Latest / Falcon Forward / The Hidden Risks of Personal Cyber Threat Coverage
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: All right, welcome to a Falcon Forward. I am Peter and I'm here with our president Mike Tangy. we were out out of commission last week. actually the reality is we had so much to do that neither Mike or I could find time to to carve this out. But here we are, we're back, we're fresh and we're ready to go. So Mike, how's your week going so far? And and as you said, it felt like Tuesday for you and Thursday for me. So we're both kind of on different planets. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, no, funny back and forth in the beginning when you shared that you thought it was Thursday and I was about to correct you saying it's Tuesday and here it is actually Wednesday. So Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: a good partnership, right? We meet in the middle. Peter Brecht: Right, yeah, yeah. We're doing all right. So man, Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: so so being busy this week and and it's like, okay, great, what what does that entail? And and we we've recently we've gosh, we've been doing so much. We've got new people that we're bringing in, new hires, just launched a s a cyber program, so a personal cyber program, and that's all kind of up and running and and and going well. And obviously, you know, I think we started talking about this, the personal cyber stuff maybe six months ago. if I don't if I remember correctly. and just researching, Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: really there there's kind of like a lack in the market for what what we saw as like a real cyber threat, right? There's there's cyber coverage for commercial. but really when it comes to like you know ensuring private client high net worth or even just people that have kids that are clicking around on a computer you know, or have access to an iPhone, there's not a whole lot of coverage on some of the standard carrier forms. And so we set out the operations team to go find some options. And I think we talked to was it three companies, something like that. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, we narrowed it down to three, and you know, there's a a few different criteria for us. because you're absolutely right, there's a wide variety, you know, of insurance available in both the personal and commercial market. And in the personal market, what we found out was carriers will have kind of like they would call it cyber light. so they'll do some sort of add-on to your home policy that will give you some coverage. But I would say that coverage is probably ten years outdated in the marketplace. Like it's more concerned about identity theft. Like if someone gets a hold of your credit card and runs up a bunch of charges. And that's just almost a way of life now for credit card companies. but that isn't something that's gonna come back to you, meaning you the consumer, that you're necessarily gonna be on the hook for that. And I mean, I probably like twice a year get my credit card stolen, which Curiously, is usually after we've been to the Del Mar Fair, is when when it seems Peter Brecht: Ha ha. Mike Tanghe: that the credit card seems to get taken. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: but but so the the policies, so so I guess the problem with that is or that we see for our clients is that a client could be like, yeah, I I have cyber coverage on my, you know, I see it right here on my home insurance policy. And what we found out is that it just it doesn't cover like today's exposures. in where there's significant and yes you if your credit card gets stolen it's a hassle you gotta call a credit card company you gotta cancel you know any sort of recurring charges and you know update i it's a pain but it's not anything that's gonna be like my gosh I'm out you know tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars. but what what the exposures are or the risks that is I mean we we've seen prospects have these types of claims happen and clients have these types of claims happen. are like the the wire frauds and computer frauds, or like where you're you know you have either a young person or older person, like a parent that gets fleeced in some sort of scam. Like those are our big claims, you know, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of dollars. and what we found is that the carriers out there, if they provide it, it's with very, very low limits. And then the other thing, just you know, we're we're operating a company here. and if we have to complete an application that has a whole bunch of questions that our client aren't necessarily sure how to answer, and then if the policy is it doesn't have like a flat pricing, so all these types of things, like we could sell these policies and effectively lose money in the amount of time it would take us as an agency to educate the client. Ask the questions, complete an application, send it into the carrier, you know, all these kind of steps. So you're absolutely right. We we set our our admin team out, our operations team out to be like these are the criteria that we want. and it took a lot of inquiry, took a lot of legwork, but we're super excited that we did find a fantastic carrier to partner with that has not only what we feel is the best product out there in the marketplace as far as the coverages, as far as the limits, but also We were able to configure our systems so that we can, you know, really with a couple questions of the client and a couple of clicks, issue one of these policies that allows us to again profitably write a small premium policy on it. So as a combination of those two things that you know, can we efficiently write this? Is it a good product? Is this something our clients need? You know, checking all those boxes, we were able to find that out and and we're super excited and we've gotten very good feedback in just Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: launching of this this week. So Peter Brecht: Totally. Yeah. I was surprised. I mean, we launched it on Friday and you know, people are looking at this on Tuesday. I mean, it was it was awesome. So but anyways, into some details, I guess, and and kind of like, you know, and and I really this podcast has always been intended for our team, right? It is really who we kind of started out with. Like, hey, how can we stay on top of communicating with everyone that we work with in a in a a virtual brokerage, right? So but nonetheless, I I think it's interesting to kind of think through some of the scenarios where where this would be useful. And I remember we were sitting through one of the product demos and one of the comments was like, Okay, so first of all, if you have a client that has, you know, a credit card that gets stolen, you know, have them contact the credit. That's not the kind of cyber we're looking for. they're also not trying to ensure, true story, the guy that wired a million dollars three times and He was only supposed to do it once, but he wasn't sure if it went through. So they're not ensuring like just blatant, you know, hey, disregard for safety and security, right? They want to be looking for people who are like, hey, look, I'm I'm doing things the right way, but I need this protection because I have I have a high risk. So, anyways, kind of thinking through it. So I I love history, I love technology and kind of looking back, but the first spam email was actually sent in 1978. Of course, it was a marketing guy trying to sell computers. and I think marketing has almost ruined everything it touches in some sense, but email was the first thing to go. you had a brilliant point, and I didn't know that the term spam came from a Monty Python skit, but that's a great skit. I didn't know that they were correlated, but fantastic stuff there. so, anyways, let's dig into some stories here and and some examples. So biggest thing is Think for us when we were looking at this was like wire transfer fraud, right? So you know, there was a couple that was was buying a home and you know, they as with any wire, if you ever sent a wire before, it's extremely stressful, right? you gotta the banker basically wants to make sure that you are absolutely sure that you know you're not under duress sending this wire. I mean, there's a lot of stuff that kind of goes on in sending it. But nonetheless, you know, they wired several, several thousands of dollars in order to get this you know home done. And they they were not able to recover you know, it was a very small percentage they actually recovered. So the how did it happen though? I think that's kind of the important piece is is just simple and straightforward. FBI is always looking at email compromise. So it's a lot easier now with AI. Technology's getting so good. That a lot of times these criminals will simply get access to your email inbox and they'll just wait and they'll sit there until something comes up and they're not looking in your inbox every day, but they have kind of this ability to scan through all these email inboxes. And as soon as they see the idea of a wire transfer, they'll actually go in and they can swap out emails and change directions. So one of the reasons your bank will say, Hey, look, I need you to You know, is this the account? Have you called and verified? All that stuff is to make sure that that email hasn't been swapped out. and Mike, I don't know if you have any other commentary on that, but that's something that I've heard of happening so often. And especially, you know, we even talk to, you know, businesses. It's, you know, they have to have protocol in place where it's like, hey, if you're sending a wire, who's signing for that? Are there two people? Is it one person? There's got to be more than kind of checks and balances, right? On every Mike Tanghe: Yeah, and this is by far the trickiest form of cyber fraud because you're sending the funds out, right? They're tricking you. so it's not like someone coming in, you know, breaking in and making off with a bunch of money and and you know, kind of the more traditional ways we think of theft, but you're actually willing I mean it's really no different than you're walking out your house and you know, taking a big box of money and handing it over to some stranger that's outside your house. That you've never seen before. So it's the equivalent of that. And you know, how do they do it? You're absolutely right. It's and it's not like they're sitting there reading your emails or any like this is, you know, when people talk about like the power of AI to do things, like this is all hundred percent AI type driven losses where it's scanning, it's looking for keywords and emails, it's looking for all those things that are traveling in in open space, if you if you will. and once they see that and flag that, then that's when like the scams or the hooks start to get put in is can they get access to the actual inbox? Or can they just spoof and make very legitimate looking emails? So and we had a client that had a claim that was exactly that where and if you just think about it, of and this is why the policy that we're selling, we're very keen on it for a lot of our clients, because it covers your assistant willingly sending funds out. True story was we had a client that was working with a contractor, and just imagine you know, there's multiple people on an email chain of subcontractors, contractors, construction managers, assistants on it. And during someone got hacked within that that realm and and said, you know, when they would send the bill every other week saying, you know, here's the work done, send it, send, here's your invoice, send it. and so my client got an a email that said, Here's your invoice, and then didn't realize that the good actor or or the real person had been substituted by the bad actor in this until and then if you just imagine busy person sends this off to his assistant and says, Pay this bill, in assistant pays the bill. This wasn't even a wire transfer fraud, this was actually just mailing checks. And then again, like all these checks and balances could have countered all this, but the assistant was just like, hey, I got an email from my boss telling me pay this bill, wrote the check, paid the bill. again, in an in a perfect scenario, the contractor would have been like, you know, after one week been like, hey, you guys pay me every week or every other week, and we haven't gotten we didn't get your last payment from it. But the contractor was busy and just thought, maybe these guys are, you know, they're a little bit behind or cash flow strapped or whatever. You know, we've worked with them for ten years on other projects, they've always been a good client. We're not gonna sweat them just being a couple weeks late on stuff. And so fast forward this goes on for eight weeks before the contractor's like, man, I don't wanna have this conversation, it is uncomfortable, these guys are really falling behind. and so but eventually when they raise their hand and said, Hey, like, how come you guys haven't paid us in two months? And they're like, Well, what do you mean? We pay you every other week, just like we always have. And only then did they realize that, man, we've been sending Yeah, in this case, hundreds of thousands of dollars out. and they were able to recover some of it, but the point is, is not all of it. and then it's not a quick recovery on this too. You can't just call up your bank and be like, hey, I sent out four hundred grand over the past two months, and these guys really want to get paid. So it's almost like a double loss of Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: you've paid that money out, but now you owe someone money for real. So you gotta write another check, and then can you collect any of that back? So just significant And again, this wasn't overly sophisticated, but it's just it's it's how we interact. You know, you get something on your phone, I'm gonna fire this off to my assistant, they're gonna get the email from me, they're gonna pay the bill. I'm not gonna bother anyone because you know we're all busy, busy, busy. so it's stuff like that. That those are just these things happen, and then you know, again, that's just one example because the there are numerous examples of people like getting the the email, getting the wire instructions, you know. ever had to you know go through an escrow period, whether it's the purchase of land or purchase of a a home is the most common one. No, it's confusing. You're getting all the you're getting questions from title, and then the real estate agent or the title company uses a different closer, is a different third party. and they gotta send funds here, and everything's on this time crunch of the sellers are getting nervous, and we gotta close by this day. And it's just ripe for someone to just insert them in and Again, it's a numbers game for these criminals. It's not like they're like, here's my sales funnel and here's how many cyber frauds I have to close. It's just this is all purely on an automated basis. Peter Brecht: Mm. Mike Tanghe: and it's again a numbers game. If you send it out to enough people, there are people that are gonna click on things, there are people gonna be too rushed, there are people who aren't gonna have those checks and balances. And again, why we think carrying this type of coverage is very, very important, especially for our clients like who have assistance paying the bills for. Peter Brecht: Totally. Well, yeah, I mean, speaking of the volume, right? So, you know, you're saying this is an automated thing almost. And I mean, I got an email today from somebody and I used to be able to look at the email address and be like, someone spoofed it. This came from their email address. It came, you know, was sent Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: from their server. I mean, it was really, really well done. but anyways, the the FBI, so they have a division called IC3, which is the Internet Crime Complaint Center. Last year they reported losses of $21 billion. Okay, so and that's just through cybercrime. So that's a that's a lot of money. I mean I don't care how you slice it on on on what side of the table you're on. the last time that they just did personal, you know, people that were, you know, families that lost it, there was 86,000 extortion complaints in one year. So that Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: number just keeps going up and it kind of speaks to Just the you know, the technology, right? There's there's good guys and bad guys on both sides. in the development world, right? You're gonna red team something and blue team something to kind of see what the security is on both ends. And really, you know, there's always gonna be good guys and and insurance is really there to kind of help be a backstop for that and when when when you're not able to kind of contain it. So just fantastic stuff there. But yeah, lots of big numbers. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. And those yeah, in the Yeah, it in for sure big numbers. And I would venture that it's probably a fraction of what's actually 'cause just think about it, like, you know, if you're losing five grand, I'm probably not gonna call the FBI in and just, you know, one there's an embarrassment factor, like how could I fall fall to this? and then just two, just just the sheer like You know, I can't imagine there being, you know, a task force assigned to recover Mike Tangy's five grand loss, especially Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: if it was something where you know I wired it out on it. So those numbers that we're talking about there, I'm guessing are just either probably very dated by the time they publish it, just because this is something that we see growing exponentially. and then you know, what gets reported to them. But you know, again, we speaking just from personal experience, you know, knowing numerous customers or friends or family that ha have fallen victim to this. It's just it's it's pervasive. And again, we're what I don't like about that is it's a a a shock when people find out that, what, you know, I've been paying my insurance all these years. why isn't this covered? So again, which puts the onus on us to A, you know, get that word out and then make sure that we're partnering up with quality companies that will cover these types of things. Peter Brecht: Totally. I mean, and it this even, you know, this coverage that we're talking about, you know, it people get you know, if someone opens up a credit card in your name or a line of credit on your home or you know, stuff where you know it's it's just th I guess it's just so endless, like I can't really even like wrap my head around the the possibilities on it. One thing just to kind of mention is like just basic a couple basic things that you, you know, want to pay attention to. you know, if you if you're ever using a computer, like please use multi-factor authentication. if you have the ability to set that up on anything. I just found an account today that I I mean it's it's got a lot of a lot of information for us and I didn't two factor on it. Like, what am I thinking? Like I need to have that on just in case someone gets in there. but just use basic. you know, basic common sense. Teach your kids about it early. I know kids get devices so much younger now and if you don't have parental controls on there, but just teaching them about links and websites and like how all that works and, you know, I I think that that goes a long way too on top of just making sure that you have kind of your your your house in order, so to speak. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, a hundred percent in in ounce of prevention, you know, is is worth a lot in in terms Peter Brecht: Yes. Mike Tanghe: of cure. and and you know it's kids are a great example, kids getting devices. And and you know, we see this too with older family members that that you know may not have the same level of of tech awareness. But you can just imagine, are these folks targets by the criminal world? Of you have someone who who likely has a lot more assets. You know, your your 70-year-old out there probably has more assets than the 18-year-old out there. and then doesn't necessarily have that tech savvy. you know, true story in my parents' kitchen, and I hear my dad, you know, he's on his iPad and he's and my you know, we have a another brother named Paul. And I hear my dad, like overhear my dad just say, like, why is Paul sending me this weight loss information? And he's like, I'm gonna click on this to see, you know, why Paul, my brother Paul is sending me this information about weight loss. I'm like, no, dad, like don't don't click on that. so and it can and again, sometimes we make it out that it's the older p folks or the younger folks, but the to to your point earlier about like the legitimate or credible looking You know, it's it's It's very difficult to tell what is something real, what isn't real. and you know your best position on that is just to be skeptical of everything. If you weren't expecting something, be skeptical. Contact them through a different means of how you're so if you get a strange email, you know, don't call in, don't click on anything in there, but call that person from a number that you know is good for them. don't just go by an email or the phone number in in that email itself. and just yeah, have a good good level of skepticism on anything you see. And then if you're involved in any sort of like that that home purchase or something like that, just be aware that you know the the bullseye is on people going through those transactions. and there is so much stuff out there that you know you can use public records, like, do you your home's listed for sale? Very easy to find out who the owner of that home is and And all of a sudden, guess whose email is gonna try and get targeted for a hack is someone who's put their home on the market. or someone with, you know, job transfer. So there's just all these ways that you can that that that effectively you become more of a target and you just again have to have that very high level of skepticism when you're in those situations. Peter Brecht: Absolutely. All right. Well, I think we'll I think we'll close it out here. We've gone gone 20 minutes on this, and I think that's Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: really all we need to do. We have a an article that we have on our website. There's a landing page if you know our team needs to learn more about it or or anyone else for that matter. But Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: yeah, really cool stuff and just thankful that there's actually an option out there. after all the research we did, it was it was looking dry for a minute and then you know found something at the very end. So great stuff and Mike will hopefully do this again next week. Mike Tanghe: Sounds great, Peter. Thanks as always for your time. Peter Brecht: See ya.