Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 258:1-7. Tzedakah: Pledges For Charity, Anulling, Consecrating and Redeeming Hekdesh, Ownership and Possession

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 258:1-7. Tzedakah: Pledges For Charity, Anulling, Consecrating and Redeeming Hekdesh, Ownership and Possession · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  OK, good morning. We are in Euro de ho Sedaka
• 0:03
  Reish nun. We are continuing with Siif
• 0:07
  Gimo. Just going to go back a drop to
• 0:10
  Siif Alef. So we need a little bit of
• 0:13
  better clear explanation. The case was within the Rama
• 0:17
  where he says a person was maktish something to haktish
• 0:23
  right the here someone pointed out that the person just uses
• 0:27
  the word truma. So then nowadays that would mean
• 0:30
  any sedaka A person uses the word sedaka.
• 0:33
  It means any sedaka a person that is giving money to Sedaka,
• 0:37
  then he's not. It's the sucking machuva's
• 0:40
  quotes numerous postscheme point out nowadays that we mentioned
• 0:44
  yesterday lashom baneadam. It means any sedaka lav dafka
• 0:47
  for the poor. That's you know, that's when
• 0:50
  that's how we what we mean. We have all kinds of things in
• 0:54
  mind. The case in the Rama when he
• 0:57
  doesn't, when he's. So normally if a person says
• 0:59
  sedaka goes to sedaka and even if a person uses the word
• 1:02
  hectish, it means sedaka. But if the case in the
• 1:06
  Ramallahs, but if he actually specified no, no hectish mamish.
• 1:10
  I'm saying this item belongs to hectish.
• 1:15
  So Khazal tell us famous Salaka amiraso la gavoa misiraso la
• 1:24
  Hedyot. When a person says it belongs to
• 1:26
  Hegdish and it it automatically, it's as if he handed it over to
• 1:31
  Hedyot. So it's either mamish or it's
• 1:34
  similar but not mamish kehedyot. So we'll see you in a second.
• 1:39
  Basically, when a person says that, is that a micekinian or
• 1:44
  not? This this whole halacha in
• 1:46
  general of when you just a verbal say.
• 1:51
  So it seems to be in my hocus. If it's in from, is it from an
• 1:55
  asmatta, the puzzle or is it only MI darabana?
• 1:59
  So the Magid Mishnah says and and the Kasif Mishnah says in
• 2:03
  the Rambam in Mahira Paracet, it's only a it's only Derabana.
• 2:08
  But others seem to say it's a derisa that it belongs, that
• 2:14
  when you when you say it now it belongs to Hedyot.
• 2:21
  It's a question. I would say Shah thrashbat
• 2:25
  stereisa the the Shah. If you want to look at it a
• 2:29
  little bit, he discusses it in Khoshin Mishbat in where is it?
• 2:34
  Reish nun hai Saif vav. That's what he called Sarash,
• 2:38
  but he talks about over there anyways, according to the Gumar
• 2:42
  Nadarim daft kaftat over there, the rush on the page seems to
• 2:46
  say it's only Midin Neda and a person says it's a Mira Lagovoa
• 2:51
  belongs to Hegdesh, only Midin Neda.
• 2:54
  You have to bring it to a you have to, you have to give it to
• 2:57
  the to the to the base on Megdash.
• 3:00
  But the the rush was clear. It's it's, it's a Kenyan, but
• 3:04
  it's not the same as if you hand it over.
• 3:06
  We're going to get to that Zardasham real soon.
• 3:09
  It doesn't make a difference if you hand it over.
• 3:12
  As long as you don't hand it over.
• 3:13
  You can still take it back. You can do kilo Hataras Nadaram
• 3:17
  or Shawal Shawal. It's not Hataras Nadaram.
• 3:19
  But is it Nikola Nadaram? Is it similar to Nadaram?
• 3:24
  Whatever. Just Simply put, you could just
• 3:26
  say it. It's similar, though that might
• 3:28
  be part of the whole explanation.
• 3:30
  But you can, as long as it's only Amira, you said it, you can
• 3:35
  still go back on it. It was it was a maisa Kinian,
• 3:39
  the the Rashba says, and that Paskin's the Shah and Paskin's
• 3:42
  Zaraka Shulkhan. It's Mamish, A Kenyan.
• 3:45
  And that's what it seems like according to well, perhaps
• 3:50
  that's what it means according to the Rama.
• 3:51
  It depends how you understand the Rama.
• 3:53
  So it could be a Kenyan daraisa. Yeah.
• 3:55
  That's the most simply a simple way to understand it's a Kenyan
• 3:59
  Mamish daraisa. But until you actually hand it
• 4:04
  over, we're about to see or you give it to the Gabi Sedaka, for
• 4:07
  example, you give it to the Gabi Hekdish, the Gizbar.
• 4:10
  So then you can still go back on your you can and go back on it.
• 4:14
  How is that possible? So it's either basically like a
• 4:18
  halakhala motion musini, but that's the halakha, just like
• 4:21
  it's the halakhala motion musini.
• 4:23
  That saying makes it transfer ownership.
• 4:26
  So too undoing it. That's a you could do Shoal not
• 4:31
  only by Nadarian, but also by by this concept of amira to heck.
• 4:36
  This you also have this power of shoaling, no time limit.
• 4:40
  We also see a similar principle. We're going to get there soon by
• 4:43
  Truma Hafrasha khala. Even though it's Adindar Isa
• 4:48
  doing Hafrasha, you can still do shoaling and undo Adindar Isa.
• 4:53
  So it's it's not completely foreign to other halachas and
• 4:59
  concepts in the Torah, but so anyway, so there the the shock
• 5:03
  points out interesting. Why can you do?
• 5:05
  How could you undo it? Is this because what's the
• 5:08
  difference? Because dibor is Mavato dibor
• 5:11
  just like you did it the Amira. You can also do shoaling the
• 5:14
  Amira. But once you hand it over and
• 5:16
  you did a Kenyan with Amaisa, then it gets to a point where
• 5:19
  you can't just undo it verbally and you can't undo it anymore.
• 5:22
  And it's more like and then it's more like a head yolt.
• 5:25
  Once you give it over, you can't take it back anymore.
• 5:27
  No trade backs when it comes to Kenyanya.
• 5:30
  Once you give it to the Gizbar, to the balls, to the Gabi Sidaka
• 5:33
  or Gabi head dish, you can't go back anymore.
• 5:35
  We'll see that inside. We'll discuss that if you want
• 5:37
  afterwards. But that's as long as you only.
• 5:40
  It's on a level of D board and araka Shokhan wants to explain
• 5:43
  the the Rashba a little differently than the shock.
• 5:46
  It says it's more like we look at it as if it was hectic.
• 5:49
  Batalt if you're doing shoaling this Torah gives you a
• 5:53
  permission to look at it as if it was done Batalt then you can
• 5:56
  still go back. So anyways, a couple different
• 5:58
  ways to understand it. I'll just throw in real quick
• 6:04
  interesting. And the mission of Bura seems to
• 6:06
  possible that it's a Manish, A Kenyan, presumably the Raisa
• 6:10
  more like the like the Rashba. And how has that come up And
• 6:13
  Shin Vog Sivkat and Kav Zain regarding if you want to donate
• 6:18
  a safer on Shabbos to the base to the Beit Knesset.
• 6:24
  So just saying so he says you can't make a Kenyan, right?
• 6:28
  I mean, there are a bun and we don't do Kenyanyon on Shabbos.
• 6:30
  Certainly for things that you're not going to be using on
• 6:32
  Shabbos, if it's something that's usable, maybe you can
• 6:35
  pull separate topic we've learned before, but something
• 6:38
  that you're not going to use and or it's not usable necessarily
• 6:42
  and you're giving it as a as a Kenyan or maybe just by food,
• 6:47
  it's OK, But whatever you want to make a Kenyan, you want to
• 6:49
  give a safer to a bait Knesset on Shabbos.
• 6:52
  So just say this safer now belongs to the bait to the bait
• 6:55
  Knesset. He says you're not allowed to do
• 6:57
  that on Shabbos because just saying so is Mama Shekinian.
• 7:03
  And then the flip side on air of Shabbos at home, you can say
• 7:06
  this belongs to the bait Knesset and therefore just saying it
• 7:10
  belongs to be connected. The Kenyan happened air Shabbos.
• 7:13
  Then on Shabbos, if there's an Arab, you can walk over and
• 7:15
  carry it with you and bring it to the bring it to the shop.
• 7:18
  So that's, that's just a tiny little there.
• 7:22
  Now the other concept over here again, it's we're going to get
• 7:25
  there soon. Pigeon.
• 7:29
  Are you allowed to do pigeon on hectish?
• 7:32
  So I know we're digressing just to drop more pigeon on head
• 7:36
  dish. So the halacha normally says
• 7:38
  Bisman based on migdash, it's us or to do pigeon unless you add a
• 7:43
  fifth, right? If, if it's your own, if you're
• 7:46
  opposed to your own item, you have to add 1/5 to it.
• 7:50
  But when there's no based on migdash, it's going to go to
• 7:54
  waste. So that was that was a question
• 7:57
  over here the the Rama says if you made something hagdish
• 8:00
  mamish, the only way out is to do shoalings.
• 8:03
  The shock pointed out there's another way and that is pidion.
• 8:07
  So he said maybe according to the Rama doesn't hold the
• 8:09
  pidion. Maybe it's only by metaltoline,
• 8:11
  I mean by karka, but postchem the Rambam, others seem to say
• 8:15
  it definitely does work on metaltoline as well.
• 8:19
  You know, so nowadays, and this is in a few places anyways Araki
• 8:25
  and we're going to see it later on.
• 8:26
  When it comes to Maister Shani nowadays, even though you're not
• 8:32
  Lakhatili, you're not supposed to when it's when there is no
• 8:36
  based on Migdash Lakhatila, you're allowed to be put at
• 8:40
  something on a Shava pruta or on a pruta.
• 8:46
  And the Gemara, even if it has it's 100 zoos, it has a value of
• 8:50
  whatever it is. It doesn't matter any value.
• 8:52
  You could be put a A on the Gemara clearly says Shabba pruta
• 8:56
  mahukas, Shmuel Rabiuda. But can you do it on a pruta
• 9:00
  mamish and or does it have to be on Dalitzusim?
• 9:03
  Just so that just to make it more obvious that that we have
• 9:07
  to be stripped by heckfish or things that are Maister Shani.
• 9:13
  That's that's sugia. But without getting into it,
• 9:15
  well, Maisudhara Khashoghan says you could even do pigeon on
• 9:19
  metaltoline of any value on a pruta.
• 9:24
  Yeah, when there's no base on megdash because we don't want to
• 9:26
  lose the value. But nowadays, if you can't use
• 9:29
  it, there's no base on megdash, you're just wasting the value.
• 9:31
  I I donated a table. Now it's just sitting here and
• 9:34
  it's it's a waste or it's going to be a niche.
• 9:36
  All other people or money, whatever it is, you can take
• 9:39
  that large amount of money and we put it on a pruta and then
• 9:42
  you you rub it out. So it's worth nothing.
• 9:45
  Or you throw it to the bottom of the ocean.
• 9:47
  That that Pruta that we do that, you know, take the full value of
• 9:51
  mahalo on a pruta. And then you go just like we do
• 9:54
  every three years, whatever it is you throw on the bottom of
• 9:56
  the ocean. We will see that later on.
• 9:58
  How can you destroy? OK, so that's that's a luck
• 10:01
  because you can't use it and you want you don't want someone to
• 10:04
  use it by mistake. So you're supposed to get rid of
• 10:07
  it to dispose of it in a way that no one's going to use it by
• 10:10
  mistake because it's mamish asser to get any benefit from
• 10:13
  that. So that will hopefully clarify
• 10:17
  better than the previous Alaka. OK, Gilmore.
• 10:22
  I know there's a duck of any of their common Nadar Marbalitae
• 10:26
  Nachima. Look, look coca with Kavanti.
• 10:29
  If you donated money for a Sedaka, you, you're right.
• 10:33
  You, you made a nether. You're going to give Sedaka.
• 10:35
  So, but then you forget how much you you promised that you made a
• 10:40
  nether. So you have to make you have to
• 10:42
  cover yourself. And it's normal for me to donate
• 10:45
  to the show for an Aaliyah $100. I would never donate $500.
• 10:50
  I know myself. So even though everyone else in
• 10:52
  the show might donate for 1000, I'm not, I'm not that type.
• 10:55
  I'm going to keep it to 100. Depends what kind of show you go
• 10:58
  to. So if you you only have to give
• 11:02
  how much you know, it's possible that you would have donated
• 11:06
  dollar the Omer to Numa time zoos Osifertara libeta Knesset.
• 11:11
  So then you need to know libeta Knesset Shihu raghyo bahir shihu
• 11:14
  darshan person says I'm I'm donating 200 zoos or a safer
• 11:20
  Tara, whatever it is, whatever you're donating to to to the
• 11:23
  beet Knesset. But you didn't specify which
• 11:27
  show you donated that money to. So then you you only have you
• 11:32
  you're supposed to give it or you need to give it to the show
• 11:35
  that you are that you're a member of.
• 11:37
  That's the show you always go to.
• 11:39
  I mean, if you're dual membership where you don't go to
• 11:42
  the show you're a member of. OK, so question mark, but
• 11:46
  basically you give it to the one that's obvious.
• 11:48
  That's the one that you're shy of to.
• 11:50
  But what if you have two shows? You're you.
• 11:52
  You always go to you remember it two shows.
• 11:54
  It's unclear which one you gave it to.
• 11:56
  So the shock says you have to give it to both of them.
• 11:59
  But you don't have to give 200 to both of them.
• 12:02
  You give you only you only pledge 200.
• 12:05
  So that's all you have to pay. But now you have to divide it
• 12:07
  half and half to both Shoals. Kuf kuf Zeus.
• 12:12
  Oh, you have kuf kuf. I have my time.
• 12:14
  Zeus. OK, interesting.
• 12:16
  Haga veem raghil bishteim he tamely shteyam.
• 12:22
  So that's the Rama you give to both.
• 12:24
  I just explained it. You don't have to give double.
• 12:26
  You just give half to each Omar Litaine Shemin Lama or each in
• 12:29
  the beta Knessa, a person says he's giving to Shemin Lama or so
• 12:35
  that's so that's normally intended to be for the show or,
• 12:40
  you know, to keep the the near Tammy lit.
• 12:42
  So that was it's known that that's supposed to be when a
• 12:46
  person says that the Stam qabana is that it belongs to the show
• 12:49
  and not to the bait midrash. Again, it depends on what the
• 12:53
  Stam qabana is. OK, let's go to the next one.
• 12:58
  Hey, Omer to Numa times, the person says Stam give it to the
• 13:05
  poor people. Then you're supposed to give it
• 13:09
  to the poor people of your city because the stammer, that's who
• 13:13
  you had in mind, right? We similar had a similar halacha
• 13:18
  like this. If a person, let's say you're a
• 13:21
  guest in another city and you make a pledge, let's say for
• 13:24
  Yiska, and you just say stung, I'm making a pledge for the poor
• 13:28
  people. You know, obviously if the show
• 13:30
  has a particular appeal and you join that appeal, then you're
• 13:33
  stuck. But if you just say a stung, I'm
• 13:36
  giving a certain amount in honor of the loved one who passed
• 13:39
  away. So then you you bring it home to
• 13:42
  your if you're travelling, you bring it home to your city.
• 13:44
  OK, That's what the shock points out, right?
• 13:47
  It says if you don't know, you don't, you don't live anywhere.
• 13:49
  So then you give it to that show that where you were that that
• 13:52
  time when you made the pledge. OK, hug up.
• 13:54
  You can make a pledge in general.
• 13:57
  Yeah, of course you can always make a pledge.
• 14:00
  Sure, sure. Then you can always make the
• 14:04
  calls that mean a stump Aval. That's right.
• 14:06
  Just that this is just in general.
• 14:08
  Avalbel Malcolm Sheldon Covran Tashila Kivena Niota Irvad.
• 14:12
  But if whatever your kavana is, if it's clear, you made clear
• 14:16
  where your kavana is. So that's where it needs to go.
• 14:18
  Kagana and komocha derak ashiri mitzaka arbe bishad mitatan
• 14:24
  derak l'hotana. It's it's dakot ako anim hokhin
• 14:29
  al kariza. If when a person is normally
• 14:32
  passes away, if the custom is that it goes that they give a
• 14:36
  big sum of money, the wealthy ones.
• 14:38
  So then when they pass away, so then it's for any of the anime
• 14:42
  that go there but feel another stump, even if you just make
• 14:46
  another stump, you go after the minag.
• 14:48
  All these things, you just go after the Minag, the yeah,
• 14:53
  Yukalkul, you're Shayam. It's Daka.
• 14:55
  And the inheritors, they give out the portion that's dedicated
• 14:59
  for. It's Daka Wakhol, Aniim at
• 15:01
  Tohim, Beniham, whoever are good, Aniim, whoever that's good
• 15:05
  in their eyes, whoever they want to give feel aim on the ear.
• 15:08
  And even if it's not from their city, because that was the
• 15:11
  custom, it wasn't dafgom a you had for the city, the field ITA
• 15:15
  OTA sedaka munaka umm of cadet biyad Aker yitsu OTA lyorshim
• 15:22
  yodi umm shekin nadara and mahayev atsimo the canas, it's
• 15:27
  Dhaka. That doesn't matter who's
• 15:30
  holding the money. Whenever, whatever, wherever it
• 15:32
  was intended to go to, then you tell the person who you're going
• 15:36
  to give it to give out the Yorshim in that case and or
• 15:41
  whatever the net there was. And that's how it you, you just
• 15:44
  divvy out based on what the Quran of the person was or the
• 15:46
  Stam, the minog. I'm a Kaya ratsuaba kanasits
• 15:49
  Dhaka the Ava. A person makes himself, he wants
• 15:54
  to motivate himself so he makes himself.
• 15:56
  If I don't do such and such, then I have to give myself a
• 15:59
  penalty to give X amount of money to Sidaka.
• 16:02
  So right money motivates the Ava.
• 16:05
  But then made it, didn't keep his agreement, so now he has to
• 16:08
  get Sidaka. Sorry, who leads Nova anem Shiba
• 16:10
  ear? You have to give it to the
• 16:12
  anime, the poor people of the city, you can't say it goes to a
• 16:17
  different city anime the Yuhala gabai la tovo and the Gabai of
• 16:22
  the city can go to claim from him the money.
• 16:25
  The Mikri mamanchiech la tovim. It's considered mamanchiech la
• 16:28
  tovim. I'm not sure if that applies
• 16:30
  nowadays, but OK, maybe right. And also nowadays everything is
• 16:36
  so more, so much more global. OK, let's keep going.
• 16:39
  Aval me shihitish mammon harbe. A person sets aside a lot of
• 16:43
  amount of money. Ulmina alayam yorshav lahalko
• 16:46
  and you appoint your yorshum. You know when I pass away, go
• 16:49
  ahead and give it out If you have Tobin AM based on who you
• 16:51
  want to give to. I feel like even for a different
• 16:55
  city. So we know it doesn't belong
• 16:57
  specifically for that city, right?
• 16:59
  Or that was the custom, even if you didn't specify.
• 17:02
  So then Mikre Mammon Shayla told him so then that's not called
• 17:06
  money that someone could be can claim because it's unspecified
• 17:09
  who it goes to. No one has any dibs on it.
• 17:12
  The a in Gabba, I hear you call him a Koof Koof hotel and the
• 17:16
  Gabba. I cannot force the Yorshim to
• 17:19
  give it to him or the Toba Shikaim Mutsuvata mate and tell
• 17:22
  them you have to be Makayim the what your your father or
• 17:27
  whatever. Whoever it was who the the
• 17:29
  Yurish and whoever they told you, the one who was an Iftar,
• 17:35
  because it doesn't belong to any particular city.
• 17:37
  If Alpha God, the Ovarium, the Gosia, my name Nikomakomikrim
• 17:40
  Mammon, she ain't in La Tobin. Even if they delay and they're
• 17:44
  like stealing from these poor people, they have to give it
• 17:47
  right away to poor people, especially if they're around.
• 17:50
  All right. That's what you learned about
• 17:53
  Taher. You can't hold on yours.
• 17:55
  You can't hold on to it, but still so, so they have their
• 17:59
  avera of holding on of delaying and holding on to it.
• 18:01
  But the Gabi of the ear can't be Tovea from them.
• 18:05
  Even if they're stealing the money, the Gabi can't can't
• 18:09
  claim it because it doesn't belong to that Gabi or to the to
• 18:11
  that, to the Enuma, that city. OK, they're using the money.
• 18:14
  Yes, it's in their pocket already.
• 18:16
  They're using the money. They're still using it and
• 18:19
  that's tovea can't claim it from them even though the cash is
• 18:23
  right in front of them here. Let's keep reading.
• 18:27
  So shayna tobim hoyel vyakholi mahaliko call mishiyirtsu
• 18:30
  because this money in their pocket, they're allowed to give
• 18:33
  it to whoever they want to fillo hayu apatropos shnaim umat ekhad
• 18:39
  mahen anakal yukholim leemnot Aker and even if there is 2
• 18:43
  apatropos whatever people taking care of their money.
• 18:47
  So then one of them passes away. Doesn't matter the, the the they
• 18:54
  can't, they can't. Maybe the right it could be the
• 18:58
  inheritance of the trust had to be decided between the two of
• 19:01
  them. Well, but one of them passed
• 19:03
  away. So unless it's in the will or
• 19:05
  whatever the the the city can't appoint another another of
• 19:10
  apotropos and that one has full jurisdiction to decide what to
• 19:14
  do with it. OK komo shetziva noting because
• 19:17
  that's as if that's what he asked the afilu bishtaka shell
• 19:21
  bidena ear en adamyakoli to go itzdaka in Kane yeshua harsha
• 19:26
  Mina goodbye to the ear and unless they have permission,
• 19:30
  they can't the city can't demand it.
• 19:33
  Hamakdish Shimano itzdaka person that is makdish 100 where it's a
• 19:39
  daka the Ain lol is Shalim and he doesn't have what to pay
• 19:43
  massage the shar Bal khol. So then we deal with him like
• 19:50
  anyone who needs who owes money. So we'll see you there in
• 19:55
  Khoshin Mishbat how that works out in Saudi, Saudi design.
• 19:59
  I'm assuming I have to look at what it says over there.
• 20:02
  But based on what we learned until now, we help him out for
• 20:04
  basic expenses, but we don't have to pay him out of his khol.
• 20:09
  That's his problem with his. Debtors or whatever he owes
• 20:13
  money to Vav. I know there it's Sedaka Eno
• 20:16
  Yahoo, Loxorbel. So this is what we alluded to
• 20:19
  earlier when a when a person is gives money, basically it's
• 20:26
  another right now he pledges Sedaka or even says this Sedaka
• 20:32
  belongs to this onion or to this Sedaka fund even says this money
• 20:38
  belongs to them. It's only on the level of Amira.
• 20:42
  So then he can't go back. He has to give the money.
• 20:46
  It's certainly when it's talking about Sedaka, everyone agrees
• 20:50
  it's Miedin Neder. When it's talking about hectish.
• 20:54
  So there are many seem to say it's Miedin, Kenyan Mamash Allah
• 20:57
  in Kane. There's no way out.
• 21:02
  You have to give the sedaka to whoever you gave it to, you
• 21:06
  promised it to or said it belongs to, even though there
• 21:08
  was no physical action yet. But you do have the option of
• 21:13
  what you call Shoal, similar to the concept of ataras nadarim.
• 21:16
  You can ask for it. You go to a generally it's based
• 21:22
  in three and you undo it. You do PETA Karata and you get
• 21:26
  it back the E Miguel Yadaga by but once you give it to him
• 21:31
  physically and it's in his hands, you can no longer undo
• 21:36
  it. It's his no trade backs.
• 21:39
  It's a done deal like every Misira Tehadiol Zion.
• 21:43
  Let's do one more. A person has no right, is not
• 21:49
  able to be maktish anything that he doesn't own or to give it as
• 21:53
  Sedaka that now belongs to the Sedaka or yet to be Makayem
• 21:56
  Deneder that doesn't. It's not shy if it's not Khal
• 22:00
  Mactish or or Sedaka normal Sedaka here.
• 22:04
  If you can't, you can't designate and say this money
• 22:07
  belongs to Sedaka if it's not yours.
• 22:09
  And therefore the dinette there in the field is not called yet.
• 22:13
  It's not called at all because it's not your.
• 22:15
  It has to be both yours. You have to own it and it has to
• 22:19
  be in your jurisdiction or Rashut.
• 22:22
  Does it have to be in your property or pocket?
• 22:24
  No, so that we're going to see Keita.
• 22:27
  Hiya love Picado me Adaka. If you had a picado you you own
• 22:31
  the item and it was in someone else's house.
• 22:33
  Right now they're comfortable and the the the one who's
• 22:38
  watching it, the guy in the house says what do you mean it's
• 22:40
  mine? It's not yours.
• 22:42
  Zo shuhu exlo with the item that's in his property.
• 22:46
  He says is it's his. So now you guys are arguing over
• 22:50
  who owns this picado. You know that you own it.
• 22:54
  It's yours. It doesn't change them.
• 22:56
  It's yours. It is yours.
• 22:57
  The guy is stealing it from you or holding it from you, but it's
• 23:00
  not Rashuto right now because you can't go in and just grab it
• 23:04
  in a volume holding magnesium. You can't be in mockery this
• 23:06
  item because it's not in your rashut.
• 23:09
  You don't have jurisdiction to go pick it up right now.
• 23:12
  All right of all him look afarbo.
• 23:16
  He says you're right. I don't I don't disagree with
• 23:18
  you. I'm I'm holding it for you.
• 23:20
  I'm not giving it back to you right now, but I agree it's
• 23:22
  yours. Hurray Uber should Balov so
• 23:25
  that's called Beershud Balov because it really is yours and
• 23:29
  you do have jurisdiction. No one argues about it to go to
• 23:32
  the base and of course it's yours.
• 23:33
  No questions asked. Nicole Malcolm Shahu doesn't
• 23:36
  matter where it is, doesn't have to be in your possession right
• 23:40
  now. You just have to own it and have
• 23:43
  Rashut over it. You're some kind of jurisdiction
• 23:45
  over it. But another way I'm worrying
• 23:46
  them and talk to him. We're talking about right items
• 23:49
  that you can move from one from one place to another about
• 23:53
  Kharka as opposed to land Shigaza, Akhar Bakafa, you have
• 23:57
  land, you own it, but someone else is on it and he's telling
• 24:00
  you no, it's his. So you're arguing about it.
• 24:04
  But the but the Yanin, if you can go to a basin with the Yanin
• 24:07
  and you can pull it, get rid of him and victim.
• 24:10
  And if you take a bath, I raise a Yahoo Latisha, then that's
• 24:13
  considered in your a shoot. You're right, there's a time
• 24:16
  delay. It's not maybe you can't get in
• 24:18
  there right this second, push you out.
• 24:21
  It won't let you in. It's a fence, it's locked,
• 24:23
  whatever, but it's essentially yours and you can't use it this
• 24:27
  second could be on the other side of the world and you can't
• 24:30
  get you can't use it right now. Even if it's been talented, it
• 24:32
  doesn't matter. That's considered yours and your
• 24:34
  reshoot. The Alpha Bisha download Sia
• 24:36
  Bishop Karka Ozma Hirehi reshoot bell.
• 24:38
  Even though you didn't, you can't remove them yet just yet
• 24:41
  takes time it's process so, but still that's called in your
• 24:45
  rishut A Gozo Caviro Bruni Tasha violin shnehm and employ
• 24:48
  Mahakisha Zella fische Eno Shalo, the zella fische Eno
• 24:52
  Ricuto. If you someone steals an item
• 24:55
  from somebody, but the guy doesn't have yeush, so one of so
• 25:00
  one of them it's not in his rishuts and one of them he
• 25:02
  doesn't even own it. So there then neither one of
• 25:05
  them can be mocked Ishit and make it hectare shirts Zaka
• 25:08
  either for either reason, because it has to be both.
• 25:11
  It has to be shallow and has the coyote baze.
• 25:15
  That's the principle, and so it applies in all similar cases.
• 25:18
  How about what happens if you have a MASH gown in someone
• 25:23
  else's hand? You, you borrowed money.
• 25:26
  Maybe you gave him a MASH gown. You borrowed $100 and you gave
• 25:29
  him a watch that's worth $1000. So now what's the din your mash
• 25:33
  gong's worth much more. So in mash gong be Al Javier
• 25:37
  mash who negate halva, the opposite the halva.
• 25:40
  So the portion that's equivalent $100.00 of the mash gong is for
• 25:46
  the halva. So therefore you can't do that's
• 25:49
  not considered in your issue in a yakola hatish, the Hamotar
• 25:53
  yakola hatish, but the other $900, the other, the value
• 25:57
  that's above the halva, above the loan that you could be
• 26:00
  makush. He's holding it for you.
• 26:02
  He doesn't deny it. He's going to give it back to
• 26:04
  you. I'm just waiting for you for the
• 26:05
  give back the loan. So that's considered for his and
• 26:08
  his in his reshoot, the extra part above the loan.
• 26:11
  All right, but the part that's equal to the loan, it's not
• 26:13
  considered in his reshus because he's never allowed to take it
• 26:16
  back until he gives back the loan.
• 26:18
  We show him that filohan motar inyakola haqish but some say no
• 26:23
  the whole thing since it's all one item you can't and the
• 26:27
  maktish so some say you can't. Next case I'm makti star kov.
• 26:31
  Sorry tira. I'm Masira Komoda head yield and
• 26:34
  a star. If you want to be makti a star
• 26:38
  it has to be written and given over like head yield.