Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Dependent Personality Disorder - (Chapter 1) (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. Today's episode is a deep dive on dependent personality disorder.
- 0:06This is the first chapter. I think there'll be three or four chapters.
- 0:09I'm not quite sure yet. This is just for patrons of the podcast,
- 0:14but I have a little bit of a long intro here for everyone.
- 0:17So at first I thought it was just going to be a short episode.
- 0:21You know, I've done a lot of deep dives, and some deep dives
- 0:24take me months to work on, and some deep dives take me, you
- 0:27know, maybe one month or three weeks or something. I didn't think there'd
- 0:31be that much prep. But the more I got into it, the more
- 0:34I realized that dependent personality disorder is a very important disorder for me to understand
- 0:41as a clinician, but also I think for everyone else. I understand there's
- 0:45a lot to it. It's pretty complicated. And the more I thought about
- 0:49people in my life, the more I realized that dependent personality disorder is everywhere.
- 0:53I mean, you know, it's not everywhere everywhere, but it's a
- 0:56lot more prevalent than I thought. I've had many clients with this disorder.
- 1:00I didn't really understand that they had this. I mean, I might have
- 1:03conceptualized them kind of, but not in the way that I could have if
- 1:07I understood this disorder and its causes. And a lot of people in my
- 1:11personal life have suffered from disorder or they're on the spectrum, if you will,
- 1:15and understanding this disorder really helps me understand them, and they're weird behaviors
- 1:23or weird behaviors according to me, I should say, and I consider dependent
- 1:27personality disorder to be as important for clinicians and maybe even for lay people to
- 1:34understand, just as important as narcissistic personality disorder or borderline personality disorder, all
- 1:41of us, even lay people, especially if you've listened to this podcast.
- 1:44You've heard of narcissism, you've heard of borderline. But I think dependent personality
- 1:48disorder is an equally important concept for everyone to understand because I think there's a
- 1:53lot of people that confuse us, that are operating from the schemas involved in
- 2:00this disorder. It's very useful to know about, very rarely talked about.
- 2:04We hear a lot about narcisism and our culture and our clinical work. We
- 2:08hear a lot about borderline. We don't hear a lot about dependent personality disorders.
- 2:13Strangely, and I have my theories, which I'll get into you later.
- 2:15So in this lecture, I'm going to present on a number of things.
- 2:19I'm going to have a number of in depth case examples, And this
- 2:23is really where my learning sort of pinnacled when I was able to pull together
- 2:29all that I learned and come up with some case examples. They're fictionalized,
- 2:34but I think you might be able to recognize other people in your life,
- 2:38maybe even yourself in some of these case examples, because when you hear about
- 2:40dependent personality disorder on the internet, it seems kind of one dimensional, but
- 2:46it's not. There's a lot of different types. There's a lot of different
- 2:49ways that people will present in the same way that borderline can look a lot
- 2:52of different ways. Narcissistic personality disorder can look a lot of different ways.
- 2:57Dependent personality disorder can look a lot of different way and if you just read
- 3:00the symptoms, you really do not understand how it will present. Because people
- 3:06with dependent personality disorder, as with all personality disorders, they don't know they
- 3:10have a personality disorder. They think that their perceptions and their behaviors are reasonable.
- 3:15That's the definition of personality distorts, particularly before they get treated, and
- 3:20so I'm going to provide some in depth case examples that might help to really
- 3:25humanize this condition. I'm going to provide a lengthy description, and I really
- 3:31want you to know what this disorder actually is and what it feels like.
- 3:36Again, if you go on the internet and you hear people just rattle off
- 3:38the DSM criteria, you get, you know, a little bit of an
- 3:43idea of what this is, but in my view, not really. And
- 3:46so it's it's in the details that I think that this disorder lives. I'm
- 3:51also going to present on the types. I'm not a huge fan of typologies
- 3:54at all times, but I find that the typologies that have been developed by
- 4:00two different groups of people with dependent personality sorder I think are very very helpful,
- 4:04particularly one I'm going to delany at it between codependency. You know,
- 4:10we hear that word all the time, and you hear me always kind of
- 4:14railing about it, and so I'm going to go into that a little bit.
- 4:15I'm going to talk about the prevalence, the differentials called morbidities, assessment
- 4:20methods, treatment methods, the outcomes, you know, what kind of problems
- 4:25result from dependent personality sortom. I'm going to go into the history of how
- 4:30this construct has been seen within the field of talk therapy and psychology. I'm
- 4:36going to go into DSM history, the psychoanalytic history. I'm going to go
- 4:40into the causes quite a bit as well, because I think that's where you
- 4:44really start to understand why people develop this disorder. And there are several causes
- 4:47that we can talk about, genetics, parenting methods, It's a big one
- 4:53abuse, Big five temperament sort of issues, object relations, attachment style schemas,
- 4:59relational traumas, and much much more. So I'm going to go into
- 5:02a lot of different things, and I'm really looking forward to this. So
- 5:06the first thing I want to get into is one of the case examples,
- 5:09the very first case example that I developed. I'm going to call this fictional
- 5:13composite person Aiden. This is a person named Aiden. So this is a
- 5:18only child in a somewhat isolated family. So Aiden is the only son,
- 5:25the only child in a family that lives in a rural area. In an
- 5:30isolated area, the parents had a style of parenting that was very firm and
- 5:35perhaps a little controlling. I think from the outside Some people might see the
- 5:40parents as being nice, firm, and maybe a little controlling if they knew
- 5:45the full extent of the parenting. The parents were excessively emotionally reactive, meaning
- 5:51that when anything happened in their lives, they tended to have big emotions,
- 5:58and they tend they tended to almost histrionically express themselves. You know. They
- 6:03had high happiness and high anger, and high disappointment and all the kinds of
- 6:10emotions. So very very reactive, very undifferentiated in this way. There's nothing
- 6:15wrong with emotional expression, of course, but when you're undifferentiated, you tend
- 6:18to react in ways that you shoot yourself in the foot. So the parents
- 6:23were like that, very very reactive. They would regret having gotten angry frequently.
- 6:29The parents would also, particularly the father, would parent in a way
- 6:32that was a style of my way or the highway. He came from a
- 6:36very old school way of parenting, shall we say, very firm, and
- 6:42so he would he put his foot down, and it was his way or
- 6:45the highway, and both the mother and the son aidan followed his direction.
- 6:50When he put his foot down, they obeyed. The parents were also somewhat
- 6:55self centered, a little bit immature in this way. From the outside might
- 7:00not see that at first, but once you got to know them, you
- 7:01might think, wow, they're really kind of self focused. They don't tend
- 7:05when they especially when they're emotional. The mother became and meshed with Aiden as
- 7:12a young person. She saw him as the one person who she could really
- 7:15trust, even as an infant, as he grew up. As Aiden grew
- 7:19up, she would occasionally use guilt trips to modify his behavior. For example,
- 7:24when he talked about moving out after high school, she became sad and
- 7:28sullen for a week. And now in her mind she's thinking, well,
- 7:31I'm just sad that he wants to move out because I thought he wanted to
- 7:34stay at home. And then another part of her thinking, well, you
- 7:39know, eventually he's going to move out. But then another part of her
- 7:41thought, well, you know, it's a big, scary world out there.
- 7:44But the way that Aiden received it was he was being punished for exploring
- 7:48the idea of moving out after high school. The father was again firm but
- 7:54distant. He was mostly pleasant with the boy, but he would occasionally get
- 7:59angry and would speak in an aggressive tone. The boy grew up to be
- 8:03a young man, and he functioned pretty well and he seemed happy, no
- 8:09major problems in his life. He got a job, but he still lived
- 8:11at home and he didn't really have any huge aspirations of moving out, and
- 8:16when asked, he would say, well, you know, I like where
- 8:20I'm living, and I'm saving up for money to buy a house. He
- 8:24seemingly liked living at home with his parents. He got along well with his
- 8:28parents on the surface, but deep down he knew that things weren't so great.
- 8:33He knew how to handle them when they got emotionally reactive. He knew
- 8:39that he would shut down and he would become a leaf in the wind,
- 8:43meaning that he would comply. He would not his head. He just knew
- 8:48to sort of check himself out emotionally because it was the only way to cope
- 8:52with their emotions, and he prided himself on his ability to remain calm when
- 8:58his parents would flip out. According to him, he didn't have any ambitions
- 9:03in life. None. He was totally happy living at home with his parents
- 9:07and working at his entry level job, perhaps for the rest of his life.
- 9:11But he didn't really think about the future very much. But deep down
- 9:15he knew that something was wrong with his life, but he couldn't put his
- 9:18finger on it. When he thought about it, he quickly changed the subject
- 9:22in his mind and would just get back to his normal routine. He got
- 9:26along well with friends. His friends felt like he was pleasant, but they
- 9:31also saw him as distant, as if he didn't really have a personality.
- 9:35He liked his friends, but he felt more comfortable at home with his parents,
- 9:41and soon as he aged into adulthood, his friendships started to dwindle.
- 9:48He had a few short romantic relationships. He tended to attract women who had
- 9:52quote unquote strong personalities, women like his mother by the way, Women who
- 9:58were ambitious and into, women who were blunt and upfront about things, women
- 10:03who were very emotionally expressive. These romantic partners, these women, you know,
- 10:09they really loved him at first because he was nice and accommodating. He
- 10:13was stable, and he seemingly had a good relationship with his family, which
- 10:16was a good sign. And he never ever ever got angry, and that
- 10:20really pleased a lot of his romantic partners. But over time they felt frustrated
- 10:26with him. He seemed strangely distant at time, at times as if he
- 10:31wasn't there again a leaf in the wind, and sometimes he seemed like a
- 10:35child waiting for mommy to tell him what to do. Partners complained that he
- 10:41never stood up for himself and never seemed to know what he wanted. He
- 10:45felt anxiety while in romantic relationships, as he did in any relationship. He
- 10:50felt like women were always pressuring him to do things like to make a decision,
- 10:54or to speak up, or to have ambition or something, and he
- 11:00developed a narrative that women were too demanding and too much trouble. His relationships
- 11:05usually ended with the woman breaking up with him and him thinking that they were
- 11:11overly emotional. When confronted about things, he deflected and avoided the conversation.
- 11:18He would say anything to get the other person off of the topics so he
- 11:22could return to normalcy and equilibrium. In arguments, he was very good at
- 11:26remaining calm and changing the subject and at deflecting. He was very good at
- 11:33making the other person feel like they were the crazy one and he was the
- 11:37normal one. He eventually married someone. She was very extroverted and she seemed
- 11:43very confident. They fit very well together. She would get him out of
- 11:48the house and he would quote unquote ground her and stabilize her. That's their
- 11:52narrative together. But over time she became increasingly frustrated with him. He would
- 11:58hurt her feelings very strange ways. She began to think of him as a
- 12:03man child and not as a manman. He didn't have any ambitions, he
- 12:07didn't seem invested in their life together. She thought that having children might help,
- 12:13so they had children. It did not help. She quickly realized that
- 12:18he wasn't ready to be a father. In fact, he became even more
- 12:22childlike. She felt like a single mother of her baby and her husband,
- 12:28and she would often tell her friends, I have three children, my daughter,
- 12:33my son, and my husband. The conflict that they had grew until
- 12:39they were fighting almost every day, and they eventually got a divorce. After
- 12:43the divorce, he entered therapy. He didn't know why he was going,
- 12:48but he knew he probably needed to go. The first therapist was supportive but
- 12:52didn't see the core of his issues. Years later, he went to another
- 12:56therapist. This therapist saw his core issue, his schemas of dependency. With
- 13:03this new insight, he suddenly understood everything. He learned how to stand up
- 13:07to his parents, he learned how to have confidence in himself. After a
- 13:11few years of therapy, he healed from his inner schemas and was able to
- 13:16live a happier life. But he always retained the tendency to become dependent,
- 13:22but he knew how to manage it much much better. So that is my
- 13:26case example of Aiden, again fictionalized. It's a composite of people I know
- 13:31and clients I've worked with, and this is an example of which I'll get
- 13:37into you later, of two different types. So the six types that I
- 13:43have developed, and I'll get into it later are separation, anxiety, dependent,
- 13:48and mesh dependent, childlike dependent, compliant and eager dependent, life avoidant,
- 13:52dependent, and passive aggressive. A point, this Aiden case, fictionalized
- 13:56example is a representation of two of the types two of the six types.
- 14:03One is the enmeshed dependent. This is the dependent that merges with other people,
- 14:09someone that they're dependent on, And so Aiden merged with his mother and
- 14:13then later merged with his wife. These individuals, these people with dependent personality
- 14:18sor are willing to give up their identity and they become essentially an extension of
- 14:26another person. The other type that this exhibits, Aiden in. An example
- 14:33is the childlike dependent. These people with dependent personality distor will present in a
- 14:37childlike immature way. They will seem inexperienced, and they will seem incapable of
- 14:45assuming adult responsibilities. So in this deep dive, I am chapter one,
- 14:52I'm going to go into the description of dependent personality disorder. This is the
- 14:58psycholo in Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkhana. I'm a therapist
- 15:03and a professor. This episode is just for patrons of the podcast. So
- 15:07if you want to listen to the rest of this episode, you have to
- 15:09be a patron of the podcast by going to patreon dot com. When you
- 15:13become a patron of the podcast, so get instructions on how to listen to
- 15:16this episode and the other chapters in the Dependent personality sort of deep dive,
- 15:22along with hundreds of other episodes that are only available to patrons and are probably
- 15:28our best episodes. I think I'm confident in saying that you know, our
- 15:33top ten percent episodes are just for patrons. So go to dot dot com
- 15:37become a patron of the podcast if you want, and take care of yourself
- 15:43otherwise because you deserve it, You really really do