Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Bonus: Buckeyes land big offensive line commit out of the transfer portal
Transcript
- 0:01Hey everybody, Tony Gerdeman here got a bonus episode for you. This is
- 0:06Mark Kiler and myself on Mark's Skull Session Recruiting podcast discussing the commitment of San
- 0:15Diego State offensive lineman Josh Simmons via the Transfer Portal on Sunday, Mark,
- 0:22can I talk about what the addition means? Where he might end up?
- 0:25Did the Buckeyes just land a starting offensive lineman? Stuff like that? Where
- 0:30he might you know, as he better at left tackle the right tackle.
- 0:33We discussed that and more so give it a listen. I would also suggest
- 0:39subscribing to the Skull Session Recruiting podcast as well, available on all of your
- 0:44platforms, just like this one. Thank you and Tom and I will be
- 0:48back Tuesday and Thursday probably for some shows. Definitely a couple of shows this
- 0:52week, if not more so. Thank you all for tuning in. Hello
- 0:57everyone, Welcome to the Skull Session Recruiting podcast, brought to you by Buckeye
- 1:00Huddle dot Com. I am Mark Giveler. We've got a first timer,
- 1:06I think in Skull Session recruiting podcast history. We've got Tony Gerdeman of Buckeye
- 1:10Huddle dot Com here. How are we doing Tony, I'm doing well,
- 1:15Mark, thanks for having me. It's about time you have a recruiting expert
- 1:18on the show. Yes, uh, you know, we've had maybe too
- 1:22much Kevin noon On, you know, just not just not as just not
- 1:26up to snuff. Get the real recruiting expert on staff up here. You
- 1:30know, we'll get Alex on here eventually, see if see if he can
- 1:34take the crown. But uh yeah, so, yes, we have Buckeye
- 1:38Weekly Star Tony Gerdeman in the house. Um, this is our special commitment
- 1:45edition. We got a big news here on a Sunday evening, I guess
- 1:52late Sunday afternoon. We'll call it. Since we're not like ninety years old.
- 1:56But Ohio State lands San Diego State offensive tackle transfer target Josh Simmons out
- 2:04of the transfer portal. Simmons was on his official visit this weekend. We
- 2:08were hearing good things coming into the visit. It was kind of one of
- 2:12those deals where Ohio State. As much as Simmons feeling out Ohio State,
- 2:15I just think Ohio State wanted to make sure you know, Simmons was kind
- 2:19of the right fit for them. Looks like a visit one great obviously,
- 2:23committed Tony definite starter, maybe starter. I mean, how how do we
- 2:30look at this seventy thirty definite to maybe? I think my biggest question is
- 2:38could he possibly play left tackle? And then you move Josh Fryer over to
- 2:43right tackle where he's as I assume he's better at right tackle. Joss Fryer
- 2:46better at right tackle than left tackle. But you've got an established starter.
- 2:53Let's say Joss Simmons with the twelve starts as a red shirt freshman last year,
- 2:58the kind of experienced that Ohio State frankly doesn't have on the offensive line.
- 3:01So they needed to go and find or wanted to go and find and
- 3:07definite starter. I mean, I'm I'm going to if you're asking me to
- 3:15lay some odds of the three right if we throw them into mix it right
- 3:17tackle with Zen Moholski and Taker Shabola, I think Josh Simmons is a smart
- 3:23money right now. I agree. I mean, I think obviously they want
- 3:30a starting caliber guy. They've been searching for one for for months, had
- 3:35some guys either they decided not to go on, or had some other guys
- 3:39they weren't able to corral. I mean, at this point of the process.
- 3:45You're now you're through the end of spring now, so this, you
- 3:49know, Simmons only gets you know, he'll get summer workouts of course,
- 3:52but you know fall camp is going to be kind of his time to shine.
- 3:55I don't know that you're doing this unless you're expecting a starter out of
- 3:59it. I just because he's not going to push the competition during the spring
- 4:05because it springs over. Yeah, And we know when they do go to
- 4:10the portal, they're trying to get a starter. They're worried about the position
- 4:15that they have, and so they're trying to get a starter. And to
- 4:18hear to be in the room when Ryan Day is talking about still having concerns
- 4:21about the offensive line after spring and knowing that the right tackle watching the right
- 4:28tackle position to have issues all spring. You saw it as well with the
- 4:31past rushers that in Ohio State had. I think there's a sizeable concern.
- 4:35And so they go to the portal. They get somebody with experience, somebody
- 4:39that justin Fry knows about, somebody that you know, was a legitimate recruiting
- 4:46prospect, four star guy, and you know, I don't know if it's
- 4:48a capital capital letter offers from places like Georgia and stuff like that, you
- 4:54know, being a California kid, but you can run down his recruiting profile
- 4:58and see miss in Georgia, Oklahoma, places usc offers from places like that,
- 5:06and so choosing to go to San Diego State, it's it's an interesting
- 5:10decision. But now he's clearly ready to take that next step, and I
- 5:15think Ohio State's a pretty good, pretty good option for him. And I
- 5:19kind of assumed once Ohio State finished up with Spring that there would be some
- 5:25alerts being put out by Ohio State saying, hey, we could we could
- 5:29use any kind of offensive tackle, right tackle, whatever, and you look
- 5:33at what else is out there, and I'd say, of this second wave,
- 5:39this Spring wave, I don't know if there's anybody better than Josh Simmons
- 5:45or you know, he's he's on the level of the best guys out there.
- 5:47I don't know if that means he's great. It just means this is
- 5:50kind of what you're picking through. This is kind of, you know,
- 5:54what you have to deal with in the Spring. That being said, the
- 5:56people at San Diego State seemed to love him, and I know a lot
- 5:59of other people did, and they see him as they saw him as a
- 6:01pro prospect, and you know, I assume Ohio State does as well because
- 6:05they're bringing him in. Yeah, I think it's important to kind of lay
- 6:12the foundation here. I would talk to Josh before his visit. We were
- 6:15speaking about his interest in Ohio State, and you know, he started talking
- 6:18about Justin Frye. Justin Frye was the offensive line coach at e c LA
- 6:24when Simmons was coming out of high school and he went to Hillis High School
- 6:27out in the San Diego area, which I believe is the same high school
- 6:30at Reggie Bush comes from. So that's why he ended up at San Diego
- 6:33State. He's from that area, so he just wanted us. He stayed
- 6:36close to home. It wasn't a thing where he was from Texas and picked
- 6:41you know, San Diego State over Michigan and Georgia and all those programs.
- 6:45So he was a very highly recruited kid. He had over thirty offers.
- 6:48It's a four star prospect, but he, like I said, he was,
- 6:53he camped with UCLA and they offered him. But he worked that day
- 6:58with Justin Frye and he even told me he said there were things, some
- 7:00techniques I learned that day from Justin Frye that I carried with me to San
- 7:03Diego State. So you have to give Fry some you know. However,
- 7:09this turns out this was a Justin Frye production here. I mean, if
- 7:13this works out really well, you give Fry all the credit in the world
- 7:15for this, because this is a guy who used his prior relationship with Josh
- 7:19to get him in the fold, and I'm sure it was pounding the table
- 7:24for him there in the room as they try and pick through some of the
- 7:28portal names. So we're this was kind of the first year the twenty twenty
- 7:34twenty three kind of recruiting class and everything else where or twenty twenty four recruiting
- 7:39class where Fry gets to kind of put his fingerprints all over things. Tony,
- 7:45I mean, so, what have you, I guess seen so far
- 7:48from him as someone who I know likes to watch all the action on the
- 7:53recruiting trail. Yeah, it's it's unfortunately he's had to work from behind so
- 8:00for so much time, and then to actually see him, you know,
- 8:03you're seeing a lot of people talking about him. But then at the end
- 8:09of the end of the day, it still comes down to who can you
- 8:11land, because you see what happened with the defensive line last year, like
- 8:15Ohio State had their pick of all of these five star defensive ends. But
- 8:18at the end of the day, you can recruit, and you can recruit
- 8:20and you can build relationships, but sometimes the NIL just takes over. And
- 8:24so if Ohio staking at the nil part situated, which sounds like they are,
- 8:30and the recruiting situation with Justin Frye, it seems like he could start
- 8:35to really build some things here at Ohio State. And he's the kind of
- 8:41guy that can relate to guys still because he's still pretty young himself. And
- 8:46it helps when there's a good Ohio class then you can build some momentum there
- 8:50in Ohio has that and you know, in fact, I'd say it helps
- 8:52when you have a good Midwestern class and Ian Moore being part of that.
- 8:56In Indiana, of course, Justin Frye, being an Indiana guy, likes
- 9:01to recruit Indiana guys as well. And you look at Ohio State Josh fry
- 9:07Josh Fryer right there as an Indiana guy. So it's it's getting back to
- 9:13where it should be. At Ohio State, I think on the offensive line,
- 9:16but again it gets bolstered by the Ohio recruiting. It reminds me of
- 9:20the Thad five back in the day, like that Thad models recruiting. Even
- 9:24aside from that class, a lot of his great recruiting was because Ohio and
- 9:28Indiana were very strong and that's where he had his biggest ties. But I
- 9:31think with the Ohio State, your best offensive lines are always going to come
- 9:35when you have good in state recruits. But then to be also having a
- 9:41California connections to be able to go into the portal and get adjust Simmons,
- 9:45I think that's a strength and it kind of reminds me of I think some
- 9:48things that maybe Larry Johnson and Tony maybe Tony Alfred have said in the past,
- 9:52where you recruit these guys for so long and the guys that you miss
- 9:56you can still keep in touch with. And this was years before or the
- 10:00portal like now, it's like, don't ever cut anybody off that you've recruited.
- 10:05Basically like oh, I always send you know, text at least once
- 10:07a week. You know, if if you see somebody and I wonder and
- 10:13we can probably talk to Mark Antonia about this. But I wonder if they
- 10:16have a scale of guys that they lose out on and recruiting that they like
- 10:20on a scale one at ten, that guy's probably an eight. He's going
- 10:22to be in New Portal at some point, and you just, you know
- 10:26what, touch base with this guy a little bit because I think when I
- 10:30think we both see guys that you figure, yeah, he's he's signing with
- 10:33this team right now, but in two or three years and he's going to
- 10:37be in New Portal. Yeah. And I've I've told this story before.
- 10:41I'm not going to get us too far off topic here, but I have
- 10:46I think it is somewhat on topic because we are talking about the portal here
- 10:48with the Portal edition of Josh Simmons. But we were on the road last
- 10:52spring. We do our Southern Swing, which is coming up, so get
- 10:56on Buckeye Huddle dot com and get ready for that here soon. But we
- 11:00were doing our tour through the South and we were at a high school in
- 11:03Georgia and an assistant coach from a G five school walked in and I'm like,
- 11:09well, you know, I was asking him, who's here to see
- 11:11and he was reeling off names that like like Kudo, who's he's down here
- 11:16in the Georgia area to see And he was reeling off names that like we
- 11:20were going to see two And I was like, I'm not trying to be
- 11:28like rude here, but like, you know, like are you are you
- 11:31actually in the game for these guys or any He said, Look, he
- 11:35said, I've got to let He pulled out this list. He's like,
- 11:39I got the top fifty linebackers in the country, and I'm recruiting all of
- 11:46them. And we're probably not going to get many, if any of them,
- 11:50but I know half of these guys are probably going to be in the
- 11:52portal in two years, and so I'm recruiting all of them right now so
- 11:56that when they do hit the portal, I'm gonna be there to swim been.
- 12:01And so this is trickling down obviously. This is you know, so
- 12:03you've got you know, American Athletic Conference and Conference USA, You've got those
- 12:11assistants on the road recruiting four and five star kids, knowing they're not going
- 12:16to get them coming out of high school, but just to get the relationships
- 12:20in place when when it's portal time, it's crazy. And now you have
- 12:24also the trickle up basically from San Diego State to Ohio State, and it's
- 12:31just it's another avenue to bolster your roster. And if you ignore it,
- 12:35Dabo Sweeney, if you ignore it, then you'll see that you'll you'll start
- 12:39to take a down turn. Now there's different levels of we're only going to
- 12:45you know rely, so you know, rely as much as possible into portal.
- 12:48I think, obviously recruiting is still the best way to build your program
- 12:52is through the high schools, but I think the portal. I like the
- 12:56way Ohio State uses the portal to just fill out some some flat spots and
- 13:01some blank spots rather than you know, you can be mercenary, like with
- 13:05Alabama, where they shouldn't have as many flat spots as they've had if they're
- 13:09recruiting, and yet they you know, to go go get a Jimire Gibbs
- 13:13from Georgia tack or Jamison and Williams from Ohio State like or even a Tyler
- 13:18Buckney from Notre Dame. Should you really be having those kinds of issues?
- 13:24Yeah, that's a good question. I mean, if you look at it,
- 13:28I guess I guess every school at some point has has a hole to
- 13:31fill. You know, we've seen a high state go with Jonah Jackson.
- 13:35You know, the Buckner thing I thought was kind of in a different league
- 13:37of its own. I thought there was you know, as someone who was
- 13:41pretty high on Jamison Williams coming out of high school and saw him flash at
- 13:45times at Ohio State, that kind of made sense to me. And but
- 13:48yeah, I mean there are times where it looks like a program's really reaching
- 13:54and I'll you know, the other the flip side of this is, you
- 13:58know what we're seeing happened today and what we've kind of at Michigan State,
- 14:03it's kind of like, look, did they reap what they sewed there?
- 14:07Because i mean, melt Tucker gets that job and just goes out and it's
- 14:11like thirty mercenaries is first year. So it's like it's one of those things
- 14:13where you know, if if you go out and hire all these mercenaries,
- 14:16they are mercenaries, Like, don't be shocked if they you know, if
- 14:20they can find a better situation, if they're going to leave you in a
- 14:22year or two. So you're playing with fire a little bit and for to
- 14:28lose productive players, unlike the last day is I mean, that's almost it
- 14:35feels purposeful on the players part to leave this day in the process, like
- 14:39I am doing this on purpose, and you know what is the messaging there?
- 14:46Yeah, that's a good point that I hadn't really thought about, because
- 14:48I can't imagine all of a sudden they woke up this morning and said,
- 14:52hey, I think I'm going to transfer that. It had to be brewing
- 14:54for a good little bit, so that's interesting. And then, of course
- 15:01there's no tampering going on, so I'm sure that way into it at all
- 15:03either that no one would tamper, although wouldn't it be a very rivalry like
- 15:11to wait until the last day and then throw some money at your rivals best
- 15:16players That way, you know you can bring them on over. And now
- 15:20now you've left your your rivals without a quarterback and a receiver. Although I
- 15:26keep seeing rumblings that maybe Peyton Thorne had lost the jobber was losing the job
- 15:31in the spring, which would shock me considering he's a two year starter and
- 15:33I think a pretty decent player. But I obviously haven't paid too much attention
- 15:37it's going on any slanting until today yeah, always interesting in the portal um.
- 15:43I kind the last thing I think we'll talk about here. You know,
- 15:46I wanted to get back to a point you're making earlier about Josh Simmons
- 15:50where he would fit into this line. Should he You know, I could
- 15:56argue us both ways. I mean, should he stay right tackle and get
- 16:00him in his comfort zone and let Fryar continue to work where he's been working
- 16:07all spring? Or do you get Friar back into a spot that he did
- 16:14very well in spot duty last year? He started right? Did he started
- 16:19a game or two Duan got injured? Douan was battling an injury there for
- 16:22a while and we didn't really notice a drop off. So do you get
- 16:30Friar back to where he's comfortable and then give Simmons the summer to work on
- 16:34his pass sets from the left side instead of the right side and hope that
- 16:38works. I mean I could go either way on that. I think it
- 16:44depends on how well as they've watched the film Friar graded out the spring.
- 16:48I think that will play into it now. Ryan day after Spring, after
- 16:52the spring game, didn't want to say that Josh Fryer had locked down that
- 16:55position. Even though he was the only first first stringer that we ever saw
- 17:00really at left tackle. But yeah, it's and how long do you go
- 17:06with whatever you choose? Like how long in fall camp do you like we're
- 17:11gonna be Like, Okay, let's just continue to give Josh Friar time.
- 17:14He's not where we want him yet, but maybe with two weeks in fall
- 17:17camp he will be. But by that point, you know, can you
- 17:22go that long? How long do you go with m say you want to
- 17:25try Josh Simmons at left tackle? How long do you go there? And
- 17:27so it almost feels like this decision has to be made before camp ever,
- 17:32you know, even for you know, summer workouts so that guys can get
- 17:34you know, doing their you know, their drops and things like that from
- 17:38their footed position right or left. So I think this has to be made
- 17:44this summer, and it, you know, it just depends on how they
- 17:47feel about Josh Friar at left tackle and whether they see was was the trajectory
- 17:52going up or had he just stayed the same throughout spring? And I think
- 17:56if you just stayed throughout the same throughout spring, do you expect him to
- 18:00stay the same throughout Paul camp, it is that same good enough and do
- 18:03they think it would be better than Josh Simmons at left tackle. So still
- 18:08some things to be sorted out as well, but I think they'd love for
- 18:12Josh Frior to be able to handle left tackle. That way, Josh Simmons
- 18:17can can just continue to blossom. But being a richer freshman going to a
- 18:21retcher softmore year, he's going to grow anyway, because that's the first year
- 18:26of starting to the second year of starting. It's a different world. We've
- 18:29seen that throughout the years at Ohio State. And maybe if we do get
- 18:34to talk to the Ohio State coaches yet this spring, I'm sure that will
- 18:38be one of the topics brought up. Um. I think they have to
- 18:45cross train them in the summer at least, you know whatever you're obviously you're
- 18:49giving them the workout plans. I know, like it's not like they can
- 18:52they can really be out. I know they have guys that can be out
- 18:55there kind of working them out, but I would be telling them like equal
- 18:59equal right and the left side and kind of see when they come into fall
- 19:03camp, you get an idea of like, Okay, I've been doing this
- 19:06all summer, like who looks the most comfortable on do something like that and
- 19:11just kind of figure it out. But I think they have to. I
- 19:15mean they cross training. That's not the same thing. This is actually much
- 19:18more difficult than what they do with the receivers. They cross train the receivers
- 19:22defensive tackles too. Yep. So this isn't like unheard of, but it
- 19:29is kind of a tough thing to do when you're everything's like backwards. Yeah,
- 19:36club your right handed, like swing a golf club left handed, and
- 19:38some other buck guys who have had to make the change have made much more
- 19:41crude, uh you know, analogies as to what it's like going from right
- 19:45handed to left handed. But for Jess Freyer, he's that's all he's ever
- 19:51known in his career, going from one side to the other. And that's
- 19:53where we talked about this bring. You know, he's played every position,
- 19:56doesn't matter which side, So it's a lot easier for him. For his
- 19:59Zen Mahall Sky to be a left tackle last year and that's spent his first
- 20:03two years at left tackle. Then to learn and the new handedness of right
- 20:08tackle this spring was more difficult for him because that's the first time he's ever
- 20:14done at Josh Friar. That's why I tend to think you can, as
- 20:17you said, continue to cross train Josh Fire. However, he's a guy
- 20:21that they just wherever they put him last year he did well and he also
- 20:26remember I think he knocked from how he got to start late in the season
- 20:27at right guard and he struggled that first series. They put Josh Fire there
- 20:32and boom, everything was fine. So I mean it seems funny too,
- 20:36not that we're doubting him, but to question whether he can handle left tackle,
- 20:40because all he's ever done, when given an opportunity, has played well.
- 20:42And that goes back to when he was a very young backup and he
- 20:47held his own as this three star throw in from Indiana who just continued to
- 20:53impress. Yeah. I think that's right. I think wherever he settles,
- 21:00they'll be confident with him and he should be able to get the job done.
- 21:04Yeah. I guess, just finally, how big do you think this
- 21:07is getting? Simmons? I think it's huge? Am I overreacting? I
- 21:11Mean I've been scared to death of that right tackle situation all spring? Yeah?
- 21:15No, I think it's it's very big because, for one, it
- 21:18gives them more options, but two, it gives them a starter and not
- 21:22necessarily started for them, but somebody who has started, and now it gives
- 21:26them technically another upper classman. He's going into his third year and he's played,
- 21:30and it's experience, and it's better competition. It's more competition for Zen
- 21:37Moholsky and Taker shot Ball like, those guys can still win a job,
- 21:40but they're gonna have to raise their games up, which is exactly what Justin
- 21:42Frye and Ryan Day wants. So this is this is an addition that you
- 21:48know, it's the raises all boats that kind of tied. And whether he
- 21:52starts or not, I think whoever starts because of this competition will be better
- 21:57than whoever would have started had they that brought in Simmons. All right,
- 22:03Well, another big portal edition for the buck Eyes. That makes two over
- 22:07the weekend. Taiwe alone on campus, still looking a couple. It looks
- 22:11like they're looking at the defense back out of UAB whose name escapes me just
- 22:15released a top six. But Simmons in the fold for the Buckeyes. Oklahoma
- 22:19was his visit last week. Florida was scheduled for next week. Obviously that
- 22:22won't be happening now, so they didn't you know they were. They beat
- 22:26out some some pretty big programs for Simmons and we'll see what they've got here
- 22:30once fall camp opens. But you know, personally, like I said,
- 22:33I think this is pretty important given how that right tackle spot seemed to struggle
- 22:37during spring. So appreciate everyone watching, listening. We will catch you next time.