Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Parenting Plan Assessments (PPAs): LA County Practice Overview
Transcript
- 0:03We are delighted to welcome you to today's CLE
- 0:07about parenting plan assessments. I am April
- 0:11Zonis and along with Dan Bemel, I am co -chair
- 0:14of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Family
- 0:17Law Section. Our section is sponsored by White,
- 0:21Zuckerman, Warsawski, Luna, Hunt, and Soberlink.
- 0:25White, Zuckerman, Warsowski, Luna, and Hunt provides
- 0:28a wide variety of resources to complete almost
- 0:31any project, large or small. They also provide
- 0:34traditional accounting and tax practice services.
- 0:38We invite you to contact them to discuss your
- 0:40specific accounting needs and learn how they
- 0:42can be of service to you. Our newest sponsor,
- 0:46SoberLink, we are very happy to have them. To
- 0:49help ensure smoother negotiations for a more
- 0:52efficient legal process, consider using SoberLink's
- 0:55trusted alcohol monitoring system to eliminate
- 0:58hearsay and protect your client's best interests.
- 1:02SoberLink provides objective, real -time data
- 1:04that can be used to reduce disputes over alcohol
- 1:07consumption, leading to less conflict in custody
- 1:10cases. With an unprecedented combination of features,
- 1:14including advanced reporting, facial recognition,
- 1:18tamper resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 1:21testing, the discrete system has been the leader
- 1:24in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. In addition
- 1:29to today's program, we have so many great programs
- 1:31coming up, so please mark your calendars and
- 1:34register now if you haven't already. November
- 1:371st is our annual Family Law Symposium. This
- 1:41year, it is called Order in the Court, Tactics
- 1:44for Addressing Bad Faith and Incivility. November
- 1:485th, we have State of Department 2, one of our
- 1:51annual in -person flagship events. And November
- 1:5513th, we have Spotting and Managing Slap Issues
- 1:58in Family Law. Other exciting programs are on
- 2:02the calendar and in the works, and you are all
- 2:04welcome at our section meetings on the third
- 2:06Wednesday of the month at 430. We plan events,
- 2:10hear directly from Judge Kaufman and other bench
- 2:12officers, brainstorm on cases, and even have
- 2:16fun. If you have any interest or questions, you
- 2:19can reach out to anyone at the bar, to Dan or
- 2:22to me. Turning to today's program, Judge Shelley
- 2:26Kaufman is the supervising judge of the Family
- 2:29Law Division of the Los Angeles Superior Court.
- 2:32She was appointed to the court by Governor Jerry
- 2:35Brown in December 2013. Prior to her appointment
- 2:39to the bench, Judge Kaufman was a partner at
- 2:41the renowned firm of Garagos and Garagos with
- 2:44its main office in Los Angeles, representing
- 2:47a diverse group of litigants. As you all know,
- 2:50she is a tireless advocate for the bench and
- 2:52our bar. Susan Thrall is a senior administrator
- 2:57at the Los Angeles Superior Court, where she
- 2:59has served for more than 30 years in a variety
- 3:02of leadership and clinical roles. She oversees
- 3:05family court services, probate investigation,
- 3:08and mental health hearing referees, and was honored
- 3:11with the California Lawyers Association's 2024
- 3:14Court Staff Award for her contributions to the
- 3:18family law courts. If you have any questions
- 3:21during the program, you can go ahead and submit
- 3:23them through the Q &A button below. Your question
- 3:26may be answered throughout the planned program,
- 3:28but if not, Judge Kaufman and Ms. Thrall will
- 3:31do their best to address outstanding questions
- 3:33at the end. And with that, I will turn this over
- 3:36to Judge Kaufman. Thank you very much, April.
- 3:40And thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar and to
- 3:42the lawyers that helped come up with this idea.
- 3:44But in particular, I want to thank Susan Thrall.
- 3:49This is her program. I'm helping to fill in some
- 3:53blanks. She is, in fact, a tireless advocate
- 3:57for children and our division. So she's basically
- 4:02volunteered her time to present to you so that
- 4:05everyone can understand what this tool, the Parenting
- 4:09Plan Assessment, offers what it's about and help
- 4:13everyone understand the resource better and utilize
- 4:16it in the best way. Every resource we have is
- 4:19helpful. Could we always have more resources?
- 4:22Yes, we'd love to have a million other resources,
- 4:25but this is an excellent resource and today's
- 4:28presentations to explain to you what the resource
- 4:31is and how it works. I will be going through
- 4:34the questions and answers at some point. I may
- 4:38interrupt the presentation if I think the question
- 4:40should be answered right now. Maybe the question
- 4:42is going to be answered later or maybe this is
- 4:45just not the right form for it. So I will try
- 4:48to pay attention to that. And so I'm gonna let
- 4:50Susan take it away. And again, I thank you profusely
- 4:53Susan for putting this together. Of course, it's
- 4:56my pleasure. Good afternoon, everyone. And thank
- 4:59you for joining our presentation today. Our goal
- 5:02today is going to be to provide an overview of
- 5:05the parenting plan assessment process that's
- 5:08used by the Superior Court of Los Angeles, its
- 5:11purpose, the structure, and the important role
- 5:14it plays in supporting families. We will begin
- 5:19our brief overview of family court services and
- 5:22the important work we do. followed by a look
- 5:25at the role and background of a family court
- 5:28services specialist within the court. Next, we'll
- 5:32review what a parenting plan assessment is, including
- 5:35the steps involved, payment procedures, and submitting
- 5:39appropriate documents and collateral contacts.
- 5:44Finally, we'll close with practical guidance
- 5:46and tips to help ensure the process runs smoothly
- 5:49and effectively for everyone who's involved.
- 5:54Family Court Services, or FCS, provides a vital
- 5:58role in supporting the Family Law Court. We provide
- 6:02parent education, conflict resolution services,
- 6:07and limited scope assessments to help families
- 6:10navigate difficult transitions. Our goal? To
- 6:14assist families in making informed, child -centered
- 6:18decisions about child custody visitation, that
- 6:21promote the well -being of their children. We
- 6:25offer several online parent education programs
- 6:28through our department, beginning with Our Children
- 6:31First, which is the mandatory online mediation
- 6:34orientation for parents. A little plug, parents
- 6:37should observe that program before attending
- 6:40mediation. with us, and we also offer a parent
- 6:44education program specifically for parents under
- 6:48the age of 24 called Young Parents Bright Futures,
- 6:53which should be completed along with our children
- 6:56first. For families experiencing higher levels
- 7:00of conflict, we provide two additional resources
- 7:03from Conflict to Agreement, which is available
- 7:06on the court website. and Between Two Parents,
- 7:09a six -session online parent education program
- 7:13that the court may order parties to complete.
- 7:17We also have available for parents the Family
- 7:20Law Online Dispute Resolution Program, which
- 7:22is a web -based tool that helps parents create
- 7:25their own parenting plan through guided questions,
- 7:29much like the format used in online tax preparation
- 7:32software. In addition, Family court services
- 7:37conducts assessments for minors seeking to marry
- 7:40or establish a domestic partnership. And of course,
- 7:44our core work is child custody mediation, child
- 7:48interviews, and parenting plan assessments, which
- 7:51are all designed to help families and the court
- 7:55in resolving or making decisions that serve the
- 7:58best interest of children. Our child custody
- 8:03mediators and evaluators all share the official
- 8:06job title of Family Court Services Specialist.
- 8:10They are mental health professionals who conduct
- 8:12child custody mediation, child interviews, and
- 8:16parenting plan assessments. They are experienced
- 8:19clinicians with advanced degrees and background
- 8:22in either psychology, social work, or marriage
- 8:26and family therapy. Our FCS specialists come
- 8:30to us with a wide range of professional backgrounds.
- 8:34Many have previously worked in a hospital or
- 8:37school setting, counseling agencies, or with
- 8:40the Department of Children and Family Services.
- 8:44This diverse experience allows our team to bring
- 8:47valuable perspectives and clinical insight to
- 8:50the families and courts we serve. FCS specialists
- 8:57are cross trained to conduct child custody mediations,
- 9:01child interviews, and parenting plan assessments.
- 9:04To ensure objectivity and maintain clear boundaries,
- 9:08an FCS specialist will not serve in multiple
- 9:11roles with the same family. For example, the
- 9:15FCS specialist who conducts the mediation session
- 9:18will not also conduct the family's parenting
- 9:21plan assessment. They all work a hybrid schedule,
- 9:25part of their time working remotely, and part
- 9:28of their time in person at the courthouse. All
- 9:33FCS specialists meet the qualifications outlined
- 9:36in the California Rules of Court. Within their
- 9:39first six months of employment, they complete
- 9:42the mandatory basic training and child custody
- 9:44mediation, along with 16 hours of advanced domestic
- 9:48violence training, followed by 40 hours of training
- 9:53and child custody evaluation before being appointed
- 9:57on a case, which includes observations and supervision.
- 10:01from their manager. Each year, Family Court Services
- 10:06specialists complete eight hours of additional
- 10:09continuing education, along with four hours of
- 10:12domestic violence training. They all maintain
- 10:15their professional licenses by completing the
- 10:18required clinical continuing education hours.
- 10:22Their supervisors and I are required to complete
- 10:25an additional 24 hours of continuing education.
- 10:29pursuant to the California rules of court. Our
- 10:33staff receive ongoing supervision, attend annual
- 10:37judicial council trainings, and they participate
- 10:39in monthly court meetings to stay current on
- 10:42best practices and procedural updates. Form FL325,
- 10:50the judicial council form used by court connected
- 10:54child custody evaluators to verify and declare
- 10:57that they meet all education training and experience
- 11:00requirements established by the family code in
- 11:03California rules of court is signed by each family
- 11:07court services specialist who conduct parenting
- 11:11plan assessments through our department. This
- 11:14form is signed annually and updated if there
- 11:17are additional changes in their qualifications.
- 11:20This form requires evaluators to confirm their
- 11:24education, their professional license, their
- 11:27supervised experience, training hours specific
- 11:32to domestic violence, child abuse, substance
- 11:34abuse, child development. and continuing education
- 11:40that is in compliance with the standards under
- 11:42the CRC. This form confirms again that they meet
- 11:47all state mandated qualifications and is reviewed
- 11:51and signed annually by our supervising family
- 11:54law judge. Those of you who've been practicing
- 12:00family law for a while may recall that the limited
- 12:03scope assessments through family court services
- 12:05have gone through several main changes over the
- 12:07years. We first referred to them as mini evaluations,
- 12:12then fast track evaluations, solution focused
- 12:15evaluations, but most recently as a one day and
- 12:20a two day parenting plan assessment. The one
- 12:23day parenting plan assessment was designed for
- 12:26cases involving one or two issues. For example,
- 12:31a child refusing to spend time with the parent.
- 12:34These assessments allows the evaluator to focus
- 12:37narrowly on the key issue in dispute and provide
- 12:41recommendations to the court. The two day parenting
- 12:45plan assessment on the other hand, was intended
- 12:48for more complex cases involving multiple or
- 12:52significant issues, such as allegations of substance
- 12:56abuse, domestic violence, or high conflict. These
- 13:00cases require additional time for interviews,
- 13:04collateral contacts, and review of relevant documents.
- 13:09Both formats were developed to offer the court
- 13:12focused, efficient, and well -supported recommendations
- 13:16that prioritize the best interest of the children.
- 13:21Many of you may also remember that it used to
- 13:24take several months to get a PPA date. As a result,
- 13:29in late 2023, we made some important changes
- 13:33to the parenting plan assessment process. The
- 13:36primary main goal was to shorten wait times for
- 13:40families and make sure that the assessments were
- 13:43scheduled more efficiently and fairly. Because
- 13:48of the increasing complexity of the cases we
- 13:51are seeing today, we decided to discontinue the
- 13:55one -day parenting plan assessment. Those shorter
- 13:58assessments were no longer sufficient to address
- 14:01the depth of issues presented in most cases.
- 14:04We also simplified the naming. Instead of distinguishing
- 14:08between a one -day or a two -day, we now simply
- 14:11refer to it as a parenting plan assessment, since
- 14:14there's only one version in use. Susan, I just
- 14:18want to add to that. Part of what also occurred
- 14:22is because there was more remote access to people
- 14:27and the evaluator and people not having to come
- 14:31into court, there was actually more work being
- 14:33done under what used to be called a one -day
- 14:36PPA, which really wasn't. what the process was
- 14:40designed to be. So every PPA, one day PPA was
- 14:43sort of really a two day PPA. And that was one
- 14:46of the other reasons to call it what it was and
- 14:50make it what it should be. Exactly. Thank you.
- 14:57So what's the difference between a parenting
- 15:00plan assessment versus a full child custody evaluation
- 15:04done privately? A parenting plan assessment,
- 15:08is focused, time -limited, and ordered by the
- 15:13court to assist in determining the custody and
- 15:16visitation. The cost of a parenting plan assessment
- 15:19is $1 ,950, typically shared equally between
- 15:24both parents. However, the court, of course,
- 15:27may reduce or waive the fee based on the party's
- 15:30financial circumstances. The PPAs differ from
- 15:34a full child custody evaluation. which is more
- 15:38comprehensive and may include home visits and
- 15:40a wider range of collateral reviews, contacts,
- 15:44and documents. PPAs are designed for complex
- 15:48cases where the court needs input from a mental
- 15:51health professional and input within a shorter
- 15:55time frame. Unlike a full evaluation that results
- 15:59in a written report, PPA concludes with the FCS
- 16:04specialist providing oral testimony and recommendations.
- 16:08The testimony often has significant impact, helping
- 16:12the court and parents better understand their
- 16:15history, relationships, and dynamics. Susan,
- 16:20I want to ask you a question about that. Just
- 16:23for clarity for me, for our viewers, the full
- 16:27custody evaluation is something that we see in
- 16:30a private arena, correct? That is correct. The
- 16:35court does not offer, quote unquote, a full child
- 16:39custody evaluation. That is something that lawyers
- 16:42or parties decide to do on their own, letting
- 16:46the court, either the court by stipulation is
- 16:51appointing an individual to conduct a full child
- 16:55custody evaluation, or one side might hire someone
- 17:00to prepare as an expert for them a child custody
- 17:03evaluation. But this is done in the private arena
- 17:08by stipulation and then approved by the court.
- 17:12Correct. The cost of that can ranges very differently
- 17:18than the PPA cost. They tend to be very expensive.
- 17:22And as an example, the court Although we do not
- 17:26endorse anyone who's on the list, we do maintain
- 17:28a private evaluator list on the court website,
- 17:32and some of their fees are listed there. And
- 17:36yes, very different than the $1 ,950 fee. What's
- 17:44the purpose of a parenting plan assessment? to
- 17:47provide the court with objective psychosocial
- 17:50information and recommendations that can assist
- 17:53the court in issuing a child custody order. Through
- 17:57this process, FCS specialists will gather relevant
- 18:01information, provide the court with history of
- 18:04the family, we will review limited collateral
- 18:07information, and determine what child custody
- 18:11visitation arrangement will best support children's
- 18:14well -being and stability. family court services
- 18:18specialist as mental health professionals have
- 18:20the background and experience to assess families
- 18:24and to provide insight to the court and recommendations
- 18:28that can ensure the health, safety, welfare,
- 18:31and best interest of the child. So before we
- 18:35talk about the type of cases, one of the things
- 18:39that I want to remind everyone is the purpose
- 18:44is to provide the court with this information.
- 18:47So the person who's asking for the evaluation
- 18:52is technically the court. So just because parties
- 18:56say, we want a PPA, or one side wants a PPA and
- 19:01the other doesn't, it's really the court's determination
- 19:04to say, I need this information. I need an objective
- 19:10psychosocial information and recommendation.
- 19:14So if you're surprised, because both sides stipulate,
- 19:19and we always talk about meet and confer, and
- 19:21you're surprised the judge doesn't agree with
- 19:23your meet and confer, it's because the judge
- 19:25has made a decision that that judge doesn't need
- 19:29this resource under the circumstances that have
- 19:32been presented. And understanding that it's a
- 19:35limited resource the judge is sort of weighing
- 19:38and evaluate, do I really need it for this case
- 19:41or should I wait for the next case that might
- 19:43come in that might fall more into the parameters
- 19:47that I need? Again, if every case could have
- 19:51a PPA, that would be fine, but that isn't a resource
- 19:55that is available to the court or to your cases
- 19:59from this setting. Correct. PPAs are generally
- 20:07reserved for more complex cases. They often include
- 20:11situations such as move away cases, cases involving
- 20:16serious mental health concerns, history of substance
- 20:19abuse or domestic violence, families experiencing
- 20:24ongoing high conflict, cases with a history of
- 20:27child abduction or serious child abuse concerns.
- 20:31families in which the child has significant behavioral
- 20:34or emotional difficulties, or situations where
- 20:38a child is refusing contact with a parent. In
- 20:42these types of cases, the court can rely on a
- 20:45parenting plan assessment to provide objective
- 20:48insight that helps determine what custody visitation
- 20:52arrangement will best support the child or children.
- 20:58The parenting plan assess. I'm going to stop
- 21:01and go back to that last slide. This is one of
- 21:08the, I don't want to say difficulty, but this
- 21:13is where we're. juggling and balancing of, am
- 21:18I going to have a case? Is my next case that's
- 21:20going to walk in the door? Am I going to have
- 21:22five move away cases? Am I going to have five
- 21:26high conflict litigation cases that are coming
- 21:28down the pipe? So this case in front of me, it's
- 21:33got some of these criteria, but the bench officer
- 21:37thinks they can handle it with the testimony
- 21:41of the individuals involved. what we're looking
- 21:45at, the present and the unknown. A parenting
- 21:56plan assessment is conducted over a two -day
- 22:00period and includes both virtual and in -person
- 22:04interviews. Each parent participates in the interview
- 22:09and there are also observations between the parent
- 22:13and child or children. This combination allows
- 22:17the FCS specialist to gather information directly
- 22:21from the parents and observe the child's interaction
- 22:24with each parent. The process again concludes
- 22:28with the FCS specialist providing testimony in
- 22:31court, summarizing the assessment and offering
- 22:35recommendations. Susan, let me ask this also.
- 22:40we're coming up on some of the same information,
- 22:43but for those who remember, the PPA was, if it
- 22:49was testimony on Tuesday, the party showed up
- 22:53at 8 .30 on Monday, spent the whole day with
- 22:56the evaluator. They came back Tuesday, there
- 22:59might be some more in -person meetings, and then
- 23:02the afternoon was the testimony. That's changed.
- 23:06It's still considered a two -day process, but
- 23:11What should they expect? In other words, we set
- 23:14the date for the 1 -30 hearing, but we're not
- 23:18ordering the parties to show up, using my example,
- 23:21that Monday at 8 -30. Is that correct? That is
- 23:24correct. What will happen is that the FCS specialist,
- 23:27and one of the slides is going to indicate that
- 23:30we really do need accurate contact information,
- 23:33emails and cell phone numbers or telephone numbers.
- 23:38the FCS specialist will contact the parent and
- 23:42schedule the day and time for the interview.
- 23:47Some FCS specialists, depending on the case,
- 23:50may choose to conduct a virtual interview and
- 23:52then schedule the in -person interview the day
- 23:55before or the morning of the hearing. And some
- 23:59may choose to do the entire process in person.
- 24:04So the concrete date is the 1 30 slot. That is
- 24:08correct. And the parties are told also that they're
- 24:12to appear or be ready at 8 30 that morning for
- 24:17the possible in -person with the FCS specialist,
- 24:22but there may be some change in that. That is
- 24:25correct. They should be available the day before
- 24:29the morning of the hearing. But it's quite possible
- 24:33that the interviews could take place sooner than
- 24:36that, those two days. And also spread out little
- 24:39by little. Correct. Right. So essentially, it's
- 24:44a cooperation process between your clients, the
- 24:49litigants. and family court services specialist
- 24:52who's conducting the PPA. Unlike the way it used
- 24:55to be where everything was concrete on those
- 24:57two days, really a day and a half plus the testimony,
- 25:02it's a more fluid process because of the remote
- 25:06possibilities that now exist. Correct. And all
- 25:09of that is explained in the parenting plan assessment
- 25:13brochure that was provided by the bar and also
- 25:18available to everyone on the court website. So
- 25:24moving on to what's included in a parenting plan
- 25:28assessment. Before conducting the parenting plan
- 25:32assessment, the FCS specialist will review the
- 25:35most recent pleadings along with FL 327, the
- 25:41order appointing the child custody evaluator,
- 25:44and the court form LASC FCS 007, the attachment
- 25:49to the order appointing the child custody evaluator.
- 25:53The review focuses on understanding the court's
- 25:56purpose and the scope of the requested assessment,
- 26:00ensuring that whatever work we do is aligned
- 26:03with the court's directives and the specific
- 26:06needs of the case. We will then interview parents
- 26:11and children, conduct observations between the
- 26:14parent and children to view their interaction.
- 26:17The FCS specialist follows the same process for
- 26:21each party. We assess for the parent's ability
- 26:25to understand and respond to the child's needs,
- 26:28their history of involvement in caring for the
- 26:30child, how parents resolve conflict with one
- 26:34another. and consider, of course, any history
- 26:37of child abuse, domestic violence, substance
- 26:40abuse, and psychiatric illness. We will make
- 26:44limited collateral contacts. We will review records,
- 26:47including from the Department of Children and
- 26:50Family Services, any criminal or DMV history,
- 26:55to gather relevant background information. Based
- 26:59on this information, we prepare our recommendations
- 27:03and testimony. FCS specialists conduct a brief
- 27:07post -PPA conference to review recommendations
- 27:11with attorneys or self -represented litigants.
- 27:16A brief rationale for the recommendations is
- 27:18provided. The purpose to provide this information,
- 27:23but the recommendations or rationale are really
- 27:27not open for debate. We will not be negotiating
- 27:30our recommendations. It's not mediation. We're
- 27:33simply providing the information to the attorneys
- 27:36or litigants. And of course, the cross -examination
- 27:40will be reserved for the court hearing. Oh, go
- 27:44ahead. No, no, go ahead. The recommendation that's
- 27:49verbally given to the litigants and or attorneys,
- 27:54when you say there's no negotiation, so any negotiation
- 27:57would be on the side. They would talk. So the
- 28:00recommendation says X. And they're not moderating
- 28:06that. So if one side says, well, what if we just
- 28:08tweak it like this? That's really up to the,
- 28:11the recommendation's not going to be changed.
- 28:13It would just be the party saying, we're, we're
- 28:16going to accept the recommendations, but we've
- 28:18stipulated to modify the recommendations as follows
- 28:22if the court agrees. Was that what you mean?
- 28:25So what I mean about not negotiating, so for
- 28:29example, if the recommendation is for a parent
- 28:32to have monitored time, Tuesdays and Thursdays
- 28:35and Saturdays through monitoring agency, and
- 28:39that parent objects to that and wants unmonitored
- 28:43time, we're not going to change our recommendations
- 28:45for it to be unmonitored. So that would be up
- 28:49to the other side to go and say. We agree to
- 28:52everything. If it's not monitored professionally,
- 28:55it's modified by grandma. Do you agree? That's
- 28:59not going to change the recommendation, but it
- 29:02may be presented as a stipulation. Correct. Or
- 29:05for example, perhaps a parent says, I actually
- 29:10work on Wednesdays from four to seven. Is it
- 29:13possible for me to have two to five? That change
- 29:18would not. would not impact per se the recommendation
- 29:22is just a time or day change. We will, if parents
- 29:26agree to the recommendations, we will draft a
- 29:29stipulation and submit it to the court. However,
- 29:33if there is no agreement, we will testify at
- 29:361 .30 on the hearing date that same afternoon.
- 29:40And then this is really important. Testimony
- 29:43and cross -examination is expected to be completed
- 29:46that day. the process is limited, the information
- 29:50can become outdated very, very quickly. Okay,
- 29:55should I speak on this point right now? Sure.
- 29:57Some other questions on the slide, but let's
- 29:59let's hone in on that point. So those of you
- 30:02who have been doing this for a while or heard
- 30:04about it, as you know, sorry for the noise outside
- 30:07my court, they're building. At 1 30, Everybody
- 30:13shows up in court, whether that's remote or in
- 30:15person, that varies from case to case and courtroom
- 30:18to courtroom and evaluator to evaluator. Everyone
- 30:21shows up at 1 .30. You already know what the
- 30:24recommendations are. The evaluator is going to
- 30:27take the stand, kind of go through the process
- 30:30as quickly as possible, who they talked to, what
- 30:32they did, why they did it, and the recommendations
- 30:36themselves and the reasons for those recommendations.
- 30:42not question to answer, it's the evaluator speaking.
- 30:46So one of the questions that comes up is, well,
- 30:48I want to be able to cross examine. And this
- 30:54is sort of, I don't know if I want to call it
- 30:57a paradox, but this is the reality. So that's
- 31:00where I want to go. It's a straight to the reality
- 31:02and why we're sharing this information so that
- 31:05you can see, am I on board with this process?
- 31:08Am I going to? ask the judge not to do the process,
- 31:11or am I asking the judge to do the process, am
- 31:14I going to agree or object? The PPA is designed
- 31:20for, you didn't use quick. What was the word
- 31:26you used, Susan, in the beginning? Time -limited.
- 31:29A time -limited. evaluation process. You have
- 31:33to understand that. If your goal or hope or belief
- 31:36is that you're going to want to cross examine
- 31:38the evaluator for two, three, four hours, even
- 31:42an hour and a half each side, it's not going
- 31:44to work. That's just the reality. We can't come
- 31:48back tomorrow because that evaluator is doing
- 31:50another PPA or signed up to go to a different
- 31:53court and doing mediation. And then what really
- 31:57can happen, let's just say there was a glitch
- 31:59with the next technology. No fault of anyone's,
- 32:02it just took longer to get there. And maybe the
- 32:05evaluator just didn't even get to finish. It
- 32:08barely finished the word and it was 420. So everybody
- 32:11understands we have to come back. So the date
- 32:15we're coming back is that the date the evaluator
- 32:18says. The evaluator is gonna look at their book
- 32:20and say, I can come back today's Tuesday. I can
- 32:23come back Friday. It's still fresh in my head.
- 32:26That's my availability. I'm going to be asking
- 32:29the courts to move stuff to accommodate the evaluator.
- 32:35And you're going to have to move stuff too. It's
- 32:39not going to be your schedule that's going to
- 32:42dictate because the whole process is a domino.
- 32:46And if the evaluator doesn't come back in short
- 32:48order, The assessment's going to be stale. It's
- 32:51not going to be helpful. And equally important
- 32:54is the evaluator's scheduled to be somewhere
- 32:57else, maybe one of your other cases. So that's
- 33:00why their date is the date we want to be picking.
- 33:06And also continuing testimony three, four, five
- 33:09months into the future. A lot will be happening
- 33:12in three, four, five months into the future.
- 33:16And parenting plan assessments, again, We conducted
- 33:20it based on the scope and purpose that was issued
- 33:24six months before. We will not be interviewing
- 33:28additional people. It would just continue based
- 33:32on what was learned six months ago, which is
- 33:34why I say that the information becomes outdated.
- 33:38So if you file a request to continue the PPA
- 33:43hearing, I mean the actual 130 slot, the testimony
- 33:46portion, and the judge denies it, and even though
- 33:50you think it was a great reason, something happened
- 33:52even personally in your situation, or some other
- 33:57emergency happened in another case, this is the
- 33:59reason. So you're going to have to see, do I
- 34:03have a colleague that can go instead for me?
- 34:06What can I do to fix this? it is a whole process
- 34:10that's just not one case alone. So that date
- 34:15should be marked and coveted and protected. And
- 34:19even though you say, oh, I got a surprise ticket
- 34:22from my significant other who's taking me on
- 34:25a surprise vacation I didn't know. And the judge
- 34:28says, I'm denying your request. It's not because
- 34:31the judge is mean or sympathetic. It's because
- 34:36this is a really critical resource that we have
- 34:41to covet and protect. Thank you. Our practice
- 34:47within family court services is to observe each
- 34:50parent interacting in person with their child
- 34:54or children. These observations are essential
- 34:58part of the parenting plan assessment process.
- 35:02and they allow the evaluator to see the nature
- 35:05of the parent -child relationship firsthand,
- 35:08how the parent engages, sets limits, comforts,
- 35:12or communicates with their child. Because these
- 35:16observations provide critical insight into the
- 35:18family dynamics, we will not make recommendations
- 35:23unless an observation has been conducted with
- 35:26each parent. This ensures that our assessments
- 35:30are balanced, thorough and based on direct observation
- 35:35rather than assumptions or something someone
- 35:38has reported to us. And is that in -person meaning
- 35:43in -person so it's not a remote where the parent
- 35:46and child are remote and they're engaging in
- 35:50that observation remotely? Is that correct? It
- 35:53is in -person at the courthouse in one of our
- 35:57offices. So if your client is out of state and
- 36:02not willing to come here, Los Angeles County,
- 36:08to engage in an in -person observation, you better
- 36:11know that and tell the court, please don't do
- 36:14a PPA because my client can't or won't come.
- 36:17Because then we've set the time, we set the space,
- 36:20we've reserved the spot, and it won't go forward.
- 36:24No exceptions. Correct. Judge Kaufman, I think
- 36:32this one's yours. OK. So this has been a question
- 36:38of concern to many lawyers. How can I wave Sanchez
- 36:44hearsay if I don't know what the process is and
- 36:50I don't know what's going to be set? So my answer
- 36:53to you is that I guess you're going to let the
- 36:56court, then you're not going to have a PPA. It's
- 36:59not a punishment. It's not anything like that.
- 37:04It's because, again, I've repeated probably three
- 37:06times now already, it's a limited resource that
- 37:10we cannot, do not have for each and every family
- 37:13in every case. So we need to use the resource
- 37:16where it's most effective, meaning the evaluator
- 37:20is going to come and provide the recommendation
- 37:22based on the information that was received in
- 37:25the process that we've just described. You don't
- 37:29want to do that. That is your prerogative, your
- 37:32client's prerogative. No ill will. You need an
- 37:35evaluation. You can hire a private custody evaluator
- 37:39and proceed that way and bring in all the collaterals
- 37:44that you want to bring in in your trial or your
- 37:47evidentiary hearing. We just cannot do a PPA
- 37:52without a SAMHSA's waiver. You know what the
- 37:54process is. You know how it's going to happen.
- 37:57And that's how it's designed. So in court, the
- 38:01judge should be asking, and now there's a little
- 38:04box to check that they took a Sanchez waiver.
- 38:08If you're not hearing that, don't be silent.
- 38:11Please don't be silent and say, hi, I didn't
- 38:13take it. Say, I want a PPA. My client will not
- 38:17waive Sanchez. Let's not waste a resource that
- 38:20can go to another family. Did I cover that? Yes.
- 38:26Thank you. And then what was the second question?
- 38:30Did I get that? So one of the others, there's
- 38:33an authorization to be able to interview collaterals.
- 38:36And some of you have asked, well, I don't know
- 38:39who you want to talk to, and I'm not going to
- 38:40sign a blanket document. Again, you're prerogative,
- 38:43no ill will. But why do we have that? We're trying
- 38:47to, again, utilize the resource in the best way
- 38:51possible. So your client's talking to the evaluator
- 38:55if they hadn't signed and they say this happened
- 38:58this happened at the soccer field and the coach
- 39:01knows all about it and now the evaluator wants
- 39:05to speak to the coach calls the coach and the
- 39:07coach says i don't know how anybody feels if
- 39:10i talk to them so i'm really uncomfortable so
- 39:13i don't really want to say anything but if the
- 39:16authorization has been pre -signed it's easy
- 39:19for the evaluators say, no, your parties have
- 39:22already allowed us to talk to people that we
- 39:24think are necessary. Again, we're not trying
- 39:27to hurt anybody. We're trying to utilize the
- 39:30resource in the best way possible. So that's
- 39:31the purpose. I mean, that's it. That's the purpose.
- 39:38Please make sure your client understands if there
- 39:41is a payment. I'm going to go back. This is a
- 39:44question I want to answer at this point, is what
- 39:47if one of the parents lives out of state? and
- 39:49so they're not here locally and they're not coming
- 39:52locally, then they're not going to have a PPA
- 39:55or they have to make arrangements to come. Isn't
- 39:57that correct? That is correct. Okay. Yes, somebody
- 40:05else. I'll repeat it again. A PPA requires your
- 40:10client waving Sanchez. Thank you. Please make
- 40:18sure your client understands any payment obligation
- 40:21and that your client fulfills this obligation
- 40:24promptly. Any concerns regarding inability to
- 40:28pay should be raised at a time that the parenting
- 40:31plan assessment is ordered. So orders accommodating
- 40:34your client's financial situation can be issued.
- 40:39A friendly reminder. If the PPA carries a fee,
- 40:43it must be paid within 14 calendar days after
- 40:47the order is made. If payment is not received
- 40:51within that timeframe, our office will cancel
- 40:55that parenting plan assessment. Please, please
- 40:59remind your clients of this deadline to avoid
- 41:02any delays or cancellations. So I want to speak
- 41:06to that. You don't get a notice or a reminder.
- 41:08There's no red flag that says if you didn't pay.
- 41:12It automatically cancels. And that includes even
- 41:16if they submit a fee waiver, the fee waiver has
- 41:19to be ruled on. And it has to be both sides.
- 41:23If the fee or the fee waiver was ordered for
- 41:26both parties, you have to check to make sure
- 41:29the other side did what they were supposed to
- 41:31do, because it will just disappear. And if it
- 41:34disappears, getting it back on calendar is not
- 41:37only difficult because you can't just really
- 41:39call the courtroom and say, hey, I need it back
- 41:41on calendar. It might require an ex parte. It
- 41:46might require a different month. So you need
- 41:50to... Follow up. Follow up with your opposing
- 41:53counsel or even a self -represented litigant.
- 41:56Did you pay? Did you not pay? Is there a fee
- 41:58waiver order? And do something about it. You
- 42:03want to file the ex -party ahead of time to get
- 42:05it extended rather than the automatic cancellation.
- 42:09It's not like it just gets back on. So I think
- 42:11you need to understand that. And I want to just,
- 42:14you're looking at this form. This is our drop
- 42:16box now. It requires the court to check off that
- 42:19the parties have waived the hear Sander Sanchez
- 42:23and that they've agreed to allow the FCS specialist
- 42:26to speak to collateral. How attorneys can assist
- 42:36in the process. Attorneys play a key role in
- 42:39preparing clients for the parenting plan assessment.
- 42:42You can support your clients by reminding your
- 42:45clients to provide our office with their current
- 42:47phone number and email so that we can schedule
- 42:50and communicate and not have any further delays.
- 42:55Encourage your clients to complete and submit
- 42:57timely the parent questionnaire, which was attached
- 43:02as a handout and the authorization for release
- 43:05of information as soon as possible. Both forms,
- 43:09by the way, are fillable and can be submitted
- 43:12directly through the court's website or on a
- 43:15smartphone even. Advise your clients to speak
- 43:19candidly with the FCS specialist about their
- 43:22child's needs and any safety concerns your clients
- 43:26may have. Remind your clients to limit the number
- 43:30of documents to only the most relevant, such
- 43:34as school. or treatment records and provide copies
- 43:38to opposing counsel. Limit collateral contacts,
- 43:43I would say, to no more than three professionals
- 43:46who have current and direct knowledge of the
- 43:50family. Remind your client that materials and
- 43:55contacts are made at the discretion of the FCS
- 43:58specialist and within the time constraints. Preparing
- 44:07your client for the parenting plan assessment
- 44:09is one of the most important ways you can ensure
- 44:12that the court receives clear, relevant, and
- 44:15accurate information. Begin by explaining the
- 44:19purpose and process. The parenting plan assessment
- 44:23provides the court with a current snapshot of
- 44:27how the family is functioning, focused on the
- 44:30specific issues the court has asked us to assess.
- 44:35Encourage your client to review the PPA brochure
- 44:38available on the court's website. Clarify that
- 44:43the FCS specialist role is to be neutral, to
- 44:47gather information, assess family dynamics, and
- 44:51make recommendations that serve the best interest
- 44:54of the child, not to advocate for either parent.
- 44:59Help your client understand what to expect during
- 45:02the process. There will be individual interviews
- 45:05with each parent and the children. There will
- 45:08be parent -child observations and a limited review
- 45:12of relevant documents and a small number of collateral
- 45:16contacts as time permits. Emphasize the importance
- 45:21of honesty, cooperation, and respectful communication
- 45:25throughout the process. Set realistic expectations.
- 45:30Evaluators are going to be looking at the patterns
- 45:33of behavior rather than isolated incidents. And
- 45:37recommendations may not always align with what
- 45:41your client hopes for. The goal is always to
- 45:46serve the child's best interest. Encourage your
- 45:50client to review and organize key documents that
- 45:54demonstrate parenting involvement, such as school
- 45:56communications, school records, medical records,
- 46:00activity schedules. They should provide concise,
- 46:04relevant, and well -organized information and
- 46:08avoid excessive or repetitive information. Finally,
- 46:13advise your client to respond clearly, briefly,
- 46:16and honestly during interviews. focusing on how
- 46:20any concerns directly affect the children's wellbeing.
- 46:23If sensitive issues such as mental health or
- 46:26domestic violence or substance abuse are involved,
- 46:30they should be prepared to discuss openly and
- 46:33factually and describe any steps they've taken
- 46:37to address these issues. When it comes to collateral
- 46:44contacts, again, it's important to be selective.
- 46:48Each party should provide no more than three
- 46:51collateral names and contacts, and collaterals
- 46:55should be available by telephone the day before
- 46:58the hearing or the day of the hearing so that
- 47:01the FCS specialist may attempt to reach them
- 47:04during that time and then they are available.
- 47:07Please again remind your clients, and I've said
- 47:09this multiple times now, that we will only review
- 47:14written material and collateral contacts as time
- 47:18permits. So be selective. Since this process
- 47:22is so time limited, we are going to be prioritizing
- 47:26the information that we think is most essential
- 47:30in the case. So I would add to that, if you've
- 47:33got 250 pages of talking parents to show how
- 47:36the parties are communicating, that's not going
- 47:39to be helpful. You want to pull out five or 10
- 47:43of the top important ones. It's just not, you
- 47:46know, if you feel on behalf of your client, you've
- 47:49got to submit the 250 pages because you're going
- 47:53to be have a problem with your client, put the
- 47:55top 10 in the beginning and say the top 10 are
- 47:58the worst or the most, the best example, but
- 48:02here's 250 pages of similar conduct. It's time
- 48:07limited. I think that's the best thing to keep
- 48:10in mind. And I think it's important if you really
- 48:12want the FCS specialist to speak to a collateral,
- 48:16you make sure that collateral can be reached
- 48:18all over the place, that they, the cell phone
- 48:20is going to, there's a way that they can be contacted.
- 48:25If it turns out they have a limited opening,
- 48:28you'll say that. They can only talk between nine
- 48:30and 10 that day and the FCS specialist will do
- 48:34the best they can to accommodate. Exactly. We
- 48:39recently updated the Authorization for Release
- 48:42of Information Form, LASCFCS031, to provide greater
- 48:47clarity regarding who we may contact for information.
- 48:51This update enables FCS specialists to obtain
- 48:54information directly from individuals who have
- 48:56worked with the family. This includes mental
- 48:59health professionals, medical providers, educational
- 49:03staff. supervised visitation monitors, law enforcement
- 49:08agencies, criminal and DMV records, and any other
- 49:12professional with relevant information. The parenting
- 49:17plan assessment brochure, which again I said
- 49:20is available on the court website, was also recently
- 49:24updated. It specifically highlights what parents
- 49:27can expect during the assessment process, including
- 49:31information regarding fees, written materials
- 49:34they may wish the FCS specialist to review, collateral
- 49:37contacts, general information regarding the process.
- 49:41It also now informs parties that information
- 49:45may be requested about their family from the
- 49:48Department of Children and Family Services. As
- 49:56we stated throughout the hour, parenting plan
- 49:59assessments are a limited resource. Each family
- 50:03law courtroom is typically allotted two assessments
- 50:06per month. The court will schedule these assessments
- 50:10within a four to six week window. Because the
- 50:14PPA is designed to be brief and a focused evaluation,
- 50:19it is intended to be completed within the shorter
- 50:22timeframe to provide the court with the important
- 50:25information that's needed about the family. Continuances
- 50:31should be avoided and the information will be
- 50:35outdated if there is a continuance and may no
- 50:37longer reflect the family's present circumstance.
- 50:41All right, so let me just answer one of the questions
- 50:44that was asked earlier as well as explain this
- 50:46a little bit better. As many of you know, when
- 50:49a PPA was requested or asked or the court wanted
- 50:52one, and we turned to the JA and said, when's
- 50:55the next PPA? They gave us a date eight months
- 50:57out. And that's understanding that the RFO was
- 51:01filed at least six or eight weeks ago, so we're
- 51:03almost a year out. In 2023, we looked at this
- 51:07and we said, this isn't right. This isn't fair.
- 51:09It's not good. What can we do differently? And
- 51:13this is the process we've come up with. Most
- 51:16of the slots are being used now by all the judges,
- 51:19whereas before there was an imbalance, some judges
- 51:21never used it because they didn't want to wait
- 51:23eight months and other judges were using it more
- 51:25than others. And so now it seems like every courtroom
- 51:30is utilizing their resource. we turn to the JA
- 51:34and say PPA and they today's October mid -October
- 51:37and they say I have one December 1st and you
- 51:40say to the judge can't do it no can do no can
- 51:43do we don't want the date in March again you've
- 51:47got to move and adjust your calendar it's just
- 51:50a 130 slot it's not the whole two -day period
- 51:54that you need to be open the goal is to have
- 51:59information and assessment done in the essentially
- 52:03heat of the moment. If somebody filed an RFO,
- 52:07there's an immediate need. We've got a PPA. We're
- 52:11trying to get this all done in a three to four
- 52:14month process from the filing of the RFO to the
- 52:17actual ruling so that it's best for the children.
- 52:21So you have to help cooperate. Someone also asked,
- 52:25can we have more than two a month? Maybe. It
- 52:31depends. Susan's going to make a plug here that
- 52:35we are trying to hire more family court services
- 52:39specialists who can conduct this. So make your
- 52:42pitch, your public service announcement. If you
- 52:45are aware of any mental health professional who
- 52:47would be interested in working for the court,
- 52:50specifically family court services, I invite
- 52:53you to please inform them that we are currently
- 52:56hiring. The information is available on the court
- 52:59website. The court is a wonderful place to work.
- 53:03I have been with the court for more years than
- 53:06I wish to say. And it's a great place to work.
- 53:11You learn a lot. You get a lot of support. And
- 53:15please, please tell anyone who might be interested
- 53:18in applying. So I think the answer to that question
- 53:22is part of it is a limited resource in terms
- 53:24of just availability, because mediation is a
- 53:28big hunk of what the family court services specialists
- 53:31do. But other is resource related to employees.
- 53:39So it's both. But yes, it depends. Maybe there'll
- 53:44be more than two a month. And yes, there is some
- 53:46horse trading. Somebody asked the question. That's
- 53:48really complicated for another story. But it's
- 53:50not up to you to do it. It's kind of a complicated
- 53:54process. Sometimes there's a courtroom during
- 53:57a month or two months, they'll have more than
- 53:59two PPAs. So if you see it, it's for good reason.
- 54:05Again, the PPA is a tool for the family law court.
- 54:08It provides the court with the input from a mental
- 54:11health professional. And it is important to note
- 54:14that the PPA is not an investigation into allegations
- 54:17of child abuse. Instead, the focus is on understanding
- 54:21the family, communication patterns, and each
- 54:25parent's ability to meet the child's needs. While
- 54:28ideally, as Judge Kaufman has stated, every family
- 54:31could benefit from this level of input, resources
- 54:35are limited, and PPAs are reserved for cases
- 54:39where the court determines that this information
- 54:42is needed by the court. As a reminder, parenting
- 54:50plan assessments are conducted within a very
- 54:53tight time frame. The FCS specialist strives
- 54:57to gather as much relevant information as possible,
- 55:00but not every document or collateral contact
- 55:02can be reviewed. Recommendations are based on
- 55:06the information that was made available at the
- 55:10time of the assessment. And because the process
- 55:13moves quickly, it's important to remember that
- 55:17case information can become outdated. block your
- 55:21calendars at 1 .30 on the day of your hearing,
- 55:24and please conclude cross -examination the same
- 55:27day. As we wrap up, some key takeaways. Please
- 55:31prepare your clients early so they understand
- 55:34the PPA process can provide timely and relevant
- 55:37information. Explain the process, have them review
- 55:41the brochure, limit collateral contacts, limit
- 55:45the number of documents we are to review. encourage
- 55:49cooperation transparency throughout the process,
- 55:54and please, please avoid any continuances. By
- 55:58helping your clients understand the purpose and
- 56:01limits of the process, you are also supporting
- 56:04the court and the court's ability to make decisions
- 56:07that are efficient, accurate, and focused on
- 56:11this particular family. Parenting plan assessments
- 56:14are one of the court's most valuable tools for
- 56:17understanding families, and your assistance and
- 56:21partnership in helping us set the appropriate
- 56:24expectations and minimize delays ensures that
- 56:28these assessments serve their purpose, which
- 56:31is to help the court in making these important
- 56:34decisions in the best interest of children. Thank
- 56:38you, Susan. I'm going to go to a couple of questions
- 56:40here. One is, what is the best way to send the
- 56:43collateral information to the evaluator? And
- 56:46how is that done? Is that after the evaluator
- 56:48contacted the parties? So the parents are supposed
- 56:51to complete that intake form and the authorization
- 56:54for release of information. And they're able
- 56:56to include that information on the questionnaire.
- 56:59And once they FCS specialist communicates with
- 57:03them, they can say, I'd like you to please speak
- 57:05to the teacher, the coach, and the therapist,
- 57:09and hear the contact information. When should
- 57:11I say that you're going to be calling? And then
- 57:16there's another question about whether the other
- 57:19side doesn't pay what happens. So one of the
- 57:22things I'm asking bench officers to do, but you
- 57:24could ask them to do it, is to set an OSC -RAE
- 57:26payment of a PPA on the same date that it's due
- 57:30and remote appearance is acceptable and make
- 57:34sure that everybody submitted their payment or
- 57:36a fee waiver was issued. That ensures that it
- 57:39got done and you know what happened. I'm trying
- 57:43to ask bench officers to do that but you can
- 57:45always ask them to set it just to make sure that
- 57:47it doesn't get cancelled and no appearance if
- 57:51everything's taken care of. There's a question
- 57:55about the We have two minutes about the criteria
- 57:58to include private custody evaluators on our
- 58:01website. The information on how to apply is available
- 58:08on the court website. There is an application
- 58:10that needs to be completed and signed along with
- 58:14supporting documentation, which includes the
- 58:16number of evaluations that they performed in
- 58:19the last three, four years, the training, they
- 58:23need to provide certificates of the training
- 58:25that they've received. So all of this information.
- 58:31insurance, they need to have insurance. All this
- 58:33information is then submitted and it is reviewed.
- 58:36And then if they meet all of the different criteria,
- 58:40they will be added to the court website. Thank
- 58:44you. Susan, thank you so much. I hope you all
- 58:46found this helpful. I'm still open later to receive
- 58:50emails if you have questions to understand this
- 58:52really important resource that the court does
- 58:54have for families for children. Thank you for
- 58:58all your work you do, Susan. Thank you. Thank
- 59:00you for having and inviting us to speak on this.
- 59:05This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 59:08so much Judge Kauffman and Susan Thrall for assisting
- 59:11us and for educating our members today. Have
- 59:13a good afternoon everybody. Thank you. Thank
- 59:16you.