Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Sonic Turns Volume Knob, China Has Too Many Cars, Polestar Gets Served
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Monday, August 17th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mountserre.
- 0:06Today, [laughs] we're talking about Sonic turning up the knob on used cars, China making too many cars for themselves, and Polestar, uh, well- Here we go...
- 0:14it's an ongoing thing The people really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. So yeah- If it don't make dollars, it repeat...
- 0:18what was that, what was that soap opera back in the- Run up on me, watch how far it be... Days of Our Lives? Feel like- [laughs]...
- 0:22Polestar's in the middle of an episode of Days of Our Lives right now, and it's probably not ending anytime soon. I feel like sometimes a retail auto kind of is a soap opera. [laughs] Oh, yeah. Like, in general.
- 0:34Like, we are just great at just being, I don't know- Oh, my gosh... gener- generally dramatic, but also it's like this, this, a- ethereal drama that isn't- [laughs]... really real.
- 0:45And, like, if you really talk to the people, they're like, "Nah, there's not really any drama." I just- "We're just selling cars. It's fine"...
- 0:50I, now I just wanna make a soap opera where all the characters represent, like, dealer groups, OEMs. [laughs] Con- the consumer is, like, one character. The OEM is, like, one character.
- 1:00[laughs] So they're always kinda like, "Are they cheating on me with the... Uh, the, the-" [laughs] "What did they say?" Right? Like, the, the tight shots, the zoom-ins, the emotional music. I never knew you.
- 1:09Dude, that- [laughs]... that would crush. Like, you know these new miniseries they're making? You know, all these- Ugh... the social media miniseries? That would crush. In another life, we'll have time for that one.
- 1:17Oh, my goodness. Someone at, at a dealership make that right now. Oh, that, that's- Please... that's actually a lot harder to make than The Office was. Way harder. Yeah. Way harder. But, but way more rewarding.
- 1:26You need that music. The payoff's bigger. [laughs] The payoff's bigger. Just use Suno, it'll be fine. Yeah. [laughs] W- it'll be... use Suno. It'll all be fine.
- 1:33Oh, we wanna make sure, uh, that our friends at CarRX get a little bit a- another sh- uh, shout-out the week after NAMAD, because they made it possible for us to be up on the ground and- Yeah...
- 1:43bring you all this content that we brought from NAMAD. We have interviews that are dropping. We were on-site. Uh, a lot of great insights, so, um, you know, we've covered that.
- 1:51We're gonna be dropping more on the socials. If you don't follow along on LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, make sure you do so you don't miss this stuff.
- 1:58Uh, we also- It, it, man, I, I'm biased 'cause I got to interview him, but the interview with Michael Lee was dialed in. Oh. Kyle Whittler was amazing.
- 2:06Like, a lot of people see him on social media, but when he's, talks about operations, he's super dialed. Smart, bro. It's not just, like, it's not just like, uh, you know, shirtless bro- Yeah... doing workouts. Yeah.
- 2:16Like, this guy can, this guy can operate. But he's also ripped 'cause he played, actually, football- Just ripped... and he just keeps- It's unbelievable... [laughs] Like that. Uh, we are releasing...
- 2:23Speaking of just ripped, um, re- released a new episode of our Auto Collabs podcast with Don Hall. You may have seen the screenshot.
- 2:30Too many dealers are full of sh- right, we couldn't put the word on the screen for this audience. I mean, they can take it, but you know, we're trying not to get flagged by YouTube. We know.
- 2:37Uh, Don, both barrels, full force on this is what is happening, and this is what- Double barrel, man... we can be doing again about it. Wow.
- 2:45Uh, he doesn't play, but you know, uh, his punchline is, "It's about the people. It's about the people," and he's got some, uh, special- We'll take it... let's call them, thoughts about how that might go.
- 2:54You can, uh, go to Auto Collabs, C-O-L-L-A-B-S, on your favorite podcast platform, or you could search it on YouTube as well. Auto Collabs, Don Hall.
- 3:02It's gonna pop up, and, uh, you're gonna have a, a fantastic 20 minutes of your day listening to Don. Fantastic. I mean, or you might get really mad at him. Either way, either way, uh, that episode's gonna deliver.
- 3:13[laughs] All right. All right, let's talk about some news. Speaking of delivering- Oh, wow. Segway time. I, I thought that that was- That's, that's where I was going. That's too good. I didn't know it.
- 3:22Sonic Automotive is betting that a little gr- a little less gross can lead to a lot more cars sold in the back half of 2026.
- 3:28The retailer leaning hard into used cars at both its EchoPark and its franchise stores, uh, while affordability is pushing shoppers toward vehicles carrying, uh, a little lighter of a price tag.
- 3:39Sonic President Jeff Dykes says the used car business really fires when prices hit the sweet spot, or the average price of a used car is half of what the average price of a new car is.
- 3:51And if you're watching that tracker on automotivenews.com, it's over 52K right now, average price- [sighs]... of a new car. So we're getting there.
- 3:58Sonic is willing to trade some margin for volume, targeting 25% more used car sales at their franchise stores, or about 20 additional units per rooftop.
- 4:07EchoPark, their used car division, retailed 19,601 vehicles, used vehicles, in Q2, which is up 17% year over year. Retail margins, uh, retail used gross fell 9%, but total gross up 3%. So they boosted- Interesting...
- 4:22non-auction sourcing from 32% to 42%, helping, uh, you know, get those vehicles, used vehicles cheaper. Wow. Uh, buy them cheaper.
- 4:30After shrinking from 52 locations all the way down to 18, EchoPark is planning to add at least one location, so they're on their way back in Q4, with Sonic believing its hub model has plenty of room to grow. Okay.
- 4:44The key stat here is non-auction sourcing going from 32 to 42%. Massive. Meaning they are targeting your in-market buy- your in-market buyers and traders and getting their used vehicles off the street.
- 4:59If you're a retail dealer, you should be paying attention. This is not just a Carvana or CarMax play, it's people within the ecosystem. Yep.
- 5:07So if you're not going and getting some of that, like, it is, it is ripe, it's available, and these people wanna sell their cars.
- 5:12The other thing that I wanna state, which is really an interesting, uh, uh, uh, a separation of, like, the primary call to action from, like, a CarMax or Carvana, you go to the website of EchoPark, and their primary call to action is actually to test drive.
- 5:27They're leaning in- Hmm... to those 18 locations and trying to provide a different level of service- Interesting play, yes... and experience. Um, it's an interesting play.
- 5:36Kudos to Sonic for dialing that in and paying attention to what I think consumers are actually after.
- 5:41Um, hey, if you're not paying attention to used cars second half of this year with new cars continuingly, uh, meeting and, and crashing into an affordability issue, then what are you even doing?
- 5:52Speaking of what consumers are actually after- Yep. Segway. Got 'em. In China. China. In China. China's automakers have a problem most dealers can relate to.
- 6:02They have plenty of product Not enough buyers with domestic sales sliding for 10 straight months. Chinese brands are increasingly- Oh my... looking overseas for growth.
- 6:13Their domestic sales fell to 2.3 million units in the first half of 2026, while exports are up 71%. Excess capacity, uh, makes, you know, global expansion a necessity for these automakers.
- 6:26BYD illustrating the shift, domestic sales down 35% through July, while overseas sales up 79%, led by markets, markets including Brazil and Britain, and maybe other ones named with a B. Chinese brands- Wow...
- 6:40have grown from 3% to 6 per- 16% of Europe's passenger g- vehicle market only in the last three or four years. It represents now a quarter of European EV shipments.
- 6:52Um, Abhilash Gupta, Counterpoint Research on the European expansion, he said, quote, "Tariffs can slow the curve, but they're not gonna reverse it." We've always known that this is China's play.
- 7:03Their research and development, their ability to gain capital from their local ecosystem was always an export play to get these vehicles elsewhere, where the dollars are greater for the vehicles that they're shipping.
- 7:15Europe was a clear target early, and so many of our European friends have warned against this type of, uh, kind of- They want-... hostile takeover- Yeah... of the market. Once it goes, it goes fast.
- 7:26Once it goes, it goes fast. And, and they've, they've done this in Australia, they've done this in, in other parts of the world.
- 7:31Um, and so this is what a lot of automakers are fearing, a lot of politicians are fearing, uh, local, because they are clearly after a global market because most likely, I don't think they're worried about the sales pressure declining locally.
- 7:45Locally, no. Be- I think they knew it was coming... because it's, it's just like dime a dozen for how many they, the, of these brands are out there.
- 7:51They, well, they've basically, if you look at it closely, they've done the equivalent of what, what the US has done in removing the federal tax credit, is that- Yep...
- 7:57they knew they got mass adoption early because they heavily incentivized these vehicles. They got people in them very inexpensively while they were early.
- 8:05It allowed them to build, to develop, to hone in their engineering, and they knew this was going to back off dom- domestically. They pulled the incentives.
- 8:12They say, "Okay, this industry can now stand on its own, and now all of our focus is going to be how do we get these vehicles into other countries and reap all the benefits of exporting?"
- 8:21And I mean, they're running that playbook and they're running it well. Speaking of not running that playbook well. In the US. Segway. [laughs] In the US. Segway. I like that segway. It's a little bit of a volley.
- 8:32Hey, good friend of the pod, a New J- Jersey dealer group is suing Polestar for $25 million, arguing the EV maker is using a federal sales ban as an escape hatch from its franchise obligations.
- 8:44Prestige Imports, led by friend of the show Matt Haken- Woop woop...
- 8:47filed a $25 million, uh, lawsuit alleging Polestar violated New Jersey franchise law and owes the fair, fair market value of its franchise plus five years of parts, uh, warranty support.
- 9:00Uh, we know we've been covering this. Polestar is set to be barred from US sales beyond the 2026 model year because of its ownership by China's Geely.
- 9:09Prestige is claiming Polestar spent two years planning its exit and maneuvered the government into a ban. Mm.
- 9:16Prestige, one of 32 US Polestar retailers, argues Polestar's force majeure notice effectively terminated its franchise without the required 60-day notice or good cause, which is banned by New Jersey law.
- 9:28The dealer also alleges Polestar didn't pursue an exemption similar to Volvo's, which we called out as well, despite Volvo also being owned by Geely.
- 9:38Here's our, uh, friend, Senator Bernie Moreno, who was cited in the suit and argues Polestar was treated no differently than Po- Volvo. "Polestar was screwed by Polestar. It wasn't screwed by the US government," he said.
- 9:49He called Polestar's force majeure argument a convenient excuse. First of all- Coming in hot... I wanna be at a dinner table with Bernie Moreno and Matt Haken. They got it. Full stop. Um- They got a full fire.
- 10:01Listen, Matt is one of the most articulate communicators in this industry. He's also a New Yorker. Um, he also understands the broad game. I would not want him coming at me because he's gonna make a very- No...
- 10:12clear, articulate case, which he has. People have been saying Polestar has been looking for an excuse to back out because their adoption wasn't what they were. Matt was an excellent operator.
- 10:22His mall location, they were moving more vehicles. He was kind of the darling of the brand in the US- Yep... because of how well he operated and how much he invested into the brand.
- 10:32This suit feels like it's got all the right components to it, and- It's got legs...
- 10:36I mean, I wouldn't be surprised if there's a fast settlement on this, but regardless of how they settle this, it's going to trickle down across every Polestar franchisee.
- 10:46I'm so upset about this because I really like the Polestar brand. I- Yeah... have a little thing on this.
- 10:50Every time I went somewhere, I rented the Polestar 2 if I could, because in my mind it was- Well, and I love their go-to-market strategy of the malls and the- Yes... and the, and the little outdoor malls- Yes...
- 10:59and this system. They had, they had the right, they just didn't wanna c- they didn't wanna carry the ball. They didn't wanna carry the ball. That's right.
- 11:03They didn't wanna fight the fight, and I think they used, you know, US legislation as the reason to get out and say, "Oh, we can go undercover." Ooh.
- 11:10They didn't even put up a fight when people- Look, I heard some inside, I heard some inside scoop for some peop- from some people that were in DC on those days, and, and there's, there's a lot of legs on this.
- 11:19[laughs] There's a lot of legs on this- That's great to know... is what I'm trying to say. But look, if that's not an, uh, if that's not an example of dealers pushing back, I don't know what is. Hey, that's right.
- 11:27There's one group of people you don't wanna mess with because you don't wanna do things the wrong way. No. It's the car dealers.
- 11:31Look, I hope they hold everybody accountable for what they should be, but for today, you're in the store, you're face to face. Take care of the people, and everything else will fall into place. We'll see you tomorrow.
- 11:39[upbeat music]