Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Which Country is best to start a crypto company, regulation wise? w/ Patricia Ho of Scroll
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashton Addison from the Crypto Coin Show and today i'm Blockchain Interviews with Patricia
- 0:04Hoe, general counsel of Scroll. Patricia, welcome to the show and thanks
- 0:08for taking the time. Thanks Ashton, it's great to talk to you and
- 0:13thanks for having me here. You're very welcome excited to dive into the regulatory
- 0:18environments of cryptocurrency, not just in the US, Hong Kong, Singapore,
- 0:23London, all around the world. I know you're very tuned in with that,
- 0:26and there's a lot of updates happening as crypto becomes more mainstream. It's
- 0:31hard to follow along unless you're really paying attention like you are, and that's
- 0:35part of your job at Scroll as well. I know we'd love to hear,
- 0:40first of all, before we dive into the whole world, a little
- 0:43bit about yourself Scroll, maybe what is Scroll for those who aren't familiar,
- 0:49and your role there as general counsel, and then we can dive into all
- 0:52the latest updates. Sure, thank you, Ashton. So a little bit
- 0:57about Scroll. Scroll is actually a to roll up scaling solution for Ethereum.
- 1:03So we use what we call zero knowledge proof technology to scale the use of
- 1:07Ethereum to make it cheaper and faster for developers and the user to interact and
- 1:14basically build their decentralized applications on Ethereum. Now, my name is Patricia.
- 1:19As you mentioned, I'm based in Hong Kong, spent a lot of time
- 1:23in Asia, worked sort of everywhere globally London, US, other preservation as
- 1:29well my career. I before Scroll, I was actually at one of the
- 1:34largest scrypto exchanges in the world. I was at okay X. Prior to
- 1:38that, I was in fintech with we Lab, one of the unicorn digital
- 1:42banking and digital lending platform out here in Asia. And I actually come from
- 1:48a traditional finance background and train as a lawyer back in London. UH during
- 1:53the global financial crisis, so very interesting times, particularly when we think about
- 1:59a lot of you know, what we're going through in the past here in
- 2:00crypto sort of reminds me of the time back in eight nine when the traditional
- 2:07financial system was also coming through with their difficulties. So that's a little bit
- 2:12about myself. I think crypto is a super interesting space, particularly with people
- 2:17from TraFi. I think there's a lot of opportunities for people. I guess
- 2:23to contribute. Very cool, Thank you, Patricia. And yeah, I
- 2:25feel like right now is a great time to be paying attention. As you
- 2:30mentioned, I think more people in trad FI are starting to pay attention,
- 2:32especially with the ETF news and other traditional financial vehicles coming in to bitcoin in
- 2:38the crypto space. And with that also comes regulation, and now I think
- 2:44at the forefront of the regulatory news is sort of the US, although it's
- 2:47not the entire world, you know, there are many other parts of innovation
- 2:52happening, but the US seems to have a lot of media around it.
- 2:54I'm guessing that you've been paying attention to the regulatory environments in the US.
- 3:00What's happening. Maybe you can talk a little bit about one of the most
- 3:01important topics right now for regulation in the US. Sure, yeah, So,
- 3:08I mean crypto is really a global business and with the Project Let's Grow,
- 3:14we're open source from day one, and we have our teams decentralized across
- 3:19like many different time zones, so there's really no you know, one country
- 3:23or one market or one continent even that we focus our efforts. And that
- 3:28comes with just being you know, very importantly. We have to be on
- 3:31top of all the regulatory developments around the world. Now, US is very
- 3:36very interesting because I would say it's been leading the innovation and the technology in
- 3:42the decentralized finance space and the blockchain technology space. What has been a bit
- 3:47less fortunate is really the regulatory uncertainty that we've been seeing in the past year
- 3:54year and a half. And we see that in very high profile US like
- 3:58the FTFS trial and numerous enforcement actions that we see both the SEC and the
- 4:04CFTC taking against both really large platforms like coinbase and binance, as well as
- 4:11the smaller projects, you know, the the libraries of the world, uh
- 4:16and and I think it's quite unfortunate because it does have an impeding impact on
- 4:23the innovation. A lot of project teams I talked to that are based out
- 4:27in the US, frankly speaking, they're a little bit cautious about being very
- 4:32high profile and what they're developing. They would, you know, think about
- 4:38whether they need to block US users onto their apps, and that creates a
- 4:42very strange situation because they want to build something, but they find that whatever
- 4:46they build may not be suitable for the US market. And I feel that
- 4:50they're also looking for other ways to grow their protocol, particularly like you know,
- 4:57going to the European market coming out to Asia. So I'm certainly seeing
- 5:00a lot of project teams coming to Asia, both Hong Kong and Singapore in
- 5:03the past three to six months, just exploring opportunities to set up here.
- 5:09A little bit more on the regulations, I think, for example, cases
- 5:14like Ripple, cases like Unie Squaw, these are enforcement cases that you know,
- 5:17have been sort of dominating the news in the past few months. Some
- 5:21of them are more easy to understand than others, and you know, for
- 5:26the Ripple case, they make a bifurcated decision against whether something is offered to
- 5:31institutional investors on a primate basis or offered to retail investors on a secondary you
- 5:39know exchange. Right. That is in a sense not really that logical because
- 5:45if you apply the US how we test to determine what it's the securities,
- 5:48it doesn't quite make that distinction between whether something is a primary offer or secondary
- 5:54transaction. And I'm afraid that some of these decisions leave you know, project
- 6:00teams or other people in the industry with some uncertainty about how to plan forward
- 6:06in terms of taking their project mixed up further, right, like, are
- 6:10they going to potentially get into trouble or not. Some of the bigger platforms
- 6:14like coinbase, they've been you know, engaging with regulators for many years and
- 6:18very vocal about it. But even they are not spirited from a lot of
- 6:21the sec enforcements. And for example, they're staking as a service that has
- 6:28been alleged by the SEC as offering securities. And that's also very difficult for
- 6:33the industry to get move forward on, you know, whether they should do
- 6:36more on staking or whether they should step back. So I'm just going to
- 6:42pause here. I think the state of the US is is difficult, and
- 6:46I personally don't think there will be much more clarity coming out until probably the
- 6:51election and Congress basically being able to make clearer laws, which of course takes
- 6:58some time. Yeah, no, great points, Patricia, And I did
- 7:00see some news this week about Biden saying to Congress that not necessarily, you
- 7:06know, we need to look at the regulatory environment more, just we need
- 7:10to crack down more, which could mean anything, but it seems so far
- 7:14that it's sort of meaning cracked down in the wrong areas, as we've seen
- 7:17with coinbase, ripple, Uniswapper Library the example that you gave all very legitimate
- 7:23companies that are bringing innovation to the financial world, and meanwhile, you know,
- 7:28it looks like we've seen justice with FTX, but there was also,
- 7:31you know, throughout twenty twenty two a lot of other breakdowns of companies Celsius,
- 7:35Voyager, et cetera, that their names had almost never been spoken,
- 7:41and they were the ones who seemed to have done the most wrongdoing on their
- 7:45customers and on US citizens and residents, and they seem to focus on Library,
- 7:51who had done nothing wrong at all. And I feel like that's part
- 7:55of the reason why a lot of these new companies, as you're saying,
- 7:58they're looking at other markets to start expanding, because they even if they're doing
- 8:03everything right, they don't want to have to go through the scrutiny of the
- 8:07SEC coming at them because they're targeting the wrong actors. Absolutely. Yeah,
- 8:15I think this is unfortunately the consequence of you know, having a series of
- 8:20enforcement action and you know, potentially not very logical, you know, from
- 8:24legal principle basis or decisions coming to life. I think with some of the
- 8:31bad players like FTX of the world, right, there's clearly a fraudulent element
- 8:37to the operations, and you know, I do agree with the prosecutors that
- 8:41you know, when it's a fraudulent operation, it doesn't matter whether you're in
- 8:45crypto or any other industry. You know that frauds are just something that we
- 8:48need to protect all investors against. So it's a it's a bit unfortunate that,
- 8:52you know, it's given crypto and the other good builders in crypto a
- 8:56bit of a hard time, you know, just by associate of being in
- 9:01the same industry. And I hope that you know, with the Eptics trials
- 9:03now being more settled at least and so Marsh we'll get the sentencing, but
- 9:09it's sort of the initial sort of excitement and focus has gone down now,
- 9:13so I hope that the industry can go back to building and also stay true
- 9:18enough the opportunities that you know are around globally. Maybe we can talk a
- 9:22little bit about that MM And for the companies at least if they move,
- 9:30you know, I've seen even with Coinbase, I believe was moving part of
- 9:33their operations overseas. It's not like, you know, they can still service
- 9:39most of the world minus the US if they want to play it safe.
- 9:41But I know a lot of companies are going to Singapore and Hong Kong where
- 9:46you are, and you're probably familiar with that. Can you talk about the
- 9:48environment there and maybe why are they choosing to go there, and what is
- 9:52it like for them if they go there? Is it the opposite where you
- 9:56know, they're just like open the doors and please come in and we want
- 9:58your business. Actually it is a bit like that action, you know,
- 10:05no exaggeration intended at all, and it's it's uh, it's my you know,
- 10:09it's my observation. It's also shared by a lot of friends that have
- 10:13come here from Europe and the US in the past few months. So I
- 10:16think let's start the beginning. So, so Hong Kong last year in October
- 10:22basically came out with the government policy to support you know, Hong Kong becoming
- 10:26the next global health for virtual assets. So with a coordinated effort, it's
- 10:33between the policy makers, the government, the regulators as well as like the
- 10:37ecosystem, so they're really encouraging businesses, Web three businesses, virtual asset businesses
- 10:43to come and set up. So with that, you already have a much
- 10:46more friendly sort of welcome and I can tell you that it is actually very
- 10:52accessible to have meetings with the regulators in Hong Kong, So the Securities and
- 10:56Futures Commission, which is the securities regulators, as well as the Hong Kong
- 11:00Monitory Authority, which is going to be the stable coin regulator. And I
- 11:05think there is a recognition that the industry is growing at a very quick innovative
- 11:11pace, and the regulators therefore want to talk to the market participant to understand,
- 11:16DeFi a lot better to understand what is the need for liquidity and to
- 11:20understand how is that different from traditional financial institutions and what are some of the
- 11:26bridges the gaps that the crypto industry can work with the traditional industry. So
- 11:31in the conversations that participated, for example, with the Hong Kong Monetory Authority
- 11:35on stable coins have been very open and transparent discussions. So that's one thing
- 11:41that has been very very encouraging. And on the regulation side, actually there's
- 11:48been a lot of work already done as well. So Hong Kong already has
- 11:52an acted a Virtual Asset Services Provider regime in June of this year. This
- 12:00allows crypto trading platforms to come and apply for a license to operate in the
- 12:05city. Now this is also open to retail investors as well, so it's
- 12:13very clear that if you want to offer a centralized exchange, there's an avenue
- 12:18for you to do this with regulatory recognition. Obviously, there's a lot of
- 12:24study requirements, segregation of client assets. There's also a lot of policies and
- 12:28procedures, risk management, all the stuff that you would expect from a fully
- 12:31fledged regulatory regime. But at least there is a way and it's very clear
- 12:35and how you get there. That's really good to hear. And two things
- 12:41you mentioned there were about DeFi and stable coins as well. I feel like
- 12:46there's a growing transition from centralized trading platforms, which obviously have to follow all
- 12:54the rules, and then when you throw in DeFi decentralized trading, there's slight
- 13:00differences on how those platforms work, and you know, if there's not as
- 13:03many centralized parties that are there to help control the assets for you, but
- 13:07the protocol probably still has to follow some rules. And of course with DeFi,
- 13:11if you want to mitigate risk, stable coins are really nice to add
- 13:16on to ensure that you're not taking too much risk, and I feel like
- 13:20there's probably a lot of regulation. Most people don't know the inner workings of
- 13:24the regulation around stable coins, but obviously you want to make sure that they're
- 13:28stable and the proper assets are backing them as well. Maybe you can talk
- 13:33about the stable coins and defy part of it and what sort of applies in
- 13:37terms of regulation, what's needed for those two parts of the industry to grow.
- 13:43Sure. Yeah, staple coin is a really hot topic and it's a
- 13:46really important one because I feel that it is going to be that catalyst to
- 13:52bring on the next bill n of users, including bring on all the TRAFFI
- 13:54bring on all the fintech guys into the crypto space. It's actually it's also
- 14:00so critically important in terms of being a trading pair for cryptal assets. So
- 14:05a little bit around you know, how regulated are thinking about staple coins.
- 14:09I think in Hong Kong, Singapore and also the UK, there are already
- 14:13you know, different levels of government policy supporting a staple coin regene. So
- 14:22Singapore announced the Framework Hong Kong for staple for licensed Singapore staple Coins. Hong
- 14:28Kong is due to announce a consultation on Hong Kong dollar staple coin and UK
- 14:33and of October also announced their plan for UK staple coin to be used as
- 14:39a means of retail payment, so you can see that, you know,
- 14:43we're starting from I guess the simplest from staple coin. These are staple coins
- 14:48that are referenced to Fiat currency and they are fully back by reserved assets.
- 14:54So to your point about maintaining stability, I think regulators are starting with,
- 14:58you know, the safest sort of types of stable coins, the ones that
- 15:03you can point to full backing reserves, so to maintain the stability between the
- 15:09staple coin value and the underlying assets value. And you mentioned there about the
- 15:16UK and Europe as well. You know, obviously that's a huge market and
- 15:20that there's a lot of countries that sort of need to communicate and get on
- 15:24on the same page so that they can hopefully stay up to the innovation of
- 15:28what we're seeing in Southeast Asia. I'm curious and where the innovation is being
- 15:33led in Europe, and you know how far along are they compared to the
- 15:37rest of the world. Yeah, so I think that London is becoming a
- 15:41hub for some crypto projects. I think France is as well, although France,
- 15:48I think being part of the European Union, obviously they have their own
- 15:50comprehensive regime on MICA which is also by face and it's quite rigorous regulatory standards.
- 15:58So I think, as you know elsewhere around in Europe, I do
- 16:00think that UK is going to be one of the innovative centers. It also
- 16:06benefits from being traditionally a major international financial center because you know, staple coin
- 16:12is to make something sustainable and used by many people. It's about liquidity,
- 16:18so you do need a very deep liquidity and trading market for that staple coin
- 16:22to take off and being widely adopted. Mm hm no, that's a great
- 16:26point. I feel like right now there's also a rise in people are looking
- 16:33for other ways to innovate stable coins. I'm not sure if it needs innovation.
- 16:37There's us d T Tether and USDC Circle as sort of the main ones,
- 16:42but there's also movements saying, you know they're there, we don't agree
- 16:48with the companies that are running them, and we want to make decentralized stable
- 16:52coins, or we want to experiment with ways to back other assets, or
- 16:56maybe make buoyant stable coins so that you know, it's not like the US
- 17:00dollar being depreciated over over the years. You know, how can we sort
- 17:03of make it truly stable and not according to the US inflation. I'm curious
- 17:10if you know anything about these are the future of stable coins and do you
- 17:12think that the two stable main stable coins that we see right now will be
- 17:18the main ones for years to come. That's a really interesting question. I
- 17:22think when I look at USDC circle and I look at tether and sort of
- 17:27a different passive taken, it is a very different approach. I think it
- 17:32is quite I think it's quite obvious a circle, it's going down the license
- 17:37route. They're very engaging with a number of regulators globally. They're also engaging
- 17:42with regulators in various markets in Asia too, and they want to serve the
- 17:48TRAFFI. They want to work with the institutions and be able to you know,
- 17:52increase the adoption of of U s DC. The us d T Tether
- 18:00actually is the most used stable coin from a crypto native perspective. So a
- 18:04lot of the DeFi proto calls and also a lot of the trading pairs are
- 18:08actually you know, using usd T, and I think they're also becoming more
- 18:15visible. I would say with their recent CEO, you know, being appointed
- 18:19allow who was their previous CTO. So I think time will tell in terms
- 18:23of, like, you know, whether they also go down a more regulated
- 18:27path or they continue what they're doing now, which is which is really great.
- 18:30I mean they're very, very impactful from a crypto native ecosystem perspective.
- 18:36Now to your point about whether those are the two dominant stable coins going forward,
- 18:41I don't know, but I would think that there is space for innovation
- 18:47for not just VIAT referenced stable coins. For example, we can see die
- 18:52with the maker down stable coins and you know other even curve you know that
- 18:56there's staple coins. There's a lot of innovation terms is a stabilization mechanism.
- 19:02Where I'm coming from is that the regulators are not ready to give regulatory recognition
- 19:08these sort of algorithmic stable coins just yet. I think part of the reason
- 19:14is also with Luna, the collapse of Luna last year, So I think
- 19:18we need to give them a little bit more time to really kind of battle
- 19:22tests some of these stabilizing mechanisms in order for them to get comfortable. But
- 19:27this is one area, for example, where I think, like the Hong
- 19:30Kong regulators are very very open to discussions and learning about what works, what
- 19:37doesn't work, and to work with the industry to find a way great insights,
- 19:42and we've sort of talked a little bit about most of the parts of
- 19:45the world. There's one other one that I want to touch on that is
- 19:48very growing space is Dubai in the Middle East seems to be you know,
- 19:53I'm seeing so many giant blockchain conferences there. I know they have innovation zones
- 20:00and great company setups for blockchain companies. What do you think about them as
- 20:04an up and coming space for the blockchain startups and the regulatory environment there in
- 20:11the Middle East. I am very bullish on the Middle East. There is
- 20:17actually a Ripple conference that is going on right now Rippo Mataco, and they
- 20:22have actually today announced it partnership with HSBC as well, so really going into
- 20:27the institutional space and helping institutional adoption of critical assets and staple coins. I
- 20:33think Dubai from a regulatory environment perspective is extremely open. So they have set
- 20:41up var out just their virtual assets regulatory authority not very long ago, and
- 20:47again they are highly engaging with the industries. I have many friends and contacts
- 20:52that are having regular roundtables in Dubai with the regulators. They are engaging with
- 20:57not just centralized exchange, but also custodians, so they have a number of
- 21:02different types of licenses already. So it's a very ready made regime already.
- 21:07And I believe there's a lot of excitement about you know, people setting up
- 21:11in Dubai and also Abu Davi as well, So it's the entire GCC,
- 21:15the Gulf, you know region is becoming quite a hub for major talents and
- 21:21also major culture platforms. Sure that's great to know. And if you were
- 21:25to go and start a web three company and you know, you weren't located
- 21:30anywhere specifically, where would you go to do that? Would it be Hong
- 21:33Kong? I would definitely be in Asia or the Middle East, because I
- 21:38think that there is really a lot of talent in this part of the world
- 21:45and there's a lot of room for experimentation. So it's uh, it's sort
- 21:49of a very open kind of environment where you feel that you can test a
- 21:55lot of things out, especially if you are starting your own project. You
- 21:59sometimes want to test different ideas, you want to fail fast. You want
- 22:00to know, you know one of the things I can improve and iterate on
- 22:04that product, and I think this is the best place to do it with
- 22:07that level of engagement with regulators and the industry as well. Very cool,
- 22:12Patricia. I appreciate all the insights into the whole world. It's hard enough
- 22:15to follow along with the US news when you know you're focused on so many
- 22:21other parts of the industry, So I appreciate your expertise and all of it.
- 22:25What is the best way for people to follow along with this or your
- 22:29work? Or scroll? Yeah, so definitely follow, you know, scroll
- 22:34on x or Twitter. It's scroll ZKP and I am also on LinkedIn.
- 22:41I write prolifically about regulatory developments around the world. So I just recently wrote
- 22:47a piece about token is securities, which was something that came out about six
- 22:51days ago in Hong Kong. So if you're interested in your assets tokenization and
- 22:56what are the regulations in Hong Kong about that, feel free to follow me.
- 23:00I'll soon be writing more about stable coils as well as the Hong Kong
- 23:03regime comes into play later this month. Very cool. And I can leave
- 23:08the link to your profile and scroll in the show notes below as well.
- 23:12I really appreciate you taking the time. All the best with everything moving forward
- 23:17in your work and hopefully for the entire regulatory environment of crypto and blockchain,
- 23:22and let's definitely follow up in the near future. Thank you, Action,
- 23:26happy building,