Latest / Newcomer Pod / Vinod Khosla on the End of Jobs and the Future of Capitalism
Transcript
- 0:00I've never understood why rational people believe in God.
- 0:04It just makes no sense. I didn't sour on philanthropy.
- 0:09I soured on the efficiency with which philanthropy works.
- 0:13Are you going to go all in for AOC in the president?
- 0:16I I feel like you're much more of a Don't your fellow venture
- 0:18capitalists want to murder you over this?
- 0:20Is Vinod Khosla in 25 years a socialist?
- 0:24He called technology as religion before AI existed.
- 0:27Now he thinks it can deliver something no religion ever
- 0:29could. Material abundance for everyone
- 0:32on Earth. Today I'm talking to Vinod
- 0:34Khosla, founder of Khosla Ventures, one of the earliest
- 0:36VCs to bet on open AII. Couldn't get my head around why.
- 0:41He seems to. Support tons of liberal programs
- 0:43but hates AOC and Momdani. We're talking post capitalism,
- 0:48the Silicon Valley New Deal, and why this billionaire thinks a
- 0:51little differently from his friends in venture capital.
- 0:53I'm Eric, author of the newcomer Substack, where I write about
- 0:56startups and venture capital. Now let's get into it.
- 1:06I was looking at an old 2014 interview you did where you said
- 1:13technology is my religion. And I think that dates back.
- 1:16You know, I think that was a take you started cooking up
- 1:18maybe in the early 2000s, and now we live in this world of AI.
- 1:22Obviously, you were the first venture capital investor in AI.
- 1:25Feels like AI could create a religion of its own.
- 1:28Yet is technology still your religion?
- 1:31It is. And you know, I've since I was a
- 1:35little kid, I've had an opposition to religion because
- 1:38especially in India, it's about manipulating people to do do
- 1:46your bidding and really give you revenue.
- 1:50If I look at the Catholic Church, all the money collects
- 1:55from all over the developing world.
- 1:58It's just criminal in it goes into golden accompaniments in
- 2:06the Vatican. It's a poor use of money.
- 2:12When you look at technology, it has the ability to benefit
- 2:17humanity in a way no other technology does.
- 2:23If I look at where we are today, probably 10% of the global
- 2:27population has a rich lifestyle. And by rich, I mean rich in
- 2:32housing, rich in healthcare, rich in entertainment, rich in
- 2:36transportation, rich in education.
- 2:42If you get to 100% of the population, being rich and
- 2:47everything will destroy the planet.
- 2:50If you do it the way we've done it for the top 10%, ten times
- 2:54the number of cars, 10 times the number of amount of cement or
- 2:58steel or energy or everything else, the only solution that
- 3:05necessary, it's not sufficient. It's, it's necessary but not
- 3:09sufficient, is to have technology multiplied resources.
- 3:14And in fact, I've long believed that and said technology can
- 3:19help. And with the advent of AI, which
- 3:22was not really a thing when I first said this, it's become so
- 3:28real to me that the world can be such a different place in the
- 3:34next 25 years. By 2050, we can have a very
- 3:37different world. There's so much we're going to
- 3:40entangle, I think with this one idea, right?
- 3:42Because there's the piece of it that is improving quality of
- 3:46life, really the main thing we can sort of deliver to people.
- 3:49Because I think we're also in this crisis of meaning.
- 3:53There's the climate element, there's the how technology,
- 3:56what, what it's like, you know, to be a billionaire 100 years
- 4:01ago and whether that's better, you'd rather be alive today or,
- 4:04you know, the Super wealthy of 100 years ago.
- 4:06So there's so many pieces of it I want to get into, and we will
- 4:08get into just the first. When you say it like technology
- 4:12is a religion, you don't believe in God, right?
- 4:14I don't believe in God. Yeah, we share that.
- 4:15I, I grew up, my mom's partner was a Unitarian Universalist
- 4:20minister in Macon, GA So I was very much, you know, the liberal
- 4:24moms in the South arguing with people about, oh, there's no
- 4:27God. I literally in public school
- 4:29have teachers on the board trying to which I love trying to
- 4:32make arguments for, you know, religion because it was, you
- 4:35know, so I, I share that sort of, yeah, not not believing in
- 4:39God, but I think at the same time, there's this crisis of
- 4:43meaning in the country right now.
- 4:46Do you think technology in the technology industry can really
- 4:50like, give them, give the public sort of the meaning they crave
- 4:53and it's just like improving their quality of life the same
- 4:56thing as giving them an answer to this question?
- 4:58So those are very different questions, right?
- 5:02I I've never understood why rational people believe in God.
- 5:06It just makes no sense. I believe and admit there's some
- 5:10infinitesimally small probability God exists, but
- 5:14there's no proof. In fact all the proof is to the
- 5:18contrary. But you still have to allow for
- 5:21a probability that's very very low.
- 5:25But if you're rational, you believe in the highest
- 5:27probability things, which is no God exists because there's never
- 5:31been proof of God. Why do people believe in it?
- 5:35Because their brains have been programmed from age 3 or 4 to do
- 5:40this and this. So being religious is being
- 5:47programmed by an ecosystem. And so my world view is meaning
- 5:55shouldn't come from being programmed, then you're a slave
- 5:58to God and open to exploitation by religion as a surrogate for
- 6:04God. I'd rather say what are you?
- 6:10What are you programmed to do? And I won't go into the meaning
- 6:13of life, but. That is sort of what I'm getting
- 6:18at though, because I get certainly I agree with you, we
- 6:20shouldn't let me. Explain that a little
- 6:22differently. What should the brain brain be
- 6:27programmed to do? In the old world, there was
- 6:31religion. It was the only way to keep
- 6:35people under control. In fact, 500 years ago, you
- 6:39couldn't even get to a remote location, maybe by horseback.
- 6:44It took five days. You couldn't enforce any laws
- 6:49and so you had to have the fear of God in people as a law
- 6:52enforcement mechanism to be good.
- 6:56Otherwise God would punish you. So maybe it even served a really
- 6:59useful purpose a long time ago of law enforcement was the
- 7:05purpose of the fear of God. Today, and if I look at last 50
- 7:14years, what do we program kids with?
- 7:16We program kids with if you're 5, go to school, do your
- 7:21homework, do well, you go to college, you'll get a good job.
- 7:26So all of it is about income and supporting yourself.
- 7:32It's not about meaning. I think what changes
- 7:36dramatically, yeah, is for today's 5 year old child born
- 7:42today. I had a grandchild born 2 weeks
- 7:44ago. You.
- 7:47You had a grandchild. I had a Congratulations.
- 7:49I have a. Seven month old daughter.
- 7:51So I'm I'm new to this game not but it's it's an exciting time.
- 7:55It's amazing. It's very exciting, I.
- 7:56Mean meaning at the moment is reading a children's book like
- 7:59if you, if I had to ask directly, like what is meaning
- 8:01in your life? It is, even though she doesn't
- 8:03really understand it right now, just having her pay attention
- 8:06and reading a book with beautiful art and rhyme and
- 8:09human language. So that is different kind of
- 8:13meaning whether you're a human being or an animal.
- 8:20Looking after a young is just instinctive.
- 8:24Otherwise we wouldn't multiply as a species.
- 8:28So what will my grandchild, when they're 5, be programmed that
- 8:35hopefully to be human, to care about the things that today
- 8:41people don't have time for. Looking after their kids,
- 8:44looking after their grandparents, parents, the
- 8:48relationships that matter. I think that should be meaning
- 8:52striving to be whatever you want to be good at.
- 8:56And this could be pretty random. I want to be awesome at surfing.
- 8:59I want to be awesome at singing. I want to be awesome at
- 9:02painting. I want to be awesome.
- 9:04Are you? Are you?
- 9:05Post capitalist now because you're you're saying that the
- 9:08story recently was do all the right things, climb the ladder,
- 9:11get a great job. Now you're saying go surfing,
- 9:13spend time with your family? Like is this?
- 9:15Post I'm saying for the first time kids born now we'll be able
- 9:20to exercise freedom. Look at most of the jobs in this
- 9:25country today. They're not jobs.
- 9:29They're not meaningful jobs, even though people call them
- 9:32meaningful. If you're a farm worker in
- 9:34Salinas in 100° heat picking lettuce 8 hours a day for 30 or
- 9:4040 years and then don't have retirement income.
- 9:43So you depend on your kids. That's not jobs.
- 9:47If you're if you're assembly line worker at General Motors
- 9:50mounting a tire on a car for 8 hours a day for 30 or 40 years
- 9:54or till your back gives out, that's not job.
- 9:57That's servitude to survival. I think that's what it is.
- 10:01So do you think the American social contract, like if you're,
- 10:05I'm going to spend time with my kids and surf, should America
- 10:08provide you healthcare and and the basic standard of living?
- 10:12Or do you need to still find, even if it's just 10 hours a
- 10:16week, something that the economy says is meaningful?
- 10:21Well, first, in 25 years we can have great abundance so people
- 10:28don't have to strive for a living.
- 10:31They don't have to do everything so they can pay their mortgage
- 10:35or support their kids or feed their kids.
- 10:38And it's sad when you have to do that, but it's necessity today,
- 10:44an economic necessity that will go away.
- 10:47I think all goods will become abundant almost every level.
- 10:54You'll have so much abundance. Distribution won't be an issue.
- 10:59People will still be people. People love competing.
- 11:01So today it's I have a bigger house because I have a better
- 11:05job and I can do more. I think it'll be competing in
- 11:08the Olympics, It'll be competing in X Games or.
- 11:14You're saying that's where we'll get meaning or that's where
- 11:15we'll get money? That's where we really get
- 11:18meaning, because competing is a human trait, right?
- 11:23We will. Still need money to allocate
- 11:24like 0 sum resources like houses.
- 11:27Yes, there are few and housing is the one area that is the
- 11:31hardest to see how it's dramatically impacted.
- 11:35I could see the cost of housing going down by 20 or 30% and we
- 11:39we can go down that alley later. It's it's hard because it's so
- 11:44much physical goods. But will we have shortage of
- 11:47copper or lithium? No.
- 11:50So is Vinod Kosland, 25 years a socialist?
- 11:54I believe we will have so much abundance and depends on how you
- 11:59define socialism or capitalism. Socialism is not everybody
- 12:06shares equally. My personal view is everybody
- 12:11gets a best level of guaranteed lifestyle provided by the
- 12:17government and that's the socialist part.
- 12:20But then they can do more whether they choose to pursue
- 12:23more income or their passion and happens to generate income.
- 12:28I I don't think Beyoncé got into singing for making more money.
- 12:33She got in because she has a passion for for singing, but it
- 12:37also happens to generate money. So I do think people will
- 12:41follow. For the first time, kids born
- 12:44today will be free to follow their passion and be more human
- 12:49then they've been allowed to be in the face of economic
- 12:52pressures. I think that's the big
- 12:55liberation. AI will free humans to be humans
- 12:59and do what they come naturally, spend time with their kids,
- 13:02spend time to their parents, spend times on their passion I.
- 13:05Think there are a lot of people watching this that are going to
- 13:08say why not cash in now like we have a technological abundance
- 13:12today, you know, we could produce the food that we need.
- 13:15Why not sort of create the utopia today?
- 13:18Why is it always sort of, you know, a couple decades from?
- 13:20Now today, there's a distribution problem.
- 13:23OK, because goods aren't cheap, you know, there's no question in
- 13:31in a few years, even now, you could provide free primary care
- 13:36to every citizen in this country, in fact, every citizen
- 13:40of the planet, All billion and a half people in India could get
- 13:45free primary carefree. This is like a bridge.
- 13:48Open evidence you're you're saying use.
- 13:50AI Yeah, I'm, I'm saying AI doctors, not AI tools, tools are
- 13:55for humans to use. I think we are past that.
- 13:58Free AI tutors for every child. And I'm doing such a project in
- 14:03India to make free AI tutors for every child.
- 14:05It's a non profit effort. Free AI doctors for every
- 14:09person. And it's not only just the
- 14:11primary care doctor, because the same AI is also a great
- 14:15endocrinologist or a great gastroenterologist, AI
- 14:20oncologist, Everybody gets that and it's almost free.
- 14:24It's cheap enough where one person can do it for a country
- 14:29like India. And I hope we can do that,
- 14:32though I'm also doing an AI agronomist for the small
- 14:35farmers. So those things should all be
- 14:38free. Entertainment should be near
- 14:41free. The cost of production is going
- 14:44down dramatically. People talk about AI slop, but
- 14:48it's on the learning curve of improving at such a fast pace.
- 14:52Soon we will have AI that's tuned to each person that they
- 14:58love based on their watching history and maybe their rating
- 15:01history. So entertainment, legal
- 15:04services, so people can access their legal rights, education,
- 15:10healthcare, those can all be free.
- 15:12Anything that relies on expertise will cost a dollar an
- 15:15hour. I mean, a key insight here is
- 15:18the things that don't require asking another person to do work
- 15:21for you, where where something can be autonomously provided is
- 15:24something that can be a benefit versus, you know, sometimes the
- 15:28socialist case goes wrong when they're sort of insisting upon
- 15:31other people acting on their behalf and taking their time
- 15:35for. Themselves and relying on the
- 15:36efficiency of people doing things because people have other
- 15:40motivations. AI will be just as efficient in
- 15:44government as outside. You know, it's something people
- 15:47haven't got. Efficiency comes from humans or
- 15:53inefficiency come in in government comes from humans and
- 15:59bureaucracy and all that. All that can be automated way.
- 16:03So my view, we entered this world of abundance.
- 16:09And back to your original question, where will people
- 16:11follow meaning because they will be programmed from age 5 to be
- 16:17express their desires and be themselves, whether it's their
- 16:21relationship with their parents or it's a relationship with
- 16:25their passion for sports or art or something else.
- 16:29I think that's it's a very liberating kind of it's.
- 16:32Very structured. It's very you're, you're sort of
- 16:34trusting the average person to create their like self story.
- 16:37I feel like a challenge of the Trump world is that people want
- 16:40these leaders that, you know, you know, fascism is appealing
- 16:43because it's like the strongman leader who you can project all
- 16:46these views onto. Like who do you think like
- 16:50should be our societies like heroes today?
- 16:55Who are our heroes today, right? I would say used to be, you
- 17:03know, I like to say used to be only the basketball stars,
- 17:08right, The sports stars. And then when entrepreneurship
- 17:11really became a thing in the late 90s and it was existed long
- 17:16before then, but people got to recognize a Larry Page or a Mark
- 17:20Zuckerberg and they became heroes.
- 17:22So lots of people started thinking they could be they
- 17:27could be an entrepreneur. I think the next big turn first
- 17:32most of corporate America should be 4 times more efficient, which
- 17:36means to get the same amount of goods and services, maybe 1/4 to
- 17:40110th the number of people for enterprise in the what happens
- 17:46to the rest of the people? They can be micro entrepreneurs.
- 17:49How many people want to work at IBM's 4 levels down at a desk?
- 17:56Or would they rather be their own boss?
- 17:58I think micro entrepreneurship becomes trivially easy because
- 18:03AI does your accounting for. You like I'm a hero, I'm a sole
- 18:07or now I have a small team from small business owners and.
- 18:10All the whole creator phenomena is because it became easy to be
- 18:16a creator if you had some talent.
- 18:20And so we've seen millions and millions of creators created
- 18:23almost overnight in the last couple of years that projected
- 18:31forward many, many times. If you're a great Baker and make
- 18:36the greatest bread, it's very hard to be in business.
- 18:39You have to get an accountant, you have to get a lawyer, you
- 18:41have to incorporate, you have to know marketing, you have to know
- 18:44sales. You got to know all these
- 18:47things. If AI does all those functions
- 18:50and there's start-ups that say will will the creator in the box
- 18:53where you're the creator, everything else is taken care of
- 18:56you. That will happen for every micro
- 18:59entrepreneur, whether you have a passion or skill at carving wood
- 19:03or baking or entertaining, it doesn't matter.
- 19:08I would guess by 2035, ten years from now, that's a very short
- 19:15time, we will have 1/4 the number of corporate employees,
- 19:21maybe less and we will have 50 million micro entrepreneurs
- 19:25doing their thing, being their own boss and some people won't
- 19:29want to there's. Actually a lot of work, you
- 19:30know, being a micro entrepreneur, you know, today
- 19:33it's easier to be an employee, you know, you make more money.
- 19:36It's obviously amazing to be able to run a business and you
- 19:38can sign a big deal and make more money.
- 19:40But it is a lot of work. Back to the meaning of life.
- 19:44I don't think people are afraid of work.
- 19:47They're afraid of work, working for a boss who doesn't
- 19:50appreciate them. And most people in the country
- 19:54would say that's true. Most people in the world would
- 19:57say that's true. I think what matters is when
- 20:01people have agency, and that agency is being a micro
- 20:06entrepreneur, doing your thing, You're the boss, you're
- 20:09responsible. People love taking
- 20:11responsibility. I think that's where meaning
- 20:13comes from, from more people and their life will be more
- 20:17meaningful than working in a cubicle or an assembly line.
- 20:21Or on a farm you've. You've, you know, looking back
- 20:27into the 2414 article, I need to, it's like the business is a
- 20:30publication in India. I can't remember exactly the
- 20:32name, but you, you were early to be sort of soured on
- 20:35philanthropy. I think the tech industry sort
- 20:38of has grown more sceptical, though now you're talking about
- 20:40some philanthropic efforts. I did sour on philanthropy.
- 20:46I soured on the efficiency with which philanthropy works.
- 20:51There's a big difference. I think there's great pleasure
- 20:55in giving. There is, but if it's really
- 20:59inefficient, then it doesn't appeal to people like me.
- 21:03There's plenty of people who don't care about efficiency and
- 21:06say you. Just don't want a bunch of
- 21:07bureaucrats taking the money along the way to whatever.
- 21:10Consultants and people writing reports and.
- 21:15Right, because then you're effectively when you're creating
- 21:17the misery you're trying to get rid of, it's.
- 21:19Fully leads compliant. It's not lead certified.
- 21:22Why? Because there was 5 consultants
- 21:24who wanted to have a take at certifying it on this or that.
- 21:30I hate that bureaucracy. So I'm not leads qualified.
- 21:34I don't care. I'm happy to know how I built
- 21:36the building and how sustainable it is, how climate efficient it
- 21:41is. That's all I care about.
- 21:43So I think people have have motivation more internal than
- 21:48external, and they will do what they have a passion for and they
- 21:53have much more agency. I think agency is the key to
- 21:57human meaning. You have agency to do what you
- 22:00want and the freedom to pursue it because your basic needs are
- 22:04taken care of instead of today's jobs, which are for more than
- 22:0950% of the jobs in this country, service you to survival.
- 22:13Everybody can't wait to retire. Yeah, I, I just, I feel like the
- 22:21first of all, people always shift sort of the minimum that
- 22:24they want to meet all. That will happen.
- 22:26But you know, I just do think goods.
- 22:28Will be infinitely flexible. The services you need will all
- 22:32be free and infinitely flexible, other than token costs and power
- 22:37costs for tokens. Yeah, I do think the challenge
- 22:41is it's all, it seems like it's always we're almost there.
- 22:43You know, it's like, I mean, looking back, I think you said
- 22:49in that 24 interview that I'm really latching onto, you said
- 22:51in 15 years everybody would be able to get the quality of care
- 22:56you could get at Stanford, yes, which you still have time, but
- 23:00do you think that's going to come true?
- 23:02Absolutely 2040, I had projected 2040 OK and I think it'll be way
- 23:12before. I think this is 2029 but.
- 23:15I I wrote a long paper on healthcare called 20% Doctor
- 23:21included in 2016, which is when I published it and I projected
- 23:252040 and my part was. Somebody was like, oh, give
- 23:29yourself a little bit more wiggle room.
- 23:31You had a good advice. No, I.
- 23:34Assumed 3 eight-year cycles. In fact I called it V1V2V3 all
- 23:41the way to V8. If there were three-year
- 23:43innovation cycles and it'd be 24 years or roughly 2040.
- 23:49There's not great precision in any of this.
- 23:52In fact, all of what I projected happening much faster.
- 23:57I won't say who somebody from the healthcare establishment
- 24:02won. The better known names had been
- 24:04critiquing me for the last 10 years for this projection came
- 24:09to me last year and said he was wrong.
- 24:13He's a public health policy person.
- 24:16He was absolutely wrong. I was wrong, but I was right.
- 24:21But I was wrong in projecting it take much longer.
- 24:25So I think he would say today and we're doing a joint
- 24:30publications, so I won't so publication in a medical journal
- 24:35together saying AI will do doctoring better than doctors
- 24:40is. We're already seeing some.
- 24:42We've seen lots of examples of that.
- 24:46And my sense is doctors are embracing.
- 24:47I mean, they're overworked, you know, they want to get the right
- 24:50answers. They want to help people.
- 24:53Are in a different business than they thought they would be when
- 24:56they were in medical school. Most doctors got into medicine
- 25:00because they enjoy taking care of people, right?
- 25:04Today, they're slaves to billing.
- 25:08You are at the hospital, you're billing, meeting billing codes,
- 25:12not what's the best patient care.
- 25:14And what empathy. Empathy isn't the characteristic
- 25:18that's optimized in medicine today and most doctors got into
- 25:23it because of empathy for people who needed help.
- 25:27I think that's true of the majority of doctors, not 100%
- 25:32and some percentage have still mostly work on empathy for and a
- 25:37sense of service so. Look, just a direct question, do
- 25:41you support single payer healthcare today?
- 25:44Today, absolutely it'd be a fraction of the cost if we had
- 25:48single payer healthcare and rapidly declining costs if we
- 25:52did that. I think we're people are wrong
- 25:56is to assume that single payer will be too expensive.
- 26:03The cost of healthcare in this country, the $4 trillion could
- 26:07easily cut, you know, and it's a, it's, it's on a pretty strong
- 26:12inflationary cycle that'll become rapidly deflationary if
- 26:16we had single payer. Why can't you get?
- 26:19You know, the sort of right, you know, can, can you get Keith
- 26:23Roboy on on board with that one or like what's the resistance
- 26:26among sort of your, your fellows in the tech?
- 26:28Industry, there's a general assumption because there's no
- 26:30proof that single payer will become inefficient and fraud and
- 26:36all those things. The thing is, if a doctor costs
- 26:40a dollar a month for every American, imagine it costs a
- 26:45couple of $100 million a month to give free doctoring to every
- 26:50American. And that means primary care.
- 26:52It means gaps in care, it means chronic disease management, it
- 26:57costs means mental health for a dollar an hour.
- 27:02How much downstream cost would you reduce today?
- 27:06All the incentive. All the incentive.
- 27:10Why is every hospital system start with Stanford or UC buying
- 27:16small medical clinics? Not because they want to run
- 27:18them well, they want to feed off their cardiac patients, right?
- 27:23Are you going to go all in for AOC in the president?
- 27:25I I feel like you're much more of a less than you even sort of
- 27:28see yourself. You're to support single payer.
- 27:31You want what you said you want capital gains taxes, income tax,
- 27:35which would be dramatic. Here's here's the problem with
- 27:38AOC. She has this model of the well
- 27:43off against the not so well off that is not.
- 27:46You want to be. You just don't want to be
- 27:47villainized. If you weren't villainized,
- 27:49you'd be OK with it. No, I think what I'm for is what
- 27:53technology enables in this country.
- 27:56In the next 10 years, basic services become so cheap we
- 28:01don't need to meet around. I was in the board of a Telecom
- 28:05US West quest when I argue that it was costing them more to send
- 28:11the paper bill to people's homes than to provide the telecom
- 28:15service and stop charging. By the minute 90s almost
- 28:21everything was built. Every phone call was built by
- 28:24the minute and today every medical visit is built by the
- 28:30visit. That should go away.
- 28:33I don't understand how does this connect to the AOC point.
- 28:36To the if things are cheap, then you can give them.
- 28:40I still do think AOC doesn't care about economics and there's
- 28:44plenty tax people. That's just the wrong approach.
- 28:48I think what's the right and and and you know, AOC and Bernie
- 28:53Sanders all said, let's not let people lay off jobs like those
- 28:57are all the wrong things in the intermediate thing the.
- 29:01Pro union lock in jobs, not like a dynamic economy.
- 29:04That's a really bad way to run an economy.
- 29:08It'll sink the economy before we get to abundance.
- 29:11If we free up the economy, and I'll come back to this point and
- 29:16protect people against their biggest fear, which is AI will
- 29:20cause my job to be lost, We protect those people, then we
- 29:25can have a very efficient economy.
- 29:29All of corporate America getting much more efficient.
- 29:33The revenue per employee, every CEOI meet.
- 29:37I say within five years you could quadruple your revenue per
- 29:43employee and every CEO should be striving for that.
- 29:47And it's very possible. Let's let's do.
- 29:49It I I just really think like. I still wondering all over the.
- 29:51Place no, no, I love it. No, no, I'm I'm supporting what
- 29:53you're saying. I'm saying we need a Silicon
- 29:55Valley new deal. It's like you get single payer
- 29:58healthcare. We reform the tax code.
- 30:01We say, oh, there's a minimum quality of life every American
- 30:04can have. But in exchange, we're not going
- 30:06to be super pro union. We're not going to sort of jerk
- 30:09around companies and it's going to be about sort of minimum
- 30:12government standards instead of sort of distorting capitalism
- 30:16and stopping companies from being able to be dynamic.
- 30:18We shouldn't. Distort capitalism, but we
- 30:21should recognize capitalism is by permission of democracy.
- 30:25You know, we really get a mumdani elected.
- 30:28My biggest fear is we get a mumdani elected, AOC runs for
- 30:32president and there's this anti AI backlash for fear of jobs
- 30:37that elects AOC. You know, look, Trump got
- 30:41elected because people were fed up with the nonsense of
- 30:44everything became ADEI issue. DI went to extremes that it
- 30:49shouldn't have gone to. I can't use certain words.
- 30:52I I I can't even. Nothing Americans say more than
- 30:55being told what they can and can't say.
- 30:58Yeah, that that kind of nonsense went so far all because of the
- 31:03extreme left. And there's different
- 31:05constituencies even in the left. Ma'am, Donnie, you know, I live
- 31:09in New York City. He has taken a very pragmatic
- 31:12approach that to succeed in governing from the left, you
- 31:15actually have to deliver results.
- 31:17You know, he brags about the potholes.
- 31:19He talks about public safety. I really do.
- 31:22I didn't talk about where he's going to get revenue.
- 31:27He wants new taxes. I mean, I'm sure you would sign
- 31:29on to your capital gains one he's trying to do get a terror
- 31:33taxes. There's rational reasons and
- 31:36irrational reasons to do this. OK, for the next 15 years, so
- 31:42let's say to 2040 before we get to abundance in 2050, we want a
- 31:48fair economy. What is AI doing?
- 31:51It's disadvantaging capital, boosting the returns on capital.
- 31:56That's why you get so much more investment going in.
- 31:59It's suppressing the results for Labour.
- 32:04So Labour is 16 trillion of the USGDP.
- 32:09That will keep declining. And I think we could, if we let
- 32:13systems be efficient and let every corporation do what they
- 32:17want to do without people embarrassing them against
- 32:21layoffs, we'd have it. Labour be, say, 5 trillion of
- 32:26the US economy in real terms. That much decline in labour is a
- 32:35big, big deal, right? OK, but you agree.
- 32:38And guess what? Who gets the benefit?
- 32:40Capital, right. And what do we do in our tax
- 32:42system? We favor capital over labor.
- 32:46Why are ordinary income taxes much, much higher than capital
- 32:50gains? Because we we've got all these
- 32:54tax breaks, every tax break, and there's ten of them I could
- 32:59point to, is worth thirty, $40 billion to the US.
- 33:02Country. My, my point is the things
- 33:03you're saying right now are things that bring you closer to
- 33:05AOC Mamdani. And my point is that I.
- 33:08Believe the thing that. Turns you off most about them is
- 33:12that they villainize the billionaire class, but actually
- 33:14you have a lot of policy agreement.
- 33:17No, there's not policy agreement.
- 33:18I'm not saying slow down layoffs like Bernie Sanders.
- 33:24Is right you're saying smaller companies Yeah has been very
- 33:27anti AI I feel like. AOC I'm done.
- 33:30It's a little bit efficient. Right.
- 33:31I'm not talking about Bernie specifically because I agree.
- 33:34Bernie is that sort of old school, sort of like union.
- 33:38But look, we can't constrain people from laying off people.
- 33:41If you're going to have an efficient economy and compete
- 33:45with China, like that is our big bugaboo.
- 33:49We have to compete with China globally, so we don't want to
- 33:55constrain capitalistic efficiency, OK?
- 34:00What we want to do is say all taxes, whether you earn it on
- 34:05capital or income, have the same rate of return and we will cut
- 34:11more so the tax breaks out. If we just did that, we'd have,
- 34:16my estimate, $400 billion a year.
- 34:20Don't your fellow venture capitalists want to murder you
- 34:22over this? This is like the number one
- 34:23thing the National Venture Capital Association has to
- 34:26fight. It's like keep carried.
- 34:29Funny fact, we should go back to that topic because it's a very
- 34:33important topic. But I've never been a member of
- 34:37the NVCA and I've they made multiple attempts to get me to
- 34:41be a member of the NVCA. And I've said for 20 years, if
- 34:46you will not advocate for carried interests getting
- 34:50special treatment, then I'll join the NVCA.
- 34:53If you're at, if your principal job is to advocate for carried
- 34:57interests getting special treatment, I'm not joining the
- 35:00NVCA. I'm not a member.
- 35:02You're probably the only major firm that's not a member of the
- 35:05NVCA. I've had that principal for 20
- 35:08some years. Amazing.
- 35:10I didn't know. That yeah.
- 35:11So very few people know that because these principles matter,
- 35:16right? So going back to this issue, if
- 35:22we equalize capital gains and and ordinary income because AI
- 35:28is favoring capital over labour, then we have 400 billion a year
- 35:34or so to take care of people who are displaced by AI, to allow
- 35:41people to be displaced, which I think is what capitalist
- 35:47efficiency is about. You need to take care of them.
- 35:51And you know, COVID cost us about 250 billion a year when
- 35:55there was mass unemployment, that was roughly the bill for
- 35:59annual additional bill for COVID unemployment.
- 36:03It's something like that. It will happen gradually over
- 36:06the next 10 years. It's not happening suddenly.
- 36:09And so between equalizing taxes, I'm saying we have reverse
- 36:15taxation against, you know. I, I agree, I think many people
- 36:20listening to this, I think it's a great point and I get.
- 36:22Why should one get which is being favoured by AI get special
- 36:27treatment? Look, MLPS are worth 30-40
- 36:31billion a year. Step up bases in estate, that
- 36:34planning, and all this worth 30-40 billion a year without
- 36:40even getting to any inheritance tax issues.
- 36:43There's all these tricks, a dozen of them, worth 30 to 40
- 36:48billion a year MLPS. What is MLP?
- 36:51Master limited partnerships, so oil and gas or housing and like
- 36:57there's all these things that have been engineered through
- 37:00political influence to favor people, but has nothing to do
- 37:04with capitalism. They have nothing to do with
- 37:06capitalism. They're SPECIAL perks engineered
- 37:09in because I could afford to make a controversy.
- 37:11Republicans are never going to fix this issue, right?
- 37:13Your only hope of fixing this issue is aligning with
- 37:16Democrats. Do you agree with that?
- 37:17I think it's an independent who takes a new view I I want.
- 37:21The United States to set up, you know.
- 37:23So, by the way, I've never been a Democrat.
- 37:24I know, I know, I know. I'm an independent.
- 37:26Free marketer who became more sort of because of environmental
- 37:30policy that that moved you a little.
- 37:32Bit I was a Republican most of my life because I thought fiscal
- 37:35was the most important. Then I added climate to this and
- 37:39the early Republicans or both the Bushes were pre climate
- 37:47action. It's a long term risk, just like
- 37:50Homeland Security is a risk. We should spend a certain amount
- 37:54on risk insurance, whether it's for climate or Homeland Security
- 37:57or National Defence. That's my view.
- 38:00But that's not where the Republicans ended up.
- 38:03So I became an independent. But back to this issue.
- 38:06If we could do equalized taxes, get rid of special breaks, we'd
- 38:12have 400 billion a year. Add to that a token tax
- 38:16intelligence, which is what AI is, you get to a trillion
- 38:23dollars a year that you can use to support the people who would
- 38:28be displaced. So instead of slowing down the
- 38:31economy and saying stopping displacement, let's let the
- 38:35economy be efficient, but let's find other ways to take care of
- 38:38them and encourage things like micro entrepreneurship.
- 38:42Do you think open AI is going to align with this?
- 38:44I mean, they put out with Chris Lehane a policy paper.
- 38:47It was pretty progressive, but then they're also supporting,
- 38:50they're supporting some, you know, I don't know, anti
- 38:53Democratic, you know, effort. So I'm sort of confused where
- 38:56they're actually going to spend their.
- 38:58Energy I would guess, and hopefully they'll call me.
- 39:02Sam would support token taxes? I've asked him I suspect Daria
- 39:07would support token taxes on intelligence because they both
- 39:11see the impact it can have and good impact, as well as ways to
- 39:17reduce the negative impact of AI.
- 39:19He's a subtext of what you're saying for the listener is that
- 39:22we're going to have a new class divide problem, which is
- 39:25intelligence is going to be something you can easily buy and
- 39:28that reinforces the power of capital even more because you
- 39:31can spend money and get intelligence and that further
- 39:34advantages people. Without with this, I suspect in
- 39:37this world a farm worker gets paid the same as an oncologist
- 39:42because they're both up skilled to the level of the AI.
- 39:45So it's it's the capital, it's the money holders that are at
- 39:49the biggest advantage. It's probably by 2050 we have
- 39:52the greatest opportunity we've ever had to have equality.
- 39:56What happens to a few percent of the population?
- 39:59Who? Owned AI.
- 40:01One of the great human problems is, you know, who gets to live
- 40:03on Central Park or whatever, You know, I, I don't know if we saw
- 40:06we just because we have abundance, we do we care more
- 40:09about abundance or do we care about relative status?
- 40:12I do think in a world of great economic efficiency and AI based
- 40:17abundance, we start to pay more attention to equality, which we
- 40:23have not done under capitalism, and say we'll sacrifice some
- 40:29minor level of efficiency to get much more equality in society
- 40:34and society. I suspect we'll be happier.
- 40:37More equal societies are happy both in the rich people and the
- 40:42not so rich people. I want to change gears slightly.
- 40:45I mean, one, and it's sort of already come up, but one of the
- 40:48things you want to animate, animate the United States right
- 40:50now is sort of a rivalry with China.
- 40:52And part of what you're using to justify that is the sense that
- 40:56America is a great democracy. We should protect democracy.
- 41:00China, you know, is a totalitarian regime.
- 41:03You know, I agree. But it feels like the American
- 41:05democracy is under a threat right now.
- 41:08Like what is your sense of how you know, Trump is literally
- 41:12joking? And I know you're anti Trump,
- 41:13but Trump is literally joking. Joking, you know, that he'll be
- 41:16president in six to eight years. Still, like what?
- 41:19What do you? What is your view on how secure
- 41:21American democracy is today? Look, there's a great book on
- 41:25this I'm trying to remember by Russ.
- 41:29I think it's Russ. Feingold was the senator.
- 41:31That is the senator. I'm not sure what you're
- 41:33talking. About he wrote a book on
- 41:35democracy in peril or something like that.
- 41:37I buy his thesis that we are. We are not as safe in democracy
- 41:44as we'd like to be. Institutions are no longer safe.
- 41:49We have the era of individual individuals like Trump.
- 41:56So I don't think we are safe. I don't think Western philosophy
- 42:01is safe and Western values are safe, and we have to fight for
- 42:06that. And that's why I think winning
- 42:08against China is so key. What political philosophy the
- 42:13world adopts will depend on who wins the economic race, and that
- 42:18will depend on who wins the AI race entirely.
- 42:22So that's why it's so critical to win the AI race.
- 42:25Why? Why it's important we win the
- 42:28economic race and bring benefits to the rest of the world with
- 42:32our. You see a distinction between
- 42:36Western values and Western democratic values.
- 42:38Are you drawing a distinction? There.
- 42:40Not really. I mean you can get endless.
- 42:44Right. Are you still largely like
- 42:48you're pretty opposed to open source a couple years ago?
- 42:50Is that still true? I'm not opposed to open source,
- 42:53so remember I was at Sun when we started the open source
- 42:58movement. But AI open source.
- 43:00NFS was the first open source product.
- 43:03I feel like Son was responsible for making open source happen
- 43:08and starting with the files, NFS file system and then open source
- 43:16operating systems and all that. And I was a huge investor in
- 43:21GitLab and it was four people. It's open source and.
- 43:25But today, are you comfortable with your portfolio companies
- 43:27using Kimi and Deep Sea Kimi? I'm not.
- 43:29OK. So I'm not because I think
- 43:32China, we are too open to subversion.
- 43:36And when we open source, and I had this debate with some of the
- 43:41executives at Facebook when they were open sourcing llama, they
- 43:46were feeding technology to the Chinese and it has helped them
- 43:50catch up. Now China's smart population,
- 43:53they'll catch up anyway. But we shouldn't be helping them
- 43:56catch up. And we should stay at least a
- 43:59year's breath ahead of them because I think our fundamental
- 44:03system is superior and we have the talent.
- 44:07Now they have the talent too. But many more of the most
- 44:11brilliant minds on the planet want to move to the US or did
- 44:15before Trump instead of moving to China.
- 44:20And so I think that was one of our strongest assets in staying
- 44:24ahead. And Trump has killed that, to be
- 44:27honest. It's.
- 44:28Terrible. I mean getting Chinese
- 44:30administrators. Ever done to this country long
- 44:33term is making it less attractive for the best talent
- 44:37in the world to come to this country and keep us ahead.
- 44:39And it's insane that Elon is one of his biggest if not biggest
- 44:42funders and Elon's companies are full of immigrant founders and
- 44:45is highly dependent and he's an immigrant himself.
- 44:48There's hardly a successful company in Silicon Valley that
- 44:52doesn't have immigrant founders and in some key role in the top
- 44:59management. And it's one of the things that
- 45:01makes, you know, America great in my view.
- 45:04I mean, I like if I'm really pressed on, like, you know, I
- 45:06asked you who the heroes are. I mean, some of the people I
- 45:09think about are like, you know, Sundar Alphabet and like Satya
- 45:12Nadella, Microsoft, who have been great stewards of important
- 45:16companies that it feels like through a terrible culture
- 45:19shift, you know, are real stewards of institutions that
- 45:23provide no. Great value, done a great job
- 45:26and immigrant founders have had immigrants have had a huge role
- 45:30in the knowledge economy. In fact, immigrant doctors, we
- 45:34have a huge shortage if you didn't have immigrant doctors.
- 45:39So no matter where you look, do you?
- 45:41Try to talk to Elon about you. Talk to him occasionally or not.
- 45:44Much. Not a whole lot now.
- 45:46He used to be like, oh, I have this space company or you're,
- 45:49you're on the outs at this point.
- 45:51Look, I'm not afraid to call him when it needs to be called.
- 45:58Look, the nice thing is I can't be fired.
- 46:00So I don't worry about, I never worried about a career because
- 46:04it's just done fine for me. I've never create feared about
- 46:09the things other things fear, which is somehow but.
- 46:15You don't. I don't imagine you want to be
- 46:16on his list of Twitter people. He just like spices randomly or
- 46:20like you've avoided the mass public sort of Republican
- 46:23animals. Yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm probably
- 46:26avoided that. But you know, look, I admire
- 46:29Elan for what he's done. Well, as an entrepreneur, he's
- 46:32done a great job. We wouldn't have electric cars.
- 46:35We had we left it to General Motors.
- 46:38We wouldn't have had space launches, though.
- 46:40I'd say Rocket Lab or one of our company deserves as much credit
- 46:45if it wasn't for Elon and we had relied on Boeing or Airbus or
- 46:50somebody else to do. This is a business question, but
- 46:53do you think the SpaceX IPO is going to take down the whole
- 46:57whole mania happening right now? I know it just the expected, you
- 47:00know multiple on revenue is like ludicrous.
- 47:03I don't care about Wall Street. I don't care about prices.
- 47:06I don't. The reason I don't care is
- 47:09people think that's reality. It's not reality.
- 47:12When people talk about a bubble, I say a bubble in whatwasthe.com
- 47:17thing A bubble? Not if you look at real usage of
- 47:21the Internet. Look at Internet traffic and
- 47:25tell me where. You know, yeah, they just
- 47:27overpriced where I was. Going to go whether investors
- 47:32bounce between fear and greed and that causes change in
- 47:35valuation, that's not reality. It would kill a bunch of good
- 47:39companies probably. If you know the bubble popped,
- 47:42you know it's just brutal it. Just you can do nothing about
- 47:45investor bouncing between fear and greed, which is what comes
- 47:51causes bubbles and busts. So I don't worry much about Wall
- 47:56Street. I don't trade almost ever.
- 48:00I just do my thing with companies and frankly, I don't.
- 48:05I've never in 40 years said I'm in the investing business.
- 48:08I've never called myself. What's fun is helping
- 48:14entrepreneurs build companies and helping them with mistakes
- 48:18you've already made. I made more mistakes than
- 48:21anybody on the planet when it comes to building companies
- 48:23because I've been doing it for a long time and I hope I can help
- 48:27entrepreneurs avoid some of those.
- 48:29That's my job and that's how I define what I do.
- 48:32And it's a lot of fun. We're we're.
- 48:34Recording this obviously as Sam Altman and Elon Musk are
- 48:37fighting in court right now. You you are the earliest venture
- 48:42investor in open AI. The the read read often was in
- 48:47the round, but as an individual right or you guys who got the
- 48:50bigger sure. That's right.
- 48:52Yeah. What is I there was a viral
- 48:54tweet that you sort of knocked down about the returns you've
- 48:59seen on Open AI. Will you say anything about how
- 49:02well you've done? I think the the the worry is
- 49:04that it's been just so dilutive that what should have been sort
- 49:07of an all timer has gotten diluted.
- 49:09It's a fabulous return. I won't go into specifics, but
- 49:14it's been a fabulous return by any metric.
- 49:18Have you sold some along the way or?
- 49:20Very tiny amount a long time ago, most most of it internal
- 49:24between our funds. So you know, do you think?
- 49:28It will be 1 of the all time great investments.
- 49:31I think so now my all time great investment was Juniper Networks
- 49:37where we got 2500 times our money on a $3,000,000 investment
- 49:42in a world where the largest funds were two or $300 million.
- 49:47Not happening. It was sort of a fabulous
- 49:50return. Why?
- 49:51Because we bet on TCPIB being the core of the Internet when
- 49:56everybody else was betting on another technology called ATM.
- 50:00Because the telcos were thinking ATM and Cisco was thinking ATM
- 50:04Cisco CTO told me they would never do a TCPIP router above OC
- 50:1012, which is less than my home service today.
- 50:13So we just built Juniper to be TCPIP for the public Internet.
- 50:18So that's the best, but obviously you'll make far more
- 50:20money off the volume of open net, but the level of return
- 50:23won't be the same. I hope it's 2500 X.
- 50:26It could be. What what do you make of this
- 50:29idea Like that you know they stole a non profit or obviously
- 50:32you were investing when it was becoming a non profit.
- 50:35You know Sam went outside because Elon failed to fulfill
- 50:40his commitment to fund the company last minute.
- 50:44There was no real source of funding so Sam had to go looking
- 50:49and perfectly reasonable for a non profit to have a for profit
- 50:55subsidiary. Look no, no desk is set up in
- 50:58many European companies. IKEA is set up that way where a
- 51:02non profit owns a for profit in has profit for profit
- 51:07shareholders. It's just not the first time
- 51:10it's been done. In fact the best companies in
- 51:13Europe have the structure of a for profit subsidiary with for
- 51:20profit investors, but the majority is still owned by a non
- 51:25profit. It depends on the how much money
- 51:28they've raised, how fast they've expanded.
- 51:30It's been a pretty fabulous story.
- 51:32I mean. Like what is the alternative?
- 51:35Right, I'm sympathetic to the idea.
- 51:36To build this AI company, you needed the money.
- 51:38The only way to get money on that scale is from people trying
- 51:41to make a profit. Therefore, you needed to be a
- 51:43for profit if you believe in the mission of delivering a.
- 51:45Formation is a key function of capitalism.
- 51:49That wasn't possible. Look, Elon is just jealous.
- 51:54It's nothing but jealousy that. It's amazing how much he's just
- 51:58like, desperate to be in control.
- 52:00I mean, you know he. Wanted to be in control, he
- 52:03wanted to own. There's lots of things I won't
- 52:06go into. He didn't have the best
- 52:09intentions. He definitely didn't have non
- 52:12profit intentions. He doesn't even care about
- 52:16climate. It worked out well for him at
- 52:18Tesla. That wasn't his pitch
- 52:20originally. Should we still worry about
- 52:22climate? Nobody talks about it anymore.
- 52:23We absolutely need to worry. Just because Trump had made it
- 52:28bad bad to talk about climate doesn't mean it's the problem
- 52:32has gone away. We've just buried our head in
- 52:35the sand. We are continuing to invest in
- 52:37climate as now our view is climate technologies have to be
- 52:42competitive. We have the best steel company
- 52:45or beat a coal plant based steel plant any day.
- 52:50I can build a build a beat a coal based cement plant any day.
- 52:56So these fundamental technologies have to be cost
- 52:58comparative. You can't defy the laws of
- 53:01economic gravity. Our climate philosophy is more
- 53:04about new technologies that are cost competitive with their
- 53:08fossil competitors. Fusion will be that way.
- 53:11We did fusion cement steel. Pro energy you need, you need
- 53:16energy. It's not about sort of being, I
- 53:18don't know, like monks. So this is another place, you
- 53:20know, people efficiency legislation, consume less.
- 53:25That's the wrong way to approach climate.
- 53:28Make it cleaner and cheaper with sustainable technologies.
- 53:33That's the right way. That's what fusion will do.
- 53:35That's what super hot geothermal will do.
- 53:37We working both those areas, in fact have the dominant companies
- 53:41in both those areas the most cost effective company.
- 53:44Same with cement. Our cement is cheaper than
- 53:47regular cement. Our steel is cheaper.
- 53:50Now we have to build large plants to get to those cost
- 53:53points, and capital is hard to get in some of these areas in
- 53:58the Trump climate area. But most people would agree with
- 54:02me that that's the way to scale sustainability, not by saying
- 54:07it's OK to pay twice as much. Are you cheering for Anthropic?
- 54:12I cheer for all AI including entropic.
- 54:15What do you make of, you know, I feel like the Trump
- 54:18administration in places has made me more of a libertarian.
- 54:21Like, you know, I, I guess during Biden, I would have been
- 54:24a little bit more comfortable with the Biden administration
- 54:27regulating in some at least wanting to be alerted to what's
- 54:30happening with different models. Now the Trump administration.
- 54:32Nuanced matters here. We can't have private values
- 54:39determine what our national policies on National Defence
- 54:42are. We can.
- 54:45In fact, everybody in government, no matter who they
- 54:48are, are required to abide by the law.
- 54:51They don't always, but they're required to abide by the law.
- 54:55So if a government agency is abiding by the law.
- 54:59But it's the Trump administration, an
- 55:01administration that has no history of abiding by the law.
- 55:04The the version of abiding by the law is what we can get away
- 55:07with until, you know, they arrest us.
- 55:08In 20 years, I agree with that. My fundamental problem with the
- 55:11Trump administration is lack of values.
- 55:15So why? Saying let's just defer to
- 55:17democracy is sort of laughable. Democracy includes first number
- 55:20one. The main branch is supposed to
- 55:22be Congress, which has done nothing to react to AI.
- 55:25So to say, defer to democracy. Well, our our main.
- 55:28Branch Let's look at the principle.
- 55:30A private company can choose to sell or not sell.
- 55:35That's always been true. But that's what Anthropic was
- 55:38saying we want we'll just walk away.
- 55:40The the issue was that it was a new contract.
- 55:42My tweet was I admire Dario for his principle.
- 55:47I happen to believe that particular principle was wrong
- 55:51in trying to constrain the Defense Department.
- 55:54I think building a constitution in the claw, teaching AI to have
- 55:58values, I mean to go back to sort of technology as a
- 56:00religion, like one of the commendable things they're doing
- 56:02is being thoughtful and intentional about the technology
- 56:05they're building. And in a free market society,
- 56:08they are one company that is allowed to build it in their
- 56:10way. I think they're doing in a very
- 56:11admirable way. And I don't think we should
- 56:13encourage the federal government to bully them into doing what
- 56:16they. Want I think the federal
- 56:17government, the Department of Defense or Department of War,
- 56:22whatever it's called now has 1 objective.
- 56:26Not set by Congress. So I think the Department of
- 56:29Defence is still, by the way, God.
- 56:31Not lose to Putin or be subject to Putin.
- 56:36If Putin walks into China, she walks into Taiwan.
- 56:42They need to be able to defend US and and the western world
- 56:47against that. OK, I think that discussion
- 56:53shouldn't lie with a private company, but they should have
- 56:56the ability to not sell their technology to the Defence
- 57:00Department or Department of War. Well, that's that's effectively
- 57:04what they're doing. They're saying we're not going
- 57:05to sell it. Unless you agree to this
- 57:06contract. That's why I admire Dario for
- 57:09sticking with his principles. Right.
- 57:10But then you sort of bought into this idea that if you're
- 57:12following the law, if as long as they agree to follow the law,
- 57:15that's sufficient. But you agree with the idea that
- 57:17they're not a set of people that are can be trusted to follow the
- 57:20law. That I I agreed.
- 57:22That's true. I hope it's very temporary.
- 57:26Hopefully another two years and we are done with this problem of
- 57:29defying the law and we recur. We go back to democracy.
- 57:34Like corruption matters, right? I mean, as a business person,
- 57:38what do you make of sort of just the, I don't know, rewarding, I
- 57:42mean the crypto? Is huge.
- 57:45Does anybody know what happened to TikTok?
- 57:49Senator Cantwell was on the committee that decided to ban
- 57:54TikTok or not. I talked to her multiple times
- 57:58to convince her TikTok should be banned.
- 58:00She was against it and then came around to believing it should be
- 58:05banned. There's a couple of Democratic
- 58:08senators who were key to that, but now it's disappeared into
- 58:13the abyss. Nobody knows who made what and
- 58:16who owns it, who's in charge. Fascinating.
- 58:18I haven't even really. You're right.
- 58:19Nobody knows. There's.
- 58:21So many things it's hard to keep track of.
- 58:23That Santa on the committee waiting for the ban had no idea.
- 58:28She asked me recently, do I know what happened to it?
- 58:32I have no idea. She has no idea.
- 58:34I maybe I shouldn't have an idea.
- 58:36She should. There's no.
- 58:38Accountability left. Corruption is just rampant.
- 58:43Are there any politicians that you're optimistic about, whether
- 58:46it's the California governor primary, Democratic primary
- 58:49coming up, independent, any, any politician of any stripe that
- 58:53you're like, oh, I have some optimism about them?
- 58:57Let me not name names. Oh, come on.
- 59:01Look, in the California primary, I'm supporting Matt Mahan over
- 59:06any of the other candidates. I like him.
- 59:08I had him on this podcast. Nobody watched it.
- 59:12You need to be a little bit like dynamic.
- 59:14I mean, I like him. I was set up.
- 59:16The problem the problem with mainstream media, but it's the.
- 59:21Public. It's the public like.
- 59:23Yes, right. Why did Trump get away with
- 59:27saying immigrant Haitian immigrants are eating your pets?
- 59:30Not that he believed it, not only not that maybe the people
- 59:35in Ohio believed it. It just it enforced the idea are
- 59:40immigrants are bad, which was his campaign pledge.
- 59:43So he's a great communicator in that sense, even if it sounds
- 59:48irrational to some of us that why would anybody believe that?
- 59:53How can a person be president who says that?
- 59:56I mean, but. Look, I hope we restore a sense
- 1:00:02of democracy and law abidedness in in in Washington.
- 1:00:09Yeah, I mean, I like, I like Matt Mahan.
- 1:00:11I think he's smart. I I think he's a little, he's in
- 1:00:14a weird position where he doesn't want to talk about Trump
- 1:00:16too much because he needs to somehow get Republicans.
- 1:00:19But I feel like that's a hard path to win and it seems seems
- 1:00:23unlikely. I mean, the, yeah, California
- 1:00:25governor's race. Do you think the billionaire
- 1:00:27tax, you've been less worried about that than some, right?
- 1:00:30I think it's really bad policy. I critique Rochana over it.
- 1:00:36I think he's taken less of a stance in favour of it since,
- 1:00:41but it's a really bad idea. We've in essence reduced our tax
- 1:00:47collections over 10 years by all this wealth leaving the state
- 1:00:51that would have happily paid ordinary income tax as they sold
- 1:00:55their stock. Wealth taxes have lots of
- 1:00:59problems. I'm not against more taxes, but
- 1:01:01wealth taxes have are a bad idea.
- 1:01:05Net net reduced tax collection in California.
- 1:01:10The last, last question I'll ask you, you know, you're, you're
- 1:01:14investing in all these great startups like companies that
- 1:01:16people haven't. Heard by the way.
- 1:01:17I just want to say I chose to stay in California and I'll stay
- 1:01:21in California despite the tax because my lifestyle is more
- 1:01:24important than the 5% wealth tax might.
- 1:01:27Well, the real issue is sort of the paper.
- 1:01:29You know, it's like if if it turns out that control over
- 1:01:33Google is like super is valued as.
- 1:01:35Well, there's lots of other problems.
- 1:01:37Even the goal of tax, tax collection, tax collections over
- 1:01:4110 years will go down, not up. Because they're scaring people
- 1:01:45away. Because they're scaring people
- 1:01:46away and scaring away the people who created the wealth who
- 1:01:50should be rewarded for that wealth.
- 1:01:53But no. And nobody on the presidential
- 1:01:54level that you're willing to say you're.
- 1:01:57I think it's too early. Do you think you'll be a big
- 1:02:00donor? If there's an independent
- 1:02:04candidate for sure, I think right now to win in a Democratic
- 1:02:10primary, it's not a position I'm likely to support.
- 1:02:14To win in a Republican primary is not a position I'm likely to
- 1:02:18support. Start-ups that people should be
- 1:02:21paying attention to right now after so many I know.
- 1:02:25After, well, there's we're not done with innovation in AI or
- 1:02:30even approaches other than large language models.
- 1:02:34I think there's lots to do that's innovative, not just
- 1:02:38create another competitor to open the Iron Tropic.
- 1:02:43I think that business is done, but are there more innovations
- 1:02:49to be had? Absolutely.
- 1:02:52Huge gains in efficiency. Everybody knows inferencing is
- 1:02:56really inefficient. You're using the same GPUs to do
- 1:03:02both inferencing and training based.
- 1:03:05On Together Fireworks you have a bet or what?
- 1:03:07What is your inferencing bet? My bet is so I won't talk about
- 1:03:11specific investments. Coming down the.
- 1:03:14Yeah, We have plenty of ways to make GP US much more efficient,
- 1:03:21have alternatives to GP US, transform models that are
- 1:03:25alternatives to GP US. We just announced SO1
- 1:03:29announcement was Prism ML that reduced an 8 bit model to a one
- 1:03:33bit model so it can run on a phone.
- 1:03:36Like that's innovation, like a mathematically equivalent model
- 1:03:41that can run on a phone that's fun.
- 1:03:44There's other ways to do those things.
- 1:03:46So lots of room for innovation around L alams, lots of room for
- 1:03:52alternative to LLMS World models has a really, really interesting
- 1:03:56area and lots of fun things happening and a lot of diversity
- 1:04:00in approaches in in how world models and robotics are being
- 1:04:07approached. Big area for innovation the next
- 1:04:09five years outside of here. I've talked about some of the
- 1:04:15climate areas for the first time in a really long time.
- 1:04:20I'm bullish on quantum. I think I won't talk about it
- 1:04:27yet. I've looked at a dozen quantum
- 1:04:30start-ups over the last 10 years, most multiple times.
- 1:04:35I've never had the confidence we'll get to quantum in any
- 1:04:38reasonable time frame. I think we have finally have a
- 1:04:41shot. Well, Vinod, 'cause we started
- 1:04:44talking about religion, you're you know, we by 2040, you need
- 1:04:48to help deliver us material abundance get make sure
- 1:04:51Americans have the and everyone around the world has quality
- 1:04:54healthcare. No, no pressure.
- 1:04:56Excited to watch your start up investments and I'm sure we'll
- 1:04:59have you back on the show soon. Thanks for coming on.
- 1:05:01Thank you. Lots of exciting things to talk
- 1:05:03about. I loved it.
- 1:05:05All right. Thanks.
- 1:05:05That's our show. Thanks for listening.
- 1:05:07Please like, comment, subscribe. We're a new channel and we can
- 1:05:10use all your support. Go watch some of the old videos.
- 1:05:13You can follow along on the Sub Stack, newcomer.co.
- 1:05:17Or if you've got endless time on your hands, go watch the Super
- 1:05:21Bowl Valley show, my chat show with Max Child and James Wilson.
- 1:05:24Thanks for watching. See you next week.