Latest / Drop Ship Lifestyle Podcast / My Thoughts on Shopify Collective for Dropshipping
Transcript
- 0:00What's up everybody, Anton Crowley here and welcome back to
- 0:03Wednesday Night in the piano school parking lot, also known
- 0:07as the Dropship Lifestyle Podcast.
- 0:10Now, this is the third week I'm recording one of these episodes
- 0:13here. So definitely seems like it's
- 0:15becoming a habit. So I think it is safe to say
- 0:17that as long as my son stays in piano school, you will keep
- 0:21getting Wednesday night episodes.
- 0:23And it's also a good day for me to to record these, not just
- 0:27because I'm sitting in my car for 30 minutes or so, but also
- 0:30because Wednesdays are pretty much like a stacked day for me
- 0:35the way I schedule my week. So Friday is I pretty much
- 0:38always have nothing scheduled. If I need to work, of course I
- 0:41can, but I like to have that day with literally 0 on the
- 0:44calendar. So, you know, don't need to
- 0:47worry about doing anything specific.
- 0:49I can have a longer weekend, I can go away for the weekend.
- 0:52I can have that day anyway, with that being said, today being a
- 0:57busy day, it is the day of the month that I do our members
- 1:01coaching calls for dropship lifestyle.
- 1:03If you remember, hopefully you were there.
- 1:05We always get a good crowd, but basically I go live in Discord
- 1:10for anywhere between, you know, could be an hour and a half, it
- 1:13could be they've been up to four hours and basically I answer
- 1:16every question. I, you know, share my screen,
- 1:18try to help everybody move forward.
- 1:20But on that call today, somebody mentioned that they were in the
- 1:25supplier outreach stage of drop ship Lifestyle X and they had
- 1:30secured a couple suppliers the way I recommend, which is a
- 1:33direct relationship you call them, become an authorized
- 1:36retailer, get their products information, get it uploaded to
- 1:39your store, etcetera, etcetera. And they had done that, but then
- 1:42they also started picking up suppliers through collective and
- 1:46they wanted to know my thoughts on that.
- 1:48And I definitely have thoughts, so share that them obviously
- 1:51with everyone on the call, but wanted to share some of them
- 1:54with you because maybe you, you know, weren't on the call or
- 1:57maybe for some crazy reason you are not a member of dropship
- 2:00lifestyle. And if you're not, I don't get
- 2:02why it's the fastest way you can get to success.
- 2:05But I wanted to give you again this little, you know, example
- 2:08or demonstration or thing that we talked about when it comes to
- 2:11Shopify collective. First off, I think it's worth
- 2:14mentioning some context like what is collective?
- 2:18Basically it's a, it's a really good idea Shopify had and the
- 2:22idea is that different brands that manufacture or import or
- 2:27private label products basically that have access to a product
- 2:31catalog that they control the inventory on.
- 2:33They can choose to have their brands on this Shopify app
- 2:37called Collective. And then other Shopify store
- 2:40owners, you know, retailers can basically request to sell the
- 2:45products from these brands. So if you're on the brand side
- 2:49of it, on Collective, you make a brand accounts, you list what
- 2:54products you will let other people sell.
- 2:56You put the product images, the product name, the product
- 2:59descriptions, the shipping information, and you also put
- 3:02the price that the retailer should sell at and you put the
- 3:07profit margin that they'll make whatever they sell.
- 3:09And then if you're the retailer, you log into the Shopify
- 3:13collected app as a retailer, I should say, on the retail side,
- 3:16you can search for whatever your niche is or whatever you want to
- 3:19sell. You could find all of the brands
- 3:21that are available. You can basically, you know,
- 3:24request to sell their products, They authorize you and then you
- 3:27click a button and you import whatever products you want to
- 3:30sell from them onto your store. When they sell, the order goes
- 3:34straight to that supplier, AKA brand.
- 3:36It's drop shipping, they ship it to your customer, you make the
- 3:39margin. They told you you were going to
- 3:40make an advance, right? So sounds good, right?
- 3:42Makes life easy. And again, it is a good idea,
- 3:46but there are many things that I've seen while working with
- 3:49obviously many different drop lifestyle members that I would
- 3:53call maybe red flags or things that you definitely should be
- 3:56aware of because collective, hopefully one day it gets to
- 3:59what it can be. But right now I'm not the
- 4:02biggest fan. So I'm going to walk you through
- 4:04a few different things again that I've seen within the past
- 4:07several months. Again, just being inside of tons
- 4:10of drop ship lifestyle member stores, some of which have
- 4:13worked with Collective. So the first thing that you
- 4:17know, really got me thinking about using this is or not using
- 4:21it, I should say is a member that I work with still.
- 4:25I was going to say I was working with, but I still work with him.
- 4:27He found a brand on collective again, did what I said, reached
- 4:32out, they said yes, you can sell our stuff, import all the
- 4:34products. You know, they automatically got
- 4:36sent over to Google Merchant Center.
- 4:38All good there started running ads for them.
- 4:41And then maybe a week or two weeks later, gets an e-mail, he
- 4:44gets an e-mail from Google Merchant Center saying his
- 4:47account was suspended. Obviously cause for concern went
- 4:50in. And the problem was that all of
- 4:52the products from that brand were no longer available, not
- 4:56just, you know, out of stock, but they were gone, that they
- 4:59didn't exist anymore. So then he went into collective
- 5:02and he saw a message for that brand that said something like
- 5:07this brand is no longer eligible for collective, meaning that the
- 5:11company he was selling for. So I don't know exactly what
- 5:14that means. I can only assume that they did
- 5:16something the brand did something against Shopify's
- 5:18policies where Shopify kicked them out of collective.
- 5:21And when that happened again on his side, the retailer side,
- 5:25everything was just removed from his store automatically.
- 5:28And he had an issue with Google when she did get resolved
- 5:30relatively quick, you know, maybe two or three days, but
- 5:33still it was like just shows when you don't even have control
- 5:36over your, your product because random products are being
- 5:38inserted and in this case removed, it can call cause
- 5:41issues. So that was the first thing
- 5:44like, OK, I really, I, I don't like that.
- 5:46And just so you know, I'm going to go through, I'm not talking
- 5:48yet, but just so you know, like the way it typically works with
- 5:52us, and I say typically like 99.9% of the time it works with
- 5:56us is we find the brands that we want to sell for, we find them
- 6:00online through Google. We go to those brands websites,
- 6:04we call them, have a very specific, you know, method of
- 6:08getting approved. But you know, we say what we
- 6:10say. They authorize us to sell their
- 6:12products, then they send us their product information,
- 6:14typically in a spreadsheet format.
- 6:16Then we import all those products to our store.
- 6:19We have full control over the product pages, shipping
- 6:21policies, basically everything. We have complete control over it
- 6:24and that's, you know, instantly resolves the issue of what
- 6:28happening to him happening to me or you because no one else has
- 6:32control over what products are on our store.
- 6:35So that's how we typically do it.
- 6:36So that was the first major red flag because again, luckily he
- 6:39got his account back within two or three days, but you know, I,
- 6:43I seen Google be finicky, so it could have been a lot worse.
- 6:46And again, this is one out of many, many brands he sells for.
- 6:49And if one brand that you know came and went within two to
- 6:52three weeks can ruin everything, that's that's a problem.
- 6:56Next thing that I really don't like about most of the brands on
- 6:59collective is the margins. So what we want when we become
- 7:03an authorized retailer to sell for different brands is we want
- 7:06to see map, which is minimum advertised price.
- 7:09This is what we typically list products for sale at.
- 7:12We want to see that be two X wholesale cost.
- 7:15So let's say I was selling, you know, rims for cars.
- 7:20If my wholesale price for a set of four rims was $1000, I would
- 7:24want MAP to be $2000, so I would sell it for 2000.
- 7:27My cost of goods sold is 1000 and that's what you typically
- 7:31will see when you become authorized to sell directly for
- 7:34brands. Now on collective, I have seen
- 7:37much more frequently the profit margin that they offer you be
- 7:4120% and 20% you can live with if that was after all your
- 7:46expenses, you know, cost of goods sold, shipping, credit
- 7:50card processing fee is advertising.
- 7:52But if it's 20% before any of that, it's just almost
- 7:56impossible to make things work with paid ads, you know, not a,
- 7:58it's not something I would want to do.
- 8:00Now, why are the margins so low with suppliers on Shopify
- 8:05collective? Well, in my opinion, it's
- 8:07actually, you know, for a really simple reason.
- 8:10Basically, it's what it sounds like Shopify collective is all
- 8:13internal to Shopify. So what you have to think about
- 8:16is how do they get those suppliers right on the brand
- 8:19side, not the retail side, but the brands.
- 8:21How is Shopify finding them and onboarding them to be a brand on
- 8:24collective? Well, they're looking at Shopify
- 8:27stores that already are doing, you know, a good amount of
- 8:30volume, of course, that have their own inventory.
- 8:33They invite them on to collective.
- 8:35And basically these are brands that already sell direct to
- 8:39consumer because they're already, you know, integrated
- 8:41with Shopify. And the brands from their
- 8:44perspective, the way they think about it is sure, we'll take on
- 8:47some retailers and give them 20% margin if they bring us extra
- 8:51sales, right, Their cost of customer acquisition might be
- 8:5320%. So for them, yeah, 20% fine.
- 8:56If it gets extra sales, great. If it doesn't, it doesn't.
- 8:59So those are the type of brands that you're going to see the
- 9:02vast majority of on collective. Whereas the brands you want are
- 9:06the ones that are, you know, not selling direct to the public.
- 9:09They're the ones that you can find their websites, contact
- 9:11them like I mentioned earlier, become an authorized retailer
- 9:14and they're the ones that give you good margins because the
- 9:16brands you really want to sell for are not the ones that are
- 9:19selling direct to the public, just looking for additional
- 9:21sales channels. The brands you really want are
- 9:24the ones that focus on making great products.
- 9:26They focus on logistics and they focus on distribution through
- 9:30partners like us, right, Like the stores.
- 9:32That's why we get good margins. So whereas collective, I feel
- 9:36like the brands there have it more of an afterthought.
- 9:39When you reach out directly, you're a sales channel for them,
- 9:42you're a partner, you get very solid margins.
- 9:44So that's probably the biggest reason that I'm not even close
- 9:48to anywhere all in on collective and something to be very
- 9:51cautious about if you do decide to source brands through there.
- 9:55And then finally again, still not done.
- 9:58One more thing that I saw that really bothered me with somebody
- 10:01I was working with that used collective is that they they
- 10:05basically, you know, reached out again to a brand, they got
- 10:08authorized through collective. They imported all their products
- 10:10and two weeks later they noticed that every product page they
- 10:14imported from this brand had multiple links on every product
- 10:19page in the description that linked straight to that brand's
- 10:23product pages where they were selling the same exact products.
- 10:25Again, this is because these aren't the type of brands we
- 10:28really want to sell for. These are the brands that are
- 10:30already selling direct to consumer.
- 10:32They're like, sure, we'll go on Shopify Collective, maybe get
- 10:34some more revenue, but they're using it.
- 10:37The brands on Collective again, not all of them, but the vast
- 10:39majority, they're using it as an additional sales channel rather
- 10:43than their primary distribution. So while I have seen, you know,
- 10:47some wins on collective, they are at this point what's today,
- 10:50it's April Fool's Day on April 1st, 2026.
- 10:53Those brands are far and few in between.
- 10:56I do hope that the ecosystem expands more overtime and just
- 11:01for simple ease of use, there are more legitimate brands that
- 11:04we actually want to sell for on there.
- 11:06But at this point, again, April 2026, it's not where you should
- 11:10be going to source your suppliers, at least not unless
- 11:14you, you know, check those three things I just mentioned.
- 11:16So anyway, just wanted to share that, give you a little taste of
- 11:20some of the things we discussed on our monthly members coaching
- 11:23calls. Again, if you're a member,
- 11:24hopefully you join us. They're the first Wednesday of
- 11:26every month at 2:00 PM Eastern. And if you're not a member yet,
- 11:29I don't know what you're waiting for.
- 11:30Best place to start is dropshiplifestyle.com/webinar.
- 11:34Again, dropshiplifestyle.com/webinar.
- 11:37I got a brand new one hour long training up there that goes deep
- 11:40into everything we do. And at the end I tell you how
- 11:42you can get started with us should you want to.
- 11:44So thank you all. Appreciate you and I'll talk to
- 11:46you next Wednesday night, if not sooner.
- 11:49See everybody?