Latest / Serves You Right / #94 Wink Lorch: Little Known Grapes and Regions in France You Need to Know About
Transcript
- 0:01Thank you for listening to Serves You Right.
- 0:02My name is Andrew, and if this is your first time tuning in,
- 0:06I've worked in the hospitality industry for the last 20 years.
- 0:09I've done everything from bar back, bartender, all the way up
- 0:11to general manager. And part of my journey has been
- 0:15going through the Quartermaster Psalm certification process.
- 0:18So I try to find people who've done interesting things in the
- 0:21beverage world, wine, spirits, and today I'm talking to Wink
- 0:25Lorch. So Wink has a speciality that
- 0:28you don't see all over the place.
- 0:30She is big in the wines of the French Alps, the savoir, the
- 0:34Jura, some of the smaller satellite regions that pretty
- 0:38much only super interested sommeliers are into.
- 0:41But these are some wines with great authenticity.
- 0:44There are some interesting regions, cool history.
- 0:47They've got everything from obscure grapes to insane
- 0:52landsides. So you get to talk about South.
- 0:54Super fun region and Wink has a tour of the region coming up, so
- 0:59it's a very timely moment to get to talk to her.
- 1:02But without any further ado, here's Wink, and thank you for
- 1:05listening to Serves You Right. And hopefully you're not going
- 1:11to ask me how I got my name and all that rubbish.
- 1:13No, feel free to tell us, but we don't have to go into that.
- 1:16No, Yeah. Stick to the let's stick to the
- 1:19wine stuff. Awesome.
- 1:21Thanks for joining us on Serves You Right.
- 1:23Well, thank you, Andrew. It's great.
- 1:25I'm excited for this. Now for the listener at home,
- 1:27where in the world are you joining us from again?
- 1:29I'm in a village in the French Alps above Anasi, specifically
- 1:34in Saint John the 6th above Anasi and Otesavoir.
- 1:39Thanks, now that's that's awesome.
- 1:40Your French pronunciation rocks. It's going to beat the socks off
- 1:44of mine so I was really excited to talk to you today.
- 1:47Wine is a passion of mine, but I thought it'd be helpful for the
- 1:51listeners at home that may not know you to kind of give a very
- 1:55brief overview of who you are, what you do, and why.
- 1:58I'm so excited to talk to you today.
- 2:00Very brief is very hard because I've been working medium brief.
- 2:05Yeah, all right. Medium brief.
- 2:07I've been living wine, working with wine for decades.
- 2:10I'm old and I started very young and I started in the wine trade
- 2:14in the UK and worked for importers and for a short while
- 2:18had my own business selling wine and, and through that started
- 2:23speaking and educating about wine.
- 2:25While all the time I was personally learning about it
- 2:28through the Wine Spirit Education Trust set as it's also
- 2:31known and this is many decades ago.
- 2:34And through that I realised that actually I enjoyed communicating
- 2:39in wine more than I enjoyed selling wine, which you might be
- 2:43able to relate to. And so I continued on, did lots
- 2:50of different things, teaching a little bit of writing, and then
- 2:54fell into the world of publishing wine books as a sort
- 2:58of assistant, researching books, researching maps, photos,
- 3:04information, generally providing backups for authors and
- 3:08publishers. Did a lot of work with Oz, Clark
- 3:10and a few other well known British authors.
- 3:14And in the meantime, cutting to the chase of why Jura and
- 3:19Savoir. I have always adored mountains
- 3:22and I've always adored skiing. I was skiing this morning a few
- 3:26hours ago. It's definitely my last ski of
- 3:29the season. My knee was complaining hugely.
- 3:32So I have to stop. And it's real springtime here.
- 3:36Skiers will understand. It always intrigued me driving
- 3:39up to ski resorts that. Occasionally you'd see vineyards
- 3:43pretty high up in Switzerland, in France and those two
- 3:47countries in particular, which were the ones I went to the most
- 3:50to ski. And because I worked in wine, I
- 3:52always recognised vineyards. And so whenever I could, I tried
- 3:57wines from the mountains and local wines, and they were often
- 4:00made from rather obscure local grapes and I would always read
- 4:05up what background I could. So then I was very lucky to be
- 4:10able to get a, a property in the French Alps, not where I am now,
- 4:15but very close, the same area in the early 90s.
- 4:19And so the first thing I did was check out, well, certainly in
- 4:24summer was to check out some of the Savoy producers and the
- 4:27local producers and understand the wines better and so on.
- 4:32And Zura, which is the region that I'm sort of often
- 4:36associated with, didn't really get a look in except that the
- 4:41drive from England from London, which was technically and still
- 4:44is my main home, would go on a freeway that goes sort of past
- 4:50the juror. And they in those days actually
- 4:53had service stations that with shops that would sell juror
- 4:59wines. And I now know that they were
- 5:01from what today you would consider to be pretty good wine
- 5:04producers, but you you have a hard time getting these wines.
- 5:10And then they were just available in the in the shop the
- 5:14paying for the fuel. So I would pick up a few.
- 5:17And again, I tried reading about it, but I never got round to
- 5:20going there because it was about 3 hours away from where I was
- 5:24living in the Alps. So, and all that changed around
- 5:27the turn of this century when I was asked to write about about
- 5:32Jura savoir and Bourget. And when I say right, I mean a
- 5:38tiny, tiny chapter in a huge encyclopaedia about wines of the
- 5:44world. And The thing is, I didn't know
- 5:46anything about Jura, but nobody else did either.
- 5:49So it seemed to be up to me to find out.
- 5:52So that's sort of how it began, and it's sort of gone on from
- 5:58there. So that was more than 25 years
- 6:01ago when I started exploring Jura, having already explored
- 6:06Savoir and a little bit Boucher, which is next door to Savoir
- 6:10too. No, So that's, that's cool.
- 6:12That's good to know. So where you are now, it's about
- 6:15a three hour drive to the Jura. Yeah.
- 6:18OK. Just done that.
- 6:19Because, you know, unfortunately I've never flown out to France,
- 6:23so my my knowledge of the regions are from maps and books.
- 6:27Books like yours, but still maps and books.
- 6:30So it's it's hard to remember that even though on the map it
- 6:33may look like it's right next to each other, there's still pretty
- 6:36considerable distances involved. Well, there's distances, but
- 6:40there's also mountains in between and mountains, you know,
- 6:44add to the time because either you've got to go up and over a a
- 6:48mountain pass or on slow roads, or if you're using freeways,
- 6:52you've got to go around. So even if as the crow flies,
- 6:57the distance might seem reasonable, actually it's it's
- 7:02much further than you think. And the other thing is that if
- 7:05we talk about Zura, it's much closer to Burgundy than any
- 7:08other wine region. And if you talk about Savoir,
- 7:11it's much closer to the northern Rhone region than it is to any
- 7:16other region. And actually they have much more
- 7:19in common, sure, with Burgundy and Savoir with the Northern
- 7:23Rome than with each other. And yet they're put, they have
- 7:27historically been put together in books for what I term
- 7:31editorial convenience. And it's very simple.
- 7:34You can do a map. And so I'll, I'll draw, I'll try
- 7:38and draw you the map in words. You have Geneva in Switzerland.
- 7:43So if you can place that, most people who've travelled in
- 7:46Europe can have a go at, at, at placing Geneva, which is, is
- 7:50right at the West southwestern corner of Switzerland and on the
- 7:54border of France. So you have Geneva and you have
- 7:57it's it's iconic lake. And then to the northwest of
- 8:01there is Shura and to the South of there is Savoir.
- 8:06In the case of Savoir, there are pockets, many different pockets
- 8:10of Vineyard regions. In the case of Shura, it's very
- 8:14much one sort of strip of of Appalachian area, which is
- 8:20almost uncannily parallel with the Coke Dog and Coke Chaloners
- 8:26of Burgundy, but to the east. So I hope that sort of little
- 8:30geography lesson puts them in place.
- 8:32And so the editorial convenience was that A, you could do a
- 8:36little map and you could put them both on very easily.
- 8:39B, in more than 25 years ago, really nobody cared about these
- 8:43regions. They were not except for the
- 8:45people in those regions. They were almost not exporting
- 8:50and they were dismissed because both were and still are very
- 8:54tiny in the scheme of things. And they even Paris didn't stop
- 8:58the wine. No one in Paris stopped the
- 9:01wines. And they were just dismissed as
- 9:03mountain wines and high altitude wines and wines with obscure
- 9:08grape varieties, all of which is only partially correct.
- 9:12And so it was very, very easy for them just to be lumped
- 9:16together and mixed up, which they have been over many, many
- 9:19years. And I've attempted along with
- 9:22other people to separate them now and really really talk about
- 9:26the two separately. No.
- 9:27And I, I mean, it does make sense if I am writing a
- 9:30masterful book online myself. You know, there are these two
- 9:34regions that most people don't know a lot about next to each
- 9:36other. And so it's like, OK, let's just
- 9:38group them together. It'll be this one little short
- 9:41chapter. We'll move on.
- 9:42Yeah. If you can't even get them in
- 9:44the the capital city of the country they're from.
- 9:47And, you know, I often think about it from an American first
- 9:51context. And it's just like, if you can't
- 9:53get it there, how are we going to get it here sort of thing,
- 9:55you know? Well, the interesting thing
- 9:58about Jura and to an extent Savoir, is that the wine stores,
- 10:04the trendy wine stores of New York and San Francisco, had a
- 10:08far bigger range of Jura wine before the trendy wine stores
- 10:14and bars of Paris did. Paris came later with Jura and
- 10:19with Savoir, the same pattern as followed, but to a less extreme
- 10:25level. All right.
- 10:28Sorry to interrupt. We will get right back to Wink
- 10:30and Andrew, but I wanted to take a second.
- 10:33If you have not had a chance to follow the show, please hit that
- 10:37follow button. It lead the world to me.
- 10:38And it really does help us grow, reach more people.
- 10:41All right, back to it. Well, I'm wondering too, like,
- 10:45you know, countercultural American wine store, like, OK,
- 10:49we're going to look to other places that are doing cool, fun,
- 10:51funky stuff. So it's not cab Shard.
- 10:54I wonder if there's like a a similar movement in France or
- 10:56just some like out of the way wine stores are like let's find
- 10:59the natural small producers in America and get them over here.
- 11:03Like there seems to be like denigration of what you do at
- 11:06home. Looking for something new out
- 11:08there. Maybe I'm reading too much into
- 11:09it too. Well, in the US, initially the
- 11:13interest was driven by some excellent importers who who
- 11:17literally sought about unusual wines from small producers that
- 11:23were usually family producers and they may or may not have
- 11:27been organic. But gradually the organic
- 11:30movement was growing and the natural wine movement was
- 11:32growing and all of these things of small, authentic, organic,
- 11:37natural sort of dovetailed and overlapped a bit.
- 11:41In Paris it's very different because in France restaurants
- 11:45would have the good ones, the wine orientated ones.
- 11:48May may buy direct. Individuals often that are wine
- 11:53lovers buy direct. They do it on their summer
- 11:55vacation, they go travelling through wine regions and so on.
- 11:58So it it took a sort of certain buzz to build up and then
- 12:04suddenly everyone gravitated to these regions and that's all
- 12:09happening now. So the producers are pretty
- 12:12happy because Paris has discovered them and this means
- 12:15they can sort of sell local. But it was slow to happen.
- 12:20Yeah, that's interesting. Yeah.
- 12:22And it's good for you too, if you're the champion of the
- 12:24regions, so. My folks aren't in French.
- 12:29Well, there you go that that may be a barrier, but so we talked a
- 12:33little bit before this, we'll feel like the Jura has been
- 12:36covered at like forever and ever.
- 12:39So let's let's focus on the French Alps here.
- 12:41So if I'm a listener at home and I want to know kind of that
- 12:468020, what are some of the big things that I should keep in
- 12:49mind when I start exploring this region?
- 12:52Well, first of all, it's to understand the term French Alps,
- 12:56which is an unofficial term, a little bit like you might talk
- 13:00about Mediterranean wines, you know, What does that mean?
- 13:03And so it's a term that I guess I, I mean, I didn't invent it,
- 13:08but I, it has evolved. And so the main region we're
- 13:13talking about here is savoir. And some people do actually
- 13:16write it and say it Savoy. I tend to avoid this.
- 13:21It's the old British term for it.
- 13:24It's the old historical term from hundreds of years ago.
- 13:28So I used the French term savoir.
- 13:30And so it really the term wines of the French Alps came about
- 13:35when I was writing my second book.
- 13:37Forgive the plug, but this is how it evolved.
- 13:40And that is that I already had a book called Jura Wine.
- 13:43So the obvious thing was to follow it up with Savoir wine,
- 13:47but that just wasn't going to work because there were these
- 13:50other little regions. So right next to Savoir is
- 13:54Bourget. And Bourget is about 1/4 of the
- 13:57size of Savoir. And in the southern part shares
- 14:01many of the same grape varieties as Savoir.
- 14:04And in the northern part actually has got a little bit of
- 14:08a resonance with Jura and a little bit of resonance with
- 14:11Beaujolais, which is actually not as far away as you might
- 14:15think. And so I had these two regions
- 14:18sitting there and then Oh my goodness, there's a third one
- 14:20and a fourth one and a fifth one.
- 14:23And they're all sort of little regions that are driven by the
- 14:27climate and tawa similarities. All these these regions share
- 14:33the fact that they are on what geologically the vineyards are
- 14:38on what geologically is termed the Pre Alps.
- 14:41So the Pre Alps are a lower mountain range than the Alps
- 14:45themselves and an older mountain range and therefore there's a
- 14:49limestone bedrock. On the other hand, the high UPS
- 14:53drive the weather and and so you can get some pretty fierce
- 14:58weather because the mountains, the big mountains are attracting
- 15:02that. And so the altitude none of in
- 15:06the main regions that we're talking about Savoir and
- 15:08Bourget, the altitude is not nearly as high as many people
- 15:12imagine. Even the French publicists that
- 15:16work with these regions tend to exaggerate this to the point of
- 15:21it not being a fact. So most of the vineyards are
- 15:25around three 5400 meters. So I know that you guys think in
- 15:31feet so times that by three and a bit so well.
- 15:35We think in feet and we're not good at math, so it's about
- 15:3812-12 hundred feet. 1200 feet. And also the thing to to bear in
- 15:43mind is the latitude, because altitude and latitude, latitude
- 15:46need to be taken in tandem. And so the latitude is, is what
- 15:51in Europe is often thought of for wine as a golden latitude.
- 15:56It's about 45° N of the equator. And that is the same as northern
- 16:03Rome. It's the same as Bordeaux.
- 16:05And you can go further east and name all sorts of other places.
- 16:09And so whereas if you were to compare that with the vineyards
- 16:14of California, they tend to be at around 35° N of the equator.
- 16:20And so therefore the concept of altitude is quite different
- 16:24there. So what is more important than
- 16:27altitude in my view for Savoir and Bourget are the steep
- 16:32slopes, very steep slopes and also the influence of those high
- 16:37altitude mountains that drives that difficult weather and and
- 16:42so on. So, so those are some of the the
- 16:46tell wow characteristics that these regions share.
- 16:49But historically they share something that I think is quite
- 16:52important, which is why we have ended up with so many obscure
- 16:57grape varieties. And that is the the Alps were
- 17:00always a crossroads in in Western Europe.
- 17:04This was, and they were a very difficult crossroads because you
- 17:08can imagine that before we had trains and before we had
- 17:11motorised vehicles, crossing the Alps was an extremely difficult
- 17:15thing to do. But people did it, you know,
- 17:18people did it. And when they did it they would
- 17:20travel for much longer than we do now.
- 17:23So they would bring all sorts of things with them because they
- 17:26didn't know how long they were going to stay or were they
- 17:28actually going to settle the other side or what were they
- 17:30going to do. So the grapevines actually
- 17:33crossed from what we now think of as Italy, but in those days
- 17:38wasn't necessarily Italy because it was various provinces crossed
- 17:41over the Alps. And likewise between Switzerland
- 17:44and France, Italy and France, there's all sorts of crossovers
- 17:49and that it's almost like the borders are less relevant than
- 17:54than the actual region of the Alps.
- 17:57Yeah, yeah. You know what I'm thinking more
- 18:00and more as I'm hearing you speak to, it seems like these
- 18:02groupings are like, you know, some groupings seem to naturally
- 18:06make sense. Burgundy coat door makes sense.
- 18:09It's pretty much Peter do our Chardonnay.
- 18:11It was pretty much created by man.
- 18:12Whereas these you really do get to see that some of the borders
- 18:16that we impose are kind of arbitrary because you know, even
- 18:20as you're talking about these regions, you're like, oh, and
- 18:22now it has a little bit more in common with the Shura, a little
- 18:25bit with the savoir, but actually a little Beaujolais
- 18:27too. You know, like you see it kind
- 18:29of blending as I was hoping because you know, I didn't think
- 18:34about this until you're describing it as a crossroads.
- 18:37A lot of the grapes, a lot of the local small indigenous
- 18:39grapes there. I, I'm really struck in your
- 18:42book how much detail you go into about how like they're even
- 18:45these like people think that it comes from here, but recent DNA
- 18:49analysis has disproved this. So like it also seems to give it
- 18:54a lot of different stories and background and possible origins,
- 18:58just how much of A crossroads it is and like built into the lore
- 19:02of the region a lot. Yeah, the there, there is an
- 19:06organization that I've known since it it started that is
- 19:11called the Santre en Pala. I can't even say it myself.
- 19:15Santre en en Bello graphic Alpine.
- 19:20And then there's a dash. Pierre Galle.
- 19:23Now Pierre Galle was, was arguably the most famous
- 19:27amphilographer or grape scientist of the 20th.
- 19:31And although he was based at the university in the longer dock
- 19:34in, in Montpellier, he travelled the world analysing great
- 19:40varieties and so on, and writing books and advising and this and
- 19:45that. And this was all before DNA
- 19:47testing existed. And so he was actually
- 19:51identifying great varieties through their physiological
- 19:55features and, you know, looking at the plant, looking at how it
- 19:59grew, where it grew. And how what shape the leaves
- 20:03were, how the berries set and so on.
- 20:05And this was how it was always done.
- 20:08And also they would take into account history as well,
- 20:12historical movements of people and, and royalty in the case of
- 20:16Europe and this and that. And then they would say, OK,
- 20:19this great variety is that, and it's identical to that over
- 20:23there. So the obvious one here if I can
- 20:26give an example of this. Oh, please.
- 20:28Yeah. I'm going to go off the point.
- 20:30Pierre Gallet, who I was very, very privilege to to meet, he
- 20:34died about 8 years ago or something.
- 20:36He died just before his 100th birthday.
- 20:38But he was still coming to meetings of this organization
- 20:43that was named after him right up until he was about 98.
- 20:47And he would come and say a few words and he would answer
- 20:50questions and this and that. So he was an extraordinary man.
- 20:54And there's a great variety that I'm hoping you've heard of
- 20:58called Altes. And Altes makes the wines Ruset
- 21:02de Savoir or Ruset de Bourget. And Altes was, and you will
- 21:08still find this on producer websites and regional websites.
- 21:12It was told to me that it came from Cyprus.
- 21:16And I right from the beginning thought this was pretty strange
- 21:20because you sort of think of Cyprus, this island in the
- 21:23Mediterranean. I don't think we'll talk about
- 21:26its role right now, but it's an island in the Mediterranean that
- 21:31you sort of think of has got to have a very hot Mediterranean
- 21:34climate. So how come there's a great
- 21:35there that was that's identical to one that that seems to have a
- 21:41long growing season and do well in the French Alps?
- 21:44And it didn't make sense. And even in the time of Pierre
- 21:48Gallet, it didn't make sense to him.
- 21:50So he started looking at this and investigating.
- 21:55And to cut a Long story short, he decided that it was not from
- 22:00Cyprus at all, it was from Hungary, which made more sense
- 22:03because it was continental climate, inland cold, and he
- 22:08actually thought it was the same as ferment, which is the Tokai
- 22:12grape variety. And then a few decades later, he
- 22:16was proved wrong. And I spoke to him about this
- 22:19and and he didn't mind being wrong about things.
- 22:21He was right in so many of his identifications that he
- 22:28appreciated the evolution of science and the fact that DNA
- 22:31testing had come along. And then he would just go, OK,
- 22:35I'm wrong. And so the DNA testing proved
- 22:38that our test was not ferment after all, and definitely didn't
- 22:42come from Cyprus, and that almost certainly it was
- 22:46distantly related to Shasla. And they already knew that
- 22:50Shasla was an Alpine variety. And so this matched some of the
- 22:55stories of it being planted in the 15th century in this part of
- 22:59Sagwar and that part of Sagwar and so on.
- 23:02And so it is deemed to be an indigenous grape variety.
- 23:06But it took a long time to get there.
- 23:08And these are the sort of stories that are bound.
- 23:11And I get a bit annoyed when people, even wine producers and
- 23:16even wine PR people give facts that are actually not.
- 23:22Yeah. So when they say it comes from
- 23:24Cyprus even now, yeah. You're wrong.
- 23:28Yes, yes. That can't be right.
- 23:30And, you know, kudos. You know, he may not have been
- 23:34completely correct, but directionally correct is its own
- 23:36thing. You know, it's like, OK,
- 23:38probably not Cyprus. That doesn't make sense for
- 23:40anyone who's listening, who's thinking, why can't they just
- 23:43identify these grapes? So why can't they figure it out?
- 23:46If you've ever spent any time in a vineyard and you've looked at
- 23:49different types of grapes, I know that I definitely, I can't
- 23:53tell my Merlot for my Pinot noir for my like, you can tell that
- 23:57there are alterations. But when you start thinking
- 23:59about the fact that, yeah, the savoir you go through, I think
- 24:02it's like 25 different grapes. And then you go through also the
- 24:07like obscure ones. It's like the fact that there
- 24:10are like, hundreds of these little grapes that, you know,
- 24:13but if the only thing you have to go off is the shape of the
- 24:15leaves and how they ripen and the bunch size and Berry size,
- 24:18like, I don't know how they did it before genetic testing.
- 24:22Like, it baffles my mind. Yeah, Well.
- 24:25I think, I think it's worth realising that they didn't
- 24:28actually care. So we cared deeply about grape
- 24:31varieties and about varietal labeling and identification of
- 24:36wines using grape varieties. But I've been around so long
- 24:41that I actually remember my early visits to two classic
- 24:45regions in France, and specifically one visit to
- 24:49Bordeaux, where when I was studying wine at quite a high
- 24:53level. And so I was asking loads and
- 24:55loads of questions and I was visiting a particularly
- 25:00obstreperous difficult wine producer and there were a lot of
- 25:03them. About those days, yes, Yeah.
- 25:05Absolutely, and there was far was on these far from my
- 25:10favorite resort region and that's been quite polite.
- 25:13And so, you know, I'm standing in the vineyard and I say so So
- 25:17what blend do you do use for your your main wine?
- 25:21And he looked at me and he said, why does it matter?
- 25:25And he he reached down and he got this this handful of earth
- 25:31and just said this is what matters.
- 25:33And he just wouldn't answer me. You know, I was waiting for this
- 25:36answer that said 60% cabinet Sauvignon, 30% Merlot and 10%
- 25:41cabinet France, something like that.
- 25:43And I just wasn't being given that answer.
- 25:46And the Appalachians, even though they dictate what great
- 25:49variety you grow, where they, they play, with the honourable
- 25:54exception of Alsace, they they claim they put much more
- 25:58emphasis on soil and tevoir and so on.
- 26:01And they do great variety. So little savoir comes along
- 26:05that got its Appalachian very late in the day and had a
- 26:10history of growing very obscure great varieties.
- 26:14It was like, whoa, how do we do this?
- 26:17And what is actually we've ended up with is that there are some
- 26:22wonderful, great varieties that today have been rehabilitated
- 26:27because they're perfect for our changing climate.
- 26:31And there's a history of them growing in this region.
- 26:33But they were never put on the list for the Appalachian control
- 26:37A. So the wines have to be made as
- 26:40Van de France because they're not permitted as Appalachian
- 26:43control A yet. That may change, but things
- 26:46always change. Take 10/15/20 years to change a
- 26:52little great variety and put it into Appalachian properly.
- 26:56It's one of the weird enduring legacies that I feel like the
- 26:59old world got from the new World.
- 27:01I was talking to Alice firing the other day.
- 27:03She's she was on the show about a week ago coming out and she
- 27:06has a quote, I forget what book it is that she's talking to the
- 27:10editor of Wine and Spirits, I believe.
- 27:13But he says, you know, the wine industry has been held hostage
- 27:16by variety for the last 20 years and you know it.
- 27:20It's one of those things where if you have no history to fall
- 27:25back on, which the new world does it, by definition, we're
- 27:27all new. It's not a bad entry point.
- 27:30Either we steal the place names of the people were imitating, or
- 27:34we just start describing it by the varietal name and it it took
- 27:38off and people resonated with it.
- 27:40And, you know, in America, the way that you change your bottle
- 27:44of Venier to Chardonnay is you plant Chardonnay and as long as
- 27:48you're not lying, you're pretty much good to go.
- 27:50In France, Appalachian Control A is a giant behemoth.
- 27:55It's a legal document. And there are a lot of hoops
- 27:58that I think European producers have to jump through that we
- 28:02just don't think twice about in the New World.
- 28:03But it's a it's a total whole thing.
- 28:07Yeah. You know, I've, I've again been
- 28:09around long enough to to remember when in the UK we had
- 28:13more Australian than we did California wines to begin with.
- 28:16And Australian wines started coming in all simply variety
- 28:21labeled. And as a, as a teacher of wine,
- 28:24I could see right away, you know, consumers breathing this
- 28:28huge sigh of relief. And it just, I could totally
- 28:32understand why this came about. And The thing is that why Alice
- 28:37and I and many, many other people in the world of wine are
- 28:42fascinated by all these obscure grape varieties is no different
- 28:47from the people that go to farmers market and buy the
- 28:51ugliest looking. I'll have to say it the English
- 28:54way, Tomato and the Uglish, the ugliest looking one, because
- 28:58they want an heirloom variety or buy black carrots or whatever.
- 29:03I mean, this is simplifying things, but all of them give
- 29:07different flavours and they also rescue heritage and they rescue
- 29:11things from the past and we can learn from them.
- 29:14And I know I've already mentioned it, but I'll mention
- 29:17it again because it's so important.
- 29:19The rescue of these, if you like, heirloom grape varieties
- 29:23is so vital for dealing with a changing climate.
- 29:26On the other hand, because I like looking at both sides.
- 29:30And I hope that that's what I do in my wine education and and in
- 29:33my books. In Bourget, for example, when
- 29:36they nearly like all these regions, they nearly died a
- 29:40death a few decades ago from lack of interest, from literally
- 29:45people growing grapes, just not being able to get enough revenue
- 29:49for them and so on. And they had an advisor in the
- 29:54technical advisors Regents. Had he would have been a sort of
- 29:57civil servant of sorts. And he was charged with getting
- 30:02the vineyard region back on its feet again.
- 30:04This would have been in the 60s and 70s, nineteen 60s and 1970s.
- 30:10And he advised them do not grow, do not plant Altes, do not plant
- 30:16Mondeau's, plant Chardonnay, Gamete and if you like some
- 30:21Pinot noir because, and it was mainly Chardonnay and Gamete
- 30:26because he knew that they were more likely to get a decent
- 30:30yield and to be able to make a living from that.
- 30:33Now when I learnt that time, I met him and he was a very old
- 30:37man at the time and I couldn't be cross with him.
- 30:40He was he was sharing all this history and of course it was
- 30:44commercial. It was this made the region
- 30:47viable. And it's only now that Bourget
- 30:51is viable that the growers can say, hey, let's plant some more
- 30:56mondeurs, let's plant some more L tests.
- 30:59Let's look what other traditional region grape
- 31:02varieties they used to have in Bourget, because now we have
- 31:05some interesting American importers that actually might be
- 31:09fascinated with these these varieties.
- 31:12And so it's all about the right time to do things, I think.
- 31:17Yeah, because, I mean, I like playing the devil's advocate
- 31:20here because I am a champion of, you know, the small, the local,
- 31:25the countercultural. But there is a world where if
- 31:28they didn't do this, no one would still be there producing
- 31:31because you can't take a loss forever and survive.
- 31:34Like, I'm thinking like, imagine he's just some, like, really,
- 31:37really struggling chef opening up a restaurant.
- 31:40He has really, really intense food that like, it's not taking
- 31:44off and he's trying to get his restaurant to work.
- 31:46And someone comes along and says, maybe if you put a burger
- 31:49in the bar, you know, this is like, it's like, OK, like, no
- 31:53chef ever wants to put a burger in the bar.
- 31:55But everyone does because they need that money to support the
- 31:58more like esoteric things they're doing in the kitchen
- 32:01that it's like you've got to have a little bit of the game if
- 32:05you're going to stay in the game.
- 32:06It totally happened in the mountain restaurants in the ski
- 32:09areas that I ski in. So 2530 years ago you would have
- 32:14found a combination of mountain dishes.
- 32:18They're sort of typical fondue and tarty fleet, which made made
- 32:23with rib lechon, which is the local cheese where I I am based
- 32:26and and then you would have found steak and chips, sure, but
- 32:30hey, now they're making fancy burgers.
- 32:35It's every single mountain restaurant has a fancy burger on
- 32:39offer. And yeah, it's, it's completely
- 32:42changed, but. The the scourge, the scourge of
- 32:45the new World, hamburgers and varietal labeling.
- 32:47You know, I, I don't want to go too far.
- 32:49I have two other questions and I want to talk about what you're
- 32:52doing soon. I was hoping you could tell us
- 32:56about the landslide because this was one of the points of history
- 33:00that I did not know. And it was one of the more like
- 33:04surprising things, like, do you mind talking about that
- 33:06landslide that the region went through and kind of what
- 33:09happened there? Well, I mentioned earlier that
- 33:12the pre Alps are limestone based and if you know anything about
- 33:17limestone, it's pretty soft and friable, especially after a lot
- 33:22of rain. And I can only tell the story as
- 33:27it's been told to me and as it's written and so on.
- 33:31That is the in the, there was a period that I think actually
- 33:35took went over a few 100 years where there was huge amounts of
- 33:40rainfall, regular rainfall. And in the specific mountain
- 33:45that you're thinking of, which is Montgranier, which is the
- 33:50quintessential mountain that appears on the cover of my
- 33:54French Alps book. Actually, I mean, I have it
- 33:57here, so I know this is not all on video, but you, you can see
- 34:02that there is this vertical top to it.
- 34:06And that is because a whole chunk would have broken off.
- 34:10And in fact, there's still regularly small landslides from
- 34:14this. It actually happened in in, I've
- 34:17forgotten the date, but I know the month 12:48.
- 34:22And in November 1248, apparently there'd been a period of very,
- 34:27very, very heavy rainfall this mountain.
- 34:30And geologists can today can recreate this.
- 34:34They can use modelling to recreate this.
- 34:36So they believe that this mountain, as many had sort of
- 34:41caverns and holes in it and they were all filling up with water
- 34:47and therefore destabilizing the whole mountain and and justice.
- 34:51Just so you know, the mountain is called Mongranier, but it's
- 34:55actually the northernmost mountain of a pre Alpine range
- 35:00called the Chartres. And yes, at the southern end of
- 35:04the Chartres is the Abbey where the famous Chartres liquor was
- 35:10developed and and is still made to this day, not in the Abbey
- 35:14but nearby in a factory and with beautiful Cellars.
- 35:18So this mountain was effectively becoming more and more unstable,
- 35:23but nobody would have known this.
- 35:24And at the time there were a lot of there were more people living
- 35:30directly below this mountain than even today.
- 35:34There were lots of scattered small holdings.
- 35:37So they would have been subsistence farmers, and they
- 35:40would probably have had vines, but they'd have had animals,
- 35:43they'd have had growing stuff. They'd done everything and the
- 35:47big town that's nearby, Shombury, didn't actually have a
- 35:50big population at the time. So a huge chunk of rock fell off
- 35:56the top of this mountain and it then, as it rolled down,
- 36:01triggered a lion's landslide from the lower parts of the
- 36:06mountain. And that landslide, and I'm
- 36:08sorry, I don't have the figures in front of me, but it covered a
- 36:11massive area. We're talking, I mean, there's
- 36:14a, there's all sorts of things written down as to how far it
- 36:17covered, but it was several, it was two or three miles wide,
- 36:21let's say, and went on and on and buried everything and
- 36:26anything living would no longer have been living.
- 36:30And the only reason that we know this in such detail is that it
- 36:34actually stopped just before a Catholic Abbey and the monks
- 36:39would record everything. So the monks actually wrote this
- 36:43down and so and without that we wouldn't have such detail.
- 36:49And so it was pretty spectacular.
- 36:51And then for several 100 years and nothing was, you know, no,
- 36:57nobody moved back there, nothing was grown there, nothing was
- 37:00cleared. But gradually, with the sort of
- 37:03very beginnings of machinery in the sort of beginnings of the
- 37:08industrial time, they felt they could clear it well enough to
- 37:12plant at least vines, because vines are the one plant that can
- 37:17grow in a rocky environment and a Stony environment.
- 37:20So they planted vines below, and gradually the population sort of
- 37:27moved back in and villages were established and so on.
- 37:31And the vine that they, the grape variety that they planted
- 37:35is today's most planted savoir variety, which is Jacques.
- 37:39And the 2 sub denominations or crew that are in that area are
- 37:46Aprimon, which is named after a village there.
- 37:49And and I've been actually means rubble Aprimon.
- 37:52I am, I've been ticked off recently about translating it
- 37:55wrongly. So it's means something like
- 37:57terrible mountain or difficult mountain or something like that.
- 38:01But those are the areas there and that's the sort of main area
- 38:07for Jacques today, although Jacques Air is grown much
- 38:10further afield in other villages too, because it was a very Hardy
- 38:14variety. Unusually, it was white, and in
- 38:17those days people drank much more red than white.
- 38:21But they knew that they could ripen it, that it would keep
- 38:25going until November and then they could pick it in November
- 38:28if it wasn't ripe enough before, and make a very, very, what back
- 38:33in those days would have been a very low alcohol white wine that
- 38:37in a Goodyear would have been OK and in a bad year would have
- 38:41been pretty mean. Vinegar.
- 38:42Yeah. Oh, that's crazy.
- 38:44That's why, you know, I just, I wanted to share that with the
- 38:47listener too, because I feel like, you know, the wine regions
- 38:51that really capture the imagination are those ones that
- 38:53have some some history like that, the Mount Etna, you know,
- 38:56like it's hard to get into and expired and excited about like
- 38:59Bordeaux. You know, it's like, OK, there's
- 39:01gravel caps on Merlot, but but the places that have a history
- 39:06and something exciting, it's like, OK, this is something that
- 39:10can capture the imagination. But Andrew, if I could just sort
- 39:13of say one other thing about the Tawa there, not not just there,
- 39:17but the really very close to there along the Izer Valley.
- 39:21It was a glacier before And and that means that it's moving.
- 39:26The Tawa has moved because, you know, glacier or glacier as you
- 39:31would say, it's just a, it's a frozen river.
- 39:34And so as it melted, whenever that was, I've forgotten my my
- 39:39hundreds or of years but between the glacial period and now.
- 39:44But as it melted, it would have brought all sorts of different
- 39:48layers of soil of top soil down from the Alps.
- 39:51And that's why you've got all sorts of different soils that
- 39:54work with different grape varieties.
- 39:56And it's what I call moving tawa, which is you mentioned
- 40:00Aetna, which is a little bit what Aetna has for a completely
- 40:03different reason because. Yes, there's new new things.
- 40:06So the. Interruptions are bringing the.
- 40:09If I'm a listener at home and I am into wine but I maybe haven't
- 40:13explored the French Alps, what what would you recommend or how
- 40:18would you recommend I go about trying that knowing that most of
- 40:21the people that listen to this are America based?
- 40:24Well, it's very hard to give a straightforward direction
- 40:28because it. Was such a small region.
- 40:30Areas and many States and some states probably don't have any
- 40:36savoir wine at all. It's a very, very tiny area,
- 40:39just to to tell you that that savoir is in acres, about 5 1/2
- 40:46thousand and acres and in fact a bit less than that 5000 acres, I
- 40:50would say. And if your listeners aren't
- 40:52familiar with that sort of size, that's about half the size of
- 40:57Chablis and about half the size of Santa Milion.
- 41:00So last time I knew Chablis made a white wine from a great cold
- 41:06Chardonnay. And sure, there are lots of tawa
- 41:09variations and quality variations and so on, but that's
- 41:11it. And you can say the same with
- 41:13Santa Milion, a red wine style from from two or three grape
- 41:17varieties and and that's it. Whereas in Savoir, as you
- 41:23mentioned earlier, there's sort of up to 25 grape varieties.
- 41:26There's all sorts of different villages.
- 41:28There's red, white, rose, sparkling.
- 41:31There's more likely to be white than anything.
- 41:34The thing you're most likely to find is a white wine from
- 41:37Savoir. And I mentioned earlier the
- 41:39Jacques grape. Now that won't necessarily be
- 41:43labeled be on the label, but any decent restaurant or wine store
- 41:48would tell you that it was made from Jacques.
- 41:50And it's a very good place to start because Jacques is
- 41:54arguably quintessential savoir white wine in that it's very low
- 42:00in alcohol. You'll never find one that is
- 42:03above 12% and most of it is 10 1/2 to 11 1/2%.
- 42:10And it's almost never oak fermented and oak aged.
- 42:16I say almost because there's always some producers doing
- 42:19something, as you know. Someone's always going to try
- 42:22it. You just to try it once, yeah.
- 42:24And, well, there's a couple of good ones.
- 42:26And it has a steely acidity and it's the quintessential grape
- 42:32for climate change because whereas other varieties, even in
- 42:36the savoir are beginning to get very, very high alcohols, this
- 42:40one just isn't capable of getting very high alcohol.
- 42:43It's as simple as that, and it has a delightful freshness.
- 42:47And if you can drink it on its own with some charcuterie or
- 42:51with a little bit of of cheese, even soft cheese, it'll work
- 42:55beautifully. On the other hand, if you want
- 42:58to have the the rather the sort of rather hackneyed fondue,
- 43:03cheese fondue, you couldn't have a more perfect wine to have with
- 43:07cooked cheese, with melted cheese and so on.
- 43:10And that very old fashioned term, a lunchtime wine.
- 43:15In other words, a daytime wine where it's fresh, easy, like the
- 43:19thing that you just have in your fridge to bring out to serve to
- 43:24somebody. So there are a ton of different
- 43:26names. You might see Aprimo, you might
- 43:28see Abin, you might see shinyang, and that's spelt
- 43:32CHIGNIN, pronounced shinyang. But I want to give a little bit
- 43:37of a warning about shinyang in particular.
- 43:39It's really, really important to understand the difference.
- 43:42And I have even the servers in Alpine restaurants up in the
- 43:46mountains if it's not a top restaurant.
- 43:49And get this wrong and badly advise people.
- 43:52So there is Shinya. And if a white wine says Shinya
- 43:55in big letters, it's made from Jacques.
- 43:58But there's also Shinya Bergeron, and that is a
- 44:02completely different wine. And Shinya Bergeron is made from
- 44:07Bergeron. Bergeron is none other than
- 44:11Rusan. It's a local synonym for Rusan.
- 44:15And in the Appalachian laws, you're only allowed to grow
- 44:19Rusan in the Xenia area of Savoir, and fairly obviously
- 44:24Rusan does not have that same flavour profile or structure or
- 44:29anything it could. Be 14%.
- 44:31Alcohol, it could be rich, it would be a disaster with the
- 44:34cheese fondue, and yet it can make some absolutely excellent,
- 44:38delicious savoir wines and it's just really important to know
- 44:42that difference. It's like ordering a nice light
- 44:45Chablis and getting served like the ripest oak aged Chardonnay
- 44:49from Napa. Absolutely.
- 44:51That that difference is not an exaggeration.
- 44:54It really. Is yeah, well, that's awesome.
- 44:56That's a good, that's a good hint.
- 44:57So kind of to sum that up for the listener, you if you're in
- 45:00America, you may not be able to find it.
- 45:03Definitely can find some probably joints in like the East
- 45:06or West Coast. If you find it'll likely be
- 45:09Jacques. If you see Bergeron it'll be a
- 45:12different grape, but Jacques Air is probably a good entry point
- 45:16and. So that there's a few guys doing
- 45:18blends too. And then there's also Roussette
- 45:21de Savoir, which you will find around.
- 45:24And Roussette de Savoir is always the Altesque grape.
- 45:27So the Altesque grape gives something to keep it really
- 45:33simple in between Jacques and Roussanne in both style and in
- 45:38weight. You still get that streak of
- 45:40acidity. You'll still get some slightly
- 45:42floral notes. You might get some vegetable
- 45:46notes. It's a great variety that can
- 45:48make at the top end makes wines to age extremely well.
- 45:52You don't have to drink several wines, you know, the year after
- 45:56they're made. They, they age much better than
- 46:00people used to think, obviously from the best finger ONS and so
- 46:03on. So those are the white, the main
- 46:05whites. So a good way to start, and I
- 46:07did want to say if they can't find anything in their local
- 46:10market, it's always a good idea to take a trip.
- 46:13And I wanted to bring that up because I think you have a trip
- 46:15coming up that you're planning to.
- 46:18I do have a trip very coming up that I'm working with wine
- 46:23school based in St. Cambridge, MA called the
- 46:26Commonwealth Wine School. Little plug for them there.
- 46:29I've done a couple of bits of work for them in the past,
- 46:32giving, giving classes, and they fancied going to Jura and I said
- 46:37why not add on Savoir because doing a whole week in Jura,
- 46:42there's plenty to see, but it's really hard to get the visits.
- 46:45Everybody's very, very busy, especially in the summer and the
- 46:48growing seasons. So I said let's do the 2.
- 46:51So actually we have sort of 5 1/2 days on the road and the
- 46:56first couple of days we'll be in Savoir and we'll be visiting.
- 47:02It's actually a wine and cheese trip and I have this.
- 47:06Sign me up. Lovely guy called Adam who knows
- 47:10much more than me about cheese and we've worked together to
- 47:14create a couple of really good cheese visits of cheese special
- 47:19cheese ages. So we're doing the two together,
- 47:22lots of lovely meals. So there's two days in savoir.
- 47:24There's one in between day where we drive through the Bourget and
- 47:28we'll visit Saurdon, which is the home of Method Ancestral,
- 47:34very low alcohol, pink fizz and we're visiting a top producer
- 47:39there on the way to Jura and, and then we'll be in Jura for
- 47:43three, 3 1/2 days. So there's going to be a huge
- 47:47amount to learn. We'll only be scratching the
- 47:49surface, and hopefully at the end of it, everybody will at
- 47:53least know how to pronounce Savoir's main red grape that I
- 47:59haven't even had time to talk about, which is mondeurs.
- 48:03And it's a mission in my life to to teach Americans to pronounce
- 48:09Mondeus to. Stop saying Mondeus.
- 48:12No, it's Mondeus. Mondeus.
- 48:15OK, good. Now I'll know.
- 48:16And now I'll remember for the rest of my life.
- 48:18That's awesome. Yeah.
- 48:19I mean, there's too much in this, too much in your book, too
- 48:21much in all this to do in an hour because it's a whole
- 48:25region. I mean, it's a whole lifetime of
- 48:28work for you compressed into just a couple of minutes.
- 48:30So if someone is at home listening and they're interested
- 48:34maybe in that trip maybe to find out where they could get your
- 48:36book, is there somewhere online you'd like to send them?
- 48:40Well, it can find me with my name on social media and welcome
- 48:45to direct message me as long as they reference the show and so
- 48:48on. If they've got specific
- 48:51inquiries, hopefully you can put a couple of links up on your
- 48:55website. I don't know how that works, but
- 48:57my books, my three books are sold by through Academy Duvan
- 49:02Library and so the website there is simply Academy with an IE at
- 49:08the end, Du van VIN library.com and so they can find those books
- 49:16there and the Commonwealth Wine School have got a page for the
- 49:20wine trip. I have my own website, but hey,
- 49:24I do to be too many things to keep it all up and so on.
- 49:28As I say, you'll find me on the main social media channels,
- 49:31LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook, Google.
- 49:35Just look for my name and. It's a unique enough name.
- 49:38It's easy to find. Yeah.
- 49:39And if you're listening to, I will have links for all the
- 49:43things that she mentioned and anything else that Wink sends me
- 49:46in the show notes. So you don't have to remember
- 49:48those things, how to spell them, just click all and over and
- 49:51makes it easy. And so, yeah.
- 49:53Is there anything that we haven't covered that I'd, you
- 49:56know, be a shame to leave without talking about?
- 49:58Well, I got the monders in there which I really wanted to get in.
- 50:03I think that. I mean, one thing we didn't
- 50:05mention was organics and and people really do care about
- 50:09this. Savoir and boujee have been or
- 50:11savoir in particular has been a little slow to adopt organics.
- 50:15There was some pioneers as long ago as 25 years ago, but it's a
- 50:20very, very, It's a tricky place with mountain climate and so on,
- 50:24but they're catching up fast. There's a new breed, a new
- 50:27generation of wine growers who are really.
- 50:30Caring about the farming and who are making better and better of
- 50:34wine. So, and those are the wines that
- 50:36are most likely to make their way into the US market, into
- 50:41trendy restaurants and so on. There's but the bigger producers
- 50:45of Savoir, which you'll find in the sort of lesser, not so
- 50:50trendy ones, don't tend to be organic, but they do as good a
- 50:54job as they can. They do value with great
- 50:57varieties and so on. But there's a whole plethora of
- 50:59wine producers. So, so very many.
- 51:02But yeah, look out, look out for the organic ones.
- 51:04In the case of Savoir, they really do tend to be the better
- 51:07ones. Right.
- 51:08Yeah, that's a great note. Awesome.
- 51:10Thank you for taking some time to come and talk to us today.
- 51:13It was a real pleasure. Thank you.
- 51:15Have you on? It's been fun.
- 51:16Yeah. I talk too much, I know.
- 51:18No, it's fine. Even though it is 9:00 AM here.
- 51:21No, it's later there. I'm ready for a glass.
- 51:24I'm Jacques. Let's do.
- 51:26It well, actually I'm going to ready.
- 51:27I haven't had a glass of wine today and it's 5530 here and my
- 51:32white wine tonight is going to be Mondes Blanche, of which
- 51:36there's less than 30 acres in the world.
- 51:40So it's a rare grape variety. That's awesome.
- 51:43Awesome. Yeah, Well, cheers.
- 51:44Have one for me. OK.
- 51:46Thank you, Andrew. Thank you for listening.
- 51:49That is today's episode. Now, if you have not taken a
- 51:53moment to check out our website, please do.
- 51:56It's serves you right pod.com. We have past episodes and all
- 52:01sorts of other things there. If you want to get in touch with
- 52:03me, that's the place to do it. I do appreciate that you've
- 52:07given me your most valuable asset, your time and attention.
- 52:10So thank you for listening and stay tuned.
- 52:14We have some really cool guests coming up.
- 52:16I would hate it if you missed it.
- 52:18Cheers.