Latest / Houselights: A Film Director Podcast / Da Five Bloods (2020) - Spike Lee | Houselights #184
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everybody. Tristan Riddell here, and I just wanted to give you a
- 0:03quick note before you started this episode that there was an unforeseen technical error with
- 0:09the service that we used to record. Even our backup was messed up.
- 0:12And so while this episode is very listenable and it is still a fantastic conversation
- 0:17that I'm sure all of you will enjoy, the technical quality is not up
- 0:22to our usual standards. But we didn't want to deprive you of an episode
- 0:25this week, so we hope that you can forgive us and please enjoy.
- 0:31Welcome to the ned Palty, Hello at home, and welcome back to House
- 0:51Lights. Here we are entered into the House of Lee, Spike Lee in
- 0:55specific, as we've been looking at a different work of Spike Lee through each
- 1:00decade that he has been active as a director. This is going to be
- 1:03our final week in the House of Lee as we look at twenty twenty's to
- 1:08five Bloods, which was a Netflix exclusive released to a fair amount of fanfare
- 1:15actually and with an all star cast, to discuss this Vietnam retrospective through the
- 1:21lens of the Black Experience. I'm joined by Darren Moser and Tristan Riddell here
- 1:26on house lights, gentlemen. I mean, let's just get down to brass
- 1:30tacks. No, you know, we're not going to do any sort of
- 1:32like soft shoe into this or anything, but to five Bloods. Did you
- 1:37catch this? Tristan, I'll ask you first, did you catch this when
- 1:40it came out? Or is this your first time encountering this and going in?
- 1:44What did you know about it? I had never seen this before.
- 1:49I had very rarely heard of it, Like I think I saw a trailer
- 1:53for it to begin with, and a long time ago when it first came
- 1:57out, and I just didn't really give it a second thought. Was I
- 2:02kind of chuckled a little bit at deaf five Bloods? Like even just like
- 2:07saying it out loud to you guys. Now I feel a little self conscious,
- 2:12like should I say that? Should I call it the five blood But
- 2:15it's not the five Bloods, it's the five Bloods. I knew nothing about
- 2:19it other than that it was four guys going back to looking for something.
- 2:23But I didn't even know that. I didn't even know what they were looking
- 2:27for. They were just they were ve's going back and visiting. That was
- 2:30it? Darren? What about you. Is this your first time encountering it
- 2:34and did you know anything going in? No, this was definitely my first
- 2:37time seeing it. And yeah, I don't watch as much Netflix nowadays,
- 2:44so it didn't even hang on my radar. So I probably should have looked
- 2:49at more of what Spike Lee had done as we were diving into this house.
- 2:52But yeah, it is always the fun to visit a director's work that
- 2:59is really current, because sometimes when we're doing decade by decade, even our
- 3:01most current piece could be ten years old. But this is only you know
- 3:07half of that. You know, it's interesting too because with this I was
- 3:12excited to see it. I remember seeing the trailers for it. I don't
- 3:14know why I didn't watch it before now. I was very excited by it,
- 3:17the cast, the concept. I you know, I grew up in
- 3:22the eighties and nineties, but like you know, I'm first coming up in
- 3:25the eighties. I remember seeing Platoon in the movie theater. I was entirely
- 3:29too young, should not have gone to go see that movie, yet I
- 3:31did. So. Vietnam movies have always been sort of a staple because the
- 3:36eighties was the first big pass through, you know, starting of course with
- 3:38seventy nine. You know, you get Deer Hunter, you get Apocalypse Now.
- 3:44But in the eighties there was like Hamburger, Hill, Platoon, all
- 3:47of these different movies that came out. Casualties of War with Sean Pennan and
- 3:52Michael J. Fox, directed by Brian De Palma, So I sort of
- 3:55grew up on Vietnam movies. So it's a comfortable area for me in the
- 4:00sense that it's like, you know, if you view it as its own
- 4:02genre, it's like being a sci fi fan, where you're like, oh,
- 4:05okay, I understand the rules of this genre, and I enjoy the
- 4:10war movie and the retrospective, and there's something cathartic about going through something like
- 4:15this, even though I've never been in war or anything. It always offers
- 4:17the opportunity to get in touch with some really real sort of emotions that are
- 4:21out there. So I was very excited. I don't know, I can't
- 4:25explain why I missed it, but I did. And then time March is
- 4:28forward and now here we are, And what's interesting to me about it is,
- 4:33you know, Darren, you mentioned this is only four years old,
- 4:35but this was the first feature film that Lee did after twenty eighteen's Black Clansmen,
- 4:43and it's decidedly different in tone. Right, Black Clansmen, we all
- 4:46talked about it had, you know, quasi comedic aspect to it. This
- 4:53definitely is not playing for laughs in any regard. Now, my first question
- 4:58to you, Tristan is, while I grew up, you know, decades
- 5:01ago, in the height of Vietnam era film storytelling, you know, retrospective
- 5:06storytelling, this is twenty twenty and we're in the twenty twenties. Now Vietnam
- 5:13is a very long time away. Now, did you have any challenges connecting
- 5:18with the stories it were? Would this film have benefited and I know it
- 5:24changes the whole structure of everything, but basically, is it like watching a
- 5:29World War Two movie? At this point it's so distant that there's a difficulty
- 5:32with the emotional connection of that conflict. I as someone who was born in
- 5:39the mid eighties, you know, obviously, like Vietnam was finished by the
- 5:45time I was born, and you know, being born in the in the
- 5:47Cold War, and you know, being raised on you know, Afghanistan and
- 5:53you know desert storm and everything like that, you know, like there was
- 5:56always there was always some sort of distance, like I'd never up until September
- 6:00eleventh, there was really no you know, oh my god, this is
- 6:03this is happening mentality when I was a kid, Like I said, it
- 6:08was like not until September eleventh. And but the thing is, my dad
- 6:14was born in the forties and so and my mother was born in the fifties,
- 6:17and so they went to high school. They both went to school during
- 6:21the Vietnam era, and they saw friends getting drafted and my dad got lucky
- 6:27and he had a low lottery number. And so because of their experience,
- 6:32I know more about it than probably your average person who didn't who wasn't raised
- 6:39during that time. And on top of that, I'm a huge movie fan,
- 6:43and so I've seen tons and tons of Vietnam War movies, just like
- 6:46my grandfather, who actually fought in World War Two, has seen tons and
- 6:49tons and tons of World War Two movies. And so to me, this
- 6:56didn't feel like that far away, even though you know, like I mean,
- 7:00we're getting older, Vietnam Vets are getting older. The greatest generation is
- 7:02almost gone. My you know, like my my grandfather who lied about his
- 7:08age in order to serve in the navy, I think he was sixteen,
- 7:13like, and he said he was eighteen and he's ninety seven right now and
- 7:17he's still alive and kicking just now stops driving. And so, you know,
- 7:25I have older parents who had older parents, and so I feel like
- 7:28that generational knowledge kind of got passed down as well as I try to keep
- 7:31track of it through a pop culture hemisphere. So that was a very long
- 7:36answer to say, No, I didn't feel like the disconnect, but I
- 7:40would be interested to hear what gin Z or younger you know, has any
- 7:46opinion on the Vietnam because even when you know, John, I don't know
- 7:49about you, but Darren, you know, like when we were growing up,
- 7:53did you did we even have a section a segment in school in elementary
- 7:59school, middle school, or high school about the Vietnam War. I feel
- 8:01like it was the war that was least taught about in schools, at least
- 8:03from my perspective. Yeah, I mean just a cursory coverage. But I
- 8:09think again, just World War two is supreme, like World War one and
- 8:13two like and actually you were lucky if you got a good chunk of World
- 8:16War one, because it's a very different war. But you know, by
- 8:20far eighty percent was probably World War Two. Well we covered and as little
- 8:24as you might have covered about Vietnam, the true forgotten conflict is the Korean
- 8:26War, which just is it's a shame how few people actually know learned everything
- 8:33about the Korean War from Mesh, which I'm not saying is a good thing.
- 8:35I'm just saying that's what has taught me because it's not taught elsewhere.
- 8:41Yeah, it's going back to my grandfather, who fought in World War Two
- 8:45also fought in the Korean War. And that's probably the only reason why I
- 8:48know about it, honestly, is because my grandfather. Well, just as
- 8:52an aside as we move forward, the Korean War Memorial is an overlooked,
- 8:56haunting gem. If you ever get the chance to see it on the New
- 9:00National Ball when there's snow on the ground at night, it absolutely will never
- 9:03leave you. But Darren, you know, Tristan has said, you know,
- 9:07he didn't really have a trouble connecting, but you know, I'm not
- 9:11trying to like hang onto this thing, but like, is there any trouble
- 9:16connecting on your end with Vietnam? And the whole reason I bring it up
- 9:18is because as worthwhile as it is, to explore every conflict from as many
- 9:24different angles as you can get, and you know, we'll get to Lee's
- 9:28perspective as we see it here. Like, you know, do you think
- 9:35that the time for this movie was maybe ten years prior to its release,
- 9:39or even fifteen years prior to its release, would have resonated with audiences more
- 9:45initially? I would say yes, like, like ten years prior is probably
- 9:48more of a time to resonate. But I think because it's not it's not
- 9:54just telling us, you know, an in person. We're set in the
- 10:00the seventies, is during the war. It's not that kind of a movie.
- 10:03It's a flashback movie. And because a lot of the story hinges on
- 10:09the characters and they're all old dads with families and you know, but they're
- 10:15kind of still back there. You know, there's a part of them that
- 10:18never left, that never could let go of what happened and what they saw
- 10:22their and their comrades and all of that. So I think that angle the
- 10:28older your present day actors are, the better that payoff is. So I
- 10:33think that I'll say that worked well if this had just been you know,
- 10:37the young guys in the seventies it's all in the moment and we're seeing all
- 10:41of that, and then maybe we're saving private Ryan it at the very end
- 10:46where they're around a tombstone, like, that's a different story and I but
- 10:50I think what he did worked well in twenty twenty four. So Tristan Darren
- 10:56talks about these are men who are trapped in this moment. There's a part
- 11:01of them that's never left it. Lee makes a very conscious decision not to
- 11:05deage his actors, even though they're playing the young versions of themselves. I
- 11:09will flat out admit through me when it first happened, I was like,
- 11:13wait, did they even like? I was like struggling where I was like
- 11:16wait, is this just shoddy work? Is the lighting wrong? Because I'm
- 11:20so used to it to de aging by this point, I just accepted as
- 11:24a natural thing that's going to happen. Did you appreciate what Lee was doing
- 11:28there by consciously not deaging his actors or did it take you out of the
- 11:33moment at all? I didn't even know what he was going for until I
- 11:39started doing some research after I saw the movie, where a couple of people
- 11:45commented with authority, I have no idea if they're accurate or not, but
- 11:48where they said like, oh, the reason why they didn't recast or dage
- 11:52is because this wasn't a flashback. This was actually told through the memories of
- 11:58the guys themselves, and so they're they're remembering themselves as they are now,
- 12:05and they're remembering their fallen brother because that's how old he was when he fell.
- 12:09And I was like, oh, that's pretty interesting. I didn't get
- 12:13that at all when I was watching it. It really took me out,
- 12:18Like it really took me out. Because I'm not saying he had to like
- 12:22use some sort of like Irishman technology and dage. It's just there was a
- 12:26photo that they showed of all of them together and they clearly had dyed black
- 12:31hair, no grays, no roots, no nothing. And I think Isaiah
- 12:35Washington had a lot of makeup on to kind of flatten his face. And
- 12:41I was like, yeah, I can buy that. But when I saw
- 12:43them first, you know, running around and they all have grays on their
- 12:48temples, they're you know, like they're definitely heavier than they would have been
- 12:50if they were like eighteen nineteen or twenty or something like that. It did.
- 12:56It really took me out of it. Especially during that first I was
- 13:00just like, Okay, this is what he's doing. Clearly he's making a
- 13:03choice not to do this. But I kept thinking about it every single time
- 13:07we went back, and I was right there with you, Darren, something
- 13:11I was thinking about to try to get past it. I would throw the
- 13:13idea out at you to achieve what Tristian's talking about, where it's like,
- 13:18oh, they're telling from their perspective, and so they see themselves as themselves
- 13:22in that moment. Should live instead taken a different tech and had it so
- 13:26that whoever's primary perspective we were getting in the flashback, he did not dage,
- 13:31but everybody else around them was the proper age and build for what was
- 13:37going on. Would that have helped? I mean, there's a couple of
- 13:39ways you could do it. You could frame it more where someone's like literally
- 13:43reading a diary or something, so that's very obvious. This is a memory,
- 13:48this is being a told story. You could do a perspective shift where
- 13:54the person, like you said, who is the key viewer. It's literally
- 13:58their point of you never see them third person. They're always the eyes we
- 14:03are viewing. I think I know they did some things with aspect ratios in
- 14:07the different times, which I think helps. I think it gave a lot,
- 14:13But honestly, the biggest aspect to me, it didn't bother me as
- 14:18much them not deaging. Honestly, I almost thought that they had changed actors,
- 14:22because again they did you know, make up and changed a little bit,
- 14:26so I was still in the learning who's who moment of the story as
- 14:31I was trying to like pick out, So in a way, them being
- 14:33the same actor helped. But I think the fact that Chadwick Boseman was like,
- 14:39obviously he's stuck in time. He is only in the past, and
- 14:45he's a younger guy than all these other gentlemen. So in that regard,
- 14:50I think it had a very interesting take in the fact that you have this
- 14:54young guy leading a bunch of older, visibly older guys around, but they're
- 15:00all meant to be, you know, in the same same time. So
- 15:03I think the inclusion of you know, of Storm and Norman, I think
- 15:09pulled it off enough to make it pass for me, you know where it
- 15:13gave an interesting aspect. One thing that I always felt like as I was
- 15:18watching it, I was like, it really could have been I mean,
- 15:22this is gonna be this is going to reveal a future criticism of myself.
- 15:26There's so much of this film that is spoon fed to you anyway, Like
- 15:31so much of it is spoon fed to you. I know that Spike Lee
- 15:33doesn't do subtlety very well, and he and sometimes he likes to hit you
- 15:37overhead with a hammer. So I think this addition that I'm about to say
- 15:41wouldn't be that big of a deal. Is that, like before our first
- 15:45flashback or memory recall or whatever, because they often talk, especially Paul talks
- 15:50about seeing Storm and Norman all the time, like he's like as a ghost.
- 15:54He's like he's talks to me. I see him every night. It's
- 15:56crazy. And in one of those moments, he could say, like when
- 16:00I remember the days when we were all here, you know, I look
- 16:04at Storm and Norman and he's still young as ever. But when I look
- 16:07at your sorry ass, you're you're overweight and gray haired. You know this
- 16:11is something like that, you know, like when I remember us, you
- 16:12know, it's something along those lines. So it's embedded in our brain that
- 16:18oh it's okay, we're seeing it through the eyes of so and so's memory
- 16:22and you know, then my brain would have released just a little bit.
- 16:26I mean, I think it's a I think it's a fair thing. It's
- 16:30it's challenging, and Darren, let me let me throw this to you,
- 16:33okay. I think that it's challenging because the film's structure I think betrays the
- 16:40fact that it's a rewrite. That this film was originally set for Oliver Stone
- 16:45actually to direct it, and then Lee came in and rewrote the film,
- 16:48and he acknowledged a book by Wallace Terry called Blood's in Oral History of the
- 16:53Vietnam War by Black Veterans, so he used that as a way to reshape
- 16:59the story. Do you think that some of the challenges and some of the
- 17:03decisions made here, including the deaging, including the way the characters relate to
- 17:07each other, including the spoon feeding, do you think that is reflective of
- 17:11the rewrite as opposed to it being a nature of the script from the ground
- 17:15up. I mean, it's kind of hard to say without knowing the original
- 17:19story, just like you know, anytime, you don't know how much has
- 17:22been rewritten. But it I think really the crutch that this movie has is,
- 17:34like you said, Tristan is kind of that spoon feeding and it.
- 17:38I mean I kind of mentioned as we were getting ready to record that this
- 17:42is a Netflix movie. I wasn't really meaning that as a compliment in the
- 17:48very beginning. I was meaning it in the fact that it like it looked
- 17:52like it it had a not a cheapness. That's the wrong word, because
- 17:57Netflix is quale, but it felt less cinematic, but at least to me
- 18:04by far then, especially than Black Clansmen, And that could be subconscious things
- 18:10I'm picking up on the lens uses and the cinematography and like, like,
- 18:14there's things that we think of that make us feel like that things are cinematic,
- 18:18but this felt smaller and less budget and it just always gave me that
- 18:26vibe the entire time in Tristan. Do you think that Darren's criticism, and
- 18:30I think it's a fair one, has to do with the way that digital
- 18:33video is used in this well, I mean digital filmmaking basically where they like,
- 18:38I would offer my own comment on it that what makes it feel and
- 18:42look a little odd is it has in the night scenes, specifically when they're
- 18:48out on the town in Vietnam in the beginning especially when they're outdoors. There's
- 18:55that different visual like that it's hard for me to quantify, but like it
- 18:59just it looks more like a documentary type of type of shooting. Like it
- 19:04doesn't match with when when you when you move digital into nighttime and if you
- 19:11don't light it just right, it looks like digital video as opposed to high
- 19:18quality. What you're talking about is it's kind of like your your ISO setting.
- 19:25You know, like on film cameras, you have film ISO which is
- 19:27the type of literal film that you put into the camera and that measures your
- 19:32light sensitivity. On a digital camera, it is you can adjust it where
- 19:37you can say, like you can put in your type of ISO that you
- 19:41want, and sometimes if you don't shoot at a native ISO and you kind
- 19:47of ramp it up and try to ramp up the sensitivity, which is often
- 19:49happens at nighttime like you don't have as many lights, it can make it
- 19:55look very digitally, where like the motion is different, the motion blur is
- 20:00different from what we register as film. The if you look at Michael Mann's
- 20:07work on Collateral and those night scenes, that's kind of what he shot it
- 20:12on digital tape and he kind of embraced that look. He said like,
- 20:15yeah, this is what it looks like. If you don't know what you're
- 20:18doing when it comes to lighting digital at night, it'll look like collateral.
- 20:25And sometimes it's a good thing if that's what you want to do. But
- 20:26if you don't want that, that's what can happen. And what's funny is
- 20:30that there was another scene that kind of took me out at nighttime, which
- 20:34was too blue. It was way too blue. Yes, And the reason
- 20:40why it's way too blue is because that actually wasn't shot at night. It
- 20:42was a day for night scene where they shoot it during the day and then
- 20:47just in post just make it as dark as possible and then cover the saturation
- 20:52with blue. So I don't know. Monte Cristo and the night beaches where
- 20:56it's so obvious it's day. Yeah, Like there is a two o'clock shadow
- 21:03on that horse riding down the beach. What's crazy is that, like it's
- 21:07at quote unquote nighttime and people are like squinting because the moon is so bright
- 21:15shades at night because I'm aheading to Graceland, you know, I don't know
- 21:21if I agree with Darren's statement about how it didn't feel cinematic. I think,
- 21:26well, I mean, okay, let me, let me rephrase it.
- 21:30I think there are there are things about this movie that don't feel as
- 21:33cinematic as the past, because I feel like Lee is you know, Lee
- 21:38on location is different than Lee in a city, And Lee doing an action
- 21:45scene is different than Lee doing a conversation scene, and so this is I
- 21:49feel like this is one of those movies where Lee is stretching himself. He's
- 21:52doing different things, He's doing things he's never done before, He's doing more
- 21:57of it, and it's just there were certain digital effects that didn't quite work,
- 22:03like the the blood splatter and the muzzle flashes didn't quite work to like,
- 22:07Oh, that feels kind of cheap. Also, I feel like Lee's
- 22:11visual language was all over the place with it since we're on it, Like,
- 22:15his visual language was so different from scene to scene. It made the
- 22:21tonal shifts that much more jarring. There were so many times I felt like
- 22:25I got whiplash. I'm glad you said that, because, in all honesty,
- 22:29if it weren't for knowing that it was directed by Spike Lee, I
- 22:33struggled so hard to find him in here. From a visual sense. Just
- 22:37look at the difference even with Black Clansmen in this two years apart in terms
- 22:41of their release. I would have I would have put money on different directors
- 22:45between those two, just visually right off of that. And and it's and
- 22:49it's we don't even get the the signature. Uh uh, you know,
- 22:55tracking shot until the very end, and it is it's really odd, Darren.
- 23:03Do you think that's because this subject matter is so different? Like Tristan
- 23:07mentions, Lee is obviously stretching himself here. He's trying to do something different
- 23:14than what he's done before. Do you think that this is that this film
- 23:18reflects a director who's trying something new, And as much as we give him
- 23:23credit for that, it's just not clicking the way that he had hoped it
- 23:26would. That he doesn't quite find purchase, He doesn't find his footing on
- 23:32this particular hill. I mean, it could be. I think I didn't
- 23:37even notice till Tristan mentioned it though. Yeah, the four previous films we've
- 23:41watched are all in a city, you know, different types of cities,
- 23:45but a town, you know, and this is jungle. This is completely
- 23:48different, you know. Now, I do want to say some positive things
- 23:55about it, Like I feel that the minefield tension was very well done,
- 24:02like you plant the seeds of oh, we're part of a group that are
- 24:07getting rid of mind, so thus we have let you know that there are
- 24:11minds. And then I swear as that guy's walking around with that metal detector,
- 24:15I'm like, dude, like, you're just you're you're attacking the ground
- 24:21every time there's metal, and I just I'm just waiting. I'm just waiting
- 24:25for it to happen. I hated how laughable that scene was, like building
- 24:33up to it, okay, and let me let me fill up the payoff
- 24:37and the way that the mind actually happened wasn't didn't work, or or the
- 24:41way they did the build up. You're saying I think the build up was
- 24:45infuriating, And I say laughable because it was infuriating, not laughable as oh
- 24:49he's gonna step on a land mine. That's hilarious, Right, That's not
- 24:52what I'm saying at all. Uh, it was you know, they talked
- 24:56about him being pigeon toed, and they kept talking about it, kept talking
- 24:59about and then they brought up landmines earlier at the bar, and just like
- 25:02okay, check off's gun, checkof's gun, checkof's gun. And if he
- 25:07had more motivation to move backward, I wouldn't have thought anything of it.
- 25:14Oh, but the fact that he is just randomly walking backwards further, further,
- 25:19further, still talking, still walking backwards for no reason, backwards and
- 25:23backwards and backwards. And I don't know how there could have been anybody in
- 25:27the audience who didn't know that guy was going to get blown up by a
- 25:30landmine. And then when it finally happens, you're like, well, there
- 25:33you go, and you start thinking about tropic thunder when you know, like
- 25:37the director got blown up. And then all of a sudden, you have
- 25:41this crash back to reality where you're like, wait, wait right, this
- 25:45isn't supposed to be a stupid moment. This is insane, this is crazy.
- 25:49And then it gets amped up to eleven when you see that he is
- 25:53still alive. Yeah, that is terrifying, grotesque and just beyond tragic.
- 26:02And then you have this emotional schizophrenia going on. Am I alone in that
- 26:07moment? I see what you're saying, and I agree. I think the
- 26:12general build up was very tense, and the fact when they're looking for gold
- 26:17and he's like and you're like, well, dude, You're like, I
- 26:21would be checking every single thing very gingerly. And they're like, especially when
- 26:25they get really far away from like where the first pieces are found, and
- 26:27they're like, look, there's more goal over here, And I'm like,
- 26:30is there or did you find something else? But no, I totally agree
- 26:34that was well done. The once he starts jumping back, that is a
- 26:41totally like you want to talk about telegraphing, like it is clear as day
- 26:45what's about to happen. I don't think anyone was surprised by that moment,
- 26:51but I think I don't know. I mean, if you're gonna have the
- 26:53gun, the checkof's gun go off, you know, have it be.
- 26:57It could be the same guy and the same moment, but just it's literally
- 27:03him stepping off the path between two trees and boom, like it comes out
- 27:06of nowhere. It was way too telegraphed in that part. I agree.
- 27:11As soon as they started using the metal detector, I like a little stopwatch
- 27:17started going in my head. I was like, how long have we gone
- 27:18before? The mind like I knew it was coming, and Tristan I didn't
- 27:22think it was laughable. I thought it was. It took me so out
- 27:26of it because I was just sitting there waiting for it. I was I
- 27:30was like half paying attention to what's going on with the characters, and the
- 27:33other half of me was obsessively just like, is it it's gonna go up?
- 27:37Nope? Not now? Okay, is it gonna go up? Nope?
- 27:40Not now? And like every minute I was like, is he gonna
- 27:42know? He's not gonna blow up? And I that is what took me
- 27:45out of the movie, because I knew the minute that, uh, that
- 27:49we have the discussion with the people who are looking for minds, you know,
- 27:53oh, we're saving people from minds, I'm like, all right,
- 27:56this is gonna play into things. And it's like it's a shame because I
- 28:02think it's also a very clear indication of how conflicted the movie is about what
- 28:11story it wants to like, what it wants its message to be. Overall,
- 28:15like, there's just too much. It's all over the place. And
- 28:18I think additionally, it's very very clear to me, at least that the
- 28:25maybe in a first draft or maybe at the core of it, that Paul
- 28:29is supposed to be like the main character, like it's to Five Bloods,
- 28:33but it's Paul's story in a lot of parts, but then it strays away
- 28:38at different parts, and it's that sort of It needed more disciplined storytelling so
- 28:45that I stayed with Paul a little more closely through the whole thing, because
- 28:48it very obviously was telling the story of how Paul was a broken person from
- 28:53that moment forward, and that that's why Paul was struggling with who he was,
- 29:00where he was in the world. Why this, why that? Like
- 29:03I the way Delroy Lindo plays him, he's incredibly heartbreaking. By the end.
- 29:08Lindo does an incredible job, as I would expect him to because he's
- 29:12an incredible actor with the role and he just absolutely sticks it. H I
- 29:18mean, Tristan, do you agree with me like that? I mean,
- 29:22did this script need another pass to get it to that discipline point or is
- 29:26this just it was there but it didn't come together in the edit. The
- 29:32script was by far the weakest part of this. I feel like if there
- 29:37was a tighter script, way, way shorter, way, not trying to
- 29:42do as much because there's there's a lot of interesting things in this. There's
- 29:48a lot of interesting things in this Like okay, just just as a brief
- 29:51overview of some of the concepts in this movie. We have blacks, like
- 29:56a disproportionate amount of black souled or being drafted in Vietnam concept. You know,
- 30:04we have we have four black veterans, Vietnam vets, going back to
- 30:11find their fallen brothers bones. Oh twist, it's not really just for bones.
- 30:17They want to steal some CII gold that they feel like they're that they're
- 30:19that they're owed. Oh twist. Paul's son is along on the way.
- 30:25Oh further twist, they don't get along at all. Paul's a broken man
- 30:30and he's a black man who voted for Trump. Whole can of worms right
- 30:33there. And then you know, like further down, we're like, oh,
- 30:37Otis finds out that he has a daughter he knew nothing about. She's
- 30:41an adult. Are they going to reconnect? Who knows? You know?
- 30:45Like and we like then we like land mines. We have three people here
- 30:48who you know, investigate land mines. Oh, we have some we have
- 30:52some Vietnam uh you know, uh, native native Vietnamese people who feel like
- 30:56they're owed the money. Now we got this frint, this French guy who's
- 31:00you know, like messing everything up. It's just and he's really the mastermind
- 31:04behind it all. And and all of a sudden he you know, he's
- 31:07the man behind the curtain. And it's just it's just like an all all
- 31:11why all while Paul is slowly, slowly going into madness. And as Paul
- 31:18is going into madness, like you you as you as the movie goes along,
- 31:22you're like, oh, Paul is clearly broken. He's the one who
- 31:25is not holding it together like everybody else was. You know, like he
- 31:27even mentions that where it's just like yeah, you you know, your wife
- 31:32and kids, they love you, you know, like you're a successful business
- 31:34person. Blah blah blah blah. I could never do it. And like
- 31:38we just know that, like some people came back from non were broken mentally
- 31:41and physically sometimes both. And you know when you just when you realize that
- 31:48he's snapped, you're just like, oh, he snapped and all of a
- 31:51sudden became the villain. But then you're like, oh, wait, no,
- 31:53he's not the villain. He's just snapped. He's going into madness.
- 31:57And by the time you realize he's going into madness, it gets interesting,
- 32:01and then it's over and I feel like, yeah, there's so much of
- 32:06that. I've been talking for a while, but like that's kind I just
- 32:08there's so much in there, and it's all good stuff, but it's just
- 32:13focus, focused on a few things. I agree with that, and I'll
- 32:17go ahead and offer that this is undone partly by its run time, because
- 32:23a lot of the same issues that this has in terms of its storytelling,
- 32:28in terms of its underlying script and all of that stuff, are some criticisms
- 32:32that I would have offered, or I think I did offer actually about do
- 32:37the right thing, but do the right Thing was still tighter. It was
- 32:42a single day. It was focus, It had one thing it was trying
- 32:45to say. It was less ambitious in its scope, and I think that
- 32:50worked to its advantage because it helps make up for a lot of the flaws
- 32:53that a two and a half hour plus run time. You hit that mark
- 32:59and you're kind of like, Okay, I'm if you don't wrap this up
- 33:02in five minutes, I'm gonna have some issues with you. That's really how
- 33:06I feel about a movie like this, where I'm willing to just go along
- 33:09with it. But then as soon as I realized that, no matter how
- 33:13well you stick this landing, you've outstayed your welcome in terms of how much
- 33:17time I want to spend with this, you're asking too much of me as
- 33:22an audience member. And I think to add on to what you were saying,
- 33:25Tristan, and I don't know if you would agree with me, Darren,
- 33:28but I think there are even little moments such as when Eddie Norman Lewis's
- 33:32character is saying, no, this is you know, this is for reparations,
- 33:37is for the cause we're gonna go out there, and Paul says that's
- 33:40easy for you to say you have money, and then Eddie goes, no,
- 33:45I'm actually broke. That was the point at which where I was like,
- 33:46this feels like a high school play at that point, because it's like,
- 33:51oh, okay, well this is another unresult like oh no, he's
- 33:54been broke the whole time, and the car like come off no. And
- 33:59I think it may when you mentioned do the right thing, it made me
- 34:02think back to, you know, how did I feel about those characters and
- 34:07when did I feel that about those characters? And I think the problem with
- 34:12the Five Bloods kind of one of its core issues is they kept giving us
- 34:16those curveballs. I'm okay, Like, in a way, it's good that
- 34:22we jump right into arriving at Vietnam, But in another way, I don't
- 34:25know who any of these characters are right off the bat, So we're kind
- 34:29of jumping into scene two from the very beginning, which you can do if
- 34:34you pull it off right. But I'm still like, say, let's say
- 34:37Paul for example. So I'm trying as a viewer to wrap my mind around
- 34:43how am I supposed to feel about Paul, what kind of story as being
- 34:46told to me that I should agree with, disagree with? How should I
- 34:52feel about this? And just when I kind of get a sense of like,
- 34:55oh, he he's feeling like disconnected after the war, and then and
- 35:00then we get a curveball of like, oh and his son's there and they
- 35:02have a bad relationship, I'm like, okay, and I kind of adjust
- 35:07that understanding, and then you know, eventually we get like, you know,
- 35:12the wife dies in the Birth of the Sun and he takes it on
- 35:15the sun. It's like, okay, and it's just so I think that
- 35:19happens, Like you've stated multiple times, across many characters where at the end
- 35:25I don't know how I'm supposed to feel, and not that I can't make
- 35:30my own decision about how I feel, but how my understanding comparing it to
- 35:37do the right thing. You're picking up on. This is how this character
- 35:39is feeling. This is a father son owning a business, you know,
- 35:45boom like it. That doesn't change throughout the entire movie. That is the
- 35:49core of those characters. They're developed and we're given more information, which obviously
- 35:53is good. That's the plot, but their core of who they are,
- 35:58that anchor never changes, and it does so much that it's sliding out from
- 36:02under you. Honestly, part of me would rather some sort of play out
- 36:08of the entire flashback at the beginning and do something where we the audience know
- 36:15that Paul shot Norman, but the others like that's the domino to drop for
- 36:22them to eventually learn that. But the fact that we are kept from that
- 36:25information for ninety percent of the movie. I mean, it's a choice,
- 36:30but that's how it goes. I would, yeah, I mean, it's
- 36:34always dangerous territory to get into the Oh well, this is how I would
- 36:37have written. But this is the note. The note I would have offered
- 36:39along those same lines. Actually, I would have had a scene at the
- 36:44beginning, probably before you know, the opening titles or whatever, that would
- 36:47have had Paul in his like va therapist's office, where he's talking about how
- 36:52he feels specifically guilty for Norman's death and he's hoping that this trip, you
- 36:59know, the therapist like, well, no, you should go on this
- 37:00trip with your friends. This will help you maybe work some of that out,
- 37:05and you know, and get there, you know, just remember,
- 37:07you know, say do this, take your pills, all those sorts of
- 37:10things, and then you know, and then maybe some poignt line where it's
- 37:15like, I just can't. It's always going to be my fault, and
- 37:17then in the credits and then they're arriving at Vietnam. I think just that
- 37:22little bit of a tease would have been enough for me to have that entry
- 37:25that I think you're talking about, without having without starting off with a flashback.
- 37:30Although I don't reject what you're saying now, Tristan, do you think
- 37:34that some of, if not all, of the film's woes are solved with
- 37:39a little different intro scene like that in the beginning, I think it could
- 37:45solve some like we could compound it with what I was talking about where you
- 37:53know, like if he's talking it was a therapist, and he says,
- 37:54it's like, oh yeah, when I remember back in the days, I
- 37:58remember myself as how I am today, as an old man, blah blah
- 38:01blah blah blah, maybe something like that, like you know, I don't
- 38:05know, I don't I don't know like that, that's not the film we
- 38:07were given. But it's it's an it's an interesting exercise. It's just it's
- 38:12it's I feel like we're compelled to do this because there's so much great material
- 38:19but executed so poorly. And it's you know, there's there's little sprinkles of
- 38:25Lee throughout, but it doesn't feel like a Lee movie. It only feels
- 38:30like a Lee movie when he's become aware of his own signature, like John
- 38:34wu mm hmm. So basically then that brings it to you know, I'll
- 38:39go ahead and ask Eu trist and I mean, we've all we've all repeatedly
- 38:43said, this doesn't really feel like a Lee movie. This doesn't you know,
- 38:45where is he in here? We see a couple of flashes here and
- 38:47there Is this simply a story that Lee was better suited to produce and not
- 38:54direct. Even after Stone passes on it, should Lee have stepped aside and
- 38:59found another director, you know, maybe lent his his his weight to an
- 39:05up and coming black director and said, I'll produce and I'll help write the
- 39:08script, you know, whatever it takes to get it made. Is it
- 39:12just that he failed to realize that he was not the right fit for the
- 39:16material. I think if if he, I think he could still direct.
- 39:23I believe that he could have directed it if he helped write it or said,
- 39:29you know what, this is a great concept. We can't just rewrite
- 39:32it. We can't just rewrite parts. We need to take the core concept
- 39:37and soup the nuts start over. Mm hmm. Like I feel, I
- 39:40feel like if he had more of a hand in its genesis, he this
- 39:45would have been a much better Spike Lee movie. I agree. I completely
- 39:51agree, and Darren, I'm presuming you agree as well. I do,
- 39:54and it's I feel that it is well acted at times, but I just
- 40:06I can't get it out of my head. The forenames of the original cast
- 40:10men being Samuel L. Jackson, Denzel Washington, Gina Carlos Posito and John
- 40:19David Washington, and I just I can't imagine what that movie would be like.
- 40:24I feel like they were just even with the exact same source material.
- 40:30Again, nothing against the actors that we got, but man, that sounds
- 40:35like a good lineup. It is exactly what you mean, man like it.
- 40:37No disrespect to these actors, but who I I again, no disrespect.
- 40:45I love Isaiah Whitlock Junior. I think he's just he's He's an absolutely
- 40:49charming actor. I love Clark Peters. I've always been a fan of Clark
- 40:52Peters and del Ry Lindo. In all honesty, it sounds so stupid,
- 40:59but just like Samuel L. Jackson, if you say he's in the project,
- 41:01I'm like, oh, immediately interested. Okay, I'll at least I'll
- 41:06at least let you play a couple of trailers for me about what this movie
- 41:08is about, sort of thing and setting aside anything else. You know,
- 41:14Jonathan Majors is a talented actor, so you know he brought something to it.
- 41:19And then adding gen Renau on top, I love the guy. I
- 41:22think he's a great actor. But the energy, yes, I love gen
- 41:25Renau popping up like it was just the right size role for him, yep,
- 41:30where I was like, Okay, you're just chewing the scenery. I
- 41:32love it. I love it. And while I acknowledge that you know,
- 41:37Jackson, Washington, Esposito and Washington would have been really well suited and brought
- 41:43a very big energy, you know, very electric sort of cast, I
- 41:47just come back to what Tristan was saying, it's still needed a soup to
- 41:52nuts free, right. I don't think any cast of actors was going to
- 41:55breathe the life into this that was necessary, And I think that the actors
- 42:00that we got, if anything, probably enhance the material because they all lean
- 42:07toward more understated performances, and I think as a result, they were suited.
- 42:14It's a really weird, sounds like backhanded sort of compliment, but I
- 42:19would have rather had this cast try to make the most out of the script
- 42:23that, like the script is a one to one. I think this cast
- 42:28has a more forgive the phrasing, but like a more everyman quality than if
- 42:34I'm watching Sam Jackson in this true I'm like, come on, come on,
- 42:39get it out there. Yeah, I can't wait to see you in
- 42:42a battle scene sort of thing. Whereas I'm more patient with these performances I
- 42:46think, you know, give or take. I think del Roy Lindo when
- 42:51he's going off and he gets bit by the snake and he's going like,
- 42:54those are moments where I'm like, Tristan, you want to talk about fantastic
- 42:58stuff. What about del Lindo alone, hacking his way through getting bitten by
- 43:02the snake, falling down the ravine, having the hallucination. Like that's a
- 43:07piece of the movie that I think was trying to get through the whole time.
- 43:12That I mean, that's kind of what I was talking about earlier when
- 43:14I was saying Paul descending into madness and then he's straight up looking at the
- 43:17camera, which I usually hate, Like I don't like it, Like unless
- 43:22you're doing that all the time, like in House of Cards or something like
- 43:25that, I don't really dig on someone all of a sudden just like looking
- 43:30at the camera and winking at the audience. But the idea that this guy
- 43:35is falling into madness and Lindo has that look in his eye and he's talking
- 43:40about God speaking to him, like, yeah, it's much more terrifying when
- 43:45you look straight down the lens. And then it gets taken away, Well,
- 43:50I definitely, I think the way that they have you know, actually,
- 43:52Darren, I'll ask you this. I know it serves the larger quote
- 43:57unquote story point of is it is de Roche? Is that his name de
- 44:02Roche because it's because they call him the roach at one point or something John's
- 44:07character something like that. It serves a larger story point. But did Paul's
- 44:12death feel right to you in terms of being found and then digs his own
- 44:17grave and gets shot. Did that feel like the right ending for that character?
- 44:22I mean, when he went off his own on his own, I
- 44:24was like, we're not going to see him alive again, like you,
- 44:28like I would be highly surprised if he walked out of that jungle alive.
- 44:31But it honestly, I think we're all kind of agreeing that that sequence is
- 44:37probably the highlight of the movie, like where he is like he is acting
- 44:43his heart out, he is, you know, all the wave is breaking
- 44:47through all of this stuff. And then again it's a choice. But like
- 44:55like you kind of mentioned early on, Tristan, the part where the CGI
- 45:00is used, the fake blood, the you know, it's very obvious that
- 45:05like he's not actually being shot and it's all cg'ed over to and I get
- 45:09the cost saving of that. I get it's a it's a choice, but
- 45:14that pulls me right out of it the with you know, all of those
- 45:16little moments were just just reminded me that this was on Netflix. Is really
- 45:22what it spoke to me. Well, See, the thing is, I
- 45:25take a different tack where if you're going to shoot on digital using natural light
- 45:30in a h an unspoiled environment like the middle of the jungle, I would
- 45:35prefer you not to use the environment destroying blood packets and squibs and stuff like
- 45:39that. I would actually I'll live with the the iffy digital on that one.
- 45:44See, I need my predator like I want. I know, nibs
- 45:47everywhere I know, But I just I'm I'm the type of guy I'm like
- 45:52setting that aside. What I mean is very specifically, uh, him walking
- 45:57in the jungle like basically I expected when he got bit by the snake that
- 46:00was going to lead to the hallucination, and then him face down in the
- 46:05river having one last vision of Norman forgiving him as he drifts off to death.
- 46:12It's the gun like Tristian, I see you nodding, even though it
- 46:15is not a visual medium. I'll let everybody know you're nodding. But like,
- 46:17you know what I'm saying, Like him then getting found and shot,
- 46:21I was like, that doesn't make sense. No, he No, he
- 46:23kept talking about how he wasn't going to let these guys take him down.
- 46:29It wasn't going to let the US government take him down. I wanted nature
- 46:32to take him down. And that's kind of you know, felt like when
- 46:39Paul stormed off, he was in he was in conflict with his own mind
- 46:45and his own surroundings, and that was compounded by when he got bit by
- 46:49the snake and sucking out the poison. He fell down into the ravine,
- 46:53lost his pack, he you know, snagged his foot and he was just
- 46:58kind of hanging there and you know, like he's battling the elements through his
- 47:02own psychosis and the idea that these guys caught up with them and then they
- 47:07just blast him to smithereens is just like no, like he had a peaceful,
- 47:12serene moment when he was when the ghost of Norman forgave him and said,
- 47:16it's just an accident. It's just an accident. God is love.
- 47:19Love is God, have him in a ravine, Have him in that same
- 47:22ravine on his back and looking up into the heavens, give him some sort
- 47:27of some decent exit or I don't know, But he also doesn't in all
- 47:34honesty, at that point in his madness, he doesn't seem like the type
- 47:38that's going to agree to dig the grave. That he's going to be more
- 47:42I'm just going to charge at you in mine madness and think I can take
- 47:45you out sort of thing. But even that's like, it's just too it's
- 47:47too action oriented. Right, it makes more sense. It makes more sense
- 47:52that he dies like that looking up into the sky, he has his final
- 47:55vision, and they find him, yeah, and have some sort of exchange
- 48:00where it's like, well, okay, I guess I guess that's part of
- 48:04it. All right, Well, let's grab his hat and let let Duroche
- 48:07know that he's dead and you know, this is our evidence that we got
- 48:10him sort of thing, or even not even have them find him, just
- 48:14have them find the hat and be like, oh, there's no way that
- 48:15guy's alive. Yeah, something like that. Yeah, very straightforward. No,
- 48:21I mean I picture it again. I think that great scene where he's
- 48:23actually talking to the vision of you know, Storm and Norman, and yeah,
- 48:28do a slow like a two shot over the shoulder of them talking to
- 48:32each other, and you push in enough on Norman that you can't see Paul
- 48:37anymore, but Norman's still looking like he's standing right there. And then when
- 48:43you pull back again, you see that Paul is just face down dead in
- 48:47the river, like like he pat like you don't see the cut. It
- 48:51was just yea, Now there's almost a vision without a person to envision them.
- 48:57And yeah, I like that where the bad guys are upset because they
- 48:59can't and terrogated corpse. They can't get any more information out of it.
- 49:02They'll never find the gold that he had. Yeah, you know. Now,
- 49:07obviously I have a big thing about asking about music, and we all
- 49:10loved the score for Black Clansmen. Darren, I'll throw it to you first.
- 49:15Was there anything about this score that jumped out you? Are you able
- 49:19to even remember what was happening with it? Like, is there anything that
- 49:22jumps out outside of the period music that they used? Yeah, I mean
- 49:27it, you know, it's got some fortunate son. We all know the
- 49:30songs that play during you know, Vietnam movies and that check that box.
- 49:37I guess like I, yeah, nothing really stood out to me, particularly
- 49:40in the score. Now, see that's a trap question, because Tristian,
- 49:44before I toss it to you, I will mention that it was nominated for
- 49:47Best Original Score at the Academy Awards. Does this strike you as a Best
- 49:52Original Score nominee? No, this one felt pretty How do I explain it?
- 50:01Pretty trophy for the times and for the vibe that they were going for.
- 50:07I think, you know, Terrence does fantastic work no matter what movie
- 50:12he's scoring. But I definitely felt like this was one of his weaker scores.
- 50:15But hey, if one of his weaker scores still gets nominated, that
- 50:19means you have a talent. He's a pretty talented guy. That's very very
- 50:22true, very true. And the thing is, we're a podcast that is
- 50:29pretty great at talking about music as we approach third, as we're rounding third,
- 50:34as we like to say, so this brings us inevitably to our final
- 50:37thoughts and ratings four to five Bloods, which as of this recording is the
- 50:45Lee has not directed a feature film since, so we're several years on.
- 50:50I'm very curious as to why that is. I don't know that I would
- 50:54consider this any sort of Swan song. I think Lee's got at least another
- 50:59one in him that that would be worth I think he has twenty four he
- 51:05does that he's working on, Yeah, accorating time to be High and Low,
- 51:09okay, and crime thriller directed by Spike Lee is an a twenty four.
- 51:14So no, all right, but I love the studio, really talented
- 51:19director and crime drama that sounds very much up his alley. Because you're going
- 51:25to be in the city again. To your point Tristan that this is an
- 51:29environment, probably New York, that he feels very rum to stay in the
- 51:31city. Yeah, So, speaking of knowing that he should have stayed in
- 51:36the city, I prefer to stay with Darren giving the first ratings and review
- 51:39here on any episode of house Lights. So Darren, I will kick it
- 51:43to you to help us start closing this out. Final thoughts and rating for
- 51:47twenty twenties to five bloods by Well, yeah, gosh, I think,
- 51:54like I kind of said in the beginning, it's it's a Netflix film.
- 51:58It it doesn't feel like it doesn't feel as big, as polished, as
- 52:07cinematic as Black Clansmen. I love Black Clansmen. I think that you know,
- 52:15it was a very different vibe and feel. I think we've we've said,
- 52:20we've said a lot. I agreed with pretty much everything both of you
- 52:22have said about maybe a page one rewrite, maybe you know, making the
- 52:27story your own, Like I don't know if Lee like had a grandfather in
- 52:30Vietnam or something like that, but or you know, or father, like
- 52:35some sort of personal story that he wanted to put into this. Maybe it
- 52:42would have been better to be something more like Inside Man, where I feel
- 52:45like Inside Man is less messagy, like they're like, it's a good just
- 52:51a good story, whereas this has a lot of message in it, and
- 52:57maybe it didn't need that. But I think as far as we've talked a
- 53:02lot about the actors and you know, even tossing the coin to to Denzel
- 53:07or or to Samuel L. Jackson. But I was hard pressed, in
- 53:14my lance Reddick pick for this picture just because they it's they're all across the
- 53:22pot. I would almost want to give it to Paul just just to see,
- 53:24Like I love Delroy in this. I was excited for Delroy because of
- 53:30us seeing in him. I'm not giving it to Paul. I'm just saying
- 53:31I almost want to do that because it's kind of a like a Paul or
- 53:35Nothing kind of vibe to me. But I think the thinking of ages I
- 53:42can tell I've very definitely thought this all out, But no, I think,
- 53:45yeah, I would give it to to Otis, to to Clark Peters.
- 53:52I think again, we've all said that these guys elevated and and settled
- 53:59their foremance in a good way. That kind of drove the plot. But
- 54:04I'm kind of curious what one of these four being the kind of has the
- 54:10right head on their shoulders. And that's the vibe I think Glance would have
- 54:14given. Is kind of the the straight man of like wait, wait,
- 54:17we're still going through with this, like we're still going into the jungle,
- 54:22like like there's mayans guys like hey, like wave in the flag of like
- 54:25what what are we still doing here? Like or you broke the phone?
- 54:30Why did you do that? Like I think that calm, collected voice of
- 54:35reason, he would be the voice of reason in the middle of the insanity
- 54:38that is this plot. So I'm gonna go with with Otis and I'm raiding
- 54:43it and I'm real sorry and I'm reading a two stars. I'm giving it
- 54:46a two all right, all right, Tristan. I was so excited because
- 54:52I think that recasting Clark Peters is a travesty, and I want one of
- 54:58us to take the first shot at Darren for having the gall like not even
- 55:02I mean, come on, now, Lance Reddick is a terrific actor,
- 55:06but I would never replace Clark Peters. But I've been a fan of his
- 55:09for many many years. At this point, Tristan, where do you see
- 55:14Lance Reddick final thoughts on the film and your rating? Hey, we have
- 55:19gone over this so many times that when we apply Lance Reddick to a film,
- 55:24it is not to replace a bad acting job a good one. It
- 55:30is trying to figure out where he would have fit if he was cast.
- 55:35See no, Darren, he's still trying to make up for that time he
- 55:37tried to change your rating that one time. It's all wise because I would
- 55:44go with Otis as well, for the exact same reasons that Darren talked about.
- 55:46It's just like I think Lance would give that kind of like that wisdom,
- 55:52like Otis felt like the wisest one out there, the one who had
- 55:55his head on his swivel. And on his shoulders, And I feel like,
- 56:00if it wasn't Otis, maybe Eddie. But even then, even then,
- 56:06I think it's Otis is the clear front runner for me, and I'm
- 56:10with my with my rating, I'm teetering between two and two point five.
- 56:15This was a real disappointment for me. I mean, this was there was
- 56:19so many like if I if I wanted to go on concepts, on just
- 56:22concepts that it was going for, you'd be much higher rating. But put
- 56:28them all together, and this isn't just a mediocre film, I guess I'm
- 56:32gonna have to go with with this is a this is a bad film,
- 56:36this is this is two stars. Wow. Well, uh okay, I'm
- 56:40gonna start with the landscratic thing first here Again, yes, we're not judging
- 56:45anybody's performance, but no, I'd never never take Clark Peters out. That's
- 56:49just a no go right there, no fly zone. I'm first inclined to
- 56:54go with him as Eddie because as much as I think Norm Lewis is a
- 56:59great actor, he was actually the second actor after Robert Gillohme to be an
- 57:04African American who took the title role of fan of the opera. I would
- 57:07have loved, loved stage in that role. I love Fan of the Opera's
- 57:12one of my favorite musicals of all time. But I like that Norm feels
- 57:15a little out of place. He feels a little lost here, like Norm.
- 57:21Of all of the characters, I think Norm Eddie as as Norman Lewis
- 57:27plays him. I think Lewis does a really good job of inhabiting a character
- 57:31who feels like he's not even sure why he's there with these guys, you
- 57:37know, like why am I here? You know, And it's like he's
- 57:40setting aside the whole but wait, I'm broke. Like this feels like the
- 57:45type of guy who's got everything put together in such a way that he doesn't
- 57:49feel the need to go do this right. He feels that he's done his
- 57:53part for himself and the world to be, you know, a positive influence
- 58:00on things. I would actually bring Lance Reddick in as de Roche because I
- 58:06think that adds an incredibly great aspect to it to have another black man betray
- 58:14them all, and I think that adds a whole other layer to the ending
- 58:16that winds up being even more interesting. French Lance Reddick, I come here
- 58:22for it exactly, not that it has to be French, but yeah,
- 58:25I could see it. I think I think that would have added a whole
- 58:29other layer to that conflict and would have been would have paid off very much.
- 58:34There's nothing I can disagree with you guys about what you're saying about the
- 58:37movie. Obviously we've had a long conversation. I am so disappointed with this
- 58:42film. I part of it's the expectations game, but I just I just
- 58:49don't know how it could have gone right without a page one rewrite, like
- 58:52you were saying, Tristan. As much as I think Delroy Lindo does everything
- 58:58he can to bring Paul to life, it's just it's a mishmash. It's
- 59:04trying to say too much. It doesn't know how to say everything that's trying
- 59:07to say, and so as a result, I wind up as well with
- 59:10a two. So that's all three of us agreeing on a two for Spike
- 59:15Lee's as we record. This the last film that he has released in any
- 59:21form. And so here we go, closing the door to the House of
- 59:25Lee. Darren. What are we in for next week on House Lights?
- 59:30Well, next week we're going to be covering Roland Emeric of the nineties,
- 59:36which you might think would start with Universal Soldier, But no, we're going
- 59:39back to nineteen ninety with Moon forty four. Buckle up here on house lights.
- 59:46Join the Revolution, Join the net Party.