Latest / The Vegan Report / Why Chickens Don't Belong in your Backyard.
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, this is Ryan and you are listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Today, a solo episode. I
- 0:08don't record many solo episodes, but recently
- 0:12I got into the rabbit hole of the backyard eggs
- 0:16debate and felt compelled to offer my take. It
- 0:22seems every vegan influencer has given it a go.
- 0:26It is framed in one simple question. Are backyard
- 0:31eggs ethical or not? Or can you still call yourself
- 0:37vegan if you eat backyard eggs, eggs from your
- 0:41backyard hen? Now, that is my problem right there.
- 0:46The very framing of this debate. While we are
- 0:51wasting time debating the French philosophical
- 0:54issue of backyard eggs, we are missing out on
- 0:59an opportunity to denounce the very legality
- 1:02of owning backyard chickens. Under our watch,
- 1:07without much pushback, we have let states and
- 1:11municipalities, suburbs and even important urban
- 1:15centers change zoning laws to legalize backyard
- 1:20chickens and other forms of livestock farming.
- 1:25Let me read you something Katie Shimormino has
- 1:29written on her very popular blog, The Chicken
- 1:32Chick. As of 2011, 90 % of US cities allowed
- 1:40raising of backyard chickens, including New York,
- 1:44Denver, and Los Angeles. In fact, a follower
- 1:48of mine on Facebook kept chickens on the veranda
- 1:51of his Manhattan's Upper West Side apartment
- 1:55in a custom -built coop that was included as
- 2:00a selling feature for a $1 .2 million asking
- 2:05price. She adds, Sadly, many municipalities still
- 2:11don't get it, including mine until very recently.
- 2:17Over a period of several years, I defended two
- 2:21cease and desist letters and a lawsuit brought
- 2:25by the towns seeking to force me to get rid of
- 2:28my chickens. I ultimately beat City Hall and,
- 2:33with the lawsuit in the rearview mirror, I led
- 2:37the charge to legalize chickens in my town, succeeding
- 2:41in spite of persistent political Now, Katie,
- 2:48you should know that it's not just politicians
- 2:51that oppose backyard chickens. Their constituents
- 2:55do not like the idea either. According to a 2013
- 3:00USDA study, only 4 out of 10 respondents were
- 3:06in favor of allowing chickens in their communities
- 3:10and would not mind if their neighbors owned chickens.
- 3:14An understandable position, given that backyard
- 3:18chickens can be very noisy and the source of
- 3:24just foul odors. Also, over half of respondents,
- 3:3055 .6%, believed that chickens in urban areas
- 3:36will lead to more illnesses in humans. Oh, and
- 3:41that is one frightening prospect. I remember
- 3:44raising this issue with Colin, a microbiologist,
- 3:48and one of the first guests of my show, I think.
- 3:52from episode two of the Vegan Report. And Liz
- 3:56White, the leader of the Animal Protection Party
- 3:59of Canada, take a listen to the scary things
- 4:02they had to say. They detect which ones are the
- 4:07males and they throw them into a wood chipper.
- 4:10I mean, the male chickens are just shredded to
- 4:14pieces from day one. And I don't think people
- 4:20realize that that's 50 % of the chicken population.
- 4:23So even if you're going with the backyard chicken
- 4:25thing, you're still killing a lot of chickens.
- 4:29From the get -go, yes. From the start, before
- 4:33you even purchase that chicken. For every one
- 4:35chicken you purchase, another one has already
- 4:38died. And I think even then, we've had a lot
- 4:46of... with disease outbreaks. I do definitely
- 4:53foresee the... I wouldn't be surprised if one
- 4:57of these days there's a city that does allow
- 4:59backyard chickens that says that we need to...
- 5:02Everybody who has a chicken, you need to call
- 5:04them because we have a huge avian influenza outbreak.
- 5:08A lot of these larger chicken facilities are
- 5:11huge areas where... these diseases can proliferate.
- 5:18And that will absolutely spread into these neighborhood
- 5:21backyard chickens. And, you know, I've heard
- 5:27some instances of avian influenza jumping from
- 5:32poultry to humans. I think as time goes on, we're
- 5:38going to see more and more cases of that. And
- 5:41we're going to see a lot of instances where that
- 5:44happens, where people do have backyard chickens.
- 5:47I think it's going to be a huge, huge thing.
- 5:52Huge problem, yes. And then, of course, they
- 5:55will have to get rid of them, not in the most
- 6:00human way, if there is such a problem. No, they
- 6:04burn them alive. They drown them in foam. They
- 6:10do all sorts of just because you have to kill,
- 6:13you know, countless numbers of chickens. So they
- 6:17do it in the most economically feasible way possible.
- 6:21You know, and that's often by flooding. I think
- 6:25the most common way to do a mass calling is they
- 6:28will flood it with the foam that firefighters
- 6:30use. I can't imagine that's that can't be very
- 6:35enjoyable for the chickens, I'm sure. Yeah, it
- 6:40happens. You know, there were laws passed in
- 6:44many Quebec cities here that authorized people
- 6:49to keep chickens in their backyard. But don't
- 6:55you think there is a risk of contamination with
- 6:57this whole, you know, even influenza thing? Are
- 7:02we playing with fire? by allowing people to keep
- 7:07chickens in their backyard? I actually think
- 7:11we're playing with fire, yes. We were able to
- 7:14get the city of Toronto to back off the bylaw
- 7:16that we're allowing chickens in the backyard.
- 7:19It was a big fight because people wanted those
- 7:21chickens. And, you know, it's like, you think
- 7:25about it, you rent them. You don't take, you
- 7:29know, you rent these little animals and you rent
- 7:33the housing for them. You stick them in your
- 7:36backyard and you love them for a few months until
- 7:38they stop laying, then you send them back. And
- 7:41nobody knows what happens to them. The owners
- 7:44of some of the rented chicken facilities say,
- 7:46oh, well, you know, we take care of your chickens
- 7:49and love them and you'll get your same chickens
- 7:52back. But nobody really knows. And, you know,
- 7:56and beyond that, that avian influenza is very,
- 8:01very... And you can't stop other birds from coming
- 8:07into your backyard with the chickens. And, you
- 8:10know, and that's how the contamination happens.
- 8:13So the city of Toronto decided to ban it altogether,
- 8:16which was great. But many other communities are
- 8:19going on as though nothing's happening. And,
- 8:24you know, the problem with avian influenza is
- 8:26it's transmitting to other animals and it's been
- 8:30transmitted to people. from animals. It hasn't
- 8:35transmitted from people to people yet, but this
- 8:38is a virus that is evolving. And, and somehow
- 8:42we think that it's all good and that nothing's
- 8:47going to happen. And, you know, we could be in
- 8:50a situation like COVID all over again and much
- 8:54more serious because there are no vaccines for
- 8:56it. And, and, and I think we're just playing
- 9:00with fire. So yeah. I would recommend every community
- 9:03in Canada ban backyard chickens. Those backyard
- 9:08chickens are not only a public health crisis
- 9:12in the making, they are also a magnet for wildlife
- 9:16predators. Coyotes, foxes, wolves and bears that
- 9:22can harm your pets, your children and yourself.
- 9:26Because of backyard chickens, those... once rare
- 9:30encounters with wildlife predators have been
- 9:35on the rise. Of course, the bleeding -heart animal
- 9:39lovers we are cannot help but think that those
- 9:44encounters are most often fatal for wildlife.
- 9:49The headline of one Telegram article from June
- 9:52reads, Got a wild animal damaging your property?
- 9:57It's legal to kill it. in Massachusetts. Further,
- 10:02the article specifies some examples of when this
- 10:06law is used include when wild animals damage
- 10:09crops, tree nurseries, or beehives, or when they
- 10:15kill livestock or backyard chickens, which count
- 10:20as property. Apart from wildlife protection,
- 10:24there are many more compelling reasons for animal
- 10:27rights activists to advocate for the criminalization
- 10:31of backyard chickens or any form of urban farming
- 10:36involving livestock. What about the fact that
- 10:40this has become a new lucrative market for big
- 10:44ag? As activists, we try hard to make animal
- 10:48farmers profit margins even thinner than they
- 10:52currently are, but they have found in backyard
- 10:55chickens a new promising source of revenue. According
- 11:00to Fact .MR, the global chicken coop market is
- 11:05estimated to reach a valuation of $997 .7 million
- 11:11in 2025 and further expand to end up at $1 .5
- 11:19$59 billion by the end of 2035. This is a rocket
- 11:26growth. This is money in the pockets of chicken
- 11:31breeders, of insect farmers, yes that's a thing,
- 11:34and insect chicken treats are now in every pet
- 11:38shop you know, food distributors, and more related
- 11:42businesses. In North America, backyard chickens
- 11:46have been commodified to the point of becoming
- 11:49one more item you can purchase online and have
- 11:54shipped by mail to your doorstep. Again, Liz
- 11:58White, leader of the Animal Protection Party
- 12:00of Canada. What is also shocking to many people
- 12:04is that we mail chicks out to people who want
- 12:08backyard chickens. So we put them in Canada Post
- 12:11and mail them. And you know, you look at this
- 12:15whole situation. Not only is it cruel and ridiculous,
- 12:20because the eggs cost about $2 an egg, it is
- 12:26also the cruelty and the insanity of it. What
- 12:30do you mean by mailing chicks? Well, they put
- 12:39them in a box, they seal the box, they put a
- 12:41stamp on it, and they put it in Canada Post.
- 12:47Chicks. Live chicks. And is it only in Ontario,
- 12:52I think? Is there a limit to how many days? It's
- 12:55Canada Post. Canada Post does it. Required to
- 12:58do it. And they could spend days in that box?
- 13:03Well, they indicate that there's live, something
- 13:09live in the box. So it's supposed to get moving.
- 13:13But you can imagine, we had a strike. It happened
- 13:17at a time when the chicks probably aren't moving,
- 13:19but we had a strike. If that had happened in
- 13:22the summertime, the chicks would have died. They
- 13:25would have simply starved to death or suffocated.
- 13:29And so, you know, you look at this thing and
- 13:34you think, that's just cruelty. There's no way
- 13:39around it. You can't do this. And yet it's accepted
- 13:42as a... As a standard way to get chicks. We've
- 13:50tried to fight it, but we haven't been successful
- 13:53at this point. It's pretty shocking what we do
- 13:57to animals, isn't it? Add to that how chickens
- 14:01are being neglected and abandoned by their owners.
- 14:06We've been hearing about stories of cruelty against
- 14:10cats and dogs for more than a century. The SPCA
- 14:14is 200 years old and we still need it. Do you
- 14:19think the general public treats pet chickens
- 14:22any better? Or a better question, are they even
- 14:26able to care decently for chickens? And the answer
- 14:32is a resounding no. Because in most cases, they
- 14:36do not even have access to veterinary healthcare,
- 14:41which is the bare minimum a responsible owner
- 14:45should be able to provide. I live in a place
- 14:49where it is legal to keep backyard chickens.
- 14:53It has been legal for years now. But the closest
- 14:56veterinary clinic that accepts chickens is hours
- 15:01away. I called the biggest. Veterinary Hospital
- 15:05in the province of Quebec to get some more information.
- 15:10They're located in a city called Saint -Hyacinthe.
- 15:14Take a listen. Welcome to the Centre Hospitalier
- 15:18Universitaire Vétérinaire de l 'Université de
- 15:21Montréal located in Saint -Hyacinthe. For an
- 15:24emergency concerning a dog, a cat, or an exotic
- 15:27animal, dial 1. Wait while I transfer your call.
- 15:32So, in this case, chickens are considered an
- 15:35exotic animal. Oh, yes, hello. Hi, my name is
- 15:48Ryan and I'm calling to get some information
- 15:50about the service you could provide for backyard
- 15:53chickens. I can try and help you since I have
- 16:01chickens myself, but this is not something we
- 16:06do very often. Okay, because I was referred to
- 16:11you, I was told that... Yes, everybody refers
- 16:15us everything because everybody thinks we do
- 16:18everything, but we don't. I can help you. Of
- 16:23course. So I guess my first question is, do you
- 16:27know of any veterinarian that specializes in
- 16:30backyard chickens? There's no specialty for that,
- 16:36but there are some vets that do take care of
- 16:41them. Like you want them to come to your house?
- 16:44Well, sure. Or I can travel to them. Okay. And
- 16:52where are you located? I'm located in... Okay.
- 17:01Okay, there's nothing really quite close to you.
- 17:28Yeah, Sherbrooke is like maybe three hours away
- 17:31from me. Yeah. I have some, like, on the north
- 17:38shore, like the Garda, you would have to take
- 17:40the Travertine. That's way too far. Laval. Is
- 17:55Shawinigan closer? I mean, sure. Like I said,
- 18:01there's nothing quite close to you. What seems
- 18:05to be the problem with your chicken? Well, one
- 18:09of the chicken, the hen, I think she has what
- 18:13they call egg binding. And I don't know what
- 18:19to do. I read online that you can put them in
- 18:22like a bath. with some Epsom salt, and I did
- 18:28that. And I don't know how many times we can
- 18:31do that and if there is another solution. There
- 18:38is no easy solution for egg binding. Let me just
- 18:42check. I have one resource. No problem. Please
- 18:57take your time. Okay, so it says warm bath and
- 19:05you can apply KY jelly on the clo... In French
- 19:10it's cloac. Yeah. Where the eggs come out from.
- 19:16I'm trying to make a shot about that. And do
- 19:21you feel the egg when you palpate next to the
- 19:24cloac? I did not... ...examinate the hen. Okay,
- 19:33you can try and give her a little bit of water
- 19:36with a dropper or syringe, very slowly, so as
- 19:40not to drown her. You can apply QI jelly to the
- 19:44vent to help lubricate the vent to ease the passage,
- 19:51if it's that. No oil. But KY is okay. It says
- 19:57to not massage the vent or the abdomen so as
- 20:02not to break the eggshell. Put her in a crate
- 20:07in a dark, quiet room. Oh, yeah. Okay. But if
- 20:17it's really that, you're going to have to take
- 20:22the road if you... want to save the chicken.
- 20:28They can die from egg binding if it's that. Yeah.
- 20:35But there's no vet clinic really close to you
- 20:39guys. Yes, I understand. It's surprising because
- 20:44it's legal here to have backyard chickens, but
- 20:47then there are no veterinarians that will accept
- 20:51a chicken. that do backyard chickens. A lot of
- 20:58doctors will do commercial chickens. But these
- 21:07usually will not do backyard chickens because
- 21:10of biosecurity. So it's unfortunately quite hard
- 21:13to find doctors that will treat backyard chickens.
- 21:17Just like exotic animals like rabbits and ferrets
- 21:20and stuff like that. And it's even harder when
- 21:25you're in a region where there are less vets
- 21:30to start with. I see. And am I the only one in
- 21:36that situation? Nope. Nope? Nope. No, I do have
- 21:41backyard chicken and I have no vet for my chicken.
- 21:43I do it by myself. Okay, so we're many people
- 21:47in that situation. I heard about vets that can
- 21:51travel to your house, but how much does that
- 21:57cost? And is that service available, and how
- 22:00much does that cost? We don't do home visits
- 22:04here. Right now, me, I'm an employee of the small
- 22:08animal clinic, so we do see some chicken inside,
- 22:14but there is no... but it's about $300 for the
- 22:27exam plus the care. I'm not sure if the doctor
- 22:31I have today does see chickens. I'm not sure
- 22:35I would have to check, but we don't do home visit.
- 22:38The department that do home visit is the department
- 22:41for the cows, but I have no information about
- 22:46that. I would have to, you would have to call
- 22:50back most probably tomorrow to speak with the
- 22:53technician that works in. department okay okay
- 22:58so I will monitor the situation and see yes thank
- 23:05you so much for your support no no not a problem
- 23:10I understand thank you have a nice day bye bye
- 23:14and then there's the abandonment issue Although
- 23:18hens are legal to keep, not the same could be
- 23:22said about roosters. And since differentiating
- 23:26the two sexes is very difficult, many owners
- 23:30find themselves mistakenly raising unwanted roosters.
- 23:35There's also the fact that hens stop laying eggs
- 23:39after two years, which makes them automatically
- 23:42undesirable. What happens to all those unwanted
- 23:47roosters and undesirable hens? Well, Sanctuary
- 23:52founders can answer that question. Listen to
- 23:55Catherine, the founder of Safe Sanctuary, which
- 23:58closed its doors recently. In the recent years,
- 24:04many cities across Quebec legalized having backyard
- 24:09chickens. Did you feel like this was a terrible
- 24:14decision from them because i bet you know it
- 24:19increased the the number of um people wanting
- 24:24to the number of chickens and roosters that um
- 24:28you know are abandoned and need a home i was
- 24:33furious because i thought it was another um way
- 24:40and that came from the government's encouragement
- 24:42to say yeah get a couple of chicken you know
- 24:44to keep you busy and i'll get that drink and
- 24:47um knowing how people are they're fun it's interesting
- 24:54for the first couple of whatever weeks months
- 24:56and then what do you do with them in the winter
- 24:59what do we do with them on the long term oh we
- 25:01don't lay eggs anymore what do we do with them
- 25:03we bring them to the sanctuary we leave them
- 25:06in the street I thought it was solely responsible
- 25:09to encourage people to have small rooster coops
- 25:14or to have chicken coops in their backyard because
- 25:21it was just having like a toy to play with. And
- 25:26it wasn't on my turn and it happened. We had
- 25:29tons and tons of requests to take in hens. And
- 25:33roosters are another problem. are not allowed
- 25:38by most municipalities. People that have a chicken
- 25:43coop could have a rooster to go with the hens.
- 25:46They're great protectors. The hens love to have
- 25:51a protector with them. But they're not allowed.
- 25:54People are not allowed. So that's another point
- 25:59against roosters. People think they're aggressive.
- 26:04They're not aggressive. They actually, one or
- 26:06two, they usually want to be held. People don't
- 26:09believe them. But bruceros have a big problem
- 26:15on their hands. Actually, I'll tell you a story
- 26:18about it. It happened this week. I got fooled.
- 26:23I'm sorry to say. I had a young man calling me
- 26:27that he had a hand in his apartment and he had
- 26:31to place her. because the owner was going to
- 26:35throw him out in the street. So long story, he
- 26:42was supposed to bring me her in the afternoon.
- 26:45He ended up bringing her at 10 o 'clock in the
- 26:47evening. And I usually go to bed at 8 .30. So
- 26:50by 10 o 'clock, I was really tired. I placed
- 26:53her in one of our chicken coop that we have.
- 26:56And I didn't really look at her. She looked a
- 27:03little bit different, but, and it's only in the
- 27:07morning that I looked at her and realized it
- 27:10wasn't a her, it's a him. So I now have, after
- 27:13having placed everybody, all my roosters, all
- 27:16everybody, I now have another rooster to place.
- 27:20I can't believe I got taken in because he knew
- 27:24it was a rooster. I'm sure he got kicked. He
- 27:27was going to get kicked out because that rooster.
- 27:29That is it. We will go every morning. And not
- 27:35just morning. So I have another brew city place.
- 27:40Lastly, if you needed any more reason to support
- 27:44a ban on backyard chickens, let me offer this
- 27:49opinion. I believe that the backyard chickens
- 27:53economy is doing the devil's work. of banalizing
- 27:58animal exploitation, promoting the notion that
- 28:01animal exploitation can be humane and sustainable,
- 28:05reinforcing the status of chickens as egg layers
- 28:10and meat, and restimulating people's appetite
- 28:15for chicken products. In summary, I believe it
- 28:20is great PR for the poultry industry. Does eating
- 28:26eggs from your backyard chickens vegan? This
- 28:30question just accepts the premise that owning
- 28:34backyard chickens in the first place is acceptable.
- 28:38Maybe if you own lots of lands in a rural area
- 28:42where farming already takes place, but this idea
- 28:47that vegans from the city or the suburbs can
- 28:51totally adopt rescue hands put them in their
- 28:55small backyards, and in fact we should give that
- 28:58a cool name like micro -sanctuary, is totally
- 29:01wrong. It means we have accepted that this is
- 29:06the new normal, that this cultural battle was
- 29:10lost, that the Katie's of this world have won,
- 29:13despite the popular rejection of this practice.
- 29:18To end this episode, I still want to give a direct
- 29:22answer to the question of backyard eggs being
- 29:26vegan or not. For that, let me pass the mic to
- 29:30Nigel Osborne and Julian, the founder and executive
- 29:35director of egg -true .com. Take a listen. When
- 29:40it comes to eggs, what happens more is that people
- 29:44come forward and say, oh, but I have backyard
- 29:45chickens and I'm nice to the chickens, so I have
- 29:47good eggs. So that comes out first. And that
- 29:52really isn't helping in our argument because
- 29:54from our point of view, it's still exploiting
- 29:57the animals. You still use an animal that has
- 29:59been bred to lay eggs more than is necessary
- 30:03for them in nature to keep their group and their
- 30:06species alive. So you're still abusing them and
- 30:09you're still helping the egg industry making
- 30:11eggs look natural and nice and cute little food
- 30:15for the cute little hen. Julie touched on backyard.
- 30:19And I think that's probably the one scenario
- 30:25where you'll get people advocating for more than
- 30:32anything else in terms of this humane sort of
- 30:36scenario. And, you know, look, do I think a hen
- 30:43living in a small backyard with a coop and places
- 30:47they can... you know, dust bathe and pack off
- 30:50the ground and walk around that are yes, inevitably
- 30:53going to lay an egg and the person who owns the
- 30:56home is going to eat that egg. Is that better
- 30:59than, you know, being in a battery cage? Yeah.
- 31:04I mean, let's be honest. It is better. But again,
- 31:09as I may have alluded to earlier, you know, we
- 31:13can often discuss the issue of treatment. And
- 31:16that's what this is about. When you bring up
- 31:18the issue of humane, it is an issue of treatment,
- 31:22which means regardless of the scenario, you are
- 31:28accepting that treating an animal as a commodity
- 31:33is using them as a resource for the sole benefit
- 31:36or utility of us humans. You've already crossed
- 31:40that line. And now you're into this discussion
- 31:43about treatment. The issue of use is really,
- 31:51you know, the treatment compounds the initial
- 31:53harm. The primary harm is use. And like Julie
- 31:58said, you know, yeah, they're in a backyard,
- 32:02but they're still going to be laying an egg every
- 32:0424 to 30 hours because they have 10 ,000 years
- 32:07of human intervention acting as an artificial
- 32:10agent for natural selection. And here we are
- 32:13in the 21st century. They're laying 350 up to
- 32:17500 eggs in 18 months, which is, which is anyways,
- 32:22it's, it's, it's, it's insanity. And, you know,
- 32:26I have this discussion on social media with people
- 32:28sometimes. And I always say to people, why did
- 32:32you get a backyard hen? Is it for you or is it
- 32:36for the hen? If it's for the hen, as you say,
- 32:39then my recommendation is, is to find an avian
- 32:43vet. take your, your hand to the avian vet and
- 32:47have, um, a subcutaneous hormonal implant and
- 32:52they're readily available or so in Canada, in
- 32:55the U S there's issues in the U S with the FDA
- 32:57and limitations on these hormonal implants, but
- 33:01they will prevent that hand from laying eggs
- 33:04for months and months. It isn't cheap, but you
- 33:07know, I mean, We all know a visit to the vet
- 33:10with our cat or dog can end up in three or four
- 33:12hundred dollars just like that. So this is really
- 33:14no different. And that will result in egg laying
- 33:18cessation. And you talk to people on farm sanctuaries.
- 33:22Where they do this to prevent egg impaction,
- 33:25to limit the risks of ovarian cancer, which I
- 33:28forgot to mention in the life of a hen. Julie
- 33:30mentioned it earlier. So thank you for reminding
- 33:33me on that. Ovarian cancer. They have the highest
- 33:35rates of spontaneously occurring ovarian cancer
- 33:38of any species in the world. And that is because
- 33:41of their manipulated reproductive systems. So
- 33:44this implant will help them. eliminate egg laying
- 33:49for months on an end it has to be renewed every
- 33:51so often but if the hen and their welfare is
- 33:55a primary consideration which they always say
- 33:57they are and it's really not they're after the
- 34:00eggs without the guilt they want guilt -free
- 34:02eggs but it's you know and farm sanctuary workers
- 34:06will tell you time and time again the difference
- 34:08in the animal's behavior personality is dramatically
- 34:13is altered once these hormonal implants are put
- 34:17in because this constant laying, this constant
- 34:21hormonal activity in their bodies to lay eggs
- 34:24almost daily takes a toll. I mean, and look at
- 34:27a pregnant human being, a woman, look what she
- 34:29goes through in nine months of gestation. Look
- 34:32at the postpartum depression sometimes that they
- 34:34can endure after giving birth. So look at all
- 34:37the hormonal flux that goes on in a human being's
- 34:41body, woman's body during that period of time.
- 34:45Think about it for a small animal who's doing
- 34:48it every 30, 36 hours for the rest of their lives
- 34:52potentially. So to stop that, would really be
- 34:56to the benefit from their from a health perspective
- 34:58and from their own um well -being so um the answer
- 35:03is no there is no humane scenario it isn't humane
- 35:08and you're still crossing that that in what is
- 35:11in my mind an impenetrable moral barrier with
- 35:15you cannot cross that line into accepting the
- 35:18idea that we can use other living beings for
- 35:21for our own uh benefit Thank you everyone for
- 35:24listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 35:27podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 35:30more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 35:34so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 35:37for a new episode.