Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Intuit's Stock Crashed After Record Earnings?
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you're looking at this massive, gleaming skyscraper
- 0:04from the outside. The windows are sparkling.
- 0:06The architecture is just stunning.
- 0:08And it looks, I mean, virtually indestructible.
- 0:11But then, you know, you get your hands on the actual
- 0:14architectural blueprints, and you look really closely at the
- 0:17foundation and you notice this tiny hairline fracture, like the
- 0:22building is not falling down today, maybe not tomorrow.
- 0:25But that invisible crack? It sort of completely changes
- 0:29how you value the entire structure.
- 0:31Yeah, that structural integrity dictates pretty much everything
- 0:34because a polished exterior can dazzle the public.
- 0:36But if the foundation is, you know, slowly shifting under its
- 0:40own weight, right, the long term reality for whoever owns that
- 0:43building is going to be a lot more complicated than the the
- 0:46current optics suggests. Absolutely.
- 0:48So welcome to today's deep dive. We have an incredibly heavy
- 0:51stack of sources on the table today.
- 0:54It's a one O 3 file comprehensive financial research
- 0:57and valuation package for Intuit.
- 1:00Ticker symbol Intu. That's exactly intu.
- 1:04And this is hot off the presses covering their fiscal year 2026
- 1:07earnings, which were just released today, August 25, 2026.
- 1:11And we've custom tailored this analysis specifically for our
- 1:14favorite listener, the learner. So learner, grab your notepad
- 1:17because our mission today is to kind of cut through the noise of
- 1:20complex accounting, look past the really shiny top line
- 1:23numbers and figure out if this tech begin with is a deep value
- 1:27play or, you know, maybe a cleverly disguised value trap
- 1:30following a pretty massive after hours stock drop.
- 1:32Yeah, it serves as a a really fascinating case study and just
- 1:35how complex valuation has become in the modern software era.
- 1:38The conflicting signals are everywhere, and peeling back
- 1:40those layers it it requires some patience.
- 1:43It really does. But before we hand over those
- 1:45blueprints to the learner, I do have a quick housekeeping
- 1:48mandate to cover to access more advanced researches, follow
- 1:52Guru's latest movement and leverage our latest Deep Values
- 1:55agents. Welcome to download Deep Values
- 1:57APP from App Store to track stock market temperature.
- 2:01Welcome to download iOS app, Buffett Indicator from Apple App
- 2:05Store or Bubble Watch from Google Play.
- 2:08Links are in the description and of course our mandatory
- 2:10disclaimer. All analysis is based on
- 2:12publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 2:16differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 2:18is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 2:21does not constitute any investment or financial advice
- 2:23or service. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:26before making investment or financial decisions.
- 2:28OK, so with the groundwork laid, let's let's take a look at that
- 2:31skyscraper. Let's do it.
- 2:32So on the surface into its FY20 20 sex looks like this massive
- 2:37victory lap. I mean, the headline numbers are
- 2:39undeniably huge. Total revenue hit $21.448
- 2:43billion, yeah, which is a 14% increase.
- 2:46And JAB operating income reached 5.884 billion, which is up 20%.
- 2:52And when you break down their two biggest segments, you know,
- 2:55Global Business Solutions pulled in 12.9 billion and TurboTax hit
- 2:595.3 billion. Yeah.
- 3:01So I mean, on the surface they appear to be just printing
- 3:04money. They do.
- 3:05And the margins on those revenue streams are formidable.
- 3:07I mean, when operating income grows at 20% while total revenue
- 3:11is only growing at 14%, right? That mechanism is called
- 3:14operational leverage. It basically tells us the
- 3:17company can increase its sales without, you know,
- 3:19proportionally increasing its underlying costs.
- 3:21Oh, I see. It is usually the hallmark of a
- 3:23business with incredible pricing power.
- 3:24Yeah. And a big driver of that pricing
- 3:26power seems to be TurboTax Live. The research notes that TurboTax
- 3:30Live grew an incredible 37% this year, and it now makes up 53% of
- 3:35all TurboTax revenue. But here is where we find that
- 3:38hairline fracture in the foundation.
- 3:40It's kind of like a massive theme park where overall
- 3:42attendance is actually going down, but total revenues going
- 3:45up simply because the fewer people who do show up are all
- 3:48being funneled into buying the, you know, the ultra expensive
- 3:50VIP fastpasses. What's fascinating here is the
- 3:53divergent in the underlying unit volume, because despite
- 3:57reporting a massive $5.3 billion in tax revenue, the actual
- 4:02number of US TurboTax federal units fell by 2%.
- 4:06Wait, really? Yeah, they dropped from 39.9
- 4:10million individual returns down to 39.0 million.
- 4:13The desktop versions are down 7% and even the online DIY filings
- 4:18are down 2%. Oh wow, that feels completely
- 4:20counterintuitive when you are staring at a record-breaking
- 4:23revenue figure. I mean, how does that work?
- 4:25Well, Intuit is currently masking this volume drop
- 4:27entirely through aggressive price hikes and and shifting the
- 4:31product mix the fast passes. Exactly.
- 4:33Specifically getting people to abandon the cheap software and
- 4:36upgrade to TurboTax Live, which, you know, tax on human expert
- 4:39help for a premium fee, but relying strictly on price
- 4:42increases while your actual user base shrinks it.
- 4:45It's a precarious long term strategy.
- 4:48Eventually a company hits a ceiling on what consumers are
- 4:50willing to pay, especially for something as commoditized as tax
- 4:54filing software. If fewer people are walking
- 4:56through the gates of your theme park every single year, you can
- 4:59only raise the price of that VIP gas so many times before the
- 5:03revenue growth just mathematically stalls.
- 5:06OK, let's unpack this. Because if unit growth is
- 5:08stalling out in their legacy tax products, the learners probably
- 5:12asking, you know, where is the future growth supposed to come
- 5:15from? And that leads us straight into
- 5:17what look like an FY20 27 hangover.
- 5:20Yeah, the guidance. The guidance management just put
- 5:22out is surprisingly weak. They're only guiding for 9 to
- 5:2510% total growth for FY20. 7 TurboTax is expected to grow a
- 5:29meter 2 to 3%, and MailChimp that had projected a negative 1%
- 5:34to flat, basically zero growth. Yeah, that 0% growth projection
- 5:38for MailChimp is a glaring warning signal, especially when
- 5:42you cross reference it with into its balance sheet.
- 5:45Well, this is where I need to admit some confusion.
- 5:47Obviously, I'm looking at the file here and it says into it
- 5:50has $18.62 billion in quote goodwill and acquired
- 5:56intangibles sitting on their balance sheet, right?
- 5:59That makes up roughly 51% of their total assets.
- 6:03I see this term goodwill thrown around constantly in these
- 6:06financial filings and honestly, it always trips me up.
- 6:10It's tricky. Like how can goodwill make up
- 6:13half of a software company's total asset value?
- 6:16Can you explain that mechanism to me like I'm a beginner?
- 6:19Of course, it is a notoriously confusing accounting term, so
- 6:23think of it like buying real estate.
- 6:25Let's say there is a house on the market and the raw
- 6:27materials, you know, the wood, the bricks, the land are
- 6:30objectively worth $500,000. But because it is in a highly
- 6:34desirable neighborhood, you decide to pay 1.5 million for
- 6:37it. That extra $1 million you paid
- 6:39over the tangible value in corporate accounting, that
- 6:42premium is recorded on your balance sheet as goodwill.
- 6:45Oh, I see. Yeah.
- 6:46Intuit bought companies like MailChimp and Credit Karma for
- 6:49massive premiums. So $18.6 billion of Intuit's
- 6:53stated asset value is essentially just the leftover
- 6:57premium they paid above the raw value of those acquired
- 7:00businesses. Wow.
- 7:01Which means if those acquisitions start failing, that
- 7:04$18 billion in premium value is essentially vaporware.
- 7:09If we connect this to the bigger picture, this touch is exactly
- 7:12on the intense criticism Intuit has faced from institutional
- 7:16investors, specifically Fund Smith.
- 7:19Terry Smith's fund has openly questioned whether Intuit's
- 7:21management drastically overpaid for MailChimp and whether they
- 7:26have been fully transparent about the actual return on that
- 7:28massive investment. If MailChimp is now projecting 0
- 7:31growth, it suggests they may have bought a house at the top
- 7:33of the market and the neighborhood is going downhill.
- 7:35Oh, that's a brutal way to look at it, but it makes so much
- 7:38sense. And Intuit is also making a
- 7:40major accounting change for FY20 27.
- 7:43They are separating MailChimp into its own reporting segment,
- 7:46which you know, makes it harder to hide its performance.
- 7:48But more importantly, the research says they're going to
- 7:51stop excluding stock based compensation from their non GAAP
- 7:55results. I need you to walk me through
- 7:58this one too. How does stock based
- 8:00compensation artificially inflate earnings and why does
- 8:04stopping this practice matter? Oh, this is a classic Silicon
- 8:07Valley maneuver. Tech companies love to pay their
- 8:10engineers and executives and company stock rather than pure
- 8:13cash. RSU's and options.
- 8:15Exactly. Historically, when they report
- 8:18their non GAAP earnings, which is the shiny number they want
- 8:21Wall Street to look at, they pretend that stock isn't a real
- 8:24expense because no cash left the bank account.
- 8:27But it is a real expense because issuing new stock dilutes the
- 8:30ownership slice of every existing shareholder by stopping
- 8:34the exclusion of stock based compensation into it is finally
- 8:37being forced to put that very real expense front and center.
- 8:41Wow. It will make their reported
- 8:42profitability look much lower, but much more accurate.
- 8:45So the core issue isn't balance sheet solvency then?
- 8:49They aren't going bankrupt. Now the issue is capital
- 8:51allocation. Management allocated billions of
- 8:54shareholder dollars to acquire a company like MailChimp, and now
- 8:58that segment is posting -1% growth.
- 9:01Did those acquisitions actually earn satisfactory returns for
- 9:04the shareholder? That is the ultimate test of
- 9:07management and right now the numbers look highly
- 9:10questionable, man. Well, with those legacy
- 9:12acquisitions dragging their feet, it forces us to look at
- 9:15into its ultimate long term defense.
- 9:18They serve 100 million customers worldwide across QuickBooks,
- 9:21TurboTax, Credit Karma and MailChimp.
- 9:24Huge user base. Yeah, they possess this
- 9:26incredibly massive proprietary data set of global accounting,
- 9:30payroll and taxes. But here's where it gets really
- 9:32interesting. We have to talk about artificial
- 9:34intelligence. Oh yes, AI is the looming shadow
- 9:38over every software as a service business right now, and Intuit
- 9:42is squarely in the crosshairs. See, I want to push back on the
- 9:45popular narrative that Intuit's Moat is completely unassailable
- 9:48just because they have a lot of user data.
- 9:50Couldn't AI completely destroy their core business model?
- 9:53How do you mean? Well, into its historic mode has
- 9:55always been its software interface, right?
- 9:57Taking a horribly complex tax code and translating it into a
- 10:00simple questionnaire for a layperson.
- 10:03But if generalized AI agents become incredibly smart and make
- 10:07bookkeeping and tax filing nearly free and completely
- 10:10portable, doesn't Inter its software interface mode just
- 10:13evaporate overnight? Like why on earth would I pay
- 10:16for TurboTax if my personal open source AI assistant can just
- 10:20read my PDF bank statements and file my taxes perfectly to the
- 10:24IRS for free? That is the exact structural
- 10:27threat threatening their valuation.
- 10:29If Intuit's only value proposition is, you know, we
- 10:31translate tax rules into easy to answer questions, a modern large
- 10:35language model can do that instantly and for pennies.
- 10:37But there's a flip side to this technological shift.
- 10:41If Intuit plays their cards correctly, AI doesn't destroy
- 10:44their mode, it actually deepens it.
- 10:46I'm struggling to see how giving away their core competency to a
- 10:49language model helps them. It comes down to trust,
- 10:53liability, and proprietary history.
- 10:55An open source AI might know the 2026 tax code perfectly, but it
- 10:59does not have the last 10 years of your specific businesses
- 11:03payroll, invoicing, and depreciation history securely
- 11:07integrated into a single closed system of record the way
- 11:10QuickBooks does. That's true, but beyond the
- 11:12data, Intuit has something pure software competitors do not, and
- 11:16that is a massive human expert network.
- 11:19Oh, you mean the certified public accountants powering
- 11:22TurboTax Live? Precisely if Intuit can turn its
- 11:25historical data and its human network into an AI financial
- 11:29system of intelligence, they become incredibly sticky.
- 11:32Think about human psychology, right?
- 11:33People are terrified of the IRS. Business owners are terrified of
- 11:37getting their payroll wrong and facing massive fines.
- 11:40AI can process the data efficiently, but AI cannot
- 11:44easily replicate human reassurance.
- 11:46That's what you're saying. When an AI flags a complex tax
- 11:48deduction, a business owner wants a certified human expert
- 11:52to look at it, stamp their name on it and say yes, you are safe
- 11:55to claim this. I back this up.
- 11:56Yeah, that makes sense. Intuit has the infrastructure to
- 11:59provide the AI automation for speed and the human validation
- 12:03for Peace of Mind. The fear of a government audit
- 12:05is definitely a powerful Moat. So with AI threatening the raw
- 12:09software side and acquisitions like MailChimp underperforming,
- 12:13how are the people with actual skin in the game reacting?
- 12:17Let's read the room. Sasan Goodarzi is the CEO and
- 12:21founder Scott Cook is still on the board, which provides great
- 12:24alignment. Very true.
- 12:25The research also notes management's guidance is usually
- 12:28quite conservative. They beat their initial guidance
- 12:30in FY24, FY25 and now they just beat it for FY20 6.
- 12:35Under promising and over delivering is a trait you always
- 12:38want to see in an executive team.
- 12:39It builds institutional trust. For sure, they're also returning
- 12:42a mountain of capital to shareholders, $5.5 billion in
- 12:46stock repurchases in FY20, 6 which reduced outstanding shares
- 12:49by 2%, and they still have 7.9 billion remaining in
- 12:52authorization. That's a lot of dry powder.
- 12:54Yeah, plus we have an interesting insider buy.
- 12:57Lead Independent director Vasant Prabhu bought $542,000 of Intuit
- 13:02stock on the open market in May of 2026 and around 309 to $310 a
- 13:07share. Insider buying remains one of
- 13:09the most compelling data points in finance.
- 13:11Executives might sell stock for a dozen personal reasons.
- 13:14You know, buying a second house, paying a tax bill, simple
- 13:17diversification. But they generally only buy
- 13:20shares on the open market with their own cash.
- 13:22For one reason, they believe the stock is undervalued and is
- 13:25going up. Just to round out the
- 13:26shareholder picture from the sources, there were a couple of
- 13:29notable votes at the 2026 meeting.
- 13:31Say on pay was approved by an overwhelming 93.2% and there was
- 13:36a shareholder proposal requesting a report on the ROI
- 13:39of Intuits diversity and inclusion programs, which
- 13:42received almost no traction, only .76% support.
- 13:46Interesting. But looking at the broader
- 13:48institutional investor landscape, well, it's incredibly
- 13:51mixed. This is where I want to talk
- 13:52about 13 F filings. This raises an important
- 13:55question about how retail investors interpret the actions
- 13:58of the smart money, because the value investor community is
- 14:01deeply fractured on Intuit right now.
- 14:02Deeply fractured is an understatement.
- 14:04I mean during Q2 of 2026, you have legendary value funds like
- 14:08Yakman adding over 480,000 shares to their portfolio and
- 14:13for specific initiating a brand new position with over 330,000
- 14:17shares. But on the exact same timeline,
- 14:20growth focused funds like Shaw Spring, Poland, Maverick and
- 14:24Cena completely exited their positions.
- 14:26They sold everything. Now I see retail websites
- 14:29publishing the average buy price for these funds based on their
- 14:3313F filings. Should the learner be using
- 14:35those calculated prices to decide when to buy in?
- 14:38That is a phenomenal question and the answer is a resounding
- 14:41no. Really, we have to issue a
- 14:43massive warning about the mechanics of 13 F filings.
- 14:46Relying on those average buy prices you see on financial
- 14:49websites is a great way to make a terrible investment decision.
- 14:52Why is the data so unreliable? I mean it's SEC data.
- 14:55Because of how the SEC rules work, A13F filing only tells the
- 14:59public what a fund held on the very last day of the quarter.
- 15:02It does not tell us the trade dates, the strategy, or the
- 15:05actual execution prices. Furthermore, funds have up to 45
- 15:08days after the quarter ends to actually file the paperwork.
- 15:10So if a quarter ends on March 31st, a fund doesn't have to
- 15:14report their holdings until mid-May.
- 15:16They could have bought into it in January, watched it run up,
- 15:19and by the time you read the filing in May, they might have
- 15:21already sold it all. It's like looking at a
- 15:23photograph of a marathon taken at the halfway mark and trying
- 15:26to calculate the runner's current average speed an hour
- 15:29later. Exactly.
- 15:30You are missing way too much real time data to make a
- 15:34mathematical conclusion. What the 13 F data does tell us
- 15:37though, is that there is absolutely no consensus on Wall
- 15:40Street. Some brilliant capital
- 15:42allocators look at into it and see an unbreakable software
- 15:45monopoly with a massive human Moat trading at a discount.
- 15:49Other equally brilliant allocators look at the exact
- 15:51same company, see stalling unit growth, bloated acquisition
- 15:55goodwill and the looming threat of AI, and head for the exits.
- 15:59Which brings us to the most dramatic part of this deep dive,
- 16:02the valuation and the after hours reality check.
- 16:05We have these wildly mixed signals.
- 16:07Unbelievable gross margins but dropping tax units, huge AI
- 16:12potential but heavy goodwill dragging the balance sheet.
- 16:16So what does this all mean for the learner who is staring at
- 16:18their portfolio today? Because after the regular close
- 16:21of $357.46 into its stock dropped sharply after hours down
- 16:25to $321.92. Yeah, it was a violent repricing
- 16:30event driven almost entirely by the market digesting that weak
- 16:33FY20 27 guidance we unpacked earlier.
- 16:36The research runs into it through a deep value scorecard.
- 16:38Based on these new FY20 26 numbers, it passes the great
- 16:42business test with flying colors.
- 16:44It has an 80.2% gross margin, a 40.2% free cash flow margin, and
- 16:49a 23.6% return on equity. But I want to clarify those
- 16:52terms. Why is a 40% free cash flow
- 16:54margin so impressive? So free cash flow is the actual
- 16:57cash leftover after a company has paid all its bills and
- 17:00maintained its equipment. A 40% margin means for every
- 17:03dollar into it brings in $0.40 drops straight into their bank
- 17:07account as pure unencumbered cash.
- 17:10That is an elite level of profitability that very few
- 17:12companies in the world ever achieve.
- 17:14OK, but Despite that elite profitability, the research
- 17:17notes it completely fails the traditional deep value test.
- 17:21Even after the massive after hours drop, the PE ratio is
- 17:25still hovering around 19.56 times earnings and his price to
- 17:29book ratio is over 4.5. Right.
- 17:32A traditional deep value investor, someone looking for a,
- 17:35you know, a cigar butt style bargain is usually hunting for
- 17:38APE under 15 or a price to book under 1.5.
- 17:42A price to book a 4.5 means the market is pricing into it at 4
- 17:461/2 times the stated value of its raw assets.
- 17:48It is a phenomenal business, but you are still paying a premium
- 17:51for that quality. The question for the investor
- 17:53is, does the future cash flow justify that premium?
- 17:56To answer that, the research includes a discount of cash flow
- 17:59or DCF breakdown and highlight something really important about
- 18:03into its historical growth. Over the last 10 years, their
- 18:06average free cash flow growth was 23.8% and the maximum was
- 18:09over 45%. If an investor plugs those
- 18:12historical averages into ADCF calculator today, they will get
- 18:16an intrinsic value that is dangerously artificially high.
- 18:21You might see a fair value output of $1000 a share.
- 18:24Oh wow. But projecting 24% to 45% annual
- 18:27cash flow growth indefinitely for a company that is already
- 18:31doing 21 billion in revenue is mathematically impossible.
- 18:35At that compound rate into, it would eventually consume the
- 18:38entire global economy. So the researcher ran a highly
- 18:40conservative DCF case using a -3.18% growth rate as a starting
- 18:46point to fade into terminal growth, and that conservative
- 18:49case yields an intrinsic value of $324.90.
- 18:53I have to pause you there 'cause I'll admit I'm confused.
- 18:55Sure. How does a negative growth rate
- 18:57in a valuation model actually output a positive fair value of
- 19:00$324.00? That feels mathematically
- 19:03counterintuitive. It sounds backward, but it comes
- 19:05down to the mechanics of discounting cash flows.
- 19:07Yeah, Intuit is currently generating billions of dollars
- 19:09in free cash flow every single year.
- 19:12Even if that cash flow shrinks by 3% next year, they are still
- 19:15generating billions of dollars in actual cash.
- 19:18A DCF model takes all of those future billions year after year
- 19:22and discounts them back to what they're worth in today's
- 19:24dollars. I get it now.
- 19:26A negative growth rate simply means the hyper growth phase is
- 19:29over and the business is slowly maturing.
- 19:32It doesn't mean the company is dead or worthless.
- 19:35Adding up all those slightly shrinking but massive future
- 19:37cash piles gives you a present fair value of roughly $324 per
- 19:42share. Look at the after hours price
- 19:44you just mentioned $321.92. Yep, the after hours price crash
- 19:49brought into it almost exactly to fair value based on those
- 19:53highly conservative estimates. At the regular close of 357, it
- 19:57was priced above conservative fair value.
- 19:59Yeah, the market saw the weak guidance, panicked and instantly
- 20:03corrected the price down to its foundational intrinsic value.
- 20:06The stock market acted like a perfectly rational discounting
- 20:09mechanism in the span of about 60 minutes.
- 20:11It really did, but for the deep value investor, fair value is
- 20:14not enough. Right, the margin of safety.
- 20:16Exactly. The research calculates that a
- 20:18required 30% margin of safety price, the distant you demand to
- 20:22protect yourself from being wrong, would be roughly 227
- 20:26dollars. So even after a brutal after
- 20:28hours drop, it's hovering right at fair value, but nowhere near
- 20:32a screening margin of safety. Bargain you.
- 20:34Are paying a fair price for a wonderful business, but you are
- 20:37not getting any discount for the risks.
- 20:38You know the AI threats, the unit volume drops, or the
- 20:42MailChimp integration struggle, right?
- 20:44Let's summarize the mission here into it is fundamentally a great
- 20:47business, unbelievable cash flow margins at a really sticky
- 20:51ecosystem. But it is facing real unit
- 20:54volume headwinds in its core products and it was essentially
- 20:57price for perfection going into earnings.
- 21:00The week guidance caused it to crash back down to fair value
- 21:03after hours. And we have to remind the
- 21:05learner today was just the earnings release.
- 21:07The actual audited FY20 2610K filing hasn't dropped yet.
- 21:11Once that gets filed, the math on the acquisition accounting,
- 21:14the goodwill and the true stock based compensation could shift
- 21:17the blueprint again. The 10K is where the real bodies
- 21:20are buried, but looking at everything we've synthesized
- 21:23today, I want to leave the listener with a final thought to
- 21:25Mull over. We spent a lot of time analyzing
- 21:28AI and how generalized language models make raw software code a
- 21:32case commodity. Right.
- 21:34And into it is combating that primarily with TurboTax Live,
- 21:38you know, combining their software with a vast network of
- 21:42human accounts. Exactly.
- 21:43But what if we are looking at a fundamental evolution of the
- 21:46tech industry? What if the future of the
- 21:49world's biggest software companies isn't in writing
- 21:51better code? What if to protect their moats
- 21:54against AI, these tech giants are forced to become massive
- 21:58staffing agencies for human experts who can simply hold a
- 22:01clients hand? Man, that is a wild thought.
- 22:03You start out as a Silicon Valley software disruptor
- 22:06automating human jobs, and you end up as a glorified human
- 22:09resources firm just to provide the emotional reassurance that a
- 22:13robot can't offer. It completely flips the
- 22:15narrative of software eating the world.
- 22:17It goes right back to the blueprints of that skyscraper we
- 22:20discussed at the beginning. You assume the strength of the
- 22:23building is in the modern high tech glass and steel on the
- 22:26outside, but when you look at the foundation the only thing
- 22:30keeping the whole structure from cracking is just basic human
- 22:34trust. The foundation is always human.
- 22:37Well, we will be watching closely when that 10K drops to
- 22:40see if the foundation holds. Thank you for joining us on this
- 22:42deep dive. Go conduct your own due
- 22:44diligence and we will see you next time.