Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Exploring a Sensory World: From Invertebrates to Vertebrates with Dr. Jorge Molina
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:07Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:24the Human Side, the podcast where we explore
- 0:26how science and human stories connect to make
- 0:29sense to our world. Today, we delve into the
- 0:32fascinating relationship between sensory systems
- 0:34and the natural environment, from the head of
- 0:37an expert who has dedicated his career to understand
- 0:39how organisms as diverse as insects, arachnids,
- 0:43and electric fish perceive and adapt to their
- 0:46environment. Our guest is Dr. Jorge Molina, Associate
- 0:49Professor at the University of Los Andes, Colombia,
- 0:52with an outstanding career in neurobiology and
- 0:55sensory ecology, and a PhD of the University
- 0:58of Göttingen in Germany. His research focuses
- 1:01on how sensory systems allow organisms to survive
- 1:04and thrive their natural habitats. Dr. Molina
- 1:07has made significant contributions to this field
- 1:10and was recently appointed as a corresponding
- 1:13member of the Colombian Academy of Exact Physical
- 1:17and Natural Sciences in recognition of his impact
- 1:20on Colombian science. Behind the laptop is...
- 1:24Dr. Molina combines scientific rigor with a deep
- 1:27respect for biodiversity and local knowledge,
- 1:30offering a unique perspective on the intersection
- 1:32of science, nature, and culture. His approach
- 1:35not only makes us understand how organisms perceive
- 1:38the world, but also applies that knowledge to
- 1:41the conservation and sustainable management of
- 1:44ecosystems. Jorge, thank you for accepting the
- 1:47invitation. No, thank you very much for the invitation,
- 1:50and I am very happy to be able to share with
- 1:52you. I also have to mention that Jorge was my
- 1:55master supervisor. Yes, it's been a while. Well,
- 1:59Jorge, to begin with, we would like to know in
- 2:02general terms what the sensory systems of organisms
- 2:05are and what differences there are between groups
- 2:08of organisms in this system. Yes, I think that
- 2:12when we talk about sensory systems in animals,
- 2:14we humans always take a very anthropocentric
- 2:18position, right? And so we always think of smell,
- 2:21taste. hearing, sight, and touch, especially
- 2:25those of us who are such visual animals. I think
- 2:29that everyone has recognized and talked for a
- 2:31long time about the five sense organs, and sometimes
- 2:35there are comments that some people have a sixth
- 2:37sense because they foresee things that are going
- 2:39to happen and that kind of situation, but in
- 2:42reality nature is full of sixth, seventh, eighth,
- 2:46ninth senses that many of us can't even imagine
- 2:49and that are tremendously spectacular. So, I
- 2:53have always been interested in what I call the
- 2:55traditional sense organs, which are the five
- 2:58we first mentioned, but to begin to understand
- 3:01a little bit about the others is very interesting.
- 3:03And to that extent, I have also been trying to
- 3:06get to know a little bit about those sensory
- 3:09organs, such as electroreception, which is the
- 3:12ability to detect electric fields, magnetoreception,
- 3:16the ability to detect magnetic fields, and to
- 3:19locate oneself. I always say that this should
- 3:22be spectacular for many people because many of
- 3:25us get lost, we enter a shopping mall and we
- 3:28don't know where we came in and we went around
- 3:30twice and we are already lost. So, magnetoreception
- 3:35should be very interesting to be able to return
- 3:37home without problems and there we could stay
- 3:40talking about many others. For example, another
- 3:44sense that I really enjoy is everything related
- 3:47to touch and vibrations. So, I have always believed
- 3:52that the 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th and 10th sense organs
- 3:56exist and that we do not know them, but that
- 3:59does not mean that they cannot be explored and
- 4:01studied. Oh, that sounds super interesting. How
- 4:05did you become interested in this field and what
- 4:07keeps you passionate about understanding how
- 4:10organisms experience the world? Well, I came
- 4:14to sensory ecology by accident. I mean, basically...
- 4:18I finished my undergraduate and graduate studies
- 4:21at the Universidad de Los Andes, here in Bogotá.
- 4:24And after finishing, I started looking for possibilities
- 4:28to do a PhD, and during my undergraduate, well,
- 4:32of course, at the Universidad de Los Andes, we
- 4:35had several German professors who taught us several
- 4:37disciplines, and the rigor and everything that,
- 4:40well, is classic of the German system, for example.
- 4:44And so, when I finished, the only thing I knew
- 4:47for sure, was that I wanted to continue working
- 4:50with insects, which is what I dedicated most
- 4:52of my time to during my undergraduate and master's
- 4:55degrees. During that time I worked with insects
- 4:57that transmit diseases, so I was very much a
- 5:00parasitologist, and very much into insects that
- 5:04transmit diseases. But I said, I'm going to open
- 5:07myself up to the possibilities. The only thing
- 5:09I'm going to restrict is that it be insects.
- 5:12And so I started looking for graduate programs,
- 5:15and Felipe Gull, my professor at the Universidad
- 5:18de los Andes, put me in touch with someone at
- 5:21the University of Göttingen, a Colombian woman
- 5:24who was living and working at that university,
- 5:26out of kindness and likely out of solidarity
- 5:29with fellow Latinos and Colombians, began reaching
- 5:32out to all the professors at the institute where
- 5:35she was based, and asked them what possibilities
- 5:37there would be to receive a Colombian, and then
- 5:40appeared what in German I have always said is
- 5:42the most beautiful word which is not the PhD
- 5:45director. but they call him Dr. Vater, and that
- 5:49means the PhD father. Vater is father and doctor.
- 5:53Well, doctorate. So, surely for some people who
- 5:57have done their PhD in Germany, the father has
- 6:00been quite bad. But in my case, the father was
- 6:03exceptional. I have said that Andreas Stöpner,
- 6:07who is my professor, because he is still alive,
- 6:09he became my father, and so he received me in
- 6:13his house when I arrived in Germany. He had me
- 6:16for a couple of months. Then he helped me with
- 6:18the first things in German that I should know.
- 6:21And he was teaching me all the basics about sensory
- 6:24systems. And the first thing he did was to put
- 6:27an insect exposing the central nervous system.
- 6:30Then he introduced an electrode and told me to
- 6:33talk. And I started talking. And this insect
- 6:35was a cricket. So it had ears in its legs and
- 6:38I started talking. And as I talked, I saw neurons
- 6:41on a computer screen moving. Well, the action
- 6:45potentials of the neurons. And I said, wow, this
- 6:48is wonderful. And that was my first encounter
- 6:51with sensory ecology. I could stay here now just
- 6:54talking about the wonderful experiences one has
- 6:56with one's Dr. Fatha in Germany. But the next
- 6:59interesting step was when I was finishing my
- 7:01PhD and they said, well, why don't you look for
- 7:05a postdoc? And so I started looking for a postdoc.
- 7:08And then I was working in my lab and the top
- 7:10leader of that lab, who was not my professor,
- 7:13comes up to me and says, Do you know Vienna?
- 7:16And I said no. And he said, Why don't you go
- 7:18live in Vienna? Look, I have a colleague there
- 7:21who is working with spiders and vibrations, and
- 7:24he is looking for a postdoc in electrophysiology.
- 7:26And, well, you know about that. Go and talk to
- 7:29him. And he is none other than Professor Frederick
- 7:32Barth, who is the expert in spider vibrations.
- 7:35And he had a way of seeing the world, or has
- 7:38a very particular way of seeing the world. And
- 7:41that is, not everything is biology. You have
- 7:44to mix it with chemistry. You have to mix it
- 7:46with physics. You have to mix it with mathematics.
- 7:48And at that moment, the world opened up to me
- 7:50and I said, wow. Of course, that's what they
- 7:54call sensory ecology. It's not just biology.
- 7:57It's understanding that the physics you studied
- 8:00is also useful. That the chemistry you studied
- 8:03is also useful. And that's where I became interested
- 8:06in sensory ecology. How did you get to Los Andes?
- 8:10Los Andes was also a total accident. I always
- 8:13say that my life has been full of accidents and
- 8:15the chance that biology is classic. But I came
- 8:18to Los Andes because when I finished high school,
- 8:20in my time as a child, as a young man, well,
- 8:24there wasn't what young people now have. All
- 8:27those psychologists who analyze them in high
- 8:29school and tell them, look, your best qualities
- 8:32are to be a lawyer or to be an architect or this
- 8:35kind of thing. And in my family, everyone is
- 8:37a doctor or an engineer. So I was clear that
- 8:41engineering was not my thing. And what I was
- 8:43clear about was that I liked research, and I
- 8:46thought that doctors did research. And since
- 8:48the rest of my family are doctors, I said, well,
- 8:51I'm going to study medicine. I applied to medical
- 8:54school, and I didn't get in, because I wanted
- 8:57to study medicine at a public university in Colombia
- 9:00called the Universidad del Cauca, which at the
- 9:03time trained and surely still trains very good
- 9:06doctors. So it was very strict and very difficult
- 9:09to get in, and I didn't get in. And so they said,
- 9:12why don't you go and study for a degree in biology?
- 9:15And then you can switch. And I was like, a degree
- 9:18in biology? What's that? And, well, yes, as it
- 9:23seems to be like to go and teach children, young
- 9:25people. So I said, well, let's start and see.
- 9:28And when I saw what I liked was not the teaching,
- 9:31but the biology, and I said, those who do science
- 9:35are biologists, not doctors. Some doctors may
- 9:39do it, but biologists are dedicated to it. So,
- 9:42as I was at the Universidad del Cauca, I did
- 9:45three semesters there and I told my parents,
- 9:48no, I'm going back to Bogotá and I'm going to
- 9:51start looking for a university. And I also thought
- 9:54about the Universidad Nacional de Colombia, which
- 9:57is the best. But at that time, it was on strike
- 10:00after strike. So I said no. It's one thing to
- 10:04know when you're going in, but not when you're
- 10:06going to finish studying seemed terrible to me.
- 10:09I have always had problems with the Universidad
- 10:11Javeriana for religious reasons, so I didn't
- 10:14like it, so by elimination I entered the Universidad
- 10:17de los Andes, and to biology too, as you can
- 10:20tell, by an impressive accident of life. Very
- 10:23curious. Yes, it's all very curious, really,
- 10:26if you think about it. I mean, it's all been
- 10:28accidents, go to Vienna, go to Vienna, and just
- 10:31there I meet another person, go I don't know
- 10:33where, and there's another person and all, what
- 10:36else? The most spectacular. I think biologists
- 10:39are full of meeting spectacular people in different
- 10:41places. To get into this subject, part of your
- 10:45work is the study of electric fish. What fascinates
- 10:48you about these organisms in particular and what
- 10:51can we learn from studying them? This is one
- 10:53of those sense organs that is difficult for us
- 10:56as humans to understand. But I think the easiest
- 10:59way to illustrate it so that someone listening
- 11:01to us can begin to internalize it. is to imagine
- 11:05that we get into a swimming pool and close our
- 11:07eyes, which is almost unthinkable for a human.
- 11:10Well, the vast majority of us close our eyes
- 11:13when we jump into the pool, but imagine that
- 11:16we don't open them again and we start swimming
- 11:18around the pool, and suppose that pool is full
- 11:21of obstacles, obstacles like rocks, and obstacles
- 11:25like other animals that are moving around. Well,
- 11:28if I'm human and I close my eyes, I'm probably
- 11:31going to end up crashing into most of those rocks
- 11:33and a lot of the stuff that's in there, and I'm
- 11:35going to end up coming out saying, I don't want
- 11:38to go back into the pool. But if you start to
- 11:40imagine that there are fish in Africa and South
- 11:43America that acquired the ability to change their
- 11:45body muscles so that they can no longer contract,
- 11:48but the moment a motor neuron tells the muscle
- 11:51to move or contract, and that cell lost actin
- 11:55and myosin, which are the proteins that allow
- 11:58muscle contraction, well, The cell is not going
- 12:01to be able to contract anymore, but it is going
- 12:04to move ions. And in that movement of ions, if
- 12:08I put several of those muscle fibers together,
- 12:11what I'm going to do is like putting several
- 12:13batteries together in one of those old flashlights
- 12:15that some of us probably saw at some point, not
- 12:18the new LEDs. The old ones that were an incandescent
- 12:22bulb and you had to put three or four batteries
- 12:24in a row for it to learn. It's the same thing.
- 12:27If you put several of those batteries, I call
- 12:29them batteries. but let's say they are muscle
- 12:31cells that have lost the ability to contract
- 12:34muscularly, well now you have a dipole, and a
- 12:38dipole with a very small voltage, but which nevertheless
- 12:41extends throughout the body in all three dimensions.
- 12:44And if you now close your eyes as a human, and
- 12:47had that ability to not control your muscles,
- 12:49but to produce that field around your body, as
- 12:52you swim, rocks, for example, deform the electric
- 12:55field you have around you, and so you could avoid
- 12:58them. And if you get close to another animal,
- 13:01for example, that concentrates the electric field
- 13:04in the body of the animal, of the fish in this
- 13:06case, of the human that is swimming, and so I
- 13:09know that what is in front of me or what I have
- 13:12around me are animals that I can avoid if they
- 13:15are very big or that I can consume if they are
- 13:18smaller. And the most interesting thing of all
- 13:20is that if I am in the pool and I have a rock
- 13:23in front of me, with this sense I can know what
- 13:26is behind the rock, even without going around
- 13:28it. or looking over the rock. That is the ability
- 13:32that this sensory system gives to fish that are
- 13:34in the environment. And that is spectacular for
- 13:37animals that are active at night and that live
- 13:39in murky waters, which is what the theory says.
- 13:42And that is why these fish have that ability
- 13:45to move in environments where they could not
- 13:47do it with their eyes or with other systems.
- 13:50Wow, I'm not very familiar with that. I do recall
- 13:53we worked with electric fish in Uruguay and it
- 13:56was really fascinating to detect them since their
- 13:59voltage was quite low. But of course, it makes
- 14:02you wonder, what is the difference between them
- 14:04and the electric eels? This seems so much more
- 14:08dangerous. Could you clarify the difference between
- 14:10those with low voltage and others like eels that
- 14:14pose great risk to humans? Yes, yes, these fish
- 14:20that I just described to you and this situation
- 14:22that I just described to you are called weakly
- 14:24electric fish, precisely because you can be in
- 14:27the water with them and nothing will happen.
- 14:29They are millivolt discharges, very small microvolts
- 14:34in some cases, depending on the conductivity
- 14:36of the water. Only if you are very close to them,
- 14:39you could actually find them with the detector
- 14:41that we get into. But electric eels and other
- 14:45fish, for example, that live in the oceans, also
- 14:48did the same thing. They lost the contraction
- 14:50of their muscles. There is one, for example,
- 14:54very interesting, which is the Astroscopus, which
- 14:56lives in the Atlantic. And what it did was the
- 14:59muscles of the eyes, now it does not move them,
- 15:02but it produces impressive discharges. That one
- 15:06can kill you. That's what I call the fatal gaze.
- 15:09I mean, if that fish looks at you, it can fry
- 15:12you in one go. The other one is in South America.
- 15:16the electric eels, which many of you have probably
- 15:19seen at some point or have heard stories about,
- 15:22two meters long, that live in many of the streams
- 15:25and rivers in South America. And of course, you
- 15:29look at these animals and they are impressively
- 15:31long, and what you have to imagine is that less
- 15:34than the anterior tenth of the animal's body
- 15:37is the body itself, that is, all the organs that
- 15:40we have in our abdomen. The animal has it concentrated
- 15:43in the first tenth. and in the other nine parts
- 15:46of the body are muscle cells, batteries, as I
- 15:49just described, joined together, and then that,
- 15:52of course, does not produce millivolts or microvolts,
- 15:56but full volts. And, if one of those knows that
- 15:59volts are not what kills them, but amps do, and
- 16:03that there is a direct relationship between voltage
- 16:06and amperage, well, the more volts, the amperage
- 16:10is going to be very strong, and it's going to
- 16:12end up causing me impressive damage. And that
- 16:14animal, the eel, when I'm looking for my weak
- 16:17electric fish, if I pass by and detect it, I
- 16:21usually tell the students, let's not come around
- 16:23the other side. Let's leave this animal alone.
- 16:27Clearly, it is only going to be aggressive when
- 16:30it feels that you are invading its territory,
- 16:32or that you are putting its life at risk. It
- 16:36is an animal that also tries to avoid you, but
- 16:39something unexpected can also happen. and that
- 16:41is why it is better to avoid it. Are these animals
- 16:44blind or their vision is limited? No, they have
- 16:47very good eyes. Even now we are trying to publish
- 16:50a paper where we show that most people who work
- 16:53in this field say these animals that live in
- 16:56the dark and in very, very sediment -filled rivers,
- 16:59so they don't need their eyes to see. But in
- 17:02reality, what we are going to show with that
- 17:05paper is that they have very good eyes, that
- 17:08they have very good capabilities. And generally,
- 17:11if you look at the eel, it has quite large eyes.
- 17:14In other words, it is not that they don't use
- 17:17them. They do use them. And a lot of people think
- 17:20that by using that electric field, the eyes go
- 17:23to a second level, but that's not the case. They
- 17:26actually use them quite well. And there are all
- 17:29sorts. There are some that have small eyes. Others
- 17:33have larger eyes. And what we are trying to show
- 17:36in that paper is that it is proportional. Those
- 17:39that have small eyes, then they do certain things,
- 17:42and those that have large eyes, well, maybe they
- 17:45do even more things. Yes, and what do you think,
- 17:48for example, we could extrapolate as humans from
- 17:51the special sensory abilities that you have told
- 17:55us about, both from electric fish and from other
- 17:58organisms, that have disabilities that are not
- 18:02the same as humans? Yes, I always use this anecdote
- 18:06to illustrate the situation for you to see. which
- 18:09is Plato's allegory of the cave, which you read,
- 18:12probably at some point when you study philosophy,
- 18:15and it is about the prisoners who were tied up
- 18:17in a cave, and could only see images that were
- 18:20projected past them, which were shadows, and
- 18:24they believed that that was the real world, that
- 18:27is what we believe with our five sense organs.
- 18:30Many humans believe that those wonderful flowers
- 18:32that we see, that is the wonderful world, and
- 18:36the smells that we detect, is the wonderful world,
- 18:39and many of the sounds that we hear is wonderful.
- 18:42But I always say, imagine that you had that sixth,
- 18:46seventh, eighth, ninth sense. The world extends
- 18:50even further. So, it is as if those prisoners
- 18:54were released, which is what happens in the allegory
- 18:57of the cave, and they go out and see that not
- 19:01everything was shadows, that there are many colors.
- 19:04There are many other things that you never imagined
- 19:07existed outside. The same would happen to us.
- 19:10And not only if we had the ability to extend
- 19:12those other sense organs, but the ones we have.
- 19:16For example, our eyes only see visible light,
- 19:19but there is infrared and there is ultraviolet,
- 19:22and other animals see that. Well, not infrared,
- 19:25because you can't see it, but ultraviolet. But
- 19:28if we could see in ultraviolet, we would see
- 19:30things totally different from what we see today.
- 19:33So it has always seemed to me that studying sensory
- 19:36ecology is what biologists do to expand that
- 19:40external world and understand that outside is
- 19:43as if we were coming out of a cave after being
- 19:45tied up. It is tremendously impressive what you
- 19:49can see and what animals can do with their sense
- 19:51orders. And following up a bit on what you are
- 19:55saying, how can we learn about that adaptation
- 19:58and resilience by observing nature? in a world
- 20:02that presents so many environmental challenges,
- 20:05specifically from the point that you study. Yes,
- 20:09that is very interesting what you ask, Linda,
- 20:12because if you think about it, the world is very
- 20:15changeable today. Well, it has always been changeable,
- 20:19but now what we are doing is accelerating the
- 20:22changes. And a very interesting point is to think
- 20:25about how the sense organs can respond to that
- 20:28acceleration in changes, right? That is another
- 20:32completely different area I am just now trying
- 20:35to start with a student that we are going to
- 20:37try to see during his master's degree. The effect
- 20:40that the increase in carbon dioxide concentrations
- 20:42has on the olfactory abilities of certain pollinating
- 20:45insects. I am almost certain that what that is
- 20:49going to show us is that, depending on the insect
- 20:52or animal you are working with, there are certain
- 20:55capabilities that can be extended and the ability
- 20:58to adapt is going to be, in some cases, quite
- 21:01fast. In others, no. Surely those are the animals
- 21:05that with sensory systems that are not able to
- 21:07keep up with the accelerated pace of the process,
- 21:10well, they are going to have to step aside and
- 21:13surely will not be able to continue passing their
- 21:15genes on to the following generations. But there
- 21:19are many others that are going to have the capabilities
- 21:21to have the responses to those accelerated changing
- 21:25environments. And surely, those are the ones
- 21:28that are going to play a very important role
- 21:31in the generations to come, or in the times that
- 21:34await us next with all this change that we are
- 21:36undergoing. And we can also extrapolate that
- 21:39to what is happening to us, right? If it's happening
- 21:42in another animal and it reacts or changes quickly,
- 21:46we can also see it in how it's going to affect
- 21:49us. How it affects not only our senses, and how
- 21:53we are going to live, right? Exactly. And of
- 21:57course, well, it is. Animals, I have always thought
- 22:01that they have, not only animals, in reality.
- 22:04Fungi, plants, bacteria. Bacteria are extremely
- 22:09amazing in their ability to respond to change.
- 22:13I think so. In many organisms, it is very possible
- 22:16that these kinds of things can happen. As you
- 22:19say, not only at the sensory level, but in other
- 22:23systems as well. And you were telling us a little
- 22:27bit about how they are discovering precisely,
- 22:30or how you are discovering precisely that these
- 22:33fish that were thought to be half blind or had
- 22:38poor vision, it turns out that they are not.
- 22:41Are there any other discoveries or results of
- 22:45your research that have surprised you or that
- 22:48you have found impressive within what you have
- 22:51studied? That's very good. Nice. Yes. Well. I
- 22:56think Linda will like this one a little bit,
- 22:58and I don't know if I ever told her when we were
- 23:01here or not, but, for example, when I was with
- 23:04Professor Barr working there with the vibrations
- 23:06of spiders, there came a time when I said, I
- 23:10am feeling more vibrations than most people do,
- 23:13because I remember when I first arrived we were
- 23:16in a building and the tram passed by nearby,
- 23:19and the tram is a train that is moving and creates
- 23:22certain vibrations. and we are like on the third
- 23:25floor of the building. At first, I didn't feel
- 23:28it. But I, in the end, after working so much
- 23:31with the spiders, I was already beginning to
- 23:33feel, here comes the tram, even because I was
- 23:36already feeling the vibrations of the building.
- 23:39And you could look at the other people and the
- 23:41other people as if it didn't impact them, or
- 23:43they didn't really feel the vibrations of the
- 23:45building. So I think that when you get into the
- 23:48sense organs, and begin to understand animals,
- 23:51you also begin to say, I'm not so bad at hearing.
- 23:54I'm not so bad at feeling vibrations in the ground
- 23:57either. What happens is that as humans, we are
- 24:00too visual, and we rely too much on our eyes,
- 24:03but too much, we leave almost all the sensory
- 24:06responsibility to our eyes. And that is why people
- 24:10who lose their sight are tremendously successful
- 24:12also with their hearing, with their sense of
- 24:14smell, because we are really not that bad. In
- 24:17reality, we are good. What happens is that we
- 24:20do not take advantage of the potential we have.
- 24:23So, I think things like that that have caught
- 24:25my attention that I have discovered is how the
- 24:28different animal models I have worked with have
- 24:30taught me. I have already described the fish
- 24:33to you, but, well, that is very difficult for
- 24:36us because we are not aquatic animals and, well,
- 24:39electroreception in air is very complicated to
- 24:42think that you are going to feel it. But yes,
- 24:45studying, for example, smell in insects, smell
- 24:49in other animals, infrared now that we are working
- 24:52with snakes, all that begins to attract your
- 24:55attention and to see that we are really not so
- 24:58bad and that we have a lot of potential as human
- 25:01beings. It's like studying these animals sharpens
- 25:04your senses. For instance, you and I both wear
- 25:07glasses and I have contact lenses right now,
- 25:10but even without them, I still can't spot the
- 25:13spider webs. People often ask me, how do you
- 25:16see that? And I just point to the web. It's funny
- 25:20because I can't see people clearly from a distance,
- 25:24but I can always see the webs. That happens.
- 25:27And I think the advantage that those of us who
- 25:30do sensory ecology have is that it is as if I
- 25:34exploit my sense organs more and try at certain
- 25:37times. For example, I bother the students here
- 25:40in Colombia. I don't know how it is in the different
- 25:43countries where you are now, but here I tell
- 25:46them. Look, it is that economists and those who
- 25:50manage businesses also manage you. You could
- 25:54walk blindfolded through the stores and each
- 25:57store smells different. And there is a logic
- 26:00to that, that is leading you to buy without realizing
- 26:03it. We are truly bombarded with too much sensory
- 26:07information and we don't pay attention to it
- 26:09because we rely so much on our eyes. So what
- 26:12Linda says is true. I mean, because you are fascinated
- 26:15by your spiders, you see the things that spiders
- 26:18normally do. But for most people that goes unnoticed
- 26:21and well, I see things and hear things and smell
- 26:24things that surely for most people are not very
- 26:27normal either, because the insects or animals
- 26:30I work with have called my attention to that.
- 26:32And through your career, you have also worked
- 26:35with various species, including electric fish,
- 26:37spiders, fungi. Is there a moment or discovery
- 26:41that has surprised you or challenged or changed
- 26:45the way you see science? I think the one that
- 26:50has impacted me the most, and unfortunately we
- 26:53have talked a lot about it, is the electric fish,
- 26:55really. That marked me a lot. But if I were to
- 26:58leave that aside so as not to keep talking about
- 27:00the same thing and be able to tell other experiences,
- 27:03for example, I was very fascinated by the work
- 27:06I did with spiders and vibrations. And during
- 27:09my doctorate, I worked a lot. It was with auditory
- 27:12neurons of crickets. So it's like, it struck
- 27:14me. Imagine a jungle, which is what you can't
- 27:17imagine either. Many biologists do. Because we
- 27:21are sometimes in them and we imagine it. But
- 27:24imagine being in the Amazon and having to find
- 27:26your female in order to reproduce. And you have
- 27:30to do that just by singing. And many times in
- 27:33crickets, it is only the male that sings and
- 27:36the female never sings. In other words, you are
- 27:39singing all night long, and that is why you hear
- 27:42so many crickets singing at night, because you
- 27:44are attracting a female, and you don't know if
- 27:47that female is hearing you, and if she is going
- 27:49to come, and if she is going to reach you, right?
- 27:52So you have to sing and sing, because if you
- 27:55stop singing, well, there is less chance that
- 27:58the female will arrive because she will simply
- 28:00be able to arrive by phonotaxis, by the sound.
- 28:04The moment you stop, she gets lost. And if another
- 28:07male sings on the other side, well, the female
- 28:10deviates and goes to the other side. So you can't
- 28:13stop. If you stop, you lost everything you've
- 28:17been singing. So there's no way to stop. And
- 28:20now we don't imagine that in two dimensions,
- 28:22that is, in two planes. But what happens if now
- 28:25you are in a tree and the female is below the
- 28:27tree and the female has to climb up? Then we
- 28:30put three dimensions into it. So sound in three
- 28:33dimensions is an impressive thing. And let's
- 28:35think that I am not the only one singing, and
- 28:38there is not only one female, but there are another
- 28:4010 or 15 of my own species also singing, and
- 28:44behind the same female or behind other females.
- 28:47And to complete the story, then there are also
- 28:50bats that are hearing me and are willing to eat
- 28:53me. So the story becomes kind of creepy too.
- 28:56And to top it off, there is never a shortage
- 28:59of freeloaders, which are what are called satellite
- 29:01males in crickets. Well, they are males that
- 29:05are afraid of bats, so they don't sing, but they
- 29:08stand near those who are singing and intercept
- 29:10the females. The poor guy who is singing never
- 29:13knows that others took his female and the female
- 29:15was looking for you, but since another one got
- 29:18in the way, she stayed with that one. So what?
- 29:22Nature teaches you is that out there things are
- 29:25pretty terrible, that it is not as tasty as most
- 29:29people imagine it to be. And that was also taught
- 29:32to me by my work during my doctorate in Germany.
- 29:35That's very good. Nice experience. I also remember
- 29:38that there are skrikers in Hawaii that when they
- 29:41sing, they attract the parasitoids. So they feel
- 29:44super attracted to the males when they start
- 29:47singing. Exactly. So it's not just bats that
- 29:51are the problem. There are also flies. There
- 29:54are also wasps. Mainly flies are also the ones
- 29:58that are parasitoids, that also arrive and take
- 30:01advantage of the fact that you are singing and
- 30:03singing and they go and leave their eggs there,
- 30:05and you enter a situation that is no longer predator
- 30:08-prey, but parasitoid, which is an even worse
- 30:12situation. Part of your work, you are a mentor
- 30:16to new generations, to students of different
- 30:18degrees, both undergraduate and graduate, right?
- 30:22What values and principles do you think are the
- 30:25most important to convey to young people who
- 30:27are starting out in research? Well, I think at
- 30:31the beginning, Linda, when she made the presentation,
- 30:33she said something that has also marked me a
- 30:35lot and that I try to follow to the letter, and
- 30:38that is rigor. Sometimes you get excited about
- 30:41the results, but then you say, well, but let's
- 30:44wait. Let's see. Is that really the case? So
- 30:48I think being rigorous is one of the things that
- 30:50is important. And it is one of the things that
- 30:53I try to convey to the students that I have in
- 30:55my charge, even those to whom I teach introductory
- 30:58courses. The other thing I teach them and that
- 31:01I think is very important is that, to me, I'm
- 31:05going to tell you, I've told it many times, it's
- 31:08not a scoop for you, is that I went into biology
- 31:11because I hated math. And associated with mathematics,
- 31:14well, comes physics. It's like the older brothers
- 31:17and the younger brothers. But if you hate one,
- 31:20well, You hate the other by default. I've always
- 31:24liked chemistry. I've always been fascinated
- 31:26by chemistry, and that's a good thing when you're
- 31:28a biologist. So I always emphasize to the students,
- 31:31pay attention to your chemistry classes. You
- 31:34think that's just something you have to take
- 31:36the exams, get out of there, and forget about
- 31:38it as quickly as possible. But no, it's important.
- 31:41And when I got into sensory ecology, I said,
- 31:44oh, physics is important too. So I had to start
- 31:47paying attention to what I had never paid attention
- 31:49to before. Ohm's law, voltages, resistances,
- 31:53currents, all that kind of stuff, accelerations,
- 31:57speeds, waves, well, all that stuff that you
- 32:00say, I wish this would go by quickly and I'd
- 32:03get out of this and never have to go back to
- 32:05seeing this again. I tell them, in reality, if
- 32:07they teach it to you in college, it's because
- 32:09it does work, and it's important. At some point,
- 32:13it can make the difference for you to decide,
- 32:15oh look, I didn't know about this area, and now
- 32:18it turns out I'm interested in this. So what
- 32:20I also try to tell them is, besides rigor, physics,
- 32:25chemistry, mathematics is interesting. And the
- 32:28last thing I tell them, well, I'm old, I've done
- 32:32a lot of things, and I've done a lot of things
- 32:34just with Excel, but most of you can't do your
- 32:37thesis with Excel anymore. Now you have to learn
- 32:39to program too. So, many of you are going to
- 32:42have to, like it or not, learn Python, learn
- 32:46another operating system like that, and learn
- 32:48to program. All that kind of stuff is already
- 32:51part of a biologist's life. So, the biologist
- 32:55is no longer just looking at what animals do
- 32:58and how animals do it, but also thinking about
- 33:00physics, chemistry, mathematics, and learning
- 33:04to program. Because each time the theses demand
- 33:07more complex computer systems and analysis that
- 33:10can no longer be done with Excel. So, what I
- 33:13try to promote is a lot of that. And that they
- 33:16try to do it, and that they get into it early.
- 33:19so that biology doesn't run them over later at
- 33:22the speed it's going. And I must add that something
- 33:24I learned from you was to be objective. Well,
- 33:28that is tremendously important, Linda. When you
- 33:32arrived, well, I have always applied it, but
- 33:35I thought that was very normal, but it seems
- 33:37that it is not very normal. So, well, you once
- 33:42made me realize that and I, well... I thought
- 33:45that was normal. Exploration also involves a
- 33:48lot of fieldwork that you were telling us about,
- 33:51going to rivers, looking for fish, and depending
- 33:54on your object of study, of course. How do you
- 33:58collaborate with local communities when you come
- 34:02to work to combine scientific knowledge with
- 34:05traditional knowledge? Yes, I think that is very
- 34:09important, and more so in places like Colombia.
- 34:12And I always tell the students when we go on
- 34:14field trips, look, we are passing through this
- 34:17city and this small town, and we are going to
- 34:20go now to a farm. And the vast majority of people,
- 34:24what they see is, there goes a big bus with some
- 34:27people that we are never going to see. Get off
- 34:29here. That they go to a place. They do something.
- 34:33They get on the bus. We see them pass again three
- 34:37or four days later, and we don't even know what
- 34:39they are doing or who they are or what they did.
- 34:42So, I always tell them, it can't be like that.
- 34:45We have to give something back to the people
- 34:47who live in those places. So, for example, in
- 34:51the plains where I now work with electric fish,
- 34:54if we launch ourselves towards the east of the
- 34:56Andes, we quickly descend to a very flat place
- 35:00that is what we call the eastern plains. And
- 35:03in that region, well, obviously there are populations
- 35:06that work in the countryside, live in the countryside.
- 35:10and who see that occasionally we arrive, we leave,
- 35:13and they don't know what we are doing. Well,
- 35:16what I tell them is, let's do something for them.
- 35:19Let's go to the schools. So I like them to invite
- 35:22me. So I talk to the owners of the farm who are
- 35:25also from Bogota. But they live with the people
- 35:28who manage the farm for them, who are residents
- 35:30of the area, who are very active ecologically
- 35:33and culturally in the area. So I tell them, hey,
- 35:37invite me. So they have invited me to the schools
- 35:40in the area to tell them about the fish. To tell
- 35:43them, once it was interesting, they are, in that
- 35:46place they are very interested in birds. And
- 35:49then they said to me, hey, and how do you give
- 35:51a scientific name to a bird? So I said, ah, well,
- 35:56I can tell you. So I went and told them, well,
- 35:59where the scientific names came from, and that
- 36:02the scientific names are in Latin. but what the
- 36:04scientific names try to say are the physical
- 36:06characteristics in some cases of the birds. So,
- 36:09Pyrocephalus, Firehead, and then you look at
- 36:13it and it really is a bird that has a red head.
- 36:15So, well, of course that's why they called it
- 36:18Firehead, but, well, we can't call it Firehead
- 36:22in Spanish because that's not what is used, so
- 36:25you have to say it in Latin, and that's Pyrocephalus.
- 36:28And I was impressed to see that they were taking
- 36:30notes on everything I was saying. As if we were
- 36:33in a class and I was saying, how wonderful. Sometimes
- 36:36I even said they are better than my students
- 36:38at the university. They are paying more attention
- 36:40to me. So, I think that's what really catches
- 36:43people's attention. And that's what you have
- 36:45to do. People in the countryside pay close attention
- 36:48and are amazed to see that someone comes and
- 36:51wants. To tell them something about what you
- 36:53do and that they have never seen or imagined
- 36:56it, but that they live with it all the time.
- 36:59So, I think it is important that part of interacting
- 37:02with the communities and that they are not simply
- 37:05a means of passage and that nobody wants to interact
- 37:08with them. Yes, it is reaching other audiences
- 37:11and how to connect with them. This is super important.
- 37:15And as we were talking about it one day with
- 37:18other people, it is not about lowering the level.
- 37:21It is simply about putting it in simpler words.
- 37:24One can explain electricity in simple words and
- 37:27I am not lowering the level. That is, I am not
- 37:31hiding from him that a fish is electric, I am
- 37:34telling him. But then I have to explain to him
- 37:36with electricity really how the thing is, but
- 37:39not talking about Ohm's Law. Because, well, that
- 37:43is taking it to a complex situation. But yes,
- 37:47I can explain Ohm's Law in a simpler way, and
- 37:50easily the person can understand it without me
- 37:53taking away the strength and all the academic
- 37:55part of what I am telling him at the time. Yes,
- 37:58I have always said that if you are able to explain
- 38:00in simple words without oversimplifying things,
- 38:03you understand the concept deeply. It is the
- 38:06best way to explain it. And we know that you
- 38:08were a recently appointed correspondent academic
- 38:11in the Colombian Academy of Sciences. First of
- 38:15all, explain to us what this means and what this
- 38:18recognition means to you and how you hope to
- 38:20continue contributing to scientific development
- 38:23in Colombia. That was another one of those anecdotes
- 38:26that I wasn't expecting one day. Felipe Gould,
- 38:29one of my professors at the university with whom
- 38:32I worked in the same parasitology lab, invited
- 38:34me and said, I'm inviting you to lunch today.
- 38:37So we went to lunch and during lunch he said,
- 38:40listen, I want to propose you to the Colombian
- 38:42Academy as a corresponding member. Imagine I
- 38:45immediately said no, but I still have a long
- 38:47way to go to get there. So he said, give me the
- 38:50papers and I'll take care of the rest of the
- 38:52process. and indeed the surprise was when they
- 38:54told me that I had to meet certain requirements,
- 38:57a publication and other things to be able to
- 38:59enter as a corresponding member, and then comes
- 39:02the whole ceremony and the whole process, which
- 39:05obviously as you can imagine, well, academies
- 39:08are a whole tradition, and that tradition is
- 39:10spectacular of the whole process, of knowing
- 39:13that this comes from very ancient times, when
- 39:15scientists began to organize themselves in the
- 39:18world, so there are very old associations, there
- 39:21are others newer. But in Colombia, this one is
- 39:24relatively old too, and to be part of that tradition
- 39:27is tremendously interesting. But what you don't
- 39:30imagine when they appoint you or when they appoint
- 39:32you a member of an association or an academy
- 39:35of these, is that now you also have a commitment.
- 39:38Many do not take it that way. Many of those who
- 39:41are appointed members of the academy do not take
- 39:43it that way. But it seems to me that the commitment
- 39:46is, well, now I not only have to do science,
- 39:50but also help to disseminate science, which is
- 39:54what we were talking about a while ago, right?
- 39:56And then it is no longer just thinking that in
- 39:58the cities or small towns that I pass through,
- 40:01you have to go and talk to the people of, but
- 40:03you also have to talk to the people of Bogota,
- 40:05who are many, who do not know about science because
- 40:09they have not been able to interact with scientists.
- 40:11So we have to help transmit that science as well,
- 40:14and then you think not only in small cities far
- 40:17from Bogota, But also in big cities, you have
- 40:21to do it. So that yes, that has meant that sometimes
- 40:24they invite me and I say, why are they inviting
- 40:27me? Then I found out. And it's because, oh no,
- 40:31in the academy, they said, no, invite this academician
- 40:33to go and do this in his city. And so that's
- 40:36how you really go about helping. And I say that
- 40:38you acquire more commitments by being an academic.
- 40:41But I also find it interesting to do it. Because
- 40:44it's really getting into that logic that we have
- 40:46to promote science in Colombia. And the only
- 40:49way to promote it is for scientists to talk to
- 40:52the rest of the people and let them know what
- 40:54for us is very normal. But for the bulk of the
- 40:57people, it is not. Well, you are doing it here
- 41:01with us. I am doing it. But thanks to the fact
- 41:04that you also have a different vision and are
- 41:06truly motivated for people to know not only what
- 41:09we do as scientists, but also that we are people.
- 41:12And that also seems very cool to me. Things you'd
- 41:15like to convey to your students. But like many
- 41:18of us who have had the opportunity to teach and
- 41:21give classes, this experience goes both ways.
- 41:24What have you learned from this experience of
- 41:27teaching and mentoring students? The pandemic
- 41:30changed me a lot. When the pandemic arrived and
- 41:34we had to start doing virtual classes and that
- 41:36sort of thing, I had a tremendous shock. I'm
- 41:39not going to say now that I'm the person who
- 41:41exploits the most virtuality and all the tools
- 41:44available at the moment to reach students. But
- 41:46it changed me in the sense that I said, for example,
- 41:49I'm going to start using fewer slides in class
- 41:51and try to talk more in class and interact more
- 41:54with students. Because what I realized was that
- 41:57you became a person who stood there and recited
- 41:59a story that you've been reciting for 10 years
- 42:01because they're the same slides. And suddenly
- 42:04you change some things to the slides because
- 42:06the ideal is not to become outdated, but you
- 42:09know the story and you tell it and you tell it
- 42:12and you become a machine gun shooting and shooting
- 42:15words. And almost you don't even pay attention
- 42:17if people are paying attention or if they are
- 42:20managing to follow the speed of the words you
- 42:22are saying. And what I realized is that the moment
- 42:26you stop using slides and start using the blackboard
- 42:29more, what I realize now with the introductory
- 42:32organism course is that people talk more and
- 42:35ask me more questions. I have noticed and unfortunately
- 42:39I didn't start documenting that because that's
- 42:42another thing I like to do. is to publish what
- 42:44I do in class, the innovations I make in teaching.
- 42:48That did happen to me. I never imagined that
- 42:51the pandemic was going to come and wake me up
- 42:53in that way, so I never documented it temporarily.
- 42:57But I clearly have it quantified in my head that
- 42:59before I could spend an hour and a half talking
- 43:02and nobody would ask me anything. And I would
- 43:05leave and leave the class and I would say I already
- 43:07did what I had to do. They didn't learn. It's
- 43:10their fault. Now it's very different. I talk
- 43:13and almost every two minutes. Someone is asking
- 43:16me something and I try to make the activities
- 43:18much more interactive. And so many times I don't
- 43:21answer. But I return the question to see if anyone
- 43:24can think of something. And that way you manage
- 43:27to involve many more people and the classes become
- 43:30much more interesting. And above all, you take
- 43:33away the burden of whether the hour and a half
- 43:35is up. And I didn't manage to get to this. It
- 43:39doesn't matter. I can do something else later
- 43:41to cover the subject. But before it was not that
- 43:44I have to cover these 60 slides in the hour and
- 43:47a half and whatever, so I talk faster. If I look
- 43:50at the clock and I have 20 minutes left, then
- 43:52I have to say them faster. And that's a burden
- 43:55that you don't have to take on, and the student
- 43:57less so. And for the student, it's terrible that
- 44:00you're talking to a machine gun from here. You
- 44:02can't keep up with the speed of what you're saying.
- 44:05So, I think that not necessarily everything has
- 44:08to be very digital and innovative and very much
- 44:11that kind of thing. Going back to the blackboard
- 44:13is also a good way for students to interact much
- 44:16more with teachers. That's what I've been doing
- 44:18recently. Wonderful. That's a very good strategy.
- 44:22Thank you very much, Jorge. And finally, what
- 44:25message would you like to send the general public?
- 44:28I think what I mentioned a moment ago seems to
- 44:31me an interesting term, and it is, I hope someday,
- 44:34sometime in some activity you are doing, close
- 44:36your eyes and let your other sense organs take
- 44:39control. and you will realize that the world
- 44:41is tremendously wonderful, and that many things
- 44:44sound that you have never heard, that you have
- 44:46never paid attention to. You don't have to go
- 44:49to the sea, basically the pandemic taught me
- 44:51that too. We did it here, record your city from
- 44:55the window, we did it here in Colombia, and then
- 44:57you start to hear things that you didn't hear
- 45:00before, because you come and accelerate from
- 45:02Bogota, that you don't pay attention to anything,
- 45:05and the big cities, all of you wherever you live.
- 45:09You have surely seen it, that you don't pay attention
- 45:11to what is sounding, but if you close your eyes,
- 45:14you start to hear different things, not different,
- 45:18things that have always been there, but you would
- 45:20never have heard them and you have never paid
- 45:22attention to them. So the recommendation I would
- 45:25make and the message I would leave is, let's
- 45:28get out of Plato's cave, and the only way to
- 45:30get out of Plato's cave is to close our eyes
- 45:33for a moment, and let the other sense organs
- 45:36take a little control for a while. and you will
- 45:38see what is impressive, what happens around each
- 45:41one of you. I completely agree. It's about pausing
- 45:45for a moment, listening and tuning in more deeply.
- 45:49Thank you so much, Jorge, for accepting our invitation
- 45:52and for sharing all these fascinating experiences
- 45:54with us. And of course, thank you for answering
- 45:58all our questions and explaining everything so
- 46:01clearly. No, thank you very much, Linda and Daniel.
- 46:05for really thinking that I could be interesting
- 46:06for this very interesting work that is so important,
- 46:10because it is not only interesting what you do,
- 46:12but very important. So I really appreciate that
- 46:16you considered that I could contribute something
- 46:18to that wonderful work that you are doing. Thank
- 46:20you very much for thinking of me. Of course.
- 46:22Thank you very much. This podcast is fully self
- 46:25-funded and self -edited by your dedicated hosts,
- 46:29and we rely on your support to grow. You can
- 46:32help us spread the word by subscribing, sharing,
- 46:36and leaving a review. Find us on YouTube, Spotify,
- 46:39and our official website, www .sciencebehindtheglass
- 46:43.com. Follow us on X, Facebook, and Instagram
- 46:47for the latest updates. A special thanks to our
- 46:50friend Bernardo Aguilar for the original music
- 46:53and to our promotions manager, Rafael Jordan,
- 46:56for his invaluable technical support. Let's keep
- 46:59the conversation going.