Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 7 Episode 12: Clare's Law Explained: What Survivors Deserve to Know About Their Partner's Past
Transcript
- 0:16Ruth Reymundo: And we're back.
- 0:17David Mandel: Hi, we're back.
- 0:18Ruth Reymundo: Hello, good morning.
- 0:19David Mandel: Good morning, good afternoon.
- 0:20David Mandel: Our guest is in the UK.
- 0:21David Mandel: We'll get to that in a second.
- 0:22Ruth Reymundo: Okay.
- 0:23David Mandel: And good whatever, wherever you are.
- 0:25David Mandel: Welcome back to another episode of Partnered with a Survivor.
- 0:28David Mandel: We are nearing 200,000 downloads.
- 0:31David Mandel: I'm just saying that the people.
- 0:33Ruth Reymundo: Hey guys, you know, you gotta pick up your downloads so that we can say we finally reached it.
- 0:37David Mandel: Yeah, and so we're in our seventh season.
- 0:39David Mandel: And really thank you for following and sharing this.
- 0:41David Mandel: And please, if you haven't write a review.
- 0:43Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 0:44David Mandel: Tell tell tell us how much you like cranky survivor.
- 0:47David Mandel: You know, that would be great to see.
- 0:49Ruth Reymundo: You you I should have a crankimeter where people are like, you know, turn it up and crankometer.
- 0:54David Mandel: I love it.
- 0:55David Mandel: You know, and no, but I really just appreciate doing this with you.
- 0:58David Mandel: I was just saying to you this morning.
- 1:01David Mandel: And I'm David Mandel, by the way.
- 1:03Ruth Reymundo: Oh, I didn't know I couldn't figure it out.
- 1:04Ruth Reymundo: I'm ready.
- 1:05David Mandel: Yeah, right, exactly.
- 1:06David Mandel: I was just saying, and I just think it's a nice thing to share.
- 1:09David Mandel: Just I really appreciate how much you have brought to the work we do together and to uh my work, how much working in partnership with you has really kind of advanced my thinking and fine-tune.
- 1:21David Mandel: Because I was writing about survivors experience on LinkedIn because I was speaking to folks about stuff and as I often do about men's violence.
- 1:29David Mandel: And I think it's helped me fine-tune words, thinking about things.
- 1:34David Mandel: Your idea of of men's violence versus women, stealing from women, you know, stealing their energy, stealing their, you know, taking really taking wealth and value and and on all levels.
- 1:45David Mandel: And I mean that economically, just but uh economically in other things.
- 1:48David Mandel: Anyway, just I feel like my my voice is tighter in certain areas, for instance.
- 1:54Ruth Reymundo: You know, I think it's really important for there to be really good examples of men and women and collaboration and partnership, both personal and professional.
- 2:04Ruth Reymundo: And that is something that can exist in the world.
- 2:08Ruth Reymundo: I know it's a rare thing to see, but emulating that, doing that, doing the work of it, working out, you know, how people work together in different power dynamics and gender, you know, configurations is really important for people.
- 2:23Ruth Reymundo: And I too have really benefited from our collaboration because before I was in this alone, I was a very angry survivor with no tools.
- 2:34Ruth Reymundo: And then I, it was like I had a tool all of a sudden I can use.
- 2:38Ruth Reymundo: And having a tool for a person who has experienced institutional harm is both healing and it is grounding.
- 2:48Ruth Reymundo: It's very, it's very important that people feel they have some tool or skill or way to advocate for themselves, to advocate for others, and to address the institutions that are furthering harm.
- 3:03David Mandel: Means a lot to me.
- 3:04David Mandel: So you let's do it a land acknowledgement and then I'll introduce our wonderful guest.
- 3:08David Mandel: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:09Ruth Reymundo: So we are on Tungsa Masapo land in the beautiful Farmington River Valley, and this land is in its spring riot.
- 3:21Ruth Reymundo: All of the leaves came out in a matter of about three days.
- 3:24Ruth Reymundo: And we are sending our regards to the traditional custodians of the land, past, present, and emerging.
- 3:33David Mandel: Okay.
- 3:34David Mandel: So I'm gonna tee up our guests.
- 3:37David Mandel: You know, I've been thinking about obviously perpetrators' patterns for a long time and information sharing and and issues of, you know, we know that for instance, perpetrators manipulate, and part of their pattern of course control is actually lying to new partners about their past behavior.
- 3:59David Mandel: I mean, that's actually what course control is so brilliant for helping us understand that, that that lying, that misrepresentation, that withholding information is actually part of the pattern of course control, right?
- 4:11David Mandel: And so I've always been an advocate for information sharing and you know, even for systems to child protection systems, for to say to perpetrators who are in their on their caseload or even criminal justice, to actually mandate the perpetrator themselves to actually tell that information to their partner as when they have that control over them.
- 4:31David Mandel: So anyway, so that's this has been a big patterns and understanding course control has been a bigger, you know, of interest to mine.
- 4:37David Mandel: And then uh through somebody on our Safe and Together faculty, Rasha Hamid, we were introduced to Dr.
- 4:44David Mandel: Katarina Hajamateo.
- 4:47David Mandel: And I hope I'm gonna get that right.
- 4:48David Mandel: You know, I'm gonna, you know, and and she is a a lecturer at the University of Essex.
- 4:55David Mandel: And what really drew me to her work was how she researched from the Gold Claire's Law, which is not well known in the United States, but it's a UK law, and it's being kind of emulated in places like Canada and New Zealand, and we'll talk about in Australia, well, which is a lot of our audiences in those places.
- 5:14David Mandel: So, really wanted to really dive in.
- 5:18David Mandel: So, Kat, welcome to the show and thank you for for for joining us.
- 5:24Katerina Hajamateo: Thank you so much for inviting me and for having me today.
- 5:27David Mandel: So, let's really go to the basics.
- 5:29David Mandel: Let's start with Claire's Law, which is a UK law.
- 5:33David Mandel: Just tell our audience, assume they don't know anything.
- 5:36David Mandel: Tell us about its history, of its development, its purpose, and then obviously get into what you studied, which was its implementation.
- 5:44Katerina Hajamateo: Great, thank you.
- 5:45Katerina Hajamateo: So this initiative started, well, it was first proposed back in 2009, and it was a police proposal.
- 5:54Katerina Hajamateo: And it was part of a kind of shift to trying to tackle serial perpetrators who were increasingly recognized as a problem for police and as a problem for domestic abuse services and social services.
- 6:10Katerina Hajamateo: And in particular, the fact that in my country, less than 3% of domestic abuse crimes reported to the police ever result in a conviction.
- 6:21Katerina Hajamateo: And anything that isn't a conviction is not in the public domain.
- 6:26Katerina Hajamateo: So I know that in the states, sometimes you can look up arrests in certain states, and that's public information online.
- 6:33Katerina Hajamateo: Not the case anywhere in Europe or in most of the rest of the world.
- 6:38Katerina Hajamateo: If it hasn't resulted in a conviction, it's not in the public domain.
- 6:41Katerina Hajamateo: Maybe you could find out about a court hearing if you visited the court and asked for their archives.
- 6:47Katerina Hajamateo: So the police are essentially sitting on huge amounts of information about people's criminal histories that their partner, their victim, their survivor, would never know about otherwise.
- 7:02Katerina Hajamateo: So initially the proposal came from police.
- 7:05Katerina Hajamateo: Listen, we're sharing information with other agencies all the time.
- 7:09Katerina Hajamateo: There are all these new laws coming in saying, here, let's facilitate information sharing, let's change privacy law to make it possible because we all know it's absolutely essential to protecting and safeguarding victims and survivors.
- 7:23Katerina Hajamateo: But nobody's sharing this information with the people whose lives, whose safety, whose family and children's safety is actually at stake.
- 7:31Katerina Hajamateo: There's no legal ability to do that unless it's a case of, you know, imminent harm, somebody's life being imminently at risk, then the police could step in.
- 7:42Katerina Hajamateo: So there was this proposal back in 2009.
- 7:45Katerina Hajamateo: It didn't go anywhere initially, but then in 2014, a woman called Claire Claire Wood, she had been murdered by her partner, and there was an inquest into her murder in 2014.
- 8:00Katerina Hajamateo: And that was essentially a coroner's investigation to try and find out what went wrong, given that she was in contact with the police, in contact with social services.
- 8:10Katerina Hajamateo: Why did they not manage to prevent her murder?
- 8:13Katerina Hajamateo: And one of the recommendations of this inquest report was that the police be able to share information with people who are at risk.
- 8:23Katerina Hajamateo: Claire herself, her partner, was known to police, very well known as a highly dangerous, highly violent person.
- 8:30Katerina Hajamateo: She had left him and he persuaded her to go back.
- 8:35Katerina Hajamateo: And that was fatal for her.
- 8:37Katerina Hajamateo: So then a campaign began with Claire's father leading the way in parliament to introduce a law, and it was introduced in 2014.
- 8:46Katerina Hajamateo: It was piloted, and what it did was in two things.
- 8:50Katerina Hajamateo: One, it enabled members of the public to contact the police and say, I'm in a relationship, I'm worried about my safety in this relationship.
- 9:00Katerina Hajamateo: Does my partner have a history of domestic abuse in your police records?
- 9:05Katerina Hajamateo: And the police could share information not only about convictions or arrests, but just report anything within their records that was relevant to protecting people at risk.
- 9:16Katerina Hajamateo: But the other thing that this law did was it allowed the police to go out there and share this information proactively.
- 9:22Katerina Hajamateo: So, for example, you can imagine somebody comes out of prison, whether or not they were in prison for domestic abuse, they are known as being a high risk of domestic abuse by their probation officer.
- 9:36Katerina Hajamateo: They start a new relationship.
- 9:37Katerina Hajamateo: Probation officer knows, probation officer tells the police, police can contact new partner and say, listen, we're worried about your safety in this relationship.
- 9:47Katerina Hajamateo: We've got some information we think you should know.
- 9:50Katerina Hajamateo: And that's essentially what Claire's Law does.
- 9:54David Mandel: You know, it's amazing one that the police thought, hey, we're sharing this with other people.
- 9:59David Mandel: We're not sharing this with survivors, and and and they deserve to know this.
- 10:03David Mandel: That's that's an amazing thing.
- 10:05David Mandel: And then unfortunately, you know, took a tragedy, took a murder to really kind of move it forward.
- 10:11David Mandel: So, so talk to us.
- 10:13David Mandel: That's what the what it is.
- 10:15David Mandel: Talk to us about, you know, how widespread it is globally, and then let's talk to us about how it works in reality.
- 10:23David Mandel: Because, you know, I know your research talks about a lot of strengths, but also, you know, even listening to you now, you know, I can imagine that proactive, like on paper, I love that proactive nature.
- 10:34David Mandel: Like seriously, I do.
- 10:35David Mandel: But I can imagine that, you know, that call from the probation officer.
- 10:40David Mandel: And let's say that that user violence or perpetrator has poisoned the well, so to speak, with a new partner already, some way or another, and said, Well, she was crazy.
- 10:50David Mandel: I mean, that's what we see all the time.
- 10:52David Mandel: That that that the you know, you don't understand, and yeah, I cheated on her and she was jealous.
- 10:57David Mandel: So yes, I cheated on her, but I didn't do those things, and she made them up.
- 11:01David Mandel: And and now the probation, and so so just I can imagine all the real-world dynamics or racialized policing, you know, and sort of that kind of thing.
- 11:10David Mandel: But talk to us first about how widespread it is and also the the successes you're seeing with this from the point of view of survivors.
- 11:17Katerina Hajamateo: Yes.
- 11:18Katerina Hajamateo: So it is since spread to all of the other, it started in England and Wales, now it's in Scotland, Northern Ireland, because we have different legal systems in the UK.
- 11:28Katerina Hajamateo: Then to New Zealand, to Australia, where it was piloted in one Australian state and not taken forward, and then taken forward in a different form in another state.
- 11:38Katerina Hajamateo: Australia, there is a huge debate about whether or not it's a good thing.
- 11:43Katerina Hajamateo: It's quite a contested and slightly toxic topic, similar to human trafficking or something like that, which your listeners might be aware of, or sex work.
- 11:53Katerina Hajamateo: It's really contested, and there are lots of quite angry debates in Australia about it.
- 11:59Katerina Hajamateo: That's not the case in the UK, there's general support for it.
- 12:02Katerina Hajamateo: It was also introduced in various Canadian provinces.
- 12:05Katerina Hajamateo: I think four provinces have introduced it, and Malta, and most recently, Spain, which has, which is the only country in the world, I think, to have one national level database for all domestic abuse, that is, intimate partner violence, male on female reports to police.
- 12:27Katerina Hajamateo: All of those are recorded in one central national system that also assesses risk.
- 12:35Katerina Hajamateo: And in the last few years, the Spanish police have also been sharing the information that's on that system sometimes with the victims and survivors they come into contact with.
- 12:46Katerina Hajamateo: But we don't know how much about that is working.
- 12:48Katerina Hajamateo: So those are the different countries.
- 12:49Katerina Hajamateo: It's about 10 to 11 different jurisdictions, but it's working very differently in different places.
- 12:55Katerina Hajamateo: Now, what I've done is I was lucky enough to be funded by the British Academy to travel around the world to different jurisdictions using Claire's Law, or as it's known elsewhere, the domestic violence disclosure scheme.
- 13:10Katerina Hajamateo: So in Australia, it's not known as Clare's Law.
- 13:13Katerina Hajamateo: And find out how it's working, what are the different models?
- 13:16Katerina Hajamateo: Because obviously we have different legal systems.
- 13:18Katerina Hajamateo: I mentioned the difference between the UK and the states with what is private, what is not.
- 13:22Katerina Hajamateo: That exists on many different levels.
- 13:25Katerina Hajamateo: In some countries, it's only convictions that police can share.
- 13:29Katerina Hajamateo: You may not be surprised to hear it doesn't work so well in those places.
- 13:35Katerina Hajamateo: But I traveled around and I also, most importantly, got the chance to do some research with people who have used this scheme or who have been offered information.
- 13:46Katerina Hajamateo: So I interviewed and surveyed about 600, just over 600 victims and survivors and people at risk, as they're known legally speaking, the people who access the scheme in South Australia and in England and Wales, and asked them why they sought this information, what they knew about their partner's history before, if they knew something, and if what the police told them was different to what they already knew, what the information meant to them and for their relationship, if it helped them make decisions about their safety, about their children's safety, and what could be improved overall if they had a bad experience, for example.
- 14:32Katerina Hajamateo: In in to be very short, what I found is that there are high, high levels of satisfaction across both England and Wales and South Australia with this disclosure scheme, with Clare's Law.
- 14:45Katerina Hajamateo: Significantly higher in England and Wales than with domestic violence services.
- 14:51Katerina Hajamateo: So, and those are you know the NGO services.
- 14:54Katerina Hajamateo: So this is it's pretty good news for police.
- 14:57Katerina Hajamateo: In South Australia, it's unprecedented.
- 15:01Katerina Hajamateo: So we're looking at 99% very highly satisfied or satisfied.
- 15:06Katerina Hajamateo: That's the first headline finding.
- 15:09Katerina Hajamateo: But what you need to know before we go further is that in England and Wales, we have 43 different police forces.
- 15:16Katerina Hajamateo: They all do it slightly differently.
- 15:18Katerina Hajamateo: In many of them, the information is shared by police in a meeting online or in person.
- 15:24Katerina Hajamateo: But in South Australia, the whole scheme is coordinated by a specialist domestic violence service, Women's Safety Services South Australia.
- 15:35Katerina Hajamateo: They make the first contact with applicants, they give them safeguarding information and advice that's confidential before a decision is made about whether they're eligible for the information or not.
- 15:47Katerina Hajamateo: So everyone gets support.
- 15:49Katerina Hajamateo: The police show up to share the information, and then they leave the room and there is a debrief session with that specialist worker in complete confidence where they can discuss the information.
- 16:00Katerina Hajamateo: They're allowed to bring a support person with them, they're allowed to share the information with psychologists, with social workers, with uh maybe a domestic violence caseworker.
- 16:11Katerina Hajamateo: In England and Wales, that is not the case.
- 16:15Katerina Hajamateo: Sometimes a domestic violence worker will be invited along when it's a very, very high-risk case, and the police are worried about terrifying the person that they're speaking to with the extreme violence that they're about to share.
- 16:28Katerina Hajamateo: But that is not that is not standard practice.
- 16:32Katerina Hajamateo: Often the information is just dumped on somebody and then they're left with it.
- 16:36Katerina Hajamateo: And they have to share, they have to sign a confidentiality agreement in England and Wales saying they will not tell a soul about this information.
- 16:45Katerina Hajamateo: That is a legally binding agreement that says if you share this information, we will prosecute you.
- 16:51Katerina Hajamateo: So some of the differences we can see in satisfaction and feeling safe in people in South Australia, in England, and Wales, when we look at the actual comments that victims and survivors are making, are coming down to things like I felt really terrified, alone, overwhelmed, and isolated.
- 17:11Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah.
- 17:11Katerina Hajamateo: For example.
- 17:12Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah.
- 17:14David Mandel: And that's thank you for such a clear.
- 17:18Ruth Reymundo: I mean, seriously, so much to unpack from that description and explanation.
- 17:23Ruth Reymundo: And you know, I just want to start in a place where I always pivot to the perspective of targeted populations and how this can land.
- 17:35Ruth Reymundo: And I know that the UK laws are very different than in Australia, and the, you know, that there's concern about being prosecuted for, you know, saying bad things about people that they don't want to be heard.
- 17:52Ruth Reymundo: But I really wonder about how if if when you did that satisfaction survey, if that you looked at those targeted populations and you looked at the differences between satisfaction.
- 18:09Ruth Reymundo: And again, I know that these are victim survivors that we're we're talking about.
- 18:14Ruth Reymundo: It's just a whole ball of wax with convictions being very difficult to get anyway.
- 18:20Ruth Reymundo: And that speaks to the challenges in the criminal justice system across the board globally with victim survivors.
- 18:27Ruth Reymundo: And and then again, you know, how do how do we use this information across different jurisdictions?
- 18:37Ruth Reymundo: How do we mobilize assistance?
- 18:40Ruth Reymundo: Do we just drop this information in a woman's lap?
- 18:42Ruth Reymundo: And I'm really glad to hear Australia is not doing that.
- 18:46Ruth Reymundo: Do we just drop this information in a woman's lap and make her responsible for responding to it without any assistance?
- 18:53Ruth Reymundo: Because that is just not okay.
- 18:56Ruth Reymundo: It's very dangerous.
- 18:57Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 18:58David Mandel: Like sit, like you said, there's a six things in there.
- 19:00David Mandel: Different things.
- 19:00David Mandel: So do you where do you want to start?
- 19:03David Mandel: Where do you want to finish?
- 19:04Ruth Reymundo: I think one of the places I'd really love to start is the support of survivors receiving that information and the expectations of the system about what they're going to do with that information for their own personal safety and for children's safety, because I can see that getting really bad real fast.
- 19:21Speaker 2: Yeah, absolutely.
- 19:23Speaker 2: I mean, I should say that satisfaction was significantly correlated.
- 19:27Speaker 2: And this is a paper that's coming out very soon.
- 19:30Speaker 2: I got somebody who actually understands statistics to contribute to it, thankfully.
- 19:35Speaker 2: But satisfaction was in England and Wales significantly correlated with the kind of support they were offered.
- 19:41Speaker 2: So, were you offered support by police?
- 19:44Speaker 2: What kind of support were you offered?
- 19:46Speaker 2: And people who were offered support were coming out of that meeting feeling empowered, feeling in a good place.
- 19:54Speaker 2: So it really was making a difference.
- 19:57Speaker 2: Then, in time in terms of the expectations of what somebody should do with that information in South Australia, there they were very, very clear.
- 20:10Speaker 2: This is a really trauma-informed approach.
- 20:14Speaker 2: They are there to support.
- 20:15Speaker 2: And I should also say, in response to one of the six points, just because I thought it was quite important, in South Australia, they had a disproportionate representation of First Nations people seeking the service, which was unexpected and really positive because it's not easy to engage with those populations.
- 20:41Speaker 2: I should also say that one of the questions asked was, have you ever sought support from domestic violence services before?
- 20:50Speaker 2: And over 60% of people in both jurisdictions had not.
- 20:54Speaker 2: So people are coming to get this information where they've never sought help before.
- 20:59Speaker 2: So it really is an opportunity to give that support, to engage positively with people, and it shouldn't be squandered, which of course in England and Wales it is being.
- 21:08Speaker 2: So the fact that police are the lead agency in England and Wales, I didn't ask demographic questions in my survey there because I felt it was too intrusive.
- 21:18Speaker 2: It was an online survey, so I don't know.
- 21:21Speaker 2: But but I think what we can see is that when you do not force people to engage closely with police as a condition of getting this information, you are reaching groups that are marginalized and you're able to do that in in South Australia.
- 21:37Speaker 2: In terms of the victim blaming or responsibilization, which is a term which has been coined in the debate about Claire's law, I certainly have seen that in my research in England and Wales.
- 21:50Speaker 2: That research was with police.
- 21:53Speaker 2: So I did a separate study talking to police about the how how this works.
- 21:57Speaker 2: How do you make a decision about what Is relevant to disclose to somebody?
- 22:02Speaker 2: Are there borderline cases?
- 22:03Speaker 2: What if you're not sure if someone was the victim or the perpetrator?
- 22:07Speaker 2: What if they have one incident from 20 years ago that was quite minor and nothing in between?
- 22:12Speaker 2: What if you know they've attended a perpetrator service and they genuinely seemed remorseful and their probation officer, etc., etc., has this view.
- 22:21Speaker 2: So there are lots of complex ethical decisions being made.
- 22:26Speaker 2: And one of the things that the police said when I asked them about what are the key challenges that you face, in fact, the headline challenge was children's social care, putting pressure on victims who are also mothers who are in that relationship to go and seek this information and then asking them to do something with it.
- 22:53Speaker 2: So essentially using Claire's Law as a test to see if mum is willing to protect and do what she needs to do to protect and safeguard her children.
- 23:06Speaker 2: The police were saying this completely subverts Claire's Law for us.
- 23:12Speaker 2: Claire's Law is a victim safeguarding tool.
- 23:15Speaker 2: It is about those victims and survivors.
- 23:18Speaker 2: It is not about child protection.
- 23:20Speaker 2: There are other tools that children's social workers can use to do their job.
- 23:26Speaker 2: And there is also a disclosure procedure for child safeguarding.
- 23:30Speaker 2: If somebody is a risk to children, you know, children's social workers in my country can access that police data and disclose it themselves.
- 23:38Speaker 2: But instead of doing that, instead of saying, look, we've got this information we want to share with you, they were saying, let's see if we give mum this challenge, will she pick it up?
- 23:46Speaker 2: Will she do what it takes?
- 23:48Speaker 2: And if not, we'll use that as evidence.
- 23:52David Mandel: I'm sorry, cranky survivor is go ahead and stellar.
- 23:58Ruth Reymundo: Where are you on the crankometer ratio?
- 23:59Ruth Reymundo: I am at a 12.
- 24:00Ruth Reymundo: That is absolutely horrific.
- 24:03Ruth Reymundo: And that's predictable.
- 24:05Ruth Reymundo: Sadly, it is predictable.
- 24:07Ruth Reymundo: And, you know, we see this type of pressure and failure to protect being directed at women globally.
- 24:15Ruth Reymundo: But what a horrible way to subvert safeguarding.
- 24:19Ruth Reymundo: You know, we need people who are partners in safeguarding.
- 24:24Ruth Reymundo: And if they have this information in a trauma-informed way, not in an entrapment way, not trying to entrap somebody and see how protective they are, but to really take that information as a child protection professional and say, I have a responsibility.
- 24:41Ruth Reymundo: What is my responsibility as a child protection worker to assist this person to keep their children safe in light of this pattern?
- 24:50David Mandel: Well, this is doesn't, you know, it doesn't surprise me at all, unfortunately.
- 24:54David Mandel: It does talk about, you know, where we in the with the safety of the mall really kind of kind of keep hammering away at, are we partnering with survivors?
- 25:01David Mandel: And I and it sounds like the description of the disclosure scheme in South Australia is a beautiful example of that partnering in the tethis of this.
- 25:11David Mandel: It speaks to the three-planet, you know, issue, which is, you know, that overriding that's that's Radford and Hester.
- 25:19David Mandel: And I forgot one of them promulgated it first, but the idea that gender double standards, which we talk about all the time, is this unifying and not in good way framework across all these systems where women are held to much higher standards.
- 25:34David Mandel: And this feels like this a perfect example.
- 25:36David Mandel: You create the craft this law, which has lots of potential, has lots of benefits, and then this other thing creeps in to become the use case for wrongfully for some people to say, just like, and I will say this again, risk assessment processes that were designed for use by giving victims information and in collaboration, and they're being driven by their own risk assessment, their thinking, and for their decision making, being co-opted, I'm gonna say that word, by police, by systems, and then being used to triage for bureaucratic reasons, triage resources.
- 26:16David Mandel: I think that's even the bigger example of that.
- 26:19R: You have to ask yourself a question about why a specific system has a consistent pattern of pivoting only to mothers and women, the protection of children, and why, in the context of child protection in the UK, a thought didn't arise in the mind of child protection that if there was a man in the home who was violent, that maybe it should be them who should be looking at whether or not he had disclosed and he had changed.
- 26:49David Mandel: And actually, I I that's actually what we've made.
- 26:51David Mandel: I've I've actually given instructions to child protection to make something like that a part of a plan.
- 26:56David Mandel: Actually, it's part of our written documentation, which is child protection, to make that part of their case work with him.
- 27:02David Mandel: But I want to I want to come back to something because I think this is really critical.
- 27:05David Mandel: One is I love Kathy, you talked about the nuance of what's shared and the ethics, because that's a huge area.
- 27:11David Mandel: But I really want to come back to something critical, at least for my mind, which is the success.
- 27:17David Mandel: These where you're seeing the success is women who already have a reason.
- 27:22David Mandel: Something tickles their brain, or they have some experience, or they get some information that says something's not right here, or I have a worry.
- 27:32David Mandel: Maybe it's because of past relationships, maybe because of this one.
- 27:35David Mandel: I don't know.
- 27:36David Mandel: But I'm gonna go and seek out this information.
- 27:39David Mandel: So so there's really this sort of they're getting they're asking for a service and they're actually getting it well.
- 27:47David Mandel: So I think I really want to say this how different that is than some other places in the system where the police show up because your neighbor called and you're just you're scared because police is not a good experience for you, right?
- 27:59David Mandel: So I really want to pull this through line through, which is it starts with the survivor who says, I'm really interested in more information, I've got a place to go.
- 28:08David Mandel: And if I get support, even you know, even in populations, it sounds like that are be traumatized, colonized, have reasoned this trust system, they're turning to the system to say, this will help me, and saying it did, right?
- 28:21David Mandel: So I I love that.
- 28:22David Mandel: That's can you kind of dive into that and compare it to the probation-driven examples?
- 28:30David Mandel: Do you have that kind of teased out at all that kind of and what their what those women's experiences are?
- 28:35David Mandel: Do we know something about their experience differently?
- 28:38Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah, I'm really glad you asked that question.
- 28:40Katerina Hajamateo: One thing I I think it ties into what we were just discussing with with social care.
- 28:46Katerina Hajamateo: Um, but before I say that, I just want to say that Marianne Hester, who who devised the Three Planets model and who is somebody I know well and respect very much, was also involved in designing the very, very first proposal for Claire's law back in 2009 in our country.
- 29:02Katerina Hajamateo: And and so, and she, the original design was that there would always be a domestic violence worker present.
- 29:09Katerina Hajamateo: Just want to make sure she gets that credit.
- 29:11Katerina Hajamateo: But one of the things that was really irritating police around children's social care's behavior was they were saying precisely this, and and the words you said are precisely the words that were spoken by some of my participants and that appear in some of my papers.
- 29:30Katerina Hajamateo: This is something different.
- 29:32Katerina Hajamateo: They're asking us for something, and we're giving something and not expecting anything in return.
- 29:38Katerina Hajamateo: This is transforming our relationship with people who before didn't trust us, who didn't want to report to us.
- 29:46Katerina Hajamateo: And then children's social care comes along and says, no, no, it's not your right to have the information.
- 29:53Katerina Hajamateo: You're getting this information whether you want it or not.
- 29:56Katerina Hajamateo: It's being imposed on you.
- 29:58Katerina Hajamateo: And so the police were saying one of the problems with this is that if people are not ready to hear that information, it could be really damaging to them.
- 30:10Katerina Hajamateo: And in fact, in the law here and in South Australia, uh the consent has to be there to receive the information.
- 30:18Katerina Hajamateo: So even in the proactive cases, the police are saying, we would like to share some information with you.
- 30:24Katerina Hajamateo: Would you like to receive it?
- 30:26Katerina Hajamateo: And if they say no, what should happen, and I think what does happen in most cases, is they say, That's fine, we've got it on record.
- 30:33Katerina Hajamateo: If you ever change your mind, here's my card.
- 30:35Katerina Hajamateo: So what I want to come back to your question, David, is that one of the important things that my research found was that the value of this information and the support as well, because it's not just information, it's information plus support to make sense of that information, to turn that information into something that is meaningful for your own future, your own relationship, makes you understand your own circumstance.
- 31:04Katerina Hajamateo: You need both the information and the support to work through that information, which they do have in South Australia.
- 31:11Katerina Hajamateo: But that information is meaningful in different ways to people at different stages of a relationship.
- 31:18Katerina Hajamateo: So the people who are asking for it early on, and that's the minority, I want to be clear.
- 31:25Katerina Hajamateo: It's often because they've heard something, or somebody else has said, you've got to ask about him.
- 31:30Katerina Hajamateo: I heard from this person or that person, or he's been in prison, and don't you want to know why, etc.
- 31:36Katerina Hajamateo: And at that stage, it could plant a seed, it could be a piece in a puzzle that later on becomes clear.
- 31:46Katerina Hajamateo: Those were the kind of metaphors used by police, used especially around those proactive offerings at the beginning of a relationship.
- 31:54Katerina Hajamateo: Because what police said to me is often when we we offer that information at the beginning of a relationship, the person we're describing to that person listening to us, they're saying, I don't know who this man you're talking about is, but he's certainly not the guy I just started a relationship with because that guy's wonderful and amazing and would never hurt me and would never do anything like that to me.
- 32:16Katerina Hajamateo: So in those cases, it's about planting that seed.
- 32:20Katerina Hajamateo: It's about saying, okay, let's see, here's my card again.
- 32:25Katerina Hajamateo: If things change, you've heard this from me.
- 32:28Katerina Hajamateo: But most people are coming much later on in a relationship.
- 32:31Katerina Hajamateo: They're coming when they're ready to hear it.
- 32:34Katerina Hajamateo: Those those people who are applying for the information.
- 32:37Katerina Hajamateo: So we see that quite a lot of people who are thinking of leaving, who have left and attempted to go back, who have left but but are not sure what they're facing now in terms of new risk from their ex partner.
- 32:51Katerina Hajamateo: And it's it's very interesting to see how for those people who are entrenched in a relationship and maybe considering leaving, the information can be so important in helping them see their relationship differently.
- 33:09Katerina Hajamateo: So you talked about the lies.
- 33:11Katerina Hajamateo: The lies are not just about the past relationships, they're also about the relationship they're in right now.
- 33:16Katerina Hajamateo: Who's to blame for the abuse?
- 33:18Katerina Hajamateo: What was that?
- 33:19Katerina Hajamateo: It wasn't abuse, it was a mistake, you tripped up and fell into my fist, I tripped, etc., etc.
- 33:26Katerina Hajamateo: So that the abuse might be happening, the violence might be happening, but the meaning that is given to it by the two actors in a relationship is often what keeps somebody entrapped in that relationship.
- 33:40Katerina Hajamateo: And that's where the information can be really useful.
- 33:43Ruth Reymundo: And and I'm I know I'm jumping in, you have a question.
- 33:46David Mandel: I have a question, but go ahead.
- 33:47Ruth Reymundo: I really want to put a pin in the entrapment conversation because I think it's really important that we all start to land our language about entrapment.
- 33:58Ruth Reymundo: You know, when a person is in a new relationship and they are being groomed, because that's what's happening, they're being groomed by a perpetrator to stay, to trust them, to not believe their own perception or the information that others give them about that person.
- 34:19Ruth Reymundo: We really need to work hard as professionals to understand the psychology and the behavioral responses to entrapment in intimate partnership.
- 34:33Ruth Reymundo: So that often gets projected out onto victims as blame, as a deficit, as it's as if it's crazy that it's their problem, even though it's a common experience.
- 34:45Ruth Reymundo: And we know that that's real.
- 34:47Ruth Reymundo: And the most intelligent people who have a high consideration for ethics and morality can be entrapped as well.
- 34:55Ruth Reymundo: People who know about domestic abuse, people who work in the field, people who have a tremendous amount of education about it as well, can be entrapped by a person who is not honestly conveying who they are as a human being.
- 35:10Ruth Reymundo: So we really need to be very careful about talking about entrapment and really focusing that entrapment not on the victim, but on the person who is who is creating that alternate reality until they can no longer sustain it and they start to show their pattern of behaviors, which is probably habitual and deeply embedded in their relationship way of being, we are really not good at talking about entrapment.
- 35:38Ruth Reymundo: We need to get better at it.
- 35:40David Mandel: So, you know, uh to add to that, because that's exactly Ruth, where where I was thinking, which was uh how on one level, and Kat, I'll be really interested in your thoughts about this and from your conversations, particularly with police and other professionals, that that in the in the vein of what Ruth was saying, that one of the unintended consequences when we talk about trauma-informed practice or focus on trauma or trauma history or is that we move away from this this sort of really deep commitment, I think is so important to see patterns of perpetrators in relationships and across relationships.
- 36:21David Mandel: And if I'm understanding you correctly, one of the things that this information scheme does, information sharing sharing scheme does, is it helps break that this is about our dynamic or our relationship or me as a person or my history or my choices before, or I've made bad choices, or you know, this is part of my pattern, or I don't, you know, I grew up in a home where the like there's there's a deep, and I wrote in my book sort of the myth of trauma-informed practice.
- 36:51David Mandel: This is really what's become this overriding framework, which is sort of we see we and it's well-intentioned, and trauma practice in trauma-informed practice is really important.
- 37:01David Mandel: I need to say that for people every time I say this.
- 37:03David Mandel: And it can reinforce this, it can inadvertently reinforce victim blaming, a centering in a bad way of victims, decentering perpetrators' patterns.
- 37:13David Mandel: So, can you talk about that, whatever lands for you in that?
- 37:17David Mandel: Because I think there's something in here very important that you're describing or found in your research.
- 37:21Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah, I mean, it's interesting.
- 37:23Katerina Hajamateo: This is one of the points of controversy, and I mentioned in Australia it's become a very controversial topic, and there's a kind of tug of war between survivors, groups, and and and experts and so on, about whether it should be brought in.
- 37:37Katerina Hajamateo: Is precisely that idea of is it holding anybody accountable?
- 37:44Katerina Hajamateo: Is it just another thing to put on the shoulders of people in in abusive relationships?
- 37:51Katerina Hajamateo: Personally, I think it does exactly through what you're what you're talking about, the exposure of patterns, that is a kind of accountability.
- 38:03Katerina Hajamateo: Yes, it's a narrow accountability in the sense that it's within an individual relationship, that perpetrator could go on to another relationship afterwards.
- 38:11Katerina Hajamateo: This is not criminal justice, etc.
- 38:13Katerina Hajamateo: But I still think that's important.
- 38:16Katerina Hajamateo: And so the words of of the survivors that gave written feedback, and there were hundreds of them, as I said, many of them saying, I realized it wasn't me.
- 38:30Katerina Hajamateo: I realized he would never change.
- 38:34Katerina Hajamateo: I could see the pattern, exactly what he was doing to me, he had done it before.
- 38:39Katerina Hajamateo: I thought it was because of his PTSD.
- 38:42Katerina Hajamateo: So exactly what you were saying, it's that people, I mean, it's well documented in the academic literature on domestic abuse that that many people do return because they believe their partners will change.
- 38:55Katerina Hajamateo: But seeing that somebody has had two or three victims before you and they did the same thing, they've had many opportunities to change and they haven't changed.
- 39:04Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah.
- 39:05Katerina Hajamateo: And and and that it can be incredibly powerful to people, and also it can be it can have the effect of shifting self-blame.
- 39:15Katerina Hajamateo: That as you were saying, I've had a traumatic background, I'm a damaged person, and I seek out damaged people or something like that, or we're both damaged and we bond in that way.
- 39:24Katerina Hajamateo: No, this is something they're doing to you, and also the shame of having allowed yourself, as some people might see it, to be a victim in that way.
- 39:35Katerina Hajamateo: You're not alone, they've done it before.
- 39:38Katerina Hajamateo: It can happen to anybody.
- 39:39Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah, and and seeing that history can can really expose those things.
- 39:43Katerina Hajamateo: And I'm only repeating the words of the participants in in my research.
- 39:48Ruth Reymundo: I, you know, this this is a really important talking point because there is so much conversation out there about women with bad pickers, women who choose bad men, women who don't have enough self-love or self-respect.
- 40:05Ruth Reymundo: And therefore, that's why they're in domestically abusive relationships.
- 40:08Ruth Reymundo: Again, the through line here is not looking at men and their behaviors, right?
- 40:12Ruth Reymundo: But also, I want to expand the conversation of accountability.
- 40:15Ruth Reymundo: Accountability often gets termed through the lens of the system that's talking about accountability.
- 40:22Ruth Reymundo: So in the criminal justice system, accountability means very narrow things, very narrow actions and responses and consequences.
- 40:32Ruth Reymundo: And a lot of people speak about accountability simply through an arrest and conviction and prosecution and incarceration lens.
- 40:42Ruth Reymundo: I'm gonna challenge people who simply think of accountability through that lens to expand their understanding of accountability.
- 40:52Ruth Reymundo: And just imagine a world where if a person is abusive and has a pattern of domestic abuse, that information sharing means that their their ability to abuse somebody really contracts.
- 41:08Ruth Reymundo: The ability to have power over another person contracts.
- 41:13Ruth Reymundo: And if you think about it in personal terms, if you think about it in communal terms, which is the way that I think about it, that that person then is not able to entrap multiple people in a sphere of their influence is a form of accountability.
- 41:33Ruth Reymundo: That is a personal form of accountability that actually I think a lot of perpetrators fear.
- 41:38Ruth Reymundo: They fear not being able to have an intimate relationship with somebody that they can feed off of.
- 41:46Ruth Reymundo: They fear not having that partnership because they're they deeply feel often unloved and unlovable because of their behaviors.
- 41:56Ruth Reymundo: So that, you know, we we could dive into the male loneliness crisis, right?
- 42:02Ruth Reymundo: We could let's not, but we're not gonna do that.
- 42:04Ruth Reymundo: But that's what I'm that's what I'm saying is that is that behaviorally accountability means that if your behaviors wounded your trust in relationship, and the person has the ability to say, I do not want to be in relationship with you anymore, and safely leave your relationship, that is a form of accountability.
- 42:25Ruth Reymundo: And for survivors that come from communities that are highly overpoliced and targeted by carceral systems, accountability often means exactly that: being able to safely separate from that party and have and have safety and autonomy and self-determination, period.
- 42:45David Mandel: I I think uh, you know, for me, a couple of thoughts.
- 42:47David Mandel: One is information is power.
- 42:49David Mandel: We say that over and over again.
- 42:51David Mandel: And so information is power.
- 42:54David Mandel: What I'm hearing also is this is women get to come to us, survivors get to come to us, ask for something.
- 43:01David Mandel: We provide it.
- 43:02David Mandel: It builds trust, it builds connection, it builds when it's done in this way with support, it builds again, sort of there's a container for you're not alone.
- 43:11David Mandel: Let's talk through the options, what this means, let's help you do it.
- 43:14David Mandel: But information at the bottom is information is power, and survivors are in control.
- 43:18David Mandel: These are two principles that are really very important, you know, to me, and I think they're important to you as well.
- 43:23David Mandel: So I think that's sort of you know part of what it comes down to.
- 43:26David Mandel: But there's something, there's a thought rattling around in my head, which is there's a little bit of rebuilding the village.
- 43:31unknown: Yeah.
- 43:32David Mandel: And I was thinking about I I piloted years ago when I was going through my master's program, designed a network intervention concept, a restorative justice network intervention concept, where the perpetrator, and we kind of I tested a little bit and then it kind of it actually failed or actually succeeded in the right way.
- 43:50David Mandel: But this idea was you know, what happens if you with survivors saying, We'll give you a chance to sit with the person.
- 43:59David Mandel: Has caused harm safely with support people for you, with people with him, where he is going to acknowledge publicly what he's done.
- 44:10David Mandel: There's no expectation of apology for you to forgive.
- 44:15David Mandel: There's no expectation for you to do anything.
- 44:16David Mandel: But that that in this public sharing, there's accountability.
- 44:21R: Truth and reconciliation.
- 44:22David Mandel: There's truth and reconciliation.
- 44:23David Mandel: And that and that by winding the circle out of people who know about his behavior pattern, again, with consent, with kind of a framing, that there's a potential of more safety and more change because now there's more supportive, constructive, knowledge-informed eyes on him.
- 44:40David Mandel: And she also gets relief.
- 44:41David Mandel: He's publicly said it.
- 44:42David Mandel: It's not me, it's not my dirty secret, it's his secret, and it's out in the open.
- 44:47David Mandel: So there's a lot in there, but I just think this accountability thing is we're we we this rebuilds the village a little bit because in the olden days, you would have seen what he did to his last partner.
- 44:59David Mandel: You would you would have known that.
- 45:01David Mandel: It is.
- 45:07Ruth Reymundo: I'm really enjoying that, you know, because I'm imagining from what you said, like that that communal sense of justice, where when you when you live in that communal space and somebody constantly creates violence and disruption, the the community is like, you need to go beyond the outside edge of community.
- 45:29Ruth Reymundo: You you need to behave yourself.
- 45:31Ruth Reymundo: And that in and of itself, that separation, is a form of accountability.
- 45:36David Mandel: And we also know, sorry, I've got now I've got my all my brain cells are shooting off.
- 45:40David Mandel: We also know from families that, and from I'm thinking about families that work together, moms and kids usually who work together to keep each other safe, their shared knowledge of the perpetrators' patterns gives them some sense of community and not aloneness and not isolation, which is the opposite of what you said is happening in England and and Wales.
- 46:01David Mandel: You know, and and and so there's this idea that that this even if it doesn't stop the violence, and I think there's a the sort of uh sometimes a sense of indignation, the system is not stopping the violence and not taking fully, being fully successful, which is a reasonable feeling, but maybe an unrealistic expectation at some level, that at the fully like preventing it all from happening, but that that we can create community connection that the survivor feels like, oh, this people I'm not crazy, I'm not alone.
- 46:33Ruth Reymundo: I mean, those two things by itself if you think about the carceral response.
- 46:36Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, the carceral response has historically been you do your time and everything is fine.
- 46:43Ruth Reymundo: Okay, so you can be a man who does something horrible, but you did your time, or we didn't convict you, and therefore nothing happens.
- 46:52Ruth Reymundo: So that more communal sense of accountability where everybody says, No, accountability is actually all of our job, not just the carceral system, is actually a tremendous pressure on men who are violent.
- 47:06David Mandel: Well, you just again I'm well, we're gonna need to wrap up.
- 47:09David Mandel: I was just thinking about how whose source of truth it is, and and in certain systems, the conviction is the source of truth.
- 47:16David Mandel: Right.
- 47:17Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 47:18David Mandel: Yeah, go ahead.
- 47:19Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah, something really it's it's I think what you're describing is uh absolutely the antithesis of these proposals for a public register of domestic violence offenders, which I I think is highly dangerous.
- 47:36Katerina Hajamateo: So it's a cheap and easy alternative to Claire's law.
- 47:40Katerina Hajamateo: It's let's just put a list out there in public of people and their offenses.
- 47:44Katerina Hajamateo: So firstly, the offences are going to be described in criminal justice terms.
- 47:50Katerina Hajamateo: So it's gonna be assault, grievous bodily harm, with injury, without injury, harassment, whatever, breach of the peace.
- 47:57Katerina Hajamateo: What does this mean?
- 47:58Katerina Hajamateo: It doesn't mean anything.
- 48:00Katerina Hajamateo: It could mean whatever the perpetrator says it is.
- 48:02Katerina Hajamateo: So it's not going to, it's both too much information in a way, and too little information because too much, because it could also be used if it's just placed in the public to stigmatize and and exclude people, and too little because it's it's not going to be enough to help any any survivor or victim understand really what this person's behaviour is and what they're actually responsible for.
- 48:26Katerina Hajamateo: So I'm fully for your community response and not for this, uh for the all of these proposals.
- 48:33Katerina Hajamateo: I know there have been many in the states introducing a public register.
- 48:37Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, there has been.
- 48:38Ruth Reymundo: And that and that chatter is increasing with multiple incidents.
- 48:42Ruth Reymundo: We just had a horrific incidence in in Louisiana of a man who murdered, I think it was eight of his children.
- 48:49Ruth Reymundo: It was terrible.
- 48:50Ruth Reymundo: So, you know, we hear this cyclically pop up about a registry, and we know how this has gone for the sex offender registry in the USA, and it is deeply flawed and deeply imperfect.
- 49:02David Mandel: I have one more question.
- 49:03David Mandel: I don't know if that's we're gonna stick to it.
- 49:05David Mandel: But we did talk about something in the pre-interview that I think is really important, which is, you know, in the UK you said something about the challenge of who gets identified as a victim and who gets identified as a perpetrator, you know, and that's really relevant to this law because, you know, sort of, you know, I I kind of professionally grew up in a system, you know, which had a 15% dual arrest rate.
- 49:25David Mandel: Horrible.
- 49:26David Mandel: Like way above the average.
- 49:28David Mandel: My last check was it was two or three percent, you know, was was was average.
- 49:32David Mandel: But so I was dealing, and the safety of the model came out of that soil, which is to help practitioners figure out you can't go on arrest.
- 49:39David Mandel: You're getting a lot of people who are true victims being arrested for being perpetrators.
- 49:43David Mandel: So, can you talk a little about how all that fits into to Claire's law?
- 49:48Katerina Hajamateo: I am really worried about it because as I mentioned earlier, police systems can only log somebody as a victim or a perpetrator or a witness.
- 49:58Katerina Hajamateo: There's no other category.
- 50:00Katerina Hajamateo: And whoever calls up and says they are a victim is logged as a victim because police have been burnt by their very, very poor behavior in treating victims as perpetrators or in the past and so on.
- 50:13Katerina Hajamateo: So they just defer to the system now and play it safe, knowing in many cases that the person calling them is actually the primary perpetrator in the relationship.
- 50:23Katerina Hajamateo: So I am concerned about the the gaming of the system by perpetrators to get information about their partners, their their ex-partners, put on a database and then uh inviting other people, for example, the new partner, you know, your ex-wife's new partner, go and look her up and see what the police say about her.
- 50:43Katerina Hajamateo: She's dangerous.
- 50:44Katerina Hajamateo: Yeah, I know, it's et cetera, et cetera.
- 50:46Katerina Hajamateo: So it is worrying.
- 50:48Ruth Reymundo: There's a couple of things in that, and and they're very critical, actually.
- 50:51Ruth Reymundo: This is this is a very important topic.
- 50:53Ruth Reymundo: We could go on this one for a while as well.
- 50:55Ruth Reymundo: And that is that ontology is incredibly important, labeling is incredibly important, and the system is consistent in prioritizing its own self-interest and liabilities.
- 51:10Ruth Reymundo: And that is a primary problem.
- 51:13David Mandel: Okay.
- 51:14David Mandel: So that you know, that is that we're that may be where we we wrap up because that's a huge issue.
- 51:18David Mandel: It's a real issue.
- 51:19David Mandel: Because what part of the the the through line, one of them, so that's if I can summarize and turn over to you for what you want to share, Kat, with with with our listeners, both survivors and and professionals.
- 51:29David Mandel: Two two big through lines.
- 51:31David Mandel: I mean, there's probably more.
- 51:31David Mandel: One is when you create systems and and processes that survivors want and f and find useful, and you build supports around them, and you give them the opportunity to initiate and control, and I'm kind of saying all these things for emphasis, surprise, surprise, they're satisfied.
- 51:51David Mandel: They find it useful, it helps them make decisions, right?
- 51:54David Mandel: That's one through line.
- 51:56David Mandel: The other through line is that the potential for any of these things to be misused, misappropriated, you know, often through a mother-blaming lens, you know, but also some under the hands of a perpetrator's manipulation that that these systems are are being gamed, are going to be used by perpetrators.
- 52:16David Mandel: So those are my two big, my two big through lines.
- 52:19David Mandel: Kat, what would you like?
- 52:21David Mandel: We have a lot of survivors who listen, a lot of professionals, a lot of people who are both.
- 52:25David Mandel: Can you speak to you know, each of those audiences what you want them to take away from this conversation?
- 52:32Katerina Hajamateo: I think what I'd want to professionals to take away, especially in countries that don't have these kinds of schemes, is that people should not be denied the epistemic tools, that is, the the information, the knowledge, the status to exercise their autonomy and to understand their own situation.
- 52:57Katerina Hajamateo: And to have a situation where all professionals have access to this information, and the very person who whose safety is at risk is not to be trusted with it, that is a problematic system.
- 53:08Katerina Hajamateo: For survivors, I can only say that I hope this works.
- 53:16Katerina Hajamateo: I hope they can defend their rights when it comes to these systems if they're being responsibilized by them.
- 53:23Katerina Hajamateo: I know that there are survivor groups who are that are agitating to introduce these systems.
- 53:28Katerina Hajamateo: I wish them luck and not to be discouraged, especially in Australia, where I know a very large petition of over 130,000 people signed in in support of Clare's law, but it was knocked down at the legislation stage, precisely saying it doesn't hold perpetrators accountable and it won't help anybody who's already being abused because they already know they're being abused.
- 53:54Katerina Hajamateo: So it won't give them any new information.
- 53:56Ruth Reymundo: I love it when the system tells us what to do and tells us what we need, even though we're telling them what we need.
- 54:04Ruth Reymundo: It's so awesome.
- 54:05Ruth Reymundo: That was a little bit of sarcasm.
- 54:07David Mandel: So so wait, I just have to say that we used epistemic and ontology ontological in this part.
- 54:14David Mandel: We just elevated the two of you, just elevated the the the the sort of philosophical level of the show and love it.
- 54:21David Mandel: I love it that you know.
- 54:23Ruth Reymundo: Well, I am really grateful for you being on the show.
- 54:26Ruth Reymundo: Thank you so much.
- 54:28Ruth Reymundo: And and I hope that we have you on again because this is emerging.
- 54:32Ruth Reymundo: This is you know going into different countries and spaces, and and we need to track its usage, its impact, and how it's being focused in different systems and and have a robust, continuing conversation about what information sharing looks like, what accountability means.
- 54:52Ruth Reymundo: So thank you so much.
- 54:53David Mandel: Yeah, thank you, Kat, very much for being on the show.
- 54:56Ruth Reymundo: Thank you so very much.
- 54:58David Mandel: Yeah, so you've been listening to another episode of Partner with Survivor.
- 55:03David Mandel: I'm still David Mandel.
- 55:04David Mandel: And please, if you've enjoyed the show, share.
- 55:08David Mandel: This is something like I I want all the shows to be shared, but like all Australian people share this show, like not making a direct request.
- 55:15David Mandel: It seems like if this is real live Australia, a real live thing, but everywhere and share with you, comment, and check out safety of the institute.com, check out Academy.com.
- 55:28David Mandel: And with that, we are out.
- 55:30David Mandel: We are out of the way.