Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / What Attorneys Need to Know About Title IX, 504, and Campus Discipline with Nancy Potter
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to College, Conflict, and Civil Rights.
- 0:09What attorneys need to know about Title IX, 504,
- 0:12and Cacus Discipline? I'm Samantha Seves, and
- 0:15I'm one of the membership chairs of the barrister
- 0:17section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:20and I'm delighted to introduce today's speaker,
- 0:22Nancy Potter. Nancy is the founder of Potter
- 0:25Law, where she focuses her practice on education
- 0:28law and civil rights advocacy for students across
- 0:31the educational spectrum. From early intervention
- 0:33to post -secondary institutions, with over a
- 0:36decade of experience, she represents students
- 0:38and families in a wide range of education matters,
- 0:42including special education, Title IX, and campus
- 0:45discipline. Nancy also serves as an appointed
- 0:48advisor. independent hearing officer, and external
- 0:51investigator for both K through 12 and higher
- 0:53education institutions. Her trauma -informed
- 0:57student -centered approach emphasizes practical,
- 1:00legally sound solutions to help clients navigate
- 1:03complex institutional processes. Nancy, thank
- 1:06you for being here and take it away. Wonderful.
- 1:09Thank you so much for having me. Good morning,
- 1:12everyone. As she said, I am Nancy Potter. I want
- 1:15to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:18inviting me to speak today. Today, we're going
- 1:20to take a deep look at the laws that protect
- 1:23students with disabilities in higher education
- 1:27and how those rights intersect with college disciplinary
- 1:30processes. We'll look specifically at Title IX,
- 1:33but also more broadly at those processes. I'm
- 1:36going to use real case illustrations that are
- 1:40combinations of cases that I've worked on and
- 1:43practical tools with the hope that you all can
- 1:46walk away knowing at the very least how to identify
- 1:50those legal issues early on and know when a student
- 1:53needs help, but also to protect student rights
- 1:56and provide effective legal support when things
- 1:59do go wrong for our students. Next slide. And
- 2:06she did such a wonderful job of introducing me.
- 2:09I can skip over that one and we can go to our
- 2:11agenda for the day. So we're going to start by
- 2:16laying just a foundation of what the disability
- 2:18rights are that apply in college from a federal
- 2:21standpoint. Then we'll talk about 504 in campus
- 2:24discipline and then 504 in Title IX. Lastly,
- 2:29we'll talk about the campus discipline process
- 2:32itself. And then I'll give you some practical
- 2:35and strategic guidance for what to do if these
- 2:38issues come in front of you. So let's begin with
- 2:41laying the legal foundation. Next slide, please.
- 2:50Okay, so anytime we're talking about education
- 2:53law on a federal level, we are going to have
- 2:56something about privacy come up. So I just want
- 2:58to note this piece. FERPA is the Family Educational
- 3:02Rights and Privacy Act. Essentially, it protects
- 3:06the privacy of education records at federally
- 3:09funded institutions, which are almost all public
- 3:13and private post -secondary schools. For students
- 3:17with disabilities, it governs how disability
- 3:20documentation, as well as Title IX reports, disciplinary
- 3:23records are handled and shared, including with
- 3:27parents and third parties. So at the end of the
- 3:30day, what FERPA does for secondary students is
- 3:33that at the very least, students are entitled
- 3:36to notice before a school shares their information.
- 3:40But most often, they're required to provide permission
- 3:45before the school can share any information.
- 3:48So that's just a baseline. We'll get more into
- 3:50how that applies to our students and disciplinary
- 3:53matters as we go. Next slide, please. Okay. Now
- 4:00the next foundational law I want to talk about
- 4:03is Section 504. So Section 504 of the Rehabilitation
- 4:07Act prohibits disability -based discrimination
- 4:10by institutions receiving federal funds. Same
- 4:13idea, post -secondary, that means almost all
- 4:17public and private universities. In college,
- 4:20it means that students with documented disabilities
- 4:23are entitled to what's called reasonable accommodations.
- 4:26that provide equal access. There's no advantage
- 4:30of falling under 504. It's supposed to equalize
- 4:35that field. There is, however, a really a key
- 4:39shift from K -12. Colleges do not initiate the
- 4:45support. So when you have a student with disabilities
- 4:48who perhaps has an IEP or Section 504 plan in
- 4:52the K -12 setting, the school has The school
- 4:56district the student lives in has a responsibility
- 4:58to identify, test for those sorts of things around
- 5:03students with disabilities. And then you have
- 5:06an entire team that's made up of parents, the
- 5:09student, the school, all working together to
- 5:13form the IEP team or Section 504 team where they
- 5:16come up with a plan for the student. Now, in
- 5:20college, students must self -identify. they must
- 5:24provide documentation to the school, and the
- 5:27school's required to go through what's called
- 5:28an interactive process with the disability services.
- 5:34Section 504 is really our foundational civil
- 5:38rights statute that prohibits discrimination
- 5:40on the basis of disability in any program or
- 5:44activity receiving federal financial assistance.
- 5:50And like I said, that this is done through reasonable
- 5:53accommodations. Another term you might heard
- 5:56used and what is used in a statute are academic
- 5:58adjustments. So the idea being that Section 504
- 6:02requires these post -secondary institutions to
- 6:05provide qualified students. So you have to qualify
- 6:08as having a disability as defined by the statutes
- 6:11with equal access through reasonable accommodations
- 6:14and academic adjustments. Next slide. Thank you.
- 6:26Now, how does that apply to college students?
- 6:30Like I said, the students themselves need to
- 6:33identify themselves to the school. They need
- 6:36to request the accommodations that they want.
- 6:39There's no responsibility of the school to say,
- 6:42these are the accommodations we think you need
- 6:44based on your disability. Instead, the students
- 6:48really have to say what it is they want. The
- 6:52students, like I said, have to raise their hand
- 6:53and notify the school that they're a student
- 6:55with disability. Typically, that's through registering
- 6:58with the college's disability services office.
- 7:03It might be called the accessibility office.
- 7:05It might be just called the 504 coordinator.
- 7:08There's a variety of ways that that can be named.
- 7:15And then another piece, going back to the FERPA,
- 7:18is that that student information remains confidential.
- 7:23And so what that means for the student on a day
- 7:25-to -day basis is that a professor may know that
- 7:30you have gotten an accommodation like extended
- 7:32time on exams, but the professor doesn't know
- 7:35why. The professor doesn't know what the disability
- 7:38is. All the professor knows is what accommodation
- 7:41that professor has responsibility for, and they
- 7:45don't know anything beyond that. This isn't just
- 7:53about classwork, so students cannot be excluded
- 7:55from other non -curriculum academic programs,
- 7:59cannot be excluded from extracurricular activities
- 8:01because of disabilities. The test here is colleges
- 8:07are required to make these reasonable accommodations
- 8:11unless doing so would fundamentally alter the
- 8:14nature of the program. what that interactive
- 8:19process is about is an opportunity for the disability
- 8:22services and the student to have a conversation.
- 8:26It might be verbal, it might be in writing, it
- 8:28might take place in one meeting, it might take
- 8:30place over time, about what the student's recommending,
- 8:33and then the school itself evaluating whether
- 8:36or not those requests are reasonable under the
- 8:42standard and then providing the accommodations
- 8:45to the student. The last thing I just want to
- 8:48know about college students in Section 504 is
- 8:52that 504 does, like all of our federal civil
- 8:56rights statutes we'll talk about today, include
- 8:59a prohibition against retaliation. So students
- 9:03who seek to assert their rights under Section
- 9:07504 have a right to not be retaliated against
- 9:10by the school or any of its personnel. Okay,
- 9:17next slide, please. Now we're going to talk about
- 9:22what the ADA is. So the ADA, it really works
- 9:27in tandem with 504. The Title II of the ADA applies
- 9:31to public universities, and then Title III covers
- 9:34most private institutions. Similar to Section
- 9:38504, but it really focuses on expanding protections
- 9:42to cover physical access, housing, digital access,
- 9:48and more, again, not just academics. Both the
- 9:52ADA and 504 require that individualized consideration.
- 9:57A preset accommodations menu or a rigid refusal
- 10:01without engaging in that interactive process
- 10:04violate the law. The student's needs have to
- 10:07guide that response, and there has to be that
- 10:10evaluation of reasonableness. I think what has
- 10:16been newest around the ADA has been digital accessibility.
- 10:22So I know the Office for Civil Rights for years,
- 10:27probably five years, have had many, many, many
- 10:31complaints made to them about website inaccessibility
- 10:34and have issued many agreements with schools
- 10:38to bring those websites into compliance with
- 10:42Section 504. Okay, next slide, please. And again,
- 10:49how the ADA itself applies to college students.
- 10:53The students are entitled to those reasonable
- 10:55modifications. The physical accessibility is
- 10:58really important and still comes up often because
- 11:02it's not just about having an accessible elevator
- 11:08in a building, but if we only have one chemistry
- 11:12lab on campus and for some reason the chemistry
- 11:14lab isn't accessible to a wheelchair user, that's
- 11:17a problem. And that still pops up as does accessible
- 11:21housing and apps to get to places on campus.
- 11:26It could also come up in the context of housing.
- 11:29So students might say due to a disability that
- 11:32they're requesting housing in a specific area
- 11:35of campus or single housing being guaranteed
- 11:39for them. Dining, technology, all of those things
- 11:44must be accessible. Like I said, the ADA Title
- 11:48II applies to public universities and then Title
- 11:51III covers most of those private colleges and
- 11:54universities. Okay. And again, like I said, as
- 12:00is the case in most of the statutes and certainly
- 12:03the ones we're going to discuss today, there
- 12:05is that anti -retaliation language as well. All
- 12:09right, next slide, please. Again, this is just
- 12:17for you all to have as a resource. I wanted to
- 12:20go over what those core rights are, how specifically
- 12:23they work, those differences from K -12. And
- 12:28then lastly, what's the first steps if a student
- 12:31believes that their rights are being violated?
- 12:34always the school is going to have and is required
- 12:37to have some sort of a 504 coordinator who has
- 12:41to be available through a grievance process.
- 12:45So checking your student handbook, checking the
- 12:49policies and procedures of the school, figuring
- 12:50out who that person is, and filing a complaint
- 12:53directly. They certainly take verbal complaints
- 12:56often, but of course, the best case scenario
- 13:00is that if a student has a problem, They're putting
- 13:02it into writing an email, asking for a meeting,
- 13:05and then going and seeing if they can figure
- 13:07it out. There's the Office for Civil Rights.
- 13:11While it has recently undergone a massive staff
- 13:16reduction, they are still working. Those career
- 13:19professionals who are super passionate about
- 13:22this work are still there and still addressing
- 13:24complaints. So certainly filing a complaint with
- 13:27OCR or the or the DOJ about a violation of 504
- 13:32ADA is available. And then education rights attorneys,
- 13:36we work on these matters often. I will say that,
- 13:40and I'll probably say this numerous times today,
- 13:43but something that's really important for Section
- 13:47504 or ADA violations or complaints is, much
- 13:52like many other things, it's always easier to
- 13:55address the issues upfront before they become
- 13:58a problem. So if a student asks, for example,
- 14:02for some certain test accommodations, and the
- 14:04school denies it, and then the student takes
- 14:07that, goes through the semester, and perhaps
- 14:10ends up failing a course, and now wants to file
- 14:12a grievance, that's much more challenging for
- 14:14the student to be successful with than if you
- 14:17ask for those accommodations or adjustments upfront.
- 14:21And then if you're not awarded them at the time,
- 14:23to go ahead and go through the grievance process
- 14:25then. Next slide, please. OK. So I just want
- 14:34to go a little bit more in depth of this post
- 14:36-secondary accommodation process. Because this
- 14:41process, if it's done with fidelity by the school
- 14:44and used by a student and their support system
- 14:48who knows that it's there, can really, really
- 14:51avoid a lot of the problems we see down the road.
- 14:54So once again, the first step is the student
- 14:57discloses a disability. That could be through
- 15:00a letter from a physician. It could be, you know,
- 15:05some schools have a portal that you enter into.
- 15:08Some schools, you know, when you come for freshman
- 15:11orientation or freshman enrollment, they'll talk
- 15:14about, you know, breaking off to see the disability
- 15:16services office and talk with them. But the main
- 15:19point here is, again, no one is going to be looking
- 15:23at students' records to see if they have a disability.
- 15:26You have to raise your hand. Sometimes I work
- 15:29with students who perhaps either didn't have
- 15:32an identified disability when they started school
- 15:35or subject to some illness or accident. They
- 15:43have a disability that comes to them during college.
- 15:47Most recently, a couple of months ago, I worked
- 15:49with a student who unfortunately had had a traumatic
- 15:53brain injury. even though he was going into his
- 15:57last semester of school when that happened, he'd
- 16:00never had accommodations before. He still needed
- 16:03to request accommodations for that final semester.
- 16:05So again, that self -disclosure does not have
- 16:08to happen before school starts. It does not have
- 16:11to happen at the beginning of your academic career.
- 16:17And it may be a disability that you had either
- 16:20never had or had never been identified prior
- 16:23to you coming to college. But the only way the
- 16:28school can find out is if you tell the school
- 16:30as a student. And then part of that disclosure
- 16:35to the school is providing documentation of a
- 16:37disability. And honestly, schools really vary
- 16:42widely of what they accept for that documentation.
- 16:47But most often, a school is looking for, if you
- 16:51have an evaluation, That's wonderful. A prior
- 16:54evaluation, perhaps, from the student's secondary
- 16:57education. IEPs and Section 504 plans are great
- 17:01documentation. While the school won't and doesn't
- 17:05implement those, again, it's good documentation.
- 17:11But even if you don't have that formal psychoeducational
- 17:15evaluation, or you didn't have an IEP or a 504
- 17:19plan in secondary school, doesn't mean that you
- 17:22don't have documentation or that you don't have
- 17:24a disability. So a lot of students come to me
- 17:29and they're concerned that they need to pay for
- 17:31this big psychoeducational evaluation solely
- 17:35so that they can get their services, but that's
- 17:39not the case. Once that documentation has been
- 17:43provided to disability services, which will include
- 17:47the requests for any specific academic accommodations
- 17:50that the student's asking for, then it's up to
- 17:54disability services to evaluate that documentation.
- 17:57They are supposed to engage in what's called
- 17:59an interactive process and then make a determination
- 18:04as to whether or not they're going to grant the
- 18:08requested accommodations. The other piece of
- 18:13this is not only does the student have to raise
- 18:15their hand and say, I self -disclosing my disability,
- 18:20the student also, once they get those accommodations
- 18:22approved, typically the student is the one who
- 18:25provides those accommodations, information that
- 18:28they need those accommodations to their professors.
- 18:31So sometimes disability services will forward
- 18:34the student a email that they can forward to
- 18:37all their professors, letting them know what
- 18:39their accommodations are. Sometimes professors
- 18:41want you to bring a hard copy. And some schools
- 18:44have a portal where the student can give permission
- 18:47and select professors specifically that the accommodations
- 18:50go to. But the student's accommodations are only
- 18:54implemented if the student asks for them. And
- 18:59what is really challenging, and I see unfortunately
- 19:02too often, the students coming to me after perhaps
- 19:06failing a course a semester and say, well, I
- 19:10had accommodations but they didn't give them
- 19:11to me. And then my first question is, OK, great,
- 19:14when did you ask the professor for the accommodations.
- 19:18And the students just have no idea. They're like,
- 19:21no, no, no. I registered with the office. They
- 19:23gave me accommodations. And that is a place where
- 19:29things kind of fall through the cracks. And I
- 19:34just want to note, there is some really strong
- 19:38case law out there. One case in particular that
- 19:42is a first circuit case, but really speaks to
- 19:45how a process should work anywhere is, you know,
- 19:49the fact that if the student's needs evolve or
- 19:52change, the school must reengage with the student
- 19:55if they ask them to. And that can include when
- 19:59a student enters a disciplinary process. So we'll
- 20:01talk about that more. And then the other piece
- 20:04is that it's really important that institutions
- 20:08provide those individual assessments and don't
- 20:11rely on generalizations. So like I said earlier,
- 20:15it's important that the school doesn't just say
- 20:16here's our menu that we've always approved and
- 20:20move on. And I will note there is a Ninth Circuit
- 20:24case that came out about six years ago, 2019.
- 20:29I was about to say just recently, but that's
- 20:31not recently anymore. But it really highlights
- 20:35the obligation of post -secondary institutions
- 20:37to recognize and respond to these accommodation
- 20:40requests. even if not framed in precise legal
- 20:43terms. So this is a Rogers v. Western University
- 20:47case, and it's a very helpful case because the
- 20:51Ninth Circuit really emphasized that students
- 20:53are not required to use any magic words when
- 20:56seeking accommodations. They don't have to say,
- 20:58I'm looking for a reasonable accommodation or
- 21:01an academic adjustment. They could instead show
- 21:04up and say, well, I just need some extra help,
- 21:06or I'm not sure how to handle this situation.
- 21:08But as long as they identify themselves, as a
- 21:11student with a disability. They don't have to
- 21:13have any other match courts. All right, next
- 21:16slide, please. And this is just a handy little
- 21:21chart that I often use with parents when they
- 21:24have a student who is transitioning from that
- 21:27K -12 education IEP into post -secondary. The
- 21:32laws are similar, though the IDEA does not apply
- 21:34to post -secondary. There is an accommodations
- 21:37plan in college, not an IEP or a 504 plan. and
- 21:41all that responsibility is with the students.
- 21:44The one thing I really wanna identify and highlight
- 21:48here on the chart is the parent involvement piece.
- 21:51So in K -12 education, in every state, parents
- 21:56have legal rights and a decision -making role
- 21:59that's protected by the law. That means they
- 22:02have access to their students' information. That
- 22:05means they're able to call and ask for documentation.
- 22:08they're able to have meetings without the student
- 22:10being present about the student. Parents do not
- 22:13have that automatic involvement in higher education.
- 22:17And this is something that is so frustrating
- 22:20and so hard for so many parents that I talk to,
- 22:23particularly when you have a student who's struggling
- 22:26at school or you're concerned about their well
- 22:28-being and you're unable to get any answers.
- 22:36Ways to get around that, of course, is schools
- 22:39have FERPA waivers. You can have your students
- 22:42sign a FERPA waiver before they leave for school.
- 22:45Almost every school is going to have one on their
- 22:47website. The challenge with that is that if your
- 22:50student then decides they don't want you to have
- 22:52access, they can, of course, get rid of that
- 22:55at any point they want to also in writing. And
- 22:59sometimes even with the FERPA waiver, I should
- 23:02say, not sometimes. Oftentimes, even with a FERPA
- 23:04waiver signed by the student, that only means
- 23:07the school will include you in conversations.
- 23:09They certainly won't have conversations without
- 23:12the student. And just question just popped up
- 23:15about the first circuit case. That's when W -Y
- 23:21-N -N -E be toughs. And that's a first circuit
- 23:25case from 1991. Okay, next slide please. So non
- 23:38Title IX campus discipline we're going to talk
- 23:40about before we jump into Title IX campus discipline
- 23:44because Title IX is just an entire other animal
- 23:47into itself. The thing to understand first and
- 23:51foremost about campus discipline processes, regardless
- 23:54of whether you have a student with a disability
- 23:56or not, is that those discipline processes vary
- 24:00wildly by institution. At the end of the day,
- 24:05there's very few requirements on what a school's
- 24:10disciplinary process must have. And that can
- 24:20be super frustrating, mainly because what most
- 24:24state laws hold is that A student discipline
- 24:27code has to follow its words, its policies and
- 24:31procedures. Common allegations that I see from
- 24:35students, academic integrity matters especially
- 24:39more and more and more with AI and kind of these
- 24:42battles of how AI can or is being used, disruption
- 24:47of campus life, and then alcohol and drugs. The
- 24:53process of of general campus discipline typically
- 24:57involves some basic due process rights. The student
- 25:01should get a notice of what the allegations are.
- 25:04There typically is some sort of an informal meeting
- 25:07with a campus administrator. And then that campus
- 25:11administrator in that informal meeting may be
- 25:14the one who's making a decision whether a violation
- 25:17happened. And if there was a violation of the
- 25:20student code, what the sanction is going to be.
- 25:24That can be a little tricky for students. And
- 25:27really, they need to know this going in. If you
- 25:28get accused, for example, of an academic integrity
- 25:31violation by a professor, most often the first
- 25:34step in that process is that the professor makes
- 25:37a finding against you. And then if you disagree
- 25:40with that, you're really appealing to some sort
- 25:43of a board or another administrator to overrule
- 25:46that. So it's really important that students
- 25:49walk into those meetings with professors knowing
- 25:51that it can have that sort of a long -term effect.
- 25:56The due process standards can differ at private
- 25:59institutions, and one of the things that varies
- 26:04wildly but is actually pretty popular in California
- 26:07is around limiting how advisors and support people
- 26:13or attorneys can interact with students in this
- 26:16process. So some schools prohibit attorneys entirely.
- 26:21Their policies and procedures, their student
- 26:23code will say that if you have one of these conduct
- 26:26board hearings or some sort of a conduct informal
- 26:29conference, you're not allowed to bring an attorney
- 26:32with you. Some will say you're not allowed to
- 26:34bring anyone with you. Some say you're allowed
- 26:38to bring a support person so long as that support
- 26:40person is a member of the campus community. And
- 26:44then I saw one not too long ago that even said,
- 26:48you can bring a support person as long as they're
- 26:51not an attorney, and that includes your parents.
- 26:53So if your parent is an attorney, they cannot
- 26:54be your support person in the meeting. Those
- 26:57limitations are allowable. Even when an advisor
- 27:02or an attorney is allowed to be present in a
- 27:04meeting, they nearly all prohibit those advisors
- 27:07from speaking. explain to my clients when I'm
- 27:11working with them that once we're in the meeting
- 27:13itself, I'm really a potted plant. But unfortunately,
- 27:19students often do attend these alone or unsupported,
- 27:23even though these are very high stakes meetings.
- 27:26I do want to note that students can really benefit
- 27:30from preparation, even if it's a meeting where
- 27:32they're not allowed to bring anyone with them.
- 27:35And then in meetings where they are allowed to
- 27:36bring a support person or advisor with them.
- 27:39There's always the opportunity to take breaks
- 27:41and speak with that advisor or support person
- 27:44in private. Okay, next slide, please. So we're
- 27:52going to look through a particular situation
- 27:54through the eyes of Marina. Marina is a biology
- 27:58major with ADHD and has anxiety. She's registered
- 28:03with both of those things at a private university.
- 28:06She has testing accommodations. but nothing that
- 28:10addresses anything around executive functioning
- 28:12or communication devices. Mid -semester, she
- 28:16was accused of cheating. She used her phone during
- 28:20an open note exam to access a time management
- 28:24app that was recommended by her academic coach.
- 28:27The professor reported her directly to the student
- 28:32conduct office, and neither he nor the student
- 28:35conduct office consulted disability services.
- 28:38Marina requested that she be able to bring a
- 28:41support person to a disciplinary conference,
- 28:48and that was denied. Her disability context and
- 28:52her direction that this time management app could
- 28:55be used from her academic coach was ignored.
- 28:58She was sanctioned, placed on academic probation,
- 29:01and received no further accommodations or discussions
- 29:04about that. So I just want to pause there. just
- 29:08to point out some red flags. Here, I would argue
- 29:13certainly the law wasn't followed, but also there's
- 29:16just some practical best practices that could
- 29:18be put into place that weren't happening, not
- 29:22because the institution lacked a policy, but
- 29:25because no one coordinated. Next slide, please.
- 29:32All right. And right before I jump into these,
- 29:34I'm just going to answer a couple of questions.
- 29:37Have I ever requested an exception to the rules
- 29:39prohibiting attorneys as a reasonable accommodation
- 29:43or prohibiting returnees speaking as a reasonable
- 29:46accommodation? And how successful are those?
- 29:48I have. I frequently make that request as a reasonable
- 29:52accommodation. We're going to talk a little bit
- 29:55more about that in our next example student.
- 29:58Um, but certainly there are situations where
- 30:02I ask for an accommodation, either that I'm allowed
- 30:05to read the student's own, you know, opening
- 30:09statement or personal statement. Um, or if a
- 30:12student has, you know, is registered as a student,
- 30:16maybe with anxiety recently, I asked for an accommodation
- 30:20just that the student could bring a support person
- 30:22and it'd be me because the school didn't allow
- 30:24support people. So. I have had success requesting
- 30:27those accommodations. They're not always approved.
- 30:32But my experience is that schools, once I get
- 30:36involved, tend to be pretty flexible about allowing
- 30:39accommodations around the process. And then there's
- 30:43another question about what if you have a minor
- 30:45child taking a college class. So absolutely,
- 30:50and I'm sorry to make this clear in the beginning,
- 30:53the issues about FERPA limiting access is for
- 30:56students over the age of 18. What happens is
- 31:00that at the K -12 level, parents are entitled
- 31:03to information, even if the student is 18 or
- 31:06older. But at the higher ed level, that's very
- 31:09different. And I have worked with students in
- 31:12the past who are not as young as this question
- 31:15asks, but who are 17 and were freshmen in college
- 31:18and had a lot of pushback when the school when
- 31:23the parents wanted to get involved in conversations.
- 31:26That's less of a FERPA issue and more of a school
- 31:28culture and policy issue. But yes, that certainly
- 31:32would not apply to a K -12 student who's taking
- 31:35college classes. OK, so here are four big chunks
- 31:40of where we see some legal failures for Marina.
- 31:44First of all, at no point was there a consultation
- 31:47with disability services. Again, really important
- 31:52that the school has set up some means of communication
- 31:56between their Student Conduct Office and their
- 31:58Disability Services Office so that if a student's
- 32:02name comes through, some sort of flag gets thrown
- 32:05to know at least that that student is registered
- 32:08with the Disability Services Office and then
- 32:11have the ability to ask the student or give notice
- 32:15to the student that you're going to contact Disability
- 32:18Services Office. In this situation, there was
- 32:21no individualized assessment as to the denial
- 32:28of the support person. So she asked for a support
- 32:30person as an accommodation, they immediately
- 32:34said no. Again, their response in this particular
- 32:38situation was, sorry, that's just against our
- 32:41policy, we never allow that no matter what. And
- 32:45saying we never allow that no matter what. is
- 32:47not a legal compliant response to a request for
- 32:51an academic accommodation. And then just this
- 32:57overall situation that the disability context
- 33:00was ignored. So she had a coach, an academic
- 33:04coach, that had been assigned to her through
- 33:06disability services who had suggested that she
- 33:09use this time management app on her phone. And
- 33:12they had specifically set up you know, like a
- 33:17part within the app to help her with time management
- 33:19during exams. And no one had communicated to
- 33:25either disability services itself or her professors
- 33:28that being allowed to use this time management
- 33:31app was a reasonable accommodation that she was
- 33:33allowed. So it's really important again to remind
- 33:37our students that if they find something that's
- 33:40working for them, that's outside the formalities
- 33:44of the accommodations that they've already provided
- 33:46to their professors, they need to go back to
- 33:48disability services and get those in writing.
- 33:52I always tell students, we can depend on your
- 33:56written accommodations. We cannot depend on personalities
- 33:59who might not be there tomorrow. So that's really
- 34:02important. OK, now we are going to talk about
- 34:08when Section 504 and Title IX intersect. Next
- 34:11slide, please. OK, so first we're going to talk
- 34:17just a brief overview of Title IX. The first
- 34:20thing I want to say before I get into really
- 34:22the weeds of this is that Title IX as a statute
- 34:28prohibits sex -based discrimination in education.
- 34:31That's broadly. A lot of issues that are happening
- 34:36right now and changes in the law and trying to
- 34:38figure out policies is around how Title IX does
- 34:42or does not protect students who identify or
- 34:47are identified as LBGTQ, also pregnancy and post
- 34:53-pregnancy protections for students under Title
- 34:56IX. I think most of us hear Title IX and we think
- 35:02athletics. So all of those pieces are very, very
- 35:06important parts of Title IX. And I sometimes
- 35:10do day -long trainings on each of those discrete
- 35:13parts of Title IX. But for today's purposes,
- 35:17we're just going to be looking at these grievance
- 35:21procedures inside of a Title IX process that
- 35:25apply to a student disciplinary matter. So in
- 35:34recent years, I personally have seen a spike
- 35:37in cases where student behaviors tied to disability
- 35:40are really misread as Title IX violations. Title
- 35:45IX prohibits, like I said, sex -based discrimination
- 35:48in educational programs. Again, those receiving
- 35:51federal funds, which is almost all public and
- 35:55private post -secondary institutions. Compliance
- 35:59should be enforced on campus by a Title IX coordinator.
- 36:02Again, I will say OCR is still there, so filings
- 36:06with the Office for Civil Rights. I'll also note
- 36:10that While Title IX is, of course, not a state
- 36:13law, many states also have state -level agencies
- 36:16where you can file similar complaints with them,
- 36:19but they're not quite the same. The big part
- 36:25of Title IX and the regulations that apply to
- 36:29what we're talking about today with discipline
- 36:31is part 106 of the Title IX regulations. That
- 36:36really goes in specifically to procedural requirements
- 36:39for Title IX compliance. That includes investigation
- 36:42protocols, notice requirements, evidence requirements,
- 36:47hearing and appeal rights, and access to advisors
- 36:52and accommodations. In the course materials,
- 36:56there's a link to really the most notable section
- 37:00around those grievance procedures, if you want
- 37:02to follow up and learn more about that later
- 37:03on. I also included just some important and easy
- 37:10to read resources that are still in place from
- 37:15the US Department of Education. So OCR put out
- 37:19a question and answers regarding the final Title
- 37:23IX rule that went into effect in 2020. They also
- 37:27have just a letter, what's called a Dear Colleague
- 37:32letter, which is just guidance to schools. again,
- 37:36how they implement these significant regulatory
- 37:39changes that were made in 2020. That included
- 37:43updated definitions of things like sexual harassment,
- 37:47changes in jurisdictional limitations from before
- 37:492020, and then how these grievance procedures
- 37:53could apply for employee -related complaints.
- 37:58Okay, next slide, please. So for Title IX, as
- 38:05it stands now. Colleges are required to have
- 38:08some sort of a grievance system where a student,
- 38:12again, applies certainly to more than students,
- 38:15but today that's just what we're talking about,
- 38:17where a student can file a formal or informal
- 38:19complaint of sexual harassment or misconduct
- 38:22with the school. Typically an initial assessment
- 38:25is made by a Title IX coordinator as to whether
- 38:28it qualifies as, you know, what are defined as
- 38:31these offenses under Title IX. Sometimes something
- 38:35might not be sexual harassment, even the allegations
- 38:38themselves might not be sexual harassment by
- 38:41Title IX's definitions, but they may be sexual
- 38:43harassment under the definitions either of the
- 38:46school's policy or their own state policies.
- 38:53The Title IX regulations require written notice
- 38:56of the allegations to both of the parties. So
- 38:59that's an opportunity both for the complainant
- 39:01or the complaining party or the reporting party,
- 39:04all the same person, to make sure what they're
- 39:07complaining of is captured accurately. And then
- 39:09also gives that notice to the respondent or the
- 39:13responding party of what the allegations are.
- 39:17In the investigation itself, there must be evidence
- 39:20gathering. There must be the opportunity for
- 39:23the parties themselves to participate in an interview.
- 39:26and also the parties to request witnesses be
- 39:30interviewed. And then similarly with evidence
- 39:33that the parties have the opportunity to provide
- 39:36evidence and also review the evidence that is
- 39:39submitted by anyone else, witnesses or the other
- 39:41party. At that point, the report is put together
- 39:47by the investigator that is to be issued to both
- 39:49parties. And there's certain timelines about
- 39:52how long they have to review those reports. and
- 39:56respond to them. And then once a final report
- 40:00is issued, the hearing typically is scheduled.
- 40:03This is a live hearing that includes cross -examinations.
- 40:08So under those regulations that came out in 2020,
- 40:11schools are required to hold live hearings and
- 40:14to have cross -examination available. the students
- 40:19must have an advisor to do the cross -examination
- 40:21for them. Students are not allowed to, the parties
- 40:24are not allowed to cross -examine each other.
- 40:27At the end of the hearing the parties are entitled
- 40:30to a written determination and there must be
- 40:33an appeal process. I would say in general appeals
- 40:36are very challenging because the reasons why
- 40:40you're allowed to appeal are very very narrow.
- 40:45Okay so let's talk about my client Jordan. just
- 40:49of course, not his real name. Next slide, please.
- 40:54Jordan was a student I worked with at a large
- 40:57public university in the South. Jordan was autistic.
- 41:02He had registered with the school as a student
- 41:04with disabilities, and he received testing accommodations,
- 41:08quiet room, extended time if needed, but that
- 41:12was it. There were no accommodations related
- 41:15to class seating. behavioral supports, or anything
- 41:19around letting his professors know information
- 41:23about his disability. His third semester at school,
- 41:31a classmate in a large lecture hall class filed
- 41:33a Title IX complaint against Jordan. That complaint
- 41:37alleged that Jordan had haste outside of their
- 41:41classroom, watching her before class and after
- 41:46class. It alleged that Jordan had set near her
- 41:53in class every day, and she was taking that as
- 41:57interpreting that as some sort of stalking. She
- 41:59also alleged that Jordan was masturbating in
- 42:02class. Jordan would tell you that the masturbating
- 42:09wasn't happening, but that all of those were
- 42:11self -regulation strategies. So Jordan paced
- 42:16out in the hallway before class because it was
- 42:18a way for him to get his energy out, a way for
- 42:20him to get physical movement, so that then he
- 42:22would go into class and sit and be still and
- 42:25able to sustain his attention for the duration
- 42:27of the course. As far as seating is concerned,
- 42:31Jordan sat in the same seat in that classroom
- 42:34for every course he had had at the university,
- 42:37which included multiple courses both that semester
- 42:40and semesters before. And then the the masturbation
- 42:45allegation, Jordan had a stem. So when he was
- 42:50trying to pay attention ways that he would help
- 42:52himself pay attention. And one of those ways
- 42:54is that he would scratch his leg. Now, it was
- 42:58the top of his thigh at that crease in his leg.
- 43:01And so from where that student was sitting on
- 43:04the on the far side of him certainly could have
- 43:07looked as if he was touching his genitalia. But
- 43:10in fact, that was not the case. First of all,
- 43:20he was immediately suspended from campus. The
- 43:24complainants reported this to the professor in
- 43:26class. The professor was appalled because he
- 43:34didn't think he had any reason to think that
- 43:36any of those behaviors could be explained or
- 43:41could have been innocent in nature. And so he
- 43:44immediately reports it to the Student Conduct
- 43:45Office. The Student Conduct Office immediately
- 43:48puts him on an interim suspension. Eventually,
- 43:53he's, and we're going to talk about this in detail,
- 43:56he's denied a communication support person, his
- 43:59medical documentation is dismissed, he loses
- 44:01an appeal to get back on campus, and is found
- 44:05responsible under Title IX and suspended. Fortunately,
- 44:09Jordan came to me, we were able to do an appeal,
- 44:13and we were able to be successful in that appeal,
- 44:15where the school's internal grievance process
- 44:19acknowledged multiple procedural errors and disability
- 44:23bias. So next slide, please. So these are some
- 44:29of the clear legal failures that we were able
- 44:32to be successful on in the appeal, which you
- 44:36know, was wonderful to be successful in that
- 44:38way, but certainly was hugely disappointing that
- 44:41it all could have been avoided. Again, when this
- 44:46complaint came in, there was conversations between
- 44:48the Student Conduct Office and the Title IX Office,
- 44:51but no conversations, no way for anyone to know
- 44:54that Jordan was a registered student with a disability.
- 44:59Because of those verbal laws, you know, no one
- 45:02had ever told his professor about his disability
- 45:06and how that might manifest itself in a classroom
- 45:09setting. So, you know, again, that wasn't a failure
- 45:13of the school, but working with my client and
- 45:15his parents, we were able to, you know, come
- 45:19to the agreement that in the future it would
- 45:21be better for Jordan, individual assessment,
- 45:24that the beginning of the semester he sent his
- 45:26professors an email and let them know that he
- 45:29has some physical behaviors that are not problematic
- 45:33and certainly are not. do not interrupt class,
- 45:36but that some people might not be used to seeing,
- 45:38so to let the professors know about that. He
- 45:43asked for communication support both during the
- 45:47investigation and during the hearing. That was
- 45:50denied. Again, it was just said we can't do that
- 45:53because we don't provide that to the complainants,
- 45:55so we can't provide that to the respondent. So
- 45:58there was no individual assessment. The investigator
- 46:02had no disability training whatsoever, and didn't
- 46:05coordinate or consult with anybody in the disability
- 46:08services office despite Jordan asking them to.
- 46:12Same was true of the hearing officer. Jordan
- 46:15had asked for a set of reasonable accommodations,
- 46:20which included having the hearing officer meet
- 46:23with disability services or a professor at the
- 46:26school who had some sort of expertise in students
- 46:29with autism. And that was denied as well. Okay.
- 46:40Next slide, please. Some other breakdowns that
- 46:46happened, you know, this I told you about how
- 46:49he was immediately removed from school. That
- 46:53was not done with any sort of an individualized
- 46:56safety assessment. So Title IX says, if you're
- 46:58going to remove a student from campus, you have
- 47:01to do, and before the process is completed, you
- 47:04have to do this individualized safety assessment.
- 47:08The school did not do that. They set his hearing
- 47:11during finals week. And initially, when he asked
- 47:15for it to be moved, just because it was finals
- 47:18week, they refused. We came back and asked for
- 47:20it to be moved as a disability accommodation
- 47:22and got general counsel at the university involved,
- 47:26and so that was approved. The same hearing officer
- 47:31was hearing unrelated cases that stemmed from
- 47:35some of the same types of issues of other students.
- 47:40Jordan asked that the hearing officer who did
- 47:45not have any interaction with the other student
- 47:49or any of the witnesses previously be assigned
- 47:52to the case. And that was denied as well. And
- 47:56at the end, oh, sorry, next slide. So those are
- 48:05really part of the Title IX matters, Title IX
- 48:08regulations that weren't followed appropriately.
- 48:11As I said, I just go down through here again
- 48:13at what those failures were so that you have
- 48:17it all in one place. All the failures that we've
- 48:20talked about, both under 504, the ADA, Title
- 48:23IX, and also the school's own policies and procedures
- 48:26were brought to the attention through this appeals
- 48:29process. And thankfully, Jordan was successful
- 48:35in that appeal. He was able to come back to school.
- 48:39And it's never exciting to have a client who's
- 48:43done something that has been subjected to a process
- 48:46that's hurt them. But it is very rewarding when
- 48:49they do come to you and that's happened, when
- 48:51you're able to work with a major university to
- 48:53change the way they silo their student services
- 48:57offices. So after the appeals officer came back
- 49:02and overturned not just the sanctions, but overturned
- 49:06the findings, we were able to come together at
- 49:09the school and figure out. first for Jordan,
- 49:12and then how they could do that more broadly,
- 49:15try to prevent this from happening in the future
- 49:18for students with disabilities. Next slide, please.
- 49:26And this is what some of those things were that
- 49:28we worked on. So including behavioral accommodations
- 49:31at intake, again, realizing that accommodations
- 49:35and academic adjustments can go outside of those
- 49:38typical academic curriculum focus type accommodations
- 49:42that we're used to. Provide some disability specific
- 49:48faculty and staff training when appropriate,
- 49:51helping faculty that are involved in the Title
- 49:55IX process and certainly investigators and hearing
- 49:58officers. whose only job on campus is to be part
- 50:02of the Title IX process, but they understand
- 50:04common disability -related behaviors of the types
- 50:08of disabilities that their students on campus
- 50:09might have. Coordination proactively between
- 50:15Title IX office and disability services. Again,
- 50:18the ability for a flag to be raised either for
- 50:21the Title IX office or the student conduct office
- 50:24that a student's registered with the disability
- 50:26services office is hugely important and can have
- 50:30such a positive impact. And then of course, initiating
- 50:34that interactive process early on. So despite
- 50:38the fact that Jordan was repeatedly asking for
- 50:40reasonable accommodations, he was just getting
- 50:42back nos, nos, nos without any of that engagement
- 50:47with the student or the disability services office
- 50:50to really modify supports, modify accommodations.
- 50:55before some sort of discipline or exclusion was
- 50:58considered. Next slide, please. And again, this
- 51:06is just a tool for you all to have if you would
- 51:08like to look through specifically what grounds
- 51:11for appeal look like, what some major procedural
- 51:15failures can be, how to identify bias, and takeaways
- 51:21from that. Next slide, please. So at the end
- 51:27of the day, it's really important that Title
- 51:29IX and Disability Student Service offices coordinate
- 51:33with each other. And this is not reinventing
- 51:36the wheel. So Title IX is already coordinating
- 51:38with student conduct at every university, certainly
- 51:42every university that I've ever either worked
- 51:44with or had a student in. So it's not that different.
- 51:49It's easy, really, and even the computer programs
- 51:51that... the schools use to house this information
- 51:54to put those red flags in place. Accommodations
- 51:59for a student might look like a modified hearing
- 52:02format, support persons, extended breaks, not
- 52:07having a hearing last a full day, only doing
- 52:09so many hours of a hearing a day, and also alternative
- 52:13questioning formats. So instead of having a student
- 52:16be asked questions by the hearing officer, Live,
- 52:23you know, the hearing officer could provide their
- 52:25list of questions to the student beforehand.
- 52:27The student could answer them in the hearing.
- 52:29And of course, the hearing officer could ask
- 52:31follow -up questions. But at least that way,
- 52:34their processing is able to take place in a modified
- 52:38way. OCR guidance does require disability -informed
- 52:44procedures, though unfortunately does not give
- 52:47much guidance on what that looks like. And I
- 52:51guess the last piece is, if you looked at my
- 52:55client's school file, that hearing probably did
- 52:59appear procedurally valid on paper. But it certainly
- 53:03was not legally sufficient. And once he was able
- 53:12to tell the whole story of what isn't really
- 53:13shown in the student file, it was clear that
- 53:17it needed to be overturned. One question is about,
- 53:20are objections permitted at the hearing? Absolutely
- 53:22not. Most schools have a code of conduct for
- 53:30the advisors and for the parties that says that
- 53:34no objections can be raised at the hearing. Typically,
- 53:37you're getting all the evidence and information
- 53:38before the hearing, and you do have the opportunity
- 53:40to raise concerns and objections to the materials
- 53:44prior to the hearing. And then the appeals process
- 53:47allows you that ability to come back and say
- 53:51that something is a procedural violation that
- 53:53is one of the one of the bases that you can appeal
- 53:56on. Next slide, please. And this is just a reminder
- 54:05that even if a student is not involved in a Title
- 54:08IX disciplinary process, there are these general
- 54:12disciplinary protections under just basic due
- 54:15process ideals that we have. Certainly public
- 54:20universities have that as government actors,
- 54:24but most private schools include these guarantees
- 54:27of due process in their student handbook. And
- 54:30so if they don't follow them, there's typically
- 54:33some sort of a quasi contract claim against them.
- 54:37Next slide, please. If a student comes to you
- 54:44and this perhaps isn't your practice area or
- 54:47it's a student who's in your life for some other
- 54:49reason and you see that it's a student with a
- 54:52disability and for whatever reason, disability
- 54:54services has not been involved. The student hasn't
- 54:57talked to them. It's clear the school hasn't
- 54:58talked to them and there's an academic integrity
- 55:02or other disciplinary matter going on. That's
- 55:06a big red flag. This is a student who really
- 55:08needs help. Once you're in a case, you have to
- 55:11be really critical of the individuals involved
- 55:15and whether they could be displaying bias or
- 55:17lack of training. And then, of course, the support
- 55:24and accommodations piece. If a student tells
- 55:27you they've asked for those things and they've
- 55:29been denied, that's a big red flag that they
- 55:31could use some help as well. Next slide, please.
- 55:37If you are working with students in this situation,
- 55:40the biggest thing upfront is to push for coordination,
- 55:44demand those individualized assessments, make
- 55:47sure that accommodations are not just happening
- 55:48in a classroom, but there are ways for those
- 55:50to happen procedurally. Remember that you're
- 55:54not just looking at case law when you're thinking
- 55:56about Title IX or Section 504, either one. You
- 55:59also want to be looking at guidance and resolutions
- 56:03that have come out of the Office for Civil Rights.
- 56:07Next slide, please. These are kind of the biggest,
- 56:13most often things that I see from institutions
- 56:15that they could cure proactively. And I've worked
- 56:20with some schools on trying to implement processes
- 56:23and best practices so that these don't happen.
- 56:26Denying support persons, rigid code enforcement,
- 56:30not doing any sort of a behavioral assessment
- 56:32as part of those temporary immediate suspensions.
- 56:36and just the overall lack of staff training.
- 56:40Next slide, please. OK. And then I just want
- 56:46to give you a kind of a little update of what's
- 56:48going on in general. So before I do that, one
- 56:50more question. If you lose a Title IX appeal,
- 56:53is there a right to review by a state court or
- 56:55state agency? There's no right to review. No.
- 57:00So if you lose if you lose the case, lose the
- 57:05appeal inside the school's administrative process,
- 57:07you could certainly file a complaint with the
- 57:10Office for Civil Rights that the school didn't
- 57:15follow Title IX in their processes or procedures
- 57:18and that therefore made gender discrimination
- 57:22happen. And you can file court cases under Title
- 57:27IX as well and under Section 504. The challenge
- 57:31is that the standard to show a violation that
- 57:36leads to liability is very, very high. But certainly,
- 57:41while there's no said right of appeal, there's
- 57:45no right of review. You can certainly appeal
- 57:47those by filing a new action that attacks the
- 57:52process by which the decision and the appeal
- 57:54were made. Okay, so as I have talked about repeatedly,
- 58:00and I'm sure you all know, OCR's capacity is
- 58:03shrinking. But again, those career enforcement
- 58:07staff, they remain strong. There were new revised
- 58:11Title IX rules that came out last summer, but
- 58:15those were vacated by a federal court, and this
- 58:20administration isn't proceeding to fight that
- 58:22in any way. So the 2020 Title IX rules are in
- 58:26place. Section 504 regulations, they haven't
- 58:31had a rewrite since, I believe, 1974. Department
- 58:36of Ed was taking comments about that under the
- 58:39previous administration, but under this administration,
- 58:43there's not been any updates. So it hasn't been
- 58:45pulled back, but they also haven't made any progress.
- 58:48Next slide, please. And that's really just to
- 58:55wrap up. If you are a student or have a student,
- 58:58you want to make sure before they go to college
- 59:01and throughout the process that they understand
- 59:04their rights, that they're advocating for themselves
- 59:06early on, and that they understand the process,
- 59:09both in academic integrity, student conduct,
- 59:13and Title IX. For parents, you really have to
- 59:17support your students in navigating that self
- 59:19-advocacy and encouraging your student to have
- 59:24documentation of all disability -related needs,
- 59:27especially in preparation for school. Institutions,
- 59:31it's really about proactive collaboration, pulling
- 59:33down those silos. Schools are already doing that
- 59:37in so many ways, and so it's really easy just
- 59:39to include disability services into those processes.
- 59:44And then for attorneys, you know, when you have
- 59:46a case come in that is about a student who's
- 59:49having some sort of issue with a disciplinary
- 59:51process or a Title IX process, asking the question,
- 59:54are you a student registered with disabilities
- 59:56with the university? And then advising clients
- 59:59about how to use the investigative process and
- 1:00:03how to file grievances if they want to self advocate.
- 1:00:07And that's all I have for you today. Thank you
- 1:00:11so much for being here. We are right at the time,
- 1:00:14but Certainly, if anyone has any other questions
- 1:00:17they want to enter into the question box, I'm
- 1:00:19happy to answer those. All right. Seeing none,
- 1:00:31I will just say thank you so much for having
- 1:00:33me here today. If something pops up that you
- 1:00:36want to talk about later, don't hesitate to reach
- 1:00:38out to me. I do work on these matters. around
- 1:00:41the country and for, you know, both institutions
- 1:00:44and students. And I'm always happy to have these
- 1:00:47conversations. So thank you so much. you