Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP317: Unlocking Profit - The ROI of Building Accessible Websites, With Industry Expert Bet Hannon
Transcript
- 0:00Now, when you start to think about that, 25% of adults that
- 0:03have disabilities control about $8 trillion in disposable income
- 0:08globally. When you're not fixing this
- 0:10stuff, you're leaving money on the table as an E com grant.
- 0:15You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:18and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:21and re platform specialist James Geddick Paul Rogers.
- 0:23Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:25industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:28practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:33This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:35Got another really important topic today.
- 0:37I love it when we get subject matter experts on the pod.
- 0:40So we're talking about understanding web accessibility,
- 0:42free common 2025 Turing compliance.
- 0:45What do you focus on What the impacts of doing this properly?
- 0:48Um, I'm just having a chat with our guests are introduced
- 0:50properly in a minute prior to recording this.
- 0:53And Bette says something really spot on, which is this isn't
- 0:56just about compliance. You fix accessibility and you
- 0:58prove the UX for all users and you can model an ROI on that.
- 1:01So we will be coming to how you do model ROI.
- 1:04But first, let me give a warm welcome to Bette Hannan, who's a
- 1:06web accessibility and E com expert.
- 1:08Also, the CEO at Excessive got Hey Bear, welcome to the pod.
- 1:12Hey James, welcome. Thanks for having me.
- 1:14Well, I really appreciate it because it was you who who very
- 1:17kindly initiated the conversation of while back
- 1:19through LinkedIn. And it's, it's an area at the
- 1:22time I said, well, do you know what, we'll come to that when
- 1:25the time is right. And I'm really happy that we've
- 1:27now had the opportunity and I believe you're joining us from
- 1:30an equally cold place you're over in the US so.
- 1:33I am. I'm in the Pacific Northwest.
- 1:35It's pretty chilly below freezing this morning, so nice
- 1:39fall day. Yes.
- 1:40Well, I'm a few hours ahead of you in the day, so I'm about two
- 1:43degrees above freezing, so I'm going to gloat on the relative
- 1:46warmth that I have. Oh, there you go.
- 1:48Go for it. So look, before you start
- 1:49getting into all of the, the, the good practice and the, the,
- 1:52the juicy stuff around accessibility.
- 1:54There's a lot of instructions. So if those who haven't come
- 1:57across excessive cart and you and what you do, do you want to
- 1:59give people the flavour, who you are and what excessive cart is?
- 2:02Yeah, so web accessibility is about helping people, making
- 2:07sure you're you're letting people with disabilities use
- 2:10your site just like everybody else.
- 2:12I run Excessive Cart for the last.
- 2:15Before that we were more of a general web dev firm.
- 2:19We did a lot of stuff with E Com and then about 10 years ago, we
- 2:23had a client that needed web accessibility.
- 2:25We dived in and it was kind of this light bulb moment for us
- 2:29where all of us on the team realized there were people in
- 2:32our lives that we knew that we cared about that needed
- 2:35accessibility in some way or or a fashion.
- 2:38And it became just sort of this passion for us.
- 2:40And so now we are a services company that focuses on testing,
- 2:47help people test for accessibility, both automated
- 2:50testing and manual testing. We do some testing with users
- 2:53who have disabilities and then we're doing support and
- 2:55consultation about how to fix and then reporting.
- 2:58And in many ways, the reporting itself is the biggest kind of
- 3:02legal leverage that brands will have.
- 3:05So providing that whole spectrum of support around accessibility.
- 3:10Yeah, I think it's when when I have conversations, yeah.
- 3:13And I'm not in the detail like you are when I have conversation
- 3:15people and and talks about accessibility.
- 3:18The thing that startles me is how few people understand the
- 3:21size of the population that are impacted by adjustable need.
- 3:24Because I think a lot of people think, oh, this is about people
- 3:27with with blindness and visual impairment.
- 3:28It's like, OK, that's one element.
- 3:30And actually, you know, in in a lot of Western countries, that
- 3:34proportion of the population's grown as well.
- 3:36But then you talk about those who might have a physical
- 3:37disability that impacts uses of laptops, keyboards and where
- 3:42they need additional support. It's amazing actually.
- 3:45How many? Yeah.
- 3:45So across most of the developed world, the estimate is around
- 3:4925% of all adults need some accommodation, whether a
- 3:52permanent, they have a permanent disability or sometimes a
- 3:54temporary one, right. You know, I'm, I may break my
- 3:57hand and I can't use a mouse for a while, right.
- 3:59So there's some of that, but it it does go much broader.
- 4:02You know, I'm doing some research just yet, yesterday
- 4:04actually, for thinking about, well, what percentage of some of
- 4:09these different kind of accessibility fixes, what
- 4:12percentage of your customers are you blocking when you don't fix
- 4:15them? And I'm thinking about when you
- 4:17fix color contrast, for example, that's where you have the, the
- 4:21color of the font and the, and the difference between that and
- 4:24the background that it sits against.
- 4:26You know, that impacts people who are low vision, who might
- 4:30be, for instance, legally blind, but still have some vision, but
- 4:33they, they need a good color contrast.
- 4:35It impacts people who are color blind.
- 4:37That's about 9% of all men. And then it impacts people who
- 4:42are over 50 who don't think about themselves as like me, who
- 4:46don't think of themselves as disabled.
- 4:48But you know, the lens of the eye starts to yellow at with age
- 4:51and that impacts color perception.
- 4:53So you'll you'll find it a lot harder to start seeing those
- 4:56color contrast things. And then it also, you know,
- 5:00begins to impact folks. So people over 50.
- 5:04So when you start to look at all of those people altogether,
- 5:06that's somewhere between 35 and 45% of all adults.
- 5:11And so it's like if you're not paying attention to that, you
- 5:14know, those kinds of accessibility issues, I mean,
- 5:17it's really a wide swath of people.
- 5:19So yeah, I think, you know, you were right.
- 5:21We talked about, and I try to stress a lot, you know, when
- 5:23you, when you fix accessibility issues, yeah, the people with
- 5:27with sort of legal, legally defined disabilities will have
- 5:31an improved experience, but you're improving that user
- 5:34experience for everybody and that translates to conversions
- 5:37in ROI. Yeah, and I mean, I can attest
- 5:40this as as I'm, I'm 49, I'm 50 in April, but I'm long sighted.
- 5:45But my sights got worse. I am.
- 5:47I have elements of colour blindness, sorry, red light Reds
- 5:51and greens nightmare for me and my daughter laughs at me.
- 5:54She says, what do you mean that's not that is not green,
- 5:57Yes. My brother's colour mine too.
- 6:00And and I have this the contrast bit I see all the time where
- 6:03somebody is has put like white copy on a background and it's,
- 6:08it's really hard for me to read without focusing and I just will
- 6:12give up half the time. Yep, exactly.
- 6:15That's it. People will just give up and
- 6:17move on. And so you know, when you start
- 6:18to think about that, 25% of adults that have those
- 6:23disabilities control about $8 trillion in disposable income
- 6:28globally. And so when you're not fixing
- 6:30this stuff, you're leaving money on the table as an E com brand.
- 6:33So really it's about, you know, are you, you know, there's some
- 6:37great, you know, you're getting that better conversions, you're
- 6:41getting, you know, better SEO, both traditional SEO and AISEO,
- 6:46you're getting brand, you know, brand, you're positioning your
- 6:49brand as being more inclusive and welcoming of folks.
- 6:52There's just a lot of great benefits to it the beyond just a
- 6:56technical compliance. Excellent.
- 6:59For those of you listening, we're going to get into
- 7:02accountability for this in businesses, calculating ROI,
- 7:06state of legislation, the USUKEU steps people can take some
- 7:11examples, etcetera. So there's a lot of really
- 7:13practical stuff in this. So let's let's get going.
- 7:16The first bit I wanted to get into is accountability.
- 7:20The issues you see, because we're talking about this
- 7:22earlier, I often see this as as as quite fragmented where there
- 7:25isn't a single person accountable even though multiple
- 7:28teams need to execute to make site accessible, which is one of
- 7:32the key points you were making to me before we recorded.
- 7:34But what, what do you see? What are the issues you tend to
- 7:36find it in terms of like accountability and ownership and
- 7:38what is the impact when that accountability is spread across
- 7:41a business? Yeah.
- 7:43So, you know, making a site accessible in terms of a
- 7:46sustainable practice within a brand has to come, as you said,
- 7:51you know, from multiple teams, right.
- 7:52So you have some things that are developer related, some things
- 7:55that are design related, and then a lot that's content
- 7:58related as people are putting content into sites.
- 8:01And so one of the problems is that no one person or no one
- 8:06team has some accountability for that.
- 8:11We see a lot of times when in the US when we have E com brands
- 8:16reaching out to us because they've been sued, it's a
- 8:19director of marketing that's reaching out to me.
- 8:21But, you know, they they, they often when I approach directors
- 8:26of marketing who are not being sued, they think of
- 8:29accessibility as that's illegal thing, that's somebody else's
- 8:33problem because that's a compliance issue.
- 8:36And I don't have to deal with that.
- 8:38And so, yeah, I think it's problematic.
- 8:41And people tend to bury their heads in the sand until they get
- 8:44sued or there's a complaint filed and then they are
- 8:47scrambling. What do Mattel, Victoria
- 8:52Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 8:56They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 9:00Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 9:04the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 9:07converting check out on the planet Shopify Powering the
- 9:13future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 9:16shopify.com/enterprise. Yeah, I think this is such a
- 9:21spot on point is that if you only see accessibility as
- 9:23compliance, you put the wrong people.
- 9:26And that's not detrimental to the people who've got an eye on
- 9:28compliance because that's absolutely critical and you fund
- 9:30them. Oh.
- 9:30Absolutely yes. But yeah, the impact is far
- 9:34wider and I hope that one of the key things I want people to take
- 9:36away who might not understand accessibility in detail because
- 9:40it's not in their day-to-day job, it's just that this has a
- 9:42fundamental impact on your ability to trade online as well.
- 9:47Oh, absolutely. So that, that that dovetails
- 9:49nicely into that you've built an ROI calculator.
- 9:52And there's the question they get all the time when people,
- 9:54for example, if I'm in a conversation with someone about
- 9:57what the benefits are of ensuring you're in the UKWCA,
- 10:00G2, AA, complying all the benefits to going to trip a on
- 10:04some elements outside public sector.
- 10:06It's not a legal requirement, but there are some advantages
- 10:09depending on your audience. But then the classy thing will
- 10:12be what's the ROI? Why should I spend on that?
- 10:14I could put money in paid media. So how does your calculate a
- 10:17work? How does it factor in variances?
- 10:19Because not all businesses are at the same stage of
- 10:21accessibility. Right.
- 10:23So there's not a lot of great research out there about this.
- 10:27There are a few studies that are like Tesco in the UK actually
- 10:32did you know that thing is study is nearly 15 years old at this
- 10:38point, but they've did a massive overhaul of their accessibility
- 10:42and their their ROI improved 37%.
- 10:46Well, you know, part of that is the time when they were doing
- 10:50that and people are more using online ordering.
- 10:55People are ordering groceries. So they're ordering every week,
- 10:58right? You know, so some of those
- 10:59factors that were made that kind of a Unicorn sort of, you know,
- 11:03result typically we might see somewhere between I would say
- 11:07between a half a percent and you know, up to three, four, 5%.
- 11:12And some of the factors are, you know, how bad is the
- 11:15accessibility at the beginning before you start your at your
- 11:18remediation work. So for example, if you have
- 11:22problems with the checkout and no person who's blind can ever
- 11:25check out on your website, you know, that's pretty serious
- 11:30versus, you know, do you have a kind of the color contrast you
- 11:33were describing where it's a friction point?
- 11:35It's like people are giving up, but some people persevere,
- 11:38right? That's a less of a lift, right?
- 11:40If you think you're still getting some lift, but it's not
- 11:43the same amount of lift as if you're like totally opening up
- 11:46the checkout. So, so there's a factor in how
- 11:49bad are your, you know, was your accessibility as your current
- 11:53accessibility, then how much you're going to invest in it.
- 11:56You don't have to, you know, this is the thing, right?
- 11:59You don't, you don't have to fix everything all at once.
- 12:03It can be, it's almost always anyway a, a, a, a process,
- 12:08right? You're, you're moving toward it.
- 12:10It would be great if people could move faster, but most of
- 12:12the time it's a process. How much are you investing?
- 12:15And then also then the factor is, you know, what's, what's
- 12:18your revenue level, what's the traffic?
- 12:21How, how much, how much are you actually doing business?
- 12:24You know, a, a 1% improvement for somebody who's doing
- 12:27$1,000,000 a year is different than a company that's doing $100
- 12:32million a year. The so the investment is a, is a
- 12:36bigger chunk, you know, it's a percentage of your revenue,
- 12:39right. And so, you know, I would say if
- 12:41folks are investing 1% or even a half a percent of their annual
- 12:47revenue and accessibility to begin with, you know, that there
- 12:51can be some great things. But for a company that's making,
- 12:54you know, $5,000,000 or pounds a year in revenue or not, yeah, I
- 13:00don't know the pound exchange anymore.
- 13:01That all kind of went crazy for a while.
- 13:04But you know, a $5,000,000 U.S. dollar revenue, they, they can
- 13:09see an ROI on their investment and accessibility within a
- 13:13matter of months. I mean, it does not take a long
- 13:15time to start seeing an ROI. And So what why it's one of the
- 13:19few compliances that can pay for itself, right?
- 13:22And so I don't know why people don't.
- 13:24And I think there are people who are starting to jump on this as
- 13:27kind of, you know, as companies are wanting to make those
- 13:31incremental improvements that kind of drive ROI.
- 13:36Yes, Yeah, exactly. And then so very, very closely
- 13:40linked to the, the point of ROI is the cost element of not doing
- 13:45this right. And let's get into the
- 13:47legislation because I think the the impact of lawsuits in the US
- 13:52under Aida, the Discrimination Act in the US feel more high
- 13:57profile than what's coming in the EU and into UK.
- 14:01And I know that we're starting to see some, some legal action.
- 14:03So we'll have to let's split the 2.
- 14:05So do you want to talk about the current state legislation in the
- 14:08US and what, what are the implication?
- 14:09What's been happening? Yeah, so, so ADA Americans with
- 14:13Disabilities Act was passed in 1990 before we really had
- 14:17commercial websites like we have today.
- 14:19So that that law itself doesn't really have anything in it about
- 14:23web or digital accessibility. There have been a few lawsuits
- 14:29around government websites and pieces around public services,
- 14:35things like banks and utilities that have been pretty clearly
- 14:38kind of moving us toward applying ADA to private, you
- 14:43know, business websites. But in the US, it is all almost
- 14:48exclusively driven by what we call serial plaintiff lawsuits.
- 14:55And so that's one attorney and one plaintiff, typically a blind
- 14:59plaintiff who who might sue dozens and dozens of companies
- 15:05together with a kind of cookie cutter lawsuit.
- 15:08Sometimes they will get a what's called a demand letter.
- 15:11And that's just a letter that comes in the mail to the
- 15:15business owner or the the business.
- 15:18And it says we intend to sue you because you have left alt text
- 15:21off of your images. And it will be very vague.
- 15:24It won't be a specific page. It'll just be very vague because
- 15:27they're sending that same letter to dozens of people and so it
- 15:31can look spammy or scammy and people sometimes throw it away.
- 15:35If you get the letter, that's the best way to, you know, you
- 15:38want to try almost 99% of these cases and in a settlement almost
- 15:44some of them do go to court because the next step is
- 15:47ambulance chasing kind of attorneys is kind of to drive it
- 15:51to court and then get a settlement out of that.
- 15:53When you and so you can, you know, the cost for those suits
- 16:00ranges, you know, you pay the settlement of like a fee to the
- 16:05attorney and the plaintiff. By the way, the plaintiffs
- 16:09actually don't get a lot of money.
- 16:10The blind person doesn't get a lot of money because if they
- 16:14have some kind of disability benefits, they can't get a lot
- 16:19of money to, they lose those benefits and that's a bigger
- 16:23deal to them. And so they don't actually get a
- 16:25lot of money. It's the attorneys making and
- 16:27driving a lot of this. So they will, you know, the, the
- 16:31person, the attorney and their person, they get a settle.
- 16:36There's a settlement money. Then there's also the attorneys
- 16:39fees and the brand pays both sides of that.
- 16:42And so the total cost for that probably ranges somewhere
- 16:46between $10,000 to $50,000 or more.
- 16:51And then you still theoretically have to make the website conform
- 16:54to WIC Egg 2 point. At this moment, most of the
- 16:58court cases are coming out to 2.1 AA and you get within a year
- 17:02or two maybe you get 24 minutes. So you get that kind of a
- 17:06lawsuit thing and it's kind of a scammy shakedown kind of thing.
- 17:11On the other hand, that law is how we got, you know, how we've
- 17:15gotten some really good benefits for people with disabilities,
- 17:17right? So it's, it's, it's both sides
- 17:19of that coin. Being able to file those
- 17:21lawsuits is why there is Braille on ATMs in the US, right?
- 17:24And so, you know, it's, it's both sides of that.
- 17:28But that's how it happens is that's kind of those kind of
- 17:32scammy lawsuits that people are, are, are driven by and people
- 17:35can get sued more than once. About 80% of those lawsuits are
- 17:39e-commerce sites because you think about the total, you know,
- 17:43the user engagement, what a user, you know, there's a lot of
- 17:46places for problems and friction accessibility issues on that
- 17:50e-commerce interaction. So about 25% of them are running
- 17:55overlays already, accessibility overlays.
- 17:59And you know, about 25% of them have been sued before.
- 18:02So sometimes it's two or three times before that they're sued
- 18:06before they say, hey, maybe we should just buckle down and make
- 18:08the site accessible. And so that's when we hear from
- 18:12people. A lot of times it's when they're
- 18:14they're doing that. And how do you see a different
- 18:19in the EU approach to enforcing compliance?
- 18:22Are you seeing many high profile cases coming?
- 18:24Yeah, in urgency. So, so there is, you know, we've
- 18:30been kind of waiting to see. So the in the EU, the European
- 18:36Accessibility Act was passed six years ago and we had until, you
- 18:41know, businesses had until June 28, 2025 S last June to that's
- 18:47when enforcement started. So enforcement was going to
- 18:50start then it actually, and so we kind of expected like with
- 18:54GDPR, everyone would wait till the last minute and then start
- 18:56scrambling. Nobody really started
- 18:58scrambling. And then the enforcement, you
- 19:01know, under the EU, you know, there's the directive that
- 19:06that's the Accessibility Act and every nation under that
- 19:09transposes into their own national laws.
- 19:12And so it's kind of frustrating because the intent of the
- 19:16Accessibility Act was to kind of give more standardization.
- 19:19But what it did is created all these individual national laws
- 19:22that are a little different. They have different fine levels
- 19:25and different structures a little bit differently.
- 19:27So we're just starting to see some of that enforcement start
- 19:31to kick out. So there are one of the things
- 19:34that the EAA does is gives advocacy groups on behalf of
- 19:39people within disabilities the standing to file complaints as
- 19:43well as individual customers. So an individual customer can
- 19:46come to the business and say I can't check out on your site,
- 19:51but the advocacy group can do that on behalf of people with
- 19:54disabilities as well. And so we saw at the in July,
- 20:00there was a group of two advocacy groups in France for
- 20:04the visually impaired and a legal pro bono legal group that.
- 20:10Very publicly made those complaints.
- 20:12Now they didn't have to they they filed their complaints with
- 20:15the businesses for grocery store chains in France and their apps
- 20:18and websites, but they also released a press release.
- 20:21And so that's the kind of piece that we're kind of starting to
- 20:24see is there can be big reputational kinds of hits
- 20:27because now these advocacy groups have a lot of motivation
- 20:31to kind of make those things public.
- 20:33So the four grocery store chains, they were notified in
- 20:36July that they gave them until like September 1, they would
- 20:40pursue legal action. They actually didn't pursue the
- 20:43legal action until just a couple of weeks ago.
- 20:46So now there's been a legal case filed with the summary to like,
- 20:51tell these people, these grocery store chains to start following
- 20:53the law. And we don't know how that's
- 20:56going to go. But there you get that kind of
- 20:58public, you know, shaming, I guess, in a way, right?
- 21:02So that's one front. Another front is that in the
- 21:06last few weeks the Swedish so every country has a the IT gets
- 21:13translated in English as the market surveillance authority,
- 21:17which sounds to US ears like like surveillance sounds really
- 21:23dodgy and kind of you know spy like but it's really their
- 21:27authority, their accountability group, the Swedish oversight
- 21:32agency announced that they were going to start doing proactive
- 21:36auditing of large E com retailers in Sweden.
- 21:40They would be looking at websites only, not apps.
- 21:42They would be looking at the home page, a product page and
- 21:45the search pages functions. And so it's kind of fairly
- 21:50limited, but still, you know, out there.
- 21:52And but they're proactively starting.
- 21:54So some of these oversight bodies will start to proactively
- 21:57audit things. And then finally we learned that
- 22:01the nor we the Netherlands has a put out a, a, a piece about
- 22:11reporting. And I was kind of surprised by
- 22:16that. I and so I read more about it,
- 22:18about self reporting. If you have issues still on your
- 22:23website, if you have accessibility issues and you've
- 22:26identified them through some kind of testing, you are
- 22:28required to report that to their of oversight authority.
- 22:32And I was, I thought, wow, on a special form and, and not only
- 22:37to report it once, but to report it if you, if you get a test and
- 22:43you learn about an issue or a Consumer Reports an issue, if
- 22:47it's a, you know, in under kind of the standard auditing
- 22:51practices, we grade the severity of an issue.
- 22:54Like there's critical, severe, moderate, minor.
- 22:58If it's a critical or severe issue, you have to report it
- 23:01within a week. If it's a moderate or minor, you
- 23:03have 30 days. I thought that was in some ways
- 23:06ingenious because it motivates those teams to if you fix the
- 23:10issue within that amount of time, you don't have to report
- 23:13it. If you find a critical issue,
- 23:15you fix it within a week, you don't have to report it.
- 23:17So that's like the motivation for actually just fixing things
- 23:21quick instead of getting a big backlog of pieces.
- 23:24But what I later discovered was that that obligation to self
- 23:29report any issues that are remaining on your site is
- 23:32actually a part of the EAA directive.
- 23:36And so we expect that more nations will kind of come back
- 23:39and fix their national legislation that didn't put that
- 23:41in. We know that there is an
- 23:43obligation to self report in Germany and in Spain as well.
- 23:48It's not as clear, there's not a special form for doing that so
- 23:51far, but we expect that that will come back.
- 23:54And so I was kind of surprised by that in just the last few
- 23:57weeks about how that's unfolding.
- 23:59So many different kinds of levels of, wow, they're taking
- 24:03this seriously, this has some teeth.
- 24:04People really are going to have to start getting, you know,
- 24:07proactive about dealing with these kind of their compliance
- 24:12on that. That do you know, that's really
- 24:14interesting. I hadn't understood that part of
- 24:16the requirement framework of the self reporting piece.
- 24:20And I imagine Foo there'll be some out there listen who
- 24:23understand it and others who don't and realise that that
- 24:26there's a process that has to be put in place.
- 24:29And this is one of the reasons of having conversation like this
- 24:31is to help the gun some processes and documentation that
- 24:34you need to prioritise. Yeah, and it's not only that.
- 24:37I mean, there's when you say processes, there's a lot of
- 24:40other kinds of things. So for instance, in in some and,
- 24:45and the countries are a little different now, but like when a
- 24:48consumer makes a complaint to the business, like your
- 24:52accessibility statement needs to tell people where they should
- 24:56make a how they can file a complaint.
- 24:58So e-mail this or call us or do you know you can contact us in
- 25:02these ways when they, when a complaint comes in, then some
- 25:07countries give you a week to reply that you're, you know,
- 25:11initiate a reply back. Others give 30 days.
- 25:15In France, it's supposed to be fixed within 30 days, right?
- 25:20And so there's some like some deadlines for fixing things.
- 25:23So wit you need to think ahead about when a complaint comes in.
- 25:28It's not if, it's when, because no website is 100% accessible,
- 25:31right, that somebody's going to find an error at some point.
- 25:34So, so plan ahead like what's that process going to be?
- 25:37So you're not wasting time trying to figure out your
- 25:40process when you have this very narrow window for making the
- 25:44complaint. Because if you don't satisfy or
- 25:47fix that complaint, then the then the next step is that
- 25:50person can, can escalate their complaint to the oversight body.
- 25:55And that's what you want to avoid in all of that.
- 25:57But all of that piece, what you did, the complaint that came in,
- 26:02all of that has to be preserved for documentation.
- 26:05You have to document that the complaint came in, you have to
- 26:09document what response was going out to that consumer, what
- 26:13happened internally, where it's been logged, how who fixed it,
- 26:16how did it go, what's the testing?
- 26:18Did the consumer verify that it was fixed?
- 26:20You all of that documentation piece has to now be you know you
- 26:24have to maintain that documentation as you as a part
- 26:27of processes going forward. Yeah.
- 26:30And this is, this is where I think a lot of businesses have
- 26:33gaps is they don't have a process for this.
- 26:36They will have as part of maybe their ongoing website
- 26:40optimization, they'll have streams of looking at fixing the
- 26:44accessibility issues where yeah, an audit tool said you're
- 26:47missing alt tags or by the wrong or raise and and you'll fix it.
- 26:51But there isn't that formal, I guess legal process of if there
- 26:56is an issue, we've got to make sure that if we're then audited
- 26:59we can demonstrate action. Well, and and you need to train
- 27:03your support people so that you know if if the complaint about
- 27:08accessibility comes in through a support channel, the support
- 27:11people know what to do with it so that it gets handled properly
- 27:16and legally for going forward, right.
- 27:19That is a great point. Now let's come on to some of the
- 27:22specific issues that you because obviously you're working with
- 27:24lots of different businesses, you'll see all sorts of things.
- 27:28I want to just highlight a few to people listening of the, I
- 27:31guess the sort of things that you've found that cause an issue
- 27:34for somebody with an accessibility challenge.
- 27:38So for example, you'd mentioned to me when we're planning this
- 27:42episode about keyboard navigation being broken for
- 27:45choosing product variants. So the product with a variant
- 27:49couldn't actually be added to the car.
- 27:50Now, if you're UAT testing the site as a, as somebody without
- 27:54any accessible issues, you'll just go through his normal bang,
- 27:57click it. Oh, everything's working great.
- 27:59My site's good. I've passed that test.
- 28:01So can you explain a few and and and what the impacts are?
- 28:06Yeah. So I think it's important to
- 28:08note for folks as you're testing that there's automated testing
- 28:11that you can leverage that will help you identify issues.
- 28:15And you should absolutely leverage automated testing.
- 28:18It will help you find things like color, contrast and heading
- 28:22structure, you know, heading structures that are not properly
- 28:26semantically nested. It'll help you find images that
- 28:30may be missing alt text. And then, you know, it may help
- 28:37you identify places where you have ambiguous link text or link
- 28:41text that's the same in various places.
- 28:43It's important to note that automated testing will only help
- 28:46you find about 30% of issues. So you still have to do manual
- 28:49testing. Things like keyboard navigation,
- 28:51things like looking at the alt. Just because alt text is is
- 28:54there is alt text doesn't necessarily mean that it's valid
- 28:58alt text, right? So sometimes people have put,
- 29:00you know, the product, the product type name or title
- 29:04instead of actual alt text in an image where they put, you know,
- 29:08we even see things like, you know, JPEG 6932, right, you
- 29:12know, or whatever as the alt text.
- 29:14And so you know those kinds of things.
- 29:16It won't, you know, automated testing won't help you find, but
- 29:19you know, we, we see things, a lot of problems with keyboard
- 29:22navigation, things like you mentioned where you can't select
- 29:26a variant. You can't, you know, we audited
- 29:28a site one time where the person you could get a product, you get
- 29:33through keyboard navigate, you navigation, you could get the
- 29:37product in the cart, you could get there, you could fill out,
- 29:39except you could not tab out of the last field to click the
- 29:43submit button. So you could never pay for the
- 29:49product to complete the thing. And that is resulting then of
- 29:52course in abandoned carts. And right, you know, you're
- 29:54getting yeah. So it's those kind of pieces of,
- 29:58you know, you got to test that whole process of the search, the
- 30:03making sure your search works, getting through there, putting
- 30:06things in the cart, reading through the products, all of
- 30:09that. It's a it's a piece.
- 30:12So we see stuff like that. We see a lot actually for
- 30:16e-commerce. A lot of times what happens is
- 30:19we see problems with add-ons and plug insurance and you know,
- 30:22apps that are being added to the platform.
- 30:26So, you know, there's problems with that will not announced to
- 30:32screen readers properly depending on what they are not
- 30:34will not, you know, aren't keyboard navigatable, whatever
- 30:39are mess up the heading structure in terms of where
- 30:41they're placed on the page. So all kinds of things that apps
- 30:44may do. So and as this the brand owner,
- 30:48the brand is responsible for any third party things they put on
- 30:51their site. So you might think that all
- 30:53that's the problem for those, you know, the developer or the
- 30:56the third party platform over there, but it's actually your
- 30:59liability as the brand owner to make sure that everything's
- 31:02working on your site. And you know, I think that
- 31:06that's the other piece is getting making sure when you're
- 31:11when you're vetting those kinds of solutions for adding features
- 31:14to the site that you're looking at accessibility as one of the
- 31:17things that you know you're testing and when you're looking
- 31:20at at items. Yeah, some great examples.
- 31:24And it's just it's reinforced to me actually just the importance
- 31:28of having this conversation upfront and projects about who,
- 31:32what test is going to be done and who's doing which because
- 31:34developers who are building SATA, a AA standard site will do
- 31:38their their code testing. But you're right, it's the, it's
- 31:42the wider testing of of what about the app?
- 31:47What does that do to user journey?
- 31:48What does that do to like page templates so the core code could
- 31:51be accessible and then you've introduced something which
- 31:54creates A barrier to that user journey.
- 31:57So it's a really good point to tease out.
- 32:00It and it happens really frequently and, and when that
- 32:03happens, you, you want to have you need to push back with those
- 32:09with those app you know the, the app that you've bought from that
- 32:13vendor and they, they, if they're smart, they're realizing
- 32:19that you've just saved them thousands of dollars of testing
- 32:22and identified an accessibility issue for them, right.
- 32:26If they're not, they get defensive and they just say
- 32:29we're never going to fix that. So then you have to figure out,
- 32:32you know, what risk you want to take or you maybe you move on to
- 32:36somebody else, you find a substitute that's that is
- 32:38accessible. But a lot of times people are
- 32:41very, you know, very eager to fix things they can be.
- 32:46And so it's just, they just haven't known before that they
- 32:48needed to fix it. And so that's, that can be a
- 32:50piece of what we do. And we do some consulting with
- 32:54some of those kinds of companies too, and helping them fix
- 32:57things. From my experience of working
- 32:59with a wide range of development agencies is there are a lot who
- 33:04want to knock. There are a lot, a lot.
- 33:06So there are some who just want to knock the project out and
- 33:08they have their way of working and they're very entrenched in
- 33:10there. But there are so many good
- 33:12agencies who want to deliver good projects and you care about
- 33:15their work and are trying to constantly upskill because it's
- 33:17constantly changing. Browsers are changing, platforms
- 33:20are changing, its standards are changing, compliance are
- 33:22changing, and it's actually really hard for them to keep up
- 33:25with everything because that's not they're trying to do code
- 33:28full stack coding. They're not an accessibility
- 33:30expert and actually having an accessibility representative to
- 33:33guide and point out to them how their code could get tighter.
- 33:36Yeah, and that's some of the that's some of the most fun work
- 33:40that we do is when we we don't do it as much as I kind of had
- 33:45hoped maybe we might. And that is to come alongside as
- 33:48kind of an accessibility subject matter expert along with
- 33:52development teams. And so they would bring us in as
- 33:55a part of the project. We would kind of have some
- 33:58predictable touch points with them.
- 34:00You know, like at that beginning conversation about what are the
- 34:03features, what are the apps, what are the add-ons that we're
- 34:05going to use? Let's let's what, what you know,
- 34:08so we can help them understand, well, there's some kind of
- 34:11predictable things in this particular feature.
- 34:16You're going to need a date picker and date pickers often
- 34:18have accessibility problems. So let's, you know, be conscious
- 34:21of that, right? We give them some advice.
- 34:23We can give advice to the in the design phase around the design,
- 34:27you know, look at the lock ups and we can tell you where
- 34:29there's going to be some problems.
- 34:31And then as the build out is happening at the end and we can
- 34:33kind of do some auditing as they're moving through that.
- 34:36What we found was that as teams did that two or three times with
- 34:40us, those developers levelled up their accessibility skills and
- 34:44that was great. It was fun to see them kind of
- 34:46growing and we love teaching in that way and so that was kind of
- 34:49a lot of fun to do. Yeah.
- 34:51Do you know, it's just triggered me to on the current project I'm
- 34:53working on actually, because it's even small elements like a
- 34:56client who's got a countdown timer on the PDP for next day
- 34:59delivery cuts off. I'm stopping and thinking about,
- 35:03well, actually that's not a static text, that's a simple
- 35:06like readable division, but I'd say dynamic piece of content.
- 35:09Yeah, is, is that accessible actually, or is it rendered in a
- 35:13way that's unreadable by like a screen reader for example?
- 35:16You're going to have to test it with a screen reader, yeah.
- 35:18Yeah, exactly. That's just made me realise that
- 35:20there's additional things that I'd not thought of before, which
- 35:23is why I love speaking to experts.
- 35:24It's always, always open my eyes to new things.
- 35:27But so let's come on to the the manual testing because and we'll
- 35:31talk about free tools to do an automated test in a bit.
- 35:33And I think a lot of people are more used to OK, well, I'll use
- 35:37a tool and I'll do a test. I'll get a report and I'll know
- 35:39that oh, I've missed some old tags or you know, my yeah, as
- 35:42you said, you know, issue with certain DIF classes, etcetera.
- 35:46Great. OK, I can work the deads.
- 35:48But you said before, and I've seen this stat in many places
- 35:52about the automated can only find a small percentage.
- 35:55I think you said about 30%. I've seen 3035 somewhere else.
- 35:59Yeah, how? How does manual testing differ?
- 36:02What is it? What values are adding?
- 36:03What can manual testing find the automated calm?
- 36:07Well, because you've got, I mean, you just kind of talked
- 36:10about a great example, right? You've got that JavaScript
- 36:12driven, I'm assuming JavaScript driven count a countdown timer,
- 36:14right? And so we have to go in the, the
- 36:18automated testing can't get in to see what's happening there.
- 36:23So you're going to have to just use a screen reader.
- 36:25You're going to have to actually get in and turn on a screen
- 36:28reader and see what see what it reads out for you.
- 36:33You, you have to kind of begin to get some comfort level with
- 36:37some of those tools. And I think, you know, it's kind
- 36:39of critical. If developers are going to do,
- 36:42you know, build accessible things, then you need to get
- 36:47some comfort with keyboard navigation and using a screen
- 36:50reader. And there are some, there are
- 36:52some, you know, online courses that you can take to kind of
- 36:58learn those skills. It's not, you know, rocket
- 37:02science to to do it. Now you're, you're never going
- 37:05to be, as I would never claim to be proficient with screen
- 37:12readers or keyboard navigation as people who depend on them
- 37:15every day, right? But the basics you're going to
- 37:17be able to, you know, learn to identify sort of the basic
- 37:22problems. And so I think that's, you know,
- 37:24just critical basic work to to putting out accessible code.
- 37:32Yes, yeah. And it's, it's, it's it's I
- 37:36always, I always find that as well.
- 37:37The when it's seen as a cost, people aren't thinking about the
- 37:40benefit and costs get cut. Whereas if you see here at ROI,
- 37:45you invest to achieve ROI and I think trying to get people to
- 37:48understand that spending money upfront saves a lot more and has
- 37:51a stronger ROI than trying to retrospectively fix.
- 37:54Well, I'm, I'm kind of coming around to, you know, yeah,
- 37:59there's an expense, but it, but the other side of that is how,
- 38:03what percentage of your site visitors are you comfortable
- 38:07turning away? Yeah.
- 38:10Right, you know, maybe it maybe it's not, maybe you'd maybe
- 38:14you're never going to get to 100%.
- 38:16You know, of everybody can do everything on your side maybe.
- 38:19But you know, are you comfortable turning away 5%, ten
- 38:23percent, 30% of your users, you know, making sure that people
- 38:30can can use. And you know, that's part of a
- 38:32broader in many ways, accessibility is a form of user
- 38:36experience, right? It's taking user personas that
- 38:41have people with disabilities as a into account, but it's a form
- 38:44of UX. And if you're not paying
- 38:46attention to user experience, customer experience, customer
- 38:49journey, you know, you're not going to, you know, it doesn't
- 38:53turn out well for you, right? Yes, you're losing money.
- 38:57You're leaving money on the table when you don't pay
- 38:59attention to those things more broadly, but especially also
- 39:02including the accessibility. Yeah.
- 39:04And I think apart from companies are very compliance obsessed and
- 39:10you know, concerned about about legal cases where actually
- 39:15that's the driving force. They're not Fundamentally, every
- 39:17other business is about. I think there are a lot of
- 39:20companies that really don't care about legal compliance until
- 39:23they get sued. They think of it as a really
- 39:25small risk. They don't and until and then it
- 39:31takes off like fire. Like it's like, you know, once
- 39:34somebody in their, in the, in their kind of niche get sued,
- 39:39then more people are paying attention to that.
- 39:42You know, for a while it was home decor, right?
- 39:47And home decor people were. And now it's more apparel, a
- 39:51more apparel sites are getting sued and then people start
- 39:55paying attention to that. But I think in many ways you're
- 39:58right. They, they don't think about it.
- 40:01And that's why I've tried to shift.
- 40:03In men, you know, I want people to think about it not as
- 40:06avoiding legal action only, but I try to.
- 40:11I mean, it is that and that's what motivates people.
- 40:14But I want it to be more than fear that motivates people.
- 40:16I want it to be like you are leaving money on the table.
- 40:20I can help you, you know, claim some of that money that you're,
- 40:25you know, and, and especially if you were first in your niches to
- 40:30be doing that right, your competitors that you can be
- 40:33making more money than your less accessible competitors.
- 40:36Yes. And that's a nice way of framing
- 40:38it. And let's as a final question,
- 40:41let's come on to tooling. I know we talked about the
- 40:44service kind of services you provide, the value of the human
- 40:46element on top of the tools, but there will be people who
- 40:49initially their standpoint will want to be right.
- 40:52I want to just run a quick audit and see what my site looks like.
- 40:55Overall, choosing a tool is really, really important because
- 41:00you could get something that's going to give you some
- 41:03information that's not practical or might not be reliable.
- 41:05So what free tools do you use? Do you rate, Do you recommend to
- 41:09help people, I guess get a starting point of knowledge and
- 41:12then when somebody's at an all mature stage, what are the paid
- 41:16options that you rate? Right.
- 41:20So I think if you're just starting out and you have never,
- 41:25ever thought about accessibility, a good place
- 41:28that's fairly easy to to start getting a sense for how bad
- 41:33things are or what you might need to fix is the
- 41:36wave.webaim.org tool. And it is a free tool that will
- 41:42do an automated scan of your site and just give you a, you
- 41:47know, a, a feed out of the numbers of issues for a single
- 41:50page of your site. So run your home page, run a
- 41:53couple of product pages. It it will only provide those
- 41:57automated things. So it's going to give you total
- 41:59errors. And then and then it'll give you
- 42:02in addition to that contrast errors, color contrast errors.
- 42:06Do be aware that when you look at that, you know, automated
- 42:10tools have limitations, right? There can be false positives and
- 42:13false negatives, but you there are a lot of false positives for
- 42:18color contrast when there's text on top of a background image
- 42:22because of course the automated tool can't see the background
- 42:25image. They only see.
- 42:27So when you look at the color contrast test and it says white
- 42:29text on white background, that's a color contrast violation.
- 42:33So really because there's an image there that's providing the
- 42:36contrast. So you have to kind of do some
- 42:39but be thoughtful about it, but that can give you a good sense
- 42:41and kind of begin to, to help you to focus on that.
- 42:44But that's a free tool. It it's pretty simple.
- 42:47It's pretty straightforward. There's a browser extension I
- 42:49use all the time. There are Axe tools in the
- 42:52Chrome inspector that you can use that kind of similar.
- 42:56I think those are harder for non developers to use that, you
- 42:59know, if you're a brand owner do that.
- 43:01But the Axe tools are probably the next best free level of
- 43:04those. And there's some other plug
- 43:08insurance and extensions for browsers that can help you look
- 43:11at reading order, things like that in the, in the in the
- 43:15browser window as you're testing.
- 43:17So those are kind of free tools. I like then as you I, I don't
- 43:23think it's super helpful to start.
- 43:27Well, you can you can start doing regular automated scans of
- 43:34all the pages of your site and that will help you find the
- 43:38places on all the pages where you need to start fixing color
- 43:43contrast and things like heading structures that are out of
- 43:47place, alt text that's missing all of those kinds of pieces.
- 43:51Just understand that if you start using those tools and
- 43:54fixing those, that's that's only going to get you a certain part
- 43:58of the journey there. And it may not even be the the
- 44:03really blocking pieces. So you may certainly a, a, a
- 44:08good, you know, getting started on those things is a good thing
- 44:12for those I use. We we've worked with site
- 44:15improve is 1. They're not very transparent
- 44:18about the pricing on the thing and but I also really like AAA
- 44:25Aardvark, so Aardvark accessibility and they're much
- 44:28more transparent about their pricing.
- 44:30And I really like the tool is good for people who both
- 44:34developers. There's a lot of information for
- 44:36developers, but also non developers for giving reports,
- 44:38but also kind of understanding issues and finding information
- 44:43about that. So those are the two kind of
- 44:45paid tools that I like for that. But just understand that at some
- 44:48point, even if you're just using those pieces and moving along,
- 44:51you're probably going to want to have some kind of help from an
- 44:55accessibility professional in terms of some testing and or
- 44:59guidance around the remediation. It's important to look carefully
- 45:04at that. It's kind of like the early days
- 45:07of SEO. Everybody's hanging out their
- 45:09accessibility shingle, especially in the EU now with
- 45:13all of the stuff coming up, a lot of people kind of piling on.
- 45:16So you'll want to look for folks, you know, a good thing to
- 45:19do in terms of asking folks, interviewing folks is to ask do
- 45:23they do manual testing? Because some people are only
- 45:26depending on automated testing And you know, do they do
- 45:30automated testing? Do they test with screen
- 45:32readers? Do they, you know, do can they
- 45:35help you find testing with people who actually have
- 45:37disabilities? So that's you can begin to kind
- 45:40of, you know, be a little wary of folks asking those questions.
- 45:44You can look for the a certification from the
- 45:47International Association of Accessibility Professionals,
- 45:50IAAP. The basic credential is a, what
- 45:54we call C PAC certified professional and Accessibility
- 45:58core competencies. That can be an indicator having
- 46:02that kind of, you know, a credential, but just know that
- 46:08it was, there wasn't a big push to get credentials for a long
- 46:11time in inaccessibility work because it really didn't matter
- 46:17in some ways until the EU Accessibility Act now talks
- 46:20about, you know, professionals. And so more people are getting
- 46:25that credential, but there's only about 3500 of us in the
- 46:27whole world that have that credential right now.
- 46:29And so, you know, it's growing and there's a certainly a
- 46:31widespread interest in folks getting that credential.
- 46:34But but you know, it can be an indicator, but also there are
- 46:36people who are very experienced accessibility professionals who
- 46:39don't have that credential. So just asking about them, get a
- 46:42sample report, see, you know, talk to folks.
- 46:45Do they talk real human language or do they, you know, do are
- 46:49they understandable and supportive and help you learn or
- 46:52are they, you know, not not helpful, right?
- 46:57I mean in that way. I've, you know, I've really
- 47:00enjoyed this and I, I love talking about accessibility.
- 47:03I must be one of those strange people who really enjoys geeking
- 47:07out on E com, but it's so important.
- 47:09It really is important and it's it's going to be increase.
- 47:11If you look at the if you look at the trends of the, the and
- 47:15definitions of accessibility and where like population challenges
- 47:19are going with things like vision, etcetera.
- 47:21The numbers are going up. They're not going down,
- 47:23especially people are people are generally living a lot longer
- 47:26and therefore the amount of time that people are living with
- 47:29these challenges is increasing. So you're right.
- 47:32Well, and, and generationally we're shifting right, You know,
- 47:36so people, especially a pandemic accelerated this, but all, you
- 47:40know, people who were in their 80s and 90s before, we're not
- 47:44really online in the way that now incoming 80 and 90 year olds
- 47:48have been, right. And so we have more increased
- 47:51use of the web. But you know, it's really about
- 47:54if you are lucky enough to not die suddenly you will acquire a
- 47:59disability and need this. So there's some self maybe you
- 48:03should think about the experience you want for yourself
- 48:05in the future, your future self or your future, you know, spouse
- 48:09or children, what what you would like for them in terms of
- 48:12accessibility because we all will have a disability at some
- 48:15point. Yeah.
- 48:16I think that's a really nice way of framing it.
- 48:17And it's not, not not ending the negative ending on the
- 48:20practicality that actually this coming back to your earlier
- 48:22point, this is fundamentally about protecting your business
- 48:25and opening it up to the widest possible audience and, and
- 48:28giving people a decent experience so that they, they
- 48:30feel valued and they want to come back and shop with you and
- 48:32not somebody else. So bet I've really, I've loved
- 48:34it. Thank you for reaching out and,
- 48:36and, and setting this up. But if somebody's interested,
- 48:40they want to learn more, they've got a specific challenge or they
- 48:42want to know more about how you deliver that kind of human
- 48:45expertise. How do they connect?
- 48:48The best place is our website, excessivecart.com and you can
- 48:53reach out to me there or via LinkedIn, Beth Hannon.
- 48:57Excellent. And the links will be on our
- 49:00landing page on our website. So if you do want to find
- 49:02details of the website or Bet's LinkedIn profile, just go and
- 49:05have a look at the landing page. Bet, thanks so much.
- 49:08And I mean, I wish you a wonderful weekend.
- 49:11Thank you. I appreciate that.
- 49:13Great to chat with you. Yeah, and you and thanks
- 49:15everyone. As listened.
- 49:15As always, keep your ears peeled for next week.
- 49:19You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 49:21experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 49:24Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 49:27featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 49:30industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 49:32explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 49:35and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 49:37really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 49:40to help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and tech
- 49:43stack. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 49:45out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an e-commerce
- 49:48project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 49:50episode.