Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Tell Your Boss You're Underpaid Without Getting Fired
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've done your research. You know you're being paid fifteen to twenty percent below market for your role, your experience, your city. And now you have to tell your boss. That conversation might be the most stressful five minutes of your year. Luna: And the stakes are real. People worry it'll backfire — that the manager will get defensive, label them as difficult, or worse, start looking for a replacement. Lucas: Right. And the instinct is to either avoid it entirely or lead with frustration. Neither works. I want to walk through what actually does work, and I'll use a specific case: a marketing manager at a mid-size SaaS company in Chicago. We'll call her Sarah. Luna: What was Sarah's situation? Lucas: She had been in her role for about two years. Great performance reviews. She'd taken on more responsibility than her job description originally covered. But her last raise was three percent. She checked sites like Levels.fyi and Glassdoor, and she saw that the median total comp for her title in Chicago was about fifteen percent higher than what she was making. Luna: So she had data. That's the first step most people skip — they go in with feelings, not facts. Lucas: Exactly. She scheduled a one-on-one with her manager — a normal weekly check-in — and she asked for fifteen minutes at the end to discuss compensation. No ambush. She gave a heads-up. That matters. Luna: What did she actually say? Lucas: She opened with something like: 'I really enjoy working here and I want to stay for the long term. I've been looking at market data for my role, and I've noticed that my current salary is below the median range. I'd like to talk about whether we can adjust that to be more aligned with the market.' Notice what she didn't do. Luna: She didn't say 'I'm underpaid' or 'I deserve more.' She framed it as a retention conversation from the start. Lucas: Exactly. The frame is: I want to stay. I'm not threatening to leave. But the data shows a gap, and I'm asking you to help close it. That's cooperative, not adversarial. And it works because it gives the manager something they can take to HR or their boss — a business case, not an emotional demand. Luna: I've seen the opposite go badly. A friend of mine once went to his boss and said, 'I know what the guy next to me makes, and it's not fair.' That conversation ended with tension that lasted months. Lucas: That's the comparison trap. You never want to compare yourself to a specific coworker. It feels petty. And it puts your manager in a defensive position — they have to protect confidentiality or explain someone else's pay. Instead, compare yourself to the market. That's objective. Luna: So what's the actual script? If someone's listening right now, thinking 'I need to have this talk next week,' what do they say? Lucas: Three parts. Part one: state your commitment. 'I value my role here and I want to continue growing with the company.' Part two: present the data. 'I've researched salaries for my position in this market and my current compensation is about fifteen percent below the median.' Part three: ask for a specific action. 'Could we work together to develop a plan to bring my salary in line with the market?' Luna: I like that last line — 'a plan.' It's not an ultimatum. It acknowledges that adjustments might take time. Lucas: Right. And it invites collaboration. If your manager says, 'Let me look into it and get back to you,' that's a reasonable response. You follow up in a week. If they say no outright, then you have a different conversation. Luna: What do you do if the answer is just no? No wiggle room. Lucas: Then you ask why. Is it a budget issue? A policy issue? A performance perception issue? Sometimes the 'no' is actually about timing — the budget cycle doesn't allow mid-year adjustments. In that case, you ask: 'Can we revisit this in the next review cycle with a target adjustment of X percent?' Get it in writing. Luna: And if it's a straight 'we can't afford it'? Lucas: Then you have a decision to make. But you've done the professional thing. You've opened the door. And you've gathered information. Now you know where you stand. That's valuable whether you stay or leave. Luna: One thing I'd add: timing matters. Don't have this conversation when your company just announced layoffs or when your manager is clearly stressed about a deadline. Lucas: Absolutely. Pick a moment when the business context is stable. And ideally, do it after a win — you just finished a big project, you got positive feedback, you're top of mind as a contributor. That's the leverage point. Luna: Sarah from our example — did she get the raise? Lucas: She did. Her manager took the case to HR, and within three weeks she got a fifteen percent increase. Not the full twenty she wanted, but close. And she got a commitment to revisit in six months. She framed it well, and she got most of what she asked for. Luna: It's interesting — the preparation itself probably gave her confidence. Even if the outcome had been different, she'd know she handled it professionally. Lucas: That's the thing. If we've helped you think through a career move or a tough conversation like this one, we're glad. And we want to keep making these episodes without any sponsor interruptions. The way that happens is through listener support. If you find value in what we do here, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's that simple. Luna: Yeah, no ads, no gimmicks. Just people who care about the show chipping in. Appreciate it. Lucas: Alright, back to the conversation itself. There's one more thing I want to flag: the phrase you should never say. Luna: What's that? Lucas: 'I have an offer from another company.' People think that's the nuclear option for leverage. But it changes the dynamic completely. Now you're negotiating under a threat. Even if you get the raise, trust is damaged. Your manager knows you were looking. And if you stay, you might be first on the list if cuts come. Luna: Unless you actually have an offer and you're prepared to leave, right? Then it's a different conversation. Lucas: Right. If you have a real offer and you're willing to take it, then by all means, have that conversation. But don't bluff. I've seen people bluff and then stay, and their relationship with the manager never recovers. Luna: So the takeaway is: prepare data, frame it as retention, ask for a plan, and never compare yourself to a colleague. Lucas: And one more: practice the conversation out loud. Say it to a friend, say it to your mirror. The words will feel awkward at first. That's normal. The more comfortable you are, the more professional you'll sound in the room. Luna: Good advice. I'd add: write down your key points and bring them with you. It's okay to have notes. Lucas: Absolutely. This is a business meeting. Treat it like one. Alright, that's our time for today. Next episode we're tackling a question we get a lot: how to handle a micromanager without quitting. See you then.