Latest / Rewire To Rise– Beyond The Mindset / AI & The Human Future | Episode 4 : AI & IDENTITY (Live Panel)
Transcript
- 0:11Hello everyone, let's wait a couple of minutes to see if
- 0:16someone still have to connect please.
- 0:45Fantastic. Well, I think we can start.
- 1:04Hello everyone and welcome to the live series AI and Human
- 1:08Future In this life Rewire to Rise AI and Human Future
- 1:13discussion. We will explore AI and identity
- 1:17through 4 connected layers. One is the body, what happens
- 1:23before identity becomes language?
- 1:26Another one it's the self. When does AI stop reflecting us
- 1:31and start defining us? Competence Is AI making us
- 1:36skilled or just skilled looking and environment?
- 1:42Who is shaping our thinking? But before I will introduce the
- 1:471st guest, I would like you to be aware of a couple of
- 1:51important parts of this life event. 1 is that please do
- 1:56remember to sign up on my website to be able to receive
- 2:00the guest goodie bag at Mirella bulkanet dot Mailer page dot IO.
- 2:07You of course have the link in the description of this life
- 2:11event on YouTube, Facebook or LinkedIn and in the comments
- 2:16section. 2 Please be aware that if you don't Sign up today, you
- 2:22will not have the opportunity to receive the material from
- 2:25today's speakers to if you want to go deeper into learning and
- 2:31practicing for free, you have the possibility of using the
- 2:36interactive tech guide website that I have Co created together
- 2:42with Mark Sinclair Fleeton at interactive dot AI dash portalin
- 2:48dot DK. Again, you can find the link
- 2:50here in the comments section. And please do remember to
- 2:55support and be part of this huge, immense project at
- 2:59buymeacoffee.com, Rewire to Rise.
- 3:03I just wanted to let you know that your support isn't just a
- 3:07contribution to a podcast or see something similar to that, but
- 3:12it helps me well create the next collaboration project.
- 3:17It helps this platform remain independent because it is an
- 3:21independent project. And it helps me grow into what I
- 3:25believe this project can become. So please allow me to introduce
- 3:32the 1st guest. The 1st guest.
- 3:37Hello, Tosten. Hello Marella, and thank you for
- 3:42letting me be here today and talk about something about AI
- 3:46and the identity. My pleasure Tosten, Please allow
- 3:53me to share your presentation. Yes.
- 3:58Bye. Bye.
- 3:59Must see I can fix this. Yeah.
- 4:13Yeah. Here we go.
- 4:20Ebola. Ebola.
- 4:21Ebola. Yes.
- 4:24Thank you. You're welcome.
- 4:29Well, long before we, we have this opportunity to use the AI,
- 4:40we have lived our lives, we have seen things, we have learned
- 4:48things in a human slowly way to found this identity we have
- 5:00today. And after the AI was coming in
- 5:08our lives, there are those who use it.
- 5:14We're going into the AI and we we asked it a question and we
- 5:23got an answer. This is how you can shape the
- 5:32system to shape shapes you back. When you then come back home,
- 5:41back to the system again, you get you are changed in a little,
- 5:49little direction and then you are shaping the system new again
- 5:55and it shapes you back again. And this is a kind of of of
- 5:59loop, yes, as I said we have become our identity after it's
- 6:16lived. But with AI is some something
- 6:20different again, it's a recusive loop we are in together with the
- 6:29the AII shape it, it shapes me back and this forefront.
- 6:35What are we becoming after this? I think, well, again, what what
- 6:45is what, what is your identity? You can even you can say you,
- 6:52you are this. You can have some kind of mask
- 6:56on, but you are aren't this you are telling, but you are maybe
- 7:01becoming this what you are. You are you are you are telling
- 7:06about your own identity. This is a direction and this
- 7:10direction you can form. There you have it again.
- 7:20What I say I am, what I repeatedly do, and what remains
- 7:27available after under pressure. You cannot always certify the
- 7:40first thing, but you you can also have another human looking
- 7:46at it, who you are and not only let the machine tell you who you
- 7:53are. Well, there's also this this
- 8:01kind of compression here you'll get from the the answers.
- 8:06It's very quick. You get the the answers and but
- 8:13the answers ain't going into your nervous system right away.
- 8:18You'll have to let it give it give it some time so so it can
- 8:26so it can can ride in place. But I can say yes.
- 8:34And I got some tools for you. Also.
- 8:38When you, when you read something, you're going to,
- 8:43you're going to, it's something you're, it's, it's going to,
- 8:50you're going to, you know, it's, it's OK.
- 8:54You got you, you may you, you feel something in your body and
- 9:02well, well, when, when this happens, you're, it's a good
- 9:07thing just to look away from your screen again and, and, and,
- 9:14and have to think about it. Do I have, do I have to actually
- 9:20decide right now? Do I have to write more?
- 9:24Because it's, it's, it's very intense or something like this.
- 9:30You have you, you have to, to, to take this pause.
- 9:35It's, it's very, it's very important because then you
- 9:40overload your body with something the AI tells you in a
- 9:46very, very compressed time. Well, again, the identity you,
- 9:59you tell the machine what you are and what you actually trace
- 10:08in your life is it's absent in your life.
- 10:17The next small action if you if you change the form and you form
- 10:25it back to it again. What might make these your
- 10:30question or your answer may make it more truth.
- 10:36Who knows? You need 3 witnesses.
- 10:45The system can know your patents and other human can tell all the
- 10:53patent or see who you are or tell you who thinks you are and
- 10:59then the reality again what your actions actually show who you
- 11:04are. So here I think I have this
- 11:15question, what is this interaction training me to
- 11:21become? Well, I'm going to leave you
- 11:25with another question. And this is what are we training
- 11:33to become together with AI? And so far, this is my
- 11:40contribution for now. And I have and I would like to
- 11:47again, like Mirela, talk to, to sign up and take the, the, the
- 11:59goodie bag with you. And with all the good things we
- 12:03have leave behind there also very, very lot about the AI and
- 12:13identity. I hope my contribution doesn't
- 12:18leave you with more questions that I have been bringing on
- 12:24this today. Thank you, thank you, thank you
- 12:28so much, Tosin. So let's go to the 2nd guest.
- 12:36Well, in theory and in practice should be here.
- 12:39Mark Sinter Fleeton, but he had an inconvenience, but Co will
- 12:46take his place and he was so nice to do that for Mark.
- 12:51So here we are. Hello Co.
- 12:55Hello Mirela, and thank you, I'll share my screen.
- 13:00And I'll, I'm quite sure. To be sure.
- 13:03That Mike will be very happy. I will do my very best to
- 13:07present like like he would have done and for a start I have his
- 13:13presentation. So far so good.
- 13:16The. Floor is yours.
- 13:18Thank you. The theme is about AI and
- 13:24identity. And The thing is that yes, you
- 13:27do have your identity independently of AI, but AI is
- 13:33little by little affecting your identity.
- 13:38That can be how others see you, but that can surely also be how
- 13:42you see yourself and how you feel about yourself.
- 13:45And AI has so much memory, so many resources, it remembers
- 13:50things might also misunderstand. And let's dig in and see what
- 13:56it's all about. There are some challenges.
- 13:59There are fortunately also solutions.
- 14:03We really start out that in a previous episode about the human
- 14:08judgement, it was about how AI can help you in leadership, in
- 14:14decision making. And now we are digging a little
- 14:19deeper and asking if we hand judgement to AI, what happens to
- 14:26the self. That judgement was building and
- 14:34it's quite an interesting story and fortunately have we have
- 14:38time to dig in and look deeper into the details.
- 14:45Let's start by looking at the identity stack.
- 14:49We could have put this from bottom and up, we could put it
- 14:52in this order, but it starts out from level 1.
- 14:56The biological self that has nothing to do with technology is
- 15:01about the body, it is about the brain, and it is about, well,
- 15:04the person. As such, then we can move on to
- 15:09#2 in this stack, it's still about the actual person, but now
- 15:15it's about the self of the self. And it is about what thoughts we
- 15:21do, what choices we make. We also make mistakes.
- 15:25That's also what defines us and what shapes us as humans.
- 15:29And, and hopefully we have these independent thoughts, but we can
- 15:34build 2 layers on top of that. And that's where the AI kicks in
- 15:39because in #3 we have the digitally mediate itself now.
- 15:47It's still about our identity. But as we interact with these
- 15:50services, it's still it little by little shapes how we see
- 15:57ourselves, how we act and, and navigate on platforms and how we
- 16:03use tools that can be social media, that can be other places
- 16:08on the the Internet. And little by little, we get to
- 16:13the top of the stack or the the 4th and top layer that now the
- 16:19algorithm has little by little shaped how we see ourself.
- 16:24And if it puts us in a slightly different framing, which we
- 16:30already see on social media, and now with the help of AI, we can
- 16:34do it even more well. Is it still compatible with the
- 16:38layer one and the layer two, our actual self, which is also about
- 16:43learning through life. It's also about mistakes and
- 16:46everything. I'll get back to to this stack,
- 16:48but for start, it's established and before getting back to the
- 16:56stack, it's not only what I say or in this case what Mark would
- 17:01have said and that I have the pleasure to present.
- 17:05This is also what all all the studies has told, in this case
- 17:14from the Eland University that tells about how the deep and
- 17:22meaningful of fundamental or revolutionary change will little
- 17:30by little affect us. It is expected to increase in
- 17:34strength up to 61% by 2035. We also have that it could imply
- 17:45a negative shift. I'll not read all every word
- 17:50aloud, but there are surely some themes.
- 17:56Unfortunately, when we are aware, when we make relevant
- 18:01choices, there are also ways of navigating through this.
- 18:04So let's move on to that. We're back to the four layers. 2
- 18:11is your actual self, the three and four is the digital self,
- 18:18which is to a large and large extent based on AI.
- 18:24And we still have the first layer that reflects you.
- 18:28It is still about your behaviour, your choices in the
- 18:32actual world, in your actual body, in your actual everyday
- 18:35life, which is not only digital but when moving on to the top
- 18:41layers, the layer 3 and the layer 4.
- 18:45It is a possibility or risk, however we put it that it will
- 18:51little by little define you and it might be totally true to who
- 18:56you are. It might also try to adjust a
- 18:59little in order to make you appear even wise or even more
- 19:03reflected or even with the bigger knowledge and, and the
- 19:10challenges that you cannot always inspect what this machine
- 19:15or these machines are, are, are doing for you because it's put
- 19:19in an algorithm. And once again, we're
- 19:21establishing this story. Of course there are solutions
- 19:26when we go further down the line and let's put into structure
- 19:34where it's little by little erodes.
- 19:38We start out from an overall perspective with these three
- 19:43headlines about the fragment itself, the deskilling of the of
- 19:47the certain narration, the external validation over
- 19:50judgement. There are more details and those
- 19:53details will follow in the the the following slides.
- 19:57So we really put into structure where are the risks of erosion
- 20:04because once we are aware what the risks are, it's much.
- 20:08Easier to navigate how to act in that situation.
- 20:13So let's dig a little deeper in the first erosion, the fragment
- 20:18itself, we can see in the top that if they see you on LinkedIn
- 20:25or if on Instagram or on other digital channels, well, with the
- 20:32help of AI, you will appear in a certain way, which might fully
- 20:37or in part be compatible with who you are.
- 20:41And if you do an effort to put yourself in a in a different
- 20:46light, or if the algorithm tries to drag you in a certain
- 20:50direction for LinkedIn, it might be beneficial to your career.
- 20:54In Instagram, you might appear even more beautiful or or with
- 20:59even more fascinating life or whatever it it will be.
- 21:02Well, little by little you start drifting away from yourself.
- 21:06That is an erosion. And that means that in the
- 21:10bottom box you can see that. Let's make sure that you are
- 21:16aware of what are the different versions.
- 21:21There is surely the online version and it need not be a
- 21:23problem, but it is a potential erosion and you should be aware
- 21:28of that. There is also the second
- 21:33erosion, because little by little the self narration might
- 21:39change. This is actually based on what
- 21:43Mark has written about in his book.
- 21:45Which also means that a little of this is written in Danish,
- 21:49but it's translated to to English afterwards.
- 21:53Because if a child is telling a story with fantasy and
- 21:58everything and AI is asking for facts instead, well, you are
- 22:03drifting away from the natural creativity, from the natural
- 22:07human behaviour. And once again then we should be
- 22:12aware of this self narration because humans aren't perfect
- 22:17and we're not supposed to be perfect, but AI might drag us in
- 22:20a direction where we try to appear more perfect.
- 22:27The erosion #3 is that we might end up in a situation where this
- 22:32external validation might actually be how we judge
- 22:37ourselves. And little by little, we also
- 22:40see on these digital channels, it be it LinkedIn or Facebook or
- 22:46others, that it is looking for proof profiles.
- 22:49Because not all proof profiles are actual humans.
- 22:52Not all appear as actual humans. They're also fake profiles out
- 22:57there and these services make a score about how you behave.
- 23:04So maybe you start behaving differently and maybe the AI and
- 23:08maybe the algorithm will little by little drag you in a certain
- 23:11direction. And it might be that when you
- 23:15follow the rules of the the algorithm, it is weighting
- 23:19you're higher. It is a really presenting your
- 23:23content in in a different way. And you can get more or less
- 23:26addicted to to to that approach and you should really be aware
- 23:31of it. But fortunately, there is a
- 23:35turning point to this, because this paradox cuts both ways.
- 23:41Yes, you start out from yourself.
- 23:43Yes, AI and digital services is building on top.
- 23:47But if you take control, and if you practice and if you are
- 23:53aware of yourself, it is possible to take back your own
- 23:59story, your own appearance, your own imperfections, your own
- 24:03humanity, really. And and the more aware we are,
- 24:09the more conscious choices we make, the better.
- 24:14After this session, I advise you to do this mirror test.
- 24:19You do one step at a time. First start, you ask AI to
- 24:23describe yourself in Step 2, you read it aloud and then you
- 24:28compare it with how you see yourself because there are most
- 24:34likely that gaps and if you name those gaps, that's the fourth
- 24:39point to this. Then at least you have an
- 24:42awareness of where are the differences.
- 24:45It need not be that LinkedIn should be in every aspect true
- 24:49to who you are, but at least you should be aware of the gaps.
- 24:52The same goes for Instagram. The same goes for Facebook or
- 24:55TikTok or whatever channels and it could even be websites, it
- 24:58could be YouTube videos. It could be so much content, and
- 25:03that means that if you are aware, if you are aware of the
- 25:12gaps, you can still little by little try start practising the
- 25:18self narration without correction.
- 25:21Being human, being imperfect, being creative, being
- 25:26independent of the algorithm. And then you might sometimes let
- 25:31AI describe you, but you can then contest it.
- 25:35You can take control. You can edit what should be
- 25:38edited on social media or whatever, digital presence, and
- 25:42then you can treat what is the the self of yourself.
- 25:48Because at the end of the day, you are still a human being.
- 25:52You should be a human being. Yes, AI can help you out.
- 25:55Yes, AI can present you. But you need to have the
- 25:58awareness about it. And that means that we are still
- 26:04humans. We should not and we cannot
- 26:07outsource the judgement. It will affect who we are, it
- 26:13will affect how we see ourselves.
- 26:16But it it really comes down to us still being conscious about
- 26:21it, still being humans, still navigating in this digital
- 26:27world. Thank you for your time.
- 26:35Thank you so much, Kurt. Thank you.
- 26:37I appreciate it. Perfect.
- 26:42So before we go forward with the next speaker, I would like you
- 26:49again to remind you that you can still and you are still able to
- 26:53sign up to receive the goodie bags of our guests at mirella
- 26:57dot Mailer page dot IO. If you want to discover, learn
- 27:02and experiment with the rewire to write in AI protein for
- 27:07interactive tech guide, it's for free at interactive dot AI dash
- 27:12portal and dot DK. And if you want to support this
- 27:16wonderful project and be part of of it, you can do it at
- 27:22buymeacoffee.com. Rewired to rise.
- 27:25Thank you guys. I hope you are going to be
- 27:28thrilled about this new idea. So let's go forward with used.
- 27:33Hello use welcome. Thank you Morella, always a
- 27:37pleasure to be here. Thank you.
- 27:39The floor is yours. Well, Mila Grazzi, so as as I
- 27:45think you all know, I am an educator.
- 27:50I spend my days teaching bright young people at the Business
- 27:55Academy Copenhagen. And what I'd like to talk about
- 28:00on this Sunday is to sum up my thoughts here and, and reflect
- 28:06over the passing weeks and try to say some thoughts that I have
- 28:11on how artificial intelligence will affect my students,
- 28:18specifically how it will affect their formation of a
- 28:22professional identity. Now, identity is many things.
- 28:29I'm a Dane, I'm a father, I'm a husband, I'm a chess player.
- 28:39But you know, my professional identity is, is one part of it.
- 28:43And it's something that I acquired throughout the years.
- 28:46It's something that I, I built up.
- 28:49And right now, I think we have a situation where a lot of young
- 28:53people, they're going through the same process that I went
- 28:55through back in the 90s, but they're going through it with a
- 29:00competitor called ChatGPT, Claude or whatever have you.
- 29:06That quite frankly is a lot better than they are ever going
- 29:09to be. And that worries me.
- 29:13That worries me. So if I look at my great Co
- 29:16hosts where you can see we're doing a competition here and who
- 29:19has the best beard? But we all have a professional
- 29:25identity. Core has one as an IT expert.
- 29:28Torsten has 1A psychologist. I call myself a professor, which
- 29:33is my translation, I guess, of the Danish term lecture.
- 29:36But the question is, those young students that I have who are
- 29:40trying to become someone, what's going to happen to them?
- 29:45And my fear is that before they find their feet, well, AI will
- 29:50already have taken the seat. And what do I mean by that?
- 29:54What do I mean by that when we go through creating stuff with
- 29:59AI, but you know what of the stuff that we created is
- 30:04actually mine? Was it my idea, my wording, my
- 30:09analysis, my achievement and ownership is something that you
- 30:17know, where we have to question ourselves?
- 30:19Is this really my win or is it a place where the machine snuck
- 30:23in? So my students specifically I'm,
- 30:26I teach at a couple of bachelor's degrees in
- 30:29e-commerce. So, you know, there's a number
- 30:32of things that my colleagues and I, we try to teach our students
- 30:36to become really good at that stuff like, you know, build a
- 30:40web shop, but you know, and AI can do that better.
- 30:44It's something like writing product content, but you know,
- 30:48my students will look at me and say, well, you know, but AI can
- 30:51do that better. We can, I can ask them to
- 30:53generate campaigns or ideas for say Marella to market her
- 30:57website. But you know, let's let's be
- 30:59honest, not my students are bad, but an AI can do that better.
- 31:03And so if if AI is is doing the doing, but my students might
- 31:11well ask, what am I pursuing here?
- 31:14What am I trying to do? And I think we come into a
- 31:21question whether we have a young generation that is skilled.
- 31:26All that is, is, is skill looking because it's never been
- 31:30easier to, you know, put out a professionally looking report to
- 31:37have a great speech prepared. But it's also never been easier
- 31:43to outsource that to some artificial intelligence.
- 31:46Yeah. And I think I have a truly, I
- 31:51have a true worry that, you know, AI is faking the glow and,
- 31:57and preventing skills from growing and, and, and where does
- 32:02this worry, where does this worry lead me?
- 32:04Well, over in the United States of America, there was a lawsuit
- 32:11that was settled earlier this month where one of the states in
- 32:17the, in the USFA had filed A lawsuit against Meter for
- 32:22purposely harming young people by getting them addicted to
- 32:26social media. And I'm not going to go into the
- 32:29details of the case, but just to say it's kind of a well
- 32:32established fact that social media has had some harmful
- 32:38effects on young people. It's also had positive effects
- 32:42for for adults in, in many ways. But social media has been
- 32:49without much doubt linked to a rise in uncertainty and anxiety
- 32:56among young people, and specifically, specifically among
- 33:00young women to a larger degree than than young men.
- 33:05And, and what is what is the worry?
- 33:07What, what is sort of the harm that social media has been
- 33:12causing here? Well, the The thing is that that
- 33:19back in the old days when, when, when me and the other panellists
- 33:23were young, well, we compared ourselves to our peers, to the
- 33:27people around us. But all of a sudden with social
- 33:30media, our peers is the most beautiful, the most successful
- 33:36people of, of the world on their best day.
- 33:41That's what people post on Instagram.
- 33:43They don't push, you know, like take #37 that was, you know,
- 33:47kind of bad or, or, or not that good.
- 33:51They post the picture that was the best out of the hundreds
- 33:55that they took. And does social media ends up
- 33:58setting some, some rather unrealistic standards for what
- 34:01beauty looks like? And I mean, there's, there's a
- 34:06nice little theory out there that one of the reason social
- 34:08media didn't affect young boys that well is that young boys,
- 34:12they overestimated their own looks.
- 34:15So, you know, I mean, we, we got off easy on, on that account.
- 34:18I mean, show, show me a picture of, of George Clooney and core
- 34:23and Torsten myself will go, yeah, we, we look as good as
- 34:25that guy, right? But, you know, show my niece a
- 34:30picture of Beyoncé and she'll say, I'll never, I'll never look
- 34:33like that. I'll never look like that.
- 34:34But if that was the harm that social media did, let's take a
- 34:37moment to think about what generative AI will will do here.
- 34:43Because all of a sudden you have a machine that will spit out in
- 34:47a number of seconds, if not minutes, something that would
- 34:50take a professional like me hours to make and a learner A
- 34:56beginner days, if it's even possible.
- 35:00And so, you know, I mean, I'm worried about this.
- 35:04I'm worried that, you know, if Instagram made us feel ugly,
- 35:08well, chat TBT is, is, is going to make a lot of humans feel
- 35:12stupid. And this is also the problem,
- 35:17some of the problems that we see when people they use AI to, to
- 35:20create things. I, I've talked about the, this
- 35:24study before the Kasimla study. It's an experiment done over in
- 35:28in the US where you asked some students to to write stuff with,
- 35:35with ChatGPT. So they weren't given like fixed
- 35:37prompts. They had to, you know, get that,
- 35:40make that up themselves. But they came back with
- 35:43something and they said, you know, was this a good time?
- 35:46Yeah, yeah, it was a good time. But, you know, did they feel
- 35:48they owned, you know, the essay that had been produced this way?
- 35:52Do, you know, did, did they agree with it?
- 35:54And, you know, half of them were like, yeah, you know, kind of,
- 35:57kind of not. Then came the test.
- 36:00You know, can you quote something from this paper that
- 36:02you've just given me? Can you, can you explain, you
- 36:04know, just provide a simple quote?
- 36:07And all of them tried but, but, but the vast majority couldn't,
- 36:11couldn't quote the essay because obviously, you know, they they,
- 36:15they didn't write it. And, you know, if something is,
- 36:19is good, it no longer feels like mine.
- 36:21But what happens then to my own perception of of my competence,
- 36:28you know, are we are we getting to to this point where we are
- 36:32collectively, you know, entering into a sort of real life
- 36:37imposter stage where a perfect page is, is hiding an empty
- 36:43stage? I don't know, but I fear it.
- 36:46And, and one of the things, one of the theories that is out
- 36:50there that captures where this fear could go is Carol Dweck's
- 36:56fixed versus growth mindset. I mean, for, for those of you
- 36:59who, who don't know this theory, the the fixed versus growth
- 37:02mindset says postulates that we as humans, we approach a
- 37:09situation with either growth mindset or a fixed mindset.
- 37:13If we have a fixed mindset, we consider our capabilities to be
- 37:17fixed. So if I try to build a webshop,
- 37:20it doesn't go that good. Well, I conclude, OK, you know,
- 37:23I'm not good at building web shops.
- 37:26I shouldn't do that. I should do something else.
- 37:31If I approach it with a growth mindset, I say, OK, you know,
- 37:34this was my first try. I made many mistakes.
- 37:36But let me learn from those mistakes.
- 37:38Let me try to do it better the next time because I believe that
- 37:41as a person, my competencies can grow.
- 37:44Yeah. And this is where, you know, one
- 37:49of the things that surprised me when I became a professor is a
- 37:51lot of students actually have a fixed mindset.
- 37:53They enter a degree like e-commerce and they take the
- 37:56different courses that we offer, but they take them in order to
- 37:59go on a journey of self discovery to find out what they
- 38:04are good at, what they're not good at.
- 38:05And if they take, you know, my methodology class and they do
- 38:08poorly there, they just conclude, well, you know, I'm
- 38:11not good at methodology. Let me in my next project where
- 38:15that's important, let me do together with a student of mine
- 38:17that is good at it because I'm never going to be better on it.
- 38:21And of course, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm making a
- 38:24cross generalisation here, you know, kind of the theory that
- 38:27here suggests, you know, there's only two kinds of mindsets in
- 38:31the world. But, you know, I see this
- 38:34sometimes and, and I see it exactly, you know, as Carol
- 38:37Dweck described it, you know that, that each of us has a mix
- 38:39of, of fixed and growth mindsets.
- 38:41And there's, there's also, you know, there's, there's a,
- 38:44there's a reason for why it might be a good idea to have a
- 38:47fixed mindset sometimes, you know, at least to less
- 38:50disappointment. And you know, how much can we
- 38:52really disappointment can we really handle at certain stages
- 38:55in our lives and and so on and so forth.
- 38:58But my fear here is very very specifically, if I have some
- 39:03students that have a fixed mindset, then they see what
- 39:05ChatGPT is is able to do. Will those students with a fixed
- 39:11mindset simply not conclude that I'm not ever going to be as good
- 39:16as this so why even bother? Why even try?
- 39:21And that is, that is my worry with AI and professional
- 39:27confidence. So let me shift gears a little
- 39:30bit because I've been talking about students, but I think, you
- 39:35know, that's not the majority of our dear listeners here.
- 39:41But you know, we can be affected as well because we we can have
- 39:46professional identities and let's be honest, you know, they
- 39:48can be lost in a distant past. I used to be a business
- 39:54developer. I'm no longer that and I
- 39:57transitioned, I guess one could say, but we can sometimes, you
- 40:02know, lose our professional identities.
- 40:04And there are some professional identities that AI has already
- 40:07earmarked for extinction, a translator, for instance, and
- 40:13analysts, you know, are these job categories really going to
- 40:17be around a couple of years down the line?
- 40:21Maybe, maybe not. Maybe the skill set that is
- 40:24there can be used in a different contest And and maybe sort of,
- 40:28you know, that can but but the the the profession itself, the
- 40:33profession itself will radically be changed.
- 40:37Yeah. And and this is not something
- 40:39new. I mean, we we've lived in an era
- 40:43of technological progress would be one way to put it.
- 40:46I think in my lifetime, I think I've been fortunate to live in
- 40:51an age where human technological progress has been off the chart
- 40:56compared to previous historical errors.
- 40:59So new technology is not something new new to us.
- 41:02I mean, we can discuss whether the rate of change here is
- 41:05faster and what impact that has, but there are fairly robust
- 41:10studies out there that say if you lose your job due to a shift
- 41:15in technology, So if your own skills are no longer have been
- 41:19made obsolete, well, unemployment hits you harder.
- 41:23I mean, it's banal, maybe even. But but I think, you know, we're
- 41:26already seeing anecdotes about this, the people who get told
- 41:29when they're fired, you know that you're, you're not being
- 41:32fired because we're replacing you with a another human, but
- 41:34we're replacing you with an AI. This, this has happened a couple
- 41:37of times, but they take the loss much more serious because, you
- 41:43know, what's happened to their professional identity.
- 41:48And, you know, I guess, you know, I could sum it up like
- 41:51this. You know, if you lose the job,
- 41:52you lose the pay, but if you lose the craft, you lose part of
- 41:55your way. Yeah.
- 41:57So that worries me a bit too. Another thing that worries me,
- 42:01this is this is my Sunday where I get to worry.
- 42:03Yeah. That's the sort of cultural
- 42:07aspect of it. Because let's remember, sort of
- 42:09our identity does not exist in a vacuum.
- 42:13It is formed on the basis of an into a culture.
- 42:19And culture is then sort of what defines what competence is, what
- 42:27identity can be, what the range is, what the options are.
- 42:31Yeah. And well, my worry here is that
- 42:36if culture tells us what companies competence looks like,
- 42:40well, AI may make every culture more alike.
- 42:45And I think AI is, is is in some ways a representation of
- 42:51globalisation in hyperdrive. Yeah, we've never had more push
- 42:55for globalisation, for internationalisation.
- 42:57And if, if Hollywood shaped what we see, then AI may shape what
- 43:02we think and, and who will be. And because we're, we're pulling
- 43:07AI into our process of forming words, of forming opinions and,
- 43:13and those opinions, you know, as Torsten argued, well, you know,
- 43:16that's the part of identity that we we practice.
- 43:19Why do I consider myself a good professor?
- 43:21Well, you know, I make good slides, but if I'm using AI to
- 43:24make those slides, you know, who made the slides and, and where
- 43:28did this, this come from? And it's been sort of, I think
- 43:32readily established and, and corn myself.
- 43:34I think we, we did another podcast with familiar where we,
- 43:37we talked about that some 95% of the training material for
- 43:44ChatGPT is American English. And there is a bias in that
- 43:51sense. And, and we see it also very
- 43:53clearly when when we make sort of smaller local AI models like
- 43:58the Danish model Mimne that just came out, which was trained
- 44:01exclusively on on Danish material, it actually
- 44:04outperformed ChatGPT on certain benchmarks when tested in
- 44:09Danish. Yeah, but it was a lot poor in a
- 44:14lot of other languages. So there is something there, but
- 44:18what I'm talking about here is very basically that AI is making
- 44:23us a little bit more into Americans.
- 44:27And they're not just any kind of Americans, the West Coast
- 44:30liberal elite type of Americans, the best or worst, kind of
- 44:33depending on your political persuasion.
- 44:36Yeah. And there's some studies out
- 44:38there. This is a not very widely quoted
- 44:41study that I'm, I'm basing myself on here.
- 44:43So, you know, remember, just because one study shows
- 44:45something, that's not a, a given proof, but it's an indication
- 44:49that there might be something here.
- 44:50There's one study here that that, you know, tested how
- 44:53Indian students they write and found that when they used chat
- 44:56TBT, their style became what the professors concluded was
- 44:59classical American writing. It nudged them over there
- 45:02because the Indian students there came to see that way of
- 45:05writing as being the best one. And and I guess, you know, the
- 45:11the best way to to put this is maybe as as as Rammstein did in
- 45:16in their song. We all live in America where
- 45:18this this next line is this is not a love song.
- 45:21Yeah. So AI is is making a hard push
- 45:25to make us sink all more alike and beyond sort of, you know,
- 45:29the the loss of cultural diversity here.
- 45:34You know, that leaves, I mean, with an interesting question to
- 45:37ponder, you know, what if we all start writing the same thing a
- 45:43little bit more? Yeah.
- 45:46And we see this effect with people who use ChatGPT or their
- 45:54eyes to write, paint, do stuff in general.
- 45:59What performance increase? But the range, the range that
- 46:03comes out becomes much more streamlined then when it's just
- 46:08humans doing work on their own. Yeah.
- 46:13And you know, this, this is not that surprising.
- 46:17You know, when everyone asks the same mechanical brain, but don't
- 46:23be surprised when the answer rhymes, right.
- 46:27So that's also a little bit of worry here that I have yes.
- 46:33And Co and myself, we, we talked about this this earlier before
- 46:38on on some of Marella's other podcasts that basically this
- 46:44lack of diversity. It was not a one to one.
- 46:47It's not exactly the same idea that comes out every time.
- 46:50But because they get more alike, we will get less diversity and
- 46:54we will sort of maybe end up getting human AI hybrid slop as
- 47:02a result, which I think would be a loss in many ways.
- 47:07So let's I think this is where I try to wrap up.
- 47:12I've gone a few minutes over time.
- 47:13I hope that's OK, Marilla, But I I think I'd I'd pass the word
- 47:17over to you, who you then give it to to core.
- 47:20I guess who I hope will will come into a little bit on who
- 47:24owns the brain here that that streamslined this.
- 47:28But with that, thank you and I guess I'll be back for the
- 47:33panel, right, Marilla? Yes, indeed.
- 47:35Thank you so much. Yes, thank you.
- 47:39Well, we finally have the real core.
- 47:43So welcome Core again. Thank you so much, Mirela.
- 47:49Thank you very. Welcome.
- 47:52And thank you also to to use for handling it over so, so nicely.
- 47:55I'll just share my screen. Like this, let's see if the
- 48:17screen is actually shared. Just checking, it seems that
- 48:34there might be a delay can. Yeah, I cannot see it
- 48:41unfortunately, at least for now. I'll try once again stop the
- 48:47share and I'll try again share the screen on this.
- 49:01Computer. I suppose and and let's see if
- 49:08it works better, I think. It's this one.
- 49:10Is it though? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 49:12Looks perfect. The floor is yours.
- 49:15Thank you. So by now we have been through
- 49:25the journey where Torsten showed us the biological foundation,
- 49:30how the algorithmic pace and constant optimization will
- 49:34challenge our nervous system. The presentation from Mark that
- 49:38I had the pleasure to to conduct mapped out the cognitive stack
- 49:44warning us about what happens when the system stop merely
- 49:48reflecting us and start defining our judgement.
- 49:51And just used just highlighted the development risk how instant
- 49:56and polished answers can disrupt our growth mindset and subtle
- 50:02homogenize our cultural and professional voice.
- 50:07And just left us with this very fundamental question, can our
- 50:11personal identity remain sovereign when the digital
- 50:15infrastructure is shaping and thinking and owned and
- 50:18controlled elsewhere? My answer is not necessarily.
- 50:24If you don't build your own architecture, you quietly become
- 50:27part of someone else. But this solution isn't to
- 50:31retreat from AI or to resist technical progress.
- 50:35The solution is to translate classic systems and into human
- 50:38boundaries. And that's what I call the
- 50:41personal firewall. Let's look at it.
- 50:48Firewall is really a technical term.
- 50:52It protects the fire from entering one part of the
- 50:55building in in large building in a technical system, it will
- 50:59protect the view from intruders. And now I'm transferring that
- 51:03term into the personal firewall because in the global
- 51:09infrastructure, there are so many professionals now that are
- 51:13using these AI models, often American ones, often trained on
- 51:18whatever content is available and, and, and helping us out in
- 51:23some situations, but also little by little, at least trying to
- 51:27shape our appearance. And the real threat is here that
- 51:32it's a subtle and quiet and little by little change.
- 51:38And the, the, the question is who is actually controlling that
- 51:43infrastructure? Who is little by little shaping
- 51:47your mind? We need to be very aware of
- 51:50this. And let's see if the screen is
- 51:58updating. There it goes.
- 52:00And there are really steps to this.
- 52:04For a start, the algorithm will do its part and little by little
- 52:09it can drift. So it can be daily micro
- 52:13adjustments. Little by little we accept the
- 52:17suggestions. It might be that it suggests an
- 52:20auto complete, or it tries to rewrite our original thought and
- 52:26polishing it and so on. And little by little that leads
- 52:30us into the second box with the data feedback loops.
- 52:33Because little by little it is scoring how we behave.
- 52:36It gets to know us, it tries to support us in the way that is
- 52:40compatible with the system. And the algorithm might not be
- 52:44with the true self as already mentioned by the other
- 52:49presentations. And that means that little by
- 52:52little we don't lose our identity.
- 52:55It's, it's not a sudden crisis. It is this little step by little
- 53:00step, a little in the algorithm, a little in the data and, and
- 53:04little by little we might surrender to this technology
- 53:09unless we are aware. And of course, there's solutions
- 53:11to to this, but let's take it from the biological self in the
- 53:22left hand side. Let's make sure that we look
- 53:26into the identity stack as already presented by Mark, which
- 53:31I had the pleasure to to conduct in reality, but it was still
- 53:34Mark's presentation. And make sure that we can retain
- 53:40our growth mindset as used was presenting.
- 53:44We still start out from our biological stealth.
- 53:47We can still be aware of that identity stack and we can still
- 53:53do our best to retain that human mindset and hopefully growth
- 53:59mindset. And when doing that, it's often
- 54:08about implementing friction. If we are to write manually, it
- 54:14does take time and we might be in doubt and we might need to
- 54:18think before we write the next word, or we might go back and
- 54:21correct when we speak. Sometimes we will need time to
- 54:25think, or we will phrase it differently, or we will act
- 54:30depending on what response we get, what questions we get, what
- 54:35we will see from the person we talk to, if we can see the face
- 54:39of that person or hear the tone of voice.
- 54:41And we really need to make sure that that is still there.
- 54:45The risk is when using AI that there is too little risk, too
- 54:51little sorry friction, which means that it gets too polished,
- 54:55but it also gets too little personal.
- 54:58So we really need to be aware of our inner self, be true to our
- 55:04inner self, make sure that we still use these systems and
- 55:10still introduce the friction. And I'll put a few more words to
- 55:13to that because if we introduce what I call the personal
- 55:20firewall, we can introduce what would be in a technical term, an
- 55:26inbound field. If you shield your own mind from
- 55:31this algorithmic noise, you're much better off.
- 55:36And now we can base it on the systems that Mark was
- 55:40presenting, or in reality, I was, but it was Mark's
- 55:43presentation. If you're aware of what are the
- 55:46differences, what are the gaps, you're much better off knowing
- 55:50what is your actual self, not the polished version made by AI.
- 55:55It is also about being aware of the outbound filter, because
- 56:00when you're on dialogue with other people, well, it is one
- 56:04person to face to face with another person.
- 56:07But when you act on the Internet, being at social media,
- 56:11being at YouTube, being at whatever, you should still be
- 56:14aware of how to feel that. So you're still true to
- 56:17yourself, including imperfections, including doubt,
- 56:21including all. What it is is part of being
- 56:24human. And then you can get to that
- 56:27core purpose. So the tool is serving your,
- 56:30it's serving your judgement. It's serving you as a person,
- 56:34but not changing who you are as a person, or at least you being
- 56:39aware. In some situations, this is
- 56:42compatible to what with what we saw at the earlier stages.
- 56:45Actors have many situations, some sometimes taking on a role
- 56:50and maybe had a hard time letting go of that role.
- 56:53Or if a photo model is all shined up with the makeup and
- 56:58everything, what will that person look like the day after
- 57:02without the makeup? Or how about other kinds of
- 57:07actors and artists and so on? I mean, the concept is not new,
- 57:11IT just applies to much more people nowadays.
- 57:16And that means that you can little by little make sure that
- 57:23your in identity is still insect.
- 57:26And there might be external roles.
- 57:29They might not in every detail be that exact person that you
- 57:33are, but at least you know who you are.
- 57:37And from that you can start to navigating when the disruptions
- 57:43come. Which means that when you
- 57:46succeed in protecting your core identity, when you proceed in
- 57:51succeed in protecting your core values, then you can adapt your
- 57:58role. We all do in in certain
- 58:00situations, adapt to a certain setting with certain persons,
- 58:04professional contexts, whatever life is is, is made of.
- 58:09But at least you start from a human perspective.
- 58:12AI is a tool, it can support you, but it shouldn't take over
- 58:16your personality. And that's what I got for you
- 58:20today. Thank you for for having me.
- 58:24Thank you so much. Thank you.
- 58:27Let's bring all the guests, the speakers on the stage again.
- 58:39Here we are. Hello again.
- 58:47Well, before we dive into Q and AI, would like to remind to
- 58:51everyone guys that you really have to sign up to receive the
- 58:56booty bag for our speakers and at Mirana buccanet dot Mailer
- 59:01page dot IO. So please do that in order for
- 59:04you to receive all the material that we you have seen today and
- 59:10much more than that. Yeah.
- 59:13You, you. You'll never guess what's in the
- 59:15goodie bag. Yes, exactly.
- 59:19Precisely, Yes, good point. I just realized not the free
- 59:23slide, but but but I guess that's part of the goodie bag,
- 59:25yeah. True.
- 59:27So by the way, I have this this comment from LinkedIn actually
- 59:35from someone who says when it comes to eye writing, the range
- 59:40actually gets narrow as we have regression to the mean.
- 59:45At least we get average outcomes, definitely nothing
- 59:49about our outstanding. What do you think about this
- 59:54guys? Yes.
- 1:00:00I acknowledge that if we are not good at using the systems, if we
- 1:00:06do very basic prompting, we will quite likely get to an average
- 1:00:11answer, an average tone of voice and average whatever.
- 1:00:14But I think that if we introduce sources, if we make sure that
- 1:00:19the system actually asks questions to people, if we
- 1:00:22actually take control and put our own perspective to it, I
- 1:00:27still think that we can generate something that is not just an
- 1:00:31average of what is already there.
- 1:00:33But it does take the work. It does take the consciousness,
- 1:00:36It does take well, basically also the friction built into it.
- 1:00:41So when doing it properly, I still think we can remain
- 1:00:45humans. Somebody else want to add
- 1:00:50something? Sure, sure.
- 1:00:52I can add something. I mean, yeah, I think, you know,
- 1:00:58it depends also what, what AI writing we're talking about.
- 1:01:02Yeah. I mean, if, if it's a reminder
- 1:01:06that I need to be at location X at time Y, you know, an an
- 1:01:12average mean is, is great. I mean, if it's if it's
- 1:01:17simplistic, rudimentary messages, yeah, I think average
- 1:01:21is actually kind of good. I think a reflection is that
- 1:01:26this sort of progression to the average, there's a lot of
- 1:01:30cultural factors that also pushes us into that, into that
- 1:01:38direction. I mean, if you look at sort of
- 1:01:39big Hollywood productions, for instance, it goes through a very
- 1:01:43systematic process with writers, reviews, test audiences,
- 1:01:48screenings. Yeah.
- 1:01:50And, and there's been a lot of talk about that process in and
- 1:01:53of itself has actually narrowed the, the type of, of Hollywood
- 1:01:58movies that sort of, if you've seen one, you, you, you'd seen
- 1:02:01them all. Yeah.
- 1:02:04So I think sort of, there's a lot of other things that can
- 1:02:06cause regression to the mean in, in, in, in writing.
- 1:02:11I, I think that one of the things that is interesting about
- 1:02:16AI is now that we're moving into sort of developing even larger
- 1:02:20large language models. Yeah, the requirement for data
- 1:02:25becomes even, even even larger. So where are we going to get
- 1:02:30that data from? Some people say the answer is
- 1:02:33synthetic data. So we make an AI create sort of,
- 1:02:37you know, manuals and we proofread them all, have some
- 1:02:40sort of quality control. And then we do that.
- 1:02:43Or we have sort of that interesting notion right now
- 1:02:46where I think it's a couple of the big AI players, you know,
- 1:02:50they're buying up old books in order to get unique data that
- 1:02:54nobody else has because you want to find sort of that unique data
- 1:02:59set that that nobody else has. I agree with course general
- 1:03:03answer though, that we're talking AI writing sort of in
- 1:03:06terms of competence development, reference text, good
- 1:03:11instructions. So basically being the editor of
- 1:03:16your own writing then then a writer, that can go a long way.
- 1:03:21But then again, if we flip that back to sort of the question
- 1:03:25the, the, the theme for today, identity, this this mean we'll
- 1:03:30all think of ourselves as editors of our writing rather
- 1:03:33than writers. Yeah.
- 1:03:37That's a good point. Well, actually guys, this is
- 1:03:41towards all of you, but to be completely honest, it's more
- 1:03:45towards used. I want to challenge you deeply
- 1:03:50because you are talking specifically about the current
- 1:03:52generation Gen. Z and the future generation Gen.
- 1:03:56Alpha, right? So my reflection is about that.
- 1:04:01So as we all might know by now that every generation has
- 1:04:06encountered technology that's change work, right?
- 1:04:09But generative AI may be usual unusual because it enters
- 1:04:16directly into one of the processes through which identity
- 1:04:20develops, which is the experience of becoming good at
- 1:04:25something, right? Don't you think, used that this
- 1:04:29might be or become an identity crisis?
- 1:04:33Or do you think it's simply another historical change in
- 1:04:37what professional competences means?
- 1:04:42The easy answer to that question, Mirela, is yes.
- 1:04:47I mean both at the same time with varying strengths.
- 1:04:51Yeah. So I mean, I've been, I've been,
- 1:04:56I've been thinking a lot about sort of how to use AI for
- 1:04:59learning. And I've been reading a lot of
- 1:05:02the research on this. And in general, sort of, you
- 1:05:05know, the the research right now part sort of seems to suggest
- 1:05:11that we can we can have good results for learning with AI for
- 1:05:15adult learners. So my typical student will be
- 1:05:202122 year old Samsung. Yeah.
- 1:05:24But if you go lower, yeah, 9 year olds, 10 year olds, 12 year
- 1:05:29olds, 15 year olds, early teens, then the answer is that right
- 1:05:35now AI seems to be harming a lot more than it seems to be
- 1:05:38helping. Yeah.
- 1:05:40There was a study that came out two weeks ago where the research
- 1:05:47that they'd followed sort of thousands of Chinese kids from
- 1:05:55ages of of nine up to 15. And, and what they found was
- 1:06:01that overall, the, the general sort of national administered
- 1:06:05tests, the Dalco and so such it fell.
- 1:06:09And I mean this, this has also been reported in national news.
- 1:06:12This is the thing. So standards seem to be slipping
- 1:06:15and, and, and, and where they seem to be slipping are
- 1:06:19specifically for the students that use AI to solve the
- 1:06:21homework and then, you know, don't do anything else.
- 1:06:26There is, however, also evidence that in that study that seems to
- 1:06:32be a segment that uses AI for learning.
- 1:06:35But here comes the kicker, The things that makes me a little
- 1:06:37depressed or worried, those that use AI in a learning manner and
- 1:06:43they only get as good a learning as without AI.
- 1:06:47Yeah, they don't surpass the the reference group of the students
- 1:06:52who are studying without AI. They simply match them, which
- 1:06:57and they use as much time, you know, on homework, on on
- 1:07:01studying. And so I think that there's a
- 1:07:05there's a there's a that is where I think we see, we see the
- 1:07:08problem on this one. Yeah.
- 1:07:09What? About you guys, what do you,
- 1:07:14what are your thoughts in regards to this Yes.
- 1:07:19I think just has a strong point and I think I can add on top
- 1:07:26that if using the system properly, if knowing what is our
- 1:07:30starting point, what is our own perspective, what is our own
- 1:07:33identity, our own standpoint and everything.
- 1:07:36It is possible to use the systems to also understand
- 1:07:41others, to make sure that it's easier for others to understand
- 1:07:46the communication that that we try to get through.
- 1:07:49I, I, I know as as a, as a professional IT trainer, AI
- 1:07:55trainer, whatever you call it, that if I go to a certain
- 1:07:58company with a certain speciality, well, I might have
- 1:08:02to adjust my, my communication in order for, for, for, for the
- 1:08:06communication to actually work out, I need to do my
- 1:08:09preparation, which is much easier with these tools.
- 1:08:12So I think that is also can help us really understanding each
- 1:08:16other if we do the work and if we still are true to what we
- 1:08:21what we are and who we are as humans.
- 1:08:24Of course, with, with, with my age and my current experience,
- 1:08:28independently of, of technology, it's a different situation than
- 1:08:32the youngest generations. But at least for me, I mean, I,
- 1:08:36I have children who are in their early 20s now, sometimes it's
- 1:08:42hard for me to understand what is their worldview, how do they
- 1:08:46see things? And sometimes technology can
- 1:08:49actually help me tuning in so we can have a better dialogue.
- 1:08:53So I think kind of goes both ways, but it's about using it
- 1:08:58properly. What are your thoughts in
- 1:09:02regards to this? I'm curious.
- 1:09:05Yeah, well, like I said, you have to, you have to use it
- 1:09:12properly to get the the right things, what you what you want.
- 1:09:17I have also been looking into the kind of writing I use it
- 1:09:21always too. And before I have wrote many,
- 1:09:28many, many things also some books and I got some writing
- 1:09:36skills also. And I write in many different
- 1:09:41ways also. It's coming in.
- 1:09:43Is, is it fiction? Is it about gardening?
- 1:09:48Is it about psychology and anything like this?
- 1:09:53And also with the with the words and pronunciation and and this
- 1:09:58kind of stuff, you can contain the, the AI to write like you.
- 1:10:05And it's already a problem for for many, also for for for those
- 1:10:11like like used when they managed to to do this.
- 1:10:19So it don't look like machine writing, but it it can't be in
- 1:10:25any case, it can't be what you call it.
- 1:10:29That can be can be really authentic like like this.
- 1:10:36You will want to write it to, but it also can find some
- 1:10:39sentences you you never have wrote like this.
- 1:10:45So and also and then this, if you read it to what it's a
- 1:10:50wrote, you'll be become better in writing this kind of
- 1:10:56different languages pronunciations too.
- 1:11:01So you copy the machine, copy you and you copy the machine and
- 1:11:06you format it's again the loop, you know, and it's going to be,
- 1:11:12I don't know, it's going yeah, like it's it's going to be this
- 1:11:20kind of what you call it average.
- 1:11:27Yes, yes to. To, to build on that toast.
- 1:11:30And I mean, there was an article from the chairman of the Danish
- 1:11:35Pupils Association last month where he wrote that he believed
- 1:11:41a lot of students or pupils in the high school in, in, in
- 1:11:45Denmark would use a prompt. Like, please insert 2 to 3 minor
- 1:11:51mistakes in this paper and make the writing a little bit more
- 1:11:55garbled so it sounds more like a high school student.
- 1:12:00We can do anything with a prompt, right.
- 1:12:02But, but in terms of identity formation, you know what, what
- 1:12:05the hell are these young people doing to themselves here?
- 1:12:08You know, please make it, please make it more bad.
- 1:12:11So it's like more B, Yeah. Indeed so true.
- 1:12:16Well there is a LinkedIn user saying.
- 1:12:18I agree on the last point, which means the input of the user
- 1:12:22themselves is what makes a piece of AI outcome better or at least
- 1:12:27different than the average. What do you think guys?
- 1:12:33Well, to take the professor angle on it then that we just
- 1:12:39got the, we just got the person's definition of better.
- 1:12:42Yeah, if better is more like me, then obviously more reference
- 1:12:47text equals better. Yeah, if you have reference
- 1:12:52text, if you have, if you're able to formulate inputs, that's
- 1:12:56where I sometimes see young people struggling.
- 1:12:58They don't even know what the range of of choices that they
- 1:13:05can choose between are. Yeah, over to you Core.
- 1:13:10I can also see, I mean, CA I so many places it can be Jetti
- 1:13:16Gemini, whatever it's called. But I can also see when, when,
- 1:13:19when I study languages. I've I've been interested in
- 1:13:22languages for so many years. It is as it is actually a way of
- 1:13:27also understanding people and understanding culture.
- 1:13:30Currently, I'm trying to improve my, my, my French and I'm using
- 1:13:33the, the, the app called Duolingo.
- 1:13:35And nowadays it is has a subscription where I do spoken
- 1:13:40exercises where it actually little by little gets to know
- 1:13:44me, gets to know about my interests and what I do
- 1:13:46professionally and, and, and simulates A dialogue.
- 1:13:50And I think that way of making it tailor made is so much more
- 1:13:54efficient than if I was to do a very generic language study.
- 1:14:01Of course, there, there is a basic vocabulary needed, but the
- 1:14:05one needed specifically for for for my purpose, I find it quite
- 1:14:10efficient that that that AI can support me in that.
- 1:14:13But then again, of course, I've chosen that exact service.
- 1:14:16I've chosen that exact subscription.
- 1:14:18I could choose another service if it did not serve me well
- 1:14:21enough. So, so I think that that the way
- 1:14:24of, of also building it into other products in order to serve
- 1:14:29us a well. I mean, for me, it really helped
- 1:14:32me out when this summer, I was actually visiting friend France
- 1:14:35and, and, and, and suddenly I was communicating face to face
- 1:14:39with, with people because I, I had the the help from, from,
- 1:14:43from this service, including AI. I find it quite fascinating.
- 1:14:49Someone on LinkedIn again said that indeed.
- 1:14:52And that is why the average Hollywood movie, it's a failure
- 1:14:57only the top few percent succeeds in or achieve a break
- 1:15:02even. Yeah, I have a question for
- 1:15:07Chosen someone asked on social media tours.
- 1:15:11And how can we tell if AI is generally reducing our cognitive
- 1:15:15load, or if the constant speed and availability is actually
- 1:15:20keeping our nervous system in a state of hidden chronic
- 1:15:24ulterness? Yeah, well, it's like told you
- 1:15:32have to, you have to to make these passes so you don't
- 1:15:42overwhelm your, your body if your body is already stressed
- 1:15:46out. It's very, it's very interesting
- 1:15:51to get the next answer for, for this, but but it can also give
- 1:15:58your nervous system more alarm or whatever.
- 1:16:02It depends on the situation you are in right now.
- 1:16:08If you're working with this, you can also make some make some
- 1:16:17stop some some breaks. You have to do it make some so
- 1:16:25it can regulate instead of make your nervous system more more
- 1:16:31pressed if it gave makes sense. Actually regarding to this
- 1:16:38matter to assume you have another question which is kind
- 1:16:41of related, someone says you talk about AI as a cognitive
- 1:16:46lift. What is 1 physical or somatic
- 1:16:49warning sign that tells us we need to step away from the
- 1:16:53screen and rest our nervous system?
- 1:17:00Well, it depends on what you are working in rights if if it makes
- 1:17:07sense, if you were a kind of of a session with the with the with
- 1:17:14the direction and you have to become kind of state in your in
- 1:17:20your body, you you have to always continue.
- 1:17:24That's that's right. But but if you are very what's
- 1:17:29what's you call it very, very pressed take those poses and if
- 1:17:42you if you if you were going to going to if you if you feel it
- 1:17:46and your body is is kind of if you feel it here, right here or
- 1:17:51or something else, if you very it's go deep inside.
- 1:17:55You have to to to take the this kind of time for yourself so it
- 1:18:00can land. If it doesn't land, you have
- 1:18:04some chaos in your in your in your system and you don't really
- 1:18:11comprehend what you are thinking or what you have to ask the the
- 1:18:20next question about this is going to affect the next
- 1:18:24question you're asking. And then then you have the
- 1:18:29answering right in your nervous system again in this profound
- 1:18:35way. And then you are just going in
- 1:18:40this loop again again again. It also if you if you're, it
- 1:18:45also can give you some dopamine if you think you were but being
- 1:18:51seeing of from from the machine as some somebody seeing you.
- 1:18:57But this is a machine, but it feel right.
- 1:19:00It feel good, but it's it's it's not a human.
- 1:19:04It's a machine that gives you the the kind of feeling and this
- 1:19:10gives you dopamine and then you are you are going to be some
- 1:19:16kind of addicted to it and then you again turn it on and then
- 1:19:23it's yeah, the loop. It's it's a kind of it can can
- 1:19:30go both ways. It can harm and then can it can
- 1:19:34be a good addiction if it can say yourself yes, I hope it can
- 1:19:39make sense. I think it made great sense.
- 1:19:43Could could I add to that Marilla?
- 1:19:44Yeah, sure. Please.
- 1:19:46Do that. Yeah.
- 1:19:47Because I think, I think, Torsten, I'd like to introduce
- 1:19:49the the concept of prompt baiting here.
- 1:19:54Prompt baiting for me. That's when an AI finishes an
- 1:19:58answer with, you know, but if you ask for this and this, I
- 1:20:02could do this and this or, you know, here is a draft e-mail.
- 1:20:05But look, should I try to make the even smarter version of that
- 1:20:09e-mail? Yeah.
- 1:20:11And so it's it's baiting you into firing off another prompt.
- 1:20:16And a lot of a is ChatGPT especially.
- 1:20:19They do this. Yeah.
- 1:20:20I think Claude is actually even worse.
- 1:20:22And they do it, of course, because they want you to keep on
- 1:20:24prompting. Yeah.
- 1:20:26So, you know, like news, news media uses click bait to get us
- 1:20:30to click on it. Well, AI companies uses prompt
- 1:20:33bait. Yeah.
- 1:20:34And I think this is where AI challenges the cognitive load of
- 1:20:39people who are anxious. AI forces us to be very hard
- 1:20:44about when is something good enough.
- 1:20:47Yeah. And I think that's something for
- 1:20:50for for established professionals like us, that we
- 1:20:53have an easy time with it. But when I look at my students,
- 1:20:56you know, who are learning about something, they struggle with
- 1:21:01this part especially, you know, when is something good enough?
- 1:21:04Because they don't know. They have a lack of reference
- 1:21:08that that we have throughout our years of experience.
- 1:21:12And I think people who are in situations where they are
- 1:21:14uncertain about, you know, when something is good enough or you
- 1:21:18know, for for whatever reason, the personality has a tendency
- 1:21:22to keep challenging themselves to make it just, you know, 1%
- 1:21:26better all, all the time. Well, AI is going to be a hell
- 1:21:29for them. That's a that's an extreme
- 1:21:33position, but you know, that's out there.
- 1:21:35Paul, the counterpoint from you maybe well.
- 1:21:36We are here to debate as well, so thank you for that.
- 1:21:40Doing that, yeah, yeah. Definitely.
- 1:21:41Well, I'm I've, I've, I've, I've, I've I've get that point
- 1:21:46and and and I think there is an important topic to it.
- 1:21:50In some situations, I think it's actually it magnifies what was
- 1:21:54already there. I remember years back at at a
- 1:22:00business conference, there was a very successful American
- 1:22:05businessman on on the scene. And he said from, from the scene
- 1:22:08to, to the audience, I was one of, of, of, of people in the
- 1:22:11audience that what in business life is called success is what
- 1:22:16this school system calls cheating.
- 1:22:18Because in business life, you try to get as, as quick as
- 1:22:22possible to, to, to the solution and move on to the next thing
- 1:22:26and, and do things efficiently. In the school system, you will
- 1:22:30often be rewarded by spending the time available for doing the
- 1:22:34exam or doing the assignment and digging even deeper and so on.
- 1:22:38And of course, that's it. That's good with the learning
- 1:22:41process. But it seems that there is a
- 1:22:43shift from the, the study life to to the professional life.
- 1:22:47And, and I've seen it during the, the years independently of
- 1:22:51technology, I sometimes had the interns in my company and, and
- 1:22:55it seemed that they wanted to get a school assignment and they
- 1:22:58wanted to get a school grade, but, but that's not necessarily
- 1:23:02how business life works. And now it seems that AI is
- 1:23:06magnifying that. So, so it seems to be an
- 1:23:10existing dynamic and, and now it has gotten even further.
- 1:23:14I think that students will probably use it differently than
- 1:23:17than professionals in in many situations.
- 1:23:21Yeah. And and, and to add to that, I
- 1:23:24mean, Mark and I, we're we're sort of putting the finishers
- 1:23:27touches to a book where we argue that performance and learning is
- 1:23:31sort of becoming opposites with AI.
- 1:23:34We can perform quite quickly if that's our goal, but that
- 1:23:38minimises the learning and vice versa.
- 1:23:43So sometimes I say to my students when they work in
- 1:23:45groups, if your goal here is performance, then you figure out
- 1:23:49who in the group is best suited for each task, and you let them
- 1:23:52do it. So the guy that knows most about
- 1:23:54CEO, well, he does that part of it.
- 1:23:56The guy that does most about knows most about coding.
- 1:23:58He does that part of it. Yeah.
- 1:24:00But if your goal is learning, your setup should be totally
- 1:24:03different. You can pick the guy in the
- 1:24:05group that's the worst of coding and make him do the coding
- 1:24:08because he has the biggest learning need.
- 1:24:10But yeah, we'd never do that in a company.
- 1:24:12We'd never hire sort of, you know, the the worst IT expert to
- 1:24:16teacher. Of course, we'd never go to the
- 1:24:18to the to the worst psychology, you know, a psychologist to to
- 1:24:22make him learn, right. I mean, because we need
- 1:24:24delivery, we need performance. So I think, you know,
- 1:24:27performance and and learning becomes enemies with AI.
- 1:24:32Over to you, Torsten. Maybe?
- 1:24:35Yeah, well, I thought just came in mind about the the perfection
- 1:24:40you're you talked about, about the the people who are anxious
- 1:24:47and, and this kind of stuff. I have, I have some deep trauma
- 1:24:52about this PTSD and this kind of things and what I, what I, what
- 1:24:59I see in this, I have some trauma response and what, what
- 1:25:07this is is it's never going to be perfect enough.
- 1:25:11It should be absolutely perfect because if I make it wrong, it,
- 1:25:17it turns against me and, and and so on and so on.
- 1:25:22And this kind of question or push the AI do can be very
- 1:25:33harmful if you ain't aware of the trauma response.
- 1:25:39So so again, like always nearly answered the next question about
- 1:25:49this kind of if you can keep the strong personal identity.
- 1:25:57Yes you can. If you to build your own
- 1:26:00architecture in into the AII think it's going to, it's can be
- 1:26:06manageable in in this way, yes. We have a question from Pizza
- 1:26:13Real Estate. Thank you so very much for your
- 1:26:16question. It's it's asked, do you think
- 1:26:19people can use AI heavily while still maintaining a strong sense
- 1:26:23of personal identity? And, and I think this is where I
- 1:26:30would like to use Torsten's own presentation against him because
- 1:26:34Torsten, you said that if I understood you correctly,
- 1:26:37identity is something that is claimed, it's something that's
- 1:26:41practice and it's something that that is confirmed.
- 1:26:45Yeah. But if we're using AI to do
- 1:26:48stuff in terms of our professional identity, well,
- 1:26:51we're no longer really practising it, are we?
- 1:26:56Oh, then you are, I think are you protecting and you are you
- 1:27:05can't really see the difference, tell the difference.
- 1:27:15This is this is a problem with the the AII think what what is
- 1:27:20mine and what is coming from the machine, the AI, this kind of
- 1:27:26stuff. You have to maybe you have to
- 1:27:33take it, take it parts. Maybe it's 2% of me and the rest
- 1:27:37is machine. I think it's maybe it's better
- 1:27:41to to look in in this way and because I think many have this
- 1:27:47kind of experience. Oh, I just just found something
- 1:27:53new out. No, you don't.
- 1:27:56The machine has because of you have asked a question.
- 1:28:02As we have a question from Rochelle, she asked, do you
- 1:28:05think identity will eventually become something partly Co
- 1:28:09created between humans and AI rather than something formed
- 1:28:14entirely by human experience? Yes, correct.
- 1:28:16Please. We're going to go a little bit
- 1:28:19further from our time deadline, but I hope you give us guys.
- 1:28:25I would like to answer to all this question if it's if it's
- 1:28:28possible. Thank you for your.
- 1:28:31I think it's a great question for start and I think we should
- 1:28:34first start distinguish between the professional identity where
- 1:28:39many of us depend on tools and and I mean it need not be
- 1:28:43digital tools for my case, it's often digital tools, but others
- 1:28:47will depend on on on a range or a book or whatever the tools.
- 1:28:52So, I mean, in a professional we often do depend on tools, and
- 1:28:56nowadays we have these very strong and very flexible tools.
- 1:29:00But I think that it's important from that point to make sure
- 1:29:04that the personal identity is still personal.
- 1:29:08At least I, I try for myself very hard to make sure that yes,
- 1:29:13I do have the professional identity, but that's only a part
- 1:29:16of me. When I'm not at work, I'm still
- 1:29:19the person that I am. I still interact with other
- 1:29:21people. I still try to behave OK, I'm
- 1:29:24still curious. I like to go in to the nature
- 1:29:28and do things that is totally independent of my professional
- 1:29:32identity. So I think it's important to
- 1:29:35have that fundament that is independent of tools, being a
- 1:29:41digital AI, whatever. And then we can build whatever
- 1:29:45identity on top. And of course, for student it
- 1:29:48can be a different story. But once again, we navigate in
- 1:29:51in different areas during a day, during a week, during a life.
- 1:29:57Yeah, we. Have another question?
- 1:29:59From could I, could I, just before we, we go on, could I add
- 1:30:02to that? Sorry, because I, I just wanted
- 1:30:04to add that when it comes to professional identity, I think
- 1:30:07we, we, we are way past eventually.
- 1:30:09I think people's professional identities are being shaped by
- 1:30:14the AI systems that they use today.
- 1:30:17And I mean, maybe if we get a few years down the line, then in
- 1:30:21the same way that we had, you know, the PC tribe, the Mac
- 1:30:25tribe, maybe we'll have the claw tribe, the, the ChatGPT type.
- 1:30:30And maybe we'll get to a point where we can sort of spot.
- 1:30:32Oh, you've been using a Chinese AI to write that answer, haven't
- 1:30:36you? I don't know.
- 1:30:39But but I think, you know, we are.
- 1:30:42I would say we're already seeing signs that professional
- 1:30:45identities are being shaped by by A and the sign specifically
- 1:30:49that we're already seeing is this globalization in hyperdrive
- 1:30:52that I talked about earlier. We have a question from Kelly.
- 1:30:57Thank you, Kelly so much deeply for this question.
- 1:31:00I think is brilliant. How can organization encourage
- 1:31:03people to use AI without allowing AI to become the
- 1:31:06default decision maker? Please, guys, answer is it's
- 1:31:10really a good, good question. Yes.
- 1:31:16I mean that a lot in in in my role as an AI trainer, I, I
- 1:31:21serve many big organizations. Currently, I serve a public
- 1:31:25organization and they are still responsible for what they do.
- 1:31:32They can use whatever tools they can look up in books, they can
- 1:31:36ask colleagues, and they can of course use AI nowadays, but they
- 1:31:40still are responsible and they need to document how they reach
- 1:31:45that conclusion. And I think it's a very strong
- 1:31:49standing point that yes, you can use whatever aids and please use
- 1:31:54efficient and modern aids, but you're the one in charge At the
- 1:31:59end of the day. We need to have that human in
- 1:32:01the loop. We, we, we still need to make
- 1:32:03sure that the human can take responsibility for whatever is
- 1:32:07being done. I think that's a healthy
- 1:32:10principle. And maybe to, to, to, to add on
- 1:32:14that, I mean, if we go back to Max Viber's concept of the, the
- 1:32:19iron cage of rationality, you know, if we, if we start
- 1:32:23defining rules for decision making, you know, where we state
- 1:32:28logics, how can we prevent those logics from forcing us to make
- 1:32:33certain decisions that we just can't argue against?
- 1:32:37And I think sort of in, in a way as, as I think both you call and
- 1:32:43Torsten mentioned before, AI is, is putting power to something
- 1:32:48that's there already. And I think in organisations,
- 1:32:51what we're going to see is that organisations that have good
- 1:32:53decision making process where they have humans in the loop at
- 1:32:57the right times, they will not fall into the threat.
- 1:33:00But the organisations that that have, shall we say, are less
- 1:33:05thought through decision making processes in practice.
- 1:33:08Yeah, they are going to struggle with this enormously.
- 1:33:16That's so interesting. We have another good question
- 1:33:18from Clayton. Thank you so much, Clayton.
- 1:33:21He asked, do you think people can use AI heavily while still
- 1:33:24maintaining a strong sense of personal identity?
- 1:33:27Oh, that's a good one. Thank you, Clayton.
- 1:33:32Yes, guys, who wants to nobody. Well, I mean, you, you, you
- 1:33:38would have a strong professional identity, I guess, as an AI
- 1:33:40user, right. That's, that's the easy answer
- 1:33:44to Clayton's question. But.
- 1:33:47But I think, you know, to break it down, I mean, Clayton is
- 1:33:49asking specifically about a personal identity.
- 1:33:53Yeah. And again, you know, as Torsten
- 1:33:57was saying before, you know, personal identity, where's that
- 1:33:59form from? You know, the claims we make,
- 1:34:01what we practice, what we, what we see being confirmed by
- 1:34:05others. Yeah, so I think you could still
- 1:34:08in a personal sense easily have that.
- 1:34:10But you know, how many of us use AI deeply into to our our
- 1:34:14personal as opposed to our professional identity?
- 1:34:18I mean, I, I don't I don't ask chat TPT on how to parent my my
- 1:34:24two boys, right. I go other places for for good
- 1:34:28advice on on that. Yeah, but I guess, you know, if
- 1:34:32you had people who did that, well, you know, maybe yeah, but
- 1:34:37I think personal identity for me that would that that is still a
- 1:34:42holdout. But I I'm an educator, you know,
- 1:34:45so I look at people forming professional identities and
- 1:34:48there I think it is sadly a very different story we.
- 1:34:54Have yes. Co Yeah.
- 1:34:57At least among the people that I meet on on the way and many are
- 1:35:02more or less my age. Many have a professional
- 1:35:06interest in in AII see a growing interest in personal
- 1:35:10development. Fortunately, I see many people
- 1:35:13in this area doing meditation, doing yoga, doing whatever is,
- 1:35:19is, is part of shaping yourself in order to, to also be true to
- 1:35:24yourself. I mean, for, for my own part,
- 1:35:26I'm, I'm a Freemason, which is also related to, to personal
- 1:35:30development. So I think that we, we, we
- 1:35:35somehow if, if we succeed in balancing the life in order to
- 1:35:40be efficient, being curious, but also being curious independently
- 1:35:47of those digital tools and the speed and, and, and the way it
- 1:35:51tries to, to drag us. I think it it it, it, it gives
- 1:35:54us a much better life, a much healthier self really.
- 1:36:02Maybe maybe just a there are just a small add to what caused
- 1:36:05that here, because I think sort of in terms of of of the
- 1:36:09personal identity as well. I think one thing, and I believe
- 1:36:13that for adults at least, you know, AI is both, you know,
- 1:36:16affecting it, but it's also giving people opportunities that
- 1:36:20they did not have before. I mean, Google glasses, they've
- 1:36:23had a lot of bad press. But, you know, let's think
- 1:36:25about, you know, that they help blind people see literally.
- 1:36:28Yeah. But I think sort of there's in
- 1:36:30in a lot of softer cases, AI is also giving people options to
- 1:36:34express their personality, to be somebody to to practice
- 1:36:37something that they could not have done before.
- 1:36:39And I think I looked at at Torsten here, who's published a
- 1:36:43couple of rap songs, right, as a colleges by day, a rapper by
- 1:36:46night. And forgive me for saying so,
- 1:36:49Jorsten, but you know, AI helped you do that.
- 1:36:52And with if there hadn't been AI potentially we'd never have the
- 1:36:56world would never have known your skills as a rapper.
- 1:36:59Yeah. Not so, not so professional.
- 1:37:06But personal, I did not. Yeah, personal.
- 1:37:08Yeah, but the avatar? Yeah, but but there must be a
- 1:37:11lot of people out there who has a dream of, you know, if only I
- 1:37:14could make a rap song, if only I could write a sci-fi novel, if
- 1:37:19only I could make a painting. And all of a sudden with AI,
- 1:37:21well, you don't have to Daydream about it either.
- 1:37:24You can make something and you know, maybe it's not going to be
- 1:37:27the defining thing, but you can, you can dream much more vividly.
- 1:37:32Yeah, definitely. Yes, I can.
- 1:37:36Well, much indeed. Well I call the AI Aladdin Slam
- 1:37:412 point O, but you have to, but you have to be careful about
- 1:37:47what you are wishing. Maybe you'll get it, maybe it's
- 1:37:51never should be in the world or things like this.
- 1:37:56First time I have meet the AI, I thought, God damn it, the people
- 1:38:03are gonna use it as a psychologist, psychotherapist,
- 1:38:11you know, And then I saw it to have to have to be in have some
- 1:38:18layers over it. So it doesn't tell people some
- 1:38:25stories and then they go after it and then they do something
- 1:38:30wrong and then they pull on the plane to to the AI.
- 1:38:36But it's it's a human who who does all these kind of stuff to
- 1:38:40to themselves with AI and that we have to have some some safety
- 1:38:48layers. Who, who can?
- 1:38:52Who knows when, when, when do I have to stop?
- 1:38:56Over for the human So it doesn't give.
- 1:39:01Yeah, this kind of imagination about who you are.
- 1:39:07We have a really nice question from Nick.
- 1:39:10Thank you so much Nick for your question.
- 1:39:13He asked how can professionals make sure AI straighten their
- 1:39:17real competence instead of creating dependency on tools
- 1:39:21that do the thinking for them. I mean, in a way, Marilla, I
- 1:39:29think this was our episode 2 on, on AI and learning, right?
- 1:39:33So, so, but, but I think Nick's question is, is always very
- 1:39:37relevant. And, and I think the answer we
- 1:39:39came up to in in episode 2, that was basically that if we believe
- 1:39:44that AI separates performance from learning, you need to
- 1:39:47dedicate time to learning. Yeah.
- 1:39:51So you need to sort of define what competence you want to be
- 1:39:54really good at. And then you need to use AI or
- 1:39:57other tools to dedicate yourself to becoming better.
- 1:40:00That what the disconnect that is there now is that if you are say
- 1:40:05a management consultant simply by, you know, right, having an
- 1:40:08AI, right, management consulting reports for you, you're not
- 1:40:11learning in the same way anymore.
- 1:40:14So you need to sort of figure out what key skills you need to
- 1:40:17build up. And you need to have a dedicated
- 1:40:19plan for it. So you need in a way to be to be
- 1:40:22much more conscious about what skills you need and to make
- 1:40:28choices. And again, you know, coming back
- 1:40:30to to the thing that I think Tawson and myself have had some
- 1:40:33good rounds on on today, you know, this places even more
- 1:40:36pressure on you because all of a sudden, you know, you can't
- 1:40:39blame just the system or the company.
- 1:40:41It's it's the choices you made, right?
- 1:40:43And so if it pans out poorly, well, who was the idiot that
- 1:40:46made that decision that you decided to be the expert in this
- 1:40:49one? That's the person looking at you
- 1:40:51in the mirror, right? Someone want to add something
- 1:40:58else guys? It's I, I think that the, the,
- 1:41:04the concept that we depend on tools is not new.
- 1:41:07I mean a farmer depends on a tractor or bricklayer, it
- 1:41:12depends on whatever tools of bricklayers using AI for my own
- 1:41:16part depend on a computer, whatever digital devices.
- 1:41:19And I think that little by little we do get dependent.
- 1:41:25And I also see people. I mean, nowadays a taxi driver
- 1:41:30can enter an address with the GPS and then drive a generation
- 1:41:34back at taxi driver needed to know the streets of Copenhagen
- 1:41:39or whatever city. Nowadays car repair person,
- 1:41:46mechanic can put the scan tool and read out the codes.
- 1:41:50And early on it was about listening to the noises and
- 1:41:52everything. So I think that the the concept
- 1:41:55of depending on tools is not new.
- 1:41:58But now we depend on, I mean the next tool in line, hopefully
- 1:42:02still having our critical sense, hopefully still having our own
- 1:42:06professional judgement, hopefully still being
- 1:42:09responsible for for the the output, no matter if we're using
- 1:42:14one tool or another. I have something that Adventure
- 1:42:19Show says states. I really like the distinction
- 1:42:24between AI reflecting us and AI actually influence us.
- 1:42:29Can you add quickly something about this guys?
- 1:42:31Because I think it's very relevant.
- 1:42:38I think it's much in line with with the presentation from from
- 1:42:42Mark that I mean now what today was presented by me that we as
- 1:42:47long as we distinguish between what is still human and what is
- 1:42:51I mean that digital extension, we should still be on safe
- 1:42:55ground, but it does take awareness.
- 1:42:59We have a question from David. Thank you so much, David.
- 1:43:03Are we becoming more capable through AI or are we simply
- 1:43:08becoming better at producing the appearance of competence?
- 1:43:13That's a good one. It's actually connected to what
- 1:43:16I asked I propose to you guys to answer to, so please go ahead.
- 1:43:21But when? Well, again Mirela, the answer
- 1:43:23here is yes. So, so, So if we define
- 1:43:29capability as as, as output, we can, it's fairly recognised we
- 1:43:35can produce a lot more output than we could before.
- 1:43:38Yeah. The problem is where does all
- 1:43:41this output go? I mean, as, as I think I, I've
- 1:43:45alluded to a couple of times in, in our, you know, meetings on
- 1:43:51the lead up for this, I just published a new book on, on
- 1:43:55digital marketing. And, and one of the things that
- 1:43:57AI and digital tools do is they make digital marketing a lot
- 1:44:01more easily accessible. A lot more people can do it and
- 1:44:03they can do it better and they can do it more.
- 1:44:05You know, having a social media post where you post 10 times
- 1:44:08daily, easy stuff to build an AI that that does that.
- 1:44:12And you know, as Cor will tell you, the more prompts, the more
- 1:44:14reference text you put in, the better it will be at putting
- 1:44:17stuff out there. But you know, it's there.
- 1:44:19But what's happening in marketing is strangely enough
- 1:44:21then that because everybody can do this and do this cheaply,
- 1:44:27marketing seems to pivot back to what the AI can't do because
- 1:44:31that becomes the differentiator. All you go deeper into that
- 1:44:35point. Thank you.
- 1:44:36Because you brought it up. Yeah.
- 1:44:37Thank you. Yeah, no, no with you.
- 1:44:40Yeah, because all of a sudden I've never gotten as many
- 1:44:44invites to professional events as I have this year because that
- 1:44:50one of the things where AI can't come in.
- 1:44:52So I mean, I think you know what we're having and and I know I'm
- 1:44:56sort of sidestepping the question a little bit, but but
- 1:44:58but I think sort of, you know, it's changing what competencies
- 1:45:02are are sought after. Yeah, it's nudging at that
- 1:45:06because it's it's taking over some and allowing us all of them
- 1:45:09to make a lot of output there. But then what can't you make a
- 1:45:14lot of output bit with and maybe sort of that's where the the the
- 1:45:18current frontier for for the competition isn't across a lot
- 1:45:25of fields. Yeah.
- 1:45:28So, so yeah, I think you know, it's it's it's it's pushing what
- 1:45:32we define as competence would be would be my answer.
- 1:45:35Col. I also have a question from
- 1:45:40social media from you for you, sorry.
- 1:45:44They asked how much of our professional voice is generally
- 1:45:47ours and how much is becoming shaped by the same global AI
- 1:45:52systems. I think it's so powerful, this
- 1:45:54one. Oh surely.
- 1:45:59And it one thing affects the other and and and and back and
- 1:46:03forth. I mean, nowadays it's about
- 1:46:09staying up to, to, to, to what is the most recent thing.
- 1:46:13And they're making sure that you dig deep enough and making sure
- 1:46:16that you present, present things properly.
- 1:46:20And, and I think somehow we, we, we, we do get dependent on, on
- 1:46:26these tools. But as long as we use them
- 1:46:28properly, I'm, I'm still OK. But it, it is a lot about the
- 1:46:34consciousness. It is a lot about the
- 1:46:35responsibility. It is a lot about the the, the
- 1:46:38human aspect to it. These tools can be so much used
- 1:46:45and so beneficial to us, but they can surely also be misused
- 1:46:50and and the risk is that they drag us in a certain direction.
- 1:46:55It definitely takes human skills, human decisions, human
- 1:47:01responsibility and all of that. Someone we should wrap up
- 1:47:06because we are definitely way beyond the our timeline here.
- 1:47:10I would really love to keep going and going.
- 1:47:13But yeah, I can see also that there are really a lot of people
- 1:47:17showing up today. I'm so happy and thrilled to see
- 1:47:20you all of you guys. So nobody excluded.
- 1:47:24Thank you for your support and being here because I think
- 1:47:27without all all of us, again, nothing can be done without
- 1:47:33human touch and presence. So yeah, one of us.
- 1:47:39So you want to add something else guys in regards to just to
- 1:47:44wrap up everything or? It has been truly a pleasure
- 1:47:51and, and I'm so happy that the Q&A is putting additional
- 1:47:56perspective pleasure to have these good questions and that
- 1:48:00opportunity for, for, for tying it all together.
- 1:48:03There's so many possibilities and there's so many great use
- 1:48:07cases, but it it's about doing the right thing in many aspects.
- 1:48:15Please remember for all of you to sign up to receive the goodie
- 1:48:19bags of today's guest speakers at mirela dot Mailer page dot
- 1:48:25IO. You can find it in the
- 1:48:27description on YouTube, LinkedIn or Facebook.
- 1:48:31Please use that link from the website to subscribe and get
- 1:48:36after right away. After this event will be ended,
- 1:48:39you'll receive all the material. So the surprise materials used
- 1:48:43to just call it right into your directly through your e-mail
- 1:48:48box. Thank you so very much to all of
- 1:48:50you. Again, I don't want to repeat
- 1:48:51myself, but I really, really, I am very honored to see how many
- 1:48:54of you are you here today. So thank you so much.
- 1:48:57It means a lot to me and I'm sure also to my guests because
- 1:49:01this is not just random, random YouTube or LinkedIn.
- 1:49:06Life is really hard work behind all this just to make it happen.
- 1:49:11So again, thank you and we'll keep you updated for the honor
- 1:49:16to put the next episode that we are going to have at the end of
- 1:49:20next month saying thank you and have a really stunning Sunday.
- 1:49:24Thank you.