Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Earth vs Soup Ep 198 - Hound Of The Baskervilles (1959)
Transcript
- 0:00I didn't electoral care it the mind bogles. You see, you see your
- 0:04stupid mins, stupid stupid Santa Claus. Long enough, we will bring him
- 0:09to Mars. I've been afraid a lot of times in my life, but
- 0:12I didn't know the real meaning of fear until until I kissed backy. One
- 0:16thing. I'll be clear, it's not for man to interfere in the ways.
- 0:19You've got good evening, everybody, and welcome to Earth Versus Soup Episode
- 0:45one. I'm Aaron Paulier, I'm Darlene. We switched things up a little
- 0:50bit today, closing in on episode two hundred. We are trying to like
- 0:58look at slightly different things for Earth Versus Soup. Not that we've run out
- 1:02of movies, because we actually haven't. I did a brief survey of the
- 1:06movies that we have watched and what movies I know that are out there available
- 1:11for science fiction and horror from this time period, and we can easily go
- 1:15to four hundred before we run out of material and need to talk about other
- 1:22things. But that doesn't mean that we can't put our fingers in other pies,
- 1:26so to speak. And I think this is well. We we've done
- 1:33this a couple times talking about monster squad or stalker. Correct, we've we've
- 1:42we've kind of strippers versus werewolves. There is all this. This one actually
- 1:49fits, even though you might not think immediately that it does well because it's
- 1:53Sherlock Holmes. It's Sherlock Holmes. But why it fits is because it is
- 2:00Hound of the Baskervilles by Hammer, so horor it's well, the hownd of
- 2:07the Baskervilles, you can make an argument is always a horror movie when it's
- 2:12done as a movie, because there is the suggestion of a supernatural creature hunting
- 2:20down the Baskervilles, and therefore it fits into our genre very solidly. But
- 2:29since it's Hammer, it fits even more snugly into our area of expertise because
- 2:37it has many of the people that have been a part of many other horror
- 2:43films and science fiction films that are in England. This is well, I
- 2:47should say that the UK. So it's directed by Terence Fisher, who has
- 2:53done many many of the actual Hammer horror films and science fiction films. He
- 2:59is heightly associated with Hammer. We have a writer that helped with the screenplay.
- 3:06I mean, obviously it's a story by Arthur Conan Doyle. But we
- 3:09have Peter Bryan who did the screenplay for this, and he has done other
- 3:13science fiction work for British productions. But most importantly it's our cast, so
- 3:22it's a Hammer production. Who do we have. We have Peter Cushing as
- 3:27Sherlock Holmes, Sir Christopher Lee, Christopher Lee as Sir Henry Henry Baskerville,
- 3:34Andre Morrel. Andre Morral is doctor Watson, and I think he might be
- 3:38the more controversial pick for this, but well I wouldn't. Maybe controversial is
- 3:45not the right word. He's a strange pick four hit for it because he
- 3:52is a fantastic actor and he does a very good job acting in this movie.
- 4:00He just doesn't feel like Watson to us. Correct, That's what I
- 4:04said, is he didn't feel but he's still a very good actor. Now,
- 4:09the actress in this place to say, I want to say, is
- 4:15not good. She overacts yes, But as I was saying, we have
- 4:25a lot of British film giants in this. We have to also before we
- 4:32get into the plot, if you don't know how to the Baskervilles, you
- 4:35know the spoiler alert is it's one hundred and twenty year old story. You
- 4:43should be spoiled at this point just through osmosis of culture. Correct, So
- 4:48we can we can talk. But before we get into the plot, I
- 4:51wanted to talk about our experience with hownd to the Baskervilles. Well, I
- 4:57should say that it was eighty seven minutes long, okay, and it was
- 5:00released on May fourth, nineteen fifty nine. Okay, it is. We
- 5:06also watched it for free on Amazon Prime. Okay, so if you have
- 5:12Amazon Prime in the United States, you very well might be able to just
- 5:15watch us for free if you sound interested in this. Okay, Darlinge,
- 5:18what is your background with how did the Basker Bills? I read Sherlock's Holmes
- 5:25when I was very young. I've watched a lot of Sherlock Holmes overall,
- 5:34and your favorite one is well, I'll talk about it here, okay.
- 5:39So I probably came to Sherlock Holmes a little later than you. I didn't
- 5:43really read the Holmes Cannon until I was in my late teens. But that
- 5:49being said, I read the entire Homes Cannon in one go and enjoyed every
- 5:57bit of it. Yeah, it was a huge amount of reading, but
- 6:00it was a point in my life where all I did was really read books,
- 6:04and so I think I got through the entire homes Cannon in like five
- 6:09or six days. The other thing we should say is that Sherlock Holmes and
- 6:15Watson and those characters are open source, not because of how long ago now
- 6:21they are. It was open to doing well. Can I continue with my
- 6:29I am a huge fan of Jeremy Brett and Sherlock Holmes. In my opinion,
- 6:32Jeremy Brett is Sherlock Holmes. When I imagine when I'm reading the canon
- 6:39again to this day, when Sherlock is speaking, the voice in my head
- 6:46is Jeremy Brett. Okay, he is to me, he is Holmes.
- 6:51This is the character who has played Holmes. If you have never out there,
- 6:56if you have never seen the Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes television series, it
- 7:02is like small episodes, like hour long episodes, and then there's sometimes big
- 7:06movie events like how of the Baskerville's is an hour and forty minutes that they
- 7:11did. But if you have never seen Jeremy Brett, do yourself the favor
- 7:15to see Jeremy Brett. Correct, I mean, you like Jeremy Brett too,
- 7:21you might not think he's your favorite. Maybe you do, but I
- 7:26don't have a favorite. Okay, I just know when I don't feel like
- 7:30that's say Sherlock Holmes. Oh yeah, okay, see, but you feel
- 7:33Do you feel that Peter Cushing does the role justice this one? Hmmm?
- 7:40He does it? Okay, Yeah, I think he does Holmes fairly well.
- 7:45I think he actually does do Holmes fairly well. Not as good as
- 7:49Jeremy Brett, which is saying something because I love Peter Cushing. I think
- 7:53he's a fantastic actor, and I think he does a great job in this.
- 7:56It's just that to me before we even get into the plot again.
- 8:01Peter Cushing plays him as a little bit more affable, as a little more
- 8:07friendly then you would typically expect Holmes to be. Holmes is generally kind of
- 8:13a cool He's a cucumber, right like he's I don't always get that either.
- 8:20There's some episodes in the writing that he uses charmed. Yes, he
- 8:30can be quite social, he's more he doesn't like to be though. He's
- 8:35more social than his brother. Hm. I don't know. It depends on
- 8:41how you look at it. It depends on how you look at it.
- 8:46Because his brother is yes, a member of a dining club, which would
- 8:52suggest that he is very social, but he likes being by himself in his
- 9:01social club. He likes the quiet, He likes just telling people what to
- 9:05do, right, I don't know Holmes. And anyway, anyway, you
- 9:11were saying that you were saying something else about the Homes canon, Well,
- 9:22it's it's open source. It's open it. There's a lot of fiction that
- 9:28is written by amateurs that uses homes, that uses homes and has been always
- 9:35been able to I thought, be able to use it because I thought that,
- 9:41uhh okay, well this is a weird thing. Okay, this is
- 9:46this is a weird one. And it comes down to like US law versus
- 9:50UK law, Holmes is a very strange example of something that isn't in public
- 10:01domain only because there are portions, and I'm talking about in the US.
- 10:07Holmes isn't in the public domain because not all the homes stories are in the
- 10:11public domain yet. Okay, most are. But if there is a story
- 10:20that has Holmes that isn't public domain, then often I think the Codan Doyle
- 10:26Estate can still say no, you cannot use him as open source. You
- 10:30have to have our blessing to it now. That being said, Conan Doyle
- 10:35back in the day, when he was still alive, said, I don't
- 10:37care what you do with Holmes. If you want him to marry in your
- 10:41story, you may so. At least while Conan Doyle was alive, Sherlock
- 10:48Holmes was kind of open source, a character that you could write. And
- 10:54so today it's still a little different. Today, it's a state wants to
- 11:00make money, you know, it's descendants want to make money, So it's
- 11:05you still have to get their permission to use the character in many different ways.
- 11:11So yeah, I have a whole bunch of like unique, brand new
- 11:13Sherlock Holmes stories that were written within the past, let's say, twenty years,
- 11:16and some of them are very good. Some of them are very good,
- 11:22but they still have permission of the Conan Doula state. I'm not sure
- 11:26when the entirety, at least in US law, I'm not sure when the
- 11:30entirety of the canon will become open source, so to speak. Public domain
- 11:39probably depends on Mickey Mouse. Yeah, because guess what steamboat Wally Comes becomes
- 11:43public domain in twenty twenty four. Do you think that's actually going to happen.
- 11:48I don't know. I'm sure that there will be billions of dollars spent
- 11:52to make sure that the that the public domain laws get changed just because Steamboat
- 12:00Willie comes up in twenty twenty four. Anyway, let's get into the plot
- 12:03and then we'll talk about what works in this movie and what doesn't. Again,
- 12:07I might spend a little less time on this plot, because if you
- 12:11don't know the hound of the Baskerville's plot, I'd be surprised. Now,
- 12:20I do have a question for Okay, okay, this one, Sir Henry
- 12:24Baskerville is from southa was living in South America. The Jeremy Brett version has
- 12:31him coming from America America. Which one is it? The where does it
- 12:35have in the original story? Yes, in the original story he comes from
- 12:39Canada. He was in Canada. I thought that was it. Okay,
- 12:45So let's talk about the plot at least with this movie. So our opening
- 12:52scene is a painting. It actually we actually get some nice paintings of a
- 12:56manor home on the moor, and it's clearly like an oil painting. It's
- 12:58not supposed to be a matte painting for a background chot or anything. Like
- 13:03that. It is clearly art, okay, And we have our titles that
- 13:07go over it. And I loved it. I thought it was actually a
- 13:11very nice painting. It was a painting that I arguably would have in this
- 13:13house hanging on the wall. It was it was. It was spooky.
- 13:18It was a little dark and menacing, but still beautiful in like this kind
- 13:24of manner home at night with a light on in the window. I liked
- 13:28it. It goes with the movie. Oh yeah, no, it goes
- 13:31with the story overall, right. So it starts at this kind of voice
- 13:37over. No, then the legend of the Hound of the Baskervills, and
- 13:41we get a prologue basically to the story where this this guy gets thrown through
- 13:46a stained glass window and I'm like, okay, this is kind of intense.
- 13:50He gets like thrown into a puddle or is it a moat? No,
- 13:56it's a just just dirty dirt, dirt road. Okay. So this
- 14:01guy, Sir Baskerville of the seventeen forties, I guess Sir Hugo Baskerville is
- 14:09a complete nutter deck. Like, this guy is a bourgeoisie that you damn
- 14:18well would walk to see up against the wall in the Revolution. To put
- 14:22it mildly correctly, he he tortures the father after throwing him out the window,
- 14:31coming back and getting him and then putting him in his head into a
- 14:37fire. And it's all because of his The guy is fighting him for his
- 14:43daughters. He yeah, the father, his daughter has been kidnapped by Baskerville,
- 14:56is being held in a room upstairs and Askerville Hall, and is implied
- 15:05that she has already been raped by all, all the whole party, by
- 15:11more than just sir Baskerville. Okay, so this is why I say Sir
- 15:16Hugo is the first against the wall. This guy is an ass. No,
- 15:20he doesn't worse because she runs away and he sends his hunting dogs after.
- 15:28Oh yeah, all the beagles, all the beagles, and she runs
- 15:31to a what is called the abbey ruins. Yes, and he stabs her.
- 15:41Oh no, he doesn't just stab her. He stabs her with like
- 15:43an ornate dagger, like rips her. Yeah, and it's curved, so
- 15:50it's uh, it looks like it's a Middle Eastern dagger of some sort.
- 15:52Yeah, it might be being that that might be wrong. And I apologize
- 15:56for people that have seen this and our sword or dagger people. I don't
- 16:00know. My impression is that he stabs are on what looks to be a
- 16:07sacrificial rock, and there's blood and it's the there's like a howl, and
- 16:15all the dogs are running away and he ends up backing off this body and
- 16:26he's killed. He's killed by something that we really don't see. Yeah,
- 16:32it's supposed to be like a ghost of a dog or ghost. Yeah,
- 16:37and then we we we go into the quote unquote present. Okay, Okay,
- 16:45So so I'm sorry we paused for a second because I needed to do
- 16:48a little bit of digging because Conan Doyle is known for being incredibly detailed with
- 16:56dates and times, and while I'm not sure I don't remember the exact day
- 17:03or time in the original novel, we're actually told what date this is like
- 17:10a few days after, so we actually can figure out when this is supposed
- 17:15to be taking place. Now, the original story was like written in nineteen
- 17:18oh one nineteen oh two, so we actually get a reference here because it
- 17:26turns out that this whole story has been being told to Sherlock Holmes by a
- 17:30doctor Mortimer, who has come from Baskerville Hall. Okay, and we learn
- 17:40that the most recent Baskerville that has been in has been at Baskerville Hall.
- 17:48Charles, Sir Charles was just murdered on Friday the thirteenth of June. That's
- 17:56all they say. But since we know that Conan Doyle was anal retentive about
- 18:03dates and times, I e. You can if if they say that Holmes
- 18:07left from Saint Pancras at this time to go to this place, you can
- 18:15tell exactly what train he was on and when he arrived, as well as
- 18:22the date that he did it. And and so that like when you when
- 18:25you get down to like the irregulars, like the the very famous, and
- 18:30the irregulars are like the big Sherlock Holmes fan club, like you have to
- 18:34have an invitation to become a member of the irregulars. These are like the
- 18:37real people. But anyway, in this film, since we get that date,
- 18:41we can actually kind of figure out about when this is supposed to be
- 18:45taking place, about what year. And it turns out that nineteen oh two
- 18:52as a June Friday the thirteenth, So this is just after June thirteenth,
- 19:00nineteen oh Two's that's what we can tell. I think it's supposed to be
- 19:03the Thursday afterwards or something like that. It's been like six days, for
- 19:07five days, I didn't write how many days it was. So it turns
- 19:12out that Sir Charles has been murdered. That doctor Mortimer says that he saw
- 19:18the body and it had a look of terror on it, and Baskerville's footprints
- 19:22were the only ones scene and they were on his toes. So he also
- 19:30says that the medical inquest found that he died of a heart attack. Okay,
- 19:37So Holmes suggests that Basketville wasn't sneaking around even though he was on his
- 19:41tiptoes. It's that he was running, Okay, Holmes. Watson and Mortimer
- 19:45go to a hotel to meet the new Baskerville that's just been brought in from
- 19:51in this movie Johannesburg, South Africa, South Africa. Okay, so we
- 19:59get to meet Sir Henry Baskerville. Sir Henry Baskerville is again played by the
- 20:03great Christopher Lee. Again, I've already said in many previous Earth Versus Soup,
- 20:11Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee were incredibly close friends. They truly cared about
- 20:17each other. Christopher Lee was there for Peter Cushing when his wife died and
- 20:21got him back into acting because it was like the only kind of release that
- 20:26Peter Kushing. He has said that several times they have chemistry on screen regardless,
- 20:32and Henry is screaming, thinks that they're part of the hotel, yes,
- 20:37and is screaming about missing one boot. There's a boot missing, okay,
- 20:41And Holmes is like, I'm sorry, you you're mistaking us. I'm
- 20:45Sherlock Holmes. This is my this is my friend, doctor Watson. And
- 20:49he's like, oh my god, I'm so sorry. You know, I
- 20:52apologize. So the we learned that Henry's father left one thousand pounds to the
- 21:00Barrymores. Mortimer does not like the fact that a thousand pounds got left to
- 21:10the quote unquote help but he got twenty or forty he got forty thousands.
- 21:15I thought it was forty thousand, And I'm like, you, Dick,
- 21:18it's look sir Charles. He loved the Barrymorees. The barry Mories were like
- 21:26a part of the family to him. You don't leave your in that time,
- 21:30you don't leave your servants with nothing well, because it might it's more
- 21:34than that, though they might be not kept on with the next person.
- 21:40Yeah, so you got to give them the retirement ability. But again it's
- 21:45that Sir Charles understood that the Barry Mories had been with the the Baskerville estate
- 21:53for generations and you took care of family like that was a thing. Right,
- 22:00So obviously Mortimer is a dick, is a a he's a pompous dick.
- 22:08Yeah, he was in this one. He was okay, And we
- 22:12also learned that Sir Henry will now inherit about a million pounds, which is
- 22:18a significant amount of money, but it's all tied up in states a state.
- 22:23But there has to be some liquidity in it obviously to pay staff for
- 22:30food and all that blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Right, but
- 22:36yeah, I guess Baskerville Hall is a good investment because I mean it is
- 22:41a beautiful estate, so supposedly. Yeah. Yeah, so Holmes says,
- 22:48hey, Watson, you need to go with Baskerville to his home. I
- 22:52need to stay here. Well there's also the tarantula. Yeah, there's the
- 22:56scene with the tarantula. That's that's right there, that's right after that where
- 23:00he says, hey, look, Watson, you need to go, a
- 23:03tarantula comes out, and it's just a big rose tarantula. My brothers used
- 23:07to used to keep them as pets. I never really liked spiders. I
- 23:12don't mind tarantulas because they're just huge, gentle kind of creatures in general.
- 23:18So you know, while I might be squeezed out by like a black widow
- 23:23or something like that, I laugh Sherlock Holmes in this one goes there's no
- 23:30tarantulas in South Africa, and yes there are, Yeah, there are.
- 23:33There's rose tarantulas in fact, aren't there. I don't know. There's the
- 23:37African one of the African yeah tarantulas. Okay, yes, our hunters,
- 23:45but I think the rose one though, is from South America. In general.
- 23:48I'm not going to want to have a tarantula on me. I totally
- 23:52understand being like you, but seeing a rose tarantula, I'm not like,
- 23:57he won't let me have one. I don't want. I'm not going to
- 24:00run away from it. No, I just don't want a giant spider in
- 24:03the house. Come on, we have cats. The cats will eat the
- 24:08transl You have a problem with the one that's in the shower today. Nope,
- 24:15because house spiders are our friends. Don't throw them outdoors? Yeah,
- 24:18because house spiders are helpful, helpful to the house. Yeah, And if
- 24:22you throw them outside, they'll they'll die because their their environment now is inside.
- 24:27Yeah. So uh, we end up having a scene with a carriage.
- 24:32Well, I should say that Holmes kills the spider, knocks it off
- 24:36off, Sir, Sir Baskerville. And I'm glad it's clear that it was
- 24:41a fake spider. Folks, they didn't. I was worried though for a
- 24:44bit. I'm like, are they really going to hurt a spider here?
- 24:47The only way you'd get sick from one of those, there are some that'll
- 24:51make you really ill, sure, but the only way you'll get even if
- 24:56they're left with their venom packs is if you've got weakness or something that will
- 25:03you're allergic to him somehow, some way, Because I mean, most spiders
- 25:07you can be bit by them, unless it really is like like a brown
- 25:11recluse or black widow or something. You're not going to die from a spiderbidy.
- 25:15Do you have to have something really wrong with you to die from a
- 25:18spider bydy? But that being said, we do know that there is a
- 25:22congenital weakness in the Basketville line with hearts correct, so maybe right, like
- 25:30okay, So anyway, we get a scene where we have Watson going out
- 25:36to Baskerville Hall. Mortimers dropped off before they get to the hall because he
- 25:41needs to go into the village in the discussion of an escape prisoner from Dartmore.
- 25:48Dartmoor Prison was created in eighteen no somewhere around there. Okay, So
- 25:56anyway, the carriage continues on to Baskerville Hall. Watson enjoys a dinner with
- 26:00Sir Henry, and Henry toasts toasts the family, and he doesn't really he
- 26:08doesn't really believe the curses anything but a legend. And Barrymore, the butler,
- 26:15he's the one that originally found Baskerville, I guess, not Mortimer.
- 26:18So it's just like, okay, well, Baskerville and that was out of
- 26:22them. More so, it's like, okay, well, Mortimer is already
- 26:26kind of lied about something, right because he said he found him. No,
- 26:32he actually because Sherlock in this one goes, is that the only footprints
- 26:37around that couldn't be yours the pee. Yeah, yeah, the Devil's basically
- 26:45the summation of that is the devil's in the details. You have to be
- 26:48precise in what you speak because, again Holmes, if he's not there directly
- 26:52looking at something, he needs to, you know, he needs you to
- 26:56describe it as accurately as possible. And I think it's better Barrymore that finds
- 27:03Charles anyway, or the wife. I can't remember which one in the ridge
- 27:07in the in the book, I'd have to look that up. We also
- 27:11have Barrymore saying that he heard the howl of the hound when he was out
- 27:17there. Now, that night, Watson hears noises and walks out into the
- 27:21hallway to look around, and he hears a hound howl in the distance.
- 27:23The next day, the local bishop shows up on a bicycle. I actually
- 27:26shouldn't say a bicycle. It's a tricycle. Yes, it's actually you said
- 27:30you you thought it was really cool. Yes, all right. He's an
- 27:34older man who's a bit bumbling. It turns out that he's really into butterflies
- 27:42and natural the natural world. He has like a telescope. He collects beetles.
- 27:48He's an expert on spiders and apology. What is called insects, he's
- 27:56well, he it's entomology for insects, but it's a wreck. Well,
- 28:00I don't know if there's a specialty for spiders directly, but he he's actually
- 28:04one of the most noted experts on spiders in the United Kingdom. That comes
- 28:10up later and I'm like, okay, well that's obviously a freaking red herring.
- 28:14Come on. But the next day the local shows up. Like I
- 28:18said, Watson gets a telegram from home saying that he should never allow Sir
- 28:22Henry out on the moors at night. And Watson is walking back from the
- 28:26village and runs across a farmer that has set animal traps out. It turns
- 28:30out that this is what it's mister Stapleton. He has a daughter named Cecil.
- 28:41Oh I haven't all as Oh god, yeah, you and your inability
- 28:47to hear words. His daughter is Cecil. Now this is different from the
- 28:51story again because in the story the Stapletons are brother and sister. In this
- 28:57it's father and daughter. Yeah, there are changes from the book. I
- 29:03don't think it hurts the story at all. I'm just saying there is a
- 29:06difference from the cannon. Okay. Uh. Watson ends up seeing Cecil runs
- 29:18after her because he's like, you you know, you can't run out on
- 29:21the moors. It's dangerous. She was doing something something that you wouldn't do
- 29:26at that time. She was showing a lot of skin, a lot of
- 29:30leg, She was sitting in such a way as to her be suggestive.
- 29:37Yes, and she made she came across as maybe something that was a gypsy
- 29:42or that, because her accent really was supposed to be Spanish, but again
- 29:51she came across as Eastern Europeans. Sometimes where is the act actress from it's
- 29:56Maria Landy Uh, She's she's Italian. Huh. Well yeah, I mean
- 30:04the character is supposed to be from Spain. Anyway. Anyway, hold on,
- 30:11maybe we can explain some of the weirdness with accent is that her her
- 30:15mother was Spanish, her father is British. She was born in Spain but
- 30:21came to the UK at a very young age. So her accent might be
- 30:26just strange because changing changing where she lives so young. I just either she
- 30:37wasn't given directions right, or maybe she just only she couldn't do a different
- 30:44accent besides her own. Because yeah, you're right, if knowing that she's
- 30:49Italian, you could say, yes, that is an Italian accent. But
- 30:52she came across to me at that point where she's talking in the mars to
- 30:59doctor Watson. I thought she was trying to play a gypsy. Well,
- 31:03I think it's because also the way she was dressed seems like one of those
- 31:07typical ways that you would see a quote unquote gypsy woman. Okay, I'm
- 31:15sorry that if it's I'm not trying to insult the Gypsies, but I'm saying
- 31:21this is what it was portrayed as. I think there's actually a more accepted
- 31:26term now than than gypsy. I don't know what it is offhand. I
- 31:30apologize romey. Is that what it is? I don't know, so I
- 31:34apologize. If we've used an appropriate term, I apologize that was not done
- 31:41out of any kind, but in this period of time, how she was
- 31:45acting betrayed that. Yeah, that stereotype. Stereotype. Okay. So Watson
- 31:53runs after her and he falls into a sand pit while quicksand a bog.
- 32:01Now this woman and her father pull him out. They drive him back to
- 32:07Baskerville Hall and mister stap Uh Stapleton says, hey, look, I want
- 32:12to talk to sir Henry. Henry, sir Henry rides up and the girl
- 32:15runs away, and Sir Henry wants to know why she ran away, like
- 32:20he chases after and this is where we're introduced to her name. It's it's
- 32:23Cecil. She kisses him, just kind of out of nowhere. Well that's
- 32:28what you want, right. Stapleton finds Henry Uh Henry outside but didn't see
- 32:36anything of what was going on, and then she's all acting coy about it,
- 32:39like and not like in a koy wink wink kind of way. It's
- 32:44she's acting totally like nothing happened that night. Sir Henry and Watson are investigating
- 32:51noises and we find that there's a candlelight in the attic room and that there's
- 32:54a light out of the moor that is signaling the house. Was it attic
- 32:59or was it just the storage room. It's either a storage room or an
- 33:01aut of room, regardless, it's not a well used room. It's because
- 33:06there's a rocking horse and some other st So they run outside and they find
- 33:10a person out there and give chase. There's a howl and Henry grips his
- 33:16chest, having heart troubles. They go back to Baskerball Hall. So there
- 33:20is a person out of them all mores so home. Holmes actually ends up
- 33:24showing up at night while Watson is out investigating, and Holmes has been in
- 33:28the area almost as long as Watson. It was all kind of play him
- 33:31staying back because he just didn't want anyone knowing that he was there because they
- 33:36got on the next train. Yeah, so Holmes captured the escape prisoner that
- 33:40was out of the moor, who was the person that they actually saw.
- 33:44Oh I laughed at this when Henry grips his heart in that. Yeah,
- 33:47what does Watson give him? Oh yeah, liquor whiskey. Yeah, yeah,
- 33:52it's that's whenever anybody in these shows show like gets faint, Watson is
- 33:58almost always there with like liquor. That that's usually just as that as as
- 34:04doctor McCoy. Oh yeah, well, hey, liquor is medicinal. Right.
- 34:07Anyway, let's see here, Holmes captured the escape prisoner and questioned him
- 34:14about what he'd seen out of the moors, and it turns out that like
- 34:20and I might be skipping around a little bit, but he's actually the brother
- 34:23of missus Missus Barrymore, Missus Barrymore, and that she has been because Look,
- 34:31he might be a murderer, but he's still family. And I gave
- 34:35him some of Sir Henry's clothes and food, and I signaled him with this
- 34:42candle in the window to let him know that it was safe to come up
- 34:45to the house to get these to get these things. And she's really ashamed
- 34:52about it, but it's like, oh, you know what, Holmes captured
- 34:55the guy and then like let him go again, So this guy doesn't you
- 35:00can you can either argue that Holmes at this point is a bad person for
- 35:05letting like a mass murderer go. Do you remember he just like captured a
- 35:10question and let him go again. The guy escaped from Dartmoor and was a
- 35:15convicted mass murderer, insane insane mass murderer. Is is Holmes ethically correct in
- 35:22doing that? No, No, that's not right. But is missus barrymar
- 35:30ethical and this either that's both of them are could be really ethical? Really,
- 35:37I would say, well, mister Barrymore Watson has nothing. He didn't
- 35:40really do anything wrong. I'm just saying those two a bitt a fugitive.
- 35:47Okay. So they they actually hear a scream outside and they rush and they
- 35:54think they see Sir Henry dead on the more, but it's actually the brother
- 35:58that escaped prisoner who's wearing Sir Henry's close. So they come back to the
- 36:05hall and that's where they see that it is Sir Henry and they figure out
- 36:07that it was the prisoner who does That's where they pick up that knife,
- 36:09isn't it no? See? The next day they go out to investigate the
- 36:16body. To go get the body, the body's gone. They follow a
- 36:20blood trail to the sacrificial rock and the ruins and they find a dagger there.
- 36:23That's that's the dagger though, yep. So they also find that the
- 36:30body has been badly mutilated. It's just been ripped apart by this knife.
- 36:36So Holmes asks the Barrymore's question, and this is where we learn all about
- 36:40Missus Barrymore. Holmes goes to question the bishop. The bishop turns out to
- 36:45be an expert on tarantula's and he says everyone's been asking him about Tarantula's recently.
- 36:51Holmes asks what what the vicar, what visitors the vicar has had over
- 36:58the past few days when he lost a tarantula that was in his care,
- 37:02and he's like, well, there was a whole bunch of people that came.
- 37:05I don't know. So Sir Henry goes to see Stapleton, but he's
- 37:10left, but he's actually left to go to Baskerville Hall. He meets with
- 37:15Cecilia, and Cecilia says their home's actually in Spain and they kiss. So
- 37:22it's Cecilia kind of playing a game with him. So Mortimer ends up Doctor
- 37:25Mortimer ends up meeting with Holmes and Watson. They say that Mortimer is fond
- 37:30of repeating the legend of the hound, seems to be really interested in making
- 37:32sure people believe in this legend. And Holmes wants to be shown the way
- 37:37to the old tin mine because he thinks that that's somehow important to all of
- 37:39this. Mortimer says he won't show him, but is convinced a little bit
- 37:45later to go out to this tin mine. Holmes then goes out there.
- 37:52He tries to find this knife from earlier, and the knife is gone.
- 38:00But this is after they go out to the to the tin mine. The
- 38:02ten mind thing is is a big deal, so I probably should talk about
- 38:07the ten mine thing first. So they go out to this tin mine.
- 38:09They go down to investigate and a mining cart gets like thrown down a ramp
- 38:15at homes and it costs the cave in. Yes, but the ones that
- 38:20are behind the cart is Barrymore and doctor Mortimer was not Barrymore. That wasn't
- 38:29Barrymore. Who was that Stapleton? Stapleton? Okay, so there's a big
- 38:36collapse. Yeah, I do have Stapleton here, yep. And then Holmes
- 38:38is trapped down there, and Mortimer says, oh, there's no hope.
- 38:42There's absolutely no hope. We should just give up. We can't get Tom.
- 38:45And Watson's like, I'm gonna go and get people from the village.
- 38:51We're gonna dig his ass out because I am not leaving homes in there.
- 38:54That mine was huge. There's more than enough air in there for him,
- 38:58unless he's like just trapped in a pocket, right, And so they run
- 39:02back to the cart and it turns out Holmes is just like sitting in the
- 39:05cart and he's like, I've I've hurt my leg. We should go back
- 39:08to the hall. I'm hungry and cold, and they're like what, but
- 39:14what what's going on? Well, it turns out that like Holmes is like,
- 39:16I wouldn't have gone down there if I didn't know that there were multiple
- 39:19ways of getting out of there, I figured the murderer would try to kill
- 39:22me down there now that they know I'm here, and sure enough, somebody
- 39:27tried to The knife is gone again that they found, so that means that.
- 39:30So when does he throw it at doctor Mortimer? He throws it at
- 39:37the table. Oh that's earlier. Yeah, that's earlier. Okay, keep
- 39:45going. So Stapleton turns out I'm kind of skipping around a little bit.
- 39:51I apologize, But Stapleton turns out to have web fingers, which is a
- 39:53thing that a lot of them, yeah, Sir Hugo Baskerville had, And
- 39:59it turns out to they pay pay the one of his paintings is gone because
- 40:04it shows the webbed fingers, and it turns out that Stapleton is like the
- 40:07bastard son of Sir Hugo, the original Baskerville, and that he's been like
- 40:12trying to kill off all the Baskerville so he can like make a claim to
- 40:15it, and oh, look, it's it's that. So we end up
- 40:23having her homes and Watson going out to the ruins and they see Cecilia trying
- 40:27to kill Sir Henry, and she actually ends up doing like a whole villain
- 40:31monologue about how she's hated the uh hated the Baskerville's, how they ruined her
- 40:37family, et cetera, et cetera, and uh, we have a huge
- 40:42dog that jumps out of like a tomb that is from Stapleman Stapleton Stapleton,
- 40:51and Stapleton ends up showing up and Watson like shoots him, killing him,
- 40:57and then Cecilia runs away and ends up shooting the dog. And it turns
- 41:01out like the dog had a mask on its head, yes, to make
- 41:05it look even more terrifying than it was a great dane. Yeah, all
- 41:08it was was a great dane that was kept in the tin mines to be
- 41:15made hungry so when it was released, it would attack whoever it saw and
- 41:20whoever has the smell and whoever has the smell that it's been given. That's
- 41:23why there's the missing shoe. Yeah, So Cecilia ends up falling into quicksand
- 41:30as she yeah into the bog as she's running away, and Holmes and Watson
- 41:34just watch her eye without without trying to like help her, and we go
- 41:40back to two twenty one B. Baker Street and Holmes explains that the missing
- 41:44boot at the beginning of the film was used for Sir Henry sent to train
- 41:47the hound to find him the end. Yes, Now, with all that
- 41:54said, this is not the best how to the Baskerville's adaptation. The prologue
- 42:00was done, yes, except to make us really hate Sir Hugo. But
- 42:06again, Sir Hugo is killed. He's no longer a part of the movie.
- 42:12He is not an antagonist in this movie. His story is done.
- 42:17Why do we need to see why years ago? Yeah, well one hundred
- 42:22and fifty, we're like one hundred and sixty. But why do we need
- 42:25to see that? It has no real bearing on the story. All we
- 42:29need to know is that the Stapletons are trying to take the inheritance of the
- 42:35land for themselves because they don't they were just there. They're they're kind of
- 42:42like bastard side of the family was disrespected one hundred and sixty years ago,
- 42:46and they want the land for themselves. That's all we need to know.
- 42:51This is, like I said, not the best adaptation of hounda the Baskervilles.
- 42:55Again, I point to Jeremy Brett as Sherlock Homes and they're kund of
- 43:00the Baskervilles. In my opinion, it's much more accurate too. It's not
- 43:05perfectly accurate to the Cannon, but it's much more accurate to the Cannon than
- 43:08this. But let's talk about what works in this film. Okay, okay,
- 43:15some of the sets, but some of the sets don't. Okay,
- 43:17what what sets do work? I like the house, Okay, I like
- 43:25the carriages. Uh, when you're on this, when it you're out in
- 43:34the More, it's good. But when you're in the set of the More,
- 43:38it's not. Yeah, the set of the More does not look good.
- 43:45Well, I shouldn't say it doesn't look good. It's just not up
- 43:47to the standard that I would expect from Hammer. And then there is things
- 43:52like that Chinese furniture. Okay, I just I don't the Basketville have traveled.
- 44:01Yeah, they've collected, but that there's always weird things in Basketball Hall.
- 44:07That's that's kind of the point, Like it's supposed to be a little
- 44:08spooky and weird, so to a British eye of like nineteen o two,
- 44:15there should be things that are Maybe it's that it looked way too new,
- 44:20okay, and the time that that kind of stuff would have been from almost
- 44:30eighty years in the few in the past, when Prenny was print, when
- 44:36Prince it was Prenny, Yeah, Prenny, which was King George the fifth,
- 44:46fourth fourth when he was the regent. He liked a lot of the
- 44:52Chinese stuff, but it was British Chinese, okay, and that was what
- 44:58it came off at. But it way too new. Look, so what
- 45:04else worked? I'll say the acting overall worked. Again, Peter Cushing and
- 45:12Christopher Lee elevated it. They elevate the entire movie to a point where you
- 45:17can say, yes, overall, the acting worked very well. That being
- 45:21said, there are exceptions to that, like mar La Landi as Cecil just
- 45:28wasn't good in this. But Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee fan fantastic. I
- 45:34don't even know if I like the acting that Doctor Mortimer did the Francis de
- 45:39Wolf. It was fine. He was fine. He was supposed to be
- 45:45a little bit smarty, and you were supposed to kind of think that he
- 45:47was, that he was a possible suspect, which he was, but it
- 45:55turns out he wasn't, you know, he was just kind of a dick.
- 45:58That worked. I don't think anybody truly didn't work as an acting except
- 46:04for Marla Landy, And I'm not sure that that's really her fault because it
- 46:09might just be in comparison to Christopher Ley and Peter Cushing. Again, these
- 46:14people are top A list actors and they are great in this kind of genre
- 46:22acting, and compared to them, she doesn't really stand up well. She
- 46:29overacts in most of it. Yeah, it's very over the time, comes
- 46:31across as an insane. Yeah, she comes across it, but I mean
- 46:37she arguably is crazy. Yeah, her character I don't think is supposed to
- 46:44be though. Yeah, So anything else that worked in this? I think
- 46:49the pacing was good, I like the music. I thought the cinematography of
- 46:54it was very good. I still think it's average. Okay, what didn't
- 47:00work then? Besides, besides Marla Andy as cecil, the truly did not
- 47:08work, Like this is prologue. Okay, the prologue doesn't need to be
- 47:13there, but if you just look at the prologue, with how it was
- 47:16filmed, how it was acted, how it was written and paced, we
- 47:22were like, Wow, what the hell's going on? Oh my god,
- 47:25he's gonna rip her? And he does like he full on murders this woman
- 47:30on a rock like it was an intense opening sequence. Yes, it does
- 47:35not need to be there, I agree, But what is there is very
- 47:37good in that opening. It just isn't needed for the plot, is it
- 47:44fine? Like? I think I understand why Hammer put it there, and
- 47:47I don't understand what this romance thing would be. It was her trying to
- 47:52like well, she explains it in her monologue. She explains that she wants
- 47:58to get him out into the moors by himself for a romantic tryst so he
- 48:04can be killed. That was entirely a pre planned gain of hers. But
- 48:09if that was him, I wouldn't have fallen for that. She was creepy.
- 48:15Well, yes, but you have to go with the story, Like,
- 48:20what's the needs of the story? It's not supposed to be reality.
- 48:22It's just supposed to be How To the Baskervilles. So is there anything else
- 48:29that did not really work? Honestly, this isn't like the Like I said,
- 48:32this is not the best adaptation of How To the Baskervills, But it's
- 48:37not bad at all. That's the thing. It's it's actually pretty darn good.
- 48:43Any overall thoughts about that like that statement instead of just kind of looking
- 48:46at me anything, I say, you're telling me I'm wrong. No,
- 48:52I haven't said you're anything, You're wrong. I'm saying I think that opening
- 48:57sequence, well, I agreed with you, needs to be cut. It
- 49:01was good for what it was, and I understand why Hammer put it there.
- 49:05It's the shock value of it. You're shocked by it. Remember,
- 49:08Hammer is is making movies that are there to really get under your skin really
- 49:14quick. For Hammer's style, that opening I totally get white. I didn't
- 49:19like it. Yeah, it doesn't fit for the rest of the story.
- 49:22Sure, that's fine. I think I think I would not put it into
- 49:25the category it did not work. I think it worked very well. It
- 49:29just didn't need to be a bit. I put it in the did not
- 49:31work okay, anything else and her acting was bad? Anything else, because
- 49:38I can't think of anything. Honestly, I actually think, like I said,
- 49:42this is a good movie. It's good. It's just it isn't Jeremy
- 49:47Brett. So like the Jeremy Brett Hound to the Baskervilles. And the person
- 49:53that played doctor Watson I didn't feel was doctor Watson. He's not doctor Watson,
- 49:59but he does and do a bad job. No, but it just
- 50:01never gave me the feel. Yes, So I was gonna say the Jeremy
- 50:06Brett Hound of the Baskervills, I would if I gave it a one out
- 50:09of ten or you know, one to ten, I would say that the
- 50:12Jeremy Brett is like a seven and a half or eight. It's very close
- 50:16to the cannon Jeremy Brett is Holmes. This is more like instead of a
- 50:22seven and a half to eight, I would say this is more like a
- 50:27five and a half to six. Mine is it five? Like it's just
- 50:32a five? But would you recommend this? You can't, You can't,
- 50:37can't fence it. See, I'm gonna recommend it. I actually do like
- 50:42Sherlock Holmes. And you want to see a Sherlock Holmes movie. Yeah,
- 50:47absolutely, yeah, absolutely, This is definitely worth watching. This is better
- 50:52than a lot of modern takes on Hound of the Baskervills. When I say
- 50:57modern, let's say nineteen ninety two present the Jeremy Brett Hound to the Baskervills
- 51:02was like nineteen eighty eight or eighty nine, something like that, And it
- 51:07does not look like it. That's the thing. The the ITV series that
- 51:12that that they were doing used like old film stock and all that, so
- 51:15it looks like it's kind of early eighties, which is always it always is
- 51:19weird when watching that. But again, Jeremy Brett is Holmes to his decktor
- 51:24to my definition. All right, So any other final thoughts on this?
- 51:30Nope? Okay, So this was episode what you said, we have one
- 51:36ninety nine and then two hundred. What are we going to be doing for
- 51:38two hundred? We've already decided what we're gonna do, The Invisible Man.
- 51:40We're going to be doing The Invisible Man for two hundred. To prepare you
- 51:45for what we're doing. You can listen ahead or watch ahead, and then
- 51:50you can kind of listen to our discussion. I don't know what we're gonna
- 51:52do for our next one, though, well we'll figure that out. So
- 51:58I'm Aaron Arlene, good evening. You keep watching the Skies. At no
- 52:01point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could
- 52:08be considered a rational thought. Thanks for listening to this episode of This Week
- 52:15in Geek Hungry. For more, check out our website at this Week in
- 52:17Geek dot Net. You can subscribe to the podcast, browse our Twitter and
- 52:22Instagram, and leave your thoughts on today's topics. If you'd like to give
- 52:25us some feedback, send us an email at Feedback at This Week in geek
- 52:29dot Net. Tune in next time, and remember, lower your shields and
- 52:32surrender your listenership. We would be on a if you would join us.
- 52:37Thank you for your cooperation. Good night,