that they thought
- 35:12were being perpetuated through the film. There
- 35:16are like... There were just critiques in it that
- 35:19I thought were so modern where I said, well,
- 35:21if you just take that out of it, it's so progressive
- 35:23for the time, which like it absolutely is. And
- 35:26I don't want to take that away. But it just blew
- 35:28my mind to know that today's critiques were already
- 35:31being said back then. Yeah. You know, I understand
- 35:36completely where people are coming from. And
- 35:38I can't say that I didn't also feel like it felt
- 35:42a little. Like, maybe it got the messaging wrong.
- 35:44But, Kyle, I think you're right. I think that
- 35:46of its time, like, in 1934, like, I'm happy to
- 35:49praise the project for, like, tackling such a
- 35:52rough issue. I shouldn't say rough, but, like,
- 35:54such a taboo issue at the time. I mean, even
- 35:56now, it's a difficult thing to talk about. So,
- 35:58for me, I'm willing to overlook some of those
- 36:01things, because it doesn't feel offensive, and
- 36:03it doesn't feel stereotypical, and it doesn't
- 36:05feel like they are punching down anyone. They
- 36:08just may not have gotten some things right. And
- 36:10I think that's okay. learn from that um as long
- 36:13as it doesn't feel patronizing which it never
- 36:15did to me that's true like don't let uh perfection
- 36:18get in the way of progress absolutely yeah i
- 36:21i think one of the biggest things too is Any
- 36:23type of or any of the stereotypes that do exist
- 36:27specifically with Louise Beaver's character,
- 36:29I feel like it plays a role in the film. Because
- 36:32again, Piola is so against like becoming that
- 36:36or following that like predetermined destiny
- 36:39that you kind of have to have Louise Beaver's
- 36:42play that particular type of character and role.
- 36:46Because then it becomes something to kind of
- 36:48want to move away from. So it's like, yes, there
- 36:52are stereotypes, but it adds to that plot. Yeah.
- 36:56I think maybe then I would just, I wish that
- 37:00Freddie Washington, I wish that Piola sometimes
- 37:02could more overtly say, this is exactly why I'm
- 37:08running away from this versus a lot of implications
- 37:11that we've got to interpret. Yes. And that's
- 37:14true. And I imagine most of that. comes from
- 37:16the production code of not being able to vocalize
- 37:19too much. We can talk about the end of the film.
- 37:21We touched on Claudette Colbert's finale here,
- 37:25which is just not the big part of this movie,
- 37:28but specifically with Delilah after Piola runs
- 37:32away and basically tells her mother, like, I
- 37:34want nothing to do with you. If you ever see
- 37:37me again, don't talk to me. I don't exist to
- 37:39you. We are not connected. We are not related.
- 37:42And this causes Delilah to basically succumb
- 37:46to heartbreak. And in all of the movies that
- 37:49we've watched for the podcast, we've dealt with
- 37:52some films that do have like a death in the final
- 37:55act. And even some of the most severe and dramatic
- 37:59ones, like what is the Ernest Hemingway movie?
- 38:02Farewell to Arms. Farewell to Arms. That has
- 38:04a very dramatic death scene. East Lynn. East
- 38:07Lynn, yeah. And all of them, all of the heaviest
- 38:10ones. To me, don't even come close to the level,
- 38:13like the magnitude of Delilah's death. How did
- 38:18you guys feel during that scene? Well, I can
- 38:21say, I mean, it was heartbreaking feels like
- 38:25the wrong thing to say, but. I think for me,
- 38:28it started with where they find Piola and when
- 38:31she is working that retail job. And we've seen
- 38:34her reject her race and reject her mother, but
- 38:37we haven't seen it in public before. And the
- 38:39idea of her like. disowning her mother and disowning
- 38:43her race in front of other people, not just,
- 38:47uh, B, but like, you know, other like men like
- 38:50standing right in front of her. To me, I think
- 38:52that was the, the nail, the proverbial nail in
- 38:55the coffin of like, this is an unfixable relationship.
- 38:59And at that point, I think I felt the way that
- 39:02Delilah is portrayed of like laying in the bed
- 39:05and just like heartbroken. So I thought it was,
- 39:08You know, we talk a lot about melodrama and,
- 39:10you know, you and I have talked about how sometimes
- 39:12that's like a bad word. And when a movie has
- 39:14any kind of melodrama that we aren't as interested.
- 39:16And I was so captivated throughout this. And
- 39:20it's because I think the themes and also just
- 39:22the acting has kept me through. It felt earned.
- 39:25And everything that felt like maybe just a little
- 39:27overdramatic did feel earned and did feel realistic.
- 39:30So I was captivated by A, the performance and
- 39:34B, just her situation. Yeah, maybe the... it's
- 39:38i while i understand she like died of heartbreak
- 39:40that part specifically is like a little hard
- 39:43for me to get on board with but going back to
- 39:45that scene when you're talking about piola publicly
- 39:47disowning her i think that is where my heartbreaker
- 39:52where i do feel like it's so meaningful when
- 39:54she's like you know do i really like do i look
- 39:57like i could be her daughter do i you know that
- 39:59whole thing um I think is very meaningful. I
- 40:05also think that's one place where the book deviates
- 40:09or the movie deviates from the book a little
- 40:11bit is at the funeral, we get to see Piola come
- 40:15back and kind of have that moment. In the book,
- 40:19I don't think she ever comes back. She's just
- 40:21never heard from again. That's terrible. Yeah,
- 40:25no, they did the right thing by adding that in
- 40:27the movie, because at least it's a chance to
- 40:29say goodbye. Again, I don't think it's fixable.
- 40:31And I think that to your point that you made
- 40:33earlier, and Tony, I think the idea of being
- 40:35a mother is just, you know, that you do want
- 40:38a better life for them, even if it's at the hindrance
- 40:40of your own. And I think that that's something
- 40:43that Delilah is happy to give her is like, I
- 40:46personally don't think that she can forgive her
- 40:48for that. But she can. At least she can give
- 40:52her the idea that she's forgiven her, at least.
- 40:54Yeah. Yeah, I guess I'm with you, Antonia, as
- 40:57far as, like, the heartbreak goes. I think any
- 40:59time that shows up in a movie, like, I know this
- 41:01happens in real life, too. But when it shows
- 41:03up in a movie, I'm like, but what really happened?
- 41:05And they're afraid to say it, right? They're
- 41:07never like, oh, she died of what? Of heartbreak.
- 41:10Yeah. They have to kind of infer it. I always
- 41:12think about Star Wars and Padme dying of a broken
- 41:16heart. I'm like, I seem to remember when she
- 41:18got force choked. That might have had something
- 41:20to do with it, but sure, whatever. But yeah,
- 41:23I think that part is a little hard for me to
- 41:26grasp as well. But I think when Delilah is laying
- 41:29in bed and she's talking about the procession
- 41:33that she wants and Bea is kind of, she's taking
- 41:36this all in. She's like, okay, this is real.
- 41:39There's a very big chance that like I'm going
- 41:41to lose my friend that I've had for all these
- 41:43years. And I love that. She, in fact, gives Delilah
- 41:49that exact procession. And I think my favorite
- 41:52part of that whole thing was seeing the hearse
- 41:54that was pulled by the horses because she didn't
- 41:56like the smell of gasoline. I think when I saw
- 41:58that particular moment, that's when I started
- 42:01to feel myself get a little choked up. And I
- 42:03was like, oh, no. For me, it was that scene specifically,
- 42:08but I think it was also that I can't say that
- 42:11it was completely unbroken, but it felt like
- 42:14the camera wasn't trying to shy away from the
- 42:16entire performance around, or at least the ceremony
- 42:19around her funeral. So to me, it felt like, you
- 42:23know, in a world where Delilah was trying to
- 42:26like fight for her identity and fight for her
- 42:28race, she in passing. fully embraced it and i
- 42:32really enjoyed that whole ceremony um but you're
- 42:36right that little connection of her not liking
- 42:38gas and them having the horses it felt very personal
- 42:40um i also really like the moment right after
- 42:43when jesse asks the um how did you meet or you
- 42:47know tell me how you met because it was almost
- 42:49a reminder for me just how long delilah and piola
- 42:52had been you know As long as she was a conscious
- 42:56human, they had been a part of her life and they
- 42:58had been there. And I think condensed into a
- 43:0190 -minute movie or whatever it is, it's easy
- 43:04to lose sight of that time. Yeah, for sure. The
- 43:07one thing that I didn't like about the funeral,
- 43:10and Antonia, you had mentioned that you wish
- 43:13you saw more of Bea and her business moves, if
- 43:17you will. I also wish, at this funeral, you see
- 43:21all of these people who... we assume played like
- 43:24a big part of Delilah's life. I wish that we
- 43:27would have gotten at least a couple of scenes
- 43:29of her, like interacting with these people, either
- 43:32going to church or, or whatever organization
- 43:35she was a member of, like all of these people
- 43:38kind of just show up. And I guess in, in one
- 43:40way you can just say, Oh wow, look at, look at
- 43:43all of these people's lives she touched. But
- 43:45I also think it would have been interesting for
- 43:48Piola story as well to kind of see, like, not
- 43:51only does she kind of, shun her mother but she
- 43:54is shunning like this whole culture and i i kind
- 43:57of wish we saw that but i know it's a very short
- 43:59film well i i think you know i i took it in that
- 44:03way and i took it that you know piola had seen
- 44:06her mother at least from our the the audience
- 44:09view she had seen her mother only in in one way
- 44:13or another serving like a white woman right and
- 44:15like living in like the downstairs area or basement
- 44:18area of a white woman's house so i think to see
- 44:21her life being celebrated by her community by
- 44:25people that looked like her i think maybe that
- 44:28was peeled as kind of a opening and awakening
- 44:30of like i have rejected a culture and like being
- 44:34uh black isn't who we serve and what we do but
- 44:37it's like who we surround ourselves with and
- 44:39that community so i took it as like the movie
- 44:42not spending 20 minutes to say that but like
- 44:44kind of saying it in passing with Peele is, you
- 44:47know, I mean, obviously very, very sad and very
- 44:49well acted goodbye when she runs up to her mother's
- 44:53casket when it's being taken away. She's fantastic
- 44:56in that last scene. She is. I think. It's also
- 44:58never a good time to bring it up, but I do want
- 45:01to just go ahead and segue ourselves real quick,
- 45:04Kyle, to our annual what is Ned Sparks doing
- 45:07here segment of the show. Yeah. I think he has
- 45:11fully cemented himself as someone that when he's
- 45:13on screen, I just, my eyes, I cannot take my
- 45:15eyes off Ned Sparks. Yeah. And you're referring
- 45:18to Lady for a Day? Is that right? Lady for a
- 45:21Day is, I think, maybe not the first time we
- 45:24saw him, but certainly the time where I feel
- 45:26like the camera knows the facial reactions he
- 45:28can make. Sure, yeah. And it's not afraid to
- 45:31linger on it. And this movie is no different.
- 45:33And there are many scenes where Bea will say
- 45:35something sarcastic back to him, and the camera
- 45:37will just, like, be behind him and wait for him
- 45:40to turn around and make the most disgusted face
- 45:42at the camera. And I just... I'm obsessed with
- 45:45that man. It did feel out of place for certain.
- 45:49It felt like some comedic relief that was needed
- 45:51in the story. But when he showed up, I think
- 45:53I'm going to call it the What's Ned Sparks Doing
- 45:55Here Award. Yeah. Because I said that to Taylor
- 45:57when we were watching it. I was like, what's
- 45:59Ned Sparks doing here? It's so good. I love his
- 46:03physical acting as well. There's a moment where...
- 46:05Oh, 42nd Street. That's the other one. Right.
- 46:08Yeah. When Steve, he's talking to him because
- 46:10they have this like friendly little feud throughout
- 46:12the entire movie. But there's a moment where
- 46:14Steve is making himself like the longest drink
- 46:18ever. First of all, it takes him forever. But
- 46:21he finally makes it and he grabs it and he walks
- 46:23away after saying something snarky to Ned Sparks.
- 46:25And Ned Sparks just grabs an empty glass and
- 46:28like goes to take a sip. And he's like, wait
- 46:29a minute, puts it down. And it's such a like.
- 46:32quick moment of nothingness really but i think
- 46:36it just highlights like his level of comedic
- 46:38acting that does at time feel out of place in
- 46:40this movie but man it's i loved it so much yeah
- 46:44no big fan uh not a surprise it's so funny to
- 46:47hear because i i think i gravitate more towards
- 46:50the like he's always felt a little out of place
- 46:52to me and so i don't give him as much regard
- 46:56so it's so interesting to hear you both adore
- 46:59him like this well and it's funny because i don't
- 47:01think it's it's fully deserved in this movie
- 47:03but it is something that we saw i mean it must
- 47:05have been 42nd street first and then lady for
- 47:08a day i'm thinking lady for a day oh first the
- 47:10first time okay so we saw him in you know frank
- 47:13capper picture in more of a busby berkeley one
- 47:16in 40 42nd street and For me, it's just, I have
- 47:21some kind of appreciation for when character
- 47:24actors, character actors in the 1930s, and Ned
- 47:27Sparks is fully that. I was almost expecting
- 47:29him to have more of a dramatic role in a movie
- 47:31like this that is much more dramatic. So when
- 47:33he shows up, it was totally inappropriate for
- 47:37him to be on set and doing those things. But
- 47:40it was so... It is just so for me and Kyle specifically
- 47:44that he was showing up for some reason. But I
- 47:46agree with you. It feels like it's out of place.
- 47:49It's it's I mean, honestly, a lot of Stephen's
- 47:52story, I think, is out of place, too. But Ned
- 47:54specifically just feels more like a I have to
- 47:56be the character to introduce Stephen and B.
- 47:58And then I'm off camera for the rest of the movie.
- 48:00Yeah. You know, I think we like him because he
- 48:04kind of reminds me of a Muppet. That's what it
- 48:06is. I think that's what it is. You're right.
- 48:08He's Sam Eagle. Like the voice and the... Yeah,
- 48:11he's very stiff. Oh, he's literally Sam Eagle.
- 48:14Oh, Antonio, you're right. It's the voice. That's
- 48:16what it is. Oh, man. You just unlocked it. But
- 48:19I will give him a little bit of credit. While
- 48:21he does feel out of place overall in the movie,
- 48:24I think towards the end when he is required to
- 48:28understand the gravity of the situation between
- 48:31Piola and her disappearance. Or no, it's Delilah.
- 48:35basically on her deathbed yes he does pull back
- 48:39i think just enough to be like okay he's not
- 48:42just a silly goofy guy this he understands the
- 48:45situation so i'll give him credit for that too
- 48:47yeah i mean he does the job and it's not like
- 48:50he's terrible or anything it's just outside of
- 48:53that one scene you're right he's mostly just
- 48:54comical yeah yeah i mean does anybody else before
- 48:57we get into ratings have anything they want to
- 48:59bring up for the movie If not, it's totally cool.
- 49:02We can move on. Yeah. So let's hop into it. All
- 49:06right. So this is another classic one where I
- 49:08rated it a certain thing. And then, you know,
- 49:10shocker, you talk about it with other people
- 49:12who have also seen the movie and you change your
- 49:14opinion. I think I originally had this at three,
- 49:17three and a half stars. This to me is four. This
- 49:20is a four star. Again, the swing, the absolute
- 49:24like bravery to tackle something like this in
- 49:271934. is just mesmerizing. And being able to
- 49:31hear a little bit more about this story and see
- 49:34the evolution of something like this, because,
- 49:36you know, we... I guess, spoiler alert, we haven't
- 49:39fully learned these lessons in cinema or otherwise,
- 49:42even like 2026. So it's incredible to see this
- 49:46story being tackled with as much deft and weight
- 49:49as it does in 1934. And Antonia, credit to you,
- 49:53unlocking that little memory or the little realization
- 49:56of what mothers do for their daughters and that
- 50:00being kind of the crux of the story, that absolutely
- 50:03elevates it for me. So that's easily a four star
- 50:05for me. I loved this movie so much. It was four
- 50:10and a half stars. I think that the Warren William,
- 50:15William Warren, why am I forgetting? Warren William.
- 50:18Warren William, that character, not even that
- 50:20character, like the romance, it's a great romance.
- 50:24I just, I wish that the ending of this movie
- 50:27lied with Piola and the family rather than just
- 50:31Claudette Colbert and Rochelle Hudson. Yeah,
- 50:36that, that. is the one issue I have with the
- 50:39movie, where it just kind of loses its footing
- 50:41at the end. But beyond that, I think it's fantastic
- 50:43and a very important movie as well. How about
- 50:46you, Antonia? I will also give it four stars.
- 50:51I think that it is so beautiful and there's just
- 50:55incredibly gorgeous and creative shots. It obviously
- 50:59tackles such important subject matter at a time
- 51:03when a lot of movies would not even try to go
- 51:06there. But there just are those parts of me that
- 51:09think that parts of the storyline feel a little
- 51:12out of place or cheesy or extraneous and maybe
- 51:16could have gone a little bit further even. even
- 51:20at the time. So four stars from me. Great. Yeah.
- 51:24Another tradition that we have on the show here,
- 51:26Antonia, is that we always like to pair it with
- 51:28a double feature, something that if someone is
- 51:30unable to or hasn't seen this movie before, maybe
- 51:33we can give them an example of something that
- 51:34they have seen or should see that reminds them
- 51:36of the movie. So we'd love to start with you.
- 51:38Do you have a double feature that you would recommend
- 51:41for Imitation of Life? I am going to recommend
- 51:44Crash. which is another modern movie that i think
- 51:49is really great i think it's i really enjoy crash
- 51:53and i love watching crash and it's another film
- 51:55that tackles race and you know very tricky topics
- 51:59but is equally as controversial and you know
- 52:04has a lot of people wishing that things were
- 52:06done a little bit differently so there's there's
- 52:10something very same same but different about
- 52:12that film Yeah, that's a great call out. Yeah,
- 52:15I agree. And, you know, that's that's the exact
- 52:17kind of logic I was thinking of. I was thinking
- 52:20of like the controversy that can exist there,
- 52:22you know, Green Book, which is something you
- 52:24mentioned off pod before. Crash is a perfect
- 52:27example. I went literal with the with the theme
- 52:31of the movie and with the idea of like racial
- 52:34identity and how these races can like coexist
- 52:38and the expectations that we have of each other
- 52:41from those races. And I went 2000s Kevin Hook's
- 52:46Disney Channel original movie, The Color of Friendship.
- 52:48I think this came at a time where, you know,
- 52:51at my age group, my wife and I, we hadn't seen
- 52:54a lot of movies that kind of tackled something
- 52:56like this. And Disney Channel original movies
- 52:59were typically like, you know, that dog is doing
- 53:01what? So to be able to have like something very
- 53:04serious tackled like this in The Color of Friendship
- 53:07really was one of the first times I think we
- 53:09started asking ourselves those questions, at
- 53:11least this generation. And so that to me felt
- 53:13like an awakening. And I think that this movie
- 53:16equally was probably an awakening, hopefully
- 53:18an awakening for some people at the time. And
- 53:20certainly could still do the same now for current
- 53:23modern audiences. Words. I loved that movie growing
- 53:27up. And I actually was just thinking about it.
- 53:30I went to South Africa like a month ago. And
- 53:32so I was thinking about. That film in particular.
- 53:35Oh, there you go. That's a movie that is constantly
- 53:38talked about in this household. My wife and I
- 53:40are very big DCOM fans, and that movie is no
- 53:43exception. Is it on Disney Plus? I think it might
- 53:46be. Okay. I hope so. I'll make a note to watch.
- 53:50I will message you afterwards and let you know,
- 53:52but I believe it is. Kyle, did we... amp up enough
- 53:55for you you did thank you so much uh for buying
- 53:58me time no there was a short film that i watched
- 54:01uh a few years ago it's called illusions and
- 54:04it was directed by julie dash and i when i first
- 54:07started watching imitation of life i was like
- 54:09oh this is going to be my double feature and
- 54:10i immediately forgot so i just remembered but
- 54:13it's the story of an african -american studio
- 54:16executive who is passing for white and it's it's
- 54:20really kind of just the story of how she exists
- 54:24in this world in the landscape that she kind
- 54:28of has built for herself by passing. I wish I
- 54:31could say I remembered like a ton of details
- 54:33of the movie, but I just remember being very,
- 54:35very just engaged because it was kind of the
- 54:38first encounter I had with this type of story
- 54:41where I was like, wow, that's not something that
- 54:43I personally have given much thought to. understandably
- 54:47so so it's it's a short film i definitely recommend
- 54:50it it's called illusions if anyone wants to check
- 54:53it out very cool how can you find that oh man
- 54:57How did you watch it? I don't know. It was years
- 54:59ago. Whatever way I watched it, I'm sure you
- 55:01can't watch it that way now. Well, that's fine.
- 55:03We'll establish if you can watch Color of Friendship
- 55:06on Disney Plus. Crash, I imagine, has to be streaming
- 55:09on one of the major streamers. So maybe Peacock.
- 55:12We'll see. It's on Canopy. Hey, look at that.
- 55:15Check it out. As you should. Yeah. Yeah. Antonia,
- 55:18thank you again so much for being on the show.
- 55:21It's always a pleasure having you. The opportunity
- 55:24to speak with you, especially about these Universal
- 55:27films, is so cool to me still. Super cool. So
- 55:32we really appreciate it. I absolutely love being
- 55:37here. So thank you. Yeah, we would love to have
- 55:39you back. It's an honor to have you back on here
- 55:41to even cover an episode with us about one of
- 55:44these movies. And obviously one that's so close
- 55:46to you and your family. So thank you for being
- 55:48here. And where can everyone find you? You can
- 55:51find me on YouTube. My channel is called Universally
- 55:54Me, or you could look up youtube .com slash Antonia
- 55:57Carlotta. And I've got new episodes coming out
- 55:59every week. I want to shout out a recent episode
- 56:02you did as well, which will be a little bit later
- 56:04than when this drops, but you did the preferred
- 56:07or the recommended order of watching the Universal
- 56:09Monster movies. Oh, dang. It's very cool because
- 56:12she, not to spoil the video, but she doesn't
- 56:15follow the release order. She follows themes,
- 56:18which is like. It's so cool. Oh, that's awesome.
- 56:22It's very cool. I was such a huge fan of that
- 56:24video. And I think that's what I like the most.
- 56:27You don't just say, this is the history of this
- 56:29movie. You dive into things that I don't think
- 56:32people really talk about very often. And I really
- 56:35appreciate that. No, I appreciate that. And I
- 56:37actually take pride in that, I think, because
- 56:40that's been a real growth moment for me. I think
- 56:42when I started my channel, it was so much more,
- 56:44this is the history. And it was a little more
- 56:46textbook. And as I have really like learned and
- 56:50grown with these monsters, now I'm able to tackle
- 56:53them in new ways and kind of dive in really differently.
- 56:56And I've been like proud to see that in myself.
- 57:00You should be. No, because it's fantastic. And
- 57:02that's not to downplay the level of history and
- 57:05research that you do put into those kind of history
- 57:07and fact -based videos. Those are great too.
- 57:10Big fan of the channel overall. Thank you very
- 57:12much. Check it out, listeners at home. It's awesome.
- 57:15On the next episode. Kyle went to Los Angeles.
- 57:19Oh, yeah, I did. How did that go? Did Kyle see
- 57:21the movie? Did Kyle enjoy the movie? There's
- 57:24only one way to find out. Stay tuned. You like
- 57:26how I did like a Days of Our Lives type like
- 57:29narration? We need like a keyboard like as I
- 57:32do that. I'm glad you did because we need all
- 57:33the buildup we can get for that episode. But
- 57:35yeah, that's going to do it for this episode.
- 57:37Thank you again, Antonia. As always, I'm Kyle.
- 57:40I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies. Thank
- 57:52you.