Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Dynamic Pricing to Balance Supply and Demand
Transcript
- Lucas: So New Year's Eve 2025, Manhattan, around 11:45 PM. Uber's surge multiplier hits 4.2 times the base fare. A ride that normally costs 30 dollars is suddenly 126 dollars. And the internet, predictably, loses its mind. Luna: I remember the screenshots on Twitter. People were furious. But I also remember Uber's response — they said it's working as designed. Lucas: Right. And that's the tension we're going to unpack today. Dynamic pricing — adjusting prices in real time based on supply and demand — is one of the most powerful tools a two-sided marketplace has. But it's also one of the most misunderstood and often hated. Luna: Let's start with the theory. Why does it work economically? Lucas: It solves the fundamental coordination problem. On New Year's Eve, demand for rides spikes maybe five-fold. But supply — drivers — can't just appear instantly. So without a price signal, most riders would open the app, see no cars available, and get frustrated. Surge pricing does two things: it rations the scarce supply to riders who value the trip the most, and it gives drivers a financial incentive to head toward the busy area. Luna: So it's a rationing mechanism and a supply signal in one. Lucas: Exactly. Uber's data from past New Year's Eves shows that without surge pricing, the number of completed rides would drop by roughly 30 percent because drivers simply wouldn't bother. With surge, completion rates stay above 90 percent. The price is higher, but the service actually works. Luna: Yet the public outrage is real. People see it as price gouging. And regulators have taken notice — London's transport authority has considered capping surge multipliers, and California's Assembly actually debated a bill last year that would limit surge to 1.5 times base fare during emergencies. Lucas: That bill didn't pass, but it signals a real regulatory risk. And it raises the question: is dynamic pricing a feature or a bug for long-term marketplace health? I'd argue it's a feature, but only if implemented transparently. Luna: Let's pivot to a different marketplace — Airbnb. They have something called 'Smart Pricing.' How does that work? Lucas: Airbnb's Smart Pricing is an optional tool for hosts. You set a minimum and maximum nightly rate, and Airbnb's algorithm adjusts the price within that range based on local demand signals — things like major events, seasonality, how far in advance the booking is, and even the prices of similar listings nearby. Luna: So it's not as dramatic as Uber's surge. It's more of a gentle nudge. Lucas: Right. A study from 2023 found that hosts who used Smart Pricing saw an average revenue increase of 13 percent. But here's the interesting part: only about 20 percent of Airbnb hosts actually enable it. Most hosts prefer to set their own prices manually, even if they leave money on the table. Luna: Why? Because they feel a loss of control? Lucas: Partly. There's also a behavioral bias. A host who sets a fixed price of 200 dollars a night and gets a booking feels good. A host who uses Smart Pricing and sees the price drop to 150 dollars for a Tuesday in February feels like they're being undercut — even if they'd have gotten zero bookings at 200. Luna: So dynamic pricing can erode trust on the supply side if it feels like the platform is squeezing them. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the delicate balance. On Uber, drivers generally like surge because it boosts their earnings. But riders hate it. On Airbnb, hosts dislike the unpredictability, but guests benefit from lower prices during off-peak times. So the same tool has opposite emotional effects depending on which side you're on. Luna: And let's not forget the platform's take rate. When prices surge, does Uber's commission increase proportionally? Lucas: It does, and that's a subtle but important point. Uber's take rate is roughly 25 percent of the fare. So on a 30-dollar ride, Uber keeps 7.50. On a 126-dollar surge ride, Uber keeps 31.50. The take rate percentage stays the same, but the absolute dollars are much higher. Critics argue that creates a perverse incentive for the platform to keep prices high. Luna: Is that a real concern? I mean, Uber doesn't control the surge directly — it's algorithm-driven based on real-time supply and demand. Lucas: But the algorithm is designed by Uber. And there's evidence that platforms can tune the algorithm to be more or less aggressive. A 2022 paper by researchers at MIT found that Uber's surge pricing could be modeled as a profit-maximizing strategy, not just a market-clearing one. They showed that if Uber reduced surge levels, rider satisfaction would increase, but platform revenue would decrease by about 8 percent. Luna: So there's a tension between short-term revenue and long-term trust. And that's the real challenge for marketplaces. Lucas: Yeah. And it's not just Uber. Think about Amazon's pricing on third-party products — it also fluctuates based on demand and competitor prices. Or even ticket resale platforms like StubHub, where prices for a hot concert can double an hour before showtime. Luna: Let's talk about one more case: the food delivery marketplaces. DoorDash and Uber Eats use dynamic pricing too — peak pricing during dinner rush. Lucas: They do, but it's less visible to the customer. Usually it's baked into a 'service fee' or 'delivery fee' that changes. DoorDash calls it 'DashPass' pricing for subscribers, but non-subscribers see variable fees. A 2024 Consumer Reports study found that the same order from the same restaurant could cost 4 to 7 dollars more at 7 PM than at 2 PM, just due to demand. Luna: And that feels sneaky. People don't mind surge if they know it's surge. But when it's hidden in a fee, it damages trust. Lucas: That's a key takeaway. Transparency matters. In fact, research from the University of Chicago showed that when Uber explicitly labels a ride as 'surge priced' and shows the multiplier, users are 15 percent less likely to cancel compared to when the higher price appears without explanation. Luna: So the framing shapes the reaction. Lucas: Exactly. And that's something all marketplaces can learn from. Dynamic pricing isn't going away — it's too effective at balancing supply and demand. But the way you communicate it to users can make the difference between them feeling taken advantage of and them feeling like they're making a choice. Luna: I want to zoom out for a second. This whole conversation — about balancing supply and demand, about trust, about transparent communication — it really gets at what makes a marketplace work long-term. And honestly, it's why shows like this exist. Lucas: It is. And look — we do this every day because we genuinely find these mechanics fascinating. And a small but meaningful number of listeners have told us they do too, and they've started supporting the show directly. Luna: Yeah, we don't run ads, and it's not backed by a big network. It's just listener-supported. So if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, there's a way to keep them coming. Lucas: Exactly. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but that's what keeps the lights on and the episodes ad-free. And we really appreciate the folks who've already chipped in. Luna: Alright, back to pricing. So we've covered how dynamic pricing works and the trust issues. But what about the future? Any new trends? Lucas: One interesting development is personalized dynamic pricing. Imagine Uber charging you a different surge multiplier than your friend in the same area, based on your past behavior. It's technically possible, and some travel booking sites already do it. Luna: That sounds like a minefield for trust. If people find out they're being charged differently, the backlash could be severe. Lucas: I agree. But some marketplaces are experimenting with it in subtle ways. For example, offering a loyal user a slightly lower price to retain them. The key is whether it's perceived as fair or manipulative. Luna: So what's your take? Is dynamic pricing ultimately a net positive for marketplaces? Lucas: I think it is, but only if it's transparent, predictable, and gives users some control. The best implementations I've seen are the ones where the user understands why the price changed and feels they have alternatives — like waiting a few minutes for the surge to drop, or choosing a different time slot. Luna: So it's about empowerment, not exploitation. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the line every marketplace has to walk. Thanks for listening.