Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Overcoming Bias in Order to Successfully Negotiate Litigated Disputes with Lee Mendelson
Transcript
- 0:05I'm Belinda McCauley, executive director of the
- 0:08Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm delighted
- 0:10to be here today to introduce our speaker, Lee
- 0:13Mendelson. Lee's a mediator with ADR Services,
- 0:16Inc. He has more than 27 years of experience
- 0:19and a strong focus on dispute resolution, particularly
- 0:22in commercial litigation, personal injury, insurance
- 0:25coverage, workers' comp, and subrogation matters.
- 0:27From 2006 to 2023, he served as the managing
- 0:31attorney of Mendelsohn Law Group APC and holds
- 0:34the certified subrogation recovery professional
- 0:36designation from the National Association of
- 0:39Subrogation Professionals. A frequent speaker
- 0:41and published expert, Mr. Mendelsohn, and brings
- 0:44a wealth of practical insight and leadership
- 0:46to his mediation practice, helping parties efficiently
- 0:49resolve complex legal disputes. And with that,
- 0:52I will turn the floor over to you, Lee. Thank
- 0:55you, Belinda. And that was a great introduction.
- 0:58That makes me sound really good. Thank you so
- 1:00much. I'm going to talk just for a minute before
- 1:03we get started. Belinda hit on just about everything
- 1:06about me. But let me just to give you a lay of
- 1:09the land. As she mentioned, I was a litigator
- 1:12for 27 years. I sold my law practice and I mediate
- 1:18full time now. Mostly what I mediate are personal
- 1:21injury, products liability, premises liability.
- 1:25I do a good amount of employment mediation and
- 1:28just general business mediation. While I'm not
- 1:32doing that, I'm also an adjunct professor at
- 1:36Pepperdine University where I teach negotiation
- 1:41theory and practice. And I'm a total nerd when
- 1:45it comes to negotiation theory and practice.
- 1:47I love it. I am so happy that I learned more
- 1:50and more about it probably about 10 or 15 years
- 1:53ago during the course of my litigation career
- 1:55because it helped me to successfully negotiate
- 1:59cases and to come to better resolutions because
- 2:02I understood the theories behind it. So what
- 2:05are we here to talk about today? We're here to
- 2:07talk about bias. uh what is bias bias is a it's
- 2:14like a filter that goes in front of a person
- 2:17to stop them from making rational decisions if
- 2:20i have a bias i'm going to have an unfair or
- 2:23prejudiced way of thinking i'm by prejudice i'm
- 2:26not necessarily talking about racial or racial
- 2:28or cultural prejudice i'm talking about a way
- 2:31of prejudging things i am looking at things from
- 2:35a gut feeling Rather than from a rational feeling
- 2:39a rational thought and I'm not thinking it through
- 2:42prior to making decisions And so that's what
- 2:45we're going to talk about today. We're going
- 2:46to talk about bias We're going to talk about
- 2:49how to see bias in ourselves and how to see bias
- 2:54in other folks. And by recognizing the bias in
- 2:58ourselves, I'm going to discuss how to recognize
- 3:01those biases and how to take that recognition
- 3:04and get rid of the biases so I can make a rational
- 3:07decision when I'm negotiating a dispute. On the
- 3:10other hand, I'm also going to say. how to recognize
- 3:15the bias in other folks. So when I'm negotiating
- 3:19with someone, I can see, hey, they have this
- 3:22particular type of cognitive or motivational
- 3:25bias and how I can utilize that, of course, always
- 3:28in an ethical manner, but how I can utilize that
- 3:31to help me get a better settlement for my client.
- 3:36So those are the tasks that we're going to do
- 3:38today. To start, let's look at The main different
- 3:43types of biases the big categories that things
- 3:46fall into and the first one is cultural bias
- 3:49and that's what people think of most of the time
- 3:52when they think of bias. What is a cultural bias?
- 3:55It's a prejudice based on cultural norms or social
- 3:58expectations. That's what most folks think about
- 4:03when they think about bias. The other types of
- 4:05bias and the ones that I'm really going to focus
- 4:07on more today are cognitive bias and motivational
- 4:10bias. Cognitive bias are biases of the mind.
- 4:14There are these mental shortcuts, these quick
- 4:17gut decisions that we make when we're negotiating
- 4:20disputes. Motivational biases are emotional biases.
- 4:25These are what I like to call biases of the heart.
- 4:29And there's a great book called Negotiation.
- 4:31ingenious that outlines these different types
- 4:35of biases further. And I would recommend that
- 4:38you take a look at it, the cognitive and the
- 4:40motivational biases. But let's first go and spend
- 4:44a few minutes. Before we jump into cognitive
- 4:47bias, and we can just hang tight here on the
- 4:50slides, let's talk a little bit about cultural
- 4:53bias. And what I'm going to tell you is there's
- 4:57a great book. that i would recommend that you
- 5:00look at with regard to cultural bias and it's
- 5:03called the culture map it's by a woman named
- 5:06erin myer and what is my rights about is where
- 5:11to find yourself on the cultural bias spectrum
- 5:14she takes a different. scales like communication
- 5:19feedback leadership and where do you find yourself
- 5:23on those scales and where will you find other
- 5:25people on those scales and how folks from different
- 5:28countries Generally fall on those scales. So
- 5:34I'll take a couple of the things in the cultural
- 5:38bias Handbook that she has written and I'm gonna
- 5:42Excuse me Take a couple of things from the cultural
- 5:46bias handbook that she's written and I am going
- 5:49to outline them for you tell you what countries
- 5:52most of those fall under and Where you can find
- 5:57yourself one thing I would recommend also is
- 5:59she also Erin Meyer the cultural map the culture
- 6:02map has a great website I would recommend that
- 6:05you go and take a look at it because you can
- 6:07pay like five or seven bucks something like that
- 6:10it's not a lot of money and Sign up for it for
- 6:13like a day pass and answer a bunch of questions
- 6:16and then you'll find where you fall in the cultural
- 6:20map and you'll find where you fall on these scales
- 6:23and be able to help you to recognize those biases
- 6:28in yourself. So what are the cultural bias and
- 6:32another thing well let me just talk about this
- 6:34and I'll get back to it. What are the main scales
- 6:37in the cultural bias? One is evaluating. How
- 6:41do you take feedback and how do you give feedback?
- 6:46Do you have direct negative feedback or do you
- 6:49have indirect negative feedback? So countries
- 6:51like the Netherlands and Russia, they are extremely
- 6:55direct in their feedback. They're going to give
- 6:58you negative feedback. People from those countries
- 7:00generally are going to give you straight negative
- 7:03feedback. And the important thing is to recognize
- 7:07that you're going to get straight negative feedback
- 7:09from those places and are from particular types
- 7:13of people and to not be offended by it and be
- 7:16able to utilize it to do a better job with whatever
- 7:19conversation you're having, with whatever negotiation
- 7:21you're having. These people are going to be very
- 7:23direct with you. There's other countries that
- 7:27do indirect negative feedback. They don't come
- 7:30at you straight on. They come at you in a roundabout
- 7:34way. People generally from Japan and Thailand
- 7:37are very indirect with their feedback. They come
- 7:41in a roundabout way. And the thing about that
- 7:43that's important to recognize is you don't want
- 7:45to miss that feedback because it's going to make
- 7:47it more difficult to settle your case if you
- 7:51miss that type of feedback. So that's in evaluating.
- 7:55Let's go into leading. How does leading happen
- 8:00from different countries and from different perspectives?
- 8:04Are they more egalitarian? Are they more hierarchical?
- 8:09What is a egalitarian? Leading mean it means
- 8:14it's a flat hierarchy. It's a consensus building
- 8:18situation People lead by consensus mostly from
- 8:22like Denmark and Sweden. They're very consensus
- 8:25based cultures, but hierarchical feedback is
- 8:31a respect for rank. The boss is usually right
- 8:35with hierarchical feedback. When I ran my law
- 8:38firm for 27 years, I listened to everybody, but
- 8:41it was a hierarchical situation. India and China
- 8:48are very hierarchical. Same within the United
- 8:52States, actually. It's a very hierarchical situation.
- 8:55So when you're negotiating with those people,
- 8:58you need to make sure the boss is on the right
- 9:01page with you. But if you're negotiating with
- 9:04a large organization that's egalitarian, you're
- 9:07going to need to form a more consensus with all
- 9:10of the people you're negotiating with, the different
- 9:12parts of the organization. To me that's more
- 9:15difficult, but sometimes it's not. It depends
- 9:19on who you're dealing with. Next is how are decisions
- 9:23made in different cultures? Who makes the decision?
- 9:27How are the decisions made? What happens? Some
- 9:32cultures are very consensual in their decision
- 9:34-making. That's in Japan and Sweden. Some are
- 9:37more top -down. That's in the United States and
- 9:40China. Same kind of a situation as what we were
- 9:43talking about before. If there is a decision
- 9:46-making process from someone in the United States,
- 9:49you have to convince the boss to make the right
- 9:51decision. The next one is Trusting, how do people
- 9:56trust each other? Is it a task based trusting
- 9:59or is it more relationship based trusting? Task
- 10:06based trusting is you trust a person. when they
- 10:10do a good job. You look at how they did a good
- 10:12job on a previous task, and that means that you
- 10:15trust a person if they did a good job on a previous
- 10:18task. People in the United States are task -based
- 10:23trustors. People in the UK are very task -based
- 10:27trustors. But on the other side of the coin is
- 10:30relationship -based trusting. Prop like in Brazil
- 10:38and in Saudi Arabia. They are relationship based
- 10:42trusters They trust you if they know you they
- 10:46trust you if they know your family You're gonna
- 10:48need to spend time with these people you're gonna
- 10:51need to talk to these people about things other
- 10:54than The case if you want to develop a rapport
- 10:57with a client in order to negotiate a deal later
- 11:03And that client's from Brazil, for instance.
- 11:05You're going to need to develop trust with that
- 11:08person by spending a lot of time with them not
- 11:10dealing with your particular type of case. They're
- 11:12going to trust you as an individual attorney
- 11:15later. And then when you negotiate the deal with
- 11:18the other side in whatever dispute you're dealing
- 11:20with, they'll trust your decision because they
- 11:22trust you. Then there's disagreeing. How do different
- 11:27people disagree in different cultures? There
- 11:31is confrontational disagreement and there is
- 11:35avoids confrontational disagreement. Israelis
- 11:38are direct and cultural and their culture is
- 11:42very direct and disagreement. French folks are
- 11:45direct and disagreement. People that avoid confrontation
- 11:48are people from India. Indonesia and Japan are
- 11:53going to be very indirect, which means they're
- 11:56not going to come straight at you with whatever
- 11:58their disagreement is. They're going to they're
- 12:01going to do something a little more nonchalant,
- 12:03a little more from the side. So you want to not
- 12:07miss their disagreement. You want to know that
- 12:09they're disagreeing with you or else you're not
- 12:11going to get a deal. So you're going to have
- 12:12to pay really close attention to that and not
- 12:15expect them to be as direct with you. And you're
- 12:17not going to want to be as direct with them.
- 12:20Then finally, the last cultural bias that I'm
- 12:23going to talk about is scheduling bias. That
- 12:26is some folks believe in linear time and some
- 12:29folks believe in flexible time. Linear time means
- 12:33punctuality, strict schedules. People from Germany
- 12:37and Switzerland are very into linear time. And
- 12:42then people with more flexible time are people
- 12:45really from India and Nigeria. They're goals.
- 12:50are not gonna be as much on a punctuality timeline.
- 12:54They're gonna be flexible with their timeline.
- 12:56My wife and I, we get along great. We have a
- 12:59great relationship. But I am very linear with
- 13:03my timeline and she is very flexible with her
- 13:05timeline and that is the only place where we
- 13:07have disagreement and I have to know that she
- 13:10is going to be flexible in the way she's going
- 13:12to show up to something and she's going to have
- 13:14to know that I'm going to try to be really punctual
- 13:17and When we know that we get along great and
- 13:19we and we work things out So it's important to
- 13:22know those types of things. So now And I do think
- 13:26that cultural bias is important in the cases
- 13:29you may see down in LA County Superior Court
- 13:31and that you may deal with these types of biases
- 13:34on a regular basis. You're also going to look,
- 13:37and I did a lot about talking about different
- 13:39countries and the types of biases that come from
- 13:43different countries and those kinds of things.
- 13:45But to be honest with you, These are parts of
- 13:50egocentrism. These are parts of a definite motivational
- 13:53bias called egocentrism It's the way I look at
- 13:56it from my personal perspective from my point
- 14:00of view and if I can get beyond that motivational
- 14:02bias that egocentrism I'm going to be OK, and
- 14:05I'm going to be able to do a proper negotiation.
- 14:08So let's move on, and let's talk a little bit
- 14:10about cognitive bias. So we're on the slide here.
- 14:15OK, cognitive bias. What are those cognitive
- 14:17biases? They are biases. of the mind. Those are
- 14:22those mental shortcuts. Those are those decisions
- 14:24we make just with a gut reaction without thinking
- 14:28through them. They're just like secondhand in
- 14:31our mind. The biases that are cognitive biases
- 14:35generally, and I'm going to go through these
- 14:37in just a minute, are fixed pie bias, the vividness
- 14:40bias, the non -rational escalation of commitment
- 14:44bias, and the susceptibility to frame bias. Now
- 14:51before I get into that, let me tell you a little
- 14:52story about something that happened to me I guess
- 14:57a week or two ago. So I'm a mediator. I'm mediating
- 15:00a case regarding a church. It was a very emotional
- 15:07case. This one religious institution, this one
- 15:12I'll call it religion. It's not really its own
- 15:15religion, but I'm going to call it its own religion.
- 15:17They didn't have a church in Los Angeles and
- 15:20they wanted to build one. So 40 families got
- 15:23together. They raised a bunch of money and they
- 15:27went out to look for a piece of property. They
- 15:30opened up a 501 C3. They opened up a non -profit.
- 15:33It's a non -profit organization to buy this church
- 15:36and to run the church. And they raised all this
- 15:39money about $500 ,000 and they put it into the
- 15:41501. They went to look for the property. Unfortunately,
- 15:47it was a brand new 501C3. Corporation and they
- 15:52couldn't get any credit They went around and
- 15:55they just couldn't get credit They found the
- 15:57perfect property that they wanted to buy but
- 15:59they couldn't buy it because no one would make
- 16:01them alone So what did they do? Somebody from
- 16:04the church a woman from the church volunteered
- 16:06and say hey I can get credit we can put the church
- 16:09property in my name So they bought the property
- 16:13using the 501 c3 money to buy this piece of property
- 16:17but what they did was they took the money from
- 16:19the non -profit they gave it to this one individual
- 16:22church member and she bought the property she
- 16:25put it in her name every month for a year she
- 16:28made the mortgage payments out of her own checkbook
- 16:30but that money came from the 501 c3 the money
- 16:34that had been raised by the church uh so the
- 16:39church gave them money the corporation gave the
- 16:41woman money she paid for the church property
- 16:44every month so Unfortunately, over the course
- 16:49of a year, there became some real dissension
- 16:51in the church. The person that they had hired
- 16:54to be the religious leader, a big chunk of the
- 16:56church did not like the type, the way he was
- 16:59teaching that spirituality, the way he was teaching
- 17:02that religion to the parishioners and to the
- 17:05kids and to the families in the church. So out
- 17:09of those 40 families, I would say about 30 of
- 17:12them, didn't like the way they were running the
- 17:15church, and about 10 of those family units did
- 17:18like the way they were running the church. The
- 17:2030 didn't like it. Unfortunately, the woman that
- 17:24actually owned the church property was in the
- 17:26minority. She was in the 10 that liked the way
- 17:29they were running the church. Also, the great
- 17:32chunk of the money that had been raised had been
- 17:35raised by those 10 people, those 10 family units
- 17:39that liked the way that the church was going.
- 17:42of the churchgoers the majority of the members
- 17:44the people that I'll call the corporation folks
- 17:47they did not like the way the church was going
- 17:50so anyway what happens the the people from the
- 17:54corporation are no longer going to the church
- 17:56they stop paying the bills and they file a lawsuit
- 17:59against the woman that the property was in her
- 18:03name to get all of the money back that that they
- 18:07had They had given to the church. So let's move
- 18:10on to the fixed bias black fixed pie bias. Let's
- 18:12go to the next slide here Okay, what is a fixed
- 18:17pie bias? It's a focus on what's called distributive
- 18:22bargaining while ignoring what's called integrative
- 18:25bargaining So let's go to the next slide here
- 18:28and I can explain the difference between distributive
- 18:29bargaining and integrative bargaining distributive
- 18:32bargaining is claiming value if you are a distributive
- 18:37bargainer. One side wins, the other side loses.
- 18:41It's a zero sum game. Integrative bargaining,
- 18:45on the other hand, creates value. It seeks ways
- 18:49in which both sides can obtain their goals. It
- 18:53looks for the lowest cost to make sure all of
- 18:56the goals are obtained. The pie is expandable.
- 18:59You can grow the pie. We're not just talking
- 19:01about that one thing that we filed the original
- 19:03lawsuit about. We can What we need to do in integrative
- 19:07bargaining is focus on interest, not on positions.
- 19:11So let me get back to the church. Let's talk
- 19:13about what the problems were with the church
- 19:15and what they were focused on. They had very
- 19:18much of what I would call a fixed pie bias. They
- 19:22were very upset and very focused the corporation
- 19:27people on getting that money back. That's what
- 19:30they were looking for. They filed suit for that
- 19:33money. They wanted to distributed bargaining.
- 19:35They wanted to claim value and get as much of
- 19:37that money back as possible. They wanted the
- 19:39other side to lose. They wanted them to be out
- 19:42on the street. They wanted to get their money
- 19:44and move on. It was a zero sum game to these
- 19:47people. The defense was the same way. She was
- 19:49like, these people are total jerks. They're trying
- 19:52to mess up our church if we pay them all this
- 19:54money. we're going to lose our church. There's
- 19:57no way we're totally focused on the money. So
- 20:01what did I have to do in this mediation? I had
- 20:06to talk to these folks and find out not their
- 20:10positions. not where are they set in their positions
- 20:14in the negotiation. One position, I want the
- 20:17$500 ,000 back. The other position, I won't give
- 20:20you the $500 ,000. What we needed to focus on
- 20:23is what they were really interested in. Why did
- 20:26they raise this money to begin with? Why did
- 20:28they want to do this in LA to begin with? They
- 20:31wanted to provide a church to their kids to teach
- 20:34their religious beliefs. to have life cycle events
- 20:39for their family in that church. They wanted
- 20:43to have a place to worship and to be together
- 20:45and to fellowship and to do those types of things.
- 20:48So that's what everybody wanted, both sides of
- 20:51it. That's what they really wanted. So I had
- 20:53to spend probably a good hour or two getting
- 20:56down, letting them say, emote their feelings
- 21:01and say what why they were so upset about the
- 21:04money to get down to the point of what were they
- 21:06really interested in? What did they really want?
- 21:08And then at the end of the day, I explained to
- 21:11them that they had this fixed pie bias. I didn't
- 21:13straight out say it, but through a series of
- 21:15questions, we're able to get to the point to,
- 21:18hey, you're focused on on the wrong thing because
- 21:21if they give you all of this money you're still
- 21:23not going to have enough money and you're not
- 21:24going to have the credit to go buy a new church
- 21:26and they're not going to be able to keep their
- 21:29church. Nobody's going to have a church if you
- 21:31do that. So we have to figure out a way to do
- 21:33it. So what did we do? There was an exchange
- 21:35of money that took place but mostly the agreement
- 21:41was based on ownership of the property, and more
- 21:44than even ownership, it was based on use of the
- 21:47property. So they kept the church, they used
- 21:49one religious leader for church services during
- 21:52one part of the day. The corporation people hired
- 21:55another religious leader for services during
- 21:57another part of the day. They were able to use
- 21:59different parts of the church, and that's what
- 22:03they did. So we're able to come to a resolution
- 22:05by overcoming the fixed pie bias. So let's go
- 22:07to the next slide here. vividness bias. That
- 22:13is paying too much attention to vivid features
- 22:17while focusing less attention on less vivid features.
- 22:21So what do I mean by that? So in most cases,
- 22:27and also I'm going to go back to one thing I
- 22:29want to mention really quickly about the fixed
- 22:32pie bias. And this is the same truth for the
- 22:33vividness bias. There are a whole heck of a lot
- 22:36of cases where it is just money and that's it.
- 22:39And, you know, I know that, you know that, we
- 22:42all know that. You know, a lot of times it's
- 22:44just a payment of money, but a lot of times it's
- 22:47not. Especially, I see that in the employment
- 22:50cases that I do. I see a lot of, you know, here's
- 22:55this employee that's worked for this small business
- 22:58for 25 years who is now suing this small business.
- 23:03On a wage an hour claim or something like that
- 23:05the small business is like hey I employed this
- 23:07person for a long time and they're suing me because
- 23:10I didn't properly notate their lunch and then
- 23:14the person that's Suing them the employees like
- 23:17hey, I worked for these guys for 30 years and
- 23:19they never gave me time to eat lunch I mean these
- 23:21are very emotional types of situations that You
- 23:27can't just be focused on the money. You have
- 23:29to focus on other things in order to get them
- 23:32properly resolved and look at the emotions and
- 23:34let people vent them. So anyway, what is vividness
- 23:38bias? That's paying too close attention to vivid
- 23:41features. And I'm going to give you an example
- 23:44so you can know what vividness bias is. It's
- 23:47the Aton Pats case. a lot of you probably people
- 23:51that are like my age i'm in my 50s i was in prime
- 23:54time when the aton pat's case came about it affected
- 23:57my childhood and i think it affected especially
- 24:00more in new york city it affected their people's
- 24:02childhood he was a kid six -year -old kid cute
- 24:06little blonde -headed kid uh that was uh lived
- 24:11in Soho in New York City and walked to the school
- 24:14bus every day. All of a sudden, one day, he disappears
- 24:18when walking to the school bus. Kid is abducted,
- 24:22never seen from again, and that's it. All over
- 24:26the news, wall -to -wall coverage of this kid,
- 24:29all over the place. Because of this situation
- 24:32when I was growing up if you sat down for breakfast
- 24:36and had milk in your cereal You would look at
- 24:39a milk carton and there would be picture of an
- 24:41abducted kid. It was talked about a lot There
- 24:44were seminars for parents on it. It was a major
- 24:48thing and kids moved further away from free range
- 24:55childhood to going to events that were supervised
- 24:59and everything, you know, there were more helicopter
- 25:01parents, you know, watching the children and
- 25:05it wasn't like play until the lights go out.
- 25:07Like when I was until I got to about 10 or 11
- 25:09years old, it was more of go to practice and
- 25:12have a supervising adult that's being paid to
- 25:16watch you while you're there. Those kinds of
- 25:18things changed. in a lot was because of the Aton
- 25:20Pats case. The problem with the Aton Pats case
- 25:24and the problem on the laser beam vividness,
- 25:28the laser beam focus on this one particular case
- 25:31is child abductions by strangers are extremely
- 25:37rare in the United States. They are very rare
- 25:40back in those days, and they're very rare today.
- 25:43I'm not saying it doesn't happen, and it happens
- 25:45a bit, but it's not a widespread problem all
- 25:49over the country that happens all the time, and
- 25:52people were very vivid, people were very focused
- 25:54on this case, and it clouded their rational decision
- 25:58-making. Parents were very clouded by their rational
- 26:01decision -making. This happens in court. a lot.
- 26:05And good litigators know this. And that's why
- 26:08they depose a lot of witnesses. Sometimes it's
- 26:10to get information. It's always to get some information.
- 26:13But a lot of times it's to see demeanor. It's
- 26:15to see how good this witness is going to play
- 26:17in court. Because like I said here, an example
- 26:20of the vividness bias, of course, is the jury
- 26:23is going to be swayed by an emotional victim.
- 26:26The jury will be very swayed by an emotional
- 26:28victim rather than by the dry forensic evidence.
- 26:31If I put a forensic accountant on the stand to
- 26:35ask him a bunch of questions about check about
- 26:37what happens in the checkbook. It's not as convincing
- 26:40as the vividness of that emotional victim. When
- 26:43we negotiate with people to resolve our cases,
- 26:46we can't be focused on the vividness. We have
- 26:49to be rational in our decision making process.
- 26:51Let's go to the next slide. OK, next slide here.
- 26:58Non -rational escalation of commitment. What
- 27:01is non -rational escalation of commitment? What
- 27:03are the steps to that? You make an initial investment.
- 27:08You get negative feedback, but rather than when
- 27:11you get that negative feedback, you escalate.
- 27:14You don't pull out. You continue to escalate
- 27:16and it is completely non -rational, but it is
- 27:20done all of the time. Let's go to the next slide
- 27:23here. What are some example the best example
- 27:27of non -rational escalation of commitment is
- 27:29gambling You go to the casino And you sit down
- 27:34at the $10 blackjack table Make your first bet
- 27:38You lose next make your next bet dealer comes
- 27:42up with 21. You'll lose again make a third bet
- 27:44You lose again. So now you've bet three $10 hands.
- 27:48You've lost all three $10 hands. What do you
- 27:51do? Smart person the rational person would walk
- 27:54away from the blackjack table the non rational
- 27:59person Which is listen. I'm gonna tell you right
- 28:02now. I own a house. It's a nice house Don't own
- 28:05a whole big massive building like the MGM Grand.
- 28:08There is a reason why they own it and it's because
- 28:10of non rational escalation of Commitment what
- 28:14most people do with a lot of people would do
- 28:17after losing those three $10 blackjack hands
- 28:19is oh I'm gonna bet $30 and get my money back
- 28:23That's how you lose. That's non -rational escalation
- 28:26of commitment. It happens in business projects
- 28:29quite a bit. People put more money into a real
- 28:32estate deal when it looks like it's going down
- 28:36rather than when it's going up because they want
- 28:38to double down on what they believe in. It happens
- 28:41in war of course. It happens at the negotiation
- 28:44table obviously. It happens a lot in personal
- 28:47relationships. I don't know how many people here
- 28:53are family law litigators. But if you are a family
- 28:57law litigator, you have seen, especially if you're
- 29:00doing, obviously, mostly if you're doing divorce
- 29:02or child custody things, you have seen where
- 29:04there is abuse in a family law situation. And
- 29:09for many years, rather than leave a person who
- 29:11is abusing their spouse, the spouse stays and
- 29:15escalates. They say, oh, He's just abusing me
- 29:19because I'm not doing X, Y or Z, right? I'm going
- 29:21to double down on that. And that's non rational
- 29:26escalation of commitment. It's a bias that we
- 29:29that most of us have. We have to recognize it.
- 29:32Next one, please. Susceptibility to framing.
- 29:40People are influenced by tone. People are, people
- 29:49are influenced by the way you say things to them,
- 29:52not necessarily by what you say. I have learned,
- 29:55I have three daughters and I've learned this
- 29:57a lot with my kids, the way to lay things out,
- 29:59the way to frame a situation in order to avoid
- 30:04dispute and to get compliance. People tend to
- 30:09avoid losses. more strongly than they seek gains.
- 30:14People are more loss -averse than they are to
- 30:18seeking the gain. People rely on these types
- 30:22of mental shortcuts rather than analyzing the
- 30:24data. People will make snap decisions rather
- 30:27than analyze the data. Let's go to the next slide.
- 30:34What are some good examples of susceptibility
- 30:36to framing? The offer discount. If I'm going
- 30:40to give you 10 % off, it's more appealing than
- 30:43if I'm going to charge you a surcharge of 10%,
- 30:45obviously, right? It's going to be the same price.
- 30:51It doesn't matter. It's the same price. But the
- 30:54way I frame it makes a difference. A hamburger
- 30:58is 75 % more lean. Sounds a lot better than a
- 31:02hamburger has 25 % fat. Uh, susceptibility to
- 31:07framing. I'm going to give another example. This
- 31:08is the case I mediated last week. Uh, it was
- 31:11a fee dispute, uh, for an attorney that filed
- 31:14suit against her former client family law case.
- 31:18Uh, this attorney did not have good documentation.
- 31:24She did not have a, uh, Assigned fee agreement.
- 31:28There were a lot of problems with this case.
- 31:29She didn't have a signed fee agreement She had
- 31:31a fee agreement, but there was no she couldn't
- 31:33find the signature the signed copy the other
- 31:35side claimed There was no signed fee agreement.
- 31:38She waited too long. It was within the statute
- 31:40of limitations Maybe if you use that kovat exception
- 31:44to stay in litigation, but it was maybe not There
- 31:48were a lot of problems with this person's case,
- 31:50but that family law attorney had done a heck
- 31:52of a lot of work For the client and the client
- 31:56owed her a chunk of money, right? The family
- 32:00law attorney, first of all, let's talk about
- 32:03how the defense attorney operated. The family
- 32:06law attorney framed the case as she was owed
- 32:09$50 ,000. She wasn't owed, this is a small case.
- 32:12She wasn't owed $50 ,000. The defense attorney
- 32:16framed it as, hey, Not only do does my client
- 32:21not owe you that much money. You don't have a
- 32:23fee agreement I'm gonna go to trial and win on
- 32:26the merits because you don't have a fee agreement
- 32:28and your problem and you may even be outside
- 32:30of the statute of limitations But I'm gonna win
- 32:31on the merits I'm gonna win on the fact that
- 32:33you don't have the written fee agreement and
- 32:35after I went on the merits the defense counsel
- 32:37said I'm gonna sue you for malicious prosecution
- 32:40so the Susceptibility to framing in this case
- 32:46was hey attorney that thinks they're owed all
- 32:50this money, not only are you not owed all this
- 32:52money, you're going to be sued for malicious
- 32:55prosecution. And at the end of the day, the case,
- 32:58they ended up paying a little bit of money to
- 33:00that attorney. And I felt bad for her because
- 33:02hey, listen, I'm a lawyer. I want to see other
- 33:04lawyers get paid for their services, but you
- 33:07have to dot your eyes and cross your keys and
- 33:09do the right thing or else you may not get paid.
- 33:12And it was upsetting. It was an upsetting situation
- 33:14because I really liked her and I really wanted
- 33:16to see her get paid. But it was not something
- 33:19that also she was afraid that she was going to
- 33:22get sued. And she was probably rightly afraid
- 33:24because I do think this defense counsel was going
- 33:26to do it. So anyway, let's move on to the next
- 33:28slide. Motivational biases. OK, so we talked
- 33:33about cultural bias. We talked about cognitive
- 33:36biases, which are biases of the mind. Let's talk
- 33:39about motivational biases. These are biases of
- 33:43the heart. These are things that we do. emotionally
- 33:48to see things through, not necessarily things
- 33:51that we do in our mind, but things that we do
- 33:53through emotions. The types of motivational biases
- 33:57that I'm gonna focus on are conflicting motivations,
- 34:01egocentrism, optimism bias, self -serving attributions,
- 34:07and what's called regret aversion. Okay, let's
- 34:09move on to the next slide. Okay. Conflicting
- 34:16motivations, short -term versus long -term. What
- 34:18does that mean? Of course, that's I want to eat
- 34:21a piece of cake today, but also I'm trying to
- 34:24lose weight. Those are conflicting motivations.
- 34:28Self -interest versus fairness. When I was an
- 34:31attorney and I represented clients, I... Was
- 34:36aggressive and stealth and I was very focused
- 34:39on the interest of my content zealously representing
- 34:41my clients But I also wanted the deal to be fair.
- 34:43I wasn't trying to do anything unethical I wanted
- 34:46to make sure it was a fair deal and those are
- 34:49conflicting. Those are conflicting motivations
- 34:52that I had Today obviously I Aggressively represent
- 34:57the deal. I want to see the deal happen, but
- 35:00that's not what I did back in those days Avoiding
- 35:04conflict versus expressing truth. A lot of reasons
- 35:08why we end up in litigation to begin with is
- 35:12because people avoid conflict early on. When
- 35:17the conflict arises, they don't express truth.
- 35:21They just continue to avoid conflict. And then
- 35:24eventually it all boils over. It goes to a crescendo
- 35:27and they have to file suit and then they're willing
- 35:30to talk. their truth and I spend a tremendous
- 35:33amount of time with people in my mediations saying
- 35:38hey you need to say this not in an unkind manner
- 35:41not in in a way to insult someone but you need
- 35:46to say it in a way that tells the truth of what
- 35:49the way you see things and stop avoiding the
- 35:51conflict to move forward compliance versus autonomy
- 35:55that's another conflicting motivation I see this
- 35:58a lot with my kids I got I have three teenage
- 36:01daughters in my house. They're good girls and
- 36:04they want to be compliant with things, but they
- 36:07also want to do their own thing. They want to
- 36:08be autonomous. That's a conflicting motivation
- 36:11that I see all the time with them. And then of
- 36:13course with security versus opportunity. That's
- 36:19the old thing of do I stay in the secure job?
- 36:22I'm making enough money. I'm getting by I'm able
- 36:25to pay my mortgage. I'm doing okay I don't have
- 36:27fun at work. I'm not ever gonna get that big
- 36:30payday, but I'm okay I'm not necessarily happy,
- 36:33but I'm doing alright versus that opportunity
- 36:35out there. It's a big risk You may totally lose
- 36:38everything it may not be worth it, but it may
- 36:41be a great thing Those are conflicting motivations.
- 36:44Let's go to the next slide Of course, we all
- 36:51know what egocentrism is. That's when we're focused
- 36:55on our own perspective and I have a difficulty
- 36:58understanding the views of others. I'm so focused
- 37:01on my own perspective that I can't see how to
- 37:08deal with things directly. Let's go to the next
- 37:10slide. How does egocentrism cause problems in
- 37:16negotiation? biased fairness perceptions. I think
- 37:20what's best for me is fair. And it may not be
- 37:25best for you. And that's gonna cause a big problem
- 37:27in negotiation. It's gonna prevent a settlement.
- 37:30Overestimating how clearly we communicate. There's
- 37:33a lot of people that are egocentric people that
- 37:36think they said it and the other person totally
- 37:39should understand it because there's no other
- 37:40way for them not to understand it because I said
- 37:43it correctly. That's egocentrism. Communication,
- 37:48if we're not communicating clearly and the other
- 37:51side doesn't understand what we're talking about,
- 37:53we're not going to settle the case. Misinterpreting
- 37:56other people's behavior. With egocentrism...
- 37:59Think everything that you do has something to
- 38:02do with me if you don't respond to me when I
- 38:06ask you a question It's because you are being
- 38:08rude to me It's not because you have seven other
- 38:11things going on in your life that you have to
- 38:14deal with Right now and it has nothing to do
- 38:16with me. Most things don't have anything to do
- 38:20with Lee Mendelson That's egocentrism. I have
- 38:23to get over that to know that and move forward
- 38:26Failure to anticipate reactions. If I'm egocentric
- 38:29and I'm focused on the way I think about things
- 38:32all the time, I'm not going to see your reactions
- 38:35to things. I'm not going to understand the way
- 38:37you react to things because I'm only focused
- 38:40about it through my lens, which is going to I'm
- 38:43not going to be able to settle the case. Let's
- 38:44move on to the next slide. Optimism bias. This
- 38:52is where I think. Good things are more likely
- 38:55to happen to me and bad things are less likely
- 38:58to happen to me. If I have the optimism bias,
- 39:02which in a lot of ways, I am a pretty optimistic
- 39:05person and I don't think that's a bad thing overall.
- 39:08But if I do have the optimism bias, I'm going
- 39:12to be okay. If I do have the optimism bias, I
- 39:20am something popped up on my screen. I apologize.
- 39:22If I do have the optimism bias, uh, I'm going
- 39:26to be, I'm going to have an illusion of superiority.
- 39:29I'm going to be overconfident because I am so
- 39:32optimistic things have to go my way. And if I'm
- 39:35overconfident, I, I I'm going to not, I'm going
- 39:37to miss the ball and I'm not going to see what
- 39:39happens. Let's, let's move on to the next thing.
- 39:43Self -serving attributions. That's when I believe
- 39:46everything goes right because of me, everything
- 39:49goes wrong because of you. And that's how we
- 39:52end up in a lot of litigation too because of
- 39:54that. Some of the, you know, I put on here some
- 39:56examples of self -serving attributions. And like
- 39:59I said, I have three daughters and I hear this.
- 40:00If I get an A on a test, it's because I studied
- 40:03hard. I worked so hard. That's why I got an A
- 40:05on a test. If I got an F on a test, That teacher's
- 40:08unfair. That teacher, he doesn't know what he's
- 40:11talking about. I can't believe he gave me an
- 40:12F. We see it the same way in court. You know,
- 40:17I had quite a few associates that have worked
- 40:19for me over the years When those associates came
- 40:21in and told me they want a motion for summary
- 40:24judgment, it's because they made a strong argument
- 40:26That's why they won the motion when those associates
- 40:29come in and tell me that the motion did not go
- 40:32their way That's because the judge was out to
- 40:35lunch man. That judge didn't know what he's talking
- 40:37about He didn't understand the issues that judge
- 40:39just doesn't like me. He likes the other person
- 40:42that judge was biased Those are self -serving
- 40:45attributions Okay, let's go to the next slide.
- 40:51Okay, regret aversion. That's when regret aversion
- 40:56is making a decision to avoid future regret rather
- 41:00than use rationality to make the decision. I
- 41:08cannot tell you how many times It's this is especially
- 41:13true when cases get sent to mediation when one
- 41:16of the parties does not want to mediate When
- 41:19cases get sent to mediation and one of the parties
- 41:21does not want to mediate a lot of times They're
- 41:23doing it because they think they're gonna settle
- 41:26the case too soon if they mediate now a Lot of
- 41:31people that don't settle the case because they
- 41:33think they settle the case to they're gonna settle
- 41:35the case too soon I've noticed this is more just
- 41:38my personal You know what I've noticed in life
- 41:42there. I don't have data for this This is just
- 41:44what I've noticed in life by talking to a lot
- 41:46of people that have When they decide not to settle
- 41:49a case because they think they're gonna settle
- 41:51it too soon They come back later and I helped
- 41:53them settle the case But I'm not able to get
- 41:54them as good of a deal as I would have gotten
- 41:57them earlier when they thought they were settling
- 41:59too soon This is regret aversion. You want to
- 42:03you want to avert you don't want to have to regret
- 42:06it later Basically, if I make this decision now,
- 42:09I'm going to regret it later. These are all biases
- 42:12that we've talked about here. These are all things
- 42:15that are blocking us from making rational decisions.
- 42:20How do we overcome these biases? How do we make
- 42:24rational decisions without being biased? That's
- 42:27what I'm going to talk about next. Let's move
- 42:28on to the next slide. How to avoid being biased.
- 42:33OK, we can move to the next slide after that.
- 42:36System one versus system two thinking. System
- 42:40one thinking. Those are gut reactions. Those
- 42:44are making quick decisions on the fly based on
- 42:47feeling. I'm going to tell you, probably for
- 42:50the first 10 years of my practice in law, maybe
- 42:53after the first couple of years I got used to
- 42:55it, a year or two I got used to it, and I thought,
- 42:58hey, Can make this I can look at any case I can
- 43:02make a quick decision I know where this case
- 43:05should settle. I don't need all this other information
- 43:08I just I can see it and I can make a decision
- 43:11quickly and Get it done. Those are gut reactions.
- 43:16Those are system one thinking Once I started
- 43:20studying negotiation and understanding the theories
- 43:23of negotiation. I realized I really need to become
- 43:26more of a system to thinker. I need to pause
- 43:29and reflect before I make a decision. I need
- 43:32to write out pros and cons. I need to use checklists
- 43:36and decision trees in order to make decisions.
- 43:39Sometimes I don't need to make that decision
- 43:41today. I need to sleep on it. I need to think
- 43:43it over. That's why a lot of times it seems like
- 43:46in mediations it's becoming more and more common
- 43:49that people want me to give them a mediator's
- 43:53proposal. the case, we argue, I listen to both
- 43:57sides, I see where they're going with the case,
- 43:59and then they ask me to give a proposal of how...
- 44:04I think the case should settle a lot of times.
- 44:06That's just so they can get a minute to think
- 44:09about it. They've already come. I, you know,
- 44:10I let people kind of know where we're going with
- 44:13the case and where if I do give a mediator's
- 44:15proposal about the way it's going to be, they
- 44:17understand that before I give the proposal, but
- 44:19they want a minute to sleep on it. And I think
- 44:21a lot of not always, sometimes you should make
- 44:23the decision today. A lot of times you should,
- 44:25but there's also a good amount of times where
- 44:27you need to sleep on it. You need to think about
- 44:28it. This is system to thinking. Let's move on
- 44:32to the next slide. The pre -negotiation analysis.
- 44:38This is crucial in negotiation. You must prepare
- 44:43prior to a negotiation. If you want to get to
- 44:48a good result, if you want to not be biased during
- 44:52the course of the negotiation, if you want to
- 44:54not let these biases, this emotion, these cognitive
- 44:58quick Decision biases affect you during the course
- 45:02of negotiation. You need to do proper pre -negotiation
- 45:05analysis There's a five -step program to pre
- 45:08-negotiation analysis that I'm I teach this in
- 45:11my course and I'll go on and on about it for
- 45:14at least Two hours, but I'm gonna do this In
- 45:19about five minutes, okay assess What's called
- 45:22your BATNA? What is your best alternative to
- 45:26a negotiation agreement? What would you do if
- 45:28you don't reach an agreement in your negotiation?
- 45:32That's your BATNA. Then you have to assess. You
- 45:35have to determine what's called your reservation
- 45:38value. What is your walk away point? Your walk
- 45:43away point is not your BATNA. It's not your best
- 45:46alternative to a negotiation dispute because
- 45:48you may want to walk away. Prior to going all
- 45:52the way to the best alternative you may want
- 45:55to walk away before that And that's your reservation
- 45:58value and you have to figure out where that's
- 45:59at then you want to look at Everything you want
- 46:04to look at all of the documents you want to look
- 46:07at all of the you know Deposition transcripts
- 46:12you want to look at all all the motions that
- 46:14have been filed You want to look at the pleadings
- 46:16and then you want to try to determine what is
- 46:19the other party's BATNA? What do you think the
- 46:22other party's best alternative to a negotiated
- 46:27agreement is going to be? After you've done that
- 46:32you wanted to determine what is the other party's
- 46:35reservation value how are they gonna walk away?
- 46:40When are they gonna walk away? What is the other
- 46:42party's walk away point? Which, like I said before,
- 46:45is almost never the same as the other party's
- 46:47bat nut. It's at a different scale. You might
- 46:51wanna walk, you generally wanna walk away before
- 46:54you reach your bat nut. And by looking at this,
- 46:57by analyzing this information, you're gonna come
- 47:00down to what... is the Zopa. What is the zone
- 47:04of possible agreement? The zone of possible agreement
- 47:07is that area between my reservation value and
- 47:12your reservation value. It's the area between
- 47:14my walk away point and your walk away point.
- 47:17Once you determine both sides walk away point
- 47:21from doing proper pre -negotiation analysis,
- 47:25you're ready to find the zone of possible agreement
- 47:28and then you want to bargain. in a way that the
- 47:32negotiation goes where you settle for something
- 47:36closest to their reservation value. You want
- 47:39to settle within the zone of possible agreement
- 47:41in a place that's closest to the reservation
- 47:44value, closest to the walk away point of the
- 47:47other party without letting them walk away, and
- 47:49that's how you get the best deal. Let's go to
- 47:51the next slide. Okay. We've done our pre negotiation
- 47:58analysis. We know the zone of possible agreement
- 48:01We're ready to go in there and get this case
- 48:04resolved I'm not gonna let bias go go in front
- 48:07of me because I'm being a rational person. I've
- 48:09thought this through I'm in the negotiation,
- 48:13and the other side starts bringing up things
- 48:15that I've never heard of before. This always
- 48:17happens. Not always. This happens 75 % of the
- 48:20time in mediations, it seems like. Something
- 48:22comes up at the other side. I never heard of
- 48:24that before. They may have heard of it, but it
- 48:26wasn't on top of their head. I've never heard
- 48:28of that before. How do I deal with that? When
- 48:30that happens, you have to, you know, the old
- 48:32thing with Reagan and Gorbachev, trust but verify.
- 48:38You look ... When somebody gives you information
- 48:41that you haven't heard before during the course
- 48:43of the negotiation, you want to see the documentation.
- 48:46That's always my first question. If there is
- 48:48documentation, you want to see where they're
- 48:50coming from and you want to understand it. You
- 48:52want to listen to the other side in a negotiation
- 48:56like a therapist. I've read a lot of books on
- 49:00therapy and how therapists operate, and I highly
- 49:03recommend that you do the same. You want to there's
- 49:06a great one called Oh, what's it called? I'll
- 49:12find it's about disagreement is that is in the
- 49:15title. I'll find what it is, but difficult conversations.
- 49:18It's called difficult conversations. Great book.
- 49:21You need to listen like a therapist. You want
- 49:23to hear the other person you want to be able
- 49:26to. not talk so much. You want to listen. You
- 49:31want to pay attention to what they're telling
- 49:32you and what they are not telling you, where
- 49:35they are coming from. Find out what they're,
- 49:38is this person overconfident? Is this person
- 49:41egocentric? Have these biases that we talked
- 49:43about written in front of you while you listen
- 49:46to what these people are saying and say, oh,
- 49:49this guy, he's very he's afraid of regret. That's
- 49:56what he's going to base his decision -making
- 49:58on, is he's afraid of regret. You'll understand
- 50:00the other side. You listen like a therapist.
- 50:03And as you do this, as you're in... the process
- 50:07and this is the difficult part this is the art
- 50:09of negotiation before when i'm talking about
- 50:12pre -negotiation analysis that's a science the
- 50:15art is being able to re -evaluate your pre -negotiation
- 50:20analysis during the course of the negotiation
- 50:23during the course of the negotiation you want
- 50:26to see maybe that person has a different reservation
- 50:30value than i thought it was in that and if they
- 50:32do You may be able to get a much better or much
- 50:35worse agreement today than you thought you would.
- 50:39And your zone of possible agreement may grow
- 50:42or it may shrink. And if you do think that the
- 50:48reservation value on the other side has changed
- 50:50a lot during the course of a negotiation, that's
- 50:53where you're going to want to rely on that system
- 50:54to thinking. And you might want to take a day
- 50:57and think it over before you make a decision.
- 51:00Let's move on to the next slide. Scoring. Highly,
- 51:07highly recommend scoring. So let's go back to
- 51:11the church example where the two church parties
- 51:14were suing each other, where the corporation
- 51:15from the church was suing the entity, the people
- 51:22that actually owned the church building. they
- 51:25were just talking about money and that's all
- 51:27they came in there talking about right and it
- 51:29took me a very long time to get away from money
- 51:31but if they would have looked at what they were
- 51:32actually interested in and scored it given a
- 51:36number value from one to a hundred on their interest
- 51:39they would have realized that owning their own
- 51:42church property was a high place to score but
- 51:46the biggest place to score may have been having
- 51:48a place to have worship services not necessarily
- 51:51owning a place And actually getting money back
- 51:54in their pocket was pretty low down because just
- 51:56getting the money back in their pocket would
- 51:58not have allowed them to have a place to have
- 52:00their church services. So that was actually a
- 52:03lower place on the scoring scale. My oldest daughter
- 52:06just applied for colleges. And when she applied
- 52:09for colleges and she was making her college decision,
- 52:12I recommended that she use the scoring scale
- 52:14for different aspects. You know, what how is
- 52:16the location of the college? What do they teach
- 52:19the kind of stuff you're willing you want to
- 52:21learn about? They teach it in a way that you
- 52:23want to learn it. Score those things to make
- 52:26your decision. After you've scored those things
- 52:28and you're in a negotiation, you can use that
- 52:30score to calculate your BATNA and your reservation
- 52:33value. And you can use it to try to score the
- 52:35other sides. So let's go to the next slide. How
- 52:40to utilize the bias of the other side. We've
- 52:44talked about that quite a bit. Well, let's talk
- 52:46about that a little more. One thing is framing.
- 52:49This is huge, OK? How do you make your first
- 52:55offer now I do a lot of personal injury cases
- 52:58and in those personal injury cases, I'll talk
- 53:02to the plaintiffs attorney and I'll talk to the
- 53:05plaintiff and we'll do the we'll try to get an
- 53:10offer from them and 8 out of 10 times the initial
- 53:16offer is whatever the insurance policy limit
- 53:19is for the defendant. If the defendant has a
- 53:21$5 million insurance policy, that's the offer
- 53:23from the plaintiff. It's not always, that's the
- 53:25initial demand from the plaintiff. Why? They
- 53:27want to anchor the case. They want to put it
- 53:30at a certain number value in order to resolve
- 53:35it. They want to start high. I had a case not
- 53:39too long ago. Well, I'll tell you, even that
- 53:42attorney fee case that they didn't get a good
- 53:44settlement for, but she tried to anchor it at
- 53:46like $50 ,000 when she was probably only owed
- 53:49about $15 ,000 to be truthful. This was a small
- 53:53case I was doing as a volunteer, but it was a
- 53:56good one. It was interesting. So anyway, she
- 53:59tried to anchor it high. She didn't succeed,
- 54:00but a lot of times when you make your anchor
- 54:02and you anchor it in a specific spot, you can
- 54:07negotiate. bite case not too long ago where in
- 54:12the dog bite case the plaintiff anchored very
- 54:15high. They made a first offer that was very high.
- 54:18And I have to tell you, I was very surprised
- 54:20that the defense came to the table and made it.
- 54:24Once they heard that demand, they came to the
- 54:25table at a much higher first offer from the defense
- 54:27than I would have expected that they that they
- 54:30were going to get. Another way to frame things
- 54:33is based on loss aversion. You know, we talked
- 54:36about this a lot earlier about how people, you
- 54:42know, are more afraid of loss than they are of
- 54:46getting, they're more afraid of loss than they
- 54:49are excited about getting gain. And if you frame
- 54:53your offer in the in a way of loss aversion like
- 54:56the defense counsel did in the attorney's fees
- 54:58case the defense counsel said hey attorney that
- 55:01you're suing your former client But you don't
- 55:04have a fee agreement for your former client.
- 55:05Not only am I gonna win on the merits. I'm going
- 55:08to Sue you for malicious prosecution Afterwards
- 55:12and you're gonna end up paying my client a lot
- 55:14of money because of that They framed it in a
- 55:17way of loss aversion which In that case it was
- 55:21ethical It was it was smart and they were able
- 55:25to get a good deal because of it. Let's go on
- 55:27to the next slide here. We're getting close to
- 55:29time, but I'm going to zip through these last
- 55:31two slides. Ego centrism. You want to validate
- 55:38the other's perspective. If somebody after you've
- 55:42listened to them, listen, listen, listen. Can't
- 55:45see there's two things that if you get anything
- 55:47out of this today I want to say I want you to
- 55:49hear prepare prepare prepare prior to a negotiation
- 55:54and then once you're in a negotiation Listen
- 55:56listen listen and listen for that person's egocentrism
- 56:01Where are they egocentric and you want to validate
- 56:05their perspective you want to validate what they
- 56:08say? Everybody wants to be heard everybody wants
- 56:11to be validated. It's a incredibly important
- 56:15for folks, especially in more emotional types
- 56:19of negotiations. In employment law, it's really
- 56:23important to validate the other person's perspective
- 56:27and understand it. And then from there, once
- 56:31their perspective is validated, they're usually
- 56:33willing to come to the table to talk to you.
- 56:36And I put in here, you know, I understand that
- 56:40you want X, but here's my offer. that can make
- 56:43that happen. And it may not happen in the same
- 56:45way that you want X, but I can try to make it
- 56:48happen for you. And then the last thing that
- 56:53I'll talk about here is optimism bias. So everybody
- 57:01wants to feel like they're the winner. Everybody
- 57:05wants to win. And there's a lot of people They
- 57:08come into negotiation. This is especially a lot
- 57:11of people that are not sophisticated Most people
- 57:14that are unsophisticated negotiators. Most people
- 57:16that are not as sophisticated litigators are
- 57:18focused on winning Let them feel like they want
- 57:23let the other guy feel like you want as long
- 57:25as my interests are met I'm happy and a lot of
- 57:30times I can let them feel like they win and give
- 57:32them that and I get all my interests met, I'm
- 57:35ready to go home. So to keep my perspective,
- 57:38to know what my interests are, to write them
- 57:41out, to know what my pros and cons are, and then
- 57:45try to get those interests while letting the
- 57:49other side feel validated and feel like they
- 57:51won, I'm able to get my interests met and I'm
- 57:54able to move on with life. Okay, that's all I
- 57:58got. I don't know if there's time for questions
- 58:00or if there are any questions here. Are we still
- 58:05here? Yeah. Yes, we're still here. It looks like
- 58:09we have a couple questions. Shouldn't be too
- 58:11much time. We have one from Ashley McCurchin
- 58:15asking, do you recall the name of the book or
- 58:18author recommended earlier when you were discussing
- 58:20cognitive bias? It's a female author. Oh, cultural
- 58:25bias? Cognitive is what the askers are going
- 58:30to buy us a great book for cognitive bias is
- 58:33negotiation genius. There's also a great it's
- 58:37called negotiation genius. It's from a Harvard
- 58:39Law School. Perfect sure actually sitting on
- 58:41my desk here. Max Baser back Max Bazerman. That's
- 58:45a great book for cognitive bias. Looks like somebody's
- 58:51asking about reservation value is reservation
- 58:54value essentially the thing they most want to
- 58:56avoid. that would make them walk away from the
- 58:59deal? If not, can you help? Okay, it's not necessarily,
- 59:02it's just your walk away point reservation value.
- 59:06It's like, okay, my best alternative to winning
- 59:11at litigation, sometimes my best alternative
- 59:13is to continue, my best alternative to negotiated
- 59:16agreement is to just continue the litigation,
- 59:19right? But, That's my best alternative. But my
- 59:22reservation value might be, hey, I'll walk away
- 59:25if I get $100 ,000 on this case. I'm not going
- 59:28to be happy. It's not what my client wants. It's
- 59:30not what I want. But it makes a heck of a lot
- 59:32more sense than spending all the money on this
- 59:35litigation. So my walk away point is the reservation
- 59:38value. That's the reservation value. I hope that
- 59:41makes sense to you. Also, can you tell us about
- 59:44the class you teach and where we can find it?
- 59:46I teach at Pepperdine Law School. It's in the
- 59:52Dispute Resolution Straus Center for Dispute
- 59:55Resolution, and it is a part of the LLM and law
- 1:00:01school curriculum. A lot of students actually
- 1:00:06from the business school take it too. So if you're
- 1:00:09enrolled in Pepperdine, I'm pretty sure you can
- 1:00:11enroll in my course. And the book for cultural
- 1:00:14bias is The Culture Map by Aaron Meyer. And somebody
- 1:00:22asked how long I volunteered as a mediator before
- 1:00:24I became one. I think it's all, listen, that's
- 1:00:30a little bit outside of the subject, but I'll
- 1:00:31tell you. In my estimation in life, Volunteer.
- 1:00:37Get out there and do everything you can do to
- 1:00:40get the experience for what you want to be. And
- 1:00:42then people will eventually see, hey, this person
- 1:00:44is what they say they are. They have learned
- 1:00:46what they can do. And also, I'm a strong, I still
- 1:00:51volunteer. Like I was talking about that attorney
- 1:00:53fee case. I mean, I got paid on it, but not a
- 1:00:55lot. It was kind of through a volunteer program.
- 1:00:58And it was like a volunteer with a small payment
- 1:01:00kind of a program on that attorney's fee case.
- 1:01:03And it was... I get a lot out of that. I feel
- 1:01:07good about it. And I'm going to mention this
- 1:01:10since we're talking for the Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:01:11Association today and I'll wrap it up. They have
- 1:01:14a great volunteer program that you can volunteer
- 1:01:17for if you want to learn how to be a mediator.
- 1:01:19I think they do the mediation training and they
- 1:01:22also have a great program and most of that is
- 1:01:26on attorney fee agreements from what I understand.
- 1:01:28But anyway, thank you so much. I appreciate everybody
- 1:01:31being here today and That's all I got. I can
- 1:01:35be reached at ADR services if anybody ever needs
- 1:01:37me. If you have any questions, you can look me
- 1:01:40up on the ADR services website. I'm happy to
- 1:01:43answer any questions or talk to anybody about
- 1:01:45the stuff. I love it. So anyway, take care. Thank
- 1:01:48you so much. You may be eligible for CLE credit
- 1:01:52in your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts
- 1:01:56for more information.