Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 08/22/26 - BOOK CLUB: YESTERYEAR by Caro Claire Burke
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Alright, we are back with Book Club in the 323 Bourbon Library. Cause what is better than books and bourbon? Nothing. Nothing. Nothing. ⁓ Yeah. And we have some good books. I mean, we get through quite a few. We're we're even digging back. Well, okay, no, this book we're not digging back. No. But we're pairing ⁓ first West Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey. It is 102 proof. ⁓ so ⁓ what we're trying to do is match our bourbs with our books somehow and whether it's where they were from or a vibe. Yeah. You know, I we're just trying our best. Yeah, we're trying our best. Making sure. So ⁓ first West we're gonna pair with yesteryear and I will let Vanessa tell you about that but It's a doozy. I'm so excited. I am too. So it was one that we just recently finished. It was of the moment recently. I don't even know if I want to say it's good, but talk about it in the wall. Okay. Let's let's go. Let's start there. Let's talk about what it's about. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right. So yesterday by Carol Claire Burke is a psychological suspense novel that explores family secrets, memory, obsession, and the lingering effects of the past. The story follows Natalie. A woman who becomes increasingly consumed by unresolved events from her past as old relationships and buried truths resurface, she struggles to distinguish between reality and the stories she has told herself over the years. Her search for answers focuses her to confront grief, guilt, and the consequences of a long held of long-held secrets. With an atmosphere of Mounting Tension yesteryear examines how memories can shape identity, how trauma can distort perception, and whether it's possible to move forward without first facing the past. The novel blends emotional family drama with psychological mystery, keeping readers questioning what is true until the final chapters. Okay, so first of all, first of all. I think I would have written the description differently. Huh? Like this is okay, so from someone who who doesn't write books, this is a trad wife influencer. So think TikTok. she has a following. Baller Ballerina Farm esque. We love Ballerina Farm's best protein powder. Listen, yeah, yay. But that vibe. that vibe. and and sort of the background. So when you when you start to read this, it's what is the dirty secret behind an influencer? Right? Yeah. And and then it takes a turn and and it goes back in time and and w how she's trying to live as a traditional wife kind of comes to bite her in the ass, let's say. And and it definitely Take some turns. There there is some unclear ⁓ situations you don't It's hard because a lot of people didn't like Natalie because she is very like she had kids because it's what you do if you're an influencer and that's how she got her farm and the money and where the description was right on point is like it there is this very blurred line between reality and the reality she was trying to sell everyone, you know, through her social media content. Okay. I just Had an epiphany. Okay. So not the same, not the same. But I just watched the documentary on the woman who mother something is. Yes. I haven't seen it. Who took the baby. Tell me. Okay, but it's very her tenancy. So it's a we have to find the name of it. It's a very ⁓ it's a documentary, real life, about this woman who ultimately Takes someone else's baby. She's pregnant and basically C sections this baby out. Anyway, when you watch the documentary, it is very adjacent in ways to ⁓ yesteryear. Like that whole kind of discombobulated what people are seeing as opposed to what you're actually doing, yeah, type of situation. Well, so you mentioned Natalie. Natalie's the main character in the book. Then it's told from her perspective. Which we get to hear a lot about, like her her inner thoughts. Yeah. ⁓ she's a little unhinged. She's spicy. ⁓ I mean we all are sometimes in our heads, but she just has these beliefs that, you know, many share with her, but even ⁓ like if we're going back to Current day reality, like even people who might share in those beliefs are like, absolutely not. Like, that is not what we stand for. There are very mixed reviews on this book, which is why I was so excited to talk about it because people are on one end or the other. You either loved it or you hated it. I I it's been a couple of weeks since I finished it, and I've gone back and re-listened to the last couple chapters because I'm like, I don't. No, did I like it? Did I not like it? And it sounds like you were kind of feeling the same. I still can't tell you whether I did or didn't. Because I think I think the problem that some people had is that it's this whole story and then this dramatic ending, but it was compiled in this little part of the story. And you're like, ⁓ if you would have dragged that out a little longer. Or anymore. But It's very like I keep comparing it to things ⁓ that have nothing to do with don't don't go down that rabbit hole. One one one more thing. Okay. It's very like secret lives of Mormon wives. I haven't seen that either. Okay, so Okay, apparently I need to get on this. But it's like you have this persona and then when you get a T V show and people see what it's actually like, you're all dirty as hell. Like get it together. So Okay. Ultimately I think I decided not a big fan of this book. And it's because I wanted to like it so much. At the beginning, I I remember I was texting you guys. It had a lot of build. What is happening? Like in the first couple of Well, I was behind three of you were further and I kept seeing that group chat and I'm like, whoa, calm don't ruin it. It was j it was just it had such good potential. Yeah. And then the way it just feels like the ball was dropped. There was more of the story that I felt like needed to be developed. you know, the I listened to the audio. It was I don't know, ten ish hours. I would have been okay with a thirteen, fifteen hour book. Yeah. Because I wanted to know like, okay, and then what? Like right. I know that there was just so much more that could have been told in the story and I feel like we just Yeah. I feel like there was five chapters that were just ripped out of the middle and you were just left with the end. And and I think that's the only reason I say that I didn't like this book. Because it just it left me hanging. Well, it's a little bit like in a I want more. You learn at this point I'm over it. You learn all about her and then all of a sudden she walks off a cliff. Not literally. However, that's what it feels like. Yeah. Like wait. Wait, what? And I don't we're not I don't think we're spoiling the end here. We're not telling you kind of what happens. No, it's just it's it's a little lack a little lackluster. There could have been more build in the end than there needed to be in the beginning. Yeah. So Or in the middle. A couple of pieces that we've left out. You know, the book does start off telling us about Natalie. ⁓ Tradwife, influencer. It puts us in the story, in a place in the story where she's You know, maturing, she's a young adult, she's getting married, you know, to a very wealthy man whose family's in politics and her family's ⁓ it just her mom, single mom, ⁓ very religious. Yeah. So that's kind of a basis of this. Yeah. Yeah. And and the story there's like part one where we're where we're kind of, you know, learning about her as a young adult and her marriage and, you know, her getting with Caleb, her husband. Yeah. them starting to have children. And then there's like part two of the story where like shit goes haywire. Yeah. And we do this like weird back and forth. So, you know, she's she like goes back in time. She's a trad wife influencer. But really again, we've alluded to behind the scenes, things aren't really what she's presenting. Yeah. To her audience. Yeah. And part two d uncovers that a little bit more, but also tells us a little bit more about her upbringing. A little bit more about her her family as she's as she's, you know, coming up and a little bit more about what happened with her dad. And so I feel like part two, everything just kind of gets jammed in there. Like there there was more to tell in that story. And we just didn't get that part of the story. I so I'm happy I have a hard time with it because I I feel like I want to say I liked it. Part one was great. But then I do feel like it could be different. I don't write books, so I am not one to judge. However, as someone who reads books, I would like it to have been a little bit different. ⁓ yeah. Yeah, I don't know. I think the I think the premise, especially in the present day time that we're in with TikTok and influencers and Instagram and Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and Secret Lives of LA and blah blah blah and blah blah blah and whatever reality shows. Yes. I think this was right on Trent. Like sh this author could not have picked a better time to have put this out. Like the build behind it. And I think that's why it was disappointing. Because there was more to the story that could have been told. Mm-hmm. And listen, I'm not trashing the author. This was the author's debut novel. So there's a lot of like commentary on it. But man, if she writes another book, I am for sure going to because I definitely think her storytelling was good. Yes. I think there was an opportunity here at the I think it was very good character building. Yeah. Like I I pictured every person that they were talking about. And even when they talked about the one person in two different lights, and you'll see that if you read it. That I saw them differently. Yeah. Even though it was the same person. So I think I if she has a great gift to tell story. I think it could have been different. I think it was a great time to come out with this though, in the time we're in. But absolutely am on board to read her next book. I wonder if maybe she does I'm gonna have to go on a deep dive later and find out. Like, does she tell a little bit more about why? Because again, this is this was the biggest issue I had with this story. It's just it felt abrupt. But again, I I really liked the character. I wanted to know more. ⁓ I I I just think, man, she n this Natalie character, I felt I found myself hating her in some moments. And then relating to relating to her moments and then really liking her and like she was super smart. She went to Harvard. Like she didn't have a great upbringing. Yeah. As far as like, you know, she wasn't super wealthy. She you know, grew up in a a single parent household. Yeah. Middle but not class, I would say. But she got herself to Harvard. Like she was clearly very smart. I I just think this is a good Mmm, a good reality check that what you're seeing online is not always what it is. Yeah. Very good reminder. So when all of us are like, ⁓ but look at their house and look at this, and why can't I be more like that? Because they're crazy. She was for sure narcissist. She was she was unhinged. Yeah. Bless her heart. But you know what? She also worked real hard to get there. Got some of her inner thoughts, right? Like wouldn't people think we were a little if we got our inner thing. Well, and I will say I loved the documentary on who was that girl who became an influencer and Anne. Yes. Anna Anna Delvey or something. Yes, Anna Delvey. I watched that and I was like, Yes, Anna, shame on you. However, shame on everyone else. Let her get away with what she's getting away with. Yeah. She worked hard for that. She was scheming her little tail off. I know she was. And that's sort of how I felt about this. Like, okay, yeah, I don't like her. I'm probably not gonna be friends with her, but you know what? Get it, girl. Do what you wanna do. And if everyone else is going along with it, they also kind of suck. Well, fine. Yeah. Fine. Yeah. And and as far as her being relatable, ⁓ There was this like part of her as a character. She wanted to better herself. Yeah. You know, that might mean something different than what you and I would envision as bettering ourselves, but that was something she was striving for. So like I could relate to Listen, claw yourself out. And sometimes that's not appealing to everyone. Yeah. Sometimes that means marrying a politician's son and having him by you. And he's a little bitch, so you have to just do Yeah. Okay, let's try this. Okay. Cheers. Cheers. Tee. Books and bourbon. This is so fun. Me too. ⁓ that's most I and I think the key is really to let it sit out. Yeah. I think that's it. I agree. ⁓ I mean I still stand by I even I even told Ronnie and some of the other stuff we do. I was like, maybe we should pour it and then record it like twenty minutes later. I think we're missing an opportunity. Yeah, that's nice. I don't feel like it's too so sometimes in the beginning I get a lot of ethanol and even just a mild bit of ethanol and I don't care for that ⁓ in general. Like I want it immutable. Yeah, like like it just hurts my nose adjacent to hurting my nose. You know what I mean? And I wanna smell it and be like, ⁓ Did anthropology come out with a new candle? Like that. Yeah. Enjoy it. Yeah. Enjoy the scent. And sometimes it like this one I feel like's has a little bit more Ethanol. Yeah. To it. And we're at a hundred and two proof. Yeah. Which isn't no. No. I typically my sweet spot is like one Seventeen, I would say. Before it starts getting too well that I that I like. I we've had some, honestly, that have been I think hazmat and you wouldn't know on the you wouldn't know on the nose and then you take a sip, you're like, Well damn it. That hit. That's happening. Mm. I feel like it drinks hotter than one ⁓ two. getting some honey notes. I I'm getting kicked in the throat. Really? Yeah, I know. I I feel the heat. Like definitely feel the heat. Maybe I took too big of a slurp. I mean give I've been accused of that so give it a moment. Swirl swirl. I'm not getting very much on the nose, I'm being honest. Yeah I'm not I'm I'm getting bourbon. Like I Well like like the alcohol. Yeah. Yeah. No like distinguishable Well then I hate to sit here and sniff it for four hours and this poor audience has to watch us sniff our taste. I would say I'm in I've enjoyed the first couple of sips that I've had. I am a big fan of honey and I do feel like that's what it's ⁓ listen. I have honey in my coffee every day and I could r and and in my sleepy time tea. The amount of honey I ingest per day is ridiculous. No, that's tasty. I enjoy that. ⁓ you mentioned talking about price next time. We'll definitely have to put that in. Yeah. Just I'm I'm kind of curious to know where I think it's a hundred dollars. What this one would be at, but let's see. I wouldn't call it a daily sipper. ⁓ no. It's ⁓ is that the same bottle? It's like eighty. Seventy, sixty, some of ⁓ are sixty three. ⁓ wait. ⁓ No. Did you just find this actual That can't be right? You've gone down a rabbit hole. $260. Maybe. By the way, it is a really nice bottle, and I know I haven't commented about bottles. ⁓ it's beautiful. I do love a good bottle. I know. It is I would say it, you know, there there is some artistry to the design in the of the bottles. in addition to ⁓ all of the work and we talked a little bit about tradition before that goes into developing each of these as well. Okay. I don't know that this is my favorite. I don't dislike it. I feel like it's low proof and it hits in the wrong way. It doesn't hit it it it it hits higher than a low proof. Right. Yeah. Which which I normally am very on board with, but I think I need I I always call a meaty. I w I need a meaty like mm hmm. Like a woman flavor and hit. Yeah. I would I'm gonna if I'm gonna rate this, I'm gonna give it a five out of ten. Like it's middle of the road. Will I probably finish sipping this? For two fifty? Absolutely not. And there's, you know Options I might go ahead and move on. And if if this bottle is what I'm looking up at 250, absolutely not. Molly has said no. No, no offense. I think it's good. I I would drink it. I would not pay $250 for it. ⁓ but I would taste it. Also not pay two hundred and fifty dollars for yesterday or but I would read it. So well, it's a good thing it wasn't $250. Yeah. ⁓ so I don't think we gave too much away. I think that just just to give you a little snippet. Yeah, it's just unhinged. The whole thing's unhinged. You have to you have to read it. We can't talk too much about it because Honestly, even just through part one. Like I no, but I do feel like once you're that far in, just commit to the full thing. Just commit to it. I know I said I didn't like it. Man, there were so many good so many things to like and so many things to dislike. I didn't like that it left me hanging. I and that made me mad. But I don't it was not a terrible book. Again, I would read something by this author again. I look forward to seeing what else. She might come out with. Yeah, I will say, based on that description, you don't know you don't care for the book until you're finished reading it. Yeah. So you really have to get through the whole thing. And we committed. Yeah. We were already in it. And you have to because you're honestly, there's enough that you're like, ⁓ my gosh, what is she gonna do? And even though I didn't love how it ended, I did enjoy the ending. Does that make sense? Like Yes. It was abrupt. I wanted more. I wanted there to be more to that story. I know that there was more to that story, but it was just kinda left. It's like she just walked away. I don't know. But but I did like how it ended. I understand why it ended the way that it ended. Yes. I think I maybe was just left wanting more and that just it it didn't leave me wanting more in a good way. Yeah. It was just like Frustrating to be less. Well, I feel like, okay, so let ⁓ the last thing I'm gonna say. I feel like the book ended how a documentary starts. Mm-hmm. Right? Like you're sitting in the chair and the people are coming in and they're starting the interview while you're at your lowest. Yeah. That's how it felt. Yeah. And I didn't want to keep like relating this to documentaries. I watched too much TV. But people recently have made fun of the crash documentary super often. Okay, the girl who like drove the car into a building at a hundred miles per hour killed the two people in the car except for herself because it only hit their side of the car. ⁓ yeah. Crazy. Anyway, she should be on orange is the new black. Like sh of course she a hundred percent intentionally killed those people. But that's sort of like when I when I picture the beginning of her documentary of her sitting down to start the whatever, that's how I fig that's how I picture Natalie sitting down to start talking about her life. They're like that she did nothing wrong. And how did she end up here? ⁓ my gosh, someone will get her out because she did nothing wrong. Right. Yeah. ⁓ well, there might be a movie, apparently. No. We will see. ⁓ fingers crossed. I will watch it. I will watch it. Yes. And Netflix might pick it up because it sounds like they like they're unhinged. Girls night. Girls night. Love. All right, more to come. Yes. Okay, we will see you next time for another book club. Cheers.