Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Benjamin Franklin Effect Builds Office Allies
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Ben Franklin once said — and I'm paraphrasing — 'He that has once done you a kindness will be more ready to do you another than he whom you yourself have obliged.' That's the Benjamin Franklin Effect in a nutshell. And today I want to talk about how that counterintuitive insight can actually help you build stronger allies at work. Luna: I've heard of this — the idea that asking someone for a favor makes them like you more, not less. But it sounds almost backwards. Why would doing you a favor make someone feel positively toward you? Lucas: Right — our instinct is to think that if we do someone a favor, they'll like us. And that's true, that's the reciprocity principle we covered back in episode 115. But Franklin's insight flips it. His version says: if you get someone to do something for you, their brain will rationalize that they must like you, otherwise why would they have helped? Luna: So it's a cognitive dissonance thing. Their mind justifies the action by changing the attitude. Lucas: Exactly. And the origin story is great. In the 1760s, Franklin was a member of the Pennsylvania Assembly, and there was this rival legislator who opposed everything Franklin stood for. Instead of trying to win him over with arguments, Franklin did something clever. He heard the rival had a rare book in his library, so Franklin wrote a polite note asking to borrow it. The rival sent it immediately. Franklin returned it a week later with a warm thank-you note. And after that, that legislator became one of Franklin's strongest supporters in the chamber. Luna: That's a great story, but it's an anecdote. Is there actual research backing this up? Lucas: Yes — and it's a classic. In 1965, psychologists Jon Jecker and David Landy ran an experiment. They had participants win money in a trivia game, and then a researcher approached some of them and asked if they'd return the money — explaining that the research budget had run short. The researcher said it would be a huge favor. After the participant agreed, they were surveyed on how much they liked the researcher. Compared to a control group who never got asked, the ones who did the favor rated the researcher significantly more positively. Luna: So the act of doing the favor created a positive feeling toward the person they helped. That's wild. Lucas: It is. And it's been replicated in different contexts. One study in the 1970s looked at sales: customers who filled out a short survey for a salesperson were more likely to make a purchase from that person later. The favor created a sense of investment. Luna: Alright, so how does this actually play out in an office setting? Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Let me tell you about a marketing manager I know — let's call her Sarah — who worked at Procter & Gamble a few years back. She was leading a cross-functional project to launch a new product, and she needed buy-in from a senior R&D lead who was famously skeptical of marketing. Every meeting, he'd push back on her timelines and her claims. Luna: Classic tension. So what did she do? Lucas: Instead of trying to prove him wrong or butter him up, she asked him a small favor. She knew he had a background in material science, so she asked if he'd spend fifteen minutes reviewing a technical claim she wanted to put on the packaging. She framed it as 'I'm out of my depth here — could you help me make sure I don't embarrass us?' He agreed, gave her a few notes, and she sent a handwritten thank-you card the next day. Luna: And I'm guessing that changed the dynamic? Lucas: Completely. She said that in the next team meeting, he was noticeably less combative. And within a month, he was actually volunteering to help on other parts of the project. She ended up with a strong ally, and later, when she was up for a promotion, he wrote a letter of support. Luna: That's a great outcome. But I have to ask — where's the line between strategic favor-asking and manipulation? Because if you're only asking a favor to engineer someone's feelings, that feels a little unethical. Lucas: It's a fair question. And I think the key is authenticity. The Benjamin Franklin Effect works best when the favor is genuine — you actually need the help. Sarah genuinely didn't know the material science well enough. Franklin genuinely wanted to read that book. If you're faking a need just to manipulate someone, people can sense that, and it backfires. Luna: So the favor has to be real, and it helps if it's small — something they can easily say yes to. Lucas: Exactly. The size matters. If you ask for something huge, you're creating resentment, not affinity. But a small, reasonable request — fifteen minutes, a piece of advice, a quick review — that's the sweet spot. And the follow-up is critical too. You have to show genuine gratitude. Franklin's thank-you note was sincere. Sarah's handwritten card mattered. Luna: What about timing? Should you ask early in a relationship, or wait until you've built some rapport? Lucas: The research suggests it actually works better when there's some initial distance or even mild friction. If you're already friends, the effect is weaker because there's less dissonance to resolve. But with someone who's neutral or slightly negative, the favor creates a cognitive shift. So early in a relationship, or when you're trying to turn a skeptic, that's the ideal moment. Luna: So you're saying: if there's someone at work who seems cold or indifferent to you, ask them for a small, legitimate favor — and then thank them properly. Lucas: That's exactly the playbook. And I want to emphasize — it's not about being fake. You're building a real connection by showing vulnerability and respect for their expertise. That's actually a healthy dynamic. Luna: I can see that. I've had experiences where someone asked me to review a draft, and I ended up feeling more invested in their success. I never thought of it as the Benjamin Franklin Effect, but that's exactly what happened. Lucas: Right. And that's the thing — once you're aware of it, you can use it intentionally, but it's really just a description of how human psychology already works. The question is whether you leave it to chance or you're deliberate about building relationships. Luna: One thing I wonder about though — what if the person says no? Doesn't that create the opposite effect? They might like you less because they feel guilty or annoyed. Lucas: That's a real risk. So you should only ask favors that are likely to be granted. That means keeping them small, time-bound, and framed as a request for expertise — something most people enjoy being asked about. If you ask for something unreasonable, or if you've already burned that bridge, then a no can reinforce negativity. So pick your spots. Luna: And I guess it also matters how you ask. Tone, body language, not putting them on the spot in public. Lucas: Absolutely. One-on-one, in private, with a respectful tone. Something like, 'I know you're busy, but I'd really value your perspective on this.' That makes the favor feel like a compliment. Luna: Let's talk about the thank-you. You mentioned the handwritten card. Is that really necessary? Lucas: I think it's a huge amplifier. The Jecker and Landy study didn't test the thank-you separately, but later research on gratitude shows that expressing thanks reinforces the positive feelings on both sides. For the giver, it confirms that their help was valued. For you, it shows you're not just taking. A handwritten note in the office environment — that stands out. Everyone sends emails. A physical card shows you invested time. Luna: So the full sequence: identify someone you want to build a better relationship with, ask a small genuine favor, thank them warmly, and then watch the dynamic shift. Lucas: Exactly. And over time, you can repeat it. But don't overuse it with the same person, or it becomes a pattern and loses its power. One or two targeted asks per relationship, well-spaced, is plenty. Luna: That reminds me — you know what, this show itself is kind of built on a version of that. People ask us to cover topics, they share episodes, they recommend us. And we honestly couldn't keep doing this without listener support. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good point. And speaking of that — a quick honest thing. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through Buy Me a Coffee dot com slash Fexingo, and that literally funds us making as many of these as we do. No ads, no corporate backing, just people who find the show useful. Luna: It's a small group, but it makes a huge difference. If this show has helped you navigate a tricky office situation or think through a career decision, that's exactly the kind of connection we mean. Lucas: Alright, back to the Benjamin Franklin Effect. One last practical tip: if you're in a new job or a new team, you can use this proactively. Pick one or two people whose collaboration you'll need, and in your first week, ask them for a small piece of advice about the company culture or a process. You're not just gathering intel — you're planting the seeds of an alliance. Luna: I like that. It turns onboarding from a passive experience into an active relationship-building strategy. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the larger point here. Office politics isn't about scheming or manipulation. It's about understanding how people's minds work and using that knowledge to build genuine connections. The Benjamin Franklin Effect is one of the most counterintuitive and effective tools for exactly that. Luna: So next time you need an ally, don't try to impress them. Ask them for a favor. Lucas: And thank them like it matters. Because it does.