Latest / Newcomer Pod / 'This Monolithic Other That Is Acting in Some Dark Confederacy Against What Is True and Good in the World' (w/Antonio García Martínez)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome silicon salad. Hey it's Eric, welcome to dead
- 0:14cat. I'm here with Tom dote on and
- 0:16we've got a great guest, super excited.
- 0:19Antonio Garcia Martinez, author of chaos monkeys, you have a
- 0:24crypto startup Facebook, exactly one point and very aware.
- 0:30Where is exact overstating things?
- 0:32I think title inflation is pretty standard Tetra knows him.
- 0:36So by all means, but we're going to talk about the managerial
- 0:40class so you know you have to be in management there reporter
- 0:43trick you call somebody exact if you want to sound like you're
- 0:46sourcing is higher level, that's exactly why they do it.
- 0:49That's okay. And that can anything be from
- 0:51like product manager to director to any anything that isn't like
- 0:55I was hired yesterday is like oh an exact just told me that this
- 0:58is the strategy. That's right.
- 1:00So if you resource for anyone, you were definitely an exact.
- 1:02Okay, well, alright, I'll take it.
- 1:05If you like our goal with this show is just to sort of
- 1:08understand what's going on on Twitter and like the cultural
- 1:13War, you know like, yeah. I feel like in classic sort of
- 1:16fiefdom division. It's like literally we had, you
- 1:19know, Alex Stamos on last week and it's sort of like he's
- 1:23basically on our side of this whole like free speech internet,
- 1:26moderation war and we're asking him like Like what's the best
- 1:31version of the other side? Like that's as close as we can
- 1:33get to sort of direct engagement with the other side in your
- 1:37game, like you. And I sort of had it out, I
- 1:40think, on Free Speech a little while ago.
- 1:43And so I, my first question is such a big one.
- 1:45I feel bad throwing to you but like, what is going on or like
- 1:49how would you articulate this sort of reporter versus musk
- 1:52sort of thing or like based versus whatever like explain to
- 1:56the audience? Like what is this conflict?
- 1:59That's happening. I wouldn't presume to speak for
- 2:01Ilan or know what's going on said, obviously.
- 2:03But I have commented, I think a lot in the past on the tech
- 2:06media divide to some degree because I think I'm one of the
- 2:08few people who spend it to some degree.
- 2:10I was one of the few people kind of dumb enough to actually write
- 2:13a book about my time in scitech and then like, I actually did
- 2:16fact-check reporting for Wired shortly after that and was kind
- 2:19of a journalist, I figure. Yeah.
- 2:21And you wanna sub stack and add a sub?
- 2:23NS F stack as well. And I had my own podcast and
- 2:25whatnot. So I've played a little bit on
- 2:26the media side of things, which again is pretty unusual for tech
- 2:29people and then, Then definitely very unusual for media.
- 2:31People is actually building things in Tech.
- 2:34So I've seen both sides of it. I do think there's like a two
- 2:36cultures thing going on in which they have just morally
- 2:39foundational, different views of the world.
- 2:41And then there's also a lot of like them in going on by them
- 2:43being. I mean, the other side seems
- 2:45like this monolithic other that is acting in some dark
- 2:48Confederacy against what is true and good in the world which I
- 2:51think is just a natural state that humans think about like the
- 2:53other tribe. And I just think it's wrong very
- 2:56often and there's an acknowledgement of power on both
- 2:59sides, right? Like The reporters, look at the
- 3:01tech entrepreneurial class and see them, you know, exorbitantly
- 3:05wealthy or at least they have access to Capital.
- 3:07And then on the other side, I imagine they're looking at us
- 3:10and saying, you know, we have some sort of magical control
- 3:13over the narrative and what's the game live?
- 3:15The purer? The elite know, you're the like,
- 3:17the one thing you don't want to be right?
- 3:19Now is an elite. Your I am not an elite either.
- 3:22Just everyone knows my arm. Not too late.
- 3:24I'm I want has ever admitted to being an elite team or I'm like
- 3:26give it up. Like what how can I be like you?
- 3:29You know it's just like You get to.
- 3:31I feel like if you get to write but not be blamed for being a
- 3:34journalist, that's sort of the best situation to be in at the
- 3:37moment. If you can have an entire
- 3:38podcast of millionaires and billionaires railing against the
- 3:41elite, then there literally is no such thing as a bully.
- 3:44So, here I would disagree and this gets back to the comment
- 3:46about the manager elite elite obviously means different
- 3:49things, right? But in the context of like
- 3:51America, right now, almost 20 23, I made a reference to
- 3:55Burnham and Burnham was actually a collaborative Trotsky start as
- 3:58a communist actually and ended up on the right.
- 4:00Cited a lot in the writing is very formative for like sort of
- 4:02mid-century conservative thought his book is called the
- 4:04managerial Elite, which I think is kind of a classic Marc
- 4:07Andreessen has been a big booster.
- 4:08This book recently to lots of. Yeah, it's big topic of
- 4:12conversation. Yeah, I think it was in the book
- 4:13list that he tweeted the key thing to understand.
- 4:16And I this is why I think Elites an overloaded term to use a tech
- 4:18term. The elite that James Burnham was
- 4:21referring to was not sort of the WASP Elite that ran.
- 4:23The US for however many decades or was not the sort of Bourgeois
- 4:27capitalist elite that marks railed against, for example.
- 4:30Oil or that Burnham used to rail against in his in his marks.
- 4:32His face, the idea was that there'd be this sort of middle
- 4:35tier technocratic side to society, that would form its own
- 4:39interest group, right? Traditional capitalist, right?
- 4:42Like the original robber, barons of, you know, Vanderbilt and
- 4:45Carnegie and whatnot. They were the elite, they were
- 4:48the founder, they were the management team.
- 4:49They were the capital, they were everything, right?
- 4:52And the dynamic that you see today, in which you often have a
- 4:54middle management layer, that is politically of one mindset, and
- 4:58the founding class, that is another Like a lot of these blow
- 5:01up. You saw it.
- 5:01I mean for God's sake at the Washington Post that they're all
- 5:04hands that devolved into a screaming match or whatever.
- 5:06Right. There's a Delta, a cat and I
- 5:07think it's partially generational, as well, by the
- 5:09way, just to add more complexity to this early muddled thinking,
- 5:12but there's a Delta there between someone who went to an
- 5:15elite school, like an Ivy League school, or Stanford or whatever,
- 5:18and then takes their place in the firmament as a middle
- 5:21management person at a large company.
- 5:22And then there's the founding class employee who often didn't
- 5:25have that background or rebelled against that background.
- 5:28They didn't go to Goldman and Mackenzie when they got out of
- 5:29school, Cool. Right?
- 5:30They did some weird little thing that grew into this massive
- 5:33thing and now they're responsible for this.
- 5:35This is sort of how you have a situation where Ilan seems to
- 5:40not be blaming Jack Dorsey for what happened to Twitter, but
- 5:43blaming the Twitter employees, maybe disagree, right.
- 5:46I mean it's or maybe that's just incoherent, but it's hard to
- 5:49understand how you could not blame the CEO of a company.
- 5:52But have this idea that basically the employees went off
- 5:56and did whatever they want, or your sir, rolling, your eyes at
- 5:58that, so, Look I admire your attempt to try to put some like
- 6:02ideological coherence behind what's going on here because it
- 6:05does seem to be fairly reactive and arbitrary to the moment of
- 6:09who feels like they're attacked. But I think it's interesting to
- 6:12put it in like Marxist terms because what we're talking about
- 6:16essentially is a internecine war between, you know, middle class
- 6:20or professional managerial class and management.
- 6:23So there really isn't almost any blue collar worker to speak of
- 6:26here, which is why this is so, you know, it's based on so many.
- 6:30Also makes it easy and the stakes seems so incredibly low
- 6:33right, you know, no one's livelihood is really at stake
- 6:35here. The cultural divide between, I
- 6:38don't know, sort of the market injury since David sacks of the
- 6:42world and the reporter class like, is this just going to keep
- 6:46accelerating, are like what Bridges?
- 6:48What Bridges, this again, you're citing specific individuals,
- 6:52some of whom I know and so I don't want to speak for them and
- 6:55I think the Divide goes deeper like it's not just a few, they
- 6:58might be lighter about it, but I think Is a divide between the
- 7:01way Builders think about the world, on the way that media
- 7:04people think about the world is just different.
- 7:06Is this shape rotators? Whoa.
- 7:08No, no, no, no. I mean, I've never want to talk
- 7:10about that again, but why don't you, why don't you lay out to
- 7:13me, as a builder as a Founder? What is, what is, what is the
- 7:16view of the world? I mean, that is so distinct from
- 7:18at the very least journalists. But maybe the broader public.
- 7:21So I had lunch with a tech reporter that I think all of us
- 7:24here probably knows and I won't call them out by name.
- 7:26It's a guy that I kind of know personally and have known before
- 7:29I went before. This whole war or whatever you
- 7:31want to call it started, but it still seems as if we're talking
- 7:33past each other, and I think here's how I see it.
- 7:38Builders they can come across as potentially naive, or insincere,
- 7:44or to Ernest. And I think particularly,
- 7:46because a lot of reporters had to come from the East Coast,
- 7:47just to make a regional this, the mega a big Regional
- 7:50generalization Earnest proclamations of like the
- 7:53excitement of building come off as like naive and dumb and
- 7:56childish and I think there's a number of inputs that Silicon
- 7:59Valley. And by this, I mean more, the
- 8:00mentality, Silicon Valley, it's no longer a place, it's really
- 8:03an attitude. A lot of the inputs, you need to
- 8:05make a Silicon Valley work, some of them are a little weird, and
- 8:08they're not the inputs, you have, and other powerful
- 8:10Industries. So a childish sense of wonder,
- 8:13this sort of reflects his desire to sort of disrupt everything,
- 8:16no matter what, I'll sort of engineering solution is mm that
- 8:19everything seems to have an engineering solution, many of
- 8:21these, which by the way I think are legitimate critiques of the
- 8:23culture. I think some of these things are
- 8:24a little bit like I understand why they need to exist but it
- 8:27also means that the view of the world's a little bit incomplete.
- 8:30Eat right? Yes.
- 8:31Okay. Now to create the conflict, I
- 8:33mean, as clearly a member of the media class.
- 8:37Yeah, I feel like the media classes, much more optimistic
- 8:40about the builders. Like there's no, why not?
- 8:43There's no denying we're searching for positive Tech
- 8:46things like there was falling. That's what I heard.
- 8:48The run is not true. That is mr.
- 8:50Doyle splint are Eric. No, don't leave me wrong.
- 8:56I mean, there are but like there's a total acceptance.
- 9:00That sort of Cs type. The Mark Zuckerberg type is like
- 9:05going to build sort of tech companies.
- 9:08I think there is no respect that.
- 9:10There is any sort of expertise in policy or like this, where
- 9:15the content moderation fight breaks down.
- 9:18So much musk declares were just gonna follow the law, this is
- 9:22the framework. They're going to follow the law,
- 9:24he says it over and over again, every expert, whether its media
- 9:28people have focused on it or people.
- 9:30People at Stanford or whatever, says this is ridiculous.
- 9:33And my sentiment was always as soon as Ilan has to literally
- 9:36engage with this and think about it.
- 9:38There's no way he's going to just follow the law which is
- 9:41literally what we're seeing to happen now.
- 9:42But why does the whole world have to suffer through his
- 9:45naivete on this? Just being so arrogant.
- 9:48What why is it naive? I in terms of and I'm not
- 9:51following the law like right now.
- 9:53Mmm, he's falling, he's following the American free
- 9:56standard which is a Brandenburg, the Ohio, you know, imminent
- 9:59Lawless action team. Third, which is what typically
- 10:01rules. Free Speech cases in this
- 10:02country, he has fallen Below in America.
- 10:04You're allowed to have the swastika, right?
- 10:07He banned. Kanye over the swastika in
- 10:10America, it is legal, like, the jet tracking is put out by the
- 10:14government, I believe, like, and he's Banning that from Twitter,
- 10:18right? I think doc.
- 10:19I think doxing is dangerous. Actually, I didn't get to get,
- 10:23it's not against the law, okay? Let me just lay out my view.
- 10:25I don't wanna be a reactive feelings because I don't claim
- 10:27to have inside and see those view.
- 10:28Well, Im questions whether they're Following freedom of
- 10:30speech. One thing I've been very
- 10:32consistent in this. In fact, I have a wired piece in
- 10:332017. I forget the exact title, but
- 10:36basically saying this is when the whole content moderation,
- 10:38regime was kind of spinning up. And I have to say, like I don't
- 10:41often do this, but like I was right two things, one.
- 10:44It's going to be impossible to implement is going to be
- 10:46impossible to actually fairly Implement at scale.
- 10:49Any sort of Oracle of truth, whatever you call it.
- 10:51Disinformation misinformation basically, trying to make things
- 10:54right. In an editorial way online is
- 10:56just not going to be technically and operationally possible one
- 10:59which it hasn't been Then two, if you give that much power and
- 11:02again, I kind of come from that world.
- 11:04I've worked at a company like Facebook, if you give basically
- 11:07like the effective de facto Supreme Court of free speech, is
- 11:10inside a closed or a conference room at Twitter or at Facebook
- 11:13or wherever that is not a good development, you don't want
- 11:16Facebook, the necessarily have that power.
- 11:18And if they do have that power that will be either captured by
- 11:22politics or Joe and by politics, I mean either the left versus
- 11:25right or just internal politics. This guy is politically Ascend
- 11:28it inside Facebook and he has a certain policy and This other
- 11:30guy has a different view or girl, or whatever.
- 11:32And then due to the internal politics, one side wins out of
- 11:34the other and it's just going to be unsustainable going forward.
- 11:37And in my opinion, that's what's happened.
- 11:38Like ask yourself. This are we safer now are, is
- 11:41there more truth online than before?
- 11:42Thanks to this whole concept. Mother has it worked?
- 11:44No, no. The answer is, of course not.
- 11:46And and I mean to the Facebook side, specifically, I mean, I
- 11:49think one of the biggest failings of the media and just a
- 11:51general multi-year, embarrassment on the part of the
- 11:53media, was the way that we covered Facebook in the wake of
- 11:56the 2016 election. I thought it was story after
- 11:59Story. Didn't hold up.
- 12:00That, remember, we said there was a moral Pinconning and and
- 12:03yeah, it was absolutely moral panic and I think that actually
- 12:05gets a maybe a little bit more to the specific mindset
- 12:08differences between entrepreneurs and journalists or
- 12:11the meteor. Whatever is the assignation of
- 12:13moral intent and who is like, on the side of what is morally.
- 12:16Correct. Is it moral to like Advanced
- 12:18humanity and create new things or is more moral to like, bring
- 12:22down the Bad actors that they view as responsible for any of
- 12:26society's ills. And I actually think if you view
- 12:29things through those Those two lenses.
- 12:31It's not completely incompatible.
- 12:33You just need to decide like who is haunting site has, you know
- 12:36it? Whether it's better to try to
- 12:37push things forward at all costs, or to kind of like sit
- 12:40there and ruminate over things and criticize, people may be on
- 12:43Good Grounds and I don't know. It's a tough one.
- 12:47I mean, it's definitely the case that there's a certain
- 12:49acceleration isn't inside the tech world that by default
- 12:51Stomps on the gas. Like unless there's a good
- 12:53reason faster. Right.
- 12:54And I think most people don't look at.
- 12:55I can that's one of the unique inputs for the tech side.
- 12:58One thing I do want to clarify just to finish up with Terms of
- 13:00my views on content moderation because I the incident like
- 13:02people have argued with including Stamos, by the way and
- 13:04other people in this organization around this whole
- 13:06issue of net. And Renee, for example, I've had
- 13:08a whole bunch of screaming arguments over, is that like do
- 13:11so you're a free speech absolutist?
- 13:13Absolutely. No, I'm not, I'm not at all for
- 13:16starters there, again. There's the American free fee
- 13:18standard in, which if you invoke violence or cause violence or
- 13:20have doxing out you go instantly and then, secondly, when I would
- 13:24call sort of Common Sense, decorum like no porn, no
- 13:28hyper-violent video. Obviously going after child
- 13:30Predators, right? There's lots of content that you
- 13:33would go after and that I'm in fact, there's a whole chapter in
- 13:35chaos monkeys, which is basically a love song to the
- 13:38teams that we do you. These are exactly that huge
- 13:40categories. You're going to be like, hate
- 13:41speech. I mean, that is one of the key
- 13:43ones people are fighting over. I mean, the swastika thing
- 13:46doxing like these are all that Elon is by facing all the things
- 13:50that people wanted moderated. And that Free Speech would
- 13:53allow. And so just invoking free speech
- 13:56over and over again and then saying, well, of course, you
- 13:58would want to moderate that. Makes it, I just feel like the
- 14:01arguments have been disingenuous.
- 14:03Why wrap yourself in American law?
- 14:07If you're not actually going to use that as the reference point
- 14:10like nobody is Connie's not going to jail for anything.
- 14:13He said like, nobody's going to jail like right now you can go
- 14:16online and follow the Elan jet tracker.
- 14:18Things off Twitter. There are legal.
- 14:20Yeah, but in his case and again I really don't want to speak for
- 14:22him because I'm not like I'm his lawyer.
- 14:24There was a case of from what I understand.
- 14:26Obviously I'm concerned of myself and actual in person
- 14:28harassment of his child and they come after you Family.
- 14:30It's a whole different story, right?
- 14:31I've got children. If the character my family, it
- 14:33would be a different story, and that that speaks to the level
- 14:37that we have. On the one hand, the Facebook
- 14:39side is sort of the bureaucracy, right?
- 14:42Which journalists myself included.
- 14:44You know, we're born to criticize bureaucracy, that sort
- 14:46of the funny thing. Normally, I feel like that's
- 14:49sort of big, you know. Anyway, but there's the
- 14:52bureaucracy. But at Sycamore, they're just
- 14:54sort of individual action of musk.
- 14:56Oh, okay, but just a quick one thing there.
- 14:58Eric, I mean, and again, this is I think one thing Distinguishes
- 15:00because earlier saying oh you know media is a cheerleader for
- 15:03Tech. I think that hasn't been true in
- 15:05like 10 years since you know, David Pogue was reviewing
- 15:07gadgets and most tech reporting was like at reviews Tech is
- 15:11definitely - now, I don't want to miss my report when there's
- 15:14interesting building and Builders are doing it, like I'm
- 15:19hyping up generative aii right now.
- 15:20People want a positive tearing it down.
- 15:22Everyone should read my latest period want BT. 49 be like the
- 15:25media would love things to Hype up.
- 15:28Look at it this way. This And it's a conversation.
- 15:30I think the nature of Journalism capital J.
- 15:32Journalism is actually changing in a big way and that's what's
- 15:34really going on. And we're just talking about the
- 15:36specific like symptoms that we see of it, but I think this
- 15:39business of accountability journalism.
- 15:41Speaking truth to power whatever, the man can quote, the
- 15:44Cara likes all the time, whatever it is, comforting The
- 15:46Afflicted and afflict the comfortable here.
- 15:48I don't know that, that sort of like look at crypto.
- 15:50For example, the sort of media Borg has tried to find hostile
- 15:54stories about crypto specifically about, for example
- 15:56coinbase an American company. That's about the squeakiest and
- 15:58cleanest cryptic. Um, You can name and the
- 16:01generational villain the Madoff level Scandal was like hiding in
- 16:04plain sight. And in fact got invited to New
- 16:06York Times called for in total, right?
- 16:08How amazing is by the New York Times conference.
- 16:09You're talking about the recent conversation.
- 16:11Yeah. Yes they did a good job Aaron
- 16:13Ross Sorkin. Yes.
- 16:15Well I mean that was supposed to be like an opportunity I mean it
- 16:18was it was an embarrassing moment for him.
- 16:20He he looked like a criminal spilling water on himself and
- 16:24lying you know, and to a point that it was part of his
- 16:26indictment. I mean, coin desk was I mean the
- 16:28media embarrass itself. And was blind FTX oh yeah said
- 16:31yeah, there's no I agree with you 100% about Bitcoin desk
- 16:34helped flag it you know the yeah the media is imperfect.
- 16:38It's like an organ is it's it's just like the queen desk is an
- 16:42industry rag, right? Like they broke the story,
- 16:44right? Whether they're medial and I
- 16:46mean there's a specialist. Okay?
- 16:50I don't do look. We don't get any credit for
- 16:51that. I mean it's just sort of it's
- 16:54not the Democracy dies in darkness people, right?
- 16:55It's a different set of people, right?
- 16:57Yeah. Here's what I think is really
- 16:58going on. Okay, I think.
- 17:00LJ journalism and I've published pieces about this and I'm not
- 17:02the only one who's observe this, but I think capital J
- 17:04journalism, the eighth, call it, but I guess not almost a century
- 17:06of Journalism ad-supported which everyone thinks is evil.
- 17:09It's actually good in many ways in which you have relatively
- 17:11objective, both sides journalism, right?
- 17:13The sort of, you know, Woodward and Bernstein, you know,
- 17:17Watergate style stuff that was a product of a business model,
- 17:20Macy's needed the widest. Most nonpartisan, you know,
- 17:23audience to actually advertise with a little bit of a logical
- 17:25stuff there as well. If you go back to 19th century
- 17:27journalism, of course it was very different.
- 17:28It was more like it is now it Sub Stacks, right?
- 17:30It's pamphleteers it's you know, an openly political press
- 17:34download on which was, right? And that model was both better
- 17:37and worse. In some senses, it was better in
- 17:40the sense that, well, there's no pretending to be objective,
- 17:42which I don't think you actually can't be as hard as you try or
- 17:44on the flip side. The political culture was way
- 17:46more volatile and violent than it was today, right?
- 17:49There wasn't this comment. I mean, he'll there was a civil
- 17:50war in the middle of 19th century.
- 17:52Great. And so I think it's politically
- 17:54very volatile and dangerous to go down that road as well.
- 17:56Not that there's anything. I think we can do about it.
- 17:57I think the old journalism is basically dead and As you are
- 18:00pretending like, it's still exist, right?
- 18:02I mean, I don't think the New York Times even pretend anymore,
- 18:04they themselves have said they're basically a collection
- 18:06of Juicy narratives, which is fine, that's perfectly, fine.
- 18:08And that's really what most people would actually pay for.
- 18:10Most people actually don't pay for truth, unless your
- 18:12livelihood depends on Truth, which is why the Wall Street
- 18:14Journal Bloomberg ft, or doing. Okay, because business people,
- 18:18me goes between the New York Times and I were to Bloomberg.
- 18:21I interned, at the New York Times, no law school, both?
- 18:24I just think the tech people for this narrative, want them to be
- 18:27so far apart, they're not so far apart.
- 18:29I mean, A Bloomberg. People successful ones, go to
- 18:32the New York Times like they're very the pipeline New York Times
- 18:35is through the wall. Well, there I would say they're
- 18:37probably there's something different in their journalists
- 18:40abilities. Yeah, you know, editorial
- 18:42Direction. You know, I do think there is
- 18:44some sort of influence that are broader newspaper has and it
- 18:47inculcate within the reporters to a degree that informs the
- 18:51narratives that they look for. I am sympathetic to that.
- 18:53Yeah. What did you say?
- 18:54Matt Levine's coverage of tech is rather different than Mike
- 18:56Isaac's, for example, sure? I mean, they're, they're totally
- 18:59ready. Job.
- 19:00Yeah, very different reporters different coverage things.
- 19:02I mean, look, here's, here's the interesting thing, I'm glad that
- 19:04you picked up in the idea of Juicy narrative, because I do
- 19:07think that, that is a huge part of what drives reporters to
- 19:09cover a story. And it's one of the reasons I
- 19:11find it completely insane that people like David Sachs and
- 19:14other people on the island podcast have this idea in their
- 19:16head that it is a reporter's best interest to write nice and
- 19:20flattering and ask covering stories about SBF at this point
- 19:23because, you know, reporters are politically aligned with him
- 19:26because he's, you know, a mainstream Democratic voter.
- 19:29We are Us if they're if towards anything towards a juicy
- 19:31narrative and a Bernie Madoff, level downfall of someone who is
- 19:35clearly a character is going to attract any reporter, no matter
- 19:38what. I just don't buy this idea that
- 19:40reporters are looking to soft-pedal anything to do with
- 19:43sandbank manfried because it suits their kind of political
- 19:47interests. I mean, he's a great story.
- 19:49There will be incredible pieces written about him by all the
- 19:52outlets that I'm sure the entrepreneurial class hates
- 19:54because that's the bias. The bias is towards a great
- 19:57story so I don't, I don't know. I'll bet it.
- 20:00But he mentioned made off, because I think one of the
- 20:01things I got published is actually coverage of the Madoff
- 20:03Scandal, specifically Madoff also made political donations,
- 20:06right? And the media actually pushed
- 20:08the politicians of the donated to, which were both Democrats
- 20:10and Republicans to give it back. And somehow, there hasn't been
- 20:12the same push in the SPF case, although he's sprinkling money,
- 20:15made our card charge very like as soon as it was public he was
- 20:18being charged, right? If I remember correctly and I
- 20:20think part of the issue with SPF has just been These things
- 20:25evolve over time, people were defending Elizabeth Holmes, like
- 20:28tech people were defending Elizabeth Holmes post the Wall
- 20:31Street Journal story and then it took a long time for that
- 20:35narrative to really turn. And I just think like there is
- 20:39just smart positioning from people who want to be.
- 20:41Very critical of the media who accurately said, the media
- 20:44hasn't gone sour enough fast enough but it's just like it is
- 20:48going. Now, the media is just not going
- 20:50to get credit for accurately recalibrating when they're
- 20:52actual charges, which is Of how Humanity works.
- 20:55You process information and the mood of Olives.
- 20:58Here's a question Eric I'm going to turn the tables.
- 21:00I'm the I'm the podcast, Captain asseline ideas, the Captain
- 21:03Phillips thing. You know, it's funny.
- 21:05I all said I don't try not to get embroiled in these cultural
- 21:07or things as a like they stress me out and I find them kind of
- 21:10pointless but I do think they reflect underlying phenomenon
- 21:12right? Like in machine learning there's
- 21:14this notion of What's called the other statistics of a latent
- 21:15variable. So like you're measuring like
- 21:17these categories but actually there's like another category
- 21:20that is really what you should be looking at this actually
- 21:22driving the phenomenon. The variables you're looking at
- 21:25are only weakly reflecting that and it like you're kind of wrong
- 21:27if you're not looking at the underlying thing total.
- 21:29So one of the weird like binary latent variables that I find and
- 21:32it applies equally both the tech and media people.
- 21:34By the way, is I think I called it.
- 21:37And what am I a subset footnotes institutionalist versus anti
- 21:40institutionalists? And the idea here is that there
- 21:42are those who don't think there actually is a viable political
- 21:46Senate like small L liberal political Center and that
- 21:50institutions are not worth rescuing.
- 21:51And, you know, it's either all About political war in the ruins
- 21:55of whatever, political life is left.
- 21:57And then by the way, let's just create fundamentally new
- 21:59institutions. And then there are those who,
- 22:01although they might be on the right of the left, they still
- 22:02believe in those fundamental institutions.
- 22:04And I had that thought was somewhat, I won't name her
- 22:06because I don't want to drag you into this, but a noted
- 22:08journalist who is in our mix, right?
- 22:11And I realized I thought she was kind of in my camp and then I
- 22:14realized that actually they were an institutionalist they believe
- 22:17in the institutions even if they publicly have it out with us
- 22:20institutions. And I'm a less a believer in
- 22:22that in that the There's a sort of viable Center
- 22:25institutionalism and it's where do you find yourself?
- 22:27Do you think there is a center with saving that there that the
- 22:29institutions are actually worse in spring or know my college
- 22:32application? Essay was about how this is the
- 22:36most embarrassing thing I could reveal but you know it's
- 22:39embarrassing and same what college you went to Macon,
- 22:41Georgia. You know around Republicans and
- 22:44so when John Kerry was running for president.
- 22:45I held up, you know, a sign like friends don't let friends vote
- 22:48Republican and then by the time, you know the Obama campaign was
- 22:52working. I'd like cut off my ponytail.
- 22:54Dale and I was volunteering for the Obama campaign and you know
- 22:57is high school state coordinator for him and in Georgia.
- 23:00And so it was sort of the evolution in sort of my personal
- 23:04psychology into more of institutionalists and I just
- 23:08don't see how anything is achieved if not through
- 23:11institutions. I think media is meant to Chris,
- 23:15you know, I feel like the classic media story that the
- 23:17iconic media story obviously still is springing down Nixon
- 23:21with Watergate which is sort of like the Your of Institutions,
- 23:25but fundamentally Humanity needs to be organized and I feel like
- 23:30the only viable alternative to the institutional thesis is this
- 23:33crypto sort of imagination game that you're going to answer with
- 23:38and like it's not here, they're it.
- 23:40What, what is the non institution answer?
- 23:42Like, should we be critical of Institutions?
- 23:44Absolutely, but institutions are the only game in town, you know.
- 23:47Maybe it's good. That you start the Watergate
- 23:49thing cuz I've often like throwing that in journalist
- 23:51faces like you're all trying to be Woodward and Bernstein.
- 23:52I got Tony's, I still It is the platonic abstract.
- 23:55It's the Aaron Sorkin movie, Lion of like institutions are
- 23:58corrupt but ultimately there's a happy ending and they come
- 24:00through in the end. The reformed and rise in
- 24:02American flag, right? And the crypto thing you're
- 24:04referring to just for reference. I assume is like Balaji.
- 24:06He's Network State type thing, the idea sort of.
- 24:08Yeah, so I did a review of his book.
- 24:11I know biology personally as well, I'm a bit of a theme of
- 24:15this will be the named and unnamed people that your
- 24:17clothes. Yeah.
- 24:18Well, it's weird, but whatever. I, it's I'm trying to be
- 24:21sensitive because I know these people and, you know, I don't
- 24:23like trashy people. I like the Network's a, I think
- 24:25it's interesting idea and you might be throwing shade on it,
- 24:28but I'll tell you this, I imagine there was a Balaji and
- 24:31network state that encompassed like the three neighborhoods in
- 24:33San Francisco that everyone in Tech lives in and the two
- 24:36neighborhoods in Miami and whatever five neighborhoods in
- 24:39New York and like the urban archipelago of this network.
- 24:42Say, imagine that actually existed.
- 24:43And there was like, borders, and passports.
- 24:45And checkpoints, would you even notice?
- 24:47Or would you not notice because you've never left it, right?
- 24:50And I noticed that in my life, I'm a little bit weird in that
- 24:52I've often had some weird rural red, A place to hide out in.
- 24:54So I would cross the border occasionally but most of I think
- 24:57our cohort wouldn't even notice it exists because they'd never
- 25:00cross its borders. And so sure it's easier to throw
- 25:02shade on the network State, not existing, but functionally, it's
- 25:04already here, right in the sense that very few of your friends
- 25:07are our friends live in the flyover and have very different
- 25:10political views than we do or very different backgrounds than
- 25:12we do. And so that fragmentation is
- 25:13already here. And I think what Balaji is
- 25:16highlighting and Balaji is right about a lot of things.
- 25:18And hyperbolic about other things, is that we've decoupled,
- 25:22like how information I said this in more than one.
- 25:24Yes, how information moves around, and how we physically
- 25:26move around, and the political structures that govern our lives
- 25:28are. Now totally decoupled.
- 25:30Write like, this is a prism through which, I reflect
- 25:32reality. And this has nothing to do with
- 25:33the fact that I'm in San Francisco, California, Nine
- 25:35States of America, right? Okay.
- 25:36I'm gonna make a very high-level point that I want.
- 25:39You sure to it? Sure.
- 25:40Okay, I'm glad Balaji exists like definitely fundamentally.
- 25:45I think people Elites are way too boring, conservative.
- 25:50They don't say anything interesting.
- 25:51The McKinsey of vacation of the world is Terrible.
- 25:54Like I'm against it all, I'm glad Balaji exist but the
- 25:57problem that I see with tech is that then it goes from okay,
- 26:02Balaji only needs to be right five percent of the time, 10%
- 26:06the time to be interesting. But all of a sudden these people
- 26:08are literally governing Elon is in charge.
- 26:11We're not applying the startup model.
- 26:13They want to apply the startup model to actual government.
- 26:17They want to apply it to the actual control of platforms and
- 26:20they're, they're sort of, oh, we'll be right 10 percent of the
- 26:23time but I'll be really Saying doesn't work anymore and they're
- 26:26criticizing the people who are trying to be right 90% of the
- 26:29time and therefore are more conservative, you know,
- 26:33conservative. Even though they're all
- 26:34Democrats in that, they're trying to protect institutions
- 26:37and can't blow everything up every time.
- 26:39Maybe, but I mean, this is my sound.
- 26:40Like what about is in? But how is what he loves doing a
- 26:43Twitter and he different than what the Salzburg is have been
- 26:44doing for the New York Times for five generations.
- 26:46The New York Times is one of the best institutions in America.
- 26:49I'll say that. That's well, I mean, we could
- 26:51argue that, that's where we disagree.
- 26:52And some people think it should be Bring to the ground.
- 26:55Is it is holding? It is holding truth together
- 26:58here. Oh, is it now?
- 27:00Imagine that Mark Zuckerberg actually picked like his
- 27:02smartest seeming Sun as the next CEO of Facebook and did that
- 27:05for, you know, what is it five or six generation?
- 27:07Yeah, would you be such a fan of that sort of dynastic and
- 27:10savagery, and timing nepotism rules all over the world.
- 27:13So but they just accept it. You're fine with it.
- 27:15Do you think that a New York Times employee can criticize
- 27:17ourselves burgers in their internal slack?
- 27:19And the same way that you could do it inside a tech company.
- 27:21For example, Bloomberg definitely did not allow
- 27:24Internal criticism. And I think some of the internal
- 27:26criticism doesn't really make sense.
- 27:28I mean, their hierarchical institutions like edited like
- 27:31part of the value is the, you have an editor-in-chief we sort
- 27:33of makes the calls. So I'm not advocating for open
- 27:36to send. And I think there are plenty of
- 27:38reporters who are annoyed by the people who tried to hijack,
- 27:41these organizations from the bottom up.
- 27:42I don't, I guess I'm less concerned about the ownership of
- 27:45the New York Times, then the world view that it is
- 27:50comforting, and the lack of ability.
- 27:54To challenge broader structure is beyond kind of, the most
- 27:58obvious institutions that it will write about.
- 28:00I mean, I think Facebook has been the most egregious example
- 28:03of that, bring it all back to their coverage of Facebook.
- 28:06You know, with 2016 election. The Fallout of that the New York
- 28:09Times basically did two things one, they sent a bunch of
- 28:11reporters to diners across the middle America, to have them
- 28:14interview random people and have them try to explain.
- 28:17You know why? They did such a horrible thing,
- 28:18which is voting for Trump, and then they wrote a bunch of
- 28:20stories about how Facebook is also responsible for Trump
- 28:22because they allowed a All number of Russian Affiliated
- 28:26actors to, you know, advertise on the platform.
- 28:28None of these are actually dealing with the broader rot
- 28:30that is happening in America. That would cause people to take
- 28:32a drastic action. Like electing a completely
- 28:35unqualified person who had no interest in actually running the
- 28:37country, but the New York Times wouldn't deal with that.
- 28:40And so, like, this gets back to like institution.
- 28:42I don't think the New York Times like that, maybe it's some
- 28:44result of it being a multi, generationally owned fam.
- 28:47You know, family business, that is a East Coast elitist, view of
- 28:51what is and isn't acceptable speech.
- 28:53Or it's The nature of the subscribers and the readers of
- 28:56the play. I like, I am somewhat
- 28:57sympathetic to this world view that, that, you know, the
- 29:00entrepreneurial class talks about with the New York Times,
- 29:02but I guess like, I find it. So unfulfilling as an American
- 29:05to hear the solution to our problems is, let's write a bunch
- 29:10of stories about obvious things rather than dealing with broader
- 29:13challenges. And it seems like there's very
- 29:15little interest in dealing with broader kind of social material
- 29:18challenges that are happening right now.
- 29:20I rest my case Tom you said it better than I could but I would
- 29:22go further and say that If the New York Times grappled with,
- 29:25from the way did is it? Perhaps, because it could do
- 29:27nothing, but look down its noses and contempt at those who
- 29:29actually voted for Trump for whatever reason and that's why
- 29:32they couldn't ask the real questions of.
- 29:33Why that why that happened? And they'd rather blame hundred
- 29:35thousand dollars in Russian Facebook spend which would never
- 29:38win any election anyway, right. But to be clear I don't think
- 29:41there were a bunch of other you know, institutions in America
- 29:44that were doing that either, right?
- 29:45I mean I certainly don't think elon's Twitter and this kind of
- 29:48half-cocked idea of free speech and you know, really just
- 29:51railing against journalists and And I don't know, you know,
- 29:55Taylor Lorenz or something is any sort of actual response to
- 29:58it. It's just kind of like
- 29:59participating in a similar type of culture War, but in like a
- 30:03uh, Nidia logically coherent way.
- 30:05Yeah. I mean, a lot of this such I
- 30:08think certain unlock to American culture is actually what used to
- 30:10be called WWF when I was a kid or now, WWE, right?
- 30:13Like this is all kayfabe, right every, and every tribe that on
- 30:16this podcast, and every tribe has its heel.
- 30:18Right? And, and I often, that's also
- 30:19part. Why didn't participate?
- 30:20You can always find a tweet of some idiot.
- 30:22On the other side is doing some The thing and that doesn't
- 30:25really represent a trend or anything real in the world, but
- 30:27one side not to our side, desperately wants to talk to
- 30:32your site and your sides and they will strategy is not
- 30:35engagement acknowledge that like Balaji is telling people not to
- 30:39engage, we are invite. I email, Mark and is why we're
- 30:42engaged. I had second thoughts about this
- 30:44podcast. I almost did come out.
- 30:45I was in writing this money thing.
- 30:46Sorry. It's all we don't you think we
- 30:47have a productive discussion like or at least like look how
- 30:50many times we'd agreed Antonio, we all know we have the all The
- 30:54same reference points. We see, we see a lot of like, I
- 30:56feel like we should have taken a survey before like what's your
- 30:59true or false, this true, or false, this just to see where we
- 31:02were before. We came in I mean look I'm not
- 31:04I'm not besides just about most things and I'm definitely not
- 31:07like, you know, don't talk to any tech journalist ever.
- 31:09I you know, my mother was a librarian.
- 31:11I myself wrote a book, you know, I think recording history and
- 31:14some drafter and others important.
- 31:16And it may not be within the rubric of like capital J
- 31:18journalism as it exists today but I think we need to record
- 31:20history. Tech is interesting.
- 31:22There's weird ass shit that goes on in And I think what I would
- 31:25encourage people do it. This point rather than talk to
- 31:27reporters is tell their own story.
- 31:29Like, I think more tech people should write books or have blogs
- 31:32or address directly Their audience and it may not be seen
- 31:35through the rubric of the framing of what media has.
- 31:38But if we take away journalism, as the thing, as it exists,
- 31:41today, chronicling reality, and having interesting viewpoints I
- 31:44think is worth having. And so, I just think this model
- 31:46where everybody is just self disclosing most people do not
- 31:51give honest portraits about themselves, like Like, would you
- 31:54want to consume that world? Like I would love a good
- 31:58conservative media. Like actual like fact-based
- 32:00reported Scoopy. Like I love a conservative
- 32:04outlet that delivers Scoops, just to show that they're
- 32:06actually trying to get information but that doesn't
- 32:09exist and I just don't. But with my question here is, do
- 32:12you really think you could get a good picture of the world?
- 32:14If you weren't a super Insider who already knew people
- 32:17personally and Samaria get information from just people's
- 32:21self published work? I think it would be different.
- 32:24Write a memoir, right? Citing my own books, it is which
- 32:27is slightly douchey, but you know, it was fact in the sense
- 32:30that I reconstructed it from emails and texts and I tried to
- 32:32get the timing as correctly as possible.
- 32:33It was not some like lived experience piece of creative.
- 32:36You know fiction that said it was one view, right?
- 32:39And writes. A proverbial elephant think so.
- 32:41I think they need to be combined.
- 32:42I mean, look, when I need your, they need to be synthesized by
- 32:44someone look, when any tech journalist reaches out and says,
- 32:47look, I know, you know, about ads and attribution and track it
- 32:50all this stuff. And like, I'm just going to
- 32:51forget the story. Like, I don't understand it.
- 32:53Can you just walk me? Through like, what's the most
- 32:55recent Apple? Privacy thing?
- 32:56You know what I got on the phone and in good faith.
- 32:59Try to explain it to the person, I still do it, like I forget the
- 33:01financial times, Brian Mcgee or whatever, he covers her apple
- 33:04stuff. I've been a source on background
- 33:06or quoted or whatever more than once and it's precisely because
- 33:09yes I or Steven Levy for example I've been interviewing so you
- 33:12believe in journalism to now I say for fun on Twitter.
- 33:16No no I don't enjoy journalism as it exists today.
- 33:19I do not I think chronicling you what these are worth.
- 33:23No I I don't want to fight Eric. I've often said it, I'm not
- 33:27really a narcissist. I just play one on the internet.
- 33:29This is why I have that, will that 100% a group, not that
- 33:32aspect, but filtering. All this through Twitter is such
- 33:35a perverted way of viewing anyone's personality.
- 33:37What I earnestly believe on Twitter, but people I am so
- 33:41that's what scares us Eric. Yeah, but I agree, I don't know.
- 33:47Like, I think social media like I retweeted balls you today,
- 33:49right? He said one of these classic
- 33:51Balaji isms social networks to show Socially filtered tribes or
- 33:55something, right? And what I think what you mean?
- 33:56I don't know. I'm trying to interpret Balaji
- 33:58here, but I think what he means by that is like, the weird
- 34:00private groups that were all in. That is a closer approximation
- 34:03to healthy social media, right in that there's a, there's an
- 34:06admin. We all kind of know each other.
- 34:08It's below dunbar's number of 140, which is like the number of
- 34:10people you can keep in your head.
- 34:12It's like it's like a saint or way of doing social media.
- 34:14Then I think Twitter, which is like a union of worsts.
- 34:17It is like the worst part of like, you know, improvisational
- 34:20oral culture and the worst parts of searchable text Will culture
- 34:23and Sprocket to everybody, it's just hard with with the
- 34:26engagement mechanism sprinkled in there so that you can feel
- 34:28rewarded for for outrageous Viewpoint.
- 34:31Ketamine just quickly on your book front because you did, you
- 34:34know, you written a book. Everyone knows you for having
- 34:36read that book. It's very entertaining.
- 34:37But it also like later on, you know, was used against you,
- 34:40right? I mean, this was a situation
- 34:42where I don't know how often you've talked about this before,
- 34:45but you were hired to go to Apple.
- 34:47And there was essentially, you know, a slack lead Uprising
- 34:52against the fact that you were joining, That's company.
- 34:54And it was filtered through the media and the way that maybe
- 34:57inform some of your viewpoints on, you know, the ACT.
- 35:00Yeah, that's what the other guy said last week and that's
- 35:02totally not sure. I've been fighting with the
- 35:03media web. Right?
- 35:04Waiver that happened. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 35:07And I'm not saying this is some sort of, you know, damage in
- 35:11your purse, that anything like that.
- 35:12Anything I found I found that whole episode to be rather
- 35:15frustrating on on your part. I thought it was journalistic
- 35:17malpractice or at the very least, it was, it was one of the
- 35:20elements of bad acting in journalism, which is Simply
- 35:24taking any sort of internal information and creating a story
- 35:27around that and not every single thing that is leaked to you as a
- 35:30reporter needs to be made into a piece.
- 35:32And I well, that's that's what that's one of the problems with
- 35:35what I'll call the journalistic epistemology.
- 35:37Like, how do they figure out truth?
- 35:38They necessarily have to talk to people who want to talk to them.
- 35:41Right and who is that person? It's typically disgruntled
- 35:43people to rank every bite. It's right.
- 35:45It's a crank or it's an internal person who has some political
- 35:47battle and they want to co-op the media to try to advance
- 35:50their internal thing right? Like dude I worked at companies
- 35:52and talk to journalists. I know I know The score.
- 35:54I know how the square worker and you're not really, but that's
- 35:56why the non-cooperation is so infuriating because then it's
- 35:59like, well, you're making the medium or biased against you,
- 36:02right? Obviously.
- 36:04Like I said, I think journalists who actually try to like, help
- 36:06me understand how this actually works.
- 36:09I'm happy to talk with and I think those were trying to find
- 36:12a villain to cast in their little movie.
- 36:14I agree. They should be totally and
- 36:17utterly shut. You don't think things.
- 36:19You don't think character-driven like you wrote A Memoir like
- 36:23People are going to understand history through people.
- 36:25I think this idea and this is part of the Builder versus
- 36:28writer divide, is it? They almost don't want it to be
- 36:32about people. They wanted to be about, but
- 36:33because it's not about people, didn't care about people care
- 36:36about, I know, I know, I know and I understand it and that's
- 36:39why the book is a little bit over written on the sort of
- 36:41saltiness front in the sense that like, you know, you have to
- 36:43make it be this personal, like Hunter as Thompson as thing.
- 36:46When really 99% of the book in this, what pissed me off about
- 36:50some of the coaches, a book 99% of the book is trying to explain
- 36:52how like the media markets were Right?
- 36:54He's like the nerdiest book that hopefully, an entertaining way
- 36:56try to understand. Like how does a company like
- 36:57Facebook decide to make money can I it's not, it's not easy
- 36:59but any good. Yep.
- 37:01Well, it just because I, you know, do you consider yourself a
- 37:03Republican or how much do you speak for though?
- 37:05I know I don't talk. I don't address.
- 37:06Well, 6-foot head all whatsoever at all.
- 37:08No I mean well then you can dodge this one or I don't know
- 37:12but I mean part of the challenge.
- 37:14I feel like we faced with the sort of conservative Tech Elite.
- 37:18Is that they're playing? Now, there's a conservative Tech
- 37:21Elite okay. Are there not We were you don't
- 37:25know named individual people. So I was trying to, you know,
- 37:27I'm gonna just saying sacks and Marc Andreessen whatever,
- 37:29whoever that represents. I think we trick ourselves into
- 37:32thinking of thing exists. When we assign a name to it,
- 37:34that's what I think. What do you mean?
- 37:35You've just declared her to be his thing, right?
- 37:38And now there's this thing that we're talking about.
- 37:39What are you get polling? It's, I'm not sure.
- 37:41I'm not sure it even exists present like a view.
- 37:43I mean, look, the political donations inside fan companies
- 37:46is public record. You can look at it, does it seem
- 37:48to you that there's some sort of conservative faculty?
- 37:50So, is the takeaway that we're sort of being the media's been
- 37:52hoodwinked by, like, Paying too much attention to, at least we
- 37:55employ sorta. Like, but my point was just the
- 37:58conflict between like the profess populism, whereas, like
- 38:02the actual sort of policy interest seems to be sort of low
- 38:06government intervention, low taxes.
- 38:08I mean, you think there is genuine.
- 38:10Here's one thing I will comment and again in a very distant
- 38:13abstract descriptive rather than normative way.
- 38:16One thing that I find this interesting on the right is and
- 38:18I think you're you put your finger on it.
- 38:19The traditional sort of GOP Republican was like, you know,
- 38:22small government low This is like the Reagan Republican and I
- 38:25think you're seeing the creation of a capital and capital r mu,
- 38:28right? That doesn't perceive itself
- 38:30that way, that is more comfortable with using
- 38:32government authority to implement some agenda and yeah,
- 38:35broadly speaking sees itself, it's weird because yeah it sees
- 38:39itself in revolt against some sort of elite that it doesn't
- 38:41feel. It's a part of Rick.
- 38:43And yeah, that definitely is novel, right?
- 38:45That's definitely not the, you know, I was raised in the 80s in
- 38:47Miami and everyone loved Reagan and this is not that it clearly
- 38:51something has changed on the right.
- 38:53And yeah, I don't Don't know where this is going.
- 38:54I don't have an answer but I think you're right.
- 38:56That there is a big, there's a big difference.
- 38:57I wanted to ask you a question about advertising because that
- 38:59is a space that you professionally spent a lot of
- 39:02time in and I covered advertising for a while.
- 39:05I think there's an interesting thing going on right now, in
- 39:08terms of advertisers and where they play a role in the internet
- 39:12culture wars. Because you're seeing, I mean,
- 39:14this is all just about Elon and Twitter but you know,
- 39:18advertisers pulling off of the platform because they view it as
- 39:20not brand safe and it's an interesting.
- 39:23Upon reading about the way Republicans or conservatives,
- 39:27you advertisers in the in the 70s and the culture wars then,
- 39:31which is basically like they're on our side right there.
- 39:34Going to stop us you know the left from being too Progressive
- 39:36because they're trying to sell the most number of products and
- 39:39you know the Democrats or whatever you know the left is
- 39:43culture. Warriors then we're pushing
- 39:45things too far from what mainstream America wanted.
- 39:48What do you think about? You know the the internet
- 39:51advertising's role in like being a Creating force on either side.
- 39:56I think it's to use Tyler Cowen language.
- 39:59It's an underrated point in the sense that I think people don't
- 40:01bring it up. I think advertising catches a
- 40:03lot of heat, some of it Justified for sketchy data
- 40:05practices, but broadly speaking, the thought that, you know,
- 40:09media has gone to the shitter because of advertising is like
- 40:12not only wrong. It's like the exact opposite of
- 40:14the truth like advertising is again.
- 40:17I think we addressed this earlier in the podcast is the
- 40:20thing that maintain the sort of objective both sides.
- 40:23Let them in which, you know, sure newspapers had certain
- 40:27Slants to them. But whether you were the New
- 40:28York Times or the Cleveland Plain Dealer, the Chicago
- 40:31Sun-Times you can CO2 off the rails because Macy's or pick
- 40:35your Normie Advertiser. Just wouldn't want to co appear
- 40:38with like some radical opinion. And so I think advertising has
- 40:41been a moderating force. I think people again, who
- 40:44Advocate. Oh, subscription driven
- 40:45journalism is better. I encourage you to go read about
- 40:48the history of nineteenth-century, American
- 40:49journalism, and see or, you know, even further back that,
- 40:53you know, 18th century, American journalism.
- 40:55Ben Franklin was basically in a non account shitpost, who wrote
- 40:57Under at least 20 different aliases, the whole Hamilton
- 41:00Burr, wonder what he wrote in Federalist Papers, your
- 41:03Federalist Papers words. He was a very pugnacious time,
- 41:06right? And at the end of the day, the
- 41:08customer gets what they want. And in the case of advertising
- 41:10driven journalism that means fairly non-inflammatory
- 41:14even-keeled coverage which is what the advertiser wants and
- 41:17the case subscribers they want their worldviews echoed back at
- 41:21them and more articulate form but nothing To fuel the culture
- 41:24War. It wasn't the media that was
- 41:26saying clickbait journalism was the problem.
- 41:30Yeah, I'm not I'm not finger-pointing here but no, but
- 41:33there, but there is like a discourse that's like
- 41:35advertising. It's bad and its influence on
- 41:36the media's been bad. And I'm the other side of that.
- 41:39Oh, I was just making a petit Petit, point that clickbait.
- 41:43Yeah, I know, I think there's no accountability.
- 41:45Like, we just get yelled at about clickbait journalism.
- 41:47Like, you know, this is how internet fights start.
- 41:50It's like reporters experience, just getting yelled.
- 41:53Old at constantly accused of Click bait when I'm working.
- 41:56I don't Loom Berg. Yeah.
- 41:57And then it's like, it just makes you very hostile.
- 42:01It increases the hostility towards the text.
- 42:03That when you're like, I mean, you're to really broaden this.
- 42:07And I think what Tom is talking about is sort of like the
- 42:09business model incentives of behavior.
- 42:12And I think often, you know, tech people want to talk about
- 42:17like the business model b instead of behavior of their own
- 42:19businesses. But then media criticism isn't A
- 42:23judge through the same lens of business model.
- 42:27Well look, I mean to put on my media had I guess, for one like,
- 42:30you know, Split Second. Yeah.
- 42:32I mean a lot of people don't understand how media works,
- 42:34right? Like the clickbait thing again,
- 42:35Bloomberg is ridiculous. When people write whatever it
- 42:37is, two thousand dollars, a pop. Just just use a Bloomberg
- 42:40terminal. It's not about the clickbait.
- 42:41Yeah, right think that's just not what, it's not what it is.
- 42:44Yeah, I agree. I mean yeah no, but I've
- 42:46actually my point was less about journalism here and more about
- 42:49social media because you know, we've seen advertisers play A
- 42:53Part occasionally, as a response to Media outcries against
- 42:57platforms, right? I mean, you saw the ad pocalypse
- 42:59with YouTube, you saw, you know, whatever movement against
- 43:02Facebook and in the wake of, I don't even remember which
- 43:05controversy that caused big advertisers to claim they were
- 43:08advertising on Facebook and now we're seeing the same thing
- 43:10happening. Not so for the same reasons, but
- 43:12with Twitter and a ton of advertisers are just pulling off
- 43:16of the platform and I'm interested in your your take on
- 43:19whether because I don't believe advertisers or moral actors.
- 43:22I don't think for the most part, they are trying to advance some
- 43:26sort of moral, cause I think they want to see where they
- 43:28believe the direction of the country is at, and make sure
- 43:31that they are aligning their products with the most safe,
- 43:35place for them to be which, you know, from, you know, from a
- 43:38broader cultural standpoint now appears to be a little bit more
- 43:42liberal or or towards you know like a broader Embrace of
- 43:45genders and identities and things like that which I know a
- 43:48lot of conservatives are the people that are backing Elon
- 43:51feel is, you know, is woke and it It's this idea of what
- 43:54capitalism and you know, as you're seeing advertisers
- 43:58pulling off of Twitter right now in response to this, you know,
- 44:03content moderation, Free Speech, a absolutism whatever that his
- 44:06group is pushing, what do you see?
- 44:09As I don't know, what is the role that advertising is
- 44:11playing? Is it a factor that you think
- 44:13that side should be listening more to, or are they just in
- 44:16thrall of like the woke leftists?
- 44:18I mean, it's a good question. I think to advertisers represent
- 44:22popular will are they trying to As the reach or do they express,
- 44:25the will of a relatively small Elite Class that has certain
- 44:28values that may not be. Let me not being happy
- 44:32representative, I'm not sure. Yeah, I mean brand advertising
- 44:36is a whole different Beast than like the performance advertising
- 44:38the dice typically works on, right?
- 44:39You're trying you're trying to convey and for those who don't
- 44:42know what that means, like Performance Marketing is like by
- 44:44this thing, right? It's like the direct to Consumer
- 44:46as you see in our Instagram feed and then brand advertising is
- 44:49some like snazzy BMW or Burberry.
- 44:52Add that tries to convince you not necessarily by that thing
- 44:55right now. But when you're in a financial
- 44:56position to flaunt your wealth you'll think to buy a BMW 5
- 45:01Series. It's or whatever great and it's
- 45:02a very different. It's like Vibes versus click on
- 45:05this thing and a lot of brand marketing is always been a
- 45:07little bit, you know, not exactly a person of the people
- 45:11sort of thing, right? Because you're trying to events
- 45:14Elite values. I don't know.
- 45:16I again, I hate them in things right from any side.
- 45:20Like oh this monolithic them, but it does seem like there's a
- 45:23certain set of values that again, you see incorporation
- 45:26Academia and media that have a lot more in common than they
- 45:29have a part. And it's You used to have like
- 45:33to Eric's point about, why isn't there a better conservative
- 45:34media used to have kind of right-of-center newspapers that
- 45:37were like respectable, and not intellectually brain-dead?
- 45:40And you could and, you know, a liberal could read and
- 45:42appreciate, right? Like, who's left the Wall Street
- 45:44Journal, but I mean, most reporters at the Wall Street
- 45:47Journal are liberal and, and like The Economist is clearly,
- 45:51pretty definitely. Liberal by American Standards.
- 45:55I don't know if I would say, the economist is probably like
- 45:59institutionalists and like scary Biden.
- 46:01It's very aligned with the B like a my part.
- 46:03I wouldn't say it's like, okay well what a rag, but a
- 46:05neoliberal shills cancer term the yeah, I'm almost like fight
- 46:15with this more. I mean, one observation, I think
- 46:17from this conversation is that I do, wonder, how much of our
- 46:21problems are specific to where they happen, right?
- 46:25Like a lot of my frustration with the arguments they have is
- 46:29that they come in Twitter. Matt and that people basically
- 46:34take advantage of the fact that they can be withholding, right?
- 46:38If I'm a powerful person, I can put out one tweet and my fans
- 46:42don't expect me to engage with every like reasonable argument
- 46:45and so then I really no obligation to go back and forth.
- 46:50And so then we have these sort of just like spot.
- 46:53We have these statements with no real discourse and I feel like
- 46:57it just fuels a lot of anger. I don't know how much do you
- 47:00think it's a Twitter? A problem rather than a cultural
- 47:03problem. Like I don't feel so far apart
- 47:06in view with you. Like, or at least convince me
- 47:08where besides the New York Times, which feels fairly
- 47:11trivial to me. I've yet to be convinced that
- 47:14were actually ideologically so far apart.
- 47:17Yeah, I know the truism and startup culture that most
- 47:20startups problems are not really technical problems.
- 47:22Although, the founders tend to think that's what it is.
- 47:24It's usually human problems, right?
- 47:25There's a management problem. There's a product problem.
- 47:27Something else I do think, I do think social media cannot be
- 47:31Next, which is why I'm very skeptical of content, moderation
- 47:33and do. The algorithm will fix things
- 47:35will guess what? WhatsApp doesn't have an
- 47:36algorithm and if there's been all sorts of fucked up, shit,
- 47:38thanks to fit to Whatsapp, right?
- 47:39There's no algorithm there. So I don't think there's fixing
- 47:42it. That said, I do think there's
- 47:45forms of social media that are more kind of Humane and normal
- 47:47for the average use case, then other ones.
- 47:49So like again like who thrives on Twitter, you have to be like
- 47:52a total narcissist or the most disagreeable human on the
- 47:55history of the makes me angry, right?
- 47:57It makes you angry and you have to like being angry or you have
- 47:59to be so disassociated that you don't get angry.
- 48:01But like right, you know, like I've had conversations with
- 48:03people like Barry Weiss to a lesser extent, metaclass.
- 48:06He has Matt Taibbi and they're very good at what they do,
- 48:09right? Like they're, they're like, born
- 48:10to be on Twitter and drive engagement.
- 48:12I don't mean that in a bad way, right?
- 48:14But it's like, man, I cannot do what you do.
- 48:16I cannot just get up in the morning, say a thing and then
- 48:19get kicked in the face by 10,000 people there though.
- 48:22I mean, I don't know how much you try to mix it up and just
- 48:25throw bombs into the crowd, but you're pretty good at it.
- 48:27Like I would say among the class of people in Tech who you Or in
- 48:32certain ways spokesperson of the mindset feel like you're out
- 48:35there, you know, you're you got a lot of Miami stuff.
- 48:38I feel ya to me the perfect you know the perfect way to me is
- 48:41it's a tweet that both pleases or pisses off both camps.
- 48:45Equally that to me is the perfect tweet.
- 48:48You can read it in both directions and everyone gets
- 48:49pissed off. I don't quote tweet and like
- 48:52dunk on people that much. I mean, very rarely.
- 48:54Yeah. I just I don't like playing the
- 48:55game. I think it's bad.
- 48:56I think it's - Mojo. Yeah, I agree.
- 48:58I don't know. I mean, I don't know what comes
- 49:00after it though. And it seems like the
- 49:03alternative that we're moving towards which is just smaller
- 49:06and smaller networks is just going to eventually push itself
- 49:09towards even more insular thinking, right.
- 49:12I mean, maybe it won't be as angry, which is some sort of
- 49:14benefit. But if the at least there was
- 49:17some sort of exchange of ideas, I've seen a lot of Facebook
- 49:19people arguing this, that like you actually are more exposed to
- 49:23other viewpoints. Yeah, you're on social media,
- 49:24then you would have been yes prior to it.
- 49:27I think that's true. There's a number of studies.
- 49:28You can say and these studies can prove almost anything I
- 49:31don't think filter bubbles are real and the sense that I think
- 49:34the problem is that you're actually exposed to view points
- 49:37that are diametrically opposed to yours all the time, right and
- 49:40presented in the most like outrage producing way.
- 49:43I mean again the reality I think I mentioned this earlier like
- 49:45disconnecting what we see and think and talk with from the
- 49:49sort of bubble of community and the little border on the map
- 49:52that would typically have defined your linguistic and
- 49:55cultural and political boundaries.
- 49:56That's a real problem right? Like the u.s. used to be a lot
- 49:58more Regional, right? The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
- 50:01Could have its little editorial policy that flies in Atlanta and
- 50:04the guy in l.a. never had to get pissed off about it, right?
- 50:07And there wasn't some way to like, oh, look at this stupid.
- 50:09Align the Journal-Constitution. Yeah.
- 50:10Yeah. And then there's a whole
- 50:12cancellation order stockpiling, whatever, like it was just hard
- 50:14to do like I do you know? I mean, we're all probably
- 50:16roughly. The same age.
- 50:17I'm were being raised in the 80s.
- 50:18If you wanted to read the New York Times, like you have to
- 50:20find a copy was hard. Like it didn't matter.
- 50:22What the fuck happened in New York?
- 50:23You didn't care. There's no way to create that.
- 50:24You were just defined by your little world.
- 50:26And we've strayed from that, and I think I have a very aggressive
- 50:29block policy. I think Erica probably had you
- 50:31blocked. Point.
- 50:31Sure, actually blocking I don't block like newsmakers but I
- 50:35block their sycophants all the time, right?
- 50:38I do it all the time, like I hear block trigger and by the
- 50:40way, I've had people ask me like, hey, like we had a
- 50:42misunderstanding. Can you unblock me?
- 50:44I'm like, sure, bro, like this, just get over it.
- 50:45This move on, I do it all. If I, what I wish there was was
- 50:48like, a seven-day block button like timeout.
- 50:51So I just don't have to see your seven days, but then, it's okay,
- 50:53we're back, right? I think we have to recreate the
- 50:55walls. It's the only way to live in
- 50:57society. Like, I don't want to sit here
- 50:58and argue the moral Foundation Society every day, with all the
- 51:01entire inner, like, I just can't do this exhausting, it's
- 51:04exhausting? Yeah, I actually find by the
- 51:06way, the most of the people that I've locked over time or people
- 51:08that I like it personally. And when I see them acting a
- 51:12certain way on Twitter, and I start feeling negatively about
- 51:14them, I'm like, well, that's not how I actually feel about them.
- 51:17Can I ask you, though, because you are certain friends with
- 51:19certain people that do, you know, quite publicly attack
- 51:22media and journalists talk to them in person?
- 51:25Are they ranting about us? I mean do they really truly
- 51:27spend their time offline being like these fucking guys?
- 51:30I can't. Vols confidences.
- 51:33I'm not even naming names. I'm just saying, like, is that
- 51:35even a topic of conversation? I mean less than the other side,
- 51:38probably thinks, but definitely more than 0.
- 51:42Do you think, like, do you think both sides are debating in good
- 51:46faith? I think they think they are.
- 51:48What's your assessment of good faith?
- 51:50The failures and success like when it's genuine and not
- 51:54perceived to be and when it when it's not like, I mean, I'll
- 51:57refer to again something I said earlier, which I think that the
- 51:59latent variable we see in society E is between
- 52:01institutionalist and anti institutionalist.
- 52:03And when you say good faith, what you mean is you?
- 52:05And I, even though you might be one point in the political
- 52:08Spectrum, another, we can find some common ground that we can
- 52:10discuss the thing. And I think the difference is
- 52:12some people think that can happen.
- 52:13And some people think it can't happen and I think that's the
- 52:15Delta and I think if you're feeling increasing
- 52:18radicalization or like a hardening, in the tone from the
- 52:20tech side is because more and more people are giving up and
- 52:22never having that Common Ground. Yes!
- 52:24Okay, that's the most reassuring thing ever.
- 52:27But I guess as somebody who isn't You won't let us talk
- 52:32about specific people, but if you're a techno Optimist,
- 52:36shouldn't you believe that Society can be fixed.
- 52:38Therefore, these gaps can be bridged.
- 52:41Therefore, in speech, there should be an attempt, to bridge
- 52:44them. Like, that's the ideology.
- 52:46I can't connect. It's like you're a techno
- 52:48Optimist but you are, you believe, in sort of Doom and
- 52:51Gloom about sort of human, sort of us, being able to be
- 52:55reconciled what? But maybe nuking the journalist
- 52:57is the fix, right? If you're looking from their
- 52:59point of view, right? That That's the that's the fix.
- 53:03Yeah. Do you believe that or like we?
- 53:05Yeah. Wait is like, let's just get
- 53:08what? I don't want to walk away from
- 53:10this. I feel like where we didn't
- 53:13wear, you didn't really say your strong truly held position like
- 53:18engage with the actual journalist in front of you.
- 53:20Like, what is the, what would the solution be able to get rid
- 53:23of just like, shut down? All the papers, or like what?
- 53:26And what is the policy vehicle to get there?
- 53:28Or what's the way? What do you even expect?
- 53:31T', look, I don't think anyone. Well, that's not true.
- 53:33Some people probably say that I don't think anyone would.
- 53:35Seriously entertain like literally you know, killing the
- 53:37journalism industry to as it exists.
- 53:39I think what all she talks like that and yes well okay you know,
- 53:42policy has his views. I think, I mean the nature of
- 53:45Journalism is changing, like we talked about it, the Woodward
- 53:47and Bernstein model, I think it still can exist.
- 53:49Like I see I see pieces even coming out of the New York Times
- 53:51or the Wall Street Journal, but are still pretty good.
- 53:53Like I read it's like okay like you know yeah.
- 53:55If I was a Layman this is a pretty good sort of summary of,
- 53:57like, kind of what happened. I think it's rare, but it does
- 53:59happen. But I think The juicy narrative
- 54:01thing is what's happening. People are just want juicy
- 54:03narratives and I think I would be satisfied if like and you
- 54:08hear this a little bit in the Elan rhetoric, at least from
- 54:10what I've read that like he wants everyone on an equal
- 54:13footing, like, being a journalist doesn't, just let you
- 54:16dock people and show up on their door.
- 54:18It's like, I don't like, where is this special?
- 54:20Like I was again like a factor journalist who got paid by like
- 54:23respected Conde Nast Publications, where's my little
- 54:25special magic journalist card like license to Doc's thing.
- 54:29I am 007 license, the dock Yeah. Yeah, I can show up on your
- 54:31doorstep and nobody else. Can anyone else does it?
- 54:34Oh, and it's a threat to safety. But I do hear sure defending
- 54:36democracy like what the hell, why?
- 54:39Right? We you don't Well, I mean
- 54:45interesting place, right? Because I'm not a news
- 54:47organization, right? So what gives me sort of this
- 54:50journalistic principle is whatever sort of ethical sort of
- 54:55class status that exists in journalism and only that.
- 54:59And I feel like showing up at someone's door to ask them.
- 55:03A question is like a great example here, we're totally if
- 55:06you just had some I mean, if you had somebody show up, you're at
- 55:09your door. I mean I think there's actually
- 55:11easy now. They Better for one second.
- 55:13If someone shows up at your door and they're not trying to
- 55:15publish a piece, they're clearly showing up as a threat.
- 55:19Right? Like what is you need a reason.
- 55:21Whereas, if you're a journalist showing up at the door, I think
- 55:24people see it as a threat because they see the power of
- 55:27Journalism, but obviously, it is actual sincere attempt to get
- 55:32comment in a belief in good. Faith, like this is where the
- 55:36not believing that. There's a real possible Bridge
- 55:40makes journalism so hard because there is Is like Bloomberg runs
- 55:44and almost to my frustration would run statements from the
- 55:49subject that I thought were like so flatly like false that it we
- 55:52should even like give them are. But I do think media companies
- 55:56are bending over backwards to represent what these people
- 56:00believe by going to their door and trying to get comment when
- 56:03they won't respond. Okay, dude.
- 56:04But you know, a lot of that salt, a lot of that falls into
- 56:07the so sir. When did you stop beating your
- 56:10wife category? It's like you can frame
- 56:12question. Certain way and you frame the
- 56:13sorts of certain way and that's where the journalistic bias
- 56:15comes in. I mean again, but you have to
- 56:18accept that journalists have some sort of crown like, oh, I
- 56:20am on a fact-finding mission. Anyone else shows up on your
- 56:23door is a threat and I think that's a hard dichotomy to
- 56:26maintain when you have a media that's perceived as being
- 56:28extraordinarily placed. Yeah, well I use sort of said in
- 56:32the beginning of this conversation and this is where I
- 56:35can't quite Square the circle that like part of the value of
- 56:39add base sort of shared media, is that we Created sort of this
- 56:43Collective narrative and, you know, if you have that model,
- 56:47then you have people who are sort of empowered by Society.
- 56:50This is literally the first amendment I had to look it up
- 56:52the other day, just to reassure myself mentions the Press
- 56:55specifically. Like it is part of the Bedrock
- 56:59of America. You talked about all the
- 57:00founding fathers being writers, like if there is press that sort
- 57:04of is a unifying force that allows people to see the culture
- 57:08through a shared lens like you just don't believe in that
- 57:11anymore note. True.
- 57:13But you realize this key you, I mean not that I'm a
- 57:15constitutional originalist but the press as it existed in Ben
- 57:18Franklin or George Washington's time.
- 57:19Sure. Very different than the
- 57:21Bloomberg of today. That's the difference, right?
- 57:23And again, many would argue that the press that the founding
- 57:26fathers were thinking about is more encapsulated with what
- 57:28perhaps you're doing right now, with this podcast, journalists
- 57:30are more supportive of me than your Tech Builders like let me
- 57:34tell you, I have not had the door open to Tech Builders by
- 57:38being independent. It's exactly.
- 57:39Did what do they gain talking to you?
- 57:41They're gonna get screwed. Dude, these they don't believe
- 57:43they're not gonna get screwed. Honestly like, are you getting
- 57:46screwed? Like I'm are you getting
- 57:48screwed? Like oh but I you know I you're
- 57:51not doing a story on me. Write it like this is like more.
- 57:54I'm trying to interrogate your views, that's what I do.
- 57:56Professionally like, yes, I'm happy to are the recording of
- 57:59Marc Andreessen if he wants to do the interview but like it's
- 58:02cowardice and disingenuous. And like I respond, like I'm
- 58:07begging. You, I have an argument.
- 58:08That's what we're here for again.
- 58:10Why would they do it? Because I see everything through
- 58:13strategic a strategic lens and not through as you've imposed
- 58:18that because I every CEO and this like talk to any CEO and
- 58:22they will have the story of when they got burned by whatever Wall
- 58:26Street Journal. Wopo.
- 58:27New York Times. They'll have the, I got fucked
- 58:29by the reporter story and that's what sets the tone.
- 58:32That's why you're seeing it with her upside if they want to
- 58:34address Their audience or they, you know, as a CEO, there's two
- 58:37reasons to talk to the media. One is obviously brand building
- 58:40of some sort establish a certain tone I meant etcetera, you can
- 58:43message us channels directly. Now, why would you need the
- 58:47journalist is in the gatekeeper anymore.
- 58:48Is the reality? Sure.
- 58:49Yeah. Audience.
- 58:50Their strategic lens and then there's this earn it.
- 58:53I it's the earnest tea that I'm looking for, on the right.
- 58:56That's why I feel like, I'm in a strong position on this.
- 58:58Like, yeah, this strategic lens I've been all over the pro go
- 59:02direct. You know, I wrote the story
- 59:04about Andreessen Horowitz, going direct like I totally understand
- 59:07that, but if people on the other side, have sincere reviews
- 59:11having them out. Like you're doing here is part
- 59:14of it. Okay, well I you know, Bradley
- 59:16one thing that I think is interesting is that this whole
- 59:18notion of like building and doing in public like what Elon
- 59:20is doing with Twitter, the fact that he's kind of live tweeting
- 59:23this complete reboot, like, whatever you think of it.
- 59:25The fact that he's actually like, tweeting, what's happening
- 59:27as it's happening, is something that would never have happened
- 59:29in the corporate culture of 10 or 15 years ago.
- 59:31And for those who are fans of it and he does have many fans.
- 59:35If you look at the replies, I think that level of directness
- 59:39that freshness comes off as authentic and real and not Not
- 59:42fake and not stay calm. Sure.
- 59:45But he know, I mean, I think it's predictions about what
- 59:47happens in the future are extremely inaccurate.
- 59:51Well Pete, but you know, journalists have gone to the
- 59:53extreme against Elon. Now I think yes, they are
- 59:55because because Twitter is such an open-air debacle in in so
- 1:00:00many, I think unassailably true ways, or, you know what I mean,
- 1:00:02like, it's unassailably true that it is a mess right now,
- 1:00:06but, you know, is it though? But it, but it's but there di a
- 1:00:08user through the roof and it's the greatest, Showdown them.
- 1:00:11I mean, he's he claims that they are No, I haven't seen it either
- 1:00:13but he leaked the deck slides and and Casey Newton would have
- 1:00:16reported on the real numbers. And suddenly from the Twitter
- 1:00:18growth guy, had been faked like, 'oh, then I miss, I missed that.
- 1:00:22I mean, we Casey report on the numbers.
- 1:00:23No, no. I'm saying Ilan posted slides
- 1:00:26from what looked like a growth chart and if they were
- 1:00:29fraudulent which is what you were you know, perhaps floating
- 1:00:31then the real numbers would have looked instantly because there's
- 1:00:34a level of scrutiny being applied as well.
- 1:00:35Look, I missed that I certainly think like setting a car on fire
- 1:00:38is also going to get a lot of people gawking at it.
- 1:00:40And if you're also the revenue sir, Only downright are you
- 1:00:43questioning that like I don't know.
- 1:00:45I mean so probably I was I was actually gonna give Elon some
- 1:00:48credit here. I do think that because there is
- 1:00:49such an extreme view on journalists part that he is
- 1:00:52doing such a certain job when running Twitter.
- 1:00:56There's this desire to throw everything that he's done to
- 1:00:58this point. You know, it throw it in the
- 1:01:00same light and I think there are reasonable people can make cases
- 1:01:03on the value that Tesla has given to the society broadly.
- 1:01:06And I actually think space accent specifically starlink are
- 1:01:09like great great offerings and I can you say that Personal
- 1:01:12reasons. So like journals aren't willing
- 1:01:14to accept that now because it's a great story to throw along
- 1:01:17under the bus. But right, I mean Ilan has been
- 1:01:20just a fanboy for one second. I mean, the most Transformer
- 1:01:23individual of our time in the long range view of history,
- 1:01:25between space, exploration and electric vehicles, full
- 1:01:29disclosure. I own a Tesla 3, I like the car
- 1:01:31lot. That's been a transformative
- 1:01:34thing. And if anything right, like I
- 1:01:36think I once joked that the Fermi Paradox which is a
- 1:01:39paradox, like why don't we see more human life in the universe?
- 1:01:41Is that We planted evolved to the point where the most
- 1:01:44ambitious smartest person buys their version of Twitter and
- 1:01:47then the whole society falls apart.
- 1:01:48And then they and they never actually get to Mars because
- 1:01:51they get so distracted with Twitter flame Wars.
- 1:01:53And I hope that's not what happens with you on because I
- 1:01:55would like wish Marcel. I wish there were more people
- 1:01:56making that argument honestly and saying Ilan, you're trying
- 1:01:59to get us to Mars. Why are you fighting with?
- 1:02:01There are ones with her and not as many not as many as it should
- 1:02:03be like because things have gotten so tribalist and
- 1:02:06defensive in in the interactions there that I would feel like
- 1:02:09people that truly believe he is the greatest entrepreneurial
- 1:02:11timer. Said saying he is the only free
- 1:02:14speech warrior in the world. You know?
- 1:02:17They're saying that instead of like Elon, you should be
- 1:02:19focusing on Mars right now, what are you doing?
- 1:02:21I mean, I'm going to say say extremely sanctimonious, which
- 1:02:24I'm sure you're think most of what I've said is been
- 1:02:26sanctimonious. But I mean, journalists are
- 1:02:28super biased towards honesty, right?
- 1:02:30I mean, they what? Oh, come on.
- 1:02:32Yes. The problem with you, on his
- 1:02:35head, he's in inveterate liar. He lies all the time.
- 1:02:38Oh, yeah. And a journalist.
- 1:02:40It's just utter. God's Own truth, do they?
- 1:02:41That's The go, like, you know what you think or know if I'm
- 1:02:47not, if I don't know if I'm with you on that one.
- 1:02:49All right, I think that a lot of the hate is the spin around,
- 1:02:52journalists have the manipulator.
- 1:02:54So do many times over the gas of decades, but you like any any,
- 1:02:58any like objective observation on this character would have
- 1:03:01been, like boy. Elizabeth Holmes does not seem
- 1:03:03like she's an honest actor. Up until this point journalists
- 1:03:06are incredibly gullible. We are called.
- 1:03:08Call me. Your fucking weapon on Angeles.
- 1:03:12Isn't that a line with like believing and caring about
- 1:03:15honesty? Because you're taking someone at
- 1:03:18their work. That's quite the rhetorical her
- 1:03:20shoe, by the way. This reminds me where that NPR
- 1:03:22show left, right and Center, where they had like three
- 1:03:23different people. Yeah, it's like, we've got this
- 1:03:25weird. Cryptic going on, one thing you
- 1:03:27could do and I know it's unrealistic but you could get
- 1:03:29jobs in tech for starters, right?
- 1:03:32Like one thing I note that I think is the missing Bridge.
- 1:03:34It's like it's easy to opinionated about a terrific
- 1:03:37eight about tech and I hate Sports analogies in general but
- 1:03:40when you're sitting in the stands versus Standing on the
- 1:03:43field. Anything a lot of journalists
- 1:03:44won't name names, think that they're kind of players on the
- 1:03:47field and really, they're just loudest guy in the stands and I
- 1:03:50think if they were ever in the position that anybody who's
- 1:03:52worked at any level of authority and Tech like you're sitting at
- 1:03:55a little standing desk. Like this one, you've got some
- 1:03:57dashboard and you're tasked with making that number go up into
- 1:04:00the right. And that number is some like
- 1:04:02complex thing around user engagement, monetization
- 1:04:04content, moderation, whatever it is.
- 1:04:06It's some weird multi-factor thing in a very real business
- 1:04:09and Technical and political environment, and you have to
- 1:04:11Grapple with that reality. I think if a lot more
- 1:04:13journalists and just the commentary at because, you know,
- 1:04:15at this point, there's academics, there's sub stack,
- 1:04:17whatever it is. I think those people would
- 1:04:19benefit from being in that position and understanding the
- 1:04:23difficulty of what that means to build something to ship it, to
- 1:04:26monetize it to scale it and all the problems does imply.
- 1:04:29And I think, I wish we had more journalists, who would do that.
- 1:04:32I mean, to make a broad point on this.
- 1:04:34I think it's very insightful Point you're making, but it's a
- 1:04:38problem that has existed throughout culture, right?
- 1:04:41I mean to think, About Ratatouille, or I just saw the
- 1:04:44movie The Menu, right? The restaurant industry.
- 1:04:47Bristling at critics who really don't know how to cook aren't
- 1:04:51experts in. Their field is something that
- 1:04:53has existed throughout like art and culture where the creative
- 1:04:58class bristles at critics, but the public find the critic fight
- 1:05:03has at least in the past found the critics necessary as sort of
- 1:05:07a vehicle to differentiating or learning about.
- 1:05:10And so, attack, I think one thing, To say and I'll let you
- 1:05:13say it is the tech, maybe doesn't need the critics
- 1:05:16anymore. No, but to the I feel like just
- 1:05:21is so powerful that they're bristling at the critics is
- 1:05:24actually much more impactful to society in a way that a chef can
- 1:05:29sort of be angry about it. But then still still accepts
- 1:05:33this as part of life, see how my response was not gonna be the
- 1:05:35critics don't exist or that Texas Beyond criticism.
- 1:05:38I mean even if you recast monkeys, there's a bunch of
- 1:05:39criticisms of tech and Tech culture, kind of implicitly.
- 1:05:42Professional critics. Yeah.
- 1:05:44Well, yeah. And people have made this
- 1:05:46argument to be for online when I've when I've criticized media.
- 1:05:49I think the fault in your analogy is that the analog the
- 1:05:52journalistic analog of the restaurant critic, that
- 1:05:54restaurant critic is taking the users side, or the eater side.
- 1:05:57And yeah, the restaurant and they're having the same
- 1:05:59experience that the consumer would have in saying, you know,
- 1:06:01I have a distinguished palette, I've sampled 100 restaurants,
- 1:06:04here's my take on it because I'm an informed consumer, the analog
- 1:06:06to that is not Tech accountability journalism.
- 1:06:09It's what tech journalism used to be, which is mostly gadgetry.
- 1:06:13And kind of being, I'm a professional consumer of tech,
- 1:06:16like, what thing do I buy or what do I use?
- 1:06:18And that's a very different flavor of criticism.
- 1:06:20Well, I think a lot of the fights are over.
- 1:06:23I'm a professional consumer of content moderation.
- 1:06:26Especially since these user, the Twitter, the reporters are the
- 1:06:29ones getting harassed, and so they're like, oh, I've thought
- 1:06:32about this a lot. This is how this company handles
- 1:06:34it. This is how this one does, you
- 1:06:36know? I mean, those are a lot of the
- 1:06:37fights about content moderation right now, and they are sort of
- 1:06:41professional. Consumers of content moderation.
- 1:06:44Well, but I think including and especially in content,
- 1:06:46moderation, the experience of being behind a dashboard and
- 1:06:49that trying to do content moderation, that scale would, I
- 1:06:51think be very educational to those critics.
- 1:06:53And if there's one thing that you notice among them with the
- 1:06:56exception of Stamos, I think was a guest before, who has been
- 1:06:58kind of in that seat, almost nobody in that class of
- 1:07:00commentary, it has ever done it. And as a result, by the way,
- 1:07:03Stamos, I think is one of the most reasonable voices within
- 1:07:05that class. Yeah.
- 1:07:06But I mean the problem in life and you know I think there will
- 1:07:09be more cross-pollination. I mean, the top Tech Right now,
- 1:07:12who I adore this guy, gergely rice, pragmatic engineer, was
- 1:07:16it? Who brr?
- 1:07:16Yeah, he gets all these Scoops. The drive-in he's very - out.
- 1:07:19He lied to me. He's actually very culturally
- 1:07:21aligned, I think with the journalist class, but you know,
- 1:07:23he was in industry and he gets him.
- 1:07:25Lots of Scoops from developers and I think it's great.
- 1:07:28So I want to see more than the of that.
- 1:07:30I don't think it'll solve any of the problems that you think.
- 1:07:33And I think the reality is that specialization just like in Tech
- 1:07:37is very valuable in reporting. I was an anchor on my Elementary
- 1:07:41School news. Just like there is such
- 1:07:43disrespect for how hard it is. Like journalism jobs were dying.
- 1:07:48Like, you know, how many people from like the Crimson are like,
- 1:07:51oh my God, you actually went into journalism.
- 1:07:53I feel like the just crass like condescension towards
- 1:07:57journalism, when it is actually top journalism, jobs are
- 1:08:00extremely rare. And so I think the idea that
- 1:08:03it's just like, oh yeah, like go have a totally different career
- 1:08:06and then figure out journalism, just ignores, all the
- 1:08:10specialization that exists in Many industry, no.
- 1:08:13But if I could actually argue a little bit of Antonio's Point
- 1:08:16here, I do think maybe what you're describing is not
- 1:08:18necessarily having a different career but having like at least
- 1:08:21an ounce of empathy of the people that are writing about
- 1:08:24know what? Because, you know what, listen
- 1:08:25to me. I think one of the most
- 1:08:26formative things for me as a journalist was the fact that
- 1:08:28most of my time was spent at a journalism startup at the
- 1:08:31information which was not always a very functional company.
- 1:08:35Frankly. You know, I don't mind saying
- 1:08:36this on the podcast, it was really tough early on and I've,
- 1:08:40as I've read stories that have come out about Oops and just
- 1:08:42saying oh this is a total catastrophe.
- 1:08:44I've actually been like look, I've been at a company that was
- 1:08:46tough that had like a lot of problems early on.
- 1:08:49I've seen that you can get through it.
- 1:08:50I've seen that the feeling in the moment isn't the
- 1:08:53encapsulation of everything that the person who's leading it is
- 1:08:56and what the company stands for and journalists tend to forget
- 1:08:59that they you know they they get the - you get you get the
- 1:09:03critical sourcing from people at the company who frankly have an
- 1:09:07agenda, don't know what they're saying is wrong, doesn't mean
- 1:09:10that what they're saying isn't some element of the truth.
- 1:09:12But if you have an experience, at least, in some way, what it
- 1:09:15could be like inside the company, and that there could be
- 1:09:17multiple perspectives, not even just the CEO, but other
- 1:09:19employees there that feel slightly differently about it.
- 1:09:23You if you don't understand that, you're not going to be a
- 1:09:25very good reporter. And I think what we're what, I
- 1:09:28totally agree. I mean, part of the problem is
- 1:09:30it's like, yeah, I mean, it's terrifying.
- 1:09:32That is a twenty-year-old, you know, with like no experience in
- 1:09:36life. You're given a lot of power over
- 1:09:38powerful people as a journalist. So I accept that there's sort of
- 1:09:42But some of that is just the feel like if journalism was like
- 1:09:45a, very lucrative industry, maybe we would just write.
- 1:09:48Yeah. Recruit away like the former
- 1:09:51ctOS, you know, like some of it is like an economical on there
- 1:09:54is important but he, but here's the one thing I would push back
- 1:09:57on that. And what I think, maybe Founders
- 1:09:59can understand better from journalists is that I've
- 1:10:02discovered over time. I don't think at least founder
- 1:10:06CEOs people to high-level their companies.
- 1:10:08Really always know everything that's going on.
- 1:10:10I think they are often. Extremely Focused on the
- 1:10:13business that they're, you know, the money they're trying to make
- 1:10:15the up into the right looking at the looking at the dashboard,
- 1:10:17all the things that you need to run a successful company and
- 1:10:21they often have very little insight into anything outside of
- 1:10:24that. And so what comes off as like
- 1:10:26journalists attacking them can would be legitimate criticisms
- 1:10:30by employees at their company that because their company is so
- 1:10:33not functional in a lot of different ways, they have no
- 1:10:35outlet with which to express it and they take what I consider in
- 1:10:39Katie's talk about this in a previous episode The Fairly
- 1:10:41nuclear Option, which is talking to a person.
- 1:10:44They don't really know in order to make some sort of changes.
- 1:10:47Now, that's the most generous interpretation of someone
- 1:10:50leaking, but I do think it is the case.
- 1:10:52I do think it is the case more often than Founders are willing
- 1:10:54to recognize. And and I think it is a myopia
- 1:10:57on the part of Executives, not really knowing what's going on
- 1:11:01in their company and rather than assuming that there is something
- 1:11:04that they could change in address.
- 1:11:05They sort of push it off on the journalists and in many respects
- 1:11:09we are just a mouthpiece for people inside companies that are
- 1:11:12That are, you know, airing Grievances.
- 1:11:14And I think that's missed a little bit in a dialogue on the
- 1:11:16other side. Maybe you don't see that?
- 1:11:20I was, that was my most generous.
- 1:11:21Wait, no, I snitches get stitches.
- 1:11:25No, don't talk to the journalists who work at the
- 1:11:27company, but he's you. I do think the media criticism
- 1:11:32to just point out, like, doesn't acknowledge the reporters are
- 1:11:36talking to sources, right? I mean sources.
- 1:11:39Yeah. You don't believe it.
- 1:11:40Like, do you believe that? There's no, no, it's not alive,
- 1:11:43but it's, it's some guy who just got canned or just suffered
- 1:11:48Internally and they're going in blabbing to a mouthpiece and
- 1:11:50you're presenting it as if that's fact.
- 1:11:52And it just isn't it isn't the entire picture?
- 1:11:54And I look and I must post modernism next guy and I realize
- 1:11:56there's no capital-t truth in human literature here but you're
- 1:12:00no, we're just getting, you're just getting well, you're just
- 1:12:03getting a hyper skewed view of what's going on and and and and
- 1:12:08you know how you throw it like fact-checking has value to be
- 1:12:11clear again, I've written fact-checked pieces before it
- 1:12:14does have some value, but the way to cheat and journalism is
- 1:12:17not Like lie and make things up. That's like that's too easy to
- 1:12:20catch into dumb. It's the framing of the story is
- 1:12:23who you choose to quote who choose not to quote you know
- 1:12:25there's all these various tricks.
- 1:12:26You can play to give fact-check truth, a certain slant and that
- 1:12:31appears in the world as truth. And the average Layman has no
- 1:12:33way to cross check that. Because they're not Insider.
- 1:12:35It's right. I agree.
- 1:12:36On a percent with what you just said.
- 1:12:37Yeah, that said, I just think that cynically the anti-media
- 1:12:42crowd is intentionally making the media worse by depriving
- 1:12:45their own voices. To the media.
- 1:12:48And that's only pushing them closer to employee source and
- 1:12:52not budget of the reason that the public likes these stories
- 1:12:55is because there's clearly more appetite to understand counter
- 1:12:58narratives of what's going on, like you think so, actually, I
- 1:13:00disagree. I think the whole negative 2 in
- 1:13:02shorts Tech actually, sours people and they would, rather,
- 1:13:05they'd rather hear, I don't know, the occasional positive
- 1:13:08story about it, there's a reason Twitter.
- 1:13:10So - I mean, that's what travels like, if it bleeds it leads but
- 1:13:13you're supposed to elevate, the discourse here, mr.
- 1:13:15Journalist. I am trying but I can't I And I
- 1:13:18honestly can do. I feel like, yes, I that's where
- 1:13:21a subsection Advantage. But really, it's just like
- 1:13:24Having excess profits. I mean, that's why media was
- 1:13:27great in some ways before because they were so profitable
- 1:13:30that they could put values above profits.
- 1:13:33Yeah. Now go.
- 1:13:33Now, here's squeezed. Yeah.
- 1:13:35People forget newspapers, actually, you to make a lot of
- 1:13:36money. All right.
- 1:13:38Look at the Phantom's of newspapers up to like the 80s
- 1:13:40and 90s because of the news stories though it was because of
- 1:13:42course out. Yeah.
- 1:13:43It was like, you know, the bullshit story is in the back of
- 1:13:45the paper so I will let you go. But now this one let me connect
- 1:13:48to make one confessional. Can we go into confession
- 1:13:50ammonia for a second? Something not that many of you
- 1:13:53probably know about me. You know what?
- 1:13:54My first job was in high school in high school, like my first
- 1:13:56W2, like, actual paycheck. I got.
- 1:13:59Did you throw on newspapers or something?
- 1:14:00Right, you have someone you for that.
- 1:14:03I worked. I worked on a city desk, a
- 1:14:04newspaper. I was, I was my first actual
- 1:14:07paint job was a journalist. I was at the sun-sentinel, as a
- 1:14:09news, intern on the city desk and I'd go around and Report
- 1:14:13stories on the ground back. When you had police reporters,
- 1:14:15listen to the police scanner and they'd hear about the shooting
- 1:14:17go race. Off back before the internet and
- 1:14:19then the job after that was Miami, Herald actually
- 1:14:21throughout the senior year of high school and then I
- 1:14:24originally picked my college based on journalism programs and
- 1:14:26the whole plan was coming at journalisted.
- 1:14:28There's a whole sequence of events how we ended up in the
- 1:14:29stem side instead. But that was my first, actual
- 1:14:32paying job there. Now you know, my secret are and
- 1:14:34now you're full of resentment against.
- 1:14:36That's right. I was yeah.
- 1:14:38What's your what's your like grows?
- 1:14:40But I know that no one was actually.
- 1:14:43So I was like what's your? What's your moment that that
- 1:14:45turned you against journalism? Like was there like a Crusty
- 1:14:47reporter like in the Miami Herald.
- 1:14:49He was just no, you're never going to make it kid.
- 1:14:51Oh no. That experience actually
- 1:14:53surprised. I think one thing I think Tech
- 1:14:56doesn't realize like back in the Golden Age of Journalism, like a
- 1:14:59newsroom. I'm sure you've had this
- 1:15:00experience. Probably worked out of
- 1:15:01Bloomberg. My worked if the sun, sun, all
- 1:15:03one point. How did you really?
- 1:15:04Yeah injured. Yeah.
- 1:15:05And like The Newsroom used to be an exciting place to be right,
- 1:15:09because again, there was no internet, right?
- 1:15:10Like shit happen, right? And the people who knew about it
- 1:15:13were sitting right there next to write.
- 1:15:14Some guy would literally run out to report on a thing and and
- 1:15:17there was this feeling of you were in the center, it almost
- 1:15:20like a trading floor. It.
- 1:15:21We felt like this Buzzy Center of action and you were part of
- 1:15:24recording, the realities of life and it was kind of very
- 1:15:26exciting. And that's, that's kind of not
- 1:15:29journalism anymore. Well, I guess in New York Times
- 1:15:31is probably that way if you're actually sitting inside a
- 1:15:32newsroom but but things have changed a lot.
- 1:15:34Now it's now it's tweets and subjects.
- 1:15:37Yeah. I feel like in the world There's
- 1:15:40a lot we don't know. Like do you feel like there's a
- 1:15:42lot that needs to be uncovered or you think fundamentally.
- 1:15:46We're uncovering. Most of it.
- 1:15:47Who's we? The journey is just the world.
- 1:15:49Like, do you think the world is sufficiently surfacing?
- 1:15:52Secret facts? No, fortunately, this desirable
- 1:15:55and that's why I broke ass monkeys because I felt Tech was
- 1:15:57so interesting. It was being so badly.
- 1:15:58Reported someone needed to write the book but like a hundred
- 1:16:01years from now. If you were going to ask like
- 1:16:02what happened when humans like ported their brains online like
- 1:16:05what was it like and I felt in a you know and obviously the
- 1:16:08completely narcissistic way that writers are Great.
- 1:16:10But okay. I'm going to go right at least
- 1:16:11one of your only a narcissist on Twitter.
- 1:16:14Yeah. I feel like you're not being
- 1:16:15very consistent. Well the the artist temperament
- 1:16:19is a difficult. One artists are terrible people
- 1:16:21by artist. Probably know my narcissism
- 1:16:23contains multitudes. Well thank you so much for
- 1:16:27coming. I feel like that's a great place
- 1:16:29to end it as long as unless there's a last word you really I
- 1:16:32feel like I pushed you a little so if you you're free to say
- 1:16:36anything you want. No no.
- 1:16:37Thank you Eric. Thank you.
- 1:16:38Tom thanks. Thanks.
- 1:16:39Antonio, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 1:16:55goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.